0:09 Hello, I'm P.S. 0:10 Butler in London and welcome to the Macro Brief from HSBC Global Investment Research, our weekly look at the key drivers of financial markets. 0:18 Now, from the pandemic and conflicts to rising protectionism, global trade has had plenty to contend with this decade. 0:25 Although exports have remained resilient, these shocks have exposed how dependent many economies are on a narrow set of suppliers, prompting some to attempt to diversify their supply chains. 0:36 But have they succeeded? 0:38 That's the question Shanela Rajanagam, senior trade economist, addresses in her new report. 0:44 She joins me here in the studio. 0:46 Shanela, welcome back to the podcast. 0:47 Great. 0:48 Thank you for having me. 0:49 So your report is called Fault Lines. 0:52 So in simple terms, what are the main fault lines in global trade today and why should we care about them? 0:58 And in fact, even before that, there was a lot of data crunching, I think, in this report, wasn't there? 1:03 There was a lot of data crunching. 1:04 This is a massive analytical undertaking. 1:08 Effectively, we looked at imports from 65 economies and that led us to have about 78,000 importer product relationships. 1:19 Exactly. 1:20 It's a lot. 1:21 Was steam coming out of your laptop? 1:23 Exactly. 1:24 It took months to prepare, so I'm glad we finally got the report out. 1:28 But it is a great analytical piece. 1:31 And effectively, as you described, the purpose was to look at some of the fault lines of global trade. 1:37 And what we particularly focus on is where there are critical import dependencies. 1:42 So, you know, the COVID-19 pandemic really highlighted how certain economies were very dependent on certain suppliers for critical products. 1:51 And we wanted to see whether these dependencies have changed or whether these underlying vulnerabilities, the fault lines, as we call them, still remain. 2:00 So before we get into a little bit more detail, global trade has faced pandemic, walls, shipping disruption, extreme weather and rising tariffs. 2:11 And despite all of this, isn't it right that goods trades volumes are now around 20% above their 2019 level? 2:18 What explains this resilience? 2:20 Do people just have to trade come what may? 2:22 That's right. 2:22 It's a great question because we keep talking about how trade has been remarkably resilient. 2:28 And I think it has been resilient for a couple of reasons. 2:33 The first is that when we have had these big supply side shocks like the pandemic, businesses have actually been pretty flexible. 2:40 So they've been able to adapt their suppliers, their shipping routes pretty quickly. 2:45 And then with other types of shocks like tariffs, either companies have traded through the tariffs or they've found alternative suppliers or alternative markets. 2:56 So a combination of these factors have led to this resilience. 3:00 And really, it's just that trade keeps finding a way. 3:03 So your report finds that around 70% of the economies that you studied became more reliant on a small number of suppliers. 3:13 Why has diversification proved so difficult? 3:17 You would have thought that there would be an incentive to diversify, particularly over the recent years. 3:21 I mean, you would have thought people would really try and diversify supply chains. 3:24 In fact, it's the opposite. 3:25 Exactly, and there has been this massive push by governments to promote diversification, and indeed by some businesses as well, taking it upon themselves. 3:35 But I think ultimately diversifying is very difficult, because there is a reason trade has arranged the way it has, and the reason why supply chains have arranged the way they have. 3:46 Whether that be this is where you can get certain expertise from, certain critical inputs, certain raw materials, That's the reason why supply chains have arranged in these particular configurations. 3:59 And kind of lifting and shifting those dependencies is very challenging. 4:03 Yeah, you can't actually move a copper mine. 4:05 You know, you have to get it from where it's produced. 4:07 And in fact, for roughly half of the 78,000 importer product relationships you analysed, the top three suppliers accounted for at least 80% of imports. 4:18 Can you maybe just illustrate that? 4:20 What does that mean in practical terms? 4:22 Yeah, so that's basically some of the number crunching we did. 4:24 So looking across the 78,000 product and importer relationships, we basically looked at each individual relationship and looked at how much of imports the top three suppliers accounted for. 4:38 And then we calculated a weighted average across all those relationships. 4:43 So for the most part, most of these relationships are actually highly concentrated. 4:49 because the bulk of imports come from the top three suppliers, so over 80%. 