0:00 Good morning, happy Thursday, and welcome into BMTV. 0:02 I'm Grace Armington with Sean Hagen. 0:04 While the biggest IPO in history makes its Wall Street debut today, the Ant goes marching on as Anthropic hits the trading floor. 0:11 Yeah, it'll be an action-packed day to see what happens, and I'm really interested to see over the next couple of weeks how the broader markets might be impacted by this. 0:19 Joining us on today's show, we got Alexander Taske, founder and CEO of Frame. 0:24 Katie Stockton, founder and managing partner of Fairlead Strategies. 0:28 David Lawant, head of research at Anchorage Digital. 0:31 And Darius Dale, founder and CEO of 42 Macro. 0:35 But let's double tap on that biggest news of the day and go live to the trading floor here as Dario Amode rings the bell. 0:42 Anthropic now trading on the NASDAQ under the ticker ANT or ETH. 0:46 Ant. 0:47 Anthropic pricing its shares at $83 a piece above its original range, raising more than $81 billion, surpassing the $75 billion record set by SpaceX just five months ago. 0:59 SpaceX still holds the record, of course, for highest valuation at the time of an IPO at $1.77 trillion. 1:07 Anthropic valued at $1.5 trillion after its IPO today. 1:11 And this, of course, comes as the broader AI trade has been under pressure with investors increasingly questioning the cost of the industry's massive buildout. 1:20 So, Sean, we've spent months here talking about how Bitcoin and tech stocks have been trading together. 1:26 Now we have one of the biggest capital-raising events in market history. 1:29 Do you think Anthropics IPO put additional pressure on other risk assets, or could a successful debut here actually help restore confidence across the market? 1:39 Yeah, look, I think that it's it's anybody's game. 1:43 You have very smart people on both sides of this coin. 1:45 I think if Anthropic just rips here and it goes up, I think it's game on. 1:49 The music just got louder and nobody needs to hunt for their chair yet. 1:54 But, you know, we saw Jensen out at Nvidia. 1:58 He was sort of the chief financier behind a lot of this industry's build out. 2:03 I know Anthropic is wanting to step in and take advantage of moments like that and try to cannibalize as much as they can. 2:08 We compared them to Amazon in yesterday's show where, you know, they're going to need to start expanding into other business verticals and try to become this sort of monopoly, for lack of a better term, to continue to grow and survive, especially in a world where compute is becoming more local and more decentralized. 2:26 So it's going to be really interesting to see. 2:33 little bit here. 2:33 So fingers crossed they do well for the sake of other equities, certainly. 2:39 But we'll really see. 2:40 I don't think this is one of those that can be judged over just a week's price action, for example. 2:44 I mean, no company can. 2:46 It'll probably follow just a typical IPO. 2:49 Initial release, pump, recovery might take a little while to initially kind of churn back through to its initial list price. 2:55 But who knows? 2:57 And I think that you have other people watching like open AI who are weighing their prospects of going public as well. 3:07 So it'll be really interesting if this goes well to see how quickly then open AI might want to then bring their offering to market as well. 3:14 All right, Anthropic, the biggest news of the day. 3:16 But let's take a look at what else is happening in markets with today's headlines. 3:20 Russia's central bank plans to let everyday investors who received access to Bitcoin this week trade crypto on margin, capping those trades with a broker at 300,000 rubles. 3:30 The rule could be finalized by year end as the Moscow Exchange prepares to launch crypto trading by December 1st. 3:38 A federal task force hub co-led by the Department of Homeland Security and Justice launched a threat disruption center built on crypto tracing firm TRM Labs platform to target scam networks laundering money through crypto and banks. 3:51 Partner companies will share intel to pause victim payments after Americans reported 20.9 billion dollars in cybercrime losses last year. 4:01 Swiss crypto bank Signum estimates Bitcoin could hit a new high near $128,000 if just 0.75% of the Nasdaq's value rotated into crypto. 4:13 Its 2027 outlook also calls this Bitcoin's shallowest bear market yet a drop of around 54% versus falls of more than 70% in past cycles. 4:26 JP Morgan expects the Fed to raise rates three more times in December, January and March, lifting its benchmark rate to 4.5 to 4.75 percent. 4:36 The bank says those hikes would aim to protect the Fed's inflation fighting credibility as it sees U.S. growth slowing to 1.9 percent next year and AI spending cooling. 4:48 Deutsche Bank now expects the U.S. dollar to strengthen into the first half of 2027, with only modest weakness later in the year. 4:56 Global head of FX research George Saravellos says the AI boom is drawing huge inflows into U.S. stocks and fueling expectations of more Fed rate hikes. 5:09 IMF Managing Director Kristalina Joravija says energy and AI shocks are pushing global inflation to 4.7 percent this year, seeing bond yields in many advanced economies to their highest in decades. 5:24 At the APEC Summit in China, she warned global public debt will soon top 100 percent of the GDP, its highest since World War II. 5:33 And with that, let's take a look at how the markets are trading this morning. 5:38 Bitcoin still under 64K, though it is up 1.4% on the day. 5:47 Let's take a look at equities. 5:48 They saw a boost this morning after Anthropic officially was listed on the NASDAQ, the NASDAQ up about 1% today. 6:00 The S&P 500 caught about 2% here. 6:04 And taking a look at the big board, NVIDIA was one of the winners in this one. 6:10 Google, Micron were others. 6:12 Taking a look at Treasuries now, the 10-year yield falling just a couple basis points. 6:17 It's down to 508 on the morning. 6:20 Over in commodities, gold down 1.6%, trading around $3,700 an ounce. 6:27 And in oil, WTI crude up 1.8% on the day, almost at $84 a barrel, while Brent is at $91 a barrel. 6:37 Sean, real quick thoughts before we move on to our guest here. 6:39 Yeah, look, energy going up just slightly. 6:42 Still, macro trend is going down. 6:43 You look at crack spreads, right? 6:45 I think tomorrow's show, we really ought to get into the crack spreads. 6:48 That's what's really driving energy costs. 6:51 Recently, if you look at the inflation data with things like diesel, and it is falling absolutely off a cliff, which is really good news for the Fed. 6:56 All right. 6:57 With banks and card networks racing into stablecoins as the Genius Act nears, where does Bitcoin fit into the future of payments? 7:04 Joining us now is Alexander Taske, founder and CEO of Frame, a stablecoin and payments infrastructure company. 7:10 Good morning, Alex. 7:12 Good morning. 7:12 How are you? 7:13 Doing great. 7:14 Thanks for joining us. 7:15 So Visa just expanded its stablecoin payout service into Asia, one of several big bank and card network stablecoin moves this week. 7:24 What is really driving the rush, you think, into stablecoins and digital finance right now? 7:28 And where do you see Bitcoin playing a role? 7:31 Yeah, so I think stablecoins can support transfers really outside the traditional banking hours and more institutions are really evaluating them as a digital payment and settlement tool. 7:42 The clear rules and new entrants have really added momentum, but issuing a token is only part of the job. 7:49 Businesses still need the reliable access to payment rails, clear controls, and a way to reconcile what happened. 7:56 The real practical question is how stablecoins fit alongside bank money and existing payment systems. 8:01 I think that's mainly the key theme that we're seeing. 8:06 And Frame being a financial infrastructure company really solving interoperability, which essentially connecting the traditional and digital finance thing, we're seeing everything in between. 8:18 And it's really the policies and rules that govern how those different forms of rails, because we really see no winner, but we see more emergence and stablecoin from the cross-border element. 8:33 And Alexander, you know, there's a lot of friction in the current system, especially when it comes to passing funds through, you know, intermediary or middleman banks when it comes to cross-border payments or things like this. 8:46 I know that, you know, the World Bank Group is now doing some tests with Citi and Circle to see whether USDC can speed up funds exactly through pathways like that. 8:57 You know, is that really sort of the main driver or main thing that's trying to be solved here? 9:03 And, you know, what other areas of friction do you think maybe are of equal concern? 9:10 Yeah, well, I think cross-border payments can pass through multiple banks and systems and cutoff times and compliance checks, making timing and fees really and payment status really difficult to see. 9:23 When you come to a stablecoin transfer, you can move on chain at any time. 9:28 But the full payment really still depends on liquidity, compliance, the FX conversion and the local payout and the redemption. 9:36 So it's not as seamless as really people may see it at first glance. 9:41 But really, the faster transfer helps, but it's not a complete end-to-end fix. 9:46 Institutions still need the infrastructure that connects the rails and really applies that policy of settlement and provides a verifiable record of the outcome. 9:56 And I think that's something that you're seeing that's very interesting with maybe agents. 10:00 Agents are needing that cryptographic proof of actually making these payments depending on the rail. 10:06 So that's another emergence that we're seeing as well. 10:10 And even with banks and card networks building on stable coins, we've seen the supply of stable coins shrink by about 16 and a half billion dollars just over the past month. 10:20 How much of stable coin demand is still tied to Bitcoin and crypto trading or are everyday payments that demand starting to take over? 10:31 Yeah, well, there are different forms of value. 10:34 You know, when you talk about stable coins or tokenized deposits, it's a different. 10:40 Bitcoin is an asset more than a transfer of money. 10:44 Like a tokenized deposit really represents a bank deposit, but it's on blockchain. 10:49 And a stablecoin is issued under, you know, the issuer's own backing and redemption agreements. 10:55 Bitcoin is that separate digital asset, but it's not a bank deposit, nor is it a dollar-pegged instrument. 11:03 So institutions may need to work across all of them. 11:06 The infrastructure challenge is really connecting the systems while preserving each institutional controls and not declaring really one form of money as the winner. 11:17 And when they're using these stable coins to connect to banks and try to decrease the friction on these payments, what chain are they using, right? 11:25 Is one blockchain going to ultimately be the solution to be moving these stable coins or how are banks thinking about that? 11:32 Yeah, well, that's the challenge that we're seeing. 11:35 We met with about 150 banks probably in the last eight months, and they're trying to determine which rail blockchain is going to win. 11:44 Is it Solana? 11:45 Is it Ethereum? 11:46 Is it Linear? 11:47 Is it Avalanche? 11:48 There's certain preferences or certain kind of roadmap that they're going down, but I think you need to be agnostic. 11:55 Our CTO, Lloyd Moore, coming from Blockteam, and he really took this in as a thesis. 12:00 He looked through 62 protocols and really took the primitives and the utilitarian features out of blockchain, which has really meant what it's for. 12:12 So in short, there is no winner there. 12:15 There's preferences and integrations per one, but you need that universal plug into all of them, really. 12:22 Yeah. 12:24 Earlier this week, Fed Governor Christopher Waller said a key question is how money can move safely between stable coins, tokenized deposits and traditional bank rails. 12:34 He also said trust in payments is hard to win, easy to lose. 12:37 So at what point will this technology earn banks trust at scale? 12:46 That's a great question. 12:48 I think it comes down to trusting cryptography for what it's used for. 12:54 And to the last point of the utilitarian function, it's mathematics and the highest guarantee of payment. 13:02 So I think, you know, there needs to be a, not a trusted universal ledger, but the banks need to essentially integrate a rules and policy engine according to the rail. 13:16 So a lot of the banks, they do have rules in place for their AML, KYC, amounts, jurisdictions, et cetera. 13:24 And I think that's the piece that needs to be cryptographically proven when it comes to these new rails. 13:30 You don't want to release a settlement if it hasn't gone through that. 13:33 And I think that is the source of truth that really needs to be established is that, you private ledger on the bank that each bank trusts one another. 13:44 Right now, it's really weighed on trusting Swift, which has been around since the 70s and a natural thing. 13:51 But when you come to cryptography and blockchain, I think that's something that institutions are going to learn to trust with not only their head of architecture, their compliance, the regulators. 14:04 We're finding 14:09 I think that's what will start to continue the momentum around the trust element. 14:15 And they don't have too much time, in theory, left before there's a massive demand that's going to be coming to market January 18th and the Genius Act takes effect. 14:25 So, you know, are banks and institutions, you think, close to kind of buttoning all of this up? 14:32 Or do you think that we might be a little bit over our skis to expect this sort of instant rollout once Genius takes effect on the 18th? 14:41 Yeah, I think the Genius Act really sets the requirements for the permitted stablecoin issuers, including the ones that essentially $1 is submitted, the reserves, each dollar is issued along with the public disclosure of the redemption. 14:56 So that certainly helps getting that in a live format and having a proof of reserves on an ongoing basis is super important. 15:04 But for institutions, that makes the issuer status, the reserve quality and reporting, and the actual redemption process important in the diligence questions. 15:15 So, you know, a frame doesn't really issue or custody stable clients. 15:22 So those regulated functions really sit with licensed providers. 15:26 So very, very specific legal status or compliance and you know, check its disclosures and consult qualified counsel to really review that. 15:34 But I think that the Genius Act is really paving the way. 15:36 And we'll see what happens with the Clarity Act as well. 15:40 Looking at Tether here, the S&P Global kept Tether's USDT at its lowest grade, citing riskier backing like gold stocks and Bitcoin. 15:51 So once the Genius Act takes effect, how much will backing decide which stablecoins banks and businesses use? 16:00 That's a good question. 16:01 I think when it comes to Tether, obviously from historical, they've been unorthodox, but I think one of their plans is to be more institutionally focused. 16:15 And what's better than an audible blockchain ledger, not only on the cash leg piece, but on the way that they operate? 16:27 And I think And that really will help them get into the point where they can be worldwide and get more market share. 16:36 But essentially, I would say generally, they have to work on working with the regulators with the proof of their infrastructure so that they can institutionalize across the board. 16:51 And Alexander, you know, as Bitcoiners, we focus a lot on lightning payments and Bitcoin as currency. 16:59 But it seems like stable coins have really come in and cannibalized that market for payments and medium of exchange. 