0:00 Can you imagine spending days believing your spouse might be killed, only to eventually hear recordings of what was actually happening while you were trying to save them? On the afternoon of Friday, September 4, 2009, 38-year-old Reed Allen Gray returned 0:19 to the oceanfront home that he shared with his wife and their two daughters in Ponte Verde Beach, Florida. The house looked orderly, and there was no obvious signs of forced entry or a struggle, but his 37-year-old wife, Quinn 0:33 Hannah Gray, was gone. On the kitchen counter, Reed found a handwritten note in Quinn's handwriting saying, quote, There are three men holding me right now, and they want $ 50, 000 cash. 0:46 Stay at the house. No cops. Keep your cell phone on you. Keep the kids with you. Please do this, honey. Please. 0:53 According to the note, Reed supposedly owed $ 75, 000 to an Albanian loan shark, and the men holding Quinn were trying to collect part of that debt. Reed was warned that his car was being tracked by GPS and threatened that 1:08 Quinn would be killed if he involved law enforcement. Reed had also received a phone call from Quinn. She told him that she'd been taken at gunpoint by three men in her white Mercedes SUV and said the note at the house explained what they wanted. Even though Reed was 1:25 terrified that calling for help might get his wife killed, he still dialed 911. Quote, My wife made a phone call to me. She was held by gunpoint by three men. 1:36 There's a note on the table with the gunman's demands. 1:39 If I call the police, they will kill her. It sounds like a freaking movie, but it's not. Reed was so concerned about what the supposed kidnappers might do that he hesitated to even give the dispatcher his address. He didn't want marked patrol cars suddenly pulling up to the 1:55 house with lights flashing while men claiming to monitor his movements were threatening Quinn's life. He told the dispatcher, quote, I'm not going to just have you guys roll in there, but a gun's a gun. If that's really what's going down, 2:09 then I need to know that I'm talking to somebody who really knows what they're talking about. The St. John's County Sheriff's Office and FBI began treating Quinn's disappearance as a genuine high-risk kidnapping. They had a ransom note, a 2:23 husband who appeared terrified, and direct communication from Quinn claiming armed men were holding her. So investigators launched a major search and surveillance operation that would eventually cost the sheriff's office more than $ 86, 000. During another phone call with law 2:42 enforcement listening, Quinn sounded frantic and angry. She yelled at Reed, quote, Why aren't you answering your phone faster? What the F is wrong with you? I've been tied up all night long, Reed. 2:54 You need to get in the car with the money and go down Butler Boulevard. He's got the cops. You're going to get me killed. Welcome, lambs. Welcome to Love and Murder, Heartbreak to Homicide. I am your host, Kai. 3:06 And before we continue... Make sure you're subscribed to Love & Murder on whatever podcast platform you're currently listening on so you never miss an episode. And if you want to keep up with everything happening with the show, come 3:18 follow Love & Murder for free at patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. 3:22 If you'd like to get even more Love & Murder while helping me to continue telling victim stories, you can also join one of the paid Patreon tiers and become part of the LAM fam at patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. 3:35 And I'll tell you more about Patreon at the end of this episode, but in the meantime, let's get back to this case. Quinn and Reed had been married since October 2000 and had two daughters, ages 6 and 8. 3:47 They lived in an estimated $ 4 million oceanfront home where the monthly mortgage payments exceeded $ 25, 000. That's more than some people make a year. Reed was the chief operating officer at Advanced Home Care, a successful healthcare equipment business, and 4:07 the family had significant money. I mean, yeah, $ 25, 000 a month, I can only imagine. Their marriage wasn't nearly as comfortable as their finances made it look. There had been heavy drinking, distrust, and allegations of infidelity on both sides. Reed later told 4:26 investigators that Quinn developed a serious dependence on alcohol. frequently stayed out partying, and went to bars where she dated men who were around 10 years younger than she was. 4:37 He described one occasion when Quinn came back home in the middle of the night heavily intoxicated, carrying her underwear inside her handbag after spending the night with another man. 4:48 By June 2009, Reed told Quinn that she needed to enter treatment for alcohol abuse or he was going to file for divorce. Quinn went to the Hazelden Treatment Facility in Minnesota, and completed treatment that June. Reed said that the eight weeks after she came home were some of 5:05 the best they'd had in their marriage, although the deeper problems between them hadn't disappeared. Quinn believed Reed was controlling, suspected he had money hidden in offshore accounts, and apparently believed that he wanted her harm, while Reed described a 5:21 marriage that had been damaged by drinking, infidelity, and years of distrust. None of that changed what investigators were dealing with on September 4th. As far as the police knew, Quinn was still missing. On Saturday, September 5th, Quinn started 5:37 giving Reed increasingly specific instructions for getting that money together. 