0:06 Amy Robach and TJ Holmes present Killer Thriller with your host, Alisa Donovan. Hey, everybody. Alisa Donovan here from Killer Thriller, joined by Jen Fessler from Killer Thriller Docu. Good morning, Jen. 0:23 Good morning. 0:24 Well, today, let me just tell you, I'm so happy that Billy Evans did this interview because it allows us to talk more about all of this. So, Today, we are talking about Billy Evans, Elizabeth Holmes' partner, who just 0:38 gave his first interview since the release of the bizarre documentary, You Can See Everything. Jen, did you watch his interview with CBS Sunday morning, and what did you think? 0:50 Of course I did. I certainly did. What I think is, like this happens with us, my girl, don't know that we're going to completely agree. Uh-oh. 1:01 Uh-oh. 1:02 Here's why. I think that he is the creepiest. I think that narcissist, you know, he, I think he is misogynist, all of the things, right. But if we're going to talk about how he did in this interview, objectively, but I'm just talking about performance. I'm talking about how I 1:26 think he came off to people that maybe even, I don't know if they hadn't seen the film. I don't, I think he came off better than I would have ever expected. And I actually think that Matt Gutman came off as a little, I don't know if aggressive is 1:44 the right word, but almost like there was not much that Billy could have said that would have been right, according to Matt Gutman. And I think he was. 1:52 Did we watch the same interview? 1:54 Right? 1:55 I knew it. I told you. I think he was, you know, wide-eyed. What is it? Bright-eyed and bushy-tailed? This, again, if you've seen the film... doesn't really matter because I saw the film. So I know, you know, from the film who this guy is, but this particular interview, I 2:10 don't know who coached him. And there was even the moment where Matt said to him, you know, you were very different just now off camera during commercial break, whatever it is, then now that when you just came back, what's that about? So I don't know what it was 2:24 like off camera, but I felt like on camera, he was very submissive. I mean, I don't know. What did you see? I mean, I'm sure– I feel you're going to say, oh, I thought he was a big faker. But, like, what did you see? 2:38 I'll say to start that he's definitely doubled down on the look them in the eye without blinking and they will believe you instruction manual that he has been following. Right. 2:48 I think he is utterly full of it. And this– I can break it down, all of it. Oh, sometimes I take too big of risks is one thing that he said in terms of answering why he would allow– The documentarians in his home. And in my opinion, that 3:07 is an opportunist, opportunistic narcissist way of saying, I thought I was smarter than everyone else, including Nathan Fielder. And I will always come out looking like the supportive, warm genius that I believe that I am. Just because someone 3:24 can twist a scenario, press anything to their favor, does not mean that they are right or telling the truth. 3:32 It means that they know how to manipulate situations to make themselves seem vulnerable. 3:39 Is there, though, anything that he could have said, any way that he could have behaved during that interview today? 3:45 that would have changed your mind. 3:47 No, because he's full of it. And he's everything you said in the beginning. He's a misogynist. Yes. 3:53 So having said that, he was still having to be him, right? 3:56 He had to go on TV for whatever reason that he chose this. He decided to go on and sit down with Matt Gutman and do this interview, whether, you know, whether in the end it, I don't really think it matters, but it proved helpful or harmful to him. But having 4:12 said that, There was nothing much that he could say. 4:15 And I think that, and I think I did read as well, that reactions to him, believe it or not, were better than expected. 4:24 I can say a dear friend of mine in New York who is very intelligent, very well-educated, is an attorney and an entrepreneur, and she felt that way, that he came off so much better. And I said, I am concerned about your instincts. 