0:01 Welcome to BrainStuff, a production of iHeart Podcasts. Hey BrainStuff, Lauren Vogelbaum here. When you get up in the morning, if you took a second to think about it, would you have a pretty good idea of what you're going to eat that day and when you're going to eat it? 0:19 The foods and the mealtimes that we encounter on any given day can feel routine, but they're really a weird intersection of a lot of societal factors. Not just local availability and personal preference, but also social class and economics 0:35 and familial structure and corporate marketing. Modernly, in many places around the world, three meals a day are common, a breakfast, lunch, and dinner. And you probably have specific ideas about when these should be eaten, and what counts as appropriate food 0:51 for each, and whether additional snacks are good or bad. 0:56 But have you ever stopped to wonder why? Have we always eaten like this? Is there any biological reason to eat three meals a day? Today, let's talk about the history of the three-meal-a-day structure and how it's still changing. 1:11 One of the reasons why I'm so interested in food and do so many episodes on this show about it is that it's both a physical necessity and a facet of culture. You know, in addition to being something important that you do so that you don't die, it's also 1:26 a source of pleasure and entertainment. and creating it requires craft and skill. Throughout history, people have eaten based on both of these aspects, necessity and culture, with different pressures shaping exactly what that looks like. First off, electricity and 1:45 inexpensive electric lighting has vastly changed how we move through the world in general. For millennia before that, people oriented more of their routines around available sunlight. it would have been pretty expensive to use candles or lamps to artificially 2:00 light kitchens and rooms in order to prepare and serve food, so evening dinners would have been a luxury. Also, early morning breakfasts would have often been scant and simple before a. 2:12 the sun came up to light your work and b. 2:14 you got a fire going and started in on food preparation, which also took a lot longer before modern appliances and other conveniences made the work easier. In ancient Egypt, for example, the norm was two meals a day, one light one 2:29 in the morning and a heavy one in the late afternoon. 2:32 In ancient Rome, the main meal of the day also fell in the afternoon, right around 4pm, with light snacks eaten in the morning and around noontime. It was considered unhealthy to eat more than one full meal a day. 2:44 A quick etymology note here about the word meal. The first time I looked into any of this, I had guessed that the meals, as in the times that we eat, And the meals, as in the ground-up grains, you know, your cornmeal, oatmeal, etc., I figured both came from the 3:01 same linguistic root and probably indicated the importance of these grains to our ancestors' diets. But they're actually from two totally different root words. The grain meal comes from the Proto-Indo-European root mele, meaning crush or grind. This meaning has 3:18 been around sort of forever. The eating time meal didn't come about until around the 1200s CE, from the root for measure, through the Germanic word meal, meaning a measure of time or an appointed time. The 1200s are when 3:34 this word began to apply exclusively to first special occasions where you gather and eat, and then to any eating session. 3:43 In medieval European towns, religious observance helped shape meals. people who attended morning mass wouldn't have broken their nightly fast until afterwards. This is where we got the word breakfast from, right around the middle of the 1400s. Breakfast was still 4:00 a lighter meal at the time, involving leftovers and bread from the previous day, plus maybe additional protein that could be cooked up quickly over a new fire, in the form of eggs. As far as I can tell, eggs are a breakfast food in some cultures just because they 4:16 cook fast. Similarly, preserved meats like cured sausages and bacon are already made, you don't have to go butcher an animal, and quick to heat up. Around this time, laborers in England would have followed breakfast with a light midday meal 4:32 called a beaver or a moonshine, and had their main meal of the day later, after work. The more well-to-do might have chosen either midday or after-business hours for their main meal. But the nobility shirked all of this. they 4:47 might have not risen early enough to need or want breakfast, and favored a sometimes sprawling, heavy midday meal starting around 11 a.m. or noon that they called dinner. This was the first meal of their day, and the word dinner 5:01 comes to us through the French language rooted in the Latin for break one's fast, or sayunare. So, dinner originally meant breakfast, and was eaten at what we would now consider lunchtime. Note here that the word dinner has maintained 5:18 its midday connotation for some English speakers, particularly in the UK, I think, though I did also grow up with my grandparents in Ohio using it that way. Meanwhile, back in the 1300s, the word supper developed to describe a usually 5:35 light evening meal. It came to English again from French, and from the practice of having a heavy midday meal and then a less formal repast of maybe just bread and soup, Soup? Supper? Yeah, later on in the evening. 