0:01 The public has had a long-held fascination with detectives. Detectives see a side of life the average person is never exposed to. I spent 34 years as a cop. For 25 of those years, I was catching killers. That's what I did for a living. I was a homicide detective. 0:17 I'm no longer just interviewing bad guys. Instead, I'm taking the public into the world in which I operated. The guests I talk to each week have amazing stories from all sides of the law. The interviews are raw and honest, just like the people I talk to. Some of the 0:31 content and language might be confronting. That's because no one who comes into contact with crime is left unchanged. Join me now as I take you into this world. A decentralised online cult is coercing Australian children into self-harm. torturing 0:52 their pets, and even taking their own lives. They're an extremist, right-wing, Satanist network called 764, and they are a top priority for authorities worldwide. Former WA detective Rebecca Nyssen has spent almost two decades protecting kids on the front line, and 1:10 today she reveals how 764 operates and how law enforcement is trying to tackle it. Take a listen. Rebecca Nyssen, welcome to I Catch Killers. 1:21 Thank you, Gary. Good to be on your show. 1:24 Well, I'm looking forward to having a chat with you because I've got to say in the preparation for the podcast, my eyes have been opened up to a lot that's going on in the cybercrime space. 1:36 Yeah, there is certainly some pretty dark spaces on the internet. 1:42 And I guess my role is to try and uncover those spaces to bring them into the light so that people are aware of them. 1:50 Yeah, well, perfect background. You spent a long time in the WA police and now you've got your own business, Lighthouse Cyber Education, and that's what you're out there doing. 2:00 But I've got to say from the way that crime's changed, isn't it, from the traditional, the way that we looked at crime that occurred on the streets, now the battle against crime is very much in this cyberspace area. 2:14 Yeah, absolutely. I think there's... Any crime now always has an online element to it and some sort of technical aspect to it. Plus, now we're also talking about cross-jurisdictional. 2:30 So what I mean by that is you might have, say, a victim in WA, Western Australia, but the offender might be in a completely different country. And how do you navigate that when the offender in their country, it's not a criminal offence. But over in Western Australia, it is 2:49 or vice versa. So you can make it very complex. Yeah. 2:53 And as both as former cops, we know how difficult it is working cross-jurisdictional and how matters can be lost because we operate sort of in a silo in our own jurisdiction. It makes it very hard. 3:08 Yeah, definitely. I mean, I think even in Australia, we have different state laws that to other states. So even within Australia, it can certainly be challenging. 3:18 It's a different world now for parents raising children. You're watching a kid play on the phone, you're thinking, oh, well, at least I can keep an eye on my child. 3:28 I know what they're doing, where they're up to, or they're in their room. But it's a changing landscape very much, isn't it? 3:35 It is. I mean, as parents, our number one aim is to try and protect our children, right? And we think that if we shut the door and not let people in or not let them out late at night, that they're going to be safe. But the internet, whilst 3:52 it has been a positive thing and really enriched our lives, it's also created certain complications and I guess threats. When we connect to the internet, we open up a portal to the outside world. And we just don't know where that could be. And not every place online is safe. 4:14 And I think that that's one of the most important messages we can get out there. 4:19 I looked at this group called 764. Now, my ears pricked up when I heard about them in the media at different times, but I hadn't had a close look at them. I had prior to doing this podcast. I'm horrified what they're up to. Can you give us a 4:34 bit of understanding of what this 764 group is all about and what they do? 4:40 Yeah, absolutely. So probably about February, March this year, it started really being highlighted in Australia. But it started years ago and it started in Texas. And so the name 764 comes from the postcode or zip code. of where 5:00 the original person who was charged in relation to online offences, and he was 15 years old. So what it is, is it's a right-wing extremist group that is operating in online communities that has tendencies for neo-Nazi idealisation. and very 5:25 sadistic abuse attached to the group. And what they do is they operate in two areas. There's a comm network, which is the recruiting arm, and that operates in online gaming arenas. So we talk about where are our kids going to be. They're going to be playing Fortnite. They're 5:46 going to be on the Roblox gaming platform, playing all those different games, and on Minecraft. And this group operates from a recruitment level on those games. And they're chatting with kids, looking for kids that might be desensitized to violence, 6:06 meaning that they probably play a lot of violent video games. 