0:02 Hi, guys. 0:02 Welcome to Legally Brunette. I'll be your host today, Emily Simpson. 0:06 And we have a very special episode today. I'm actually in the iHeart Studio, which normally I'm not. Normally, I'm at home with Shane. But we are here today with Aliza Rosen. And we're going to talk about a new podcast that just came out called The Gilded Rage. So 0:19 before we get into our conversation, let me just do a little background on the podcast. So The Gilded Rage is a new true crime podcast. It's an investigative show hosted by Lauren Malloy and Aliza Rosen, produced by AYR Media. 0:33 The story begins with an email from Penelope, who goes by Penny McGee. She says a man who they refer to on the podcast as Jay sexually assaulted her as a teenager back in 1981 and was never held accountable. 0:47 Her search for justice grows into a wider investigation of police reports, court records, and firsthand testimony. The show looks at a pattern of allegations against the same man, warnings that were missed, and an investigation full of inconsistencies. It 1:04 premiered in mid-October 2026 and releases new episodes weekly. The third episode branches into a related case. It examines the October 1985 death of Sherry Clark and an 18 year old CU Boulder freshman who was found face down in a drainage ditch beneath a bridge. Jay was the last 1:24 person to see Sherry the night of her death. Is it possible that Penny's alleged assaulter could have played a role in the death of Sherry Clark? 1:33 All right. 1:34 I'm so excited that you're here. 1:35 Thank you so much for having me. 1:37 I'm so happy. Thank you for being here. So let's just start out. Who gets the email from Penny McGee? 1:43 Lauren. 1:44 So the connection is Lauren's in Rhode Island, Penny's in Rhode Island. Lauren had been public on Twitter at the time. 1:51 For My Mom's Murder, which is actually a show we did together for Audible, which is about her own investigation into her mother's murder. Because she always thought her mom died of natural causes. Gets this crazy email. Another crazy email. 2:02 A different crazy email. 2:02 A really different crazy email saying, like, actually, your mom was murdered. So when she and I link up, we're in the middle of producing My Mom's Murder. 2:09 She sends me this, forwards me this email from Penny. 2:12 And she writes her saying, I believe that this man... is, you know, not only did he sexually assault me when I was 15 outside the Dunes Club, which is like a very she-she exclusive club in Narragansett, Rhode Island, but I believe he may be responsible for all of these 2:27 other assaults. And he could possibly have, you know, been responsible for the death of Sherry Clark, like you talked about. 2:33 So we were intrigued. And then obviously we found out Penny's background and were doubly intrigued and thought, okay, there's definitely something here. 2:39 And this was almost three years ago. 2:40 That's how long this is, you know, Because the investigation, so we just like basically started becoming detectives. Normally, you know, with my company and my podcast, there's producers under me, there's people, I'm just sort of like overseeing it. 2:52 But this one just like took a hold of me. 2:55 And I just, this has become my life for almost the last three years. 2:59 So that's how it all started. What was it about this case and what she said in the email that intrigued you so much? Because I would assume, based upon who you are and what you've been, you get lots of things like that. Do you have people reaching out? 3:09 Because even I do just on Instagram, I have a lot of people that will DM me and say- this happened to my sister or this happened. Can you look into it or can you talk about it? And obviously you can't do that for every, every person that comes forward. 3:24 Oh, you don't know how many times I don't even, you know, most of the time I don't take it on because it's just not, it's always interesting, but it's like, it's this one. 3:31 I think there were a few reasons. One is Sherry was. 3:34 Exactly two years older than me. So Sherry's birthday was October 17th. The party that she was at was October 18th. 3:41 That's my daughter's birthday. My daughter's a freshman in college now. 3:44 Sherry was a freshman in college. She was found dead on October 19th. That's my birthday. And I was like wild and crazy when I got to college and would get drunk and, you know, flirt with guys, et cetera. 3:55 And I just remember thinking like there by the grace of God, I could have been Sherry Clark. Literally she knew this guy for five minutes and she's dead. And having the night of her life, couldn't wait to celebrate her 18th birthday with her friends that weekend. And I 4:08 just felt these weird connections. Plus there were some other really weird similarities. I had been one of the co-creators and executive producers of the, case of JonBenet, Ramsey, for CBS like 10 years ago. 4:20 And that was Boulder. 4:21 And the same coroner that did JonBenet's autopsy did Sherry's autopsy. 4:26 In fact, Jim Kohler, who wrote a book, he was a special investigator in 2006. I brought him on board because I knew him from JonBenet because we needed to talk to all of these old law, I mean, old literally in their 80s, law enforcement people who I knew 4:39 wouldn't talk to me. And he opened the door to all of these old investigators who were amazing that really were like, Ultimately, like, wow, we really blew this case. 4:48 Because we, you know, and this is not tooting my own horn. 4:50 It's just a fact. We did the work they never did. 4:52 Yeah. 4:52 And there's a lot of reasons behind that that we get into in the podcast. But it just, I had never seen something so wonky. And again, like, I did JonBenet. 5:00 I've done tons of true crime with really, really weird cases. 5:04 I mean, but for some reason, this one and then the layers of it with, you know, this pattern of other women. 5:09 And once we started... It was like, well, you're a little too young for this, but there used to be this commercial. 5:14 I don't know. 5:14 I know. I think I know how old you are. 5:16 I don't know. Maybe you will know this, actually. 5:18 So there was this commercial back in the 80s with Heather Locklear for Faberge Organics where she was like, and I told two friends, and they told two friends, and so on, and so on. And the screen kept getting bigger. 5:29 And bigger with the same person. 5:30 And that was how this case began. 5:32 It was like once I talked to one woman, they would talk to all their friends and more women. 5:37 And that's what's happening now that the podcast has dropped. 5:39 And we just dropped episode five. 5:40 Today, but it's kind of unbelievable, all the group chats that are going on from college and high school between all of these women. Some of them totally were like, oh, we knew all this, we just couldn't do anything, or like, we knew something was off, but we didn't know, and 5:56 so it's sort of like we were all people that grew up without social media, without phones, without texting, so everything was just word of mouth, but like, it was just a different time, and also the way that people looked at sexual assault was a different way, and we 6:09 had had like horrible cases on our campus freshman year and so there were just a lot of things I connected to and then I felt and this is going to sound corny but I truly believe it like I felt once I dug in and I saw how screwed 6:22 up this Sherry's case was like forget all the other women that had come forward I thought like she did this family does they're an amazing family too and and her brother was the one that kind of reopened it with Penny and I thought like Everyone just went on 6:35 with their lives. Like, this woman, she had the rest of her life ahead of her. 6:39 And not that people didn't care. There was just nothing they could do. 6:43 And this is not okay. Like, I don't care that it's 40 years later. We're going to find justice. And I really still believe we will. And we're kind of, like, on the path. 6:50 They're looking. 6:51 Boulder Coroner's Office is poised to— perhaps hopefully change their manner of death in her case. 41 years later, the DA's office has told the Daily Mail that they're looking at it again with the sheriff and the coroner. 