0:00 A ship captain faced a manslaughter charge for a sailor's death in a river in China. 0:04 The manslaughter section said high seas. 0:07 The section on murder also said river. 0:09 The Supreme Court ruled that the federal court couldn't hear that charge. 0:13 That was United States versus Weldberger, 1820. 0:16 The ship was the Benjamin Rush off Wampoa, China. 0:19 Two words in the DEA's rule can change a dispensary's rent deduction or other expenses. 0:24 The government wanted to borrow the river language from the murder section. 0:28 Chief Justice John Marshall compared the two sections. 0:32 Congress already knew how to say river. 0:34 That's a canon of construction called meaningful variation. 0:37 When lawmakers use different words and related parts of the same law, take that difference seriously. 0:43 Put the two lines next to each other. 0:45 Circle river where Congress actually wrote it. 0:48 Copy it over and you've changed where the government can bring the charge. 0:52 Now open the DEA's April rule. 0:55 Schedule 3 includes marijuana and an FDA approved product and marijuana subject to a state medical marijuana license. 1:02 Section 280E takes away business deductions and credits for trafficking in Schedule 1 or 2 drugs when a federal or applicable state law prohibits that trafficking. 1:13 Keep both pages open. 1:14 I'm Tom Howard, a cannabis lawyer. 1:16 Subscribe and we'll read the next rule together. 1:19 Now let's see what the words do at the sales counter. 1:21 Picture an Illinois dispensary with one product on the shelf. 1:25 It holds its own medical license and an adult use license. 1:31 Illinois has it reconcile the product in the store as medical cannabis inventory every day. 1:37 It still has to track its stock and sales. 1:40 In our shop, both receipts point to the same product. 1:44 Start with the product and the license. 1:46 The two words were subject to. 1:49 If the license governs the product, the product is subject to the license. 1:53 The medical license covers this product. 1:55 My reading is simple. 1:57 It's covered until something actually takes it out of that license. 2:00 The separate checkout button doesn't split the inventory because mine just takes money. 2:04 You have one sale to a patient and another one to an adult customer. 2:08 Show me where the listing tells you to start over with a separate scheduled test for each buyer. 2:14 The sale can still break DEA's handling rules. 2:17 For 280e, show me unlawful trafficking in Schedule 1 or 2. 2:22 If the product stays in Schedule 3, it doesn't trigger Section 280E. 2:27 Put the rent back on the counter. 2:29 $60,000. 2:31 40% of sales went through the medical register. 2:34 Somebody multiplies and tells you the deduction is$24,000. 2:38 They just assume the rest of the inventory was Schedule 1. 2:41 If the inventory stays covered, 280E gives you no reason to split the labels on those receipts. 2:47 That's$36,000 of expenses. 2:50 Somebody just took off the return before we could even get to the tax rate. 2:54 Ask them to put three things next to that spreadsheet: the license, the record for the product, and the act that took it out of coverage. 3:02 In HarborSide, the government won by arguing it was all one business. 3:06 So nothing got split out. 3:08 All or nothing. 3:09 Now Treasury says it might split or apportion expenses, so the 40% spreadsheet does not reflect the case law. 3:17 Show me what put the product back into Schedule 1 when it's sold to an adult. 3:22 Pull up the registration provision. 3:24 DEA expressly excludes non-medical activity from what its medical registration authorizes. 3:30 That sentence tells a registered business what it can do. 3:34 The listing tells you which marijuana is in Schedule III. 3:37 Read the two side by side and give each sentence the job the DEA gave it. 3:42 Suppose the listing said only when sold to a qualifying patient. 3:46 I just made that word up. 3:48 It's not in the rules. 3:49 With those words, who's buying becomes part of the test. 3:52 Now read what's actually on the line. 3:54 It asks whether the marijuana is subject to a state medical marijuana license. 4:00 Congress can write a use condition. 4:03 In the drug analog law, it wrote to the extent intended for human consumption. 4:07 You can put your finger on the words that make intended use matter. 4:10 Do the same thing with the marijuana listing. 4:13 Look at the approved drug containing GHB. 4:15 It can be Schedule III. 4:17 Congress separately applied penalties for Schedule I or two trafficking to certain violations involving that drug. 4:24 Same product, two provisions doing two different things. 4:28 Congress can amend the lists and federal scheduling actions can amend them under the statute. 4:33 The Schedule I entry gives way when the product falls under a different entry. 4:38 Now a sale can change the facts that tell you where the product fits. 4:42 If your cash register can amend the code of federal regulations, tell me what brand you bought. 4:47 We don't have that in our store. 4:49 A sale can be the point of diversion if it takes the product outside of the license. 4:53 Show me which term of the license or which fact about the sale gets you there. 4:58 Put the receipt next to the product history. 5:00 In some states, the first fight is whether a combined license qualifies at all. 5:05 Missouri's comprehensive license is one license for both markets. 