0:14 Hey there, Duke fans. Special episode of the DBR podcast here. 0:17 It's our spy mission. It's our undercover episode, so to speak. 0:24 Episode number 160 of the Duke Basketball Roundup. Jason Evans, I'm here as your host. I'm joined by Donald Wine. Donald, where are you today? You're in an unusual location. 0:34 I am in Austin, Texas, as me and my guests were joking, not Austin, Massachusetts. I'm down here for the Texas-Florida game this weekend with some buddies. And funny enough, Jason, the house that I'm in has a podcast studio. I'm going to kind of demo this weekend of some sort. 0:50 It has that mixture of stuff. I literally tried to get it set up for this. It's 8 in the morning here. I didn't know how to make it work. 0:56 So by the end of this weekend, Jason, I hope to have this working maybe on the next episode that we have. 1:01 Oh, there you go. Podcast studio. 1:02 Wow. 1:03 I just go in my dining room, pull out the mic, and I'm all set. 1:07 I walk five feet to my chair normally in my studio apartment in D.C., but here we have rooms. Novel concept. 1:14 Let me go ahead and set up what this episode is going to be. As you all recall, the Dribble for Victory happened at Duke, and thanks to all of you, Jessica and her son August, who is a cancer survivor– who partnered with us on the Dribble for Victory, they 1:34 ended up as the second biggest fundraising team. And by they, again, I mean all of you, because there's no way that this happens without the myriad of Duke Basketball Roundup listeners contributing and helping out August and Jessica. Anyway, the reason 1:52 I'm bringing it up is that part of their prize, part of what they won for being the second best fundraising team was... access to a Duke practice. And unfortunately, Jessica and August couldn't make it. And so they said, well, why don't you get someone connected with the DBR to 2:09 go check out this practice and give all of us a little bit of intel. And as a result, we were able to send our good friend, someone who's guested with us many times, one of the co-hosts, co-writers of The Vector, which is a wonderful sub stack analyzing Duke basketball, 2:26 Carl Heimel. Carl, how are you doing, buddy? 2:30 I am fantastic. It's great to be back with you. 2:32 Yeah, so Carl went to this practice just a few days ago, and now he is joining us to give us all the inside poop. Buddy, let me start by saying thank you very much for being available for us. 2:47 It's hard for us to get to Durham in the middle of the week sometimes. 2:51 Yeah, exactly. I like the fact that you guys send me to go watch a Duke basketball practice and you're thanking me. 2:57 It feels like that role should be reversed. 3:02 Donald, why don't you get us started? 3:04 Yeah, so Carl, let's start kind of overall. You got a real chance to get a peek behind the curtain, not just at how the team and how the coaching staff handles them, but like everything, including how John Shire operates. 3:17 So Can you start first with just what you saw in terms of general observations about the way John Shire runs and orchestrates the practice? 3:28 Yeah, I think the analogy that I would use is he's very much a CEO out there on the court. 3:35 He's not afraid to give his assistants some rope to work with. it should be noted that both Sewell and, uh, coach Thornton were not there. I think, uh, Sewell probably was out, uh, uh, delivering a Sharpie to Asa Montgomery perhaps. Uh, but, uh, 3:56 I think, uh, coach Thornton was up at Howard for an event up there. Uh, so it was, uh, it was John and then, uh, coaches Dilde and Conklin. And, uh, 4:09 the team broke up into two groups to start off. 4:13 And Coach Joldy was down running the players going through defensive foundation drills. And Coach Conklin was working on the offensive side of the ball. And then John was basically observing everything and stepping in on key moments. So the 4:35 The thing that stood out to me the most, the two things were that and then also just the level of technology that is associated with a Duke basketball practice now. 4:45 I think I told Jason that there were more laptops on the sideline of Cameron than you would see in a Silicon Valley Starbucks. Just everything is tracked, everything is monitored, just right down to the most minute details. And, you know, 5:03 it's great to see that because, you know, obviously analytics are taking a greater and greater role in basketball in general. 5:12 So having somebody that's ahead of the curve like that is certainly bodes well for the future. 