0:01 Body Bags with Joseph Scott Moore. You know, there's a movie from many years ago that I can still watch it today. There's two movies, but one in particular that will make me cry every time I watch it, hands down. 0:24 And I don't know why it is necessarily. It just goes right to my heart every time I watch it. 0:33 It's Rain Man. And the way that movie closes out where Tom Cruise puts Dustin Hoffman on a train and he's sending him back to where he had been housed for many, many years, as far back as can go, is just. 0:54 It just pricks my heart every time. But there's a scene in that movie that always gets me, and I laugh about it. Kimmy and I still laugh about it today. 1:03 And it's, they're trying to make it a cross country. 1:07 Tom Cruise and Dustin Hoffman, who plays his older brother, that's autistic. He's an autistic savant. And he wants, he has this thing about people's court. He has to watch it every, single day and he takes these tedious notes. Well, 1:23 they're on the road and they're in the middle of nowhere. 1:25 He goes up on the porch. He tries to convince a lady that his brother's got to watch people's court. 1:32 He throws a fit out on the porch and Tom Cruise looks at him and says, Raymond, they're making, they are making legal history in there right now because you can't control yourself. You can't get in there to see. 1:44 That always struck me as quite amusing and very poignant. Today, we're going to talk about a case that involves people's court and a mystery that still, to this day, after all these years, still remains unsolved. I'm Joseph Scott Morgan, and this is Body Bags. 2:14 Brother David, I'm so glad you didn't tell me you were going to do that for the opening. Five minutes for Wapner. Five minutes for Wapner. I forgot all about it. 2:22 Five minutes for Wapner. 2:23 Wapner. 2:23 Oh, my gosh. Yeah. I don't know. It's just that movie always affects me. In case anybody wants to know the other one, and I know this probably gets you too, is Field of Dreams. When he looks up and he looks at his dad and says, Dad, you want to have a catch? 2:38 Stop that. 2:39 Every single time. 2:40 That's enough. Yeah. 2:41 No. 2:42 Can't do it. 2:42 But those two movies, you know, and they kind of. 2:45 They're kind of in the same era of Tom. 2:47 I'm not going to do it. I'm not going to cry. 2:49 I'm going to make you cry before it's over with. 2:51 For those of you who are movie people, and you know Joe and I are, a very quick Peter Guber story, okay? 2:57 John Peter and Peter Guber, they owned the Guber Peters JPO, okay, in the mid-' 80s before they sold their whole company to Sony. 3:08 And then Peter Guber and John Peters, the guy who used to be Barbra Streisand's hairdresser in the 70s, They took over for Sony Pictures. They bought Columbia TriStar. All right. Well, before they got to the Columbia TriStar, they did Rain 3:21 Man and they did Batman. Okay. Now, they weren't really involved in production on Rain Man at all. As a matter of fact, they weren't barred from the set, but pretty close. But anyway, the thing is that Peter Guber, who now owns the San Francisco Warriors, Golden State Warriors, 3:37 a basketball NBA team. Yeah, yeah, yeah. They came in for this pitch meeting on the movie and he's like, all in, you know, we've got this going on. We're talking about Tom Cruise and Dustin Hoffman and Peter Goober goes, I got a great ending. I got a great ending. 3:51 They get back to LA and Tom Cruise's character convinces the Los Angeles Dodgers to let Ray come in and pitch the ninth inning of the World Series and they win the World Championship. And the writers are going, we just crafted this brilliant, touching, loving story. And you want 4:14 to do what? Yeah, exactly. So the producer who had had experience with Peter Guber before said, we're going to take your notes and we're going to work on that. 4:24 And he goes, look, man, he's going to forget about it by tomorrow. And thankfully he did, or that movie would have been crap instead of an award-winning movie. But anyway, that cracks me up. You stuck me with that one. 4:33 I didn't know that's where we were going. But People's Court actually is a major part of today's story. I told Joe, I wonder if we're ever going to do a body bags episode where the bag is empty. 4:45 There you go. Here we are. Yeah, good point. 4:46 Today's the day. 4:47 Yeah. 4:48 Today is the day that Joseph Scott Morgan is going to show you how forensics come into play when you have a no body arrest. 5:02 Yeah. 5:03 See, let me get these straight. Michelle Parker and Dale Smith Jr. have been in a relationship. Michelle Parker is 33. 5:09 Dale Smith Jr. at the time, this is 15 years ago, so he was 40, 2011. And they had been engaged. 5:18 They did have three-year-old twin boys. And they weren't sharing custody really well, okay? Matter of fact, they'd had many ups and downs during their time together. Many things we have found out that you're going to hear about in 5:31 the coming minutes, okay? But first, at the time, they were engaged and they broke up. And during one of these breakups, they had an argument. And Michelle took the engagement ring off her hand during the ninth floor of a hotel room. And she throws it at him. And 5:45 he doesn't catch it. So the engagement ring goes over the balcony down nine floors. And lo and behold, well, Dale Smith Jr. couldn't find it. And he wanted her to pay for it. And Michelle's like, I don't need money. 