0:08 If we've learned anything from the next couple of years, my publicity is last freedom and liberty are in great. 0:19 America Out Loud PULSE brings together the top experts in healthcare-related fields to keep you a feature. 0:28 Welcome to America Out Loud PULSE Radio on the iHeartRadio Network, and on the America Outloud apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa. Don't miss a moment. Join us every Friday at 5 p.m. 0:37 Eastern. I'm Dr. Randall Bock here to unpack myths, explore innovations, and give you actual insights into the world of medicine and health. Violence is a medical concern because its consequences include gunshot wounds, disability, and premature death. 0:50 Our health also depends on how we live, the choices we make, and the communities in which we raise our children. In this interview, recorded March 2025 and presented here for the first time on Podcast, Keith Abloh turns the questions toward me. We examine guns, family life, 1:06 and personal responsibility, asking what prevents violence and whether some policies intended to help can make matters worse. You're focused on the facts, and I believe that the truth empowers people. And when they try to dodge the truth, they disempower them themselves. 1:23 Right? So, um, in this case, by the way, it's such a great honor to play interviewer to you because of what you've written. You've written an incredibly thoughtful piece and article about the fact that we shouldn't be uh uh content with the myth that gun control is going to fix 1:49 crime or that it's going to change the dynamics of racial relations or rid um uh the country of black on black violence or any other kind of violence. Um, and so I'd love to hear more about why, first of all, why was that topic of interest to you? 2:08 And you're fairly intrepid, obviously, because you're not going to endear yourself to those who are. 2:14 No, I know it's a funny thing. Nobody wants to cover this topic. And uh it's um, I have to tell you, it's it's a segue from uh topic that we sort of hold near and dear to our uh professional hearts in trying to treat people with addiction. Uh so I you and I spoke 2:31 uh a few months ago about my methadone article, and everyone's you know, after watching Dope Sick and Painkiller on um you know Netflix and what other channel, um they're they're all convinced that the opioid epidemic uh was a result of oxycontin. Right, that's the standard one. 2:48 And so people get convinced and then announce fentanyl, that whatever. But but they're they're missing the elephant in the room, uh, which was the introduction of methadone maintenance and basically a paradigm shift. So thoughts, you know, as as 3:01 uh our dear leader uh Barack Obama said, elections have consequences. Well, thoughts have consequences, and um, it's a funny thing, but but the way we conceive of something uh changes you know vastly our reactions to it and those reactions on us. So for instance, 3:18 COVID, uh this little, I don't know if you ever heard of that thing, but there was a little virus around not too long ago. And the virus does its virus things, you know, flu, bad flu, uh bad flu, considering no vaccines at the time, whatever. But 3:29 the reactions to it, the way we conceived of it, the way we kind of funneled and channeled people, um, a little bit like the abattoir, you know, we we corralled our cattle in a certain way to go towards vaccines, not toward treatment, not to, you know, 3:43 we didn't do Sweden, we didn't do, you know, so so the ideas have consequences. The virus will do its virus thing, you know, guns will do with their gun thing, uh, narcotics will do their narcotic thing, but sometimes the way we react to these things have 3:56 consequences and unintended consequences. And and I was reading a uh post on X by Alex Baronson, uh, who's a very thoughtful, interesting guy, and he had similar ideas about COVID as I did at the time. Uh, he had a post today or yesterday that harm reduction you know is its own 4:16 ill. And and um, and that that's kind of so harm reduction is the concept of somewhat cushioning people um from the consequences of their of their actions, taking away the agency, taking away blame, taking away shame, all that kind of stuff. And that all 4:31 sounds well and good, but you know, anybody who's had kids realizes you can't do that and get a productive, unspoiled child. 4:39 Um so the the the these things, so so uh this actually stemmed this particular article stemmed from a conversation endless back and forth and back and forth and back and forth. I had with an educated guy. We were both squash players back in the day. He's better 4:54 than I am, um, not you know, in many ways, uh including squash. And um uh but we we have diametrically opposite opinions on this, and he uh is kind of of the DEI affirmative action persuasion that you know it's all white guilt and white privilege 5:10 and all this kind of stuff that has brought on the crime problem. And um, and I you know, back and forth, and I I just wanted to my my feeling is not color, it's culture. Um, and that was kind of the genesis of this. And I got tired of you know doing this little 5:23 picky um back and forth debating. I thought, well, he is bringing up interesting points, and I I really should address them. And while I'm doing it, you know, it's it's uh, you know, why not put them, you know, pad to paper or you know, uh stylus to pixel and and just try to get 5:39 this out. Well, I think that's great. Um, because you know, as medical people, uh, we know that if you're gonna introduce a variable into an equation, uh, you better watch what happens. That's the whole reason for double blind clinical trials. But it seems like when 5:56 you add an ingredient culturally, or you add an ingredient like you're like, well, let's just unleash this program uh into the ecosystem. 6:04 Surely not. Nothing go wrong. What could really happen? Um, and ideas are that. Ideas are, in fact, no different than a medication taken by someone. Uh, and the question is, what's it gonna do in the body? Uh, so the idea comes up hey, guns are 6:21 bad because they lead to violence and murder. 6:24 That's what's roiling our inner cities. You weren't content to go with that supposition in part because you're a critical thinker, but in part because your critical thinking is informed by the scientific method. And so when you got into this, and I know you 6:39 you have a presentation related to it, which we can launch into at any time, but sort of what was the headline or a couple headlines that you actually took away from a really deep dive into this? 6:53 This wasn't you, uh it doesn't seem to me that you start with any preconception. You may have argued with your squash player friend, but uh when I read this, it it seemed to me to be comprehensive, sober, objective, and analytical the way a 7:08 doctor would look at gun control. An admirer, a near classmate uh in the same residential uh house at at Yale called colleges, um, Berkeley College back in the day with Heather MacDonald. And she writes for uh City Journal. 7:22 She's possibly the best reporter out there. She's an attorney originally, but she's been writing, uh she wrote The War on Cops, um, and going against this narrative. So I've I've been a big devotee, and I had her on my show about a year, two years ago. 7:35 And I'm also a big fan, uh, really informed my work, the psychiatrist Dr. Anthony Daniels, aka uh his uh pseudonym, uh Theodore Dalrymple. 