0:00 Poor little Maria is a little slip of a woman. 0:02 Is it she? 0:03 Tanya, who's a very strong woman because she goes to gyms and everything, she garrots her with a piece of rope from behind on the orders of Joe. 0:12 Threw them out in a rubbish bag in a household bin and off they go, taken away to a tip. 0:22 I mean, what sort of an animal, a beast, whatever... 0:28 do that I'm Andrew. 0:29 Rule this is Life and Crimes last week we caught up with former police woman Narelle Fraser who talked to us at length about her career as a police woman and she's doing this because she has just starred in a documentary which is oddly. 0:46 Enough called The Police. 0:48 Woman I think you're starting to get the idea this week we talked to Narelle again because she has so many stories we couldn't fit them all into one episode Now, I've just been watching an advanced copy of your documentary and I was struck with quite a lot of it. 1:04 I was struck with one case. Tell me if it's a Box Hill rapist. There's certainly a prolific rapist. I think he raped 72 people. He was a young man who lived with his grandmother. And that brought home to me how good you were at sort of striking up 1:26 a rapport with people in order to do your job. 1:29 Can you tell our listeners the short version of that story? 1:33 I don't want you to redo the whole documentary, but what was that case and what led you to that rapist's grandmother's house? 1:43 I'm not very good at short versions, Andrew, but I'll do my best. 1:47 Okay. 1:49 We had identified this offender, and as you said, he'd raped a lot of women. 1:54 He stalked them. He raped them. Tied them up. Did some terrible things. And we identified him. We're at his house. 2:02 We're executing a search warrant. And it must have been about lunchtime. And the boys went and, of course, got him some McDonald's, as you do. 2:11 Half price. And we're sitting there having lunch. 2:16 And the boys must have gone outside to, I don't know, get a coffee or something. And I'm just sitting at the kitchen table with this young man. And... something came up about his grandma's cooking. And I said to him, just out of nowhere, I said, does your grandma make 2:34 bread and butter pudding? Because I don't think anyone could beat my grandma's bread and butter pudding. And so we then started talking about the ingredients that his grandma used and my grandma used. 2:46 And it only took about 30 seconds. 2:48 And that's when he just stopped telling me and he put his head in his hands on the table and goes. 2:54 Narelle, it was me. 2:55 I did rape those women. So I think it was more just like who would ever think that a discussion about bread and butter pudding would ever be a connection. 3:07 But that's how fickle or how minor some of those connections are. It doesn't have to be getting into, you. 3:16 Know, the deep and meaningful. So it was about bread and butter custard. 3:20 You establish this fine rapport with, Someone who had a grandmother like you did and suddenly he wanted to confess to you. Yep, yep. Whereas I take it he had not been answering questions very straightforwardly before that. 3:37 No, he didn't. 3:40 But after that, in fact, he actually agreed to a re-enactment. 3:45 And so for the next two days we did re-enactments and that was absolutely amazing. scary, mind-blowing stuff, that number of women that he had stalked. And he could tell us what some women wore to bed, what they were reading in bed. 4:04 Like, it was, boy. Yeah. And so that was the fellow that was called the Box Hill Rapist, was it? 4:12 Yeah, that's right. 4:13 Yeah, yeah. And it was in a pretty tight area, like 10th Street. 4:17 Very. 4:17 Those streets around Box Hill Central, yeah. 4:20 Yeah. 4:21 Okay. 4:21 Yeah. 4:22 And he got a long sentence, no doubt. 4:27 I know he's out now. 4:28 Yep. 4:29 Yeah, yeah. 4:30 I know he's out now and he's married with some children and I know. 4:34 That because I got. 4:37 An email from his sister and I never say his name anymore because she asked me. We had a lovely, well, it wasn't lovely at the start and here again is a bit about what understanding and compassion is But she absolutely, I named him on a podcast that I did years ago now. 4:59 Yes. And she said, how dare you? 5:02 You know, he's trying to get on with his life. 5:04 It's ruined our lives, our family's life. Anyway, bottom line is we had a few discussions via email. And in the end, she is actually, I wouldn't say a friend, but I said to her, I won't use his name again because it was causing so much grief. 