Show full transcript 0:54 Terms apply, see CapitalOne.com for details. 0:59 We are rolling on the trial right now. 1:02 It's the start of another work day for the Dateline team. 1:05 The next morning, she doesn't show up. 1:08 Our producers are swapping tips and story ideas. 1:11 He did not say that to police, 1:13 he only said to his family. 1:14 Both said, you know, we just don't wanna mess this up. 1:16 Still had a lot of questions. 1:19 Welcome to Dateline True Crime Weekly. 1:21 I'm Blaine Alexander in for Andrea Canning. 1:24 It's November 5th, and here's what's on our docket. 1:28 In Ohio, five years after a married couple were found shot to death inside their burning home, 1:33 their business partner is on trial for their murder. 1:36 His defense attorney says the prosecution's case is based on nothing but lies and innuendo. 1:41 They're alleging that all the prosecution witnesses are unreliable 1:45 and raising questions about why they have said what they said. 1:49 In Dateline Roundup, we've got news about Lori Vallo-Debel, 1:53 aka Mommy Doomsday, and new details about the investigation into the Florida man 1:59 accused of murdering his ex-fiancé back in 2011, 2:02 hours after they appeared together on an episode of the People's Court. 2:06 There's cursing, there's name-calling, really hostile conversations. 2:11 Plus, a convicted killer escaped from a Tennessee prison last month, 2:15 sparking a multi-state manhunt. 2:17 we're talking to a former U.S. Marshal 2:20 about what it takes to track down a fugitive. 2:22 You can run, but you can't hide. 2:24 When you run, you only go to jail tired. 2:26 But before all of that, 2:27 we are off to Southern California 2:29 for the dramatic final chapter in a case 2:31 we've been following all year. 2:33 It's one that involves murder, 2:35 heartbreak, and spellcasters. 2:40 Back in July, former Navy optician, 2:43 Larry Miliette, was convicted of killing his wife, 2:46 Maya, and hiding her body. 2:48 But even after the verdict, 2:49 there have been plenty of questions. 2:52 Maya's body has never been found, 2:54 and the years that have passed since her 2021 disappearance 2:57 have worn on her friends and her family, 3:00 who have been desperate for answers and for closure. 3:03 On Monday afternoon, 3:04 they gathered in a Chula Vista courtroom 3:06 for Larry sentencing, 3:07 which was at times very emotional. 3:10 Tell us where my sister is and how to bring her home. 3:15 The court also heard directly 3:17 from Larry Miliate himself. 3:19 She wasn't just my wife, she was my best friend. 3:21 Here to fill us in on all of this is my friend 3:24 and fellow Dateline correspondent Andrea Canning 3:27 who was in the courtroom for that hearing. 3:29 Andrea, you have been covering this case 3:31 for quite some time now. 3:33 I mean, right now you're actually sitting outside of jail 3:35 waiting to go inside and talk to Larry, right? 3:37 Yeah, we're at the Vista Detention Center 3:39 in California here. 3:41 You know, we have a lot of tough questions for him. 3:43 There is a lot to talk about. 3:44 And I know that you will certainly 3:45 be the one to press him on that. 3:47 I mean, just take us back real quickly. 3:49 Remind us how all of this started. 3:51 Yeah, so, Blaine, this all started in January of 2021. 3:54 39-year-old Maya Miliette. 3:56 She vanished from her home in Chula Vista 3:58 that she shared with her husband, Larry, 4:00 and their three children. 4:02 She got out of her car. 4:03 She'd come home from work. 4:05 She walked into the house. 4:06 But she has never actually seen leaving the house 4:10 and her body has never been found. 4:12 Wow. Larry Miliette was arrested and charged with Maya's murder nine months later. 4:17 He pleaded not guilty. Finally went to trial earlier this year. 4:20 That's more than five years after Maya's disappearance. 4:24 Andrea, just remind us what prosecutors said at the trial. 4:26 Yeah, this was a very long trial. 4:28 Weeks and weeks. 4:29 The prosecution painted a picture of a marriage in trouble. 4:34 Maya was unhappy. 4:35 Her friends and family testified that she was planning to divorce Larry imminently. 4:39 we learned from various witnesses that Maya had been having an affair with her 4:44 married co-worker, which obviously none of this sat well with Larry Miliette. 4:50 You know, the prosecution argued that he was willing to go to any means to 4:53 control Maya, to stop her from leaving him, even hexes. What was that about? 4:58 Yeah. So, Blaine, our listeners will probably remember this case because of 5:02 that one fact in particular. The prosecution called an online spellcaster 5:08 as one of their witnesses. 5:10 He testified that Larry was purchasing these spells. 