0:06 Amy Robach and TJ Holmes present Killer Thriller with your host, Alisa Donovan. Hey, everybody. Alisa Donovan here from Killer Thriller, and I am joined by Jen Fessler from Killer Thriller Docu. Hi, Jen. 0:21 Hi, Alisa. 0:23 So today we are talking about Netflix's new InstaDocs documentary, Jane Doe v. 0:30 Cornell. 0:31 Seven men accused of sexual assault, disturbing fraternity messages, and a university facing some very serious questions about how it handled the case. So we have talked about this before, Jen and I, on another podcast and just in life. 0:48 And we've actually gotten a lot of detailed factual information from journalists and psychologists and psychiatrists. Jen, what has struck you most about this case? 1:06 Watching Cornell's newspaper and the women that worked on the newspaper, the way that they got the information from Jane Doe, the way they processed it, the editor said something towards the beginning of the documentary that when she had found 1:25 out about Jane Doe, or Jane Doe had, I guess, contacted them and she had said to her parents, yep, so I guess this is really just a very stereotypical American college where things like sexual assault are going on. 1:38 And I guess she wasn't, maybe her parents weren't from the country, I don't know. But I thought to myself, that is so sad. And I think that that's part of what is so hard about this case and being able to you know, take it in and then you 1:57 continue hearing about, and we've done a lot of talking about sexual assault on college campuses and how prevalent it is. 2:04 And a lot of this was about that. And that was, you know, that definitely struck me. 2:10 Yeah. So we should say the, the sun, which is the Cornell newspaper is an independently financed and run college newspaper. 2:19 So they are not beholden to the university in any way. 2:23 And the, That journalist in particular from The Sun, the young woman, said it was so graphic, meaning the text messages and the case, that it was so graphic that it was important for me to personify these individuals so that people understood that these young men were still on 2:46 campus and could be in your class. You could be in the quad with them. And So they listed their names so that people would know. And it's a really bold action to take. And I was just struck by how powerful these young women were in this documentary, From 3:10 the Sun. And they were very even keeled and articulate. 3:17 I just thought like, wow, that is really amazing. um, courageous. 3:24 Yeah. Um, I don't think, I think we'll probably disagree here, but until I think that it's, they were able to do it because they are privately run and they're not funded by the school putting out names without having all of the facts. I, again, I think you're going to 3:42 probably disagree with me about, about this, but I probably think that we needed to have, or Cornell needed, the students needed more information. There's, I know there's at least one case, one of the boys who says that he wasn't, she wasn't naked when he was in the room. They 4:02 didn't have sex. He didn't know the other, that she was having sex. Now, whether or not that's true, I'm just saying. 4:07 But doesn't that just take us off the point that they are all culpable? Like when we get, certainly, sure. 4:13 Except that he's saying he's not. He's saying he's not. 4:15 Sure it's worse to be, to have physically experienced assaulted this woman or to have pushed drugs on her, et cetera. 4:23 But it's not good to have been there, seen it, been on the text message, and do nothing about it. 4:31 This is the part that really, because then the onus, once again, is on the woman to have to prove these horrific things happened to her. That's also what I was really struck by in this, how they spoke to another Cornell student who has since graduated. And they are 4:52 talking about Title IX. They were encouraged, instead of going to the police, to just file a Title IX report. 5:00 And what that means is that it stays within the university environment, and then they don't. So her perpetrator was allowed to graduate, left, was something like was banned from campus for like two months. And then he graduated anyway. 5:19 And he had to write a paper. 5:21 Of course, awful. And she was so watching her show us, she showed parts of her journal, her old journal and pictures of her fighting Title IX. And, you know, the hearts just break for her. But what I was saying is that I am trying as best I can to 5:42 still believe in due process. I am trying really hard to subscribe in cases like this that are so horrific to hear about, forget about living them, right? But like even to hear about this and this young woman and it's right, it's very hard to say anything, but she 5:58 was gang raped. There were seven of them. There was a text or a Snapchat, whatever the hell it was that went out, all of it, right? So yes, I try though to at least make room for maybe one of these kids, the one that I'm talking about, his 6:15 lawyer saying, He wasn't, she wasn't naked when he was in there and he didn't touch her. And now when I don't want to, I'm not interested in getting into defending these boys. That is not why I'm here and I don't want to, but we're talking about how they 6:29 released the names of all of them. Okay. 6:31 So, so, so we can just sort of say some of the details here. This dates back to October 19th, 2024. 