0:01 Hi guys, welcome to Death Do Us Part. I'll be your host today, Emily Simpson and... Shane. Okay, we are talking about a case that happened in Las Vegas. And of course, I feel like when you talk about Las Vegas, it always gets a little strange. Well, shouldn't it stay 0:15 in Las Vegas? It gets a little strange in Las Vegas. 0:19 This is the case of a woman named Devin Michaels. 0:22 This is a very interesting case. You're going to like this one. Let's do it. All right. In the summer of 2023, a mother in Henderson, Nevada, went to check on her adult son and found a scene that would haunt investigators for years. Jonathan Ouellette was dead in his 0:41 own bed, was missing his head, and had bleach and ammonia applied to his body. Someone went to terrible lengths to hide what had happened to him. The last person seen with him was Devin Michaels. a former adult film actress and mother of his two little girls. She was 0:59 also married to Jonathan's son. Okay, did you get all that? 1:03 That was a lot. 1:04 Did you draw like a chart in your head? All I got was he's in Vegas and he's a porn star. 1:08 No, she's a porn star. 1:09 She's a porn star. That's what I meant to say. 1:10 Yes. They were never married, but they were together. They had two daughters together. 1:14 Okay. 1:15 Then he has an adult son from a previous marriage and she ends up marrying his son. Okay, did you put it all together? 1:24 Okay, aside from the fact that they were never officially married. 1:27 Yes. 1:28 It's like the stepson married the stepmother. 1:31 Yes. And, hold on, hold on, hold on. And she really is a porn star. So this is like. 1:39 Your fantasy, whatever, your typical genre turned into reality. This is a reality show. 1:47 Yeah, but he also is missing his head too. Yeah. 1:53 That's a problem. Yeah. 1:54 What followed was a tangle of secrets, shifting stories, and missing evidence, and a courtroom moment nobody saw coming. What really happened inside that house, and who was willing to go that far to keep it hidden? All right, let's 2:05 talk about Devin Michaels. She is a 45-year-old former... She's a former adult film star. She's also been known as. 2:13 Why not retired? Because that makes you sound old. 2:16 Yeah. Then it's like... Do you really retire? Do you get benefits and stuff? 2:20 Well. 2:22 Pension plan yeah no i don't know but technically you still work right what do you mean i mean like you still do the same. 2:30 Oh you mean like if you're just having sex with your your boyfriend or your husband or whatever. 2:34 We're gonna talk about there's murder involved if she was an accountant you wouldn't have mentioned it once that she was an accountant right and and i and no one would i'm not saying to you yeah but when it's a porn shot it's like oh let's mention that Yeah. 2:47 Well, that's the same thing I said. There's always those key... Mormon. 2:50 If somebody's Mormon, they always mention that. 2:52 Mormon and strippers. 2:53 Mormon, strippers, cheerleader. That's another one. Cheerleader. Cheerleader always gets... 2:58 That's what I'm saying. If someone's a soccer player, they never say soccer player. But if it's a cheerleader, it's always in the headline. 3:04 No one says a Baptist went to a bank on Sunday and robbed it. 3:08 No, but if it was a Mormon, it's going to be in the headline. 3:11 Witness, what? 3:13 All right. So Devin Michaels is a 45-year-old former adult film star. She's also been known as Nikki and Tracy Tavares. 3:21 Jonathan Willett, who is the victim, was 46 years old and the father of Devin Michaels' two daughters, ages seven and nine. The two had an on-again, off-again relationship for years. 3:34 Then this third player in this is named Devere Willett. 3:38 And this is Jonathan's son from a previous relationship. Devin Michaels married Deveree after having two children with his father, Jonathan. 3:47 Okay, so what are the ages of the new husband and the stepmom girlfriend? 3:53 The stepmom wife. 3:55 Girlfriend. 3:56 No, wife. 3:56 Well, she was a girlfriend, right? No. She was. 3:59 She was. 4:00 She was the girlfriend. 4:01 Of the dad. Of the father. 4:03 Right. They were never married, so she's like a stepgirlfriend of the dad. 4:07 Yes. Yes. 4:08 This is why incest is not a good idea. It gets really confusing when you're trying to talk about the different relationships. 