0:00 But the most important thing for Bitcoin is the global wealth management industry. 0:03 It's $170 trillion, and they didn't really own it. 0:06 And in Europe, they own pretty much none. 0:08 In America, they probably own a bit more than they do in Europe, but I still don't think it's a big number. 0:13 And so, you know, Bitcoin's still got to break down all those barriers, and they've got to, one day it will appeal to wealth management, and then I think we'll get this big structural demand. 0:24 Then I think the whole thing will change, and it'll become a very different asset to what it is today. 0:30 you 0:34 Hello and welcome back to the Bitcoin Magazine podcast. 0:37 I'm your host, Spencer Nichols. 0:38 And today we are sitting down with Charlie Morris, the CEO of ByteTree, who is behind the Bold Index, which blends Bitcoin and gold on a volatility adjusted basis. 0:48 We're going to be talking all things macro, whether that comes to inflation expectations, volatility we've seen in sovereign bonds, and of course, how equities and hard assets have been faring amidst all this. 1:00 So, Charlie, let's get right into it here. 1:03 I think I just want to zoom out a little bit and talk about the macro picture here. 1:06 We've seen a ton of volatility when it comes to things that cause inflation, namely energy. 1:10 It's been a wild ride here. 1:11 Everything going on with the straight-up or moves. 1:14 You know, we had U.S. midterm elections kind of shaking up expectations in terms of energy-driven inflation. 1:21 And, you know, we've also had kind of this expanding volatility in U.S. treasury bonds. 1:27 So, you know, we have the next Fed rate meeting coming up in December. 1:31 The market market is likely likely pricing in a hike right here. 1:35 So from your seat, what are you seeing in terms of the volatility picture? 1:38 I think we've seen some hot CPI readings in the United States, you know, but do you think that that's something that's going to continue to be sticky? 1:46 And how do you rate how the Fed has approached us to date? 1:48 Are they behind the curve, ahead of the curve? 1:51 How are you kind of critiquing what the Fed has been doing in the midst of everything I just mentioned? 1:56 There's a lot to unpack there, but let's go. 1:58 I think the Fed, I mean, it's not my own expertise, you know, Fed policy, but you can tell quite clearly the economy in America has been incredibly strong, much more so than most, you know, Europe. 2:10 Over here, it's not nearly so strong, but we have plenty of inflation to make up for it. 2:14 And so there's been some sort of nominal GDP growth at least. 2:18 And I get the impression that the rate hikes are kind of driven by oil and the oil price is cyclical and there may be an attack. 2:30 There may not be attack. 2:31 Who knows? 2:33 And I get the impression that the bond market really doesn't want too many rate hikes from here. 2:41 We're attacking the old yields. 2:45 There's a lot behind the scenes. 2:47 I mean, is it inflation? 2:48 Well, the break-even rates are not confirming that it is inflation. 2:52 Investors are not buying tips for protection over conventional bonds for some reason. 2:57 So there's a good question. 2:58 Then you look at the commodities landscape, and precious metals being weak, gold, sorry, the oil, the war premiums gone, agriculture. 3:10 again, as he's back in recent months, and the copper trade seems to have rolled. 3:15 So the inflation picture, the bond market picture is complex. 3:20 And on the one hand, you've got the whole, the 10 years about right, given where growth and inflation are. 3:28 On the other hand, you've got the issuance argument. 3:31 You know, have we just got too many bonds coming to market? 3:34 Are deficits structurally too high? 3:40 But the hard evidence is still pretty unclear. 3:45 But what I'd say, you know, bringing it back to Bitcoin, is that Bitcoin really likes a fiery monetary environment and, you know, lots of liquidity and that sort of thing. 3:56 And that's kind of cooling it down a bit right now. 3:58 Understood. 3:59 And I also think that amidst this backdrop of the sovereign bond picture and the inflation picture you just painted, we're at a really interesting point in terms of equity valuations, especially relative to commodities and precious metals. 4:10 We've seen the latter two fall pretty sharply. 4:13 I know you mentioned copper being one of those that's really cooled off here. 4:17 Of course, gold has come off of its highs, silver as well. 4:20 And so what do you make of this setup right here? 4:24 How do you see this equity picture unfolding? 4:26 And I know you've been looking at historical data as it relates to the Shiller PE ratio as something that we should be keeping an eye on as we think about kind of these broader structural changes in the investing environment. 4:37 Yeah, well, I mean, the Shiller PE, it's a great concept, but it's a bit like a stopped clock, you know, when it's right twice a cycle. 