6:40 Jane Doe alleges she was coerced into consuming drugs and was sexually assaulted by multiple men at Cornell's Chi Phi fraternity house. And in November, the Cornell police investigated, provided materials to the DA's office, and the prosecutors did not 6:57 bring charges at that time. However, sidebar, her report was almost 100 pages or something. And what they gave to the DA was six pages. So they omitted the majority of what she had to say, of which included her saying, there is no doubt in my mind that I was raped. 7:21 I felt like meat. I felt like an object. She says all sorts of things like this, which is completely omitted. 7:30 So then in 2025, Cornell's Title IX disciplinary process resulted in sanctions, including expulsions and suspensions. Two expulsions, two suspensions. 7:41 And the university also barred the Chi Phi chapter from campus. 7:47 And then in September of 2026, Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit against seven of the men, Cornell, Kai Fai, and other defendants. Now, the thing that was interesting about this documentary is her attorney says that entire time, people say, oh, 8:05 why did she wait so long? Let's even put aside the emotional side of that and how difficult it is for women to talk about these things and how much it builds in you. That aside, she was under the impression that Title IX was handling this investigation, that it 8:25 was ongoing, that it was continuing. And it wasn't until September that she learned that the case had been closed, and no one was doing anything. And that is why she then decided to really take it further. I mean, this girl's life was destroyed. She had to leave campus. 8:45 The other rapists got to stay. It's really, there's something very, very wrong with this entire system. 8:55 It's interesting because the president, Cornell's president, has very recently, I guess, put out a public statement and he apologized for how it was handled. But yet he says he's made so many claims that it was that they, the 9:10 university did everything that they could possibly do. And he He's sort of unapologetic. At least that's what I've seen. 9:16 I don't know what you've seen of him. He's unapologetic. 9:18 And then all of a sudden there was a, he issued a statement that he does apologize. I'm not sure. 9:24 I'm not sure what he said. 9:25 He's like backtracking. He questioned, he, he, according to this documentary and the, the letters that they have, he questioned why she didn't, say something about it sooner, and that sort of line of questioning, right? Then he backtracked and said, no, 9:46 I didn't say that. I wondered why no one else said anything, and it's terrible how it was handled. So then he just bans all the fraternities. from having any kind of gatherings or parties, which I also appreciated. There is a young man who used to be the president 10:08 of a fraternity who is in this documentary and he speaks very eloquently. He gave me great hope actually. 10:15 He said that we're supposed to be creating great men. 10:19 Yes, he said we're supposed to be creating great men and instead it's creating a culture of drinking and just misbehavior. 10:29 He threw his phone when he found out that all parties had been terminated on Cornell campus. He was so frustrated by that, which I thought was interesting too, because I guess he was really taking in that. Is it the fraternity's fault? Is it the system or is it these boys, right? 10:48 Right. And I loved, he said, a blanket suspension is not the way you fix a cultural problem. 10:54 Right. 10:54 And I think that is a very articulate statement. And they were failed by the administration. That is how these students feel. Like, why didn't they help her? And why didn't they report and investigate? And then they also include, well, 11:12 Let's also talk about the governor of New York for a second. Kathy Hochul, she is a badass, in my opinion. 11:20 I love her. And her response was spot on that is disgusting. And she said, I can't believe this is happening again, something to that effect. 11:44 Elisa, I just recorded a pod. There was a movie that you and I had actually discussed, Hunting Ground. Yes. 11:52 From 2015. And I don't know if you had a chance to see it, but I would highly recommend it. 11:57 I have not seen it, but I will see it. 11:59 It's a difficult watch, but it gave me so much insight. 