0:01 Body Bags with Joseph Scott Moore. 0:10 A while back, Brother Dave and I covered a story involving arguably one of the worst cases that I've come across from an acute standpoint of abuse involving not just a small child, but a newborn. And not just one newborn, but two. Today we have an update. And as I 0:36 promised back then, we would dive back into this case. 0:42 And I think that it's very important because things have changed now. The ground has moved beneath our feet a bit. 0:49 If we can say in a good way, I would say in a good way. Because now we have more of an explanation of what happened to two precious little angels one of which has died, and we now have an understanding of the dynamics of the injuries involving not 1:11 only his death, but the injuries sustained by his little brother in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. I'm Joseph Scott Morgan, and this is Body Bags. it's no secret, Dave, I hate these kinds of cases. It's something that just absolutely, uh, rocks 1:36 everybody to their core. Um, and, but I, I think, uh, you know, if you go around and I, I do sometimes, you know, you try to rationalize what, what value, uh, these cases have, you know, when we talk about them. 1:51 And I think that from my perspective, all right, I have to say that, um, For me, I want people to understand that we're in a world that is filled with monsters. 2:08 Oh, my gosh. 2:10 Absolute monsters that will do anything to the least of us. 2:16 And as you noticed, we're not talking about a perpetrator that went out against two full-grown criminals. construction workers here. 2:28 We're talking about babies. 2:31 Oh, yeah. Six weeks old. Six weeks old. Joe, the kicker on this one, OK, as we start the story of Nicole Verzi, when we first did the story, we were all kind of looking at this going, wait a minute. 2:46 Why was she there? What was she doing? Because Nicole Verzi lives in San Diego. But She was best friends with the mother and father of these twins, Savannah Roberts and Ethan Katz. They were the parents of the twins, Leon and Eric Katz, six week old boys, twin boys. 3:07 And Nicole had been in Savannah's wedding party. She was a bridesmaid or was. 3:12 It was the girl like a server, you know, that. Yeah. 3:17 The ring of honor girl or whatever. Anyway, I know y'all are screaming at the screen going, how do you not know that? Well, she was that. And she's a former clinical psychology doctoral student. 3:29 All right. 3:29 This is an educated woman. And she was best friends with the mom and dad. She had come from San Diego. 3:35 She's out in Pennsylvania to visit her best friend and to help with the kids. Because, first of all, having twins is a handful for anybody who's ever had twins. Look, having one child, that'll rock your world. You add two, whoo, buddy. 3:52 And so at six weeks old, Nicole had been there for a few days, and she was living in her own place. She was not staying at their place. She had got her own. And she was there to help, okay? 4:03 And one thing that she had done was, I'll watch the twins, and y'all can go have a date night. 4:10 Because think about it. Um, carrying twins, you know, for a nine month pregnancy twins, it's a lot different pregnancy than just one. And, uh, anyway, all I could think of is what a great friend, right. To, to come to town, to be there and help you out. So 4:27 while she's watching Leon and Aerie that afternoon, Joe, um, and Savannah and Ethan are just out being a couple and enjoying their time. They get a phone, they get a picture on the phone and a text, um, Aria's hurt. 4:43 Something's going on. You know, I just noticed this on his genitals. And that picture is enough for them to go. 4:52 It's like at 635 in the evening. They're in the middle of dinner. 4:56 Yeah. 4:56 Yeah. We got to go home. This is our six week old baby. We got to go home. And so they did. They go straight back to the babies, man. 5:04 And they're like, thank you so much, Nicole. This we got to figure out what's going on. She goes, hey, I got it. You take care of him. 5:12 I got Leon. 5:14 I'm right here with him. I'll take care of this little baby. You go take care of him. So they did. 5:19 They went to the hospital with Arie. And they were trying to figure out what could have possibly caused this to happen to Arie. And while they were there with Arie at the hospital, another call. Leon has been taken to the hospital, Joe. Bumped his head. He's hurt. I 5:44 can't imagine what these parents were going through in that moment. 