0:06 Amy Robach and TJ Holmes present Killer Thriller with your host, Elisa Donovan. Hey, everybody. 0:15 Elisa Donovan here, and this is Killer Thriller. In the summer of 1969, a group of young women followed Charles Manson into one of the most notorious murder sprees in American history. But how did these women fall under his spell? 0:30 And what happened when they finally began to question the man they had followed? The film, Charlie Says, explores those questions through the experiences of three convicted Manson followers, including Susan Sadie Atkins, played by today's guest, actress Marianne Rendon. 0:47 Marianne joins us to talk about stepping into the mind of a real-life killer and the disturbing psychology behind one of America's most infamous criminal cases. Marianne, welcome to Killer Thriller. 1:00 Thank you so much for talking with me today. 1:02 Thank you so much for having me. 1:06 I don't even know where to start with this film. 1:09 I was so deeply unsettled in, I think, an important way by this. It's so good, and it's so unlike any of the other films and TV shows based on the Manson case and I just really appreciated how it digs so deeply into the cult itself and how these 1:32 women could have been seduced and brainwashed into doing these horrible things. But just to start, for anyone who hasn't seen Charlie Says, tell us a little about the film and the woman that you portray, who is Susan Sadie Atkins. 1:49 Yeah, so Charlie Says is, like you said, more of a portrait of Three of the Manson women, they focus more on them, you know, Leslie, Patricia, and Susan, Sadie. 2:05 And it really follows how Leslie in particular gets involved with the family. So, you know, what brought her to the ranch and meeting Manson and meeting the rest of the family and, you know, everyone in the cast is so wonderful. 2:22 And then it. 2:23 Really shows how easy it was for these really young people to just be really easily coerced into anything from, you know, sort of like almost torture tactics of sickness and drugs and, you know, just having a sense of belonging, 2:45 you know, isolating them so much from their beliefs families and their and the people that knew them so and then it follows the second half of the film their incarceration and their work with um with carlene faith who 3:04 was their social worker played by merritt weaver who's incredible oh incredible um really how she was so instrumental to their process of de-brainwashing which. 3:14 Took a lot of time um And that's, that's really the film. 3:18 And, you know, Matt Smith is wonderful as Charlie and, um, I think did a really beautiful job and, you know, it's what a, what a, what a hard part to play. 3:27 And, you know, yeah, it's so it's, uh, you know, when you, when you see it on film, the, one of the reasons to me why this is so arresting this particular, um, you know, vision is because you, you see it's predominantly women and, He's the only one, like, 3:47 it just really puts into stark relief the manipulation and the misogynistic overtones of all of it and how this one, you know, I think the screenwriter described him as, like, a charismatic loser, which I think is an excellent term. 4:07 Yeah. 4:08 But you really see it, and that's one of the ways that it's so heartbreaking is you're watching these, women be manipulated and but you know you really can't understate how important the drugs were and how how he gave all of the women he was taking the drugs as 4:29 well but they were given just like constantly and consistently and consistently abused and yeah so you, you said that you wouldn't have participated in the film if it had been, you know, simply just another Charles Manson biopic. So what 4:44 was it about telling this story through the women's perspectives that interested you? 4:48 Yeah. Well, I mean, Guinevere's writing, like you said, like she really understands, I mean, she grew up in a cult. 4:55 She wrote a really beautiful piece in the New Yorker about growing up in that community. What intrigued me was, was, uh, 5:05 what you're saying. It wasn't this sensationalized, gory sort of slasher. 5:10 And they weren't one-dimensional characters whatsoever. I mean, they were really trying to look at who these people were and why they did the things that they did. 5:21 I find Susan really interesting. 5:23 I mean, she was one of the much darker people of the family, I think, similarly to Charlie in that, like, really all she kind of. 5:32 Knew was a kind of. 5:35 Feeling of being abandoned and having no one seeking out danger, seeking out thrill just from, I mean, I obviously didn't know her and she died before, you know, any of this came out, but I read her memoir and she wrote it. She eventually became a born again Christian in prison. 