0:00 All right. 0:00 For more narratives in the macro markets, we go to everyone's favorite chicken and analyst combo. 0:06 It's Doomburg, the founder and author of the Doomburg Macro Newsletter. 0:11 Well, Doomburg, your hair looks fantastic today. 0:13 Thanks for joining us. 0:15 Great, Sean. 0:16 Great to be with you. 0:17 Fantastic program you guys have put together. 0:18 Congrats on the launch and very much enjoyed listening to the to the opening few minutes. 0:23 And boy, talk about no shortage of things for us to pick apart today. 0:28 Yeah, absolutely. 0:29 Well, let's start with yesterday's Fed meeting. 0:32 Fed Chair Kevin Warsh taking the time to stress that the Fed has not met its 2% inflation target for more than six years. 0:39 He also noted the importance of geopolitical developments, disruption in the oil market. 0:44 So with where Iran and Russia currently stand, do you think 2% inflation is in the cards? 0:50 What's your read on that whole dynamic? 0:52 Well, first thing I would say is it's quite funny to hear that. 0:56 The Fed chair talked about the information that he needs to see before the next meeting, and that information is the midterm elections need to happen. 1:02 Let's not kid ourselves. 1:04 There was no universe in which the Fed was going to hike or cut in October ahead of the hotly contested, highly polarized election. 1:14 And so that's what the Fed is. 1:17 It is nothing if not a hyperpolitical body. 1:20 To your question, you know, the whole inflation discussion around the diesel shortage that we're seeing is is a really important one. 1:30 And the real question, the real information actually that the whole world is waiting for is, is is Trump going to restart the war in Iran for a third time once the midterms have come and gone? 1:43 And that is the real sort of bifurcation in, trying to sort of predict the future of where these markets are going. 1:49 And it's really impossible to say with certainty, A or B, because depending on whether or not the president intends to restart the war, you have two wildly different worlds. 1:59 And so if your base case is that the war in the Middle East will settle, well, then I think diesel is going to collapse. 2:07 Inflation will come back under control. 2:09 The fed will be in a wildly different position. 2:12 And, If Trump and whoever emerges as the prime minister of Israel decide to go back into Iran and Iran counterpunches by destroying much of the oil and gas infrastructure in the Middle East, well, then you take the exact opposite of everything that I just described to you. 2:27 And we're in we're into a very, very deep crisis. 2:30 You know, our base case is the president by now must know that he has a losing hand in Iran and he is unlikely to go for the sort of Hail Mary bet it all. 2:42 long shot chance to snatch victory out of a quagmire by who knows if the elections go against him or it's disputed or we have a replay of what happened in Brazil over the weekend, which is an underrated macro development that's affecting all these things as well. 2:57 But that's sort of a high level view. 3:00 You have a bifurcation of the world coming up soon. 3:04 And how that goes is really going to drive all the other things that you've talked about in your 3:12 I want to stay on the oil market for a second here and the disruption in the Middle East. 3:17 So Yemen's Houthis say they hit Saudi Arabia's biggest refinery. 3:22 Brent crude sitting around one hundred ten dollars a barrel today. 3:25 But it's I mean, it's been hanging out anywhere from there to one fifteen. 3:29 Do you think the market is more worried about lost crude or lost refining capacity? 3:35 And how does that show up at the pump? 3:38 Yeah, at the moment, it's a bit of both. 3:40 But if you had to pick one, you would say that the lack of refining is the real challenge. 3:46 There's plenty of crude in the sense that there's far more crude being stored around the world by governments for just these purposes. 3:56 And so when you destroy a refinery... 3:59 this is sort of a nuance of the oil markets that people who aren't as familiar with it might not get, oil prices go down because refineries are really the only true customers for oil. 4:09 In fact, we have a saying to drive this point home, which is oil is worthless until it gets to a refinery. 4:16 And so if you knock off all of the world's refineries, well, the price of oil goes to zero or negative because it is a negative carry toxic fluid. 4:25 And so if you start knocking off Russia's refineries in the war in Ukraine and, you know, you see the Houthis blowing up Saudi refineries, well, that is actually bearish for crude, even though it is bullish for prices at the pump in the sense that they will rise because in between China. 4:43 crude and the nozzle when you pull into your local gas station sit the global refining network. 4:50 And so that's the real sort of challenge that we see. 4:52 If Ukraine keeps blowing up Russian refineries or the Houthis blow up a Saudi refinery or the war in Iran kicks off and the whole Middle East goes up in smoke, well, then all bets are off. 5:04 And, you know, I know that you don't have a crystal ball and you just said all bets are off. 5:08 But what do you think the implications would be if the U.S. does get back involved? 