0:03 [SPEAKER_01]: I'm Jason Perk and I'm Jane Kiddenmont and this is Disorder, a podcast where we keep trying Jason to find some semblance of order in bits over increasingly mad, mad, mad world. 0:19 [SPEAKER_00]: And this week, why has the world got so disordered? 0:22 [SPEAKER_00]: And what do the listeners think about it? 0:24 [SPEAKER_00]: It is our truly favorite time of the month, where we get to take listeners' questions. 0:32 [SPEAKER_00]: And if you're a mega-orderer, your question always gets answered. 0:35 [SPEAKER_00]: So please support the podcast. 0:39 [SPEAKER_00]: I personally fund this podcast. 0:41 [SPEAKER_00]: And although, Jane and I love recording these episodes for you, [SPEAKER_00]: we need to have our time compensated so that we can do the research, stay, O.F. 0:50 [SPEAKER_00]: with various things and give you the high production values that you the listeners deserve. 0:56 [SPEAKER_00]: Therefore, please go to disordershow.com forward slash club. 1:00 [SPEAKER_00]: Join the mega order as club. 1:02 [SPEAKER_00]: Every episode now has bonuses. 1:03 [SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if you've noticed, but we saved some of the best or most interesting topics for the bonus, like I think we did about the Brazilian election and this week we are keeping 1:12 [SPEAKER_00]: one of the hot button issues, which is the upcoming is Rayleigh Elections, which happened next week. 1:18 [SPEAKER_00]: It's likely to go down to the wire, it could require a complex coalition negotiations, and it's the kind of thing that is really going to be shaping the future of that region, as well as for us politics nerds just thinking about, like, how do you triangulate between Alvictor Lieberman Raam? 1:37 [SPEAKER_00]: and got the ice and cut to all these exciting questions. 1:41 [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, and conscripting the ultra-orthodox. 1:43 [SPEAKER_00]: So join us for that in the mega-orderous bonus. 1:47 [SPEAKER_00]: Okay, to the first question, Jane. 1:50 [SPEAKER_01]: So thank you to J.S. 1:52 [SPEAKER_01]: R for our first question of the day. 1:54 [SPEAKER_01]: It's short, but it is hard-hitting. 1:57 [SPEAKER_01]: J.S. 1:57 [SPEAKER_01]: says, I'd love to get your perspective on the protests we think across Europe. 2:05 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not that centrism has failed, but rather McCone, even though he wanted to rationalize the French economy, get rid of some of the things that don't work about their pension plans and become more competitive and undo the 35-hour, a week, work week. 2:21 [SPEAKER_00]: He just couldn't because he has the Relage on Protesters, and then he has the co-habitation, and with the co-habitation, which is that the [SPEAKER_00]: Senate and Parliament is of a different party than the president. 2:31 [SPEAKER_00]: You can't pass legislation. 2:32 [SPEAKER_00]: It's like if Trump gets hammered in the midterms, of course nothing will be able to happen in the U.S. system. 2:37 [SPEAKER_00]: So it's not centrism. 2:39 [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe Macron has failed because he hasn't been able to bring people with him and hasn't had leadership skills. 2:44 [SPEAKER_00]: But my missing something has centrism failed, sir. 2:46 [SPEAKER_01]: There is seemingly in lots of countries assert for more radical solutions, but I don't think it means that centricism is the wrong answer or that the more radical solutions are the right answer. 2:59 [SPEAKER_01]: We are seeing something we also talked about on the last episode, we're seeing some deep problems with the social contracts. 3:05 [SPEAKER_01]: in a lot of rich Western countries where people's expectations of what they should be getting as their living standards and what the status providing are just massively outstripping the state capacity to provide things and the economy's capacity to grow, which maybe has a lot to do with productivity and innovation and how we're dealing with. 3:26 [SPEAKER_01]: absorbing technology into our economies, but there does seem to be something where people blame the central governments for a lack of the progress they want to see, and therefore they are searching for different solutions. 3:39 [SPEAKER_01]: On the other hand, when we look at France in particular, I mean Macron's been there for quite some time, and you know we've just been discussing Jason how in the UK, maybe the pendulum is swinging. 3:48 [SPEAKER_01]: We have a lot of people moving towards 3:55 [SPEAKER_01]: So in a way, I think it's almost even more unstable than centrism failing. 4:00 [SPEAKER_01]: The parties of all kinds are struggling to deal with some of the political challenges. 4:05 [SPEAKER_01]: People think governments and states should be doing loads of stuff that might now be out of the power of governments and states to do. 4:13 [SPEAKER_00]: That was really well put, Jane. 4:15 [SPEAKER_00]: I think that what's happening is you get anti-incommency everywhere. 4:18 [SPEAKER_00]: The more someone is in power, the more they hate him. 4:21 [SPEAKER_00]: the more that they see, hey, this hasn't delivered for me, this hasn't done this, but a chance at government just doesn't have the ability to deliver one. 4:27 [SPEAKER_00]: AI companies and various tech things, they're the ones who have the power to change stuff and government, you know, can't even control its on electricity grid. 4:35 [SPEAKER_00]: And it could change things, but not in the current configuration with the current solutions. 4:40 [SPEAKER_00]: And [SPEAKER_00]: that is very scary and it leads to people wanting to protest for change because change is needed. 4:49 [SPEAKER_00]: The problem is that the protesters are like Arab Spring style, they're leaderless and they're burning things and they're getting into street fights with the police and they don't have a coherent, implementable message. 5:00 [SPEAKER_01]: So still hope for centrism, but it's going to need to be a lot more robust, a lot more serious, a lot more honest, also about what's coming, none of which is very easy for politicians in the medium environment today. 5:15 [SPEAKER_01]: I'm sure we'll be coming back to these protests because they're not going away any time soon. 5:19 [SPEAKER_00]: No, you and I have spoken about them previously. 5:21 [SPEAKER_00]: We are going to come back to them. 5:22 [SPEAKER_00]: I guess I have a worry. 5:23 [SPEAKER_00]: I was speaking to a friend earlier today and she was saying, what am I going to do when the protests come here and there's looting and burning and [SPEAKER_00]: not central London, but maybe in places like Tantnam and Etchware and where there are used to be riots. 5:35 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not something I thought about Montenegro, but it is a sobering thought. 5:38 [SPEAKER_00]: So now as the Mounties go past us here in Westminster, there's no doubt those horse-mounted police with their little silly iller jackets, they will take care of things. 