5:19 You know, I remember like a decade or so ago that we started to hear that John Shire was the guy who was like all about the analytics and that Coach K had put him in charge of that kind of stuff, and I am not at all surprised to 5:34 learn that a modern Duke basketball practice is ahead of the curve from the standpoint of technology. I'm sure those guys are wearing all kinds of monitors and stuff, little tiny things in their uniforms, so they can track every 5:46 movement on the court. It's really, really interesting. Speaking of those guys, Carl, let's get to the players a little bit. 5:53 And everyone out there sort of debates, oh, is John Blackwell– you know, the Duke All-American and best player? Is it maybe Joaquin Boomchay Boomchay? But you saw someone else stand out when you watched practice, didn't you? 6:12 On Tuesday, the best player on the floor, in my opinion, was Big Pat. You know, the Coming off the Belmont game, everybody's concerned because those numbers were down. The only numbers that weren't down were his fouls and all that. But 6:31 on Tuesday, he looked like the guy that people are talking about being a first-round pick. He was hitting, you know, hit a couple of threes. I don't expect that to be like the staple of his game, but it's certainly something that opens up the rest of his game. But 6:47 not only was he effective there, he was just much more explosive down low, had at least two or three dunks throughout the course of practice. And I'm not talking about dunks and one on one drills. I'm talking about in traffic during five on five scrimmage action. 7:06 Very explosive off the floor. 7:08 Rebounding, scoring, really showcased his entire game much more to the extent than what we saw in the Belmont exhibition. 7:19 You know, it's funny, Carl, you're one of the first people to really say that of all these players, we've heard a lot about two players we'll talk about in a second, but we haven't heard a lot about Pat this summer. And all of a sudden, now we're starting 7:32 to see this, like, no, this guy is going to be very good. I know we know this, but I think he's maybe the new The new candy in the store that people are kind of looking at, and you go to the old tried and true, the Mike and Ike's, if you will, you know is going to be solid. 7:45 Donald, John Shire has been saying that. 7:49 I know, yes. 7:50 He said that as much, but it's interesting to see now all of a sudden people who are starting to see these practices once again going, Nope. 7:59 Sorry. 7:59 It's Big Pat. Big Pat is the man. But let's talk about the other two preseason All-ACC players, John Blackwell and JoJo Boucher-Boucher. What did you see from them in this practice? 8:10 Well, I think that one of the things that I saw from Blackwell is one of the reasons why John wanted him so much. I think that, you know, the book on him, everybody, the The quick and easy read on him is, hey, he's a great outside shooter. You know, 8:29 he can hit shots, open up the offense. There's more to it than that. You know, in the Belmont game and in this practice, What I saw from John Blackwell is a guy who has a pretty mixed bag. He can get to the hoop. He can score from the outside. 8:49 But the thing that really stood out to me, so they ran about 20 minutes of just sort of general five on five. And then at the end of practice, they set the clock to six minutes and they were going to do end of game scenario where they Uh, 9:04 my one team had one point lead over the other. Uh, and during that six minutes, you just see the aggression, uh, the intensity pick up with Blackwell. Uh, and it's just, to me, that's that experience. That's the, it's time to go. 9:18 It's clutch time kind of thing. Uh, and so, you know, beyond just his physical characteristics on the court, I think that that's one of the reasons that made him such a valuable addition, such a coveted get in the portal. Um, As for JoJo, I think that if you look back 9:40 on media day, the messaging coming out of that, there was such a dichotomy between what the coaches were saying and what the players were saying. The coaches were like, well, he's going to need a little while to develop. There's going to be ups and downs. And the players were 9:52 all like, no, he's fabulous. right? So he is fabulous. 