5:59 I'm not paying for that. And so they end up on the people's court. I'm not kidding. And I don't know how they came to this idea that it was a good idea to go. They couldn't get it resolved. 6:11 And so they went on the people's court and allowed not Judge Wapner, but whatever judge took over after he died. 6:17 Okay. Yeah. 6:18 Bottom line, they did appear on the people's court. And now you tape a TV show like that months in advance. 6:25 And the day their show aired, it did not show either of them in a particularly good light. They didn't come off really well. And the judge listened to the whole thing. And in the end of it, she said, okay, going to split this down the middle. Michelle, you're going 6:42 to have to pay him $ 2, 500, half the value of the ring. So that episode that they had taped months earlier aired on November 17th, 2011. Right. And it was airing locally in Orlando at 2 p.m. What we knew until a few days ago was all a lie. Because 7:03 what we have been told is that Michelle Parker took the boys to Dale's house, to Dale Smith Jr. 's place, because it was his turn for visitation, that she took the boys over there at 4 o'clock on the 17th, and Dale said they didn't really talk, okay? She dropped 7:21 the boys off and left. She was there 10 minutes and gone. And she vanished. 7:26 Gone. 7:26 Doesn't show up for work, doesn't get in touch with any family members, nothing. There's only one last text message from her and she's prolific at text messaging everybody constantly texting family and friends but after 4 10 there's nothing 7:41 joe except for one became a 4 26 p.m and it was a one word answer when her brother said where are you the answer was waterford there was no other commentary beside that joe and that was unusual and that was the last thing anyone heard from her she 7:56 didn't reply didn't make another phone call and that's pretty shocking to everyone who knew her because she didn't show up for work. She didn't touch base with anybody throughout the rest of that night. Her mom calls and reports 8:10 her missing, says this is totally unusual. She's a mother. 8:13 She has three children. This is not how this goes with her. And so immediately they began looking for her. 8:18 She does have a Hummer. It's an H3, not the big one. I like it. The very cool looking model, H3. 8:26 And it was missing as well. So, Joe, they did the all points bulletin. Be on the lookout. Gave a description of Michelle. Gave a description of the vehicle. And she had a decal on the back window. The big back window of this thing. It was for her mobile 8:43 tanning company that she had. Big decal. So imagine if you're driving an H3 in 2011. Yeah. And you've got this huge decal across the back window. That's going to be a pretty identifiable vehicle. 8:57 Yeah. 8:57 And noticeable in the city of Orlando. Yeah. So noticeable is the fact when they started looking, Joe, they found it on red light cams, you know, on her way to Dale Smith Jr. 's house. 9:12 Funny, though. 9:14 After seeing her vehicle going through these red light cameras and, you know, with the big decal on the back, they didn't see it again. The decal. They did see the vehicle. 9:24 The decal had been removed. Yeah. They found the vehicle the next day on November 18th, about 12 miles from Dale Smith Jr. 's house in an apartment complex where Michelle didn't know anybody, didn't have any friends. To our knowledge, 9:41 she'd never been there before, never been in that area. 9:43 It's 12 miles south. So we have her vehicle that now has been defaced with her business logo taken off the back of the window. It's parked in an area where she has never been. Her phone's not inside the vehicle, she's not inside the vehicle, and Joseph Scott Morgan, that's 10:02 all we have. 10:04 Yeah. And I got to tell you, Dave, the thought of her just vanishing, you know, into thin air is nonsensical because we can track movements even back then, you know, but I think one of my questions would be when you're thinking about this abandoned Hummer, you know, that's been 10:26 left behind. And again, some distance away, there's been thought put into this, I think, where this vehicle is placed. Also, that she has no geographic connection, you know, proximity. You know, like this is not near her home necessarily. This is 10:43 not near her fiancé, lover, boyfriend, father of her twins. 10:49 home either. I think one of the questions that's a driver behind this for me is I want to know how was that vehicle treated, right? So it's interesting in the sense that when we have, and follow me here, when we have a case, and we have a lot 11:11 of them that we cover, involving a motor vehicle, If you've got kind of a domestic situation where an individual is, they're housed together, they're cohabitating, the fact that you have someone else's DNA or fingerprints inside of a vehicle other 11:30 than the primary driver, say you're domiciled with them, there's not a lot there, okay? However, if you've got two individuals that are living apart, okay, and you take that vehicle and you treated carefully. I really wonder in this case how far in depth they would have gone with 11:52 the interior of this vehicle when it was found. And, you know, at that moment, Tom, did they suspect that she may have been snatched or did they just kind of treat the car and treat the vehicle in a manner in which it would not have preserved any kind 12:10 of deposition inside of the vehicle? Because even Even when you're thinking about DNA in the context right now, and I don't know what, 15 years later, right? Yeah. We still had an understanding of looking for DNA in that environment. 