0:00 So I think in the long run, higher yields are actually bullish for Bitcoin because high rates, right? 0:04 High interest expense means the government just has to borrow more, which means eventually, especially in a fiscal dominant scenario, which is what I believe we're in, the Federal Reserve will have to print more. 0:14 But even in a high interest rate regime and inflationary. 0:18 As long as there's QE and some sort of fiscal stimulus, either on the Treasury side or on the Fed side, I think it's massively bullish for Bitcoin. 0:25 And I actually have reason to believe that this cycle we're going to go to $300,000 just because this bull market started so much earlier than should have been predicted by all of the models. 0:39 Hello and welcome back to the Bitcoin Magazine podcast. 0:42 I'm your host, Spencer Nichols. 0:43 And today we are sitting down with Roberto Rios, author of the Dollar Endgame Substack. 0:48 Roberto, otherwise known as Peruvian Bull, has been covering the dynamics of the yen carry trade for quite some time now. 0:55 Roberto, we last spoke in 2023, which feels like ages ago in Bitcoin terms, certainly. 1:01 And, you know, a lot's changed, but a lot stayed the same. 1:04 I think, you know, the yen carry trade is kind of the... 1:08 the tail wagging the dog of the market in a lot of ways, and really excited to unpack that a little bit more with you. 1:13 I think we've also had a lot of volatility and fixed income across the world with U.S. Treasury market, the 10-year sitting just under 5% yield right now, as well as volatility in the Eurozone. 1:25 We're seeing really high yields on French bonds. 1:28 We have the French OAT and German boon spread blowing out pretty aggressively. 1:34 And I think there's just so much to dig into, whether that's the growth picture and its impact on bond yields, the inflation picture and its impact on bond yields. 1:42 And of course, how all of these intertwine into portfolio construction. 1:46 And probably no surprise for folks tuning in here. 1:49 We're going to be covering what this all means for Bitcoin and hard assets as we move forward here. 1:55 But Roberto, excited to kick this off. 1:58 I think let's start with just the latest news. 2:01 We saw just today the October CPI numbers coming in a little bit hotter than expected, up 0.4% month over month, higher than expectations. 2:12 Notably, energy inflation has cooled, yet the number still continues to climb. 2:16 And I think this has both the 2:20 feds december meeting all but a lock for a rate increase but at the same time we see the u.s 10 year continuing to move up a little bit retracing its move back down right now hovering just under five so you know what's your reaction to what we're seeing in the bond market right now is this more of an inflation story at hand is this you know strong ai growth that's making the bond market compensate its investors you know how are you reading the current situation 2:46 Yeah, I think the current bond market is basically pricing in higher for longer from the Fed. 2:52 And the reason for that is multifold. 2:54 First, like you mentioned, inflation appears to be elevated and consistently elevated despite the Fed's recent rate hike in September. 3:04 And the Fed's You know, promise to hike further and to, you know, do whatever it takes to stamp out inflation. 3:10 The problem that the Fed faces right now and that Warsh has stepped into is that the monetary policy that he wants to design is basically contradictory on its face. 3:21 On one hand, he wants to have high interest rates and stamp out inflation. 3:25 And on the other hand, he doesn't want to increase the balance sheet, but he is. 3:31 And so when you do something like the Reserve Management Purchase Program, which is what they've been doing since December of 2025, you're basically creating bank reserves to buy treasuries and mortgage-backed securities. 3:43 That creates liquidity, and that funnels that liquidity into the financial system, which And although it's not directly inflationary in the sense that like a stimulus check would be, it's at least asset price inflationary. 3:55 And asset price inflation does eventually lead to capital gains, which eventually leads to more consumer spending, especially for the wealthier consumers who own the majority of stocks and bonds. 4:06 And so on the face, Warsh is trying to thread that needle. 4:09 And this was actually the – the subject of one of the essays he wrote back in like 2017 before he even, you know, was considered for a fed chairman. 4:18 He wanted to create this, you could call like disinflationary monetary policy where you'd, he'd be able to, normalize interest rates, but also not expand the balance sheet, right? 4:31 He wanted to have low rates, allow consumer lending to explode, allow borrowing to grow, especially on a corporate side, but not allow the balance sheet to grow. 4:41 And Normal macro policy is that both of those have to move in lockstep because in order to move the Fed funds rate, you generally have to also look at the rest of the yield curve. 4:53 And by doing QE, by creating bank reserves, you're able to suppress yields all across the yield curve because you're buying those bonds, which pushes their price up and pushes their yield down. 5:05 And what Warsh is doing is basically a contradiction of what he had promised to do at the outset, which was not to increase the balance sheet. 5:12 The balance sheet is growing by, you know, 10 to $15 billion a month. 5:15 Now that's a far cry from what, um, you know, the QE infinity program was in 2020 and 2021, which was 120 billion a month. 5:25 Um, but it, it's not nothing, you know, um, it's definitely stimulatory and that stimulus is still flooding into, into markets, I think. 5:33 And that's why, uh, stocks have recently until very recently been on a tear this year, um, And bonds, I think, understand that this stimulus and then paired with the high fiscal deficits that the U.S. is still running, right? 5:47 We're still running like a $2 trillion deficit every single year equal to 7% of GDP means that any QE that's done – especially on the monetary side, is going to eventually bleed out into inflation and eventually push up CPI. 6:03 And that's exactly what we saw this last month, right? 6:05 You have normal CPI up 0.4% month over month, core up 0.3%, despite the fact that energy prices have cooled down a lot, oil is down about 18% just since the start of the month. 6:19 It's now below $90 a barrel. 6:21 And so although you might see some pressure easing on the oil side, Generally, oil shocks like what was caused this year, obviously, with the Iran war can flow through into the rest of the market and cause inflation broadly to rise even after you cure the oil shock problem. 6:37 And this kind of like inflation lag is similar to what we saw in the 1970s, where you have multiple oil shocks. 6:43 And even if the oil shock was resolved, inflation would still continue to take higher with a kind of momentum or inertia that inflation tends to have across the economy. 6:53 Yeah, I think I see a lot of that as well. 6:55 It's kind of this idea of like cascading inflation. 6:57 You have oil as this coordinating good. 6:59 You have refined petroleum products, namely gasoline. 7:02 The prices have come down, but in some ways the damage has been done. 7:05 And now I feel like it's the system is kind of digesting, you know, this move higher and kind of this more structurally high. 7:12 higher priced petroleum market. 7:15 And I think, you know, the biggest question for me is, is this something that we're going to have to contend with for, you know, another matter of months even, but, you know, potentially this conflict could drag on. 7:27 So do you have thoughts on how concerned the Fed needs to be about this. 7:32 And do you think that we ever can get back to this two, two percent inflation target? 7:36 This is something that Warsh has been talking about publicly. 7:39 You know, we've missed this two percent inflation target for six years now. 7:43 And he's kind of, you know, jawboned, at least to a degree that, hey, we're trying to get back to that, to that two percent inflation target. 