12:04 But unfortunately, one of the things, one of the most interesting, interesting parts of watching hunting grounds and now talking about Cornell is the lack of change. And I, you know, I spoke to the filmmaker and she, it was very sad and very, very sort of depressing, but we also 12:26 spoke about, because I said to her, do you feel like, you know, Greek life fraternities specifically should be abolished? And she didn't think so. And she said, you know, very much like this boy, but, what has to change is how we not only deal with our girls and we 12:44 warn them right of the dangers and we prepare them, but what are we doing in terms of our boys and what are, or they even hit a college campus? 12:52 What are we teaching them and how that, that film actually should be required viewing for both young men and young women before they ever hit college freshman year. 13:05 Yeah, I mean, I have to say, you know, Jen, I get a little hot under the collar about this topic. 13:11 And sometimes I really, so I'm trying to be very democratic-ish. 13:17 But I am really, really sick of women having to be the ones who have to protect themselves and don't walk alone at night or make sure you have a friend. 13:29 What about teaching men how to properly treat women? What about teaching young men the value of human life, the value of women's bodies and their minds and their spirits? 13:43 I am beyond about this. Because to me, the worst part of this, I don't know. I don't even know if it's the worst part. One of the worst parts is that 50 people on that text string, 5-0, and not one of them said anything. hey guys, this is 14:04 really bad. Or hey, maybe you want to think about the fact that this isn't okay. I mean, that tells me that fraternity culture is rape culture. That's what that tells me. 14:17 So Amy Ziering, who made The Hunting Ground, she is a huge advocate. She has been remarkable and indispensable in terms of really trying to change law. So she... has, this has been, you know, one of the focuses of her life. So it was interesting to talk to her 14:37 about what you're talking about in terms of the 50 boys. 14:39 And we spoke specifically about that. And she said, you know, all 50 boys are not bad, right? Those 50 boys, we talked about how some of them are just brand new onto campus. They're it's, you know, they just got into a frat. Their lives are just starting. They see it. 14:57 Maybe something, there's something occurs. They move on. They're just like, fuck. And, and, So those boys, but those boys are not rapists. That doesn't make them rapists. But what it makes them is she was putting it this way. They need to be educated. 15:18 And it doesn't matter if we say, you know, the owner should not be on the woman to always. No. 15:23 It's not because it's not her fault. Right. 15:25 They have to be taught. 15:27 She said it. It doesn't mean that they're bad boys. 15:29 It means that they are in a packed culture. Yes. 15:32 Impact mentality. Yes. Boys impact mentalities. So as opposed to just saying, you know, scrap the whole thing, scrap Greek life. 15:43 What are we talking about? She said, well, she thought that one of the best things that we could do for young boys is to make them watch film, watch The Hunting Ground or a film like it so that they at least they understood, had awareness, right? These are 15:57 still kids. The boys' frontal lobes are not developed until they're 26. Yes. And that's, I'm not excusing, believe me when I tell you, I'm not excusing the behaviors. I'm not excusing rape, but I'm saying that we're looking at what's this big picture of what are we going to 16:11 do with this culture? 16:15 It's a cultural change. And when I say cultural, I'm not even, I'm not talking about Greek life only. I'm talking about in society because there is something that these young men felt either Oh, I don't want, which is 16:30 very common for young people, teenagers especially. You don't want to be the person that calls somebody out. You don't want to be ostracized. Those are real feelings and struggles when you're that age. As an adult too, but not 16:44 as much. So while understanding it's difficult to be the person to say this is not okay, it is vital to be the person who says no. This is not OK. 16:59 So we need to teach our young people, men and women, but especially the men, that that is what being a man is. That's what being strong is. Not getting on the bandwagon and gang raping some young woman for seven hours, and you're going to tell me that this young woman 17:21 Wanted to participate in this. 17:23 I'm not going to tell you that. No. I don't believe that for one second. 17:25 And also the idea that you can say yes to one thing and then you say no to something else. 17:32 So if this young woman said yes to having a threesome with two other boys, and even if she said yes and then went, meh, actually, I'm not cool with this. 17:44 guess what? You have to stop. And so this idea that somehow all of this is consensual is despicable. And this movie really covers how, I mean, again, Kathy Hochul, she just was like, there's something that is so. 18:07 You know, she's so concrete about what she's saying and speaking about her own experience at Syracuse university when there was a series of rapes on the campus when she was there and that, that nothing has changed. 