0:01 [SPEAKER_01]: I'm Jason Pack. 0:04 [SPEAKER_01]: And I'm Jane Kinnon-Mont and this is disorder. 0:07 [SPEAKER_01]: A podcast where we still try to find order in our increasingly and insanely mad, mad world. 0:19 [SPEAKER_00]: This week, can it get worse? 0:22 [SPEAKER_00]: Yes, it can actually still continually get worse. 0:29 [SPEAKER_00]: UK party conferences and craziness in the bond markets, the interest rates, the further collapsing with the British economy, Bill Gates talking about AI reaching an inflection point in the super intelligence maybe taking over. 0:43 [SPEAKER_00]: And just small things like, 0:48 [SPEAKER_00]: the end of the universe, the midterms, and Jane's recent trip to New York for the U.N. General Assembly, Jane, I know we've got a lot to get to, and then we're gonna have a mega-orderer's bonus about the election in Brazil, which is interesting, exciting and very, very scary. 1:06 [SPEAKER_00]: So Jane, Francis Burning, is it really a normal thing to throw to your guests at under 15s? 1:14 [SPEAKER_00]: Or is that only once they've already set their trash on fire? 1:18 [SPEAKER_01]: Well, we all know that cracking down really hard on young protesters always works to just make them shut up and go away, right? 1:26 [SPEAKER_01]: Or indeed the opposites, I mean, just as we've got through the summer wildfires here in Europe. 1:35 [SPEAKER_01]: we get lots more man-made fires starting, right? 1:40 [SPEAKER_01]: We know that France has a particular tradition of protesting and that the police often are heavy-handed, but I think something that is really striking about these protests is that in many cases students have wanted better schools and your heart goes out to them that there's been protests about not enough teaching staff, school buildings 2:03 [SPEAKER_01]: And it brings us to one of the underlying factors in the disorder that we're experiencing, especially here in the West, which is really the strains on the intergenerational social contract that might sound a bit of an abstract term, but essentially, 2:21 [SPEAKER_01]: The feeling among many young people that the world they're being given by their parents and their grandparents isn't good enough and that things are deteriorating, that their life won't be as good as their parents' life or as their grandparents' life. 2:36 [SPEAKER_01]: This is a pervasive narrative. 2:39 [SPEAKER_01]: throughout the rich world, right? 2:41 [SPEAKER_01]: And there's some tooth in there and there's probably some narrative and belief in it that's not completely objective, right? 2:49 [SPEAKER_01]: There is a certain randomization of the past, but there is a feeling that it's just so tough to get a job, it's so tough to pay for an education when you get to that point. 3:02 [SPEAKER_01]: And one of the symptoms we see 3:08 [SPEAKER_01]: It seems too expensive and too difficult to bring more people into this world, which obviously everyone makes so into different choices about kids, but when you see that with a large scale that people feel it's impossible. 3:20 [SPEAKER_01]: This is a problem. 3:21 [SPEAKER_01]: So it's speaking to something quite deep in European societies about the type of future that young people see before them and then how can we actually give a future that isn't just a doom spiral. 3:39 [SPEAKER_00]: I agree with everything you've said, and the protesters are no doubt right in calling out the problems. 3:44 [SPEAKER_00]: And this is something that I love to return to whether it's about neo-populous politicians or protesters on the left or the right. 3:51 [SPEAKER_00]: People are really, really good at accurately pointing out the problems. 3:54 [SPEAKER_00]: There is a lack of intergenerational fairness. 3:57 [SPEAKER_00]: And anything that can be said about the boomers using up the resources and then 4:02 [SPEAKER_00]: running up the debt, it's all true, essentially in broad picture terms, and therefore you and I will have had better class sizes and better education opportunities in government schools than people who are 10 to 20 years younger than us. 4:15 [SPEAKER_00]: It's just the case. 4:17 [SPEAKER_00]: However, what's kind of sad looked at from a Anglo-Sphere perspective is like, why does this need to lead to burning of tires and looting and throwing tear gas? 4:28 [SPEAKER_00]: And I'm blaming the protesters in the police equally. 4:30 [SPEAKER_00]: I would have thought incorrectly that given that the French love to strike, train strikes, wage strikes, retirement age cut strikes, that they would have a very lack approach to policing them, because there's a lot of genre do their thing and others do their thing. 4:46 [SPEAKER_00]: You can't just like club people and throw it to your guests at them because they're just not only letting off steam, but this is a way of expressing kind of civic participation in it. 4:54 [SPEAKER_01]: It's not your new heritage. 4:56 [SPEAKER_00]: It's civic participation. 4:58 [SPEAKER_00]: It's very surprising to me because I don't understand that tradition. 5:03 [SPEAKER_00]: I do understand French, and I spend quite a bit of time in France, but I don't get why they throw it to your guests at the kids. 5:10 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm missing something here. 5:11 [SPEAKER_01]: It was notable during COVID, you know, just contrasting the different policing styles over Europe. 5:18 [SPEAKER_01]: That the French police were really tough. 5:21 [SPEAKER_01]: You know, there was an expectation that you had to be doing something wrong if you were outside the house unless you showed a permission slip to the police. 5:28 [SPEAKER_01]: So I think there is something going on around attitudes among the police. 5:33 [SPEAKER_01]: It just seems that there are so many examples from all over the world that when you have this heavy-handed crackdown when people who feel they're being unfairly treated, it often fuels the fire as it were, rather than bringing it to an end, and there surely could be ways to deal with it where you promise some kind of negotiated solution. 5:55 [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, what they're not going to be able to do, because these are student protestors without leaders, is deal with the underlying causes of the French economy and particularly the upon markets. 6:07 [SPEAKER_00]: You know, already France has set 100% debt to GDP ratio. 6:13 [SPEAKER_00]: It's looking more like Italy or Greece was looking five, 10, 15 years ago. 6:18 [SPEAKER_00]: And now French bonds are being judged worse than Italian bonds. 6:23 [SPEAKER_00]: That's the sentence I literally know that I never thought we would say that, you know, because traditionally the French economy just to be clear has been Northern European in style, right? 6:32 [SPEAKER_00]: Yes, France hasn't Mediterranean coastline. 6:34 [SPEAKER_00]: Yes, when you're on the Co-desur, you're living in Mediterranean lifestyle, but traditionally the economy has been 6:40 [SPEAKER_00]: You know, under the European style economy with a lot of saving and investment and a lot of exposure to, you know, the most elite international capital markets and whatever and I'm oversimplifying, but high end exports better than the British economy, so both the kind of Italian luxury good sector, but then banking and engineering almost like Germany. 