0:00 Can hundreds of tiny pieces of evidence prove a murder when nobody actually witnessed the killing? On the afternoon of February 18, 2023, Todd Harari went to the Indian Harbor Beach Police Department in Florida with his two children and 0:17 reported that his ex-wife, 44-year-old Nancy Harari, was missing. Nancy and Todd shared custody of their children, and Nancy was supposed to pick them up from school later, in Satellite Beach on February 15th, but she never showed up. Then 0:34 she missed school pickup again on February 16th, which was completely out of her character. Officer Christopher Maligan began checking Nancy's neighborhood, calling hospitals and jails in the area, and requested an emergency ping on her cell phone. Investigators were 0:52 trying to figure out where Nancy had gone and when anyone had last been able to account for her. On February 19th, Sgt. Timothy Gannon located Nancy's gray 2014 Honda Odyssey Touring near the intersection of Platt Avenue and Oakleaf 1:09 Street in Palm Bay, which was about 3.8 miles from the Malabar gun range. That van was locked, and Nancy's driver's license, bank cards, personal belongings, and freshly purchased groceries were still inside. A neighbor named Jonathan Rowland said that 1:29 he had noticed Nancy's van parked in that unusual location before he left town on February 16th. And then, when he came back on Sunday, February 19th, it was still there. 1:43 Because the investigation was now pointing towards Palm Bay, the case was transferred from Indian Harbor Beach to the Brevard County Sheriff's Office, or BCSO. Homicide agents Neil Lee and Tyler Peterson became the co-lead investigators. Welcome, lambs. Welcome to 2:04 Love and Murder Heartbreak to Homicide. I am your host, Kai. 2:08 And before we continue with this case of a missing mother, I want to remind you to subscribe to Love and Murder Heartbreak to Homicide on whatever platform you're currently listening to it on. The best way you can subscribe, though, 2:21 is through the Patreon. Patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. You can do that for free so you do not miss the next episode. However, if you do want to support the podcast, you can choose any one of the paid tiers, starting at the $ 3 a month tier and up. And I'll 2:38 tell you more about the tiers at the end of this case. But in the meantime, let's get in and see what's going on with this missing case of Nancy Harari. 2:48 Nancy was a mother of two living in Indian Harbor Beach, and she was closely connected to the local Brazilian community. 2:55 Her friends described her as warm, hardworking, and deeply devoted to her children. She worked from home running an Amazon reselling and arbitrage business, buying products in bulk and selling them online. She stayed connected with friends and family through apps, 3:11 including WhatsApp and Snapchat, where she used the username Good Vibes 2020. Nancy was divorced from Todd, but the two of them had an established custody schedule, which is why missing those school pickups immediately raised alarms. She had also 3:27 been involved in an on-and-off relationship with 32-year-old Daniel Loren Stearns, who lived in Palm Bay. Daniel was a U.S. Army infantry veteran who had served in Afghanistan and said he suffered from service-connected PTSD. He also claimed that he had 3:45 formal training in military combatives and Aikido martial arts. Nancy and Daniel met on Tinder roughly two years earlier, but they did not want the same things from the relationship. 3:58 Daniel wanted complete exclusivity, while Nancy valued her independence and continued seeing other people. Daniel said, quote, I don't want someone who goes and sees other men. which brings us back to Wednesday, February 15th. That morning, Nancy went to 4:17 visit her close friend, Iana Ramos, a Palm Bay store owner who also shared Nancy's Brazilian heritage. The two women drank coffee and talked about food, their culture, and rental properties Nancy had been looking at. While Nancy was there, 4:33 she got into a long, heated FaceTime argument with Daniel. 4:37 Iana remembered that the call was interrupted several times because of battery issues, but the tension between the two of them was obvious. At 11.18 a.m., Nancy stopped at a BP gas station and made a $ 20. 16 purchase. Agent Daniel 4:54 Geneva later reviewed her TD Bank records and confirmed that this was Nancy's final in-person debit card transaction. After that... 5:04 The only charges on her account were automatic recurring payments. 