4:45 So I don't think you want to do short term trading on the back of that. 4:47 But we know we're in a lofty market. 4:49 I mean, you can't deny it. 4:50 I mean, it's, you know, the Shiller PE is high. 4:53 The levels of speculation in the system are high as measured by margin, concentration in indices. 4:59 And in the last six, seven weeks, we've had this massive rotation within stock markets, you know, out of AI, let's call it, but other things too, into, say, stocks. 5:09 And, you know, we haven't seen... 5:12 the state stocks, safe, it's hard to say safe stocks, isn't it? 5:16 And we haven't seen the safe stocks. 5:19 It's really hard to find them. 5:21 We haven't seen much of a bid in those for the last five years. 5:23 In this, bringing it back to rates, you know, the bond yields have been rising. 5:29 But it's happening now. 5:30 And, you know, the, So we've got a stock market data system called Bytrend, bytrend.io. 5:37 And you can see there on the breadth data that we had a market in 2009-10 where 40% of all stocks were beating the world index. 5:48 And just two months ago, it was down to 8%. 5:51 You know, one of the lowest readings ever recorded, and that's now turning back. 5:55 I mean, people have been saying small caps have been underperforming large caps and all this sort of stuff. 6:00 And all of this in the rotation is highly relevant. 6:04 And, of course, there's an NVIDIA story as well and the data centers. 6:08 And I mean, this is so much going on at the moment. 6:09 It's incredible. 6:11 Yeah. 6:11 And are there any historical analogs you think can help us understand kind of these transformations we're seeing? 6:17 As you mentioned, you know, it's been an incredibly narrow market. 6:19 You've seen, you know, the top end of the equity spectrum being dominated by tech, you know, just massive concentration there in terms of the indexes. 6:28 You know, you mentioned 2008, 2009 as something that you look at. 6:32 You know, are there any other comparable transformations? 6:36 I know people have been looking at, hey, You look at the dot-com bubble and you chart it to the same point in time when ChatGPT launched to the public. 6:45 And Urien Timmer from Fidelity has been kind of banging the table on that. 6:49 In his words, entertainment purposes only, looking at overlaying those charts. 6:53 But is there any point in history that you think rhymes with what we're seeing currently for how we can understand how this might evolve from here? 7:00 Well, 2008 has had something in common because you had an oil shock. 7:05 Although oil shock today would be 200, not 100, given inflation adjustment. 7:11 And that was a financial crisis. 7:13 I don't think the financial crisis that there's always a financial crisis when things go wrong at the end of it. 7:18 But I think that's a primary driver this time. 7:21 You know, private credit markets, again, might might be a bit overcooked. 7:24 But but I don't think that is the big problem. 7:28 It's more of a government problem. 7:30 bond problem than a private sector bond problem. 7:33 But just keeping it to the stock markets, the similarities, the parallels, 1972 and 1999, you know, when you had a big concentration of 50-50 or tech or what have you, depending on the cycle, and then it started to unwind. 7:48 And so I think that's what we're looking at right here, is something akin to 1999. 7:53 But of course, there are loads of earnings this time, which was less the case. 7:58 But still, if you've got very, very high valuations, a lot of stocks can haunt. 8:04 And even more stocks can go down by 90%, which is what happens when the system unwinds. 8:10 So I think it's a precarious time for markets. 8:13 But I don't think it necessarily happens in a short period of time. 8:18 These corrections can be a process and a topping pattern. 8:21 I mean, the World Index or the S&P are not down very much, but the NASDAQ, the SOX, AI, those are, because there are a lot of things that have stepped in. 8:32 So the big consumer staples and stuff, they've got up whilst those things have been coming down. 8:38 So it's a process, I think, that's going to unwind. 8:41 But we should always look to history, because there's one thing that never changes, and that's us, us humans. 8:48 Yeah. 8:49 And as we look at the current market, something I've been keeping an eye on is kind of the spread between the volatility of Bitcoin and the volatility of tech. 8:58 That's compressed to extremely low levels historically. 9:02 I think on the one hand, there's an argument that, you know, Bitcoin had its IPO moment in terms of the birth of the spot Bitcoin ETFs in the United States and kind of the. 9:11 The market has fundamentally changed. 9:12 You know, you'd think as the market matures, Bitcoin becomes less volatile. 9:16 You know, you also look at kind of the mean reversion risk there in terms of Bitcoin volatility is this is an asset unlike anything else. 9:22 You know, absolute scarcity, a novel invention for the market and is also an extremely small asset. 