5:49 No, I can't either. And you talk about really doubling up on trauma here. And when I'm saying trauma, I'm talking about and I'm thinking back to, you know, when I was a young father and you you worry about everything, you know, I mean, mom does the majority of the work. OK, 6:09 but as a daddy. You know, anything that's wrong with them, you want to try to attend to it. And I cannot, this wave of terror, horror that washes over you because it's not just one child that you're thinking about now. 6:26 You've got two. And why in the world would, in an otherwise seemingly normal context, How do you have two six-week-olds that sustained this kind of significant trauma that is going to require medical treatment? And, you know, the one 6:50 constant in the universe here is actually the friend, right? 6:56 One thing I was thinking of, Joe, and I don't know how to actually ask this, but what type of injury could a six-week-old baby... to their genitals because that was what got Airy away. That's what split the children up was that Airy had injuries and some were to his genitals. 7:21 It didn't make sense to me in the sense from the perspective of if you're thinking about some kind of manifestation on a baby's body and you're talking about genitals, the first thing I'm going to think of is they're unclean, unkempt, 7:39 dirty diaper, you know, they're wetting themselves and you're not changing the child. But Dave, what's related in this initial conversation, it doesn't sound like that. This actually sounds like trauma, trauma to this child's genitalia. Now, if you, you know, 8:00 and there are certain complications with little baby boys, uh, that can happen if they've been circumcised, you can get like secondary infections and all these sorts of things. 8:10 Andrew was born with a hernia. He had a testicular hernia and boy, you want to get scared. Holy free holies. 8:17 It was, could not, couldn't leave him with, uh, at daycare that they wouldn't keep because of that. You know, you're like, Hey, cause they didn't want to be accused of doing something wrong. It would look, it was that severe, but That was dealt with early on, you know, and 8:30 it was very specific. And that's why I said, what could it possibly have been that happened in that moment? 8:36 You know, because the baby was fine when they left and not fine when they get home at 630 and take him to the hospital. 8:44 The math doesn't add up here. You know, when you think about how how specific, you know, this particular trauma is and not not just. not just the fact that he's got, you know, there's like bruising, swelling, these sorts 9:07 of things that have been inflicted upon this little angel's genitalia. Dave, this child has got scratches on his face. So you probably remember this as a young parent, you might recall it, you know, babies, you know, they'll put, many times they'll 9:23 put mittens on baby's hands, you know, so they don't scratch their faces. And, I remember having this with one of my children along the way, and you don't like to see it, but it's explainable. 9:37 My grandson, Braylon- He was a gripper like that, you know, and he would do my face. And if I didn't shave, OK, he would. It felt so weird to him. I for the first year of his life, I had scratches on my face and in my arms like it looked like 9:52 I was getting abused by somebody. And it was so funny because I didn't realize it until I looked back at pictures and went, dude, you were terrible. me. 10:00 But you know what? I would go back in time and receive any of those insults to my face because it's such a precious time. It is. 10:08 It's just amazing. 10:09 And you know, the thing about babies is that, and we still do it as adults, but we're very tactile creatures. 10:16 And so babies explore the world, you know, with their hands and with their mouth. And as they get older, we're talking about six weeks old, this is very young, to kind of be experiencing the world around them. And every child is different relative to their development. But when 10:33 you see injuries like this, oh, and by the way, relative to Ari, there is another interesting injury that this precious one has sustained. He's also got um a contusion or contused area beneath his belly button okay so this 10:57 is not associated with the genitalia there's actually an area that's inferior to his belly button how how in the world yeah how in the world do you do you actually explain that because as we've talked about many times on body bags is that you know when you have 11:15 a contusion that's evidence of impact trauma um And babies, you know, babies are so fragile, you know, their little skin and everything. But they're also very pliable. And I'm thinking about this and I'm thinking, you know, how in the world could any adult that is in charge, if 11:37 you're asked directly about this brother, how are you going to explain this? How do you explain that this child has not just a swollen penis, and also other insults to his genitalia, but he's got a contusion on his belly and his face is scratched and they don't go 11:58 into a lot of detail relative to the facial scratches. Um, you know, anytime that we're looking at kind of trauma like this to a face and we have scratch marks, how many times have we talked about scratches in regards to sexual assault? 