0:14 Hi, guys. 0:14 Welcome back to Killer Thriller, docu-edition. I am Jen Fessler. So, in May of 2005, 18-year-old Natalie Holloway traveled to Aruba with her classmates to celebrate their high school graduation. And when it came time to come home, Natalie never made 0:31 it onto her flight. And her disappearance sparked an international investigation, a media frenzy, and a nearly two-decade search for answers led by her mother, Beth Holloway. So, you guys, I... 0:43 know this case very, very well. This was happening in 2005, so sort of in real time for me. And I was obsessed and heartsick for this mother and this beautiful young woman and the family. So at the center of the case was Joran Vandersloot, who was the last person 1:05 known to have been with Natalie. And for years, he gave conflicting accounts of what happened. And You know, Beth and the family and friends, they were desperate to find the answers. And now there is a Netflix three-part documentary 1:19 called Taken Natalie Holloway. And it revisits the case with new interviews and previously unseen FBI footage, firsthand accounts from people directly involved in the investigation. Joining me today is director Danny Sloan. And I am honored to have her here. 1:36 We're going to discuss the revelations. the years of unanswered questions and what it took to revisit one of the most infamous missing person cases in recent history. Hello, Dani. 1:47 Hi, thanks for having me. 1:49 Thank you so much for coming on. So I have to tell you that this is what we do here, right? 1:55 We do true crime documentaries, but it's very rare to get a call from, well, I got a call from my daughter. Mom, have you seen the Natalie Holloway documentary called Then I got a call from my best friend. 2:07 Are you doing the Natalie Holloway documentary? Because so many people in my world and in the world are being, well, I guess some are being introduced to this story and some are revisiting it like me and getting answers that were not there before. But it seems to be having 2:28 a very deep effect. People are talking about it and it is an absolute honor to have you here to talk about it. 2:35 Thank you so much for saying that. 2:37 I know my bellwether is I was dropping my toddler off at preschool the other day and like all the moms came up to me and they. 2:42 Were like, oh my God, congratulations. We've seen your doc. 2:45 I'm like, okay, well, if I've hit the moms at preschool, clearly, you know, people are watching it. But it is interesting, the generational divide, like as you said, it's crazy to see like Gen Z kind of learning about it. 2:57 For the first time. 2:58 And, you know, people a little older are going, oh yeah, I remember that one. It's an interesting like bellwether, I think. 3:05 Well, my friend Shari and I, who were the same age, and the story of Natalie Holloway was at the forefront of our minds raising kids, especially kids that were going to travel abroad. Really not just that. I don't want to minimize it. When our kids even went out to 3:26 do anything alone or went to a party, for a lot of us of a certain age, Natalie, her face was there, right? And just... I remember just following the story with so much sadness. But tell me, you know, again, it's been this is a story that began 20 years ago. 3:46 Tell me what it was for you that made you feel like this is a story that needed to, you know, be retold, not retold, but sort of looked into further. 3:56 What what brought you into the story? 3:58 So I was like that, you know, middle school and the middle school, early high school age when this happened, it was 2005. And I have these like very vivid memories of being in the grocery store at like the checkout line and seeing Natalie's picture splash on. 4:12 All the tabloids. Like, I feel like that was very present in my mind. 4:16 And obviously as I got older, as you say, like, you know, my mom would have those conversations with me. 4:20 We went away, you know, I went with my friends for a senior year trip, you know, out of the country. And, you know, this was always kind of present and talked about and thought about. And, you know, when I went 4:31 to college, just conversations about not leaving a bar by yourself. And, you know, I'm sure you did the same thing with your kids. They'll like cover your drink when you're at the bar. And so, you know, I know it was on my mom's mind. It was really kind of something 4:45 that I just felt was very present in my like teenage hood as I was growing up as kind of a cautionary tale, sadly. 4:52 Yeah. 4:53 As I got older, I've, you know, been doing this for a long time, making documentaries for you know, all of the platforms, you know, Netflix especially. 5:01 And this case popped. 5:04 Up back in the news in 2023 when Euron finally confessed and got, you know, a sentence in the US. 5:10 And so when it came back up again, I thought like, oh, didn't we already know this? Like, is this new information? 