9:57 But I think the ups and downs may have seen a little bit of that on Tuesday. Not that he was bad, but he didn't hit 40% from three. He probably hit 35% from three. He didn't dominate inside. He was effective inside. So it's just a reminder that He's 10:20 a different guy than the last two guys that played that position, which is not a bad thing, though, when the last two guys were both national players of the year. 10:29 I think that he's probably not the guaranteed going to give you 20 and 10 every night out. But I think he's probably going to be, at the end of the year, you're going to look down. He's going to have 18 and 9, 18 and 7, whatever average. But 10:46 there'll be games in there that he's going to have. 10:48 28 points. There'll be games in there where he's going to have 12 points. But even with that 12, he has such gravity that it's still an effective 12. 11:06 I love the way you talk about gravity. It's such an important... It's something that I think goes a little underappreciated by lots of folks. How much a how much the play on the floor revolves around what a certain guy is doing. And that's what you're talking about, I think, 11:23 with JoJo. Hey, I want to get to two other freshmen who we expect to play big, big roles in this team. Everyone knows by now I'm like maybe the world's biggest Sebastian Wilkins fan outside of his family. By the way, it seems weird almost to talk about Sebastian 11:40 as a freshman because he was here last year. It's just he didn't. But he is a freshman. at least from an eligibility standpoint. Although I don't know how the five and five probably screws him, I think. I'm not sure about all that. 11:53 I actually think the five and five, and this is an observation my friend Jim made to me, the five and five is going to make him the answer to a great Duke trivia question, and that is, who was the last Duke guy to redshirt? Yeah, you're right. 12:05 That's definitely true. But anyway, I was going to say, I want to hear about Sebastian Wilkins, and then everyone is excited about the athleticism of Deron Rippey Um, talk about the role they were playing when, when you watch practice. 12:19 The big surprise in practice, uh, was that, uh, the white team consisted of three guys. You expect, uh, Jojo, Pat and Blackwell. Uh, but the other two guys, the freshmen that you just mentioned were the, the two guys that joined them. So Rippy was, uh, uh, running point 12:38 and Wilkins was out there, uh, at the three. Uh, and I think it, uh, I think it's probably more of an experimentation thing or just a little different look rather than it symbolizes like some radical shift in what you expect to see in the starting lineup for the 13:00 next game. But I'm fully on board your Sebastian Wilkins train. 13:08 I think that Watching him, I get real Nate James vibes. 13:14 Just a bigger version of Nate James. You know, he's 6'6. 13:19 Nate was 6'6. Bashy is 6'8. And I think he's just a bigger player. But it's that physical intensity and being a guy who can contribute. without taking up a lot of ball time. I think John mentioned this earlier in the year, and surprisingly or not surprisingly, I guess 13:40 it's a really great observation. He doesn't really demand the ball a lot. but he contributes all the same. He scores inside against seven-foot guys while being 6'8. He just has a real good read on angles and timing. He can hit the three, plays defense. Just a guy that 14:01 does everything that you want. Ultimate little guy, whatever cliche you want to make. But that's going to demand playing time. 14:12 he's going to be a hard guy to keep off the floor. 14:17 Rippy, I think, I. 14:20 Don't want to say it's fortunate that Caleb Foster is sitting on the bench for a little bit here, but it does open up a great opportunity because if you've got a team that has 10, 11, 12, depending upon how you want to count guys who can play, one 14:39 of the things you might want to be considering is let's play at pace. And if you're going to play at pace, it does not hurt to have a guy like Rippy out there with the ball in his hands because he's got one speed and that speed is just 14:53 blazing fast and pushing tempo and really just very aggressive with the ball. The downside of that as a freshman is there's an adjustment period you have to get used to where you're where everybody on the floor is going to be that extra step quicker than what you were 15:11 seeing in AAU ball, where everybody on the floor, you know, including the defense. And so, you know, if you're pushing tempo in that situation, you can have some turnovers. But the more you play, the more experience you get, especially 15:27 if you're a guy like Rippy, who's clearly talented, the more experience, the more you settle in and you get, the more effective you're going to be. So, I don't mind the fact he's going to be seeing some extra run these first three games. 