0:01 Body Bags with Joseph Scott Moore. Do you remember when you were a little kid and perhaps it was your first time in the pool with, say, your buddies? We're talking about past that age where maybe mama's not right there with you, but you're in the pool, you're with 0:28 your buddies, and you're playing around, and you might be the little one. And then all of a sudden, your so-called buddies grab you and hold you under the water. Fear-inducing, right? 0:39 I mean, we panic. It's natural. It's what you do because not only are your lungs screaming for air, your brain is screaming for air. And you revert to this kind of primal state where you'll do anything, anything to break free. And when you finally do break the surface, 0:59 your friends or sitting there giggling and laughing. And you catch your breath. And you go on. Today, I'm going to talk about two little boys who were essentially held beneath the water. But it wasn't by a couple of friends. 1:23 This was perpetrated at the hands of their mother. The person who should have cared for and loved them the most in this world. Today, we're going to revisit the case of Susan Smith. I'm Joseph Scott Morgan, and this is Body Bags. Brother Dave, I don't go back and 1:55 revisit old cases lots of times, but some things have occurred. 2:01 And I think is, I think that it's time that, that, uh, we talk about Michael Smith and Alex Smith. Um, I have to, because, you know, this, we were just reflecting, uh, this is a long time ago now. Um, it seems to us that it's just fresh in our mind, but 2:19 you know, I, I was working as a senior investigator with the ME's office when I heard about this case. And, you know, I still, to this day, remember, um, us at the, at the office, we had a television up on a big stand and we all gathered around it 2:36 to watch it because I'm not saying that evil had not occurred prior to that, but a case like this was so incredibly impactful that it, it got as jaded as we are in my field. It got our attention. We, we were just, I don't know, I'd say stupefied, dumb, dumb, no, 2:54 not dumb, I was without speech, I'll put it to you that way. 2:59 For those of you who are wondering why would we be talking about Susan Smith and the death of Michael and Alex, it's because Susan Smith is up for parole again. 3:08 I said again because two years ago she came up for parole, and I remember we covered it on Nancy Grace and went through the whole thing of what she'd been doing in prison, and I kept thinking, are we going to have to deal with this every two years 3:22 now until she either gets out or whatever and I remember at the time, and I'm going to take one for the team here. 3:29 Earlier today, I said to my daughter, you know the story of Susan Smith. 3:34 Yeah. 3:35 And she goes, well, huh? No. And it hit me, and I told Joe this before we started. Yeah. 3:42 This is now 32 years since this watershed criminal event took place because it didn't start off as a mother killing her children. It started off as a single mother who had her car carjacked from her in the middle of the country at night with her two children in the car. 4:04 And a madman had taken off with them. 4:07 And, you know, you immediately believe a story like that when you first hear it, or a lot of people do. 4:14 And a lot of Americans did. And a lot of South Carolinians immediately, Joe, they got on it. They were looking... 4:21 They started really, I mean, everywhere. They're scouring everything they can because this is in the days when not everybody had a cell phone. Not everybody. We didn't have flock cameras. 4:30 We didn't have security, you know, videos on our houses like we do now. So it was more boots on the ground looking, you know, for this and doing interviews. 4:39 Did you see anything? Did you hear anything? But it's actually that type of work that was done by investigators trying to find these two little boys to deck with the car. just trying to find those boys and walking the location of where this took place. They went, oh, 4:58 wait a minute. The story Susan Smith is telling us does not match this at all. The one thing she came to is she said she came to a stoplight and she stopped. And when she was at the stoplight, black man came, grabbed her car, grabbed her out of 5:17 the car, got, you know, and took off. And she went running to a house calling 911 or she's banging on the door and a man called 911 for her saying that she just got carjacked. Somebody stole her car with her two kids in it. That's what got America looking. 5:35 That's what got America talking. The morning TV shows brought her and even though she and her husband were not together, they came together as a couple to ask for help finding their children. 5:47 Yeah. And I got to tell you, one of the things that has happened in the last few days, um, I caught, um, I caught an image or at least Kimmy pointed it out to me, uh, my wife, um, and she's still furious about this case. I think that 6:05 most right thinking mothers are, um, and, you know, you can come at me for saying that, but, you know, let's face it, you know, I don't know where you would come down on this, but there's no way to explain away what she had done. And, There was an 6:21 image of the boy's father in the newspaper in today's, in the present. And, of course, you know, I remember seeing him there with her. And, you know, back years and years ago where they were both very young. He looked particularly young. I mean, he looked like a kid 6:45 right out of high school. And I tell you, Dave, if the wrinkles in a face could tell a story. 