5:21 To their family. 5:22 I mean, yes, she could say about the victims, but her family were a victim of his offending. 5:30 So he was quite a young man when he was arrested, yeah? 5:34 Oh, yeah. 5:35 He was only about 22, yep. 5:38 And he'd been living with his grandmother. Why is that? 5:43 He hadn't been getting on with his parents or something, his mum. And, yeah, he was living with his grandma, but, you know, he just looked like any young man walking down the street. In fact, he was quite a, like he was tall, he was really quite handsome. He had 6:01 everything going for him. I just, I could never get to the bottom of what it was. I think it was power. In fact, I'm sure it was power that he didn't have in his everyday life. 6:13 Did you form any opinions about the deep, seated reasons for some people offending, like that, you know, often I think we find that very violent people have been treated badly as kids often, suffered themselves, and it's sort of 6:32 a self-perpetuating cycle, it would appear. Did you see that with some of the people you dealt with? 6:40 I'd say most of the time, Andrew, most of the time... 6:46 You could find something that had happened that they had affected them and they'd never really been able to deal. 6:54 With it and just got angrier and angrier. 6:57 And I've always found sex offending, my view is, that it starts off as, you know, watching people masturbating. They'll then go to stalking and they really like that power. 7:13 And to me, stalking is the gateway to. 7:16 to nearly every rape that I've ever investigated. 7:19 Undoubtedly. 7:19 It's a really dangerous, it's a really dangerous offence and I don't think enough people really understand it. 7:27 Very interesting when you see the characters and the MO of certain people. I did a book many years ago about the man that's called Mr Stinky Raymond Edmonds, who of course was a multiple rapist and a murderer, although his murders were really part of a sex crime. He 7:47 was a rapist. But he was a peeping Tom. He was an arsonist. He'd burn things, a fire lighter. And he was cruel to animals. Now, in that way, he was a bit like Paul Dania, you know, that killed the three girls down at. 8:04 That's what I was just going to say. 8:06 All those attributes crop up again and again, don't they? 8:10 Yes, absolutely. 8:11 If they killed their sister's rabbit, Or killed their girlfriend's dog and they sneak around at night looking through windows and they light fires. 8:20 These are all warning signs, aren't they? 8:23 Absolutely. Huge. 8:24 Red flags. 8:26 Red flags. Absolutely. And you come across it so many times in your job. 8:32 Whereas somebody like Joe Corp, I'm thinking you had a lot to do with that case, the Joe Corp case. 8:39 Mm-hmm. 8:41 He strikes me as something like a classic narcissist, not necessarily been knocked around himself, but just a supremely selfish man. 8:51 Would that be right? 8:54 I don't know how to say anything nicely about Joe. No. 8:58 Remind our listeners who he was. He was the fellow who lived. 9:02 Just north of Melbourne, Craigieburn or out that way. And he was married to Maria, his wife. They had children, sort of suburban life, but he had a bad habit. 9:15 He was very keen on having affairs with a series of other women and he used to trawl those adult sites looking for partners. 9:23 Is that right? Yep, yes. 9:26 He was a hopeless womaniser and you're right, he had a number of affairs, but him and Maria, he went to Maria. 9:36 When you say hopeless, you mean he couldn't help himself, he'd keep doing it? Yeah. 9:40 Just pathetic. 9:42 A pathetic excuse for a man. 9:44 It was. 9:46 Yeah. And with Maria, he wanted to spice up their sex life. So he says to her, what about getting on the internet and going for a threesome? And like, Maria was just horrified. 