5:43 Because he was supposedly limited in how much cash he could withdraw from a single bank branch, Reed was told to visit five different branches and take out about $ 9, 500 at each one. One set of instructions sent him towards 5:58 Butler Boulevard, while another ransom drop was supposed to happen at a Chick-fil-A. Police and federal agents were watching while trying to stay out of sight. But before the exchange could happen, Quinn called again and said the men holding 6:12 her had spotted undercover officers, and the drop was canceled. 6:18 At that point, investigators had to consider the possibility that whoever was behind the kidnapping was either had people watching the area or somehow knew more about the police operation than they expected. My question is, why am I only 6:33 talking to Quinn, though? Isn't it usually the kidnappers on the phone, probably with a voice disguiser, telling you what to do? The instructions changed again on Sunday, September 6th, and this time Quinn's mother was told to make the delivery. 6:49 A text message sent her to a public restroom near the beach, where she found instructions telling her to leave her phone behind and take the money to a nearby seafood restaurant. Quinn's mother followed the directions and left a 7:03 bag of cash. Undercover officers watched from nearby, waiting for someone connected to the kidnapping to pick it up. Two men eventually approached the bag, took it, and drove away. 7:14 and officers stopped the vehicle believing they might have had someone connected with Quinn's disappearance. Finally, some answers. Instead, the car contained four German tourists' visit in Florida. They'd found an unattended bag filled with cash, picked it up, and 7:33 were actually in the process of calling 911 to report what they'd found when police stopped them. By Monday morning, September 7th, Police still had no confirmed kidnappers, no successful ransom exchange, and no reliable location for Quinn. Then, after 7:51 three days of calls, threats, and failed money drops, she suddenly reappeared in a mall parking lot in Orange Park in Clay County. Quinn called 911 herself and waved a red Coca-Cola can so respondent deputies could identify her. Crying 8:08 into the phone, she said, quote, My name is Quinn Gray. 8:12 and I was kidnapped, and I'm not sure where I am right now. I was kidnapped on Friday for money, for money that my husband owed, and he literally raped me, and I just want to see my kids. Quinn said she'd been dropped off from a van after spending three 8:27 terrifying days in captivity. According to her, she'd been taken at gunpoint, moved between vehicles, restrained with duct tape, and strapped to a chair in the back of a van. 8:39 She also said she'd been held in a dark garage or warehouse and was repeatedly sexually assaulted by one of the men. Investigators initially continued treating Quinn as the victim of a violent kidnapping and sexual assault. As detectives and 8:54 FBI agents started interviewing her in detail, though, parts of the story became difficult to reconcile. Her descriptions of where she'd been held, how she'd been restrained, and what happened during those three days kept changing. and investigators also believed 9:10 her physical condition didn't match the prolonged restraint that she described. St. 9:16 Johns County Sheriff's Detective Kevin Kerr was among the investigators working through those inconsistencies. Quinn was given a polygraph examination and performed poorly, which wasn't proof that she had committed 9:29 a crime, but became another reason investigators continued questioning her account. 9:35 As the questioning continued, Quinn changed part of her story, and admitted that she'd had sex with a man named Jasmine. 9:42 She claimed the sex was a survival mechanism and said she pretended to cooperate and enjoy what was happening because she was afraid Jasmine would kill her or harm her children if she resisted. Um, so, did Jasmine kidnap you, 9:57 according to your story? Quinn gave investigators his name and information about a white Volkswagen Jetta, finally giving them a specific person to look for. Detectives eventually identified him as 25-year-old Jasmine Osmanovic, a Bosnian immigrant who operated an auto 10:16 repair and body shop from a warehouse in Jacksonville. As investigators started looking into Jasmine and trying to understand how he fit into Quinn's story, they learned that he hadn't simply entered her life during the supposed kidnapping. Quinn had 10:31 met Jasmine at a gas station roughly a month to six weeks before she disappeared, and the two had already begun a sexual relationship. Investigators continued tracing Jasmine's movements, and reviewed security footage connected to the area around the Emerson 10:49 Inn on Phillips Highway. On September 14th, law enforcement released surveillance images of Jasmine and his white Volkswagen Jetta to local news outlets as part of the kidnapping investigation. Jasmine saw his picture and car on the news and called 11:06 the sheriff's office to arrange an interview. By then, Quinn had accused him of being involved in her kidnapping and repeated sexually assaulting her, So Detective Kerr explained just how serious the situation was and the kind of charges Jasmine 11:22 could potentially be facing. And that was when the entire investigation changed. During that interview, Jasmine