7:02 So like things are happening and it just shows that like, if you're. 7:04 Annoying enough, persistent enough, which I know you get. 7:08 That because you're a dog with a bone in the best way. And that's the way I look at it. 7:12 I am a dog with a bone. I totally understand that. 7:15 You're like a detective. 7:16 It's the same thing. Yeah. 7:17 Let's just back up a little bit for our listeners and let's just talk about Penny. So she came forward, she sent the email and, You were intrigued by the case. 7:25 You guys decided to... Now, what was the first time you talked to her? 7:29 March of 2024. 7:29 Was it a phone call, Zoom? 7:31 It was a Zoom. 7:32 Okay. And what did you think? I mean, did you... No, 7:36 that was. 7:37 Kind of a diabolical laugh. It was more, I didn't know what to think. If we're being honest, I just didn't have... Because I'll tell you what I thought. 7:43 Yeah, no, please. 7:44 So I listened to the first episode. I found her to be very entertaining. I mean, the way she speaks, you're drawn in. She is a very good storyteller. Um, I also found her to be very credible. And I think that's very important because when you're listening, you want 7:59 to root for the, that person, right? That's what draws you in. That's what you keep, keeps you. Cause you're like, how does this end up? Do we find justice? So I found her to be very credible in her story. She, even though it happened so long ago, and I guess 8:12 we could talk a little bit about it, but I do want the listeners to listen to your podcast. I don't want to give away too much information, but so she was sexually assaulted when she was 15. 8:20 She says, yes. 8:21 Yes. And so, um, So she talks about that. She recounts the story. And even though it was over 40 years ago, she gives a lot of details about that night. 8:29 She remembers a lot of things. And then I assume after you talk to her. did you make phone calls and things to corroborate what she was saying so that you knew, okay, let's go forward with this? Yeah. So, so to your question, I, I believed her right away. 8:44 Okay. 8:44 And that doesn't mean that she's not a complicated person. 8:47 That doesn't mean that she's not, doesn't have skeletons. That doesn't mean that she's made mistakes in her life. Like that's what attracted me to her was like, She's not a perfect victim. 8:55 Yeah. She's complicated as hell. Doesn't mean she wasn't sexually assaulted. 8:58 When she was 15. 8:59 Right. 8:59 One doesn't mean the other, right? 9:01 Like we're complicated human beings. 9:03 And also you could argue that that informed the rest of her life. 9:06 She was really young. 9:07 I mean, you know, that is interesting because I was thinking about that when I was listening to it and I thought, well, now she's got these complications later in life. 9:14 But she also, assuming that what she says is true, she's a victim that never came forward, that never told her parents, that never got, help that never sought any kind of therapy or anything for it. So was what she went through at such a young age and held inside, 9:32 I mean, it could have been a predictor for a lot of things that happen later when you're not healed from traumatic events. 9:38 I agree. And I think she agrees too. 9:40 You know, we talked about it, but one of the things that was most credible to me, other than very specific facts, like remembering super freak on the radio, you know, like, cause I know like I've worked with FBI profilers and 9:50 that's a very, that's an indication of authenticity when something that, that specific a detail. 9:55 But the other thing were the white jeans. 9:56 So back in the eighties, the Calvin Klein jeans, um, her sister loaned her, her skinny, you know, her white jeans and they were bloody the next morning. So Jennifer didn't, her sister didn't know she had been raped. So she had said, but so Penny had said, we just have 10:10 to be careful to. 10:12 Call them allegations. 10:13 But I, I believe Penny, um, Jennifer, um, remembers the bloody jeans. So even when Penny, you know, didn't tell her till much later, she remembered that. And so this was all also all corroborated in Penny's criminal complaints. So 10:27 I already had like hard evidence and they investigated it too. So, so even though I knew that Penny's life was complicated and there were a lot of, you know, things we're going to have to explore, she was the jumping off point for us to see like, okay, was there a pattern here? 10:51 Penny was the one that connected with the Sherry Clark case. 10:53 Is that correct? The way I understood it was that they basically said there's not enough probable cause to arrest to go to investigate this further because it's just based upon your recounting what happened 40 years ago. So she said, well, 11:08 if there's other women involved, then obviously that would be more probable cause. They said, sure. And then she made the connection between this same man, Jay, and another case, Sherry Clark. 11:21 Yeah, so she was in college and had heard about it because everyone kind of. 11:25 Heard about it in Rhode Island because it was this horrible thing. 11:28 Well, in Rhode Island, it's like. 11:29 Oh, literally, it's smaller than this room. I'm like convinced there's 10 people that live in Rhode Island at this point. 11:35 So she had, you know. 11:38 She was determined once they said that about like, is, are there other women? Cause she felt like she knew there would be, there was other women. Cause she just had heard so much over the years, but she'd also being, she remembered Sherry Clark story. So it's really actually hard 11:51 to find anything out about it online. So, you know, I love the image of her like holing up with Diet Coke and cigarettes and pizza all weekend. Cause I'm like, that's so relatable. And she finds Jason, Sherry Clark's brother. 12:03 And she calls him up, cold call. And she's like, my name's Penelope McGee. You don't know me, but I was raped by a man named Jay, you know, in 1981. 12:13 And I believe that he may have had something to do with your sister dying. And Jason was like, what do you need? Because Jason had been raped. always wanting to reopen Sherry's case because he knew and his whole family felt in their bones that this was not right. 12:27 And it wasn't an accident. 12:28 So when they hooked up, it was like, well, if I can help you, because, you know, then Penny felt like, wait, this is way bigger than me. 12:34 Like, I want to give her parents closure. 12:38 And but it also can help me because if we can somehow prove that this wasn't an accident, that gives more credibility to the fact that, you know, a pattern of violence, right, that he was capable of these things. 12:47 And he admitted that he and Sherry had sex, he called a consensual before she died. So who knows what happened there, but she did have two rape whistles in her bag in the dance hall that were left behind. 12:57 So that always said something to me. 12:59 Oh, that's interesting. Let's talk a little bit about Sherry just that night. So she goes to a dance. 13:04 So Sherry, yeah, she's eight weeks into school. She's a sorority pledge. She's happy as a clam. Again, just turned 18 the night before. She's living with her best friend, Laura, from high school. So their dream was to go to 13:16 CU Boulder together. So they are, they decide to room together. 13:19 They go to this kite and key party, which I think it still exists today. It's like between these two sororities. They, they all had dates and like, this was back in the eighties when we were just like getting smart about drunk driving. 13:31 So like they all took buses. 13:33 Jay did and he drove, but pretty much everyone else took, you know, caravan of buses. They get there, they're having a great time. She's with, on a date with someone else. 13:41 She was like I'd gone out with him like once or twice. 13:43 Yeah. But they were great. 13:45 And so all of a sudden, the date says I'm going to the bathroom. And she ends up talking to Jay, who they've never met each other before. He didn't even know her name the next day. And next thing you know, 13:57 according to witnesses, like less than five minutes later, they're outside. 