5:13 I mean, we're seeing these reports from the Wall Street Journal saying American warships are preparing for a possible new round of strikes in Iran. 5:19 And it feels like the market's kind of largely desensitized to this reality now. 5:23 It's sort of become like the new normal or new expectation. 5:27 But, you know, China has has drawn down a lot of their oil reserves. 5:31 Inflation is a persistent problem here in the U.S. with with multiple aspects of our market. 5:37 You know, what would be the impacts not just in the U.S. domestic quagmire, but also just globally if the U.S. were to reescalate? 5:46 Well, our base case is that the counterpunch is what matters most. 5:51 And I think the evidence is pretty compelling that the U.S. and Israel underestimated Iran's capacity to counterpunch. 6:00 And they must know that they can now. 6:02 And Iran has been very clear that any renewed hostilities will immediately trigger a cascading series of escalations that would be difficult to control and that they have in their targets sites that. 6:18 the highly sensitive, priceless, irreplaceable assets that are spread all across the Middle East and well within range of Iranian high-precision missiles. 6:28 So you're talking about destruction of Qatar's LNG facilities, the U.S. 6:33 You're talking about the oil producing nerve centers of Saudi Arabia, all of the pipelines, the east-west pipeline. 6:43 You knock off the entire Middle East in a way that is effectively irreversible, and then you kind of go into full tilt. 6:50 You're talking about a global economic crisis where it's hard for us to see. 6:55 any good outcomes, things would get extraordinarily volatile in the long run. 7:01 But that's sort of you're talking, you know, fourth turning, great reset, that jubilee time with the ultimate Fed printer go burr, because the crisis that would follow from that is almost inconceivable. 7:14 And so the reason why the market is, sorry, the reason why the market is sort of playing down the prospects is they just can't believe that that would actually happen. 7:22 And so until it does, the market is going to sort of pretend that it won't. 7:29 And things look grim regardless, right? 7:32 I mean, even if kind of things continue with the jawboning and kind of just snapping narratives around without really taking much action, the world markets are kind of held hostage. 7:45 And to exacerbate that, like you said, a lot of refineries have already been hit. 7:48 A lot of damage has already been done along with global distrust. 7:52 But, you know, even if we continue with the current status quo, the World Bank is forecasting, you know, commodity prices rising 23 percent this year, you know, energy, food, metals all being higher. 8:05 But they're also warning of something not in not picked up in many headlines, which is the strong El Nino and attacks on on black sea grain shipments, driving the potential to trigger a new food crisis heading into 2027. 8:19 You know, which which of these kind of situations that you're monitoring, do you think are actually posing the biggest risk to the markets heading into 2027? 8:28 So I concur with all of the assessment of the risks on the board. 8:33 So then the question becomes, what's the inverted case? 8:38 In our view, we're starting to see the beginning of the end of the war in Ukraine. 8:44 That is an entire topic that we could spend a show on. 8:47 But we would note with interest that our open source sort of signals have indicated that Ukraine has not attacked a Russian refinery since I think about October 16th. 8:58 Russian refining capacity is now once again, exceeding its domestic needs. 9:04 And so there's the possibility that Russia may reenter the export market. 9:10 And if the war in Ukraine does wrap up, then you can at least take that risk off the board. 9:15 El Nino, I can't predict the weather. 9:17 And then, so it all really comes down to the war in Iran, in our view. 9:22 If... 9:23 The settlement in Ukraine is sort of a two-bet parlay with a settlement in Iran that may be brokered by Russia or helped to be brokered by the Kremlin in a post-midterm situation. 9:39 you know, scenario, you could see a boom. 9:41 I mean, I do think, like, if you asked us for our bull case, you know, let's imagine that, you know, the Republicans get wiped out and Trump suffers this setback in the midterms and has to really reassess. 9:53 There's lots of ways that could go. 9:55 One of the ways that could go is we see the Bill Clinton... 9:59 you know, Newt Gingrich contract with America, where the White House and Congress recognizes they have to work together to get stuff done. 10:07 And don't forget, that was like the one time the US balanced its budget. 10:10 And Bill Clinton was pretty pragmatic. 10:12 And Trump is certainly no ideologue. 10:14 And so he's sort of capable of pragmatic behavior as well. 10:18 And so you can imagine Trump and the Democrats maybe getting together and Trump cutting a deal to end the war in Ukraine, end the war in Iran, and suddenly you go from shortage to glut, which is coming. 