5:13 And the requests from Larry ranged from trying to get Maya 5:16 to not leave him, to her falling in love with him again. 5:20 But then they got more intense. 5:22 One request, even asking for Maya to suffer from an accident 5:26 and to have a broken bone. 5:28 Does the prosecution have a theory 5:30 about how Larry killed her? 5:32 So they suggested that Larry had shown an interest 5:35 in hemlock, which is a poisonous plant. 5:37 But blame the reality of all of this because Maya's body has never been found. 5:42 They cannot say for sure how she died. 5:46 Wow. And I would imagine that that's something that Larry Miliette's defense really leaned into. 5:51 Yeah, the defense was entirely about reasonable doubt. 5:53 Eventually, Andrea, after all of this, in July the jury had a verdict 5:57 and Larry Miliette was found guilty of first degree murder. 6:01 That brings us to the sentencing on Monday. 6:04 You were there. You were inside the courtroom. 6:05 What was it like covering the final chapter in all of this? 6:08 There was not one available seat in that courtroom. 6:12 It was packed, family everywhere, Maya's family, 6:16 all wearing green, ready to speak their peace, 6:19 to say how this has affected them. 6:21 But we also saw Larry's supporters there as well, 6:23 his mom and dad. 6:25 This was a long, long time coming for both sides. 6:29 And I know that in Monday's sentencing, 6:30 you really got a strong sense of who Maya was. 6:33 Can you just tell us about some of those statements 6:35 from her family and friends? 6:37 Blaine, one thing was clear, Maya was loved. 6:40 It was impact statement after impact statement 6:43 about how much she has missed, how much they love her, 6:46 what a strong presence she was in their lives. 6:50 We heard from Maya's siblings, 6:52 she was one of six children, obviously all very close. 6:56 Also her extended family and her niece especially 6:59 talked about how they feel her absence all the time. 7:02 Atia Maya's laughter is no longer her that family parties. 7:06 Her smiling face is absent from my family photos. 7:09 And we no longer hear her singing hopelessly devoted to you 7:12 by Olivia Newton-John during karaoke. 7:15 And it's a constant reminder that our family 7:17 will never be whole and quiet the same way again. 7:20 We also got a sense of just kind of what Larry 7:23 and Maya's relationship was like leading up to her murder. 7:27 Yeah, I mean, it sounds like it was this 7:28 started off really sweet. 7:30 They were very young when they got married. 7:33 But we got this sense from her sisters 7:37 that Larry's behavior just started to become controlling. 7:41 You were her love of her life, the sickness and in health. 7:46 But that doesn't mean you have to take her life 7:49 to say till death do us part. 7:51 Everything went crashing down 7:53 because of your obsessive controlling paranoid, 7:56 increasingly abusive behavior. 7:58 And then Andrea, I know a lingering question on everyone's minds. Where is Maya? 8:03 Of course, her body has never been found. That was literally in every statement from the family members. 8:10 It is not too late to do what is right. You can still tell us what may it's. 8:15 Larry, knowing that you hold the answer, is a cruelty beyond measure. 8:21 It's such an unspeakable pain on top of an already horrifically painful situation to just 8:27 not know. And then in the midst of all of that, Andrea, we got the most heart-wrenching 8:31 part of this entire thing, which was hearing directly from Maya's own children. 8:37 Yeah. And that was really hard to hear, Blaine. The two daughters made a statement, you know, 8:44 her son is young, he did not. So the prosecution, they played a video of Maya and her son playing 8:50 singing together. At that point, Larry seemed to show maybe his first sign of emotion. He 9:03 was possibly tearing up. It certainly wasn't, you know, sobbing or anything like that. 9:09 Wow. 9:10 You know, we heard from the couple's middle child and she talked about how good of a mother 9:15 Maya was. But she also talked about how great of a father Larry was. 9:20 She was awesome to me and my siblings, regardless of anything. 9:25 She was a person I would never regret having in my life. 9:28 And I know that hearing from their eldest daughter, I mean, she spoke last and really 9:32 seemed to kind of talk about how difficult of a position they're in. 9:36 Yeah, this was a profound statement. 9:38 I've heard children testified before never has a child for me dissected so much what 9:46 it's actually like to be the child. 