0:09 Hello and welcome to The Macrobrief. 0:11 I'm your host, Piers Butler, and this week I'm in Hong Kong. 0:15 We've got a special Asia-focused episode for you today. 0:19 Our goal, challenge the standard narratives around mainland China and the rest of Asia that many of us in the West take for granted. 0:27 Helping me to do that are my studio guests, Jing Liu and Innis Lam, from our economics team here in Hong Kong. 0:33 We're going behind the headlines and into the world of economics, policy, energy, climate, and more. 0:40 From HSBC Global Investment Research, you're listening to The Macrobrief. 0:45 So Jing and Ines, welcome to the podcast. 0:48 Thanks, Piers. 0:48 Thank you. 0:49 First time on Macrobrief. 0:51 Indeed. 0:51 First time for me to record it here in Hong Kong. 0:54 Very excited by that. 0:55 And obviously, as I said in my intro, the idea is to kind of go beyond the headlines in terms of what maybe some of our macro brief listeners would commonly perceive about China and the rest of Asia. 1:08 And maybe, Jing, I can start with you. 1:10 So China is often described through two headlines. 1:13 One is the property downturn. 1:15 Everybody knows that the property market in China has had a big downturn. 1:19 And also the sort of growth miracle of China is kind of maybe over. 1:23 So does that framing miss some of the underlying things that are going on in the China economy? 1:29 Indeed. 1:30 I think first of all, if China managed to continue growing at 4.5% or even 4%, I think that's still quite a miracle. 1:39 I guess, yeah, for the size of the economy, that's actually really a big number still. 1:44 Indeed. 1:44 I think the deflation has weighed on China. 1:49 over the past several years. 1:50 So that might be part of the question. 1:52 But the positive side is really this transition. 1:56 China was talking about, or I should say has been talking about transition from high-speed growth to high-quality growth. 2:04 It's unclear what that means, but now we see in different high-tech areas, China is breaking through. 2:12 That is something quite notable. 2:14 In particular, if we look at the government basically phrased as three new kind of new business format, new technology, et cetera, type of economy, nowadays they account for over 18% of the GDP, which is already larger than even during the peak time property. 2:39 And maybe just to sort of dig into that a little bit more, what do we think about the sort of policy choices that Beijing is making in terms of managing the economy? 2:49 I think a lot of people would have expected large-scale stimulus packages, but that hasn't come through. 2:54 What is underlying those choices? 2:56 Right. 2:57 I think this is a fundamental difference. 3:00 China actually does not quite believe helicopter money, if you will, can be the miracle solution. 3:08 And they tried the durable good trading. 3:13 The marginal effect starts to fade off. 3:15 And then their recent history of the large-scale stimulus should be the 2008 $4 trillion package. 3:24 And then they are still dealing with some aftermath, such as the local government debt issue. 3:29 So they prefer a different way of dealing with it. 3:33 Ines, let's bring you into the conversation. 3:35 We've published a lot of articles on demographics. 3:39 Your colleague Fred Newman, you know, in his latest Under the Manutri talked about we need more babies. 3:45 How big an issue is demographics in Asia? 3:48 It is indeed a very big issue and I think it's underestimated the extent or the speed of aging in Asia. 3:55 And for Asian economies, the impact is very significant. 3:59 First and foremost, there will be a decline in working age population. 4:05 And if we look at Japan, for example, Japan is the first Asian economy that began its aging journey. 4:13 And Japan right now is facing a rather serious labor shortage. 4:18 So after COVID-19, Japan's economy is recovering and it's having a manufacturing upswing. 4:25 But right now, Japan, it's dealing with a shortage of workers and it has to import more foreign workers. 4:33 But of course, immigration, foreign workers is a rather sensitive issue in the society. 4:39 And we are seeing some backlash in Japan already that people are pushing back on foreign workers. 4:46 So, Jing, maybe we can talk about AI. 4:48 How can we have a podcast without talking about AI? 4:50 Yes, of course. 4:51 But obviously, in developed markets, there is this hope that it's going to be a significant source of productivity growth. 