0:00 Hey, everyone. Welcome back to Bulwark Takes. 0:01 I'm Katherine Rampell, the economics editor here at The Bulwark. 0:05 Congressional Democrats are launching a probe into whether Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick or his family has financial ties into NVIDIA that may have influenced the administration's response to the alleged chip smuggling into China. 0:19 Joining me today is one of those Democrats leading the charge, ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee, Congressman Jamie Raskin. 0:26 Congressman, welcome to The Bulwark. 0:28 I'm very psyched to be with you, Katherine, and happy Thanksgiving week to you. 0:32 Likewise, likewise. 0:34 So just to start, can you break down what exactly you are looking into with the Lutnick, Cantor Fitzgerald, NVIDIA connection for our listeners? 0:44 This scandal is obviously dominating every conversation right now, but it has a lot of twists and turns, so I'm just wondering if you can lay it all out. 0:51 Every aspect of it. 0:52 Look, the Secretary of Commerce, Howard Lutnick, Has his family money tied up in Fitzgerald Cantor. 1:00 And they are very heavily invested in artificial intelligence. 1:06 And one of the lead, if not the lead companies in the world is Nvidia. 1:12 Which basically has no competition in terms of creating the most advanced AI chips that are now being used. 1:21 So right there you can see the seeds of a vast conflict of interest that he is the Secretary of Commerce who's supposed to be enforcing the export controls against export of the AI chips to China. 1:35 And now we've got NVIDIA. 1:38 Which has created all of these back channel routes to get around the export controls through various countries. 1:46 And also has been trying to weaken the export controls. 1:51 And what do you know, the Secretary of Commerce himself has been participating in the weakening and the erosion of the export controls against China. 2:01 Meantime, we've got Donald Trump and his administration saying, we will let artificial intelligence and the AI companies self-police, self-regulate, because anything that Congress would try to do or the states would try to do 2:14 or the people would try to do We just undermine our ability to beat China in the AI race. 2:21 In the meantime, they're making billions of dollars off of AI chips going to China. 2:28 So there are huge contradictions between what the back channels doing. 2:34 And there's a lot of money being made. 2:36 And could have been hundreds of billions or trillions of dollars that would have gone to America, American businesses, American And The US government through taxes paid, but instead they've opened up these side routes to get the AI chips over to China. 3:01 And I guess the last thing I'll say is Donald Trump was over in China with President Xi, praising him. 3:07 As great and outstanding and amazing. 3:10 He says he's from central casting, the brains, the looks. 3:14 He's got it all controlling 1.4 billion people under his thumb. 3:18 Never does he say a word for the Uyghurs, for the Tibetans, for Hong Kong or Taiwan or anybody under the boot of Chinese oppression. 3:28 And the third part of their little autocrats triumvirate over there, Vladimir Putin, is... 3:36 In a savage, illegal, imperialist war against the people of Ukraine, and Donald Trump is hailing him and praising him at the same time. 3:46 It's like we've gone over to the side of the tyrants. 3:50 The American people have spoken in this election and it is a repudiation and a rejection of that kind of politics where the government is just an instrument for money making for the president and his cabinet and his friends and their families. 4:04 And then the American people, well, we all can go to hell because Trump has said repeatedly he doesn't care about us. 4:11 And then as for the rest of the world, he's on the side of the autocrats and the dictators. 4:15 Right. 4:16 So let's talk a little bit more about the specific Howard Lutnick, Cantor Fitzgerald angle. 4:22 It's not just about whether his old firm, which is now run by his sons, owns Nvidia stock, right? 4:31 It holds a bunch of NVIDIA stock. 4:33 Cantor Fitzgerald also has these other extensive commercial ties to NVIDIA. 4:38 It's helped arrange billions of dollars in financing for companies in its AI business universe, financing for companies. 4:46 Data centers in Southeast Asia, for example, Cantor Fitzgerald has hosted top executives from NVIDIA at its company headquarters. 4:55 So talk me through what the actual incentives are given these financial entanglements if you are Howard Blutnick. 5:05 Well, and that's what's so interesting about it, because everybody's using the phrase conflict of interest, which, of course, it is in a legal sense. 5:13 But in a business sense, it's just a massive convergence of interest. 5:17 Donald Trump is invested in NVIDIA. 5:20 His family's invested. 5:22 Cantor Fitzgerald has all of these massive business entanglements and alliances with them. 5:29 Politically, Trump He doesn't like to go anywhere without the recently resigned CEO of NVIDIA, Mr. Wang. 5:40 And Howard Rutnick, he and his family continue to make tons of money through Cantor Fitzgerald and the relationship with NVIDIA. 5:51 And then politically, they're aligned with China. 5:53 Despite all of the fierce anti-CCP rhetoric in Congress, in reality, they're all as chummy as could be and are all on the side of the autocrats. 6:06 And all that matters for these people is that they're making money for themselves. 6:11 And they don't care if they're making money with communist tyrants like President Xi or capitalist tyrants. 6:17 I guess that's what Vladimir Putin is now. 6:20 As long as they're tyrants and they're all on the same project of making money. 6:26 And what I find so uplifting about this election, Katherine, is the American people saw it and rejected it and say, we want to get back on the path towards democracy and freedom, including free markets and fair markets for people to participate and away 6:43 from this form of tyrannical government where it operates like a mafia state. 6:48 And if you're friends with the boss, Then you can get yourself a contract or a good dirty deal. 6:53 But everybody else is just left hung out to dry. 6:56 And the reporters literally ask President Trump, well, what about the living standards of the American people and the cost of living? 7:02 And he says, I don't care about that. 7:04 And that at least is true. 7:06 He really doesn't care about it. 7:07 He doesn't give it a moment's notice. 7:09 He spends a lot more time thinking about the golden ballroom. 7:12 And the reflecting pool, which we call the Strait of Warm Ooze, or the golf course he wants to build at Haines Point in East Potomac Park, then he thinks about the economic well-being of American people. 7:24 You mentioned the... 7:26 Midterm results, obviously, you are going to be getting the gavel back. 7:30 I understand you have already sent a letter to Lutnick's son, who's now the chair of Cantor Fitzgerald, demanding answers about the company's involvement. 7:40 What are you hoping to get out of that request for information?
Community discussion