6:11 Because even though it's 18 plus, it can be very easy to access it online. They have a real desire for status. They want to be that apex predator, that top dog, always kind of winning and and bettering their peers and so what they do is is they find 6:30 these kids that are looking to connect and they connect with them and they get a bit of a rapport going and then they go hey let's move to a different platform an encrypted platform and that could be discord or that could be telegram and they pick these platforms 6:48 because they have high functionality they have high privacy and security, and you can actually have secret groups that nobody else knows about. And so they move these kids onto these platforms and that's where the radicalization happens. That's when they 7:05 send them their manifesto and they send them all the information that backs up their right-wing ideology. And then they say, okay, if you want to join 764, there needs to be an initiation process. And so what they say is now you have to go back to the online gaming platforms 7:26 and you need to find a victim to abuse online, essentially. 7:31 So generally they're looking for teenage girls that might be struggling with their appearance, body image. They are struggling to connect themselves and asking questions, who am I? They might've gone through family separation or mental health issues. And then 7:55 they start chatting to these girls and they then use a term called love bombing, which is essentially they move them to a different platform. Generally, again, we're talking Discord, Telegram, and they just bombard them with contact and communication. over 8:16 a really short period of time. So they're sending, you know, they might find their mobile number and send them text messages or calls or constant messaging to make the person feel that this is the only person in the world. 8:30 And they do that because they want to isolate their trusted network. They want to isolate them from their peers or from their parents. So it feels like that this is the only person in their world. And then once they do that, then they kind of start manipulating and control. 8:49 And so they do things like they won't answer any calls for, say, 24 hours. And the victim's left going, what have I done? What have I done? How do I fix this relationship? And then they come in and go, okay, well, if you self-harm, if you cut yourself and live stream 9:11 it to me, then I know that You care about me. 9:15 Yeah. 9:16 And then what they do is they record that and then send it or they even live stream it onto the Telegram or the Discord channels for all these members to watch. And we're talking about members all over the world. 9:32 And remember, we're dealing with, I guess, an ideology that they're always trying to do more and more and more and more. So it gets more sadistic and darker. 9:43 Yeah, well, Rebecca, what you've just outlined there, it's horrifying. 9:47 Like I look at crime and I think crime, you've got a bad person, they commit a bad offence. You're talking a group of people that are manipulating vulnerable people, not just in one small town, or one city, across the globe. The people that set it up, the boy 10:05 that you referred to, Bradley Candonhead, he was 15 at the time, and he's currently serving 80 years in prison. So, that's how serious they take it. And we're talking self-harm. 10:19 We're talking, I've read an article about killing the family pet to prove their loyalty to this group that they want to become part of. Yes. 10:30 So animal cruelty, being cruel to their siblings is some of the common traits of what they do. And fortunately, some of the The victims have actually committed suicide because of, I guess, this group and this abuse that has taken place. 10:48 Is this a product of what kids have been exposed to? 10:51 Because I'm thinking at that age growing up, yeah, a generation ago, unless you had the outlier, the pure evil person, no one was thinking along these lines. 11:04 I think it's an innate will for us to feel like we belong. and to have community. And what's happened with the digital space is, you know, in 2020 COVID hit us and all of a sudden now we're telling our kids, okay, it's not safe for you to go 11:24 down to the park and hang out with your mates. 11:27 You have to connect online. And whilst that was happening, then from a policing side of view, We were in a state of emergency, so we were focusing our efforts away from the predatory behaviours online and towards trying to make sure the state was safe. And as a result, 11:50 all these online predators had essentially a full rein on our kids that we were being telling go online, and then mainstream social media were telling kids about different hidden platforms like Discord and saying, hey, come check this out. 12:09 And it's just not a safe necessarily place, I guess, for kids to be. 12:14 Let's wind it back a bit. And I want to get further into 764 and some of the stuff that they've done. But your background, why did you become a cop? 12:25 What inspired you to pursue that career? 