18:20 That's what, yeah, that's what we were. That's what I was literally taught. And almost it might, things may, um, the hunting ground came out in 2015, um, that maybe things are actually worse now. Can you imagine? 18:32 Yeah, it's awful. Um, And Casey Lee is the 2025 graduate who I was speaking about that was raped at Cornell and reported through Title IX. And she said it was like one long gaslighting session. She said she felt like I was screaming into a crowd that couldn't hear me for a year. 18:53 Yeah. 18:55 For a year. I mean, and the fact that, again, she has to verbally state I was raped and I didn't want it. And she has to plead with people to believe her. This system is broken. It is broken. 19:12 And this boy had to write a paper also. 19:14 It's so stupid. I can't, that I can't get. What do you think that you are going to accomplish? You're going to give a boy who just raped a girl, write a paper. Yep. 19:23 And he graduated and he was found guilty of sexual assault so that we're all clear here. He was found guilty of sexual assault. And then they asked him to write a paper, and he graduates. 19:34 They said that they didn't think that he was malicious? 19:37 Yeah, it was like, oh, this was, you know, I made a bad choice or something. 19:41 I don't know. 19:45 So, Anne, I was also, I don't know, were you familiar with... Emma, the Columbia student who carried the mattress around? 19:54 Did you know about this story before? 19:55 No, I didn't remember it. You did. 19:58 It is something else. This is a young woman. 20:01 Graduated with it. 20:03 Who, yep. who was raped and her rapist was allowed to continue to be on campus with her and in her classes at Columbia. So she carried the mattress that she was raped on around everywhere with her. And she said, as long as my rapist has to be here with me, 20:20 I'm going to carry this mattress around. And she even carried it across the stage at her graduation. And the president of the university turned away from her. The same Chanel Miller, who was raped by the swimmer, Brock Turner at Stanford. He served three months. 20:38 So doing true crime documentaries, there's, it's just can be so hard. And this particular story is just so absolutely just devastating. The one thing I can say is I am amazed when I see films like this, I'm amazed at the resilience of these women. I am so, and 20:58 the courage that it takes to, Think about it. This just happened. This story really just broke. How long ago? 21:03 A few weeks ago? 21:04 Yes, in September. 21:06 And here is this woman who is now out of college, bringing up her old notebooks, showing how she was feeling gaslit by Title IX, and that she was screaming. And she's able to talk about it. Nobody's paying her to talk about this. 21:23 That's right. 21:25 And there's just this inner strength that is... just amazing to me. And for Jane Doe, after all of this time, and her lawyer talked about how she's gotten death threats, how they've doxed her, how there have been people that have called police to go to her house, claiming that 21:41 there is something going on in the house and her parents, they've had guns put to their head and all of this, you know, all of this trauma that's going on and it just pile, it's piling up and piling up. And yet, you know, she was strong enough to, to you know, 21:57 really just, just say, bring it out. This is what I'm going to do. It takes unimaginable courage. 22:04 It really does. 22:05 There's never, I'll say there's no bright side here. It's just not, but I am always amazed by like young girls specifically in their resiliency. 22:13 I am too. It's like, it's what, it's what we have to do, which I can't even believe that that's what it is, but that's what it is. 22:26 We talked about also, so in terms of like the laws and the politics of all of this. So when you think about politicians, right, male politicians, let's talk about specifically, these men who are now governors or senators or whatever it is, or mayors, or these are men that may 22:51 have been in an many, many, many cases have been part of fraternity, a fraternity. They went to school, they went, maybe they went through four-year college and then they went and they did even more than that. And so there 23:04 is this, this frat bro mentality that pervades also our politics, our government, our institutions that are, you know, there to hold people accountable and, and, we talked about this yesterday. 23:23 I've seen other documentaries on it that that frat broke. 