0:00 Hello, everybody. Welcome to Command Post. 0:02 I am Andrew Egger filling in for the usual host of the show, Ben Parker, joined as always by General Mark Hurtling to talk about all the stuff that's going on in military news and foreign policy around the world today. 0:15 General, thanks for coming on as always. 0:17 Yeah, well, thank you for substitute hosting for my good friend, Ben Parker. 0:22 He's getting some, as we call in the military, some R&R because he needs some time with that little toddler that he has. 0:29 And it's good to have you taking his place and giving him a chance to get some rest. 0:33 Yeah, well, don't thank me yet. 0:34 I mean, anytime Ben leaves, I feel like just wheels start coming off all over the place around here because that guy's doing like 86 different tasks that people don't even necessarily realize he's doing until he's gone. 0:45 With my newsletter with shows like this all around the whole Bulwark, he's sort of like a load-bearing pillar of the entire enterprise. 0:52 But I... 0:53 As I often do when I end up having to host this show, you know, he knows everything about everything like you do. 0:59 I'm more of like an idiot layman when it comes to all this stuff. 1:02 So we take a little bit more of an idiot layman approach of you just sort of filling me in about a bunch of stuff, which hopefully is also helpful out there. 1:09 And I wanted to start with some reporting that we got just this Monday out of CNN. 1:15 Very concerning reporting, at least on its face, and it's not quite clear about So, of course, big headline. 1:21 Wow, that would be really bad if that were to happen. 1:22 We but it's exclusive US intel indicates Iran go ahead and play that detonate a dirty bomb in Washington, sources say. 1:31 So of course, big headline. 1:33 Wow, that would be really bad if that were to happen. 1:36 We have some audio of the president being asked about this yesterday. 1:40 Let's just go ahead and play that quick. 1:42 Is there any imminent threat to 1:44 Washington DC? 1:45 Well, If there is, they will pay a price the likes of which no country has ever paid before. 1:52 But is there any reason to... 1:53 I hope it's not, but we take it very seriously. 1:56 Because they happen to be crazy. 1:59 This is why they can't have a nuclear weapon, by the way, in case people had any questions. 2:05 Now, Mark, going from at least CNN's original reporting there, my read of that, it almost seems like the president was overstating the credibility of like an imminent threat here. 2:14 I mean, can you just talk a little bit about what we do and don't know about this story? 2:18 And then we can maybe talk a little bit more abstractly about what a dirty bomb even is and what such an attack might look like if it were ever to take place. 2:25 Yeah, well, the first thing I'm happy about, to be honest with you, Andrew, is the president didn't say, oh, gee, I hadn't heard about that as he But his response to me tells me that it is something they've discussed in either the Situation Room or the Oval Office. 2:41 And he does know about it, although I'm not sure he comprehends exactly what it is. 2:46 But then the second response of, well, if they do, they're going to suffer the consequences, is not really the kind of response I would have liked to appear, which is we're Actively gaining intelligence on it and trying to prevent it 3:00 as opposed to waiting until it happens and then bombing the hell out of Iran. 3:05 Yeah, so it seems like it indicates that there is some type of threat. 3:10 But when you go deeper into the CNN reporting, the article was a relatively short one. 3:15 They had six sources from the intelligence community. 3:19 They did not say which intelligence agency gave the four reporters the information. 3:26 But basically, they also said this is in the plans. 3:30 It's not like it's going to be executed anytime soon, but there are indicators they are planning courses of actions to do it. 3:38 And from the sources, they said they actually have potential locations for this to be planted. 3:45 But I got to tell you, that's really jumping far ahead of what could possibly be the truth behind this dirty bomb. 3:53 Yeah, yeah. 3:54 So let me just drill in on that a little bit, because I think it can be hard, actually, for people like me, for Lehman, to really know what to do with these reports about what essentially amount to contingency plans from military leaks, military strategy leaks. 4:10 I mean, I think back to, I believe, earlier this year when there was a news report that Canada was for the first time ever released You know, making military contingency plans for if America were to invade over the border. 4:23 And of course, that does say something about the state of the world, right? 4:27 But it also doesn't necessarily mean we should be increasing our own threat assessment as we're just sort of sitting here thinking about what things to worry about in a given day that that even necessarily needs to cross the threshold 4:40 into something we're really thinking about at all other than just as a fact of the world that we know about that this is going on in the military minds up there. 