0:02 Hi guys, welcome to Legally Brunette. I'll be your host today, Emily Simpson and. 0:06 Shane. 0:07 Okay, today we are talking about a case that I am really excited to talk about. I mean, I always love talking about true crime. I always love talking about the cases. But this one, this one is so intriguing to me. It has been living in my head. I 0:22 remember when it happened. I was reminded of it recently. 0:26 I looked it up. There is a documentary on Hulu. 0:29 I watched it. I read a lot of articles. It is one of those cases that most likely will never, ever be solved. But I cannot, for the life of me, it's just so intriguing and so interesting and so compelling that it's just so fascinating to talk about it because 0:46 I have no idea what happened that night. I mean, we have ideas. We can put it together and we can try to speculate, but we have to figure this out. 0:53 We're going to figure it out today. 0:55 All right. 0:55 We're going to figure this out. 0:56 All right. He did it. Guilty. Problem solved. 1:00 All right. So this is the Rebecca Zahao case, if you've heard of this before. 1:04 Z-A-H-A-U. 1:06 Z-A-H-A-U, Rebecca Zahao. So this happened back in the summer of 2011 on the coast of Coronado, California. By the way, Coronado is very close to where we live. So I am definitely planning on driving my car down to Coronado and visiting this mansion. Just wanted to let you know. 1:25 All right. All right. 1:25 By yourself? 1:26 I don't care whoever wants to go with me can go, but I am going to visit this mansion. 1:31 Well, let me ask a question. Oh, wait. Okay. 1:33 Already? 1:34 Yeah. You've followed this case since the beginning? 1:39 No. I remember when it happened. 1:41 What year did it happen? 1:42 It happened in 2011. 1:43 And the hotel's not that far from here. Why haven't you gone the last 15 years? 1:49 Because when I just remember it being. 1:51 You even lived in San Diego. Oh, no, you didn't live in San Diego any of that time. 1:53 Not during that time. No, I just remember being... I just remember hearing about it briefly in the news or something, but not investigating it or really getting into it. 2:04 Oh, okay. 2:05 In the summer of 2011, on the coast of Coronado, California, stood the Spreckles Mansion, which is a grand historic home overlooking the Pacific and owned by pharmaceutical executive Jonah Shackney. 2:18 He's worth billions, actually. He owns a pharmaceutical company. 2:22 Oh, well, there you go. 2:23 That had the brand Restylane, which is an injectable. 2:30 An injectable what? Pharmaceutical? 2:33 No, like when you get filler. Like when women go and put filler in their face. 2:38 Women will pay for that. 2:39 A lot of money for that. 2:39 That's why he's a billionaire. 2:40 Yes. 2:41 If it was like some thing that solved like some, I don't know. What? some other issues with men, it probably wouldn't sell very quickly. 2:53 No, but this is wrestling. 2:54 So he's a billionaire. Yes. 2:56 His girlfriend, 32-year-old Rebecca Zahal, was living in the mansion with him. One afternoon, Jonah Shachnai's six-year-old son, Max, has a fatal fall inside the mansion. Two days later, Rebecca turns up dead too. The scene is unsettling and the 3:14 questions start right away, but the sheriff's department reaches a conclusion. Suicide. 3:19 Rebecca's family refuses to accept that ruling. They insist that the woman that they know would never have done that. 3:25 Two deaths in one house. Theories that contradict each other. 3:29 More than 15 years later, people are still asking what really happened inside the Spreckles mansion. Oh, I can't wait to visit the Spreckles mansion. I am so excited. It's like 27 rooms. It sits like right across from the ocean. 3:42 Is it open to the public? 3:44 No, but I will do a walk-by. 3:45 You're going to be like, I'm considering buying this home. 3:48 Can I do a walk-through? 3:49 All right. So let's go back and talk a little bit about Rebecca Zahow. She was born on March 15th of 1979 in Falam, a small town in the Chin Hills of Myanmar, formerly known as Burma, and is one of six children. 4:03 Also where Rambo 4 had taken place, in case you didn't know that. 4:08 I was wondering that. Thank you for that bit of information. 4:12 That's where he resided after Rambo 3. Yes. And then more issues come up and he saves some missionaries and some mercenaries. 4:20 I remember. I've seen that movie. 4:21 Yeah, it was good. 4:22 It was a good movie. 4:22 It has a kill count of 237. Is that more than John Wick? Oh, yeah. Really? I think so, yeah. Oh. 4:30 All right, that was enough fun facts for you. Go ahead. 4:31 Okay, so in Rebecca's late teens and 20s, after living in Nepal in Germany, Rebecca moved to the United States about 10 years before her death. She had first met Neil Nalipa while both were attending the Calvary Chapel Bible College in Austria, and the two married in 2002. I 4:50 think she was only married to her first husband for, I don't think it was very long. I think it was three years, three and a half years, something like that. 4:55 So she had a brief marriage prior to meeting... Jonah Shackney, who is the billionaire guy. 5:03 Okay. 5:03 She worked as an ophthalmic. I can't talk today. 5:08 Ophthalmic? Eye. 5:10 We'll just say eye. She worked as an eye technician. 5:13 She first met Jonah. He was 54 when he had been a patient at the eye clinic where she was working. 5:21 Between 2008 and 2009, Rebecca began dating Jonah Shackney. He's the CEO of Medellin. Disses. 5:28 Yeah. 5:28 He's the billionaire that owns the pharmaceutical company that made Restylane. 5:32 While she was still legally married to Neil, over time, she quit her job to help care for Jonah's children, especially his youngest son, Max. Then Rebecca and her first husband, Neil, officially divorced in February of 2011. In August of 2009, 5:49 Rebecca was arrested for shoplifting and stealing $ 1, 000 worth of jewelry from a Macy's in Phoenix and pleaded guilty. 5:55 Hmm. Hmm. Hmm. And so it begins. 5:58 And so it begins. 6:00 All right. 6:00 So let's talk about this week at the Spreckles Mansion. 6:04 You like that name, Spreckles? 6:05 I do. I like to say it. 6:06 Does it make you think of sprinkles? 6:07 It makes me think of cupcakes. And I like the word mansion. 