17:06 Do you see this as being sort of like the runaway winner? 17:09 Do you think Bitcoin will ever come around and compete with stable coins for payments in the future? 17:16 I think it's just a different way of thinking about money. 17:20 When you think about Bitcoin as an asset class or a value transfer, when you go to pay something, there's a lot of volatility. 17:28 Stablecoin is backed by a currency, so certainly there's not a lot of volatility. 17:33 I frankly don't think there's a winner here. 17:35 I've been in payment infrastructure for the last 20 years, and I think every form of payment has its use. 17:43 So whether it's a cash element or an RTP out of the US or a wire internationally, then I think the wire international kind of plays a role with the stablecoin piece. 17:54 And you'll see erosion of swift international payments in comparison to stablecoin. 18:00 So I think there's a balancing effect that happens there amongst all the rails, but truly there is no winner. 18:07 Alexander Taske, founder and CEO of Frame. 18:09 It was really great talking to you. 18:10 Thanks for joining us. 18:12 Thanks so much for having me. 18:14 While Anthropic has finally gone public, let's take a look at another AI giant that's been in the spotlight lately, and that's NVIDIA. 18:22 The firm released its Q3 earnings after the closing bell on Tuesday, the company's first report since its CEO change, with CFO Colette Crest now serving as interim CEO. 18:32 Most quarters, NVIDIA reports earnings and files its 10Q the same day, like clockwork. 18:38 But not this time. 18:39 On its Tuesday earnings call, NVIDIA reps said they plan to file the 10Q in the coming weeks. 18:45 No reason was given for why. 18:47 NVIDIA has until December 4th to file, but it's the first time the firm has missed a deadline since 2024. 18:54 On a private call after earnings, Timothy Arquery, the lead semiconductor analyst at USB, asked NVIDIA about the delay. 19:02 He says management told him it was related to the ongoing investigation and whether any additional risk factors would be needed, would need to be added to the filing. 19:13 that quote, according to TechCrunch. 19:15 Now, Edward Dowd, previously co-manager of large cap strategy for BlackRock, shared his take on NVIDIA's departure from routine on the 10Q filing, calling it a red flag. 19:25 Dowd says typically in post earnings calls, large investors get opportunities to ask tougher questions than sell side on how large investors received NVIDIA's responses. 19:35 He says the following. 19:36 They don't believe the future guidance is real. 19:39 The bottom line, the market is worried that the former CFO and board are in CYA mode on the China question. 19:46 He goes on to add speculation is that they will open the kimono on China numbers after an investigation and pretend they didn't know. 19:54 So strong words from Dowd there. 19:56 Sean, do you agree with what he's saying? 19:58 Does the 10Q delay worry you at all? 20:00 Well, there's a lot of complexity and a lot of tea leaf reading, right? 20:02 I mean, the NVIDIA situation is complex and it's ongoing. 20:07 And there's a lot of speculation. 20:09 I mean, this is straight out of a 007 thriller, right? 20:12 Is she a spy? 20:13 Is she not a spy? 20:14 What subsidiaries knew? 20:15 What didn't? 20:17 Where is it on the books? 20:18 And so, yeah, I mean, it certainly raises eyebrows to have this document, you know, not submitted and, you know, in line with their earnings, which has been sort of the orthodox way that NVIDIA has always done it. 20:32 And so it's certainly a break from that pattern, which which, of course, raises suspicion. 20:36 And, you know, I do think the Jensen situation is pretty concerning. 20:41 Ultimately, I know there's a big move amongst other founders and thought leaders to continue. 20:47 to bring him back. 20:48 And, and, you know, I, I hear their case, but you know, frankly, I think this is all just going to be sort of a headwind for NVIDIA narratively for, for a little while here. 21:00 And, you know, if you look at the data on this, you know, mega, mega speeds you know, Alice Wong was based in Singapore. 21:08 They imported at least 4.6 billion worth of NVIDIA tech, according to, to trade records that are accessible. 21:16 And they also arranged for import of more than 12 billion of NVIDIA Hopper units into China. 21:21 So there was certainly, you know, reason for concern on paper on their own reports. 21:27 And, you know, NVIDIA's 10Q for the quarter ending July 27, 2025 showed 19 billion or 21 percent of first half revenue built to Singapore now. 21:38 And we know that that's sort of the corridor into China. 21:41 And NVIDIA stopped reporting a broken out Singapore number now. 21:45 So that change, again, raises eyebrows. 21:48 Some reports allege Singapore billing was used to get chips into China. 21:51 You know, I think that's sort of maybe a priori reasoning as well. 21:56 NVIDIA has said that over 99% of its controlled data centers revenue built to Singapore was for U.S.-based customers. 22:03 There definitely is some of that in the mix. 22:06 But the question is, at what makeup and at what blend? 22:09 So I don't know what's exactly going to be the case here, but the market is going to do its best to sniff it out. 22:16 That's for sure. 22:17 I see that they're pumping a little bit this morning, so maybe the market isn't too concerned. 22:23 But if you're an NVIDIA investor and you want to be long AI, but you don't want the risk, Uh, you know, we have this Anthropic IPO. 22:32 So it'll be interesting to see kind of what happens here. 22:34 Maybe there's a pivot. 22:35 Maybe there's not a lot of chaos in NVIDIA land, probably some deep value if you think that this music isn't stopping and you think the train's going to keep rolling. 22:45 But nonetheless, certainly some eyebrow raising behavior. 22:50 I'm not going to go so far as to say they were certainly doing X percent to China. 22:55 And there's so much data on, you know, left unseen and unread. 23:01 I think that investigation is owed. 23:04 I think that it should be looked into. 23:06 But then again, there is also special interest. 23:09 I mean, there's when there's trillions of dollars at stake. 23:12 And it becomes geopolitical and this sort of wealth creation engine. 23:16 I mean, there is going to be messy politics. 23:21 You know, this is kind of like an episode of Game of Thrones in a way, too, where, you know, some people benefit from Jensen being out. 23:28 Some people benefit from him being in. 23:30 So you got to be really careful what you believe. 23:33 Look for the data and let's see what an investigation kind of objectively can turn up. 23:38 And let's let the dust settle a little bit before we have any baseless accusations. 23:42 I think I think that there's more sound objections. 23:45 I think that there's more sound reason for concern for for this trade outside of having to baselessly speculate on on some of these on some of these matters. 23:55 NVIDIA shares rebounding about two and a half percent this morning, trading at one hundred fifty four dollars and seventy five cents. 24:01 That comes after Anthropics debut on the Nasdaq today. 24:05 Pivoting a little bit here, the MSCI is kicking Bitcoin Treasury behemoth strategy out of its indexes at the close on November 30th. 24:15 Index funds have to sell. 24:17 No choice, no haggling. 24:18 So what usually happens to a stock after it gets the boot? 24:21 Well, let's take a look in chart of the day. 24:28 All right. 24:29 Chart of the day. 24:31 We're doing it early today, trying to start the day on the right foot. 24:36 So MSCI is cutting strategy from its indices at the close on November 30th. 24:42 Today, we're going to take a look at what usually happens to a stock that MSCI kicks out. 24:46 So this is one of the biggest studies of the MSCI index changes that I could find. 24:51 You know, 1,400 deletions, 1,800 additions across 38 countries from the year 2000 to 2015. 24:59 Every number here is measured against its stock's own market. 25:03 So this isn't just, you know, price movement for the sake of movement. 25:07 This is where it is relative to what it's either being included in or removed from, so to speak. 25:13 Orange is the stocks that got cut from the indices. 25:19 So from the announcement to their last day in the index, they fell 6.3% behind the market. 25:23 That's forced selling. 25:25 On that last day alone, they dropped 1.6%, which is about six times normal volume. 25:31 And then the sellers are generally done. 25:33 20 days later, the gap is down to 2.4%. 25:35 By 40 days, it's 25:40 Three months. 25:41 The average deleted stock is one point five percent ahead of the market. 25:46 A little bit counterintuitive from what you'd expect, especially reading the negative dooming headlines. 25:52 So that's a swing of almost eight points off the bottom up towards that recovery against what the equity was removed from. 25:59 So. 26:01 You know, if if we, you know, look at some of this data from a 2025 study as well of MSCI changes in 56 markets through 2023, it found that deleted stocks bottom on their last day in the index. 26:17 And when trading runs more than 10 times normal, which which is pretty interesting. 26:22 And then over the long run in the U.S., research affiliates found that stocks continue cut from the S&P 500, the Russell 1000, the NASDAQ 100. 26:31 They beat the market by more than 5% a year for five years following their removal. 26:38 And so, you know, obviously there's some fine print to turn through, right? 26:41 Like when you're presenting data, I think it's best to be honest about all of it so you can take the full picture here and have your own takeaways. 26:49 The medium- deleted stock was still a hair behind the market at 60 days. 26:55 A handful of big rebounds really did pull this average up. 26:59 And then, you know, this study also covers Europe and Asia. 27:02 And, you know, in deeper markets like the U.S., the dip and the bounce are both smaller, which, of course, I think can be expected with more efficient, deeper liquid markets here in the States. 27:12 You know, and then... 27:14 Most deletions are stocks that shrink and then they can come back later and get included. 27:20 Strategies are a bit categorically different because it's out by this sort of decree or it's out by rule. 27:26 So it won't be back at the next review. 27:28 So You know, what does this mean for strategy, though, is very much an open question. 27:33 And I think it's important to look at this data simply because of all the FUD and the doomerism you see online, right? 27:41 I mean, if you look at the chart, I put a nice sort of like gradient line of where MSTR is in this time base. 27:50 So it's not based on like percentage. 27:52 It's based on time. 27:53 How many days into this disclusion cycle are they? 27:57 Yeah. 27:58 And, you know, it's about halfway through the selling window, right? 28:01 MSCI is tracking funds that hold, you know, they hold about 13 million shares, which is only three point, you know, I think it's like 3.1, let's call it three flat percent of micro strategy. 28:12 And that's less than one day's trading volume. 28:15 So, you know, certainly not that big relative to the volume that they're doing on a daily basis. 28:22 And so, you know, those funds sell MSTR stock. 28:25 Not a single Bitcoin is going to have to be forced sold as as as a result of that. 28:29 This doesn't change their directional thesis or their strategy. 28:33 That all stays the same. 28:35 And so, you know, MSTR is just probably going to keep tracking Bitcoin far more than any index effect. 28:42 You know, I think where it where it does have a chance to buy it might be on that premium side where, you know, one of strategies tools that they've historically used is this idea of, you know, selling their common for more than what its Bitcoin is worth and then turning that into Bitcoin per share. 28:58 You know, you hear that called Bitcoin yield. 29:00 It's very accretive. 29:02 And so, you know, as strategy issues, stocks, index funds by their slice of it. 29:07 And so obviously that is now stopping. 29:10 But, you know, I think the biggest impact is always just going to be Bitcoin price, right? 29:14 And, you know, you look at the amplification that they're using now, you look at the modern engineering, the modern rendition of this engineering for micro strategy and things like the Bitcoin price and things like digital credit have, you know, 99% of the impact on the equity, not an MSCI inclusion. 29:32 So, you know, history says that an MSCI cut can hurt going into the forced sell. 29:38 But I think it's very interesting and you don't hear people tell you the second part, which is that on average, they heal quite well after you get that 8% boost from bottom to recovery. 29:48 And it actually ends up generally outperforming what it was discluded from for a couple of years afterward. 29:55 And so, you know, for strategy, you know. 29:57 The fourth sale is, you know, the November 30th close. 30:01 And then, you know, that 60 day marker that we talk about where it kind of comes back and has this recovery by lands around March 1st. 30:08 So, you know, I think the yardstick from STR remains Bitcoin. 30:14 But, you know, we got to quit the doomerism. 30:17 This deletion is it's a lasting cost to strategy, but it's small relative to their daily volume. 30:24 And it doesn't impact the, you know, the thesis that runs through what they've built or their strategy. 30:32 And, you know, seeing the general normative trends here historically, I think it's also interesting that, you know, if you line that up with what's cyclically expected for the Bitcoin price, which we know drives MicroStrategy's price, you know, more effectively, 30:47 It's there's seemingly this forced sell off at the same time that Bitcoin is going through its window of weakness. 30:52 And then when Bitcoin would typically turn around and show some strength is when this, you know, MSCI revenge tour would typically take place. 31:00 And so you kind of have this opportunity here for for some reversing momentum. 31:05 And if that's something you're aligned with and you think that sort of directionally that that might be more correct than not, then perhaps Bitcoin. 31:13 you're going to get an opportunity for some really deep value here on a firm like Strategy. 31:19 Looking at how Strategy is trading today, it's at $91.71. 31:25 Its previous low looks like it was June 26, around $82. 31:28 So, I mean, we're getting close to a six-month low here. 31:32 And then even just over the last five years, Strategy is only up 27%. 31:37 So just what's kind of your read on how it's priced right now? 31:41 deep value. 31:42 Look, they're trading at a discount to their book. 31:46 And so anytime you get an opportunity to invest in the markets, you're looking for value, right? 31:54 And so this is not financial advice. 31:56 Don't go take action on this. 31:58 I am not your certified financial advisor. 32:01 But Generally, it's a good idea to find stocks that you believe in their long-term vision, their long-term thesis. 32:10 A lot of folks do. 32:11 A lot of folks don't with micro strategy. 32:13 They've gone through multiple iterations now of what their strategy is. 32:19 You had the initial common equity sales, and then you had the convertible notes. 32:25 And now you have the amplification through the prefs and the digital credit story. 32:29 And so it's changed. 32:32 You have sort of this more complex structure now. 32:35 I think that everybody should take the time and understand something and the nuances and the risks associated before they consider any potential investments. 32:45 But nonetheless, if you're somebody that was bullish on microstrategy leading up to this 32:54 you've gone through the most of the time where this is going to impact your price. 