7:06 [SPEAKER_00]: and exposures just what's a lend and stuff. 7:08 [SPEAKER_00]: So it's kind of surprising because my call came in saying he was going to reform the things that didn't work throughout the French economy. 7:16 [SPEAKER_00]: So how do we get to this place, Jane? 7:19 [SPEAKER_01]: There's a lot of different interest groups that always will resist different types of fiscal reform and we know that, you know, in France, the constituency of pensioners have really made their voices felt by doing protests. 7:33 [SPEAKER_01]: And so, in a way, there is a logic that students would try to do the same thing and to say that there needs to be more investment in education and more the remaining public sector spending should be directed towards younger people. 7:47 [SPEAKER_00]: or at least towards giving them the skills to grow the economy and to reform the structures of the French state that are so fundamentally broken, potentially around the retirement age or social care and productivity and employment and the same productivity. 8:05 [SPEAKER_00]: It's like a worse version of some of these problems than bread. 8:09 [SPEAKER_00]: So that's the situation on that side of the channel, not looking so good. 8:14 [SPEAKER_00]: Here we have had party conferences. 8:16 [SPEAKER_00]: And now, before we get into a range of kind of wild things that have happened in the labor and Liverpool, green and bright and Tory party conferences, why are there party conferences every year where you know, Kemi is gonna say, I wanna lower inheritance tax, but she had a party conference last year, but she's been the leader for this period of time. 8:40 [SPEAKER_00]: I don't get that. 8:45 [SPEAKER_01]: It's the way to get the party together without opposing voices or at least to deal with the internal opposing voices and work on policy. 8:55 [SPEAKER_01]: It is interesting that it happens every single year going back, even to times when the governments were much more stable. 9:01 [SPEAKER_01]: You could understand it happening frequently when we've obviously got a new Prime Minister and new ministers and so on. 9:07 [SPEAKER_01]: But it's seen as an important part of party development. 9:11 [SPEAKER_01]: and the party members are taking part. 9:13 [SPEAKER_01]: So it is a chance for the membership to have their say to advocate with the party and then it's a huge thing for civil society and NGOs who show up and do things. 9:25 [SPEAKER_01]: So you know, my colleagues have gone down to the Labour Party conference in order to do an event about AI and the military and campaign for the UK to support a treaty 9:39 [SPEAKER_01]: And we can also do that kind of advocacy in Westminster, but when you're doing that advocacy in Westminster, at any point the MPs you're trying to talk to could be pulled away from your meetings because they have to go and vote on things. 9:53 [SPEAKER_01]: So for a civil society organization getting down to that party conference gives you a chance to have a conversation about politics that isn't interrupted by the voting bill. 10:03 [SPEAKER_01]: And of course a lot of companies will be there. 10:08 [SPEAKER_01]: the ruling party conference, the governing party conference, more and more of them now of course are going to the reform conference as well because of people thinking maybe those will be the next people in power. 10:20 [SPEAKER_01]: So there's a whole kind of ecosystem around it. 10:23 [SPEAKER_01]: I've been to two and I've been to a conservative conference and a Lib Dem conference, both at times when those parties have been recently [SPEAKER_01]: kicked out of power. 10:34 [SPEAKER_01]: Basically, because when I was working at Chatham House, the director would always go to the governing party conference and then analysts like me would go to the less important ones. 10:43 [SPEAKER_01]: So I usually got to go to the ones where everyone seemed really depressed, but there would always be a load of lobbyists paying a lot of money for stalls to talk about anything from innovation to shouldn't you be nicer to the arms trade and the fur industry. 10:58 [SPEAKER_00]: So I'm going to give my takeaways quickly. 11:01 [SPEAKER_00]: That was very interesting, Jane, and that background. 11:03 [SPEAKER_00]: I'll give my takeaways no need to respond to the different party conferences, and then we can move on. 11:09 [SPEAKER_00]: Starting with labor, because they are, as you say, the governing party or the ruling party, social care. 11:15 [SPEAKER_00]: Andy Burnham has made kind of pre-manifesto pledges that if he's going to run in 2021, as he clearly wants to, or if he's going to call an early election, which God, I hope he doesn't. 11:25 [SPEAKER_00]: He wants to have a social care like the NHS [SPEAKER_00]: free at the point of view, since for everybody and that it addresses the social crisis. 11:33 [SPEAKER_00]: To my mind, that can only happen if you're dealing with the immigration and labor shortage issues. 11:39 [SPEAKER_00]: So it's a little worry to hear about this when they don't really have plans to deal with the labor shortage problems. 11:49 [SPEAKER_00]: And clearly, we need more people in that productive economy here, not only for social care, but for roads and bridges, 11:59 [SPEAKER_00]: hospitality is a sector that needs social care is a sector that needs it, but clearly infrastructure builders everything. 12:04 [SPEAKER_00]: So I'm not across all the details. 12:06 [SPEAKER_00]: It is interesting that he has taken such a social tack. 12:12 [SPEAKER_00]: Burnham in making rough sleeping his day one pledge and now social care is kind of party conference and pre-manifesto thing. 12:20 [SPEAKER_00]: Um, I hope it resonates with people and it sounds reasonable. 12:23 [SPEAKER_00]: Of course, I have the worries about it being costed and, and, you know, is this really the most pressing thing. 12:29 [SPEAKER_00]: Moving on to the Tories. 12:31 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm someone who doesn't like Kenny Badenock. 12:34 [SPEAKER_00]: I like some of the ideas of some of the, 12:38 [SPEAKER_00]: remainder, Tory dominant grief style people who've left the party, something about I really dislike her and the more that it goes on, the more that I dislike her, which is a shame because I'd like her to be a nice counterbalance to reform and I want her to be something and I don't want to be accused of oh my god. 12:53 [SPEAKER_00]: you're anti-woman or you're anti-black. 12:55 [SPEAKER_00]: It's really not that. 12:56 [SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of how reactionarily conservative she is and I don't really get why. 13:03 [SPEAKER_00]: So whenever she talks about a topic, she really doubles down on what seems like a very out-of-date view. 13:09 [SPEAKER_00]: And then she's like, we're going to abolish it, heritage facts, and you're like, [SPEAKER_00]: Since I've moved here, the one thing that blows my mind is how under-tax Britain's are. 13:17 [SPEAKER_00]: The whole reason we have this crisis and the housing sector is that really aren't property taxes here. 13:22 [SPEAKER_00]: And then it's like, yeah, there's inheritance tax, and that's problematic, but people just avoided it, and it's not really done properly, and you just need to tax wealth clearly, and one way to do that is to have a better 13:36 [SPEAKER_00]: So they're like, okay, we're just gonna get rid of it or we're gonna like decrease it. 13:40 [SPEAKER_00]: And if it's costed, then we can get rid of it. 13:42 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm like, what? 13:44 [SPEAKER_00]: That sounds about as crazy as the reform proposals, before I go on to the greens. 