12:26 I mean, we've had cases that go back further than that where they've swabbed areas and they have collected sample, but the technology was not as sensitive back during that period of time as we have today. Thank the Lord for what we have now because- You know, a whole 12:43 new world opens up to us. But then you think about things like latent prints that are also in here. 12:49 Because if she's not in the vehicle and it's not a location that she would normally gravitate to. And then I find it very interesting what you said about the removal of this decal. You're talking about really, really intensive points of contact here. All right. So let me just 13:09 kind of break this down. Just looking at the back, the back glass, okay? I don't know about you, but if you have a sticker on anything, first off, you're going to have to manipulate that thing in some way to get it off. Now, was it scraped off or 13:26 could you get your finger underneath it and peel it off? 13:31 When we're doing fingerprints, and I'm teaching my students, you think about surfaces that fingerprints are deposited on. 13:39 Okay. 13:39 So everybody listening to me right now, just imagine this in your, like, if you go to your bathroom, okay. 13:45 And you go to your mirror. Okay. And you look at your mirror, just, um, don't get in trouble with whoever you're living with. Cause you're putting smudges on the mirror. 13:54 Just blame it on me. Press your fingers onto the mirror. 13:56 And you've probably done this before. You can do it on your cell phone too, because the glass case that's called a non-porous surface. What that means is, and you got no pores in it. As a matter of fact, It's going to be very, very smooth like glass. What 14:11 does that tell us? Well, you can actually look at a surface like that. You can actually see fingerprints. You can see them very, very clearly. They're not necessarily latent in the sense that, you know, like if you think about a dark surface where you can't see things and 14:26 you have to dust it. I've worked cases involving glass where you look at that surface and you say, wait, hang on. My Lord, I see a fingerprint right here. 14:37 and you kind of obliquely light it. Now, you would dust that area and lift that print, but wouldn't it be, because if you can take someone that has had this area scraped back there, for instance, and they've removed it, it's one thing to say that you might have a 14:54 subject that was seated in the front seat, maybe as a passenger in her vehicle, and you've got maybe a fingerprint there, but we're talking about a labor-intensive event here where you're actually contacting the surface. Did they lift prints 15:09 off that? Were they able to find? And what else was missing off of the surface? If you go to the interior of the car now, kind of backing up a little bit, and you're driving this car to place it somewhere, brother, you're not talking about just passive touches, right? 15:29 What people need to do is think about next time you go to get into your car, Think about what, and this is something most folks don't, and it drives my students nuts. I actually have them do a demonstration in class of this. I'll call a volunteer up and 15:44 I'll say, demonstrate getting in your vehicle and starting the vehicle. 15:50 Show us how you do it. And I'll take them through step by step because there's all these points of contact. 15:55 You don't think about where to leverage yourself, what you have to hang on to. Some people grab hold of the edge of the door. Hummer, kind of elevated, even an H3. You have to kind of leverage yourself up into the seat. The roof of this thing, have you 16:11 touched it? Has your thumb contacted some kind of surface in there? Also the door. People don't think about how they open the door. Some people will stick their hand, you know, up under the latch or pull it like this. Well, on the backside of that latch, you've got a surface 16:27 there where you can deposit fingerprints. Some people grab the doorframe and pull it open and then press it out and you've got a point of contact on the palm of the hand, then how do you get into the vehicle? Well, once you get into the vehicle, you got to pull 16:42 yourself up in. If it's a taller vehicle, maybe you grab the steering wheel and pull yourself in. You sit down. Hey, what do you got to do next? Put on your seatbelt. Smooth, non-porous surface because it looks like stainless steel. Well, on 16:56 that surface, there's a place where you can look for latent prints. You click it in. Oh, then you got to grab the gear lever, okay? Now, with a Hummer, I know because I have one or had one, you've got to grab the center console. It's right here. It's 17:10 got a thumb thing. You move it back and forth. Oh, by the way, you've also got to grab the steering wheel. 