9:49 While I feel the complicated pain of knowing as a person what he did was unimaginable and 9:54 as a human being, unforgivable, as his daughter, I cannot stop loving him, for he's the only 10:00 parent that we have left. 10:02 It's too much to ask of me to pick sides when I have so much love in my heart for both 10:06 of them. 10:07 Oh, that sounds so incredibly powerful. 10:09 We heard so many people speaking on Maya's behalf, but the defense, Larry Miliette, 10:14 also had people speaking on his behalf. 10:16 And that's when I mean things took a pretty big kind of turn walk me through some of those statements 10:21 Yeah, so first his his mom came up. She defended him. I am not a shame of you 10:27 I am proud of you because I know that she did not hurt anybody and then Larry's dad came on 10:34 He he echoed the same sentiments, but then it took a turn. There was a medical emergency 10:40 There was apparently static from the microphone that was messing with Larry's father's pacemaker. 10:49 So it appeared to keep zapping him, and he was saying, it's shocking me, you know, it's shocking me. 10:56 And then finally, after several times of this happening, he said, I need medical, I need medical. 11:02 They end up taking him out on a gurney to an ambulance. 11:05 And I mean, I believe he's okay at this point. 11:09 Wow. Yes, it was crazy. So then after all of that subsides, Larry Miliette, what did he have to say? 11:16 Yes, he talked about Maya, how much he loved and missed her, how much he wished he could have protected her. 11:21 I know I wasn't the best greatest husband, but I don't consider myself a decent great-grandmother. 11:26 I'm not a bad person. 11:28 And I know Andrea that he also spoke directly to Maya's family. How did that go? 11:33 That didn't go well. So Larry had actually finished and they had gone on to some procedural things. 11:39 Suddenly, there's a message from the defense attorney, Larry, has more to say. 11:43 He starts saying he hopes to make amends with the family, with Maya's family. 11:47 He said, I love you naming names. 11:49 I love you. 11:50 I love you. 11:50 I love you. 11:51 I'm going to start to believe, but I really love you, sister, and I miss you every day. 11:57 I could feel the tensions rising as he was saying these things. 12:01 You could just feel it. 12:03 So what happened was Maya's niece starts screaming. 12:07 This is a boiling point for her. 12:10 One day, where's Maya? 12:11 Why did you do that? 12:20 She's so upset, no one can blame her for being upset. 12:23 The bailiffs came over and they, you know, they got her to leave and, you know, 12:28 your heart just went out to her. 12:29 I mean, all of it sounds so intense, so incredibly difficult for Maya's family. 12:35 I know, Andrea, that after that it was up to the judge. 12:38 What did the judge have to say? 12:39 Yeah, well, he noted just how stone-faced Larry had been. 12:43 The Rugged Sports Court has not demonstrated 12:45 humility or acceptance of responsibility. 12:48 He has maintained a posture of denial and defiance. 12:53 He actually called him vicious. 12:55 He said that this plan was cold and calculated. 12:59 He threw the book at him. 13:00 Larry was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison for the murder. 13:04 And then in additional two years for a gun charge, 13:06 Larry pleaded guilty to after trial. 13:08 effectively 27 to life. 13:10 The judge also instituted a 10-year protective order 13:13 restricting Larry's contact with his children. 13:15 Once each child turns 18, 13:17 they can petition to have the order lifted. 13:19 But it appears though that the children 13:22 would like to have some kind of contact with their father. 13:24 So we'll see what happens with that. 13:26 Wow, okay. 13:27 And I mean, the big question again, 13:29 and all of this is where is Maya? 13:30 I mean, is that search for her body still going on, 13:33 Andrea? 13:33 Yeah, there was, I attended a press conference 13:35 after the sentencing and the DA 13:37 and the police chief talked about, again, we don't know where she is, we need to find 13:43 out where she is. 13:44 They urged family members of his, anyone who might know to come forward. 13:49 The DA said, we have our speculation. 13:50 I said, well, I asked, that was the one question I asked, well, what is your speculation? 13:54 And she would not go into details about that. 13:57 Well, Andrea, I mean, this was just a gripping account from the courtroom. 14:00 Thank you so much for bringing it to us. 14:02 Yes. 14:03 and I'm about to interview Larry, Miliette, in jail, 14:06 so we will have that full interview on the date line 14:09 that we are putting together for the future. 14:11 That is going to be a must-watch. 14:13 Good luck with the interview. 14:15 Thanks, Blaine. 