4:44 I get it. But it doesn't take away from knowing who he is. Do you know what I mean? Like it's not. 4:48 What do you mean? 4:48 These are two separate things. The way that he came across in this interview for me is separate from who I think he is. 4:57 So you mean you think he's still playing a character of some sort? I'm not sure what you mean. 5:01 I do think that he is a misogynist. I do think that he is a narcissist. All of that, that's from watching the film, right? But going into this interview and just looking at it, Right? Sort of like if we just put it in its own little microcosm. And 5:18 I'm watching this and did not know anything about the film. 5:21 I thought he seemed like, I'm sorry, Lisa, an okay guy. 5:26 Oh, my God. You didn't think he's measured the whole time, just like he is in the film, until in the film, you see him get pressed. 5:40 Right. I think it's also because Matt... Went after him kind of hard, right? 5:44 I feel so funny that you said that. I felt like it was this passive, easy interview that he didn't even... Yes. 5:52 I was like, what kind of an interview is this? 5:55 I did not feel like he pressed him at all. 5:58 Even when he was asking him about whether or not he thought Nathan had romantic feelings for Elizabeth. 6:04 And he.... 6:07 There's stuff that he said. It's true. I think it was everything out of his mouth that seems so benign, but I don't remember even exactly what he said, but Matt was like pressing him on it. 6:15 Right. 6:15 So you're telling me he was like, he gave his answer and it wasn't enough. 6:20 That was the only authentically truthful thing that Billy Evans said. 6:24 I thought in the whole entire interview is when Matt asks him if he thinks that Fielder is formed an attraction to Elizabeth as it's shown in the film. And Billy says Nathan Fielder played up certain bits in the film to criticize his own bias. And I think that 6:42 is correct. I agree with that, which is just smart filmmaking, but it doesn't exonerate Billy and Elizabeth or in any way make it better for them. 6:51 I don't know if I'm, I want to make sure that we're on the same page. I don't, this doesn't, this interview doesn't exonerate him and it doesn't change my opinion of him. So I want to, like, at all, right? 7:02 So that's not what I'm saying. But if we're talking about the interview itself, right, just if you take out all the rest, but you've never seen the film, and you're just going to look at this interview, maybe you are more perceptive than me. Maybe I don't have the 7:16 best judgment. But if I was looking at just the interview, I thought that he did as well. Knowing who he is, I thought he did as well as he could have. Now, it doesn't really matter because the guy's a dirtbag. 7:28 Yeah. He also went to MIT. He's not a dummy, and he's always looking like a deer in headlights. Like that, no one looks like that. No one keeps their eyes open for that long staring at someone except for these two people when they think I'm going to either Jedi 7:49 mind trick you or, again, I read on page 42 that if you make eye contact, people will believe you and think you're telling the truth. 7:58 Listen, I think. Absolutely saw it with the eyes. But even Nathan Fielder started to pick up on the eye thing. 8:05 He started to, obviously it's that hilarious scene where he's, you know. 8:09 Yeah. 8:10 So like, you know, that's, I guess it's something that can be learned. But, you know, I think that, I don't know what his, going into this interview, like what did he want to get out of it, right? Like what, not what he said he wanted to get out of it. 8:25 What do we think he wanted to get out of it? 8:27 He wants his, wife home. He wants, what is he looking for here? 8:31 He's looking for more attention and to try to get on the right side of public opinion. But everything that he said, look, for example, the shower, when Matt asks him, did you know that's going to happen? And he says, my recollections were different on that. That is laughable. He 8:50 obviously knew. You have a film crew shooting you in broad daylight, completely naked in the shower, and you aren't aware of it. I am just so insulted by this guy's arrogance, assuming that viewers are idiots. It is infuriating to me. 9:10 Yeah. I don't know that he even, maybe he thought that he could convince somebody of something. I can't imagine if anyone had seen the film, this interview would have changed their mind in terms of their perception of who this man is, right? It didn't change mine, even though 9:26 I can I'm looking at it and my, my feeling is that's as