9:27 We saw something like gold, many times larger market cap, move pretty violently up to its all time high. 9:34 And so, you know, as we look at the current state of Bitcoin relative to kind of the other, you know, the investable universe, you know, what are you seeing out there? 9:42 I think the, excuse me, equities is one of the most jarring comparisons. 9:47 But, yeah, we'd love to get your take on just the state of the Bitcoin market right now. 9:51 Sentiment, you know, near FTX lows even right now, despite, you know, we're sitting around $65,000 per coin today. 9:58 Yeah. 9:58 When I start off, I'm still bullish Bitcoin. 10:01 Doesn't mean to say it can't go down in the short term. 10:04 But I think we had the low in February. 10:06 We had that big crash, and we've had the market settling. 10:10 There was a retest, wasn't there? 10:13 But basically, we're still above those levels. 10:15 But it is going down point for point with the NASDAQ. 10:18 Now, why is that really exciting? 10:20 Because it used to go down five points for every one point in the NASDAQ. 10:23 Now it goes down one for one. 10:25 So that's, you know, for anyone who's a sort of long term bull on Bitcoin, that's a sign of his maturing. 10:31 And if you look at the Mag7, for example, you know, Meta and NVIDIA have similar volatility to Bitcoin and only Tesla's higher. 10:40 The other guys, you know, Microsoft and stuff, they are, of course, lower. 10:42 But, you know, the volatility of Bitcoin is a long way from absurd. 10:47 and as it once upon time was. 10:50 So, you know, it's a pretty established asset. 10:52 And even when it declines, it declines much more slowly than it used to do in the old days. 10:56 So that's all a sign of its progress. 11:00 And as we look at Bitcoin right now, I've kind of seen it historically trade in these different regimes. 11:05 You kind of have this high beta to equities regime, you know, going to just go up and down with the NASDAQ. 11:11 You have kind of this correlation to gold regime, which we've kind of seen a move into over the last six months or so. 11:17 We've seen peaks of that. 11:19 And then, you know, folks like BlackRock putting out research saying Bitcoin could move into an uncorrelated regime. 11:24 How do you think about how Bitcoin may trade going forward here? 11:28 I think on the one hand, you know, people are some people are saying, hey, we should try and get a decoupling from equities. 11:33 You know, would be lovely if we saw, you know, AI, the bubble pop and people rush into Bitcoin. 11:38 On the other hand, people are saying, 11:42 These equity indexes higher. 11:44 And that's really a more sustainable long term bull case. 11:46 And of course, there's, you know, the sound money thesis that I think is just a different regime entirely being more correlated to gold. 11:53 You know, what kind of regime do you think we are in now? 11:55 In my estimation, we're kind of caught in between and Bitcoin's trying to decide where it goes. 12:00 You know, what do the tea leaves tell you or what are you seeing in the market that might give us a clue of how to read that? 12:05 Yeah. 12:06 Well, things like the VIX is going up, obviously, in the short term. 12:09 But things like credit spreads have been widening for some time now, particularly in AI-related areas. 12:15 And there's just a lack of liquidity. 12:17 And some people have described Bitcoin as the ultimate expression of liquidity. 12:21 I mean, there's no earnings, there's no CEO. 12:23 So, you know, as a pure liquidity player, it makes a lot of sense. 12:26 And Bitcoin these days is the vast majority of all of crypto. 12:30 I mean, Ethereum has a bit of a hand in there, but basically it's Bitcoin is the whole asset class. 12:35 And it's not a similar way that, you know, gold dominates the commodity sector. 12:39 You know, it's the vast majority of the above ground supply of gold overwhelms everything else. 12:46 And so, you know, those are why I find those two assets so interesting. 12:51 But, you know, why are they both going down? 12:53 Well, For gold, it's really easy. 12:56 You can put your finger on it. 12:57 Real interest rates are going up. 12:58 So the bond yield's going up and the long-term inflation expectations are not going up. 13:04 So real yields are going up and gold hates that. 13:06 But just like in 1972 and 1999, that number is really high. 13:13 We don't actually know what it was in 1972, but we do know what it was in 1999. 13:18 But we can be pretty sure it was high in 1972. 13:21 And the result of that It's when you've got a high number, the presumption is it can only go down. 13:27 So at some point, they're going to have to cut rates because, you know, higher interest rates squeeze the economy and drain liquidity from the system. 13:34 And that's going to be good for gold. 13:36 Now, Bitcoin's a bit different. 13:37 The reason it hasn't got a good correlation with gold, it's only about 9% on average over five years, last time I checked, although it feels it's higher. 