gave investigators a completely different version of what had happened. He said there had never been a kidnapping at all. According to Jasmine, Quinn 11:41 had never been kidnapped by anybody. and she and Jasmine had actually spent Labor Day weekend together while police, federal agents, and Quinn's family searched for her and tried to follow weird ransom instructions. Jasmine also had something to back up 12:00 his story. He said he'd become worried that Quinn might eventually blame the entire situation on him, especially if police got involved, So while they were staying together in room 207 of the Emerson Inn, he secretly recorded hours of 12:16 their conversations on his phone. Jasmine said, no, no, you ain't taking me down. Instead of sounding like someone being held against her will, Quinn could be heard talking casually with Jasmine, laughing about what was happening, discussing how she 12:31 would behave when she returned, and rehearsing parts of the stories that she planned to give her family and police. Wow. 12:39 At one point, Quinn said, quote, I don't think anyone in their wildest dreams would think that I could concoct something like this. During another conversation, she discussed how she would behave when she saw her mother again, saying, quote, 12:54 When I see my mom, I'll be hysterical. I can work it. Quinn was also recorded saying, quote, I'm just going to lie and lie and lie and lie. How am I going to prove that I'm telling the truth? Well, I guess people just believe me. Yeah, they'll believe me. 13:10 Then Quinn said, quote, $ 50, 000 is a lot of money, really. 13:16 Now that I'm looking at it, the way that what $ 50, 000 is going to mean to me in the future, either that or you could just blow his head off. And then Jasmine responded, say what? And Quinn repeated, either that or you just blow his head off. The recording also 13:33 captured the pair laughing about officers failing to find Quinn's Mercedes, which had been parked only about a block away from her house. Jasmine said, quote, I can't believe they didn't find your car. How stupid. And Quinn responded by laughing 13:49 and saying, quote, They're no fucking CSI. The tapes included consensual sexual encounters as well. In one recorded exchange, Jasmine asked Quinn whether Reed got as much sex as he did, and Quinn answered, quote, You know he doesn't. I guess 14:06 we're not that sexual. There were even conversations about making the kidnapping story more convincing. Jasmine suggested firing a bullet through a Coca-Cola can from a distance so Quinn could later show it to police and claim that one of 14:20 her captors was an expert marksman capable of killing her from far away if she cooperated with investigators. Once police knew Quinn and Jasmine had spent the weekend at the Emerson Inn, they could start checking what actually happened there. 14:36 Motel manager Andy Mohan also told investigators that Quinn had been moving around the property freely and didn't appear to be in distress. She was able to leave the motel on her own, including going to a nearby store to buy beer while Jasmine was away, and nothing that he 14:53 saw suggested that she was being held there against her will. 14:58 Combined with Jasmine's recordings and what investigators were now learning about their relationship, the evidence was pointing away from a kidnapping and more towards Quinn and Jasmine having spent the weekend together while everyone else was searching for her and 15:12 trying to deliver a $ 50, 000 ransom. Jasmine described it by saying, quote, It was the dumbest freaking kidnapping job on the face of the earth. St. Johns County Sheriff David Shore said, quote, The details of this case read like a book or 15:30 a TV show. It's by far the most convoluted, complex scheme I've ever encountered. On September 14, 2009, Jasmine was arrested and charged with felony extortion. Two days later, on September 16, detectives arrested Quinn at the Point Verra Beach 15:47 home and charged her with extortion as well. Her bond was initially set at $ 1 million before later being reduced to $ 200, 000 on the condition that she enter an inpatient mental health treatment facility in Georgia. Are they going for 16:03 the mental health route now? The case continued developing after the arrests. During a recorded proffer session on January 13, 2010, Jasmine told detectives that he'd had a loaded. 45 caliber handgun during Labor Day weekend. He agreed to cooperate with prosecutors, 16:23 plead guilty to extortion, and testify truthfully if Quinn's case went to trial. Part of that cooperation included revealing the location of the gun. Jasmine drew a map showing investigators where the gun and several pieces of Quinn's jewelry were 16:39 hidden inside his auto shop. He also claimed there had been a time where Quinn was alone in the motel room with access to the weapon, telling detectives, quote, When I opened the doors, she almost shot me with the 16:52 damn thing. Reed was furious, and I think that's an understatement, about the agreement and later complained directly to the judge, writing, quote, The fact that the state attorney's office recovered a loaded firearm on Thursday night, then struck a deal with the 17:09 defendant for his release the next morning and not tell the court or me, the victim, in this case is astounding. 