7:45 I think he's one of the great, great writers, uh, fabulous writer, brilliant man. Um, and he's a former socialist, and frankly, Heather MacDonald is a former leftist, and they might also still be current leftists, but obviously the left has changed and mutated. And 8:01 so they actually both write for City Journal, and their work over time has informed me in many ways. Uh frankly, uh, you know, as Theodore Dalrymple, his book uh here, it's called Romancing Opius, in the UK is called uh junk medicine, with the pun on junk 8:14 as heroine, uh, informed my narcotic treatment, frankly, uh, before I even started. I read that book before Saboxum came out. And um, you know, his conception is that uh narcotic abuse is a bad, bad thing, uh, but it's not a disease. And and this kind of 8:29 segued into the thoughts behind my metadone article. 8:32 And and frankly, you know, we get into, you know, words have consequences, thoughts have consequences, and this medicalization has consequences. So, in a sense, gun control is the methadone maintenance analog of of um of guns. For you know, 8:45 narcotics, we're gonna like supposedly right now we have you know narcotic control, um, and it's illegal and whatnot, but doesn't really stop the problem. So, in a very similar way, uh, gun control doesn't stop the problem and it no pun intended bleeds out into society. And 9:00 so I'm I'm just gonna uh bang away. 9:02 You can interrupt any time you want, we can pull these things down. Uh good, great. 9:07 Um this is uh um let's see, here we go. Uh so I'm gonna put on my glasses on because I can read better. Uh so this is just the intro paragraph. I'm not gonna go over people can stop and pause and read this if they want. Um, but the the concept here is that, you know, in in a 9:23 sense, you know, it's knives don't, you know, aren't problems. You know, you can use a knife to carve a turkey or you can stab somebody. You know, cars can be drunk in accidents, or you can do, you know, mass terror like New Orleans and Munich and 9:36 whatnot. And and so, you know, the stories always come down to you know bigger problems, societal fixes that no bans fix. Like again, we heroin's illegal, but people don't stop doing it. You know, oxycontin off, you know, fentanyl, whatever, those are illegal. People do them for 9:50 their own other reasons. And we have to kind of get at those reasons if we want to deal with the problem. And then, you know, so we think we're dealing with the problem sometimes when we have you know Black Lives Matter. Uh, the Great Society, the 10:00 1960s LBJ program, uh, people may or may not remember um or have experienced, uh, was there there to fix that. It was part of the civil rights movement, was there to fix the problem of of um you know black poverty in a sense, uh, or poverty 10:14 in general. But the the solutions uh brought their own problems, just kind of having a welfare um you know, money injection for single parenthood, yes, same thing, basically grew the problem of single parenthood. Um so I'm just gonna kind of move around, 10:31 but but basically, you know, I mentioned here, you know, the harm reduction strategies, you know, they end up encouraging the very problems they seek to solve. And uh here we see uh kind of going back uh a little bit, the history of incar bla black 10:44 and you know, incarceration of black Americans. And up to the basically, you know, 1970s, we were pretty much at a flat line. 10:52 If you want to go back to the 40s, um, you know, it actually had decreased. 10:56 If you look at the peak in 1940 or so, uh the incarceration had dropped. Now, this is supposedly the deep dark, you know, part of Jim Crow era and pre-civil rights movements and segregated schools and you know parts of the south, segregated everything, water fountains and 11:10 buses and all this kind of stuff. And and yet, incarceration rates, you know, people would love to have this type of incarceration, incarceration, I can't even say it, incarceration. Incarceration rate of black Americans now. Um, but you know, 11:23 this graph is from uh from Science uh magazine. Uh so this is supposedly science, uh, and it's called Exclusion and Exploitation, uh, the incarceration of black Americans from slavery to the present. And and so from the title, you can get the essence that uh this author 11:39 uh has a uh his Professor Christopher Muller, he's now at Harvard, um, uh has a different point of view uh from what mine is. Um and um, you know, so what is what is his point of view? Uh he argues um that uh you know he never actually actually never mentions Lyndon Johnson or 11:58 the Great Society in his efforts to ascertain this this the rationale for this increase. So I kind of helped him out a little bit here. I I put a gap uh in this say the pre- and post-Great Society. 12:09 So that's right of the blue thing here. 12:10 So you can kind of see the you know the before and after. Um he his emphasis, mind you, uh, we're gonna have to get our thinking hats on here to ponder this. Uh I'll I'll use my my thinking pose here. Uh he emphasized the impact of 12:24 deindustrialization, declining agricultural labor demand, and economic exclusion, but never um, you know, any actions by those arrested in prison. So, you know, his his you know, he's not really looking at what why people are being 12:37 incarcerated. He's kind of putting the societal you know paint job on it, on the thing, kind of you know, painting over the problem. 12:43 Um, and obviously we can't you know run any laboratory experiments to un you know unwind or rewind the great society and whatnot. It's all always messy. But you'd figure that you know the 20th century with you know lynchings, Jim Crow, so forth didn't ever produce you 12:59 know the the the incarceration rate that happened after the Great Society. And he never mentions, you know, never touches once on on the heart of it, how people live, love, raise their kids. You know, the road to hell, you know, as they say, is paved with 13:10 good intentions. And this uh you know pavement basically you know in invariably runs right through broken homes. And you know, so the this next chart is from um the very well-known um uh black author Tanahisi Coates. And he got involved with um 13:26 Marvel Comics in kind of the you know, they they wanted to basically uh you know, kind of I guess ethnically diversify uh the Marvel um universe and so forth. He's done very well with literally the Black Panther. It's a kind of a mild irony because his dad was a Black Panther. 