7:50 It just feels like we're not getting there. 7:52 And, you know, If we do get there, I feel like that could spell trouble for asset prices. 7:57 But yeah, how are you thinking about that structural tailwind in terms of energy prices? 8:02 Is that something to be concerned about? 8:03 And does that ultimately preclude us from getting back to that 2% target rate? 8:08 I mean, I think the energy prices obviously exacerbate the problem. 8:11 But the fundamental issue is that the U.S. is just far too indebted, right? 8:16 And especially by running fiscal deficits, that causes that indebtedness to start to leak out into the broader financial system. 8:23 Something that a lot of people don't know is when the Fed does QE, they don't print physical cash and hand it to banks. 8:29 They create what are called bank reserves or settlement balances. 8:33 Now, these balances are basically money, but only for authorized participants that use the Federal Reserve's Fedwire system. 8:41 And so it uses like a credit on their balance sheet that's allowed to be swapped for any sort of financial asset. 8:46 Normally, again, treasuries, mortgage-backed securities – But once you buy those treasuries and MBS off of the bank's balance sheets, now the banks are freed up with a bunch of cash to go speculate on the rest of the market. 8:58 But when you buy that treasury, right, especially if it's issued at auction from the U.S. treasury itself, that reserve balance goes into the New York Fed's treasury account, right, the TGA, the Treasury General Account. 9:14 Right. 9:15 And that reserve balance is magically converted into basically M2 money supply. 9:21 And the reason why is because if you think about it logically, a reserve balance can only be spent by a financial institution to pay for another financial institution's asset, right? 9:31 The treasury is the one big financial institution in the system that needs to buy real goods and services, right? 9:38 It needs to buy bridges. 9:39 It needs to pay for military veterans benefits. 9:42 Payrolls. 9:43 payroll, guns, bombs, healthcare, all these things, right? 9:47 And it's spending, right, trillions and trillions of dollars a year to do so. 9:51 When it does that, right, it basically takes that financial system money, those reserve balances that were previously stuck in the financial markets, and it converts them into broad money, and that broad money is pushed out into the market and causes inflation, 10:05 And so that goes back to what we talked about earlier, 7% deficit to GDP, $2 trillion deficits a year that we haven't been able to be for the last five years. 10:15 That represents a steady flow, like because this is the Treasury General account is the spigot, a steady flow of money from the financial economy into the real economy. 10:25 And that is the conduit mechanism that will create persistent inflation, even if you solve the energy problem. 10:31 And so until you solve the deficit issue, I don't see how inflation can really normalize. 10:37 And with the level of debt that we have gotten to and especially the level of interest rates that the Fed is forecasting, it looks like we're going to have higher inflation for longer and – Anything they do, in my opinion, really makes it worse. 10:50 If they hold rates really high, well, that ratchets up the interest expense on the debt, which means the deficits blow out because you're paying way more interest expense. 10:59 And we're already paying like 21% of federal tax receipts on just interest. 11:03 And if you lower rates, right, you run a QE program, let's do the 2020 playbook all over again, you create massive amounts of money. 11:10 And that massive amounts of money flows into the financial system and eventually finds its way to the Treasury General account and then eventually goes into broad consumer prices. 11:18 And so no matter which way you turn, the Fed is trapped in what I call a black hole of their own design. 11:25 No matter what they do, it makes the problem worse. 11:27 Mm hmm. 11:28 And this sounds like to me that it rhymes with fiscal dominance in a lot of ways. 11:32 I think as we look, we just had the midterm elections, Democratic blue wave. 11:36 You know, many people know this. 11:38 And I think the market is now trying to figure out, OK, what does this mean for the fiscal outlook for the U.S. government when it comes to expanding social programs, expanding spending? 11:49 You know, there's kind of like that. 11:50 kind of tailwind on kind of the government spending side. 11:53 But at the same time, they're trying to crack down on kind of the hottest sector in the entire economy in the AI space. 12:00 But I think to my eye, it just looks like, you know, this train is going to continue rolling on. 12:06 only to be met by this kind of debate over the debt ceiling increase. 12:11 And that, I think, is where things could get pretty spicy when it comes to the bond market. 12:16 Do you foresee that potential debt ceiling increase battle between Trump and the Democrats to be an issue? 12:23 Is that either something that's going to have yields increase? 12:26 Or how are you thinking about what that coming conflict looks like for the market? 12:31 Yeah. 12:31 Well, I think that the debt ceiling issue is mainly a – almost like a red herring that has been put into place by Congress in order to make the appearance of fiscal austerity. 12:45 They've moved the debt ceiling I think what like 35, 36 times in the last 25 years. 12:51 Probably more soon, I would say. 12:52 Yeah. 12:53 Yeah, yeah, exactly. 12:55 And each time they move it, they make all these statements that, you know, this is unsustainable. 12:59 We can't keep doing this. 13:00 We've got to come up with a more balanced budget. 13:02 And yet no one ever wants to make the cuts because, of course, as politicians, their constituents rely on a lot of federal funding, whether in the form of, you know, like government jobs or subsidies or benefits or grants. 13:16 And taking away the free money from your constituents, taking away the piggy bank from the people who vote for you is universally unpopular among Republicans and Democrats. 13:26 And so what I see most of the time is just political maneuvering over the debt ceiling. 13:31 And if the debt ceiling does get hit and the government shuts down, like we saw, I think it was January of 2024. 13:37 Usually you do see a huge spike in yields because the market starts to get a little uncertain over what's going to happen in the future. 13:44 And generally uncertainty leads to a run to cash, which means selling risk assets, including bonds. 13:50 But the short-term spike is always followed by a long-term smoothing. 13:54 And then what I would argue is like – because of the inflation figures that we just talked about earlier in the deficit problem that, you know, we'll continue to see a steady grind higher in yields. 14:06 So I view it as like a short term bear signal for bonds, but definitely not long term because I think they're just going to keep moving the ceiling because the issue is defaulting on the bond obviously is – is basically a non sequitur. 14:21 You can't do that. 14:23 As the largest bond market in the world with $40 trillion of debt outstanding and probably over $200 trillion of debt instruments that are tied to the treasury, either treasury rate, either directly or indirectly, a blowup of the US treasury market would essentially mean the collapse of the entire financial system on a level that we haven't seen since 2008. 14:43 And the people in charge don't want that because what allows them to maintain their power is in large part their wealth. 14:50 And their wealth is dependent on the fiat-based banking system and the equities and assets that are within it. 14:57 Yeah, I think this situation is also interesting in that you mentioned that Warsh has this desire to tighten the balance sheet and start rolling assets off, has really not been able to do that with much staying power. 15:12 You know, we're seeing QE increase slightly, you know, bringing it back to what you were talking about. 15:18 But he so he's kind of at odds with himself in some ways. 15:21 And at the same time, he's in ways at odds with U.S. U.S. 15:25 Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. 