5:49 [SPEAKER_00]: We are going to pivot to Lucy H's question. 5:51 [SPEAKER_00]: She writes, something I've been thinking about recently and after listening to your Prof Galiati episode is that Russia does have the staying power that in the West we can't or don't have. 6:02 [SPEAKER_00]: When things are so disorderly at home, how do we get that continuity we need to stay the course in Ukraine? 6:08 [SPEAKER_00]: Continuity, Jane. 6:10 [SPEAKER_01]: So much that's interesting here because it does link back to the previous question about centrism protests and at the end of the day, the ability of democracies to make people's expectations. 6:23 [SPEAKER_01]: And yes, it sometimes can look like, on the authoritarian country, has got greater staying power as simply because they can to some extent ignore public opinion. 6:33 [SPEAKER_01]: The counter-argument I would make though is that European support for Ukraine has continued and has remained very firm despite multiple changes of government. 6:44 [SPEAKER_01]: Now, we don't know what will happen with the next French government, if Marine Le Pen's party gets in, but it is noticeable, even in the last couple of weeks, one of the most staunch defenders of Ukraine in the European discourse has been Georgia Maloney. 7:01 [SPEAKER_01]: uh, teppered on NATO and weaker on Ukraine, which she has realized that this is something that she needs to stand firm on. 7:08 [SPEAKER_01]: We are still seeing, you know, for Andy Burnham here in the UK, Kiev was his first foreign visit. 7:14 [SPEAKER_01]: He's just hosted Zelensky here with a kind of guard of honor, welcoming him to Downing Street. 7:20 [SPEAKER_01]: It does seem to be, you know, Zelensky has outlasted multiple British prime ministers. 7:25 [SPEAKER_00]: All three ministers are listed like 20 different prime ministers. 7:30 [SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, there is something about Europe saying the course here, I think the bigger issue Europe is having is how do you actually take on securing Ukraine if the US isn't backing you? 7:43 [SPEAKER_01]: And it's really come to the crunch now with what we've seen over the past few days, Zelensky being increasingly vocal that, as he said in his most recent interview, he believes that the US wants Ukraine to capitulate. 7:55 [SPEAKER_01]: And since we have a European security model that is dependent on being underpinned by the US, it's made life extremely difficult for Europeans. 8:04 [SPEAKER_01]: They're giving arms, they're giving aid, they're giving moral support, but it's still difficult for them to call the shorts at the end of the day. 8:12 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, this comes back to something that we've spoken about at life. 8:16 [SPEAKER_00]: the Europeans inability to make air defense missile defense and certain kinds of satellite communications and it's not that Europe couldn't make these things that it doesn't have the industrial base or that there isn't the tech firms and tech abilities here. 8:33 [SPEAKER_00]: There is the potential, they just haven't invested in it, and they haven't nurtured the ability to have it independent capabilities. 8:39 [SPEAKER_00]: So I don't believe that Trump is just wanting you cramed to lose. 8:45 [SPEAKER_00]: That's the idea, oh, he's a Russian agent. 8:49 [SPEAKER_00]: That's a degree of oversimplification. 8:52 [SPEAKER_00]: He wants whatever's going to help him stay in power and when the next midterm or whatever. 8:55 [SPEAKER_00]: If he could make a peace deal, and the Ukrainians could win in that peace deal, and Russia could also win and he could win. 9:01 [SPEAKER_00]: It's fine. 9:02 [SPEAKER_00]: Whatever is going to get him to his win, he doesn't mind that he's screwing our allies. 9:08 [SPEAKER_00]: It's a caricature to say that Trump is just a Russian agent and we're going to come in the next question to the issue of the diesel deal. 9:15 [SPEAKER_00]: But Trump cares about Trump. 9:18 [SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if our listeners will have heard the Mary Trump interview on Restis politics leading. 9:25 [SPEAKER_00]: but it's a devastating psychological portrayal of someone who is not only a Megalomaniac narcissist with all these dark triad trades, but has such a lack of personal confidence and so reasoned by his own insecurities that anyone who flatters him most recently, 9:44 [SPEAKER_00]: wins. 9:45 [SPEAKER_00]: And anyway, it makes him seem more powerful that he has the right to withdraw the satellite coverage or the right to violate American congressional law by not implementing the sanctions that he himself passed. 9:58 [SPEAKER_00]: You know, that plays into his psychology. 10:02 [SPEAKER_00]: But let's get back to Lucy's question. 10:06 [SPEAKER_00]: What does the West need to stay the course? 10:07 [SPEAKER_00]: A clear narrative. 10:09 [SPEAKER_00]: Britain has been pretty good at that between anti-corban labor all the way through Lib Dems to remain a tourist, to hardline tourists. 10:16 [SPEAKER_00]: People understand why fighting for Ukraine is fighting for Britain and why fighting for Ukraine is fighting for our values. 10:21 [SPEAKER_00]: So that's been done really well. 10:23 [SPEAKER_00]: Some other countries haven't done that as well. 10:25 [SPEAKER_00]: It'll be as a classic example where until Maloney was in, you know, in power and she's done a good job with the narrative war, many on the far right and far left, and it'll be like they don't support Ukraine. 10:35 [SPEAKER_00]: And then the closer that you get to the front line in the non-slava countries, people are willing to throw their lock in with the Russians, obviously I'm thinking of hungry, but also Romania, and, you know, look back here, depending who's in government. 10:51 [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that is a slava country, but same idea. 10:53 [SPEAKER_00]: So how do we win the narrative? 10:55 [SPEAKER_00]: I think that like with AI regulation or climate, [SPEAKER_00]: people need to believe that this larger issue for which they're going to make sacrifices is actually something that they're going to benefit from and that they're not losing out on. 11:15 [SPEAKER_00]: And if we were all in it together, I think that the spirit of the British people on the spirit of a whole range of other Western peoples, there would be up for it. 11:24 [SPEAKER_00]: But the narrative has been wanting, I guess. 11:28 [SPEAKER_01]: I think there's still a gap. 11:31 [SPEAKER_01]: in many European countries between the governments who see Ukraine as being on the front line for all of Europe and many people in the public who might sympathise with Ukraine but don't necessarily see a direct connection and I do think that leaders have struggled to explain in what way Russia is a threat. 11:52 [SPEAKER_01]: We have seen this current government in the UK talking quite a lot about Russia's interference in British politics, but it's also a minefield. 