9:59 However, I. 10:01 She thought well I need to keep the marriage alive I'll you know I'll give it a try and that's when unfortunately Tanya Herman was on the other end of an internet wanting a. 10:11 Threesome as well and all right really was. 10:15 The beginning of the end for the three of them well they'll It affected so many people. 10:21 You know, Joe ends up having an affair with Tanya. 10:25 Yep. 10:26 Oh, God. 10:27 Then he persuades Tanya, who's sort of a vulnerable person in her own way, that if she helps him dispose of his wife Maria, they can live happily ever after. 10:41 And Tanya is somehow inveigled into this and he basically works out a murder kit. gloves and rope and all this nonsense. And he gives himself an alibi by, you know, driving the kids to school or whatever it might be 10:57 or something, you know, he gets himself out of the house. Meanwhile, Tanya has been hidden in the corpse garage. She gets in the back of the corpse family car. And when Maria unsuspecting comes down, hops in the driver's seat, poor little Maria is a little slip of a woman. 11:18 Is it she? 11:18 Tanya, who's a very strong woman because she goes to gyms and everything, she garrots her with a piece of rope from behind on the orders of Joe and then drags around, unconscious body, puts her in the boot of the car, drives the car from the northern suburbs into the city. 11:36 Is that right? That's right. Or near about. 11:39 Crosses over the Princess Street Bridge, I imagine, I'm guessing here, and parks the red car. Corp family car up near the shrine where it sat in the February heat for four days. 11:52 That's right. 11:54 And this poor woman, she wasn't actually dead. She died in the boot. She died of. 12:02 No, she didn't die in the boot. She actually died in hospital six months later. 12:06 She died in hospital. 12:08 Oh, I'm sorry. 12:09 She was virtually dead when we found her. She was decomposing in the back of. 12:13 The boot, yeah. 12:16 Even though, but she's still, to some extent, her brain and heart was still working. Her heart was. Her brain wasn't, yeah. 12:25 So she was basically almost dead and survived for a while. 12:31 But he was charged later, wasn't he? He was charged, as was Tanya Herman. But Joe Corp was the architect of that whole thing, wasn't he? 12:41 Absolutely. 12:42 And you know what? Oh, what I could never get over was just the audacity, that cheek of him. When we went around, he reported her missing. So that next day we go around and say to him, you know, what's happened? Can you give us a bit of history 12:58 or whatever? And we go, do you know anybody that would want. 13:01 To harm Maria? 13:03 Because at this stage she's just missing. And, you know, he couldn't put Tanya under the bus quick enough. 13:09 He said, oh, you know. 13:10 Yeah, within minutes of us arriving at his house. But what he did was he told us all these lies about Tanya. We go around to see Tanya, of course, to, you know, get her side of the story. 13:23 It was like the complete opposite. Oh, they were in love. 13:26 They were going to get married. Jo was actually paying for her rent. And that's when we, I mean, you know, you smell a rat pretty bloody quickly when it was just, I thought, Why didn't, like, lots of people have affairs. 13:41 I'm sorry. 13:42 It's just the way it is. 13:43 Why would he have the guts to say to Maria, look, I've fallen in love with somebody else or. 13:48 Lust, whatever it be. But, oh, no, you know, he has. 13:51 To use Tanya to, and she did it willingly. 13:56 Look, you know, he didn't put a gun to her. 13:58 Or unwillingly. Yeah, she did it. Yeah, yeah. 14:01 Yeah. 14:01 And all she was looking for, Andrew, was love. 14:03 That's all she wanted. And she happened to, unfortunately, meet this man. So you've... Looking for love in all the wrong places. Isn't that a song? 14:12 All the wrong... That's true. She's... Yeah. 14:15 So you've dealt with some despicable people over the journey, over your time, what, nearly 30 years in the job? 14:23 Did you have? 14:24 27. How many years? 14:26 25 and two years on. 25 and two more. 14:27 Yeah. So you joined at 27, then you pretty well did another 27, near enough. 