13:46 Um, they ran a Black Panther bookstore. Um, his dad was kind of like um uh latter-day uh Mormon or Muslim. He had like five different wives running simultaneously, and Tanahisi Coates grew up obviously the the the sired by by this guy, you know, through one of 14:02 the moms, and they all had kind of this group home, it was very you know weird um kind of instance. But so but lo and behold, the hero that he winds up uh putting up through the Marvel is is Black Panther. It does it fairly well from what I gather. I haven't seen the 14:16 show anyway. Uh he in this his article is called The Black Family and the Age of Mass Incarceration, as if the age of mass incarceration just happened, you know, and he actually quotes Daniel Patrick Moynihan quite a bit. 14:28 And and Moynihan was a contemporary in the 60s of this great uh great society, and I believe he began as a Democrat as well, but but he warned uh in his famous you know 1965 report, The Negro Family, the case for national action, uh contemporary 14:45 uh with the great society, he said that that lower class behavior in our cities is is shaking them apart. Okay, fine. Um, so we need needed to deal with the crime problem. Bind you, the crime problem was just a fraction from that previous you know chart, 14:59 um what it had been. So if you go back to the 1960s, we we would love to have 1960s crime level, but they thought it was crime. And but Moynihan um you know worried about the collapse of the black family. Um, and he actually said 15:13 the principal objective of American government at every level should be to see that children are born into attacked families and that they remain so. Um so what happened in 1990 here? 15:23 I'm looking at the graph and I'm like, huh, 1990, something unfolded that set a new trend in motion, or or am I misinterpreting? Uh yeah, well, so so what what you have here is exactly right. Um, so if we look what what happened in 1990 is this this is the violent crime rate went 15:46 up. Um, and then it may very well have continued to go up, except the imprisonment rate was was lagging. So this is a lagging indicator. So crime happened, and then we started having greater imprisonments. This is the Reagan era, Reagan-Bush era. So they they had, 16:02 you know, kind of it took away some of the liberalization of sentencing, and people were basically getting incarcerated more. I'm not sure it had much to do with sentencing, frankly, but crime was going up. So more people got imprisoned. But as more people got imprisoned, finally 16:14 this rate started to go down. So I think it was I I think it's uh an issue um of effect and cause or cause and effect, one of those things. But obviously they're correlated. 16:25 But getting to you know Moynihan's um problem, he he was arguing that the collapse of the black family, not just structural oppression, was driving poverty and crime. So, you know, I think we have the Great Society, black families um break up. Uh the boys grew up 16:40 without a dad, without a role model, without a disciplinarian. Great society was like 1968 or so. Um mid-60s, 65, whatever, civil rights movement. After that, uh the non-marital birth rates um wound up going much higher. That is so blacks did not have intact families uh at the 16:59 initiation of childhood. It's some somewhat tapered off, and it's a bit stayed about this level, but it's enormously higher, 70%, versus like in the 1950s, it was 20%. Now, mind you, sure, that's that's where whites are now, higher than that. So the white families have uh 17:14 a non-marital birth rate that's probably 50% higher than what the blacks were in the 50s. And blacks, Thomas Sowell, uh the economist at Hoover Institute and brilliant philosopher in a sense, um he he says kind of blanks, blacks were doing hunky dory. Actually, their 17:31 their rate of increase of income was was the highest between the 50s and like mid-60s, much higher in general than they are now. 17:40 There's there's higher for certain upper levels, but the the middle and lower class blacks were doing better proportionally uh in this kind of uh you know Eisenhower um era than they have been since after the Great Society. We're gonna take a break right now. 17:57 Stick with us. Keith Abla will be back with us as we examine personal responsibility and what immigrant achievement tells us about opportunity. This is America Out Loud PULSE, always beat ahead. 18:10 Mom, Tyler sneezed on me directly on you twice. Let's face it, kids bring home more than homework from school. 18:19 Clear nasal spray is a gentle mist of saline plus xylitol to clean and block bacteria and viruses in your nose. And it helps rinse away what they've been breathing all day. No drugs, no rebound. Make it as routine as washing hands. Can I have a 18:35 snack? Wash your hands first. Learn more at clear.com. That's xl-e-a-r.com. 18:43 Clear, breathe better, live better. Your heart is the most crucial muscle in your body. Are you doing enough to keep it strong? Introducing the Wellness Company's Breakthrough Healthy Heart Formula, designed by Dr. Peter McCullough, now upgraded with taurine. 18:57 This daily supplement supports cardiovascular health and works to protect cells against oxidative stress, packed with D-ribose to boost heart function, taurine to help maintain heart muscular health, coenzyme Q10, and selenium citrate to help reduce risk of cardiac 19:12 disease, and a vitamin B complex with L-carnitine for energy and muscle support. Endorsed by the wellness company's chief medical board, this formula is your ally for heart health. Reclaim your health now at TWC.health forward slash outloud and use code Outloud for 20% off 19:30 your first order plus free shipping. During treatment, the structure of tap water gets messed up. 19:34 Yes, we have to purify water, but what are we doing to fix the water structure so the body can actually absorb it? That is why we created our lab certified structured water devices. These devices restore water molecules back to their natural structure just like a mountain 19:48 stream, making them highly absorbable. It's not how much you drink, it's how much you absorb that counts. Better hydration, better energy all day. 19:56 Get one for your home or on the go at ChemicalFreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. 20:55 Dr. Keith Ablaub continues asking me the questions as we examine how competing explanations for disadvantage shape our understanding of responsibility and the possibility of change. Tanahisi Coates, uh Moyne had this had this thing called Tangle 21:11 of Pathologies, and he brings up his own tangle of perils. Now, I I don't want to parse this too much. People should read this, uh, the article, I guess. Um, but this is kind of an agency. Tangle of pathologies mean there's something wrong with me. Okay, 21:24 I have to deal with it. I've got my own issues, no doubt. Uh, my wife is happy to tell me all the time, my issues and whatnot. Um, but a tangle of perils is external, means that I can't do things because they're outside. So if there's a lot of poison ivy around my house, 21:38 I don't go out. Or it could be I'm agrophobic and I don't go out. So maybe it's a little bit both. Maybe I'm too scared of poison ivy, or I'm too timid to cut down the poison ivy, or whatever. That would be something I could do actionable to change the way I want to 21:51 leave my house. But if I just keep saying, oh my God, there's poison ivy out there, I can't do it. Oh my god, you know, that's the tangle of perils. So this is kind of a paradigm shift, if you will, uh, between Tanahisi Coates and and um and Moynihan. So I bring up the 22:05 Black Panther part. Um, there's a you know, a RFK senior, we have to make that distinction now. It used to just be RFK, um, but now we have junior. But his speech writer from the 60s and whatnot, uh Adam Linksney, so a liberal, a Democrat, um, 22:20 by 1995, he was kind of expelled, you know, from polite society in the Democrat Party because he said something that Jesse Jackson said also, uh 1993 or so. Uh he said, we we shrink in fear of teenage thugs on every street. More important, we shrink even 22:35 from contemplating the forceful collective action we know is required. I thought of making this is the kind of the um epig epitaph of this article, because this is really the essence. 