6:12 Mansion and cupcake. 6:13 Those are like two of my favorite things. 6:14 It's a nice combination. Yeah. 6:16 All right, so this is July 11th in the morning. 6:18 Rebecca Max, and Rebecca had a younger teenage sister named Zina who was visiting. She was at the house. 6:24 Zina, you like that name. 6:25 I like that name too, yeah. 6:26 Is it spelled with an X? 6:27 Yes, Zina. So Rebecca Max, this is the six-year-old son of her boyfriend. Her teenage sister Zina, they're all at the house. And this is when Max reportedly fell face first over a second floor banister. He is rushed to 6:45 the hospital in critical condition. So her boyfriend, Jonah, had two previous wives, I believe. 6:52 Okay. 6:52 This is the second previous wife, who is the mother of Max. Her name is Dina. 6:56 Okay. 6:57 I believe she lives in Arizona full-time, but they vacation in Coronado. 7:00 Okay. 7:01 She knows. 7:02 So clearly these people don't have any financial issues. 7:04 No, there's no financial issues. 7:06 They have homes and they're... Just emotional issues between each other. Okay. 7:09 So... Rebecca goes to pick up Max's mother, Dina, at the airport. On July 12th, this is the next day, Rebecca drops off Zina at the airport for her flight back to Missouri. So that's her younger sister, goes back home. 7:24 And then she picks up another visitor. This is Jonah Shackney's brother, Adam. So her boyfriend, Jonah, who's the billionaire, has a brother named Adam who's coming to stay at the Spreckles Mansion. 7:36 Mm-hmm. I imagine lots of family members and friends come to the Speckles mansion to stay with this billionaire. Right. 7:42 And Adam and Jonah are brothers, but Adam is completely different than Jonah because Jonah is the billionaire businessman, right? 7:48 That owns the pharmaceutical company. Adam, the brother who's coming to visit and stay. 7:53 What's his issue? 7:53 He's a tugboat captain. Oh, okay. 7:56 So there's two different careers. 7:57 Right. So he arrives. 7:59 I bet the tugboat captain's happier than the billionaire. 8:02 I knew you were going to say that. You're all about- Tugboats. 8:05 Tugboats. 8:08 So Adam arrives on a flight from Memphis, Tennessee. Then that evening, Adam, the brother, Jonah, the billionaire, and Rebecca all eat dinner together. And I believe at some point when they're questioning Adam later, he talks about how Rebecca 8:23 was very quiet at this dinner. Obviously, because this child, Max, that was six years old, had been under her care when this tragic accident happened. Well, accident. I don't know. 8:33 There's still... Lots of questions about what happened to Max. 8:38 I've seen pictures. 8:40 Wait, he fell a second, a banister, a little step, and he fell in his critical condition already? 8:47 Well, let me add more to this because I've seen photos of the home. It's a huge mansion. I believe it has almost like a double staircase that goes up. 8:54 And I believe he was on the second level. And there's a banister. Somehow... He went over the top of the banister from a second level. 9:04 I picture just like he tripped on a few steps and fell down. 9:07 No, he's actually on a level, on a hallway. 9:09 Okay, that could be critical. Yes. Okay. 9:11 So he's actually up high. And the foyer is like marble or something. 9:15 Right. 9:15 Then also, there's a huge crystal chandelier that came down with him. What? 9:20 Yeah, so the- Did he grab onto it? I mean, is that the story that he grabbed onto it? 9:25 I believe the story or what makes, sense or what investigators put together is that somehow he also had a scooter that was laying on top of him. So I think the thought was. 9:36 And then there was an iron clad that came from the sky and fell on him. 9:40 I think the thought was that he was riding his scooter maybe up on the second level. But somehow, I don't know how the scooter. 9:49 And then somehow he hopped over the banister. 9:51 That's the part that doesn't make sense. 9:52 Onto the chandelier and then everything came crashing down. 9:55 Yes, this kid ends up going... over the top of a banister lands on the landing. 9:59 A six-year-old, mind you. 10:00 A six-year-old. The scooter lands on top of him and the chandelier comes down. How all those things happen with a six-year-old. I mean, I know six-year-olds could be, but I mean. 10:11 Sounds like Wile E. Coyote or something. 10:13 But that's crazy. I do believe at some point, I remember when I watched in the documentary, maybe it was something else I watched, that they said that they found paint on the wheels of the bottom of his scooter and the paint matched the banister. So then I'm like, 10:26 was he putting the scooter like on top of the banister? 10:30 And then he fell off of it. 10:31 But that would mean he was, I don't know. I don't know. We could sit here all day long. 10:35 Anyway, no one actually saw what happened. 10:37 Wait, what year is this again? 10:38 This is 2011. Oh, yeah. And the girlfriend, Rebecca, is in the mansion watching the six-year-old, but she was like. 10:44 Well, clearly she's not watching the six-year-old. 10:45 I believe she claimed she was in a bathroom or something at that time. at that time the younger sister zina's in the house but she doesn't see it happening in the bathroom long enough for him to a chandelier to come down and the. 10:57 Scooter mini episode of jackass she. 10:59 Did claim and i i think this is important she claimed that he was able to say one thing i guess when she ran up to him and she was like trying to help him that he said ocean and ocean is the name of the dog i. 11:12 Think you're gonna say something else oh shit No, he said Ocean. 11:16 And Ocean is the name of the dog. 11:17 Oh, okay. 11:18 So that's what she claims. That was her account was that he said that one thing. 11:21 I like that name. 11:23 You like the name Ocean? 11:24 For a dog. If we ever get a blue dog, we should name it Ocean. Okay. 11:27 Well, I'll keep that in mind. All right. So we have that the brother came to visit. That's Adam. He's going to stay in the guest house. He's not going to stay in the main mansion. Then we have that evening that Adam, Jonah, and Rebecca ate dinner together. Two 11:41 days later, this is July 13th. Around 1230 a.m. So we have to we have to let's put ourselves in the mindset of Rebecca. She's taking care of the six year old. She's in charge of him. They had to take him. The ambulance came and took him and they 11:55 had to induce him and put him into a coma. 11:57 Think about like what her mindset is at that point. 