12:13 Right. 12:14 Um, And by the way, that's not off the table here as far as I'm concerned, because anytime you have trauma to genitalia, and this is a very personal thing to me, you begin to think, is there, you know, why that specific area as opposed to, say, on the 12:34 backside or on the lower legs or on the arm? 12:37 This is very, very specific. So what would a person do? 12:44 be communicating via this kind of trauma, these kinds of insults to this little one's body. It's almost like a striking out to me. You know, I've seen cases where you have genitalia that are so grievously traumatized. You know, 13:05 I'm a death investigator, so we're seeing this as it's like an adjunct to everything else that led up to the death. But, you know, Aerie didn't die. You know, Aerie, Aerie survived. Um, and the fact that you've got this individual that is saying, I'll watch, I will watch Leon. 13:25 You go ahead and take him to the hospital. Um, I was thinking about something just, just a moment ago. Uh, you know, you were talking about a date night. That's like gold to new parents. Oh my Lord. Uh, you know, and I, I remember, you know, when Kimmy and I 13:40 wanted to go out of the house and we had somebody to watch the watch the kids. It's like, oh my Lord, you know, I just, you just want to breathe free air for even if it's just two hours to sit across the table from one another, you know, and enjoy a meal, have a glass of wine and 13:55 just relax and maybe reflect. It might be the first, the very first time they had a chance to catch their breath and reflect on this joy that they have in their life. But brother Dave, this turned to absolute terror, man. 14:08 Well, you know, when you look at this, okay, you look at the injuries on Aerie and, We realize, and you already said this, Ares survived. So while his injuries were significant enough to be treated because they're, well, where 14:20 did these come from? You don't get scratches on your head, arms, you know, you don't get this by just laying in a crib. So what happened? And all I'm thinking of is, was this so planned out that she focused, we're talking 14:38 Nicole Versi, She focused injuries on one child just enough so that mom and dad would have to take her so that she could be alone to focus all of her evil intentions on one of the children. Because that's what happened. She was left alone with Leon from 6.30 p.m. 14:56 until I believe it was 11 o'clock when she called for 911. And it was on that call when she said, He bumped his head. I dropped him. I think that was her call. Wasn't it that he had fallen? He had fallen and sustained a head injury. I wanted to make sure of that. 15:17 I think that the story was that he had fallen and struck his head on a bassinet. I'm thinking right now, the bassinets that we had in our house, I can tell you this. You may get a little bump on your noggin if you bump up against the edge of 15:39 a bassinet, but you don't expect to see that there would be such trauma to a head that it would lead to the death of a six-week-old child. 15:52 Music Dave, I. 16:04 Got to tell you, I'm kind of perplexed here. Who would, in their right mind, would be able to make a comment relative to the parents to explain away what they're watching in real time? And also to take it up another notch, the police are going to have their eye 16:31 on something like this. I mean, In the medical legal world, when we have the death of a child, it's a full-court press with everything that we do, at least in the offices I've been involved with. I'm very proud of our practice when it came to child deaths and how 16:49 we handled them. We would look under any kind of rock with this. I'm thinking if it were I that were sitting there you know, with an individual and I've got questions, volumes of them. I want, you know, help me understand how all of this happened because I got 17:09 to understand the dynamics of this because it's going to have to be explained to the medical examiner and what they can factor in relative to their assessment. Going back to Ari just for a moment, when he's being treated at the emergency room, I can only imagine, you know, 17:26 those practitioners in the ER, the nurses, and certainly the doctors, They're taking a look at this. In their minds, they're thinking, I have to treat this child. I have to try to understand how this happened so that I know what course of treatment to take. But in the back of 17:44 their mind, and you'll learn this about ER people, they see so many things that come through there. There are certain signals that will be flipped, and they'll be aware of it. And they're making notes in their brain, you know, 17:58 because they know that certain pattern injuries, certain areas of the body that are injured, it just doesn't marry up with what you would see in a normal event that's coming in. Because, you know, with just Aerie himself, all right, 18:15 I would come closer to like seeing this child and saying, okay, he's got injured genitalia, all right, and I'm going to treat it. and work the problem from there. But then when you begin to inspect him and examine him and you see these other kind of satellite insults, you begin 18:36 to kind of stitch all this stuff together. I wonder if at one moment in time they're in the treatment room with Aerie and they're thinking, I wonder. 