0:00 What happens when police start investigating two unknown attackers and discover those men never existed? A coroner in Albany, New York, called police and asked if investigators were planning to attend an upcoming autopsy for a deceased fetus. The problem was, 0:21 police didn't know what the coroner was talking about. There hadn't been a report explaining what had happened to this baby, or what had happened to the baby's mother. On May 18, 2024, a 19-year-old woman in Albany, New York, had delivered her son, stillborn, 0:38 after being hospitalized with serious injuries. When investigators started looking into what happened to this young woman, they heard that she had been attacked on Central Avenue in Albany by two unknown men. That gave investigators somewhere to start. But 0:55 as police started looking into that supposed attack, things were not adding up. Investigators found inconsistencies in the story and eventually determined that the woman had not been jumped on Central Avenue at all. Instead, they found that the real 1:13 crime scene was an apartment on Orange Street in Albany, and the person police began focusing on was the victim's 18-year-old boyfriend, Tyleek Young. Hi, lambs. Welcome to Love & Murder, Heartbreak to Homicide. I am your host, Kai. And before 1:30 we continue, make sure that you're subscribed to Love & Murder on whatever podcast platform you're currently listening on so you never miss an episode. And if you want to keep up with everything happening with the show, come follow 1:43 Love & Murder for free at patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. 1:47 If you'd like to get more Love & Murder while helping me continue telling the victim's stories, you can also join one of the paid Patreon tiers and become part of the LAMFAM, patreon.com forward slash 11murder. And I'll tell you more about the Patreon at the end of this episode, 2:03 but in the meantime, let's get back to this case. 2:07 The victim's name has been withheld because she was a victim of domestic violence. And once investigators started digging into her relationship with Tyleek, they learned that whatever happened on Orange Street was not the first time he had been 2:23 violent with her. She would later talk about going home more than once with injuries that she had to explain away to her family. Quote, I remember coming home numerous times with black eyes and scratches on my face, and when my parents would ask me what happened, I would 2:39 lie and make up a story each time to protect you. 2:43 She later admitted that she didn't even understand why she had kept trying to make the relationship work or why she kept giving him chance after chance. By 2023, the violence had gotten even worse. During one assault, Tyleek beat her so badly that he knocked out one of her teeth. 3:03 Then when her brother stepped in to defend her, Tyleek stabbed him seven times. However, because of Tyleek's age at the time, he didn't face severe legal consequences for that attack. 3:18 Then in December 2023, the victim learned that she was pregnant with Tyleek's child. Tyleek didn't want her to continue the pregnancy, and he demanded that she have an abortion and gave her a deadline of February 1st to do it. 3:35 She refused because she wanted to keep her baby, so his threats became even more violent. Investigators would later recover text messages and voice recordings where Tyleek threatened to, quote, beat the shit out of her, kill her, kill her family, 3:52 and burn down their house. In one voice message he sent to her, Tyleek actually sang. Sang. Quote, Homicide. There's gonna be a homicide. And those threats continued while her pregnancy progressed. By the night of May 15, 2024, the 4:12 victim was 27 weeks pregnant with their son. Sometime overnight on that same day and into the early morning hours of May 16, She was inside Tyleek's apartment on Orange Street. 4:24 At some point, Tyleek took her cell phone and car keys so she couldn't leave or call for help. Then, over the course of several hours, Tyleek repeatedly hit her in the abdomen with a hammer. After the assault, instead 4:42 of immediately getting her medical help and telling police what had happened, Tyleek and his mother... pressured her to give police a different story. They wanted her to say that she had been jumped and beaten on Central Avenue by 4:56 two unknown men. Tyleek's mother then got the injured victim into her car and started driving towards Albany Medical Center Hospital. 5:06 But instead of taking her inside, she left because one of the victim's friends worked there. She drove her instead to Samaritan Hospital Albany Memorial Campus, which didn't have a labor and delivery unit. Assistant District Attorney Ariel Fallon, Bureau 5:27 Chief of the Special Victims Unit, and the prosecutor who later handled the case explained, quote, her child had a heartbeat at Memorial, and by the time she was stable and they could bring her to labor and delivery, he no longer had a heartbeat when she got to Albany Med. 5:44 The victim had suffered a severe placental rupture from all of the trauma to her abdomen, and by the time she had been stabilized and transferred to the maternity ward, there was no longer a fetal heartbeat. Two days later, 6:00 on May 18th, the 19-year-old mother delivered her stillborn son. 6:05 Which brings us back to that call from the coroner. 