0:00 What is up, guys? Welcome back to Bitcoin Audible. I am Guy Swan, the guy who has read more about Bitcoin than anybody else you know. 0:09 And I'm very happy to welcome Giacomo Zucco to the roundtable today. 0:14 We've got Steve, Jeff, myself, and Giacomo all breaking down a whole bunch of things. 0:21 talk and we took talk a little bit about bit 110 but mostly we talk about just everything that's been going on the hacks the the blasting of the internet with you know ai attacks or the insanely 0:34 aggressive bug exploitations and bug fixes going on in this massive flood and about you know what the economics of that really is like where how should we see things playing out and what's the 0:50 safe thing to do, how to think about going into this environment. So I'm not going to waste any more time. We're going to jump right into it. This is Roundtable 26. Don't forget to check out 1:01 the Bitbox hardware wallet. Honestly, one of the few things that you can just always do is hold your keys and, you know, be very careful and learn about your setup and test your setup 1:12 and have good backups, all of those great things. In fact, I think for the sake of like the infinite number of things that I can't actually say every time I'm just telling you, you know, go get a BitBox and, you know, use this hardware wallet, use multisig. 1:25 I think I'm going to put a kind of like just a basic guide of my favorite setups and the things that I consider for creating keys and safely holding Bitcoin. 1:37 Basically everything, all the main things that I do with the various people that I personally help set up and keep their stuff safe. 1:45 So I'll try to have that available on the website. 1:47 You can check that out at BitcoinAudible.com. 1:49 Don't forget to subscribe to the Guys Take channel. 1:53 So many more videos and great content to come. 1:57 And the InShittification video, I highly recommend it. 2:01 I think we did a really good job and we put a lot of work into that one. 2:03 So I hope you guys like it. 2:05 Subscribe and use my affiliate code when you grab yourself a BitBox. 2:08 And with that, let's get into today's show with Giacomo, Steve, my brother, and myself. 2:15 This is Roundtable 26, the Internet's Black October. 2:30 Welcome. 2:31 Welcome back to the Roundtable. 2:33 We have got special guests. 2:35 Nobody cares about Steve or Jeff. 2:37 Giacomo is on the show with us today. 2:39 Welcome to the show, man. 2:41 How you doing, dude? 2:42 Thank you very much, guys. 2:44 I'm fine. 2:45 And I'm very happy to be here. 2:47 Good to have you on the round table. 2:49 Finally have somebody worth talking to up here. 2:51 I'm usually just sitting in here with Steve and Jeff all by myself. 2:55 And I got to figure out how to carry the conversation because those people just talk about bullshit. 3:02 But we had a couple of people. 3:03 I feed it. 3:05 We had a couple of people watch the show last month. 3:07 It was like seven. 3:09 Yeah. 3:10 Well, true story. 3:11 So, Jeff, how are you doing, man? 3:14 What did you call me about yesterday? 3:15 that I didn't answer? 3:17 I don't even know. 3:19 I thought it was like Paradox. 3:20 Nothing in particular. 3:22 No, I'm not quite there yet. 3:24 I'm waiting on a new computer. 3:26 And so I'm trying to finish putting together a 3D printer I bought and might actually have a semi-normal, for me, stuff to work on. 3:44 soon but um can you get your agent up and running finally we're in the new place well like i said i gotta get the device here first but um we're we're in the new place and somehow i managed to 4:00 hurt myself at the gym and so i'm i'm a little uh in pain right this minute but otherwise i'm alive it'll be okay it's just a couple of days it'll it'll be fine so hang out hang out after this i want to show you the new uh the new ui for a pair drive because like i love 4:23 some things about it but there's some things that just seem like unintuitive to me that i didn't i didn't realize until i was kind of like walking through it all and it's like stressing me out 4:33 because i don't know what the what the solution is and i'm curious solution is yeah i want to i want to give it to you and then we can play around with it again because there's like so much that's 4:41 better about it but it still just feels off in this particular way so we'll get into it afterward but stick stick around so we can chat um uh steve uh welcome welcome back brother how you been 4:54 and talk to you all month i want to go back to the i'm by the way i talked to my wife i'm gonna come back to the meetup i'm gonna see you guys sometime yeah jump in man i'm gonna come hang out 5:03 and it's been like a year dude i've been pretty good but um i need to ask for a confession booth my my in the confession booth oh yeah okay i've committed a uh a big a bitcoin sin i've um sold 5:17 large amount of bitcoin to put a down payment on a house this is judgment and uh you just bought a i know where i went wrong i know i went wrong it's the whole like getting married and deciding to have kids thing oh yeah that was the thing that got me full shit coin so like 5:33 dude to be a good bitcoiner just to clarify do you have chairs in the view yeah i got one oh god i'm so sorry oh my god you're beyond beyond salvation also um i probably need to be forgiven for how i acted towards the mortgage lender who was just 5:54 kyc raping me like to death it's amazing i don't know if it's the same in italy but like trying to get a loan for a house in the U S they want like your blood samples, your DNA. They want to know 6:11 all of your accounts and your entire history of everything. Dude, I'm surprised this worked. So yeah, we need all of your accounts at all of your financial things, all of your credit cards, all of your banking accounts, all of your exchanges, all of your retirement accounts, 6:31 like stock trading, like everything. 6:35 And I got up the courage to say like, yeah, that's not going to happen. 6:42 I was like, I'm going to give you guys what I think you need to prove that I'm worth it. 6:50 Yeah. 6:50 You can tell me if that works or not, or I'm going to use somebody else. 6:56 Like they actually went for, I mean, like, really, you think I'm going to give you every Bitcoin exchange I've ever logged into. 7:02 Like, I mean, it's just not happening. 7:05 Let me say something very out of character. 7:08 I think that KYC is not only dangerous, but also economically retarded because the reason we have money is basically to dispense vendors from knowing their customers. 7:19 But if there is one market where some level of Orwellian surveillance may make some sense, is credit market, because it's the only case in which they really have to know. 7:31 I mean, they have to assess the risk. 7:33 So if I'm lending you some money, some level of nosiness is economically rational, I think. 7:43 But it's correct that they don't need anything which is beyond your credit history, basically. 7:50 And that's the crazy thing about it is people don't recognize this is another one of those things that's so deeply tied where the structure of society is so deeply tied to how money works. 8:00 If most of your money is created as credit, how could you possibly have a world without a massive Orwellian surveillance system? 