5:56 And it was just really interesting to hear about how her family lived she grew up around alcoholism and, you know, really just this feeling of wanting to belong. And I thought in a lot of ways how it was such a universal story. And that's what Guinevere is trying to 6:13 express is just like how anyone could, any woman could end up in this situation. And I think, you know, regardless of being involved in a murder, I think a lot of women can relate to being with, someone in that kind of power dynamic and losing a sense of 6:35 themselves doing things that aren't them for the sake of what they think is love or being loved. 6:42 And it is interesting how this idea of free speech and free love and free expression and all of that is a part of what he is offering. But that actually turns into no freedom whatsoever. It's, it's like, it's, it's his version of what that is. And that kind 7:05 of manipulation is really. 7:08 Scary. 7:10 Yeah. 7:10 I mean, without, regardless of being a psychopath. 7:14 There are people that, there are people that are master manipulators of, and, and the ability to love bomb you. 7:22 I mean, the way that the women described how, he would just make you feel like you were the only important person in the world. And who hasn't felt that in some, in some way, you know, so, and yeah, just this thing of like building them up and then 7:37 immediately tearing them down. And the, and the confusion of that and the question, the questioning of that, especially, you know, they weren't mature women. 7:50 Right. Right. That's another part that I think we forget, especially because they were, so demonized these women. 7:57 I mean, and rightfully so to a degree. 7:59 But we forget that they were like teenagers and 20 and not fully formed brains. And that time in history, it was just kind of the perfect storm and that sort of exploitation of wanting to not follow the rules and not be a part of this system that seemed 8:25 like it was not what anybody wanted. And, you know, as a parent, I mean, I have a 14-year-old daughter, so I think about these things like, oh, dear God, you know, that thing. 8:38 Of, because a couple of these, most of the people. 8:41 I think, and Susan, as you said, included, certainly came from really troubled backgrounds, and they desperately really needed a place to be. But some of them didn't even, I think it was Leslie, right. That had a more traditional 8:58 kind of background and urban life that it's like, it could be, you know, anybody. And I really, so the, the film does a great job of almost kind of showing how seductive he could be while not there is, I want to say straight up. We talk a lot 9:18 on this podcast about, you know, that responsibility of, being accountable to someone when you're telling the story of a real person and real people who have gone through things. 9:28 And I absolutely think this film does that really well and respectfully. 9:37 It does a great job of showing kind of this slow burn of how you could be seduced by this environment where it's all people your age and you have this, as we said, freedom that's presented to you. And then slowly the abuse comes in. And so there's a really 9:57 powerful scene with you and um manson where he physically abuses susan and it's particularly upsetting what what she says in response to that and it comes at a point in the film that really kind of shifts the whole story can you talk about shooting that scene a bit 10:18 and how that was. 10:21 Yeah. Um, I think they did a really beautiful job, like you said, of wanting to show the joy and the love like first, you know, just like these people aren't, you know, they're, they're smart people too. And, and that there, there was a reason that was, they were staying there. 10:40 And so, yeah, one of the, the dinner scenes where they're, they're, you know, they're finding food in dumpsters and they're, um, they're cooking communally and they're probably eating, you know, rotten salad. 10:52 But my character makes salad and Charlie asks who made the salad dressing. And what I had read about a lot of, especially with the three girls incarcerated is that Sadie was kind of more of the provocateur in terms of like giving it back to Charlie, you know, intentionally 11:15 sort of as for attention. And initially my line wasn't scripted as it was. And I, I think the line was, well, so Charlie says, who made the salad dressing? And Sadie says, I did. He's like, well, it tastes like piss. And I, 11:31 and I'm supposed to say, well, hold your nose or something. 11:34 And I just felt sort of as an actor, I was like, I think she's got to say something a little bit, like, like a little bit more of a, you know, being a little shit. So I went to behind camera with Mary and Guinevere and I said, can I say this? 11:48 And they were like, yeah, that sounds great. 