12:30 Yeah, so... I joined the police in Perth, Western Australia when I was 20. I always had a desire to become a police officer and a bit strange because none of my family are sort of in the policing arena, but I've always wanted to be a voice for people 12:51 who felt like they've lost their voice and I always wanted to help people. So the main reasons I joined was to. 13:00 To help the community, to protect the community and be a support in situations where, you know, they really needed it. 13:10 What areas in WA did you work? Because it's a big state and there's many different roles you can have in WA Police. Where did you work? 13:20 Yeah, so I just worked Metro. I didn't work rural, but I started off in Belmont. And that was a bit of a baptism of fire, learning the streets there. 13:34 And then I moved to a burglary task force that was set up in the district to try and curve the amount of burglaries that was happening. That was quite a fond, I guess, time of my career. We had a really good partnership with our detectives in the district. 13:52 So the uniformed officers would go out and deal with the burglaries and the property side and And then the detectives would deal with more the drug-related aspect of it. 14:03 And it was a really good aspect, I guess, a positive of being a female in the police force is when you do a search warrant, you generally need a female to attend the search warrant in case there's female occupants there. So I did get some great opportunities to 14:22 be able to learn from the detectives who attended these search warrants because they needed me to come along to cover that sort of aspect. So there was certainly, I guess, some positives involved in that as well. 14:38 You went into plainclothes. What areas did you work in as a detective? 14:44 So I worked in child protection. And I think that that was probably the first area that I saw that exploitation of children was happening online as well and not just physically and so I really enjoyed my time there but I found it very confronting and difficult as well 15:05 particularly when you're dealing with children and it can be difficult when they can't disclose and in criminality you have an offence you have to be able to prove every element and if you can't prove every element then you 15:21 can't charge. And when you're dealing with children as, I guess, the complainant or the victim, it can be very hard to kind of get that over the line. So it was challenging, but it was definitely rewarding work. Then I sort of moved to Midland and did some work out 15:38 there and back then into the city before sort of then, I guess, taking the turn of my career where I moved more into computer crime and technology crime. 15:50 With just holding the spot on child protection, that's, and every time I speak to police officers and I saw it in my own career, it seems like an area that's grossly under-resourced. Everyone there seems busy. They're always juggling 16:07 multiple cases and their cases are not, homicides are bad investigation, but invariably when the homicides occurred, you're not preventing a crime. 16:17 You're trying to find the perpetrator. With child protection, a lot of hard calls for you because you've got kids at risk. And I would imagine Friday afternoon, you're looking forward to knocking off and some information comes in and it would be very hard to walk away from that 16:35 information and not do what you could do to save the children. 16:40 Yeah, definitely. I think hit the nail on the head Friday afternoon, the priority one jobs always seem to sort of rock into the desk. And they were always very complex. Generally, they involve people in authority. And, you know, that could be, 16:59 you know, school teachers in government, in high profile positions. 17:05 There was generally an aspect to it that made it And it could just be a family as well. I mean, the amount of times she would rock up and, you know, either partner, the wife or the husband had no idea what was going on. And the amount of times that 17:23 they would back each other up and not believe that their kids was definitely an eye-opener. 17:30 Yeah, it's a thing that we've got to all take a good hard look at ourselves on that because I see people that would support their partner and not believe the kid. And a lot of it's about, well, if you take the partner away, invariably it's the male. So 17:49 they're the money earner. What are we going to do? 17:52 The shame of being a partner that's been sexually assaulting children. 17:57 There's so many complexities to it, but it's a crime that I think it helps to talk about. I think we sweep it under the carpet because it is so confronting, but we need to talk about it because it's so prevalent. 