12:02 [SPEAKER_01]: Recently Andy Barnum said Russia interfered in the Brexit vault. 12:05 [SPEAKER_01]: He quickly had to clarify that he didn't mean that the Brexit vault had been rigged by Russia, or that the result was illegitimate, because of course that's something that really offends Brexit vaulters. 12:16 [SPEAKER_01]: and I think it was even the head of MI5 who came in to say we don't think that Russia unduely influenced the result, but we do know that Russia tried to stir just as we also saw Iran has tried to stir up 12:30 [SPEAKER_01]: Scottish independence as an issue that doesn't mean that Scottish independence isn't a real issue that lots of Scottish people do believe in. 12:36 [SPEAKER_01]: So I think politicians are finding this sort of hybrid, graze-owned stuff from Russia quite difficult to explain to the public. 12:44 [SPEAKER_01]: Germany has said recently that citizens need to prepare for war potentially by 2020-29. 12:52 [SPEAKER_01]: That sort of thing obviously scares people, but I'm also not sure that the public generally has a clear sense that that's something that is a real risk. 13:01 [SPEAKER_01]: And if it is a war, what kind of war is, what do they need to do to prepare? 13:05 [SPEAKER_01]: So I think there's a huge amount of work still to do. 13:08 [SPEAKER_01]: There's still a big gap between where the security services see things and where European public see things. 13:14 [SPEAKER_01]: But still in a context where the support for Ukraine remains really pretty still. 13:19 [SPEAKER_00]: We know that when the Welsh have their referendum now that played, come raise in power, we will blame the Eritreans for their desire to interfere with the Welsh independence referendum. 13:29 [SPEAKER_00]: This is something that I have been waiting for is the Eritrean and to grey in interference in the Welsh independence referendum. 13:40 [SPEAKER_01]: You had it here first. 13:42 [SPEAKER_01]: Tell me. 13:43 [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, yes. 13:43 [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, yes. 13:44 [SPEAKER_00]: Just as Iranians want Scotland to be independent, there are many people sitting in Tigray who are thinking of only we could achieve Welsh independence and have our own relationships with Cardiff that it would solve the issues in the Horn of Africa. 14:00 [SPEAKER_01]: So the world has also burned the chaos, that's what you're saying. 14:02 [SPEAKER_01]: Exactly. 14:03 [SPEAKER_01]: That makes a little sense. 14:04 [SPEAKER_01]: We couldn't explain everything that way. 14:06 [SPEAKER_00]: So, continuity is saying, of course, I mean, we live into such a mean, mean, mean generation. 14:12 [SPEAKER_00]: If this generation got, you know, invaded by Nazis of the Soviet Union, would they really be ready to fight? 14:18 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm just not sure. 14:18 [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I see such moral failings in this idea that you should vote for or do what is best for you now, like the idea that Trump would appeal to voters, I will give you all $5,000. 14:35 [SPEAKER_00]: And it's like, but boss, that's going to cause inflation and this'll tank the economy and this will, whatever. 14:41 [SPEAKER_00]: But we will like, yeah, but I'll have 5,000 bucks. 14:44 [SPEAKER_00]: So I just, I don't know how you can make these arguments when the news cycle is so fast, memories are so short. 14:51 [SPEAKER_00]: And it says, if being selfish is now seen as, you know, being more, that's moral, you know, that you're a sucker. 14:59 [SPEAKER_00]: if you're doing something for somebody else, and that's why it's hard to make the case about Ukraine, because it's obviously right from a principal perspective, but you need to make people feel that it's right for their own interests. 15:11 [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know. 15:12 [SPEAKER_01]: I think a lot of young people are very motivated by working on climate change, joining anti-war protests, like thinking about a bigger picture, but they don't necessarily trust what governments have to see. 15:24 [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and we understand why, of course, I'm into connect to the French protests more and then to go to break. 15:31 [SPEAKER_00]: So these French protests, chain, there are real reasons to be disillusioned and we can sympathize with just the horrible state of if you're someone under the age of 18, like, am I gonna get a job? 15:45 [SPEAKER_00]: How can we even learn anything? 15:46 [SPEAKER_00]: The computers do everything? 15:48 [SPEAKER_00]: And then there's just such wealth in equality gaps. 15:52 [SPEAKER_00]: But why is it that leaders can't emerge, who are saying, but the real thing that we need to be about is meritocratic university entrants places. 16:02 [SPEAKER_00]: Like if there was a single ask, I think that the thing would succeed. 16:07 [SPEAKER_00]: If it's so general about, but it's also classized and it's also welfare and it's also inequality and it's also taxation and then we also want to tax billionaires and we want to, well, you can't achieve that with this free protest. 16:18 [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, yeah, you did at least a committee and the list of demands that people who can go in the Gucci. 16:23 [SPEAKER_00]: He's probably one demand. 16:24 [SPEAKER_00]: It's like a good. 16:25 [SPEAKER_00]: If we go back to Occupy Wall Street, it achieved nothing because they didn't even have one demand about the one percent. 16:31 [SPEAKER_00]: If they just said, we want, let's say, a 0.5 percent per year wealth tax, which I support. 16:39 [SPEAKER_00]: Okay, many people would say, oh, that's to the left of Bernie Sanders, we don't whatever. 16:43 [SPEAKER_00]: But if the Occupy process said only one demand. 16:47 [SPEAKER_00]: I don't know, but it might actually work, and then if you didn't even a sharper demand, and we want that 0.5% wealth taxed to be used to build infrastructure, which will, for example, simultaneously decarbonize green-new deal-style, but also create jobs. 17:03 [SPEAKER_00]: Wow. 17:04 [SPEAKER_00]: That would be really difficult to resist, like a linearly focused, bipartisan, future-looking thing. 17:13 [SPEAKER_00]: But if you just burned some tires and then like, Clash with the police and it's a well, tear down the system, I don't know what can that achieve, Jane. 17:21 [SPEAKER_01]: So if you're listening to this podcast at a French school protest, take notes and come and join us in the podcast and tell us what your one thing would be. 17:29 [SPEAKER_01]: It's much easier organizing against all the stuff, right? 17:32 [SPEAKER_01]: But you are gonna have more impact if you have something that can help to set the agenda, do completely agree with that. 17:39 [SPEAKER_01]: Let us move to Ryan Ells question, coming back also to Trump, Russia and Ukraine. 