5:08 At around 11.30 a.m., Nancy left Iana and said that she was going to meet Daniel at a CVS on Emerson Drive so that the two of them could make up after their argument. At 12.06 p.m., Nancy's phone registered near the Malabar gun range in Palm Bay, and that 5:26 was the final active location from her phone. Once investigators learned that Nancy had told Ayanna that she was going to meet Daniel that morning, obviously, they wanted to talk to him. On February 19th, Palm Bay Police Officer Corey 5:40 Presley went to Daniel's home for a welfare check. He told Officer Presley that he had not seen Nancy in weeks and claimed that he didn't even have her phone number. Well, while he's flapping his gums and obviously lying, investigators were 5:55 pulling information from Nancy's phone that and the infotainment system inside her van. BCSO digital forensics agent Jason Hammond used Burla software to reconstruct movements from the Odyssey and the Celebrite to examine Nancy's phone. Her WhatsApp record showed two 6:13 rejected calls and one missed call from Nancy to Daniel on the morning she disappeared. I thought he didn't even have her phone number! Investigators also started looking at Daniel's black Chevrolet Silverado. Flock license plate cameras showed his truck 6:30 making repeated late-night trips into a remote area of Palm Bay known as the Compound. Now, the Compound is roughly 12.2 square miles or about 2,700 acres of undeveloped land in western Palm Bay. Rhodes had originally been laid out there 6:49 for development in the early 1990s, but the development stalled, and that left much of the area heavily overgrown and isolated, and it was frequently used by trespassers. By March, BCSO had Daniel under intensive surveillance. On March 7th and 8th, 7:09 Game Over Task Force agent Tyler Harrell followed Daniel's movements into the compound near Maury Court and Walscott Street. Agent Harrell eventually went into the area on foot and hid in the brush overnight. That is dedication. While he was 7:26 out there, he heard a loud metallic pinging sound. When daylight came, he found freshly disturbed dirt with circular grind marks that appeared to have been made by a shovel. Then, on March 8th, Agent Lee interviewed Daniel again. This time, 7:44 his story was different. Instead of saying that he hadn't seen Nancy in weeks, or that, you know, he didn't have her phone number, he admitted that the two of them had planned to meet on February 15th, but he claimed they had called it off. Then Daniel admitted that 8:00 he had actually seen Nancy that morning. So it's like, by this time, which story is it? Did you know her? 8:08 Did you not know her? Do you have her number? 8:10 Do you not have her number? Did y'all meet? Did y'all, like, come on. He said that he saw her pumping gas at the BP station, but was pissed off and decided not to approach her, blocked her number that, you know, he didn't have, and drove the long way home. When 8:27 investigators confronted him with texts and WhatsApp records between him and Nancy, Daniel said that those records had been forged. Basically, he said AI did it. and compared it to things that he claimed had happened while he was in the Army. So, 8:43 the government and tinfoil hats and all that stuff. For some reason, they came into your WhatsApp, fabricated this to set you up for taking the fall for her missing? 8:57 Because her missing had something to do with the Army? Like, make it make sense to me, please. Sheriff Wayne Ivey later said, quote, In both of those interviews, Stearns showed significant areas of deception and truly identified himself as a 9:13 prime suspect in the case. I mean, he 100% did. 9:17 Investigators also searched Daniel's internet history, and some of what they found was very specific. There were visits to Aligor.com. Oh, wait, no, my bad. It's called Alivegor.com. I don't even want to know. 9:32 involving graphic content including, quote, woman dies of stab wounds, uncensored videos, murder, execution, suicide, terrible accidents. Who would want to watch anything like that? There was also a search asking, quote, 9:47 which materials can hide you from thermal devices? And another asking, quote, if I lose a lot of blood, how long before I can't put it back into my body? What? If I lose a lot of blood, how long before I can't put it back into my body? You can't put 10:05 it back into your body. What are you talking about? 10:09 Investigators also found Amazon searches for high-powered tactical torches and butane torches, along with searches about local crimes and missing persons. 10:20 One of those was, quote, two black teens found dead at the compound, and investigators said it was searched days before police had even contacted Daniel. By then, the BCSO Game Over Task Force, Fugitive Unit, and Aviation Unit were 10:36 maintaining around-the-clock surveillance on Daniel. They were like, it is go time. We are going to use everything at our availability to watch this guy. Altogether, they logged more than 50 continuous hours watching him. Oh my God. Late on 10:54 March 8th, Agent Tyler Dunn saw Daniel loading items, including the shovel, into the bed of his Silverado. Then at around 4.15 a.m. on March 9th, Daniel left his house in the truck and headed towards the western side of Palm Bay. Above him, Deputy Connor Gray was flying a 11:14 BCSO Star Helicopter equipped with thermal infrared cameras. Now, somebody tell me in the comments. No, I'm not going to look it up. I know I can. But