0:01 Body Bags with Joseph Scott Moore. You know what my favorite sandwich is? How could you know? But I'm going to tell you. My favorite sandwich in the entire world is a roast beef po' boy from Mother's Restaurant in 0:25 New Orleans, Louisiana, completely dressed with extra gravy. Now, for those of you that have never had a roast beef po' boy in New Orleans that is made the way that it should be made, you ain't living. Because the way you measure the quality of a roast beef po' boy 0:45 in New Orleans is that when you take a bite, when you take a bite, you have gravy that starts here at your wrist and it rolls down and it drips off of the tip of your elbow as you're bending up. That's when you know you got sufficient gravy 1:00 and oh my lord, it is so good. Well, today on Body Bags, we're going to talk about a sandwich in a context which I never in my wildest dreams thought that I would be conversing about. It's about a cheesesteak sandwich and how it was used to try to 1:20 leverage a case that is currently being tried. I'm Joseph Scott Morgan, and this is Body Bags. Brother Dave, don't give me any of these chain places. I don't go to places like Subway or Firehouse or any of that stuff. 1:43 If I'm going to go out and get a sandwich, I have to get in my car. And drive multiple hours to go home that or I'm going to make it myself. That's how strongly I feel about this. And there's a whole litany of po' boys, you know, and 1:57 I'm talking about made with real fresh French bread, not some kind of imitation thing. My second favorite is probably fried oyster. 2:06 Po' boy. Just so y'all know. Yeah. This is not a show about cooking or sandwiches. 2:12 It could be. 2:13 It could be. Because body bags, you know, we'll just start renaming sandwiches. You can buy the Dave. You can buy the Joe. 2:22 I pull bodies out of canals in New Orleans and out of the marshes in New Orleans. Out of the canals, you get bodies that have crawfish all over them. 2:34 Oh, okay. 2:35 And then out of the marsh, you get them that have blue crabs on them. Which is kind of fascinating. 2:40 You know, they're scavengers. 2:42 Yeah. Maybe that all fits. I don't know. But I know that I said a no to Joe. I'm like, OK, we actually first of all, Joe and I have an attorney friend that we've done Nancy Grace's show with over the years. His name is Randy Kessler. He's out of Atlanta. 2:59 When Joe and I first saw the name on the story, we both went, ah, the the suspect here is a 74 year old man named Robert Kessler. And Robert Kessler is accused of murder. He's accused of murdering a 47-year-old woman named Stephanie. And then making her body smaller intentionally 3:22 and putting the smaller parts into bags and putting the bag in a body of water to be found by fishermen. 3:33 Yeah. 3:33 That's the accusation here. And that is the case we're looking at. The victim, her name is Stephanie Crone Overholtz, 47, and her mother wants justice because this has turned into a mess is all I can think of. The suspect here is a 74-year-old blind man. Now, when I first 3:57 saw this story, Joe, I thought Robert Kessler was like a lifelong blind guy because that's the way the story is headlined. which goes to show you why you cannot believe headlines of stories or even the first paragraph a lot of the time. You got to read further to 4:13 find out that at the time of the alleged murder, Robert Kessler was not blind. And so that kind of changes everything, but we need to know why is he blind now, I guess, is the better thing. 4:32 Yeah, and it's a curious thing. You know, I got to share a little bit of insight to this. I was not tracking on this case so much. This came to me, and I think it came to you separately. 4:46 It wasn't me making you aware of it. All the work you have to do as a producer, you came across it. But Kimia brought it to my attention. So we're drinking coffee, which is our normal thing to do early in the morning. And she's reading over, you know, 5:01 she'll look at cases and all that. And she's sitting there and saying, how did a blind guy get mixed up in a case like this where he's being accused of a really horrific crime and then has the facility to be able to go out and essentially render down 5:20 a body and deposit parts of the body over a very widespread location. And, oh, by the way, not only is this guy sightless, uh, it turns out that he's non-ambulatory. 5:35 He's in a wheelchair. So you've got this thing that's kind of working as kind of the driver behind this, but you've got to go back to 2021, which I think is when all of this kicked off. He is hooked up on charges relative to this, and he's been 5:52 cooling his heels for a while. Well, Dave, in the meantime, he's developed cataracts, right? So they do cataract surgery, and You know, probably half the country has had cataract surgery. 