good as he could have done. He almost, he almost, if you didn't know better, if you hadn't seen the film, you might have seen. And again, you have to factor out the fact that you saw the film. 9:40 He might've even seemed sympathetic. If you factor out the fact that you know who he is already, you know what I mean? 9:45 Like I do, but like you can't like the whole reason he's doing this interview is because of that. 9:52 Right. If we're going to watch it separate from all that. 9:55 And like, even when he talked about his, You know, daughter learning to walk in... federal prison, right. And he, I'm just saying in that moment, if you didn't know who he was and you hadn't watched the film and you saw this guy get choked up about that, right. 10:12 It would feel authentic. 10:14 Well, yeah, because, but you can't remove the fact that it's their own fault. that their children are taking their first steps in prison. 10:25 I didn't say I feel bad for him. I said, he comes off as sympathetic. There's a difference, right? Like I didn't then think poor Billy, a little bad for the little girl, to be honest with you. 10:35 Absolutely. As do I. 10:37 There's that. I didn't feel a lot of poor Billy at all. And I also didn't buy the whole, when they were filming, I don't know, I guess I'm trying to look at it. Cause what your friend said, you were saying that she also said he came off, For 10:50 people that didn't see the film and haven't formed an opinion, I think he probably did a good job. Nothing changed for me in terms of who I think he is. 10:59 But he is, again, even when he talks about, I 11:04 loved this, when Matt asks him, you know, I forget how I worded it, but when they're talking about the potential of suing Fielder or, you know, H24. 11:17 Right. 11:19 Zero basis for him to be able to sue them. 11:22 That is a bunch of horseshit. They're probably worried that he's going to sue that. I mean, no, they aren't. 11:28 There is no way that A24 would have ever done this without making him sign off that they have 100% final say. And then he's saying he's a better person for not suing. Again, he is manipulating the narrative to make himself look vulnerable like he is the victim. And 11:47 I am not here for it. Like, I am not taking it. 11:51 I don't think he's the victim either. What about when he talks about when a car pulled up, he's with his kid, dropping his kid off at school and screaming and death threats. Do you believe the story? 12:18 No, I don't. And if it did, I'm that's terrible. 12:21 Like that, no one should go through that. But then for him to say, now he has a gun to protect his family. You think that guy didn't have guns before? 12:30 He talked about it when he showed his true self in that documentary and When he started going off about Charlie Kirk and going. 12:40 Over all of this stuff, that is who this person is. 12:44 So if he's, again, trying to turn it into, oh, I had to do these things because now my poor family is at risk. No, no, I don't believe it. 12:56 So he says also that he talks about whether or not he knew who she was when they met. Right. 13:04 And we'd already covered that in the documentary. 13:06 Yeah. 13:06 Nathan had already challenged him on that and said, you know, give me a break. But we find out in this interview that he had just been to Theranos. Yeah. 13:17 Had just been in her office. He's like, well, I did see her in her office earlier that week. 13:24 Right. 13:25 And then maybe my favorite part of this. Is when he says that he spoke with Elizabeth before the interview and Matt says, what did she say? And with his big doe eyes, he says, she told me to just be Zen, embody love. Oh, okay. So was she embodying 13:47 love when she lied and cheated people out of hundreds of millions of dollars? Was he embodying love when he's saying, I know, I know important people or whatever he was saying in the documentary that like, he has so much power and he's out for vengeance. This guy is a liar. 14:02 Yes, he is. But like, I'm looking at it right now. 14:05 This thought just occurred to me, right? This guy is creepy, a liar. I'll never get past the eggs. And that was just the beginning of the whole film, right? So all of that, but he didn't commit the crimes, right? 14:17 That was, that was Elizabeth, right? He didn't. 14:20 Yes, correct. 