11:50 So I did that and Matt didn't know I was going to say what I said. Well, that's because I pissed in yours. That's what I had. So then he smacks her across the face and then he basically pulls her up from the table and really beats her up. 12:07 And the reaction shots are all of the girls which. 12:13 I find like very. 12:14 Powerful and that like it's clear that that happens a lot and you're getting to experience it happening for the first time for Leslie right. 12:27 And so when I shot that scene. 12:30 At the time I was I mean this was 10 years ago so I was I was like just out of school and I was I was so physically strong and Matt and I like did this it was like a real we had a we had a fight choreographer but like it really did feel like a real fight 12:45 and I remember we have we had this incredible DP Crilla Forsberg who was such a physical DP like he was just always right there with you and it was like this dance with him the whole time and I remember him just being like, whoa, Rendon, are you okay? 13:02 And I remember like, I had to put both of my hands on the ground because we don't cut. We like do the shot and then they follow Leslie. They follow me into the kitchen, but I'm in the kitchen waiting for Leslie. And I had to tell, cause my body thought it was real. 13:19 Yes. 13:20 Right. 13:20 Yeah. 13:21 I had never experienced that before. 13:22 Like I'd done plenty of stage, stage combat and choreography and, Never before. I mean, I was like, I was like trying so hard to breathe because I knew we had to keep shooting. And yeah, that was the first time where I was like, oh, wow. 13:38 Yeah. 13:38 The body doesn't know we're pretending. 13:41 Right. 13:42 Cause that's what I was going to ask. 13:44 You know, this material is so, is so dark and so complicated and, you know, it's psychologically dark. 13:52 It's physically dark. It's all of that. 13:55 Like, how did you, protect yourself or like how how how did you handle that on the daily. 14:02 I'm not sure that I did other than there were just such amazing women around I mean I think that's what helped to having like women at the top of this whole project for one you know like I I dance naked in the rain and And I get back to my trailer and Mary Herron has left me a 14:24 bottle of wine with like a love letter of just like, thank you for taking your clothes off for me or just for this reason. You know, but also like all the rest of, we created a family, like everyone there really loved each other. And you could, I mean, I've 14:42 always felt this about California. I've always felt this about Los Angeles is like, there is a really dark energy there on this sort of underbelly. And it felt, it feels haunted and it, and it, and the, and the subjects of that felt haunted. I mean, like being in 14:57 the neighborhood in which we were shooting those murders felt very. 15:02 Very dark. 15:03 So I think the way that I protected myself was really just like, we were really checking in with each other a lot. Yeah. 15:09 Yeah. 15:10 Yeah. And Hannah Murray, who played Leslie and I, I felt like, you know, we were all staying at the same hotel and we. 15:18 Would, We just spent time with each other. We weren't, no one was really that isolated. 15:22 Right. 15:37 So Carleen Faith, who is, as we said, played by Merritt Weaver, she is an, I mean, well, first of all, Merritt Weaver is an extraordinary actress and, I just, she's wonderful and everything. But so Carlene Faith is an extraordinary 15:54 woman in my opinion. And I didn't actually, this is another thing, great thing about this movie is I didn't know that she was a real person. 16:02 Like that was never a part of any of the. 16:09 Journalists talking about, like there was, I never even heard of her before this, which I find unbelievable. 16:15 Yeah. 16:17 Considering how vital, she was a vital part of their incarceration and the work that she does with the imprisoned women. 16:24 So can you talk a little bit about her and your experience of her? 16:29 Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I mean, I know she's around. 16:33 I don't know that much about her other than, yeah, she was assigned to them in the beginning of their incarceration. 16:42 And while they were still there, in the spell of what we know as those like iconic photographs and videos of them walking to and from the court and like, you know, all the people waiting for them in the street and doing sort of almost like performance art roles 17:01 of like about Charlie. And, but what we do in the script is, you know, what, what she did is she was feeding them a lot of feminist literature and You know, Our Bodies, Our Cells, which was like so iconic at that time. 17:15 Yes. 17:15 Yeah, it was huge. 17:17 And, you know, really just trying to ask them what they thought, you know, trying to provoke their own critical thinking. 17:28 And I think it must have been a huge challenge. 