15:42 All right. Well, so if, if Rippy is the point guard and Sebastian Wilkins is playing small forward, we got to find out about what's going on with Caden Boozer and Dominic Saar. We're going to get to that after a quick commercial break, much more from our Intel inside 15:59 the practice in just a moment. 16:20 All right, we are back. We continue our discussion with Carl Heimel, again, our secret agent that was inside the Duke practice earlier this week. And Carl, we talked about the point guard, Deron Rippey, and how he was on the white team. But let's talk about the guys who 16:36 have kind of moved aside a little bit so that Rippey and Wilkins can get some bigger roles. Talk about Caden Boozer and Dame Saar and how they were doing during this practice. 16:46 So... Again, using the Belmont game as a, as sort of a baseline. Um, I thought that Caden, uh, struggled in like one of the areas that I consider his strength and that is finishing around the rim. Uh, I'm happy to tell you that, uh, that was just a 17:04 temporary situation. He was back to what he does. Uh, he was, you know, driving against, uh, bigger players and finding a way to get a shot off. And those shots were falling inside, uh, I also think that he shot around 30% from three last year. I expect that 17:24 number will go up just based on what I saw from him out there. I will say that it's probably not an accident that even though the white team ran about 20 minutes of general scrimmage, even though the white team had those three starters out there and Pat Jojo 17:46 and Blackwell, the blue team ended up winning. So I think that that's probably not a surprise because you kind of associate winning with the Boozer brothers and, you know, one of them was out there. As for Dame, it's a good reminder of the adage that progress isn't linear 18:07 because last year, you know, the defense is always going to be there. It's just, you know, it's baked into his DNA. But last year, He did struggle putting the ball on the floor and finishing at the basket. Against Belmont, that was a completely different story. He looked like an 18:27 entirely different player. He was somewhere between those two extremes on Tuesday. He was not the guy you saw in the Belmont game, but he was still more effective than he was for much of the year last year. But he did have a lot of occasions where he did 18:46 not convert, taking the ball in either by turnover or by missing the shot. And as I was making that observation to myself while I was at the practice, he threw down what was easily the best dunk of the afternoon. 19:04 Probably the best dunk we're going to see, that I'll see for a while out of that group. He was... 19:10 He basically did a straight line drive from the top of the key and just threw down a monster jam over JoJo, which is, you know, that's a little bit of a guy that's 7'2, not an easy thing to do. 19:24 But the aggression was still there. I expect that we'll see more of it going forward. And I think that it's probably going to be more in line with what we saw in the exhibition. 19:36 So, Carl, there are three other newcomers here. Cam Williams, Bryson Howard, Max Meyer. By all accounts, they're a little bit further back in the rotation. Uh, is that what you observed at the practice? Give us, you know, give us a quick lowdown on, on what you saw from 19:51 each one of those guys. 19:54 So I think that, you know, the easy one to address here is, is, uh, Max Meyer, right? Uh, he's the guy who's got a little further to get, uh, uh, he's just a little further behind on his development curve. Uh, But at the same time, you know, my opinion is 20:13 that his time will come. And when it comes, I think he'll be ready for it. That time, to paraphrase Jay Billis, he may be a year away from being a year away, right? But unlike guys that we have had in the past as developmental bigs, I think he 20:30 has a better physical toolkit than what we've seen from other guys. What I like is that, you know, He has the best lateral quickness of any seven-foot hockey player I've ever seen. Unlike guys like Christian Reeves or other big guys we've had in the past, he can move 20:51 side to side. He's got more quickness and he has a real innate feel for the game. I just think that given where we are with the other guys in the front court, that's a pretty steep rotation to get into. 21:05 The Similar thing with Bryson. I came away from the practice thinking to myself, he may be the second fastest guy on the team in the open court. He had a couple of moments where he picked off a lazy pass on the wing and he was gone in the 21:28 other direction in a flash. I think that His shot is