0:00 All right. 0:00 Well, let's bring in our first guest of the day, and that is Jeff Booth, author of The Price of Tomorrow and co-founder of Ego Death Capital, a Bitcoin-only venture capital firm. 0:10 He's also the co-founder of Orange Juice, a long-term focused private equity firm backed by Bitcoin. 0:16 Jeff has been at the forefront of the convergence of technological deflation and fiat debasement, arguing that Bitcoin is necessary technology to resolve the tension between those two forces. 0:27 Jeff, good morning. 0:29 Morning. 0:29 Thanks for having me. 0:30 Yes, thank you. 0:32 So you've been vocal about the economics behind the current AI boom. 0:35 Can you summarize the current state of the sector's valuations and if those valuations are defensible, given what you're seeing? 0:44 Well, in a free market, prices fall to the marginal cost of production. 0:48 So AI, a line of code creating other lines of code, following that access in a free market would have to be free. 0:56 And that's why I run a frontier model on my computer that four months ago was the best model for free. 1:04 So the economics underlying the entire path require regulation to protect a monopoly or prices fall. 1:11 Now, the abundance gained from those prices falling should flow to us in a free market. 1:17 But what ends up happening on the other side of that ledger, you have to create regulation or protection for a monopoly to stop the free market from acting. 1:30 And to that point, you know, tech in general, you know, especially AI is deflationary. 1:34 And this is something you've spoken on several times. 1:38 What do you see happening as that collides with our current debt driven system that requires monetary expansion? 1:43 You know, is this what you're kind of alluding to where protectionism kind of comes in to guard those? 1:49 Yeah. 1:50 So nothing I wrote about seven years ago in Price of Tomorrow is any different. 1:55 You have an exponential trend of productivity trying to reach us. 2:01 And on the other side of that ledger, you have a debt-based system that has to expand exponentially to stop that productivity from reaching us. 2:11 Yeah. 2:12 And so what that means is if you're measuring through the debt-based system, that credit has to expand forever exponentially against what I just said. 2:24 It means you're centralizing everything. 2:27 You're living more and more in a surveillance state, and things are going to get very confusing if you're measuring from that position. 2:39 We have the $40 trillion debt. 2:40 Bond yields are spiking. 2:42 It's very unlikely this gets paid back in real terms. 2:46 Can you walk us through how this resolves and how volatile it gets? 2:51 Very volatile. 2:53 When the world hits this spot, which it hits every 80 to 120 years, typically there's a global crisis to condition people that it's not their fault, it's somebody else's fault, and there needs to be a great reset. 3:06 And that typical reset comes through war, conflict, and it comes because people believe in the debt-based system, that they make stronger through their belief in the debt-based system. 3:18 So they're easily manipulated from that system. 3:21 They're easily conditioned to believe it's somebody else. 3:24 And so what that means is this is going to get really, really confusing for people measuring from a system that is already insolvent. 3:34 And when you say 40 trillion US, you're just talking about the US debt. 3:38 If you measure that globally, it's 350 trillion. 3:43 That 350 trillion is already insolvent. 3:46 There is nothing that makes it insolvent. 3:48 So every asset on top of the 350 trillion, if you're measuring assets, is tethered to something that people already know is insolvent and is only solvent by their belief in somebody else's power to print their money. 4:07 And, you know, speaking of uncertainty, I think I think that as this accelerates, you know, there's increasing uncertainty, especially around things like the A.I. 4:17 trade. 4:17 Right. 4:17 There's a lot of claims and it just gets continuously confusing, one from kind of the perspective you're talking about, but also from the technical perspective. 4:25 Now, I'd love to hear your thoughts on the claims being made by these leading AI figures about, hey, we're entering the singularity. 4:31 Hey, we need to slow down. 4:32 You know, in your estimation, are these legitimate claims? 4:36 Are they coming from genuine places or is it sort of this protectionism creeping in? 4:42 Really important topic and a really important topic on your show and everything else. 4:48 If you're inside a framework that has to debase and requires your conditioning to debase it, then you can expect all of these things to happen because it works off fear. 5:00 You ask yourself a different question. 5:03 If prices fell of AI and everybody benefited from the prices falling of AI, would there be a danger of AI? 5:12 Versus would there be a danger of AI if you consolidated it all in a couple companies? 5:18 So they controlled you. 5:20 Very different paradigms. 