18:10 And you would have seen, as I've seen, the impact that people that have been abused as children, the destructive patterns in their life years later, they carry it for a very long time, if not for their whole life. 18:23 Yeah, definitely. And I think for me, my sort of detective and policing career, it helped me to see that side. 18:32 So that later on when I was dealing with, you know, drug offences or someone that's, you know, a priority offender that is in and out of jail, and then sort of you could drag it all the way back and... 18:52 a lot of the time they actually were exposed to or were victims of child sexual abuse themselves. And so from that perspective of dealing with these people as victims, not the offender, it gave you a look into their 19:12 life and certainly didn't excuse what they did or their behaviour, but it gave you a bit of understanding and I think a bit of empathy to see We're all just humans and some people have just had horrific things happen 19:28 to them. Certainly doesn't excuse the decisions that they've made in their life, but it helps you get, I guess, a little bit more empathy for them or to be able to deal with them as a human, which is so important as a police officer. 19:44 Look, I've seen it since I've left the police. I identified it when I was 18. in the police, but since I've left the police and interviewing ex-cops on the podcast or just speaking to people, all the police officers I look up to, no matter what area they work in, 20:03 are ones that have that empathy. I think it's so important in policing and we've really got to look for that. 20:09 And that doesn't mean you're soft or weak or, you know, empathy is just an understanding. And I think it carries you a long way in policing. 20:17 Absolutely. 20:19 Working in child protection, whether it's child protection, homicide, sex crimes, or whatever, it's very victim orientated. Did you realize going into cyber crime that it was going to be very victim orientated too? Because I've got to adjust my thinking. 20:34 I think cyber crime, I'm thinking bank frauds, that type of thing, which there are victims in that. But Cybercrime has changed now. We've got to change our thinking that you've got victims, like when we talk about that 764 20:48 group and the type of things that can happen. Sexploitation of young kids. And you hear some horrendous stories where kids take their own lives because they've been shamed by what's been posted. Yeah. 21:02 So that can be very challenging because I think when I first kind of got into technology crime and computer crime, it was It was more a chance for me to sort of step back away from the front line for a bit. But as I sort of sat there for 21:18 a bit and learnt more of what was going on, you would have victims in WA, for example, and they would be terribly extorted online because they've sent sexual images and now all of a sudden a black male is saying, hey, pay us this money. or we're going to share your 21:40 images with all your friends and family. And majority of the time, the offender was overseas. And I'll say majority of the time, because we do know examples where there has been victim and offender actually in the state. But 21:56 generally speaking, most of the offenders were overseas. So it makes it very hard because whilst there is an element that has happened in WA which is the victim and it's very real what's happened to them from a state policing perspective there was very little we could do in 22:19 terms of the criminality and actually charging someone and holding someone to account to that so it was difficult from the policing perspective that you had I guess, an organization and bosses that went, well, if we can't charge anyone, you have to move on and deal with the next 22:39 crime because we've got so much to deal with and not enough resources. But then at the same time, you're still dealing with a real person. And what's the fallback from that? The schools, the parents, the kids themselves, and they're left kind of in this lurch of no one's 22:58 really supporting us. No one really understands. What do we do with this? And that's probably where I first got the passion to kind of go, I want to do something about this. It doesn't feel right to me to just leave these people. 23:16 Give me an example of someone that's been exploited in that way. 23:19 Yeah, absolutely. So you've got a teenager, say they're 14 years old. We'll use the example of a young man, 14 years old. He's on Instagram. And he's looking at Instagram reels every day and then all of a sudden up pops a DM, a direct message. And they look 23:39 at it and it's from someone they don't know. And they have a look and this person looks like a beautiful, attractive young lady. And they start chatting with each other and within a short few minutes, the conversation turns sexual, 23:57 it turns intimate. And they go, well, you look hot, I'm hot, let's, you know, exchange some pictures together. And they don't really think with their critical thinking brain. They just think on impulses. And they put their video or 24:16 we've got a phone now, right? You just hit record, record yourself doing, you know, sexual poses like masturbating or something like that. And then they on send it to this person. The other person, generally speaking, would come up with ideas of, oh, my camera is broken. I can't 24:38 do it. But I want to caveat that to say now with AI, they are getting, they are receiving similar content back. So they feel like it's legitimate. 24:50 So I'm the 14-year-old kid sending photos of myself and then you're getting something back and that's AI now. So it's before it used to be an excuse why they couldn't send it. So the kid's lapping it up going, oh, this is great and I can trust this person because 25:05 they've made themselves vulnerable as I am. 25:08 Exactly. 