8:08 Credit is surveillance. 8:10 You have to have KYC. 8:13 And so if your money is fractionalized by default, the simple way, without even the leverage and the next layer and the additional banking system on the banking system that's selling leverage tokens as their own debt money. 8:29 If 90% of the money is literally created as debt in a fractional reserve system, from the standard methodology, that means 90% of all economic activity has to be surveilled down to everybody's butt crack and DNA scan and banking history and mortgage history 8:48 and every financial choice in retirement. 8:51 It is ubiquitously tied. 8:53 It is irrevocably attached to a surveillance, a total surveillance system if all money is created as credit. 9:02 If all money, if 90% of money is actually savings, it's actually just not arbitrarily printed and created into debt, well, then that's 90% of economic activity. 9:12 Did you have to give a shit about the history? 9:14 You have the proof. 9:15 It's the money. 9:16 You hand it the fuck over and you own the thing that they give you. 9:20 So they are the one in the same. 9:22 The credit system and the surveillance apparatus Leviathan are the same mechanism and they are indistinct. 9:29 You cannot detach them from each other because the credit system doesn't work without the surveillance and the surveillance is supported by the credit system. 9:36 So anyway, I was just going to say like one thing that that brings up, though, is I think you've been thinking about lately with all like the paperization and all the layers being added on top of Bitcoin is that even in a total free market, like even like without the government, 9:51 You can't stop private individuals from making contracts with each other for custody and effectively creating paper Bitcoin. 10:04 I mean, paper Bitcoin would exist without any kind of government institute. 10:09 It's just like a private thing. 10:10 And maybe this is like the theory for open money or free money or whatever that is. 10:15 but it's like, I feel like the world that you talk about, Guy, that's my ideal dream world too. 10:23 But realistically, because paper money is free to make and no one can stop making paperizations of the assets, it's just, it's always going to be that even whether you're a sound money basis, 10:37 there's always going to be this paper layer that forms on top of it that is unfortunately probably going to be pretty prominent, like even without a government. 10:45 Absolutely. Absolutely. But the question is whether or not it can be systemically, the cost of it can be systemically socialized or it has to be isolated into the institution. Mt. Gox goes under when they promise more Bitcoin than exists. FTX dies when they promise more Bitcoin than exists. And it's not even a very long timeline. 11:05 It takes a little bit of Reddit sleuthing and some Twitter posts to go viral for it to be a month before they're freezing accounts to keep everybody's money safe. So it will always exist. There's always a risk of arbitrage. And there's always a price of arbitrage for how much capital you have versus how much you think you're going to have in the future. And you can sell that. But you and the people who trust you are the ones that should have to pay for that. 11:31 When you get to create it through a fractional banking system systemically, you get to hide it in everybody else's money. 11:38 And so your retirement account and your wage and your groceries end up paying the bill for somebody else's incompetence or JP Morgan's 40 to 1 fucking leverage on every dollar they have in the bank. 11:50 You don't get to find out where the fraud is actually coming from. 11:53 And everybody pays for it instead of the fraudsters or the people who are irresponsibly leveraging themselves. 11:59 The whole thing goes together. 12:00 So you're 100% right. I'm not even arguing with you, but there's a vast difference between localized risk of committing more capital than you have or obligating yourself to more capital than you have and systemically being able to defraud the money and everybody has to pay for it even when they don't know where or how they're paying for it. 12:24 But yeah, there'll be paper money in every system. Yeah, without a doubt. 12:28 Yeah, the risk would eventually find an equilibrium with the compensation of the risk. 12:36 When you have a few FTX style bankruptcies, you have bank runs, you have chain failures. 12:45 And if you don't have a bailout made by stealing money from other unaffected or unresponsible people you do have at least a decision loop which stays with people with skin in the game So we can assume that in front market the credit risk cannot get to the hypertrophic 13:08 level that you get when you put a violent mafia in charge of robbing people that manage risk well in order to compensate and bail out people that mismanage risk. 13:19 Yeah, I saw that Michael Saylor at least added a third exchange. 13:24 And I think his paper Bitcoin is split between three exchanges now instead of just Coinbase and Fidelity. 13:32 There's one more. 13:33 That's responsible. 13:34 I like seeing that. 13:35 Like, I think we're kind of reliant upon some kind of competition and mistrust between the institutions and the exchanges. 13:45 Like when we were in that position where all the ETFs were and all the, you know, corporate entities were using Coinbase and nobody was ever withdrawing. 13:54 I just don't think we would ever, it would ever get revealed, you know, if they were rehypothecating. 14:00 But yeah, I mean, I'm starting to see a little bit of a competition amongst custodians and, you know, that helps a little. 14:10 Well, dude, when TLS and PHP are getting like scaled 9.8 rated vulnerabilities across 70% of the web, like you sure as shit better be separating it up between exchanges if you hold a substantial amount that you have to have in a custodian. 14:30 And don't put it in your cold card. 14:34 Or at least have multisig. 14:36 Dude, multisig is a superpower. 14:37 with Ledger and Trezor this month, both being hit with the supply chain hack. 14:46 And Binance just got hit two days ago. 14:50 Liquid got hit this month for billions of dollars. 14:52 Binance was 6.43. 