18:51 If Leon is okay. 18:54 You know, if it's almost like a foreshadowing moment, because, you know, I've never had twins. I have friends that have had twins. And there's that certain things, body senses that go off with parents. I really wonder if they're 19:06 having to fight this before they're actually made aware of what's happened to Leon. 19:12 You know, I know that there is in every hospital a child advocacy physician that is brought in whenever you have a child that's injured or there's something suspicious. And that was the case here as well. Um, so you've got the injuries. Let's just stay with Aerie for a 19:27 minute because when Aerie is brought in, remember, um, his injuries are not life-threatening. His injuries are, are bad enough that mom and dad had brought him in. But when mom and dad show up with Aerie, um, doctors and nurses are going to hear them say, well, we weren't 19:45 with him at the time this happened. And they're immediately going to think, okay, call the cops. We gotta start investigating. 19:51 And that's just SOP, I would think. And so, you know, when you find out, hey, we've got another twin at home with our best friend and he was fine. That's why we just brought Ari. So I would imagine that some point in time, because They're there for several hours, Joe. 20:08 They are at the hospital with Ari when 911 is called by Nicole about Leon and having hit his head. Now, you mentioned the bassinet a minute ago, and I was thinking about the different bassinets I've had with different children. And, 20:26 you know, all the bassinets we've had, they were round, lightweight, they were sturdy bassinets. But they didn't have corners on them. 20:35 They didn't have anything where a child would hit their head and get hurt. As a matter of fact, we didn't have anything like that when you have children in your home. You just don't. And so a bassinet would not be a decent starting point for injuries to the head. 20:50 But she said, that's what she reported when she called 911, that he had fallen and hit his head. So immediately you've got one child already being treated. And now you have another on the way. I cannot imagine what is 21:07 going through the parents' minds, but they, at this point, Joe, you know the suspicion on the wounds with Ari. See, I don't know how much information that the parents were getting from doctors and nurses about the injuries to Ari because they're going to be suspects, you know? 21:32 So what are they being told? There will be a bit of information coming out to them. I'm not going to say that they're going to be a font going through every jot and tittle, if you will, with the parents at that moment in time. And by the way, right, 21:47 you are about an advocate. In my experience, at least, over the years, it's been where we would have, generally, it's a clinical social worker. and they are assigned specifically in major hospitals, and you'll have a team of them 22:03 that are assigned to the emergency room. They have their own separate office there, and they come in and talk to families. They deal with acute situations where you might have families that are fighting there. The dynamics of an 22:19 emergency room are unlike anything else that if you've never worked in one or been around one, It's unlike any other world that you could enter into. Many times I've got a lot of friends that are in nursing and some people love it. They love the adrenaline rush of 22:38 being in an emergency room and working in that environment. 22:42 You know, the old adage, you know, three things. We either send them to the floor once we get them stabilized. 22:49 We send them home or we send them to the morgue. 