11:59 Like that happened under her watch. 12:01 It happened under her watch. It's this young six year old kid. All right. So then around 1230 a.m. This is two days later after Max falls off the foyer. balcony, second story, whatever you want to call it, in the mansion. Jonah, 12:15 the dad, and her boyfriend leaves a voicemail for Rebecca on her cell phone. This is around 1230 a.m. He was crying and telling her that doctors said if Max survived, he was not expected to walk or talk again. All right, so she gets a voicemail from And according to her 12:40 cell phone, it shows that she listened to her voicemail for two minutes at 1250 a.m. on July 13th, about two hours before her estimated time of death. So this is two days after he's injured. Then on July 13th in the morning, Adam, the brother who had stayed the 12:56 night in the guest house, he calls 911 and claims that he found Rebecca hanging from the balcony the following morning and that he climbed up on a table in order to cut her down. Now, this table only had three legs on it. However, I guess he claims that 13:10 he found the fourth leg and kind of like put it underneath the table and stabilize the table, climbs up on the table and cuts her down. 13:19 So far fetched. 13:22 Well, okay. This is how she was found. Okay. So this is a small balcony that's off of a guest bedroom. 13:30 Okay. 13:31 With like, you know, doors that open out into the small balcony. 13:34 Okay. 13:34 She's found hanging over this balcony. She's found naked with her hands and feet bound with rope. And investigators also found. 13:46 How is she hanging? Like she's tied. 13:48 Around the neck. It's tied. 13:49 Oh, so she's a. 13:51 It's a noose around her neck. She has her arms are bound behind her, not in front of her. Her ankles are bound. And also she has a t-shirt around her head to like go through her mouth like a. 14:06 Okay, like a gag. 14:07 Like a gag, yes. That's what I was trying to say. Also, investigators found that within the guest bedroom where she goes over the balcony in this guest bedroom, right? They find a message painted on the bathroom door inside this bedroom 14:21 that said, she saved him. Can you save her? This is in black paint. 14:27 Him being who? 14:29 I don't know. I mean, there's no decoder ring that. 14:33 Goes with this. And the child's not dead yet at this point. 14:35 No, but she did receive a voicemail from the boyfriend about 12.50 a.m. before her body is found hanging over the balcony in this guest bedroom. And that he did say that he was not doing well and that he probably won't recover and that he won't walk. He ends up dying. 14:52 Yeah, but at that point, she only knows it's not looking good. Right. You can't argue a suicide of a parent. 15:01 Or I should say it's tough to argue a suicide of a parent Because of the accident of a child when that child hasn't really died yet. That's a tougher one. 15:12 And he passed away, sadly. And then the parent commits suicide, at least in order that makes sense. But here it's like she just gets wind of it's not looking good. Yeah. 15:24 But you know what else is interesting? And I don't know what your take is on this. I didn't even... 15:27 They know, I guess, according to the digital forensics on her phone, that she did receive a voicemail and that she listened to a voicemail, but that voicemail was deleted. 15:36 So it's not on her phone. But, you know, Jonah, her boyfriend, there's not very much about him when you watch a documentary or you watch anything on this case. 15:46 There's never really any mention. I believe that they have surveillance video of him staying at the Ronald McDonald house at the I believe that's where they allow parents to stay when your children are gravely sick and you're staying 16:02 at the hospital. They have him on surveillance at that Ronald McDonald house during all this time period. So I think it was just very cut and dry that he had nothing to do with. 16:12 And then the text would make sense because he's there, right? 16:14 Is that what you're saying? 16:15 You mean the voicemail? 16:16 Yeah, the voicemail. Right. But I mean like he's there, he sends a voicemail. 16:19 But I'm just saying he was... Even though it was his son and then his girlfriend... that die within two days of each other in his mansion. He's never a suspect. 16:28 I'm just saying, I think it was so cut and dry as to where he was as far as surveillance and things like that, that, that he was never a person of interest or a suspect. 16:39 Legit alibis. 16:41 Yeah. Because, but even though it's, I, it always seemed to me that they, I always felt like I wanted to know more about him, but he really doesn't come up in a lot of this is really focused on his brother and her and the son and, The ex-wife, 16:53 but he's really not a player in any of this, even though he's the connection between the two, the son being dead and the girlfriend being dead. Right. Within two days, within the same mansion. 17:05 Right. 17:05 And the same police officer that arrived on scene for both of them. 17:09 It's the same guy? 17:10 It's the same one. 17:11 It's the same officer? 17:12 It's the same officer. 17:13 Is that because it happened like the same time the next week? Like, and the sheriff just has the same shift every week? 17:19 Well, first of all, it's Coronado, so I assume that They probably don't have a large police force. 17:24 I don't know. 17:25 My thought was, because it's the same officer, I'm sure there was a level of confirmation bias where I believe there were conversations when they got the call, when the brother called and said, there's a girl that's dead. She's hanging. 