4:54 Is that because ultimately from a business perspective, it's more efficient? 4:59 I mean, you don't want to be dealing with multiple different suppliers. 5:02 So there is a sort of, even though there is an incentive from the disruption to diversify, from a business perspective, being concentrated actually leads to greater efficiencies? 5:11 I think that's right. 5:12 And as we were saying before, there's a reason these supply chains have arranged the way they have. 5:17 It's very difficult to, for example, as you mentioned, to source certain raw minerals from other countries outside of the African continent. 5:27 And then where those processing actually takes place tends to be in China. 5:31 And so there isn't much incentive to actually shift those types of complex supply chains, even if it means that importers end up being quite dependent on imports from these particular countries. 5:45 Now, talking about diversification, you draw a line between genuine diversification and trade rerouting. 5:53 When you talk about trade diversification has been often incremental, not transformational, is that kind of what you're referring to? 6:01 Yeah, exactly. 6:01 So there obviously has been this push to diversify and de-risk, but I think it's important to distinguish between what is that genuine trade diversification, where you have production capacity, expertise, certain supply chain activities that have actually shifted to alternative markets versus simple trade rerouting. 6:22 And in the report, we talk about the many ways that you can actually rewire supply chains And when we consider things like trade routing, it's around perhaps the relabeling or the reinvoicing of trades. 6:35 So you're kind of just changing the origin. 6:37 But in actual fact, the product comes from another market. 6:42 Also, potentially, if, certain supply chain activities that are associated with just minor processing or final assembly ends up relocating, that doesn't necessarily mean that the highly value-added activities have shifted. 6:59 And indeed, you know, some countries may still be dependent on the original suppliers for inputs. 7:05 So that trade dependency hasn't necessarily gone away. 7:09 Yeah, it sort of optically maybe looks like it's changed, but fundamentally it hasn't. 7:13 Which products are most vulnerable if a major supplier or shipping route is disrupted? 7:17 I suppose oil must be a case in point, but are there others? 7:21 Yeah, exactly. 7:22 And, you know, we could go through the very detailed list of products. 7:26 But basically in the report, we do have a table with nearly 100 products where the top three importers accounted for at least 80% of imports. 7:34 So that highly concentrated. 7:37 in terms of import concentration. 7:39 And these range from things like silk to fertilizers, sulfur, textile machinery. 7:45 Some of these are obviously relatively low in terms of import value, but it just goes to show that that concentration is across the spectrum. 7:53 What about sanctions and geopolitical shocks? 7:56 How have they reshaped trade? 7:58 Yeah, so as we say in the report, you know, you can have this push by governments to kind of de-risk and diversify, but nothing actually facilitates a shift in trade dependencies like a big supply side shock. 8:12 So if you think like the pandemic. 8:14 sanctions, for example, on Russian trade that really forced it to diversify for a broad range of products. 8:21 And now it sources a lot more from China and its Central Asian partners, for example, compared to Europe. 8:28 But even things like, you know, ongoing geopolitical tensions, really broad export restrictions. 8:34 These are the types of things that make suppliers very quickly decide to shift where they're sending product to and indeed economies where they're sourcing product for. 8:44 The issue with this is whether it's actually durable, because we can have a big shock like the pandemic, there's a push to diversify, and then not too much actually happens after the fair. 8:54 Alternatively, you could do the shift, but you're trading one dependence for another. 8:58 Is there a risk there as well? 9:00 Yes, absolutely. 9:01 And this has been really highlighted with US trade data because when you look at the headline data, the US has significantly reduced its import reliance on China. 9:11 But when you look at the data on a value-added basis, China's contribution to US imports is actually flat-lined and more of this value-add is now being rerouted through Taiwan, through Vietnam, through Mexico. 9:23 So in that sense, the US is almost trading its Chinese dependency for dependency on these other economies without fundamentally removing the upstream dependency. 9:34 Very interesting. 9:35 So what should governments and businesses focus on next? 9:38 The choice is there, building more domestic capacity, finding more suppliers, holding larger inventories, or actually simply accepting that some dependencies can't be eliminated? 