6:05 You know, when you hit a certain age, you know, your eyes begin to, you know, to decline their abilities, that sort of thing. And you have the surgery where there's stuff you have to do in the wake of it. 6:18 It's not like you have the surgery and then good luck, God bless, Godspeed, you know, peace be with you. You have to take follow-up medication. Well, guess what this guy did? 6:30 He refused to take his meds. 6:31 Now, was he like in county jail waiting on trial? Yeah. 6:35 Yeah. He's hanging out there and he's ensconced there. And so while he, this is the way the defense attorney is telling the story. So while he is there, he's in decline as a result of his eyes and his refusal to do any kind of follow up, you know, 6:52 with this and this sort of thing. Well, he's bedridden. 6:56 So he begins to get the dwindles, you know, so he's laid up in the infirmary. And, you know, after a period of time, legs don't work anymore. You can't ambulate. 7:07 At least that's the story that the defense attorney is giving. 7:12 He wasn't like, okay, when he's accused of committing this heinous crime in November of 2021, he was 69 years old and he could see and he could walk, right? 7:26 Yes. Yeah. He was sighted and he was ambulatory at that point in time. 7:30 Now, five years later. He now is blind and in a wheelchair. Yeah. 7:35 Yeah. And, you know, yeah, it's an amazing thing because, you know, just when you think of it, you know, it's one of those things that we always say. If you if you were to walk into a Hollywood producer's office and try to pitch the story, they'd say, you're 7:47 an idiot. Get out of here. There's no way this could happen. Exactly. And it's one of those little curious little things that goes along the way. So but it also gives you an idea of the passage of time here and also. I don't care how blind you are, 8:01 and I don't care how wheelchair-bound you are. You committed what turns out to be an absolutely horrific homicide, Dave, against a woman that it would appear, and I think this probably goes without saying, it's kind of down on 8:18 her luck. She's an easy mark for whatever his reasoning was, allegedly. um, in, in this event. And so she's easy to kind of take advantage of. Um, you know, the story had gone is that she was down and out and needed a place to stay. And brother Dave, he, he offers her 8:41 this opportunity to stay at his place. And this is when things begin to kind of spiral out of control at this, at this point in time. 8:50 I kind of have an idea that he didn't say, um, hey, I'll give you a place to crash as long as you'll be my snack, you know, or be my victim. 8:59 I mean, I got a feeling that wasn't part of it. 9:02 By the way, the sub thing, the sandwich thing does come into play in this story. It does. It wasn't some weird aside that Joe is using to set you on some path because he's hungry. It actually fits into this story, but you're going to have to wait because 9:15 we can't do it yet. It comes up later on because right now we're still trying to figure out, Joe and I are trying to figure out why as a 47-year-old woman, in the home of a guy. Again, at the time he's 69 and he might be a little bit older, but he's able to walk and talk and 9:31 he can see. And he's not the same guy, I guess what I'm pointing out. The guy that we see in court or don't see in court because he won't go in there. But again, later on. 9:42 Again, that's another piece to this. It's really super bizarre. Yeah. 9:46 But it makes you just wonder, you know, what we're seeing now is not a good example of of what was taking place in his world five years ago. I think it's a good way to put it. Yeah. 9:59 Yeah, it is. And I got to tell you, there's part of me, I've seen enough of these trials now, you know, over my period of time of covering things in the media where I've seen people that are in our psychology people that are out there will understand this. 10:16 When you get somebody that is engaged or they are being accused of something, many times they will feign illnesses. 10:25 And they actually call it feigning is what they'll say. 10:28 It's kind of like deceptive behavior in order to influence an outcome. I'm not saying he's doing that. However, there are many people that lose their sight that are not suddenly you know, bedridden. And, you know, and I guess you can't compel him, you know, to get out of 10:51 the bed and go do physical therapy or whatever it is. 10:55 If he chooses to lay there, he will. We know that muscles atrophy, your brain begins to get real sloggy, if you will. And that sort of thing can, in fact, happen. But, you know, Dave, I've got questions about this in the 11:09 sense that this is a trial, right? involving appearances here. 11:16 And not just his inability to see any longer, but the appearances of how he presents himself in this courtroom environment where he looks very disheveled, hair is a mess, kind of scraggly beard that he has here. And he comes rolling in in a wheelchair. And I don't know, 11:38 to me, it smacks... of kind of playing on the emotions and leveraging that before the court. 11:46 Robert Kessler met Stephanie in a McDonald's parking lot, Joe. 11:51 And while they were talking in the parking lot, he found out that Stephanie was living in her car at the time, a 2008 Hyundai, I think, something along those lines. 