6:51 You know, I sat there and I was just looking at this image of this man in today's, in present tense. 7:00 And the constant grief that has beset him, you know, lo these many years carrying this burden around with him. Because, you know, he did stand with her. in this circumstance. 7:15 And I cannot imagine a more horrific tale to have to come to grips with, first off, initially, that your kids are missing, that some stranger has essentially driven off with them. You know they're strapped in that car. You know, 7:33 they're little kids. They're going to be in their car seats, respectively. 7:37 And then to find out that the most terrifying thing a parent can experience turns out to be a complete fabrication, Dave. 7:50 And he has to live with that. And then also, you know, let's don't undersell this. It's the fact of when they were found, when they were found, he had to come to grips with that. And who had perpetrated this? 8:06 You know, how do you, I don't know. I guess I'm asking you, brother, how do you even take the measure? 8:11 How do you even take the measure of something this profound and this horrific. I don't, I can't imagine having to explain, you know, explain a circumstance like this. 8:23 His name's David Smith and these were his boys, Michael and Alex. And, uh, he had dealt with many things that he and Susan were a young couple when they got together and had the children and, uh, things didn't work out as it does for many young couples that 8:38 have young children. And, um, When he when she first when well, again, when the story first started, it was not what it became. And so David Smith immediately stood side by side with her. 8:52 You know, I'm here. We're together. We need to find our boys. That was his sole focus. 8:57 And every time he answered a question, you knew this was a man on a mission to find his boys. And, you know, all these years later, Joe, that's the one thing I noticed in him as well as it has been over 30 years. 9:08 But. 9:10 It's taken his toll. And I don't know how it wouldn't. 9:13 I can't imagine what that deception feels like. I can't imagine losing my two children when I stood next to their mother slash killer at the same time. You know, it's just mortifying when you really get down to it. 9:25 But the reality of the show and Joe is that a lot of us don't know what happened because I'll be honest with you. It was a little bit different time in the way stories were covered today. There would be a lot more coverage about what the boys went through, 9:44 what exactly happened. We did learn some things about their final moments, but not to the level that we know now. 9:52 And you're not going to be happy when you see this, friends. 9:55 I would hope you'd never be happy hearing about children dying. 9:57 But you know what I mean? 9:59 It's a much. 10:00 More horrific death than I knew. And the thought that Susan Smith could get out of prison now. And I would look, just so you know, I'm a Christian man. 10:15 I believe in forgiveness. what goes on between you and God. 10:18 God forgives all. He knows the sincerity of your heart. 10:22 But I do think there are certain things that just, yeah, you can be forgiven. 10:26 You can go to heaven. 10:28 But your days on this earth are going to be in a 10 by 12 cell if I have my way. 10:32 You've earned that. 10:33 Yeah, and I think that that extends to, I think that the court caught a sense of how horrific This was the thing that that always puzzled me about Susan Smith case is there was not a more significant push for capital punishment in this case, particularly in South Carolina. 11:00 The reason is, is that you had planning that went into this. You had weaponization of a motor vehicle and you had a level of torture and terror. that is exacted upon two little boys who are just so completely helpless. 11:22 You know, you've got these two babies in their car seats in the back of their mama's tiny little sedan, you know, probably have made rides with her all over the place, you know, for their short little lives. You know, they had no... What little child actually has any kind 11:46 of understanding or thought that any kind of foreshadowing that something horrible is going to happen? And all I can think of, Dave, is that when little Michael and Alex were in that car with their mother, and she pulled up to that boat ramp, and they're sitting there. And maybe, 12:07 just maybe, in some way, they could catch a glimpse of the water. I thought, wow. This is a place we've never been before. This is something that I've never seen. 12:18 I wonder why Mommy's here. And then all of a sudden, all of a sudden, that thing that they saw suddenly became their doom. 12:31 The End. 12:42 There are many ways. I was just lecturing about this this week, Dave, to my intro forensic class at Jack State. 