5:16 I thought we always knew. Yeah, I think everyone did. 5:19 We were like, wait a second. 5:20 We knew it was this guy all these years, like whatever happened to him. And so my curious kind of brain was, started researching and looking into it and realized that actually like there was a lot more to the story than I certainly knew. 5:30 And it turns out that most people. 5:32 Do, I think that are coming to this and going, wow, I didn't know so much of what was going on behind the scenes over 20 years. 5:39 Yeah. I mean, I definitely remember Euron. I definitely, I remember the story and, and, but the specifics of it, how frustrating it was for Beth Holloway, all the steps she took, how he was able to you know, evade justice. 5:56 And for so long, no, I did not know all of that. And it is really fascinating and really horrifying, but so well made. So did you think, do you feel like you had a pretty clear idea when you went into it, like in terms of what happened and 6:12 then you started uncovering more and more and talking to people, were you just amazed at all the evidence that started coming out? 6:20 I mean, I think when we started making this, we really understood and obviously understood more and more the more we spent time with her, you know, Beth's like arc within this from getting the phone call to getting the answers. 6:31 Like it was very important to like kind of understand that trajectory. 6:34 But then there were all. 6:35 These like complicating factors, right? Like we talked to Natalie's friends who had their own stories. really horrific experience traumatic experience within all of this not just you know their friend going missing when they're 18 years old I mean 6:47 can you imagine the summer before you go to college like this was a four-day trip this was supposed to be nothing it was a blip on the radar for these girls to look back on years later and go oh remember that time we went to Aruba and it 6:59 obviously turned into so much more but then seeing the way that they were treated in the media you know in the in the months and years after all of this was really horrific so That was, I mean, you see those clips and you're just like, oh my gosh, like what? 7:13 They were not the villains here. 7:15 So awful. I think like what a mind, excuse me, but like for these young girls and you did such a good job when Beth was showing her room even and showing the dresses that were hanging for Rush. She was about to go to Alabama and talking about, you know, 7:34 she wanted to join the sorority and literally seeing the dresses hanging from the door. And that's where these girls were at. They talked about how, you know, she was just part of that excitement. They were all going to go off and start their lives. And then this nightmare, 7:48 but no, I cannot, it's hard for me to imagine how these girls who also, you know, in a sense have been through real trauma with this were then not blamed, but they were, there was this. No, they were. Yeah. 8:03 There was something that they should have done, could have done and didn't do. 8:06 I mean, to, to be like treated like the villains in the story when you know I mean again it was a different time and I think Madison explains it so perfectly in the first episode like taxis didn't look like taxis in Aruba like no one talked to them 8:21 about a buddy system and going home with your friends this was 2005 and you know you watch them in these clips afterwards being told like you know, she should have had her cell phone on her, like a cell phone in 2005. Like it was a piece of metal 8:35 when you were out of the country, like you had to have the right SIM card. Natalie didn't. And all of this without context. I mean, it was very, I mean, you see them talking about, they were very confused. It was confusing for them to think like, did I do something wrong? 8:48 Was this my fault? And they've had to like live with that for 20 years. It was horrific. 8:52 That was Nancy Grace. Maybe that was really sort of putting it, to one of the girls. Like, well, so you did try to call. Did you not call? Like, what are you talking about? This is, I mean, they're 18 and their friend disappeared. Yeah, that part of it 9:11 was really just so shocking and awful. So the part, the thing about the documentary for me that is the best resiliency is the part of it that really sticks with me the most. And that I think will stick with me for a long time to come. And she 9:29 is a perfect example of, you know, a mother that will not quit, quit. I don't know where in the world she drew her strength from, but I'm wondering if when, you know, you were filming it, first of all, it must've been very hard for her to, you saw that 9:44 it was hard for her. She was from the, from the get-go, she was very emotional, but to convince her to sort of go through the whole thing again, was that a challenge for you? And really, cause it got you guys were, you were so specific in the details. 