32:59 Typically, you see a reversal just based on outperforming what you're discluded from. 33:04 And microstrategy is driven from something a bit secular to that, which is Bitcoin. 33:09 So you could almost have, you have this expected revenge tour as is, but you know they're going to be accumulating Bitcoin at the same time. 33:16 And you know that Bitcoin is probably at its relative lows as well, at least in some sort of landing zone from now on. 33:23 till that 60 day mark when you expect that, you know, rally for the MSCI deletion anyway. 33:28 So if you're looking for value and you think that, you know, you have alignment with MicroStrategy's long term vision of buying Bitcoin, holding it forever, then, you know, you start to scratch your head and say, hey, you know, this is looking very undervalued at the moment. 33:44 Well, and what about Stretch? 33:46 Because it launched around the time of Bitcoin's all-time high. 33:50 I mean, we've been watching it kind of hover around $99 getting close back to par, but it's fallen back to $96 lately. 33:57 Do you think the market's rejecting Stretch? 33:59 No, I think that they issue too much Stretch. 34:02 Right. 34:02 So, you know, it's one of those things where they have so much cash on hand. 34:08 They have so much Bitcoin. 34:10 It's not a collateral issue. 34:11 I think it's just a supply issue. 34:14 It's a market saturation issue. 34:17 You know, they want to increase that amplification and they can only do that by issuing new STRC. 34:23 Now, they have a whole suite of prefs. 34:25 STRC, of course, is the most popular. 34:28 And so they want to do that every chance they get because they want to buy as much Bitcoin in the present so that it's a better cost basis in the future because their thesis that Bitcoin goes up over X amount of time. 34:40 And so they're always looking to be a buyer in the present. 34:43 Michael Saylor jokingly says he's going to buy the top forever because he is. 34:46 But that's because it's going up forever in his estimation because it's a scarce asset. 34:50 And so, you know, they simply issued too much. 34:54 They did it to buy Bitcoin. 34:57 They're still a net buyer of Bitcoin. 34:59 But, you know, they've been having to buy back STRC because they overissued. 35:04 And so maybe they're going to have more prudence with that. 35:06 Maybe not. 35:08 But I don't think it's so much the market rejecting is maybe just market saturation and needing to expand that market of who's looking at digital credit. 35:17 And narrative changes everything, right? 35:19 The NGU technology of Bitcoin, that's going to bring more attention to the space when Bitcoin starts to catch a bit again. 35:24 I think you're going to see people be more accommodative and more exploratory for ideas like digital credit. 35:29 And then you're not going to have this sort of saturation issue. 35:32 And I think you're going to see an increased demand for digital credit as well, sort of riding on the coattails of the swing in popularity back towards Bitcoin. 35:39 All right, let's get to our next guest now. 35:41 With NVIDIA's blowout quarter, Anthropics, Nasdaq debut, and Bitcoin still sliding, what are the charts saying for stocks and Bitcoin heading into the year end? 35:50 Katie Stockton, founder and managing partner of Fairlead Strategy, joins us now with more. 35:54 Great to see you again, Katie. 35:56 So Bitcoin... 35:57 has fallen below its 200-week moving average, sitting at about 63,000 today. 36:04 What do you make of Bitcoin's fall below those key moving averages? 36:08 And what levels are you watching right now to understand the market? 36:12 Yeah, I mean, it has been quite the pullback or retracement. 36:16 Our longer term indicators for Bitcoin are somewhat constructive. 36:20 We saw a major low put in place June, July, and that was near long term support between about 58 and 60,000. 36:29 Now we're headed back, it seems, towards that support level on negative short term momentum. 36:35 We don't have any indications yet that this retracement is done, meaning oversold things. 36:42 upturns or things of that nature on the charts. 36:45 We don't have that indication yet. 36:47 But as long as it holds above that 58 to 60,000 or within that range, then it preserves the potential for a long term basing phase for Bitcoin, which is still supported by things like our monthly MACD indicator, the monthly stochastic oscillator. 37:04 These are things that we track closely. 37:08 And Kaya, I think that's a good point I want to double click on here is there's so many indicators that seem, you know, you look at seller exhaustion, you look at the amount of days since the all time high, you look at the short term holder cost basis, you look at things like RSI, which is at its lowest reading since March 2020. 37:27 At what point are there enough indicators firing for the consensus to become that we've reached some sort of relative bottom here? 37:37 Well, we definitely have a backdrop, I think, in terms of market sentiment to allow for a low, because we do look at sentiment from a contrarian perspective and referencing it as it pertains to the Bitcoin fear and greed index or just the broader fear and greed index. 37:54 It's certainly a conducive environment to a short-term low. 37:59 And yet, while we have the oversold condition that you cite in the RSI and in our stochastic oscillator, We don't yet have that catalyst, and we have some signals that we track to designate whether a down move is exhausting itself. 38:13 And we're still likely a few days away from that type of signal. 38:17 So that's the type of thing that we like to see enhance the oversold condition significantly. 38:22 And then also we always like to see what we call support discovery. 38:26 So that would simply mean it's coming down fast and hard and needs to stabilize for a few days and show that the buyers are stepping in. 38:35 That means that the support is still there. 38:38 So we don't feel like we need to buy the falling knife, so to speak, but rather allow it to find its footing. 38:44 And that will then start to show up in the indicators as well as improve short-term momentum. 38:51 Anthropic just began trading on the NASDAQ today, which should serve as a key test of Wall Street's faith in the AI boom. 38:58 Looking at the board here, there's a lot of green out there. 39:01 So how do you see this playing out? 39:03 Do you think the momentum could help bring the AI trade back around? 39:08 I think so, but I think so only temporarily. 39:10 We are in a very seasonally strong period for the market, both the Thanksgiving week and then year-end influences tend to be positive for the equity market. 39:22 And they're in most things that are sort of farther down the risk spectrum, including cryptocurrencies. 39:28 We feel that this would be a natural timing for a relief rally after what has been a very pronounced decline, as you know, for the semiconductor sector and NVIDIA in particular. 39:41 We feel that this oversold condition has gotten to that extreme. 39:44 And we do have some countertrend signals in our work to suggest that at least for two weeks, if not perhaps a little bit longer, given the seasonal influences, we could see a rebound. 39:56 However, we would be thinking about that rebound for some stocks as a selling opportunity, because a lot of them have seen weakened long-term momentum with this downdraft. 40:07 Now this is nothing new, but it is something that is showing up on the monthly charts. 40:13 And if we see November closeout, even... 40:17 higher than here, but still quite weak for a lot of these names. 40:20 And we're going to see sell signals on the monthly charts that put us in that framework of selling strength as opposed to buying weakness. 40:29 And what about gold? 40:30 It's fallen below $3,700 an ounce today. 40:33 That's down one and a half percent. 40:35 It's falling alongside Bitcoin. 40:37 So with both hard assets under pressure simultaneously, which one do you expect to turn higher first and why? 40:46 Well, gold has been trading lower alongside Bitcoin. 40:48 It has also been outperforming Bitcoin, and that's pretty normal, of course, when they're both going down. 40:55 So it's not to say that gold's acting like a safe haven versus the equity market, but it is going down a little bit less aggressively than Bitcoin. 41:03 The correlations between Bitcoin and gold... 41:06 fluctuate, right? 41:07 Sometimes Bitcoin is actually much more closely tied to the Nasdaq 100, which you could argue is the case right now as well. 41:15 Both peaked in October, essentially, with the semiconductors peaking then as well. 41:20 So I think there's more of a broader sentiment issue than something specific to Bitcoin. 41:25 Bitcoin and gold. 41:27 For gold itself, it's testing support and it's around $3,900 per ounce. 41:32 The secondary level is not far below. 41:34 It's around $3,600 per ounce. 41:37 So I don't think the bottom has dropped out for the price of gold, but we know already that it's been in a downtrend. 41:43 It's a cyclical downtrend. 41:45 There are some signs of downside exhaustion already for gold that we soon expect from Bitcoin. 41:51 So we suspect that both will likely bottom here in the relatively near term and at least find a footing. 41:57 And suppose they don't, Katie. 41:59 Suppose, you know, Bitcoin, you know, we just kind of sliced through several key levels like butter over the past couple of days, found our footing around 63K, which is a pretty key level according to a couple of different metrics. 42:13 Let's suppose that we drop below 63, below 62. 42:16 What do you think is that next natural level where Bitcoiners could expect maybe to find some support? 42:22 So we're not watching the 62, 63 area, but more the 58,000 to 60,000 area. 42:29 And it's a confluence of very important support. 42:32 It's derived from a Fibonacci retracement level. 42:35 That's quite important. 42:37 It's derived from something that we call the cloud model on the monthly chart of Bitcoin. 42:42 It's derived also from former peaks and troughs in the charts. 42:46 So it really has threefold importance in our work. 42:49 Now, if that level is to be taken out, well, then it would be a big breakdown in our work for Bitcoin. 42:56 And of course, we'd just respond accordingly. 42:58 It would tell us that while the June-July low was a low, perhaps it doesn't hold the importance that the indicators suggested. 43:08 So if we see a breakdown, we're always going to be ones to respect that breakdown because it would increase downside risk. 43:14 It would just mean that those buyers that were there before or should be there are not there anymore. 43:20 And how do you assign your probability as a firm to whether, let's say this is a local low or perhaps a higher low, or if the previous low was more probably going to be the cyclical low, right? 43:33 I mean, we look at a couple of different levels here. 43:36 We look at forced sellers. 43:37 We pulled up some data from Glassnode the other day, looking at leverage traders and forced sellers and seller existent. 43:44 Exhaustion, sentiment, things like that. 43:47 Do any of those go into your considerations? 43:48 Or what are sort of the key ratios or metrics that you're looking at when you're trying to assign these probabilities? 43:54 So we are strictly technical analysts. 43:56 And with that, it means we're wholly price-based in our research. 44:01 And so we're using trend-following metrics, things like moving averages in the cloud model that I mentioned. 44:09 We're using traditional means of deriving those things. 44:13 proposed support and resistance levels. 44:15 And that can be things like peaks and troughs on the chart. 44:18 Again, price-based, of course. 44:20 And then the indicators that we use are where we can assign probabilities with some level of accuracy we feel it's, You know, it's always there's an art to technical analysis, of course, because it's in how you're weighting the various indicators and combining them. 44:38 But the indicators are often giving you a binary takeaway, whether it has positive or negative momentum, improving or deteriorating. 44:46 Is it overbought or is it oversold? 44:48 So these technical indicators are incredibly valuable because they help also take some of the emotions out of what is a very volatile market. 44:58 And I know you've mentioned the cloud a couple of times here. 45:01 What are some other technical indicators that, you know, can our audience would be able to pull up that aren't proprietary necessarily that could drive real signal in a market like Bitcoin? 45:12 Of course, yeah, the cloud model has proven to hold relevance as a trend following gauge and as support and resistance. 45:19 We find that it's especially relevant for commodities and FX. 45:23 So probably not accidental that it relates very well, we feel, to the cryptocurrency market. 45:30 We also use other traditional indicators like the MACD, so the moving average convergence divergence method. 45:37 We use the stochastic oscillator and then a couple of more proprietary measures. 45:44 And, you know, when we're looking at the order books, for example, on Binance and Coinbase, it looks like they now, you know, the buy orders are now outweighing sell orders by more than two to one near today's price. 45:56 So when Bitcoin does break out of this downtrend, it sort of raises the question of what is that first target to the upside? 46:03 From a technical perspective, what are some of those key levels you'd be looking for? 46:08 Should we see a reversal? 46:09 Yeah. 46:10 Right, and we think about targets are something that we can derive from breakouts, but otherwise we focus on resistance levels for a gauge of upside potential. 46:22 And resistance now with this downdraft was left in its wake, I'd say between about 78 and $80,000 for Bitcoin. 46:30 Above that, the cloud model on the weekly chart is relevant in our work, and it's ranging up to about 92,000 So that 92,000 is a more important threshold for it because above that level, it would, in our work, officially reverse the down cycle that began in late 25. 46:49 Katie, it was great hearing from you again. 46:53 Thanks so much for bringing all the insights. 46:54 Katie Stockton, founder and managing partner at Fairlead Strategies. 46:59 Thank you. 47:01 Well, when buying Bitcoin, what I really care about is the final amount of Bitcoin I'm getting for my dollars. 47:06 When every sack counts, even a small spread can make a difference. 47:09 Cash App charges zero fees and zero spread on Bitcoin buys over $2,000. 47:14 The same applies to Bitcoin purchased through auto-invest, roundups, and paid in Bitcoin. 47:19 The number that matters is how much of your money ends up in Bitcoin. 47:23 For a limited time, new customers can get $21 added to their balance. 47:27 Just use the code BMTV21 when you sign up. 47:30 And don't forget this part. 47:31 Send at least $5 to a friend in the first two weeks. 47:34 Terms apply. 47:35 Bitcoin services by Block, Inc. See the Bitcoin disclosures at cash.app.legal.podcast. 47:42 Gold and Bitcoin have both been struggling this year, with gold down about 14 percent year to date and Bitcoin down 27 percent. 47:49 But one investor is making the case that these two often compared assets aren't as similar or correlated as you might think. 47:57 Our very own Spencer Nichols sits down with the founder of ByteTree for more. 48:02 Hello and welcome back to the Bitcoin Magazine podcast. 48:05 I'm your host, Spencer Nichols. 48:06 And today we are sitting down with Charlie Morris, the CEO of ByteTree, who is behind the Bold Index, which blends Bitcoin and gold on a volatility adjusted basis. 48:16 We're going to be talking all things macro, whether that comes to inflation expectations, volatility we've seen in sovereign bonds, and of course, how equities and hard assets have been faring amidst all this. 48:28 So Charlie, let's get right into it here. 48:31 I think I just want to zoom out a little bit and talk about the macro picture here. 48:33 We've seen a ton of volatility when it comes to things that cause inflation, namely energy. 