22:46 It's something that people think, I think it's what's the name, Juan Williams, uh, kind of got booted out of uh NPR for saying the same thing that he's fearful when he sees a black man on the street. Jesse Jackson said that you know, when he looks 22:57 back and he sees somebody's white behind him on a dark uh street at late at night, he's he has a sigh of relief. 23:03 You know, this is something that happens, but but people no longer uh can speak of it. Um, and and you know, so uh Coates kind of again with his tangle of perils, he said that you know, basically uh blacks tend to live in more criminogenic, which 23:18 is a new word for me, conditions, but with but you know, never says why those are there and how getting rid of police, for instance, or not in incarcerating criminals and gang members would would help that criminogenic condition. 23:30 And his basic feeling, and he's a Marxist, I believe. Um, you know, he he claims that black communities are victims of so-called resource extraction, his term. Um, but he never says what resource is being extracted from those black communities. You know, I mean, is there oil 23:46 on parts of Detroit and not under other gold? I mean, what what's what's being extracted from that community? You know, it's just kind of an odd formulation. Right. 23:55 His solution, mind you, is reparations. And that's you know, kind of echoes the same welfare-driven approach that fractured families under the Great Society. 24:03 It's a, I believe, a false, you know, kind of Marxian materialistic view rather than kind of the spiritual uh fix that is needed. 24:12 Um, and and you know, oddly enough, you know, despite all this claims of more racism, um, you know, amongst whites uh towards blacks and and to until very recently from blacks towards whites, there was kind of a diminution in racial perception. This is evidenced by 24:29 you know, kind of steady rise in in intermarriage. Um, and this is you know kind of the where the verb meets the road. 24:35 You know, you come home, uh, you know, and your daughter says, I want to marry, you know, it's kind of like uh the man who came to dinner, Sidney Poitiers, the famous movie. Yeah, and that that that wouldn't work today, which wouldn't work, it wouldn't be 24:46 a big, deep, big deal. You know, people are happy as well. If you're not marrying a robot or you're not marrying your right hand, or you're not marrying a goat. Um, marrying someone transgender who's a robot, exactly. Yeah, so so then yeah, there's actually a comedian 24:59 who says, you know, we look upon our our relatives as so uh antiquated, whatnot, because you know, we say we say, you know, it's we come home, it's like, oh, here's my you know, lesbian, whatever relationship. But but it's like, how are we gonna be like 25:10 50 years from now when our kids come or 20 years from now when our kids come us home and I want to marry a robot? Now we're gonna be any better. 25:17 Um question. I I hope I hope that we won't come to that, but it it seems like it will. Um so the Great Society you're saying uh seems to have been coincident with and may have fueled this epidemic of violence. And the connection you make is that it can 25:37 encouraged families to break apart because society would take care of them anyhow, and maybe you don't have to be as disciplined because society's there to pick you up if you fall. Is that and that made people listless and angry that they weren't 25:53 being effective people? Is it I mean, is that some of it? Yeah, I think it's I think it's there. I mean, I I can't put my finger on it because I, you know, it's not as sciencey as uh gravity um and whatnot, but I think I think there are forces there that that play 26:08 out. Um I I'm gonna kind of just kind of move along to make best use of of your time uh and my time. 26:14 Um, but I just think that in a sense, despite the intermarriage thing, you know, the the the the racism industry, um, you know, going back to the the marriage slide here, you know, people are more accepting of of you know different colors um than ever before, 26:30 and frankly, more than any other society on earth, contemporaneously or ever, most likely. 26:36 Um, I mean, uh that's an arguable point, but um uh but despite that, the racism industry needs to be fed. You know, we uh on this chart here, you can see you know, around 2008, um, when Obama was elected, you know, a lot of uh whites, 26:52 I guess, thought that was the breakthrough. You know, we are in a post-racial society. We have a uh, frankly, he's supposedly our first black president, but he was equally white, frankly. 27:00 He's the merger of white and black, his parents um and like he grew up in a white family with his white grandparents, and he had Indian, whatever, he's poly-ethnic, he was in Indonesia and Kenya, whatever. Um, but but not nonetheless, it's kind of the the this 27:14 is just uh you know, frequency of use in the Times post and whatnot of the racist, racist, racism, racism words, and they've really skyrocketed. I mean, look at this. 27:24 This is like lunacy. Amazing, insanity. And and so just you know, despite the you know, so-called breakthrough perceived by the majority white elector in 2008 and having elected you know Barack Obama, um the academy, you know, the the you know, uh 27:41 universities and whatnot, and our great thinkers like Tanisi Coates, you know, white privilege. This is this is from the Google Engram, the use of these words, white privilege, critical race theory, like started, and obviously these things have gone 27:52 up ever since. So we did not get fixed. And the oddity is that actually, again, um prejudice is is is on the decline. Uh, these are just uh from a you know Professor Dan Hopkins. Um uh I forget where he is, not Johns Hopkins, but Dan's Dan Hopkins. Uh he he has 28:11 an article in 538 um where he actually kind of couches it. He says, white Americans say they're less prejudiced, but but his own research uh done in academic, not 538, uh shows that that these numbers are going down amongst Republicans and Democrats. Everyone has kind 28:26 of less anti-black prejudice. Um and and you know, it's just an anti-Hispanic prejudice is on the right. So both these things are going down. Um, and again, this is wordy, so I don't expect people to, you know, they can stop and look at it if they want, but basically you can't 28:42 even look, even in our you know, modern world today of having the Library of Congress at your fingertips, you know, and a smartphone or whatnot, if you try to find out whether you know there is anti rising anti-black, excuse me, blacks anti-white sentiment increasing, which I 28:58 think has happened uh through the you know BLM and whatnot, riots and whatnot, George Floyd and so forth, um, we actually you can't almost every Google search, OpenAI, ChatGPT, Bing, Grock, whatever, they all will divert you to something bad has happened to the black 29:14 community. There's never you can't find anywhere the graph. I can't, I I wanted to include it. I can't find the similar graph to this one from like anti-white prejudice amongst blacks. 