22:53 And it's not like you're on a med-surg floor where you're watching patients all night long and monitoring them. It's very hit it and get it. But within that dynamic environment, you have these tragedies that kind of unfold before you, and you're so busy. I worked as an ER tech 23:11 for a number of years while I was in college, and it's like you know, actors that come and go across the stage and you can't keep track of them because you're wondering now who's in room two, who's in room one? Is this person ready to be discharged? Doc, 23:25 what do you need next? And so it's very frenetic, but it's very well orchestrated. So the clinical social worker would come in. And at that point in time, I'm assuming that's probably what happened here. And that individual is going to be the person probably with the blessing of 23:46 the treating emergency room physician, they're going to say, yeah, you need to go ahead and ring up the people with the PD, whatever department it is. And they would know, and they have a running list of these people that they're going to reach out to. And that's probably what 24:01 happened in this case. 24:02 Okay. Now, I just, reviewing, because we covered this before when it was When the story first came out, Joe and I looked at it and went, there's something seriously wrong with this. 24:12 This is bad. 24:14 And now that we've actually gotten to where we are today, it's worse than what we knew then. But when Nicole Versi first called 911 and they asked what had happened, she said that she fell asleep after the parents took Harry to the hospital and she is there alone with Leon. 24:31 Nicole says she fell asleep and she woke up and he was hungry. And so She had placed him in his little baby bouncer thing while she went into the kitchen to heat up a bottle. And while she was out of the room, he was able to tumble out of the bouncy seat and bump his head on the 24:51 bassinet or whatever. That's how he hit his head while she was preparing the bottle. Now, she made the call at 11.17 p.m., Joe. 6.30, she's left alone with Leon and less than five hours. She's on the phone with 911, and he's got this severe head injury that is going 25:12 to require a trip to the hospital, this time for Leon. 25:16 Ari is already there, Joe. They're already still treating him. 25:20 And now the parents, one's going to stay with Ari. 25:23 The other is going to go with Leon, his six-week-old twin brother. And when they get Leon to the hospital, Joe, I was telling you before we started taping that The damage done to this six-week-old baby, Leon, is worse than 25:45 anything I've ever seen before. Because you mentioned it, little babies are pliable. They don't break like we do as you get older. 25:54 No, not when your bones ossify. Even when you're 12 years old, you still have flexibility, obviously. but it ain't to the point of a baby. And what I'm talking about now, flexibility is really not the right term. You think about the pliability of the bone itself. When you 26:23 begin to think about a head injury with a tiny baby, 26:29 how do you explain away? Because, Dave, I've got to tell you something, and I'll go ahead and big reveal here, is that With Leon, his little head, he did not sustain a single fracture. He's got multiple fractures to his skull. So, how can I describe it for people that have not 26:58 been around a baby like this? 26:59 You know, Joe, even at my age now, with little babies... 27:03 I'm afraid of the soft spot on their hair. 27:05 Yeah, I know. 27:06 And by the way, the fontanelles, and you've got a couple of them. There's more of an anterior fontanelle. There's also a posterior fontanelle. And that's where the skull is beginning to fuse and close up. And it, you know, it takes some time. You can still see in up 27:21 to three years of age, you can still see the presence of a fontanelle when you get into those cases. 27:28 But these fontanelles would be very, very noticeable, you know, with any kind of imaging that you would have. And they did do a CT scan of Leon at the hospital. 27:42 But when you think about, because the way they're categorizing these injuries is that Leon had multiple fractures to his skull. Brother, you don't get that in a bouncy seat, falling a single time and striking the head on a bassinet first off, 28:03 I would question even how plausible that would be. Particularly when you think about how bouncy seats are set up and that sort of thing. I just don't see how that could happen, that dynamic. And all you have to do, like we always suggest on Body Bags, is look back 28:22 to the science. What is the science actually telling you? 28:26 When you're doing the examination, and I'm sure that they've got a team of people that are going to assess this baby that have gone back to CT to do a CT on this child. And you're going to have radiologists, the emergency room people, everybody looking at these images, and 28:43 they're probably really scratching their heads over this, thinking, you know, we've seen babies in car accidents that don't have this kind of trauma. But there it is. And it's very, very hard to kind of, explain it away. And I have to tell you with Leon's dad, um, the, the 29:04 doctors use the term catastrophic trauma. Most of the time physicians, you will not hear them use the term catastrophic. Um, and it can mean any number of things, but I'm thinking massive trauma, uh, very specific fatal trauma where you're 29:24 talking about inflicting injuries that is, you know, particularly when you're talking about the brain, that's going to cause the brain to swell. You've got indwelling hemorrhage, all this stuff. And, you know, their brains are thinking, you know, how do 29:35 we solve this? How do we save his life? And I got to tell you, Dave, he was a sinking ship. 29:40 you know, when he rolled through the door. Brother Dave, you've been following this case so very closely. You know, it's it's It's rather complex, I think. But you had an interesting finding here that I think is crucial to try to understand what had happened. 