10:30 It's just a matter of time. 10:31 There will be a glut of diesel coming. 10:33 Happy to talk you through why that's inevitable. 10:36 All shortages lead to gluts. 10:37 And so there's a world where at maximum negativity, maximum concern, maximum risk. 10:44 you pull back from the brink and you see all of the dominoes of, of sort of the next bull market begin to fall. 10:50 That's the base case. 10:50 We certainly would be proponents of it. 10:53 We hope it materializes. 10:55 That's the sort of the bull case, sorry, not the base case, but you can see that happening as well. 11:01 Since you mentioned it, yeah, could you take us through the steps? 11:04 Shortages turning into a glut? 11:07 Oh, sure. 11:08 I mean, there's a bit of math here, but since this is a Bitcoin-oriented crowd, 100 million barrels a day of oil. 11:14 That's like the headline number. 11:16 From those 100 million, you produce 28 million barrels of diesel. 11:21 But 21 of those 28 are consumed in the countries in which they're produced. 11:26 And so the real global market for diesel that is driving all the price action we see is actually just 7 million barrels a day of diesel. 11:34 That's what we call the jump ball diesel, the auctionable barrels of diesel that set the price. 11:39 Russia was 800,000 barrels a day of that. 11:42 So 11% of the market went offline. 11:45 The US was 1.3 million barrels of that seven. 11:49 It's raised it to like 1.9, trying to offset that loss of 800. 11:53 You see where the math is going here. 11:55 So you're talking about really small numbers swinging the diesel prices in a wild way. 12:01 Imagine a world where refiners make the investments needed to take that 100 million barrels of oil and produce 30 million barrels of diesel instead of 28. 12:10 And at the same time, Natural gas, powered trucks, and other switching, like you talked about with the organic beef, reduces that jump ball diesel demand from seven to six. 12:21 Well, now you have 9 million barrels of diesel chasing 6 million barrels of demand, and the price of diesel collapses. 12:27 That's how we get from a shortage to a glut. 12:30 They always happen in the commodity world. 12:33 One of the big... 12:35 mistakes that analysts make is they are always tempted to draw tangent lines to sine waves, means regress in the commodity world. 12:42 And just when you think things are going to the moon, the arrival of new demand in the face of demand destruction converts that shortage into a glut. 12:52 And the bigger the shortage is, the larger the glut, because you pull on that rubber band. 12:59 And when you finally let it go, it snaps back with violence. 13:01 And so people like, so if you're a propagandist and you want to minimize the impact of the attack on the Russian refineries, you say Russian exports of diesel are less than 1% of global oil. 13:13 And that is true. 13:15 But it's 11% of jump all diesel. 13:18 And the price of diesel that the farmers are paying in Milwaukee is set by those 7 million barrels because the U.S. participates in the global market. 13:28 OK, thank you. 13:29 We hadn't had anyone give that detail of a breakdown yet, so I wanted to get that in there. 13:33 But I want to ask you about Europe as well, because they're heading into winter short on gas. 13:38 The bond market is feeling it. 13:40 We're watching France's 10-year top 5 percent for the first time since 2002. 13:45 The gap over Germany, the widest since the Eurozone debt crisis. 13:49 So when you look at all of that, how much is Europe's debt problem really an energy problem? 13:55 And how could it spread to U.S. treasuries? 13:59 Yeah, it's a great question. 14:00 So just to give some numbers for people, natural gas in the U.S. today is trading for $3 a million BTU at the Henry Hub. 14:09 That's the rough equivalent of about $18 a barrel oil on an energy content basis. 14:14 That's how cheap natural gas is in the U.S. 14:17 In Europe today, landed liquefied natural gas is at $31 per million BTU, which is the rough equivalent of $180 a barrel oil. 14:28 And that is the fuel that's meant to power home heating, heavy industry, fertilizer plants. 14:33 Those sectors are wildly uncompetitive. 14:36 And then you end up in a position where everybody's paying more for energy. 14:42 People do less stuff. 14:43 The economy contracts. 14:45 And France, unlike the US, can't print euros because it's part of a shared currency. 14:52 And reserves are basically stored future energy. 14:56 You liquidate your reserves to get energy. 14:58 That's sort of our mental model for what your reserves are. 15:02 And so France needs to raise funds to clear the market, to get the energy it needs to power its economy. 15:08 Yeah. 15:11 People are going to take that risk into account and they're going to charge more for it. 15:14 And then next thing you know, you're in a sovereign debt crisis. 15:16 And unlike what France used to do, which is occasionally devalue its currency, it can't do that because it's in a currency marriage with Germany. 15:25 And they don't control the printer. 15:27 And so French debt is selling off because you can't just pay it off the old fashioned way, which is inflated away. 15:35 And and then you mix in the fact that you have immigration riots. 