9:57 I could only imagine how hard that must have been. 9:59 It was a process I mean look I will say Beth is a pro at talking to the press she really cultivated and you see it in the series like This was, when she was doing it in Aruba back in 2005, this was part of her strategy, right? To put pressure on the police, to put pressure on law 10:18 enforcement and really try to get answers. So Beth is good at getting into a live-to-tape situation or sitting with an anchor and really kind of doling out the information that she needs to say. Sitting down and telling the 10:32 exhaustive story 20 years later obviously is a very different thing. 10:36 It requires a lot more introspection. 10:38 It requires. 10:39 you know, going places that, you know, you may not go on a normal day. And especially in a story like this, really sitting with the grief and thinking about what does it all mean? You know, she's in a different place now. It's been 20 years. She's gotten those answers. 10:56 I don't think that this was something that she would have been able to do while she was in process. 11:01 But I think it's just like a beautiful testament to kind of coming out on the other side of, of grief in a lot of ways, like the resiliency and pushing for answers. 11:11 Like that was her version of grieving, right? Like we all, do it so differently. 11:15 And who's to say if you're faced with the unimaginable, especially as a mother, like how you're going to respond. 11:21 I don't even think she knew she was going to respond this way. Like she has said there was nothing in her previous life to indicate that she would have responded this way. She was a school teacher, a mother of two, like a wife, like she was never tested 11:34 in this way. So I think she was kind of, relearning who she was over the last 20 years. And I think this is really a testament to like her coming out on the other side and going like, yeah, I have this inner strength. I can be an inspiration 11:47 to other people and I can show that there's not one way to grieve, right? 11:51 Like she doesn't fit that archetype in a beautiful way. 11:55 It really touched me. She said that the hardest part of it was the not knowing, you know, she knew that her daughter, obviously she knew that her daughter was gone. 12:03 She knew that she was dead and she knew that she was murdered by Euron. But she needed those details. And, you know, it was so interesting. I was watching thinking what I just wanted to block it at some point. 12:16 No details, you know, bury my head in the sand, survive somehow. But she needed to know exactly what happened. 12:23 And that was the hardest part was the not knowing. 12:26 I've had the same question for myself. 12:28 I've been working on this for a long time and we've talked about it within our internal team. I've kind of had that conversation with myself. How would I be able to handle this? And what would I want to know or not know? I think, again, it's like, you 12:42 don't know until you're in it. And I think the fact that on day one, he was already lying to her. 12:48 I don't know. 12:50 If she hadn't clocked the fact that he knew something And that it was going to kind of become this cat and mouse game, which I think she realized on day one when she was having that confrontation with him in the driveway. 13:01 I think that changed things for her. I don't know. 13:05 I don't know what the trajectory would have been if like she hadn't kind of sized him up and realized who he was early on. But I know I've had the same conversation just like once. How would you, what would you want to know? Would you bury your head 13:19 in the sand? But again, it's the grieving process, right? 13:22 And it just shows that there's not one size fits all for how to handle grief in a horrific, unimaginable situation like this. 13:30 I mean, listen, I don't know how I would react in a situation like that, but I could only hope that I would show the amount of grace and strength that this woman did. I mean, that's what's beautiful about this film is that, you know, it's not just about 13:44 this unimaginable thing. It's also about the journey of this woman who is the absolute definition of like what I would hope that I would be as a mother. God forbid something were to happen. So one of the really interesting interviews is from the former Aruban Deputy Police Chief, 14:05 Gerald Dompik. He is speaking publicly for the first time. 14:09 I know there was no video. He didn't want video. 14:11 But how did you get him to even speak? 14:13 It was a process. 14:14 Obviously, you know, look, he was not the most, you know, excited to do it. I think, you know, the kind of condition that he didn't want to go on camera was a big piece of it. He has, you know, a private life elsewhere. And it was a lot for 14:28 him to want to drum this up again. I mean, again, everyone in this, it was not an easy, like, hey, sit down, go on camera. It was conversations with everybody about how this would be, what this would look like. 14:39 Netflix is obviously the most visible platform in the world. 