there. He's got solid fundamentals on his shot. So I think it's going to be a consistent weapon for him from the outside. I just think, you know, similar to a lot of guys when they come in as 21:45 a freshman, you just have to adjust to the pace and be more accustomed to getting that shot off more quickly without it, but at the same time, not rushing it. 21:55 But I'm not really concerned about his path, his development path. 22:01 I think that he's just got a lot of guys in front of him that are pretty, pretty good ballplayers too. 22:09 Same story for, you know, for Cam Williams, everybody, you know, I think that Cam came in as at one point, you know, at the end of the normal recruiting cycle, he was like Dick's top rated recruit. And then he, steps into fall practice and he finds two other guys 22:30 there that are playing really well. And both of those guys have a really good amount of experience advantage over him. 22:39 You know, Wilkins has been in the system for a full year. So he's, he knows how that's, he knows how Duke plays. He knows what's expected. And, you know, Jojo has been playing with old grown men since he was, I don't know, what, 14. So, Both those guys have 23:00 a little bit of an advantage when it comes to that. 23:03 And I think you can see there are a couple of times where Shire would pull him aside and pull Cam aside and address him directly on some of the things he was doing in practice. There were teachable moments. 23:15 So I think that he's got that disadvantage. But at the same time, he's There are real skills there. You don't find guys that are seven feet and that quick. 23:29 He's bouncy. He's got a touch from the outside. There's a lot to work with. So even though you've got one guy who is destined to be a top one, two, three draft pickets in the year after next, and another guy who is just the fundamental team role player kind 23:51 of guy in Wilkins, I think that you've got to find time to get Cam Williams on the floor. 23:59 Carl, there's one more player that we want to talk about, one that we know wasn't directly involved in the practice, but we've all been trying to hear about the update of how Caleb Foster is doing with the tweaked ankle. 24:11 But it sounds like you were able to see him do some sort of recovery work during this practice. So tell me what you saw from Caleb Foster and how his recovery seemed to be progressing. 24:23 I'm glad we waited a couple of days to record this. 24:25 It gave me time to get on Polymarket and place my bet that Caleb Foster will be in the lineup come opening day. Both he and Drew were on the sidelines watching practice. But when there was a break in practice, Caleb would step out and shoot around. And this was 24:47 not like the shoot around we saw at the end of last year where he He was out there with a boot on, hoisting up shots. He was out there in sneakers, and he wasn't just standing out there taking spot-up threes. He was moving around. He was dribbling, and 25:02 he was taking step-backs. I mean, if we were playing Florida tomorrow, he would be on the court. So I think you can rest assured that he'll be ready when the season comes. 25:17 All right, Carl, last question. you've been watching Duke basketball for a few years now, um, based on, you know, your wealth of experience, uh, how do you feel about this team? You know, you've now gotten to see them in the scrimmage. You got to see them at this practice. 25:36 Where do you think they are? Um, you know, compare it maybe a little bit to what you've seen from past Duke teams. 25:43 It is a different John Shire team than what we've had the last couple of years, right? Uh, we basically had two guys who, again, as I said, were national players of the year, and you can use that to build around. We don't have a national player of the year. Well, 26:05 unlikely that we have a national player of the year. 26:07 We have a lot of guys, though. I think that, you know, as John Watson over at the Devil's Den once said that it's more similar to what we saw with, uh, the Filipowski teams, uh, in John's first couple of years in that there's no one really dominant guy out there. 26:31 There's a lot of different guys who can contribute. Uh, I think that the talent level is higher overall than what it was in those first couple of teams, but there's also greater size overall. And I think that, uh, It's just a question of how Duke adapts their offense 26:54 to use five guys who are all really, really solid, great players versus having a true superstar to center things around. 