0:00 Hi, Bill Kristol here. Welcome to Bulwark on Sunday. 0:03 Very pleased to be joined today by Bob Kagan, a foreign policy scholar at the Brookings Institution and contributor to The Atlantic and author of many important books, articles, et cetera. 0:13 And good time to talk about foreign policy, I think. 0:16 We just had this big summit. 0:17 Anyway, thanks, Bob, for joining me again. 0:19 And thanks for joining all of us. 0:21 Always a pleasure. Thanks. 0:23 So what do we make of what happened this past weekend, past week, I guess, in Shenzhen, China? 0:32 Well, I mean, as a spectacle, it was, from the American point of view, more of a clown show than anything else. 0:40 I mean, Trump sort of is bedazzled by meeting with these aggressive dictators. 0:46 They were having a field day with him. 0:49 When I was watching it, I was thinking about how they say if you're in a poker game and you don't know who the mark is or the sucker, then it's you. 0:58 That's why I felt about Trump. 0:59 I mean, here are these two guys, Xi and Putin, they know exactly what they're trying to get, and they are in the sense of getting it. 1:06 Putin, of course, trying to expand his sphere of influence in Russia, outside of Russia and Europe. 1:13 Xi Jinping is bullying Japan and other countries in the region. 1:19 And what they got from the United States was a big blessing and a big smile and a big love affair. 1:25 So it's a big victory for both Xi and Putin in different ways, but definitely victories for them. 1:32 And I think it really solidifies the image of the United States as a power in retreat led by A kind of mad king who really doesn't really understand what he's doing or who he's dealing with. 1:45 The thing that's amazing to me is I don't think he has any idea who he's dealing with, the kind of tough people that he's dealing with. 1:51 He wants to think of himself as being one of them. 1:54 But from their point of view, he's a joke. 1:56 He just lost midterm elections badly. 1:58 You're not supposed to do that if you're a strong man. 2:02 Yeah, and just the kind of people have focused on the embarrassing side of Trump. 2:07 Sucking up to Xi and Putin now, my friend, not reciprocated particularly, I wouldn't say by either of them, but it's beyond embarrassment. 2:15 It was reciprocated by Putin by further bombing of Ukraine. 2:21 And also by a strike in Poland at about the same time, which is something that we should talk about because that strike was not an accident. 2:32 It was definitely designed as a threat Yeah. 2:36 So talk about that. 2:37 I mean, why is it more than an embarrassment and an actual, you know, why are we in worse shape in a way? Are we? 2:43 Then we were a week before we already had this. 2:45 Yeah. 2:46 We're in worse shape in many, in many ways. 2:48 And I've just to focus on the Russia side of it in particular right now, because, um, Putin is moving very aggressively in Europe right now and probing to see what he can get away with. 3:01 I just mentioned most recently a missile or two maybe and a drone landed in Poland. 3:09 They landed near, within 30 kilometers, I believe, of an ongoing NATO exercise, so they were clearly a signal in response to a NATO exercise. 3:19 A NATO exercise, by the way, which is aimed at defending the Baltic states and responding to various contingencies like that, and that is what he was sending a signal on. 3:33 While he's doing that, while Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are actively discussing new security in Europe, which would roll back to basically leave Poland and other Eastern European countries fundamentally unprotected, all that is happening while Trump is smiling at them, 3:57 and I think it's a signal to Putin That he can move forward. 4:01 And I actually think the odds of some kind of Russian military action against a NATO ally either claiming a provocation or out of the blue within the next year or maybe even the next six months is high. 4:16 And I think the summit and these ongoing negotiations have significantly increased because Trump has shown, at best, indifference to the security of Europe, and at worst, a willingness to cut a deal over Europe's heads, which would basically return us to the Cold War. 4:33 That is what Putin is seeking, and that is what this new security architecture would be. 4:39 To be doing that at the time when Russia is becoming much more aggressive, I just think Putin has responded to the – he's been probing since 2008 to see how the West would respond to various acts of aggression that he's undertaken. 4:54 And it's worth pointing out, by the way, that he made this exact same demand of a new security architecture two months before he invaded Ukraine in February of 2022. 5:07 So he laid out this demand and then he invaded. 5:11 And now he's laid out the exact same demand, augmented a little bit again. 5:17 And I just have to believe there's a reasonable chance that it's in preparation for some kind of action. 5:24 And why would he want to do this? 5:26 Isn't it risky for him? 5:27 Doesn't he have his hands full with Ukraine and that kind of thing?
Community discussion