14:42 You don't enter into deciding to sit for a Netflix interview lightly. So, you know, it was really important, obviously, to me and the team that like everybody was aware of what this was and what the, you know, response could be, might be and how it would look. I think, 14:57 you know, you see, especially in episode three, like this weighs on his heart. I think he still had a lot to say about this. You know, he obviously wanted to talk about the work that they had done and kind of counter some of the narrative that had been 15:10 out there. So it was really important for us to include that and give him the opportunity to say what he wanted to say. But on the other hand, you know, you see like he still wants answers and I think he still wants justice. Like this actually affected him emotionally. 15:24 really deeply emotionally as well as everybody else. And I think that's the beauty of all these interviews is like, this is, it kind of starts with Bath at the nucleus, but there are these kind of concentric ripples out to 15:36 all of these other people, to her friends, to the journalists, to the law enforcement, to us as the public, like this case really touched everybody in a way that was very personal. 15:46 And I think you see that with him. 15:48 Yeah, you do. And I think it was really interesting to watch the people of Aruba and how it actually affected them. And this is, you know, this is their home and it's all about tourism. And now there is this dark cloud and how there was even at, at 16:05 one point, you know, some resentment, you know, against Beth because Aruba felt, I guess, tainted, you know, and, and they couldn't fix it and they couldn't solve it and they couldn't nailed this guy down and they couldn't put him away. And so it, yeah, we saw, we were 16:24 able to see that ripple effect, even just the citizens, right. 16:27 Living there. 16:29 They, I mean, they took it really personally. Right. 16:31 And a lot of that, I think we talk about, you know, hopefully kind of track that path in the media because nothing happens in a vacuum, right? Like this, this sort of inciting incident happens, Natalie goes missing. And then everything from there is like, a reaction to a 16:47 reaction to a reaction and. 16:48 The dominoes fall. 16:49 So, you know, Beth not getting answers from law enforcement, you know, the media starts to cover the story. The media, local media covers it. The national media, you know, starts to take interest. And really what happens is it overwhelms 17:03 the island. They're not used to this. And by the way, the police are not used to this either. You hear, you know, Gerald Dompeg talk about the fact that, you know, he's a surgeon at the operating table and all of a sudden he has to talk to, you know, the 17:15 media outlets every day about what he's doing. Like you kind of have to think like that's not a typical process. 17:21 And does that kind of confuse what's going on on a day to day basis? But then also, which I think, you know, Tony, The journalists we interviewed laid out so beautifully. 17:31 They're getting calls from their bosses every night going, what's new? 17:33 What's new? Let's keep the interest alive. 17:36 And so this becomes this like media ecosystem where like misinformation flies. And, you know, it's one thing to start out blaming you on VanderSloot, but like that gets kind of stale at a certain point. And we have to, you know, investigate every lead and tip and like they 17:50 want that baked in drama out. So I think the minute that the focus shifts away from Euron and to all these other places, to the island of Aruba, then to her friends, then to Beth herself, it kind of just becomes this like snowball that's out of control and 18:08 like nobody is safe, you know, under it. 18:26 Speaking of others getting the blame, Joran's father, who I don't know what happened. He feels culpable to me just in watching the film and sort of he was, you know, navigating what was going to happen and the outcome for his son. I understand that he's a father. But even, 18:45 you know, Joran saying no body, no crime and these sort of expert advice that he was given from his father Was there ever, was he ever held accountable, his father, for any of it? No? No. 19:01 He, look, it's one of those, like, Euron was out free for a really long time before he got arrested. 