13:47 You know, it's one of those things where people think there's a pairing, but there isn't really a pairing at all. 13:52 And Bitcoin just kind of likes a really fiery environment. 13:59 Remember 2021 when GameStop went up? 14:02 It likes that. 14:03 It likes lots of inflation and bond yields higher and the economy banging it out of the park and lots of liquidity in the system. 14:10 That's when Bitcoin does best. 14:13 But, you know, it goes down quite quickly. 14:14 So therefore, you tend to get most of the pain up front. 14:18 And that's why it's always been an indicator of where stock markets are going. 14:22 You know, often you've had big up or down moves in Bitcoin ahead of broad market indices. 14:28 And I think that's something we can't ignore. 14:30 So even people who don't like Bitcoin should take it seriously as a measure of market liquidity. 14:36 And we know the authorities will ultimately have to restore liquidity because if they don't, we're all in trouble. 14:42 Yeah, what I'm trying to figure out is a kind of when does Bitcoin find a sweet spot in terms of, you know, it needs kind of a fiery monetary environment, as you said, I think, you know, when it's, you know, kind of everything is staying neutral. 14:56 Bitcoin just it bores people to death. 14:58 Apathy becomes extremely high. 14:59 But when we do see these fundamental changes and, you know, you see either something break in Bitcoin will rip to the downside. 15:05 But the moment that that problem, that that that liquidity issue, you know, get solved with the injection of liquidity, you see Bitcoin respond in an outsized manner. 15:18 So how would you characterize the current liquidity environment? 15:21 And what are the risks in terms of liquidity contraction? 15:25 But also, where do you see a bright spot in terms of liquidity expansion? 15:29 What would it take for us to get there? 15:30 Would it be some type of blow up in sovereign bonds? 15:35 How do you assess both that upside and downside risk when it comes to Well, the risks market is huge. 15:42 I mean, we could have an oil shock. 15:44 I don't know. 15:44 I don't know what President Trump is going to do next. 15:48 Who knows what he's going to say on Truth Social next? 15:51 Yeah. 15:52 So an oil shock is a scenario. 15:54 An AI crash is another scenario, which is underway. 15:57 But that could stop and reverse. 15:59 But that's got all the ingredients in place to continue because the data center trade just doesn't look long-term profitable. 16:07 Yeah. 16:07 And I think that's a real issue. 16:09 And then we've got the NVIDIA shenanigans as well. 16:13 So there's that whole thing. 16:15 And then there's always the possibility of a slowdown at some point. 16:17 Of course, these are the bear cases. 16:18 I could give you the bull cases. 16:20 And so those are the things that are going to go wrong. 16:23 But all of them kind of lead to a liquidity squeeze one way or another. 16:28 And... 16:31 I bring it back to real rates. 16:33 I mean, if the bond yield, if they lose control of the bond yield, if the bond yield is going up because deficits in my country, your country, France and others are too high and there's just too many bonds in the world, then we've got a real problem. 16:48 Because, you know, you can't solve the liquidity issue by issuing more bonds, which has been the way they've done it pretty much every time in history. 17:00 So they're going to have to get creative. 17:02 But... 17:04 But then the other way you might get liquidity, of course, is to pick up inflation. 17:07 But we're just not seeing that. 17:08 It's just not in the data. 17:09 Tip prices don't support that thesis right now, which is curious because, you know, when you look at the ingredients in place, such as, you know, tariffs, wars, supply chain disruptions and onshoring and less globalization, you know, you'd expect those things to be inflationary. 17:27 War is inflationary and we're not seeing the market really price that in. 17:32 Yeah. 17:34 Absolutely. 17:35 Yeah. 17:36 And I think also I look at kind of the correlation between sovereign bond yields. 17:41 I think we've kind of seen them all go up across the board at the same time during this recent rise in bond yields. 17:48 And to me, that kind of... 17:49 makes me think that it's the market saying, hey, you know, debt loads are too high. 17:54 Fiscal spending, deficit spending is, you know, there's no end in sight to that. 17:59 And to me, it felt like, OK, the bond vigilantes needed to step in and say, you know, this isn't necessarily an inflation problem. 18:06 This is a debt and spending problem. 18:08 Would you agree with that take right now, given what you just mentioned in terms of how the market is viewing inflation? 18:14 Yeah, well, if you're in doubt about economics or household spending, then the hard way is usually the right way. 18:22 And the easy way is normally the wrong way. 18:24 And I just look at the difference between the UK and Switzerland over the last 25 years. 