14:54 And it was something like 3 billion got frozen by, it was Tether, Circle, so the stablecoin companies, companies yeah um ripple the decentralized ripple um uh arbitrum the arbitum whatever 15:16 whatever those layer twos on ethereum are and optimism um so funds got stolen or frozen across all that that were attached to the uh uh the hack but one of the crazy things about this story is it 15:29 seems like the guy or the perpetrator who did this was aware of this and were expecting that response. And they actually put a shit ton of this capital into DeFi. And then so they locked 15:45 it up as collateral in into the DeFi networks and then took out loans in Ethereum and ran away with the Ethereum. And so now the institutions, all the stable coins are freezing capital that's 16:01 collateralized inside a network with other. He literally socialized the costs by putting the stolen funds into a giant pool of a whole bunch of people are leveraged with collateral and basically 16:13 shot up the leverage because now it's fake collateral, right? Now that's not real collateral anymore because binance wants it back um and then he walked away with the ethereum um which is 16:24 crazy i don't know exactly how much it was um i i saw somebody looking at or trying to tabulate um how much it appeared had happened that way uh but that's that's clever some of that's somebody 16:37 who kind of knows what they're up against and had a plan because they did that really quick but that's pretty nuts yep yep this to be honest from the point of view of still manning shit coins I think that this would be a good battle test for stuff like Ethereum 16:58 usually the criticism we have is twofold one is about digital scarcity if everybody can print money every time you create the shit coins you have infinite supply but the second was always about centralization 17:11 The fact that Ethereum was controlled by a couple of insiders like during the DAO hack, when insiders lost money, they just changed the consensus unilaterally in order to get money back. 17:23 Now, it would be interesting to see if now they still try. 17:28 In theory, all the centralization vectors are still there. 17:31 You still don't have validating notes, full notes. 17:35 You still have people using out of date, people relying on a centralized foundation with a trademark. 17:42 So just like in the case of Ethereum Classic, whatever is Ethereum is defined by a very centralized power structure. 17:50 So in theory, people affected by this could make a phone call and just Binance could just make a phone call and get the Ethereum Foundation to roll back the chain again. 18:01 But now I guess that the narrative of the decentralization of Circus is a little bit more advanced than it was back in 2016, 2015. 18:12 So it's interesting to see. 18:14 Well, and my guess is that the DAO hack or whatever was rolled back because a bunch of the founders were impacted. 18:23 And in this case, the founders probably have nothing. 18:28 There's no reason for them to care. 18:30 and it would come at the cost of the narratives that they're trying to promote, that their coin is decentralized or whatever. 18:41 But it's still astonishing to me how you had to freeze a bunch of your Ethereum to like, I don't know, something to do with, I mean, if you want to mine or earn whatever the staking revenue is, you have to hand it over to somebody that has enough to do that. 18:59 like you have to hand it to an exchange or whatever so there's all these centralizing forces in ethereum anyway there was also something where like your balance had to be frozen for a certain amount of time to make it to the next you know like whatever the next update 19:13 they were going to do like if you wanted some return the glacier and the big freeze yeah whatever like and all i could think is like dude if they're telling you they're telling you you have to freeze your money for a certain number of years this is this is like an exit scam like 19:29 this is what you know this is just like the stock market where they that's what they had to do in uh uh richard hart's what's the what was the coin what was that oh yeah hex yeah yeah yeah 19:40 yeah i don't know push push chain a push chain yeah he i mean he created like five of them but but that was like the whole thing is the scheme was like locking things up so that there couldn't 19:50 be sell pressure to get the return on the new thing so it was like how quickly can we lock up coins to get the new inflation so that the founders can exit so that richard can get super rich and what was crazy is that it was like literally there was a foundation for his clown 20:07 coin and and there was like an address and then they like found out that like that address was his address that like he had control over and then he would just deflect like it was the foundation 20:17 there's policies and all this stuff it's like bitch it's your wallet like you know everybody's just locking up their money by just sending it to Richard. 20:26 But anyway, shit coins be shit coin. 20:31 Anyway, don't you think that we are in a situation in which the world seems like immune to actual realization of collapse? 20:42 It's like if a few years back, a collapse of something like Binance would have created some level of panic, worry, concern. 20:51 Now we have the complete collapse of the geopolitical equilibrium, complete collapse of any kind of metric or long-term government debt, complete collapse. 21:02 And even if we have the collapse of the internet and basically PHP and TSL certificates, and then you have Binance, 6 billion, and nobody can care. 21:12 it's like we are beyond like this poster reality situation in which there is no trigger anymore that can really trigger panic we already did this four times this is just the fifth time 21:24 i'm gonna go buy groceries i'm out of bananas you think it's because there's like nowhere to run like um yeah like people would say like run to gold but everyone knows what you mean by run to 21:35 gold is just run to some paper gold run to black rock um yeah it's like uh there's no panic because like if you panic what do you do you there's nowhere to go there's no doors like there's no 21:49 there's no room to leave yeah there is no nowhere to run there is also this is desensitization to to anything basically it's too much happening too often and then your i think your alarm circuits just get I see it on myself as well 22:06 it's just been blaring all day so you just take the battery out yeah exactly it's like a Tarantino movie the first cut head you see the blood and maybe after 1000 cut head you see the blood spilling you don't care that much anymore you get desensitized 22:24 it's just like man that guy had more blood in him than the last one just like shot right out of the top that's crazy yeah i'm gonna get a pastry i was absolutely shocked when the price did not move at all 22:37 with the cold card hack and then um with this binance hack i guess it moved maybe three or four percent or something but still like not very much and honestly it was on trend like we've just 22:49 been we've just been correcting for like a month or two and it was just like it was just like it's going down and then Binance happened. It was like, oh, oh, I didn't do anything of any consequence. 23:01 It was just like, oh, it also continued to go down a little bit. And, you know, six feet. 23:07 Okay. But doesn't it doesn't make you think like that's that's sometimes price of things is just not related to what is what it is the price of. It's kind of like we're in a GameStop situation where like when GameStop was doing crazy things, the price of GameStop and the company 23:25 GameStop had nothing to do with each other, right? 23:28 There was just games over here. 23:29 And then the company was over here and they're like unrelated. 23:32 Like, does it feel like we've gotten that way in Bitcoin now where it's like the price of Bitcoin is unrelated to what Bitcoin is? 23:38 I think there's two pieces of that is one is that's what fiat does. 23:41 It divorces the price of everything from reality. 23:43 And we're talking about dollar price and the credit is the thing that matters. 23:47 But then also I think Bitcoin is big enough and in enough places now. 23:53 I mean, it's still very small. 