17:46 [SPEAKER_01]: And Ryan says, Trump's deal with Putin devastated me. 17:51 [SPEAKER_01]: I wondered if you thought there was any hope to order the disorder in this situation. 17:57 [SPEAKER_00]: I do. 17:58 [SPEAKER_00]: I do think this helped, Jane, because it's important to not overplay how significant this a diesel deal is. 18:06 [SPEAKER_00]: It's very bad from a principle of perspective, because it means that Americans are spending money on diesel, which helps Russia have money to buy arms to kill Ukrainians. 18:15 [SPEAKER_00]: So there's a direct connection, that's very worrisome, but it's not really going to move the needle in terms of diesel in the US. 18:24 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not even 12 days of Canadian production that's being bought. 18:27 [SPEAKER_00]: It's like one day worth of American consumption. 18:32 [SPEAKER_00]: When it turned to be ineffective, then he's going to look even more like a clown. 18:36 [SPEAKER_00]: It's like he did a deal with Putin, but it didn't even lower the price of diesel sufficiently. 18:39 [SPEAKER_00]: So maybe this can add to the things like the Iran stuff that he's just so bad that people are going to be like at the midterms. 18:46 [SPEAKER_00]: this guy's a clown. 18:46 [SPEAKER_00]: He doesn't even achieve the things that he said he does. 18:49 [SPEAKER_00]: So as bad as it is and as bad as the things that are happening, there is a silver lining line. 18:56 [SPEAKER_00]: The order to the disorder is that he's made such a fool of himself, both in the Middle East and over Russia and I think in AI issues, super intelligence issues. 19:08 [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe they're just going to get crushed in the midterms. 19:11 [SPEAKER_01]: And do you see a backlash already? 19:12 [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, this was some fit quite something for Republicans to have to swallow, literally buying diesel from Russia. 19:19 [SPEAKER_00]: I don't know, do you see a chair? 19:22 [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it seems like generally the Republican Party has been very supined, but that this has been going a long way for a lot of people to swallow. 19:31 [SPEAKER_01]: I guess we are going to see the midterms as the first key test of whether it means something in politics, but I do also wonder if increasingly you can see people thinking. 19:42 [SPEAKER_01]: Trump has peaked or nadirians, if we went to invent another words, at some point the internal thinking and the party must turn more and more towards succession and who's going to be the successor who are they going to back, a feel like it's already happening in Europe that people are giving up on trying to work with Trump because he's so particularly unpredictable and reliable. 20:06 [SPEAKER_01]: I don't want your American poll taxes closely as you do, so I don't have a fuel for what there. 20:10 [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. 20:11 [SPEAKER_00]: All depends on the midterms. 20:13 [SPEAKER_00]: Yes, some candidates are trying to not have Trump in their midterm ads, but then he tries to insert himself into the ads. 20:19 [SPEAKER_01]: Of course he does. 20:21 [SPEAKER_00]: And the Dems have picked the whole range of candidates, which you know, I have my issues with such as up the side, but there are others like the whole botched thing with Grand Plattener that 20:32 [SPEAKER_00]: We don't know, and then there's the trans issue, and the trans issue, how it's going to play out in places like Texas, where Tala Rico is a strong candidate, other who has done the trans issue. 20:43 [SPEAKER_00]: So, I think that if they get creamed, Republicans might abandon Trump as a losing, you know, as a losing brand to be established with, but if he wins or holds the Senate and it's people who are affiliated with him who win and those that he went against to lose, 21:00 [SPEAKER_00]: like if Paxton would win, this means that being a loyalist for Trump, even if you're not fit for office, like in Paxton, it's seen as beneficial. 21:10 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's the rub. 21:11 [SPEAKER_00]: It's very difficult to abandon Trump when if you're anyone from the center to the right, you need his in premature to be able to win your races. 21:22 [SPEAKER_00]: And if that changes, I think that then things could flip against [SPEAKER_01]: Hmm. 21:27 [SPEAKER_01]: Now we have another midterm related question and this one has been Ben R. Thank you Ben. 21:32 [SPEAKER_01]: Ben is asking, how do you think Trump is going to react if the Republicans lose in the midterms, as well as the diesel deal that we've just talked about, he's curious about what it means for the US in the long term. 21:45 [SPEAKER_01]: Is there any chance of a fight back? 21:48 [SPEAKER_01]: And I would be curious to have to Ben's question. 21:51 [SPEAKER_01]: you know, if there are very poor results for the Republicans or we're going to see a lot of questions being raised about the integrity of the elections and claims of fault theft, I'd be really interested to hear you thoughts on that. 22:05 [SPEAKER_00]: They already know that they're going to lose and hence they're already saying it was rigged. 22:09 [SPEAKER_00]: Right. 22:09 [SPEAKER_01]: They say that it's rigged. 22:10 [SPEAKER_00]: It's a bit as rigged before the election happens. 22:14 [SPEAKER_00]: Yes. 22:16 [SPEAKER_00]: There are two schools of thought about the implication of these midterms. 22:19 [SPEAKER_00]: One is that it's the most consequential election in American history, and certainly the most consequential midterms elections in the 20th or 21st century. 22:27 [SPEAKER_00]: But then there's the other school of thought, which is that even if Trump loses, he's just going to use executive orders to do everything. 22:34 [SPEAKER_00]: And that he'll repeal tax cuts, he'll do various things that should use Congress. 22:39 [SPEAKER_00]: He'll do tariffs without Congress. 22:41 [SPEAKER_00]: Even though they're monetary things that should originate in the house, he'll still just use executive orders. 22:46 [SPEAKER_00]: And then when it comes to foreign policy, Congress doesn't really have much ability to do anything unless they either in P.C.M. 22:51 [SPEAKER_00]: or they make war powers act resolutions, but they've essentially said, oh, this Iran situation isn't a war, therefore it's not a war powers act. 22:59 [SPEAKER_01]: It's a special military operation. 23:01 [SPEAKER_00]: special military operation. 23:04 [SPEAKER_00]: Do you know the reference train? 23:09 [SPEAKER_01]: No, but I was enjoying the song. 23:10 [SPEAKER_00]: Special military operation. 23:13 [SPEAKER_00]: You know the reference. 23:15 [SPEAKER_00]: This is puppet regime, Jane. 23:17 [SPEAKER_00]: Puppet regime are puppets both on Facebook, TikTok and Instagram. 23:21 [SPEAKER_00]: I assume on all these platforms. 