0:00 In 1970s Melbourne, you could get with your mates, snatch schoolgirls and pack rape them for sport with bonding with your mates and probably nothing would happen. They enacted a 400-year-old common law about gross obscenity to cause horror to 0:19 one of Her Majesty's subjects. It was on the stand that one of the alleged offenders came to the realisation that the girls weren't just meat. 0:30 I'm Andrew Rule. This is Life and Crimes. This is the second part of our interview with the woman we call Donna, who endured an horrific assault on Melbourne Cup Day in 1976. Last week, we talked about her search for the truth and for the men responsible for that 0:48 horrific attack. So if you want to hear the story from the start, listen to that. This week, we talked with Donna about how she connected herself these evil men with other evil deeds. And now let's rejoin that conversation. 1:10 Gang rapes were a real thing in the 70s in urban Australia and to some extent in certain rural areas as well, particularly in Queensland I believe, up in the sugar country notoriously. And you were able to work out who some of these guys were, and then you looked 1:31 up other examples. Then you found cases where people have been arrested. And this is just all diligent research of old newspaper files and old all sorts of source material, open source material. And you're able to find collections of 1:49 names of offenders. Many of them repeat offenders. And what is shocking, I guess we shouldn't, I don't know why it's shocking, but still. What's shocking when you look through these names is that so many of these young teenagers and young men, 20, 21 year olds, 19 year olds, 2:11 who were in these rape gangs, like something out of Clockwork Orange, so many of them went on to be really bad, evil, serious career crooks. And Let's run through some of the names here, some of the names that you uncovered when you were looking at these rape gangs 2:34 from the 70s. Two brothers that our listeners will recall, Dennis Bruce Allen, later called Mr. Dead, responsible for the death of perhaps a dozen people directly and indirectly many others. 2:50 His brother, Peter Allen, they were co-offenders in crime. at least one rape of two, I think, two sisters who were teenagers, raped at pistol point or at gun point. 3:05 A very serious crime. There were the two Allen brothers and two other guys. Also offenders in the same era was a guy called John William Palmer. Now, Johnny Palmer was later a painter and docker. He served a lot of time in Pentridge for very serious crimes. And he was, 3:26 I think... locked up in H division in Pentridge, which meant he was a very violent man. And he was involved in a notorious thing called the great sausage war in Pentridge, which was a systematic war between prisoners back in the 1970s. So these guys, uh, these are just 3:47 some of the names of the really heavyweight crooks who were as young men involved in these gang rapes. But there's another one. There's another one that Chopper Reed used to talk about. His name was Gilbert. Now, Gilbert is still with us. He's still alive, as far as I know, 4:06 to this day. But our lawyers should note that he's a repeat offender. He's been before the courts many times over many decades. He started out at Tarana, a boys' home, where he was there with Chopper Reed back in the 70s, early 70s, and he went on to a long and 4:29 prolific career as a drug dealer and an all-round thug. Now, when you see pictures of the criminal Gilbert, and I know you have, what do you notice about his nose? 4:44 That there is a crease fold. So just to clarify, Catherine, after she came forward on Good Friday in 2003 when the article ran, she did do a statement and also Richard Parsons, the lead investigator, showed her photos and she 5:02 positively identified. And so she positively identified that man. So it was from the familiarity of my description that is what resonated with her. And that is why she came forward and then went through those procedures. One of the things I also wanted to say in response to what 5:24 you were talking about, it's that in the trajectory, so these were quite dysfunctional ecologies. And there's a thing called broken windows theory, which is, you know, someone just does a little graffiti or smash. And the neighbourhood becomes desensitised 5:42 and that normalises the lawlessness, even though they're visible signs of disorder. That creates a very safe ground for further criminality. 5:51 And so in that era in the 70s, it would be fair to say that what we would now maybe call toxic masculinity, but certainly we'd call it patriarchy, that there wasn't, this was a taboo subject and young girls were put in a dreadful situation of either, as I was, 6:12 treated like a tarnished slut, but no one really connected and unpacked what happened because people were just so appalled. 6:24 But unfortunately, that distaste for it, the horror of it, got projected. 6:31 At the girls. 6:33 And so the law treated them terribly, which is what happened with the Heidelberg rapes. 6:38 At this point, we should explain the Collingwood rapes a little bit. In the course of your research, obviously you knew everything about your own case, but then you widened it out, especially after those other two, after Catherine came 6:54 forward in 2003, after your story was first published, you sort of took, an interest in the context and in the fact that other events had happened. Now, the big one, and one of many, because these happened all over Melbourne 7:13 and they happened all over Australia, but one notorious case was the Heidelberg schoolgirl rapes. That's true, isn't it? That's correct. 7:21 A location that I've always tried to describe in words because the western suburbs was, you know, foreign ground for me. 7:28 Black Arch. 7:29 And if you remember that Saturday morning when I sent you a text and said, oh, my God, I've found the, I've jagged it, which fits the route that those guys would have taken on such a wet, rainy day. And so then I just did a bit of. 7:43 This is a Bluestone Railway Arch Bridge in. Correct. 