14:21 So let's say he's a creepy guy, right? And we can agree on that. He's not the criminal that Elizabeth is. 14:30 He's getting so much attention. He didn't even know Elizabeth when she masterminded. 14:34 Theranos, right? 14:36 He's just a creepy guy. I don't know. In all of this, I feel like he has become the villain, even more than her. 14:45 But he put himself there. 14:47 Regardless, I'm saying to you, He didn't commit those crimes. 14:50 She did. That's why she's in jail. But there's been so much attention to what a villain this guy is, right? 14:56 And I just think it's interesting because, you know, we're talking about how creepy he is. 15:01 And he is. 15:02 I can't take away from that. But also, it's a different thing to be creepy and a jerk-off and a criminal. 15:11 to rob people and ruin people's lives. Do you know what I mean? 15:15 Yes. 15:16 And I just think, so I think it's kind of interesting how there's so much attention to him as the villain. Right. 15:22 That we've almost forgotten that this is actually about Elizabeth Holmes and her crimes. 15:27 Yeah. 15:27 I mean, that's a fair point. Maybe that's a part of their, their whole plan. 15:33 Strategy. 15:34 I don't know. 15:34 I mean, they spoke right before, before he, he did it. 15:37 He said they spoke and I don't know what, what does she have a cell phone? They're speaking before the interview. 15:41 He's going to talk to her after the interview. I mean, all right, baby. Talk to you later. 15:48 Yeah. 15:49 Talk to you later. 15:50 Yeah. 15:52 I realize how incensed I get and like how enraged I get about this. And I, I really do think it is because I see so much of this in, in the Bay area in terms of, And it's usually men because the women are never given power. As I 16:13 said before, there aren't a lot of women startups and founders. 16:18 And if there are, they've had to work so hard to get there. So it's generally men. And it's this arrogance and elitism and manipulating of language that to me is in such a simple way. Like if you're not If you're going to drink the Kool-Aid, then yeah, you're 16:37 going to believe all of it. But from the outside, when you hear it, I'm just like, and then to, and I'm particularly sensitive when somebody tries to exploit any kind of spirituality. It really makes me crazy. So him saying that was like the capper to me when he said, 16:56 be Zen and come from love. I was like, I just could not get over it. 17:02 Watching the documentary and even the way he spoke to people, right? 17:05 even the way he spoke to Nathan and the crew and like, he was so, he had this presence in that house, this, this control freak arrogance and sort of this, you know, obnoxious condescending attitude. And so he just wasn't likable, 17:25 like period. It just wasn't right. And he did those gross things like the shower scene and, um, The eggs. 17:34 Right. 17:35 The eggs and all, right. All of that stuff. And so, right. 17:39 It's just, I don't know how in this, but in this particular interview, I think he purposely pulled back. I think it was transparent, but I will still go on record as saying, I think he did as well. If he wanted to be, I don't know if he changed 17:54 anybody's mind, but if he wanted to at least have anybody be a little more open to him, he couldn't have done. I think that he did a good job. Again, didn't change my mind, but that's how I do feel like he did as well as he could have with 18:08 this interview. He let Matt Gutman, I can't explain it like for a lack of a better word, he wasn't aggressive, but he was more commanding. And I think that Billy took this sort of submissive posture. 18:21 But that's his whole shtick. 18:23 Yeah, well, you did it. 18:24 I'm so like, this is the woman I love. I'm so connected to my femininity and I'm such a kind Zen guy until I have a drink and you push me and then I'm going to start talking about guns and revenge. 18:39 Listen, I think he hates Nathan Fielder's guts. I think he hates the film. I think he hates every single thing about it. But if I didn't know him before and I hadn't seen it, I wouldn't maybe... I was like, yeah, okay. 18:53 You're a big fan of Nathan Fielder. Get the fuck out of here. 19:10 To your question of like, why would he do this? 19:12 Maybe that's why he's actually trying to get to the people who haven't seen the movie. Which could, you know, is, although the numbers on this, the box office are kind of just astronomical. 