13:59 She's kind of leaning on him. Where are we going? 14:02 A witness hears them, you know, where are we going? 14:04 And he's saying, shh. And then according to his account, they get in his car, they drive. 14:08 And this is all, like, we put diagrams and videos on our Instagram and our Patreon. But, like, it's all very, we've walked it now, like, 50 times. But it's a very small area. And they get in his car. They go past the security gate. They have consensual sex. 14:23 You say consensual in quotes. 14:25 Yeah. 14:25 For those of you now watching, the consensual is in quotes. 14:29 And according to him, she was fine. And she just wanted to stay outside a little while longer. And she either climbed out the window, fell out the window, got out the passenger side, got out the driver's side. There's about 13 different versions of how she got out of 14:42 the car. All we know is that the next morning she's found face down in the drainage canal 12 to 15 feet below the bridge with a laceration on the back of her head that was a fatal blow, an instant fatal blow. and her long dress is hiked up 14:58 above her waist, but she was fine. Her stockings in tatters. 15:02 One shoe off. 15:05 He comes back to the park. So this was off campus, right? 15:08 So this was not sanctioned. 15:09 By the university. 15:10 So they actually drove somewhere together. 15:12 Literally a hundred, like, like, like a hundred meter, like literally. 15:15 A short distance. 15:16 Yeah. 15:16 They could have walked it. Okay. But where would they have sex? 15:19 I guess. 15:19 Yeah. It was probably his thinking. So, um, so they went to his car. 15:23 So the broad strokes are basically, um, she's found dead, um, He ends up being arrested, which we get in, you know, I'm skipping a lot of steps, but when they impound his car, there was an aluminum club with white tape found on both ends that was logged as a weapon. 15:43 That was never tested. That was given back to him three days later after they, because they never charged him. 15:47 So they arrest him on first degree homicide and they book him. He spends the night in jail. They give us, and we have his mugshot, everything. But then they let him go the next morning because the autopsy was, Even though they were treating it that night as a murder. 15:59 It's all over the press as a murder because of the blow. Because if you're found face down. 16:03 That means that you hit your face when you landed. 16:05 You didn't hit. 16:06 Right. Except that if you look at her face, there's no injuries on one side. There's no injuries to her nose. 16:11 And there's blood coming out of her ear, which is consistent with the laceration on the back of her head. 16:16 So how does a skull laceration on the back of your head kill you if you're found face down? 16:22 Mm-hmm. 16:23 So they're looking at it like a murder. 16:24 Mm-hmm. 16:25 So, but then all of a sudden, the next morning, they're not. It's an accidental fall from a bridge. He gets let go. And they give everything. 16:32 Back to him. 16:32 But he's let go because the autopsy. Because of the coroner ruling it an accident. An accident. 16:37 And then, you know, we have, so basically, he's never charged. 16:43 There's a civil suit that follows. And I won't get into the weeds of that. But thank God for the civil suit. I won't say how that, the outcome. But because of that suit, we have this treasure trove Of stuff. 16:56 We've got all the police reports. We've got except his interview, which is sealed. And that's a whole other story against department policy. 17:03 I should wait his interview that evening. Yeah. 17:06 So there's a summary, but all of his files are expunged without a court order, which was not department policy at the time. And we get into the weeds on that, too. 17:15 And we get into the relationship between his lawyer and the sheriff who were very friendly. So the reason we call it the Gilded Rage is because it's kind of like that good old boy network in Boulder is kind of like this metaphor for someone rich, privileged, powerful, who 17:33 can potentially get away with crimes. And we've seen that obviously in the media all the time now as well. 17:39 And it felt like If this had just been any old Joe Schmo, it maybe wouldn't have ended up this way. 17:44 Because he came from a very wealthy family in Rhode Island. 17:48 And apparently, again, this guy that he hired, the defense attorney, was the DA in Boulder. 17:55 And again, very small. So they all know him. They respect him. 17:58 He's an amazing lawyer. Very well respected as a DA, then equally as respected as a defense lawyer. So everything was able to go away very quickly. I mean, very quickly. 18:06 Yeah. 18:07 And even though they were, you know, the Clarks, Sherry's parents hired a private investigator. And we had these incredible interviews on tape from the time of women saying, he assaulted me. He's dangerous. His nickname is Psycho Killer. That 18:19 was his nickname before Sherry. Just didn't connect for law enforcement, I guess, even though the day after he's arrested, a girl goes in to report him sexually assaulting her, allegedly, six weeks earlier. And they said, do you want to 18:34 report it? And she said, no, he's psychotic. He owns a gun. I'm terrified of him. No, he denies that. 18:40 He says that it was consensual. She says he pinned her down and orally raped her. So, you know, and again, and then we find all of these other women from these cassette tapes. And then since the podcast has dropped other women coming forward. So it's just curious. 18:53 That's interesting. So how many women have come forward since the podcast? I mean, you probably don't know like a specific number, but has it been? 19:01 I think it's like four or five. Actually, men have come forward too. Oh. 19:05 Not that he assaulted them, but my girlfriend, I know this girl, you know, so I'm not direct, but my point is it's like these men want justice too. 19:15 And they're like, oh yeah, we remember this. I remember my girlfriend told me this. I remember my friend told me this. 19:21 So we've been overwhelmed, honestly, and we're vetting everything, right? 19:26 Because- That's what we do. 19:27 And that's why it took us three years to put this together because you can't just put. 19:30 It out there. 19:31 But it's clear that there's a, you know, a preponderance of people here. 19:35 And, you know, women. 19:37 You know, it's interesting when you talk about how there was a weapon actually found in his car, which was a bat. Is that what you said? It was a club. 19:43 They called it an aluminum club. Okay. 19:45 Like a, golf club? 19:47 No, like a club. And then I guess he wrapped the tape because when we asked the sheriff about. 19:53 It, he's like, who needs that other than our plumber? 19:55 A college kid doesn't need that. 19:57 We were laughing. 19:58 And he said, I'll tell you why he had it wrapped on both ends, because that's the only way you can make sure you have. 20:02 A grip on it. 20:03 Otherwise it would be slipped. Slippery in your hand. 20:06 Right. So we don't know what the club looked like. 20:08 We know the scalp laceration was about an inch long. 20:10 It was small and a little jagged. 20:13 So when we, we actually hired our own independent pathologist and we asked her, I said, do you think. 20:17 The club could have been used? 20:18 She didn't say yes. 20:20 And she didn't say no. She's like, we can't rule it out, but I can't say definitively this is, this was the club. So who knows if the club was used at all for anything? 20:28 We don't know anything, but it's just so bizarre that they don't tell, you know, they, they, the weird thing is they collected all the evidence. They collected fingernail scrapings, they fingerprints, like they did their job and then they 20:39 didn't test anything. Or if they did, it's not logged anywhere and we have no results. 20:43 So when you said they collected fingernails, is that something that you can still access now, 40 years later? 20:48 Well, here's the thing. He admits they had sex, right? 