5:09 That's perhaps a harder case. 5:11 The April order quotes the treaty's word exclusively about medical and scientific purposes. 5:16 Now look at the definition DEA actually wrote. 5:19 It asks whether the license authorizes handling for medical purposes. 5:24 Same order, same day. 5:25 The word exclusively appears in the explanation. 5:28 It doesn't appear in the definition. 5:30 Illinois issues the medical card license on its own, under its Medical Cannabis Act. 5:35 That makes the first question easier. 5:37 Put that license next to the federal definition. 5:40 Circle the medical authority, then put the tracking record for the product next to the listing and circle subject to. 5:46 Those are the two questions. 5:48 What authority did the state grant? 5:50 A medical license. 5:51 What did that authority cover here? 5:53 The inventory. 5:54 The treaty and the medical purpose language are why the agency can fight that reading. 5:59 DOJ has also said state license your alone doesn't automatically give you a federal registration. 6:05 That's a statement about registration. 6:06 If a final agency decision or court ruling addresses which licenses qualify, read exactly what it decides before you change the return position. 6:16 Because in Keysor, the Supreme Court said that courts have to work through the regulation with the usual tools before giving the agency's reading deference. 6:25 If the text answers the question, apply the text. 6:28 So ask what authority the license gives and whether it governs this product at the time of sale. 6:33 Change one fact: a carton of that product goes to a separate adult use operation. 6:39 The transfer record has a date and a destination and a carton number. 6:42 But in our example, the medical license doesn't cover that. 6:46 Now, if you can point to the event that took those units out of coverage, and if no other exception applies, look at the Schedule 1 entry. 6:53 You could find that event right at the counter if the sale took the product outside, it doesn't need a truck. 6:59 Follow the product through the tracking records and read those entries with the license. 7:05 That's the work a sales percentage can't do for you. 7:08 DEA's MedFarm order gives you an example of the kind of facts that matter. 7:13 That was an older application to manufacture Schedule 1 marijuana in Colorado. 7:18 On the default record, they didn't answer, the DEA found that the related companies had grown marijuana for the recreational market without a DEA registration. 7:27 DEA treated that as Schedule I diversion. 7:30 It denied the application and left open the separate medical application if that framework applied. 7:36 You can point to who made the product and what market it went into. 7:40 If the business actually traffics unlawfully in Schedule 1, then you have a tax fight. 7:45 Harborside sold marijuana and merchandise. 7:48 It offered free services. 7:50 The tax court found one business and it consists of trafficking in a Schedule 1 substance and denied the related operating deductions. 8:00 That was a Schedule 1 case before the split existed. 8:03 Show me the actual trafficking before you tell me how to apply that case to our rent. 8:09 Now, Treasury has said it expects guidance on expenses when a business has Schedule I or two trafficking and other activities. 8:17 There might be a real allocation question once you identify those activities. 8:22 First, show which inventory was outside the coverage. 8:25 Then we can talk about what the business actually did with it. 8:29 Treasury also said it expects a transition rule, generally covering a full tax year that includes the order's effective date. 8:38 For activities of the order moved out of Schedule 1 or Schedule 2. 8:42 That's a date to check when the guidance comes out. 8:44 The shop still needs the facts for its own return. 8:47 If all stock, in our example, stayed covered and the business had no other trafficking that triggers 280E, I'd put the full rent bill through the ordinary deduction rules. 8:58 Bring a lease, the payments, and the records of how you use the space. 9:02 On a real return, walk through a disclosure with your preparer. 9:05 Keep a reserve for tax and interest if the position fails, to be prudent. 9:10 Remember that Marshall was reading a criminal law. 9:13 If serious ambiguity survives the usual tools, there's a fallback called lenity. 9:18 In 1992, in a case about a gunmaker called Thompson Center, the Supreme Court applied the same rule to a tax. 9:26 The words it was reading also carried criminal penalties. 9:29 One setup could make a regulated short-barreled rifle. 9:33 The question was whether the combination counted as making one for the tax. 9:38 The lead opinion used lenity because the same wording carried criminal penalties. 9:43 I'd raise that as a fallback here. 9:45 A court would still need to decide whether it applies to this tax position. 9:49 Back to the river we started with. 9:50 Marshall asked which words actually reached the place where it happened. 9:55 At our counter, the medical license covers all our inventory. 9:59 Show me what took the sales to adults outside of that coverage. 10:04 Before you cross$36,000 off the rent bill using a tax that borrows its test from the criminal drug schedules, that's the part I want to see. 10:13 Subscribe and we'll read the next tax rule together. 10:16 Or get in touch with me about your licensed on the pinned comment.
Community discussion