somebody tell me in the comments, how is he not hearing this? 11:27 Is this a specialized helicopter that doesn't make a lot of noise or something? Deputy Gray conducted two surveillance flights that morning and at one point had to temporarily break away to refuel before returning to the area. From above, 11:43 Deputy Gray watched Daniel drive deep into the compound near Sauce Bowl Avenue. Daniel stopped his truck, got out with a shovel and a bucket, and walked approximately 50 feet into the wood. Then the thermal equipment captured him dumping 11:59 material from the bucket into the C-54 canal. Ground officers moved in as Daniel returned towards his Silverado and detained him, and I know his butthole was puckered. Because he knows he went out there and did something that he was not supposed to be doing. It's not like he had 12:17 like kitchen oil in the bucket and he just dumped it. 12:20 You know what I'm saying? But honestly, even if you did something that, you know, you weren't doing anything wrong. 12:26 If you just saw a bunch of police officers running towards you with their guns drawn, your butthole's going to pucker anyways. Tell me I'm wrong in the comments below. 12:36 Inside the truck, investigators found shovels, work gloves, a tarp, and a bucket. There was also an empty butter container that investigators believed had been used to scoop ash. BCSO Corporal David Lovell brought in human remains Detective K-9 Tito, 12:55 and Tito alerted to the odor of decomposition at five different locations, including the tailgate of Daniel's Silverado. After Daniel was taken into custody on March 9th, he gave detectives his own account of what he claimed had happened with Nancy. 13:14 Daniel said that he and Nancy had gone to the compound for a shooting lesson. According to him, he was holding his Glock 17 P80 pointed downrange in what he described as a vulnerable position when Nancy just suddenly lunged 13:29 for the gun just out of nowhere. What? According to him, Nancy, quote, forced him to kill her. Daniel claimed that there was a struggle and he feared for his life so he said that he shot her once in the head or you could have shot her in the leg and incapacitated 13:48 her or you could have shot her in the hand and incapacitated her or you could have ran being that she didn't have a gun and you did so if you were far away from her she couldn't have done anything or or or. But I still come back to, 14:04 she just suddenly lunged for the gun? Really? Daniel also admitted that he carried Nancy's body into the woods, came back later, poured lighter fluid on her, and burned her body. 14:16 He said that he collected the burned remains into plastic buckets and scattered them among five different areas of the compound because he did not trust police. That makes no sense. 14:30 But notice that he said five areas, and that's where Tito looked, too. Five different areas. On March 10th, Sheriff Ivey publicly announced Daniel's arrest for second-degree murder, abuse of a dead human body, and tampering with evidence. Sheriff Ivey 14:48 said of Daniel, quote, This is a horrific individual. And Judge Steven Henderson ordered Daniel held without bond. Meanwhile, investigators were searching the area where Tito had alerted. Crime scene investigator Conrad Schneider documented one of the main recovery areas 15:07 near Sauceville Avenue, including what appeared to be a fire or bucket area. Near a creek, investigator Schneider found a sandal-type shoe and indentations in the sand that matched the curvature of a bucket. There was also aluminum cans, footprints, 15:24 and tire tracks throughout the area that which showed that other people did regularly enter the compound. Dive teams also searched a nearby lake, but didn't find anything there. Crime scene technicians spent days sifting through ash, dirt, water, and soil. Eventually, 15:43 they recovered more than 800 burned bone fragments and several pieces of tissue. Latent print examiner Caitlin Peele also initially analyzed 18 fingerprint lifts from Nancy's Odyssey without getting anything useful, but among the tissue recovered from the compound was a 16:03 skin fragment with a fingernail still attached that had been painted red and gold. Examiner Peele cleaned the tissue, wrapped it around a gloved finger, and and rolled it through the black ink to create a friction ridge print. And 16:19 it matched Nancy's left middle finger. Former FDLE serologist Joseph Kennedy examined Nancy's full DNA profile using her toothbrush. Some of the evidence from the compound had been too damaged by heat and environmental exposure to produce useful DNA. Swabs 16:41 taken from a lighter produced insufficient DNA, and recovered scalp and hair fragments did not have roots. Daniel's DNA, however, was found on the steering wheel, but it was from his own Silverado. However, through the extensive forensic work, on 17:01 March 12th, the BCSO identification unit formally confirmed that the partial remains recovered from the compound were belonged to Nancy. 