15:27 Bessent is now issuing on the short end of the curve and purchasing long duration 30 year U.S. Treasury bonds. 15:36 You know, how do you see that that tango between Warsh and Bessent going right now? 15:42 You know, is this something where they're ultimately going to be at odds and there's going to have to be some type of more explosive resolution? 15:48 Is this something that's a bit more premeditated where they kind of know where the other is going to be throwing it before they run downfield? 15:54 You know, how does this this situation between the Treasury and the Fed look to you currently? 15:59 Yeah, I think your earlier diagnosis of fiscal dominance is correct, right? 16:05 The Fed is reticent to increase the balance sheet, right? 16:09 They want to maintain this kind of slow and steady reserve management purchase program. 16:13 They don't want to signal for their QE because they know how inflationary that is. 16:17 On the other hand, the bond market is already straining, right? 16:21 Yeah. 16:21 Like you said, we have the 10-year, which recently touched 5.2%, now slightly below 5%. 16:27 The 30-year, well above that. 16:30 We've seen auctions with bad tails this summer. 16:33 I believe it was in June. 16:34 We had a 30-year auction with the worst tail in like eight years. 16:39 And so in that kind of environment, right, especially on the long end, you need to manage liquidity well. 16:45 And if the Fed isn't able to step in, the Treasury has to come in and do what I would call Treasury QE. 16:52 And so this summer, right, they were doing a buyback, Treasury buyback program to the tune of about $2 billion dollars. 16:58 you know, a session. 17:00 And then they doubled that to $4 billion in August. 17:02 And then they increased it by 50% again in September to $6 billion. 17:06 And so now they're running, you know, pretty often every few weeks, $6 billion clips at aimed at 30 year and 20 year treasury bonds, and then issuing usually, you know, shorter, shorter term debt, like you said, five, five year bonds, or five, or five year notes, seven year notes, or even, you know, T bills in order to pay for that. 17:27 And the result of that is twofold. 17:30 For one, you're lowering long-term rates, which the long-term rates are what things like mortgages and long-term capital loans rely on. 17:39 So by doing that, that's stimulative of the economy, right? 17:42 You're lessening the borrowing costs for individuals and corporations. 17:46 The other impact of that, which is probably less appreciated, is that bonds, especially in the current, you know, you could say regulatory apparatus, have to have capital held against them in regards to their duration risk. 18:01 Meaning a short-term bond like a treasury bill that's like a six-week bill or a 12-week bill will have to have, let's say, you know – half a percent of capital held against $100 of face value. 18:13 So 50 cents held against $100. 18:15 For a 30 year bond, you probably have to hold something like $5. 18:18 So 10 times as much because the risk of that bond losing value due to an increase in rates is much, much higher because of duration risk, because of the convexity of the bond. 18:29 The longer term bonds are much more sensitive to interest rates. 18:32 And by taking those bonds out of the system, By doing a treasury QE or treasury operation twist, which is what they're doing, buying these long-term dated bonds and issuing short-term bonds. 18:43 By taking those off the balance sheets of the financial system, what they're essentially doing is freeing up capital and replacing that long-term debt with short-term debt. 18:52 And that capital-freeed-up now can go out and be used to buy financial assets, speculate on investments, right, make new loans, whatever is needed. 19:01 And so it's a form of – even if, like, the total debt load doesn't increase, which is what a lot of people have been saying, they're like, hey, the buybacks are, you know, debt-level neutral because they're buying back $6 billion of debt, but they're also, you know, issuing $6 billion new. 19:15 You have minus six, plus six, it nets out to zero. 19:18 Sure, on its face, but again, that actually – chemically changes the makeup of these bank balance sheets, which allows them to lend a lot more and is basically stimulative. 19:28 It's what I would call stealth QE. 19:31 And I've written about this a lot of my sub stack. 19:33 There's multiple forms of stealth QE, but this is one of the big ones. 19:36 Yeah, fascinating. 19:37 I haven't really heard that take before from the market. 19:39 I think like most people haven't really talked about that convexity of those long duration bonds and what that means for risk management on these bank balance sheets. 19:46 I think that's a fascinating point. 19:48 And, you know, we've talked about this kind of US centric liquidity picture. 19:53 But, you know, as you've written about at length. 19:55 You know, this is a global interconnected system and one of the largest players in the space, you know, as far as more of the largest foreign holder of U.S. treasuries is Japan. 20:06 And, you know, we have recently engaged in a yen buyback program. 20:10 And, you know, I think this yen and U.S. government bond, BOJ and U.S. government bond spread is something a lot of people are keeping an eye on right now. 20:20 You know, just what's the latest on this unfolding picture right here? 20:25 I think for our audience who might be a little bit less familiar, let's maybe we just start with the plumbing of the yen carry trade and why this has been so central to markets, you know, for decades now. 20:36 Sure. 20:36 So, you know, the story really starts back in the 1980s. 20:40 Japan had signed the Plaza Accord, which was an agreement to strengthen the yen against the U.S. dollar. 20:46 In the 70s, the yen had been set at 360 to the dollar and then was slowly lowered to 360. 20:53 And because of that weak yen, the artificially weak yen, a lot of people, especially in the U.S. automotive industry, had been worried about an unfair trade advantage. 21:03 And so they pressured the Reagan administration, they did the Plaza Accord, and they decided to strengthen the yen against the dollar to the tune of over 50%. 21:13 Now, that created what they called, I think it's called Tonda Fukio, which means the strong yen recession in the mid 80s. 21:20 And in response, the Bank of Japan had lowered interest rates to two and a half percent and kept them there and continue to increase their program of window guidance, which basically shoved a bunch of credit into the economy by allowing them to call commercial banks and order them to make more loans. 21:35 Right. 21:35 They would create a loan quotas. 21:37 So minimums the banks had to hit. 21:39 Well, all that credit. 21:41 led to this huge bubble. 21:42 And by the late 80s, it was reaching its blow off top. 21:45 And in early 1990, it popped. 21:47 And for the next two decades, the markets and the economy grinded slowly lower in a slow motion deflationary crash. 21:56 Now, in response, the Bank of Japan had lower rates to, you know, first to one, then to half a percent, then to zero percent by 1999, and eventually to negative, slightly negative by February of 2016. 22:08 And all of that served to create a massive pool of capital that was now able to go out into the rest of the world and invest in financial assets, right? 22:16 Because not only are the Japanese retail investors and institutions earning zero at home, And they're taking their yen and investing it abroad because when your funding rate is zero, everything looks attractive, even treasury bonds, which in the mid-2010s. 22:33 yield 2% or 3%. 22:36 But foreign investors would come in and borrow yen. 22:39 And since the Bank of Japan literally did not move their discount rate for 25 years, it was one of the safest trades to make. 22:48 And they would borrow yen at 0% interest and go out and buy corporate bonds, high-yield bonds, US treasuries, even yielding 2% or 3% and lever up that trade many, many times. 22:59 Yeah. 22:59 Now, that carry trade grew from about $200 billion in 1997 to over a trillion dollars by 2007. 