20:51 Right. 20:51 So they found semen in her vagina. He didn't deny that. 20:56 And there was seminal fluid on the passenger seat. 20:59 Right. He's saying we had consensual sex. She climbed out of the car. She went on her merry way. She was intoxicated. 21:05 Right. 21:06 Right. 21:06 And then I don't know what happened after that, right? 21:08 She fell off a bridge. She said she was fine. Right. 21:10 Same fine. One shoe on. 21:12 But did they find the shoe? Didn't he have the shoe? 21:14 So he goes back. Sorry, I lost that thread. He goes to the park the next morning. So it was off campus, El Dorado Springs. 21:21 He wakes up. So he goes home with his date. 21:22 They have sex. 21:23 He wakes up super early. So he was actually at the party with a date too? 21:27 With another date. 21:28 And then he managed to get hurt. 21:30 She's like, next thing I know, he's gone. I don't even remember him being gone for more than like 20 minutes. 21:34 And then he was back. I had no idea that he had sex. 21:36 She's like. 21:37 I can't believe he had time to have sex with someone else. So he has, he goes home with her. 21:41 He wakes up like, you know, a couple hours later, he's like, I forgot my sweater. So he tells police, he goes straight back to the park. He doesn't tell them that he actually stops at his friend's house to get his dog, which I just think is interesting because 21:52 why would you make that extra stop to get your dog to go to a state park? I mean, it would be a good, like good place if you're you know, around to be like, oh, I'm just walking my dog. 22:00 But he never gets out of the car because when he gets to the park, the security guard stops him and he's like, hey, did you find a sweater? And he had. When he came to the park, right next to the gate, right next to the bridge, the top 22:10 of the bridge, there was a shoe, her shoe, a sweater. 22:14 and a sole beer bottle up like this. And he said he never got out of the car. 22:18 So it's also interesting, like how do you, and he admitted it was his beer bottle. 22:22 So also how does that get there perfectly placed there, right? 22:24 Right, if he didn't get out of the car. 22:25 Right, that's interesting. So he's like, oh yeah, I have this. 22:28 So he gives him the sweater and the shoe. And Jay tells the cops later, well, I took the shoe thinking that I would just return it to her later, which he never did. He didn't try to go to the, he knew what sorority she was in. He could have 22:40 easily dropped it off at the house. So he took both. 22:42 And they were in his car when, so why did he go back? 22:46 Because if she was fine and he's giving her the sweater, presumably because she's cold, you know, it's cold. 22:51 It was like she was, you know, I think early, you know, low 30s. 22:55 It's pitch black, by the way. You're in the middle of a state park. It was like cliffs and canyons, you know what I mean? And it's dark and she's drunk. 23:01 And you just had sex with her and she's a stranger. Like, you wouldn't make sure she's okay? You wouldn't make sure she got back to the party? 23:06 You would just leave her? 23:07 That's, I mean, at the very least, right? 23:09 Right. 23:09 And so, but also, she's fine. Why wouldn't you assume she has your sweater? Why would you assume she left it? 23:16 Right. Why would you go back to the park to look for it? Exactly. 23:19 And they never got, really didn't seem to press him on that. If they did, we don't know about that. 23:23 So let's talk about his story keeps changing. He claimed that Sherry stumbled out of his car, then claimed that she, we've talked about this, crawled out of the window, then said that she fell out of the window, and then 23:35 Just from your experience, what do these conflicting stories say to you immediately? 23:41 Well, it doesn't really matter what it says to me because what it means to, what it should mean to law enforcement, when someone is telling stories, I think 10 to 13 different stories less than 24 hours after the night it happens when they say they were borderline drunk 23:57 and pretty much okay. 23:59 Why? 24:00 The truth, I was just watching the Natalie Holloway doc this weekend. Did you watch it? 24:03 Oh my gosh, I was just going to bring that up because I was just going to say what you're talking about right now reminds me of Joran van der Sloot. 24:10 I didn't say that. He had so many different... Do. 24:14 You remember what the cop said? 24:16 No. 24:16 He goes, if you're telling the truth, you have one story. 24:19 Mm-hmm. 24:20 And I was like, oh. 24:22 And that's kind of the way I look at it. 24:24 Like, why does the story keep changing? And why the window? 24:28 It's just so weird that he... And so we actually... 24:31 Lauren is amazing. 24:32 She found the exact same car, the 1982 Celica on Craigslist or Facebook. 24:37 No, Facebook Marketplace. 24:39 And she went with our pathologist to do experiments. 24:42 Because we were like, well, maybe she did fall out of the window and hit her head. 24:47 And that was the fatal blow. But. 24:50 It would have been, it was so close to the ground. Like, I don't know if you know that car, but it's small, right? 24:56 It's like three feet from the ground. 24:57 Yeah. 24:57 So even if she fell out, she would not have incurred that fatal blow, even if it was like on a rock. It just wouldn't, the force, our pathologist said the force would have to be so. 25:06 Strong to be lights out. 25:09 And also, and this was so funny because her husband couldn't come, so she had to go with her brother, which was like very embarrassing because they had to like lay on top of each other to see if they could even have I mean, obviously with their clothes on, 25:21 but like, she's like, I couldn't even, you know, and obviously like we say, our experiments were not scientific, but it would have been actually even really difficult to have sex in the passenger seat. 25:30 So it's just strange. 25:32 I know this is just speculation, but you've been to that site. You've seen the bridge and everything. 25:37 Do you. 25:39 that she actually fell from? You don't think that happened? 25:42 I did at the beginning. Okay. 25:43 And now three years, I can, the one thing I can say, I can't tell you how she died. I can tell you she didn't fall off the bridge. Like with a hundred, she only broke her collarbone, Emily. Like if you see that bridge. 25:56 It's impossible. 25:57 Like you, you would have to be superhuman wearing like the biggest fat suit of all time to break just your collarbone falling 15 foot from that bridge. It's just, and again, your face would be, your nose would be broken. 26:09 Your face would be, you know. 26:11 Half her face is fine. 26:12 So you, do you think she was just laid underneath the bridge to make it look? Did you see the pictures? No, I didn't see the pictures. 26:18 So on our Instagram, this was, and I know it's a little like weird that we posted this, but Jason, her brother insisted. So, and we didn't post all, we just posted two, but we have two of the crime scene pictures. And she was actually, when she was found, 26:31 she was turned over. So it's not face down. 26:34 So she was, but her legs were like draped like this and her arms were like this. So it was like, it looks like placed. 26:42 It doesn't. Like someone laid her down. It kind of, yeah. 26:45 So I don't know. 26:46 And again, our pathologist can't say, but she says it looks like she was placed, but she's like, that's not. 26:51 How a body would fall off a bridge. 26:53 And one of the things we still want to do is get like 125 pound, five foot five dummy. And drop it off the bridge and see. Yeah, and literally just do all the scenarios. We did some testing, like Lauren walked with one, boot, like a high heel boot. 27:08 She literally couldn't walk like even. 27:11 Because we thought maybe she stumbled because she was drunk and then fell off or fell down the ravine. She's like, I couldn't even make it one step. So it's just like the theories just didn't test out. 27:23 Now, we were talking about the evidence earlier, like the finger clippings and things like that. And I don't know if we got that far, but are those still is that all destroyed? It's all lost and it's destroyed. 