15:41 Call them what you will. 15:42 Our view for that is it's also an energy issue. 15:45 You know, your standard of living is how much energy you get. 15:49 And the more people around and the less energy around lowers that number in aggregate. 15:53 And so the immigration influx into a country goes into the denominator of that equation of energy divided by people. 16:03 More people, less energy means that your standard of living, somebody's standard of living is going down. 16:07 It's just like physics. 16:09 And so you compound error upon error. 16:12 You bungle your energy policy. 16:14 You go to war with your major energy provider. 16:16 You invite a bunch of people into your country. 16:19 And you're in a terrible marriage with Germany with your currency union. 16:24 You have a recipe for a programmed default. 16:27 I don't know how you avoid it at this point. 16:30 Other than the miraculous turnaround that I described, you know, post-midterm election, peace breaks out in the world, kumbaya. 16:39 But to your point, there's extra stress in Europe, right? 16:41 A lot of it driven by social issues, you know, a lot of immigration, a lot of unhappy immigrants as well, taking to the streets and unfortunately burning things. 16:57 When we see this spread between the French bond market and the German bond market, we know the Germans are already still holding a grudge about the whole Italy situation. 17:07 Is Germany going to ultimately have to bail out France? 17:13 And what does the aftermath of all this turmoil look like for Europe? 17:18 Is this going to shake the foundation of the EU moving forward? 17:22 Might we see more moves like Brexit? 17:26 I think so. 17:27 Look, as much as Germany has sort of taken its hands off the debt break, its debt to GDP is in the mid-60s. 17:35 France is over 100. 17:37 I think it's 105 or 110. 17:39 And one of the drivers of that, just as an example of a political hot-button issue that will no doubt saturate the headlines in Europe, I think the... 17:48 average age of a pension, you know, when you could start your pension in Germany is like 67, and in France it's still 62. 17:54 And so if you're a German taxpayer, you're saying to yourself, like, why are we sacrificing, you know, in order to prop up French early retirement? 18:04 And this is what I mean by being in this weird marriage, two wildly different economies that shouldn't share the same currency do. 18:11 And so you have these programmed in sources of friction. 18:16 And so, yeah, you see these populist party movements across Europe. 18:22 We have been saying for many years, you know, Europe has so bungled its energy policy that on the path from starvation, on the path from abundance to starvation is riot, first political action. 18:33 And then physical. 18:33 And in France, they repressed the political riot. 18:37 You know, Macron maneuvered in the elections to keep Marine Le Pen's party out of power. 18:43 So you can't vote your way out of this crisis. 18:45 Well, now they're riding in the streets. 18:47 And this is a very logical progression. 18:48 You don't go from abundance to starvation without some form of protest. 18:53 First political and then now what we're seeing physical. 18:57 And then the end point of that is is sort of even more chaotic, of course. 19:03 Let's go to gold now. 19:04 It's well off its January record highs. 19:07 Bitcoin has given back part of its rally from earlier this month. 19:10 For someone who's saving in hard assets right now, how do gold and Bitcoin compare? 19:15 And is this pullback a buying opportunity for either one? 19:19 Yeah. 19:19 So one of the nuances that we're observing in the market is our U.S. treasuries actually reserves anymore because you're not allowed to sell them. 19:28 There's a lot of pressure from the U.S. being put on its allies in the Middle East, in Europe, Japan. 19:35 Hey, don't sell your treasuries. 19:36 And so if you're staring at a funding crisis, well, what do you do in a crisis? 19:40 You sell what you can sell, not what you want to sell. 19:42 And so gold, which is competing with U.S. treasuries as a... 19:47 Neutral reserve asset for the settlement of imbalances in international trade. 19:51 If you have gold and you have treasuries on your balance sheet and you have Scott Bessent blowing up your phone saying you can't sell your treasuries or you're going to have a visit from an aircraft carrier and you sell your gold, well, in the short term, that's pretty bearish for gold. 20:04 Price action, I noted with interest that the comparison between Bitcoin and gold started on February 28th. 20:10 Well, what happened on February 28th is that's when the U.S. attacked Iran. 20:14 And all of these Arab Gulf states have payroll to meet. 20:22 They have various obligations to service. 20:24 And if they can't sell their treasuries... 20:26 without the permission from Washington, they can sell their gold. 20:29 And so you saw in the early days of the war that gold and war risk were negatively correlated. 20:37 As war risk would increase, gold would go down and vice versa. 