6:09 The investigation eventually led to Tyleek being arrested, And on June 4th, 2024, Tyleek was formally arraigned in Albany County Court before Judge Andrea Ackerman. Prosecutors said that he deliberately aimed the blows at her abdomen with the intent of 6:27 causing a fatal injury to the baby. I don't even know how diabolically, maniacally evil you have to be to do something like that. A grand jury had indicted him on five felony charges, two counts of first-degree assault, one 6:45 count of second-degree kidnapping, and two counts of third-degree robbery. 6:51 Is murder in there anywhere? One of the first-degree assault charges alleged that Tyleek acted with the intent to disfigure, dismember, or disable the victim. The second accused him of intended to cause serious physical injury with a weapon. I mean... 7:10 More than serious physical injury with a weapon, he wanted to murder the baby. The kidnapping charge was connected to keeping the victim inside the apartment, while the robbery charges involved taking her cell phone and car keys. Why am 7:23 I not hearing anything about murder in the mix? Judge Ackerman ordered Tyleek held without bail at the Albany County Correctional Facility, and initial reports said that he could face as much as 25 years in prison. That's it. After court, 7:40 District Attorney Lee Kindlan spoke about the victim and the fact that she had eventually come forward. Quote, The allegations are horrific, and I applaud this young woman, the victim, for coming forward and having the strength to report what happened, 7:55 and we'll do everything in the world we can do to support victims. At that point, Tyleek was represented by public defender Beau Melita. Quote, My client is presumed innocent. 8:08 as is his constitutional right. Yeah, right schmite. Anyways, he continues, while the charges are serious, the indictment is only an allegation, not proof of guilt. We urge the public and media to reserve judgment until all the facts come out in court. Yes, 8:25 because I don't want to be sued. I will say yes, and I will say everything here is alleged. There was also the issue of Tyleek's mother. Authorities knew about her involvement in getting the victim to give police the false story, 8:39 and they also knew what happened when the victim was taken to the hospital. But Attorney Kindland decided not to charge her. What. The. Frick. Quote, It was a discretionary charge and decision made by me, and obviously I relied upon the advice of the attorneys in my office, but 9:03 not wanting to put the victim and her family through this as much as we could. We didn't want to get too far afield, because that leads to months and months of litigation, and part of this was making sure the victim and her family didn't have to relive this 9:18 awfulness again and again and again. I hear you, but just letting this evil woman with her evil son, not saying the son is walking, but she's walking, just letting her walk, I can't say I agree with that. Tyleek's case, however, 9:36 kept moving forward, and on Thursday, September 25th, he appeared before Judge Ackerman and pleaded guilty to the entire five-count indictment. 9:46 He went back to court on Tuesday, November 25th, for sentencing. 9:50 By then, the victim was 20 years old, and when she walked up to give her victim impact statement, she brought a large framed photo of her stillborn son with her. her. 10:00 The picture was placed beside her while she spoke and people throughout Judge Ackerman's courtroom openly cried as they listened. Quote, I get so mad when I think about how all of this could have been prevented if you would have just stopped and put the hammer down. I get mad 10:18 at the fact that you didn't think to yourself, What I'm doing to her is extremely wrong and that she's carrying my baby in her stomach and that I should stop because not only am I hurting her, I'm hurting an innocent baby. You know, you could have, like I 10:32 always say, you could have literally just gone to the store and get some milk, meaning you just abandoned her. 10:40 Still a dick move, but still better than what she just did. You could have just done what a bunch of guys do and ignored the child, ignored the mother, and acted like you didn't have this child. Dick move, don't get me wrong, but still better than the option 10:58 you chose. Assistant District Attorney Fallon also addressed Judge Ackerman, quote, the pain that this defendant has caused, not just to the victim, but her whole family, this is the most heartbreaking and horrific case I have ever handled. Prosecutors asked 11:17 Judge Ackerman to give Tyleek the maximum sentence available under the final disposition of the case, 20 years in state prison. 