12:51 We were covering, we're in the medical legal section of intro to forensics right now. And I was kind of breaking it down to them where I have a thing called Morgan's Umbrella of Death. And it's this kind of visualization I've created over the years. It is literally the 13:09 image of an umbrella. And for each one of the little spines on the umbrella, there is a manner of death. 13:14 There's only five, you know, and I'll go over them very briefly. So everybody knows natural homicide, suicide, accident, and undetermined. 13:22 And if you think about those spines or categories, um, of manners of death, just about any cause of death can literally be placed under multiple categories there. Do you know, you can even place heart attack, um, under multiple categories. Um, 13:40 you know, I've had homicides that actually people were charged and convicted of homicide as a result of scaring someone with a weapon. Yeah. And so you have all these things. 13:55 I look bad in the morning, man, but I don't, I mean. 13:58 But, you know, my point here is that, you know, I use the term weaponization of a motor vehicle, Dave. 14:06 You know, you can use a car or You can accidentally strike someone with your car and bring about their death, right? 14:12 But you can actually weaponize a vehicle and say, I'm going to go get that old so-and-so that I don't like. 14:16 I'm going to run over him, all right? So you are weaponizing a vehicle. Dave, in this particular case, the Susan Smith case in particular is interesting in how it was utilized as far as a means of to end the lives of these two children. And that's why I 14:37 say that I think that there was, you know, some people use the term malice of forethought. There was intent, you know, all these sorts of things that go into it. 14:46 The level of horror that these children experienced as this car has been weaponized, as it's beginning to dip beneath The surface of that lake is stuff that most people can't even fathom. 14:59 But it took time to get there. It took time to get to the water. And I will tell you this, Joe. 15:07 We've gone through this type of story from the Clancy trial where we have the mother who kills the children and then does a feeble attempt at self-harm to take their own life. And Susan Smith has tried to say that That's what she wanted to do. She actually considered 15:26 just jumping off of the bridge with both of her boys. 15:28 And that was never the plan. Her plan was not that dissimilar from other women who are in prison for killing their children because the man they were interested in didn't want children. The man that Susan Smith was interested in, 15:42 not her ex, David Smith, not the father of the children, but another guy, a playboy around town who was from a very wealthy family, he just didn't want to have children. 15:51 And so... Susan Smith wanted him. Get rid of the kids. 15:56 And you're not going to convince me at any stretch of the way that she had an idea to hurt herself as well. She saved herself, Joe. And she wanted to save those boys she could have. If that's what she truly wanted to do, they wouldn't have died in the lake. 16:11 But October 25th, 1994. 16:13 Think about it. 16:14 We're 32 years past this now. And For nine days, the country was reeling. Actually, probably about five days. Because I think after the fifth day, there was enough questions coming out that people started doubting her story. And the 16:34 local constabulary did a good job of keeping things under wraps and talking with Susan Smith to get the truth out of her where she finally admitted. Because they were like, okay, Susan, a black man did not take your car. That stoplight that you said you stopped at a red light, it 16:53 doesn't stop when there's no other traffic, dear. It stays green. 16:57 It only turns red when there's traffic. And you said there was no other traffic, so it wouldn't have been red. 17:04 So they broke her down with the truth, and that's when she finally came up with a story that, from the physical aspects of it, is true. That's all I can think. Her mental, you know, none of that matters. 17:17 works for me, what her thoughts are, what she says. 17:20 She claims that she parked the car on the boat ramp. 17:25 Yeah. 17:26 And she made sure both the boys were buckled into their seats. Now, three-year-old Michael Smith. You know how active three-year-olds are in their seat. 17:37 Yes, I do. 17:38 They can get out of that seat. Well, back in the day, they could. Real creative ones would. They'd do all kinds of things. A three-year-old talks, plays. I mean, they're A 14-month-old, not so much, okay? They're going to be active and not like a three-year-old would. And you 17:55 mentioned what they might have been thinking. And I like to think it was at night. And I wonder what they really saw. One thing we know that Michael Smith at three years old knew that the car was moving and his mother got out. There was nobody driving this car. 18:18 And with those two children in the back seat, buckled into their car seats, she puts it in neutral, takes off the parking brake and lets it slowly roll on in. 18:33 Yep. Down the boat ramp, the concrete boat ramp right there. 