14:34 Yeah. Yeah. 14:35 You've dealt with some despicable people, but none more than him, would that be right, than Joe Corp? 14:42 I tell you who'd come close is John Sharp, the Morning Star monster. 14:46 Oh, my goodness. I think you've just– it's the clubhouse leader. 14:51 Well, for those who can't remember John Sharp, he's the fellow that planned to kill his wife and little girl and unborn child with. 15:00 A spear gun, is that right, and did it? 15:02 Oh, yeah. 15:03 And a chainsaw. 15:05 And a chainsaw. How cold-blooded was John Shaw? 15:08 And threw them out in a rubbish bag in a household bin, and off they go, taken away to a tip. 15:18 I mean, what sort of an animal, a beast, would ever do that? And, you know, you look at him, Andrew, and he's just. 15:28 A pathetic weed of a man. 15:31 You know? 15:31 Yeah, he was. 15:33 And I remember when. 15:35 the boys asked him, what was your reason for murdering Anna? 15:38 He actually said, because she was moody and controlling. That was his reason. And then they go, what's your reason for murdering little Gracie? And he goes, oh, really, she deserved to be with her mum. Oh, you crick. 15:54 Serious. 15:55 Oh, terrible, terrible, terrible thing. 15:57 Yeah. Now, how did somebody like him get to be in his 30s, I think he was, He held down a pretty fair job in a credit union or whatever it was, something, finance company. 16:10 A bank teller. Nothing against bank tellers. 16:12 No, no, no. No, nothing against bank tellers. 16:16 But he'd had a job for quite a while. He was paying off a house. He was, from the outside, quite a normal, respectable, law-abiding fellow. How had that inner demon, that evil streak, not shown itself earlier? 16:34 You know, I don't know how that manifested itself because, I mean, we never really got to the bottom of, like he's one of the few people that I've ever known to do something so horrendous like that and really had no sort of reason. You know, we came from 16:53 a really good family, you know, brothers and sisters and parents. 16:57 It was out of nowhere. 17:00 No real form. 17:01 We didn't sort of suddenly find out that he killed 10 kittens or. 17:05 No. No form. 17:08 No form whatsoever. It did come out of nowhere. 17:11 And that is rare, isn't it? 17:14 Very. 17:14 For an adult person to do something so out of character without having done something a little bit similar along the way. 17:24 That's right. But also, it wasn't just killing her, let's say, with a spear gun. 17:28 It's then... cutting her up with a chainsaw. 17:32 Like, it was just, it was one out of a box, really. 17:37 It was. 17:38 Yeah, that's the sharp case. Now, you dealt with some other pretty notorious things in your time in the job. 17:48 Take us through a couple of those. Did you have much to do with the child. 17:51 Abductions that we often hear about? Spectrum. Spectrum, the Mr. 17:57 Cruel case, yeah. 17:58 Yeah. 17:59 So-called, Mr Krukes. Yeah. 18:02 I was at child exploitation doing some temporary duties when that was sort of going. But no, I can't say I had a lot to do with that other than, you know, I'd go and do a few door knocks and, you know, pretty standard sort of stuff. But no, I didn't have a great deal to do with. 18:25 Spectrum, really. 18:26 No, Spectrum, of course, being the task force that investigated that series of abductions, which has become known in shorthand as the Mr. 18:35 Grill case. Do you have any feelings? I know police are a bit. 18:38 Divided on this case, for good reason, I would suggest. 18:42 Do you have any gut instinct about what did and didn't happen and whether the Carmen Chan case actually was one of the same group of abductions or perhaps separate? 18:56 Have you got any sense of that? Any feelings about that? 18:59 Look, it's only a gut feel that I have. I think it's probably all the same man. A very, unfortunately, a very clever man. Somebody that knows a lot about forensics. 19:11 You know, we've often thought about, you know, is he dead? 19:14 Has he gone overseas? Like, why did it just stop? 19:17 But no, no, I never really sort of, no, I don't have any. 19:23 No, no, no blinding insights or anything else? 19:25 Not really, no. 19:26 No, fair enough. 