23:07 And today it's estimated to be anywhere between $3 to $6 trillion and the more reasonable estimates. 23:14 And one Deutsche Bank analysis puts it as high as $20 trillion when you count a bunch of off-balance sheet derivatives. 23:20 So it's an absolutely massive trade. 23:22 And I believe it's responsible for maybe between a fifth and a quarter of U.S. equity returns over the last 20 years. 23:29 And that money has been consistently flowing in and into U.S. equities, U.S. bonds, and U.S. mortgage-backed securities, which has allowed us to maintain this very healthy bull market over the last 10 years. 23:42 That is even in excess of our actual economic growth. 23:47 The problem is that eventually puts its pressure on the currency. 23:50 And so that's what we saw in March 2022. 23:53 The Fed hiked in their most aggressive hiking cycle since Volcker, and the Bank of Japan was stuck at 0%. 24:00 And so the yen blew out from $1.10 to the dollar in February of 2022 to $1.45 by September, so a devaluation of almost 30%. 24:10 that prompted the Bank of Japan to do all these interventions. 24:13 And the most recent one, like you said, was the biggest, which was to the tune of $91 billion with the help of the Treasury and the New York Fed. 24:21 And so the carry trade is still in full swing, but pressure is finally starting to come in on the carry trade because the Bank of Japan has been hiking rates and doing all these yen interventions in order to stop the bleeding on their currency. 24:40 at least in the short term, may be coming to an end because of the aggressive rate hiking cycle by the BOJ. 24:46 And so this dynamic between the BOJ's rate path and the strength and weakness of the yen, can you unpack that a little bit more for us? 24:54 Just helping us understand why the spread between the Bank of Japan's rates and the rates of the US government, why that matters so much and kind of 25:04 The idea that Japan and the U.S. need each other in this dynamic, like, you know, you would think, well, you know, this is Japan's problem. 25:11 Why are we buying their yen? 25:13 I think that, you know, this dynamic between us in some sense, this might be an overstatement, but having to bail out Japan in some ways. 25:21 Can you explain that a little bit more for our audience? 25:24 Yeah. 25:24 Sure. 25:24 So again, over the last 25, 30 years, the Japanese have been hoovering up all sorts of investment assets around the world. 25:32 And one of the biggest holdings that they've amassed is U.S. Treasuries. 25:36 Right now, as of the August tick data, they have 1,068 billion. 25:40 So $1.06 trillion of U.S. Treasury bonds, which makes them the largest foreign holder. 25:47 And also, obviously, the biggest risk to the U.S. financial system because if they dumped those bonds, especially within short order, that would cause a financial crisis here at home. 25:58 Now, the BOJ wouldn't have any reason normally to sell any bonds. 26:02 But the problem is when an intervention comes up. 26:05 Because as the yen weakens, right, especially as more carry traders come in, what they're doing is they're essentially opening short positions on the yen because they're borrowing yen with one hand, they're selling it, and then they're using those yen to buy U.S. dollars and then using those U.S. dollars to buy a U.S. asset. 26:23 To intervene on the other side, you have to sell dollars to buy yen, right, to drive the USDJPY exchange rate down from, let's say, 150 to like 142 or something like that. 26:35 Now, that takes billions of dollars. 26:37 And the Bank of Japan, as wealthy as it is, can't print dollars. 26:41 So what do they do? 26:42 They turn to the Ministry of Finance and they turn to their massive treasury holdings and they sell those treasury bonds. 26:48 Right. 26:48 And so every intervention up until this most recent one was just done like this. 26:52 They would go out to the market. 26:54 They'd sell 20, 30, $40 billion of treasury bonds within the space of literally a few days that would spike yields here at home. 27:02 And then they'd use that cash to buy back the yen on their foreign exchange market. 27:07 And they drive the yen from, say, 150 to 142 or to 140 within a day. 27:12 And that would blow out a lot of the carry traders. 27:15 liquidate them, right? 27:16 Cause them to have losses and hopefully scare them off from putting the carry trade on again. 27:21 The problem is, is in the long run, this is counterproductive, right? 27:26 When you sell treasury bonds, what you're doing is you're increasing the US yield, right? 27:32 And you're doing that just to buy yen and to strengthen your own currency. 27:36 Right. 27:36 The problem is the carry trade itself relies on the gap between Japanese rates and American ones. 27:43 So you're artificially increasing the rate of U.S. bonds. 27:48 And as Japanese bonds were pinned at zero, you're increasing the amount of profit that carry traders make. 27:54 And so you're increasing the spread between the BOJ's rates and American rates. 27:58 And that's the attractiveness of that trade? 28:00 Yeah. 28:01 Yes, exactly. 28:01 Because it represents the profit that, uh, an individual can earn by borrowing yen and buying treasuries. 28:08 And especially again, four or 5% might not sound like much. 28:11 And that's true. 28:12 It isn't a huge return, but if you lever it up three, four, 10 times, it can represent a huge amount of income, uh, for you. 28:22 And it's also a very cheap trade to make, right? 28:24 Because again, you literally wouldn't have to hedge the interest rate risk. 28:27 Um, on the funding side. 28:31 And generally the currency was moving in your favor because again, like let's say you borrowed a hundred billion yen to buy a bunch of treasury bonds in March of 2022. 28:42 Well, the yen weakened considerably. 28:44 So that means your loan got easier to pay off in dollar terms, right? 28:49 Because now, you know, by the end of 2022, a dollar buys 145 yen instead of 110 yen. 28:55 So basically, you've got a free 30% return on top of the interest that you received. 28:59 So that gap represents that profit spread that carry traders make. 29:04 And so the more you push it up, the more incentive there is to come in, and especially to use leverage to juice out as much returns as you can. 29:12 So that's why they've been dumping treasury bonds. 29:15 And that's why the U.S. Treasury has finally gotten concerned, because this amount of treasury selling, especially from one of our closest allies, could prove to be calamitous, especially for long end bonds, because most of what the Japanese hold are 20 and 30 year bonds. 29:30 So how does this dynamic resolve? 29:32 Is it going to be that Japan's going to have to become a net buyer of U.S. Treasury bonds? 29:38 Or are we going to try to find other sources of demand? 29:41 And I guess within that dynamic, is it going to be one day the BOJ is like, you know, or Japan is like, hey, we got we got to sell, you know, $300 billion of these stat. 29:51 And there's kind of this this spike in yields. 29:54 Or is it going to be this this slower grind down? 29:56 So it's kind of a question of, you know, what is the dynamic and then what is the path to resolve the dynamic? 30:03 And so, you know, there's kind of multi parts to this. 30:05 But let's start with what does this look like over the next, you know, call it five years? 30:11 Is this just going to be a constant push and pull, kind of a more delicate dance between the US and Japan? 30:17 Or do you see this as something that becomes a little bit more conflict based where it's kind of the US against Japan? 30:24 How does this dynamic work going forward? 30:26 Yeah. 30:26 So Japan in many ways is extremely reliant on the U.S., right? 30:31 For one, their national security, they don't really have their own military under Article 7 of their constitution. 30:38 They're not allowed to have a standing army or navy. 30:42 And so what they have is what's called the Japanese Defense Force, which is just a small, like, basically like almost National Guard-esque military that's just meant to defend the home islands and isn't really able to project power anywhere outside of their own borders. 31:12 pouring concrete over reefs and then creating airships and naval bases. 