18:36 And what you're going to have to explain to us, and I know there was a reenactment because I saw one with the Mazda and how long it takes for it to fill with water and sink. 18:46 And it, Again, remembering that these boys are both alive, I think of Michael at three. 18:54 That car didn't go in and stay right side up, did it, Joe? 19:00 No, it inverted. 19:01 It didn't go in like a boat and just float out to Catalina Island. 19:05 No, it didn't. And, you know, Dave, the vehicle, the way this works with vehicles, first off, you have to consider the weight and then displacement of the water. Okay, so primary purpose. The heaviest end of a vehicle, obviously, 19:21 is where the engine compartment is. So when a vehicle goes in, it will have a tendency to tip downward toward the weighted area of the car. And the car begins to kind of slowly slip beneath the water. Now, what they're saying is that through this reenactment, water actually 19:46 began to come in you know, through the vents. and i know that you think that your car i'm talking to our audience right now you think your car is perfectly sealed up it ain't and so water has a way of intruding into the cabin of a vehicle and 20:03 it can seep through and as that engine presses down OK, and it's moving. It has some it has some momentum. 20:14 All right. Dependent upon the degree of slope of, you know, the the the boat ramp itself as it's being pulled forward. 20:24 You have water that's coming into the cabin. Well, that begins to after a few seconds, that begins to kind of balance out, equalize, if you will, relative to the engine. 20:34 It's displacing at that point in time. And then you've got these two little ones in the backseat. 20:38 Right. 20:40 As the car begins to move forward in the water and it's taking on water, this would not, just from the perspective of the boys back there, they would have sensed the creeping of the water. And it would have filled in in the forward portion of the cabin first. Okay, 20:59 so you think about your air vents, all right, on either side. Maybe you've got one in the center. Water's coming through. They could have heard the water pouring in. 21:11 if you think about a tap on a bathtub or a sink, or maybe if you've ever poured water out of a bucket, these little angels in the back seat would have heard that. And then all of a sudden, they would have experienced a dampness, maybe on the cuffs 21:26 of their pants, maybe on the backs of their arms, their hands. They would have felt this dampness that is coming in. And it's a shock to the system. You're looking around, you're panicking. You're You don't understand what's happening. 21:42 You're only three. You're only 14 months. You have no idea. 21:45 And then all of a sudden, as the car begins to move forward through the momentum, taking on more water, guess what happens? The vehicle begins to slowly turn. Okay. 22:00 Slowly turn until it actually inverts in the water. So it goes from side to going to the roof now. 22:08 So if you're strapped and anybody that has kids, grandbabies, maybe you've got little ones in your family where you've helped put them into a car seat, they're tied down tight, okay? 22:21 They're locked in with a seat belt that's attached to the motor vehicle itself, and then they have straps or harnesses that hold them in place, and these are locked, okay? 22:31 So no matter how much a kid struggles, and I know what you were saying, Dave, about them You know, a three-year-old can actually get out. That has actually happened to me multiple times. It's generally followed by, what in the hell are you doing out of your seat? Pulling 22:44 over to the side of the road, get them back in. But, you know, that can happen. But when, you know, now you've got a burst of adrenaline. And along with adrenaline comes panic. And along with panic becomes shallow breathing. I 22:58 know many people are wondering, well, Morgan, how long would it take for an individual to drown? Because what you're getting at as far as the mechanism of the drowning is, first off, they're going to be taking on water into 23:16 their little lungs. And they can't clear their lungs. Because even when you're extending your head up like this, even if there is an air bubble, and part of me feels like there may not have been with this thing inverting like this, maybe for a split second or two. 23:36 They don't have the strength to knock down a window or knock out a window. If it's a manual window, they couldn't even reach it. They wouldn't even know what to do. So all the while, they're struggling to breathe. 23:50 And I'm really wondering if the face of their beloved mother was passing before their mind's eye during this period of time. Because it's a struggle. And they would have panicked throughout this event. Because it's just within human nature. 24:05 you know, to try and free yourself and try to get breath. So as the lungs are beginning to fill up with water, this lake water, not only are the lungs becoming heavier and it's more difficult to breathe because now the water you're taking on is displacing any oxygen 24:26 that still remains in the lungs. Now your brain's screaming. 