Kansas and Virginia: Badges, Betrayal, and Frontier Justice

Season 40: America's 250th Anniversary — fifty states, fifty crimes, two hundred and fifty years. This double--feature episode covers Kansas and Virginia.A city marshal with a gold-engraved Winchester and a secret past as a wanted killer. A mountain doctor whopreached Sunday sermons and planned a massacre on a mountain road. Two men who wore badges. Twocommunities that trusted them. Two moments when the authority collapsed and the man underneath it wasexposed. This is the story of Henry Newton Brown and Marshall Benton "Doc" Taylor — and the people theykilled.The Victims**E.W. Wylie Payne** was the president of the Medicine Valley Bank in Medicine Lodge, Kansas. He was aMissouri-born businessman, married to Susan, and the father of nine children. He was shot during a robbery onApril 30, 1884, and died the following day — May 1, 1884. **George Geppert**, the bank's chief cashier, wasshot twice during the same robbery. Dying, he sealed the bank vault with his own hands. The robbers escapedwith nothing because of what Geppert did in his final moments.**Louranza Mullins** was thirty-five years old on May 14, 1892, traveling through Pound Gap on the Virginia-Ken-tucky border with her husband **Ira Mullins**, **Wilson Mullins**, **John Chappel**, and **Greenberry Harris**.All five were killed in a planned ambush at a place now called Killing Rock. Two survived: fourteen-year-old **JohnHarrison Mullins**, whose left arm was shattered, and **Amoda Jane Mullins**, Ira's sister, who was carrying aninfant and identified the killers by their voices.The Crimes**Case A — The Medicine Lodge Bank Robbery (Kansas, 1884):** Henry Newton Brown was city marshal ofCaldwell, Kansas — a man so trusted that citizens presented him a gold-engraved Winchester rifle in January1883. What no one in Caldwell knew was that Brown was wanted for murder in New Mexico Territory. He hadridden with Billy the Kid's Regulators and participated in the ambush that killed Lincoln County Sheriff WilliamBrady in April 1878. On April 30, 1884, five weeks after marrying Alice Maude Levagood, Brown led his deputy BenWheeler (real name: William Sherod Robinson, also a fugitive) and two accomplices to rob the Medicine ValleyBank. The robbery failed. Cowboys sheltering from a thunderstorm in a nearby livery stable gave chase. The gangwas trapped in a flooded box canyon within three miles. Brown was shot and killed by a mob that night. Wheeler,Smith, and Wesley were hanged from an elm tree.**Case B — The Killing Rock Massacre at Pound Gap (Virginia, 1892):** Marshall Benton "Doc" Taylor was aphysician, Baptist preacher, and former federal revenue officer in the Appalachian coalfields of Wise County,Virginia. In 1889, Taylor led a posse that intercepted a Mullins whiskey wagon on the main street of WiseCourthouse — approximately 250 shots were exchanged. The wagon driver was killed, Ira Mullins was shotthrough both hips and crippled for life, and several others were wounded. Taylor lost his federal appointment.Three years later, on May 14, 1892, Taylor and brothers Henan and Calvin Fleming ambushed the Mullins party atPound Gap, killing five people from behind a breastwork of sandstone and rhododendron.The InvestigationTaylor fled and was dubbed the Red Fox of the Mountains by the press. Railroad detectives captured him onAugust 18, 1892, in an empty freight car at Bluefield, West Virginia. His trial was moved 275 miles to Lynchburg forsecurity. A ballistics question emerged — rim-fire shells at the scene did not match Taylor's modified center-fireWinchester — but the jury deliberated two hours and convicted him on five counts of first-degree murder, largelyon the eyewitness identification of Jane Mullins.Brown's case never reached trial. The mob killed him and his accomplices the night of the failed robbery, afterbank president Wylie Payne died of his wounds. A coroner's jury reported the deaths were at the hands of "amob, composed of persons unknown."Historical ContextBoth...