31:18 So the Japanese don't want to upset the apple cart, right? 31:22 And especially since they import a lot of, you know, food and energy, the, the price of their yen is very, very critical to their economic stability. 31:32 So they have to thread this needle. 31:35 And the question is, how do they do it? 31:37 Because you can't allow the currency to blow out on one hand, because Japan imports around 90% of their total energy demand and about 65% of the total caloric food demand. 31:50 And on the other hand, you can't dump treasuries all the time to save your currency because you're upsetting the Apple car politically with the US and you're driving US yields higher and you're making the carry trade more profitable like we already mentioned. 32:02 So the answer would be something that's like a middle ground solution, which is – Like an example would be what they did in August. 32:09 They post the bonds at the New York Fed as a repo loan in the FEMA repo facility. 32:14 They borrow against them for, let's say, three and a half percent. 32:17 And then they use that cash to buy back the yen. 32:22 And then they pay back the loan later with some interest attached to that. 32:28 Again, the problem is that doesn't fundamentally solve the gap. 32:30 And so to solve the gap problem in the carry trade, they've been raising rates. 32:34 They've raised rates first to 1% in June of this year and then to 1.25% in September. 32:41 And this most recent meeting on October 28th to the 30th was a hold. 32:45 But it looks like there's about a 75% chance that they're going to hike again at the next meeting. 32:50 Which, by the way, this represents the fastest hiking cycle ever. 32:53 Bank of Japan has done since the 1980s, so in 45 years. 32:58 Now, I don't think that this is actually a sustainable way for the Japanese to solve this problem. 33:04 Because the issue is the Japanese have 230% debt to GDP, the highest of any developed country. 33:11 And so for every 1% higher in average interest expense that they will pay, they're going to be paying 2.3% of their GDP. 33:20 And with a fiscal budget that right now sits at about 122 trillion yen per year, they pay about like 37 trillion yen per year in debt service, about 12 trillion yen. 33:33 That is interest alone, meaning they're paying about 25% of their federal tax receipts in debt service, which is more than the US is paying. 33:44 So raising rates consistently and holding them there It's just going to cause a debt crisis on the other side. 33:50 So there's really no easy solution. 33:52 The best thing for them to do is to either use that repo facility or use the swap lines to just continue to buy themselves time. 33:59 So it seems like that repo facility is going to be how the U.S. government can kind of solve its own yield problem here. 34:08 Yeah. 34:10 I guess one thing that I've been seeing on the timeline recently is people looking at, OK, what are the net news sources of demand for U.S. Treasury bonds? 34:18 They've been looking at I see these charts and it says, you know, all other countries, namely these. 34:23 I think it's been kind of the Bahamas, if I'm not mistaken. 34:27 kind of these tax haven Caribbean countries where, to my knowledge, there's actually a lot of hedge funds based out of. 34:35 And I kind of wonder, you know, is there leverage brewing? 34:38 Is there trouble brewing or is there really just like a fast money holder entering the picture that might not always be there? 34:46 So when it comes to like the future of U.S. Treasury demand, what are you seeing there? 34:50 And how does that stack up against, say, Japan and the role they played in the Treasury market? 34:55 Absolutely. 34:55 So I think personally, I think Japan is basically getting tapped out on their US treasury demand. 35:02 And again, the reason is like for those 30 years that Japan had rates at zero, the pool of savings was growing. 35:09 The Japanese retail investor and Japanese consumer have the highest savings rate of any country in the G20. 35:16 Yeah. 35:16 They also hold about 55 percent. 35:19 Yeah, 55 percent of their household assets in cash. 35:22 So, again, the highest amount of any of any country by far. 35:27 And that kind of like saver mindset has worked really well because, again, they haven't had inflation for decades. 35:34 Yeah. 35:35 But this year, we've seen inflation go from 1.4% to 2.1% in September. 35:39 Core was up 2.0. 35:40 Core, including food and energy, was up 2.3%. 35:43 And core, excluding food and energy, was up 2.4% in September. 35:53 So blazing hot inflation reading, which is, again, part of the reason why the BOJ decided to hike. 35:58 And wages, real wages are growing over 4% year over year, which is causing trade unions and companies in Japan to have to give raises for the first time in 30, 35 years. 36:10 the Japanese are starting, especially the consumers, really starting to feel the pain of inflation, which means, again, their savings rate will likely go down. 36:18 And because that savings rate goes down, the excess capital that they're going to be able to funnel into U.S. treasuries will also reduce. 36:24 So I see Japan as, like I said, because of their political relation with the U.S., I don't see them as dumping all the treasuries tomorrow, especially as long as they don't have their own military or self-sufficient industry. 36:36 But that doesn't mean they have to buy anymore either. 36:38 Right. 36:38 They can just kind of sit on their on their pile of earnings and just continue to earn interest on it and not increase. 36:44 So the question is, then, where does U.S. Treasury demand come from? 36:48 And my long thesis has been they are going to create, you know, let's say stealth QE programs in order to generate demand where there otherwise wouldn't be. 36:58 So the first example we touched on was the treasury twist, right? 37:03 You buy long-term bonds, you sell short-term bonds. 37:07 That moves duration risks down on the balance sheet that allows the bank to lend more, to invest more, to speculate more. 37:13 They also obviously used reverse repo facility in 2022 and 2023, drew down on that facility significantly from $2.2 trillion down to, worse it's now, like $50 billion to reinvigorate that financial system with cash. 37:26 Yeah. 37:28 And they can do other things like the BTFP, right? 37:31 What would happen if you valued all bonds at par, regardless of their mark to market value, and you allowed the Fed to lend against them to any bank that wants it? 37:40 Well, right now there's a bunch of banks that are sitting on, we're still having what, a record $580 billion of unrealized losses across the banking system in the US, because all these banks had bought US treasury bonds at 0% during COVID, and then now they're holding them at 5% or 6%. 37:57 The bond itself is down 30%, 40% face value. 38:01 If you created another BTFP program and lent against them at par, that would basically create more money to be used in the banking system without doing QE. 38:10 Because you're not doing an outright purchase of assets. 38:13 You're doing a loan, right? 38:15 You're doing basically like a repo loan. 38:17 So things like that, right? 38:18 Like changing reserve ratios is another one that I've talked about. 38:21 The SLR is the supplementary leverage ratio, which is used to calculate how much capital should be held against an asset. 38:28 The SLR originally was like a 3% for treasury bonds. 38:32 And during 2020, during COVID, as the market was collapsing, the banks petitioned the Fed and the Fed agreed to lower the SLR to 0%. 38:41 meaning banks would have to hold $0 of capital against their treasury holdings in case they lost value. 38:46 So that freed up hundreds of billions of dollars of balance sheet capacity across the US. 38:52 Now, that program was ended in 2022, but in December of 2025, along with the Reserve Management Purchase Program, And quietly, the Fed also announced a change to the SLR. 39:04 So they changed it. 39:05 They didn't go all the way back to zero, which is what they did during COVID. 39:08 But they changed it from, I believe, 3% for GSIBs down to 1%. 39:12 So they cut it by 66%. 39:14 So very significant. 