19:24 Everybody has seen this movie, right? 19:26 It does seem like almost everybody has seen it. 19:29 Right. So she's going to a halfway house next summer. 19:31 Whatever game they're playing here and whatever posturing they're doing, I don't think it's going to make a bit of a difference. It doesn't matter. Like, her cover's blown. I don't think she's getting, nobody in Silicon Valley's looking for her. 19:48 I don't think she's going to have. 19:50 You know, maybe they're trying to like make it impossible to have a, well, she's not gonna be tried again. 19:56 I don't know. 19:56 Yeah. 19:56 Like, I just think that they're so manipulative and him 20:02 saying that he loves the documentary and the filmmakers and would do it all over again, even though it makes them look crazy. And has had death threats. Sell it someplace else, Billy Evans. Because I am not buying it. 20:19 Listen, but listen, here's the thing. Brought in the ratings. Yeah. 20:23 I wonder if he, I don't know how this works for 60 Minutes or any of these sorts of shows, but I do know you can be paid for interviews. 20:32 Oh, yeah. 20:33 So I'm sure that he was paid something. And I do wonder how much. Yes. 20:39 Yeah. And, and we'll maybe keep that up. 20:42 Yeah. 20:42 What is it? I don't, you know, I mean, I don't know what their money situation is. 20:47 Maybe he is just trying to keep, you know, bringing in as much money as possible. So when she gets out, they won't be, you know, like they'll be in an okay place or I don't know. Cause I still don't know how she could ever pay back everything that she. 21:01 They've got two kids and a lizard and a, I don't know what else is going on in that house. 21:06 Snake or something. 21:07 I listened to the interview that we did, the episode we did after we watched the movie, and I had also forgotten about the lizard until you brought it up, and then I started laughing all over again. 21:21 Creepy. Creepy. Give me the ick, as the kids say. 21:29 Give me the ick, as the kids say. Low-key ick. 21:32 It gives me a huge ick, I have to say. 21:36 But listen... Can't lie. If he does another one, another interview, I may watch it again. I may watch another one. 21:41 Oh, I definitely, but you know, and you asking what could he have done now that I'm thinking about it, he could have stopped staring. He could have like just said, you know, this is, he could have addressed more directly and authentically. 21:59 I mean, if he had not stared, if he had tried to be a, First of all, I don't think he would have been capable of really being authentic. Right. 22:04 And that's his personality, clearly. Right. 22:07 Right. And so I just think if you had seen the film, there wasn't much you could have done. And if you hadn't seen the film, he looks better than he definitely looked in the film. I mean, bottom line, again, like, he stayed calm. I think Matt probably wanted to beat 22:27 him a little, wanted to get out that. 22:29 Yeah, that defensive and aggressive. 22:32 The energy had, what's her name? 22:35 Amanda Seyfried. 22:38 Yes. 22:39 And that's the other thing. To do that to a woman, not to go back to the movie, he loses it, starts to unravel against her, which is so emblematic of a misogynist. He hates women so much underneath it all. 22:57 I This is just, I'm never going to, I'm never changing my mind about this situation. 23:05 Well, and I get that, but I understand what I'm saying. 23:08 Neither am I. 23:10 Yeah. 23:10 I just thought the interview is, you know, if we're just looking at the interview in a bubble. 23:18 Right. 23:19 I thought it was really interesting. And I thought this guy, if I'm his publicist, I'm going, good job, Philly. 23:28 Thumbs up, Philly. 23:30 Thumbs up. See you never. 23:32 I mean, you're not alone. You're not alone. As I said, my dear friend in New York, same. 23:40 All right, my love. 23:42 I could talk about this for hours, as is probably clear. 23:44 People are like, can you zip it up now? We understand how you feel. 23:48 I don't think so. I think everyone's talking about it. 23:51 I guess when he does the next interview, we're talking about it again. 23:54 That's right. 23:55 How's that? 23:56 That's right. Keep talking, Billy. 23:58 Keep talking. Making that payroll. All right. My love. All right. 24:03 Love you. Thanks. 24:06 Okay. Bye guys. 24:07 Bye guys for joining us.
Community discussion