13:49 [SPEAKER_00]: Am I missing something Eugene? 13:50 [SPEAKER_00]: How can that be the proposal? 13:53 [SPEAKER_01]: Well, you know, it occurred to me that I'm kind of glad to see the conservative conversation moving back to tax and welfare and less about the identity politics, but perhaps I'm now setting a very law bar for the state of British politics. 14:08 [SPEAKER_01]: Look, I think it's easy to promise tax cuts and inheritance tax has this particular 14:15 [SPEAKER_01]: Emotional issues for many people that are middle class, that would have parents whose houses have gone up in, that will give very significantly over the last 20 or 30 years, who are basically afraid that when their parents die, they lose their house. 14:31 [SPEAKER_01]: And yes, there are various ways that people plan for that and get around it. 14:35 [SPEAKER_01]: But I think it's the, the emotional appeal. 14:38 [SPEAKER_01]: that makes this quite a hot button issue for parts of the middle class who feel like they're being squeezed on the course of living and that sort of their fuse aren't being herded off. 14:48 [SPEAKER_01]: It resonates in London as well because the London property prices have gone up so much, you know, since the time that I moved to London in 1991. 14:57 [SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, I think it probably seems like a quick win especially when you're not in government and do it have to make up the actual [SPEAKER_01]: losses that cutting attacks will have. 15:10 [SPEAKER_00]: It would seem that you could raise the threshold, but the idea of getting rid of the attacks on those above, I don't know, a 10 million pound threshold, that just so crazy when everything of any economist explains that you need to be taxing a wealthy. 15:26 [SPEAKER_00]: more. 15:28 [SPEAKER_00]: We're going from bonkers to more bonkers was the green party conference Zionism is racism thing where they abandoned the amendment, which would say 15:43 [SPEAKER_00]: We understand that British Jews participate in a range of organizations, such as their synagogues, such as their social groups, which are nominally Zionists and we're not gonna sanction them. 15:54 [SPEAKER_00]: Instead, they've doubled down on the most extreme resolution, which is that anyone who in their private capacity [SPEAKER_00]: interacts with donates with attends organizations which are Zionist in nature, his resistance should be expelled from the party. 16:16 [SPEAKER_00]: This is insane because and we're going to put a link to a news agents podcast where they discuss what the guardian columnist Jonathan Friedlander and no one will accuse him of being very right-wing. 16:26 [SPEAKER_00]: He's a guardian columnist. 16:28 [SPEAKER_00]: He explained something that I didn't fully appreciate, Jane. 16:31 [SPEAKER_00]: which is that in the UK, even the most left-wing synagogues consider themselves Zionist. 16:37 [SPEAKER_00]: They would say, we're liberalized, Zionists, we're reforms, Zionists, where conservatively Zionists, but none of them say that they're not Zionists. 16:45 [SPEAKER_00]: Something, air go, more than 95% of British Jews belong to synagogues, which are in some ways referring to themselves as Zionist. 16:55 [SPEAKER_00]: meaning that they read the regular prayer, prayer book, and the prayer book talks about the return of the choose, desire, and all range of other things. 17:02 [SPEAKER_00]: There ago, any sin and God going British Jew could be accused of violating the green party resolution and kicked out of the party and denounced. 17:16 [SPEAKER_00]: And what blows my mind is that Zach Polansky, as the green party had who is himself Jewish, decided to abstain on the motion. 17:25 [SPEAKER_00]: And it's like, wait, if you're the head of the party, you either support this crazy resolution or you oppose it. 17:31 [SPEAKER_00]: How can he abstain on this motion? 17:34 [SPEAKER_00]: I wonder if we've now seen the high point of the Zack Polanski move because choosing to run in Hoburn and Saint-Pancras where it was close, but it seems after this. 17:47 [SPEAKER_00]: really bungled media campaign around this thing. 17:50 [SPEAKER_00]: Also, there's the great irony, which is that the woman who proposed this unimended resolution was then said, but what about supporting terrorism and al Qaeda? 18:02 [SPEAKER_00]: Is that non-racism? 18:03 [SPEAKER_00]: And she said, no, not exactly. 18:05 [SPEAKER_00]: And it emerged. 18:07 [SPEAKER_00]: that she is the sister-in-law of a convicted al-Qaeda terrorist that has given lots of money to al-Qaeda. 18:16 [SPEAKER_00]: So literally the drifter of the legislation we'll put links in the shoutouts to all of this. 18:21 [SPEAKER_00]: You couldn't make this stuff up, Jane. 18:23 [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you couldn't make it up. 18:25 [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I just think it's really sad, actually, because people use the word Zionism to mean many, many different things. 18:32 [SPEAKER_01]: And we should be trying to, as a society, to promote an understanding of, what is it that you're aspiring to, what are the different visions for, [SPEAKER_01]: the future of Israel and for Palestine. 18:46 [SPEAKER_01]: But this is a matter of taking a word, deciding that you and only you define what it means, and then policing people who associate with other people who accept that word. 18:58 [SPEAKER_01]: And I think it's not entirely unlike people who say, ah, you've said free Palestine. 19:03 [SPEAKER_01]: I think that that means that you want to murder all Israelis. 19:07 [SPEAKER_01]: And therefore, if you've been anywhere near somebody with that slogan, I'm saying that that's what you mean. 19:13 [SPEAKER_01]: The reality is that's not what the people mean. 19:16 [SPEAKER_01]: It's not what the people mean when they go to a group that includes Zionists. 19:21 [SPEAKER_01]: you making up what other people are saying. 19:23 [SPEAKER_00]: And then because the irony of course is none of the main parties have said we should kick out people from our party who say free Palestine. 19:32 [SPEAKER_00]: You could be a member of a former the tourist. 19:34 [SPEAKER_00]: There's no anti-free Palestine to most of the human past. 19:38 [SPEAKER_00]: I just want to clarify for her. 19:40 [SPEAKER_01]: No, you're right. 19:41 [SPEAKER_01]: It's it's been used in a different way. 19:43 [SPEAKER_01]: And I guess I'm giving the 19:50 [SPEAKER_01]: political sympathies that the letter no might have. 19:54 [SPEAKER_01]: You can't just decide what somebody else means put words in their mouth and then ostracize them for something that you have actually made up. 20:02 [SPEAKER_01]: This seems like a huge waste of time when we should be trying to understand better what people mean and then figure out where there's some common ground. 