18:30 The Swiss have balanced their budget most years, you know, the last 25 years. 18:36 And the result is they've got very low debt GDP. 18:40 They have a fabulous economy and people, Swiss people seem to be pretty happy. 18:46 What if they're unhappy? 18:47 It's not because they haven't got a good job and a good income. 18:50 And, you know, in the UK, they haven't balanced the budget since 2001, about the same time as the US as well, I think. 18:59 And even then, it was a bit of a coincidence because of the 3G license sales. 19:02 And before that was, you know, there was some good management in the 90s. 19:05 But years and years of deficits add up and you end up with a... 19:11 debt-to-GDP ratio that's very, very high. 19:14 And the thesis at the moment is, if you have your deficit, something like 4, 3, 4, 5, the nominal GDP grows faster, then technically your debt-to-GDP is shrinking. 19:26 But it's not very convincing because then the next time you really need help, whether you get an 08 or a pandemic situation where you suddenly need vast amounts of money, how's the market going to bear it next time? 19:39 And so that's the real issue. 19:41 If we get a proper crisis, then what is the government mechanism? 19:46 And under those scenarios, do people look to alternative assets? 19:51 And I think long term, of course they do, but short term, markets would have a serious liquidity problem. 19:57 In terms of what kind of crises that could foment, I mean, something that we've been covering a lot on Bitcoin Magazine is, you know, the French OATs and kind of the spread between French bond yields and German bond yields. 20:10 And, you know, we've seen that spread blow out pretty aggressively and, you know, a pretty sizable move in French tenure government bonds. 20:18 You know, that seems like... 20:21 I haven't really seen too many kind of bodies being carried out in terms of how that trade unfolded. 20:27 Do you think that there is systemic risk when it comes to what we've seen in terms of French bond yields? 20:32 And I also note UK gilts, we've seen yields rise pretty aggressively there year to date. 20:38 What is your kind of assessment of risk when it comes to particularly European sovereign bonds at the moment? 20:44 Yeah. 20:45 Yeah, so UK and Europe, they are completely different because the UK has its own currency. 20:52 And so I'm not suggesting that the public finances here are good. 20:55 They're not. 20:56 But at least we have our own currency, and that debt is issued in our own currency. 21:01 And so there are more mechanisms to get out of jail free in the UK than there are in France. 21:08 Now, France is kind of... 21:10 It was always described to me by Otmar Ising, who invented the euro. 21:14 He said France is the average country in Europe in the sense that it reflects the euro. 21:19 So when you think of the euro, don't think of it as a Deutschmark or a Grimm-Dachmark. 21:24 It's a French franc. 21:26 And that's a very good way to think about it, some sort of average. 21:30 Now, French debt to UGP is huge. 21:32 And... 21:33 out of control, their debt is out of control. 21:36 And they have a lot of benefits and they all go to the old people. 21:39 The old people need to increase their retirement age. 21:44 The young are upset with the old. 21:46 And it's a real problem. 21:47 They've got an issue there. 21:49 And, of course, they don't issue their own debt. 21:51 They issue debt in euros, which aren't French francs. 21:57 And, of course, the euro is the same in Germany as it is in Greece. 22:01 And so you've got this very different situation. 22:04 And, you know, for the European monetary system to work, they need to adopt the US mechanism where a state is a country. 22:11 You know, Portugal is number 12 or something, and France is number two or whatever, and they centrally issue debt. 22:18 But they haven't done that. 22:20 And so there will always be a problem. 22:22 And then you've got these target two balances where they're sort of a bit like a credit card between one country and another. 22:27 And those balances are pretty extreme. 22:29 They're a trillion now. 22:32 But there again, you know, NVIDIA lost a trillion in a few weeks. 22:35 So what's a trillion these days, maybe? 22:37 But, you know, these used to be big numbers. 22:40 And so maybe they can just keep on printing their way out of it. 22:44 But, yeah, France absolutely has the potential to be a real problem. 22:49 But I don't think we have to single them out. 22:51 I just think the entire bond market globally is just... 22:55 One just worries that it's just so large compared to the size of the economy as we've just financialized ever more. 23:01 The market cap of all the debt and all the equity added together compared to GDP is just off the scale globally. 23:08 And so, you know, one does wonder whether financialization can go too far back to alternative assets. 