23:23 [SPEAKER_00]: Where G and Putin, they talk to each other and they're like, [SPEAKER_00]: special electoral operation, it's not an election, it's a special electoral operation, and they have other things that pop up over here, this is really genius stuff. 23:38 [SPEAKER_00]: Link in the show notes. 23:39 [SPEAKER_00]: Link in the show notes, but there's millions of hits per one, because you know, Saturday at Live UK is actually not that good. 23:46 [SPEAKER_00]: I've committed to watching it, but I just wish they had puppets. 23:50 [SPEAKER_01]: You can't be puppets, you can't be had. 23:52 [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if you know spitting image, which is huge in the 80s in the UK, I'll have to stick a link into that as well. 23:58 [SPEAKER_01]: That influenced my whole generation in Britain, their whole view of British politics is shaped by those puppets, influential stuff. 24:06 [SPEAKER_00]: So obviously the Republicans in the House and the Senate have just become like puppets, these clowns, you know, Mitch McConnell even on his deathbed is just a puppet. 24:14 [SPEAKER_00]: So let's talk about the fight back that Ben RSks about, how do you see it, Jane? 24:19 [SPEAKER_01]: It comes back to the Senfism question, I think, that how do the Democrats actually have a fight back where they can unite people because they seem to have a strong successful momentum getting candidates and politicians who are very left, but I don't know how you unite America around that. 24:43 [SPEAKER_01]: That seems to be a key problem. 24:50 [SPEAKER_01]: They're not inspiring, and they've struggled, you know, they were slow to react to Trump. 24:55 [SPEAKER_01]: They don't really know how to deal with the new age of politics, so not good communicators. 24:59 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, particularly the older generation, like Chuck Schumer, you might be referencing that, but there's no reason why I aggression with Mer or a John Ossoff, even a Josh Shapiro, who are a little bit more tech-savail a bit younger. 25:11 [SPEAKER_00]: There's no reason that they can't be. 25:13 [SPEAKER_00]: You know, voices from the center that are bold and uniting, Gavin Newsom is trying to be that, but the idea is that somehow they're all flawed. 25:23 [SPEAKER_01]: So the fight that's not going great. 25:25 [SPEAKER_00]: However, I'm going to make an NFL analogy here, as listeners to the pod will now both George McDonald, our producer, and myself, were Sirius Eagles fans. 25:37 [SPEAKER_00]: The Eagles, I've essentially now tank the season. 25:40 [SPEAKER_00]: Our quarterback has a blood clot in his leg. 25:42 [SPEAKER_00]: He's out and definitely maybe the whole year. 25:45 [SPEAKER_00]: Second, partly, our running back, the best running back in the league. 25:47 [SPEAKER_00]: He has a hamstring injury. 25:49 [SPEAKER_00]: The back up tank bigs beat is out. 25:52 [SPEAKER_00]: So we're on our Fortstring running back. 25:53 [SPEAKER_00]: The third string quarterback, our best lineman retired, other lineman had been traded to just tanking the season. 26:01 [SPEAKER_00]: There is a point when it comes to these Trumpian Republicans that if they're made to look ridiculous over inflation or over Trump's illegal war, that they can't win. 26:11 [SPEAKER_00]: Do you know what it means? 26:12 [SPEAKER_00]: It won't matter who the opponents are. 26:14 [SPEAKER_00]: The Eagles could lose to like a division two college team. 26:16 [SPEAKER_00]: Now, because they're just bringing in guys from the street to play these positions. 26:22 [SPEAKER_00]: So, if the Dems don't do anything, [SPEAKER_00]: They may still win because the other guys, it's not just that they're on their Fort String running back. 26:34 [SPEAKER_00]: They've been made to look like such fools and hypocrites. 26:36 [SPEAKER_00]: I think that's Chuck Schumer's theory of the case, right? 26:38 [SPEAKER_00]: So I don't agree with it, and I have a lot of anger towards Chuck Schumer, but if they win the Senate, and if they win the Senate, they will have won the House. 26:49 [SPEAKER_00]: If they win the Senate, then he can say, look, [SPEAKER_00]: I didn't want to have a national message. 26:54 [SPEAKER_00]: I wanted to pick someone very different from Maine as for Texas. 26:57 [SPEAKER_00]: And so Michigan needs someone who's much more left, but then in Texas, we needed an evangelical guy and it doesn't matter that he's pro-trans. 27:04 [SPEAKER_00]: And if they win, then winning is everything. 27:08 [SPEAKER_00]: And it won't matter that [SPEAKER_00]: Uh, they've done it that way because the Republicans will be so harm having, you know, cozyed up to Russia, screwed up and Iran, dumb whenever the Republicans, they even just made a fool of themselves with this. 27:25 [SPEAKER_00]: new spokeswoman thing, Katie, whatever her name is. 27:30 [SPEAKER_00]: She lested not even one tenth of a scar moochy. 27:33 [SPEAKER_00]: You know, she was on and she like couldn't read properly. 27:37 [SPEAKER_00]: And the incident has been taken over by memes of her. 27:41 [SPEAKER_00]: It's, you don't, when your, your opponents are making a mistake, maybe you get out of the way, maybe Schumer is on to something. 27:46 [SPEAKER_01]: Yep, just let the election be lost by the incumbents, which might be a good way to do it. 27:52 [SPEAKER_00]: But we digress. 27:53 [SPEAKER_00]: The fight back is gonna all be after these mid-Chemps. 27:56 [SPEAKER_00]: It's too late to alter the strategy. 27:57 [SPEAKER_00]: There's not gonna be one big Democratic communicated between, you know, now and two weeks from now. 28:03 [SPEAKER_00]: If he loses, I think he'll start flipping out. 28:05 [SPEAKER_00]: Trump hates losing. 28:06 [SPEAKER_00]: He can't look at himself as a loser. 28:08 [SPEAKER_01]: No, it was sad. 28:09 [SPEAKER_01]: He didn't get the Nobel Peace Prize again. 28:11 [SPEAKER_00]: I know she's made so much peace in this last year. 28:14 [SPEAKER_00]: Man, he makes more peace before breakfast than Nelson Mandela or Mother Teresa made in their whole lives. 28:23 [SPEAKER_01]: Well, I feel we could do with less peace. 28:24 [SPEAKER_01]: I don't often say it, but just like a bit less peaceful, man. 28:29 [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so I think that you could behave very erratically. 28:32 [SPEAKER_00]: I think that they're mostly going to just double down on the corruption. 28:34 [SPEAKER_00]: It's all about how many billion can you get your kids and your kids, cousins and whatever that's just, it's just, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's all you can. 28:42 [SPEAKER_00]: It's a free for all for like deals with a whole range of unsavory characters. 28:47 [SPEAKER_00]: But, um, so that, that's what the fight back is going to be, right? 28:52 [SPEAKER_01]: Well, let's hope corruption could be one of those unifying issues, because sometimes it is something that people can rally around, that just seems to be more tolerant. 29:01 [SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god, it just heard, it's just a curtain maybe. 