17:38 I just cut her down. And he says on the 911 call, you were just here a couple days ago for the boy. 17:45 Yeah. 17:46 And so I believe the conversation at the police department was, oh, it's a suicide because this child was injured under her watch and now they've found her hanging. And so I'm just saying when they go into this scene, they already 18:01 have a confirmation bias that she committed suicide because that's what would make sense, right? Based upon they were just there two days earlier and a young child was gravely injured and she was, you know, watching him yeah and here we are two days. 18:17 Later maybe I don't know if I'd have a confirmation bias. 18:21 Well I'm saying logically that's what would make sense I. 18:23 Would think like oh my gosh this house is has tragedy I would think is it related I don't know if I'd like know who the suspect is all. 18:32 Of a sudden no I'm saying I think they go in with a preconceived notion that she committed suicide there you go and then when you have that in your mind yeah. 18:39 Before you see her in in the position that they put that she's put in yeah you would think That makes sense. Tragedy, child almost dead or dying, mom commits suicide. 18:51 But you know what else makes logical sense? 18:53 What? 18:53 You don't be biased when you arrive at a crime scene and you be open-minded. Yeah, I know. 18:58 But I would just remember before when we talked about confirmation bias, previously we talked about in the Scott Peterson case. 19:04 And it was when an investigator all of a sudden hones in on him and thinks he's the guilty party. 19:08 And only researches. 19:09 Then that's it. You're not looking at other things. You're not testing other DNA. You're not... taking other witnesses that saw her. You know what I mean? So I'm saying in this case, it's almost like the same thing where it's like, oh, well, suicide makes sense in this case. 19:22 So we're just going to go with suicide instead of being more open-minded to there being something nefarious that actually was happening in that bedroom that night. 19:32 Like someone else bound her up and hung her off the balcony? 19:35 Well, there's also knives that were found at the scene. 19:39 I believe there were two knives and they had blood on them. And one of the knives... had blood on the handle, but not blood in a way where someone had blood on their feet. 19:49 Yeah, I read that. part. It was on all sides of the knives, right? 19:52 As if it had been inserted. Oh. And so... there was the takeaway that a lot of people felt as if she had been sexually assaulted, which would be why she was naked and why there was blood, and it was menstrual blood, by the way, surrounding the whole entire 20:09 knife handle as opposed to just like someone had it on their hand and then grabbed the knife handle. It was as if it had been, you know. 20:17 Dipped in blood. 20:17 Dipped in blood, right. Also, one other thing I just wanted to mention, there was also black paint on the rope. However, they didn't find black paint on her hands. So if she was the one. 20:32 But where's the black paint from? It's from... No, the black. 20:35 Paint is from the. 20:36 Oh, the writing? 20:38 The writing that was found on the door. 20:39 Oh, okay, okay. 20:40 So if that was her suicide note, and she had painted it, and she had black paint on her hands, then the black paint would have transferred to the bindings. 20:49 And there was black paint on the bindings. 20:51 Okay. 20:52 But there wasn't black paint on her hands. So the question is, how does the black paint get on the bindings? 20:57 So there's black paint used to make the note. There's black paint on the bindings. Yes. There's no black paint found on her. Yes. What about DNA? 21:06 There's no other DNA. And that's why. 21:09 Is there no DNA and they tested for DNA or they didn't even test for DNA? 21:12 No, they tested the rope for DNA and there's no other DNA found other than hers. And I think that's why ultimately it led to a suicide conclusion because there was just not... the evidence there to suggest that there was someone else in the room, even though they did 21:28 handwriting analysis on the, you know, the, the note that was painted on the door and, you. 21:33 Know, the Ms and the analysis come up with, well, the. 21:38 Ms and the writing looks similar to the brother, to his handwriting. And so you could make the conclusion. 21:44 So nothing really, but it's like, okay, so some letters look the same and some don't. 21:48 Right. And also the, the, the note written on the door or painted on the door, She was only five foot tall, I think. She was very tiny. She only weighed 100 pounds. I think she was like five foot and weighed 100 pounds. The writing on the door was 22:01 actually up high. So if you're five foot tall and you're painting a message on the door, you do it at eye level. You don't reach up high to paint something. 22:11 So that was another thing that indicated that maybe it wasn't her that actually painted that. 22:15 Well, who was a likely suspect? 22:17 Well, the only likely suspect is the brother that's staying in the guest house. 22:20 Adam? 22:20 We're going to get to Adam. All right, so then the San Diego Police Department becomes involved in this and opens an official investigation. On September 2nd of 2011, Rebecca Zahal's autopsy results were released and her death was ruled 22:35 a suicide. Sheriff Bill Gore also announced that Max's death was an accident. Officials described Rebecca's death as having happened in an unusual but not implausible or unheard of manner. 22:48 Unheard of? Has he heard of anyone committing suicide in such a way? I doubt it. 22:54 Yeah, you know, her sister is very heavily involved in the documentary and her sister's name is Mary, I believe. 23:02 And her sister talks about how in their culture, her sister would have never committed suicide naked. She would have never, you know, allowed herself to be just, because they cut her down and then she's, they, you know, once he cut her down and she's laying in the yard at 23:17 this house, she lays there for hours and hours. And even police helicopters up above are taking photos of the scene with her in it. She's naked. I mean, and I don't know who binds themself Behind their back. 23:32 No one does. 23:33 And their ankles. 23:34 No one does. 23:35 And who would gag themselves? 