4:47 Where does a report like this rank on that scale for you as we're just kind of sitting here? 4:53 It is something where the military classifies threats when they get intelligence or information into three different categories. 5:03 Most likely, most dangerous, and least likely. 5:07 Now, when you have something like this, it is probably falling into the least likely but most dangerous category. 5:14 I mean, the implications of having a dirty bomb explode in Washington, D.C. 5:18 is pretty significant. 5:19 And truthfully, these are the same kind of of early warnings, or as they call them in the intel community, chatter that was occurring before 9-11, that something was going on, they weren't quite sure what it was, they're indicators of Something to do with airplanes. 5:37 So you really didn't have a whole lot of solid intelligence. 5:40 So there are people, there are analysts in the various 18 intel agencies who are saying, hey, what am I looking for? 5:46 If this is a potential operation conducted in the United States, what kind of things should be looking for? 5:52 And what I did... 5:54 Yesterday, actually, Andrew, I put together a short piece for The Bulwark, which will appear either sometime today or tomorrow, about exactly the implications of something like this, because there's a lot of dynamics of a so-called dirty bomb that You know, 6:10 just the phrase dirty bomb sounds kind of scary. 6:14 And when it's tied to radioactive activity, you get a little bit nervous. 6:18 But what's the rest of the story? 6:20 Has there ever been one of these before? 6:23 What kind of damage could it cause? 6:25 What kind of fear factor? 6:26 It's a terrorist weapon, no doubt about that. 6:29 But I think we need to need a little bit more about it. 6:32 And that's what we can talk about now. 6:34 Sure. Well, let me just go right to, I mean, not to spoil your whole piece for future website readers, but I do think that, you know, people have a mental picture for what a nuclear weapon would look like, and they know what conventional bombs look like. 6:46 I mean, the idea of a dirty bomb is more theoretical in people's minds. 6:52 So can you just talk a little bit about, and again, I don't want to overstate this. 6:56 This is a very hypothetical possibility. 6:58 This isn't something that the people consider imminent at all. 7:02 But if Iran were to try or any actor were to carry out an attack like this in D .C., what do we think that would entail? 7:09 What would the explosion look like? 7:13 What Well, like you were saying, I mean, most people, when you talk about radioactive or nuclear weapons, they think about the film that everyone has seen on Hiroshima or Nagasaki, where there's this mushroom cloud coming out and the blast and the radiation effects. 7:29 So heat, blast and radiation are the three components of any kind of nuclear weapon, whether it's hitting the ground, above ground or anything like that. 7:38 That's not what this would be. 7:39 When you're talking about a dirty bomb, and I'll just give my layman's approach. 7:44 I've never seen one, never worked with one, because there haven't been a whole lot around. 7:49 There's been a couple that we can talk about in a minute. 7:51 But it would likely be radioactive material, not the same kind you would use in a nuclear weapon, but actually potentially even radioactive waste. 8:03 Mixed in a container with some type of explosive device, TNT, a fertilizer, it would be the equivalent of an improvised explosive device. 8:15 And the blast of that weapon would be however much TNT or explosives, syntax, that they put into the container that was going to explode. 8:29 You know, let's think about the potential of the, you know, people remember the Boston Marathon bomber. 8:35 Those were cookers, small, you know, literally pots that someone had mixed a device into and they exploded under pressure and damaged a whole lot of people because they included ball bearings and screws and they acted as shrapnel. 8:51 Instead of acting as shrapnel, a dirty bomb might have that same kind of explosive device that But with radioactive material that will spread over either a large or a small area. 9:04 Now, all of that depends on the size of the explosive. 9:08 If you get a stick of TNT mixed with some radioactive material and it explodes, you're going to get the effects of a stick of TNT and you're likely not even going to see the radioactive stuff until you get some type of Surveillance equipment 9:25 that says, hey, there's radioactive dust in this area. 9:29 So it would be contained in the explosive area or where the wind might blow it. 9:35 Now, those are all dangerous. 9:37 But think about that, Andrew. 9:38 You're talking about citizens who are going to be told, hey, a dirty bomb just exploded with radioactive waste in it. 9:46 In Washington, D.C., and if you live near DuPont Circle and it was blown up there, you're going to be concerned about it. 9:53 You're going to say, oh my gosh, can I drink my water? 9:56 Can I go outside? 9:57 Can I take my baby for a walk? 10:00 Those are all the kinds of terror aspects of something like this. 10:03 So that basically describes what the kind of weapon is. 10:07 And by the way, there have only been two, through my research, I found there's only been two Dirty bombs. 