17:11 Investigators ultimately confirmed that Nancy had been shot in the head and that her remains had been burned, dismembered, and scattered among multiple locations, just like Daniel said. Then the case took more than two years to reach trial. Daniel's 17:29 trial began on September 26, 2025, in Brevard County, before Circuit Judge Catherine Spiker, and by then Daniel was 35 years old. Assistant State Attorneys Bernadette Serafinowicz, Samantha Barrett, and Trevor Personnier prosecuted the case, while Defense Attorney Bradford Fisher 17:51 represented Daniel. Agent Peterson, one of the two detectives who had led the homicide investigation, was on paternity leave during the trial. Now, before prosecutors could present the case to the jury, however, they lost what would have been one 18:07 of their strongest pieces of evidence. Judge Speaker suppressed Daniel's entire statement to police after ruling that it had been obtained in violation of his Miranda rights. That meant the jury would not hear that Daniel had confessed to shooting 18:26 Nancy or what he had said he had done afterwards. 18:30 So prosecutors had to prove the murder using the remaining physical, digital, forensic, and circumstantial evidence they had. The state's theory was that Daniel had become increasingly jealous and angry because Nancy would 18:45 not agree to the exclusive relationship that he wanted. Then you break up with her. and you find somebody who wanted an exclusive relationship to hell. Rather than relying on his suppressed confession, prosecutors built their case around Nancy's routine 19:01 before she disappeared. The phone and digital evidence, Daniel's movements, surveillance from the compound, and the remains investigators eventually recovered there. 19:12 Some of that evidence was challenged heavily by the defense. 19:16 For example... Regular AT & T records did not show to Daniel's phone number, although AT & T custodian Monica Hasburn explained that calls made through WhatsApp would not appear on an ordinary carrier bill. Defense attorney Fisher also challenged 19:35 gaps in the surveillance operation, pointing out that there were periods when officers knew where Daniel's truck was, but could not actually see what he was doing. The defense raised similar questions about the physical and digital evidence. Attorney Fisher 19:51 questioned limitations in human remains detection work and the possibility of false positive canine alerts, and he also challenged how web history data was interpreted, emphasizing that some browser records can obtain links that load automatically instead of showing something 20:10 a person deliberately typed into the search bar, which can happen. 20:15 Prosecutors also presented surveillance evidence from the compound, including two infrared flights flown on March 9th by former deputy Connor Gray, who by the time of the trial was working as a civilian at Blue Origin. The footage showed Daniel inside 20:32 the area, shortly before his arrest. Dr. Matrina Schmidt, a former associate medical examiner, testified that she examined skin fragments ranging from about 4 to 29 centimeters, along with matted hair, teeth, and pieces of Nancy's skull. I... couldn't imagine. Dr. Schmidt 20:54 identified a defect in the frontal bone showing external beveling, which she said was consistent with a projectile exiting the skull. 21:04 She determined that Nancy's cause of death was a gunshot wound to the head and classified the manner of death as a homicide. Forensic anthropologist Dr. Heather Walsh-Haney also examined the bone fragments, many of which were only about half 21:20 an inch to three inches and a half long, because of the extreme heat damage. She determined that all of the fragments came from one person and found evidence of blunt force trauma to the left side of the skull. 21:34 She also identified a semicircular defect in a frontal skull fragment with external beveling that also was consistent with a gunshot exit wound near the right eye and temple area. 21:48 The defense focused closely on what those remains could not prove. 21:53 No entrance wound had been identified among the recovered skull fragments, and x-rays did not reveal a bullet or other projectile fragments. 22:03 When attorney Fisher asked Dr. Walsh-Haney whether the skull defect could have been caused by something other than a bullet, she said that that was possible, although unlikely. He also questioned whether the defect could have been a keyhole entry 22:18 wound rather than an exit wound. DNA evidence also had its limitations because of the condition of the remains. Serologist Kennedy explained that Nancy's reference DNA profile had been developed from her toothbrush, while some of the evidence recovered from 22:34 the compound could not produce usable DNA because of the heat and environmental damage. Attorney Fisher argued that the state could not prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, exactly how the fatal shot happened or that Daniel intentionally fired