17:31 It was really powerful how you feel like she's starting to get across to these people. young women you know she's starting to maybe reach them and then the next time you see them they've all shaved their heads and are dressed and standing there going you know this is 17:50 what charlie wants us to do and it's just. 17:54 Devastating yeah totally. 17:57 And um she so susan atkins she expressed remorse during um her imprisonment and as we said she died in prison in 2009 Did learning about her later life change your understanding of the young woman that you were playing? 18:15 I feel like I tried to read as much about all three of them as much as I could. And it sort of felt to me, you know, like with respect to their families and everything. But like it sort of felt to me that like Sadie was kind of 18:28 the one where something was like kind of broken, you know, like something. Yeah, I did. I, it's cause it just felt to me, it's like swinging from one extreme to the other of, of like, you know, the family and then going so deep into like a really radical Christian part. 18:45 Right. To me, like she, I actually, I don't know. 18:49 You know, I just, I just felt like if, if God was her new Charlie or, yeah, I mean, there's, there's just, there, there's not the same interviews of her. 18:59 Like there are, Leslie and Patricia of them speaking as, as older women. 19:04 Right. 19:04 Cause I find it so moving and I'm, and it's just, it's just so heartbreaking that they're the longest serving women in California history still. 19:13 Leslie was just released, right? 19:16 Yeah. 19:16 I remember like the possibility of her parole was coming up as we were shooting again, you know, again. And I know that like, it was difficult because I know Mary and Guinevere also didn't want to like have an effect on. 19:32 That right there's a i don't know if it's a law or there's a very strong you know belief that if you're if you're up for parole if there is anything in in the news or something that you could possibly be benefiting from or something that's storytelling or trying 19:49 to lean in one direction or another that the person is a part of, it could really have a negative impact on their release, I think. 19:57 And that's probably what they, you know, were concerned about. 20:01 Yeah. Yeah. I mean, we had to just keep remembering, like, these are real people. They're still there, you know. But to think, yeah, just to answer your question about younger Susan, I just kept going back to like her need, you know, her need to be loved, her need to belong. 20:19 I mean, I don't think that can be underestimated either as a, you know, it's one of the most basic human needs, I think, you know, to. 20:30 Feel that, to feel loved, to feel. 20:34 Community, to feel seen, like those things are so basic and if you're, if you don't have them or if you're, you learn them in a very twisted way, you know, there's bad things happen. 20:48 Yeah. 20:49 And I was also like, you know, trying to search in myself of like, I wasn't a teenager when I played it, but you know, I was pretty wild in my teenage years and I, I definitely did things for the, the thrill of them. And so I was trying to just, 21:07 see what she was doing without judgment. I mean, and, and, and how she might've just done them without thinking, you know, or, or done them because they didn't feel real. Like nothing quite felt real. Everything was almost kind of like nothing 21:22 had consequences. I mean, I think that's part of the sixties to the culture of, you know, counterculture, but also with psychedelics where I think like what, what, what's so amazing is how, how spiritually like possibility becomes larger and 21:40 larger and larger. And I think like when you're just in that space all the time, it's like, well, then there's no consequence. Nothing is real, you know? And he was at a certain point preaching stuff like that. 21:52 Right. That life, there's no difference between life and death and these kinds of, the same thing as, you know, when your character says after he beats her up, you know, there's no difference between being something I'm paraphrasing, but like 22:08 being beaten up by your man and making love to him. 22:10 That's the, there's no difference. 22:12 Like I'm getting what I need, which is just like the most out of context is the most twisted and backwards and wrong thing you could imagine. But then when you see it in the context of what she has been through, you can understand it. And getting back to 22:29 that scene when you said, cause I think this was so powerful too, that, when you see the responses of the other women, when he does that at the table, it very clearly shows, even though we have an audience as an audience, haven't seen that before. It's very clear 22:46 that these women have seen this many times. 