20:11 [SPEAKER_01]: It just seems [SPEAKER_01]: At best pointless, but at worst, actually really dangerous and counter to the dialogue and understanding that we actually need to develop if we're going to get anywhere on these issues. 20:24 [SPEAKER_00]: It's very dangerous. 20:26 [SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of absurd and ridiculous, but in terms of what does it mean coming out of party conference season? 20:32 [SPEAKER_00]: I don't know. 20:32 [SPEAKER_00]: I have been proven wrong on a lot of reproductions, but I've finished politics. 20:36 [SPEAKER_00]: I've the first to admit that it does seem to me that maybe the greens have peaked. 20:42 [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe it could be that like with the reform campaign donation scandal, the £5 million and now the 30 Brazilian pounds to reform, that although five party politics sounds well and good, 21:03 [SPEAKER_00]: for people who are following, they're going to realize that they're not like the establishment parties that whatever I happen to dislike can be bad knock, but it would be difficult to say that the stories are not a sane party with the process and all of that, but the greens and reform are frequently behaved in ways that it's like, wait a second, this doesn't make any sense. 21:21 [SPEAKER_00]: So to wrap up the party conference season, we have this five party politics. 21:27 [SPEAKER_00]: It's weird from a traditional two and a half party view of British politics. 21:35 [SPEAKER_00]: But maybe Burnham is going to channel the debate into some key things and those who are throwing fringe disorderly things on the margins are going to see a blowback from the fairly centrist and tolerant British population. 21:55 [SPEAKER_00]: People don't want to tolerate rape gangs, they don't want to tolerate genocide, they don't want to tolerate 22:01 [SPEAKER_00]: anti-Semitism, they don't want to tolerate just giving the rich all the money and it may be we're going to see a peak of these ideas and a movement towards the center, just that's unfair current. 22:12 [SPEAKER_01]: I hope so, because genuinely most people that I know and most people that I meet are very reasonable and you can have a reasonable debate with them, but somehow our politics seems to be increasingly crazy. 22:25 [SPEAKER_01]: After the break, we are going to return to Jason's favorite stalking horse, the Bond markets. 22:47 [SPEAKER_00]: We are back. 22:48 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm Jason Pack with Jane Kinnonmont and, you know, there's nothing that we love talking about more than the bloody bond markets and interest rate. 22:57 [SPEAKER_00]: I [SPEAKER_00]: did not understand the importance of the global bond markets until I started doing this podcast. 23:03 [SPEAKER_00]: So I will thank you the listener for underwriting my growth and understanding on this point. 23:10 [SPEAKER_00]: What have I come to understand? 23:11 [SPEAKER_00]: When you're a mainstream politician or you're a governing politician and you announce a range of policies that investors feel will A, we can the currency, B, decrease future growth, [SPEAKER_00]: or see run up the deficit in the future. 23:29 [SPEAKER_00]: There is a corrective mechanism, which has gotten very intense over the last let's say 10 years, that increases your country's borrowing costs. 23:40 [SPEAKER_00]: and even EU countries that use the euro have differential borough in costs. 23:45 [SPEAKER_00]: When Germany wants to go to borrow or the Netherlands, they pay less money to borrow because they are overall credit donations. 23:54 [SPEAKER_00]: And when the debt donations who need the money more Spain, Italy, Ireland, but now France, 24:01 [SPEAKER_00]: needs to borrow money, they pay a greater premium for that money, and the implication has been that the bond markets to my mind have come to exert sovereignty over centrist politicians. 24:16 [SPEAKER_00]: The reason that Macron cannot spend his way out of the kid protesting crisis, let them 24:32 [SPEAKER_00]: is if he would announce such a plan, and I would love to see more educational spending, what do you know, the bond markets will downgrade France, because he's racking up liabilities for future spending for which the benefits of that kind of spending isn't going to be felt until those kids graduate from college, and therefore the net implication for productivity is so far in the future, 24:56 [SPEAKER_00]: you're only getting to pay the cost without pricing in the benefit. 25:01 [SPEAKER_00]: That might be in the third year yield. 25:03 [SPEAKER_00]: But it's the two and five year yields that crush these countries. 25:07 [SPEAKER_00]: And I did not grasp Jane how [SPEAKER_00]: The tyranny for lack of a better term of the bond market has really made it difficult for centrist or reasonable center left to center right EU and UK politicians to take quote unquote courageous steps. 25:27 [SPEAKER_00]: And Burnham says his stuff about social care and boom, the bond market in the UK is getting towards 6%. 25:33 [SPEAKER_00]: It hasn't been at 6% since the late 90s and there were other structural features then that Britain's debt to GDP ratio was not as bad. 25:42 [SPEAKER_00]: So under Blair when the economy was growing, having 6% was because the economy was growing, having a shrinking economy. 25:50 [SPEAKER_00]: much more debt and this issue that we now have when burn them like hiccups, the bond markets are like freezing and freaking out. 25:58 [SPEAKER_00]: I really don't know where we go from here, and then the worst bit is the dominance of the U.S. interest rates and the rate of T-bills and the actions of the Fed. 26:11 [SPEAKER_00]: It should be something that anyone who studied economy would know, what I'm about to say, but there's no reason if you haven't studied the economy, you'd know the following thing, which is the British pound and the euro are affected by the relative interest rate different ratios to the rate on treasuries and the dollar. 26:31 [SPEAKER_00]: What do I mean? 26:32 [SPEAKER_00]: If, as had been the case since Brexit, [SPEAKER_00]: Britain has higher interest rates than the U.S. People move money into Sterling to get those very safe guilt rates. 26:44 [SPEAKER_00]: And they move it out of the dollar. 26:45 [SPEAKER_00]: And the price of the pound goes up. 26:46 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's how it could get to 1.37. 26:49 [SPEAKER_00]: Because even though the fundamentals of the British economy are bad, you park your money in Sterling, you collect your 5.5% and when you want to sell, you get out of Sterling. 26:58 [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. 26:59 [SPEAKER_01]: And you believe that the central bank and the institutions and the government are not going to default when you [SPEAKER_00]: people aren't worried about Trump defaults when it comes to the pound, the euro and the dollar. 27:11 [SPEAKER_00]: So let's leave that question aside. 27:12 [SPEAKER_00]: But now, Kevin Wars comes in and does the opposite of what Trump wants. 27:17 [SPEAKER_00]: He raises interest rates, curbs U.S. growth, and you might think, okay, great. 