27:34 We have the stamp that says destroyed. 27:37 Yeah, nothing. 27:38 I mean, we have her body. 27:39 I mean, not to sound morbid about it, but like technically they could exhume the body. I just don't know yet what that would show because even if his DNA was under her fingernails, he could just say, well. 27:51 We're having sex. 27:51 That's what you do. She was exactly. So that, and again, he admitted they had sex. So I'm not sure. 27:57 And again, we have very good autopsy photos. I mean, they could still be better, but you can see the laceration. 28:03 So all of that. as clear as day. 28:06 I mean, I don't think, my point is like, I don't think you need to exhume the body to do your job and to see that none of this makes sense. 28:12 Now, the pipe or whatever was found in the car, does that still exist? 28:15 No, who knows? Maybe it's in his closet somewhere. 28:18 I don't know. He's not going to give it to us. No, no, no. 28:21 They gave it back to him. Oh, that's right. They gave it back to him literally three days later. That makes no sense to me. I don't understand that because I'm like, if we have it, we could test it. 28:30 Can you imagine? 28:31 Let's do DNA testing on it. Can you imagine? 28:33 And even the sheriff, the head of the whole department was like, we never tested the club. 28:37 I'm like, no, you didn't. Yeah. Could you have tested? 28:40 I mean, did they have DNA testing back then? 28:43 No, but you could have done, if it had blood, yes, you could have tested it against hers. 28:48 Like, it didn't have to. 28:48 Like, you could match blood types or something back then, right? 28:51 You could have done fingerprints. All of that existed. 28:53 That's what people are like, well, because you guys were in 2026. 28:57 We literally did a spreadsheet. We could have written it out. 29:00 That is the sophisticated police work we did. 29:02 We matched up every witness statement and saw there were contradictions in every single statement he gave to his friends and to police. 29:08 Mm-hmm. 29:09 That's not sophisticated police work. 29:11 Penny was triggered by all of this, right? I feel like Penny was just kind of living her life. And was she OK just not ever bringing this up and ever talking about it until he moved in by her? 29:22 Is that what you feel. 29:24 Was the catalyst? 29:25 I do. 29:26 I think that she didn't think about him every day. 29:31 It wasn't like something that tortured her. I mean, I don't want to speak for her. 29:34 But that was my impression, that it wasn't like every single day she debated whether to report it. 29:39 It was like, whoa, he just bought a house a mile away from me. 29:42 What? And she had been living, was it Arizona previously? 29:45 No, she had been living in Brookline, Massachusetts. 29:48 That's right. 29:48 And then had moved back to Rhode Island to Newport. 29:50 Right. 29:51 And was in Narragansett, which is close to Newport. And that's when she heard that he had bought this house a mile away and was like, wait, that guy? 30:02 Oh my God. 30:03 And then she's Googling, is there a statute of limitations on sexual assault in Rhode Island? 30:07 There wasn't. She's like, okay, I'm going in. 30:10 That was very brave of her after so long to be able to just go into a police department and say, Well, first, I think she wanted a restraining order too, wasn't that right? Yeah, which is... When she was talking about that, I was like. 30:21 You were like, I don't have to be a lawyer to tell you. 30:23 I was like, no, Penny, that's not going to work because he's not harassing you or reaching out to you or doing anything. I'm sure he wishes that you're just far away and that you never come forward. But besides after that, then she says she wants to file an 30:37 actual criminal complaint. 30:40 And she's not the only one in Rhode Island that can still do that. And that's all I'll say about that. 30:53 How much can you talk about the civil complaint? 30:55 I can talk about anything with a civil complaint. 30:58 So we go back and forth a little bit between Penny and Sherry Clark. And Sherry Clark, we just talked about her. Her brother is Jason, correct? And Jason is working closely with Penny. Right. And they had connected. And then Jason ended up filing a wrongful, was it a 31:13 wrongful death suit? 31:13 Oh, yeah. So that suit. 31:15 Sorry, I thought you meant the original. 31:16 So it's actually because her parents back in 86 filed a wrongful death suit. Part of the settlement, spoiler alert, was that they couldn't bring suit again. But that was just Connie and Jeff, the parents. Doesn't mean Jason couldn't 31:30 do that. So Jason actually, a few weeks ago when the podcast dropped, that same week filed a wrongful death suit against Jay. But honestly, we are very separate from it. Um, you know, purposely it has nothing to do with us and that's his prerogative to do that. Um, as far 31:46 as I know today, a few weeks later, it's still an active case. 31:49 I don't know what's like, we're like, that's his thing. 31:52 You know what I mean? It has nothing to, we'll probably mention. 31:54 It in our last episode because it happened, you know, after we had already produced the first nine, we'll definitely mention it. But you know, he, so he's sort of doing that on that front. And again, like, I don't know where that's at just a few weeks later, but 32:05 he's pursuing the criminal stuff actively. And again, like I said, waiting any day, it was promised back in August, but waiting every day, the coroner's office to make a decision and you know we're hearing behind the scenes that there will be a decision very soon. 32:19 Okay well that's very interesting so he basically has two avenues going right now he has a civil suit and then he's also putting pressure for them to reopen it as a criminal case that's right yeah i want is jay just is he just like living his life living 32:32 his life and watching everything too watching everything unfold so when you got into this and you're digging through it and you're getting all this information you're putting it all together When did you think I should put this into 32:43 a podcast? Was that like from the get-go you thought this would be great for a podcast? Or as you were going, you were like, we should put this together? 32:50 10 parts. This is how we're going to do it. 32:53 No, it's a really good question because, yes, at first, I thought this was a podcast. And then for like a year, I was so overwhelmed in a good way, you know, so to speak, because there was... But it became really a criminal case where we paused the podcast 33:09 part of it and just focused on law enforcement because we were talking to so many women. And then we found these cassette tapes with women at the time saying what happened. 33:17 We literally. 33:18 pivoted to law enforcement and creating documents. And I can't tell you how long, even with the help of Claude, how long it takes to put. 33:27 I mean, you went through law school. 33:28 It's really, really hard to, you know, and it's not my thing, right? So we had to be so meticulous. 33:35 And so honestly, for like a good like half a year, we just focused on gathering stuff for Rhode Island law enforcement and for Boulder law enforcement. And then once things kind of like Penny's trial happened and that ended, it was sort of open. Like we need to kind of 33:54 closure on that to see like what the directions, because it's a hard story to tell because it has all of these layers. And then once the trial ended, like the story, like the producer, the producer and me just saw it like the way it was going to unfold. 34:09 And that's when it turned back into a podcast. Yeah. 34:12 But for a while, I was just like, I don't even care about the podcast now. This is so much bigger than us. And that's kind of how I feel now. 34:19 I still care about the podcast, obviously. 34:21 But now with all the new information, it's sort of like back to where it was, where I was like, okay, pause, get the spreadsheet out. Everything goes back to the spreadsheets because that's the only way to keep track of everything and to make sure that Little old us, you know, 34:35 we're not law enforcement, but that we're doing everything we need to do to take the right steps to make sure law enforcement knows about everything. 