24:30 As a matter of fact, your brain's on fire at this point in time. And what I mean by that, the brain is strangulating. It has no oxygen to supply it with what it needs, and that is life. It needs oxygen-rich blood in order to function. And the brain 24:50 is controlling everything. Dave, you know, it's interesting how people will talk about how long they can hold their breath underwater. 24:58 And there are certain people out there that can... hold their breath for a protracted period of time. But, you know, most of those people that do that, first off, they're professionals at what they do. You think about somebody that's like a SEAL, you know, that maybe can do that 25:15 sort of thing and hold their breath for protracted and feel very comfortable because they know that this is going to happen, perhaps. You're talking about two little babies here, Dave. 25:25 And they would be so panicked at this point in time. 25:28 that I don't know how long they could have survived in there, but those last few minutes would have been absolutely horrific. 25:34 Well, we know that in the reenactment, when they used identical vehicle, it took six minutes from the time the car hit the water until the time was fully submerged. 25:46 And as you mentioned, it's in the water. It's now floating at first, going under, but then it rolls upside down. 25:56 So with the boys being strapped, in their seats, once that car rolls over there, they are underwater. There is no, there is nothing else except water. 26:06 And so. 26:10 I can't imagine, you know, you mentioned that some people can't hold their breath for an extended period of time. 26:15 And that's very true, but that's when you know, what's coming and you plan ahead. You're talking about two children with no history of being around a lake at night, knowing even what's going on to prepare even, you know, all you could think of is panic of, Mama, where 26:29 are you? I mean, I can hear him screaming for help. Mama, please help. You know, I can picture that happening. But in reality, when you get down to the nitty gritty, that vehicle, Joseph Scott Morgan, landed at the bottom of the lake on its roof, upside down, with those little 26:51 boys dangling from their chairs, buckled in. 26:55 They died where she strapped them in. 26:58 You wonder what kind of conversation passed between her and them prior to doing that. Baby, I'll be right back. Yeah. 27:04 You know, baby, I've got to do something. I got something out of the trunk. You know, slide a hand. 27:11 Watch this hand. Don't pay attention to this one. And then she strolls back up the ramp after she has, you know, facilitated getting this vehicle down the ramp. And let me give you a little insight as well into what can be found. at autopsy. So one of the 27:29 things that we do, obviously, with any kind of suspected drowning case, and yes, these two babies were autopsied, and this is a double homicide. Okay. 27:43 And Joe, do you do an autopsy on a child where these small children that you know, based on the circumstances... No, I guess you don't. Cause she could have drugged them or any number. It could have killed them. 27:56 Yeah. And look, let me tell you, this is, this is on the defense. I mean, the defense will say, Oh, you didn't think enough of this case to do autopsies. 28:05 How do we know even what the cause of death was? 28:07 Were they deceased? 28:08 What do you call it? 28:11 The big T or the big Y or you have to do the big cut on the chest. 28:15 Yeah. It's just like an adult autopsy. And so you go in and we try to be very, very careful in these cases because we, you know, when you, And trust me, by the time this whole thing is kind of playing out in the medical legal community, they have 28:31 information coming into them from the police. Now, the public might not have that at this point. But, you know, one of the things that the doctor would have been told at this moment in time and any of the deputy coroners that were involved in this, the coroner, you know, 28:45 when they're having this conversation before the autopsy, they're saying, look, let me tell you something. This everything ain't as it seems here. We believe that this vehicle was probably used in commission of a double homicide. And we need to 29:01 be able to rule out every, I get so many questions about this day from folks that say, why did you have to do an autopsy? Well, the reason you have to do an autopsy is that if you do not thoroughly examine these bodies, and that means autopsy, okay, 29:15 if you do not thoroughly examine these bodies at autopsy, then there will always be questions. There will always be somebody asking a question that was not answered, you know. 29:29 So you have to go the full length, as unpleasant as it is to the general public to think about this. 29:36 It's the reality of death, okay? And it's the reality of homicide, a double homicide. 29:42 The reality of what Susan Smith did to her own children. 