12:02 But so they meet and he's like, I got a three bedroom, two bath house. So come on, you come and stay with us. Now, Do you know how many bad things are happening in the space of a three minute conversation in a parking lot at a McDonald's? There's 12:17 a lot because you've got options, friends. Look, I'm all for helping people. I really am. And I think a lot of us are. Nobody wants to see somebody living in their car if they can avoid it. But before you invite somebody into your home, you have to know 12:31 more about them. And there are options, you know, for for help. But anyway, that's how Stephanie this. A 47-year-old woman ends up in this man's home. Now, when we look at some of the information that has come out, it was Robert Kessler's daughter who said he heard Robert 12:54 and Stephanie arguing in her room, in Stephanie's bedroom. And it was, she couldn't tell, because, you know, listening through walls when people are talking, even if they're loud, it's muffled just enough that you can't quite make out what 13:07 they're saying. And she the daughter says she couldn't tell, but it was that Stephanie wanted something from Robert. That's what it came down to. 13:15 Anyway, it's his space. So, you know, you can imagine he gets to call the shots within an environment. And look, it's it's real easy to call the shots when the person that that is there that you have invited in. 13:31 And trust me, he he was able to observe what her status in life was. It's easy to leverage somebody like that. 13:37 Right. 13:38 Because, you know, contrary to what people say, there are always strings attached. People might say their heart is in the right place, but particularly for those that are vulnerable, living out on the streets, and also, by the way, the mother of three, she's got a lot to lose 13:57 in this life, including her own. Dave, as you well know, I'm a big fan of the Gulf Coast. I love it. 14:18 I love the fact that the water is so very beautiful and white sand beaches. You don't get beat to death by the waves like you do in other locations around the country. And the Tampa Bay area where Stephanie lives, breathed her last, um, is, is one such place. There's 14:40 all kinds of locations around there that you can go to. 14:43 And it's just, it, to me, it's really beautiful. Now, Tampa's kind of hard to get around in. It's really fast growing, a lot of traffic, oh my Lord. But you do, you get out from, you get out from Tampa and it's just absolutely gorgeous. As a matter of fact, 14:57 do you remember when we were covering the, um, Gabby Petito run laundry case? A lot of the stuff where he is found is on that portion of the Gulf Coast, approximating this area. And there's so many places you can go to. There's a lot of estuaries and bays and 15:17 all this sort of thing. Well, Dave, the way people kind of found out that Stephanie was, in fact, no longer with us, or they didn't really know it was Stephanie at first, is that fishermen that are out on a place called McKay Bay, which is adjacent to Tampa, 15:38 they're finding body parts that have apparently been wrapped up in bags, Dave, and just kind of pre-floating out there in this bay, brother. 15:46 This entire case, okay, is really not what it seems to be. He has a seven-year-old who at the time was referred to as his daughter living in the home with him. That's not true. This little girl... The girl's mother is a woman named April Thompson. Now, April Thompson 16:08 died from an accidental drug overdose in September of 2021. 16:13 Two months. Two months before. Robert Kessler is accused of killing Stephanie Krohn Overholt. All right. Now, when April dies, the little seven year old continues living with Robert Kessler. 16:34 he never formally adopted her, Joe. So she's now 12 and she is a big part of this case because she can talk about where Stephanie was living in the house, what the relationship was like, what was going on that day. 16:50 And it is this little girl who is talking about hearing the argument that went on and then relating that the next day she didn't see Stephanie and But Stephanie's room smelled bad or different. Now, after Kessler's arrest in 2021, the little girl was put into foster care. 17:15 Thank God. 17:16 Yeah. Because all I could think of, Joe, wait a minute. 17:19 We've got a drug overdose of a woman who is living in Kessler's home. She dies in September. And by November, he's replacing her. With a homeless woman he finds at McDonald's, do you see a pathway here? 17:34 Yeah, I do. And again, it goes back to being able to leverage those that have less than what we have. 17:40 It's like the Billy House of Horrors. 17:42 Yeah, it kind of is. And this guy is displaying what would seem to be at least some kind of predatory behavior. Now, I guess you could argue that he's just, you know, an absolute altruist and he's there to help people all around. In McDonald's parking lots all over the 18:03 greater Tampa area, you know, he's just going out looking for people he can help. That's me being snarky there. 18:11 Oh, no. 18:12 But, you know, you think about it and why exactly would you invest your time in a person like Stephanie? 18:22 and right on the heels of what had happened to April and her passing. And now you've actually got a seven-year-old girl that is living in the house with you. 18:32 And I got to tell you, spotty senses are tingling here. 18:36 You know, you think about kind of a foreshadowing, you know, kind of a dark road. This could go down pretty quickly. 