30:09 I was asking Joe about this because I was curious as to what takes place. I mean, I don't know. 30:14 I'm a parent, grandparent, and I've held my share of little kids, of children, of babies, which is why even now, When I mentioned the soft spot, I've learned more about that, Joe, in doing this show with you than I've ever known. 30:29 And it even makes me more scared than I already was. 30:31 Oh, don't do that. 30:32 But in this case, when they actually got Leon, they're at the hospital, got to find out what's going on. 30:39 And they find this severe skull fracture. But, Joe, they found three brain bleeds right when they get Leon to the hospital, a six-week-old baby. with a skull fracture, with three brain bleeds, what does that mean? 30:54 Those are specific areas of impact, probably. I would imagine if they are what's referred to as focalized injuries, what that means is that they have specific margins. They're limited in a specific area. I'm not going to say uniformity, 31:13 but they are individual little markers that you look for. 31:18 So So let's just go with this idea of falling out of a bouncy seat and striking the child, striking the head on the bassinet. Okay. You fall out, you strike your head. That's one. And would it be consistent? Because, you know, for me as a death investigator, I go 31:40 back and do a retro scene. If you're telling me that that's what's going to happen or that's what's happening, I'm going to the home. I'm going to inspect the bouncy seat. Matter of fact, High probability I'll probably take it. 31:52 You know, it'll be part of the evidence. And we've done this. We've taken in baby beds. I actually had a lady that refused to put the back railing up on a baby bed that had been donated to her. 32:06 And she just pushed it up against the wall. And that little angel inverted in between the mattress and the back railing. wrapped in an afghan. The baby got kind of tangled and then inverted. The mother was out smoking crack with her boyfriend and the baby inverted in this 32:24 thing and positional asphyxia and died. So a big part of what we do in the medical legal world is we want to inspect not just the environment that the child lived in, but we also want to inspect and examine any kind of of item that was in a crib. 32:47 We want to take a look at the space of the crib. We want to take a look at the functionality because, you know, sometimes there are defective, there are defective pieces of equipment that, you know, people buy, right? 32:58 I mean, you know, and you want to try to understand, is there something wrong with the manufacturing of this thing that caused it to go into this kind of fatal event? 33:10 You know, was the mechanism flawed to such a point. 33:14 Is there an innocent explanation for this that evil did not come into that home and take this baby and do this? Is there a legitimate, innocent explanation that we can blame on the manufacturer or a freak accident? Is there any other explanation? Because we are talking about a 33:31 six-week-old child, and they deserve the benefit of the doubt the parents do. It's their child that's dead and their other child injured. But now you've got two babies in the hospital at the same time. With different sets of injuries, 33:46 and mom and dad were not present for any of them. 33:49 Yeah, and the three focal areas that are there, Dave, you know, this didn't come by a one-off event, okay? It's, you know, it would be like getting struck in the head with a baseball, and it's going to cause multiple brain bleeds. These are specific areas, points of contact that 34:09 are individualized, okay? So if we say individualized, that means individual injuries. Now, how the strikes come about, that's something else to be explained. But there is some kind of impact trauma that is driving this. Because now we're talking 34:23 about this energy that was apparently applied externally, has traveled through the table of the skull and into the actual brain, deeply into the brain, where you've got these areas of hemorrhage that are going on. Then, you know, one of 34:39 the things that has come out, you've got these multiple fractures. Now, people might say, well, how do you delineate between, how do you call it a multiple fracture? You know, because a lot of people, I've heard folks say over the years, 34:53 it's like, well, his head shattered like an eggshell. Okay, let me explain that. You can have, you know, they almost look like little spider webs when you look at fractures. 