20:41 But in the long term, the real message that that tells the prospective buyer of these reserves is that you probably don't want to buy treasuries because you can't sell them when you need them. 20:53 And so in the long term, it's actually wildly bullish for assets like gold and Bitcoin as the message being sent from Washington becomes not only are these treasuries no longer neutral. 21:05 We will sanction you. 21:06 We will seize them. 21:07 We will freeze them. 21:10 But they're not even reserve assets because you can't sell them when you need them. 21:13 And so then the long term attractiveness of gold. 21:18 as a neutral reserve asset for the settlement of imbalances in international trade grows, even as the price action since February 28th would give you sort of the alternative view if you were looking at things in a more short-sighted way. 21:30 So long story short, we save by buying real assets. 21:36 I dollar cost average in my gold every month. 21:38 If it goes up, if it goes down, that's fine. 21:40 If the US dollar system doesn't collapse, I own a lot of gold and I own a lot of US dollar denominated assets, I'm good. 21:46 And if it does collapse, I'm poorer, but I'm not as poor as I would be because at least I own some gold or, in both of your cases, I assume, some Bitcoin. 21:54 That's the way I look at it. 21:56 And where does Bitcoin fit into that kind of directional thesis? 21:58 Obviously, many properties shared with gold, both long-duration, scarce assets. 22:04 But, you know, whereas gold, as you mentioned, maybe could be seized, especially on the sovereign level with folks storing it across the ocean here in the U.S., you know, in an increasingly online agentic economy, where does Bitcoin start to become more attractive comparative to gold as the first allocation of choice? 22:26 Yeah. 22:27 It's a great question. 22:28 I think it's a generational issue above all else. 22:32 And so broadly speaking, older people are more comfortable with tangible things and younger people are more comfortable being hyper online. 22:41 Younger people are far more likely to allow an agent to take over their computer than, you know, a retiree living pension, living on a pension. 22:49 So it goes with Bitcoin and gold. 22:50 I try to explain this to both sides because there is that Bitcoin versus gold debate. 22:55 And we have a lot of, sort of Bitcoin maxi type subscribers because we're pretty fair to Bitcoin for a team that owns gold. 23:04 We're a little older than both of you. 23:07 There's an overlap in the Venn diagram of reasons why you would want to own both assets. 23:11 And I think there's a place for both. 23:14 there is less, let's say, confiscation risk in gold than there is in treasuries today, which is why we're seeing gold behave as a reserve asset should, which is it gets sold during a crisis to raise funds. 23:29 So Bitcoin becomes more valuable over time. 23:31 I think I understand why people own it. 23:35 The big problem with Bitcoin that keeps my generation from going all in is the volatility. 23:42 It's just got a much higher beta. 23:44 It has the sort of the second problem with Bitcoin is its association with crypto. 23:51 And a lot of people get that confused. 23:52 So, you know, you have all of the Trump coin and the rug pulls and the memes and the speculative bubbles and the and and and the sort of the crowd in my cohort that would be looking for nontraditional ways to own a hard asset as a hedge against Bitcoin. 24:11 future crises is going to be shying away from, you know, from the crypto part of the world and sticking with the more familiar. 24:24 And, Doonberg, real quick before you go, the ECB released its rates decision this morning while President Christine Lagarde announced she would be stepping down early in February. 24:34 And a quote from her, her solution to France's bond problem, she said it lies at home in France and has to do with fiscal policies. 24:43 So what was your reaction to the news? 24:45 You think she was realistic there? 24:47 So let me give you our real reaction to that news, which teaches you how we think. 24:52 That is a form of political repression. 24:54 This whole sequencing of her resignation is the European Commission's way to install 25:05 a head of the European Central Bank that will refuse to do the bidding of the populist parties taking over Europe because Lagarde is resigning early and the person replacing her will have a full term and therefore Marine Le Pen, if she becomes president of France, is not going to have influence over who runs the ECB and neither will the alternative for Germany, the AFD, 25:32 If they take over the chancellorship in Germany, they are basically freezing the power using sort of bureaucratic tricks like this. 25:41 And so what she says about the solution to the French fiscal situation is not nearly as relevant to us as, aha, this is Ursula von der Leyen playing her typical tricks, which is – 25:52 In protection of their democracy, they have to act in anti-democratic ways, which tells you that when you look at a phrase like our democracy or their democracy, the emphasis is on their and not democracy. 26:07 Well, Doonberg, it was fantastic talking to you. 26:10 Thanks so much for joining us today. 26:12 Hey, congrats on the show again. 26:13 It was a real blast and good luck.
Community discussion