29:28 This does not exist. So if somebody has it, please inform me. But the funny thing is, you know, so this is kind of this relentless framing of white guilt, what I by what I call the racism industry, and and it becomes its own, you know, kind 29:41 of self-fulfilling prophecy. Obviously, we have the anti how to be an anti-racist, which really took over the academy. Um, in Bring Kendi, it's part of the whole kind of George Floyd uh BLM narrative. And whether it's you know uh Coates, Kendi, Al Sharpton, whatever, there's just 29:57 kind of the sensibility that that um you know things happen to the blacks, they can't break out. So I I kind of wanted to look at the the counter to that. 30:06 I mean, frankly, Nigerians and people from Ghana and West Africa in general are are former black, I mean visually blacker than than uh you know legacy uh black Americans here, which because of miscegenation and whatnot, on the you 30:19 know, slavery, whatever, and intermarriage or whatnot. I think blacks here are like uh you know, like six fifty to sixty percent African, and Africans are like hundred percent African. So so people are blacker, and yet, you know, Nigerians 30:32 who've been here pretty much just like 1.5 generations or so, coming like I guess in the 90s, you know, they they do better. 30:39 They're right in the middle of this chart here. Uh they do better than um the average of Americans in it total, right above all USA and Ghanaian uh from Ghana Americans do even better than they do. And they're pretty much on par with white Americans 30:54 who have been here for say centuries, many of them, uh, aside from obviously more recent immigration, maybe a century. And Indian Americans, you know, we're kind of median darkness of skin between blacks, uh, between Africans and and and 31:07 uh Caucasians, they do better than everybody else. 31:10 And they've been here probably, you know, an extra generation from the from the Nigerians, probably starting in the 80s and whatnot. And so, you know, what happens? Well, obviously, this cohort is a little more educated than legacy blacks. 31:20 We're on the bottom here. The black Americans are there, but but Nigerians already within one generation are doing like probably about 40% higher income than black legacy black Americans. Uh we'll call inner city or whatever. And and you know, part of it is is selection 31:35 bias because they come here having arrived with better education credentials. Fine. Um, but you know, it it's it's odd that immigrants can can figure this out and get over here and do this when we've kind of been you know trying to do affirmative action and 31:49 all kinds of boosts to you know black school districts and whatnot, uh, busing, all these programs which are there specifically to kind of raise black Americans. And what happened? Why did it not happen? Well, and you know, I'll just put in my two cents. Uh, the 32:06 motivation for said uh programs is thought to be innocuous or better than innocuous. So we want to help people. Uh, there's there are people who would say, well, that's not the motivation at all. The motivation was to uh to cause racial division, 32:22 to um harm the United States, bring it to its knees, uh, and and then put it into a big melting pot with the rest of the world and have one world government so that these DEI, DEI initiatives and the rest of it was meant to tilt America toward socialism 32:39 um and essentially dissolve it in into a non-entity um or into the great world government. And so I don't know exactly what they were looking for. I could see that it quote, it didn't work for those of us who care about people, but uh it did work. That always makes 32:58 the assumption that people want the same results as you do. Like when Mr. Obama took uh the office in in 2020, we were at that um you know Bush era um crash. Um from the uh was the savings and loan, was it not the savings loan? 33:14 It was um uh what what was the name of that? The housing bubble uh Burst. 33:20 Right. The yeah, the um mortgage crisis or whatever. Yeah, so so we were at a at a at a re you know recession depression point, and and uh Obama look went to the FDR um uh playbook of doing massive government works programs and and and flooding the zone 33:39 with money um and and borrowing and whatnot. 33:42 And I think that was all been discredited economically, but you know, but there's the assumption that he wanted the same thing as as what I did, which is a return to a bustling economy. He wanted something different, which we've seen play out. He wanted equity, which 33:56 had not been really a term of art then. He wanted kind of equal outcomes and spread money around to places and people um based on on race. So, you know, that's why we did not get the post-racial world that he um you know maybe espoused or or or promised us and whatnot. Um 34:15 so just kind of moving right along here, it's getting I pass over this quickly, but you know, Nigerian thing, this is second generation Nigerian Americans, their their number percentage of college graduates, not just attending, but graduating 74%. Um, you know, amazing legacy 34:32 white Americans um are less than half of that, and the legacy African Americans or blacks or whatever are about half of that, even so it's almost you know, it's almost like two to one to two to one. So there's almost a quarter here. I mean, you can do the math later, uh, of black 34:47 Americans, legacy uh college graduates versus Nigerian Americans who are just their one generation. Like, what's up with that? Um really interesting. It's culture, obviously, as you're making the point. That's your point. Yes, so so as far as 34:59 like earning the money, going back to that slide where the black Americans are on the bottom, you know, there's a little bit of choice here. You know, the the legacy black Americans. Um I'm I'm sorry to come up with such a cumbersome term, but until somebody 35:10 comes up with a better one, because we've got Nigerians where it's just it's not really about color. So again, Nigerians are blacker, or if you want to, you know, just look through a uh simple photography lens, are blacker than than American blacks, and and yet they've 35:24 done better. So, you know, legacy black Americans, meanwhile, you know, kind of find themselves funneled into a different lane, you know, what what I call secure but low growth government jobs, a small business, little room to soar. This is this is a study, I think, from 35:37 Pew Research Center, and the type of jobs uh from amongst, you know, that that are, I guess, business related, um, not government work, but um, you know, so they they kind of like it's more like postal workers, food service, social work, clerks, home health care. 35:53 You know, they're steady gigs, but they're rarely the kind that spark innovation or wealth. And they so there's been either a choice or um kind of a movement of towards stability over risk, you know, what's a ceiling that's mistaken for a floor. You know, you're not 36:08 necessarily going above that. And so, you know, economic independence through education trumps grievance. 