5:22 And you understand from a paradigm of I need to control my monopoly. 5:27 or my monopoly of AI, why you'd have to drive fear into the market. 5:33 Because that's how you get regulators to protect your monopoly. 5:37 And monopolies favor regulation. 5:43 So how do you gain regulation? 5:44 You drive fear into the market. 5:47 And do you think this is something the industry can innovate around or maybe better put, people will be able to innovate around? 5:53 You mentioned you're running a model for free on your computer that used to be the equivalent of a frontier model just a couple of months ago. 5:59 Is that expands? 6:02 Do you think that the attempts to come in and intervene and kind of and and concentrate this industry will be thwarted by the ability to just kind of spread code around the world? 6:11 Both of you are going to happen at the same time. 6:13 That's what's going to get so confusing. 6:15 And depending on your measuring, depending on the ruler you're measuring from, if you're measuring from a debt-based system that has to expand and manipulate your money forever, you're probably also watching the news from that system and everything from that system. 6:28 And you're inside a system problem that can't resolve the system problem of the free market. 6:33 Free market is going the other way. 6:35 That productivity is flowing. 6:37 And so if you're measuring in Bitcoin that cannot that is decentralized and secure and bounded by energy, you're participating in all of the abundance flowing to you. 6:51 Jeff, can you walk us through how to think about productivity in a Bitcoin denominated future and how to think about Bitcoin's true value when we can unleash technological deflation? 7:03 Well, for this, just imagine us as humans, as what we do as humans or entrepreneurs or anybody contributing into a market is we solve scarcity. 7:15 Things that were once scarce, we create abundance from them. 7:19 That abundance comes from our mind. 7:21 AI is no different. 7:22 It's just one portion of what I'm talking about. 7:25 And so we did it with fertilizers. 7:27 We did it with every single thing before us, books that turned into digital books that turned into the internet, miracles. 7:35 And the more people contributing to that... 7:38 The margin itself, the scarcity itself produces margin that then the free market attacks with creative ideas to produce more value. 7:48 And then what happens with us on the other side of that ledger? 7:52 We use more value. 7:54 No entrepreneur that has ever existed produces less value and survives. 8:02 So how could a market that is a free market exist when we create the value and we only use more value? 8:11 How could prices go up? 8:14 And what you see is the lie we've been told our entire lives that we live in a free market. 8:19 We don't live in a free market. 8:21 There cannot be inflation in what I just described. 8:24 It has to be deflation. 8:27 So where does inflation come from? 8:29 It comes from us believing debt is money. 8:32 And that debt is money has to expand forever because if you lend money into existence and you pay it back, there's no money. 8:43 And you've said before, the $1 million price target for Bitcoin is thinking too small. 8:49 What are people fundamentally misunderstanding when they try to value Bitcoin in dollars? 8:55 Well, they're pricing from a game that they know is rigged. 9:00 They're pricing something outside of the system from a game that they know is rigged by debasing, by creating more currency units. 9:08 It's ludicrous. 9:13 and understand what Bitcoin is, it's imposing a new discipline in the world. 9:17 It's imposing, it's not, even people are calling it a coin. 9:22 It is the beginning of a protocol stack that it'll look a lot like the internet, but it will be decentralized, secure, private, that people cannot attack. 9:33 And from that system, all prices will fall forever. 9:37 In fact, what Bitcoin is, is the first It is it's evidence of the first free market that's ever existed now against the other the other system looking at it because we don't understand what I just said. 9:51 We've always lived in a zero sum game until we move. 9:56 We won't understand that because we'll be most people will be measuring Bitcoin. 9:59 Yeah. 10:00 Like it's a coin, like it's something that is an asset within that other system rather than a new system pricing everything. 10:12 Jeff, you mentioned that it's hard for people who are existing inside this faux paradigm to kind of step out and measure and assess things effectively. 10:22 You're also someone who's spent thousands of hours working on trying to break your Bitcoin thesis. 10:29 Given recent events, When people are looking at Bitcoin, you know, there's a lot of conflation between UI or products built on Bitcoin and Bitcoin itself. 10:38 With everything moving at such a fast rate and the masses kind of living inside this paradigm where it's hard to kind of make ups and downs of the world. 