19:08 You know, there were obviously a lot of rumors flying and there was a lot of, like, confusion about how much power his father had in the justice system and how much influence he might have. I think Dom Pegg's conclusion ultimately is probably the right one, which is, you know, 19:24 we can't, he doesn't, he's never seen any direct evidence of Yaron's father, like pulling any strings, but like, yeah, of course, what advice was he giving him around, you know, the dinner table every night about what to say and what not to say, but we can't prove that. We 19:38 don't know ultimately at the end of the day, did it influence, you know, all of the kind of lies and misinformation. 19:44 That Joran started to spread? Maybe, but it's impossible without, you know, a recorded conversation or without anything in writing, which like between a father and a son, obviously, you know, you're not going to have that. 19:57 Right. It was interesting to me how one of Joran's schoolmates spoke of him so highly and said he was just the nicest and normal. And She would have never guessed it. And I thought that was fascinating because, you know, he was a monster, is. I mean, not one murder, 20:22 two murders, even the story of the bunny. I mean, Danny, this is, you know, someone who is a sociopath. And I know that he had a reputation on the island for going after American, young American women, tourists. But it sounds like his friends, the kids at school, they didn't 20:43 pick up on any of this. 20:46 I mean, look, I think it's, this is one of those where it's sort of hard to say because then, you know, Beth has the conversation with his, with his mother and father and hears that, well, you know, he had been in therapy and like, you know, there's a 20:59 lot of other stuff out there about, you know, he had been living in like the back house because he had been fighting with his brother, like stuff that we, you know, did not have the space and some of it just kind of uncorroborated. But there's a lot of 21:12 stories out there about, you know, what was going on before this. Now, you know, had he been potentially preying upon girls on the island, like the, you know, clerk at the Holiday Inn said, that's, you know, of course, that's one piece of this. 21:26 Does that rise to the level of murder? Like, I think that's the piece of it. 21:30 Like, maybe he was, you know, doing things that were a little unsavory and maybe he had this, yeah, maybe he had this reputation. 21:37 Like, was that kind of guy that you wanted to stay away from? 21:39 I do think there was genuine shock, even from his family, that it would escalate in this way. And by the way, I mean- Stephanie Flores tragically happens. It's five years to the day of Natalie. So, you know, it's like we don't know what happened that night. As much as we know, 21:56 there's a lot that we don't know about, like what snapped in him and, you know, what snapped in. 22:01 Him five years later. 22:03 But it is it is fascinating to me because there was not like a history of extreme violence before this. 22:08 It kind of just came out of nowhere. And then he could kind of go back to being like, I'm a normal 18 year old boy and people believed it. 22:16 But the wording that his mom used, it's called something oppositional defiance. Is that what it is? That syndrome? So I only know about that. I've heard of it and I don't know about it personally, but I've certainly heard enough that it's not just a kid that is acting out. 22:34 It's a kid that can't hear no or a kid that I guess can escalate so quickly, right? I mean, his mom knew that he had that. I would think that's something- compelling and something that, you know, if he never got treatment for it, I would think they would 22:52 have been worried all the time. Isn't that like a syndrome that is very dangerous? 22:58 You know, I don't know how much it was contextualized for them, right? Because at the end of the day, like he was doing okay in school and he had friends and he seemed really normal. 23:07 Like, I mean, again, it was 2005. 23:09 Like, I think we know so much more about, like I have a son, like we know so much more about being mothers to boys and like what we're supposed to teach them and how we're supposed to raise them. 23:19 And what, what consent means at a young age. Right. 23:22 Like we just know a lot more than we did then. 23:25 I'm not, I'm not sure how his parents felt about it or if they really ever did anything about it. 23:31 I think like, again, they were having trouble with him, but I don't think they understood that it was anything more than normal, you know, 18 year old boy being rebellious. 23:40 What about the brothers? I mean, you certainly, we got to know them through the film and they were exonerated, right? 23:49 But we didn't get to know that much about them. 23:52 I don't know. I'm sure obviously they didn't want to be interviewed, but I'm wondering where are they now? And, you know, I know they were driving the car, but they, Did they ever have any idea? Were they culpable in this? 24:07 Because I know they didn't serve any jail time, right? 24:10 They were released pretty quickly. 24:11 They were never even charged with anything. 