18:44 And the fact that the seven-year-old child would have at least been an earwitness to to an argument that's going on inside the house. And then she makes note of the fact that the space that Stephanie had been residing in had an odor to it when she goes in there. 19:05 So I think one of my questions would be, well, from how much time has elapsed between the time of the argument to the time when the child notes that she is missing, she's no longer around And they have the smell in the house because that comes into play, Dave. 19:25 It does. And again, you know, Joe, this story is so much different than what it appears to be. And I keep reminding folks of that because as you, like I do, I tune in. Joe will tell me about a story that he's heard about or knows about. And 19:39 I immediately, I'm Googling, you know, I'm doing, I'm looking to see, well, what's going on. And in this particular case, the blind man accused of killing and um, rendering down a body. Yeah. First of all, that is right down the body bags alley, but it's not what it appears 19:57 to be at all. And in reality, it looks like a A predator is accused of doing what he does. 20:07 And I wonder, Joe, how many more? You don't start at the age of 69 with killing. That's not where you start. That's where you finish. 20:17 We've talked about that in other cases as well. If you've got a perpetrator that's been doing something for a while and when they're at their peak, they have all their faculties about them. But as you see them in decline... 20:35 they're not as sharp as they used to be. And they make mistakes. They, you know, and you don't have the physical ability that you once had because this is intense stuff. If this is not his only victim, I've got questions about the OD case now too, to be 20:50 perfectly frank with you. And how well was that body examined? 20:57 You know, what efforts had they make? And one more big piece to this is that I would be very interested in his home to know if sampling was done throughout the house to see what other kinds of unidentified DNA might be existent inside of that dwelling. Also, any 21:19 kind of luminescence that we begin to think about with blue star or luminol and those sorts of things. Because what this comes down to is you've got a child that is actually saying that it smelled odd or smelled funny. 21:33 Is it a combination of, as it turns out, you know, we've got body parts that are popping up in McKay Bay. 21:44 Has there been a rendering down inside of that house? 21:49 And also, how long had those remains, which had been rendered, how long had they been retained? Do we have any kind of decompositional event going on that may have taken place, say, for instance, in the room, Stephanie was staying in. Was 22:05 that the odor that was being smelled or was it a chemical odor like or a combination of both? Like, was there an effort to clean up? So there's you know, you've got this entire, you know, spectrum of things that the police have to look at in a case like this. 22:20 And of course, I think that you would I think that you would probably agree with me that the fact that that an individual would be so bold to do something like this, allegedly. And plus, just recently having a lady that he was connected to because we have evidence 22:40 of the seven-year-old child, what actually became of her? And then from there, you know, as an investigator, I'm thinking, well, how much further out does this extend? Right. 22:51 Okay. So five years ago, now he's been off the street since then, but his relationship with April- had been going on for a while, long enough that at some point during the relationship, they became so argumentative and violent 23:10 towards one another. I'm talking about Kessler and April Thompson now before her death, that the daughter ended up moving in with the maternal grandparents for a time before April's death. 23:25 And After April died, and again, there was only eight weeks between the time April allegedly died of a drug overdose until the time that we know he picked up Stephanie at the McDonald's parking lot. So we don't really know. 23:37 There's that window of eight weeks that's being put together now of what was taking place. Need to dig in. 23:45 I'll spend some time finding out more about April Thompson's passing. 23:48 But to get to what we're because that's going to come up, Joe, you know, if anything nefarious happened. But anyway, right now we are dealing with the murder of 47 year old Stephanie and the incarceration in county jail and 24:04 physical decline of Robert Kessler, who is now 74 years old, blind and in a wheelchair. So a very sympathetic figure if you're just looking at him in a courtroom and he doesn't look like the monster. You know what? The devil doesn't show up looking like the devil or you 24:22 wouldn't go with him. So. 24:24 You know, Dave, I think one of the key things here to think about is exactly how in the world did the fishermen come around or come about seeing the body? 24:40 Because I've got to tell you, I've done a lot of fishing over the years. And if I see a plastic bag floating in the water, I'm not touching it. Period. 