23:15 Yeah. 23:15 And to zoom in on that, I think China has kind of had this explicit strategy of accumulating gold, something like 22, 23 months consecutively of its central bank purchasing gold, the PBOC. 23:26 And, you know, they brought in tons and tons. 23:28 And it's, I think, one of the interesting ways that as Bitcoiners, we think about how can nation states kind of create credit worthiness or protect credit worthiness by building the asset side of the balance sheet in something that, you know, there's a relative degree of certainty as to 23:44 if that will be protected from, you know, the ravages of inflation as these these countries monetize their debt. 23:50 So I think, you know, Bitcoin and gold, two very different parts of the spectrum right now. 23:54 Bitcoin, maybe you haven't checked lately, one point three trillion dollar market cap. 23:58 Gold, twenty eight trillion, give or take, you know, haven't checked lately. 24:02 Yeah. 24:04 And so clearly, you know, there's been this sovereign strategy of gold accumulation. 24:07 You know, Bitcoin, you know, we always hear, you know, the nation states are coming, the nation states are coming. 24:12 They've yet to really arrive at any size. 24:13 We've seen, you know, sovereign wealth funds out of the UAE accumulating IBIT, you know, murmurings of, you know, Bhutan mining Bitcoin, the UAE investing heavily in that. 24:22 But, you know, for all intents and purposes, nothing has shown up yet. 24:27 And so as we kind of move into this kind of restructuring of the debt, Ray Dalio calls it, you know, the long term debt cycle, you know, how do we kind of recapitalize the financial system? 24:37 I look at Bitcoin and gold as kind of the two interesting assets to consider. 24:42 And so I know your firm combines these two assets into the ETP it offers. 24:46 And so I guess just on the macro point, how would you describe kind of that sovereign appetite for gold right now? 24:55 And will Bitcoin ever get there? 24:57 It's a really good question. 24:58 I mean, the sovereign appetite for gold is insatiable. 25:01 And they want more and more. 25:03 And as you say, it shines back in. 25:05 I think the Q3 numbers from the World Gold Council were really strong. 25:10 And they report those numbers in tons. 25:13 Now, put them into dollars. 25:14 Now, I know the gold price is off a bit, but we've got more tons at a higher gold price than when they reported those numbers a couple of years ago. 25:23 They really are chucking money at the gold market and wanting to accumulate. 25:27 And global gold reserves are, I don't know, 27% or something. 25:33 But in the 70s, they were 70%. 25:35 So you can see the precedent. 25:36 There are a lot of countries that are trying to get there. 25:39 Now, European countries, not so much because they're complacent. 25:42 They think the world's fine. 25:44 But the developing countries are taking this stuff much more seriously. 25:48 Bitcoin. 25:51 Its issue here is that it hasn't got a tradition in central bank circles. 25:56 So they don't sort of look at it as a credible asset. 25:59 Now, they know what it is. 26:01 They talk about it. 26:02 They're not stupid. 26:04 But they haven't gone over the line yet. 26:07 One or two small countries probably. 26:08 But, you know, El Salvador and stuff. 26:12 But the big guys, I mean, it's just not even on the agenda yet. 26:15 Yeah. 26:16 And I think that that's the big difference, really, in the sort of between Bitcoin and gold is that gold's got this massive, well, it's got two value buyers, really. 26:26 It's got the central banks and it's got the, you know, the whole jewelry and bar and coin market in the physical demand. 26:35 And so when the price of gold goes down, there are some people, you know, punching the air going, great, I can buy more gold, particularly the jewelers and China and so on. 26:44 But when Bitcoin price goes down, less so. 26:46 You know, there's less people, fewer people jumping up and down. 26:49 I mean, I know some, you know, hard people who like the sort of pain of the Bitcoin dip are there, but they're just not in the same quantum as we have with central banks and global jewelry markets. 27:06 I mean, these are big numbers. 27:37 Yeah, I mean, I think gold just has so many more price agnostic buyers and price agnostic buyers with an outrageous amount of capital. 27:44 I mean, central banks, you know, they can they can buy a lot of gold. 27:48 That's that's for dang sure. 27:49 So with that in mind, like how do you think about kind of the investment thesis behind Bitcoin versus gold? 27:55 Call it. 27:55 you know, I would like to say like over the next five years or so, I'd be happy to zoom out a little bit more there. 28:00 I know your ETP kind of has a balancing mechanism when it looks at Bitcoin and gold together and weights it according to the volatility of each. 28:10 So I guess, you know, when we look at these assets over the medium term, so to speak, you know, what is the investment thesis look like right now? 28:19 It seems like Bitcoin and gold really just are in two different universes right now. 28:22 So, you know, why combine them in the first place? 