34:43 Right. 34:44 Now, let's say that Boulder comes back and says, OK, we're going to reopen it. We're going to make it a criminal case. What do you see happening as far as evidence and like having a solid evidence? 34:55 Yeah. 34:55 To be able to prosecute them. 34:57 Yeah. 34:57 No, it's a great question. Look, it's not going to be easy because of the evidence part of it. However, and this is, again, my opinion, I believe between, to me, the strongest evidence are the autopsy photos and then the story and the fact that they do not match. And again, 35:18 like we talked about, the changing of the story, which is just factually, as far as law enforcement goes, indications of guilt. Then you get into the pattern. Now, will a judge allow what they call prior bad acts? 35:30 Depends. It's not easy. However, here's the craziest part, Emily. 35:34 We talked to a law professor at University of Denver who used to be a prosecutor and a defense attorney. 35:40 And she prosecuted sexual assault cases. And she said that back in the day, she and her female, her fellow female prosecutors would say, if we were ever raped, God forbid, we would never report it because it's too hard. So 35:53 she said, you have a better chance of pursuing a homicide. 35:55 They have a better chance of getting a homicide case against him than a rape case. 36:00 Mostly also because she's dead. 36:02 Right. 36:02 And that's, as far as she knows, and this may be, I would love to hear from someone if this is, but it's almost impossible to prosecute a rape case if the victim's dead. 36:11 So we, you know, they can't tell their story. Yeah. 36:14 So are you hoping, I mean, what would you like to see at the end of all of this? You would like to see the criminal case reopened. 36:22 I want to see justice. 36:24 So I don't want to be specific about what that means necessarily, because I want it the powers that be to do their job. 36:31 Like that's what I really like. 36:33 I like for the powers that be to do their job because they didn't do it right the first time. 36:37 And if they do their job and they go through all the paces and they still determine that for whatever reason, either in Rhode Island or Colorado, you know, that there's not a case to be made, then at least the criminal justice system has played out the way it's supposed to. 36:52 But I don't believe in any of these cases that that it did play out. And so I would like Justice to take its course, whatever that means. And obviously it's like, you know, I have to be okay. 37:03 I'm a producer. I'm not, you know. 37:06 But you're invested. 37:07 I'm very invested. 37:07 You're very invested. 37:08 I'm very invested, and I wouldn't have basically, you know, risked my whole life at this point with, like, my family. 37:15 You know, like, there's a lot at stake here, and this has taken over a huge part of my life. 37:19 Like, my husband's, like, so sick of hearing about this every day. 37:22 He's just like, please, can we talk about something else? 37:24 Let's watch the Love is Blind reunion. Right. I have time for that. Don't worry. 37:28 So, but you know what I'm saying? 37:29 Like, it's, I... yeah, I am invested, but I also, I can't be so invested. 37:34 Where, you know, I'm still not, yeah, like, and honestly, it has become an obsession. 37:39 Like, I'm not going to lie. It has, but I also have to live my life. 37:44 And, but I would really, it bothers me to think that there's someone allegedly who's gotten away with so much for so long and has never been held accountable. 37:54 That, that really keeps me up at night. 37:56 Yeah. You know, I would think just from my perspective and just from obviously I know this much compared to what you know, but to me it seems it's the only way to get justice in this case is if the criminal case is open. Because as far as the 38:09 alleged rape and things like that, there's just, it's just a he said, she said. 38:15 Well, with Rhode Island, again, if more, they did say probable cause would be more women. And so because there's no statute of limitations in Rhode Island, whether it's Penny's case or another woman who comes forward's case, if they 38:29 allow prior bad acts and other women's testimony, even from Colorado. 38:33 And then you're looking at two states. So is the FBI going to get involved? There's a lot of factors that will play out that are interesting. So I think there's actually two ways that it could happen. I think it could happen with potential homicide charges in Boulder and 38:47 then possible criminal charges for sexual assault in Rhode Island. 38:51 And again, I don't know if any of that's going to happen, but I don't think it's just, obviously with rape it is harder, but if 10 women are saying it happened to me and the pattern is almost identical, something's going on maybe? 39:03 Yeah. Allegedly? Allegedly. Allegedly. I was watching the new JonBenet, whatever came out recently. There's a new like 2020. Oh, yeah. 39:21 I heard about it with Burke. 39:22 Yes. I haven't heard his interview yet. I only watched like half of it. But I just have to ask your opinion. Will this ever be solved for you? 39:30 I stand by. 39:31 If you guys watch the case of JonBenet Ramsey, it was on CBS in 2016. You can buy it on Amazon Prime for. 39:36 Like $ 3. 39:38 Probably anyone listening to this has already seen it because they're probably all obsessed with true crime as well. 39:42 Yeah. I mean, I probably saw it at some point. 39:45 You did. 39:47 Yeah. I'm 99.99999% stand by everything we said. 39:50 Wait, what did you say? 39:51 Okay. 39:52 So what we said in the show, which again, I agree with, but it's my opinion, is that. 40:02 Burke, the brother, was- Wait, you think it was Burke? 40:07 Yeah. 40:08 With the parents covering it up. 40:10 But that's your opinion. 40:11 That's my opinion. 40:12 That is her opinion. We're just making that very clear. 40:14 That is your opinion. 40:16 But I'm open to other ideas. 40:18 But what about the unknown male DNA that hasn't... It's not, it wasn't. 40:22 So what, another thing that I learned from the JonBenet in terms of how I approached the Gilded Rage was to test the theories. So what incredible thing that we did with the show and we had CBS money, I have zero money for Gilded Rage. 40:33 So Lauren's like trekking out to get the. 40:36 Celica, but we had CBS money. 40:37 So we created an entire house in an airport hangar in Denver. 40:41 It was so cool. 40:42 And they literally recreated the Ramsey house, like down to like the camcorder on the kitchen with the bagels out. 40:48 Like it was so amazing. And we tested the theories. 40:52 So their whole thing was it had to be an intruder. 40:55 But the cobwebs were never disturbed outside the window. So we tested that. Like Laura, who was one of the investigators, She. 41:02 Literally climbed through the window to see if it was possible to climb through without disturbing the cobwebs. And it wasn't. 41:09 So we went through theory by theory. And I think, you know, these are all, you know, FBI, Scotland Yard, Henry, Dr. 41:16 Henry Lee, who's like the foremost forensic investigator who worked on the case at the time. These were also Jim Fitzgerald. 41:22 He solved the Unabomber case through forensic handwriting. 41:25 Mm-hmm. And he analyzed the ransom note. And it was like completely. 41:29 Clear that Patsy wrote it. I mean, it was just the most bizarre note in the history of ransom. 41:34 Notes in the history of the world. It is bizarre. 41:37 And so many indicators. 41:39 All the movie quotes. 41:40 Well, and they had movie posters all over their basement. 41:43 And she was a Francophile. And then there was like an attache. You know, there was just so many weird things. 41:48 But what about the garrotte? It was so sophisticated. 41:52 Well, he was a sailor. John Ramsey was a sailor. 41:55 Okay, there's one other case that I want to talk to you about too. Yeah. Have you ever heard of the Rebecca Zahal case? Yes. 42:01 Did you watch the Oxygen show? 42:04 I watched something. 