36:14 And Nigerians prove it, they've turned school into success, had some schooling and whatnot. I mean, obviously, there's some Nigerians who are worse off in Nigeria than the ones who didn't come here, but you know, what Coates sees as 36:25 uh resource extraction in criminogenic conditions um ignores how violence feeds itself. And and you know, these other guys, Mueller, you know, talks about uh, you know, labor, this and that, and Kendi you know, has anti-capitalism. And Obama himself, you know, he he was kind of 36:42 in the middle of this. And and on one hand, you know, uh siding with BLM, and on the other hand, you know, you know, talking about uh, you know, need need for more black fathers at home. 36:53 So this is gonna be the end of our second segment. Stick around with us for our third. Uh, Keith Ablo will be with us for our final segment as we turn to guns, homicide, and the conditions that encourage violence. This is America Out Loud PULSE, always 37:06 beat ahead. Have you been looking for a healthy snack on the go, but all of the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy, savory bar made from just 37:18 six simple natural ingredients. Bear bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contain six grams of protein, and are low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit and are held together with syrups 37:32 or sweeteners. But bear bars are a simple and delicious combination of veggies, nuts, and seeds. 37:38 It's a perfect snack for hikes, workouts, or busy mums and dads. To learn more, just visit bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get a special offer just for listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash outlouds. 37:51 I'm Doug Evans, author of the Sprout Book. 37:54 I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. 38:12 For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere: city apartments, dorm rooms, off-the-grid cabins. 38:21 In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self-Reliance Revolution. Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash outloud and use the code Outloud for an exclusive offer. Prepare for the next pandemic with 38:38 the wellness company's Contagion Emergency Kit designed by Dr. Peter McCullough. Get life-saving medications like ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine, plus a free inebulizer and a guidebook for safe use. Order now by going to TWC. 39:01 Welcome back and thank you for listening. I'm Dr. Randy Bach here to Unpack Myths, Explore Innovations, and give you actual insights into the world of medicine and health. Dr. Keith Ablau and I now examine gun violence, asking what 39:12 comparisons between communities and countries tell us about its causes and how to prevent it. 39:19 And so we're going to turn more functional here. So, yes, you know, the United States' homicide rate is seven times greater than other, you know, what we call top-tier nations. Um with guns accounting for you know about 80% of U.S. homicides. However, you know, what they 39:36 they do is they ignore critical difference. Unlike the United States, European nations have had until very, very recently, much more homogeneous and socially stable um nations. And you know, if you include Japan, uh, you know, that's you know, 39:50 everyone says diversity is our strength, but you know, Japan is almost completely non-diverse. Like everybody in Japan is has Japanese great great grandparents. Um, and and that's you know been the case in most of these other countries 40:04 until very recently. We're gonna get into that because they're having obviously they're having in Europe they're having their own schisms and issues. You know, previous previously sedate, you know, sweet uh Sweden has like the highest rape um rate in in all of Europe. I mean it's 40:17 just not what we we're used to, you know. But right um so I'm just gonna put this out there that there's some you know kind of subdivisions. You know, this this map um looks at Europe gun holdings. 40:31 Um and they they vary. They're none of them are as high as a percentage of the US, but there are countries that have have relatively high uh gun holdings. Um, but but the you know, some of the countries with lower amounts of gun ownership don't 40:44 necessarily do that well. You can't really see the the the you know country subdivisions because the colors are blurred, blurring for sure. You know, some places like Ukraine and Syria, you know, had had because before their wars, uh very low private gun ownership, and and you 40:58 know, in a sense, leaves the civilians vulnerable, not necessarily you know, at risk during peacetime, but unprepared when a crisis strikes, and you never know when a crisis strikes. So, you know, in my view, it's kind of like you know, guns in a sense are are 41:09 keeping an emergency kit, you know, just uh sure to have gun controls in a sense refusing people the ability to have that. But um, you know, the the the gun picture is not the entire picture on both sides. 41:22 On one hand, like the UK has loads and loads of knife stabbings, their knife stabbings and deaths from ivy um far outpace our knife, knife wounds and whatnot. 41:34 And the other side is is not just about you know the violence itself, but whether guns have a secondary use and you know, the Warsaw ghetto. You know, I'm sure they would have loved to have guns on hand even prior to being ghetto-ized. And so, 41:48 you know, Europe is in flux basically. And so what we see here is Sweden, you know, previously peaceful Sweden, um, is now kind of up there with you know a lot of East Europe places, like um, you know, we don't have them here, but Salbania is 42:01 the highest, but you know, there are other parts of of former um uh Yugoslavia, Bosnia, whatnot, and Moldova next door. You know, so these um, you know, they have they have other issues, not just um gun problems. 42:15 They we I obviously have social censorship we we're seeing, and they have you know these Islamic rape gang um problems that we've seen in Rutherham. Um and the European crime is rising. So despite all their gun control, um, you know, Sweden and the Netherlands were once 42:29 paragons of safety, they're you know having huge surges in gang violence and terrorism. And Germany, you know, everyone's kind of crashing, and there may not be a gun death if they you know kill 26 people in Munich, whatever, with a car, but but they're having their 42:42 issues. And so these societal issues, I mean, if you just keep staring at the gun, um, you're ignoring the problem. Uh, and so you know, a lot of these things have to do with the people that are there. 