24:54 Because I don't know what's contained in it. You know, there are some people that are curious. George is out there. 25:02 I ain't one of them. I'm just going to kind of go on by it. But, you know, when you're fishing and this is a saltwater brackish area, you know, because you can fish for just about any species in here, more than likely, particularly if you're over near like where 25:17 you have freshwater dumping into the bay. And of course, You've got the Gulf of Mexico just over to the west, and it's feeding. So you've got these kind of two things blending. So they could be out there fishing for anything. 25:29 Are they fishing? Is it surface fishing that they're doing? 25:32 Or are they fishing on the bottom? Are they using lures? 25:37 Are they using popping corks? Maybe they're out there trying to catch speckled trout. I don't know. But in this environment, I wonder what drew them. to these elements that are floating out there in the bay. Did they actually hook on to a bag, for instance? And my Lord in heaven, 25:56 what a surprise. If you snag this thing and then you bring it on board with you and you pull out your filet knife or whatever it is that you're using, maybe, and I'm just, you know, kind of projecting here and you cut this thing open and you look and there's 26:11 part of a leg, you know, where... Where exactly do you go from here? And also, how long did it take them to collect the totality of the remains that they have? Because, Dave, I've got to tell you, as it turns out, yes, bags were recovered out of McKay Bay. 26:30 But you know what else? We're still missing parts. Music 26:45 You know, Dave, it's quite the conundrum for us in forensics when we have particulated bodies and we're trying to determine, well, first off, what exactly do we have anatomically? Because that's a big part. No pun intended, but it's a big 27:02 part to the overall investigation. And, you know, you begin to think about, well, whoever did this heinous crime, whoever abused the corpse here, they are missing certain elements here. 27:23 What did they do with those? Because Dave, I can tell you when you do body recoveries and there are specific elements that are, that are missing. And I'll, I'll talk about things like, for instance, like anything that has 27:37 some kind of that's leans heavily into a sexual connotation. 27:41 Like there are some people, if you're, If people are willing to put the cold steel, as I say, to human remain and particulate it, they're willing to do just about anything. If they have some kind of aberrant behavior that they're involved in, we've had cases where people have 27:57 removed breasts off of women. They've retained them. The sexual organs are actually removed. The internal, obviously, with females, those are retained. There are cases out there where the uterus and the ovaries have been retained. And there's one other 28:15 element here, which we still do not have in that case, and that is a head. The head in this particular case is gone. So when we're trying to understand all of this evidence that's being brought in, our first job here is to try to get a body identified. And 28:39 it's not like there is a DNA bank out there where we can take a sample off of a rendered body that is particulate and just floating about, and we can take that sample and put it into our gigantic super-duper database, and it spits out a result. It doesn't 28:58 work that way. So even though we have this fantastic technology that's out there with DNA, if you've got a body where the individual is not in any kind of database, it's not worth the gunpowder to blow it to hell. 29:14 So you have to look into other places. And in this particular case, Dave, the body that we have, the body that we actually have that has been pulled up from the bay has got a very, very interesting tattoo on it. And it's actually a tattoo that is, it's 29:38 got scroll work. Okay. Um, and it's kind of fusing together. 29:45 I'm not an artist, but you've got three hearts with scroll work overlying each heart and each, each scroll over each heart has a name. And And as it turns out, guess who has three sons named Sean, Greg, and Zach? 30:06 It's Stephanie. And so I think that that's part of how they came to the conclusion that it was here. 30:12 And if I'm not mistaken, they did push out this information, didn't they? 30:17 Because they did not have an identification on Stephanie. And so you've got this articulated remains found in bags by a fisherman in a bay that And nobody's claiming, you know, you're talking about nobody's missing in Tampa. You know, nobody's 30:32 being looked for that would fit this. So police put out what they had, which was the tattoo. And that tattoo went viral. And it goes up to Erie, Pennsylvania, where Stephanie was from. And by the way, she had been reported missing in Erie, Pennsylvania. So this missing woman 30:53 from Erie, PA is then identified as the what was left of the body found in Tampa in McKay Bay. 31:02 So it's one of those weird little asides to an investigation because you got to the other part of this, Joe, Robert Kessler. Okay. The linchpin of all of this. Well, he wasn't at his home at the time. Robert Kessler was arrested November 22nd on a cocaine charge. Yeah. So 31:23 