23:55 in the grand scheme, but it's also big enough that any one thing, as much as the cold card affected me personally because of the people that I knew and the messages that I answered and the whole night that I spent getting cold cards out of all of my setups, I didn't think 24:12 about like, oh God, should I sell Bitcoin? You know what I mean? Like it doesn't, my perception of Bitcoin as valuable did not fundamentally change. I was just scared of the hardware while it's sitting in front of me. 24:24 And I think most people don't know. 24:25 You talk to a Disney money, know that cold card happened, you know, like anybody outside of our circle, our circle is shockingly a small part of, you know, Bitcoiners are a tiny part of Bitcoin now. 24:38 So that scares me, man. 24:41 Well, I also, you know, it's not that unusual for the news to be bad in a bear in a bull market and the news to be good in the bear. 24:51 like we we've had yeah cycles previously where that's usually how it behaves right yeah yeah bad bad news is dominating the the cycle but we're in a bull market and it doesn't really do anything 25:02 and some of the i mean these are real events right like so it's not it's not just like oh china banned bitcoin or whatever you know it's not the the made-up stuff that we've had previously 25:13 but you know that doesn't change the fact that if you have a real event the news wants to amplify like the people that are buying want to amplify the bad things so that they can get liquidity to 25:26 buy more i mean so we're in a we're in a buying cycle and i think that that's just you know how it's going to be honestly the fact that it's not moving a lot is really pretty bullish because that 25:37 means you know maybe there's a lot of buying pressure um and i'd also just say on the notion that like bitcoiners are a minority of the people in bitcoin is that like it always had to be that 25:49 way and i felt more and more and i've i feel like i've talked about this i did an episode on this 25:54 like five years ago or some shit but the thing that we inevitably will call bitcoin in the end like the the dominant network but stays through if it remains decentralized it will necessarily be the thing that has pissed the most people off 26:08 that has not let every individual group do a particular thing that they wanted to do because they couldn't control it or they couldn't be the ones making the decisions for it. 26:20 And thus, Bitcoin will ultimately be the thing that makes the most people unhappy with how Bitcoin has turned out. 26:27 because everybody will have their vision of the way it's supposed to be. 26:32 And if it's decentralized, they're not going to have enough influence to get what they want. 26:35 And I think that's why the people I talked to in core or have been disheartened. 26:40 They're just like, I'm depressed because like nobody, but I had private conversation with people just like, this is, this sucks. 26:46 Like everybody is like attacking us and all this stuff. 26:49 And then we have these conversations on the round table and mechanics up here. 26:53 And we talk about how like core is lost and corrupted. 26:56 it. And then I've just had so many conversations from so many different people and everybody's just like mad that it's not, it's not working the way that they want it to work. But so many of them disagree about the way it should work. And it's like, well, yeah, it's not, it is, 27:10 it should piss everybody off. If it's actually, I think that's somewhat of an indication that it might be working, but you know, that's kind of a vague generalization, but I don't know. I've always saw it that, seen it that way. 27:26 Well, then just do telemissions. 27:29 Just do telemissions. 27:31 Just do telemissions. 27:31 Just make everybody mad. 27:32 Yeah, you piss off. 27:33 I'll make the most people mad. 27:35 Yeah, maximize the people you piss off the most. 27:41 Yeah, same. 27:42 Stop some of your agents, man. 27:44 Too many agents. 27:45 They're working too much. 27:46 Okay, I'm just going to tell everybody to stop everything. 27:51 I'm going to close all the things. 27:52 I got my agents. 27:54 Stop hacking Coinbase. 27:55 I'll never stop that. 27:57 What are you talking about? 27:59 That's not me. 28:01 Hey, Jokerman. 28:03 What's it? 28:04 Did you know how Coinbase has a CBBTC token? 28:10 Have you heard of this? 28:12 CBBTC. 28:12 Yeah, yeah. 28:13 The rapid Coinbase token. 28:15 Yeah. 28:15 Did you know that they actually published Bitcoin addresses backing that? 28:21 I didn't know. 28:22 Isn't that interesting? 28:24 Yeah. 28:24 Like Coinbase, we hate Coinbase for not revealing Bitcoin addresses. 28:31 And they reveal addresses for their token. 28:34 I think that is so fascinating. 28:37 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 28:38 They respond to market criticism. 28:41 Yeah. 28:43 I think that we hate Coinbase for a series of things, which is not just exhausted in this. 28:50 But yeah, this is very interesting. 28:52 But wouldn't it be nice if we got that sort of response from politicians or something? 28:57 I mean, you know, like we don't even get it. 28:59 Why would they care? 29:00 At least Coinbase is, yeah. 29:04 Oh, man. 29:06 Markets are imperfect, but everything else, which is not a market, is way more imperfect. 29:12 Way worse. 29:13 Even the worst market actors is better than the state. 29:18 Their prop is, you just know it. 29:20 The proof is in the give a shit matrix. 29:22 Is what quadrant are they in? 29:24 Like a drunk spending their own money, a cracked out drunk spending their own money is infinitely more valuable to the worth of society, to the direction of economic material in society than a politician on a fucking committee spending somebody else's tax money. 29:42 Yeah, yeah. 29:43 Set up for Justin. 29:44 Yeah, BTC pay server got hit. 29:47 Very sad. 29:48 I did not I was not affected by it and somehow that one didn't hit me the same way I've read a couple of like posts from people from BTC Pay, who was it that did the long post, like really kind of heartfelt post recently but maybe Pavalex maybe but like I feel 30:10 for them but I guess my I wasn't my BTC Pay server has just kind of been one of those things that I sit aside and it just does its thing and I didn't have lightning on at the time I didn't have my channels open 30:22 um because I shifted some things and had kind of sat there for a while um but I still used it for like basic little things but so it didn't like affect me a lot and it was kind of overshadowed 30:36 by the cold card and all the other stuff that seemed more like direct but the bz btc pay server hit was pretty serious especially for anybody who's like a business that does uses that regularly and had a major lightning instance. 30:52 For me, it was very, very bad. 30:54 I can tell you why. 30:56 Because in Lugano, we have this payment system with more than 400 businesses accepting Bitcoin, so you can live in Bitcoin. 31:03 Lugano is pretty good. 31:04 And the way that was done was with a centralized server, which was ill-managed. 31:11 So I basically engaged a battle of two years to convince people to migrate from that system to BTC per server. 