42:51 That Sweden didn't become the rape capital because, no, frankly, because of the you know, people who had great-great-grandparents who were Swedes. They have probably rape problems because their great great people whose great-great-grandparents were in Syria or in 43:04 you know someplace else, whatever. And and that's those are the people doing. So I think you have to kind of look granularly. In the US, we always hear uh, you know, certain states with with you know lax gun control have high rates of violence, and they 43:16 always point to the south. And we're gonna get to that chart in a second, but our rates, our hot spots here by coloration, and no pun intended, are you know the ones in the west and in in Florida are Latino based, yeah, and and and the ones in the southeast basically, um, 43:34 it's the you know, the southern the cotton belt, if you will, are black. And so these things track, and not only that, but the tracking has actually gotten worse. And it's kind of you have to blur your eyes a little bit, squint a little bit to see this. But the the red has gotten 43:47 redder across the nation over the decades. So this is a problem that's a problem, and it's a problem that's gotten worse in terms of violence, but the violence is concentrated in certain areas. And so if you see the chart on the right, uh, we don't have 43:59 to modernize that a little bit to the current date, but I bet that's even redder and hotter. But again, going back to the previous uh chart, that's in the uh southeast uh kind of cotton belt um black areas, which you know run as maybe as high as like 35% black and whatnot. Um, so 44:15 this is an old old cartoon, um, but it's called this this is a street light effect. You know, if you look, you know, this guy's looking for his quarter. Uh, why is he looking here? Because it's light over here. So you you know, you can look 44:27 for something because it's convenient to look for something there, but you will never find it if you're looking in the wrong place. So you drop this thing down the alley or whatever, um, but he can't look there. So people, you know, are ignoring the problem when 44:39 they're looking at the gun control issue. And the coincidence here, if you look at the southeast, the the cotton belt, they have you know uh high rates of gun ownership. Like, oh my god, I but look, and they have high murder. Well, but not really. Again, 44:52 if you look at the the map on the left and the right, you see here that you know, these hot spots is in a very strict and gun gun control area. 45:01 If you look up in the rust belt, very strict in gun control. You know, what's up with that? You know, over all the all eastern seaboard, very strict gun control. And so, you know, you have to you know kind of blow this map up later, but you know, this the gun control has very 45:16 little to do, excuse me, that this is legal gun ownership, the amount of guns owned legally. So these things, you know, there's a lot of places where there's very few legal guns and people are killing each other. And again, that has to do with demographics uh 45:30 more than anything else, and not just demographics, but the social conditions and and what people frankly it has to do with hope. You know, Barama Barack Obama was right about uh one thing hope and change. And he's right about the hope part. When people have hope, 45:42 um, they they do better, but it can't be just blank hope and endless hope. It has to be hope with with uh accomplishment. 45:49 Um, and so you know, we we're never shy about saying, for instance, that you know, men are more likely to use guns, um, and young men are more likely to use guns than old men. Uh so we're kind of you know, we're men. Um, I'm just guessing in your part, but I can state 46:04 I'm a man. And we're part of the demographic, it's like more likely to be violent. 46:09 Okay, fine, nobody argues that. But as we're older, we're less violent than young people. But you can never talk about that. There are other instances that there is, you know, frankly, a black and Hispanic effect. And and so we see here is you know, Harvard's the 46:22 guy who inspired uh Bill Cosby during his uh great run before he was uh self, you know, right absurdly uh raping and whatnot. Uh this guy, Alf Al Alvin Poussant, uh he's the Harvard, he's narrated professor of psychiatry at Harvard. Um, he wanted 46:39 he wanted Bill Cosby to present positive images of black parenting. And he said back in 1983, this is 40 something years ago, he said black homicides rates are seven to eight times higher than whites. This is then. This is the same now. Uh today, back then, 46:55 uh homicide is the leading cause of death amongst uh young black men and continues contributes significantly to shorten lifespan of the black male. 47:03 Um, in about 89% of the cases, the black victim was killed by another black. So he wrote this in 1983. So what what you know, 1983 on this chart is on the left. Um, and here we are, it goes up to 2017. It's it's it's even worse than this, worse than ever. 47:21 So, Baltimore, you know, 40 years, not much has changed. The murder rate, you know, in predominantly black urban areas are sky high. You know, Chicago, Baltimore, St. Louis, uh, they're basically drowning in blood, and the victims and perpetrators 47:32 are overwhelmingly black. And this is not from me, this is uh, I think uh from the Chicago Tribune. Simply put, Chicago has a massive black-on-black murder problem. Um, this is uh, you know, 75% of murdered are black, uh, 71% of murderers are black, and only 33% 47:47 of the population uh classified as black. So there's an issue there. This one's gonna be hard for people to see, um, but basically, this is a regression analysis, um, uh, not a political regression, but it's a maybe a progression rate analysis as well, um, that that 48:01 does um um homicide rate versus um uh black population percentage. And so you can't really read a lot of these cities' names, maybe you can see others, but but it's a correlation. Unfortunately, uh the higher the black percentage in the city, uh 48:17 the higher the homicide rate. And this kind of comes back to the central problem of the disintegration of the family. Um, and this is over over time, going from 1960 uh to 2010. And Don Lemon, uh Don Lemon, uh of X of CNN and whatnot, he says uh himself, he said um 48:37 uh he was actually talking about Tavon Martin and George Zimmerman. Uh he said more than 70 72 percent of children in the African-American community are born out of wedlock. That means absent fathers, and the studies show that a lack of male role models express train right 48:50 to prison, and the cycle continues. Uh, so we'll take the the the brilliant words of Don Lemon there. I don't think he's wrong. 48:56 Um, what's driving this violence? People can stop and look at this if they want. Um, but basically, you know, it's it's gangster culture. 49:03 It's kind of legacy media. We certainly popularize that. You know, we looked at the last Super Bowl, we had Kendrick Lamar, he's doing gang signs, he's kind of got some war against Drake, whatnot. We can't even like say the lyrics of of the last, I don't 49:15 know, 30, 40 years of hip-hop music, unless you're black. You can't probably read the entire lyrics of most of these songs, either because they're violent or because they're using that word that must not be said by anybody except the rapper and you know, uh, you know, 49:29 certain parts of the population. But you know, there's a there's a clear uh gender divide uh in crime, as we mentioned. And with the breakup of the family, the girls, uh black girls in inner city and whatnot have done reasonably well because even in a broken 49:43 family, they have their moms as a role model, but the guys don't, you know, and so I I I kind of bring up LeBron James quite a bit because I'm I'm very, very, very impressed with his um uh career, and I know we're gonna run out of time in a second here. Um, but 49:59 uh, you know, he his mom had a crack problem, but she was wise enough to put him in a family, um uh, you know, basically have him adopted by a guy who's a football coach. And that made a big difference. So I'm gonna breeze through some of this stuff here, um, and maybe get 50:15 to some of the charts. This is kind of the fall of Bill Cosby, sadly enough. 