42:05 I think that might have been the only one. Well, maybe like 2020 or Dateline did it. 42:09 I watched a documentary and then I watched where they did, I watched something where they did a recreation like what you. 42:15 Were talking about. That might have been the Oxygen. It was really well done. 42:17 Where they rebuilt the balcony and the guest bedroom and then threw the dummy off to try to see. 42:23 Yeah. 42:24 That one keeps me up at night. 42:26 I know. 42:27 I mean, JonBenet keeps me up at night, but that one keeps me up at night too. 42:30 And that one's not even that big a case. 42:32 Like in terms of, you know, it's not a household name. 42:35 Yeah. 42:35 And I mean, that's the Gilded Rage. I'm sorry. That's another, you know, wasn't he like a tech bro? 42:43 Yeah, he was a pharmaceutical tech bro. Restylane. His company made Restylane. Yeah. 42:48 I mean, you have enough money, you have enough power, you have enough connections to the justice system's going to probably work for you. 42:55 That case is, I have to drive to Coronado now, so I can just- Yeah, it's not that far, right? 42:59 It's not far at all. Yeah, you're going to have to go there. I'm going to go drive by. 43:02 Have you ever driven by the Menendez house? 43:03 Oh, yes. Obviously. 43:07 If you are going to come here, you're going to go to the Menendez house. 43:10 Oh, yeah. 43:10 I've taken photos of it. I've tried to climb up. 43:13 Isn't it so weird that it's right there on the street? 43:16 It's just right there on the street. Yeah, it's not behind the gates or- It's just right there. And when I saw it, they were remodeling it. So I was hoping maybe someone would come through and I was just going to like walk along with them inside, you know, 43:28 just a little check, a little check in, see what's going on. 43:31 And there were tons of, like there was, people were taking pictures. I was like, am I in an alternate reality? Yeah. 43:35 This is crazy. It bothered me though that it was so, they changed it so much. I wanted them to leave it exactly. 43:40 The Ramsey house, same thing with the Ramsey house. 43:42 Whoever John sold it to, They totally gutted like the whole basement had like the wine cellar and the train track room and all that. But apparently that all went away because we were in touch with the homeowners to see if we could use the actual house. 43:53 Yeah. 43:54 And they were like, but the basement's not going to help you. So that's why we recreated it. Yeah. Very interesting. Yeah. 44:00 I could just sit here all day and talk about true crime. 44:02 I know. 44:02 We still want to talk about. All right. So let's go back to your podcast. Oh, yeah. What do you want listeners to take away from it? 44:08 Yeah. 44:10 What I found from the true crime community that I love so much and I'm a part of is they see things we don't. 44:16 And that's been the case across every. 44:18 Show, every podcast, every TV show I've done is either people from the time who knew the players will come out and tell us new things, which is happening left and right with this, but they'll also see. 44:29 Pick up on little things. 44:31 You know, I have to say, even re-listening to it now for the 500th time, I'm picking up on new things because you're always, as a producer too, you're always listening for different things. 44:40 You know, you're listening for the music, you're listening for the sound effect. So sometimes when. 44:42 You're just listening for the people talking, you hear something you didn't hear before. So that's the first thing is I'm hoping for clues. I'm hoping for context, you. 44:50 Know, all of that of just like, what do you make of this? What do you make of that? 44:54 Even if it's just an opinion, it could help law enforcement and it could just help me like, you know, just to start to put, you know, because I will say I probably know this case better than anyone and that includes law enforcement. 45:04 At this point, I'm not bragging. It's just the sad truth. 45:07 And so, but I can help you know, hand over what I know. And I also hope that it, and this is happening and it makes me want to cry, that it helps women have the bravery that Penny had. Because, you know, I'm literally talking to somebody today who's going 45:24 to report what she says happened to her to law enforcement. 45:27 And you know, she's in her sixties. Like it's, it's not easy to do ever, let alone, you know, now. 45:35 And it's like, there's a lot at stake. You know, these people have families, they have reputations, they have careers. 45:39 And again, like nothing should happen to you. You should be safe to report anything to law enforcement. And the fact that we even have to think about not being believed or not having enough, well, who did they. 45:51 Tell at the time? 45:51 I mean, I just talked to someone last week that was like, well, I don't know about Penny. 45:55 And I'm like, you know what? 45:57 That's fine. You can have your opinion. 45:58 I'm not saying don't believe her or believe her, but those are not the conversations I'm. 46:02 Really wanting to have right now. I'm wanting to. 46:05 Have, you know, here are the things that can help bolster my case, you know, and then I'd like to think that, All the cases that we're seeing, like Russell Brand, Harvey Weinstein, you know, all of these. 46:18 And I'm not. 46:18 Conflating this case with that. I just want to be super clear. But I'm just saying that those cases were not one-offs. Those cases were able to be prosecuted because of the preponderance of women. 46:28 So that's all I'm saying. 46:31 Right. 46:32 You get that. I get it. I get it. You talked– I just want to back up a little because things stick in my mind and marinate. You were talking about cassettes of other women. 46:42 This was insane. 46:43 Is this– When you say cassettes, that means old. You say cassettes. 46:47 I say 1985, stick it in the old. 46:49 So is this other women at that time period in the 80s, not women coming out now, present day? Exactly. 46:57 We're 15 months into the investigation. 46:59 They hire a PI, the Clarks, to basically they believe that Jay is guilty and they want to talk to everyone to find out, does he have a pattern? What do they know about this guy? So they hire this PI. 47:09 He starts doing interviews. He records them all. but he does tons of his own handwritten notes and then he types up all his notes. So when we get the case file at the beginning of 2024, all we have are his handwritten notes and his typed notes, which are good, 47:23 but they're secondhand. And then literally, and we cover this in real time in the podcast, because it kind of like, the investigation sort of like caught up to real time. 47:30 And then we just started recording everything. Cause we're like, okay, we're literally like, I. 47:33 Wasn't even supposed to be in this. 47:35 Right. So you're literally talking about the past, the past, the past. And then all of a sudden it's like, wait, now, now it's present day. 47:41 Literally my phone dings and it's Jason going, you guys. 47:43 And he shows us a picture of a manila envelope with all these tapes. And he's like, and I see that the, the names on the tapes that correspond to the notes. 47:51 And I'm literally chills run through my body. He's like, do you think these are the, I'm like, Jason, I literally am like Googling, you know, Aurora, Colorado digitizing. 47:59 Like within a day we had all of them digitized. 48:02 This is like what a documentarian prays for this moment, you know, because you know how hard it is to, of course people can talk about what happened today and I still believe them, but to have them at the time. 48:12 And by the way, one of the girls, spoiler alert, said that she reported it to Brad Leach, the sheriff at the time, and he told her not to carry it with her. If it was his daughter in Arizona, he'd tell her to just leave it. 48:24 Just let it go? 48:24 Let it go, and I asked him about it. 48:26 Wow. 48:26 And he goes, well, it had to be true because my daughter was at ASU at the time, so he didn't even deny it. 48:32 Yeah. 48:32 Like, it was insane. 48:33 So, yes, we have these girls at the time going, well, we all— his name was Psycho Killer. 