27:07 But I think that with that many pieces to work with offensively, this team's going to be really good defensively. 27:15 You know, it's funny to say that we're going to be better defensively after you lose a Malik Brown. But defensively, again, there's dudes at every position. And I don't know which podcaster it was that said it, but I know a good line when I steal it. They said Duke's like 27:33 the Noah's Ark of college basketball. They got two of everything. 27:39 Duke has two of everything. And so there are going to be times where, that rotation that whatever 10 man rotation or whatever, eight man, whatever it is, uh, it might not be the same eight guys, same 10 guys every night, right? It, there's just enough mix and match 27:57 that you can, you can find things that are working, uh, even when somebody is not having that great game that you, that you would normally be counting on. So, you know, I mean, I think clearly we are in the mix as final four favorites. Um, I think that, you know, 28:17 if anything, from the last couple of years, it told us, though, that there's a lot of crazy things that can happen in March. But if you get enough plate appearances, sooner or later, you get a home run. And I think that we have home run potential. 28:32 That works for me, man. Carl Heimel, thanks again so much for it. You said you wanted to thank us. 28:39 I'm going to thank you again anyway for attending the Duke practice the other day and then coming on here and giving us a little bit of Intel from what you saw. Um, and, uh, we look forward to reading your continued comments in the vector again, folks, uh, one 28:54 of the best sub stacks out there when it comes to Duke basketball, lots of humor, uh, lots of, lots of cigar recommendations from Carl. What, what, what you smoking these days, buddy? 29:04 Uh, I am still high on the Valakari decimus. Uh, unfortunately it's a limited release, uh, or limited edition. So it's hard to, hard to get your hands on, but, uh, there are just, uh, there's, there's so many good different 29:18 sticks out there. Uh, really, uh, I'd recommend the apostate death mask, uh, uh, or the, uh, black label cigar, black trading, uh, works, uh, has one called, uh, the culture vulture. All three of those are just tremendous smokes. 29:35 I love it. I love it. 29:36 All right. 29:37 With that folks, we're going to take one. 29:39 Sorry. Next time you're sorry. Next time you're in town, Jason, we'll we'll, we'll get you in it. We'll get one of those in your hands. Oh boy. 29:46 Oh, the extra added incentive to come to Durham for sure. 29:49 Right there again, Carl. 29:50 Thanks a lot. 29:51 We're going to take a quick break here, folks. One more thing around the other side, college football playoff getting bigger. 29:58 Is this good or bad for Duke? What does this all mean? We'll have it for you in just a moment. 30:21 All right, back from the break here, and just a couple quick items to get us done with this week. 30:26 First thing I wanted to mention, we've talked about this guy a little bit. We haven't gone really in depth on him. Asa Montgomery, who came and visited Duke a little while ago, was supposed to have a couple additional visits that he was going to take to some of 30:39 the top schools in the country before he made his decision. 30:42 He was supposed to be visiting Arizona this weekend. Asa Montgomery in the class of 2027, considered one of the top three, top five or so players in that class. 30:53 He has announced that he will not be taking his additional visits. He canceled his visit to Arizona, um, only, um, I guess hours before it was supposed to, to get underway. Um, I'm not going to say that I have inside Intel on this, but everyone out there is saying he canceled 31:10 the Arizona visit because he has made his decision and that he will be attending Duke. We'll go into Donald. 31:16 We'll go into a full thing on Asa Montgomery once, uh, once he officially announces, I think it could come very, very soon, but yeah, uh, Looking like the Blue Devils may have picked up the top player, at least for them, that they targeted in the class of 2027. 31:33 I'm not going to jinx anything, but I'm just going to say, get my theme music ready. Get my another one ready. Let's play it. You can't have me this weekend, but let's play it in the next week for Ace of Montgomery. Let's hope that happens. 31:47 Yeah. 31:48 John Shire continues to reload, even as we think a lot of these guys may be back again. Donald, we've got one other thing we want to discuss very quickly. 