23:36 No one. 23:37 But they came up with the conclusion because they had someone at the police department that was about the same stature of Rebecca Zahal. She was a small woman. She was about 100 pounds, same stature. They make a video of her being able to bind her own wrists and 23:52 bind her... ankles and they take a video of it and they show it. And they're like, well, see. 23:58 Who did this? 23:59 The police department. 24:00 Who was the person doing the demonstration? It was someone that. 24:02 Worked at the police department. They found someone at the police department that was about the same size as Rebecca Zahal. 24:08 And they have her actually bind her own wrists. 24:12 Okay. But why would someone do it in such a way? 24:16 I don't know. I don't know. 24:18 Why? 24:18 That's a violent way. First of all, to wrap a noose around your neck, to bind your hands behind your back, to bind your ankles. 24:25 But again, why would someone commit suicide in such a way? 24:30 I don't think anyone ever in the history of anyone. 24:33 Well, apparently this police officer says it's not unheard of. Well... 24:38 Which I call BS on that. 24:39 That's the conclusion that they came to. Well, when you watch this video, this woman is able to bind her wrists and she does it behind her back. But the difference is, and this is what I was. 24:48 Yeah, but there's also probably a million people that can't do that. So it doesn't prove that... Yeah. It doesn't prove anything. 24:53 But here's another thing. When she bound her wrists... it was not replicated exactly the way that Rebecca's the house were hers were done in a very sophisticated knots. And if you remember, Adam was a tugboat captain who was very savvy and. 25:10 Nautical people that know those knots. It's like, like when you tie a shoe, you don't think about it. Right. 25:16 And someone says, can you tell me how to tie a shoe? You have to think about it. Right. You have to think, Oh wait, I, cause it's muscle memory. Right. 25:23 Same with those knots. They know them inside and out. 25:26 There is no thinking about it. So he might've done the more sophisticated knot, not even knowing he did. Like, it's just, that's the knot of choice. Right. 25:36 He also admitted to watching porn and then she's found, and he's the one that found her the next morning. 25:42 I don't know. She's naked. She's bound. There's menstrual blood. 25:46 On a knife. What kind of porn was he watching? 25:48 I don't know. So Rebecca's family did not accept the ruling of suicide. They exhumed her body. Would you? 25:55 No, absolutely not. No, absolutely not. 25:58 They exhumed her body and had it reexamined by medical examiner Dr. Cyril Wecht. Wecht did not believe that the injuries on her head could have been caused by hitting branches during her fall as the county's medical examiner contends. 26:11 That's right. According to the autopsy, she also had, I believe, lacerations on her head. And so they were saying that she got the lacerations by when she went over the edge of the balcony and then possibly swung. Because, you know, a body's hanging in its wings. 26:25 Yeah, but see, this is them, at least the way we're going through it right now, this is them coming up with possible scenarios. Yeah. And it's like, okay, yeah, that could have happened. But it's not likely to have happened. 26:38 That's what I'm saying when I'm talking about confirmation bias. 26:41 I'm saying I believe they came to the conclusion of suicide... 26:44 And then they retroactive. 26:45 And then they made everything fit inside that box of suicide. 26:48 Exactly. 26:49 Right. Right. 26:50 And they just, you know, point to the fact that she got that voicemail at 1250 talking about how Max was failing medically. And so that would be her state of mind. But she also had a lot of texts with her sister talking about happy things and plans in 27:05 the future. But nobody talks about that. They just focus on the voicemail. 27:09 And I was going to say, were there other voicemails that she received throughout the child's stay in the hospital that maybe also said he's not doing well and she didn't commit suicide then? Right. 27:18 So it's a lot of cherry picking, right? It's like, well, that voicemail goes to our conclusion of suicide. So we'll focus on that. But here's one other thing I saw. 27:27 I watched last night, I watched a recreation of this entire scene where it was an investigative journalist and a whole team got together and built on a stage. They built like a second story balcony exactly like the Spreckles Mansion. 27:44 They got the iron bed from the guest bedroom. 27:47 Wait, is this to reenact her? Yes. Yes. Death, not the child's falling on the banister. 27:54 No, they reenacted her death. They got a dummy that weighed 100 pounds and was like her, you know what I mean? It was her physical, exactly her. They even put the same carpet and same padding in the bedroom. 28:10 And they wanted to see if she went over the balcony, how tight it was, where the ligatures would be. Because they wanted to compare it to like the medical... You know, the autopsy. So they do all this. 28:23 You know, I don't buy that stuff is working very well. 28:26 But let me just tell you the rest of it, and then you tell me what you think. 28:28 All right. 28:29 So when the police found her and they investigated the scene, the noose, the rope, was tied to an iron bed in the guest bedroom. The iron bed had moved seven inches. 28:42 So the weight of her body going over the balcony caused the iron bed to move seven inches. 28:47 Okay. 28:47 So the police had a ruler. They took photos of the crime scene. The bed moves seven inches. 28:52 And they try to see if it will again move seven inches. 28:55 So they're trying to recreate it in the exact way that she went over the balcony to get the seven inches so they can figure out, did she go over feet first? Did she go over head first? Like how did she, right? Was she thrown? Was she, I don't know. 29:11 So they try all these different scenarios. Every time they do it, the bed moves 39 inches. 41 inches. 29:18 Oh, not even close. 29:19 Not even close. 29:20 And regardless of the manners in which they kept trying, it was always the same outcome that it moved like three to four feet. Right. 29:26 It was such a impact. It was such a force. 29:30 Yeah, but I bet you we could probably find a way to make it move only seven inches. 