39:15 And if they wanted to go further with self-QE, they could lower it to zero. 39:20 So there's so many variables at play here. 39:22 And I think when it comes to Bitcoin, like it trades in different regimes, it can oftentimes be uncorrelated. 39:30 Other times it can be correlated with, you know, high beta equities. 39:33 I remember, you know, when the BOJ began its rate hike, if I'm not mistaken, it was a surprise rate hike. 39:39 Something the market was not anticipating. 39:41 Bitcoin sold off extremely sharply. 39:43 Yet, as we've seen the BOJ continue to raise rates, Bitcoin has not really responded in kind of a predictable fashion. 39:51 It's had a very low correlation to moves in the Bank of Japan's interest rates. 39:56 So, you know, with this dynamic all taken together, you know, how do you expect, one, rates to move going forward? 40:02 And two, do you expect Bitcoin to move in conjunction or opposition with U.S. or Bank of Japan rates? 40:08 How do you understand that dynamic? 40:10 So I would say that, you know, I've like, for example, I've done analysis on USDJPY and Bitcoin as well as like, you know, Fed funds rate or Bank of Japan discount rate in Bitcoin. 40:21 It's not like a daily trading relationship. 40:24 But what can happen is in especially like a carry trade unwind. 40:28 So like August 8th, 2024 event. 40:31 When the Bank of Japan signals, you know, it just hiked rates and it signals more hikes are to come. 40:36 The Fed signals it's going to lower rates as we have a weak jobs number in late July of 2024. 40:42 That causes like the compression on the spread, which allowed Bitcoin to fall 13% that day. 40:50 And, you know, NASDAQ fall like 8%, SPY fall like 6%, and the Nikkei fall 12.9%, which is the biggest one-day drop since 1987. 41:01 Since that huge crash that we had globally due to those portfolio management software systems that had been set up all across Wall Street. 41:10 So it's not like a one-to-one correlation on a daily basis, but it can represent an exogenous shock that can break Bitcoin lower. 41:17 So especially in the short term, right? 41:19 Like the Fed hiking again. 41:21 Or the Bank of Japan hiking again can both be bearish for the Bitcoin price and cause Bitcoin to retrace. 41:27 I think this morning we are in the $75,000, $76,000 range, breaking below $80,000 in the last few days. 41:36 As everything, including tech, has been selling off this last week and a half. 41:41 But long term – To me, this is bullish because high rates, right, high interest expense means the government just has to borrow more, which means eventually, especially in a fiscal dominance scenario, which is what I believe we're in, the Federal Reserve will have to print more. 41:57 So it's what I call the Peruvian bull debt paradox, which is actually one of my first viral tweets that I put out in 2022. 42:04 The higher the Fed hikes... 42:07 the further they move behind the curve. 42:09 Because at 120% debt to GDP, you can't pay it back even with, you know, a huge amount of fiscal cuts. 42:19 It's just impossible to pay that debt back in any sort of reasonable timeframe. 42:22 And so- What you do is you just offload the debt via inflation. 42:27 You run it hot and you run yields not as hot as inflation. 42:32 Now, that means that in Bitcoin, that's a macro inflationary environment. 42:37 And in that environment, Bitcoin does exceptionally well in the long term. 42:41 Again, short term, yes, there's definitely going to be some pain. 42:45 But even in a high interest rate regime, as long as there's QE and some sort of fiscal stimulus, either on the Treasury side or on the Fed side, I think it's massively bullish for Bitcoin. 42:57 And I actually have reason to believe that this cycle we're going to go to $300,000 just because this bull market started so much earlier than should have been predicted by all of the models. 43:08 So to put a finer point on it, are you saying that we would see potentially U.S. rates continue to rise and Bitcoin may suffer from an initial rate hike? 43:18 But as the market digests that hike, we would see Bitcoin kind of chase those rates higher. 43:22 Is that kind of how that trade would occur in your mind? 43:25 Yes, exactly. 43:26 Because Bitcoin isn't, it's not a risk asset in the traditional sense, right? 43:32 Even though people love to say, oh, like, why would I own gold when I can earn interest on my, you know, on my bonds? 43:39 Why would I own Bitcoin when I can earn 4%, 5% on my treasury bonds? 43:43 That's true when the real rate is 5%. 43:46 But even right now, right, CPI is still above 2%. 43:51 And that means normally you're only earning a measly 3% even at 10-year treasury rates, a little less than that, like 2.8%. 44:00 But we've known for a long time that CPI is manipulated and that it's likely understated by – a significant amount, right? 44:07 I don't know if you saw, there was a tweet this morning by Charlie Belello, who said that if you break down the healthcare insurance costs of CPI, the CPI, the BLS claims has fallen by like 30% in the last six years. 44:21 And he's like, who in the world has seen their healthcare insurance costs fall by 30% in six years? 44:26 Nobody. 44:26 Nobody. 44:28 So I don't know what metrics they're using to calculate the CPI, but I think clearly it's understated. 44:35 And that means that likely real yields are closer to like one and a half percent rather than even a three percent, which is what they claim. 44:44 which to me makes Bitcoin all the more attractive. 44:46 Because if I can only earn 1.5%, which means it'll take me, what, 50 years to double my money, or I can invest in Bitcoin, which I know from trough to peak, this cycle will at least 3 to 4x, maybe more. 45:02 That's an easy trade. 45:05 And that takes way less than 50 years to take place. 45:08 So I think in the long run, higher yields are actually bullish for Bitcoin because it means more deficit spending, more borrowing, more inflation, and more QE, which all of that is a stimulative. 45:49 Yeah, I think the only piece remaining in that equation is who is going to be buying Bitcoin. 45:53 I'm sure we will. 45:55 But who is going to be the dry powder that comes in to drive Bitcoin to those highs? 46:00 And I think the nature of the Bitcoin market has changed so much. 46:02 I think, you know, 2020 to 2022, extremely retail dominated. 46:08 Now we've seen kind of the face of the Bitcoin market change. 46:11 It's becoming... 46:12 Retail trading activity way down. 46:13 I know recent Coinbase earnings, eToro earnings, many of these exchanges just reporting retail volumes are way, way down. 46:21 So it doesn't seem like retail is going to be the ones to take us there. 46:24 And to me, it's a question of, OK, what is kind of the investor psychology behind kind of the managed money that might be chasing Bitcoin and really what the narrative they form around it is looking like? 46:35 I know Bitwise has been saying this is kind of the wealth management cycle as Bitcoin all of the RAs and wealth management firms start jumping in and having their clients allocate to Bitcoin. 46:46 You know, do you agree with that statement there? 46:49 Or are there any other sources of demand that you're keeping your eye on? 46:52 And hey, it might just be, hey, I think retail is going to come swinging out again. 46:56 But we'd love to get your thoughts on that. 46:57 Yeah, I agree. 46:58 I think the story last cycle, and even this cycle, is one of institutional adoption. 47:03 First, we see the Bitcoin treasury companies like Strategy come out swinging, similar scientific meta planet, all start acquiring huge amounts of Bitcoin. 47:12 And then obviously in January of 2024, we saw the IBIT Bitcoin ETF launch to the tune of $100 billion raised in like, I think it was under 90 days. 47:23 So one of the fastest to $100 billion of any ETFs. 47:27 in history. 47:28 Um, and there's about 10 other ETFs apart from that one that are all Bitcoin based, which allows individuals, uh, and institutions to load up on, on Bitcoin. 47:36 My own dad is, um, you know, he's a boomer. 47:39 Uh, he has a, a Vanguard retirement fund and he has a fidelity fund. 47:43 And I've used, you know, helped direct him into Bitcoin ETFs. 47:50 The question is, like, how does that impact the day-to-day price? 