31:18 And we succeeded in doing that basically exactly one year ago. 31:21 So for the first time after they set up Tether and BitFenix set up the system in 2022, finally in November 2025, after really annoying everybody and harassing everybody, I got them to move to BTCP server. 31:38 And then in August, when the red team wrote me, well, you know, the typical Rob Hamilton meme. 31:46 Hey, how are you? 31:47 Can you check your PMs? 31:50 And when they happened, we had to shut down the payments for just a few hours. 31:56 It was patched very quickly, no loss of funds. 32:00 But I mean, the perception was that the software that we promoted as the industry standard, and it was the industry standard, was still insecure. 32:10 And what is even worse is that we have two kinds of merchants in Lugano. 32:15 One kind are just using the point of sale produced by the municipality with Tether and Phoenix. 32:22 And those guys, they were using this kind of externally managed BTC per server, custodial kind of things, and then they were getting Swiss francs. 32:33 And those people, they just got a no touch of a couple of hours, and then they would get back to normal, no fund loss. 32:40 while a few merchants, the only hardcore ones, the ones that we managed to convince to be really true Bitcoiner, they were running proper self-managed instances of BTC per server and some of those lost some manageable, not dramatic amount of money. 33:00 So it was something hitting the heart of the... 33:06 Only the people that actually follow us entirely and went to the hardcore path, they were hit more than the people that just remain with a gay solution. 33:17 A gay solution, a faking gay solution. 33:21 Oh, dear God. 33:23 That hurts. 33:25 That hurts. 33:25 And I, you know, I didn't even notice this until recently when I was kind of pulling stuff together that happened in October. 33:36 because this happened towards the beginning of October. 33:38 I didn't even know until a couple days ago. 33:42 But ARK got hit of a second layer, whatever their company, their liquidity. 33:52 And they lost 0.75 Bitcoin. 33:56 So not like a massive hack, but it was an exploit of the ARK service provider and they drained a bunch of funds out of it. 34:06 which is kind of crazy. 34:08 There was a blink theft as well. 34:13 And then there was an Electrum Wallet thing that a malicious server could somehow tweak or alter the transaction and trick the user into thinking it needed to be RBF'd and then edit or change the maliciously effects the next transaction in the line. 34:34 And it was like weird. 34:35 I didn't get like explicit details on every individual piece of it. 34:39 But it was basically that the Electrum server that you trusted could screw with what your wallet could see or do. 34:50 And I mean, just like the list this month has just been nuts. 34:54 Everything was broken. 34:56 Yeah, everything was broken. 34:58 So do we get stronger from all of this? 35:01 No, I mean, I think so. 35:02 Yeah, I think this is inevitable. 35:05 Like when you open the capacity to brute force everything. 35:15 The economics of defense and attack were very different four years ago. 35:20 Like extremely different. 35:21 You had to be a skilled programmer with significant capital and time to invest toward a very specific exploit. 35:31 and looking at some particular project that you had to care about and you had to diverge your attention. Each one unit of human thought had to be taken away from something else that you wanted 35:40 to build or do and dedicated entirely to, can I break into this thing? And so, and this was a small subset of skilled enough engineers and software programmers who happen to have incentives or life choices align to have that be their commitment or their focus. 36:01 Now you don't need the skill. 36:04 You don't need the time. 36:07 You can devote a hundredth or a thousandth of the amount of time or capital in that direction and probably find something. 36:14 You can just get an agent to scan through a bunch of different projects while you're going to take a shit and find out if it finds anything when you come back and sit down at your computer and you just read an output of a prompt. 36:25 Um, and that's like not a, that's not like a 50% change in the economics. 36:31 That's like a 50,000% change in the economics in a matter of six months. 36:37 You know, like that's, that's a gargantuan shift and oh shit. 36:43 Now every hole in this giant thing is Swiss cheese that we call the internet has to be plugged because somebody is going to find it. 36:50 and that doesn't come without a lot of pain like a lot of pain and so I remember I realized what you're saying in a separate matter I had a friend who had some Bitcoin locked because of a lost passphrase and that was a very ancient thing like 2014 something like that and recently 37:18 my friend told me, well, I got my money back. I'm super happy. I got a shit lot of money back. 37:24 And I said, how? Well, AI. And I was like, for a while, I was like, wait a minute. I'm still very skeptical of the AI hype and claims. And so I said, these LLMs, they cannot actually brute force 37:39 a key more efficiently. And he told me, no, no, it's not that they, I didn't use AI to brute force. 37:45 there were some automatization that were reasonable to do, but the chance of success, they were so low that I never bothered actually programming that because I said, no, this is too 37:59 many options. So I never really got to do it. With these LLMs, I just, in one afternoon, I just tried out all the different kinds of rainbow table cracking ideas that I had over the years. And instead of postponing forever because the cost of trying and failing was high, 38:17 now the cost of trying and failing was zero, just a few minutes. 38:21 So I tried them all. 38:22 And then I found the actual cracking algorithm was optimal. 38:28 So back then, it was before the apocalypse of this summer. 38:33 It was probably last February or last March. 38:38 and with just the fact that we can automatize with zero effort. 38:43 It's probably something even bigger than moving from binary code to Python higher level languages. 38:52 You could, the computers with Python can do the same things that the computer could do by punching cards with binaries It just that if you have to punch cards one by one and one and zero every time you have to allocate your cards time way better 39:12 and you can only care for very important problems like space programs and weapons. 39:17 If you can automatize that with a lot of boiler plating being done by higher level languages, then you suddenly have a lot of people programming just because even without a clear compensation or a clear goal or a clear expectation of outcome. 39:39 So it's, yeah, it changes everything. 