29:35 They tried every way possible. 29:36 Oh, yeah, really? Like just slowly setting yourself down? on the tension of the rope? 29:45 I mean, I guess according to these recreations, you could come up with that maybe the scene was staged and that she was strangled before and then hung. 29:57 Like, yeah. Yeah. 29:59 As opposed to propelling herself over, which would cause, you know. 30:04 Such a. What I was saying was the police department could make the argument, the stupid argument of like, well, if you do it in such a way and then you crawl down the balcony and you gently let yourself hang on the noose and it, you know, it's like, yeah, 30:21 you probably do that. And that's what they did with the binding thing. Right. They found someone that could do it. Right. 30:26 But again, with the bindings, it wasn't exact because it wasn't those same exact nautical knots. It wasn't duplicated. 30:35 It was replicated. You should add to your tour. Go to Tugboat Adam's place of work. Tugboat Adam? Yeah. Isn't that his name? 30:42 Yes. Tugboat Adam. That's his name. 30:44 And look at his knots. Yeah. And see what kind of knots he ties. 30:47 Okay. 30:48 Okay. 30:49 We'll find Tugboat Adam on our Legally Brunette road trip. 30:52 Or if we have any listeners that work in the tugboat industry out there. Where is he? In Arizona? Tugboat's in Arizona. 30:58 No, I didn't say Arizona. 30:59 I thought you were flying from Arizona. 31:01 No, the wife. The ex-wife lives in Arizona. 31:03 He's got to get a different industry. 31:05 No, I think he lives in Tennessee. I think he flew in from Tennessee. 31:08 Oh, the tugboat's out there? 31:10 I don't know. I don't know. Let's move on. All right. 31:14 So the family, even though there's no criminal charges brought, right? 31:17 He also did the Adam, the brother, talk about Adam. 31:21 He did take a polygraph, but it was inconclusive. So it didn't really help one way or the other. And again, there's no DNA found at the scene other than Rebecca's house. 31:32 So they come to this conclusion and say, it's a suicide. 31:36 We've investigated the whole thing. They put it up on a website. They do a press release. They do a press conference. And then they're like, there's no criminal charges. 31:45 She committed suicide. Well, the family doesn't. 31:47 Dang. That is far from like the perfect crime, but it was the perfect crime. If you were looking at it, you wouldn't think that it could be concluded as suicide. 32:02 But how, if, if there was someone else involved and someone else was in that room and there was some type of sexual assault and then she was bound and, and gagged and she was placed over or staged or whatever. 32:14 How did they get rid of all their DNA? How is there no DNA from any other person in that room? 32:20 Did they search the room for DNA? 32:21 Yeah. 32:23 Did they do a luminol test? Actually, I read that they did not do a luminol test. Oh. 32:30 Yeah. 32:31 Which then, that made me think, shouldn't there be a checklist of things you do? 32:35 You would think. 32:36 Not like... Should we do Luminol? Is there any in the trunk? I don't know. I mean, like it should be like a checklist. 32:43 Like a standard procedure. 32:44 Yeah, like you do Luminol regardless because it's a crime that involves blood. Right. 32:49 So you're saying if they would have done a Luminol test in that room, there could have been other places in the room that could have had DNA that they swabbed, but they didn't. 32:56 Or just told a story. 32:57 Yeah. 32:58 Oh, it looks like she was dragged. Right. Blood smeared from the bedroom all the way to the balcony. 33:03 I don't know. So in 2013, Rebecca Zahal's family files a wrongful death lawsuit and names three defendants, Adam Shackney, who is Jonah's brother, Dina Shackney, who is his ex-wife and Max's mother, and also Nina Romano, who is Dina's 33:20 twin sister. She was in town visiting her. Over time, the lawsuit narrows just to Adam Shackney with the family alleging that he was the one that was behind her death. 33:31 All right, so We know with a wrongful death lawsuit that it is not a criminal. It is a civil suit. 33:39 So instead of having the standard of having to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, which is the highest standard for a criminal proceeding, it is just preponderance of the evidence, which means more likely than not. 33:50 Just tipping the scale. 33:51 Just tipping the scale. All right. So what evidence did the Zahal family and their attorney, their attorney's name is Keith Greer, present at this wrongful death? This is a civil lawsuit. They obviously present that Adam Shackney was the 34:07 only other person there that night at the mansion. Greer stressed that Adam was the only person besides Rebecca that was at the mansion that night. Also, they stressed a lot about the knots. A knot expert called by the 34:20 family testified that the knots tied around Rebecca were consistent with nautical maritime knots. Adam was a tugboat captain, while Rebecca allegedly had no experience with knots. I mean, that is ridiculous to think that someone... It is ridiculous. 34:35 Even tying a noose. Was it a true noose that she had or just wrapped around her neck? Do we know? 34:41 I don't know how the part around her neck was tied, but I do know that there were nautical knots on the bindings around her ankle and her wrists. 34:49 Yeah, and where did the rope come from? I bet the rope came from Tennessee. 34:53 Yeah, I don't know. That's another question I had and I could never find the answer for that. And I never saw that anywhere is where did that rope come from? 34:58 It was red. 34:59 Did you see a picture of the crime scene? 35:01 No. 35:01 It's a red nautical type of rope. And that's not something I. 35:04 Don't have rope. What's a nautical type? You know nautical? 35:06 You looked at it and you thought that's a nautical type of rope? 35:08 Yeah, it looked like something that when you go... Why are you laughing at me? 35:11 Because you don't look at rope and know what kind of activity it's designed for. 35:16 It looks like the kind of rope that when you go out on a boat... And you tie it up. 35:23 That's the kind of boat. 35:24 It looked like one of those ropes. Yes. 35:26 Okay. You're such a jerk. 35:28 I swear. 