10:48 Has anything changed in your expectations for the timeline for Bitcoin adoption or maybe just the form that it'll take? 10:57 No, nothing that changes us. 10:59 And so if you just ask two really simple questions, and you can evidence these yourself, is the natural state of the free market deflation? 11:09 Yes. 11:10 The answer is yes. 11:11 That means we've never lived in it. 11:13 We don't have a paradigm of what I'm speaking about. 11:15 Number two, is that experiencing an exponential productivity gain? 11:22 Yes. 11:23 That should, if then, if this, then this, that should give us exponential prices falling, more value for society. 11:34 So we know we don't live in a free market. 11:37 We never have. 11:38 Now, now insert Bitcoin. 11:40 If Bitcoin stays decentralized and secure, is it pricing what I just described? 11:46 Yes. 11:47 Now, now you can do your own work and saying, will it stay decentralized and secure? 11:51 What are the chances? 11:53 How, how will this look over time? 11:55 And what will most people do instead of this and what I would just described, they will contribute their energy to the other system. 12:05 And they will measure Bitcoin from that other system like it's just an asset. 12:09 Why do you need an asset? 12:12 You need an asset. 12:13 The reason we are conditioned to believe in assets is because we cannot store our money in money. 12:19 So the very reason an asset exists is because you know the financial system, you can't store your money in money. 12:28 Which is so crazy. 12:30 So if you see Bitcoin as an asset, you're likely still inside the other system, measuring it from the other system. 12:39 So how do you see Bitcoin adoption taking place in practice? 12:43 You've backed projects like FETI at EgoDeath. 12:46 How far are we from this starting to truly scale? 12:50 We are so early in this. 12:52 Now, starting to scale is a very different thing. 12:56 It's already started to scale. 12:58 It's unstoppable. 13:00 How many people realize what I'm talking about is so, so few. 13:06 But that doesn't mean that from a very low base, it's not scaling. 13:09 We're watching in our portfolio companies that massive growth and payments around the world through different technologies on top of Bitcoin, that there's already circular economies going. 13:21 Now, what people would say from the other system is nobody uses it. 13:25 Well, I can tell you from metrics in our own companies that that is absolutely false and it's growing exponentially. 13:34 So it's us understanding what's happening and through a different lens rather than listening to the same media and circus that is empowered by broken money. 13:50 Jeff, let's talk about your firm, Orange Juice. 13:52 How did the idea come about? 13:53 And can you walk us through the thesis behind Bitcoin-backed private equity? 13:57 Sure. 13:59 The thesis was the same. 14:01 So if all of our world existed from a system that was debasing, then everything would look like a trade. 14:10 Private equity would look like a trade. 14:12 Everything, you'd build a company and you'd try to get it public so you could trade it to somebody else. 14:17 Nothing would look like long-term value. 14:19 And inside of that, you would have misincentives in the market. 14:25 And so what private equity would do because it has to trade out within four or five years, not bad people, just the function of it, they would roll up companies, take a food company that had incredible demand because they put really good ingredients in their food. 14:43 Well, private equity company would buy that, roll up a couple of others and change the ingredients and take that company with debt and everything else. 14:52 And then people, when they realized what was happening to their food, They would stop buying that food. 14:58 They would go to somewhere else and the private equity company would be faced with debt, trying to get out and trade that before it happened, before it fell apart. 15:09 If you understand Bitcoin and what it looks like, and Bitcoin is this new denominator for the world. 15:17 then you don't have to trade. 15:19 You think about businesses over a long term. 15:22 You think about family businesses that provide value to society and their generational businesses that don't want to play in the game of a trade and just get out. 15:36 They want to run their businesses for a long time. 15:39 So now you can build an operating model. 15:42 that comes in and you want to own them forever. 15:46 You're buying them because they're really great people. 15:49 They're really great operators and they provide a service to society. 15:54 And then you own them forever instead of trading them out to something else. 15:59 So the reason Orange Juice exists is, and it actually came from some of our LPs and ego death who started to see this and had these types of companies. 16:10 And said, how do we, we don't want to sell to private equity. 16:13 And then what would we do? 16:15 How do we create something that we can participate in a new model emerging? 16:23 Jeff, it was really great to hear from you. 16:24 Thanks so much for joining us. 16:26 Thank you.
Community discussion