47:53 Because ETFs and, you know, like, say, pension funds buying Bitcoin shows up very differently than retail. 47:59 Because most retail participants, at least the more sophisticated ones, want to directly hold their Bitcoin, right? 48:06 They want to self-custody, which means they take it off in exchange. 48:09 They take it off the market. 48:10 They take it off the books of another institution and they put it into a hardware wallet, right? 48:16 Institutions don't really want that. 48:17 They don't want to deal with the risk, with the custody risk. 48:20 And so they trust middlemen like Coinbase to hold their Bitcoin for them. 48:25 And that opens us up to the risk of rehypothecation, right? 48:29 Let's say Coinbase has 1 million Bitcoin investors. 48:32 in their hardware wallets. 48:34 And they have four or five ETFs that are, you know, basically like have claims on that Bitcoin. 48:39 If those ETFs start to become very popular and they issue more shares, Coinbase could lie and say, oh yeah, we have the Bitcoin to back up, you know, all the claims from the, you know, the Bitwise ETF, the Grayscale ETF, you know, Right. 48:55 Like all these other financial BlackRock ETF, the IBT ETF, but they don't actually have it. 49:00 And without like a sophisticated investor knowing how to audit them or without them releasing proof of reserves, you wouldn't really be able to. 49:09 And so that shows up obviously very differently than than than retail investors. 49:14 The other way it changes things is. 49:16 you know, institutional investors come in slowly, right? 49:19 They don't wade into the market and buy, you know, with the exception of maybe strategy, right? 49:24 With Michael Saylor at the helm. 49:27 Most institutional investors come in very cautiously and they buy slowly and accumulate over time. 49:32 They don't really chase trends. 49:33 And so- 49:34 The high amounts of volatility that we saw in the early stages of Bitcoin is likely going to continue to dampen and slowly reduce over time because institutional investors will come in to buy the dips and they'll likely sell the tops to profit from it and to increase their treasury holdings. 49:52 So the way I see it is like we're moving from that more like retail in the market. 49:58 individualistic based Bitcoin market into more of an institutional deep liquidity and strategic market where institutions and pension funds and banks are loading up on Bitcoin and holding it in custody, you know, accounts. 50:14 just as a financial asset, right? 50:16 So it's in order to become a true money, which is I believe Bitcoin is a true money. 50:21 It first has to pass through all these phases and the phase is passing through now is it's already graduated the speculative, you know, you could say like speculative instrument phase. 50:30 It's now into the financial asset phase and it's going to take probably a few trillion dollars market cap for it to fully mature in that stage until it can be used as real money throughout the financial system. 50:42 I think on the paper Bitcoin claim, I kind of want to push back a little bit on that. 50:46 I know there's been some discussion lately of, you know, strategy and these preferreds kind of representing paper Bitcoin and people saying, oh, this is demand that otherwise would have been spot Bitcoin. 50:58 And this is kind of how it could be a suppression mechanism on the price of Bitcoin. 51:01 I think And this is something I'm less well versed in. 51:04 But I think, you know, 1980s, 1990s, we saw a lot of like kind of paper gold products get issued on the market, yet gold went on a pretty incredible bull run still sitting around $4,000 an ounce. 51:16 And so I guess the point I want to make is twofold is one, I guess I don't necessarily believe that. 51:23 kind of these paper products necessarily translate into a suppression of price. 51:28 And two, I think just kind of going to bat for Coinbase a little bit, you know, do you think that, you know, with all the SEC filings and the regulation and the insurance that Coinbase needs to take on, do you think it's likely that they would ultimately misrepresent to what degree, you know, uh... 51:44 the Bitcoin that they say they're custodying for, you know, these ETF issuers actually exists or not. 51:51 I guess my gut would tell me, I think that method of kind of like rehypothecation by Coinbase would ultimately seem much more unlikely. 51:59 And I would also say that I think... 52:02 So rehypothecation is just a form of risk taking that I don't know if we can necessarily say categorically we can get rid of or is necessarily bad. 52:11 So I guess kind of a multifactorial point there. 52:14 But how does that sit with you when it comes to kind of that that pushback on the rehypothecation boogeyman, so to speak? 52:20 Yeah, I would say that I wasn't making the claim that the ETFs are completely neutering Bitcoin or they're killing Bitcoin in any sense. 52:30 I do think obviously there is some demand that would have gone to real Bitcoin, but it isn't able to be captured because it's going to an ETF instead, which is indirectly buying Bitcoin. 52:44 The thing that a lot of people miss is that, you know, I would say a majority of the ETF buyers wouldn't have bought Bitcoin at all if there wasn't an ETF product. 52:53 So those buyers, which I believe represent, you know, over 80% of the ETF buyers, they would have had zero exposure to Bitcoin anyways. 53:01 And so I don't believe, you know, I wasn't trying to make the statement that the ETFs are, you know, essentially neutering Bitcoin or like completely diverting price prices. 53:13 From Bitcoin itself. 53:15 Right. 53:15 There's probably a little bit of that, a little bit of truth to that, but I think it's under probably 20% of what is claimed to be the case. 53:23 My concern more is just the ethos of Bitcoin itself. 53:27 Right. 53:27 Bitcoin is a trustless, non-intermediary, decentralized money. 53:33 And when you have a single centralized entity that owns a lot of it, and in the case of strategy, for example, not publishing proof of reserves, that just causes me to get antsy. 53:44 It causes me to feel like, hey, of all monies in the world, like with gold, I wouldn't have a problem with this. 53:48 With silver, maybe not as much. 53:51 But with Bitcoin, I can audit, you know, I run a note on my computer. 53:54 I can audit your holdings tomorrow if you just tell me the addresses, but they don't. 54:04 a speck in their eye as, you know, I wish that they would. 54:07 Now, I'm not saying that they're definitely going and re-hypopulating, you know, trillions of dollars or hundreds of billions of dollars or whatever of Bitcoin. 54:13 But the opportunity is there for them, right? 54:16 And I think especially the other risk with a centralized custodian is if the U.S. ever decides to declare Bitcoin a strategic national asset, they can go to Coinbase and they can seize all their Bitcoin. 54:27 They can go to strategy and send black ops soldiers after Saylor and black bag him and take all of this Bitcoin. 54:35 Because somebody in this company knows the custodian. 54:38 They have the private keys. 54:40 They probably have a chain of command. 54:42 But if you lock up enough board members, if you lock up enough high-level people from the company, you will eventually get to the Bitcoin and be able to seize it. 54:50 And these wealthy individuals, of all things, they don't want to lose their wealth and their status and their power. 54:55 Now, when Bitcoin is much more decentralized and held among millions of individuals, the ability for the government to go and seize a million Bitcoin if everyone holds one is basically impossible because they don't have the manpower to do that. 55:08 But if they can one shot, you know, 5% of the Bitcoin market just by going after one guy, that to me represents a risk that I think other people don't really appreciate. 55:16 I'm not saying the government would do that, but, you know, they've been known to do things like ban gold, especially in financial crises like the Great Depression. 55:23 So I wouldn't put it past them if we face another severe financial panic. 