39:41 And what's crazy is that it's getting better and how much the harnesses, the fact that like how I interact with all the software and the stuff that we're working on on top of the engine that we built has just been so cool and i'm just constantly finding ways to do 40:00 it faster and the biggest unlock recently has been that because of the little space design is just peer-to-peer is i built like and i just did this one off in an afternoon um i was like okay i gotta 40:16 i'm so sick the biggest friction in this is me taking the prompt and the outputs from one conversation with the agent on my Linux machine and copying it over to my agent on the Mac mini 40:27 to, to test, you know, what's going wrong with this peer to peer transfer or why it transferred 20 things in this index and then paused for 60 seconds and then transferred the other thousand, 40:38 you know, like what, what the hell's like mixing up in this and, uh, and the delay of me having to read and translate and paste and then go back and forth was just massive. And so like in the afternoon, I built a chat app that I got on my phone that runs over the same engine and 40:58 plugged my agents into it, like each with a key. And then I have like a little thing that just judges rounds. Like, like you guys can go for six conversations back and forth to figure out 41:09 what's going on here. Or I can just say, you've got an hour, you know, I'm going to go do something else in an hour. We're going to pause this conversation, but I want you to, to figure out why the streaming is delayed by six seconds when I click on it. 41:23 I hate that. 41:24 That's a terrible user experience. 41:26 And then while I'm working on all my apps, I just record. 41:29 I click on stuff. 41:30 I click on stuff and I just record myself talking about the app while I'm clicking on it. 41:35 And there's a little script that just checks where I'm clicking on stuff and what I'm highlighting and which DOM is loaded underneath my cursor while I'm talking, like with the time code. 41:44 and then it it syncs to my agent over the engine in the background and then my agent analyzes and updates the app so like every time I record a project now I'm using my own freaking app 41:58 to make my shows now and every time I record a project the app is different the app updates like four times before I'm done with the project in the middle of the day because I just like find 42:09 some sort of friction I just like record and talk about it and then I keep going and then my agent updates the app and fixes the thing like it's just like that's that's wild my main mode of 42:20 interaction when i'm building stuff now is just talking about it how fucking crazy is that to some degree i'm still when you say it's getting better i i can feel it's getting better uh i'm still 42:34 maybe i like too much to be contrarian but i still feel skeptical about the exponential rate I think that we are in some regard plateauing already. 42:48 So what we're seeing here, so what is this AI thing? 42:53 First thing is the idea of self-adjusting and self-learning neural nets. 42:59 That's an idea from the 70s. 43:01 So it's nothing new. 43:02 It's different from programming bottom-up with an algorithm. 43:06 You just let shit going and evolutionarily adapt. 43:10 That's the idea of machine learning with neural nets. 43:12 That's a brilliant idea. 43:14 But then it didn't scale because it was not easy to parallelize. 43:17 It was not easy to maintain in the right way. 43:21 So the real change was Google Papers in 2017 or something like that. 43:26 The famous attention is all you need. 43:28 So with self-attention, they make it easy to parallelize. 43:32 That's the second innovation. 43:33 The third innovation is not even an innovation. 43:35 It's just an effort similar to the space program. 43:38 just train this shit with every bit of human knowledge from the internet. 43:45 Lots of GPUs and lots of memory, yeah. 43:48 Exactly. 43:49 And since these, so the first thing was actual scientific innovation. 43:54 The second thing was a game-changing scientific optimization. 44:00 The third one is just brute forcing the entire human knowledge to it. 44:04 And the expression of these three things already plateaued because neural networks are neural networks. 44:11 The attention mechanism cannot be improved substantially anymore. 44:15 And there is no data to train this stuff about anymore. 44:19 It's basically, especially, well, with images and movies and videos, there's still a lot of runaway to train. 44:26 But with text, like textual capability after ChargPT 4S, it's basically, we are basically there. 44:35 So what happened there? 44:36 Two things happened. 44:37 One thing is that people started to learn how to use this sheet and integrate it with other tools in a rational way. 44:47 So instead of just going to ChatGPT with a chat interface, we learn how to do prompts, harnesses, skills, integration with more deterministic things. 44:59 so all this back and forth. 45:01 For example, for me, it changed a lot when I just had an idea to integrate my Hermes with Wolfram Alpha. 45:10 Wolfram Alpha is the thing from Wolfram that will give you all the world data. 45:16 It's very good because it doesn't hallucinate. 45:20 It's deterministic, but it's very bad because it's slow to ask the right question in the right notation. 45:26 So when you put them together, was just so much better in so many things. 45:32 But that's not an exponential evolution. 45:36 No, yeah. 45:37 That's just, yeah, I will write you the link, but it's pretty cool. 45:41 They can also do symbolic integration, a lot of math, a lot of things. 45:46 And then the things that is missing is just applying it to other fields. 45:51 So people started to use it to write, Especially people used it to ask medical questions, legal questions, stuff like that. 46:00 And now people are first trying to apply to cybersecurity seriously because it's not real. 46:07 So it is true that the new models, frontier models have been trained on code. 46:13 But even in that case, we're very rapidly approaching the plateau of the amount of code you can train them on. 46:20 And after a while, you have this kind of incest problem where the code that you train them with is code that they generated based on the other code. 46:29 So there's nothing new anymore, that internet problem. 46:33 So I think that I would expect that for textual stuff, like to create an essay or stuff like that, I think we already picked. 46:43 Yeah, Fable is nice, but they learn how to remove the M-dash. 46:48 okay but it's we're basically there now for code is something newer and i think that we will see some shit hit in the fan for the next year or so but i i feel we're close to plateau then what i 47:02 think is still at the beginning is multimedia so the idea that we could actually change real time our languages with lip sync the the the because if you put more brute force onto that you can 47:16 actually have long format movies you can disrupt Hollywood so that kind of stuff is probably something that can still surprise us for a few years more yeah I think I agree with that I like 47:29 I mean I feel like I mean of course I don't know I mean I don't know where the peak is going to be with any of this but and that's probably one of those things like time in the market or whatever 47:39 It's just going to be hard to say. But but I think that you're right in that we will get some sort of some sort of plateau. 47:49 And then but that's sort of like kind of the nature of the tick tock advancement in technology in general. 47:54 Right. As you hit some sort of wall here and then you spend all the time applying this new things we've you know, we've built to some, you know, some counter, you know, part of the technology or some counter, some other thing that's been neglected. 