28:25 Yeah. 28:25 Well, I combined them because I'd been following Bitcoin from 2013 and gold from 1999. 28:32 And I used to write about them. 28:34 And it actually took me five years of writing about them before I even thought about putting them together. 28:39 I mean, so, you know, it wasn't even obvious to me. 28:41 And I was intricately involved in a sense. 28:45 And the reason that it became obvious, because my early view on Bitcoin was, you know, just like Bitcoin. 28:51 AOL and all that, it would be superseded. 28:54 And so you're sort of looking for new coins that were going to be more real than the original one. 29:00 And so I was on the wrong side of that to some extent. 29:04 Not that I didn't take Bitcoin seriously. 29:05 I did, but I was more concerned about something else surpassing it. 29:11 And that was never true with gold. 29:13 It was obviously already fully established. 29:16 But then, after a while, we realized that Bitcoin was always gonna be number one. 29:21 And I recognized that they had low correlation. 29:24 And the reason for the low correlation was partly what I described to you. 29:27 They've got a different source of buyer. 29:30 But really it's the fact that gold is a kind of risk off inflationary hedge and Bitcoin's a sort of risk on inflationary hedge. 29:40 And you see that through the stock market correlation. 29:44 And so the beauty of a Bitcoin and gold pairing is that you actually get some diversification. 29:49 And of course, these are the two most liquid alternative assets in the world. 29:54 And that's a really important point. 29:56 Oil is a big asset, but you can't physically store it. 29:59 You know, like a security. 30:02 I mean, you know, Bitcoin and gold are very simple. 30:04 One of them you can put in the garden and the other one you just... 30:08 put it in a wallet or whatever. 30:10 And so they're very simple and hugely liquid assets. 30:16 And that's why I think they're so exciting. 30:18 So when people talk about investing alternative assets, they start making up all this stuff like private equity. 30:23 And private equity is just equity. 30:25 And hedge funds, most of them failed in 2008, and a few of them delivered what they said they would. 30:32 And Bitcoin and gold are just always going to be there. 30:35 And they're always going to appreciate slowly over time with whatever cyclicality we have to face. 30:41 And so, you know, when I came to building a strategy, the important point was the fact they had low correlation. 30:46 If they had high correlation, I would not have bothered because there would have been no benefit to holding them together. 30:53 But because they have low correlation and you rebalance the strategy every month. 30:58 then you're effectively selling the one that's done well a little bit, and then buying the one that's done badly. 31:04 And all rebalancing strategies, if you embrace low correlation assets, then they add value. 31:09 And the bold index, what's been happening over the last 1, 5, 10 years of the bold index is that the annual return is, roughly speaking, 10% ahead of the average of Bitcoin and gold, which is crazy. 31:20 Wow. 31:22 And so the 30%, so basically turnover is 30% a year. 31:26 And so five years, 150% turnover. 31:28 That's all your gold and Bitcoin turnover one and a half times. 31:31 Leads to an outcome that's 55%, 50%, 55%, 60% ahead of the average price. 31:38 And the other thing is, you know, someone like me who's so lazy that I can't be bothered to even think about which one's going to be better over the next five years, Bitcoin or gold. 31:47 I just don't both. 31:48 And if I have a mechanism that's going to have a good outcome, then that makes a lot of sense. 31:53 And then the final point about bold is the risk. 31:55 You know, it's probably the most important point about bold is you've got Bitcoin volatility in the mid thirties, gold in the mid twenties. 32:03 Gold should be in the teens, but it's gone up in the last year. 32:07 And if you do inverse volatility weighting, you end up with, roughly speaking, 43% Bitcoin and 57% gold. 32:16 So that means that if you put $50 into each asset, you've got more risk in Bitcoin than you have in gold. 32:21 If you put 57% into gold and 43% into Bitcoin, you've got about the same risk in each one. 32:26 Now, two years ago, when Bitcoin volatility was higher, that was more like 80-20 or 75-25%. 32:33 But they're coming towards Kari Pasu, which is a funny odd thing. 32:39 So as to the volatility is conferred. 32:42 But the bottom line is the bold index has volatility for all of this year below the level of gold. 32:48 Yeah, it's not just it's not between Bitcoin and gold. 32:51 It's below the level of gold and there's an excess return. 32:55 So if you've got less risk and more return, then you have a good sharp ratio, which is You know, a pretty important thing because that did it as compounding, right? 