27:22 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, growth in Britain now looks better relative to the U.S. 27:26 [SPEAKER_00]: because it's now more attractive to sit on T-bills because the amount that you're getting has gone up 25 basis points or the implied amount, 50 basis points, but people thought he might cut rates and he's instead raised them. 27:40 [SPEAKER_00]: So then the pound goes down around [SPEAKER_00]: 50 basis points. 27:46 [SPEAKER_00]: It's gone from 1.37 to about 1.32 and it doesn't really have to do with the British economy. 27:52 [SPEAKER_00]: It's just had to do with the fact that you're now getting more interest rates. 27:55 [SPEAKER_00]: You're able to get a better deal on your T-build than on your guilt. 28:00 [SPEAKER_00]: and this is crushing because this makes that the pound buys less and if the pound buys less all Britons have just gotten less purchasing power when they're abroad. 28:11 [SPEAKER_00]: Slightly helps British exports, but this is no longer an export driven economy because the manufacturing sector has been killed and then the ability to raise funds, 28:23 [SPEAKER_00]: For Burnham, if he wants to have spending programs, each pound is worth less when he needs to go to import some of the things that they need to fix infrastructure in terms of water and defense industry. 28:36 [SPEAKER_00]: And wow, so this is what I've just been reflecting on and I just don't see a way out, Jane. 28:43 [SPEAKER_01]: No, I think you point to something that's deeply problematic. 28:47 [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I would note at least services export are still important for the UK and tourism, which is about 5% of GDP. 28:57 [SPEAKER_01]: But the bigger issue about the sort of nature of response of the bond markets is a massive one. 29:04 [SPEAKER_01]: Something I'd like to know more about is, you know, a lot of trading is going to be very mechanistic, [SPEAKER_01]: Many trades are going to be guided by AI, does that make it worse? 29:15 [SPEAKER_01]: Does that make it more likely to be knee-jerk? 29:19 [SPEAKER_01]: And less likely to take account of the complexities of current policy-making? 29:25 [SPEAKER_00]: This is a great point that I've literally not thought of in this context. 29:29 [SPEAKER_00]: I've thought of it in the fact that it is more difficult to beat the market at anything. 29:33 [SPEAKER_00]: In other words, if you could get rich in 1980 by anticipating that the pound would fall, 29:41 [SPEAKER_00]: the European exchange rate mechanism trade. 29:44 [SPEAKER_00]: That's really difficult now because it's all priced in and the AI's move one way or another. 29:49 [SPEAKER_00]: But maybe you're right that as soon as the gap opens between the Treasury rate and the rate of guilt, boom, the money just leaves the pound and goes to bitey bills where it's gonna get a better return. 30:02 [SPEAKER_00]: And then if all of a sudden, let's just say it's [SPEAKER_00]: 2027 and Kevin Ward cuts rates because the U.S. economy is growing. 30:13 [SPEAKER_00]: And here, because there's more inflation or whatever, then you need to raise rates, I'm just being hypothetical, that it's definitely those funds are gonna swing back and then the pound is gonna go from 1.31, all the way up to 1.37. 30:26 [SPEAKER_00]: And all of the positive and negative implications will almost happen instantaneously based on what the governor of the Bank of England or the Fed chair tweets or says. 30:39 [SPEAKER_01]: We should find a good guest to talk more to us about that. 30:43 [SPEAKER_00]: Jane, AI is going to be moving the money, AI is moving the betting lines on football teams, AI is going to be creating the companions that our kids go to when they want a chat with people. 30:59 [SPEAKER_00]: And now, in the last week, Bill Gates won on Ezra Klein and said we've reached an inflection point, AI is essentially going to be taking over not only from human employees, 31:10 [SPEAKER_00]: But from the very companies that created it, that AI is now getting to a point where we are subjugated to it. 31:19 [SPEAKER_00]: Isn't that great news? 31:21 [SPEAKER_01]: Hey! 31:21 [SPEAKER_01]: I, for one welcome, our robot overlords, please be nice to me. 31:26 [SPEAKER_01]: I always say please when I talk to chat GPT. 31:31 [SPEAKER_01]: Look, it's interesting that this is really hit a tipping point with the most famous names in tech speaking about it. 31:38 [SPEAKER_01]: I think this has been bubbling for quite some time that there have been concerns about AI and particularly about what could happen with artificial, general intelligence and ideas that might go wrong, that it might enslave humans, who knows? 31:55 [SPEAKER_01]: We have no idea, but there have been a lot of people from the tech world [SPEAKER_01]: doing and funding work on catastrophic risks that might emerge from AI. 32:07 [SPEAKER_01]: One criticism that some people make is that maybe we're focusing too much on the idea of they're being an apocalypse, you know, AI. 32:16 [SPEAKER_01]: becomes cleverer than our school's mad and takes over the world and that that might take away from us focusing on the more everyday and routine problems that AI is causing or at least the way we're using AI is causing like people becoming out of work and unemployed and how that ties into the 32:35 [SPEAKER_01]: into generational social contract problems we talked about. 32:39 [SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, I'm really interested when it comes to the ordering point of view in the various movements that there are for AI for good saying, you know, we need to look carefully about what we're baking into AI. 32:53 [SPEAKER_01]: I believe one of the problems with with how AI is developing is that for some reason many of the leading people 33:02 [SPEAKER_01]: who really want to develop and control AI are people who appear to really be bent on dominance or they can even display sort of psychopathic traits. 33:16 [SPEAKER_01]: They tend to be 33:18 [SPEAKER_01]: men who are extremely hierarchical, how they see the world, who don't really value the individual human experience, who are often obsessed with longevity, or with moving to Mars, who cares what happens to most of the six billion people let on this planet. 33:36 [SPEAKER_01]: You know, there is quite a worrying set of personality traits that do seem to feature among AI leaders. 33:43 [SPEAKER_01]: And then of course we have quite a [SPEAKER_01]: authoritarian or semi-authoritarian countries around the world that also want to be dominating this technology. 33:53 [SPEAKER_01]: So I think there's loads to look at in terms of how we can order AI. 33:57 [SPEAKER_01]: We are still the people making this technology and we should design it for human thriving with humanity, you know, human with values that are humanitarian and that are about progress, 34:10 [SPEAKER_01]: for everybody baked into it we could see a really beautiful form of AI and just finally because you mentioned you know the AI that will be entertaining our kids there's a movie about to come out called Clara and the Sun I haven't seen the movie but it's based on a beautiful book by the British Japanese novelist Hazel Ishiguro and it is very much about this idea of an artificial 34:39 [SPEAKER_00]: I like this, you should go a lot. 34:41 [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, his writing is very famous. 