29:44 It is. It is. You know, right now, we don't know what would have happened to those boys. They could have been on trajectory to have fine lives, you know, but she decided to snuff them out at three and at 14 months. So at autopsy, when we take the lungs, 30:01 we weigh the lungs. We will weigh them. And there's a standard weight for kids in this age range. The other thing we're going to look for is in the stomach. 30:13 And what do you do there, Morgan? Well, you actually go into the stomach and you pour out the contents of the stomach and you take a sample of it. 30:22 I'm suspecting there's a considerable amount of lake water in the stomach because they're gulping like this as they're in the water. And then in between those gulps of going down the esophagus, they're also taking on water into their lungs. 30:37 So when we open the lungs, when you go into the bronchial tree, and all you have to do is put a little bit of pressure on the lungs, on the surface of the lungs itself, and you'll see this exudate that will come out. It's water that actually comes out. 30:54 Then further, we actually go into the middle ear. And with drownings, many times what you're looking for in the middle ear are these little focal areas of hemorrhage that occur because there's such a strain and a stress, you know, 31:09 on the noggin itself that it creates these little focal areas of hemorrhage. So there's, you know, people talk about burst eardrums and all that sort of stuff. But we go in there and we will take samples in there to appreciate if there's anything in there. We check the sinuses. 31:25 It's a very, very thorough autopsy, Dave. And so you're faced with that in the medical legal community and trying to explain the mechanism. I think one of the things that folks will always say is, well, what happened first? 31:41 It's not that what happened first as much as it is kind of, it's like a series of dominoes that are pushed over. I mean, everybody knows what happens first. 31:51 If you're drowning, you take on water, right? So how does that process actually work? So when a physician says, a pathologist goes onto the stand, you sit there in a very elementary manner because the people you're talking to 32:06 in the jury, they're everyday folks. They're not forensic pathologists. 32:12 They're not forensic scientists. You explain to them the mechanism of drowning, and you have to put it in palatable terms so that they understand it. You can't go in there and try to impress them with how studied you are the sign of a really good forensic pathologist or 32:29 any forensic scientist that takes takes takes a seat on the stand is how can you take complex constructs and break them down so that everybody can understand it so that everybody can come up to a reasonable conclusion about this and the reality is the reality is is that 32:47 the conclusion that they arrived at in this case is one of pure horror. How good of a person do you have to be? Well, that's a question that people have asked for years and years. How good do I have to be? And when people commit evil acts, It 33:18 seems as though that their baseline they always return to is I'm no longer the person that I was previously. 33:24 Now I am a good person. Or the one I always love to hear people say is I'm working on myself. Congratulations. 33:33 I'm glad you're working on yourself. Sell it somewhere else. 33:38 And in this particular case, Dave, this is what all of this smacks of with Susan Smith as she's cooling her heels over in the women's penitentiary. in the fine Palmetto State of South Carolina. They have got her locked away over there. And I understand there's a huge list 33:59 of all the stuff that she's accomplished while she is in prison. And, you know, I'd like to say I'm happy for her, but I don't really care. 34:10 It would really be interesting to provide a list of what her boys could have accomplished from... the date of their death till today, because in this case, we're at 32 years. So that means that she'd have a 35 year old and a 32 year old, you know, 33 34:30 years old. I mean, that they would have accomplished a good bit by now. This didn't have that chance because she made sure of that. But, Joe, I was looking over. 34:39 When we went through this a couple of years ago, the first time she came up for parole. 34:42 It was two years ago, right? It was, yes. Okay. 2024. 34:45 This is so weird. 34:47 I'm sorry for the aside. It's weird. It strikes me as weird. It just happened two years ago and she's back into the cycle again. I think that that's the thing that kind of stoked with me about this. 34:58 It has with many people. 35:00 And, you know, it's different for how they can, they have to apply for it. You know, when their time, when it cycles around, they have to apply. And when she applied for it, you know, on her first available time, there were plenty of people that thought she might get out. 35:14 The thing is, a lot of people didn't know what she had been doing with her time behind bars. Because her first... Well, I was going to say her first few years. She spread out her bad behavior for a long time, Joe. And we're talking about... She got two guards. 