48:11 And it either gets more efficient in some way or it, you know, like, like, I think we just, it crosses domains to have this sort of back and forth. 48:20 Yeah. 48:20 Yeah. 48:20 So like one massive advancement in domain A gets applied and shows some area in domain B that can be aggressively improved and domain A plateaus, but domain B, as soon as that plateaus, the capital shifts into fixing domain B, 48:39 which is now obviously broken because of what changed in domain A. 48:43 And, you know, it's kind of like Moore's law in, you know, making CPUs and chips like, you know, a gate smaller and smaller and smaller. 48:53 That started to slow down quite a bit until we realized that we're still just communicating with a base of the bus. 49:00 Between the chip and the RAM. 49:03 Shit, let's just fuse the RAM directly onto the chip. 49:07 Let's connect it straight to the gate. 49:10 And the massive gains were now in the architecture of how we connected the things rather than the density of the chip itself. 49:17 And I think this whole thing about neural networks, I think you're right, Giacomo. 49:21 It's just slowing down a lot. 49:24 But I think the bigger thing is the economic output is slowing down. 49:28 because no matter what you do and how much better you get some crazy, super intelligent, exponential model, it's still going to be generalized. 49:38 And I don't think because you took the human brain and put it in a computer or the neural network and you put it in a GPU, I don't think the economics of specialization over generalization are fundamentally different. 49:51 And I think we're seeing exactly that right now that specialized models are vastly outperforming at specific tasks. 49:57 than giant generalized model. 50:00 Fable can't put a dime, like you can't put anything, a candle to Skyfall and Jev and Dessa, these other very specific models for very specific things when it comes to how much energy it costs to get a legitimate or high quality output in that one particular domain. 50:20 And so Fable is just going to be using those other models. 50:23 The general model is necessarily the orchestrator, not the implementer. 50:27 And I think the economics of specialization are the same whether you put it in a machine or you stick it in outer space or it's in a human brain. 50:35 The economics still matter. 50:37 Fable 5 is going to cost 20 times as much as Skyfall in building a CAD system. 50:42 If a specialization didn't matter, we will not have created a computer in the first place to do something that human brains cannot do. 50:50 So we're going back in circles. 50:51 So we created computers because they're more specialized. 50:54 And now we're trying to make them as generic as human brains, which is basically getting back to the human issue of being very general, but not very specialized. 51:03 Yeah. 51:03 Well, and I kind of wonder if there's going to be, if we're going to see some sort of, I mean, you know, there's already major changes in software anyway. 51:12 We already have major, like we have, we have vulnerabilities everywhere. 51:15 We have vulnerabilities in hardware. 51:17 We have vulnerabilities in software. 51:18 we have three layers of operating system basically on every machine because you've got bios an operating system and an explorer or a you know like browser which is it's like basically functions 51:32 as an operating system anyway so it makes sense given the the resource constraints we have in hardware and everything else that now somebody is going to be devoting a lot of resources to maybe redesigning and making more efficient some of these things. 51:51 And so we might end up, I mean, because what's the, it was like the, there's like that video of the guy that made like the, he like some really autistic guy like you know a programmed a a like an old nintendo type screen but you have to like you know 52:11 draw every pixel or whatever yourself he programmed like a train passing through a tunnel and and like they show you watch the video and like the crowd is just like going crazy because like these things 52:23 are not possible you know and he's doing video that's not possible and it the video costs like nothing to run because it's so low resource. So, you know, right. Like that, that is proof 52:34 that there are ways to get, you know, you don't need 128 gigabytes to, to do a lot of what we're doing. And a lot of this is just because we have three layers. Yeah. Yes. But in two years, we'll look back and see this as the dumbest and most inefficient possible way to accomplish 52:55 like 99 out of 100 tasks. 52:58 But right now it's a breakthrough. 53:01 Yeah. 53:02 Sam Altman being mad about you having 32 gigabytes of DVR5 RAM is like... 53:07 Are you hiding some unauthorized VRAM in your basement? 53:12 Yeah. 53:13 No, but also I said we are plateauing, but no, you're right, guy. 53:16 We still have a lot of hardware specialization to do. 53:19 For example, there was the old idea that we can actually have analog computers just to do metrics multiplication that can still send us a few orders of magnitude or speed and efficiency higher. 53:31 So we can say, I think we will see some incredible shit coming. 53:36 I just don't think it will be a qualitative difference in like the Turing test kind of impression that we had with GPT-4. 53:47 I think that moment is not going to change, but from the point of view of efficiency, we can probably have something incredibly better. 53:56 Yeah. 53:57 And by the way, I love, so I usually am skeptical of hypes. 54:02 Every hype, I tend to be contrarian. 54:04 But I really do love the fact that the AI hype, it's a hype, it's unreasonable. 54:10 There's a lot of bullshit going on, a lot of scams. 54:13 Sam Altamon is a scammer. 54:15 But I love the fact that now tokens means something valuable and it's destroying the tokenomics idea and that many crypto bros are going away from something Bitcoin contiguous. 54:30 So it's destroying the crypto hype in exchange for something that gave me back something more than the crypto hype, which is basically LLMs and the way they work. 54:41 So I'm happy. 54:43 That's awesome. 54:44 No, I agree. 54:45 They brought back tokens. 54:48 Yeah. 54:48 Yeah, finally tokens mean something. 54:50 Make tokens cool again. 54:51 exactly I don't know I mean I love AI I love what it's doing all the hacks and stuff to me I kind of visualize this thing of like a tree where like the trunk of the tree are things like ECDSA and like core cryptographic functions that like aren't really affected by 55:14 the AI and then all the stuff that gets broken is all the stuff on like the top of the tree the outside and like the outer layers and stuff like that and so i'm kind of i agree with giacoma where it's like yeah i mean ai is probably learning as much as it's learned it's learned 55:31 the whole internet now it's gonna like just break all the low-hanging fruit or all this low-hanging fruit is the stuff on like the outside layers it's it's not any of like the core stuff yeah um 55:42 And I kind of hope in a way, I mean, like I dream of the direction of like a returning to kind of command line simplicity, roll your own keys. 55:58 Like that's what I need out of a computer, you know, like the other stuff is just kind of fun. 56:04 And, you know, it's not really serious stuff. 