34:43 [SPEAKER_00]: I look forward to seeing this movie, Jane. 34:45 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, an AI that cares as opposed to one that pretends to care is something that I would love, but it seems that we've ended with an AI which is meant to maximize virologity. 34:57 [SPEAKER_00]: and that virality and attention in the attention economy is really at the core of everything. 35:03 [SPEAKER_00]: And I'm gonna plug again our brilliant producer, George McDonald's series with the Guardian called Black Box. 35:10 [SPEAKER_00]: And this is about how AI chat bots were deliberately created to cause addiction to them. 35:17 [SPEAKER_00]: In other words, it baked in as the same thing that the social media platforms have, YouTube, Twitter, [SPEAKER_00]: virality, addiction, and algorithms that push towards extreme content. 35:30 [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. 35:31 [SPEAKER_00]: And again, it seems like this could have been avoided, it just hasn't been. 35:35 [SPEAKER_00]: Exactly. 35:35 [SPEAKER_00]: Jane, we are what we are now. 35:38 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm pretty despondent. 35:41 [SPEAKER_00]: It may be difficult to have a podcast called disorder and be optimistic because so much of what I was afraid would happen. 35:53 [SPEAKER_00]: centrist politicians from merits to my call to starmen are have literally gone down in flames that Biden's legacy is enabling a more insane Trump term. 36:03 [SPEAKER_00]: And now Trump is so good at manipulating not only our democracy in the States, but [SPEAKER_00]: social media algorithms broad that we are seeing a right-wing wave across Latin America. 36:19 [SPEAKER_00]: In our mega-orderers bonus, we are going to discuss the Brazilian election where Bolsonaro Jr. is trying to take over. 36:30 [SPEAKER_00]: That's just for the mega-orderers. 36:32 [SPEAKER_00]: Now we want to try to order the disorder. 36:35 [SPEAKER_00]: Right now we're going to go back to the question of [SPEAKER_00]: AI, obviously no one company or one country can solve the AI problem alone. 36:44 [SPEAKER_00]: You've just come back from the UN General Assembly, Jane. 36:47 [SPEAKER_00]: What are the chances of countries actually working together functionally to order AI? 36:54 [SPEAKER_01]: So what we did see at the general assembly is that there's a real demand for this. 36:59 [SPEAKER_01]: It is difficult because most countries are not engaged in producing AI. 37:03 [SPEAKER_01]: They are consumers and the countries that are producing AI, particularly the US and China. 37:10 [SPEAKER_01]: They don't necessarily want regulation, if they do want it to be some kind of guard bills and standards, they would like to do that by laterally. 37:18 [SPEAKER_01]: And we did see that she came to Dain with Trump, and he did not drop by the UN General Assembly, which is interesting, because China normally likes to portray itself as a multilateral country, right? 37:31 [SPEAKER_01]: But I think I really do want to emphasize that the story that I saw at the General Assembly was about most countries wanting more international cooperation, not less. 37:43 [SPEAKER_01]: And that's something that you missed during the news headlines of the time because the headland coverage focuses on the most dramatic speeches. 37:52 [SPEAKER_01]: We hear Trump's going to annihilate Iran. 37:54 [SPEAKER_01]: We hear about Netanyahu speaking and people not listening to him and walking out. 38:00 [SPEAKER_01]: You know, we hear about all this. 38:03 [SPEAKER_01]: sort of superficial stuff in a way. 38:06 [SPEAKER_01]: And we miss what is actually coming from the majority of states. 38:11 [SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, most leaders are coming saying, we face international problems at require cooperation. 38:17 [SPEAKER_01]: They're also tending to say, we think that a few countries are driving the problems and that it's not fair. 38:25 [SPEAKER_01]: You know, so we have the Prime Minister of Nepal talking about the floods there and saying, [SPEAKER_01]: We are suffering from climate change, we didn't cause, and wars, we didn't start. 38:35 [SPEAKER_01]: That is a sentiment that was echoed by many. 38:38 [SPEAKER_01]: Now, there have been some cool AI based analyses of the general assembly speeches, so you don't have to read them all. 38:45 [SPEAKER_01]: And one of them, by Gabriel Euzondol from Al-Jazeera, will stick it in the show notes. 38:49 [SPEAKER_01]: He has a great infographic that shows what were the most discussed words. 38:53 [SPEAKER_01]: And the most discussed things were around UN reform, multilateralism, and sovereignty. 39:00 [SPEAKER_01]: AI was one of the top issues discussed and it was discussed more than human rights. 39:05 [SPEAKER_01]: That's a sign of the times. 39:07 [SPEAKER_01]: Many people call this the AI anger because so many leaders were speaking about it with urgency and I was struck that that included Zelensky warning about the risks of AI in the military starting to make battlefield decisions. 39:23 [SPEAKER_01]: We often get the impression that a country like Ukraine that wants to keep getting ahead with defense technology [SPEAKER_01]: wouldn't want limitations on AI and the military. 39:33 [SPEAKER_01]: So I thought it was really interesting that he was expressing that fear and saying we need peace now because the arms race is taking us in this very dangerous direction. 39:42 [SPEAKER_01]: That shows the severity of the worries. 39:46 [SPEAKER_01]: It was also interesting to me that Andy Burnham spoke about AI governance and tackling this information as priorities for Britain, knowing that these are not issues that the Trump administration really likes Britain or other European countries to be advocating for. 40:02 [SPEAKER_01]: So I think there's a changing sentiment and a big demand for that AI governance, but still a big unanswered question about who is actually going to deliver it and how do you get by 40:17 [SPEAKER_01]: like we have seen to some extent in the UK with some public bodies we're dating Palantir so that there is a message sent to the companies that they need to behave differently. 40:28 [SPEAKER_00]: There is a lot of opportunity for the UK to play a leading role in not only regulation, but in building every sort of AI breakthrough. 40:38 [SPEAKER_00]: AI is mostly done in English at the coding level. 40:41 [SPEAKER_00]: It's a ability to work with the US as critical 40:46 [SPEAKER_00]: Um, the problem, of course, is that it requires cheap energy for data centers and the UK's very bad at cheap energy, but I think that if they wanted to, that they could, you know, get the energy for these data centers and do it their own way. 40:58 [SPEAKER_00]: I'd love to see Burnham use not only the bully Paul put of his G20 presidency to focus on AI, but his swing position between Europe and the states. 41:14 [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I haven't seen anything really positive happen yet, and I'm not going to hold my breath, but he does seem like he's willing to take big swings certainly more than Starmer and being able to stand up to Trump and to say risky things is a step in the right direction. 41:37 [SPEAKER_00]: Speaking of Trump, [SPEAKER_00]: Just as we talked about peak greens and peak ferrage, might we have been seeing peak Trump because the midterms are less than a month away, Jane. 41:50 [SPEAKER_00]: That's right, the 2026 November 3rd, US midterms. 