19:28 What other cases stick in your mind when you're just daydreaming away quietly up in the country and having a nice life? Do some things float back into your mind? 19:39 A lot of them are to do with pornography, child abuse. 19:45 Material. I think this is really almost what. 19:49 did me in in the end was I did a fair bit of work investigating child abuse and there was one case where this young 11-year-old boy had been groomed by a young man and I did a joint investigation with It was with the AFP and I went along 20:12 to a warrant with the AFP for this child abuse material and I've never seen anything like it in my life. 20:22 We went to this pedophile to the house and I can remember walking in there and thinking, God, we've got the wrong house. 20:28 Like there's mum and dad. 20:30 They're having a cup of tea. He's the offender, let's say, the acute suspect. He was, I don't know, 22, but he's there with his girlfriend. They're getting married in, I think, the next month or something. 20:44 Yeah. 20:45 And it's like, you know, this is all wrong. And he had another brother there. And so we say, look, can we just have a look at you in your room? 20:53 We've got a warrant here. I just want to have a quick look at your computer. There was, we found, it took two days. We took it away because we saw some stuff on there that wasn't right, mind clearly. 21:07 We had the right house. 21:08 But it took me two days to view the child abuse material on his computer. And it was off the scale for anything. 21:19 I'd ever seen before. 21:21 And I remember this is towards the end of my career where I'd done a lot of warrants on pedophiles and sex crimes. But this one, like what we found were videos of child abuse material, not photos. 21:35 They were videos. So there was sound. There was, you know, visual. 21:39 And I can remember when I was looking, there was 1,700, and sort of halfway through the day, I can remember looking at one and going, whoa, and I put my hand over my mouth and I thought I was going to be sick. 21:53 Yeah. 21:54 It was completely, it's something. 21:56 I just wasn't, I'd never had that sort of response before. 22:00 Yeah. 22:01 And, yeah, anyway, but now I go past that house a lot. And there is not one day that I go past and I don't think about it. It's always in the back of my mind. 22:15 And a number of. 22:16 People have said to me before, this is crime scene experts. 22:21 Yeah. 22:22 And they said they'd never seen anything like that either. 22:24 They were just horrified. 22:26 So, yeah, that's pretty tough. 22:30 Over a quarter of a century of police work at the sharp end, was it? that stuff the child exploitation stuff that really knocked you around the most definitely police officers unless they're inhuman they must be they must be harmed to some extent by what they do and see 22:53 child abuse material must be some of the worst stuff that police do for those unfortunate enough to have to do it was that the thing that was worst for you. 23:02 Oh absolutely In fact, I'm thinking it's only about, I don't know, three years ago now that I was able, I can remember going to this party where there was lots of kids because I used to try and isolate myself. 23:16 I didn't want to go anywhere near kids because I used to get. 23:18 Triggered all the time. But I remember it was only three years ago I went to this party and there were some kids and I came home and I actually thought to myself, that is the first time I've ever seen kids playing And not actually being triggered. 23:33 It was quite a moment. 23:35 Like, I get triggered by just people with PTSD get triggered by the most normal things. I get triggered by kids. 23:45 I get triggered, and I still do, but I've learned, you know, the tools to manage it. But I get triggered. 23:51 Dogs are a trigger of mine. Now, everyone in the world nearly has got a dog. 23:56 I can never have a dog, you know, and I get triggered terribly by dogs. 24:00 So... You know, and blue tarps, which is what Anna was wrapped in. 24:06 Anna Kemp as in John? 24:08 John Sharp's wife. 24:10 John Sharp's wife, Anna Kemp. I'm with you, yeah. Yeah. Okay, the blue tarp would set you off. You'd never forget it. No. 24:17 So it's taken its toll in some respects. 