29:03 [SPEAKER_00]: Jane, if the Democrats had said make corruption great again, and they'd made that their slogan, and they just, every ad was make corruption great again, and pointed out that what Trump has done is essentially make corruption great again. 29:19 [SPEAKER_00]: That would have won in every race who would have just blow them over. 29:23 [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. 29:24 [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. 29:24 [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it should really be a unifying issue. 29:27 [SPEAKER_01]: It should, and as people are feeling squeezed, people are feeling stuff's expensive. 29:31 [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know how people can tolerate it. 29:33 [SPEAKER_00]: David Axelrad, please contact me. 29:35 [SPEAKER_00]: I have my idea. 29:36 [SPEAKER_00]: Make corruption great again. 29:38 [SPEAKER_00]: That's what they are these clowns. 29:41 [SPEAKER_00]: Okay. 29:41 [SPEAKER_01]: See a lot of images that could illustrate this campaign very nicely. 29:46 [SPEAKER_00]: Wow. 29:47 [SPEAKER_00]: Jane, we've got to go to break. 29:49 [SPEAKER_00]: It's been a lot of Russia and Trump and Russia and Trump and like negative stuff. 29:53 [SPEAKER_00]: Let's deal with something really positive when we come back like how the world is falling apart due to the climate crisis. 29:59 [SPEAKER_00]: This is like uplifting stuff. 30:01 [SPEAKER_01]: Woo hoo! 30:01 [SPEAKER_01]: See you in a minute. 30:18 [SPEAKER_00]: We are back. 30:19 [SPEAKER_00]: This is disorder. 30:21 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm Jason Pack, and I am here with Jane Kinnonbunt. 30:26 [SPEAKER_00]: We enjoy chatting with you, but we love most as listeners who write us with their questions. 30:31 [SPEAKER_00]: You can write us any time you want with your questions at DisorderShow at Gmail.com. 30:36 [SPEAKER_00]: And then we collate them and at the end of the month. 30:39 [SPEAKER_00]: We are going to ask your question, particularly if you're a mega-orderer. 30:43 [SPEAKER_00]: Ryan R writes in, saying, the climate crisis continues undelt with. 30:48 [SPEAKER_00]: Cop is coming up. 30:50 [SPEAKER_00]: So, Jane, in particular, I know that you am plays a big role in driving this conversation. 30:54 [SPEAKER_00]: How can we actually get the urgent action we need on this issue? 30:57 [SPEAKER_00]: How can the UN be useful in this context, again? 30:59 [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you so much for this question. 31:01 [SPEAKER_01]: There's a few things I'd love to pick up on there before I go to Jason for his thoughts. 31:05 [SPEAKER_01]: The world is missing the targets that they set in terms of global warming, but the climate crisis is not on the dealt with. 31:15 [SPEAKER_01]: a lot has happened, a lot has been done. 31:17 [SPEAKER_01]: The issue is that it's not going far enough or fast enough, and the world is continuing to wrangle over how to share that burden with developing countries, continuing to say what they've said since at least the 80s, which is, we are not responsible for most of this, and we want to see which countries doing more. 31:37 [SPEAKER_01]: But right across Europe, there has been a transformation of the energy sector towards renewable and clean energy. 31:43 [SPEAKER_01]: And I think that what we're seeing happening now in the state of Formus, it is only encouraging countries to double down on it. 31:51 [SPEAKER_01]: So the German ambassadors speaking last week, encouraging the UK to do more cooperation with the EU and with Germany specifically on renewable energy and on sharing electricity. 32:03 [SPEAKER_01]: So I think in some parts of the world, [SPEAKER_01]: like this is just a train that is moving ahead, but we haven't had enough global action. 32:12 [SPEAKER_01]: I do think that our criticisms of the way that climate campaigners communicate to some extent because it's easy to get the view that nothing is happening, everyone is failing, we've missed the ball and then you even get conservatives who don't want climate action 32:32 [SPEAKER_00]: That's clearly my view. 32:34 [SPEAKER_00]: I just think the reality is we're all doomed anyway. 32:38 [SPEAKER_00]: The world is going to get so warm that most of these like low-lying islands are going to disappear and people in the Sahara are going to have to flee their homes. 32:45 [SPEAKER_00]: It's like tough. 32:46 [SPEAKER_01]: So the next thing that the world will need to focus on is trying to find where are the wind winds between what of traditionally being separated out as mitigation reducing climate change and adaptation adapting to the effects of climate change. 33:01 [SPEAKER_01]: So now we are seeing this greater urgency in the British world towards adaptation because we're already living with the extreme weather, the weather disruptions, the heat, the floods etc. 33:12 [SPEAKER_01]: I found it interesting. 33:13 [SPEAKER_01]: I went to some of New York climate week when I was in New York for a UNGA, and there were quite a lot of state-level officials from around the UK. 33:21 [SPEAKER_01]: Some of them from the public and states and cities saying, we need to deal with climate, but we're not allowed to talk about climate, so it's all packaged together under resilience. 33:30 [SPEAKER_01]: But we'll come up with projects that are trying to safeguard our cities from floods and the causes of floods. 33:36 [SPEAKER_01]: We just have to call it something else, which I found quite interesting. 33:41 [SPEAKER_01]: Special climatic operation, not climatic, not climatic, not climatic, not climatic, operation, Jason, special resilient operation. 33:49 [SPEAKER_01]: That's what it's all about. 33:50 [SPEAKER_01]: No, to the UN and the Cope, we have found very little about the Cope this year. 33:55 [SPEAKER_01]: And it's happening in November, in Turkey, in Antalia. 34:00 [SPEAKER_01]: The idea of having corp rotate a bit like an Olympic Games is that every year you have a different government for whom this conference is a huge prestige issue. 34:11 [SPEAKER_01]: So they throw their weight behind it. 34:13 [SPEAKER_01]: We saw it when the UK hosted COP26 in Glasgow. 34:17 [SPEAKER_01]: The biggest one I think they've had today has been in UAE because of course so UAE's had to be the biggest so they made a huge effort to get loads of heads of state there. 34:25 [SPEAKER_00]: No one has any insecurity about that global role [SPEAKER_01]: You've got to be the biggest, that is the same as the best. 34:32 [SPEAKER_01]: Brazil, it was a huge issue for Lula to be seen as a leader on climate and get all these leaders to come down to the Amazon, but this year, it's in Turkey, where I get the impression arrogant. 