31:57 It's been announced that it looks like the powers that be in college football, which the powers that be, I guess that's the commissioner of the SEC, the commissioner of the Big Ten, the guy who runs ESPN, and the AD at Notre Dame. Would that be the powers that be? 32:14 The powers that be ain't you and me. That's all I know. 32:17 Exactly. 32:18 It looks like they've come to an agreement on a 24-team college football playoff. I don't believe they're going to try and implement. 32:27 This season. 32:28 It would come into effect starting next year. Donald, what's your thoughts on, this is probably effectively a death knell for the bowl games, I would think, but what's your thought on a 2014 playoff? 32:43 Jason, what's more concerning about this playoff, first of all, I hate it. 32:47 I hate it. 32:49 Expanding to 16 would have been fine, but I think And I love bowl games. I really do. I think the more concerning aspect of this is that this proposal would eliminate conference title games. And at that point, you're asking yourself, so why do we have conferences? Why can't 33:05 we just build towards it? We're just building towards the playoff. 33:09 Then why does the ACC have to play the ACC? 33:11 Why does the SEC have to play the SEC? Why can't everyone just go independent, line up their own schedules, and then be judged on that when it comes to the playoff? So it's really, as you mentioned, the powers that be, the SEC and the Big Ten and maybe 33:28 ESPN and Fox on a lesser extent, kind of going, we want all these chips to ourselves. And all the other teams are going to be kind of effectively eliminated, except for maybe the one team here and there that they want in there. I joked in a group chat 33:44 yesterday that we're going to have a day where we're going to say, oh, 20 of the 16 SEC teams got into the playoff. And the 21st team is pissed. 33:54 Like that is where we're headed right now because they're not going, they're going to set up the sec where every week it's a, it's a ranked game against ranked teams and doesn't matter the ebb and flow of college football. 34:09 And it's not going to leave a lot of room for everybody else to really stake their claim. But I think the conference championships matter. They still matter in college basketball. 34:19 We have an expanded tournament. those aren't going away in college basketball. So the fact that we're going to get rid of them in college football is really a travesty to me, but it also means that we need to defend our title this year, because if they're, if they're 34:34 an effectively going away, I wanted to say Duke rainy ACC champions for the rest of our lives. That's what I want. That would be terrific. But I think overall expanded 24 does not make any sense. And, We just talked about the Protect College Sports Act and how they're 34:52 trying to, we're losing money and we're having to pay all these guys and we're losing money. But now we're getting the 2014 playoff because money, money, money. So it's hypocritical in some ways, but really I lament that it's going to end bowl games and more importantly, end the 35:09 conference title games, which I think are very important still to the fabric of college sports. 35:15 So my thought on it is this. I mean, I'm not a huge fan of this. I like the notion that regular season games really matter. In a situation like a 2014 playoff, then last week's game between Georgia and Alabama, which was a big deal, becomes a lesser deal because 35:35 you're like, well, 2014, these teams are both automatically going to be in there. But on the other hand, that exists in college basketball already. You know, when Duke plays Florida... 35:48 It'd be easy to say, well, both those teams are making the tournament, but obviously they're playing for seeding. And in a 2014 playoff, being a higher seed is going to mean one less game. It's going to mean a bye. 36:01 I mean, that's a really big deal. I'm with you. 36:06 It's a pity that we're going to lose the conference championship games to make this happen. But I think overall, again, even though there are some bad things about it, and I understand the criticisms of it, I think this is a good thing because it is going to expand the 36:22 number of teams who feel like they have a real shot to make the playoff. Look at Duke. We just lost to Georgia Tech. I think there's probably a pretty good argument that we, I don't want to say that we eliminated ourselves from any chance at the college football playoff, 36:40 but it's a huge, huge long shot at this point. Well, if there was a 2014 playoff Duke would still be in the hunt right now. And there are a lot of other schools sort of similar to do it. If you have a, you know, if