25:09 And feeling comfortable, yeah. 25:11 Yeah, and sometimes it's first. So they send through a topless photo. Yeah. And then the other person's like, well, it must be real. And then they send their, you know, video. 25:22 And then all of a sudden they're getting sent loads of messages saying, we know what you've done. We're going to send, here's all your videos and your photos that we've just taken. Here's a snapshot of your friends list 25:35 from your TikTok profile, from your Instagram profile. We're going to share this with all your friends and family. They're going to know all about what you do online. Uh, unless you pay us money. 25:47 Yeah. 25:48 And, you know, and when we talk about adults, it could even be that adults are getting scammed with sextortion and they turn around and go, did you know I'm a 13-year-old child and I'm going to share with everyone now that you're a pedophile? 26:03 Yeah. So that's a big threat on someone, isn't it? Yeah. Yeah. 26:08 That's huge, right? 26:10 You can see how people become vulnerable very easily. And it's just human nature to be sucked into something like that. 26:17 And yeah, the consequences. And I would imagine, and tell me in your experience, even if they paid the blackmail money or did whatever, in my experience with kidnappings or extortions, it's never just a one-off payment and we're going to 26:33 go away. Once they know they can get some money out of you, it's going to come back. 26:37 Yeah, absolutely. You're almost on a list saying this person will pay. So they share that with other people and then other people will then target the poor victim because they're likely to pay. 26:52 Can we get back to 764 again? Because I've been going down the rabbit hole of that now that I've looked how bad it is. As I said, I heard it mentioned in the media of recent times, but some of the things that are occurring and like the AFP 27:09 have recently flagged the 764 group as a high priority. 27:14 So yeah, this is the AFP saying this is a real threat. Well, We know of the type of things where the traditional cults that, say, we had in the 70s and 80s that, you know, you could identify it and that sort of, okay, pack of weirdos, you stay 27:29 over there, we'll stay away from you. But this is, they are almost operating like a cult, the way you described it, indoctrinating people into their beliefs and trapping people in there. 27:40 Yeah, very much so. And they're not just then indoctrinating the kids that they are recruiting. they're also then indoctrinating the victims. So the victims are also being indoctrinated with the right-wing ideology whilst also being abused and exploited through 28:04 the different means that we've spoken about. So why do they do that? Well, control. Because it's all about control and manipulation. It's all about getting someone... to feel like I totally submit to the dominant person, to the alpha male. 28:24 And that's ultimately what it looks like, that domination-submissive sort of relationship, I guess. 28:32 How does the ideology come into it too, like the ideology that got going with this 764 group? What's sad about it? Are they trying to disrupt the world, like the way that they're spreading? And yeah, it's worldwide. What are they actually trying to achieve? Or are they just 28:52 getting their cheap kicks from destroying people's lives? 28:56 I think this group is connecting with each other because of pain. So it's pain that they feel themselves because they feel that they have been harshly dealt with or they don't fit in the world. And so they want to then inflict that pain on others because they sort 29:17 of have a feel of, well, I don't like where this world is. I'm going to try and mess it up as much as I can to make it as worse as it can be for everyone out there because I think the world is like that for me. 29:33 Right. 29:34 If that makes sense. So it's kind of like they're trying to increase. 29:40 The amount of violence and not just online, right? So we've got examples where, not in Australia, but in overseas where some of these group members have actually then taken the online world of 764 and and actually committed violent 30:01 attacks on random people that they don't even know in the public and live streaming it to say, well, see, I've one-upped you. I've done something that's even worse or more cruel or more sadistic. And it's just this, I guess, persona that they just want to be almost gone. 30:23 That's... Interesting, but also very scary. They're trying to one-up because I'm looking at some of the stuff they've been involved in, and it's not just the blackmailing and sextortion. 30:38 We've touched on that, but self-inflicting harm and getting them to live stream that and getting them to carve their names in blood and killing the family pet. This is sadism. 