34:46 [SPEAKER_01]: is really not that bothered by this. 34:48 [SPEAKER_01]: I think Turkey's big event this year was the NATO summit and that was a success from the point of view of the Turkish government, Trump was very nice to Turkey, the NATO summit went okay and coppers really something secondary and if you don't have the whole state really pushing 35:05 [SPEAKER_01]: the event and sending their diplomats all over the world to get people to show up, the conference just doesn't work so well. 35:12 [SPEAKER_01]: Previously, it had been thought that it was going to be an Australia, now that would be problematic in terms of the optics, because you have everybody flying into Australia, which is quite far away from many places, but I think the government would have been really motivated. 35:25 [SPEAKER_01]: Next year, 2020-27, it's due to be in Ethiopia, conflicts permitting. 35:31 [SPEAKER_01]: And there again, I think it would be a huge priority for the Ethiopian government because it's quite rare to have an international summit of that significance in Ethiopia. 35:40 [SPEAKER_01]: But for Turkey, I think this one's going to be relatively quiet. 35:44 [SPEAKER_01]: We're also, of course, going through this transition in the UN. 35:47 [SPEAKER_01]: We will see Antonio Guterreis being there as his final cop and he will probably be very outspoken. 35:54 [SPEAKER_01]: But the people who are in the running to be the next Secretary General, they will all have to work on climate change But they're trying not to shout too loudly about it because they're also trying to not be vetoed by the U.S. 36:06 [SPEAKER_00]: There's a lot in your answer there, but I want to start to unpack what you said at the beginning, which is really important, train. 36:13 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not that nothing's being achieved on climate change. 36:15 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not Ryan that climate is undelt with. 36:19 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not only that mitigation stuff is happening and adaptation, but there've been some real wind winds when it comes to wind turbines and solar and other stuff. 36:31 [SPEAKER_00]: And some countries have made a lot of money on these, the Chinese with their solar panels, the Nordics with some of their wind turbines. 36:39 [SPEAKER_00]: It's that it's not coordinated together. 36:42 [SPEAKER_00]: individual firms and individual countries take some good actions. 36:45 [SPEAKER_00]: But the problem is that climate is a cohesive, comprehensive, collective action problem. 36:52 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's what gets to the nature of this disorder podcast. 36:55 [SPEAKER_00]: I launch this podcast. 36:57 [SPEAKER_00]: because I believe that so many of our global issues were in fact collective action problems and that they were failing to succeed because disorders were preventing cohesive action. 37:11 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's the thing with climate. 37:12 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm sure that there are some German and Scandinavian and also third world leaders that do really good stuff on climate and to left in South America, there's some tree replanting and people do things. 37:23 [SPEAKER_00]: But there's not one big master plan that's been [SPEAKER_00]: well implemented. 37:28 [SPEAKER_00]: That's where the trick is being missed, so [SPEAKER_00]: How can the UN be useful? 37:33 [SPEAKER_00]: How can other actors be useful is to get people to have real coordinated collective action? 37:39 [SPEAKER_00]: That's what I think that we need on other issues, on a, a regulation, on a Ukraine. 37:44 [SPEAKER_00]: But climate may be, or should be, nonpartisan and scientific enough that people are willing to have those conversations. 37:52 [SPEAKER_00]: Do you think of Trump as out of office? 37:53 [SPEAKER_00]: And we had some in New York the UN that they could get some modero bonds, some climate things. 37:57 [SPEAKER_01]: I do, because I think, you know, minus the US, there is a pretty strong global consensus, obviously, or will producers have a different view from some others in terms of whether we want to move really quickly to facing out fossil fuels, but generally, there is a scientific consensus. 38:15 [SPEAKER_01]: That scientific consensus is laid by panels of experts at the UN. 38:21 [SPEAKER_01]: There is [SPEAKER_01]: a lot of work or the lot of issues already, but there are big picture things that are proving really problematic. 38:30 [SPEAKER_01]: You mentioned the Chinese and solar panels, the transition to binumerables is moving ahead so much that, you know, many countries are worried that China has a kind of struggle hold on a lot of the inputs. 38:42 [SPEAKER_01]: You know, this is partly part of the problem we're saying with the race and scramble for critical minerals because some of those are minerals needed for 38:52 [SPEAKER_01]: that kind of strategy needed to be thought about before and some of the sort of which countries are just catching up to that now. 39:01 [SPEAKER_00]: Less question before we go to the mega order bonus. 39:05 [SPEAKER_00]: We want to thank Suhaib, Adam, for writing in, thank you Suhaib, really good question. 39:12 [SPEAKER_00]: Have the hoothees succeeded in making the Iran war a multi-front war? 39:19 [SPEAKER_00]: Is it now a different conflict, Jane and Jason, transpiring in the Red Sea that could continue beyond what is happening in the Persian Gulf? 39:33 [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, Saheb. 39:34 [SPEAKER_00]: I'll let you start with this one, Jane. 39:36 [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you, Suhaib, it's a great question. 39:38 [SPEAKER_01]: And yes, I think the Houthis have contributed to merging these theaters of conflict around the Paris and Gulf or to where you had the Red Sea waterway. 39:49 [SPEAKER_01]: I think already the Iran War was entangled in various Middle East conflicts in which the Houthis have been involved before. 39:57 [SPEAKER_01]: But no, it's starting to join up with [SPEAKER_01]: the Horn of Africa, where we've seen a resurgence of worrying interstate conflict between Ethiopia and Eritrea, less than a decade after their rulers got the Nobel Peace Prize for ending their conflict. 40:14 [SPEAKER_01]: Those same rulers are now moving towards conflict once again, and you can think, well, what has that got to do with the Houthis? 40:22 [SPEAKER_01]: What has it got to do with the rest of the Horn of Africa? 40:25 [SPEAKER_01]: makes much more sense if we think about the geography of the seas rather than the geography of the continents because we are seeing this long-standing scramble for control over ports around the Red Sea. 40:36 [SPEAKER_01]: The Houthis have seized ports around the Red Sea. 40:40 [SPEAKER_01]: in order to be able to wield control over international waterways and disrupt shipping and use that as political leverage. 