10:17 Both of them were found and diffused before they went off. 10:21 Both of them were in Russia, both conducted by Chechnyan authorities or Chechnyan terrorists. 10:28 And both of them were found before they went off. They were diffused. 10:31 So we really never know what would happen if they would have exploded. 10:36 Can I just ask, and maybe this is a silly question, but why is it that this is not something that we have seen you know, groups that want to inspire terror reach for more often. 10:46 Is it just that they're difficult to assemble and handle and bring around. 10:51 Why do you think we haven't seen more before? 10:54 Well, they're hard to put together. 10:55 I mean, if you're a terrorist and you want to put together a dirty bomb, You're going to be handling radioactive waste to put it in with the explosive device. 11:05 You're going to be transporting radioactive waste. 11:09 So it's going to be in the back of your car or in an airplane, and that will send off signals. 11:14 So those are all the kinds of things that you talk about where you're not only handling the stuff as the individual putting it together, and you're going to probably have some kind of radioactive poisoning, but it's going to be easier to pick up 11:29 So those are probably the two key reasons. 11:33 Yeah. So setting aside the logistics of that, let me just ask you a little bit about the psychology of Iran here, because I think, like you said before, it would be good for Trump to be more focused on the interception and prevention of these sorts of plans than the promises 11:48 of future retribution. 11:50 But there would be future retribution. 11:51 I mean, it would be, this is something that the experts in the CNN article are unanimous on and It just seems obvious that if Iran were to carry out an attack like this, you know, it would be an escalation in the war that we would then, you know, 12:05 further escalate far beyond what we have seen yet. 12:08 Do you think that there is going to be, I guess, just how do you assess the psychology of Iran's leadership here? 12:14 Do you think that they, in theory, could be willing to push things this far with their backs against the wall? 12:20 Or is this more like, you know, again, just sort of contingency planning here? 12:24 Yeah, I think you have to consider it as a potential contingency. 12:27 And here's why. 12:29 They know the psyche of our president. 12:31 They know exactly what he's going to do next. 12:33 They know that even a small device in Washington that's called a dirty bomb because it spreads a little bit of radioactivity is going to be seen by the American people of, hey, the president now really has to do something. 12:47 You know, this is beyond the pale. 12:49 We've now been attacked. 12:51 It is their response in an asymmetric way, which we're seeing more and more of, of using the psychology of the individual they're going against to persuade him to do more things, commit more troops. 13:05 And the president had said multiple times that he's potentially considering invading Iran. 13:12 And if he did do that, what are the repercussions of that? 13:16 How much would it draw America into a fight that would be much more devastating to the military forces and Our national image than what we saw in Iraq. 13:28 I mean, you're talking about a country, as we said a couple of times, of Iran, that's three times bigger than Iraq, that has 92 million people, which is much larger than Iraq. 13:38 And we were in Iraq for 14 years. 13:41 Imagine the fact that Iranian citizens are going to see this as even more of an existential threat, and they're going to have There are insurgencies within that country which would damage a conventional force that we might send in. 13:58 This is not something you can deal with, with special operators. 14:00 Yeah, yeah. Well I sure hope we will not ever get to the point where we have to be contemplating these hard decisions and again this is a report specifically about Iranian planning to do this that we have intelligence on And it remains 14:15 to be seen whether they would ever even try, let alone succeed in pulling that off. 14:19 But thanks for General Hurtling for breaking that story down. 14:23 I want to turn now off of Iran and our conflict there, go a little north of there, a little east. 14:30 Donald Trump is in Asia this week. 14:34 He had a stop in the Philippines yesterday. 14:36 He's heading through a couple of these conferences. 14:38 But the big headline event comes tomorrow when President Trump is planning to have, is reported to be having, a one-on-one meeting with President Putin in China. 14:50 And then there's also going to be this trilateral meeting with Trump and Putin and Chairman Xi of China. 14:58 What are you looking at? 14:59 What are you expecting to see? 15:01 What are you hoping to see or fearing to see out of this trilateral? 15:04 Can you just sort of talk us through that? 15:06 Well, you know, this is tough, Andrew. 15:10 I mean, I've tried to think about What is happening? 