4:59 Is that, in a way, potentially an answer to the demographic challenge in China? 5:04 And Ines do contribute to that as well. 5:07 Yes, indeed. 5:08 Actually, China in particular is trying to rely on AI for certain resolution. 5:16 For example, in China's case, it already has a large manufacturing base. 5:22 So there's a lot of focus on developing the physical AI in the sense that in the future, If we don't have enough workers, maybe the human robbers can substitute workers. 5:35 So that's indeed a big promising part. 5:38 And Ines, any thoughts on that? 5:39 Well, for AI, I mean, it's such a complicated issue. 5:43 But I would like to talk about AI in India and the Philippines. 5:47 Uh-huh. 5:47 Because I visited Philippines for work like a couple of weeks ago and I could feel the AI anxiety on the ground because the Philippines has a huge business process outsourcing sector and a lot of the customer service jobs or data entry jobs, they could be easily replaced by AI. 6:07 So people are quite worried the impact on the job market in the Philippines and also in India where A big IT service sector could also be threatened by the rise of AI. 6:18 Another big threat obviously is energy, energy costs. 6:22 And Asia and China are big importers of energy, of oil. 6:29 Tell us how these different economies are reacting to that challenge. 6:32 Actually, in China, it's less of a concern because China has been focusing on energy security over the past decades. 6:40 And in particular, nowadays, if we look at the energy mix of China, oil and gas only represent about 27 percent. 6:48 And the increasing... 6:50 popularity of EV actually has decreased demand for gasoline and diesel to a large extent. 6:56 And this trend is still continuing. 6:59 So from that perspective, I think China has quite some wiggle room in terms of the stable energy supply and the stable energy prices. 7:09 So that's a really good illustration of kind of going beyond the headlines that people think of China as a massive energy importer, but there are changes going structurally that actually is going to change that dependence? 7:19 Yes, I think that's fair to say. 7:22 We have seen a lot of green electricity, etc., other different kind of substitutes China can actually use. 7:29 And it's easy to kind of say that Asia is energy dependent, but there are differences, regional differences. 7:35 Maybe sort of highlight those? 7:37 I think it's fair to say that most of Asia is dependent on energy imports. 7:43 But the responses of Asian governments, as we see, they are quite different since the start of the Iran war, for example. 7:52 So there are some governments, they have stronger balance sheets, for example, Korea. 7:56 So they can afford to provide more subsidies for their businesses and for the consumers. 8:05 But for other Southeast Asian or South Asian countries, they have less strong balance sheets fiscally. 8:12 And then the protection of their households and the business sector will be less strong than the North Asian economies. 8:21 So I guess the message there in terms of going behind the headlines is not to look at each country as having a similar dependence or similar reactive capability. 8:29 Yeah, definitely not. 8:30 In terms of imports and exports, again, one of the headlines on China is a sort of massive export growth. 8:39 Is that too simplistic a way of looking at the sort of trade economics of China? 8:44 I believe so. 8:44 For example, this year, if we look behind the numbers, the price actually contributes the most to the export growth. 8:53 And that's tied up to the AI capex frenzy. 8:57 The other element I want to highlight is that... 9:00 When we look at the enormous surplus, actually part of the contribution is coming from China importing less, in particular around the combustion engine cars, as well as certain kind of equipment. 9:16 So again, I guess that's an evidence of the kind of structural changes that are going on in the economy. 9:20 Yes, indeed. 9:21 I think when people look at the export structure, the mix about two decades ago, after China just joined WTO versus now, we can say China has been exporting a lot more high-tech capital goods as well as intermediate goods. 9:39 And is that the same phenomenon going on in the rest of Asia? 9:43 For the rest of Asia, I think similar changes are going on. 9:47 Asian economies have generally become more tech-driven. 9:53 So the stuff that Asian countries import are more intermediate products, more electronics, more machinery that they need for the advanced manufacturing sectors. 