0:01 Maybe some point AI will impact jobs, but today it's only creating more jobs as of now. 0:16 Welcome to Under the Banyan Tree, where we put Asian markets and economics in context. 0:21 I'm your host, Harold van der Linde, in Hong Kong. 0:24 Today, we've got the spotlight on India. 0:27 It's expected to be one of Asia's success stories in 2027, and it's also becoming a popular alternative for investors looking beyond the year's massive market theme, which of course has been artificial intelligence. 0:40 Hello. 0:41 Bringing his expertise to the pod this week is special guest, Yogesh Agarwal, our head of India research, who's visiting Hong Kong all the way from Mumbai. 0:50 I'm also joined by regular friend of the podcast, Prun Agar, my fellow equity strategist and your guest, fellow India national. 0:58 We're going to be talking tech, consumer spending, a dry monsoon season, equity prices and much, much more. 1:05 Let's get the conversation started right here under the banyan tree. 1:15 Well, Yogesh and Prerna, welcome to Under the Banyan Tree. 1:19 Thanks, Aaron. 1:20 Thanks, Aaron. 1:21 Yogesh, you just flew in from Mumbai. 1:22 Yes. 1:23 You had a bit of problems on the flight, right? 1:24 What was going on? 1:26 Yeah, man, there's only one flight to Hong Kong, first of all, as you know. 1:29 And it's fully sold out for the entire week. 1:32 Okay. 1:32 So I had to take a bit of a detour, which wasn't fun. 1:35 So you had to go to Singapore, I believe, right? 1:37 Yes. 1:37 So it was a bit longer trip. 1:38 Missed my flight. 1:39 Yeah, yeah. 1:40 So it was a long journey for you from Mumbai. 1:43 But it's interesting to see that all the flights are being fully booked. 1:46 I hear more people are traveling. 1:48 Clients of us are traveling to India. 1:49 Do you see that as well? 1:50 There's more interest, it seems. 1:52 There is certainly more interest. 1:53 And obviously, India has been positioned as a little contrary to the AI themes. 1:59 Yeah. 1:59 But not just for that, I think India has its own course. 2:03 The credit growth has been pretty strong. 2:06 In general, overall, India is doing what it has been doing. 2:09 And that's appealing to investors now that they want to diversify from AI. 2:14 Yeah, so they want to diversify. 2:15 So that's a factor. 2:16 Quickly, Pronar, there's other factors as well, right? 2:20 I think two reasons. 2:21 One, like, you know, towards February, March, after the onset of conflict in the Middle East, people were really worried that this will have a big impact on the earnings in India. 2:30 India is an energy importing country, but corporates have been quite resilient and their growth and earnings growth have remained quite strong despite the oil shock. 2:39 And second, the valuations, like the levels Indian equities trade at, that was perceived to be very expensive by investors. 2:46 But those levels are now back to the historical levels. 2:49 And so this is, you know, provided investors more reasons to look at India again. 2:53 Okay, that's good. 2:54 So your guess if all these people are traveling to India, what can they expect to see? 2:59 Are the Indians out consuming again? 3:01 Or is it the high oil prices keeping people at home trying to hoard money? 3:05 No, it's been pretty resilient in fact. 3:07 So it all started in October or September last year, when there has been a tax cut, the GST cut. 3:13 since then the demand has been pretty strong i mean even right now even the festive season which came on a very high base is still growing festive season you're talking about uh diwali just now people spend money yes yes it starts it's the longest festive season in india it's around 40 days uh various festives at various different states but it's been pretty strong and uh i would say this animal spirits after the tax cuts have sustained 3:40 I think one of the indicators, Yogesh, would be to just look at the auto sales that are growing by 20-25% year on year. 3:47 In China, they're contracting by 20% year on year. 3:51 The entire festive, although not like-to-like, is up 20-30% auto sales. 3:58 So it's been pretty resilient. 3:59 So all that talk about higher oil prices really going to dampen consumer demand, that's not really the case. 4:04 No. 4:05 So look, oil impacts certain places directly, like commercial vehicles did take a hit in the beginning slightly. 4:12 But there has been only one price hike in India oil prices. 4:15 And what that led to is a spike in electric vehicles in India. 4:20 So the penetration actually doubled. 4:22 Oh, the Indians are now buying. 4:24 Yeah. 4:25 And what you mean is that there's only been one price hike. 4:27 It actually means that the government is subsidizing. 4:31 Well, government always subsidizes or manages fuel prices in India. 4:36 They do make a lot of money because the taxes on crude are very high on the refined products. 4:41 But whatever it is on the pump prices, the increase was only once. 4:46 And now the crude is falling. 