41:55 [SPEAKER_00]: So after the break, we were gonna try to order the disorder of the midterms and to talk about the state of the races. 42:13 [SPEAKER_01]: And we are back, and Jason, I'm keen to really quiz you about what is going to come out all these upcoming midterms. 42:22 [SPEAKER_01]: Have we indeed perhaps seen a peak jump? 42:26 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, I believe that if the gems had played things properly, we wouldn't have to worry. 42:32 [SPEAKER_00]: Because of the inflation, because of the mess in Iran, because of all of the hypocrisy, because of [SPEAKER_00]: him saying that the Iranians are going to bomb California because of all of the craziness it should be a slam dunk. 42:47 [SPEAKER_00]: But as we heard last week from Aaron Petrie, the Democratic Congresswoman candidate that we had on, [SPEAKER_00]: There is a debate about which Democratic messages are landing. 42:59 [SPEAKER_00]: There's a lack of unity between the DSA, progressive wing, and the centrist establishment wing of the party. 43:08 [SPEAKER_00]: There isn't unified messaging. 43:10 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm worried because what we know from when Trump won in 2016, even when the polling said that Hillary was ahead by three or four points. 43:17 [SPEAKER_00]: there is a kind of low information or what's called shy Trump voter who doesn't respond accurately to polls. 43:24 [SPEAKER_00]: So this phenomenon of the shy Trump voter tends to mean that as the thing actually happens, more Republicans turn out or the polls were slightly wrong. 43:37 [SPEAKER_00]: It is encouraging to me that Trump said, oh, I want to have mail-in votes and mail-in ballots for Republicans. 43:44 [SPEAKER_00]: When he's been against mail-in ballots, and he's had other bizarre reversals. 43:51 [SPEAKER_00]: But I'm worried, I don't see anything as a slam dunk, not, I've decided. 43:58 [SPEAKER_00]: And Michigan, not Tallahureka in Texas, not the post-grim Platner main situation when getting Susan Collins out there should be that should have been a slam dunk. 44:10 [SPEAKER_00]: So if you look at these things, Kansas Senate, Michigan Senate, [SPEAKER_00]: Iowa Senate. 44:16 [SPEAKER_00]: It's all blue in terms of the polling. 44:19 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm looking at the polling. 44:20 [SPEAKER_00]: We have sand plus 12 as the Iowa governor, turret plus four Iowa Senate. 44:28 [SPEAKER_00]: But I just don't believe it. 44:30 [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I just, I've been through this cycle enough that what's called the default ballot. 44:36 [SPEAKER_00]: We're getting 50% [SPEAKER_00]: voting for the generic Democrat in 42% for the generic Republican. 44:43 [SPEAKER_00]: That would mean a blue wave of monstrous proportions, greater than even the 2018 anti-trap midterm, where we saw a blue wave against Trump. 44:55 [SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely, that means. 44:57 [SPEAKER_00]: But I just don't believe it. 44:59 [SPEAKER_00]: In other words, I, something about my experience of American politics makes me question this polling. 45:08 [SPEAKER_00]: And I think the prediction markets are much, much tighter than the polls. 45:12 [SPEAKER_01]: Well, squeaky bum type, as we say. 45:16 [SPEAKER_01]: That's probably a British phrase, right? 45:18 [SPEAKER_00]: It is, and I never understand it, because it's frequently used in backgammon. 45:22 [SPEAKER_00]: I understand it as a British backgammon phrase. 45:25 [SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, I don't know how it squeaks. 45:27 [SPEAKER_01]: But anyway, moving swiftly on. 45:30 [SPEAKER_00]: No, no, no, no, but I'm not asking how it squeaks. 45:32 [SPEAKER_00]: I don't understand the use of the phrase. 45:34 [SPEAKER_00]: Like, like, if a back em and guy is in a position where he needs to clear the midpoint, they'll say, oh, it's squeaky bum time. 45:44 [SPEAKER_00]: And I'm like, but what about clearing the midpoint makes this squeaky bum time? 45:47 [SPEAKER_00]: So what about the fact that the midterms are close? 45:52 [SPEAKER_00]: Why is that squeaky bum time? 45:54 [SPEAKER_01]: So we are very tense because something high stakes is going to happen. 46:00 [SPEAKER_01]: And we are clenching. 46:04 [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know how it translates to clearing the bit point in back oven. 46:07 [SPEAKER_00]: But um, okay, why is that said before an important role or political race or something? 46:16 [SPEAKER_01]: Because the pressure is on. 46:19 [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, fascinating. 46:20 [SPEAKER_00]: Okay. 46:21 [SPEAKER_00]: I've understood it potentially incorrectly to mean that it's an issue of luck. 46:25 [SPEAKER_00]: Like you're saying it's not. 46:26 [SPEAKER_01]: Well, we have we have gained something from this conversation. 46:30 [SPEAKER_01]: You've learned a very squeaky bum time and I've learned something about clearing the midpoint in back haven. 46:35 [SPEAKER_01]: And hopefully soon we'll learn more about what is happening with the midterms, but I'm concerned that [SPEAKER_01]: We're just going to see a lot of silliness in the run-up. 46:45 [SPEAKER_01]: You mentioned this whole thing, you know, Trump says Iran might take out L.E. 46:50 [SPEAKER_01]: And then Gavin Newsom starts seeing he's inviting Iran to come and bomb L.E. 46:55 [SPEAKER_01]: He's not doing that. 46:57 [SPEAKER_01]: Iran's not going to bomb L.E. 46:58 [SPEAKER_01]: What is everybody talking about? 47:00 [SPEAKER_00]: They lack the technical capacity to bomb LA. 47:02 [SPEAKER_00]: They can barely bomb Europe. 47:05 [SPEAKER_00]: But what they are able to do, which is quite sad and shocking, is use sleep regions to attack our F bases. 47:13 [SPEAKER_00]: So that seems to be quite real. 47:16 [SPEAKER_00]: But I'm going to not worry to do this. 47:19 [SPEAKER_00]: Trump obviously exaggerates. 47:20 [SPEAKER_00]: They can't bomb LA. 47:22 [SPEAKER_00]: But if I was a brick working in a military base or establishment, I would think, oh my God, our country has lost the plot on domestic terrorism. 47:34 [SPEAKER_00]: So who knows whether it's an attack on Jewish community, ambulances in gold or green, or bombing empty synagogues deliberately when they're empty, or maybe doing something at an RAF base? 47:49 [SPEAKER_01]: Well, I'm worried about that because I think, you know, we have seen Iran dabble in this already. 47:56 [SPEAKER_01]: We don't know yet exactly what's happened with RAF Fairford, but it does seem that that could be plausible. 48:04 [SPEAKER_01]: We've seen that Iran has used a strategy of, you know, large scale attacks on US bases in the Middle East. 48:13 [SPEAKER_01]: in its response to the U.S. attack on it, and that has been terrible for Iran's relations with its neighbors, but they may see it as having had some strategic value because it has spread the cost of the war, and I am very concerned that they could be trying to expand that strategy 48:39 [SPEAKER_01]: We know that the IRGC has got a track record of operating in Europe but primarily to begin with it was going after Iranian dissidents. 