4:14 It's very hard to keep track of. It's because the lines just go straight. They don't branch. 4:19 I know. It's a trunk. It's not a tree. It's like a palm tree. 4:26 Exactly. So he's how old? He's in his 20s when they get married. She's in her 40s. She's at least 20 years older than him. All right. So, all right. 4:39 We've got all the players in this, right? All right. So, let's move on. Both Devin, this is the mom, the girlfriend, the stepmom. And Devereux told police that the marriage was for insurance and medical purposes, but the defense said that 4:55 they had been having an affair for years while Devin had been dating Jonathan, the dad. 5:02 She should have just said she was working. Right. 5:05 It's not an affair. Right. And then he'd be like, oh, it was just work? 5:09 Oh, okay. 5:10 All right. 5:10 Get back to work. 5:11 I'll see you later. 5:11 Right. 5:12 In court, Deveree, this is the son who was 29 years old at the time, testified that his relationship with Michaels began when he was 19 years old. She was still in a relationship with his father at that time. 5:25 Devin Michaels, this is just an interesting side note, you know, because I know you like fun facts. Yeah. Just fun fact. 5:31 Devin Michaels was once married to Robert Louis Baker Jr. 5:35 Who was convicted of murdering celebrity hairstylist Fabio Simantilli alongside his lover Monica Simantilli. 5:43 Anyway. Is that a case that we should cover? 5:45 I don't know. 5:46 Maybe. 5:46 Should we highlight that? 5:48 You know like someone attracts like narcissists or attracts like dependent people? Yeah. 5:52 Someone attracts. Someone attracts killers? 5:54 Yes. 5:56 I guess so. All right. Yeah. I don't know. I attract. 6:00 What? 6:03 Nice, kind Mormon men. Okay. 6:07 Just quit while you're ahead. 6:16 We get to October 14th of 2022. The Las Vegas Metro Police arrested Devin on a child abuse or neglect charge. 6:24 An employee at a child care facility called police to report an eight-year-old with bruising on her leg. According to court documents, the child told her teacher that she'd been given a whooping for having apple juice and Devin told 6:36 a CPS employee she spanked the child and hit the child with a belt. They were in a custody fight because she was, I don't know, she's being investigated by CPS, right? 6:49 So Jonathan, the dad, was in a dispute with Clark County Family Services over the two girls. The jury learned that Jonathan had recently been granted sole custody of the couple's two children and and that he was preparing to 7:00 move back in with Devin to stabilize their family situation. 7:05 That's the part that boggles my mind. 7:07 I was just about, before you said that, I was just about to say how awkward that would be, like to have your son over for dinner or something, and then he brings his wife, and it's your old girlfriend. 7:16 Now, who's moving in with who? So Jonathan... The ex-boyfriend and the father of the two girls is going to move back in with Devin in order to stabilize the family unit. They're a family of people. But she's married now to his son. Right. 7:31 Right. 7:31 So it's one big happy family. One big happy family. 7:34 All right. 7:35 We like to keep it in the family. 7:37 Yeah. So the move-in plan was that Jonathan and Devin had discussed the living arrangement months earlier as a way to keep their family together. But investigators believe that Devin became concerned that Jonathan's presence would disrupt the home life 7:51 she had established with the Devere. At the time of his death, Jonathan will let was living with his mother, but was in the process of moving into Devin's Northwest Valley home. So that's where, where he's actually murdered in his body is found is that his mother's house. So 8:10 that's where his body was found, but he was in the process of, of moving back in with her to live with her and the children and his adult son who is now married to her. 8:20 So he's moving back in with his ex-girlfriend, baby mama, now married to his son. Yes. And he's found dead. 8:27 In his mother's home. 8:28 In his mom's home. 8:29 In his mom's house. All right, so let's talk about the night of the murder. This is August. This happens between 6th and 7th, August 6th and 7th of 2023. 8:38 This is so recent. Like, it's just crazy to me to think that, like, While we're just sitting here in our house with kids watching some movie, some guy in Vegas is being beheaded. 