he's sitting in jail on cocaine charges when they're, they're trying to identify the body. And that's where the circle begins with Robert Kessler. So go back to April Thompson dying in September of a drug overdose. You've got Robert 31:41 Kessler sitting in county on drug charges with intent to sell. 31:46 And you have a missing woman out of Pennsylvania who had been homeless and staying at his house supposedly. So As this starts to come together a little bit, police identify Stephanie as the woman found in the bay, but they still have to identify Joe. Did she do herself in? 32:07 Yeah, hardly. That's not the case because in their rendering, their final rendering relative to this body that they have, the medical examiner lists the cause of death as four. 32:24 four stab wounds to the neck. Oh, wow. Okay. 32:28 Okay. 32:28 Well, my big question is how much of the neck was left? Because you literally have a decapitation going on here. 32:37 Yeah, you said there was no head, right? 32:39 Yeah, there is no head. So, you know, you can decapitate an individual, obviously at various levels. Our friends out there are very bright. They understand that. So depending upon how high up you go, You're going to leave the 32:57 remainder of the anatomy intact. The weird thing about this, and just kind of chew on this for a second, is if you are aware and if you're the alleged perpetrator and you're aware of how she died, why would you leave that big piece of evidence? You're going to 33:15 all of this trouble to render down a body and 33:21 then you go north of the injuries, leaving them behind 33:27 so that the rest of the world can see what is there and draw their final conclusions. Because, yeah, I guess you could say, and we've had this before, we know that someone has died as a result of a homicide. 33:44 And generally, with the absence of any kind of injury, like if you have a body that has been completely rendered down, The medical examiner will not say, okay, they died of something specific. They'll say homicidal trauma. That's generally 34:00 what they'll say without saying anything. Here we have a case where the medical examiner is identifying four stab wounds to the neck. So that means that the neck is still there for this individual to examine and to hold forth on, but you're missing the head. It just seems 34:19 kind of frenzied to me. from the perspective of why would you go to all of this trouble and then leave evidence of what you have done? Because I've got to tell you, with McKay Bay out there, and I talked a little bit about the nature of an environment 34:34 like this, I don't know that there will ever be a chance that they can find everything that is left or was left behind or that is missing, rather. I think that they're very fortunate to find what they have found. 34:51 And some of that is relying upon the fact that this individual, after he did this, went to the trouble of wrapping up the body in plastic. And that's a big failure for many of these people that do this. 35:03 We have these cases over and over again where they will place body parts in bags and then transport them to wherever they're going And most of the time, you know, they'll tie them off and then throw them in the water. 35:17 And then there you go. Those parts are actually preserved to a great degree. Whereas if these remains were essentially dumped into an environment like McKay Bay that is just rife with all kinds of animal life, aquatic life in there, 35:37 that would feast on everything there. They're kind of preserved at that point in time. It's, you know, every time we cover cases like this, any of these cases, I'm always amazed at kind of the mistakes you look back and you see the perpetrators made. And if they had 35:53 just kind of altered their trajectory just a slight bit, there's a big possibility that they wouldn't have what they have right now, Dave. 36:02 Looking back at this entire case, looking at the suspect, the sandwich part that we started with, is getting ready to enter this case, but I want to give you a timeline, Joe. Um, the timeline for Stephanie and Robert Kessler is Stephanie moves in, in early November. Um, the 36:20 law enforcement has set up a timeline that begins November 5th. Uh, that is the day investigators believe Kessler killed Stephanie, uh, after an argument reportedly over money. Um, Stephanie made her last known phone call on November the 5th and, um, 36:38 placed her, the phone records placed her and Kessler near the same cell tower. So they were together when she made that last cell phone call. Witnesses reportedly saw a man dumping a black garbage bag and containers into McKay 36:56 Bay from the 22nd Street causeway. This is somewhere between November 6th, November 9th. Now, I don't know why we've got a three-day window here, Joe, but they were able to use surveillance video on November 7th at a pet 37:13 boys where it showed a man resembling Kessler parking Stephanie's vehicle and walking away. November nine investigators use cell phone photo data to place Kessler at the Bay. Um, on November 11th, a fisherman discovered the human leg in McKay Bay. Uh, 37:32 eventually additional human remains are found the next day. Uh, so you've