24:14 Which, by the way, Yoran was never charged in Aruba with Natalie's death or disappearance, right? 24:19 So none of them really were. 24:21 Look, I think that they, in Beth's mind, and I think probably in the mind of law enforcement, at the end of the day, they were accomplices. Did they actually see with their eyes what happened that night versus just dropped Yoran off like we'll never know? Did they know 24:38 who their friend was and what he had gotten up to with other girls? Probably, you know, like I think they knew who they were dealing with. It's an interesting kind of like socioeconomic thing. dynamic, though, between Euron and 24:51 the Kalpoe brothers, because the Kalpoe brothers were local to the island. They, you know, had roots there. They had family there. Euron was like a wealthier expat coming in. 25:01 And typically the expats kind of hung out with the expats. 25:04 But Euron had this friendship with the Kalpoe brothers. And so, you know, they were kind of seen very differently by Aruban society. And, you know, I think similar to the security guard's it was very easy to kind of heap blame onto the Calpo brothers. 25:21 They were not as well positioned. They were not, you know, as well equipped as Euron was with his father. But at the end of the day, like, accomplices? Did they help him? I think like the extent of what they. 25:35 Did has kind of always remained a bit unclear. But like, look, when Beth called them criminals, that was what set off the firestorm. People got really angry and felt that that was a step too far. So there was like a defensiveness towards them. 25:49 Yeah. 25:50 With the security guards, it's interesting, the one that was demanding an apology, right, from a Reuben official. I don't remember exactly who he wanted the apology from, but Did he ever get it? Do you know? Cause that was very sad to watch that. It was just awful to watch. 26:06 I don't think so. 26:07 I think, you know, but again, like this is, this is what happens when you're putting kind of, you know, your foot on the gas and moving really quickly. 26:15 Like they took your aunt's word for it. 26:18 Yeah. Do you feel like that was about the pressure in the media was exerting? And so you do. 26:25 To an extent. 26:26 I mean, look, he said we dropped her off. There were security guards there. We don't know what happened after we dropped her off. Like you would think in a U.S. 26:36 led investigation, like maybe they'd bring them in for questioning, but like Yoram would still be like. the guiltier party or that there would have been footage before they were arrested. 26:47 Like there was definitely a rush to arrest them very quickly and have it kind of be over. But, you know, we know with all these cases, when you're wrongfully accused of something and your name is out there forever, it's so damaging. I mean, it really affects the rest of 27:02 your life. It's horrific, especially in a case as high profile as this. 27:06 Right. Danny, how do you decide what to include that will So you included, there's a scene about the blouse, right? 27:15 That Beth thought was Natalie's. And I don't know, it was so heartbreaking. I mean, the FBI, you know, showed there was no connection. But, you know, why did you decide to include that? I even looked at the blouse and I'm looking for the little flowers and I'm seeing 27:30 the little spaghetti straps. You know, you're a filmmaker. This is what you do. But it's, for me, it's those kind of... That insight that we get, you know, that was so moving, hard and also moving. How do you think about like what's included or not? There's so much. 27:50 There's so much. And especially in a 20 year story. 27:53 I mean, there's so much that just simply for, you know, keeping people engaged and interested, you know, kind of. 28:00 Has to has to fall away. 28:02 The blouse, I think, was crucial because, you know, when you think about the trajectory, right? This is 2005 when it starts. It's 2023 when it ultimately ends. The world has changed. Culture has changed. Technology has changed. And so, like, 28:17 by the time this happens with the blouse, we're in, like, a WhatsApp kind of conspiracy theory rabbit hole. 28:24 And, you know, to understand why Beth would have believed any of this, I think it. 28:30 We had to explain that it did feel really believable. 28:32 Like, people were sending pictures of bones. 28:35 Right. I just remember thinking about, like, the capacity. There's so much, right, that was being thrown at so many people that were, really, it was just like these false clues. 28:46 It's insidious. 28:47 It's awful. 28:48 Yeah, it's awful. 28:50 And you think about these people who just wanted to like make money off of her or extort her. Like, of course, there's like the helpful bloggers who like are trying to help her get answers and the amateur sleuths and like the people that really want to like help 29:02 and maybe they don't have the right information. 