30:52 This is sadistic. And where does it stop? Because I would imagine a precursor to someone that's getting off on killing the family pet might be, next thing, well, how about you kill your brother, kill your sister, or do something like that? 31:07 Yeah. And the scary thing is the structure of this group is they're always trying to do more and more and more. And so when does it stop? Because There's always going to be someone that does something and someone will go, oh, I've got to better that. And I think, well, 31:25 how does it grow? Well, we talk about the online world and we talk about there's no limits. You might have someone in Perth that has ideas that they don't like the world or they want to inflict pain on someone and isolated, it wouldn't go anywhere. But now all 31:47 of a sudden we have this in digital communities online where we can find anyone that agrees with our worldviews or what we believe as great or as cruel as that could be. And so now all of a sudden we have a mechanism where people can connect and make 32:12 their own digital communities about anything. 32:16 That's the scary part, isn't it? With the outliers that used to be the village idiot or the person that everyone don't listen to him, virtually any tangent someone wants to go off on, they can find like-minded people that will support them. 32:34 Absolutely. 32:34 In their crazy beliefs. Yeah. I read an article, Swedish court documents obtained reveal that groups involved in attacks in several countries included repeated abuse of an Australian girl who's blackmailed into strangling her family pet and committing self-mutilation. So, yeah, 32:55 people in Sweden have been locked up for crimes they've committed over in Australia. 33:01 Yeah, and that's why it's so crucial that parents know that what their kids are doing online and who they're interacting with and to make sure that they're not just hearing one voice, you know, because that's how indoctrination happens, right? 33:19 They're only hearing one voice and they're hearing it over and over again, the same message. And that's why it's important that our kids are online, sure, and have their digital communities, but they also have real world connections and 33:34 And it's vital that our kids do not lose real world connections, particularly now that AI is taking over. And we know that kids are using AI as friends and as guidance and as therapy and for help. And that is alarming in itself, right? We need to make sure 33:57 that kids are talking to real people. 34:00 The digital world is evolving so quickly. Is law enforcement keeping up with the changes? 34:07 I think that they're trying. They are really trying and they want to, but it's a moving beast and it's evolving at such pace that to change legislation is not quick. 34:23 And then on top of that, they have to work within the boundaries of the law. 34:29 Yeah. 34:30 Right? So if we're talking about things rapidly happening online and they're happening on, you know, platforms like Telegram where you've got secret groups, meaning that you can only access these areas with an invite only, then how do you 34:50 then get police to have a seat at that table? 34:53 Then you have to do all your covert operations and things like that. And that takes time. And then that has to then be signed off to say, okay, well, these police officers can commit these offences, but not these offences. 35:10 And then there's risk involved in that. Because what if that then gets out and it's on the West Australian on Monday morning, they're trying to do the right thing, but they still have to work within the bounds of the law, which makes it extremely difficult. Now, in saying that, 35:27 the law is there for a reason, right? We can't go rogue or be vigilantes and just say, well, for the greater good, we can do this because where does that end? And I think that that's where the confliction is. No, nobody is keeping up with it because it's moving so 35:47 rapidly because criminals and the predators, they don't have to worry about the law and the boundaries of the law. 35:55 So they have carte blanche to do whatever they want. Granted, if they get caught, there will be consequences, but they can still work at that rapid pace where you look at law enforcement and they have to work within that bounds of the law, which has always got to hold 36:11 them back from really being at the forefront of where it's at. 36:17 I also have a concern that this is a silent crime too, that there would be a lot that goes on. 36:23 Like if there's an arson in the street, a car gets burnt out, you know police are going to have to respond. If someone's been assaulted, you know police are going to respond. This potentially is a silent crime. And I think you as an experienced former cop and myself, 36:40 we know that the police tend to respond when there's a public urgency about it. Like if there's a high profile, yeah, It might even, in a local area, it might even be a spate of break and enters, but police need to respond if it's reported in the media. With this, 36:57 it's almost a silent crime. And I dare say there's a lot of things that haven't been reported that have gone on that's caused a lot of drama in people's lives, but they feel stupid or the shame of what's occurred to them. What's your take on that? 37:12 Yeah, definitely. I mean, we know that kids and generally kids and the elderly are the most