48:38 It's been a wild ride here. 48:39 Everything going on with the straight-up or moves. 48:42 You know, we had U.S. midterm elections kind of shaking up expectations in terms of energy-driven inflation. 48:49 And, you know, we've also had kind of this expanding volatility in U.S. treasury bonds. 48:54 So from your seat, what are you seeing in terms of the volatility picture? 48:58 I think we've seen some hot CPI readings in the United States. 49:02 You know, but do you think that that's something that's going to continue to be sticky? 49:05 And how do you rate how the Fed has approached us to date? 49:08 Are they behind the curve, ahead of the curve? 49:11 How are you kind of critiquing what the Fed has been doing in the midst of everything I just mentioned? 49:16 Yeah. 49:16 There's a lot to unpack there, but let's go. 49:18 I think the Fed, I mean, it's not my own expertise, you know, Fed policy, but you can tell quite clearly the economy in America has been incredibly strong, much more so than most, you know, Europe. 49:30 Over here, it's not really so strong, but we have plenty of inflation to make up for it. 49:34 And so there's been some sort of nominal GDP growth at least. 49:37 Yeah. 49:38 And I get the impression that the rate hikes are kind of driven by oil and the oil price is cyclical. 49:49 And there may be an attack. 49:51 There may not be attack. 49:52 Who knows? 49:53 And I get the impression that the bond market really doesn't want too many rate hikes from here. 50:02 We're attacking the old yields. 50:05 There's a lot behind the scenes. 50:07 I mean, is it inflation? 50:09 Well, the break-even rates are not confirming that it is inflation. 50:13 Investors are not buying tips for protection over conventional bonds for some reason. 50:18 So that's a good question. 50:19 Then you look at the commodities landscape, and precious metals being weak, gold, sorry, the oil, the war premiums gone, agriculture. 50:31 again, as he's back in recent months, and the copper trade seems to have rolled. 50:36 So the inflation picture, the bond market picture is complex. 50:40 And on the one hand, you've got the whole, the 10 years about right, given where growth and inflation are. 50:48 On the other hand, you've got the issuance argument. 50:51 You know, have we just got too many bonds coming to market? 50:54 Are deficits structurally too high? 51:01 But the hard evidence is still pretty unclear. 51:05 But what I'd say, you know, bringing it back to Bitcoin, is that Bitcoin really likes a fiery monetary environment and, you know, lots of liquidity and that sort of thing. 51:16 And that's kind of cooling it down a bit right now. 51:18 I think China has kind of had this explicit strategy of accumulating gold, something like 22, 23 months consecutively of its central bank purchasing gold, the PBOC. 51:28 And, you know, they brought in tons and tons. 51:30 And it's, I think, one of the interesting ways that as Bitcoiners, we think about how can nation states kind of create credit worthiness or protect credit worthiness by building the asset side of the balance sheet in something that 51:44 You know, there's a relative degree of certainty as to if that will be protected from, you know, the ravages of inflation as these these countries monetize their debt. 51:52 So I think, you know, Bitcoin and gold, two very different parts of the spectrum right now. 51:56 Bitcoin, maybe you haven't checked lately, one point three trillion dollar market cap, gold, 28 trillion, give or take, you know, haven't checked lately. 52:04 Yeah. 52:06 And so clearly, you know, there's been this sovereign strategy of gold accumulation. 52:09 You know, Bitcoin, you know, we always hear, you know, the nation states are coming, the nation states are coming. 52:14 They've yet to really arrive at any size. 52:15 We've seen, you know, sovereign wealth funds out of the UAE accumulating IBIT, you know, murmurings of, you know, Bhutan mining Bitcoin, the UAE investing heavily in that. 52:24 But, you know, for all intents and purposes, nothing has shown up yet. 52:29 And so as we kind of move into this kind of restructuring of the debt, Ray Dalio calls it, you know, the long term debt cycle, you know, how do we kind of recapitalize the financial system? 52:39 I look at Bitcoin and gold as kind of the two interesting assets to consider. 52:44 And so I know your firm combines these two assets into the ETP it offers. 52:48 And so I guess just on the macro point, how would you describe kind of that sovereign appetite for gold right now? 52:59 there? 52:59 It's a really good question. 53:00 I mean, the sovereign appetite for gold is insatiable. 53:04 And they want more and more. 53:06 And as you say, it shines back in. 53:07 I think the Q3 numbers from the World Gold Council were really strong. 53:12 And they report those numbers in tons. 53:15 Now, put them into dollars. 53:17 Now, I know the gold price is off a bit, but we've got more tons at a higher gold price than when they reported those numbers a couple of years ago. 53:24 So we've They really are chucking money at the gold market and wanting to accumulate. 53:30 And global gold reserves, in a sense for the reserves, I don't know, 27% or something, whereas in the 70s, they were 70%. 53:37 So you can see the precedent. 53:39 There are a lot of countries that are trying to get there. 53:41 Now, European countries, not so much, because they're complacent. 53:45 They think the world's fine. 53:46 But, you know, the developing countries are taking this stuff much more seriously. 53:51 You know, Bitcoin... 53:53 Its issue here is that it hasn't got a tradition in central bank circles. 53:58 So they don't sort of look at it as a credible asset. 54:02 Now, they know what it is. 54:03 They talk about it. 54:04 They're not stupid. 54:07 But they haven't gone over the line yet. 54:09 One or two small countries probably. 54:11 But, you know, El Salvador and stuff. 54:14 But the big guys, I mean, it's just not even on the agenda yet. 54:17 Yeah. 54:18 And I think that that's the big difference, really, in the sort of between Bitcoin and gold is that gold's got this massive, well, it's got two value buyers, really. 54:29 It's got the central banks and it's just got the, you know, the whole jewelry and bar and coin market in the physical demand. 54:37 And so when the price of gold goes down, there are some people, you know, punching the air going, great, I can buy more gold, particularly the jewelers and China and so on. 54:46 But when Bitcoin price goes down, less so. 54:48 You know, there's less people, fewer people jumping up and down. 54:51 I mean, I know some, you know, hard, hard people who who like the sort of pain of Bitcoin. 55:00 of the Bitcoin dip are there, but they're just not in the same quantum as we have with central banks and global jewellery markets. 55:09 I mean, these are big numbers. 55:10 Yeah, I mean, I think gold just has so many more price agnostic buyers and price agnostic buyers with an outrageous amount of capital. 55:17 I mean, central banks, you know, they can they can buy a lot of gold. 55:20 That's that's for dang sure. 55:22 So with that in mind, like how do you think about kind of the investment thesis behind Bitcoin versus gold? 55:27 Call it, you know, I would like to say like over the next five years or so, I'd be happy to zoom out a little bit more there. 55:34 I know your ETP kind of has a balancing mechanism when it looks at Bitcoin and gold together and weights it according to the volatility of each. 55:42 So I guess, you know, when we look at these assets over the medium term, so to speak, you know, what is the investment thesis look like right now? 55:52 It seems like Bitcoin and gold really just are in two different universes right now. 55:55 So, you know, why combine them in the first place? 55:57 Yeah. 55:58 Well, I combined them because I'd been following Bitcoin in 2013 and gold from 1999. 56:05 And I used to write about them. 56:07 And it actually took me five years of writing about them before I even thought about putting them together. 56:12 I mean, so, you know, it wasn't even obvious to me. 56:14 And I was intricately involved in a sense. 56:17 And the reason that it became obvious, because my early view on Bitcoin was, you know, just like AOL and all that, it would be superseded. 56:27 And so you're sort of looking for new coins that were going to be more real than the original one. 56:33 And so I was on the wrong side of that to some extent. 56:37 Not that I didn't take Bitcoin seriously, I did, but I was more concerned about something else surpassing it. 56:44 And that was never true with gold. 56:46 It was obviously already fully established. 56:48 But then, you know, after a while, you realize that Bitcoin was always going to be number one. 56:54 And I recognize that they had low correlation. 56:57 And the reason for the low correlation was partly what I described to you. 57:00 They've got a different sorts of buyer. 57:03 But really it's the fact that gold is a kind of risk off inflationary hedge and Bitcoin's a sort of risk on inflationary hedge. 57:13 And you see that through the stock market correlation. 57:16 And so the beauty of a Bitcoin and gold pairing is that you actually get some diversification. 57:22 And of course, these are the two most liquid alternative assets in the world. 57:27 And that's a really important point. 57:29 Oil is a big asset, but you can't physically store it like a security. 57:34 I mean, Bitcoin and gold are very simple. 57:37 One of them you can put in the garden, and the other one you just put it in a wallet or whatever. 57:43 And so they're very simple and hugely liquid assets. 57:48 Yeah. 57:49 And that's why I think they're so exciting. 57:51 So when people talk about investing in alternative assets, they start making up all this stuff like private equity. 57:56 And private equity is just equity. 57:58 And hedge funds, most of them failed in 2008, and few of them delivered what they said they would. 58:05 And Bitcoin and gold are just always going to be there. 58:07 And they're always going to appreciate solely over time with whatever cyclicality we have to face. 58:13 And so, you know, when I came to building a strategy, the important point was the fact they had low correlation. 58:19 If they had high correlation, I would not have bothered because there would have been no benefit to holding them together. 58:26 But because they have low correlation and you rebalance the strategy every month, then you're effectively selling the one that's done well a little bit, and then buying the one that's done badly. 58:36 And all rebalancing strategies, if you embrace low correlation assets, then they add value. 58:42 And the bold index, what's been happening over the last 1, 5, 10 years of the bold index is that the annual return is roughly speaking 10% ahead of the average of Bitcoin and gold, which is crazy. 58:53 Wow. 58:55 And so the 30%, so basically turnover is 30% a year. 58:59 And so five years, 150% turnover. 59:01 That's all your gold and Bitcoin turnover one and a half times. 59:04 Least to an outcome that's 55%, 50%, 55%, 60% ahead of the average price. 59:10 And the other thing is, you know, someone like me is so lazy that I can't be bothered to even think about which one's going to be better over the next five years, Bitcoin or gold. 59:19 I just don't both. 59:21 And if I have a mechanism that's going to have a good outcome, then that makes a lot of sense. 59:26 And then the final point about bold is the risk. 59:28 You know, it's probably the most important point about bold is you've got Bitcoin volatility in the mid-30s, gold in the mid-20s. 59:36 Gold should be in the teens, but it's gone up in the last year. 59:40 And if you do inverse volatility weighting, you end up with, roughly speaking, 43% Bitcoin and 57% gold. 59:49 So that means that if you've got $50 into each asset, you've got more risk in Bitcoin than you have in gold. 59:54 If you put 57% into gold and 43% into Bitcoin, you've got about the same risk in each one. 59:59 Now, two years ago, when Bitcoin volatility was higher, that was more like 80-20 or 75-25%. 60:06 But they're coming towards Caripazou, which is a funny odd thing. 60:11 So as the volatility is conferred. 60:14 But the bottom line is the bold index has volatility for all of this year below the level of gold. 60:21 So it's not between Bitcoin and gold. 60:24 It's below the level of gold. 60:26 And there's an excess return. 60:27 So if you've got less risk and more return, then you have a good Sharpe ratio, which is a pretty important thing because that did it as compounding, right? 60:36 Lower drawdowns, and then you get the compounding. 60:39 So I think bold is a really interesting concept. 60:41 Shame we haven't got it in America, mainly because the tax rules don't allow it. 60:47 You have to do it with futures synthetically. 60:50 which I don't think it's, you know, we want to do it properly. 60:53 You're going to do it, you do it properly. 60:54 We've got real gold and real Bitcoin with us, but the tax rules are unfriendly to an ETF structure than with Bitcoin and gold. 61:04 But it's a powerful combination, and it's a hugely liquid alternative asset. 61:09 So that's why we created it. 61:11 And so that structural demand, you're saying like the wealth management industry would be kind of one of the prime targets to enter the Bitcoin market as a net new participant? 61:19 Yeah, I think they're easier to pull them in than central banks. 61:23 Yeah, I would agree with that. 61:25 Yeah, we look at I think, you know, Christine Lagarde probably would be a tough nut to crack, although she's stepping out. 61:29 So, you know, maybe there's a little bit of headway available there. 61:35 But, Charlie, I appreciate you taking the time to walk us through your thoughts on macro Bitcoin and gold today. 61:41 And for folks who want to learn more about the work you're doing in your work at ByteTree, you know, where can they find more and where can they find your research? 61:48 So bytree.com, that's byt, B-Y-T-E, and as in computer byte, not teeth byte. 61:56 So bytree.com. 61:58 But then our new project is even more exciting. 62:00 It's called bytrend.io. 62:02 And that's something people should have a look at. 62:04 Excellent. 62:04 Well, I encourage everyone to go check that out. 62:06 Charlie, it was great speaking with you today. 62:08 Thank you for taking the time. 62:09 Everyone, Charlie Morris, CEO of Bytree. 62:12 Thank you. 62:14 Thank you. 62:20 Thank you, Spencer, for the interview. 62:22 You can watch the rest of it over on the Bitcoin Magazine YouTube channel. 62:25 With Bitcoin ETF outflows piling up and leverage washed out of the market, what's really driving this sell-off and who's doing the selling? 62:32 Let's go to our next guest now, David Lawant, head of research at Anchorage Digital for more. 62:37 David, great to have you here. 62:38 So when you joined us in September, you were bullish, seeing the early stages of a market upturn. 62:44 But since then, Bitcoin's down 25%. 62:47 How has this sell-off shifted your read and what phase do you think the market's in now? 62:53 Yeah, 100%. 62:54 Hey, Grace. 62:54 Hey, Sean. 62:55 Thanks for having me again. 62:56 Great to be here. 62:58 I think what we're seeing over the past few weeks is a little bit of, I think a lot of the sell-off that we saw is not specific to Bitcoin, but I think it has more to do with the impact. 63:10 of how much, for example, capital the AI trade is sucking from many different parts of the market. 63:16 We obviously saw a big unwind on the AI trade. 63:20 So these are very dynamic markets and I think Bitcoin is reacting like that. 63:25 There are also a few pockets. 63:27 There were also a few pockets of accumulated leverage on the Bitcoin market that ended up exacerbating a little bit of these moves. 