14:18 Coming up, a man accused of murdering his business partners 14:20 comes face-to-face with the prosecution's star witness, 14:24 his best friend. 14:30 The mighty dollar wants a whole menu named after it. 14:35 No more. 14:36 But $1 a day lets you add progressive renters insurance to your auto insurance, something 14:42 your younger self would roll their eyes at, but your current adulting self appreciates. 14:48 Learn more at Progressive.com, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and 14:53 other insurers, average premium costs based on progressive home data from 2025, product 14:58 and prices may vary by state. 15:01 For kids, summer means freedom, and as adults summer still means freedom thanks to Mint Mobile's 15:07 summer sale. Right now, all of Mint's plans are $15 per month, even unlimited. Free yourself 15:13 from big wireless and switch to Mint for high-speed data and coverage on the T-Mobile 5G network. 15:19 All plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text, 15:23 delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. You can even bring your current phone and your 15:28 number. To get your new wireless plan for just 15 bucks a month, go to mintmobile.com 15:34 slash dateline. That's mintmobile.com slash dateline. Cut your wireless bill to 15 bucks 15:40 a month at mintmobile.com slash dateline. That's it. There's no catch. Upfront payment 15:46 of $45 for three months, 90 for six months, or 180 for 12 months. Plan required $15 per 15:52 month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50 GB may slow 15:59 when network is busy, includes up to 20 GB hotspot. Capable device required. Availability 16:04 speed and coverage varies. See MintMobile.com Granger knows if you're a procurement manager 16:10 at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while 16:14 sourcing critical supplies across the operation. Too much inventory? Costs climb. Too little? 16:19 Well, production slows. 16:21 Granger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory 16:23 helps you get what you need when you need it 16:26 so you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. 16:29 Call 1-800-GRANGER, click Granger.com or just stop by. 16:33 Granger for the ones who get it done. 16:40 On September 21st, 2021, firefighters in Belmont, Ohio 16:45 responded to reports of a house fire 16:47 at the home of Tom and Angela Strussian, 16:49 the owners of a local Tex-Mex restaurant, Salsa Joes. 16:54 When they got there, they found Angela and Tom already dead, 16:58 but not from the fire. 16:59 They'd been shot to death before it was even set. 17:03 After a years-long investigation, 17:05 prosecutors charged the Strussians business partner, 17:08 Andrew Isaac Griffin, with the grisly double murder. 17:11 This month, he stood trial. 17:13 Prosecutors told the jury that Griffin, 17:15 who pleaded not guilty, had orchestrated 17:18 an elaborate multi-state murder plot as an act of vengeance for a business deal gone bad. 17:24 The defense called the investigation sloppy and said the prosecution's star witness was, 17:29 quote, the lowest scumbag on earth. On Wednesday, jurors returned their verdict. 17:35 Here now to help us get up to speed on all of this, including what the jury decided, 17:40 is dateline producer Rachel White. Rachel, I know you've been following this case all 17:44 So thank you so much for being here. 17:46 Excited to be here. 17:47 Rachel, let's start by talking about 17:49 Destruction's Tom and Angela. 17:51 Just help us get a sense of who they were. 17:53 Sure, so Angela and Tom met on a dating app 17:56 when they were both living in Texas 17:57 and they got married about 10 years ago. 18:01 The couple then moved to Ohio where Tom was from 18:04 and they opened up Salsa Joe's restaurant. 18:07 You know, we talked about the discovery of their bodies 18:10 so many times in dateline cases 18:12 as we see where someone has set fire to the house 18:15 in hopes of covering up evidence or covering up a murder. 18:19 Let's talk about what investigators found that day. 18:22 Yeah, so the fire destroyed a lot 18:24 and so did the water from the firefighters 18:27 trying to extinguish the fire. 18:30 So we saw during the trial a prosecution expert 18:33 who testified that she was not able to isolate 18:36 any DNA or fingerprints from the crime scene. 18:39 So essentially investigators were right back to square one. When did they first start looking 18:45 at Griffin? I would imagine that as a business partner of Tom and Angeles, he must have come 18:50 under scrutiny pretty early on in this investigation, right? So investigators definitely 18:54 checked him out, but he seemed like he had a good alibi. He told investigators that he was 18:59 back in Oklahoma at the time of the murders. And when they looked at his cell phone records, 19:04 it seemed to corroborate his story. So he was kind of set aside at that point. 