it. He 22:50 suggested several possibilities, including an accidental discharge, a struggle over a gun, self-defense, or suicide. Because you just gotta throw suicide in there. We already know that Daniel confessed to doing it, so you didn't have to say suicide. You 23:08 know how detrimental that would be to her kids to learn that? If that's what you were putting forward and they had to read that in the paper, do you know how bad it would make the children feel? But you know, your defense, your only job is to win, 23:23 so I don't think you care. The defense also tried to separate Nancy's death from what Daniel did afterwards. Attorney Fisher's position was that if the shooting had been accidental or self-inflicted, Daniel could have panicked and made terrible decisions 23:39 afterwards without those actions provided that he had deliberately murdered her. 23:44 He even characterized the destruction of Nancy's remains as an attempt to cremate her after her death rather than proof of calculated mutilation following a murder. Is he freaking serious? 23:59 After the state rested, Attorney Fisher asked Judge Spiker to enter a judgment of acquittal, but she denied the motion. 24:07 I rest my case, Your Honor. Now, you know, I will just ask you to acquit this entire case. What? 24:13 Daniel chose not to testify, and the defense called no witnesses of its own, relying instead on cross-examination, and what Attorney Fisher argued were gaps in the prosecution's evidence. During closing arguments, Attorney Fisher again emphasized that there was no 24:30 direct evidence showing Daniel intentionally fired the shot that killed Nancy and asked the jury to consider the alternative explanations that he had raised. Assistant State Attorney Barrett argued that the evidence could not be viewed one piece at a time. 24:47 The prosecution's position was that Daniel's jealousy His change in statements, his digital activity, his movements around the compound, and the physical and forensic evidence all worked together to prove second-degree 25:02 murder beyond a reasonable doubt. The state rejected the defense's suggestions of accident or suicide as unreasonable. And I agree with the prosecution. Shocker, I know me agreeing with the prosecution is like, what, 95% of the time? On the 25:21 afternoon of October 6, 2025, after closing arguments and the prosecution's rebuttal, the case was turned over to the jury. 25:30 Jurors deliberated for about two and a half to three hours before returning a unanimous, guilty verdict on all three charges, second-degree murder with a firearm, abuse of a dead human body, and tampering with evidence. Daniel returned to Judge Spiker's courtroom, 25:51 First sentence in on December 3rd, 2025. Assistant State Attorney Barrett told the court, quote, the defendant was angry at Ms. Harari. 26:01 He was jealous because she was seeing other men and that their relationship was not exclusive. She was not, to quote him, following his relationship rules. I'm sorry, sir, but that's your relationship rules. I don't remember where you gave 26:16 birth to me and told me that, you know, I have to follow your rules. How about you follow your own daggone rules? How about you follow other people's rules and saying, like, what, murder is wrong? How about that? 26:30 Follow rules that were put forth for you first before you ask people to follow your personal rules. Todd then spoke on behalf of himself and the children. Quote, what he has done to Nancy was demented and defective. It wasn't just a murder, okay? It was a savage slaughter. 26:50 Daniel's family was also there, including his mother, father, and siblings. 26:55 His mother, Gloria Stearns, became emotional when it was her turn to speak. Quote, I just want to tell him I love him, I miss him, and I'm always going to be there for him when he needs me. And I want to say sorry to the other party. Be nice. 27:12 I'm finding it. It take you that long to find it? 27:15 It does. It does. Uh. Because I just, I have nothing nice to say here. I mean, I know that's your son. I thought of something to say. Would you tell him he was wrong? Or would you just tell him I love him, I miss him, and that I'm always going to be there for him? You know what 27:36 I'm saying? Are you going to tell him he was wrong to murder somebody because she didn't follow his rules? 27:45 As the prosecution is a legend, let me put it that way. But he did say that he murdered somebody. 27:50 He did confess to that. He just didn't say that, you know, it was because I was a jealous fool because she wouldn't follow my relationship. So, but anyways. So as the prosecution is a legend, would you tell him he was wrong? Or would you just only give him 28:06 the positive affirmations even though he did something so freaking heinous? 