63:35 But I was actually impressed to see how well Bitcoin held at the low 60K level. 63:41 This is an important level of support that everybody was paying attention to. 63:45 And so far, we seem to be holding to it. 63:48 And David, it seems like everyone's always looking for a single scapegoat, a boogeyman to blame, right? 63:55 And even when it's a combination of these factors and a lot of people have chosen Binance as of late to be that boogeyman. 64:03 And, you know, the Coinbase outflows, for example, have actually drastically been outpacing Bitcoin. 64:10 what we've seen on Binance. 64:11 What has your research been telling you about who might be doing more of the selling and what might be behind those flows on the exchanges? 64:21 100%. 64:22 And Sean, I think you made a great point. 64:24 Usually when we have this massive sell offs, there's not one single cause. 64:28 It's usually a conjunction of factors. 64:31 And the interesting thing about Bitcoin is that today we have this market structure that is very layered and very complex. 64:37 So we can look into different venues on the spot market. 64:41 on the futures market, options, ETFs, treasury companies. 64:46 And each one of these pieces kind of give us a hint of what one's leave of the market is telling us. 64:52 So I was piecing kind of a lot of these things together. 64:56 And to your point, the thing that really called my attention early on the weekend was, was how much net taker sell flow we were seeing on Coinbase. 65:06 Coinbase is obviously one of the price setters for the Bitcoin spot price, but it's usually something between 10% to 15% or maybe 10% to 20% of the volume if you focus only on the top spot pairs. 65:20 But Coinbase was representing at some point up to 60% of the sell pressure. 65:25 So what this tells me is that at least at the very beginning of this movement, there was a strong selling pressure coming from the U.S. domestic side of the market, which honestly also aligns up with investors pulling off capital to position for the Anthropic IPO, which was heading up to its pricing by then. 65:46 Also, folks positioning themselves towards the unwinding of the AI trade. 65:51 So these are flows that have been impacting all the market. 65:54 And I think with Bitcoin has been no different. 65:57 After a certain point, though, after we were hitting some level in the high 60s, then we started to see those liquidations kick off. 66:05 They were pretty strong. 66:06 We're talking here about something around $2 billion or so in a little over a day. 66:13 Usually these things are very lumped. 66:15 They happen in a very short period of time and they exacerbate the price move down. 66:20 So that's what took us all the way to 62. 66:23 In my view, those were the two main factors. 66:25 And an initial selling from U.S. investors and then the liquidations kind of exacerbating the drop. 66:34 And what do you make of the action we're seeing with the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs? 66:38 I mean, they've seen outflows on 10 of the last 12 trading days. 66:42 How important are the ETFs in terms of setting Bitcoin's price still? 66:48 The ETFs are a massive and very important part of the market, of course, Grace. 66:53 And yes, you're very right. 66:55 I mean, we were seeing, actually, we were seeing a decent inflow in August and a little bit in September once we had Bitcoin show that price run up. 67:06 And then since October, it's been mostly down. 67:09 I think over the past 30 days, we're down something like $3 billion. 67:14 The way you think about ETFs, though, is that they're usually more expensive. 67:17 a lagging indicator than a leading indicator. 67:21 They're slightly lagging. 67:23 And I like to pay attention to some of the metrics that can give us a little bit of a leading edge, or at least that are not as delayed as ETF flows are. 67:33 So yes, very important metrics, especially if you're looking on the longer term horizon. 67:37 especially if you're looking more like lower frequency, as the trading folks would say. 67:43 But I personally like to pay attention to some other indicators that I think lead a little more. 67:48 Having that said, yes, definitely. 67:51 I think the interest in Bitcoin has been kind of waning and going on and off. 67:58 And we're now in an off phase, mostly because of the factors that I just mentioned. 68:03 And David, it looks like the most popular bearish bet in Bitcoin right now on the options side of the world on Darabit specifically is about a $60,000 put, like right at par at $60,000. 68:14 And, you know, what is the options market telling us about where this sell-off might end, right? 68:22 Are we going to have the, you know, the price perhaps dip below that? 68:26 Are we going to maybe hold at a key level like that? 68:29 How should we be properly understanding what the options market could be telling us here? 68:35 Great question as well, Sean. 68:36 I could be talking about this for an hour, so I'll try to make it very brief. 68:40 The options market is interesting because it gives us a very specific cut and it tells us what a very specific sleeve of the market is telling us. 68:50 And basically what we saw on the options side is that, volatility, especially on the short end of the curve, really spiked. 68:58 Skew, that was a little bit more controlled, started to go a little bit more to the put side, to downside protection as well. 69:06 So to the point you just mentioned, I think a lot of the activity that we are seeing right now, they are more concentrated on the short end of the curve, They're usually more tilted towards downside protection type structures instead of things like trying to capture upside. 69:24 We would call them topside structures. 69:26 So that's more or less what we're seeing. 69:28 The options market seems to be cautious, but it doesn't seem to be pricing a disaster or anything like that. 69:35 If I had to summarize in what sentence what the options market is telling us is, it's probably telling us that we're going to chop for a while, but it's not expecting us to see a very massive drop, even though folks are starting to hedge. 69:51 against that possibility. 69:54 It doesn't seem something that the options market is pricing as off right now. 69:58 The 60K level support has proven to be very strong. 70:02 I mean, we've seen this in the price section. 70:05 We see this at our desk. 70:06 Whenever the Bitcoin price starts to touch 60K, we see a lot of very strong inflow from buyers. 70:14 So I think the options market is kind of telling this right now for us. 70:21 Yeah. 70:21 And David, on that point of it maybe being some hedging or protection, tell me if I'm wrong, but it seems like speculators are really pulling back here. 70:28 You know, we're seeing open interest in the Bitcoin perps shrinking to its lowest levels that we can find since November of 24, you know, following some liquidations that have happened. 70:39 And that's... 70:41 That washed out leverage seems to maybe be leaving a healthier base for Bitcoin. 70:45 Is this the right interpretation? 70:47 Is it a sign that traders have stopped betting on a rebound? 70:51 And what do you kind of make of this shift and the dynamic on the perp side? 70:56 I think that's 100% right. 70:57 When I think about leverage in the Bitcoin market, I like to split between the CME side of things and then the PERP side of things. 71:04 Again, those things tell us different things from different markets. 71:08 On the CME side, which would basically reflect the more traditional part of the market, Honestly, leverage hasn't been running that high for a while. 71:17 So, for example, if you look at the CME basis, it was running at sub 4%, which is a multi-year low. 71:23 It's almost as low as it gets, given the risk-free interest rates we have today. 71:28 And then on the PERP side, to your point, we did have some... 71:32 A leverage accumulating and a fair amount of bets speculating that Bitcoin will not drop below the high 60s or maybe even 70k range. 71:46 That level was breached. 71:48 That leverage was washed out. 71:49 And I think right now we're in a much, much more comfortable situation. 71:53 I agree with you. 71:54 Very important to see, though, however, how this leverage will build up from here. 71:58 I don't expect a quick buildup of leverage, but once the market starts to chop and starts to range trade for a long time, you start to see some traders becoming comfortable with Bitcoin not breaking some of these key levels. 72:11 For now, it seems like we're still very much in this washout leverage type of situation. 72:17 We saw Anthropic go public for officially this morning. 72:24 Looking at how Bitcoin responds to or how it did respond to SpaceX, do you have reason to believe that, you know, Bitcoin might see a recovery after the initial hype of this Anthropic IPO kind of settles down? 72:39 What's kind of like the correlation or relationship you think is there? 72:43 Definitely a big driver. 72:44 We saw that with SpaceX. 72:46 I think we're seeing something similar with Anthropic as well. 72:49 We had this drop in anticipation of the event. 72:52 So because a lot of folks were pulling capital from a lot of parts of the market, we covered how Bitcoin had this drop down. 73:00 I think it's possible that in the short term, we can see a little bit of a relief rally. 73:05 There is this overarching theme of AI pulling capital from a lot of parts in the market. 73:11 This theme is not over because we still might have an open AI IPO sometime next year. 73:19 These mega deals, they'd have basically stopped a lot of the traditional deals that we'll see, the smaller but still big AI companies. 73:27 that might not be as recognizable as Entropic or SpaceX or OpenAI. 73:33 But there's still a relatively large, I think, backlog of IPOs that are going to come to the market over the next few months. 73:40 So the way I think about this AI impacting the Bitcoin price section theme is that I think we've been over a major hump Open AI was the largest IPO, I think, in history in terms of the amount raised. 73:55 I think they raised, if you include the private placement and everything, we're talking about over $100 billion. 74:02 So I definitely expect to see some relief, but this theme will probably stay with us a little bit. 74:08 And just my final point here on the Anthropic IPO is that let's see how price section starts. 74:13 In a couple of hours, we're probably going to start seeing and shares trading in the market. 74:18 They usually halt them for a few hours at the market open when you have a new IPO like that. 74:25 So let's see how it trades. 74:27 All the perpetual futures markets, if you look at Hyperliquid or Binance, they're all pricing a very positive price section from Anthropic. 74:35 They're trading at slightly above $100. 74:38 Last I checked, I think it was $102 or $103. 74:42 So they're expecting a pretty healthy 20% plus pop once these shares start trading, which I think can also be beneficial not only to Bitcoin, but to risk assets in general, at least in the short term. 74:57 And part of this trade as well has been this continued pivot of who have historically been Bitcoin miners over into the AI data center world. 75:06 You know, this year, we've seen a ton of Bitcoin being sold by many of these firms, especially the larger names. 75:12 I think nearly half of their Bitcoin, of the Bitcoin miners have held going into the year have been sold since January. 75:20 So obviously, that's put a little bit of pressure on the market, on the order books and the Do you think that's a trend that is showing any signs of slowing down? 75:27 Or do you expect some continuation on that front? 75:32 Great question. 75:32 This is definitely something that has switched, right? 75:35 In the previous market, if you think about the 2021, maybe 2022 cycle, a lot of the miners were holding the Bitcoin that they were mining in order to kind of benefit from the appreciation that they were expecting to see. 75:48 Now, the story is very different with miners. 75:51 A lot of them are... 75:53 pivoting or at least diversifying into AI, which seems to make a lot of sense from a business perspective. 76:02 I think, honestly, this is the trend that is going to continue. 76:05 I think we're going to see miners probably selling on net. 76:09 But also the important thing to highlight here is that miner flows are not as important as they used to be. 76:16 If you go further back, maybe five or even seven years ago, miners were some of the largest players in the market, or they were basically sometimes the only large player in the market. 76:28 So whatever they were doing was very impactful to the price. 76:31 Today, we have this much more complex market structure with many other large players going from, 76:42 treasury companies and ETF issuers and macro hedge funds so that miners, I wouldn't say they're a small player, but they're not the dominant player that they used to be for price section. 76:53 This is all to say, Sean, that it doesn't bother me a lot. 76:57 I mean, of course, I think this is a negative sell flow. 77:00 As you said, it waits on the order books. 77:03 But I think that the main trigger that will drive price action here will probably come from the macro side. 77:09 Topics like interest rates or how the AI trade unwinds and impacts capital drain from other industries. 77:16 I think those are the things that are probably going to be the major driver. 77:22 Well, this recent fall in Bitcoin has revived the conversation around the four year cycle. 77:28 But I know you just posted on X. 77:30 The bright side of this dump is that it weakens that theory. 77:33 So why is this dip good news? 77:36 And what does the next run look like? 77:39 Yeah, no. 77:40 Oh, nice idea to fish that sweet, Grace. 77:43 I'm not sure if I regret that one. 77:45 But the way I think about the four year cycle is I think it's a big or I think that there was something to the four year cycle in the early days of Bitcoin. 77:55 It has to do something with these miner flows and how big miners used to be in the price formation process of Bitcoin. 78:02 But I think today the reason why we are seeing some of these things develop across four years is mostly a coincidence. 78:09 And that's basically what I was trying to say. 78:11 I think a lot of the factors that drove Bitcoin towards a new market regime, they just happen to be macro and they just happen to be happening within these four year cycles. 78:24 from the COVID crash and the money printing that happened in 2020, 2022, to the ETF launch, right, some things more related to market infrastructure at the beginning of 2024. 78:37 And now we have this very interesting macro setup that some folks could argue that could, at some point in 2027, start to turn bullish. 78:48 If we see some sort of resolution in the Iranian war, opening room for further or a more sustainable decrease in the price of oil, once the AI trade is kind of already fully digested by market. 79:00 So I think those things are mostly a coincidence and they happen to happen aligned with the four year cycle. 79:07 So that's basically the way I see it. 79:11 Now, David, a lot of folks watching the show, you know, they live and die by the four-year cycle, and it gives them a lot of solace to the upside as well, right? 79:20 They're like, okay, well, I can stomach the pain because I know I'm owed this future gain because the calendar says so. 79:26 What is a more appropriate or prudent bull case heading into the future for those folks, right? 79:32 What would you do to steer them away from the calendar but still have a directional, you know, bullish thesis for Bitcoin? 79:38 What should they be really considering? 79:41 I know, maybe I'm having many friends saying that I'm not a fan of the four-year cycle. 