19:08 but that all changed in the spring of 2023. 19:12 And what happened then? 19:13 So the chief detective decided to reach back out 19:16 to Andrew Griffin, and he did not receive a response. 19:20 But he did hear from Tom's sister, Lisa Balog, 19:23 who told him that Griffin was missing. 19:26 Oh, missing, wow. 19:27 Lisa tells investigators that Griffin had driven 19:30 his truck across the border into Mexico and disappeared. 19:33 Well, that certainly caused 19:34 for suspicion there for investigators. 19:36 Now, Griffin ended up moving around after that, and eventually he was arrested in Hawaii. 19:42 But Rachel, let's talk about what exactly led up to that arrest, right? 19:46 Investigators did do a bit more digging into Griffin's financial relationship with the 19:50 Strussians. 19:51 What did they uncover there? 19:53 They figured out that Griffin had invested more than $100,000 in the business, starting 19:58 back in January 2021. 19:59 But by August 2021, without any warning, prosecutors say Tom Strushin told Griffin that he was 20:07 done with the business because it just wasn't profitable. 20:09 And they said that there was no talk of Griffin getting his money back, that investment that 20:14 he'd made in the business. 20:15 And they also said that Griffin found out a day after Tom told him that the business 20:20 was closing, he'd been locked out of his shared bank account where he'd been investing 20:24 all that money. 20:24 So Rachel, just hearing you lay out what investigators say they found, 20:29 I mean, one could certainly see why that could be a reason for anger. 20:33 So what did investigators do next? 20:35 So after that, they basically reach out to Griffin's estranged wife. 20:40 Her name is Stacy, and she mentions that Griffin's best friend was a man named Brett Cole. 20:45 So investigators decided to give him a closer look. 20:49 They subpoena Brett Cole's phone, and they noticed that on the day of the murders, 20:52 He received a call from a number that didn't match any of the numbers that he typically got calls and texts from, so it stood out to them. 21:00 And when they traced that number, prosecutors say that they discovered that that number traced back to a burner phone connected to Andrew Griffin. 21:07 And so where was that burner phone, Rachel, on the day of the murders? 21:10 Could investigators kind of pin down the location of that phone? 21:13 Yeah, so they say it was in Ohio, pinging off the cell towers close to the Stretzians home. 21:18 and investigators had a theory about how Griffin could have traveled from 21:23 Oklahoma to Ohio to commit the murders. They say that they discovered Griffin 21:28 had given Cole some money to go pick up a motorcycle for him a few weeks before 21:33 the murders and highway plate reader cameras captured that motorcycle heading 21:37 toward Ohio right before the murders took place. 21:40 Break that down for me though because even if jurors believe that Griffin was 21:45 writing that motorcycle, it doesn't automatically prove that he then went to the Strussians 21:50 home and killed them. 21:51 So how did they make that connection? 21:53 So prosecutors told the jury that they had two witnesses who could kind of tie all these 21:58 things together, starting with Brett Kool's grandfather, Arthur. 22:02 And this was a little bit unusual because the jury didn't get to see Arthur in person. 22:08 He's elderly. 22:09 He's in poor health. 22:10 and so prosecutors taped a video deposition with him 22:13 back in summer 2025 ahead of the trial. 22:16 And he told them that he overheard Griffin 22:19 making a call to Brett Cole admitting to the murders. 22:23 Andrew said, 22:24 well, I had to go get my money and I killed two people. 22:30 Wow, that's big. 22:32 Who were some of the other big witnesses during trial? 22:35 They had Brett Cole himself as well, 22:37 who, as I said, was Griffin's best friend 22:39 since childhood, his alleged co-conspirator in the murder plot, he testified subject to 22:44 an immunity deal, and he laid out all the details of the alleged plan. 22:49 He basically said that he was the one who suggested Griffin travel via motorcycle to 22:54 go carry out the murders, and he said he suggested Griffin wear a frog-tog, which 22:59 is a type of rain suit, so no DNA or blood spatter would be able to get on him as 23:04 he committed the murder. 