23:26 Cause I've done also documentaries on hazing and kids that have died, you know, boys that have even died from hazing deaths, but how hard it is to get laws passed because so many politicians are so loyal to their frats. Yep. And, 23:40 and the four years they spent as, you know, brothers in this fraternity and they are very attached to it. Right. 23:48 And they don't, They don't want it to stop. They don't want the traditions to change. Right. 23:52 Like, oh, I'm sorry. You don't want the tradition of gang raping women to change. 23:58 Well, sorry. 23:59 It has to change. 24:00 It's when you say, when you want, like, I don't know how you feel, Lisa. Do you feel like Greek life should just be abolished at this point? I don't. 24:06 Here's what I think. I was not, I mean, I went to the Eugene Lang College at the Dew School University in New York City. It's the most progressive, you know, there were no fraternities or sororities there. So I don't have personal experience with it. My husband does, and he's 24:23 got very good friends still from his fraternity. I will say, when brains are not fully formed, as we just said, and it is the first time that people are away from home and have access to essentially unbridled freedom, and 24:41 they're drinking perhaps for the first time, doing drugs for the first time, And then having to do all of these stupid things in order to be accepted into a group, you're setting yourself up for disaster. That, to me, is like a terrible, terrible system. So do I think the 25:06 idea of community and connection is good and important? Absolutely, I do. Do I think some of those things need to change? Absolutely. When you have to embarrass yourself, humiliate yourself, do something dangerous, drink to the point of nearly injuring yourself, 25:27 how is that a positive sign of connecting with people and creating community? 25:35 I've done podcasts about hazing deaths, right? So this is not about rape. This is about boys that were forced to drink until they died. Right. And the parents and the laws that were passed after that. But the Greek system, and again, I co-host a podcast called Dirty Rush, and 25:56 I was in a sorority. And there are so many wonderful things that I can say about Greek life. And there's also this other dirty, dark side of it. 26:21 It sounds very cult-like to me. I don't mean your experience. 26:25 I mean, these things that I hear of this kind of like extreme behavior. And then you have to have the bro code where you can't, you have to support each other and you never like at all costs. That is a cult to me. 26:39 I've never, I've never, I never personally experienced anything like this. 26:42 I never knew. I'm not saying it didn't happen. I had never was confided in by one of my sorority sisters that she had been assaulted. I, I didn't know anything. 26:52 boys that had, you know, been hazed to the point where they were in danger. I didn't know from that. 26:57 So my experience was, you know, really fun, like relationships with girls and mixers and matches and football games and, and, and having these traditions. And well, that's what, that's what I experienced. That's what my other two co-hosts experience. And 27:13 I think that hopefully please God is what most kids that participate in Greek in Greek life experience. Right. So, um, But there is this underbelly that is unacceptable and has to change. I don't know how because it hasn't changed since the movie Hunting Ground came out. 27:35 So I think there has to be some kind of accountability that extends beyond writing a paper. So Cornell has hired former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates to lead an independent review of Do you have confidence that university can 27:52 commission a truly independent investigation of itself? 27:57 You know, they have Letitia James. I want to say she's the one that appointed, she's the attorney general, New York's attorney general. She was put on it, and I want to say appointed the special prosecutor. But now she's being, they want to take her off of the case because 28:14 she already has said basically something to the effect of, I don't know what her wording was, but that something fine that she thinks the boys are guilty right before they've ever even, excuse me, been tried. And I don't know, I don't know these, I don't know the answers to this. 28:31 I don't know if, you know, again, I'm trying to believe in the judicial system. I really am. And, and clearly sometimes it fails. A lot of times it fails, but I try to, you know, I try to have hope that, that, due process will serve. I don't know what the answer is. 28:49 I do think and hope that something will change from this. 28:52 So far, there still have been no criminal indictments, which I am waiting for. I did want to call by name the student journalists from the Cornell Daily Sun, which they're a big part of this documentary, and they're super impressive. 