79:45 But I guess what I would say is that if you think about the macroeconomic outlook and how the scenario could shape off, it could actually align with the four-year cycle again. 79:54 I mean, the story I was just saying, like a more benign macroeconomic cycle developing into 2027, not in the very beginning of the year, but throughout the year, could result in a very positive 2027 for BTC. 80:07 Yeah. 80:09 Perhaps looking in hindsight, folks will see 2027 as a positive year and we'll see that as a confirmation for the four year cycle. 80:17 The way I think about it is that I think these macro scenarios are much, much more important for the Bitcoin price than the actual calendar. 80:27 But let's see, maybe in a year it will turn out that those things will align one more time and we'll be having the same discussion again. 80:35 David Luan, always great to hear from you. 80:37 Head of Research at Anchorage Digital. 80:39 Thanks so much. 80:41 Thank you, folks. 80:41 Great being here. 80:44 We're going to take a quick break, but on the other side of this, breaking down the Fed meeting notes that were just released and friend of the program, Darius Dale, the CEO and founder of 42 Macro, joins us next to break down what's happening in markets. 80:57 We'll be right back. 80:57 This is BMTV. 81:00 You believe in Bitcoin, so why would you ever sell it? 81:03 Life happens, an emergency expense, a new home purchase, or a great business opportunity. 81:09 With Salt, you can access the power of your Bitcoin without selling, now with rates starting at 7.5%. 81:17 The original Bitcoin-backed lender, no collateral losses, no rehypothecation since 2016. 81:24 Get your exclusive offer at saltlending.com forward slash BMTV. 81:29 How's my rent up 30%? 81:32 My washer ain't 30% fixed, but my landlord wants 30% more money. 81:36 Bro, you know investment firms are buying up all the houses? 81:40 They got like half a million houses. 81:42 How come every time them Wall Street boys crash the economy, they always get to keep the money? 81:50 That makes no sense. 81:51 That makes no sense. 81:54 That makes no sense. 81:59 Think about the last conversation you had. 82:01 Somebody said something you wanted to remember or follow up on. 82:04 You didn't. 82:05 Plod No Pin S provides a hands-free way to capture conversations the moment they happen. 82:10 No fumbling with your phone. 82:11 No scrambling to write things down. 82:13 One press and it's recording. 82:15 Pin it, strap it, hang it. 82:17 It's on you and ready when the conversation starts. 82:20 Then, Plod's AI turns your conversation into a transcript showing who said what and a summary of key points and action items. 82:27 Plod No Pin S. 82:29 Real estate has stored wealth for generations. 82:33 But what happens when absolutely scarce digital money challenges that role? 82:38 In Digital Real Estate, Leon Wancombe explores how Bitcoin is reshaping property, capital allocation, and the future of investing. 82:48 Digital Real Estate. 82:50 Available now. 82:59 Every year, this community comes together to celebrate, to debate, to build what comes next. 83:11 And every year, the stage gets bigger. 83:18 Sound Money, Center Stage. 83:21 So where do you go to celebrate the next chapter in Bitcoin history? 83:31 Nashville, July 2027. 83:37 Bitcoin didn't appear out of nowhere. 83:40 For decades before Satoshi Nakamoto, computer scientists, privacy activists, and heterodox economists tried to build digital money no government could control. 83:49 Aaron Van Werdem has been writing about Bitcoin since he discovered it in 2013. 83:54 And three years ago, he told the story behind its invention. 83:58 The Genesis Book, third anniversary edition, traces the people and projects that paved the way for the first successful peer-to-peer electronic cash system. 84:07 333 copies, one exclusive release. 84:11 Own a limited collector's edition of the Genesis book. 84:14 Repackaged, hand-signed, individually numbered, presented in an exclusive Genesis block slip case, and built for Bitcoin history collectors. 84:24 Available now. 84:30 On October 28th this past year, the Federal Reserve held rates at 3.75 to 4 percent on a 10 to 2 vote. 84:38 Fed board members Lisa Cook and Beth Hammock were the only dissenters voting for a rate hike. 84:43 Well, yesterday, November 18th, the Fed released the minutes from that meeting and turns out the decision was a close call. 84:50 Some officials said policy was not sufficiently restrictive. 84:53 A few warned that waiting to hike would let risk would risk letting high inflation become entrenched. 84:59 Looking ahead, nearly all participants said further rate hikes would likely be appropriate with two officials proposing hikes of more than 25 basis points at the next meeting. 85:09 If inflation, inflation data comes in hot. 85:11 Now, this comes after Fed staff put core PCE inflation at 3.1% in September 2026, well above its 2% target. 85:22 The catch behind the data, the same minutes say housing and other interest-sensitive sectors were weak. 85:28 Now for a look at how the market is pricing in December's Fed meeting. 85:32 The CME FedWatch tool prices the odds at about 91% for a hike in December, and 67% implied probability for another hike in January. 85:43 Okay. 85:44 Now, previous guest of the show, Dan Tapiero, founder and CEO of 50T Funds and a 20-year macro portfolio manager, says the Fed might be hiking into the largest deflationary event in history, the advent of AI. 85:59 He's seen this movie before. 86:00 Fed Chairman Greenspan hiked early in his tenure in 1987, and Ben Bernanke famously kept policy tight into the summer of 2007. 86:09 Both had to reverse course, but only after markets revolted strongly. 86:15 Tapiero cites five charts to make the deflation claim. 86:18 Fund managers' inflation expectations are at their lowest since October 2024, according to the Bank of America's Global Fund Manager survey. 86:26 And a record net, 38% of those same managers say companies are overinvesting. 86:32 In energy, the U.S. all-in barrel fell to $36.90 in two weeks. 86:37 That's a record drop bigger than the drop seen in October of 2008, which was one of the worst months of the great financial crisis. 86:45 And in housing, homebuilder sentiment sank to 25 in November, the lowest since April 2012. 86:52 So, Sean, are you seeing any other macro data here that supports the idea we're seeing deflation crop up? 86:58 Man, what an awesome tweet storm by Dan. 87:01 I think he's making some great observations here on the deflation side of the ball. 87:06 And, you know, whether or not you're aligned, I think that it's an argument that ought to be considered, right? 87:12 I think that we need to be examining both sides. 87:14 We see what the Fed is presenting. 87:16 We kind of see that the consensus view is that we need to get tough on this. 87:20 Maybe it's even too little too late for the Fed. 87:22 But let's take a look at what he's actually talking about. 87:26 And I think that we could be seeing something similar to, you know, we're breaking out in copper, right? 87:33 Or Dr. Copper, some folks call it. 87:35 And that's because it's supposed to have a PhD in economics, which I think is quite funny, right? 87:40 Copper goes into everything that gets built. 87:43 It goes into wiring. 87:44 It goes into homes. 87:45 It goes into cars, factories, data centers. 87:49 When the economy's humming, demand rises and so does the price, right? 87:53 So that's why copper is so sensitive. 87:56 So when copper is sliding, it's often an early sign that things are really turning over across the board, right? 88:03 Because it's not just dependent on one vertical of the economy. 88:07 It's literally in everything. 88:08 So This chart that we prepped for today is just taking a look at copper futures since 2015. 88:16 And what the data is really showing us is that copper is down 16% from its $6.80 per pound price on September the 8th of this year. 88:26 COMEX copper fell 11% in two weeks. 88:28 That's the third biggest drop since 2015. 88:32 And as a gauge for the economy, I think it's absolutely been showing signs of stress, right? 88:39 So I think what Dan is saying is interesting. 88:42 I think copper tends to kind of actually agree directionally with what he's saying. 88:47 And we want to make sure that we're seeing economic growth spurred along and, you know, cutting into an environment like that could potentially get pretty dangerous. 88:55 Let's go to the 3-2-1 crack spread now where James Thorne is pointing. 89:01 He's the chief market strategist at Wellington Altus. 89:04 Previous guest of the show had him on just a few days ago. 89:08 Now, this is the refiner's margin where they buy three barrels of crude and turn them into two barrels of gasoline and one of diesel. 89:15 Then keep the difference. 89:16 On October 9th, that margin was $65.56 a barrel. 89:21 As of November 17th, it's $41.90, a 36% collapse in six weeks, and it's still falling. 89:29 James Thorne says fat margins pushed refiners to run flat out. 89:33 Now gasoline and diesel are piling up and their prices are falling faster than crude. 89:38 And the pump hasn't even caught to reflecting that fall yet. 89:41 Thorne says every 10 cents off gasoline takes about nine basis points off the headline CPI, and he thinks November 2026 could bring a negative headline print. 89:52 His verdict on more Fed hikes? 89:55 It's insanity. 89:57 All right. 89:57 So are we seeing signs of disinflation out there? 90:01 And it does seem markets are starting to get more concerned for a Fed policy error, given just how hawkish the pressure has been. 90:11 But the question still needs to be asked, is this deflationary situation being driven by AI itself, as Dan Tapiero puts it? 90:20 Well, yeah, first I want to clarify. 90:21 I misspoke earlier. 90:22 In the copper segment, I meant to say it would be dangerous to raise into those conditions copper might be indicating not cut. 90:31 So, yeah, look, you know, Dan's saying that AI is the biggest deflationary event. 90:35 of all time is his quote, right? 90:37 He's saying, you know, that this is going to be fundamentally changing how we view the ability to run GDP. 90:45 I mean, obviously, everyone knows Besant is comparing this to the Greenspan era. 90:49 Interesting that, you know, it's being pointed out Greenspan hiked and then initially and then later had to cut. 90:56 Perhaps Warsh is doing the same thing here and history is rhyming. 91:01 But, you know, time will only tell. 91:04 I agree that AI is this sort of massive game changer and it should very much specifically target that unit cost or the output of that GDP equation. 91:16 And it should allow better efficiencies in the economy. 91:20 But that doesn't mean I'm bullish on Bitcoin. 91:22 the business model of some of these companies, right? 91:25 You know, I definitely think that there's some concerns to be had in the AI landscape in terms of that investment trend. 91:36 However, the underlying technology itself, I think, is fundamentally, you know, game-changing and will ultimately lead towards deflationary forces on our economy. 91:49 Yeah. 91:49 I think that's the point we keep coming back to is questioning the business models, questioning the circular financing, but knowing that the outcome, this technology will be so meaningful. 92:00 And what's interesting about those charts that Dan Tapiero showed is, Investors aren't just expecting lower inflation. 92:07 A record net 38% of those investors say companies are over-investing. 92:12 Fund managers just made their biggest monthly cut to tech exposure in 20 years. 92:18 So there's kind of two different forces here. 92:20 There's AI creating the long-term productivity boom, but then an over-investment cycle that could create economic pain in the Yeah, look, there's a lot of cards stacking up in the deck right now, a lot of dominoes in a line, and you just need one push. 92:36 There's a lot of fragility right now in the system. 92:38 A lot of things are overextended. 92:39 A lot of things are levered up, and there's a lot that could go wrong. 92:43 But that's nothing new to the markets. 92:45 I think that there's always something to ring the alarm bell on. 92:49 I think that what's so interesting about this time is the amount of global uncertainty that, a lot of shared stress globally among things like treasuries and energy, as well as just the amount of things that have stacked up, right? 93:01 I mean, there's been this sort of looming debt crisis forever. 93:04 All Bitcoiners know that. 93:06 And so, there's always these kind of big things to point to. 93:10 But now, there seems to be layers to it and additional layers to it. 93:13 And so much capital is behind it and at stake. 93:17 And now, you're seeing these forces come in and these metrics come in 93:24 And if they were to hike into this environment, it could knock over several dominoes. 93:29 And so it'll be really interesting to see what happens. 93:32 I think that the truth is probably somewhere in the middle. 93:34 I don't want to be too much of a sensationalist, but I do think there does come a moment where you have to stand up and say, hey, you know, this is sort of getting risky. 93:43 And, you know, you might look like a crazy person at first, but at the end of the day, you don't want to just be walking blind off a cliff. 93:50 And so, As Bitcoiners, I'm not entirely sure how Bitcoin would react because Bitcoin's historical data indicates that it doesn't actually care all that much about Fed funding rates. 94:03 You know, we haven't seen an 08-style crisis since 08. 94:09 And that's when Bitcoin was invented. 94:11 So, you know, we saw COVID, but that was very unique. 94:14 And obviously, we got a lot of stimulus and capital injection there. 94:16 So I don't think it's a great comparable. 94:18 And I'm also not calling for another 08 right now. 94:21 That's not what I'm trying to do and sensationalize it. 94:23 But I think it's something where we should be aware of the risk. 94:26 I think that people need to have a more discerning approach and analysis of some of the business model behind these companies. 94:31 But also, that doesn't have to conflict with the view that the underlying technology can be an amazing force multiplier for our economy. 94:38 And as we look at the price of Bitcoin this morning, just over $63,000 up half a percentage point on the day. 94:45 What does all this mean for Bitcoin? 94:47 Yeah, look, I think Bitcoin is certainly getting near what I would say is a low, whether it's ultimately going to be a lower low or a higher low. 94:57 Our previous low back in June was 58K. 95:01 And it seems that by all the metrics I'm looking at, I think that this is now officially the longest bear market market. 95:09 If we were to set a new low or go back to the exact same low from top to bottom in terms of the amount of days passed, this is the longest bear market. 95:16 I think the average drawdown from top to bottom adjusted for sigma is about 1.73, where we did 1.7. 95:25 So that's just taking the percent drawdown and adjusting that for local volatility. 95:28 So adjusted for the maturation of the asset, we've had the extent of a dramatic move, you would assume. 95:35 We're seeing record RSI lows going back several years. 95:40 We're seeing seller exhaustion metrics hit what you would expect to be some sort of a relative bottom of the cycle. 95:46 And so at the same time, we've been crunching through and digesting a lot of this macro. 95:54 you know, volatility and headwinds, along with liquidity sucks like multiple major IPOs over the past couple of months. 96:02 And so it's hard to say for certain. 96:05 And I think that everyone who's honest will just assign general probabilities. 96:08 But I think probabilistically, we're kind of near relatively as low as we perhaps will go this cycle. 96:16 I wouldn't be surprised if we continue to chop around these levels, though, for a little bit longer. 96:20 But ultimately, there will be a light at the end of the tunnel. 