35:34 She had two guards fired. Now, I'm going to be honest with you. 35:36 It meant. 35:38 This is going to sound sexist, and y'all take it for however it is. Men are the gas, women are the brakes, okay? 35:44 And I don't know why you would have men at a women's prison to start with. Put them in an environment where they could be around. But she had sex with two different guards. 35:57 Yeah, I'm not a fan. It's just not something I'm, you know, and I know people will talk about staffing and all those sorts of things, and not a fan. 36:05 No. 36:05 You know, I'm just not. But yeah, I'm sorry. Go ahead. No. 36:08 Well, one ended up going to prison himself for a few months. The other just had to quit. 36:12 No, I'm sorry. 36:15 He got put on probation for five years. Right. 36:17 He didn't go to prison. Right. That's right. No, the one guy did go to prison for three months. 36:22 Yeah. Okay. Yeah. 36:23 The one guy did. And the other, you're right. 36:24 The other guy went on probation, but he didn't actually have to go into prison. 36:27 Gotcha. Gotcha. Gotcha. 36:29 But you know what? I hope it was worth it. 36:32 Houston Cagle. He's the one that served three months in prison. 36:36 His buddy, Alfred Rowe, he's the one that ended up on probation for a while. So the thing is, is that that was the first thing she did after she'd been there for a couple of years. But then then she had a drug use problem and mutilation. That was 36:55 in 2010. They didn't tell us exactly what the mutilation was now. I was thinking of self harm, you know, that type of thing, but it could have been something a lot different. And I didn't know this until we started minutes before taping. I threw it out at Joe 37:10 because I thought, well, Joe might know what would she be mutilating herself with. 37:14 And thank you for turning to me as an authority on mutilation. No, I, I've just, I've just heard this in the past. 37:22 Sure. 37:23 There are certain locations like you can get into, you can get into quite a bit of trouble. Um, Relative to prison tattooing. Okay. And I don't know if they're classifying that as a form of mutilation because they're very non-specific. Yeah. 37:40 They're very non-specific. 37:42 No, they won't say at all. 37:43 I looked. Yeah. And you can't find it. I'm sure that some of our friends out there will probably know. 37:49 Y'all know. Please tell us in the comments. 37:51 The dirty details of this. We want to know. You know, so I was thinking about that and it's kind of a curious charge, I think. 38:00 Yeah. 38:01 And I don't, you know, and they were kind of stacking these things during this period of time. 38:05 She had three different things in 2010. 38:07 Yeah. 38:07 She had the drug thing, marijuana usage. Then she had the mutilation. And then she had unauthorized drug or inhalant. 38:16 So three different things in 2010. One in March, two in April. She lost privileges in disciplinary detention and things like that. Then you go to 2012. This was a big one. 38:27 In 2012. 38:29 She got caught using another inmate's pen. That's for making phone calls. And that's a big security violation. 38:38 It's huge. 38:39 As a matter of fact, there were many in the system that really wanted her punishment to be severe, to take away her phone privileges for every kind of thing. 38:50 That's how guarded the phone, because think about what you can do on the phone. 38:53 Yeah. 38:54 And Once you run out of your time, now you're using somebody else's. That means somebody's got to pay for that, which means something's exchanging hands to get this. It's a negotiation all the time. But what are you planning? 39:05 Think about that. 39:06 We just had a guy escape prison in Tennessee. Did he use extra pen time? So anyway, that was in 2012. 39:13 Three years later, 2015, another drug violation. But then she gets cool for a while. After the drug violation in 2015 in March, she stops. And everything, it's really clear. 39:28 All the way up until the time she's going to her first parole hearing in 2024 now I remember covering this at the time because there was a violation that crept up on her it was kind of her preparation for leaving okay a documentary filmmaker reached out to her 39:47 and talked to her on the phone and started negotiating with her. And she started giving out information about supporters, numbers of friends, including, and her ex-husband, David, gave this filmmaker his phone number. And these are all huge no-nos 40:07 in the South Carolina. Every state's different, but in the South Carolina penitentiary system, you're not allowed to talk about this. Now, you can write letters about it. She could have written all this down and sent it to this documentarian, whatever. 40:20 You're not allowed to talk about it. So she got busted for that. 40:25 And it happened. 40:25 The bust on that came down two weeks before she sat for her first parole hearing. So chalk that. 40:33 Up to immaturity, stupidity, stupidity. I can't find another one. 40:41 Shortsightedness. Dude, think about it. Yeah, you're trying to present yourself. Yeah. 40:46 You know, and it reminds me in a way. You know, there's been talk recently about Krenwinkel, right, relative to the Mansons. 