48:48 [SPEAKER_01]: We've seen journalists from around international violently attacked in London with the IRGC thought to be behind it. 48:56 [SPEAKER_01]: I think it will make it much harder to come up with any kind of negotiated solution. 49:02 [SPEAKER_01]: I think it will make it much more toxic for Europeans to talk with Iran, which has got to be part of how we get to a solution. 49:11 [SPEAKER_01]: And I also worry that it can become a political football in domestic politics in the UK, where I think the more our parties fight about how we respond to adversaries, the more tempting it will be for those adversaries to keep picking at those homes. 49:28 [SPEAKER_01]: So I also think that our politicians, they will have disagreements, they should have disagreements, but they should try to have a broadly united front against those kinds of attacks happening in the UK. 49:41 [SPEAKER_00]: For sure, and I agree with everything you've said there, there just needs to be a more robust process of vetting not only asylum seekers, but some of these activists masks and some of these sleeper agents. 49:54 [SPEAKER_00]: And it is shocking that it's so much easier for the Iranians to carry out this attack here than in the US. 50:01 [SPEAKER_00]: There are obviously lots of people of Iranian descent in the US, and there are lots of Muslims in the US, and 50:07 [SPEAKER_00]: the U.S. is the adversary, Britain isn't fighting this war, so that it can be done here and that it's so much easier for them must be because they're already so many sleeper agents here or people who are radicalized. 50:20 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's the part that I do think that we need to call out on what's gone wrong with counter radicalization, with asylum and I guess with the 50:35 [SPEAKER_00]: police and other capital terror institutions to do their jobs. 50:41 [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I don't think it's thought to be asylum seekers in this case, but the broader picture about how we deal with these complex challenges and the radicalisation, there's going to be drawing radicalisation relating to wars in the Middle East, which would not get any better. 50:57 [SPEAKER_01]: So we are going to have to deal with the [SPEAKER_00]: No, but that sounds like you're you're excusing it fascinatingly. 51:03 [SPEAKER_01]: No, no, no, no. 51:05 [SPEAKER_01]: But I think it's a true thing that there is going to be that radicalization and we are going to accept it. 51:10 [SPEAKER_00]: No, except why is it that in the US where you would think Muslim or Iranian diaspora communities have every reason to be even more radicalized because it's the US doing the war. 51:23 [SPEAKER_00]: you're not gonna see the kind of attacks on American military installations or some of the attacks in the British Jewish community. 51:31 [SPEAKER_00]: It's just much more difficult for Iranian dissidents to operate there. 51:35 [SPEAKER_00]: What I understand this to be is just because the police and counterterror and whatever is just better, right? 51:46 [SPEAKER_01]: you're just not going to have a whole spectrum to look at here between the actual defenses, the locations, to the policing, to the intelligence, to the number of people that get radicalised in the first place, who may well not be Iranian, I mean, lots of, but the majority of Iranians here in the UK are going to be against the Islamic Republic. 52:06 [SPEAKER_01]: of course, rather than working for them. 52:08 [SPEAKER_01]: So it is a really, it is a really wide spectrum of things that you have to look at. 52:13 [SPEAKER_01]: But I think that there is part of that picture is that the levels of violence that we see in the Middle East have got a radicalizing effect and they create a bigger pool that people who want to make mischief and interfere can recruit from. 52:31 [SPEAKER_00]: It's true, because you put that hook there about events in the Middle East leaving people up into radicalization, that it can happen in Britain, though, to my mind, suggests a fibrile nature of the security services, the counterterror, the media, the ability to place social media, because it's in the US or in other more staunch allies 52:59 [SPEAKER_00]: Trump, that you would think people would have more of an incentive to attack domestically. 53:07 [SPEAKER_00]: And it seems that we've witnessed Britain become more and more of a... 53:15 [SPEAKER_00]: dysfunctional operator when it comes to counter terror and policing, whether it's phone theft, bike theft, or now these terrorism things. 53:27 [SPEAKER_01]: But I think these are very different things because I think we also need to remember that there are many attempted attacks that are foiled and that the police and the intelligence deserve a credit for those and that they put a completely different type of priority on 53:44 [SPEAKER_01]: Terrorism and counterterrorism, then they do on the phone theft and bike theft because the problem with that is that the police have basically stopped responding to those things in order to concentrate their resources elsewhere being under resource and that creates those problems that are resources for counterterrorism. 54:10 [SPEAKER_01]: We have had attacks at times when the British state in general has seemed much better functioning. 54:16 [SPEAKER_01]: You know, looking back to 77, which was the time that we had the most serious attacks. 54:21 [SPEAKER_01]: So I don't think this is a new thing or an indication of the state not functioning. 54:27 [SPEAKER_01]: And fortunately, you know, this wasn't an attack that succeeded. 54:33 [SPEAKER_00]: Okay, well, it's always important to disagree slightly agreeably and slightly disagree very agreeably. 54:38 [SPEAKER_01]: Very agreeably. 54:39 [SPEAKER_00]: We are going to call this one a day, but please join us on the mega-orderers club. 54:48 [SPEAKER_00]: for the Brazil what explains the Bolsonaro dynasty come back is a disinformation or the failures of the Lula government. 54:57 [SPEAKER_00]: If you want to check that out, get an ad for listening. 55:00 [SPEAKER_00]: Early release episodes, the opportunity to come to live events, which Jane, we really should do at the UN Association of the UK and Westminster. 55:08 [SPEAKER_00]: If you want all those things, we would like to remind you, visit disordershow.com forward slash club. 55:15 [SPEAKER_01]: These are actually the best bits. 55:18 [SPEAKER_01]: Don't forget about our YouTube channel too if you want to see us have these discussions as well as extra exclusive videos and please consider subscribing the link is in the show notes [SPEAKER_00]: Finally, for more on today's topics, we have a sub-stack as well. 55:32 [SPEAKER_00]: It's the ordering the disorder of sub-stack, where I am increasingly crafting with AI, the arguments that arise from our discussions and curating them for people who like to read rather than listen and putting in the paid for sub-stack, what comes out of the mega-order 55:58 [SPEAKER_00]: And you want to find out the Brazil thing, join the sub-stack and join the pay for version and you'll get an essay about what we discussed about Bolsonaro. 56:08 [SPEAKER_01]: Our producer is George McDonald and this order is powered by Wade Circle. 56:13 [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for listening and as always, Merry Order Mass!
Community discussion