96:23 And I think that Bitcoin will turn it around here and probably have a pretty decent 2027. 96:28 Well, with a December Fed rate hike priced in as signs of disinflation build, is the Fed making a policy mistake? 96:34 And what does it mean for Bitcoin? 96:36 Joining us now is Darius Dale, founder and CEO of 42 Macro. 96:40 For more on the macro picture, Darius, it's great to see you again. 96:44 So we have the Fed's December meeting coming up, pretty clear consensus that a rate hike is coming. 96:50 But we're also seeing commentary now that the Fed could be making a mistake with inflation rolling over and a and energy cooling. 96:58 How are you reading the situation right now? 97:01 Great, Sean. 97:01 It's a pleasure to be with you guys. 97:02 And thanks again for having me. 97:04 The Fed is not making a policy mistake because a policy mistake would imply that they're going to tighten, overtighten the economy into a significant slowdown. 97:12 We are nowhere near a recession in the U.S. economy, according to our business cycle model, according to our macro weather model, according to jobless claims, according to the 42 macro FAP5 recession signal indicators. 97:24 This economy is as strong as any U.S. economy has ever been, at least in recorded history and recorded data. 97:31 You know, you look at something like nominal GDP, ex-government and exports, we're currently at the most recent quarter, we were at 9.2%. 97:37 So if you think about the core private components of the economy, consumption and investment, growing almost double digits. 97:43 On a real basis, if you look at real final sales, we were at 4.9% in Q3. 97:47 That's double the pre-COVID trend. 97:49 This economy is booming. 97:50 We're nowhere near recession in terms of the leading indicators, the long leading indicators of that cycle. 97:55 And so what's ultimately happening here from the perspective of the Fed monetary policy cycle is a Federal Reserve that's just annoyed and agitated with the slow pace of disinflation. 98:05 If you look at headline PCE, which is their Craven Walsh's current preferred metric, obviously that changes every Fed meeting, yeah. 98:13 It's currently tracking at 3.5% on a three-month annualized basis, 3.6% year-over-year. 98:18 If you want to broaden it out to something like, you know, trim mean CPI, which was the most recent data point we got last week, trim mean CPI is also at 3.5% on a three-month annualized basis, 2.9% on a year-over-year basis. 98:30 So this is an economy that's booming. 98:33 Inflation is a lagging indicator to growth. 98:35 Growth is booming. 98:36 Inflation is likely to continue booming, irrespective of what's happening with energy. 98:39 And that's something we've been saying for the entire time. 98:42 Recall that in early June, when all of Wall Street was still expecting the Fed to cut interest rates, we altered our play action pass to set up the run theme, which is a view that the Fed would tighten on a transitory basis in order to create scope and credibility within the bond market to ultimately set the stage for surprising and dramatic easing in 2027 and beyond. 99:01 We think that surprising and dramatic easing in 2027 and beyond is still on the table and is highly likely to occur. 99:06 So, Sean, I agree with your point that 2027 should be a great year for Bitcoin. 99:11 And before you joined, you know, we were actually discussing the disinflation picture and whether or not AI could really drive a massive regime shift in terms of structural deflation. 99:20 I'd love to just double click on that point you were making and really ask you what data or models you're looking at and what would ultimately tell you that there could be a, you know, AI driven shock to the economy or really kind of a multiple force coming from AI on this disinflation picture. 99:40 Yeah. 99:41 Yeah, we've done a tremendous amount of work on this in our macro scouting reports throughout the year and throughout last year in supporting our productivity boom theme. 99:48 A little bit over a year ago, we altered the theme. 99:50 And the view is that the U.S. economy is already in the early innings of a structural uptrend in productivity growth that is likely to prove durable on a five to 10 year forward basis. 100:00 Much like what we saw in the 60s, much like what we saw in the 90s and the 2000s. 100:05 And so you go back, you look at the most recent productivity cycle. 100:09 In terms of general purpose technology, you know, catalyzing a productivity cycle uptrend. 100:13 You know, we had 150 basis point trend acceleration and productivity growth then from about one and a half to three percent. 100:20 And that three percent was durable for, you know, three to five years, you know, well into the into the mid 2000s. 100:26 In our view, based as a business owner, someone who's paying a lot of money for AI at the current industry and someone who uses the internet on a daily basis as well, I can tell you right now that AI is a significantly more productivity enhancing technology than just internet technology. 100:39 And so as long as this technology does diffuse throughout the economy, which we think it will, just probably albeit on a slower pace than what markets were expecting maybe four or five months ago, but it will diffuse throughout the economy and ultimately catalyze the 100:54 at least 150 basis point trend acceleration and productivity growth. 100:59 And just the math on that, we're already tracking, if you index the growth of productivity to the low of this current productivity cycle to the low of the previous productivity cycle, we're already outpacing the 1990s to 2000s productivity cycle in terms of the amplitude of the acceleration. 101:17 And that 1990s to 2000s productivity cycles was one of the best in history. 101:21 And so what are the implications of 101:24 You have a significantly faster trend rate of corporate profitability, corporate profit growth and wider margins. 101:30 So that's check, check. 101:32 And then you typically have significantly higher asset valuations. 101:35 Another secondary consideration is that you typically see the market price in dovish policy signals, short rates declining when productivity is above trend as well. 101:44 So, you know, you could wind up with a very, you know, nirvana-type state in the economy at some point 12 to 18 months from now once the market agrees with everything that our data has been signaling for at least a year now. 101:57 The 10-year yield is back up above 5%. 102:01 And when you last joined us in October, we talked about a possible Fed-Treasury accord to help hold down long-term rates. 102:08 Do you think the case for one has gotten stronger since then? 102:11 And what would that mean for markets? 102:13 The case for a Fed Treasury Accord has gotten weaker from the perspective of the pace of data center construction. 102:22 Recall that data center construction has been about 30% of GDP growth in the year to date, perhaps on its way to accelerating to the extent that the non-AI related parts of the economy slow down from their currently exaggerated states in the coming quarters. 102:36 And so if you believe that we're going to have less economic activity, you must also believe that there will be less upward pressure. 102:43 on interest rates. 102:44 We don't necessarily buy that view from the interest rate perspective. 102:47 We do think that there will be a politically induced slowdown in data center construction that's obviously being currently debated by markets and priced into markets. 102:54 We don't think that process is over, which is why we don't think we're at the end of the current risk off market regime, which we can unpack shortly. 103:01 But just going back to this Treasury Accord dynamic, Inflation is worse than when we talked the last time. 103:07 The economy is slower. 103:09 And so that those are kind of two offsetting dynamics. 103:11 But ultimately, in our view, and we've always had this view, is that we have a differentiated perspective on what the policy recommendations will be from Kevin Walsh's five task forces. 103:20 We still have yet to see our colleagues across Global Wall Street to really actually ascertain and really debate what the outcomes of those task forces will be. 103:29 And so we've been just kind of waiting at the finish line, munching popcorn for a while, 103:33 But the reality is when you look at and you do the math on the core drivers of those of those segments of the economy where you break it up in terms of communications, balance sheet for data, productivity and jobs and inflation. 103:46 Four of the five balance sheet, productivity and jobs, inflation and data will be explicitly dovish in our view based on our analysis of. 103:53 You know, those underlying drivers in the economy. 103:57 The communications task force may yield a hawkish result, but it'll be overwhelmed by the double signaling that we're going to get from the other task forces. 104:04 And so ultimately, the point I'm making is it almost doesn't matter what's happening in the real economy when we get those task force results, because that will create the credibility, the academic framework that the Fed will need to do. 104:17 transition its policy from the cyclical tightening that we started anticipating in June, in early June, to, okay, we're done with cyclical tightening, we're done with the mid-cycle adjustment, what's next? 104:26 What's the next policy conjecture or conjuncture, which Kevin Warsh kept saying in the most recent presser, which, by the way, is a hint. 104:33 He obviously thinks there's another policy conjuncture coming, by the way, so all you guys need to pay attention to the words that these people say. 104:39 And so we think that next policy conjuncture will be a dovish pivot, particularly in the context of supporting the Treasury bond market on the long end of the curve. 104:48 And one final thing I'll say on this is when we refresh our fair value model for the 10-year nominal Treasury yield, we're at 5.88% today. 104:56 Obviously, if Besson doesn't like five, he's going to hate 5.88%. 104:59 So we think the sense of urgency in D.C. and in the treasury market is high, especially in the context of the hyperscalers needing to issue about a trillion dollars of paper over the next couple of years, which is essentially double. 105:11 It'll be a triple of what they issued this year. 105:15 And Darius, Bitcoin's lost about a quarter of its value since the start of October and stocks have been sliding as well recently. 105:21 From a macro standpoint, what do you make of this increasingly popular argument that Bitcoin is the canary in the liquidity coal mine? 105:31 It always is. 105:32 Bitcoin is one of the longest leading indicators from a market risk standpoint. 105:35 And it's nothing specific about Bitcoin. 105:37 It's just that high beta assets, high volatility assets require more liquidity to appreciate. 105:45 The further you out on the risk spectrum in terms of risk reward, all versus versus annualized returns, the more liquidity you need to have sustained an uptrend. 105:52 So we are currently in a headwind in the liquidity cycle from the perspective of our macro weather model. 105:57 And that's been the case for a couple of months now. 106:00 What's perpetuating that headwind in the liquidity cycle is the headwind, in our opinion, and in the macro weather model's opinion is the headwind in the monetary policy cycle. 106:07 And what's perpetuating that is the headwind in the inflation cycle. 106:10 We know we got residual seasonality upcoming in Q1 for inflation. 106:14 So it's probably we're not going to get to a tailwind in the inflation cycle. 106:18 It doesn't look like until we get into Q2 of next year. 106:21 Obviously, energy is coming down. 106:23 But again, anybody who pretends like they have a forecast on where energy is going needs to be inside of President Trump's head and God bless you if you're inside of President Trump's. 106:34 I'll leave it at that. 106:36 But so in our view, you know, this kind of this this this market negative dynamic that Bitcoin has been signaling since going back to you can make the case that they, you know, Bitcoin started. 106:45 pricing this in in October of last year. 106:47 Gold started pricing it in in January of this year, and now stocks are pricing it in several quarters later, almost a year later. 106:54 And that's historically been the case. 106:56 Crypto, the further you are out on the risk spectrum, the faster you break down when things start to get bad and the faster you break out when things start to get good. 107:04 And that's just the history of financial markets. 107:06 And so In our view, we do think Bitcoin will bottom first. 107:10 It's peaked first, it'll probably bottom first. 107:12 Then you'll probably see a bottom in gold and you'll probably see a bottom in stocks. 107:16 And we think those bottoms are between now and let's call it the next couple of months. 107:20 We think the window to be a bear is shrinking. 107:25 And Darius, you mentioned energy in that response. 107:27 You know, Brent is now down 20 percent this month. 107:30 You know, we still don't see any, you know, papered resolutions in either of the geopolitical conflicts, whether it's the Ukraine war or the Iran conflict with the Strait of Hormuz. 107:41 You know, how much do you see inflation and global liquidity throughout 2027 hinging on what happens there? 107:46 Or do you think the market is sort of acclimated to to these geopolitical risks? 107:52 It will matter from a base effect perspective, particularly in Q2 when you see the sharpest deceleration in year-over-year rates of inflation. 107:59 However, if you look at our secular inflation model, which is accurately forecast with the equilibrium level of core PC inflation since January of 2022, the model has consistently said we've been at or slightly above three levels. 108:12 since January of 2022. 108:13 And so you've seen the time series like Core PCE, Headline PCE, Super Core PCE, Trend Mean PCE, you know, they've all been basically trading sideways for two, three years now at somewhere between three to three to five, three and a half percent. 108:28 And so in our view, you know, Energy will become a it'll be it'll dominate the headlines. 108:34 But all the while, you're still going to have this underlying kind of three percentage level of inflation in the in the economy, unless the Fed wants to take a weed whacker to the labor market or take a weed whacker to the AI CapEx infrastructure buildup, which in our view, that's a highly both of those events are highly improbable. 108:50 Improbable. 108:51 And then also, you know, on the other side of the picture, the yen is back near the level where Japan stepped in to defend it back in July. 108:59 And the Bank of Japan governor says that rates should keep rising or be expected to keep rising. 109:05 Could Japan become the next big risk for global markets? 109:08 And how do you see this yen situation developing as we close out Q4, maybe enter Q1 of next year? 109:16 You know, our analysis suggests that the yen carry trade has been dramatically reduced from a leverage perspective. 109:23 Obviously, Japanese investors have a lot of, you know, a significant chunk of their, what, like $3 to $4 trillion of net international investment surpluses invested in U.S. equities, U.S. corporates. 109:32 US treasuries. 109:34 But that doesn't necessarily mean that Japan hiking interest rates is going to cause problems because what really matters is the pace and speed with which the Japanese investors are putting on or taking off their hedges. 109:44 That really is what matters in terms of unwinding that. 109:48 And we've seen enough movement in the data that would proxy that to suggest that that risk is diminished. 109:54 However, and one thing I would also say, the Bank of Japan's pulled poop Taki, she's packing their board with reflationists and doves. 