17:17 Quinn's case never went before a jury, so the two sides never presented their competing explanations at trial. Her attorney, attorney Mark Miller, argued that Quinn's actions had to be viewed in the context of serious mental health. Didn't I 17:32 tell y'all? And substance abuse problems. The defense maintained that she suffered from severe bipolar disorder and alcohol dependency and had experienced a psychological breakdown that left her convinced that Reed wanted her harmed, and that real loan sharks were involved, 17:51 which doesn't make sense to me because you can hear in the recording that she didn't believe that. Attorney Miller also argued that Quinn's behavior around Jasmine could be understood as a survival response, similar to trauma bonding or Stockholm syndrome. Really? Bullshit. 18:09 According to that argument, Quinn laughing with Jasmine, cooperating with him, and having sex with him didn't necessarily prove that she felt safe or was voluntarily participating, and the defense said that she was trying to placate a man she feared 18:24 in order to protect herself and her children, and I call bullshit. The defense also questioned the financial motive. Quinn had access to substantial money through the marriage, so her attorneys argued that risking everything for $ 50, 000 didn't make sense 18:42 unless her thinking had been seriously distorted. I mean, you could use that argument for literally anyone. Murder didn't make sense unless your thinking was seriously distorted. The fact that you'd hit your boyfriend with a car didn't make sense 18:58 unless your thinking had been seriously distorted. The fact that you think your mother owes you her life savings so you strangled her for it didn't make sense unless your thinking had been seriously distorted. See how I made that 19:13 defense fit for everything I just said? The fact that I'm sitting here doing a podcast trying to get the victim's stories out there, working for myself where income isn't always the same, one month is great, the next month is horrible, instead of sitting in an office as a 19:30 project manager making six figures a year doesn't make sense unless her thinking has been seriously distorted. See what I did there? Assistant State Attorneys Jason Lewis and Jenny Dutton said, took the opposite position. Prosecutors believe Quinn was a willing 19:48 participant and the drug force behind the extortion scheme, pointing to her recorded conversations and scripted emotional performance she discussed. 19:58 They also talked about the fact that she had freedom to move around the motel, the observations of the motel employees, security footage, and phone records and Jasmine's cooperation. the state didn't actually need to explain anything more. Its position was 20:13 simply that Quinn's own words and actions showed that she wasn't behaving like someone who was trying to escape a captor. 20:20 While the criminal case was still pending, Reed filed for divorce on April 19, 2010, and sought primary custody of their daughters. The marriage was eventually dissolved, and Quinn received $ 10, 000 per month in court-ordered settlement payments. Did he have to 20:37 pay her alimony? I really hope, oh my God, I really hope those court-ordered settlement payments was like they were selling the house and this was her half of it. 20:54 I can't, oh my God, I'm such at a loss for words. I can't imagine that after she did this to him, he had to pay alimony. I really sincerely hope that that's not alimony 10%. thousand dollars a month alimony. 21:11 Oh my god. On February 11th, 2011, Quinn appeared in St. 21:17 John's County Circuit Court before Circuit Judge Wendy W. Berger and pleaded no contest to felony threats or extortion. Judge Berger withheld adjudication of guilt, meaning Quinn entered the plea and received the sentence without being formally adjudicated guilty. Huh? 21:37 Prosecutors supported the decision they did because it preserved the possibility that she could eventually obtain a registered nursing license and earn enough money to meet her financial obligations. Excuse me? 21:55 You can make that same argument for anyone then. There are murderers out there who have children and financial obligations. So... 22:03 we are going to formally adjudicate the guilty plea so that they could eventually obtain a registered nursing license and earn enough money to meet their financial obligations. What do you say, Your Honor? What kind of crap is this? 22:18 Judge Berger sentenced Quinn to seven years of probation and ordered her to continue mental health and substance abuse treatment. 22:26 Completely abstained from alcohol and illegal drugs, and have no contact with Jasmine and have no violent contact with Reed? What? 22:35 Quinn was also ordered to pay $ 43, 000 in restitution to the St. Johns County Sheriff's Office for the cost of the investigation, along with $ 2, 500 in prosecution costs. I mean, she does get $ 10, 000 a month, so I guess Reed 22:51 is actually paying this? And I'll say allegedly because I don't know if those payments are alimony or not. Jasmine was formally sentenced on March 14, 2011, receiving six years of probation and his own order to pay $ 43, 000 in 23:07 restitution to the sheriff's office. Neither Quinn nor Jasmine received a prison sentence. This is insane! Later that year, Quinn, who had also resumed using her maiden name of Hannah, faced an alleged probation violation. In October 2011, probation officers 23:26 accused her of falling behind on restitution payments and provided a written statement to Dateline NBC despite restrictions connected to the case. On November 9th, Judge Berger dismissed the violation complaint. 