29:04 But like these people wanted to hurt her. I mean, it's horrific. 29:07 It is horrific and depressing. So does the confession feel like the end of the story to you for sure? 29:27 Or do you feel like you even have more questions? 29:31 You know, I kind of take Beth's lead a little bit. 29:33 Because for Beth, it is. 29:35 And I think at the end of the day, like her closure is ultimately the most important it and you see like Natalie's friends kind of take that lead too like they everybody kind of says like we accept this as the finale of this story we accept this as 29:53 like the final truth and you know Beth doesn't have questions anymore and like that's kind of good enough for all of us You know, there's definitely people on the internet that don't agree with that and don't believe it. And, you know, Yoran is a known liar and people doubt 30:08 the validity of polygraphs and all of the things that can come from something like this. 30:13 I feel closure. I want that to be it. So I think about even Stephanie Flores, the young woman that Yoran murdered in Peru. And how does her mother feel? 30:24 I know Beth, they were in communication, right? And we didn't get to see too much of, we didn't get to see her mother, but where is she now in all of this? 30:32 You know, we reached out, they declined to reopen that chapter, which is totally understandable. This is not, you know, for everyone to sit down and talk about this. Everybody, like I said, is in different stages with their, with their grief. 30:48 You know, they, it's horrific. 30:51 I mean, this was 2010. 30:51 This happened, you know, was, was years ago, but like you never, get over the loss of a child, especially so publicly. 31:00 And, you know, I think Beth's perspective is like, this could have been. 31:04 Prevented if Euron was held to account sooner, if they had figured out a way to put him behind bars sooner. And, you know, the idea that this was like another senseless tragedy that didn't need to happen, I think is a really tough pill for Beth to swallow, for Natalie's friends 31:17 to swallow. You know, and there was no question of including Stephanie's story. Like she is part of this and there's been a lot written and said about Natalie's case without Stephanie mentioned. 31:29 Really? 31:30 Yeah. 31:31 I mean, that, that is, uh, it's a wonder to me. 31:36 I don't get it. The same idea, same young girl. 31:40 And even the story was so horrible that how they were gambling and she was winning. And, you know, I don't know for sure that it was his, that's when he began to get triggered. Right. Because he'd been on a losing streak and, And then the gruesome way that 31:55 he murdered her. So, and here's the other thing. So he's in Peru. He allowed to, he's allowed conjugal visit with a woman that is now his wife. And he has a daughter and a bunny. What's up in Peru? 32:12 I know, but even here, you're allowed to get married in prison. I mean, there's a line of women who will, you know, go and write to these guys and show up and get married to them. Like, you know, you go Google a lot of these like really famous offenders 32:27 and a lot of them have gotten married in prison. 32:30 I mean, I think he probably has less, you know, restriction in Peru and there's a little bit, you know, look, he's going to get out and he's only serving 28 years. 32:40 I can't. 32:42 I know. 32:43 So the death is still isn't she still involved in getting into the U.S. after the death out? I'm making that up. 32:51 So he was he was convicted in the U.S. in a U.S. 32:55 Court for a 20 year concurrent sentence. So, I mean, theoretically, if he were to get out earlier in Peru than the 28 years, he'd already served a couple of years of that sentence. it's always possible he gets out early. 33:07 So if he ends his sentence early in Peru, then like, he's going to have to come here and serve out the remainder of that sentence, but it runs concurrently. 33:14 With the 28 years. 33:16 So he may never see the inside of a U S jail cell at the, you know, depending on what happens over there. 33:24 Whatever works for Beth Holloway is that's what I'm, that's what I vote for. Whatever is this woman piece as somebody who's not, Natalie's mother, a viewer. I'm like, let him get as much time as he can. Let him rot for the rest of his life, right? And it's 33:42 very hard to think that this man is going to be out when he is 50. I tried to do the math. 33:49 Something like that. Yeah, something like late 50s, early 60s, I think. 33:54 I'm 58. And I feel like I have a lot of life ahead of me. And brutal murder is not one but two young girls. It's just awful. 34:03 It's awful. 34:06 As somebody who actually made the film, directed the film, you've obviously been immersed in this for years. Do you feel peace now or do you feel frustrated? Like there should, like he's going to get out and it just keeps you up at night. 