110:04 They have two more pointees next year. 110:05 She's going to pack the board with more reflationists and doves. 110:08 And so whatever this price is, I think it's about three rate hikes priced in over the next 12 months in the BOJ swaps curve. 110:14 We would be fading the heck out of that, just receiving the heck out of that. 110:17 That's not going to happen in our opinion. 110:19 So that's a limited market risk where we see more market risk. 110:24 And again, we're very bullish on 2027. 110:26 We think the confluence of Fed Treasury Core 2.0 could be a meaningful catalyst for multiple expansion in equities, could be a meaningful catalyst for asset price appreciation in in gold, crypto, silver, all the things that typically require liquidity to sustain uptrends. 110:42 But the next couple of months, in our opinion, we're concerned that some of these core issues from an expectatious perspective haven't been fully priced yet. 110:51 And that's what our model signaling, our global macros matrix, which is the tool that we use to now cast a market regime, which got our clients, Dr. Mo got our clients out of Bitcoin back in September 2000. 111:01 You know, took all of our, you know, took kids up to 80% cash in late September. 111:05 You know, that, you know, that model was essentially saying things are still getting worse. 111:09 And so, you know, doesn't mean I can't refresh the model tomorrow and things start to get better again. 111:14 But, you know, things are still getting worse, at least as of today's refreshing that model. 111:18 And so that tells me that the risk of something that looks like Q4 2018, whereby you had this cascading sequence of degrossing across the bubble buy side, is still a high and rising risk. 111:28 Again, if you're up small as a portfolio manager. 111:31 And one of these pod shops, which, you know, dominate flows in the industry, you know, you're going to lose your seat if you close down. 111:38 So you're going to start managing risk in a more aggressive way just to prevent that outcome. 111:42 You know, I've seen, you know, we have many clients across the global buy side. 111:46 And I'll tell you right now, some percentage of them are no longer clients because they're no longer in the seat. 111:50 This has been a broody year for hedge funds. 111:52 And so in our opinion, the risk of the next leg down comes from a behavioral dynamic that investors may be seeking to protect P&L heading into year end. 112:01 At the same time, I'm not sure that we've truly seen the whites of the eyes of the politically induced slowdown in data center construction. 112:07 I think we all kind of assume that that's the likely most highest probability outcome, but we haven't really seen any actually action yet. 112:14 You know, we've seen some words and talks, but like what if a Texas comes in and says, you know, which is where like 40 percent of planned data center capacity is coming from over the next few years. 112:22 What if they come in and say, put a pause in everything until we renegotiate all these deals? 112:26 I don't know. 112:26 We don't know what that looks like. 112:27 I'm not saying I'm not predicting that. 112:29 I have no reason or basis to predict that. 112:31 But I don't think we've gotten enough catalysts. 112:34 I don't think we've seen enough of that catalyst yet for market participants to be confidently re-underwrite their positions because we know the data centers will get built. 112:41 We know AI is a productivity enhancing technology. 112:43 We know it's going to get diffused throughout the economy. 112:45 We know there's a bag, a pot of gold at the end of this rainbow. 112:48 It's just how much smaller is the pot of gold relative to what everybody thought in June and July? 112:53 And that, I don't know that the market, based on our discussions with clients and based on our analysis, we're still seeing 2028, 27 and 28 S&P 500 sales and earnings expectations, growth expectations still at the cycle highs. 113:05 I just don't, we just don't think we're at the end of the rainbow yet, but we're probably close. 113:08 So next few months we get sloppy, but that's probably it in terms of being a bear. 113:12 Well, along those lines, what do you make of Anthropik's IPO today? 113:16 How could that turn around the recent slump in the AI trade we've been seeing? 113:21 Yeah, no, look, great question. 113:22 I mean, Anthropik is this upsized IPO. 113:25 I think we're from $94 billion to $107 billion is one of the most bullish things we've seen in a while in terms of challenging the durability and severity of the current risk-off inflation market regime. 113:35 And I'll tell you why. 113:37 There's clearly a huge threat from open source models, you know, cheap, cheaper Chinese open source models, so much so that Anthropic cut its pricing 20 percent into an IPO. 113:45 Like, who does that? 113:47 Go on a roadshow and tell people we're cutting prices like that. 113:49 Just, you know, so the reason the market is buying into this is because I think the market is going to. 113:54 It's starting to move towards who are the actual winners of this trade. 113:58 I think the market always thought that it was going to be picks and shovels and application layer and that the frontier intelligence will get commoditized. 114:04 And I think the market is starting to rotate into, no, maybe the frontier intelligence isn't going to get commoditized. 114:11 Maybe the firm that is generating all the frontier intelligence is going to commoditize everyone else's businesses. 114:17 Right. 114:17 And take all everyone else and compete away. 114:19 Everyone else's gross margins and net margins. 114:21 And that is what I think the market is starting to get behind. 114:23 You know, if they need a champion, obviously, NVIDIA was the previous champion of the revolution and with Jensen Wang gone and questions about the durability of their revenue and their and their ability to continue all the circular financing deals that they've done. 114:38 The market is going to look for a new champion. 114:40 And it may just very well be Dario and Dario's ability to come in and put Darius Dale and you guys out of business. 114:48 Yeah. 114:49 And I welcome it, by the way. 114:52 I welcome Dario. 114:53 Put me out of business. 114:54 I will be your next U.S. president. 114:56 I dare you. 114:57 There he goes. 114:57 As long as he can give us this universal basic high income that we've been promised from these tech overlords. 115:04 John, time out. 115:05 Thank you for bringing that up. 115:07 Oh, my God. 115:07 I love coming on with you guys. 115:08 You guys are the best, man. 115:11 The same people, the same people that brought us labor share of national income cascading down off the bottom of the chart for decades are the same idiots that are telling us we're going to get, you know, abundance. 115:25 Abundance for whom, Elon? 115:27 You, because the abundance you've been creating has not gone to the rest of us, or it's gone to me, I've done quite well, but it's not gone to the rest of America, you know, and so like, I just don't think we can trust and obviously that's what the blue wave was in our opinion. 115:42 People just don't trust these fools, these knuckleheads. 115:45 You know, yeah. 115:46 Give me all of your electricity. 115:47 Give me all of your water. 115:49 I'll build some data centers. 115:51 We'll keep all the profits. 115:52 And when you guys are fighting your civil war as a function of there's no more resources left in the economy, we'll be in our bunkers in Hawaii and Dubai. 116:00 Yeah. 116:01 In Buenos Aires. 116:02 That's their trade right now. 116:03 If you're. 116:03 Yeah. 116:04 And they're renting your brain, too. 116:06 So along the way. 116:09 Now, let me ask you, I really want to double-click on the Jensen saga, because you brought it up, and obviously there's a lot of various opinions here. 116:18 It seems to me like it's something out of a 007 flick. 116:20 You know, is she a spy? 116:21 Is she not? 116:22 Are the documents real? 116:23 No one knows. 116:24 And... 116:25 You know, is the architect of all of this circular financing being out, is this a systemic risk where we could expect, you know, this to roll over into other institutions that have been financed? 116:38 We know the CFO who's come in now and is acting as the interim was not so keen on a lot of these financing deals, and now she's at the helm. 116:46 So what is your expectation and outlook of maybe some of the aftermath? 116:49 Yeah. 116:50 Yeah, well, she's smart to be not so keen as a CFO because she's definitely going to go down if there was any nefarious activity. 116:57 I mean, you're signing off on all this stuff as a CFO. 116:59 So I can see why she wouldn't be keen if there was. 117:02 And again, I'm not making the claim that there was. 117:03 Allegedly, there was. 117:05 Obviously, that's been the headlines. 117:06 And so if there was, then this is a big issue. 117:09 from the perspective of NVIDIA's ability to continue supporting the ecosystem and more importantly, supporting the open source ecosystem. 117:16 Obviously, it's highly likely at some point that the US just puts up firewalls against open source Chinese models. 117:22 I don't know how effectively they can do that, but that seems like the path we're headed down if China continues to just slash the price of near frontier intelligence. 117:32 But going back to this Jensen saga, 117:36 I thought it was a big mistake for Colette, Colette Crest, the new interim CEO, to not come in and kitchen sink the quarter, kitchen sink guidance. 117:43 Like your stock's down 30, 40 percent from the highs. 117:46 Why are you trying to prop it up here? 117:48 You have an opportunity to come in and say, hey, it was all Jensen. 117:51 Because if it turns out that you were, that the company was doing something nefarious, and again, I'm not saying they were, I'm just saying allegedly, if they were doing anything nefarious, what it ultimately means is that some meaningful percentage of their revenue has to be re-diverted. 118:04 You know, and the folks we talked to, some of the best tech PMs on Global Wall Street, they're running the biggest books. 118:09 on global wall street team key books they're like yeah like we try to figure out where to put these chips let's say if you know i'm making this all up right if there's 20 of the chips we're somehow going to china indirectly through you know uh being able to lease the lease to compute or or explicitly you know through just backdoor deals where you're going to find like buyers for 20 of nvidia gpus these aren't like cheap trinkets you know um you know obviously we can't keep building you know we're slowing down data center construction in the us 118:36 I guess people can make claims on them, but where are you going to put all this excess compute, especially in the context of a company that comes out with a new model every single year? 118:46 It's a bigger problem than if they were doing something negative, which I'm not saying they are, allegedly. 118:52 If they were doing something negative or nefarious, then that's a significant portion of sales for one of the biggest companies in world history that need to be redirected and redistributed to a market that may be oversupplied in the context of slowing data center construction. 119:05 There's just not a lot of places or else in the world to sell these ships at the current juncture. 119:09 So it seems like the market has a lot to chew through and digest and make sense of, frankly. 119:14 And one of the things that I think if you view Bitcoin as this sort of microcosm, investors are very confused right now. 119:24 There's not a cohesive narrative in the Bitcoin community of why can't it catch a bid and who's to blame for this downturn. 119:30 Previous cycles, Bitcoiners got to kind of very neatly point at somebody like a Sam Bankman Freed or, uh, you know, you name it, the villains of the past. 119:39 And, and this time it's kind of the first, uh, where, where, where it's, it's maybe more of a, a macro conditions or, or you name it. 119:46 And there's not a boogeyman. 119:48 Um, You mentioned that there's this potential for a dovish pivot on the horizon. 119:54 Eventually, we'll get there. 119:55 Bitcoin's obviously further out on the risk curve. 119:57 What do you think would ultimately be that catalyst or that narrative for Bitcoiners to finally catch a bid or maybe point to the upside in months to come? 120:08 And does that asymmetric upside for an asset like Bitcoin still exist? 120:12 Yeah. 120:14 A asymmetric upside relative to other asset classes. 120:18 Yeah, I mean, the higher beta asset class, but I mean, I made the call on Palm Show in 2020 that as institutions adopt this asset class, you're going to lose some of the volatility to both the downside and the upside. 120:28 It's going to become a more institutional asset class. 120:30 And I would argue that's probably a good thing. 120:32 I mean, like the more we have the greatest number of participants in the marketplace, which ultimately implies we have the median wealth of the participant in the marketplace is probably lower than it used to be, which ultimately means that, you know, those people can't suffer as much volatility as folks like like us. 120:49 And so that's probably a good thing that the asset class has gotten the risk to a to a to a degree. 120:53 Yeah. 120:55 You mentioned that the Bitcoiners can't point to anybody in this particular cycle to blame. 121:00 I don't know that that's a pro... Not you. 121:02 I'm not saying you did, but I'm saying just as a word of advice to folks watching, that's not a great way to be thinking about investing. 121:08 You don't want to have someone to blame for your failures in life and in yourself. 121:12 Like you're ultimately, at the end of the day, you're responsible for the trades you put in your portfolio. 121:16 And so, you know, kind of just rewinding the tapes on this, our models, our Kiss and Dr. Mo models, Kiss being the... 121:22 you know, the stocks go Bitcoin model portfolio that we run for our retail clients and Dr. Mo being, you know, basically the same risk management for 80 different factors for our institutional and sophisticated retail clients. 121:33 Kiss and Dr. Mo pivot us out of Bitcoin in two tranches on October 30th, 2025 and November 7th, 2025. 121:43 And so if you didn't get those signals, I mean, look, I've been here. 121:49 I've been on Global Wall Street for two decades. 121:51 I mean, I've been on crypto podcasts for at least six years. 121:54 You guys have an opportunity. 121:55 So don't blame Sam Bankman-Frey. 121:57 Don't blame Ben Bernanke. 121:59 Don't blame Janet Yellen. 122:00 Don't blame Sarah Warsh. 122:01 Don't blame Donald Trump. 122:04 Don't blame anyone other than yourself for the mistakes that you make in your portfolio. 122:06 And you know why? 122:07 Because you're not going to learn anything if you point the finger to someone else. 122:10 Point the finger at yourself, learn something, and do something about it. 122:15 Darius, you're one of the best out there. 122:16 We really loved having you on again and hope we can do it again soon. 122:20 I appreciate you guys. 122:21 Great, Sean. 122:22 Real, real pleasure to be here. 122:24 Darius Dale, founder and CEO of 42 Macro. 122:27 That'll do it for today's episode. 122:29 Here's who's joining us on tomorrow's show. 122:33 Tracy Shuchart is back with us. 122:35 She is the senior economist at NinjaTrader Live. 122:38 Janessa Lopez, head of digital assets and emerging tech policy at Block. 122:42 And... 122:44 and Chitanya Jain, the head of investor relations at Strategy. 122:48 And of course, we'll be keeping an eye on how Anthropic moves today and recap all the action for you tomorrow as we look to close the week strong. 122:58 All right, that's going to do it for us. 122:59 We'll see you back here 9.30 a.m. Eastern time. 123:01 For Sean Hagen, I'm Grace Remington, and this is BMTV.
Community discussion