7:47 It's apparently called the Black Arch. And so then I was looking up Sharpies. I had a look online, came up with a photographer, Carol Derrens, a black and white film I didn't know, in which, YouTube one, it was mentioned about the Heidelberg rapes. And so then I did 8:07 a bit of, you know, a little bit of researching and to my absolute horror, the figures are extraordinary. So 42 male suspects, 23 interviewed, 16 charged, 11 committed, a couple were fined. And I think you might know, Andrew, but I think it was only like Five or so 8:29 were successfully prosecuted and some got off on appeal, I think. 8:34 There was 225 offences, 87 complainants and witnesses. It's tallied as 24 girls, but there was actually more than that. 8:45 And if while we're on the tally, so my friend, school friend and I, two, Catherine and Amy, four. There's two girls in sunshine that we found a news article for. 8:59 Same MO that happened. 9:01 Yeah, same MO, yeah. 9:02 Station wagon. 9:04 The more you look, the more you found. Is that true? 9:06 There's two girls. That happened on 29 December 1973 and went to court in September 1975. So the MO is identical. 9:17 And then there's a clinical psychologist got in contact with me And had a client, he sent information. We'll call that person Maggie. So if you tally all that up in the same time period, that's 31 girls. And that's only the ones that I can say that there was 9:40 firsthand police statements or there's been media reporting to confirm and prosecutions. So they're reliable sources. There are others, by the way. just not able to be so absolute. The other problem that we came across is that these crimes, 9:59 for say that it's a Boolean, which is, you know, a search engine kind of thing, term, the terms are very different. So it could be gang, rape, pack, rape. 10:08 Yeah, I understand. It's hard. It's not always easy to find. 10:12 It's not easy, yeah. The point is that even though these big numbers that you've uncovered are These are the ones that are on the record somewhere. They're the ice above the surface of the sea. Below it are all the offences carried out that were never reported or there 10:33 were no arrests for, no convictions for. You could only really find those things that have been reported in the media in when arrests were made and people appeared in court, really. 10:45 Is that true? Well, I think. 10:48 You have the same experience as me, which is, you know, after the 2003 article, I recall you telling me that you were at some football dinner, AFL dinner, and people were asking you about it. And I remember you said a number of times that this is the experience that 11:07 people reference a lot because it's with disbelief that people people learn that there have been no successful prosecutions, charges or anything. Yeah. One of the, the Wayne guy was brought in for questioning in 2004. Yeah. And he came 11:28 in and did a no comment police statement because again, that's what they, they know what their choices are, which made it very difficult to progress from there. But yes, in 1970s Melbourne, You could get with your mates, snatch schoolgirls, 11:46 and pack rape them for sport with bonding with your mates, and probably nothing would happen. And if you speak with Colleen, the happenstance that occurred where the girls, the victims from those rapes, it was really by happenstance that it tripped 12:07 out of them. So it's like a real dark underbelly, to use your terminology. 12:12 Yeah, it is. And when you refer to Colleen, you're talking about Colleen Woolley. Now, she was a police constable back in the late 70s when I started work at Russell Street as a reporter. And I remember her reasonably well. 12:28 And she went on to a fairly long and obviously a good career. I think she's now got an order of Australia. What did tell us about her career? work on the Heidelberg rapes and others? 12:43 So as much as I know, because of course Colleen can give more detail, but Colleen had been in the South Australian Auxiliary Police Force and then she had been in New South Wales. She had done the training to join the Victoria Police Force when she was in, maybe 13:00 it was Preston Police Station. And so she was 28 and an experienced officer, you would have to say by. 13:07 That point, but still under supervision. 13:11 So two girls, I think, came in and then one of them said something and the other one was more like, that happened to me too. And then it just grew like topsy. 13:21 This is at Heidelberg? 13:22 This is at Heidelberg, Watsonia, they call them. 13:25 Heidelberg, Watsonia. Yeah. She was stationed out there in the northern suburbs. Yeah. And so she noticed this pattern of reporting. Yes. 13:36 So 40 detectives got involved with it. They enacted a 400-year-old common law about gross obscenity to cause horror to one of Her Majesty's subjects. And apparently, Colleen said that it was on the stand that one of the alleged 13:55 offenders came to the realisation that the girls weren't just meat. 14:00 And I think There was plans for the prosecution to have this at the town hall. So if you think about that, that's before Giselle Pimico in 2024 in France, where her offenders were one bulk lot of 50. This thought, you know, predates that. 14:19 It's that big. It was that big. That's huge. It's huge. 14:24 We're talking here the Melbourne town hall, aren't we? Apparently. 