50:20 Um, and and really get back to this kind of cross-cultural um country um experience here. And um uh just as far as Latin America, which has a lot of kind of analogs to you know Southwest UI United States crime based on Latino culture, um, there's 50:35 a lot um of homicides, and frankly, our numbers um are dwarfed there. Their numbers are much higher through uh Spanish speaking uh and I guess uh Portuguese speaking Brazil and whatnot. And though there's there's a very slight relationship with gun strictness, there's 50:53 a slight decrease, but basically everything's so much higher than what we have. Um, so this is United States gun law strictness versus versus homicide rate, very little relationship, it's mildly negative trend, but very little. Yeah. If you compare 51:07 their those countries, Latin American countries, with our kind of worst cities, uh there is a they're on par. So our nation is much less because we we're not comprised, you know, just of Baltimore and St. Louis and whatnot, but Baltimore and St. Louis levels are what 51:22 you see in Mexico, um, on Doris and uh Venezuela and so forth. Um so these are side-by-side charts, which kind of it's like you know, which of these is a lot like the other? Which shows the stronger relationship? 51:34 On the left, you see the the increase, the kind of the unfortunate positive rate of increase of more homicide, higher percentage of black population, versus on the right, um versus just kind of gun law strictness. So I think one has much more to do with the 51:49 problem. Uh, here we can kind of see where the United States falls as states versus Latin America states. So we have varying levels of gun strictness amongst our various states. So California over here on the right is a little bit lower, but so is Texas uh 52:02 compared to these Latin American countries. So I don't think there's that much really to do with gun control law statutes. And just kind of to round out the hour, as it were, um, Detroit um is in a place of of high gun control and strictness and 52:16 whatnot. Um, but uh, you know, the the the their crime problem, uh they have this kind of big kind of cultural and and color inversion um beginning in the 60s after the riots uh there, which were race riots and whatnot, and the white flight, um, black 52:32 increase, um, but the population as a whole has declined. So in the 50s, uh Detroit was literally the wealthiest uh city in the United States. 52:43 It was the top five in the world, and and it's not that now. We'll just leave it there. The population has vastly dropped at a time when the when the United States population is more than doubled. Uh so in this time, you know, you'd expect if 52:55 things were growing just with the rate of the US, it would be you know like three million people, but but no, it's a fifth of that. And so, you know, the or or fourth. And it's like, you know, things did not do well in Detroit. Uh, just kind of keeping in perspective, uh, the 53:09 United States has its problems, but they're not the worst. This kind of hard chart to read. On Doris and Jamaica, South Africa, Brazil, Tanzania, uh, Namibia. Um, are there you know, a lot of countries uh you may not want to visit right off the bat are 53:22 over here. Countries you do want to visit are over here. Uh, the United States is a place you want to visit, you just have to avoid certain of those hot spots, as it were, and or be armed. Um, and you know, I I I'm gonna put a different analogy here. Um, this is from 53:36 my Methadone article. Uh, it was often ignored. 53:39 You didn't hear anything about the opioid epidemic during the Trump first term, Trump 45. Um, opioid deaths dropped in the United States during that time. The reason for that is um because there was better economy. And so I think the answer ultimately to this is that 53:56 if you want to get fewer opioid deaths, you improve the economy. You give people actual hope. If you want to get rid of gun deaths and whatnot, you have to do what the Nigerians have done. You have to give yourself better opportunity, better hope. And that's 54:07 pretty much where we have a lot of these harm reduction aspects of kind of treating the extra aspects of this don't really work and they should be scrapped. And then it might be that some of the interventions, it's not intrinsic. I mean, you're you've never made 54:20 that point. You never would make that point that there's something you're making the opposite point. 54:24 It's not about being intrinsically black that leads to violence, it's what has been done to try to remedy the violence that can then resonate in a negative way with particular communities. 54:36 Uh 54:38 I bring up Latin America to that point because you know, depends how you grade these things. You know, most of those countries are white or you know, they have their own racial stuff. Don't get me wrong, there's all there was a slave, bigger slave trade to 54:49 Brazil than there was the United States. There's all kinds of interracial issues there. But but the point is it it's cultural. When when when people come and they don't they can't integrate to society, there's high crime. The Nigerians 55:00 come, they come educated, they're not integrating to crime, they're integrating to college. So it depends on a choice and what kind of things you nurture with the black community. I think they could have had that increase that Thomas 55:11 Sowell mentions through the 1950s into the 60s, whatnot, of increasing and becoming just like the Irish and the Italians or whatever. And and and kind of like you know, the Irish came over and Cambodians came over and like in the 80s, and and frankly, you know, 55:24 they not only don't speak English, but they don't even see our letters, they can't recognize the letters. Most of them came over illiterate in their own language, right? And within a generation, you know, all throughout the North Shore. 55:33 When I you see, if you look at the valedictorian list in those high schools, I used to I worked in Revere, all like the valedictorians all through the North Shore, Lin, Wana, they're all Cambodian Vietnamese. Like, how did that happen? Like in a generation. Well, it's 55:46 it's the tiger mom concept and the family together, it's church going, it's cohesive families. 55:52 And you know, God, God knows, you know, I didn't have the perfect family. I love my parents, but they were, you know, they argue, they yell, whatever, nothing was perfect, but it, but they were intact, they were working towards something together and they had expectations, like 56:03 you, you know, schnooky, sit down there and do your work. Okay, that's your job. You know, we're gonna do this, we're gonna get food on the table. Your job is to get smarter, you know, and to get yourself out of we we lived in five of us in a one-bedroom apartment in the bronze. 56:18 And and it's like the expectation was never gonna be that's where you're gonna be later. 56:23 Right. 56:24 Well, it worked. You got very smart to the benefit of all of us. So thanks for letting me interview you. Well, I appreciate that, Dr. Abloh. Thank you so much, Keith. 56:34 That's all for today. Remember, every myth has a solution, and every truth has the power to transform your health. Find us on America Out Loud PULSE Radio every Friday at 5 p.m. Eastern or on demand wherever you get your podcasts. Stay curious, stay informed, and we'll 56:47 see you next week. America Out Loud PULSE, always a beat ahead.
Community discussion