55:27 Yeah, no, I think to my eye, like if the US were in such dire fiscal straits that it would need to do such a thing. 55:35 One, I think we have a lot bigger problems. 55:37 And two, I think it's also an interesting question of like, what is the political economy of the Bitcoin holder? 55:42 Is this someone that's, you know, whose property rights are well respected in the legal, social, financial system? 55:48 Or is this someone that has been increasingly marginalized? 55:51 And I think Ovik Roy has made a really interesting point in this regard where he says, you know, Bitcoin's success at its current holder base could be its biggest risk, where to my understanding, it has much higher kind of inequality index compared to the fiat financial system where some tiny, tiny percentage of people stores. 56:10 They own, you know, the vast majority of Bitcoin. 56:13 I don't remember the statistics off the top of my head. 56:15 So Bitcoin is actually much more unequal. 56:18 In terms of just the wealth distribution, I'm not saying that's here nor there, you know, permanent of capitalism being rewarded for risk taking all of the kind of caveats there. 56:27 But the point being that if people say, hey, you know, these, you know, 2000 people are getting getting away scot free while we all bear the brunt of inflation, maybe they are the solution to our problem there. 56:40 And so in the event that Bitcoin gets more evenly distributed, I think that becomes less and less likely over time. 56:47 And I guess all that to say, I think, you know, people that assess the risk in the way that you were describing, I think, should probably just add, you know, a few a few bips to the discount rate they use when assessing an investment in something like a strategy and something like a Coinbase where there is that counterparty risk ultimately. 57:04 So in that regard, I would hope that that risk would be priced in accordingly. 57:08 But yeah. 57:09 Yeah, just wanted to kind of double click on talking about that idea of counterparty risk as kind of the Bitcoin investing base has matured. 57:17 And to your point, more derivatives and custodial products continue to take the bulk of what makes up this market. 57:25 Yeah, I would agree. 57:27 And I'll also parrot what you said about the Gini coefficient of Bitcoin. 57:32 So there have been analysis that found out that Bitcoin is more inequitable than the traditional financial system. 57:38 But I don't think that analysis is fair. 57:40 And the reason why I don't think it's fair is because Bitcoin, at least in its current – you know, insentiation in the market, isn't really fully being used as money, right? 57:51 Most Bitcoiners you meet are stacking sats. 57:55 They're not spending sats. 57:57 Stacking is the name of the game because as Bitcoin progresses from, like we said, a speculative instrument to an actual, like let's say reserve currency or international monetary medium, it has to become a financial asset first and has to gain market adoption and gain usage 58:12 as a store of value before it becomes a medium of exchange. 58:16 Now that means it's treated like a financial instrument. 58:18 And what do you do with a financial instrument? 58:20 You collect more and more of it. 58:22 So the people who are wealthy already in the fiat system and they're early to Bitcoin, they buy as much Bitcoin as they can. 58:29 And all the plebs who are, let's say, working class workers or blue collar plumbers, they're buying as much Bitcoin as they can as well, and they're not spending it. 58:38 So that lack of spending, which is essentially Gresham's law applied writ large across the Bitcoin ecosystem, has prevented Bitcoin from flowing out from the big addresses to the small addresses, right? 58:49 Because like, let's say you're a guy who owns 100 Bitcoin or 1000 Bitcoin, and Bitcoin price is going to go up 20, 30% in the next few years. 58:58 Why would you ever spend any of it? 59:00 You wouldn't. 59:01 But once Bitcoin price stabilizes, and if Bitcoin, especially if it becomes a monetary medium, then you're sitting on a huge pile of money that's no longer gaining in value. 59:10 Well, now you have a huge propensity to spend. 59:12 Now you want to go buy, you know, a new mansion, a new house, a new car. 59:16 You want to go on vacation with your kids. 59:18 And how are you going to pay for that? 59:19 You're going to take some of your Bitcoin out of your address. 59:21 You're going to... 59:21 you know, zap somebody a couple million sats to pay for your flight. 59:26 That's how the monetary velocity of the network would start to increase. 59:30 And that's how the money would start to flow out of the highly concentrated cold wallets, which are the wealthy holders and into the hands of everybody else. 59:38 But right now, again, Bitcoin isn't being spent. 59:41 The monetary velocity of Bitcoin is very, very low. 59:45 And especially when compared to the fiat financial system, you know, Bitcoin runs what, like seven trades a second on the base layer. 59:55 And the Visa network does between like 12 to 50,000 transactions a second. 60:00 And so the monetary velocity is just so much lower. 60:04 So it's not, I would say, a fair comparison until we see widespread Bitcoin adoption as an actual money, as a medium of exchange and as a unit of account where things are priced in sats and I can buy this laptop in front of me for sats, I can buy this microphone in front of me for sats. 60:19 Until we get there, I think we should have a grain of salt for those Gini coefficient comparisons between Bitcoin and fiat. 60:27 Yeah, I think one of the things that fascinates me is as we think about Bitcoin becoming this medium of exchange, as we think about countries trying to settle trade between one another, they're going to have to have these balances of Bitcoin in reserve in order to execute those trades as well. 60:41 So at the same time, you know, this kind of the number go up crowd. 60:44 kind of being oftentimes painted as though they're at odds with this medium of exchange crowd. 60:49 They kind of do have this like donut theory of coming together kind of on the tail end, interestingly enough. 60:55 So I think that is probably something that's been underexplored as to what degree kind of this like global trade settlement mechanism is. 61:01 represents Bitcoin maturing as a medium of exchange and a store value simultaneously. 61:06 You know, I think that's probably a bit far afield for the context of this conversation. 61:11 So I think it's probably about time to land this plane here. 61:14 But Roberto, you know, would you love if you could share with our audience where they can find more of your work, if they want to learn more about, you know, the dollar endgame and, of course, the interplumbing process. 61:24 as it relates to the Federal Reserve, Bank of Japan, U.S. Treasury, all the way down, bank balance sheets, et cetera. 61:31 Where can they find more of you? 61:33 Sure. 61:33 So I'm on Twitter at Peruvian underscore bull. 61:36 And it's just my username is just my name, Roberto Rios. 61:39 On Substack, I'm also Peruvian Bull and YouTube as well. 61:43 The YouTube is basically only Japan economic content, Japan macro. 61:46 So if you want to be laser focused on Japan macro, please go follow me on YouTube at Peruvian Bull. 61:52 I've been putting out a lot of great content there recently. 61:55 The channel is growing quickly. 61:56 So I'm on those three places. 61:58 I also have a book. 62:00 dollar endgame, which basically is my thesis of how Bitcoin can become a global reserve currency. 62:06 And like I said, it already has to go through this phase of, you know, speculative asset and then store of value. 62:13 And finally, like an actual bona fide currency, we're still in the second phase. 62:17 And so there's still a lot of time left in the game. 62:19 So stack some stats, buy some Bitcoin, and yeah, get ready for the next leg up. 62:25 Well said, Roberto. 62:25 Thank you for joining us on the Bitcoin Magazine podcast. 62:28 We look forward to speaking with you again here soon. 62:30 And thank you for taking the time. 62:31 Thank you. 62:32 I appreciate it. 62:33 Likewise.
Community discussion