34:22 I think to your point, for Beth, it's about Beth, right? 34:25 Like it's about what has given her peace in all of this and about, you know, how, when something horrific happens, like I can't, I can't know how I would process it as a mother. Like you said, I think it's really about for her, what allows her to feel like 34:44 that sense of closure. Like my favorite part of the, you know, series without giving anything, you know, away, but obviously people know the story is Beth says at the end, like, Closure isn't, you know, not missing the person who passed 34:58 or not missing your loved one. It's like learning how to live without them and learning how to like live a life. And I think that's the journey, right? It's, it was getting those answers. That was kind of the immediate thrust forward, but it really also was like learning 35:11 how to exist without her daughter who she had, you know, had in her life. And, you know, she had so much more life to live beyond 18 years old. So 35:23 I think she has had to like let go of some of that anger and some of that frustration in order to like keep going. 35:31 I'm sure you reached out to Natalie's father and she did have a brother or sister. 35:35 She has brother, Matt. 35:37 And they declined, right? 35:39 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 35:41 What was that like? How were they doing? Can you give us any insight into, you know, where they are? 35:46 Yeah, I think, you know, Everyone's kind of very private. 35:49 Beth has really been the publicly facing person in all of this, all these years. You know, they have had to rebuild similarly, but, you know, and her father was kind of down there as well at the time, you know, but Beth was the forward facing one really for all these years. 36:09 But I do remember her father. I do remember Natalie's father down there. I couldn't remember. And I can only imagine his pain and how, he has had to deal with this. Yeah, it's awful. So now that you've made the film, do you feel, is there anything that you 36:28 feel like you would want? I mean, I know it's about Beth and as long as she has peace, but with this story, I feel unsatisfied. So do you have any of that? Because I want him, I'm so pissed. 36:39 I can't believe he's going to get out at 58. 36:42 I mean, it's so hard to, wrap my head around that. 36:46 I'm 58. 36:47 I just want to know why. 36:49 Like he, I have to imagine there had been other girls that had turned him down. Like he had this reputation for preying on tourists. I just like want to know why Natalie, why that night. 37:00 Nothing he's ever said has made sense to me. It, you know, we know what he did. Like that is very clear from that final confession, but like, my God, like why her, like, what was it about that night that, Whatever happened between the two of them, like, we will 37:18 never know because we only have the lies. 37:21 And the Stephanie thing, she was winning at whatever game they were playing. And they were gambling. And maybe he had been on a tear of a losing streak. And so... 37:32 Maybe that was the impetus. 37:33 She was also a different person. It was five years later. 37:36 He wasn't the privileged 18-year-old kid. He had been through this media cycle of being the infamous suspect in the Natalie Holloway case. He had been trying to extort Beth. 37:50 He was such a different person. 37:51 Five years later. 37:52 Stephanie also figured out who he was when they went back to the hotel room. 37:57 I know. Can you imagine? That just killed me. The terror. 38:01 She must have felt i know but you can see why that triggered him knowing what knowing who he was five years later like the bunny story makes sense you know all of that makes sense to me but like whatever happened on that beach i'm just like why why 38:20 her why that night like there had to have been other times he was turned down by girls that he had taken to the beach or taken various places. I just, I, that'll always sit with me, the, the why, but it doesn't, that's the point. Like it doesn't change anything. We know 38:35 what he did. 38:36 Yeah. 38:37 The film is beautifully done. And I watched the story, um, develop in real time and looking, watching it in the film and seeing the details of it that, you know, I hadn't seen. And all of these answers, it was, uh, fascinating. 38:55 And sometimes it's hard because I feel like, you know, fascinating, but so horrific and so sad and all of that, but just brilliantly made. And I appreciated getting all those details and the answers to questions that I didn't even remember that I had, you know, from 20 years ago. 39:12 So I congratulate you on it. 39:14 Thank you so much. That means the world. 39:16 Yeah, I really, really do. And we are following you and your career because we want you to come back, please. 39:23 Anytime. 39:23 Danny, thank you so much.
Community discussion