48:38 We all think he did it. 48:39 And, you know, it's just why, and then telling their own stories. And actually one of the, we try to get in touch with all of them. We give them pseudonyms, pseudonyms in the pod, try to get in touch with them. 48:47 None of them responded. Then one of them listened to the podcast. Cause like I said, it's going around the surface and she reached out to me and she's like, I'm Wendy. Cause that's the pseudonym we gave her. And she told us her story again. It actually is more 48:59 graphic and more upsetting that she even told the PI at the time. 49:02 But I think she was embarrassed. Yeah. 49:05 And it was like, wow. 49:05 So she's not just corroborating what she said happened at the time, but it's actually even worse. 49:09 Wow. And she is like, I'll go to law enforcement. Yeah. 49:13 And where did that happen? 49:15 She says it happened a year before. 49:19 In his room. So would this have been Rhode Island? No, sorry. 49:25 This was at Boulder. 49:25 Okay. 49:26 So that's where he went to college. Exactly. He went to CU Boulder. 49:30 He was a senior when Sherry was a freshman. 49:32 Okay. So that's why we have the two locations because he's from Rhode Island. And then went to school at CU Boulder. 49:38 And then went. 49:38 To Harvard Summer School where this Wendy alleges that he did it to friends of hers there. And then in his deposition, he's asked about He admits he did go to Harvard summer school, but he said like all encounters that he had were consensual. So just to be clear, 49:52 like he says any allegations of his entire podcast, you know, either he doesn't remember them and like in the deposition, he's like, I don't even know who you're talking about. 50:00 Or it was certain girls. It was consensual. Like Kim Smith, the one who reported saying, I'm not going to report it. 50:07 He's psychotic. 50:07 He owns a gun. I'm not going to file charges. Right. 50:10 He denies that. He says it was consensual. So anyone, you know, listen to the podcast and let us know what you think. 50:16 Well, I feel like there's a lot of people out there that might have information because I will tell you, whenever we do a podcast, I get a lot of information back from people that someone lived next door to someone or someone. you know, is cousins with someone. I 50:28 also have, you know, like guards from prisons that will come and send me long DMs about like certain prisoners that they had, you know. 50:37 I would love to spend a day in your DMs. Oh, I know. 50:40 It's so interesting. Well, besides people telling me I should be fired and that they hate me. Why did you lose weight? Why do you look so good? Yes, or people say they love you too. I mean, you get it all. You get all of it. I'm sure. There are so many kind DMs too. 50:51 You must have the toughest skin. Like, I can't even imagine. Like, not just you, but like any housewife who puts themselves, you know? 50:57 Yeah, I mean, you have to. People are crazy. They really, they are. Like, get a grip. They really are. The majority, I would say, are kind. Yes, good. And are, you know, always send nice messages about connections or my son or Shane or our relationship or the podcast. But you do 51:12 get the, you know, this crazy. And I'm like, why does it take so much time and energy for, like, I would never do that. Like, I would never watch a reality show and then take the time and energy. 51:23 to find that person and tell them how much I dislike them. I'm like, how much free time do you have that that's what you're spending your time on? It's loser behavior. bizarre yeah it's bizarre to me like you should be watching true crime instead of dming me figure 51:39 out the john bonnet case really solve it go solve something and then come back and talk to me because i don't that's what you should be doing a hundred percent all right well eliza thank you so much for being here today i want everyone who's listening to please 51:53 listen to the gilded rage it's so good i've listened to the first one did a lot of research I'm going to continue to listen to the rest of them because I'm going to follow through with this. Follow through. 52:03 You've got to find out what happens. It's very entertaining. 52:05 It's very intriguing. You guys are going to love it. 52:08 So make sure you listen to The Gilded Rage. 52:10 And I want to plug the Patreon really quick because what the Patreon has, first of all, you can listen to the first nine ad free right now today. So if you don't want to wait week to week, obviously you have the cuts because you're you. But for the 52:22 lay people, they have to wait unless they subscribe. But we have a ton of subscribers. 52:26 I'm so happy. 52:27 But you also get amazing bonus content because, again, one of the things, like, I personally love, I don't know if you're like this, I love, like, the behind the scenes. 52:34 Well, you do because of the questions you ask. Yeah. Like, the behind the scenes of the behind the scenes. Yeah. 52:38 So, we, on the Patreon, Lauren and I do, like, this, like, a chat for an hour where with each bonus episode. 52:45 So like today you'll get bonus episode five on the Patreon when the regular episode drops where we talk about, first. 52:51 Of all, we give you more. 52:52 So like Melanie, his date at the party, like we have stuff about her in this episode, but then you get more about that interview. And then like, the behind the scenes of like me texting her and what happened with that, you know, like just things that you would. 53:04 Never hear on the regular feed. 53:06 Plus we have case files, like all great, like stuff from the depositions, photos, diagram, you know, video, like just things that you'll never get. Like we have a lot on our Instagram, the Gilded Rage, so definitely follow that. 53:17 But this, I think you get a lot of bang for your buck is what I'm saying. I just think if you're a true crime person, you want to know everything. 53:23 Well, also in true crime is always evolving. So it's like, sometimes I feel like by the time we put an episode out, it's like, oh my gosh, okay, we have to do, we have to continue to do updates all the time. And there's more information that comes out and 53:36 more things. And also- I also find that when you're really into true crime like I am, and I'm sure like you are, and you stay up at night thinking about it and it's going on in your head, and then you're like, oh, I should have said that, or 53:47 I should have made that connection, and then you want to talk about it again. 53:50 Exactly. 53:51 Yeah. No, exactly. 53:52 Like, I mean, what I told you today about Wendy coming forward after she hurt herself heard herself on the tapes. 53:59 We didn't know that when we recorded the bonus episode. 54:01 So in the show notes today, I had to put like with asterisk asterisk update, Wendy has reached out to us since she heard that, you know, so it's like, stay tuned for that. 54:08 We're going to get into that later. Right. 54:10 So like you said, it's, it's, it's an, it's literally unfolding still, which is what's exciting about it, but also so unpredictable. 54:16 And again, I don't have CBS money. 54:18 To just be like, okay, editors, okay, producers, like you're looking at her with like a team of two. You know, Lauren and then like my assistant. So we're just trying to stay, and again, like most importantly on the law enforcement side of things, but also like obviously we have 54:32 an audience now. 54:33 We want to give you guys what you are looking for, you know? 54:37 Exactly. All right. Well, thank you so much for being here today. It was such a fun conversation. I would love to have you come back. We could talk more. 54:43 Let's just do two hours on Jamba Day. 54:44 We could just talk more about lots of other true crime. 54:47 All right. 54:47 Thanks, guys, for listening to Legally Brunette. Please be sure to follow us wherever you listen to podcasts. Make sure you tell your friends and family. And also, you can find me on Instagram. And please send feedback or other 54:57 case recommendations my way. Thank you guys so much for listening.
Community discussion