8:53 Only one? It's Vegas. There might be a lot of activity going on. 8:58 Maybe. 8:58 I mean, you think about it. You ever think about when we're in a hotel room and there's like 2,000 rooms in Vegas? I think about what's going on in all these rooms. 9:06 Yeah. Or what's going on in the room we're in. 9:08 And how many people, how many things are going on that are not between husband and wife? Or married couples, I should say. Yeah. Like that's. 9:16 That 1-800 straight to you. I've never called that. Yeah, why'd you laugh? 9:22 Because it's funny. We always joke about that. That's why it's funny. 9:27 You know what's funny is Shane and I go to Vegas pretty often. We've been to Vegas numerous times. And it always kills me that when we're walking down the street together and like we're holding hands and we're clearly a couple. 9:39 And people hand you. Or no, they hand me something. Like, hey, you want to go to the strip club? Yes. 9:43 They're always handing him those numbers, the 800 numbers of straight to you. And I'm like, hello, right here. 9:50 Like, well, maybe they think you're one of them. They're like, oh, yeah. 9:53 No, but no. Or did they think you look like. 9:56 Someone that would take it and go do i look unhappy they're like here you go yeah try something. 10:02 New all right so we're at the night of the killing this is around 8 p.m on august 6th jonathan's mother yoko said Devin and Jonathan left the house together around 8 p.m. and returned around 10 p.m. I love that they're just like hanging out together. I think they 10:19 go to like a car wash in a convenience store or something. So they're hanging out together. Around 10.05 p.m., the gas station surveillance footage from Chevron shows Devin Michaels and Jonathan entering the store around 10.05 p.m. and leaving 10:36 approximately five minutes later. Then... On August 7th, so now we're getting into like 1 a.m. timeframe, Yoko, the mother, found Devin in the kitchen around 1 a.m. and heard Jonathan's dogs barking around 2 a.m. Then around 2.04 a.m., 10:53 GPS logs from Devin's Nissan Armada showed trips between the two homes from about 2.04 a.m. to 2.44 a.m. Meanwhile, back at Devin's house, because remember, she's with Jonathan at his mother's house. And they're going to a car wash 11:11 and a convenience store together. But this is at his mother's house. The children back at her house give statements that Devereux had watched them that night. So I believe he was never a suspect, even though when they go to trial, the defense tries to switch the blame over 11:25 to the son and say that he had something to do with it. But as far as I know, there's never any surveillance of him or digital forensic of him being out and about. I believe he's always in another location. 11:36 He's safe. He's safe. Around 8.40 a.m. the following day, this is August 7th, Jonathan's mother called police to say that she found him dead. Inside, police show up and find Jonathan in bed with his head missing. Okay, that means his mother found him in bed with no head. 11:59 How'd she know it was him? I assume she recognized the rest of him. It's her son. Can you imagine? 12:06 I can't even fathom that. How you function. 12:12 Even if it was a stranger in my bed without a head. 12:15 Right. 12:15 I think I would flip out. 12:16 But to find your own son in bed with, well, he has chemical burns all over his body because someone poured ammonia and chemicals all over him and no head. 12:28 Like how do you go on as like a functioning normal human after something like that? 12:35 I mean. I don't know. 12:36 I don't know either. 12:37 I hope to never find out. 12:39 Bottles of bleach and ammonia were next to him and had been applied to his body. I do know that when the police arrived, there was like literally like chemical. 12:47 What were they trying to do? They thought they'd disintegrate the body? 12:52 What were they trying to do when they decapitated him? 12:54 Kill him. Maybe they thought like he can't be identified because he doesn't have a face. 12:59 I just want to know what kind of person can decapitate someone. 13:02 A porn star. 13:04 Oh. 13:04 That marries her step. 13:06 Can decapitate. 13:07 Boyfriend's son. Yeah. 13:09 All right. 