0:09 Hello, I'm Aline Van Dyne in New York and welcome to the macro brief from HSBC Global Investment Research, a weekly podcast that looks at the key drivers of global financial markets. 0:22 Now, Brazil delivered an election surprise. 0:25 President Lula da Silva was re-elected as president for a fourth term and the impact could travel far beyond Brasilia. 0:34 As Latin America's biggest economy resets its political direction, markets, investors and governments across the region are all recalculating. 0:44 So is this just a Brazil story or the start of a broader shift in LATAM? 0:51 Delighted to be here with Joseph in Calcaterra, our head of LATAM macro strategy, to discuss these issues. 0:58 Thank you, Aline. 0:58 Happy to be here. 0:59 Joseph, let's kick off with a quick recap of what happened in Brazil and why it matters so much. 1:06 Right. 1:06 So this election was a massive surprise compared to where market expectations were. 1:11 Betting odds and the betting odds had an 80 percent chance, if you look at Polymarket, of the opposition winning this election. 1:17 So many investors were positioned in that manner. 1:20 And ultimately, we got a surprise that really went against what all the polls were telling us, even though the polls had tightened, what a lot of the secondary evidence and what the data from the first round had suggested. 1:31 So we've seen a very significant impact in markets. 1:35 You know, I would say already in the second day after, you're seeing some signs of calm. 1:39 So some people saying, look, let's look at the bigger picture in Brazil. 1:42 What is the state of the economy? 1:43 Where should interest rates be? 1:45 Where should the effects be? 1:47 So we're seeing a little bit more calm right now. 1:49 But, you know, from our perspective, we still need to see a little bit more clarity on what the election means for the key variables for next year and crucially fiscal, right? 1:57 Because this is what the markets really care about in Brazil. 2:00 So let's just zone in on that. 2:03 The reason there has been a market reaction, because obviously, the expectation was that there is a policy impact, specifically fiscal policy. 2:12 You've been writing about this, of course, for the whole year, flagged it as a key issue. 2:18 What's at stake from the fiscal perspective? 2:21 Right. 2:21 When we take a step back, you know, the facts are that Brazil has roughly 80 percent debt to GDP, much higher than the average for emerging markets and funded at a rate of around 14 percent. 2:31 Right. 2:32 So this generally leads to unsustainable fiscal dynamics. 2:35 And this has been the case for some time. 2:37 There's no impending crisis because of that. 2:39 But the markets were hoping for a fiscal adjustment going forward that would put the fiscal scenario into a little bit more of a sustainable path. 2:47 And now that is being questioned. 2:48 Right. 2:48 And I think what makes the situation a little bit more serious is that over the case of the campaign, there were numerous pronouncements from President Lula regarding fiscal measures for largely next year's budget, which actually makes the fiscal starting point even worse. 3:04 Right. 3:04 So what that means is that markets are not going to look for any evidence of a fiscal offset or the extent to which that's going to be in the budget for next year. 3:11 So basically, especially in the last few weeks of the campaign, President Lula did make a lot more promises. 3:19 And so are you waiting to see if these promises are actually delivered on? 3:24 Or are you expecting that they will be enacted? 3:26 Or is this one of the things that's now in focus? 3:30 Yes. 3:30 Right. 3:30 The totality of the measures are almost 280 billion BRL. 3:35 And if we think about the potential impact on the primary deficit for next year or the primary balance, it could add almost a point in GDP when we look at actual fiscal measures. 3:43 Now, yes, that is exactly the focus, right? 3:46 What does this all mean for the 2027 budget? 3:48 And that's why the next few weeks are going to be very important. 3:51 The very first signals that we need to see are who is the next finance minister going to be. 3:54 And those should be coming out hopefully in the next one, two weeks. 3:58 And then the budget discussions for 2027, which will have to be finalized, let's say, in late November, early December. 4:04 So markets are going to look very closely at what exactly is put into the budget. 4:07 Does Congress approve it? 4:09 And that will allow us to better understand where the situation is and does President Lula understand the fiscal implications? 4:16 Does he make an effort elsewhere or try and dampen those measures? 4:19 So that's why the next few weeks are going to be crucial. 4:21 And I think will give us a much better understanding of the situation going into next year. 4:25 And now, of course, it wasn't just the presidential election. 4:28 A few weeks earlier, we'd had results for the Congress and that did make a shift to the right. 4:35 So is there more of a divided government? 4:38 Is that another contributor to investor uncertainty? 4:42 100%. 4:43 And look, the outgoing Congress actually is generally a center-right-leaning Congress. 4:48 And the new one, let's say, is a more right-leaning Congress when you look at the distribution of parties. 4:54 The outgoing Congress, at the end of the day, largely approved of President Lula's fiscal agenda over the years, right? 5:00 Which, let's say, many investors believe have led to an increase in debt-to-GDP. 5:05 So the question is, what is the new Congress going to do? 5:07 And yes, I think the expectation is there will be some degree of gridlock, perhaps a little bit more pushback from Congress. 5:14 Of course, we need to see exactly what form that takes. 5:17 But the expectation will be, let's say, of a more tense scenario in Brasilia in the coming years. 5:23 And Joseph, why does this matter to the rest of the region? 5:27 Well, interestingly, like this result was actually different from what we have been seeing in the rest of the region. 5:32 Right. 5:32 So if you look and last year you had elections in Chile and Colombia and Peru, it all led to, let's say, market friendly outcomes. 5:39 Right. 5:40 With reform directions that the market likes. 5:43 Of course, there's still questions about that, the extent to which the Colombian government is addressing its own fiscal issues, for example, or the extent to which the pro-business reforms in the Chilean government that have been announced this year will impact investment next year. 5:57 But yeah, this is an anomaly in the sense that it's different from the political trend we're seeing in the rest of the region. 6:03 And investors do have questions. 