28:13 And I know some moms like this when it comes to their boys. Woo, it's a sore spot, so I'm going to shut my mouth. Gloria became so overwhelmed that she had to be helped from the courtroom. Judge Spiker gave Daniel the maximum sentence, a life in prison without 28:33 the possibility of parole for second-degree murder, plus an additional 22 years for abuse of a dead human body and evidence tampering. Outside court, Todd said that he was relieved that, quote, the case is finally over. What happened took away my 28:50 children's mom. It took Nancy away from her life. So what do you think? The jury never heard Daniel's confession, even though you and I heard it. They never heard it. 29:02 They had to decide this case using his changing stories, the digital evidence, police surveillance, and the forensic evidence recovered from the compound case. Even though the defense was working hard, they were working overtime. Do you hear me to say that? Oh, well, 29:20 you had police surveillance, but you couldn't really see what he was doing. Oh, yeah, he changed the story because he was panicking. Maybe she committed suicide. They were working overtime. 29:30 So tell me, if you had been on the jury, let's do the fake lamb jury, as we sometimes do, would that have been enough for you to find him guilty of secondary murder? Remember, we heard his confession, you and I, the lambs. But if you were on the jury, 29:46 you didn't hear his confession. All you had was a circumstantial evidence from the prosecution with the defense fighting that. 29:55 And I mean, other than the suicide and some of their... 30:00 defense was logical. Some of them was just stupid. They were just grasping at straws. So if you hadn't heard Daniel's confession and you were just going with what the prosecution said and then what the defense was arguing, would that have been enough for you to find him guilty 30:18 of second degree murder beyond a reasonable doubt? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below. Let me know. Yes, let me know. You know, personally, I think the prosecution did a good job with all the evidence that was coming out. I totally would have found him guilty of 30:36 second-degree murder without a reasonable doubt. And then the fact that he didn't even jump up to defend himself was kind of suspicious to me as well. So I would have found him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Let me know what you think in the comments below. And before 30:54 I let you go, I did say that I wanted to tell you about the Patreon. So as you know, every case I cover involves real people whose lives mattered. 31:04 And while we can't change what happened to them, we can make sure that their stories aren't forgotten. We can learn from them, recognize warning signs, and hopefully have conversations that might make a difference in somebody else's life. For instance, 31:19 if somebody is with somebody else, who doesn't want to be exclusive, but they want to be exclusive. Maybe they'll listen to this episode and say, hmm, maybe murder is a stupid moronic option. And I'll just go break up with this person and find somebody who wants to be 31:35 exclusive with me. Right? And that's what I want Love and Murder to continue doing. But I can't do that without your support. Research and writing and producing these episodes does take time and resources. And if you want to help me keep these stories coming, one of the best 31:53 ways you could do that is by joining the paid LAM fam over on the Patreon. Patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. 32:01 And as you know, the other thing that, you know, I've been going through that I'm not going to mention here, especially since my daughter is right here. Y'all know I don't want to mention it. Plus, I'll probably start crying my damn self. So we have that added bill and 32:15 emotional stressor happening in my family right now. And by joining the Patreon or the other ways that I'm going to give you is another way that you can help support the podcast and support my family if you so choose. 32:29 And with your contribution, you wouldn't just be supporting the podcast. 32:33 You're actually getting more love and murder to exclusive bonus cases after shows, ad free listening and extra content that you won't find on the regular feed. But I know, I know not everyone can afford another monthly subscription and 32:47 that's completely okay. You can still help me for free by just following Love and Murder on Facebook, watching and sharing my videos, or simply sharing this podcast with someone you think who needs to hear these stories. Very easy, 33:01 free ways that you can still help us out. Because at the end of the day, it's not just about growing a podcast. It's about making sure the people at the center of these cases are remembered and that their 33:13 stories continue reaching people and maybe help at least one person. So, patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. The Facebook link is in the show notes below. Or just share this episode. And with all that said... That is all I have for you today. 33:33 Thank you so much for listening. Thank you so much for your support. And I will see you in the next episode. Bye.
Community discussion