9:47 Yeah, so I think the answer is all of the above. 9:50 There are many different strategies that corporates could undertake. 9:54 We've spoken a lot previously about scenario planning, and I think that still stands because it is likely that we will see another trade shock and traders in this very vulnerable period of time. 10:04 at the moment where it is facing a series of overlapping trade shocks as well. 10:09 Looking at mapping trade dependencies beyond just your first-tier suppliers, that would also be rather helpful, especially because you can see where some of those upstream inputs actually come from, try and manage some of those trade dependencies. 10:23 Localising production, that's certainly another option as well. 10:28 It might not always be feasible. 10:29 And it takes time as well. 10:30 It takes time. 10:31 It might not be feasible for every single product or every single sector. 10:36 But even if you can try and localise some of that production of certain parts of your value chain, that could be potentially quite helpful as well. 10:46 And also, as you mentioned, building inventories. 10:50 That was quite a successful strategy for businesses during the pandemic. 10:55 And if we think that there are going to be potentially more trade shocks, then building up some of those inventories of critical inputs would be quite helpful. 11:05 Historically, you and I lived through a period of the sort of mantra was just-in-time production, which relied on very efficient trade routes, producing things just when a manufacturer needed them. 11:17 Has that sort of faded? 11:19 Yes, it's quite interesting because during the pandemic, we did speak a lot about this and the switch to just-in-time production and how that kind of created more vulnerabilities through the supply chain. 11:31 At that time, there was a bit of a push for businesses to beef up their inventories, and we did see that in some of the inventory data. 11:37 I will say since then, things have kind of reverted back to the just-in-time model. 11:43 And of course, one of the main reasons for that is cost. 11:46 So ultimately, when it comes down to it, you do want to keep quite an efficient and lean supply chain management inventory system. 11:53 And this is really one of the problems that we explore in the report, is that each time we have one of these big shocks, there's a massive push to diversify, de-risk, beef up inventories. 12:06 But then after that shock kind of subsides, things kind of revert to how they were. 12:11 And ultimately, in the end, we still have a lot of those fault lines and vulnerabilities. 12:17 Nearly out of time, but anything that our listeners should be watching out for in terms of tariff regulations or trade agreements over the next six months? 12:25 Yeah, so the FTA pipeline has been fairly successful recently, both from the UK side, but also the EU side. 12:34 The UK's trade deal with India took effect earlier this year. 12:38 So I'd say watch out for the ongoing implementation of that, along with its FTA with the Gulf Corporation Council. 12:46 In terms of trade tensions, we've written a lot recently about EU-China trade tensions and how that's being managed. 12:54 So potentially look out for more protectionism, especially if recent cooperation doesn't actually yield tangible results in the near term. 13:03 And of course, US tariffs, it's the ongoing saga. 13:07 A number of tariffs are currently in effect. 13:10 Some economies facing very high average effective tariff rates into the US and the risk that there could be more to come, particularly on the sectoral side, potentially broadening out of semiconductor tariffs and possibly in other sectors as well, like industrial machinery and robotics. 13:30 Plenty to watch out for. 13:31 But that is all we have time for. 13:33 I'm sure we'll have you back. 13:34 Just to reiterate to our listeners, that is crunching through 78,000 importer product relationships. 13:41 So there's a lot of work there. 13:43 And the report is a treasure trove of trade analysis. 13:47 So well done on that one. 13:48 And thank you for joining us today. 13:49 Thank you for having me. 13:56 That was Shanela Rajanagam on shifting trade vulnerabilities. 14:00 And a reminder that we have lots more content available to you. 14:03 If you'd like to hear more on Asia, then listen to our sister podcast, Under the Banyan Tree, and head to the HSBC CIB YouTube channel to watch our interview series discussing the rapid development of digital assets and currencies. 14:17 But that's all from us this week here on The Macrobrief. 14:20 This episode was hosted by me, Piers Butler, and produced by Tom Barton. 14:24 Don't forget to like and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. 14:28 So until next week, thanks very much for joining us.
Community discussion