23:05 Oh, wow. And I also understand that he testified that their plan was to focus only on Tom's 23:12 Strussian, right? That it was never to target Angela as part of any of this. 23:15 Yeah, that's right. He described what Griffin told him happened when he entered the Strussian 23:20 House that day. 23:21 He said, when he shot Tom, Angela had jumped up and ran towards him, and he then 23:29 and she all heard multiple times. 23:32 He said then, after he shot Angela, 23:36 he went back to asking Tom where the money's at, 23:39 and Tom says there ain't no money. 23:42 And then he shoots Tom and kills him. 23:44 I have to say that testimony is pretty specific. 23:47 I mean, up to a jury, that could be very believable. 23:50 Right, but Brett Kuhl is someone 23:51 the defense has told the jury from day one 23:54 that they can't believe. 23:55 Why? 23:56 Because he's a convicted felon. 23:57 And since the murders, Brett Cole has been sentenced to serve three life sentences for 24:02 sexually abusing a child. 24:04 Oh, good grief. 24:04 I mean, we're not talking about just writing back checks or any other crime here. 24:08 But if you take him out of the picture, how much is left of the prosecution's case? 24:14 I mean, Blaine, that's basically the theme of the entire defense here. 24:19 They're alleging that all the prosecution witnesses are unreliable and raising 24:24 questions about why they have said what they said. 24:27 Now there is the evidence of the burner phone and the motorcycle. Where do we 24:31 stand with that? So the defense says essentially none of that proves that 24:36 Griffin committed the murders beyond a reasonable doubt. They're really hammering 24:39 home that there's no physical evidence linking Griffin to the scene and you 24:44 know this is a circumstantial case. I mean I'm curious the defense is kind 24:54 of knocking down these things, but has the defense presented any theory of its own about 25:00 what they believe happened? 25:02 So the defense has suggested that Tom had been hanging out with some shady people before 25:08 his death. 25:09 And pretty much everybody who knew him does say that he did always carry a lot of cash 25:14 on him, that he wasn't shy about, you know, showing it off. 25:18 So I think they just really attempted to plant these seeds of doubt that Andrew Griffin 25:22 and was the only person that would have some motive to kill Tom Strushin. 25:27 So, thanks so much for being with us here today, Rachel. 25:30 Thank you for having me. 25:31 After taping our segment, jury deliberations got underway, 25:35 and after about four hours, they returned to verdict. 25:39 We the jury, being duly and panel and sworn, find the defendant guilty. 25:44 Guilty on all counts. 25:46 Griffon's sentencing is scheduled for December 1st, 25:49 and we'll bring you that update in a few weeks. 25:51 Up next, it's time for Dateline Roundup. We've got news about Lori Vallow Daybell. 25:57 Also a recently unsealed arrest affidavit sheds light on Prosecutor's decision to charge 26:03 a Florida man with the murder of his ex-fiancé 15 years after she disappeared. Plus, a former 26:10 U.S. Marshal takes us behind the scenes on how to catch a fugitive. 26:14 The mighty dollar. Once at a whole menu named after it. No more. But one dollar a day lets 26:27 you add progressive renters insurance to your auto insurance. Something your younger self 26:32 would roll their eyes at, but your current adulting self appreciates. Learn more at 26:38 Progressive.com, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Average 26:43 premium costs based on progressive home data from 2025, product and prices may vary by state. 26:50 Traditional home security only alerts you after a break-in. And that's too late. 26:54 Simply Safe is changing that. Stop. This is Simply Safe. Police are on the way. 26:59 We don't just alert. We help stop crime before it starts. 27:02 Plan starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70% off your new system with 27:07 of professional monitoring at simplysafe.com slash SXM. 27:11 Simply safe, ahead of crime in real time. 27:14 Outdoor deterrence plans start at 49.99 a month. 27:16 Visit simplysafe.com slash licenses 27:18 for alarm license information. 27:21 Over the years, I've met people whose lives 27:23 were changed forever in a single moment 27:25 in my new podcast, Before and After. 27:28 I explore what happens after that decisive moment. 27:32 Personal, powerful conversations with Cullen Kaepernick, 27:35 Jeremy Renner, Gabby Giffords, and others. 27:38 Join me wherever you get your podcasts. 27:41 Listen to all episodes of Before and After with Lester Holt now, wherever you get your podcasts. 27:56 Welcome back. Joining me for this week's roundup is Dateline producer Marissa Meyer. Marissa, welcome back to the show. 28:02 Thank you so much for having me, Blaine. 