17:17 And guess what else? She's a woman. She's probably a bit more diminutive than, say, this guy. What do you got to do? You got to adjust your mirrors. Oh, wow. Smooth, non-porous surface. How do you grab your rearview mirror? You ever thought about that? Do you grab it along the 17:33 frame and move it? Some people will punch it with their thumb. I've seen this. So you think about, no, really, you think about all these permutations out there about where we look for evidence, you know, this deposition. And the thing about it, Dave, is that this is a prime 17:50 area for touch DNA. You know, you hear us talk about a lot about blood, blood evidence and all that. 17:56 But in a circumstance like this, you can have touch DNA. 18:00 And that comes from dropping so many skin cells that you leave these partials everywhere, even contained within a fingerprint. 18:10 I think the big question is, who operated that vehicle last? 18:16 And who did the assessment and search for the evidence in there? Brother Dave, I need you to enlighten me about this because when I think about cars, when I think about any kind of motor vehicle, we've talked about this extensively. I always think about a mobile crime scene. 18:43 That's what I think about. And it can be moved anywhere, but within that space, inside of that bubble, it's kind of protected. And it's a very small space. 18:53 It's not just a mobile crime scene, okay? It's also a mobile business. Keep in mind that this is GLOW, G-L-O-W. 19:01 This is a mobile business that Michelle was doing where it was mobile tanning. She would come to you and do the tanning at your place. You know spray tan? 19:11 You know what I'm talking about? 19:12 Oh, spray tan. Okay, yeah. 19:14 And so you would go, and it was a going business back in 2011. I mean, it was actually, let me tell you what, Michelle Parker was doing three jobs, Joe. 19:21 She was trying to get ahead. She didn't want anybody taking care of her. She didn't want anything from anybody. 19:25 She was having a tough go of it. And it actually, in a very despicable, disgusting way, that was something we had found out in the last week. I will show you the character of Michelle Parker. 19:39 Okay. 19:40 Yeah. We were talking about the decal, the glow decal. 19:44 Yeah. 19:44 I looked this up because there are several different ways to put something on a vehicle. You know, you can wrap it, you can... actually just put a sticker or a decal. Decals are thicker than stickers. You don't have to do the mistake that I did when I was 19:59 trying to unpeel a vehicle one time. 20:01 Yeah. 20:02 The radio station, we changed logos and the idiot that, oh yeah, I know how to do that. I said, okay, well, what do we do? He said, get Easy off oven spray and spray it over the decal and that'll make it come loose. Okay. I'm like, okay, it makes sense 20:17 to me. You know, it's going to dissolve the glue underneath. 20:20 And then you start peeling and no, that was stupid. 20:23 I don't know who told him that would work, but all I did was scorch my fingers and my arms and every other place that I touched with easy. It's rather caustic. Yes. And I didn't have gloves on. So stupid. 20:32 Oh my gosh. 20:33 Yeah. Gotta wear those gloves, brother. I am an idiot. 20:35 But I learned something from that, Joe. I learned this. 20:38 Yeah. 20:39 To peel off a decal, you don't need anything. Okay. 20:42 You just need an edge. 20:44 Okay. 20:44 You just need a little finger on the edge. And it works off just like you would expect. It's even thicker than a sticker. And so the decal will pull off. 20:51 It's not a big deal. 20:52 Gotcha. 20:52 And the difference is it will leave an outline of wherever the decal was on your vehicle, especially if it's on the glass because, you know, glass gets dirty. You see the windshield wiper, it leaves a mark, right? Well, that decal will stay in. You'll be able to see 21:07 it was there. Even on glass, you can tell a difference. 21:10 No matter how many times you scrub it, you can still tell there's a difference. Now, the thing we have found out about this, again, I remember, friends, between November 17th of 2011, when Michelle Parker vanished, until October 15th, 21:26 you know, two weeks ago, there have been many searches for Michelle Parker. There have been searches of water. The first big search, well, first of all, they found her vehicle on the 18th, the day after she went missing, okay? 21:41 And the decal was pulled off. One thing that we found out, Joe, and didn't know at the time, and you know what? Her mom didn't know this either. The vehicle had mud on it. Michelle Parker's vehicle was always immaculate on the outside. It was always clean because it 21:55 was a rolling business. You don't want somebody pulling up into your driveway looking like they just went on four-wheel emission. No. 22:02 She kept it clean. This vehicle... was clean on the 17th when she was driving it to drop the children off it was not clean the next day when it was found in a place michelle parker had never been with the decal that she was so proud of removed 22:20 so i think it's safe to assume that michelle parker did not did not put her car in that parking lot don't know who did yet i say yet because i think we're gonna find out but joe The car was dirty. And you know what? Her mom didn't even 22:35 know this. Just found out in the last two weeks that the car was dirty. And she's like, oh, my God. 22:41 I never knew. You know, there's several other things that we never knew. Now, I mentioned when we started early on, I wondered when we were going to do a body bags where there was no body in the bag. And that's where we are. Because Michelle Parker's vehicle was found. 