35:29 I can't with you. I need a new co-host. I'm taking applications for a new co-host, please. 35:34 Let's just, no, it's cute. 35:38 I'm just saying that we don't have rope like that in our house. I don't know what kind of mansion has rope like that. Just, Lying around. 35:48 That's right. 35:48 But did Tugboat Adam bring nautical rope with him? In his suitcase? 35:53 He probably has, like, he probably has, like, a belt with a bunch of contraptions that hold his tugboat rope. 35:59 His nautical thing. 36:01 Gear. 36:02 Okay. Also. 36:04 Is that a nautical thing? 36:06 Also. 36:06 Are you happy to see me? 36:07 The Zahal family and their attorney focused on the painted message. 36:11 This is the one that was on the door. A handwriting expert testified that he believed the message on the door, which said she saved him. Can you save her? Was more than likely painted by Adam because of the slanting and the writing and the way Adam wrote his M's specifically. 36:27 Is she being the victim? 36:29 Well, I guess the part where it says she saved him, can you save her? I guess the she saved him part could be referring, even though Max isn't doing well, I guess it could relate to the fact that when she found him, she did call 911 and tried to 36:43 give him CPR. And so maybe that was her attempt. 36:47 But in the history of suicide notes, has there ever really been one written in third person? 36:55 No, probably not. 36:55 Exactly. But this police officer might be like, it's not unheard of. Right. It's unheard of for a female victim to learn how to do nautical knots and then kill herself that way. I mean, this guy's ridiculous. 37:10 Keith Greer, the attorney, also added that an expert would say the writer was probably about 5'10 to 6' tall because you tend to write at eye level. Rebecca was only about 5'2 while Adam was 5'11. Also, there were head injuries. Rebecca had four bruises on the right side 37:29 of her head. 37:29 Oh, my goodness. 37:31 Greer, the attorney, argued that Adam knocked her unconscious with those blows. Pathologist Cyril Wecht testified that Rebecca was strangled and that her death was staged to look like a suicide. Also, they focused on signs. 37:45 Of a struggle. Not a very good staging of a suicide, I might say. 37:49 Well, it is because they ruled it a suicide. 37:50 I guess, but it doesn't look... Yeah, yeah. Yeah, okay. Yeah. Well, you know what, though? If there's another person in Adam's life that dies by suicide in such a peculiar manner, I will be suspicious. 38:05 You will. That's very the staircase. 38:07 Yes. 38:08 Yes. 38:09 It won't be a coincidence at that point. Right. 38:11 Two women at the bottom of a staircase. 38:13 So you better quit while he's ahead. All right. 38:15 Also, there were signs of a struggle. The attorney pointed to an overturned chair and knives found in Rebecca's room. 38:23 A forensic expert testified that a chef's knife from the room had Rebecca's fingerprints on the blade, but none on the handle. The same expert also testified that Rebecca's menstrual blood was on all four sides of the handle and 38:37 Greer argued this pointed to a sexual assault, which is what we talked a little bit about earlier as far as like, and her, if her, if her fingerprints, again, there's no fingerprints of anyone else on the knives, but her fingerprints are the only ones on it, but it's 38:50 on the blade. not on the handle. 38:52 Well, you got to admit that that's odd too. You need to bring forward cases that have a nice, clean investigation and the case is solved. 39:01 No, I like these because I. 39:03 You're going to walk away frustrated. 39:04 I am. I've been thinking about this case for days and days and days. I wake up in the middle of the night trying to figure out what happened that night. 39:09 I want to know. I want to know. 39:10 You will not know. 39:11 The only way we will ever know what happened in this particular case and that night As if there is a confession. That is the only way you will ever know what happened is if someone just their conscious gets to them and they come clean. That's the only way 39:28 you'll ever know what happened. The 911 call Adam reported the death as a suicide when he called 911 and didn't even address Rebecca by name. Greer, the attorney, argued that no one seeing a woman nude bound and hanging would conclude that she did it herself. I don't know. 39:55 What would you think if you came upon that? Let's say. 39:57 If I came home and I saw you bound and gagged and all that, hanging from the balcony, I would not call 911 and say my wife committed suicide. 40:06 That's his point, right? He's saying that the 911 call said she committed suicide. So you're saying if I'm hanging from the balcony right here, there's one right here behind me. 40:15 and I'm bound by my arms and feet are bound and I'm gagged, you're going to call and say my wife was murdered. 40:21 After I wipe all my fingerprints off of everything in this house. Right. And delete messages on my phone. Okay. 40:31 Good job. 40:32 No, but seriously, I wonder how often it is when there is a suicide and then someone finds the person and then calls 911, do they say suicide? Or do they say, oh my gosh, so-and-so has been shot? Or, you know what I mean? Like I came home and 40:50 he's shot in the head and he's bleeding. What do I do? Like that's kind of the response I think that you typically, then maybe suicide will develop, but you don't call the report as suicides. Yeah. 41:01 So you're saying the fact that he used the word suicide on a 911 call is suspicious because. 41:06 Maybe it's just, it's not, it's not really evidence, but it is kind of interesting. 41:10 It's just the totality of the circumstances. It's just one more thing that you just kind of add, add to the story. 41:15 Right. 41:16 All right. Also the balcony, the plaintiffs argued that the three foot balcony railing was about half Rebecca's height and it would be hard for her to get over it by herself, especially with her arms and legs bound. They 41:26 also said there were no footprints showing someone moving across the balcony before jumping and which is what investigators had theorized. Okay, if they think that she jumped, there is no way that bed would have moved seven inches. 