13:10 And how do they? Because it's not easy. 13:13 I would assume it's not easy. 13:15 Like I cut onions yesterday and it was difficult because our knives aren't very good. I can't imagine if I was trying to decapitate someone. 13:22 I think they believe that she was able to decapitate him with a combination of a knife and some kind of saw, but they never found the weapons that were used to decapitate him and they never found the head. 13:35 Oh, we still don't have a head? 13:36 We have no head. We have a body with chemical burns and no head. But the head is somewhere. 13:44 Well, yeah. 13:46 I mean, someone's got to find it someday. 13:48 Well, someone knows where. No, it could be deteriorated and decomposed. 13:52 I assume she probably threw it into some trash and then the trash got picked up and it ended up in a landfill. And then you know how hard it is to find something in a landfill. 14:00 All your years of experience, you've come up with that, huh? 14:03 That she probably tossed it. 14:04 Yeah. That's how they never found what was the woman in like Massachusetts or Cambridge or some area. She was wealthy. 14:12 She had the wealthy husband and he, you remember he disposed of her body and they could never find her body. 14:17 Remember he drove around, he had like a Raptor and he drove around and put all her body parts and all different trash. And then he committed suicide when he was in prison. So he never went to trial, but they never, they were never able to find her body. 14:31 I believe. 14:32 Anyway, that was just a whole. 14:33 Okay. Did we cover that, I guess? 14:34 Yeah, we did. 14:35 I don't remember that one. All right. 14:37 August 7th, police contact Devin and went to her residence. 14:40 In her driveway, they found Jonathan's cracked cell phone with a dark stain that appeared to be blood. A search warrant led them to a bag in her bedroom containing Jonathan's ID, truck keys, wallet, social security card, and other items. 14:53 So her initial story in her first interview, she said that she left Jonathan's house around 9 p.m. and that he was in the garage. 15:02 Was his head intact? 15:03 I believe she would say that. She didn't say that. 15:06 Jonathan's mother told police that her meat cleaver was missing from the kitchen. 15:10 Did she take inventory? 15:12 She must have. She opened the door and she's like, that meat cleaver is gone. 15:15 Probably because she wanted to use the meat cleaver to kill someone. 15:18 Who has a meat cleaver? 15:19 We do. 15:20 We have a meat cleaver? 15:21 About a couple weeks ago. You did? 15:22 Yes. Goodness. 15:24 People that cook in the kitchen have meat cleavers. 15:35 Devin was in court for her unrelated child abuse case. 15:37 This is on August 9th, two days after the killing. 15:40 So Devin has to go to court. But this is an unrelated child abuse case. Judge Mary Kay Haltha sentenced her to one year of probation on the child abuse charge. 15:49 So in the days before and after that hearing, police were interviewing Devin and collecting evidence as part of their murder investigation. In that hearing, she told the judge that she was not an abusive person. August 15th, Devin takes 16:03 a polygraph test. The examiner told her the results showed a significant reaction to a question about whether she participated in Jonathan's death. She was arrested that day and was held without bond on one count of open murder. In 16:18 later statements, She tells police that she hit Jonathan in the head with a wooden stick while he was in bed because he had been abusive towards her. She claims she did not intend to kill him, only to hurt him enough to require hospital care. Yeah. She claims that 16:38 they were in bed and she was giving him a massage. 16:41 And it turned into hitting him with a stick? 16:43 And then decapitating him. I don't know how you go from... Oh, that's the point in time when... Yes. 16:48 Yes. 16:49 So she's being questioned multiple times. The first time she says she has nothing to do with it. She takes a polygraph. They're basically like there's some level of deceit, right? 16:58 When you're asked a question about her involvement in this crime. 17:02 Then she changes her story and says, okay, well, we were together and he abuses me and I hit him with a stick. She claims she hit him with a stick, but it was like during a massage or something. So I... 17:13 I mean, this is where my mind goes. How do you go from you're hanging out together, going to a convenience store, and you're giving him a massage to hitting him in the head to decapitating him to pouring chemicals on his body? 17:27 I'm going to say right now, I don't need a massage. 