4:48 So the other thing could play out if there is eventually a price cut. 4:52 Okay, so that's something that the government can cushion and they're doing that and it helps. 4:56 The amount is good. 4:58 But we also have El Nino coming up, right? 5:00 You can't change the weather as a government. 5:02 You can do whatever you want. 5:04 So to be honest, Erild, sometimes I feel a little sad that in 21st century we talk about monsoons quite a bit in India. 5:13 But that's the reality. 5:14 It's important to consider a few points. 5:17 Firstly, monsoons has been very bad this year. 5:20 So it's dry, right? 5:22 Yes, yes. 5:23 So it's concentrated to few states a lot more, like Maharashtra and Karnataka are particularly very badly hit. 5:30 This has been the worst for more than 30 years in some of these states. 5:35 There is already water getting rationed by the government in rural India. 5:39 But thankfully there are subsidies and there is government spending money now with farmers. 5:44 Try to cushion that as well. 5:46 The other issue is we're just getting started. 5:48 The real impact will happen what we call the winter crop, Rabi crop. 5:53 And so this is going to last for another six to eight months. 5:57 LENO is expected to only intensify in November. 6:01 Exactly. 6:02 Now, the good thing is, historic data suggests that if it's one bad monsoon, we are still okay. 6:08 Life moves on. 6:09 All the reservoir levels have come down quite a bit. 6:12 But if next year is also weak, then it's a really significant... 6:17 But does that mean, so we just spoke about people buying cars and motorcycles, I presume, right? 6:23 But in the rural areas, that's where the hit from El Nino will be a bit more prevalent, right? 6:29 They will feel that more. 6:31 Is there a difference between urban and rural? 6:33 It should be Haril, it should be. 6:34 So far, none of the companies have admitted barring one who reported there has been some hint of slowdown in rural so far, as I said, because last crop has still been okay, the impact will start to show in few months. 6:47 The other important aspect is you have rich farmers, they are still okay because the food inflation has gone up. 6:53 a lot. 6:54 But if you are a poor farmer or a landless labor, then the hit will be so in certain categories in cars, it may still never show. 7:02 But in certain staples, certain categories, it may start to show. 7:06 I think another factor to focus here on is that even the rural economy in India is getting more diversified over time. 7:12 Like, you know, in the past, it was all related to agriculture and hence monsoon. 7:15 But now, Like, you know, the non-agriculture part, like labor's infrastructure spending that work in construction. 7:22 And as Yogesh mentioned that the government, one, is cushioning the impact of higher oil prices. 7:27 They're not really transferring into end consumer. 7:30 But also the government is spending on infrastructure spending. 7:33 So, like, you know, they're building more roads, bridges. 7:35 And when you need to build more roads and bridges, you need more laborers. 7:39 So like, you know, impact would be there on inflation, probably on rural consumption. 7:44 But also there are some offsetting impacts that probably like, you know, we need to talk about our focus. 7:49 Okay, so consumption is chocking along quite well, actually, with a couple of risks here and there. 7:55 One of the other big themes in India is that India wants to be part of the global tech cycle. 8:00 They're building out semiconductor capabilities. 8:03 And what's going on in that front? 8:05 No, so lots of work is happening on semiconductors. 8:08 Government is spending almost $40 billion incentives on semiconductors and OSAT, etc. 8:17 OSAT is the testing company. 8:19 Yes, testing part of the semiconductor value chain. 8:22 So overall in EVs, electric vehicles, we have seen 10x the amount of investment by OEMs versus the subsidy or the incentives given by the government. 8:33 So 10x meaning you give $1 of subsidy, you get $10 of investment from the private sector. 8:39 Yes. 8:40 So if it's $40 billion, we hope that eventually $400 billion investment comes in. 8:46 And we are starting with low nodes like 28 nanometer and hopefully scale up. 8:51 That's still a significant amount of semiconductor consumption in India and in the world. 8:55 So let's see how it goes. 8:57 But I think these are steps in the right direction. 9:00 There is a lot of talk about data centers as well. 9:03 Domestic workload cannot run a data center because they're just too expensive. 9:09 Every gigawatt of data center is 50-55 billion dollars. 9:14 So one gigawatt if you run by solar needs 6-8 gigawatts of solar and 4 gigawatt of battery. 9:21 And one gigawatt of solar needs 2000 acres of land. 9:25 So just do the maths. 9:26 It's in unless you run it on gas, like what's happening in the US, which is not viable in India. 9:32 Right. 