6:04 To what extent is this a new trend, right? 6:06 And I guess if you're looking forward at elections, we have Argentinian elections in one year. 6:11 And arguably, those are going to be even more consequential, right, for the country, given, you know, the extent of Argentina's issues before the extent to which they've been partly addressed. 6:21 And markets are going to be looking for very clear signals that this reform trajectory is going to continue. 6:26 So, yeah, I think there's open question to what extent this is a trend or to what extent it just reflects the intricacies of Brazil, which is, of course, a very large country, right, that has some notable differences with the rest of Latin America. 6:39 And we haven't mentioned Mexico yet, of course, the second biggest economy with particularly close trade ties to the US. 6:48 Any comments on the outlook there? 6:51 I mean, what's a broader backdrop in terms of growth or other economic factors in the region? 6:57 Yeah, look, if you look at the current situation, growth has been very weak. 7:02 You haven't had a change in government, at least in terms of ideology, in the last few years. 7:08 The central bank is diverging with the Fed, so that's putting a little bit of pressure on the currency. 7:12 So if you look at those factors, it might look a little bit complicated. 7:16 But actually, when you take a step back, you know, there have been notable changes in Mexico, right? 7:21 So the President Scheinbaum's administration has done an excellent job in dealing with the Trump administration. 7:26 I mean, Mexico's effective tariff to the U.S. is around 3%, 4%, which is a fraction of any other emerging market. 7:33 So Mexico's in a good situation. 7:34 You see that in some aspects of booming trade, particularly data centers. 7:38 You also see kind of micro reforms, right? 7:40 So we've seen better interaction with the government and the private sector. 7:45 The government is enacting its investment plan called the Plan Mexico, which involves both public and private. 7:51 And that's actually really kicking off in a significant way and should drive investment growth next year. 7:56 So, you know, we actually see some notable improvements in Mexico that have been a bit undetected by investors. 8:01 And that actually is improving the medium term outlook in Mexico, even though, like I said, there's some short term challenges, mostly regards to the currency market because of this divergence in monetary policy. 8:11 And speaking of trade, Brazil and shifting back to Brazil, it is an exporter of commodities, for example. 8:21 Any impact on trade or any other sort of global repercussions of the Brazilian economic situation? 8:30 No, look, I think when we look back at President Lula's track record, maybe apart from fiscal, it's generally meant that Brazil has had fairly strong growth, actually. 8:38 The export sector has been doing very well. 8:40 The agricultural exports have been booming in almost a structural way. 8:44 You've seen significant growth in oil and gas volumes, which has helped Brazil be a little bit insulated from what's happening in the Middle East. 8:50 So look, we look at the track record on the commodity sector under President Lula. 8:53 It's actually been pretty good, right? 8:54 So we can expect that to continue. 8:57 And for Brazil to have this diversification of commodity exports... 9:00 I mean, it's still a commodity economy. 9:01 That's not diversified. 9:02 But within the commodity space, it's incredibly diversified. 9:06 And I think that continues, right? 9:07 Brazil has maintained very good relationships with China on trade. 9:11 There's been some hiccups with the U.S. in terms of tariffs. 9:13 But by and large, trade with the United States is continuing. 9:16 And. 9:16 And of course, you know, Brazil is a very strong growth and investment relationship with Europe, which we would expect to continue as well. 9:23 So I think this is why when we take a step back and try and isolate the politics, Brazil is not in a bad spot geopolitically. 9:30 And, you know, especially when you hear about a lot of investors talk about Brazil almost as like an anti-AI hedge, right? 9:37 It doesn't have an AI story in its local market. 9:40 It has commodity exports, right? 9:42 So, yeah, I think when we isolate the politics a little bit and we look at the strength of the export sector on the commodities, Brazil's in a good spot. 9:49 Let's end, Joseph, with just a recap of what the market reactions have been and what specific indicators you're watching in terms of flows or in terms of currency moves, etc. 10:02 How do we know how sentiment is towards Brazil and LATAM? 10:07 Right. 10:07 So at this moment, you know, if you look at the impact post-election, the day after the currency had depreciated by 10 percent, interest rates had significantly repriced across the curve. 10:16 The equity market, you know, basically reversed all the gains since the first round. 10:22 But there is a little bit of calm on the second day. 10:24 So you can see perhaps some interest from investors to fade. 10:26 So that's a positive. 10:28 I think that's a positive signal. 10:29 But for us, it's still a little bit too early, right, because there are concerns on the fiscal and we need to see how those are going to be addressed. 10:36 So I think the next few weeks, the appointments for finance ministry, the deliberations around the 2027 budget, those are going to be very important. 10:43 And there will be a case, actually, for more optimism if we see some, let's say, depending on how those are delivered. 10:50 But it's a little bit too early for us to take, let's say, that more optimistic view that we can fade the moves. 10:56 I think we need a little bit more time. 10:58 Joseph, thank you so much for that roundup. 11:00 And we will, I'm sure, have more to talk about in the future as we get more clarity on all these developments. 11:08 Thank you. 11:08 Thank you, Lynn. 11:15 So Joseph in Calcaterra there on the outlook for Latin America following President Lula da Silva's surprise re-election as president of Brazil. 11:24 So that's all we've got time for on this week's podcast. 11:27 Don't forget to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. 11:30 And while you're there, check out our Asia-focused sister podcast under The Banyan Tree. 11:37 And if you'd like to know more about other topics we cover, such as the rapidly evolving world of digital finance, then head to HSBC CIB YouTube channel to watch our six-part video series on the topic. 11:52 This episode of The Macro Brief was hosted by me, Aline Van Dyne in New York and produced by Tom Barton in London. 12:01 So until next week, thanks very much for joining us.
Community discussion