5:50 Over the centuries, the fashionable time for the upper class and royalty to eat a day's main meal shifted later and earlier and later again. By the middle of the 1600s, the word luncheon came to describe a sort of light 6:04 meal in between heavier ones. Luncheon originally meant a chunk or thick slice of something, like cheese or bread, so the connotation was definitely to more of a snack than a full meal. A play from 1652 said that lunching is intermediary, which is a great word unto itself. The 6:24 shorter-term lunch developed a little later, but around the same time. So, we have all of the roots of our modern three meals a day by the turn of the 1700s, but those meals wouldn't cement themselves into what we would recognize 6:38 today until the Industrial Revolution changed well, it changed a lot of things, but key here are A, how people work and attend school, and B, the creation of packaged, branded products. Here in the United States, by the late 6:55 18 to early 1900s, breakfast became a quick, simple fuel for your day. A midday lunch, a casual situation either packed with you or obtained on the go, And the evening meal, pushed later with the advent of electric lighting, was the main meal of the day, called either dinner 7:13 or supper. Previously, the average worker would have spent all day around their family, and kids were more likely to be at home. But with these shifts in work and school, breakfast and or an evening meal became the family connection points. 7:30 And yes, marketing absolutely influenced this. and developments in nutrition science, which marketers bent to their advantage. Take breakfast, for example. 7:43 The makers of packaged products noted that this was an area for growth. Some people were just having bread and a coffee. Breakfast cereals came out of wellness and purity campaigns of the 1890s, claiming that plain, cooked whole grains, 7:58 sanitarily packaged, were good for your health. As we said above, bacon was already a natural choice for a quick morning meal, but it only became a traditional part of American breakfast plates when a nephew of Sigmund Freud, one Edward Bernays, 8:13 ran a successful PR campaign for a bacon packaging company in the 1920s, claiming that doctors recommended a larger meal at the beginning of the day. Sliced bread showed up in the 1930s and drove a new market for toasters, 8:27 which would later drive markets for other foods like toaster pastries. 8:32 Orange juice joined the meal after World War II, when makers of frozen OJ concentrate capitalized on fears of vitamin deficiency to push their product. Amidst all of this, the concept of a big, sit-down, familial evening meal solidified going 8:49 into the mid-century, partially as a reaction to families being scattered to the winds during the day. It became seen as a way to catch up and to instill family values, which was also pushed through movies, television, and commercials. As 9:06 part of this, snacking became sort of vilified, or at least seen as an indulgence that would ruin your square and morally upright dinner. The sheer pressure on middle-class women to provide perfectly nutritious and delectable dinners through the 1950s 9:21 and 60s is part of what spurred the feminist movement of the 1960s and 70s. Of course, mealtimes and expectations thereof didn't play out in exactly the same way everywhere. 9:35 Some cultures, like parts of France and Mexico, developed a leisurely and social lunch as a main meal of the day. Others, like parts of Spain and Italy, developed light meals during the daytime and saved the heavier, more social one for 9:49 long after sunset. a bunch of cultures have a designated mid-morning or mid-afternoon drink and snack time built into their days. 9:59 And now... our meal patterns are changing yet again. Busier schedules, economics, more screen time, the availability of prepared packaged foods, the ubiquity of fast food, the whole snack food industry, and even the development of meal delivery apps have all influenced 10:17 what and when we eat. From the early 1970s to 2010, the number of Americans who eat three square meals a day declined from around 75% to around 60%. Just for example, a 2025 poll of Americans by YouGov found that over 85% of millennials and Gen Xers still eat breakfast, but a 10:39 full 26% of Gen Z doesn't. And that's not necessarily a bad thing, nutritionally speaking. Human bodies are complicated, and every body works a little differently, but all unbiased evidence points to our health being influenced by what and how 10:56 much we eat overall, not so much when we consume it. 11:01 There is some evidence that eating too close to bedtime, say within an hour or two, will spike your blood sugar and insulin, which can lower your melatonin, which can all make it harder to sleep. But other than that, 11:15 Scientists basically recommend eating when you're hungry when possible. You know, to pay attention to your body. Not just your cravings, but also how you feel after you eat or don't eat. 11:27 We all have some baked-in cultural expectations about our eating habits. 11:31 Just think about eating pasta for breakfast or a bowl of cereal for dinner. But both of those are technically just a grain bowl with varying toppings. We've only been eating three squares a day for... tops 150 years. And it's not a moral nor a nutritional failing to buck 11:51 that in favor of whatever works for you. Try to eat some protein and some fruit or veg and a bit of fats and grains at all of your meals, or to balance them throughout your day through snacking. Definitely hydrate. 12:06 And whatever you do, take care of yourself out there, okay? 12:14 Today's episode was written by me with additional material from the article, Is There a Biological Reason to Eat Three Meals a Day? on HowStuffWorks.com, written by L'Oreal Dove. BrainStuff is a production of iHeart Podcasts in partnership with HowStuffWorks.com 12:27 and is produced by Tyler Klang. For more shows from iHeart Podcasts, visit the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Community discussion