29:08 And their names are Sophia Dasser and Cerise Cuspa. So they're a big part of this documentary, and I'm wildly impressed with them just as human beings. And we could talk about this for a long time. I feel like they're telling us to stop talking. But I just think, hopefully, 29:33 some real concrete changes can be made. And when you and I spoke with Chloe Akers on that episode of of Dirty Rush, she is a Cornell graduate, former defense attorney, works in politics, wildly intelligent and well-versed in all of this. And, 29:53 you know, she gave very specific things that could change and you know, first and foremost is there have to be repercussions that are real and that are legal and, you know, that are, that will deter people from thinking that they can just get away with this stuff. First of all. 30:12 Right. Listen, I mean, times they are changing. We had a big election yesterday and, you know, I don't know, this, this country is, has been in a turmoil and a really bad place and very divided. Maybe, good things are coming. 30:28 I hope so. 30:28 I hope so. 30:29 I hope that we, this is all just so, so depressing. And, and I am, my daughter had started college. She was about to start it. She was embarking on a journey right now. And I have friends whose daughters are, I would be fit to be tied. I don't know. I 30:46 don't know. I don't know. I feel so, you know, just, just so frightened for her. And am I doing the right thing? Even sending her. Right. So there's that. And I didn't, that's not how I felt when my daughter went to college and left for college. I didn't have 31:01 that worry, but things are now maybe because things, these things are coming to light and Jane Doe has been brave enough to bring it out, you know, and it's going to give us a chance to, to prep our girls and to talk to our boys. 31:13 Yeah. I think first and foremost, boys need to be told that that's you, you, a real man is someone who defends a woman and, not a woman who exploits. 31:29 And, but I don't, I do not think that we have to prepare our girls. I that's not, and that's just the facts. That's not blaming them. That's not putting the onus on them alone. It is just necessary. It is not. Yes. Oh yeah, it is. We have, that is, 31:45 I think that's why we talked about it. But watching fill my hunting grounds or talking about Cornell and, and, it just has to happen. It has to happen. I think in schools, it has to be a prerequisite for starting college in my humble opinion. And whether or not 32:02 it's fair or it's okay, like our girls have to be schooled in. 32:07 Yeah, they do. 32:11 They do. 32:11 And I, as, as deeply upsetting as I find that, that is, that's the truth. 32:17 We do. Yeah. 32:18 So this case is still very much unfolding and, um, I, on a personal note, hope that there are indictments and that people are brought to justice. And I hope that Jane Doe finds some solace in the groundswell of support 32:39 that she has received from complete strangers, from her classmates, from everyone on that campus. And I do recommend watching this, Instadocs Jane Doe versus Cornell. It's only 35 minutes. 32:55 I always thought about the title. It's not Cornell 7. 32:57 It's versus Cornell. Yeah. I thought that was sort of telling. Yeah. 33:01 Because it was their hand. The film is really, of course, it's about what happened, but it's also about as important. 33:07 It's about the school's mishandling of it. Mm-hmm. 33:09 And these kids, like I said, they're very articulate, all of them. And several said that they... They were failed by the university. And they're the kids. And remember, we spoke to the journalist on another podcast who was on 33:28 the ground at Cornell, who was talking to us from there. 33:31 And he said, I just spoke to someone that said, we're the kids. We want the adults to help here. 33:40 Why are we the ones that are having to do this? 33:43 And I thought that was such a poignant thought. They are the kids. where, what happened to the administration? 33:52 Well, to be continued because this case is clearly we're not at the end of it. So we will keep following it, you guys, and sharing our thoughts with you as long as you'll have us. Exactly. 34:04 And I'll try to, I try to keep it in, you know, I just, I can't always. 34:10 I think it's exactly. I mean, I, I love listening to you and I talked about this also, but we both had full lives and they've included some, some things that are, that I relate to a lot about what's going on right now. And sexual assault is unfortunately all 34:27 too common. And, you know, we've that, so it is very sensitive. It's, we're always going to get our feelings of course are going, we're going to. 34:34 Be to get involved. 34:36 Yeah. Yeah. 34:37 Well, as always, Jen, I really appreciate these conversations with you and, um, It helps to be able to kind of break down and unravel these difficult topics. I feel like it's important that we talk about them with each other, with our kids. 34:58 Agreed. Yep. Thank you, my friend. All right. 35:01 Thank you. Until next time.
Community discussion