11:25 Why is there not murder attached to this? I don't understand that. By sentencing, Tyleek was being represented by defense attorney Justin Dermis. Attorney Dermis argued that Tyleek's decision to plead guilty showed that he had accepted responsibility for what 11:43 he had done. I'm sure it did. He also gave the court some background on Tyleek's life, saying that Tyleek had grown up with an incarcerated father and had been dealing with a heavy addiction to street opiates, which the defense argued affected his state of mind around the time 12:02 of the attack. Heavy on the bullshit. Attorney Dear Mass also pointed out that while Tyleek had been held in the Albany County Jail, he completed five behavioral and anger management courses. Okay, did that bring the baby back? I 12:20 don't get why I should care. Quote, he's done nothing but accept remorse for this horrific case. Tyleek was then given the opportunity to speak for himself, and he said, quote, I would like to sincerely apologize to the victim, the 12:35 victim's family. There's no justification for anything that happened that day. 12:40 I just want to become a better person for society. Personally, my opinion, my opinion, I think it's just a bunch of blah, blah, blah words to try and get the least possible sentence and get out as soon as he could. 12:54 People in the courtroom noted that Tyleek did not cry during the proceedings. And then, after hearing from the victim, Assistant District Attorney Fallon, Attorneys Dermis, and Tyleek himself, Judge Ackerman gave him the maximum sentence possible. He was sentenced 13:11 to 20 years in state prison. And that is the case of a, I have no even words. I called him deranged, evil. I called him all of that, but I think I haven't found a strong enough word for him. 13:27 I can't imagine somebody is pregnant with your child, your son, and you took a hammer to their stomach. That was your solution? I just can't even imagine. And then there are two things I do want to talk about with this case. And the first is what she said about 13:45 all the time she covered for Tyleek. I think that something like people on the outside of abusive relationships wonder, you know, why would you do that? Why didn't you just tell somebody what's happening? But abuse can change the 14:00 way somebody thinks, the way they respond, and even what feels normal for them after a while. So when people ask, why didn't she just leave? I think that question puts way too much attention on what the victim did or didn't do instead of asking why the person hurting her 14:18 kept making it harder for her to feel like she couldn't leave, speak up, or ask for help. The question should always be on the person inflicting the pain on the victim, not on the victim themselves. Then there's the 14:32 decision involving Tyleek's mother because I'm honestly torn on that one. 14:37 I understand prosecutors not wanting to put the victim through another court case after everything she's already been through, especially if they believe the additional prosecution would require more from her emotionally. But at the same time, I can also 14:53 understand why someone would be uncomfortable with the idea that sparing a victim another court process can also mean somebody else may never be prosecuted at all. So I don't think either side of that is easy. And I think both concerns can exist at the same time. I am 15:13 sympathetic towards the victim, of course, but also I don't want this woman to just be walking around because that's such an evil thing her son did that she was just okay with. So I'm kind of torn on this. 15:29 Let me know your thoughts in the comments below on that whole thing. And if you are experiencing domestic violence, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233. That's 1-800-799-7233. 15:38 Or go to thehotline.org. All calls are toll-free and confidential, and the hotline is available 24-7 in more than 170 languages. 15:56 If you didn't get that phone number or you need more resources, you can visit my website, which has all that information on there, murderandlove.com. That is love and murder backwards, murderandlove.com. 16:08 And that's all I have for you today. Also, if you'd like more Love & Murder beyond these regular episodes, then come join us at patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. You can follow for free or become a paid member for 16:21 exclusive bonus cases, add free listen-in, and additional content while helping keep the podcast going. Patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. Thank you so much for listening. Thank you so much for your support. Thank you so much prematurely for joining the Patreon. 16:38 And I will see you in the next episode. Bye.
Community discussion