41:38 Well, why do they think she jumped versus anything else? 41:41 Because they think that's how she would have been able to get over the three-foot railing. 41:46 But why couldn't you crawl the three-foot railing and then crawl. 41:50 Down the other side? Because her arms and legs are bound. 41:52 But how could she run. 41:53 If her feet are bound? I have a theory. She was strangled. She was bound. She was thrown over the balcony. 41:59 And someone was laying on the bed when that happened. 42:01 So it only moved seven inches. 42:04 Oh, so there's more than one person? 42:06 I don't know. I'm just saying, how can the bed only move seven inches then? 42:11 It can't. That's what I'm saying. 42:12 But it did only move seven inches. It did only move seven inches. And what scenario could that be? 42:17 Well, it could be the scenario that someone... just lowered her. 42:22 Oh lowered yeah like but i asked you earlier when they were doing all the different yeah variations. 42:28 No they did this they did what the investigator they did the suicide one. 42:32 They did all different manners of suicide right they did okay but maybe i wasn't clear but what i was getting at earlier was did they try like just as if she literally just set herself down And then had tension on the rope that way and it only moved seven inches. 42:47 No, I think they were trying to do what the actual police investigation concluded as far as her going over. 42:54 And then they said the bed only moved seven inches. 42:57 So every different way that they put her body over the balcony, it moved at least 39 inches. 43:02 Right. 43:02 Because there was so much force. 43:04 Then it would have been interesting to have someone lower her as if they had killed her and then lower her and then it moved only seven inches. That would be compelling. 43:13 Right. They didn't do that in the recreation, but they probably should have. 43:17 All right. 43:17 On April 4th of 2018, after the civil trial jurors and the wrongful death lawsuit voted nine to three, that Adam Shaq night battered Rebecca and that his actions caused her death. They awarded her mother Perry's a how nearly 43:31 $ 5. 2 million. Adam has always denied any involvement. Two weeks after the conclusion of the civil trial, the San Diego County Sheriff's office began a review of its investigation and In December of 2018, the Sheriff's Department decided it would 43:46 not change its initial findings on the case. Rebecca's official cause of death would remain a suicide. The Zahal family reached a settlement with Adam's Shackney's Insurance Company, and Adam said the amount was $ 600, 000 and that he took no 44:02 part in the talks. The case was dismissed, which left the verdict without legal force. His attorney said the outcome cleared Adam's name. Now we get to 2020, 2022. This happened back in 2011. It's just been ongoing. 44:18 Yeah, no, that's crazy. Earlier I asked what year it took place because I was wondering about camera footage. You have a billionaire's house. You'd think they'd. I know. 44:25 I thought the same thing too. 44:26 But 2011 is kind of early on. People weren't necessarily. 44:29 But if it was today, it's likely full of video cameras and stuff. Yeah, I would think. 44:34 That the Spreckles Mansion currently has. 44:37 Is under surveillance. 44:38 Is under surveillance. So it's going to get surveillance of me trying to find the balcony and get a photo of it. 44:44 And then you're lowering me down. Yeah, I'm like, Shane, Shane, jump. 44:49 You're closer to her, right? You go. 44:51 Oh, yeah, you are closer to her. 44:53 But I could climb a three foot balcony. Yeah. 44:56 All right, the Zahal family filed a lawsuit against then Sheriff Gore and his office in 2020 to gain access to the department's records. In 2022, they dropped their lawsuit against the now former San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore 45:08 and shifted their focus to getting the medical examiner to change the manner of death to homicide or to undetermined. 45:16 Where it stands now, the medical examiner's office has maintained the manner of death as suicide and no criminal case has ever been filed against The family is still pushing for a new criminal investigation. And another thing I just 45:29 read in this case, her sister Mary was very heavily in the documentary I watched on Hulu. And she just recently died of cancer. So I feel very badly for this family. They lost Rebecca and then lost her sister Mary. 45:43 And the boy. 45:44 Well, the boy wasn't her son. 45:46 Yeah, it was some tragedy during the time. Right. 45:49 I am very interested to know what our listeners think, whether they think it's a suicide or whether they think that Adam Shackney was the perpetrator, allegedly, in this case. 46:00 I want to know you guys' opinions. And if you have any other information, if anybody lives on Coronado Island, if anyone has. 46:08 If anyone has experience in nautical rope, such as Emily... Yes. 46:12 I just said it looked like a nautical rope. I just want to know what a nautical rope looks. 46:15 Like to you. 46:16 It looks like a red rope that they use to tie up boats. I have been on boats before in my life. 46:20 Yes. 46:21 Okay. All right. Anyway. 46:23 We should have had Shannon as a guest on here because she's always into boats. I know. She always talks. 46:28 I've seen when we go out on the boats with her, she's always doing the ropes. I've never seen her red, but I've seen her handling ropes. 46:35 Well, we should have had Shannon Bedore have a little guest spot, a little cameo today because she grew up on boats. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Thanks, guys, so much for listening to Legally Brunette. If you have any recommendations of cases or if you have any feedback on this 46:47 episode or if you know anything about nautical ropes or any more information about this case, please find me on Instagram and let me know. I love to hear your feedback. Also, be sure to follow Legally Brunette wherever you listen to 47:01 podcasts and be sure to tell your friends and family. 47:04 Thank you so much for listening.
Community discussion