got, uh, families, uh, Stephanie's family recognizing the tattoo, which identifies, it starts the identification because they were working hard to get her identified. But once they were able 37:48 to get it narrowed down, Joe, uh, that she was staying at Kessler's house, they, he apparently drove her car to that pet boys and dumped it. Um, you've got a guy who's a known drug dealer, by the way, uh, Robert Kessler, Joe has a long list of criminal offenses. Um, 38:06 11 convictions for cocaine possession, nine convictions for cocaine sales, one grand theft conviction, and another smaller one. So you've got a guy with a history, a criminal history that dates back to 1987. But that was the earliest reported 38:25 record I could find in Tampa Bay. And so this is a lifelong criminal. He has a woman who's living in his home, dies of a drug overdose, allegedly, in September. 38:36 Two months later, another woman who had been living with him is found in pieces in the bay. 38:44 Yeah. Yeah. 38:46 There you go. Yeah. 38:48 And again, this goes back to, you know, trying to follow this through and trying to understand how long he's been involved in this, you know, nefarious behavior that he's engaged in. The fact that he has this litany of previous charges, a lot of it, but a lot of 39:05 it doesn't seem like it extends out to violence. You know what I'm saying? Most of it is like this kind of transactional thing, whether it's drugs or thievery or whatever is going on with him. But now it begins to escalate. Or is this something that has always been 39:23 a part of him throughout his existence in this world? 39:29 It's curious now because you see him in this degraded state in the courtroom coming in. And what kind of took an interesting turn the other day is that Kessler, who, by the way, has fired his defense attorney, which is fascinating to me. 39:56 Fired and rehired, Joe. Fired and rehired. 40:00 Yeah. 40:01 And a public defender. It's a public defender for. 40:04 Crying out loud. You're firing and rehiring your public defender. 40:08 The idea was that he was going to defend himself. 40:13 And he goes to actually bargain with with the judge. 40:21 And he's like, yeah, you know, I'll give you this if you will just simply give me a Philadelphia cheesesteak sandwich and a Pepsi. And he had very specific demands as to what he wanted on this cheesesteak. And for that, he's going to roll over on this case. And it 40:42 was kind of interesting. You know, you rarely hear You rarely hear judges kind of chuckle about something, particularly when you're talking about a case that is so incredibly over the top. The judge is like, well, I appreciate this offer, 41:01 but there is no way I can accept this at all. 41:05 And of course, you know, Kessler has now stated that he is not guilty in this case. He is not rolled over. He's charged with homicide. And he's also charged with the abuse of a corpse at this point in time. 41:20 There are so many things that stick out right away on this case. And I'm wondering, where is Robert Kessler headed with this from a defense standpoint, Joe? Because you mentioned that his blindness was caused by cataract surgery and 41:35 his failure to take medication. That's why he's blind. And he wasn't in a wheelchair when he came into jail. 41:42 He's in a wheelchair now. So he's causing these physical problems for himself. But then he fires his, you know, court appointed lawyer, tries to negotiate. Hey, I'll plead guilty. 41:55 I want the Philly cheesesteak. I want French fries. And by the way, a 20 ounce Pepsi. He specifically. Yeah. 42:00 He specifically asked for a 20 ounce Pepsi. So he's very specific. And when the judge says no. Well, then he brings his attorney is. Well, I need my court appointed attorney back. But Joe. He also, Tom Kessler here, he didn't want to be in the courtroom. 42:14 Yeah. 42:15 So he's outside the courtroom. He's not in the court. 42:18 He's outside the courtroom, which I'm wondering, what is he trying to set up here? Is he trying to set up that he's a Clancy defense? 42:27 I don't know. Maybe it is. Or maybe he's just trying to find some way to weasel out of this in some way, you know, where he'll, you know, they'll either reduce the charges or. some miracle will occur and they'll say that, well, we don't have enough evidence to 42:44 go forward. I think the prosecution would beg to differ here because I think that they have sufficient data, you know, along with whatever is going on in the house, whatever happened in that house, and also this imagery that they 43:00 have where he is seen placing these remains or what appear to be remains in the bay itself off of the causeway. So all of this is quite compelling. And I've got to tell you, I think that, you know, far be it from me to give anybody advice in 43:16 some local jurisdiction down there. However, if it were me, I would be wanting to take a long look at this individual's history to see if there are any other potential cases he could have been connected with that involve women that are in desperate need. straits that have no 43:37 other way to make it in this world, and they'll do anything to merely survive. I'm Joseph Scott Morgan, and this is Body Bags.
Community discussion