22:49 Yeah. 22:49 And you see on every character's face, you know exactly how they feel about it. I mean, even, you know, like so see bacon who plays Patricia, like she's smiling through the pain and, Right. But she's, she's just like, she's trying to teach Leslie, like it's okay. 23:05 It's all this. It's fine. 23:07 And then you see like younger girls and they're used to, they look really scared. 23:11 Yeah. That's one of the things I think why it's, it was, it was so hard to watch as a woman because I, you, I could see all of the things that we do in, in, in far lesser extreme circumstances. 23:24 Right. 23:24 But that thing of, Oh, you smile through it. It's okay. 23:28 Or, you know, your instinct says this doesn't feel right, but then you just say, okay, you know, or, or say what he wants to hear, you know, all those little things that women do. 23:41 Freeze, fight, or fawn. Fawn is a big, it's a big one that, yeah, we all know. 23:46 Right. 23:47 And freeze and fight. 23:48 But yeah, Sadie was definitely, she, she could fight. 23:52 Yeah. 23:53 What was maybe the hardest or what were some of the hardest scenes to film for you? 23:58 Yeah. That the fight was tough. 24:00 Like we talked to physically, you know, the murders were really, it was just really, really dark, really, really dark. And some of the prison, cause it's just, we were, you know, I had never spent, I mean, I'd never been in a jail cell. 24:18 Right. 24:19 So I'm like experiencing and you're there for you're there all day. And, and, and it's this, I mean, not like it's anything close to what it actually is, but it just puts into context where you're just like, oh, I get to leave and go home. Or like, oh, wow, 24:37 this one's actually that small. And like, what do you, you know, like the macrame that she would make, they would sort of make while they, you know, a lot of sewing, a lot of, you know, ways to sort of occupy time. And realizing that like, yeah, these are 24:55 not spaces in which healing is made, you know, like sort of moving about Carlene's work is like what she was trying to do with so little. 25:07 Right. 25:08 That's one of the things that I'm so impressed with her with. 25:10 I mean, a million things, but that alone, like so little support, so little resources, so literal space, you know, in order to do these things. 25:20 Yeah, there's so many more initiatives now and, you know, like working with incarcerated. 25:28 Right, right. 25:43 Getting back to shooting those scenes, the murder scenes, first of all, Mary Herron, the. 25:50 She's such a wonderful director um. 25:52 And she had talked about that kind of the the difference of making those almost very uh like procedural kind of you know where there again no exploitation of it but how and and yet showing like really show it's quite uh not graphic in the violence, but in what you're, 26:17 what you're feeling and the, the blood spattering and splattering and all of that stuff. And Grace Van Dean who plays Sharon Tate, you know, is just so wide eyed. 26:28 And so, you know, it's, it's horrible. 26:32 But so what, can you talk a little bit about shooting those scenes and what that was like? 26:39 I remember Grace really, she was like really wild. warm warmed up and i mean like we were about to roll and she just got herself into a place that uh was just really really difficult to watch but so that you know she yeah she really did the work 27:01 and then with hannah i watched on the monitor like that that one shot i think you're talking about with the blood spider yeah um where it's just like the real close-up of her and to plug her book for a second, the make-believe she, she wrote about filming that, 27:17 which I, cause I didn't know what she was going through. 27:19 Like while we shooting, um, it's a really wonderful book about her own experience with psychosis and, and like going to shoot, like being in a cult herself and then like shooting. 27:31 About a cult. But then, but she writes about that specific. 27:34 Night and it was interesting to read having watched her on the monitor because she didn't talk about it with Mary. They, she didn't, planet she didn't i think she stayed up the night before because she really just wanted to experience 27:48 um that kind of adrenaline and i think someone said something i don't remember if it was on set or like or this was in her book but i'm just remembering like a sentence about like you know having the physical experience of you're like you know when you're stabbing 28:07 someone they're like the way you you're like you hit a bone you know like there's something like Like as specific as that and how just like even like viscerally hearing that, it's horrifying. Yeah, it was really disturbing watching on the monitor. You also never, it's kind of the 28:27 only point in the film you kind of see her. 28:29 She's such a quiet character and she just starts like screaming in the shot. And it's sort of like, it's sort of like seeing someone become a different person. 