35:04 And babies' heads are really completely different than looking at an adult skull fracture, okay? But when you consider the amount of force that would have to have been applied to create each one of these little fracture lines, you 35:18 begin to put two and two together because you have to be able to figure out and be able to explain to a jury, and you have to keep in mind here, that for each one of these fractures that you're seeing, like if we're in court, see this fracture 35:31 right here? This is associated with the indwelling bleed that is revealed right here in the CT scan. Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, you can see this. They might even show... Show the brain, you know, an autopsy photograph 35:46 at trial. And that happens regularly and where the doctor has dissected the brain and is demonstrating this is how extensive. And, you know, that's something that people can understand, believe it or not. They might not have seen a hemorrhage in 36:00 a brain before, but they understand hemorrhage on their body. 36:04 You know, bruises, contusions, you know, it's bleeding out, that sort of thing. It's a very powerful thing to see in court. 36:11 Now, after we got the, after the medical reports, uh, again, I wanted to stay with Aerie and Leon because Aerie was at the hospital first, um, non-life threatening injuries. Leon arrives with the skull fracture, three brain bleeds, and sadly, uh, 36:27 Leon dies the next morning, uh, around five 30 and immediately the, the autopsy has to take place. And, um, What they find out at the autopsy, Joseph Scott Morgan, is what opens the door for police to interview Nicole Versi. 36:49 What did the autopsy tell law enforcement about the death of Leon? 36:55 This is the one word I want everybody to hold on to. They identified these injuries as acute. And that means that this is not a chronic event where you have ongoing neglect, abuse, striking of a child. And we've covered a lot of cases, right, brother, where we have 37:14 kids that are subjected to horrific abuse, but it goes on for a period of time. We see healing that takes place in some of the earlier trauma, and then it's layered on top of that healed trauma. You can have new trauma. That's not what they're talking about. Every 37:28 one of these injuries that Leon has sustained, they're in the acute phase. So that means that they were sudden, They were immediate. It happened at that moment in time. 37:39 There hasn't been any chance for this to begin to heal up. So then you begin to look at a timing factor here. 37:46 Okay. 37:47 Well, Morgan, what do you mean? Well, if you've got mom and daddy out of the house and you've got this caretaker, air quotes there, that individual is a subject that is in charge of this child's well-being at that 38:05 period of time or who had access. you know, access, opportunity, means, that sort of thing. Well, it would be with her. 38:14 And so, yeah, following that, once the police have confirmed, they went to the Allegheny medical examiner's office, by the way, a corner where our old friend Dr. Wecht worked. They were, the pathologist would talk to the cops and I can 38:31 almost know how this conversation went. They're like, this is no way associated with some kind of one-off event. You're talking about this little angel that has been struck multiple times, multiple times. And the doctor goes on to talk about 38:49 blunt force trauma to the head. So that tells me it's not just underlying, you know, fractures of the skull. 38:57 This child is probably demonstrating with multiple contusions on the surface of that precious little head. Okay. Just think about What does it take for somebody to do that? You know, you're looking at this little angel, so very fragile. And 39:12 when you see these babies, the images of them, they look so incredibly fragile. Like they have to have somebody that is watching over them. You know, many times when twins are born, they can be premature. They can be 39:28 on the lighter side. you know, developmentally, these sorts of things. 39:33 So they are, you know, really, really fragile. And I can only imagine that when the police are faced with this and they're seeing this, these questions have to be asked and they have to be answered quickly. So, this individual, you want to get your hands on them as expeditiously 39:54 as possible. And you want to have a sit down with them. And you have to have them walk through this timeline with you. 40:02 Well, because the injuries do not match up with the story that she told when she called 911. We're talking about Nicole Versi here. So what they came up with was, let's talk, okay? We've got mom and dad are now, one is at the hospital with Ari, six-week-old twin that's 40:20 in the hospital injured. The other is now dealing with funeral arrangements for the baby that now has autopsy scars. Okay. 40:31 They bring in Nicole Versi. And the interview that took place, Joe, has come under some scrutiny. It became a major issue. 