28:04 So for our first story, we are heading to Idaho, where we have an update for you on Lori Vallow Daybell, a.k.a. Mommy Doomsday. 28:11 On Monday, her defense team was in court in front of a panel of Idaho Supreme Court 28:16 justices arguing that she should get a new trial for her convictions in Idaho. 28:22 Yes. So just a quick reminder, back in 2023, she was sentenced to life in prison for the 28:29 murders of her two children, J.J. and Piley, and for her involvement in the death of Tammy 28:35 Daybell who was her husband Chad's wife. Chad was convicted of killing those three victims 28:42 and is on death row in Idaho. 28:46 So what was Monday's hearing about? 28:48 On Monday, her attorneys in Idaho argued that her trial judge made a fundamental error before 28:54 her trial. In the early stages of the case, Laurie was represented by a lawyer named Mark 28:59 means and that lawyer had also represented Lori's husband Chad. So in December of 2021, 29:07 the trial judge removed Mark Means from Lori's case saying his representation could be a conflict 29:14 of interest. Lori did not get a say in that decision. At the time, she was classified as 29:19 mentally incompetent to participate in the proceedings. Lori's attorneys argued that 29:26 that the judge's actions violated 29:28 Lori's constitutional right to choose her own lawyer. 29:31 It was an abusive discretion. 29:33 We asked this court to reverse. 29:36 How did the state respond to all of this, Marissa? 29:38 So the attorney for the state argued 29:40 that the judge's decision to remove Lori's attorney 29:43 was in her best interest, 29:45 as someone who couldn't make the choice 29:47 to remove him herself. 29:49 So I know that this hearing lasted over an hour. 29:53 or the justices were asking questions, 29:56 could you get any sort of sense which way this might go? 30:00 Not really. 30:01 The justices had tough questions for both sides. 30:05 You know, one justice kept calling 30:07 what the judge had done on orthodox. 30:10 Another justice asked whether it could be 30:12 in the death penalty was back on the table for her. 30:15 All of this is just so interesting, Marissa. 30:17 The justices now will take their time 30:19 to issue a ruling and of course we will report back 30:22 back once they have made that ruling. 30:25 Next up, we are heading down to Orlando, Florida, where we're learning more about what led 30:30 up to the arrest of Dale Smith Jr. a few weeks ago for the alleged murder of his ex-fiance 30:35 Michelle Parker. 30:37 She is the 33-year-old woman who went missing back in 2011, just hours after appearing 30:42 with Dale on an episode of the TV show The People's Court. 30:46 Now, Dale has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder, but the big question since his 30:51 arrest has been why investigators decided to make a move in this case all these years 30:56 later. 30:57 Why are we just now seeing an arrest, Marissa? 30:59 Yeah. 30:59 I mean, that has been the big question. 31:02 But now we have gotten our hands on a 46-page affidavit that investigators filed with 31:09 the court. 31:10 And according to the affidavit, investigators were able to recover new data from Dale 31:16 and Michelle's phones that they didn't have access to or wasn't readable back in 2011. 31:23 And some of this evidence includes more precise location and user data, as well as some of 31:29 the text messages between Michelle and Dale. 31:33 Let's talk about some of those text messages between Dale and Michelle, right? 31:36 They're included in the affidavit. 31:38 And just reading through them, Marissa, it sounds like they had a somewhat tumultuous 31:42 relationship. 31:43 In these messages, there's cursing, there's name calling, and it's just really hostile 31:48 conversations. 31:49 Investigators also argued in the affidavit that the more precise location data that they 31:55 now have really suggests that Dale just didn't tell them the truth about Michelle's location 32:00 at the time. 32:01 Yeah, so in his initial story to police, according to this affidavit, Dale says 32:06 that Michelle dropped off the kids at his home and left after 10 minutes. 32:10 But investigators say that Michelle's phone shows her arriving in the area 45 minutes before Dale said she did. 32:19 And surveillance video shows her truck was at Dale's house for an hour, not just 10 minutes. 32:25 There is a lot to watch in this case, and of course we will keep our eye on it. 32:30 And then finally, we've got an update in the case of Lindsey Clancy, 32:34 a former labor and delivery nurse from Massachusetts who's been accused of killing her three children 32:39 At her trial earlier this year, she pleaded not guilty saying that she was in the throes 32:44 of postpartum psychosis when she killed her children. 