14:27 Is that right? Unless it's the Heidelberg town hall. Heidelberg town halls, fairly big too. So it just shows the scale of these, the Heidelberg school girl rapes. They, they were enormous and Colleen helped unravel and find, you know, 14:44 each victim and then more victims and more victims. And therefore they gradually built the police, built the picture of all those big totals that you just gave us, where there were 225 offenses. There are at least 24 girls known, 15:00 but there'll be others. And in other words, dozens. And there were many, many offenders, 42 of them known, but there were probably more. This is an astonishing thing and a terrifying really. And one of those, I mean, our listeners should know this or should hear this. One of 15:22 those young men was called Peter McAvoy. He had a lot of middle names, but his basic name was Peter McAvoy. 15:31 His nickname was Bubble Brain. That young beast was not only basically a child rapist, a rapist of teenage girls when he was, what, 20 or something. He later went on to be a close associate of the Pettengills and the Allens, the ones we mentioned before. And he became 15:59 one of the Wall Street shooter crew. Peter McEvoy and his associates were the gang who shot dead the two young policemen in Wall Street, South Yarra, a decade after the Heidelberg rapes. Again, this underlines how serious, how criminal 16:21 and how violent and how vile these young men were So many of them went on to do terrible crimes. 16:32 As shocking as that is, that fact does not shock you, does it, Donna? 16:36 Not at all. And I think something that's worth sharing for people is that there is no statute of limitations on these crimes. So people can always come and seek to have things addressed. And if they're serious crimes, so 16:54 they're Level 2 Category 1 indictable offences, And so, you know, they're just under, as you said in your previous podcast, they're just under murder. I gave you an example of the one in New South Wales in the late 19th century. 17:09 Yeah, famous case. 17:11 Is it four or five of those men were hung for what they did? 17:16 Yes, yep, they stretched their necks. Young men, same sort of stuff. Young men, I think a young female victim. 17:25 And they swung. That's what happened in those days. And it was rightly considered a capital crime. You know, sexual violence was not condoned by the system in any way. 17:38 And I can remember my own grandmother who died back in the 90s when she was in her 90s. But when she was a schoolgirl, she can remember a young, I think a young school teacher being hanged because of some sexual offence with a teenage girl. So the law 18:01 in the old days was very severe about this sort of stuff. And it shows that society abhors those sort of crimes. And yet by the 70s, a lot of people got away with it. A lot of people got away with it. As you point out, despite all the 18:20 investigation and all the arrests and all the rest of it, With the Heidelberg rapes, in the end, only a handful did time. 18:30 But that's typical of what happens with sexual assaults. I mean, if you look at the numbers in the Heidelberg what's only a rapes, that just is a really blatant example of the attrition that happens with sexual assaults. It just shows that. It just happens to be in one case. 18:49 but that kind of attrition where people fall off. And in the 70s, you know, we're counted legally as children, as minors, and yet as a teenager we had more cunning and were more, you know, powerful when we were absolutely not that. And what for me is a driving 19:09 force with this and that is I got the life sentence here. I am forever scarred by this. And I want those men to know I remember. I remembered. And I will have truth put on the public record. I 19:31 will not have this erased. Terrible things happen to young girls, schoolgirls, children, and I will not have that erased. 19:43 Yes. And on that note, I think we will end this particular episode. But I would say that I know that you are going to Queensland to another state in the near future and you are going to go to see that lovely man Richard Parsons now long retired from 20:03 the police from Victoria Police living a quiet life in Queensland. 20:08 I don't think he's been in the the best of health recently, but I know that he's always pleased to see you and that you're always pleased to see him and that a lot of what that very nice man and diligent man has done has to some extent redeemed 20:26 the authorities because he's had a go. He actually found some people. He interviewed them. He drove around to addresses. 20:38 He did... A lot of work that allowed you and your people and even the odd reporter like myself to go on with this. So I'm hoping that we can, I'm hoping that Richard Parsons is up to talking to us about this. If he is, great. If he's not, 20:58 you and I will report back to the listeners what he's got to say. Is that, is that a deal? 21:04 That's the plan. 21:06 That's the plan. Thank you, Donna. You've done it again, but our work here is not done. We hope to do more on this in the very near future because, as we said, it is 50 years. Can you believe that? 21:20 It is 50 years since you and one of your classmates were lured into a car at Festival Hall and taken against your will to the Western suburbs when you thought you were going around the corner to a harmless party. 21:37 And that was a scarring and life-defining experience. But you've just shown us that it's made you very fierce and a very, very potent enemy of those people. All I can say is good on you. 21:55 One of the things, just to conclude, I think you've heard me say this before, I feel like I've been called back from November 2022 to armour up again. 22:06 Yeah. 22:07 And fight it out of the Coliseum. That's what it feels like. 22:10 Got the armour on. Thanks for listening. Life and Crimes is a Sunday Herald Sun production for True Crime Australia. 22:19 Our producer is Jonty Burton. For my columns, features and more, go to heraldsun.com.au forward slash Andrew Rule, one word. For advertising inquiries, go to newspodcasts.com. sold at news.com.au. That is all one word, news podcasts sold. And if you want 22:44 further information about this episode, links are in the description.
Community discussion