40:55 And I think she's up again, if that hasn't already passed. 40:59 But there's always, they're at an age now, that group of them, where there's always one of them that seems like it's, yeah. And I think Krenwinkel was in the news recently. 41:11 The governor steps in and says, they get granted parole. 41:13 And the governor steps in and says, I'm pulling that card. 41:16 You're not getting it. 41:17 It reminds me of Billy Bob Thornton in Bad Santa 2 when he looks at his mother and he says, you know, they give Charles Manson parole, but he's Charles Manson. 41:29 Yeah, yeah, exactly. 41:31 I feel the same way about Susan Smith, Joe. 41:33 Yeah, I know. And it's a sad set of circumstances in the sense that now she is, I don't know, seeking to breathe free air. Yep. 41:47 Well, I do want to point something out at her first parole hearing, Joe. The parole board that, you know, people do write letters in support for people that are getting up for, that are up for parole. 41:58 Yeah. 41:59 And people voice their opinion about these things. Now, her husband, ex-husband, David Smith, says he's going to show up every time. 42:05 Every time. 42:06 And he, you talked about how he looks and presents himself. Now, this is a damaged man who is not healed. And I understand it. Maybe I want to just hug the guy, you know? It's like, Because I don't know what else you can do for him. But anyway, they had 471 42:22 letters come into the parole board during Susan Smith's first parole hearing. And I'm going to tell you what, man, that's a lot. 42:29 That is a ton. 42:30 And of these 471 letters, Joe, only six, only six were in favor of letting her out. 471 letters and only six people. 42:39 Said let her out. 42:46 All the others, 465 people took the time. 42:51 Do not let her out. 42:52 Now, remember, right before this parole hearing, she's on the phone with a documentarian giving him numbers of people to call, people who support her, who will help her. 43:02 When she gets out. 43:03 She's laying her groundwork for how she's going to come out of prison and make money against the rules, mind you. 43:10 And these people found out it. 43:12 Really did motivate people who might have just not done anything. 43:16 Once it became public, she's giving out private numbers of people who are very private. 43:22 Oh, buddy. Well, my understanding is, is that following that hearing in which she was denied, she had to come apart after that. You know, she had entered back into population, had been acting like a little fair haired angel. you know, around, oh, yeah, 43:43 very agreeable and that sort of thing. And the word around the campfire after that was that once she was denied, she turns into a little monster, you know, petulant, of course. 43:55 And I wonder, you know, we're talking 24 months later now, approximately, thinking, you know, well, gee, geez, Suze, what's changed? since that period of time. And, you know, because I got to tell you, you know, I know that Michael and Alex 44:17 are still dead. And I know that this scarred their father, David, deeper than anything. I don't even have the ability to put that into words of what she did to that. 44:30 And also community. Let's just take it. Now, I know people, you know, many times they play tennis with the whole race thing back and forth all the time but let's just think about this because she made that statement and she was so very specific about it what what what 44:47 would have happened if if they had caught some fellow that's an african-american fellow and some cop because you're talking about missing kids you know that can't restrain themselves starts putting his hands on this guy And doing something really 45:02 horrible at that point in time, all because she said it. 45:05 Because she's trying to get away to live a life that she thinks she's entitled to. 45:09 Don't look at pictures of Emmett Till. You'll find out what happens. 45:13 Exactly. Exactly. Emmett Till. And that's a very slippery slope to get upon. And again, that goes to malice of forethought. 45:26 You're thinking about these things. You're thinking about, well, how can I get away with this? You know, I'm not going to do something quick to end my kids' lives. 45:35 I'm going to do something that is part of a grand play, if you will, kind of a theater, a bit of theater there on that boat ramp. You know, I've got it all planned out. I know I'll blame it on a black guy. I'll let the car slip 45:50 beneath the waves and they'll never find them. Or when they do, we can blame it on him. And oh, by the way, it'll be quiet. I don't have to get my hands dirty, you know. And so that's what we're left with with Susan Smith. And I got to 46:05 tell you, this hearing is coming up on the 19th. 46:09 And I want everybody to be aware of that. I want everybody to know and remember those that came along a lot longer a few years after this happened. We still remember. We still remember Michael and Alex. And it is important that we remember David as well. Because this 46:30 is truly an American tragedy. I'm Joseph Scott Morgan, and this is Body Bags.
Community discussion