0:00 Hey everyone, it's me, Sam Stein, manager of The Bulwark, and I'm joined by Andrew Edgar, who, Andrew, let me see your teeth. 0:06 No, we're not doing this, absolutely not. 0:09 He asked me if he had cereal in his teeth, and he does not have cereal in his teeth. 0:13 That's not what we're here to talk about. 0:14 We're here to talk about Elon Musk, who apparently thinks we just don't have any short-term memory, or long-term memory, I suppose. Any memory at all. 0:23 We exist in the eternal present. 0:26 Maybe Elon Musk believes the AI bots have already taken over and can just zap us like Men in Black style. 0:33 He appeared virtually at a New York Times Dealbook Summit on Wednesday. 0:36 We're recording this on Thursday morning. 0:38 It was interviewed by Andrew Ross Sorkin. 0:40 It was classically awkward in the Elon sense because of the virtual element, but also because he's just like an awkward dude. 0:49 But... 0:50 The big news, of course, as you probably have heard by now, is that he is now trying rapidly to distance himself from MAGA. Let's play. 0:59 Basically, we can only do short clips because we don't want to get screwed by the times and also credit to the times. 1:05 Let's pay a short clip of him trying to distance himself from MAGA. 1:08 Oh, MAGA, whatever. I mean, I'm not MAGA -er. 1:10 Well, at least I don't like... 1:11 I'm sure what MAGA means, but I don' think I'm like... 1:15 If that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don't have that. 1:22 All right. 1:24 I buy it. 1:27 He's convinced me. I get it. 1:29 Yeah. What did you think? What does MAGA really mean anyway? 1:32 When you really stop and think about it, you know, you start to come to the conclusion that, you know, there isn't necessarily one set of policies and it's sort of a strange label. 1:42 And why would anybody ever? 1:43 I mean, Elon. Come on, man. 1:45 Like, you might not know what policies MAGA quite sets out, but it wasn't all that long ago that you were basically the guy who was picking them. 1:53 Like, you were the policy driver for what MAGA is in the White House for like a hot four or five months in there. 1:59 Oh, I thought you meant picking policy. 2:02 I thought you meant picking candidates, but you did that too. 2:05 Yeah, both of those things. 2:06 I mean, like, any way you slice it, like, yeah, it's true that it's a completely... 2:13 of amorphous and difficult to pin down concept. 2:18 And mostly what it has meant over the years is Donald Trump. 2:21 Sure, but that's always been the case. 2:22 Yeah, mostly it's meant Donald Trump, But it hasn't only met Donald Trump in particular during the sort of Elon era. 2:29 Before we get into all the ways that it's bullshit That he's trying to say he's not MAGA. 2:34 Like, what is it? 2:35 I guess it is worth sort of stepping back and trying to find what MAGA is. 2:39 It's a movement, but is that it? 2:41 Like an amorphous movement? I don't know. 2:43 It's Donald Trump's movement. 2:45 And that has had a lot of different characteristics over the years, depending on which direction Donald Trump has been trying to pull it and which other people have been in it as fellow travelers alongside Donald Trump. 2:55 But at any given point in time, what MAGA is, is the set of people who are willing to say, Trump is our leader. 3:03 We're going with him no matter what. 3:05 And that's the long and short of it. 3:07 It's Donald Trump's movement. Then your belief is it can't last past Donald Trump. 3:11 Well, we'll see. I mean, no, I mean, I really don't think so. 3:14 I don't think there will be people, I mean, there will be things about MAGA that are around. 3:19 But do you think that people will continue to self-identify with that label five or ten years after Trump? I don't think so. 3:25 Oh, no, wait, no. Yes, sorry. 3:27 Yes, they will try. 3:28 No, there's a difference between will they continue to self-identify with that label? 3:32 Of course they will because they want to, they're going to be people who are trying to vie for ownership of it, right? 3:37 Like it's a pretty potent label and you're going to say, I'm true MAGA. 3:39 Yeah. 3:40 I'm the rightful inheritor of it. 3:42 Will they be effective at doing that? 3:44 No, because I think to your point, it is a Trump thing. All right. 3:46 So if we've established that MAGA is essentially the movement led by Donald Trump, then it's very evident that Elon Musk is MAGA because he has been the biggest supporter of that movement with respect to Trump. 4:00 So just a few little data points here. 4:02 Elon, during the last campaign, spent about $446 million to elect Republicans. 4:10 Of that, he gave about $5 million to the pro-Trump MAGA Inc., okay? 4:15 Super PAC. 4:17 And he gave, in 2024, $240 million, so almost a quarter billion dollars, into pro-Trump campaign groups. 4:25 So between those two, we're talking about almost like $750 million, or $700 million. 4:33 Yeah, you do that for a few cycles, suddenly you're talking about real money. 4:36 You're talking about real money. 4:37 Now, he did go, during the, we should play this, he did express regret about spending that money, and then we could get into the other ways he is obviously MAGA. 4:46 I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and not seeing much for it. 4:51 Or maybe it would have been much worse without that. 4:57 First of all, that money, people have to understand, it's not a rounding error, but it's like the equivalent of someone spending, like a normal income person spending that like 80 bucks. 5:04 Yeah, like maxing out to one candidate or something. 5:07 Yeah, but actually not even that. Not even that. 5:09 Yeah, it's not that much for him. 5:12 He does feel foolish about it. 5:13 He did, among the more foolish investments was Ken Paxton. 5:16 We'll get to the Texas stuff in a bit. 5:18 All right, so. 5:20 Here are some other ways in which we can describe Elon effectively as MAGA. 5:26 Producer Matt, just start putting up stuff and we can comment on it in real time. 5:31 Let's start with the tweets. 5:31 I almost feel bad about this. This is like shooting fish in a barrel stuff. 5:34 We're going to be here. We're going to forensically prove that Elon was MAGA. 5:40 Here we go. 5:40 Let's roll.
Community discussion