9:33 One of the things which could like go in favor of China is because there's abundance power and solar, etc. 9:40 So they can run these data centers, but they are not viable in India. 9:44 Although the good thing is India data centers are 20 to 30% cheaper to build for various reasons. 9:50 There's government incentives as well. 9:53 Okay. 9:53 Well, you can import compute now these days as well. 9:56 You can run your models in Malaysian and import it. 9:58 Now, the sovereign workload will all be run on domestic data centers and some of the corporates may want to do that as well. 10:05 But we are at 1.5 gigawatt. 10:07 There are various estimates of 8 to 10 gigawatt in 4 or 5 years. 10:12 We think it will probably go to 5 max. 10:15 Okay, so it's still an agricultural economy, but they're building out production capabilities, right? 10:21 Trying to be checked? 10:22 No, it's not just, I think agriculture, as you know, is mid-teens contributor. 10:27 I think for India, since independence, the biggest thing which has happened is IT services. 10:32 Yeah, that's where I wanted to go to, actually, and set the stage for that. 10:35 Because I know you're looking quite intensively at that. 10:38 You've been covering these companies like Infosys and Tata Consulting and these sort of companies. 10:43 Your AI can run your software now. 10:46 And so you don't need these coders from India anymore. 10:49 Yeah, I've gone into meetings where somebody's kid has built an app on Claude overnight. 10:55 And he's very negative. 10:57 Harold is building apps over Claude. 11:00 But I am telling you, corporate's a lot different. 11:03 Corporate's a lot more complex. 11:05 There are a lot more security challenges. 11:08 And these are just legacy applications which can't be just overwritten overnight. 11:14 So obviously these companies are getting impacted right now. 11:17 They are growing by low single digits, but they're still growing. 11:21 So you are in a year of worst deflation from AI. 11:25 And despite that, these companies are still growing. 11:28 So things should only get better from here. 11:30 The other aspect from India perspective is a lot of global capability centers. 11:36 So let's say a bank like HSBC, one is you work through an Infosys TCS. 11:41 The other is you build your own centers. 11:44 Every day a new GCC is coming to India. 11:48 So we are today almost 2200 GCC is still growing. 11:52 The leasing market in India is still growing. 11:54 Maybe some point AI will impact jobs, but today it's only creating more jobs as of now. 12:01 But that's impacting the job for the tech services companies, you would say, like more penetration of GCCs in India? 12:07 GCCs is global centers, right? 12:09 Global capability centers. 12:10 They have certainly taken market share from outsourcing companies because GCCs are... 12:16 They are expensive on cost, but what the vendors charge them because these companies make very high gross margins, almost 50% gross margins in India. 12:26 So you save that when you do it in-house. 12:29 Plus the feeling of data being safe and all those other benefits. 12:36 So basically growth is pretty good to consumer spending. 12:39 Worries about rural consumption, El Nino is probably, well, valid, but it's not visible really yet. 12:45 So that's something we got to keep an eye on. 12:48 We see that they're building out their industrial capabilities in tech. 12:52 And for that, you also have all sorts of other companies that make these components like you need to anything from air conditioners to connectors and these sort of things that are locally made. 13:00 With that, I guess the banks are doing pretty good. 13:02 You mentioned that credit growth. 13:04 Credit growth last month was 20%. 13:06 Even if you adjust for base, we are made to higher teens, which is a pretty good credit growth. 13:12 And one of the reasons is that the central bank has been very proactive. 13:16 They had run this deposit scheme called FCNRB deposit scheme, wherein it attracted a lot of non-resident Indians that actually flooded banks with a lot of deposit money that they in return can lend to users because the credit... 13:29 growth is running at good, strong double-digit. 13:32 So a lot of things are moving in the right direction. 13:34 Just at the time, Yogesh, when you said that actually, yeah, there's a bit of questions on AI and other parts of the region. 13:40 So it's probably worthwhile to revisit India and look at all these growth opportunities. 13:47 Pruna, Yogesh, thanks for coming into the studio and putting India on the spotlight. 13:53 Thank you so much, Errol. 13:54 Thank you very much. 13:55 Thank you. 13:58 And that's a wrap for this week's podcast. 14:00 It's been a pleasure having you with us under the menu tree. 14:03 Please do like and follow wherever you get your podcast. 14:07 I've been your host, Harold van Linde, and the producer is none other than Graham Mackay. 14:12 We'll be back again, same time, next week.
Community discussion