22:55 Her iPhone was found three weeks later on December 7th, Pearl Harbor Day. It was found in a lake. about three miles away from where her vehicle was found. Now, I don't know how they found that phone, Joe. 23:08 Yeah, that would be a big question for me. 23:10 They had a hint. They had a tip. They had an idea, but they found the phone. And here's the kick. 23:20 In 2011, they couldn't get the information off the iPhone, even though it was in relatively great condition when they got it out of the water, out of the lake. 23:28 Maybe it had a good cover on it. I don't know. 23:30 But I know that They couldn't get this information off of it in 2011. But in 2026, they did. And Joe, this is where the forensics come to play, because even though it was 15 years ago, everything has changed so much from, you know, you were mentioning earlier about how 23:53 with forensics, you know, like think about the cases that are getting solved now in 2026 that are only 10, 15 years old, but they'd already gone cold. that we're solving now with new technologies. Same thing is true here. 24:06 It's the new technologies, the new forensic technologies for digital data that allowed investigators to get into that phone, Joe. 24:12 And you know what they found? In the six weeks leading up to her disappearance, Dale Smith Jr. told police he didn't talk to her. They had no communication. They didn't have any relationship except dealing with the children. That was it. When she dropped him off, she was there 24:28 less than 10 minutes. She dropped him off. She was out the door. That's Dale Smith Jr. in 2011. What they found out in 2026 is that between October 1st and November 17th, over a thousand text messages and 21 voice calls between Michelle Parker and Dale Smith Jr. Over 24:50 a thousand, Joe, text messages that were laying there dormant. 24:54 They've been available. They've been there in evidence since 2011, since they got the phone. But they had no way of getting it off the phone. But their technology has grown. 25:04 And now they were able to get this information off the phone. And what they found out is that, oh, my goodness, this was a vicious relationship that went. It was not good. OK, there was a lot of ugly things said between the two of them. There was a 25:22 lot of anger, a lot of frustration. They shared these two children, these three year old boys. And that was the only thing. There was a lot of arguing about that. 25:31 Michelle threatened, you're not going to see these kids. If you don't stop there, you're not going to see them. 25:36 She had a reason to feel this way because something else we found out, Joseph Scott Morgan. And I don't know why they didn't know it then. Dale Smith Jr. 25:46 allegedly beat his first wife, beat his second fiance and beat Michelle Parker as well. Unreported though it might be, now they know. And you know how they know? Because the man spent time in prison for it when he was in the military, Joe. He beat his wife in 26:05 the military and sold ecstasy to some other military men. 26:08 And they threw him away in the brig for three years and then dishonorably discharged him from the army. How did they not know that in 2011? 26:15 I don't know. And, you know, this goes to this kind of cycle of domestic violence, you know, that we've seen before. And no, it's not somebody having a bad day. It's, it's not, you know, because, uh, you know, your team 26:30 didn't win or whatever. This is, this is encoded behavior, uh, when you see it repeated over and over and over again. 26:40 And unfortunately, unfortunately with, um, with someone that becomes very, very comfortable with violence, um, I've always felt as though it's not too far of a reach or stretch for them once they're pushed to one particular point where they'll 27:02 go uber-violent at that point in time, ultra-violence, if you will. 27:07 Robbing that from Clockwork Orange. You think about someone going over the top in something like this and gets carried away. Now, I'm not saying that there wasn't intent. maybe this is something, but you take an individual that is already kind of 27:28 a hair trigger, not kind of, it sounds like, you know, based upon military background and the spousal, alleged spousal abuse and these sorts of things. You take that and then you throw kids into the mix with it. Okay. And you're, you know, you're shaking up a couple of sticks of 27:45 dynamite at that point in time, because you don't know what's going to happen. I'm not making an excuse here. 27:50 I'm just trying to get an understanding because one of the things about it is with this phone, um, that they were able to kind of unlock. And then you begin to see where this car, where the phone is moving to. There's a couple of bodies of water that 28:09 are involved in this. And we've had other cases in the Orlando area. Uh, Orlando is not for folks that are not familiar with, you know, geography in Florida. I know many of you are because you've been to the House of Mouse down there. Enough said about that. But, 28:27 you know, Orlando is landlocked, essentially. But there are a lot of these lakes that dwell. There's swampy areas, all kinds. 28:35 You can kind of take your pick. There's also a lot of agricultural areas around there, too. You've got ranching, cattle farms. You've also got orange groves all over the place, you know. And so you've got all of this area 28:52 where you could literally make something disappear quite easily. Wow. 28:58 And that's my thought, you know, with the movement of the car. Now, how would one go about taking, you know, Michelle's remains and, rendering them down to the point where you can dispose of them effectively. 