40:49 [SPEAKER_01]: And at the same time, Eritrea has become afraid that Ethiopia is going to try to seize the Eritrea import of Asab. 40:56 [SPEAKER_01]: I have no idea how plausible there 41:05 [SPEAKER_01]: that countries will abide by border agreements and by diplomatic rules, they can see a lot of change around them and start to think that things are possible, which previously would have been off the menu. 41:21 [SPEAKER_01]: And so the good I mean one good thing is I don't think any of the major powers want to see a renewed conflict between Ethiopia and Eritrea. 41:28 [SPEAKER_01]: I think this is an accidental bipodot of disorder and of you know leaders who have got their own agenda suddenly thinking maybe this moment of disorder is good for me. 41:41 [SPEAKER_01]: I think that is a desire by most of the major powers to stop [SPEAKER_01]: a resurgence of the Ethiopia erratria conflict, but there has been a real neglect of the Horde of Africa, there has been a relative neglect of Sudan, all of these things need to become down. 41:59 [SPEAKER_01]: Hopefully, with Saudi Arabia now facing these big security threats, this could be a time that Gulf countries actually start working together to come things down because that could make a huge difference. 42:10 [SPEAKER_01]: But do you think that's likely? 42:12 [SPEAKER_00]: It's all about working together, obviously, we've had the Saudi Emirati split over the last three or four years that is only deepened in the past months, and it's destabilizing because the Emirates and Saudi should be on the same side, vis-à-vis freedom of navigation and dealing with the Houthis, but they're not. 42:31 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm not super knowledgeable about the Horn of Africa issues, but I do understand it's being connected to Emorati Saudi tensions and that the Emorati's and Saudis are not on the same page and therefore it allows these conflicts to grow and fester in a disorderly way. 42:46 [SPEAKER_00]: I want to make a point about freedom of navigation. 42:49 [SPEAKER_00]: Western publics should be faced with the bill. 42:53 [SPEAKER_00]: Hey, I know that you don't want to do [SPEAKER_00]: military or naval or policing action because we're not the world's policemen, but you know what? 43:01 [SPEAKER_00]: You're paying this bill at the price of the pump and the price of your electricity and the price of your goods because people are going around the cap of good hope, but that's all you know, five, six, thousand kilometers further to get the goods to market and then you have to pay more for shipping and it's just inflationary. 43:16 [SPEAKER_00]: As soon as you have to spend more inputs on getting a good to market, [SPEAKER_00]: than price for that good is higher. 43:21 [SPEAKER_00]: And it causes inflation. 43:23 [SPEAKER_00]: And courageous leaders would say, hey, we need a global coalition to deal with these cities. 43:29 [SPEAKER_00]: Not just the Trumpians randomly bombing them, because that doesn't work. 43:31 [SPEAKER_00]: You can't defeat them air power, but back in Yemen, it dissidents, getting the golfies on board. 43:37 [SPEAKER_00]: We cannot have a power sitting in the Babel Mandab area. 43:43 [SPEAKER_00]: who is willing to hijack global shipping an act is like a state pirate. 43:48 [SPEAKER_00]: That's how I would word it. 43:49 [SPEAKER_00]: There is state like entity, which acts like a pirate. 43:53 [SPEAKER_00]: That has traditionally been the thing that causes global hedge remons to unify their allies because we can't as an international community tolerate 44:03 [SPEAKER_00]: all of the secondary causes of people who for their own selfish reasons, break global rules and impose costs on all of us. 44:16 [SPEAKER_00]: Pollution is one such cost, but these things are much more immediate. 44:20 [SPEAKER_00]: Do I think that all of a sudden we would ever get a global coalition to get rid of the Houthis now? 44:24 [SPEAKER_00]: I know that that's not the world that we live in, but we could have a global coalition about maritime policing, but the problem is it would require the U.S. or the UK or NATO to lead it, and then people to be willing to maybe have some sailors die and to spend money to try to achieve things. 44:45 [SPEAKER_00]: And I just, it's a very fibrile situation now. 44:48 [SPEAKER_00]: So this question's so hey, really gets at, [SPEAKER_00]: The implications of disorder and why I'm someone who says I like the idea of they're being a global hedgeer man. 44:58 [SPEAKER_00]: That may sound like oh it's really unfair. 45:00 [SPEAKER_00]: Oh that means U.S. or British imperial dominance. 45:04 [SPEAKER_00]: No it could be the dominance of the rule of law could be the dominance of a coalition of democracies. 45:08 [SPEAKER_00]: But we need these laws to have teeth. 45:12 [SPEAKER_00]: And if they don't have teeth, why would anyone follow them? 45:15 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's part of the reason why there's so much fragmentation. 45:17 [SPEAKER_00]: We are going to call it a week, but. 45:21 [SPEAKER_00]: It's a week, but for the mega orders, we have a bonus question. 45:27 [SPEAKER_00]: You're going to have to say, it's not about Russia. 45:30 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not about who it is. 45:31 [SPEAKER_00]: It's not even about climate. 45:33 [SPEAKER_00]: It's about something so much more fun. 45:35 [SPEAKER_00]: You've got to join the mega order as club at disordershow.com forward slash club. 45:43 [SPEAKER_00]: What will the listeners get if they join Jane? 45:45 [SPEAKER_01]: You will get ad-free listening. 45:47 [SPEAKER_01]: You will get access to our mega-orderers only recordings. 45:53 [SPEAKER_01]: And the chance to come to exclusive live events, the next one will be before Christmas in this esteemed space here in Whitehall at the UN Association. 46:03 [SPEAKER_01]: Instead of our coffees, we'll have red wine and maybe even a cheese store to mince pies, perhaps. 46:08 [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, we can. 46:09 [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, we can. 46:10 [SPEAKER_01]: She's more enthroned. 46:11 [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, time. 46:12 [SPEAKER_01]: Can't be said that as all the Christmas dinner you need. 46:15 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, they go together really well, it's well known. 46:18 [SPEAKER_00]: Do not forget about our YouTube channel because that's where you can see Jane and I in our Monday finest as we are recording this at the UN Association. 46:30 [SPEAKER_00]: And we have some exclusive videos so subscribe to that YouTube channel, the link is in the show notes. 46:36 [SPEAKER_01]: And finally, for more on today's topics, we have a sub-stack too, and the link of course is also in the show notes. 46:43 [SPEAKER_00]: A producer is the one the only he suffers even greater than I do when the Eagles lose George McDonald. 46:51 [SPEAKER_00]: Disorder is a part of Red Circle. 46:54 [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for listening and hope you have a merry-ordomance and a very ordinary week.
Community discussion