40:41 Her defense says, has challenged the admissibility of the interrogation, arguing that it was coercive. Now, I don't know how those things go by the book, but I do know that when you have a story, you said this, okay? 40:59 This is what we have that you said happened, and here are the results. This does not cause this. Nicole, you're an educated woman. You're the parents' best friend. You were the only one in the room when this took place. 41:17 Something else had to have happened. That's when she told them what happened, Joe. You've read this. Nicole Versi said that she shook Leon hard several times. She dropped him hard times. Several times. She flipped him upside down onto a bathroom tile floor. 41:53 Yeah, it's hard to even take the measure of it. And, you know, I hate why. I really do. Oh, my God. 42:00 I think what would be the question here? What was going through your mind? What was it that motivated you to traumatize this child? And, you know, I've got to tell you, the DA in this particular case, they had actually, well, let me just give you one of the bullet points, Dave. 42:28 In this particular case, the Allegheny County District Attorney's Office actually stated that the offense was committed by means of torture. 42:40 Do you get to the point as a human being where this is okay, where you are wanting to torture a child? Because the DA felt as though that they had evidence of this. And I got to tell you, the fact that it wasn't a one-off event, and you 43:06 talk about all of these different dynamics here where the baby is being tortured, well, first off shaken significantly, and we could go into a whole diatribe here about, um, you know, shaken baby syndrome, uh, but just the trauma 43:21 alone is being perpetrated on this child on multiple surfaces, probably from different heights, because we're talking about dropping a child. 43:32 And it's really hard, I think, to, for us to understand, um, how much force is applied here and what kind of height the baby would have to have been dropped from in order to sustain this kind of injury. However, if you're talking about a tiled floor in a bathroom, brother, 43:55 there's no give with that. There's no give. The head is going to lose, okay, when you strike. And certainly, you know, the height from which the baby is dropped, you know, plays into this. But Dave, she She sung on this. I mean, she actually stated that she had done this. Yep. 44:15 And they asked her why. And the answer that she gave in that interview with police, she described having experienced a, quote, compulsion to hurt children from a young age. That's her reason. Now, Joe, I mentioned how this interview with police was a battleground 44:38 for the defense. her defense team challenged its admissibility in court. 44:44 And I'm going to be honest, you throw out what she told police and you're left with horrible injuries to two children, one dead, one alive, you know. But without her explanation, you don't go as far as you can with this. Judge looked at everything and ruled that, yeah, 45:03 this statement to police will be admitted at trial. That began in negotiations. It was at that point that after admitting what she had done to Leon, she also admitted that she was the one who hurt Ari. A negotiation began, and the reason we're doing an update now is because 45:24 she has pleaded guilty to third-degree murder. And, by the way, this could have been a death penalty case. 45:35 Yeah. 45:36 That's how far it could have gone. 45:37 Well, they had hinted at that early on. 45:38 Yeah. And based on what we know about that interview and what was said, boy, I've been a tough one to fight. But she was able to negotiate out of that. 45:48 Her attorneys did. She pled guilty to third degree murder, aggravated assault, endangering the welfare of children and was sentenced, a negotiated sentence of 35 to 80 years in the state prison. And her only explanation, Joe, she's had a 46:05 compulsion to hurt children from a very early age. 46:10 Well, I don't know. I don't have necessarily a sense of gratitude over the fact that she has admitted to this. However, and I refuse to mention her name again, whose names I will mention, are going to be Aerie and Leon. Okay, because they, you know, I don't know what the path 46:32 holds for Aerie as he goes forward in life, the tales he will be told, the things that He's not going to remember how much will be revealed to him over the years. But I can tell you the family has a hole in it now. A hole that should 46:47 have been filled with the beautiful life of Leon. But he's no longer with us. But we have a monster now that's off the streets and is going to pay for her crimes. I'm Joseph Scott Morgan. And this is Body Bags.
Community discussion