17:31 You don't want a massage? 17:31 So I don't ask for a massage from you. And I'm definitely not going to ask for one now. 17:34 No. Is it a stick? She's had a stick? Like a wooden something, I don't know. I know, but like on the side of her bed? And she just whacks him on the head with it? Yeah, and I don't know. 17:44 I can't imagine that killed him. 17:46 I don't even imagine she did that. I think she was just trying to give him something. Like, okay, fine, I'll give him something. That looks suspicious. 17:52 Oh, yeah, I hit him with a stick. But then how did she kill him? You think with the meat cleaver? 17:57 She's whacked his. 18:00 I don't know. 18:01 I don't know either. That's like. 18:06 She had to have hit him on the head to kill him, right? Do we know the manner of death? 18:11 No, because the head's missing. 18:13 I know, but if he was stabbed in the heart, you could say it was that. 18:16 Well, there's chemical burns on the body, and I don't think there was anything to indicate on the body that there was any, like she didn't stab him or shoot him or anything. 18:22 So she probably hit him on the head and thought, oh, I got to get rid of the evidence. I guess. 18:27 But I don't need to get rid of his whole body, just the blunt force trauma on the head. 18:31 Or maybe she intended to dismember all of him. 18:34 She was like, that was a lot of work. 18:36 But after the head, she was like, I'm out of time. 18:39 That took a long time. Wow. All right. When asked whether she might have killed him and not remembered, she said that that was very possible. I like it when the police put that out there. Like, maybe you killed him and you don't remember. And she's like, oh, maybe. 18:52 But if she didn't remember, then that's a worthless question. 18:56 Because anything can happen if I don't remember. Maybe it did happen. 19:00 She also made allegations against Jonathan. She claimed that he was abusive and would have his oldest child take showers in front of him. Jonathan's family had disputed that claim. 19:11 The judge revoked Devin's probation and ordered her to serve a one-year jail sentence with credit for time served. A judge also denied Devin bail in the murder case. Following Jonathan Ouellette's murder, his father and stepmother took custody of 19:24 his two children. the grandparents had never met their grandchildren and never met Devin. And now they, that's interesting. Now they took custody of the kids. They'd never met the kids. 19:33 And now they have custody of these two, two daughters. 19:36 Then she decides to take a plea deal. So in September of 2024, Devin pleaded guilty to second degree murder with use of a deadly weapon for the death of Jonathan Willett. But then she tried to go to trial. 20:08 So the plea deal is out the window. And now she has to go to trial. So the trial begins November 5th through the 14th. This is 2025. I think it lasted about two weeks. So during opening statements, the prosecution argues that Devin killed Jonathan because she did not 20:23 want him living in her home. Because he was supposed to move back in, right? They were going to be like this family unit. 20:29 She skipped the, can you please leave the home? 20:32 Right. 20:32 I don't want you to live here. Right. 20:34 She skipped a lot of steps. 20:36 Yeah. 20:37 But she wanted continued access to their girls. So I guess the easiest way is to keep his head is to get right. The defense claims that Devere, Jonathan's son and Devin's husband was the real killer and left his phone home to create an alibi. Analysts found no signs 20:54 of a struggle and that Jonathan's decapitation happened after death. 20:59 But again, we don't know. She claims to have hit him with a wooden stick in the head, but I don't. 21:02 Feel like, I think she just said that just to give him something like, Oh, I better like, I better just say something. So they, you know, otherwise I look guilty. 21:11 If I had to say, no, nothing happened. 21:12 I feel like she had to have like stabbed him. 21:14 It's like those guys that say, oh yeah, well we had our troubles. 