23:41 She found that Quinn's written statement didn't violate the specific terms of her probation and clarified that Quinn had the full seven-year probation period to satisfy her financial obligations. Just being rich, you're on a whole different level than everybody else. 23:59 In the years that followed, Quinn largely stayed out of the public spotlight. She remarried in 2013, although that marriage ended in divorce three years later, and she eventually became a certified yoga instructor. After he's turned into the Jacksonville 24:14 Beach area, I thought she was going to become a registered nurse. And also, I'm surprised someone married her. But then again, Gypsy Rose. That's all I'm going to say. 24:25 And that is the end of this insane case. What are your thoughts on this? Me, personally, what bothers me is just how quickly mental illness can become the explanation for everything after the fact. I absolutely believe mental health matters, 24:44 and I believe it should be considered in sentencing, but what I don't believe is that mental health diagnosis should only come from the defense. I think the prosecution should have had her tested as well. If you want to bring that defense into the court, then it's only fair 25:01 that both sides test the person. I also don't believe that having a diagnosis should automatically erase accountability. You know, you're bipolar, okay? Your behavior showed planning, manipulation, and awareness of what you were doing, and you knew it was wrong. 25:21 So the mental health diagnosis and you doing this are two separate things. Again, I'm not saying across the board. Obviously, if she was diagnosed with schizophrenia, for instance, and she was in a hallucinatory state, and this is actually what 25:40 she saw, and the evidence backed that up, not saying she had schizophrenia, here's the proof she has schizophrenia, and then she does this, or whoever, just a general person does this, but then you hear evidence that they're like, yeah, this is all a lie, ha ha ha ha ha. Yeah, 25:58 when I get out of here, I'm just going to cry and act hysterical because it's all an act. But you know, that's literally proof that you weren't going through an episode. Yeah, you have schizophrenia. But at this point in time, you were completely sane and knew exactly what 26:13 you were doing. See how they're two separate things? And I think sometimes they get blurred together way too much. 26:20 The sentencing also bothers me. I'm all for rehab when it makes sense. But there are cases where the consequences feel so disconnected from the seriousness of the conduct that it kind of starts to feel like accountability got watered down. 26:35 Nobody here, I guess Jasmine kind of took accountability. That's literally it. This whole case was deliberate, elaborate, and involved a lot of people who had no idea that they were being pulled into somebody else's crappy mess. And somehow 26:52 the final outcome just still feels like, no. Don't do that. 26:56 Bad rich person. I also don't buy the idea that because someone has money, access to money, or a certain lifestyle, that means financial motivation suddenly stops making sense. People do irrational things over money all the time, especially when money 27:16 is tied to control, independence, resentment, or wanting something that they feel that they're entitled to. More than anything, though, this case is one of those reminders that consequences matter not just because of what someone did, but because of 27:34 what they were willing to put everyone else through in order for them to be able to do it, you know? 27:41 That part is kind of what I think gets lost when the conversation becomes too focused on explaining the person who caused the chaos. So what do you think? Do you think the outcome was fair? I have a feeling most of y'all are going to say no. Or do 27:57 you think Quinn and Jasmine should have faced much harsher consequences? 28:02 And I just, I don't know. I just don't know what gets me more. The fact that an entire kidnapping investigation was launched over something that turned out to be fake? 28:13 Or the fact that Quinn and Jasmine walked away without spending time in prison? It's all infuriating, I'll say that. Also, can you imagine being Reed, the panic, the worry, thinking his wife was kidnapped and in danger, only to find 28:27 out that that woman spent the entire weekend cheating on him and traumatizing him? I don't even know how you would begin to process something like that. So let me know what your thoughts are in the comments below. And as I mentioned earlier, you can join the LAMFAM over 28:45 at patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder for exclusive bonus cases, ad-free episodes, and additional content. You can also follow for free at patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. But if you'd like another way to 28:59 support the podcast without spending anything, then come on over and follow Love and Murder on the Facebook where watching, commenting, and sharing my videos helps support the show. And the link to that is in the show notes below. And that is all I have for you today. Thank you 29:15 so much for spending part of your Friday with me. 29:18 Thank you so much for your support. Thank you so much for being part of the LAMFAM. And I will see you in the next episode. Bye.
Community discussion