you have the current 36:56 12 team playoff, they're going to be like 16, maybe 18 teams who feel like they, you know, as you get down the stretch in the season, feel like they have a chance. When you go to 24, suddenly that's going to become 30, 32 teams, maybe even more who 37:10 feel like, Hey, you know, in their final two or three games, we win these games. We can make it. 37:15 And again, I like having more teams feeling like they've got a shot at it. I get your criticism that like, hey, yeah, you know, every single team in the SEC is going to feel like they belong in the playoff and the such. 37:27 I think, you know, we've seen in the polls this year that there's a terrible SEC bias that happens across the country that may not be deserved when you look at how the SEC does when they go out of conference and play other conferences. You know, everyone just assumes 37:42 the SEC is this incredibly dominant beast. But I think that there are good things to be said for the 2014 playoff in terms of the number of schools who get to be involved and feel like they have a chance to make it. I mean, for a lot of schools, 37:59 the final couple games of the season are pretty meaningless. Oh, are we going to play a bowl game in Charlotte? 38:06 Are we going to play a bowl game in Washington or a bowl game in New York? None of which matter. 38:11 That goes away for a lot of those teams if there's a 2014 playoff and they feel like, we've got a shot to make that 2014 playoff. So I think in the end, we may find that we actually like this. 38:23 I think last word I have on it is one, there are still some schools that appreciate the bowl games and root for the bowl games and want to be in as big a bowl game as possible. Case in point, us last year, we were kind of slighted that we 38:37 got the Sun Bowl after winning the ACC championship. 38:40 What did we do? 38:41 We went out and won it, right? But there's also this fact that College football is cyclical, but right now that cycle is trying to end by people who have all the money. And I promise, when they expanded to 24 teams, they weren't thinking about the MAAC. They weren't 39:00 thinking about the middle tier of the ACC. They weren't thinking about the Big 12. They were thinking about two conferences. 39:08 They were thinking about the bottom half of the SEC and the bottom half of the Big 10. Do you want Mississippi State If they lose four games to be in this tournament? That's the question that people have to ask, but that's what's going to be preferred over a four 39:25 loss Virginia Tech team. That's just the reality of what people are looking at. 39:29 Right now. 39:30 And the committee is, sure, it might be a cross-section of college football, but it somehow seems that the Big Ten and the SEC always get four or five teams in these things in the past few years. That's not going to change anytime soon because that's where the money is. 39:44 And ESPN, with their influence, is saying this is who the fans want to see. we don't want to see rehashes of the regular season. And that's why I think the conferences do matter. If it's one thing where we have conference champions get guaranteed access to this, and then 40:01 you have some at-larges, okay, I'm willing to have that conversation. 40:05 But if it's just going to be a free-for-all where there's no conference champions, that's where I think this can be a potential for the SEC and the Big Ten to kind of take themselves over and make this more of the meme of get in there and make it 40:17 about you. That's what this feels like to a lot of fans right now. 40:21 Yeah, we'll see how it plays out. I'm more in a wait and see kind of mode than I am immediately condemning it. In any event, let's call it a wrap here on the latest edition of the Duke Basketball Roundup. 40:34 We'll be back in your feeds very soon. The Blue Devils, the football Blue Devils. We were just talking football. Huge, huge game against UNC. We'll be here to recap that. 40:43 Basketball team about to play Tennessee. It is worth noting. 40:46 Tennessee played an exhibition just yesterday. They played Xavier and they lost. So lots to talk about with. 40:53 At home. Yeah, at home. 40:55 This Tennessee matchup coming up that's really, really interesting. We'll have a preview of that. Plenty of stuff happening here on the Duke Basketball Roundup. Don't forget, folks, if you want to interact with us, send us an email, dbrpodcast 41:09 at gmail.com. Until we hear from you. He is Donald. 41:14 I am Jason. And here's the Duke band. They're playing us out and taking us home.
Community discussion