32:47 That trial ended in a mistrial. 32:50 Clancy was back in court on Monday, Marissa. 32:53 What happened there? 32:55 Yeah. 32:55 So, Lindsay Clancy appeared in court for emotions hearing. 32:59 There was lots of back and forth about issues that we've talked about before, including 33:04 this defense request that the judge do more to investigate whether the holdout juror followed 33:10 the law and deliberated in good faith. And the judge had something to say about that. 33:15 But didn't I do that? Didn't I bring, didn't I do a void here? Didn't I bring jurors in? 33:22 Didn't I swear them in? There are so many aspects to this case that are just under an 33:27 intense microscope. So what happens next? The judge has set a hearing for November 16th 33:32 when we'll find out when any retrial might be. 33:37 The judge said he is open to having a new trial start 33:40 in March, 2027. 33:42 Gosh, a lot of updates 33:44 on some very big stories this week. 33:45 Marissa, thank you so much for joining us. 33:47 Thank you so much, Blaine. 33:52 On October 25th, 28-year-old Jacob Morley, 33:55 a convicted killer serving a life sentence 33:57 for murder in a Tennessee prison, made a daring escape. 34:01 He cut through the prison fence, 34:03 stole a pickup truck nearby and went on the run. 34:07 Officers from local, state and federal agencies 34:09 now scouring Northwest Tennessee, 34:11 setting up checkpoints and using a helicopter 34:14 and search dogs in the hunt. 34:16 On Tuesday morning, after a nine-day manhunt, 34:18 Morley was captured in Missouri and was back behind bars. 34:23 So for our final story this week, 34:24 we wanted to find out more about what exactly happens 34:27 when someone who is potentially dangerous goes on the run 34:31 and how do investigators go about tracking them down? 34:35 Here to bring us up to speed on all of that 34:37 is retired US Marshal, Linnie DePaul. 34:40 Linnie, you are certainly the expert in this subject, 34:43 so I am so glad to have you with us 34:45 on the podcast today. 34:46 Welcome. 34:47 Well, thank you, Blaine. 34:47 Thanks for inviting me on. 34:49 I wanna first just kind of let some of our listeners 34:51 know that you are very well versed 34:53 in tracking down some of the most dangerous fugitives 34:56 in the country. 34:57 I mean, names that we all have recognized, 34:59 Certainly DC Sniper, Lee Boyd-Malvo back in 2002. 35:03 The Boston Marathon Bomber, Johar Sarnaya back in 2013, I mean, your career has spanned 35:09 decades. 35:10 First, just tell me, when you think back on some of those high profile cases, what sticks 35:14 with you the most? 35:15 As a former chief inspector with the U.S. Marshals and the former commander of the 35:20 largest fugitive task force of its kind in the world in New York, we weren't going 35:24 after, you know, turnstile jumpers and deadbeat dads, they were violent people. 35:28 So, when you target these people, I've seen it happen many different ways. 35:34 I've gone after triple homicide suspects that have thrown their hands up and started crying 35:38 and simple parole violators that sadly we've been in shootings with and whatnot. 35:43 So you take them all very serious, especially escape cases. 35:46 These people have elaborate escape plans. 35:48 They get out there, they're sleeping with one eye open and it makes life pretty tough. 35:52 But walk me through that, Lenny, to start from the moment that a manhunt is launched. 35:56 What types of things? 35:57 just kind of tick through what you're looking at to even launch such a manhunt. 36:01 You know, when you have an initial manhunt going on, you know, especially with an escape case, 36:05 it's a full court press. I mean, it's all hands on deck. The assets that are available, 36:10 aviation support, drones, canines, bloodhounds, thermal imaging, you name it, we have it. 36:17 You also have a fugitive investigation going on behind the scenes. I mean, we're flipping, 36:21 you know, that person's world upside down in an escape case, Department of Corrections, 36:25 who visited him recently. What kind of calls were made? Was he on the internet? What kind of sites did 36:30 he visit? Sometimes it's old-fashioned police work, hitting the bricks, knocking on doors, Q&A 36:35 in people. I used to love going to talk to Mom because Mom would be very important. We'd knock 36:40 on the door and, you know, hey, Mom, your son just escaped from this prison. You know, if you 36:44 knew where he was, would you tell me? Digital footprints are important, cellular intercepts,
Community discussion