24:20 Although you put on a very brave face to the world. 24:25 Is that one of the reasons you agreed to make this excellent documentary, The Policewoman? 24:31 No. 24:32 Because you wanted to sort of show, you know, the public what it's like behind the scenes and what you were thinking and the effects of it. 24:41 Is that a fair summary? Absolutely. 24:44 Yeah, absolutely. 24:45 I think for responders, as a rule, we carry a real. 24:51 It's like an invisible weight, really. 24:53 Yeah. 24:54 But I want the community to understand... the sacrifices that police make. And, you know, we don't want praise. We don't want, you know, pats on the back. 25:08 No. 25:08 But we just want, I suppose, I want police to be valued. I want them to be respected. Yes, there's some, you know, questionable police out there with questionable morals and beliefs. 25:21 That's in every part of our community. 25:25 Even journalists, I understand. They're not all good. No, you're right. 25:32 And that's why you agreed to make this documentary, The Policewoman. 25:36 Can you tell our listeners and our viewers when it's being released and how? How will they be able to see it? 25:44 Sure. Well, I'm absolutely thrilled and so proud. But Echuca has been the advanced screening. 25:53 That's the Victorian premiere. 25:55 Oh, great. 25:56 And that's on the weekend. And it's a sellout. I am just so thrilled. 26:01 So thrilled. So it opens when and where? 26:05 Echuca Paramount Theatre, it's an advanced screening. There's a couple of advanced screenings before it is released nationally on the 5th of November. 26:14 Oh, okay. 26:15 So even before the 5th of November, it'll be previewed at Echuca. 26:19 Which is great. Echuca, Bendigo, Melbourne at the Carlton Nova. 26:25 and Sydney, but these are all with Q & A. 26:28 So the director, Claire Paswalski, and myself, we have a Q & A at the end of these advanced screenings. 26:35 Oh, I see. 26:35 So people can have an opportunity to ask us questions and. 26:40 You know, maybe just see I'm real. See that you're real. 26:44 You're very much very real. 26:45 And although it's, you know, as you say, it's taken its toll on you, it hasn't spoiled you. You're still You're still underneath that kind-hearted 27-year-old girl that joined the job. 26:56 Yeah, I am. That's still you. 26:58 A lot wiser. A lot wiser. 26:59 A lot wiser and a little bit sadder, but you're still Narelle Fraser. 27:05 Yeah. 27:07 You know, when you say sad, I think I was sad a lot in the job. But now I think I'm relieved. I've changed my mindset now. I'm just so relieved. 27:19 I don't have to do another death message. I don't have to see another deceased little baby. You know, they're the positives. But, oh, no, there has been a lot of sadness. But leaving has probably really been the best thing for me. I didn't realise how damaged I was. 27:36 I was very, very damaged. 27:39 Just for the record, when did you give up? police work? 27:45 May of 2012. May of 2012, okay. 27:51 Yeah, yeah. 27:52 I had a number of just one thing on top of the other and. 27:55 In the end. 27:56 No worries. You said that'll do me. You've done your bit. 28:00 Absolutely. 28:01 Yeah. 28:01 Well, Narelle, it's been a pleasure to talk to you. 28:04 I've certainly heard of you for a good 30 years. 28:08 I remember you were always reasonably prominent and often quoted about certain things you seem to be at the sharp end of a lot of jobs and it's good to talk to you and we here at Life and Crimes wish you all the best with this excellent documentary and 28:24 rather unusual in a way they use figurines and things this excellent documentary The Police Woman which is really all about you Narelle Fraser Thanks for listening Life and Crimes is a Sunday Herald Sun production for True Crime Australia. 28:45 Our producer is Jonty Burton. For my columns, features and more, go to heraldsun.com.au forward slash Andrew Rule, one word. For advertising inquiries, go to newspodcastssold at news.com.au. That is all one word, newspodcastssold. And if you want further information, About 29:12 this episode, links are in the description.
Community discussion