vulnerable when it comes online. And the reason for that is because generally they stay silent. They don't even share it. We're talking kids. 37:27 They don't even share it with their peers, let alone telling their trusted adults or their parents that can actually help them. So we look at the statistics and go, wow, yeah, online extortion of kids, it's pretty bad, but it's 10 37:45 times worse than that because probably majority of the kids aren't actually reporting. What we found when we were investigating the cybercrime and it was just kind of the tip of the iceberg in online extortion when I was sort of there is you would go speak to a victim 38:04 at school and you'd find out it's not an isolated case. 38:09 In fact, you know, a third of the classroom had experienced similar things online because what the online predators do is they target a school or they target a class in a school. They don't just randomly pick kids here 38:23 and there. They have more targeted, I guess, approach to that. 38:28 So it's definitely a silent crime out there, and I think that that's where it's our job to, one, educate the parents to say, this is happening and to try and try and get the kids to see that they need to speak up because when they speak up, people 38:47 can help them and we can shine a light on it, like you're saying. So we can have a public outcry so that something is done about it. 38:57 I've heard stories of, yeah, with sextortion where the kids from the moment it's happened, um, There was one sad one, and I won't say the name, but I saw it in the media where within 12 hours, a kid had taken his own life because of the embarrassment and shame 39:17 of what the threats were against him. That's how rapidly it can play out. 39:23 Yeah, and I think with the use of AI and AI-generated content, it getting quicker. Yeah. You know, it's taking, it's not months now to grown kids. It's much quicker and the serious harm and exploitation and abuse is happening much quicker than we were seeing before. 39:48 Has the legislation caught up with fake porn? You hear a lot of situations with fake porn. Is legislation catching up there? 39:57 Yeah. So the legislation is there. 40:01 Yep. 40:01 The hard part is identity. So what that means is trying to put a offender behind the keyboard or behind the phone who actually commits the offence. So most of the time, we know something's happened and we can prove an offence has happened and the legislation is there to 40:22 be able to hold that person to account. The difficulty is being able to pin it to a person. And that's because, you know, there's so much keeping anonymous online, you know, hiding your IP, using VPNs, you know, using proxies to kind of hide, your location of where you're 40:47 sending things. You can use different softwares to say you're in a different country. There's so many ways to hide the fact that it's a local offender. And then we talk about the cloud, right? So most people don't store their information on their computer or on a hard drive, 41:09 a physical copy in their home. They store it on the cloud. So where is their data? It's actually over half of it's over in America, half of it's over in Sweden. And then again, we're talking about that jurisdictional battle to then try and legally access that information to 41:33 actually pin it to a person. And I think that that's where the difficulty can be. It is definitely getting better, but it's also then trying to educate police officers to understand how it works. And it moves so quickly that how it was a year ago has completely changed. 41:57 Rebecca, the fact that you mentioned that, because that's what I just wanted to jump in on it and say, the technical expertise required to investigate these crimes are not what I remember was readily available within the police. We 42:12 had our technical branches and cyber areas relatively small because they weren't used a great deal. What you have described there, I'm thinking on any virtually any homicide investigation. I would be wanting an expert to come in and we have 42:29 analysts as you're aware, but there's really an expertise that's required to stay ahead of the game because we can't play, well, we shouldn't as law enforcement be playing catch up. We should be ahead of the game. And we have been 42:42 in the past when we're brought in the technical experts that can outsmart the crooks that we're after. But I'm worried that law enforcement won't have the expertise required To match it. 42:54 Yeah, well, it's hard, right? Because money talks. And we talk about a lot of these platforms and they're making so much money that they can afford to have the best legal coverage and they can afford to have the best technical people to support, you know, their defense. 43:16 Yeah. 43:17 As a state or a federal government, you're very limited in your budget, which can make it very hard that how do we then get access to these technical people unless they almost do it on a pro bono basis. 