29:14 Well, hey, let me ask you a couple of things, Joe, because there's a 46-page arrest affidavit that poured over this thing. 29:23 Let's go ahead. I mean, you guys know by now that Dale Smith Jr. was arrested and charged in the murder of Michelle Parker. That's why when you say allegedly beat her, because they were unreported, which is shocking. So I'm going to be honest with you, Joe. Um, you know, 29:40 I've talked about this, uh, with man doesn't hate you just one time. 29:44 Yeah. 29:45 It's always more than one. 29:47 Oh yeah. 29:47 If the thing is there should only be one. 29:50 Yeah. 29:51 And then you call me or Joe, we'll take care of the rest, but just leave them. Okay. You can't love them to be a good guy. They're not a good guy. Doesn't do it. But, um, Let me just get to the end. We got to get to the end of this because I got to ask you a 30:03 question about how are we going to put him in jail for the rest of his life if we don't have a body? Because, Joe, right the day that she went missing, okay, we know the last text message from her phone said Waterford, meaning Waterford Lakes. That was a 30:17 one-text thing to her brother. Where are you, Waterford? But they know now the investigators found the iPhone and once they broke it out in the last month, near Waterford. 30:29 It was miles away. It wasn't near Waterford Lakes, but it was with Dale Smith Jr. Yeah. And the thing is, is I want to get back to the very first thing he told police. Remember that she got there around four, dropped off the kids, was gone by 410. He left 30:46 right after that. That was his story. So police went and looked at his condo. They went there and investigated. Well, let's make sure that, you know, there's no blood or whatever. 30:56 We're looking for her. And he is going to be the first person they look at, right? He was pretty much the only person they ever looked at that just couldn't show anything because Joe, they looked at his place and it didn't look like anything had happened. Didn't look 31:10 like there was anything out of place. Didn't look like blood was anywhere. Nothing seemed to be broken. They don't know. 31:20 But when they started putting together these things, they found out. Okay. 31:24 Dale Smith Jr. allegedly lied because he Her phone, it was not there at 4 o'clock. Her iPhone was much earlier, a little before 3 o'clock. The People's Court episode aired at 2 p.m. Orlando time. Before 3 o'clock, Michelle Parker was at Dale Smith Jr. 31:46 's place. 31:47 They're both humiliated and embarrassed about the People's Court thing. Now, 31:54 her phone did not leave there, Joe. For a long time. 32:00 At least an hour and a half. From the time she got there to the time that phone left. Now, he said 10 minutes, 4 to 410. But now we know it was 245 to 430. Close. So, they know he's a liar. And that's where they started digging from there. Now, Joe, 32:23 one thing that did happen when she went missing, police brought him in. He's going to be your suspect. He had scratches. He had cuts all over him. You've read the description. How do you come about those? Because they 32:37 were described as what appeared to be possible defensive injuries from someone else. How does that happen? 32:44 Yeah. Well, it's interesting, the term defensive injury, because I think that many people conflate defensive injury with like the raising of the arm, for instance. And it's kind of a blocking thing, right? Well, a defensive injury can actually 33:00 present on a suspect in the sense that, let's just say that, and I don't know that this happened here. 33:08 I'm just giving you a hypothetical here. Let's say that within very intimate contact, it generally involves, I can tell you in a general sense, many times when you see this, it involves some kind of asexual death where you have 33:23 pressure on the neck, You have a smothering, for instance. 33:27 You see this a lot with people that are using pillows or a bag as they've weaponized a plastic bag. 33:36 And the person that is trying to fight for their life is defensively inflicting injuries on the perpetrator. So it's not like a defensive injury where the victim is raising their arm to try to block or parry an attack. 33:54 It's actually something that is transmitted from the victim onto that person's body. So what you will see, and I've often compared nail marks on an individual's body to the plowing of a field with the tines of the plow running behind a tractor. And you get these scratches that'll 34:18 come down on the sides of the face. You'll also see them on the neck too. I've seen them where you'll get these kind of long raking. And all three fingers or all four fingers will not necessarily be in contact. 34:34 You might just get two. And you'll see how deep they go. And you can have overlying injuries too. So you can get a scratch that's like this and then a scratch that's opposing in direction. 34:47 And those are defensive wounds. 