21:17 Oh, I had an affair, but she knew, she knew. 21:20 She knew. Right. Yeah. 21:21 She was fine with it. 21:22 Yeah. And they didn't know, but they're trying to say like, oh, okay, they're going to, they're going to corner me on something. 21:27 So let me give them something like I'm being honest. Right. 21:30 So family and forensic testimony, Jonathan's mother placed Devin in her kitchen around 1 a.m. Experts said two tools were likely used to decapitate Jonathan, a hand-powered knife and a mechanical saw. However, no murder weapon was ever found. There 21:44 was also digital evidence. The GPS showed Devin's SUV going between the two homes from about 2.04 a.m. to 2.44 a.m. Also, the lead investigator said that he found Jonathan's wallet, phone, and keys were found bagged in Devin's home with her 22:01 DNA on them. And also, Jonathan had won sole custody of the girls recently, so a caseworker said Devin told her that she had to do it. Jurors watched Devin tell police she hit Jonathan in the head, but that he had still been breathing. Then the prosecution rested. The 22:19 defense basically said that they pointed to activity. They were trying to point to the sun. So they just try to keep making it like it was someone else and that it wasn't her. 22:29 Which is weird because, well, what would be the motivation? 22:33 Because they're moving in together or something? 22:36 I don't know. 22:36 I mean, that's a week. Yeah. That's a stretch. 22:39 So after just under two hours of deliberation, the jury found Devin Michaels guilty of murder with the use of a deadly weapon. The conviction was first degree murder. Prosecutors declined to seek the death penalty. I wonder why they 22:51 declined to seek the death penalty. Maybe it was a lack of evidence to suggest that it was premeditated. It seems more like a heat of the moment type of situation. 23:01 I don't know what happened during that massage, but it seems like something happened. 23:06 I'm guessing that's not what he wanted out of a massage. Right. 23:09 That's not the happy ending he wanted? 23:11 No. 23:12 That's a different kind of ending. All right. Judge Tiara Jones sentenced Devin Michaels to 20 years to life for murder, plus a consecutive 8 to 20 years for using a deadly weapon. Even though they don't know what the deadly 23:25 weapon was, other than the decapitation was clearly some type of knife and saw combo. But was the deadly weapon the wooden stick that she claims that she hit him with? 23:36 You didn't see any pictures of the crime scene or anything, did you? 23:38 No. No. No, but now that you said that, I feel. 23:41 That I, they're not going to release that. 23:43 Devin cannot seek parole until she has served 28 years behind bars. She received credit for about two years of time that she already served. Her lawyer asked for leniency saying this is a case where the court should look at redemption. Devin also spoke to the court. She said, 23:59 I know no matter what I say, they're still going to feel the same way. And then Jonathan's father said in court, we have all been given a life sentence by a woman who, who doesn't respect life. Police never located the victim's head or the murder weapon or weapons. 24:15 Early reports said police believe the head was thrown into the trash. So that is the case of Devin Michaels and Jonathan and Devere, the son, stepson. 24:30 That is a family that has a lot of Unconventional, dynamic interactions and living arrangements. And I don't even know how to phrase it. Can you imagine if you're her cellmate? 24:46 And you're like, why are you in here? I didn't like who I was, my husband. And so I chopped off his head. 24:50 I just feel like. 24:51 I'd be like, what did he do that you didn't like? 24:54 So I can make sure I don't repeat that. 24:55 And then she's like, do you want a massage later? 24:57 Can you hand me that wooden stick? 25:00 Yeah. I'll give you a massage. All right. 25:02 One you'll never forget. 25:03 No, thanks. All right, guys, thank you so much for listening till death do us part. Please be sure to follow Legally Brunette wherever you listen to podcasts. Also, if you have any recommendations of cases for till death do us part, please find me on Instagram and send me 25:17 a message. We'd love to hear your feedback. Also, be sure to tell your friends and family about Legally Brunette. 25:23 Thank you so much for listening.
Community discussion