10:05 Jing, coming back to headline growth on China, which remains broadly on track, but domestic demand is described as weak. 10:15 Are households simply spending less or are they spending differently? 10:18 I think, first of all, consumption is still growing. 10:21 So I think they are spending less in terms of the acceleration rate, not in terms of the absolute amount. 10:30 And you're right. 10:31 We have observed this rotation from goods to services, just like in many other countries post-COVID. 10:38 So nowadays we see service consumption account for close to half of the Chinese household basket. 10:46 And in Asia, what is the mix? 10:50 And in terms of key economic drivers, is it demographics, fiscal capability, industrial structure, domestic demand? 10:58 Or is actually exposed to China one of the key drivers? 11:01 I would say all of them. 11:04 I think they're all interconnected. 11:06 All these factors, for example, fiscal problem, fiscal situation is related to demographics because when you have an older population, your labour force is smaller and so the tax base is smaller. 11:20 And also, ageing also boosts fiscal spending on healthcare and welfare, pensions, everything. 11:27 So yeah, these factors are all impacting Asia significantly. 11:32 Yeah. 11:32 So we could go on for a long time on this, but if listeners were to take away only one idea that challenges the standard China and ASEAN narrative, what should it be? 11:43 And what data will tell us whether that alternative view is proving right? 11:48 Jing, do you want to start on that one? 11:49 Yes, of course. 11:51 I think we can see that due to the global supply chain restructuring, China and the rest of Asia, especially Asien, were increasingly integrated. 12:01 So previously it's more about exporting goods, but increasingly we see the outbound direct investment done by Chinese companies are rising. 12:12 And then we still see a lot of room given that outbound direct investment still represents relatively... 12:19 small percentage of China's GDP. 12:22 So we see this continue to evolve over time. 12:26 But obviously, the complicated uncertainty related to trade policy and other things and geopolitical risks can still challenge, you know, how this whole thing evolved over time. 12:40 And Ines? 12:41 Related to what Jing just said, I think, so currently the dominant narrative is there's a lot of Chinese investment going into ASEAN. 12:50 But I think the other way is also true, meaning that it's not a one-way flow. 12:55 A lot of Southeast Asian companies, they're also investing in China. 12:59 If I can quote an example, it's that the Thai conglomerate CP Group, it's actually the first foreign company that registered in mainland China back in 1979. 13:10 So you can see the history of Southeast Asian companies investing in China is very long. 13:16 And it's also changing. 13:18 So traditionally, Southeast Asian companies would invest in manufacturing in China. 13:29 high-tech sectors such as biotech or green tech. 13:33 So the trend is changing, and I think it's not a one-way road. 13:38 And another thing is that we see a lot of Chinese tourists going to Southeast Asian countries. 13:44 But in fact, there are also a lot of Southeast Asian families, middle-class consumers going to mainland China to Chinese big cities like Shanghai. 13:54 So yeah, I think this is a Two-way exchanges are being underestimated. 13:59 So, Asia is increasingly more interconnected. 14:02 Coming from the UK, in a way, that's probably one of the strongest takeaways, which is the headline would be China and ASEAN to... 14:12 between Europe and the US. 14:14 And everybody thinks about that in terms of the trade statistics. 14:17 But what you're saying is that the intra-Asian trade is really growing and struckly changing the nature of how we would look at how these economies are developing. 14:28 I think that's a good note to end that conversation. 14:30 Thank you very much for joining me today in Hong Kong. 14:33 And hopefully, I will see you in London soon. 14:35 Sure. 14:36 Thank you, Piers. 14:43 Well, that's a wrap for this week's episode. 14:46 Thanks very much for joining us. 14:47 And now I'll be handing the studio back to my colleagues Fred Newman and Harold van der Linde, hosts of our regular Asian podcast, Under the Banyan Tree. 14:55 Listen, like and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. 14:59 From all of us here in Hong Kong, it's bye for now.
Community discussion