15:14 Because whenever a key figure like a president of the United States goes to meet with foreign leaders, the State Department and the national security apparatus usually puts together what the objectives of the visit are. 15:27 We don't know what the objectives are. 15:29 He's about to shake hands in this photograph with a guy who has become a pariah on the world stage, who has conducted criminal activities in terms of an invasion, who has an indictment by The Hague against some of his actions of committing war crimes. 15:46 And standing next to him is a guy that seems to be doing his very best, and that's President Xi, to co-opt some of our intellectual property in terms of artificial intelligence chips. 16:00 So my question would be, and by the way, let's add another figure to this. 16:05 The president says he also wants to meet with Kim from North Korea. 16:10 What are the objectives there? 16:13 Because the last time he met with him, which was six years ago, there were all kinds of promises about Kim eliminating his nuclear program. 16:21 And yet in the last couple of years, the North Koreans have sent soldiers to Russia to fight against Ukraine. 16:27 They have continued to test ballistic weapons system. 16:30 They have continued to expand their nuclear program. 16:32 So those objectives weren't met. 16:34 So I'm going to go back in a way to answer your question is, what do you think we want from this? I don't know. 16:42 I mean, it seems like what the president has mostly talked about when he's in a domestic environment are some of the buildings that he's setting up, his teleport, his ballroom, and the renovation of the West Wing. 16:58 So what he said in terms of what he wants is a big parade when he gets there, which he got yesterday. 17:06 I mean, a grand welcoming ceremony. 17:08 There's going to be lunches. 17:10 But my question is, what are his talking points? 17:13 What are his objectives? 17:14 What has his staff prepared for him in a book where he says, this is what I want to get out of this visit with all these Asian nations? 17:25 I don't know, because he's dealing with a guy who's been at war against one of our partners in Ukraine and another guy who's stealing our intelligence in terms of artificial intelligence chips. 17:38 Is he going to scold them? 17:40 Not likely. 17:41 Is he going to make some kind of new deal? 17:44 Not likely. 17:45 Are they going to try and play him? 17:47 Absolutely, because that seems to be the effect we've seen every single time. 17:51 And this is not Trump derangement syndrome playing out here. 17:55 There has been nothing from the administration saying what it is the president is trying to achieve in this visit. I haven't read anything. 18:03 Have you read anything? 18:04 No, no, you're right about that. 18:05 I mean, and I think when you listen to the specific things that the president himself has said, it's been very strange to see because the biggest thing that he has been at pains to tell reporters is the stuff that he's eager not to talk about. Right. 18:19 He has explicitly said repeatedly that he doesn't think that the Ukraine war will come up in his conversations with Putin. 18:25 I kind of think Putin disagrees with that, by the way. 18:26 I think Putin will jump at the opportunity to continue to bend Trump's ear like he always does about how Zelensky is truly the aggressor in that war. 18:35 And probably say things like your two guys, Witkoff and Kushner, are doing a great job and they're really super and we all know they're not. 18:42 So anyway, I'm sorry I interrupted, but that's that case with Putin. 18:46 Yes, 100%. And then with Xi, we heard just yesterday, I think it was just yesterday, when Trump was weighing in on this NVIDIA scandal and the internal rifts in his administration over how hard of a policy posture they want to have 19:01 toward China, which Is directly working against U.S. policy. I mean it has been U. 19:06 policy to keep the most advanced NVIDIA chips, AI chips out of Chinese hands because of the importance to the U .s. 19:14 of maintaining a technological advantage over China in the AI race And it, of course, has been the policy of China to try to get around those controls any way they can. And everybody knows this. 19:23 And they've had a lot of success in that, by the way. 19:25 China has. 19:26 But when Trump is asked about this yesterday, he sort of explicitly made the point that there's a faction within the White House that wants to take a more conciliatory stance on this issue because they don't want it to be an impediment to making some different kind of deal 19:43 with China. 19:44 And it's like, well, what other kind of deal with China is more important than I mean, like this is this is sort of like one of one of the things separating you. 19:51 But it seems like he's still thinking about, you know, a trade relationship and and these, you know, rare arts and who knows what what all else. 19:57 But it's just it is very strange, like like what you what you just said about that, that the asks are not obvious. 20:03 And in fact, most of what we're hearing from Trump is, well, don't expect me to ask about these key issues because because I don't want to make waves. I mean, is sort of the vibe that he is giving going into these talks.
Community discussion