28:44 Right. Right. Right. 28:46 Like the full transformation, that moment. 28:51 Yeah. 28:51 And she, I didn't, I didn't know this either until I knew I was going to talk with you and I did a little more research and I, I didn't know that Hannah had what she had been through either. 29:02 I can't even imagine making this movie while she, going through that i don't i mean i don't even know how you do. 29:11 That yeah yeah she did and then she wrote so beautifully about it in hindsight yeah i really enjoyed. 29:19 Her book yeah i'm i will read it so what do you think charlie says reveals about these women that audiences might not understand from the more kind of conventional accounts of charles manson and the murders. 29:36 I mean, it's interesting. 29:37 Like I still see so much content about Charlie. and the girls and like, you know, like all these thriller docs and on my TV and, you know, my husband and I will like, it just feels like we always come and we're like, wow, they're still there. 29:51 Telling the story, huh? 29:53 And are like poking at it and carving at it. 29:56 And yeah, what I think, I mean, I just think Mary and Guinevere really set out to do something different and they were so successful in trying to. 30:11 Paint the picture of these young women. 30:15 And how they got from A to B and how they became the most, you know, infamous people in California and how it was, it was from such a quotidian thing. 30:28 You know, it wasn't like they, and that's, what's so frustrating about, you know, even reading Helter Skelter. It's like, it's this sort of like, and don't. 30:39 Get me wrong. Like I love true crime. I love true crime. I love true crime podcasts. I love, I love, you know, spooky. 30:47 Stuff, but I think in this instance, like it's just a different perspective about these, these people are real people, you know, not saying they're victims necessarily, but like they're people that made mistakes and, you know, there are real 31:08 victims from all of it happening that are still in pain. 31:12 And that like, yeah, of course there, I don't think Mary herself identifies as a feminist, but, I think it's definitely centering women's stories and the coercion and the power imbalance of an older, very charismatic man. And that's such 31:37 a universal story, like time and again, no matter if you're in, you know, 69 or 26. 31:42 Right, right. 31:43 And I really.... 31:48 Whenever a project like this is made, I'm thinking of one or two other movies because there are a lot, where the women are at the center of it, of something that we know the story sort of already or think we do. And then you're so struck by, oh 32:07 my gosh, no one ever talks about this. Again, saying, I can't believe that I didn't know who Carlene Faith was. 32:15 I I didn't even know this person existed or that these women had this. The only images that I had were these women with their shaved heads and they're singing their songs without any context or any real explanation. I so appreciate that about this movie. I am very interested 32:36 in why people do the things they do and how we get there and how valuable it is to have this medium to be able to tell these things through narrative because sometimes that's how we can actually empathize or how we can come to understand something, um, in a 32:56 different way. So I, I just think it's really good. And, and you're so good in this movie and there's something that's so like just raw and authentic about everyone in it. 33:07 And, and that is no small task. Like I know how hard that is to, to do on a set, um, It's not easy. 33:15 Thank you so much for saying that. 33:17 Yeah. 33:17 It's, it's one of the, one of the things I've, I've been most proud of working. 33:23 Yeah. 33:24 Yeah. 33:24 It taught me a lot too, because I was telling a friend today that she's playing a character who doesn't say very much. 33:32 And there's so many scenes that Susan doesn't talk. 33:35 And I loved, I loved that so much permission and so much freedom to have sort of this like internal connection. 33:44 Internal world and internal dialogue. 33:45 And I find myself when I watch movies, like looking at the people who aren't talking because there's so much creativity there. 33:52 Yeah. Yeah. 33:55 It was, it was a real honor, but thank you. 34:00 Yeah. 34:00 Well, I've so loved talking with you. 34:03 Thank you so much. 34:04 You have such a lovely way about you. That's just great. 34:09 And so, I really appreciate your time. The movie is called Charlie Says. It is streaming online. I highly recommend it. 34:17 And Marianne, thank. 34:18 You so much. 34:19 Thank you so much. It's so nice to hang out with you. You're an icon. 34:23 Oh, you're so nice. Thank you.
Community discussion