43:33 Well, I suppose that's where the government's got to come in. 43:36 And I'm throwing back years gone by, but telephone services were required to keep their records for a certain period of time. So for police to be able to investigate the records had to be kept stored. That's the type of legislation that we need the government pushing for. So 43:54 law enforcement aren't disadvantaged going up against multi-billion, I should say, organizations that can employ the smartest and best people. 44:05 Yeah, absolutely. I think the data storage and being able to actually access the information that they need is so vital. 44:14 Yeah, yeah. It makes me wonder how far we're away from like a cyber homicides someone being charged, not physically there for the homicide, like we've got conspiracies to commit homicide. 44:30 But what we're talking about here, it's not that far away. 44:34 Like you're murdering, talking someone into murdering their, or murdering, to taking the life of the family pet. It's not that far away from when they're encouraging people to take a human life. 44:48 No, it's not. And I think that that's where law enforcement needs to be bold. To be able to push the boundaries. Like you and I both know, you had those cases where you needed to push the boundaries to get the case law. 45:02 Set the precedents. 45:04 Exactly. And so we need our law enforcement, we need our lawyers to be bold, to go, we're going to push this to make a precedent that it's not right and it is legal and they should be held accountable. Absolutely. Yeah. 45:24 We spoke 764. Is there other groups that are notorious or other platforms that are coming up that are creating the same type of problems? 45:33 Yeah, so I think with online extremism, you obviously have the left side and you have the right side. And there's definitely groups, I think, on both. And they do use the online platforms to do that. Definitely Telegram, Discord are two of your main ones, but you've got any 45:55 encrypted platform that has your secret groups, your private groups, your invite only, they're going to be using that. 46:06 With Telegram and Discord, how their platforms are being used and the problems they're creating, Are they getting on board and helping address this problem or are they putting up barriers to prevent law enforcement getting involved? 46:23 Yeah, so you look at Discord. Discord is a unique platform in the sense that it's open source, which means that it's not per se like Meta that's proprietary and you have, you know, Mark Zuckerberg that is the CEO of it. 46:42 Could you be held responsible? 46:43 Yeah. So the way that Discord is structured is anyone can create their own channel and then you come up with your own rules, boundaries of how that channel is structured. 47:00 So Discord kind of go, well, that's not our responsibility because we leave it up to, a community member to kind of create their group the best way that they see fit. They do have parental controls on Discord, which is good. And before they didn't have that. And so 47:20 that's a positive. But in saying that, the age assurance that social media companies are using can be bypassed really easy. 47:36 This is under the age of 15 or whatever the age is set? 47:40 Yeah, absolutely. So generally it's an age estimation where the user has to consent to AI taking a video or an image of that user and then they go through and determine an age and based on what the age is, is what the account's set at and then what permissions 48:02 that they can and can't do. But kids being kids are more tech savvy than we are because they're digital natives. 48:09 They've grown up in this world and they've figured out ways how to beat it. And so now we've got a whole bunch of kids that, you know, shouldn't be on these platforms because they're age-restricted platforms, but they are because they've figured out how to beat it and now 48:26 they have adult unrestricted accounts, which almost makes it worse. 48:33 So that's Discord. Then you've got Telegram. And the creator of Telegram, he's all about privacy and security. And he's all about being anti-government, censoring what's put on the internet and what's put on his app. So his main focus 48:53 is not money. It is security and privacy. So that will always be a program. that has nefarious people on it because of privacy and security being such a big, I guess, aspect of that platform. 49:12 Complex. 49:14 Very complex. 49:15 It was easier just seeing the bad guy run down the street with the balaclava on. on and the sawn off shotgun. That was the easy days of law enforcement. 49:25 So many different layers. We'll take a break now, if that's okay. And when we get back, we've talked about, and I've got to say, I'm somewhat shocked. And I'm just thinking as you're talking the whole time, I'm thinking, how do you stop this? How do you stop that? 49:42 When we get back in part two, I'd like you to instruct us on the best things that you can do to prevent your children falling victim to this. I also want to talk about Manosphere and the impact that has and how this plays into the digital world that 49:59 we're talking about and what you're doing in your business and getting out and educating people because, well, I need educating and you're educating me. I think there's a lot of people out there that need it. Okay, we'll be back shortly. 50:14 Music
Community discussion