34:49 Those are defensive wounds that are inflicted by a victim onto an aggressor. Wow, that explains so much. Semantics, when you're saying defensive injuries, it is defensive in the sense that the individual that's being attacked is trying to defend 35:06 themselves by inflicting an injury onto their attacker. Now, if we have bodies and we begin to examine them in the morgue, and we know that we have a suspect that's been hooked up on charges, we're going to look under the nails of the victim, the decedent, for anything 35:33 that's a tie back to a potential perpetrator. Hey, dude, where'd you get those marks on your face? Where'd they come from on your neck? Why do you have these elliptical kind of little tiny insults on the back of your hand? Well, elliptical insults, if you just imagine an 35:49 elliptical shape, okay, like a moon, okay, and that's dug in to the surface of the skin, well, it leaves these little impressions in the hand. They're very, very distinctive, by the way, you know, when you see them. It's like one of those, it's one of the few things 36:05 in forensics where you look at it and you go, oh, wow, those are fingernails, you know, because you see it, when you see it, it impresses you because there's so much pressure that goes behind it. You know that that's commonly 36:16 what it's associated with. Now, I'm not saying there aren't other objects out there that, you know, couldn't create this. However, you want to get beneath the nails of these. But unfortunately, we don't have Michelle. I think my question would be 36:30 relative to this alleged perpetrator is how well were these insults documented? Where were they? Because you can't, like in trial, you can't look at him and say, Well, first off, you can't compel him to testify, but you can have 36:50 other people make comment, but you cannot definitively say scientifically that Michelle generated these injuries on him. This is merely circumstantial information that they can look at and say, hey, you know what? He had injuries on his face, and 37:08 she disappeared. We haven't been able to find her. We can't explain the way these injuries, but we cannot actually say that she generated them. And that leaves you in a lurch here where, you know, now with a case like this, you're heavily dependent upon the timeline and also 37:26 the digital evidence in a case like this day. You know, brother, with Michelle, I'll be perfectly honest with you. I don't know where she is. I don't know that anybody actually does other than potentially the individual that last had contact 37:52 with her. The movement of the phone, I find it very curious as well. I think that there was like one lake. There's a series of these lakes up there that I had mentioned. I think Lake Conway is one of the directions that that phone was headed at one 38:07 point in time. And For those of you that have not been traveling around kind of the interior of Florida, I know a lot of people go to the beach and that sort of thing. But when you get away, you'd be surprised how many of these little lakes there are. 38:21 And they're all over the place. And it's prime real estate in order to get rid of a human remain. 38:29 You mentioned Lake Conway, Joe. And now we know at 418, remember how we had that timeline? 38:34 Yeah. 38:36 That Dale Smith Jr. 38:37 Gave. 38:37 That was the timeline that all of this investigation had been built on. I've done the story since 2011, Joe. 38:44 I know the timeline that we were working on. And until this month, until the last 30 days, and now we find out they've been able to break this down. 38:54 Lake Conway, you're dead on balls accurate. 4.18 p.m., Michelle Parker's phone is traveling with Dale Smith Jr., and lo and behold, both are traveling west towards Lake Conway. 39:09 Yeah, yeah. 39:11 At 4.18 p.m. 39:11 Yeah, and you're, you know, why would you be purposed to head there? I mean, it's free country, you can go anywhere you want to. 39:18 Except he said she left. She left eight minutes before then, Joe, according to him, but now they're together. 39:25 Yeah, and how do you explain that? You know, where you've got phones that are traveling in tandem with one another, which is kind of interesting, I think, here. And again, you would you would have to. And again, he cannot he's not capable of explaining this away. I think that 39:45 this is a big hook when it comes to the prosecution in this case. is that his story doesn't marry up with the forensic digital information that we have here. 39:56 And I don't know, I would imagine for a period of time, they're thinking, you know, maybe he was thinking that they, they'll never be able to unlock this thing. 40:04 They'll never be able to get access to it and, you know, kind of understand the movements and where the phone was and where he was and all this stuff. 40:11 And as, Words of Gilmer Powell, surprise, surprise, surprise. 40:16 You know, now, Joe, they've said not only do they have them traveling together towards Lake Conway when he said she was gone, but also they have been able to determine that once that Dale Smith Jr. deleted messages from Michelle Parker's phone. And the thing is, is that remember 40:38 I told you a minute ago I was going to show you some better character? 40:41 Yeah, sure. 40:41 All right, Michelle... She had three jobs. She's providing for her twins and another son, and she's doing the best she can. She's running tight on money. So in these text messages where some were just really mean, others were nice, 40:56 you know, I mean, they had years of time together, and, of course, they had the twins. Dale Smith Jr. tried to take advantage of Michelle Parker. He offered her money. 