33:04 Lower drawdowns and then you get the compounding. 33:07 So I think bold is a really interesting concept. 33:10 Shame we haven't got it in America, mainly because the tax rules don't allow you to do with futures synthetically, which I don't think it's โ we want to do it properly. 33:21 If you're going to do it, you do it properly. 33:22 And so we've got real gold and real Bitcoin with us, but the tax rules are unfriendly to an ETF structure than with Bitcoin and gold. 33:32 But it's a powerful combination, and it's a hugely liquid alternative asset. 33:37 So that's why we created it. 33:39 When we look at kind of the fair value of Bitcoin or gold, I mean, there's, you know, you can skin a cat 10 ways to Tuesday. 33:46 There's just so many ways you could value this. 33:47 I think a lot of people like to point at, you know, Bitcoin's ratio to M2. 33:52 And they say, OK, well, given that in Bitcoin's historical movement with M2, we would say, you know, a fair value of Bitcoin is $1. 33:59 I can't recall. 34:00 I think Andre Dragoch said somewhere around $212,000 per coin. 34:04 Andre, if you're listening, forgive me if I butchered that. 34:07 I think it's directionally correct, though. 34:09 But I bring that up to ask, how do you think about both valuation frameworks for gold and Bitcoin and really where they sit relative today, their spot price relative to how you model these assets out versus where you think they should be trading? 34:25 Do you have any thoughts or models that you'd like to look at? 34:27 Over the years, I've had so many, and I've still got loads, but I don't use them. 34:31 I've thrown them all in the bin. 34:33 I've given up, finally. 34:35 Stopped trying to value Bitcoin and gold. 34:37 I don't think it's possible or reliable. 34:39 I had a tips model, which I followed closely for years, basically modeling gold around 20-year tips, and that worked really well until 2022. 34:47 Thankfully, when I decided to let that model go, I went with gold, not with tips. 34:53 Otherwise, that would have been an expensive mistake. 34:55 I did have a blockchain-based data set, which was pretty good at valuing gold, but that's kind of lost its edge from about 2021 onwards. 35:05 And pre then, it was fantastic. 35:08 I mean, in 2015, 16, 17, 18, it was unbelievable. 35:12 And the price would very closely follow that. 35:14 But that's torn up. 35:16 It's because Bitcoin has sort of gone beyond that. 35:18 And what happens on chain doesn't necessarily value Bitcoin anymore in the way that it once did when it was going through this J-curve, if you know what I mean. 35:28 And so that's changed. 35:28 It has become a macro asset. 35:30 And that's good. 35:33 That in itself is exciting. 35:35 But the most important thing for Bitcoin... 35:38 is the global wealth management industry. 35:41 It's $170 trillion and they didn't really own it. 35:44 And in Europe, they own pretty much none. 35:46 In America, they probably own a bit more than they do in Europe, but I still don't think it's a big number. 35:51 I think your average wealth manager in the States is not allocating to Bitcoin. 35:56 And large parts of the world, it's not even legal or you can't even trade it or buy the ETF. 36:03 I mean, you can't buy it in India or China or, 36:06 uh japan i mean these are big big populations big countries where you can't touch it um and so you know bitcoin still got to uh break down all those barriers and they've got a one day it will appeal to wealth management and then i think we'll get this uh big structural demand then i think the whole thing will change and it'll become a very different asset to what it what it is today but they're still not here 36:30 And so that structural demand, you're saying like kind of the wealth management industry would be kind of one of the prime targets to enter the Bitcoin market as a net new participant? 36:39 Yeah, I think they're easier to pull them in than central banks. 36:42 Yeah, I would agree with that. 36:44 Yeah, we look at I think, you know, Christine Lagarde probably would be a tough nut to crack, although she's stepping out. 36:49 So, you know, maybe there's a little bit of headway available there. 36:55 But, Charlie, I appreciate you taking the time to walk us through your thoughts on macro Bitcoin and gold today. 37:01 And for folks who want to learn more about the work you're doing in your work at ByteTree, you know, where can they find more and where can they find your research? 37:08 So bytree.com, that's by B-Y-T-E. And as in computer byte, not teeth byte. 37:16 So bytree.com. 37:18 But then our new project is even more exciting. 37:20 It's called bytree.io. 37:22 And that's something people should have a look at. 37:24 Excellent. 37:24 Well, I encourage everyone to go check that out. 37:26 Charlie, it was great speaking with you today. 37:28 Thank you for taking the time. 37:29 Everyone, Charlie Morris, CEO of Bytree. 37:32 Thank you. 37:33 Thank you.
Community discussion