41:07 She needed money. He offered her $ 2, 000 to have sex with him. That's what he offered her. And she said, nope. 41:16 Tell you what, I'll take it as a loan if we put it in writing that it's a loan. But I'm, what do you think I am? You know better. I'm not doing that. So given the opportunity to take the easy way out, do something she had done before with him, 41:28 which is his attitude, because that's a guy. He's saying, well, we got twins. Why not? I'll give you two grand, which shows you his character, but more it shows you hers. 41:37 Now he's mad about that joke. He's mad that he got embarrassed on people's court. Got mad that she turned him down. Knowing she needs money bad and she would not do him. Yeah. That's where police are saying, this guy was on the edge. He'd already been on the 41:53 edge with his first wife, his second fiance. This is the third fiance. And we can't find her, but we can find his timeline is one big, fat, hairy lie. 42:05 Well, you know, this is what the police are alleging, too. Given... 42:09 You know, what is it, Nancy always says, you want another horse, look at the track record, right? So forgive me, didn't mean to steal that from you, Nancy, but it's the reality. You know, one of the commonalities in these 42:25 previous relationships he's had involving the domestic violence element here is that your boy loves to put his hands on women and not only put his hands on women, But in the most intimate way, try to strangle the life out of them, allegedly. I've talked about asphyxiation in the 42:47 past when it comes to control over an individual because, you know, it's not like shooting or even stabbing. The intimacy involved, and I'm glad you brought this up about, you know, him trying to initiate you know, sexual relationship with her again per. 43:09 Money. 43:12 He feels that intimately connected and certainly comfortable enough that he can actually make that request. Who does that? But because of this, you know, the rejection and everything, asphyxiation is such a personal thing. You're in somebody's space. You 43:30 talk about getting, I don't want you in my space. 43:32 People hear that, you know, that sort of thing. you literally have to wrap your hands around somebody's neck. If you're talking about a throttling, uh, which the police allegedly think that he did this to her and squeeze the life. 43:46 And I think that they're, they're drawing upon that based upon these previous circumstances, that this was essentially his MO, his modus operandi. And then you couple that with the evidence, um, that we've got defensive injuries on here. Remember, I was 44:03 talking about how intimate this is and you're trying to defend yourself or she is, Michelle is to try to drive him off. He's attacking her. He's got his hands wrapped around her throat. And it's, it's key here that I think that we understand that relative to what became 44:21 of her in that moment of death, you know, and again, we have to take a little bit of license with this, I think, because this is all alleged. Um, But the big question is, and I think also for her family and, you know, her kids, is that we don't know where 44:38 she is. And, you know, I think that we all kind of hold back and we have this Frank Capra look at life. And we think that, you know, somebody will have, you know, kind of a come to Jesus moment where, you know, all of a sudden the clouds 44:52 part and somebody suddenly, you know, grows a conscience and says, this is where she is. I'm brokenhearted over that, but Dave, you and I both know, brother, that this doesn't happen, man. 45:04 Not in the real world, but Joe, the one thing we do know is that Dale Smith Jr. has been arrested on second-degree murder charges. And investigators are confident that they can prove their case without a body. I asked you if it was possible, and you looked at the 45:25 forensics that they already have. The digital forensics. 45:29 Yeah. 45:30 And the forensics we don't know about with regard to the vehicle and some other things that we'll find out if it goes to trial. And by the way, he has– Dale Smith Jr. is presumed innocent until he's convicted by a jury of his peers or pleads guilty. But right now, 45:44 he's pleaded not guilty. 45:46 He has pleaded not guilty. We're going to see how this develops. I think it's, again– stacking tragedy upon tragedy across our country when it comes to domestic violence and events like this that robs everybody. It robs everybody of 46:02 the future. And not just Michelle, but also her family and her kids. Or it changes the course of life in a manner in which none of us can plumb the depths of, I think, to a great degree. But we'll see how this turns out. And it will make 46:19 for a compelling case. Given the absence of human remains here, these cases are very difficult to prosecute. And we'll see what tact the prosecution, you know, takes and also what the defense does in a case like this. You know, 46:35 how are they going to explain these things away? And, you know, it's really not their job to explain everything away. 46:41 Because what it comes down to, my friends, is the fact that it doesn't matter what Brother Dave or Joe Scott have to say about it. What matters is what that jury's going to say about it, what they're going to think, and is there enough, is there enough evidence 46:58 here to lay the blame squarely at his feet? I'm Joseph Scott Morgan, and this is Body Bags.
Community discussion