56:07 You know what I mean? 56:08 Like, yeah, the core stuff is simple and the core stuff, you know, I dream of kind of a version of Bitcoin core with everything stripped that doesn't have Wi-Fi, you know, that just has the most the simpler you make software, the less you need to update it. 56:28 You know, when you update things, chances are the thing that you needed to update was something that a previous updated inserted into it as an advanced feature. 56:40 You know, when you update, you're not updating like the core secure stuff. 56:45 You know, so it's like I kind of dream of just a much simpler version of Bitcoin Core for the people that don't want anything fancy, you know. 56:55 yeah Adeless Bitcoin Core well that's a very interesting thing because some people also say so on one hand this new paradigm is fucking up all the software so everything is broken everything has vulnerabilities so that's bad on the other hand people are telling me yeah but now 57:15 with an LLM I can ask them to do everything from command line I don't even need Liana anymore to do mini script because now with Bitcoin Core, I just prompt how to do a multi-seek transaction. 57:31 So it's bringing down the barrier to use minimal stuff. But then again, we're watching models destroying existing vulnerabilities, but we are not watching yet attackers exploiting models by 57:44 injecting in the weights some vulnerabilities. It will come a time in which people will just say, hey, I can just ask my agent how to verify the signature, but then the agent itself would be injected with something. 57:57 Or lie about the signature, yeah. 57:59 They will lie and they will steal for somebody else or intrinsically. 58:03 And that's a very nasty problem to have because in a way, as much as a black box as it gets, because you cannot really open an agent and check the weights and say, what is this doing? 58:16 If something is hidden there, is hidden in plain sight, but in a way that by definition is not readable because it's locally not abstractable anymore. 58:26 So it's a black box. 58:28 So I think that the effect on security will be mixed. 58:33 In some way, I think Steve is right that we will have stuff. 58:38 For example, we move from like the Unix kind of experience where you write everything to graphics. 58:45 Graphics are good because you just click on stuff, but then when you click on stuff, you have a lot of this kind of giant stack of vulnerabilities with JavaScript and the DOM in the internet and the browsers. 58:59 So you had this explosion of complexity in order to make the graphical template. 59:04 Now with these new technologies, you may rebuild the stack in a simple way. 59:10 You can generate the button, the graphical button, just when needed. 59:15 So I don't know, mixed feelings. 59:17 I think that some of it will make security easier with simple components. 59:23 Some of it will also create new vectors that are very, very hard to counteract. 59:29 So it's a mix. 59:31 Yeah, it's a mix for sure. 59:33 But I think you have two different cultures. 59:35 Like, you know, I've run a Bitcoin meetup for 10 years now, and I've interacted with thousands of Bitcoiners, as I'm sure you have, Giacomo. 59:43 And I would say like the vast majority of Bitcoiners do not want to update their node. 59:50 You know, it like their balls are in their stomach when they have to update their node. 59:55 They never want to do that. 59:57 It's only like 5% of the tech nerds that like want to be on the latest version. 60:02 And I just think there's a misconception out there from a lot of the super technical Bitcoiners that everyone wants to have an up to date node. 60:12 yeah i see that as a very small focused on a bunch of new features and wing digits and all that stuff yeah yeah it's i mean that's the stuff that you hear about on people want stability and they want stability that's the purpose of money right it's a hedge against uncertainty 60:28 exactly yeah if this wasn't money then it'd be a different story yeah add all the features do everything move fast break things but like this is money so it's not yeah yeah yeah exactly well 60:39 honestly, stability is sort of the purpose of all of our things, right? Like, like having a car that if the battery goes dead, it forgets how to roll up the windows is a complete like backwards. 60:52 Like that, that's, that doesn't make any sense. Like if the power goes out and your refrigerator doesn't automatically restart because it's got a computer in it instead of just the old mechanical, 61:01 you know, like systems that come back on, it's retarded. Now your food's dead because, you know, your food's spoiled because somebody built a vulnerability. 61:10 Your food's dead. 61:11 Somebody built a vulnerability into the system. 61:14 And it's like, there's also, did you see the stuff about somebody turning the temperature up in the freezers in the grocery store? 61:23 The internet connected refrigerators. 61:25 There should never be. 61:27 This should never exist. 61:28 Like $40 million or some shit in damage of food. 61:32 And people were commenting that the Silicon Valley TV series already already predicted this. 61:37 There was so much prescient. 61:39 They also had the, basically the agents infecting the furniture stuff, the smart fridge and stuff like that. 61:49 God, that's so crazy. 61:51 Why is your refrigerator connected to the internet? 61:54 Why did you give it a vulnerability for nothing? 61:57 What are you doing? 61:58 Really? 61:58 Really? 61:59 Really? 61:59 You have to go home and you have to change your fucking refrigerator by two degrees? 62:02 Like while you're at home? 62:03 You can't just go into work. 62:04 You just can't, You can't like really, really guys. 62:08 Like there's no reason to do that. 62:10 Set it at a, I've never changed the temperature on my refrigerator ever. 62:13 Not once. 62:16 I guess that's. 62:17 When we were in Montreal, there is a, there was an engineer that we met in our building. 62:23 And he's a young guy. 62:24 And I tried to have this conversation with him. 62:27 He's an aerospace engineer. 62:28 And I was like, you know, one of the craziest things to me is the fact that we're not, there's no more redundancy. 62:34 failure modes are not even thought about and i hope like i don't i don't think anything that i said registered with him like it really like in aerospace like i don't understand how this is not 62:48 like what what are you being taught in engineering if this is not the first thing on your mind i don't i just don't get it i don't understand how this is our reality at all it's like it's like 63:00 somebody invented this little, you know, Arduino, and now I can just put it on everything and, and we can, you know, internet connect it and nevermind any of the, you know, like any of the 63:13 possible failure modes, like just forget all of it. We should just have it control all the switches. 63:18 Switches are expensive. We should just put an Arduino and have it be all thousand of the switches that we need or whatever. Like, it's like, okay. And if that fails, how are you going to control the thousand things that you just, you know, like it just doesn't, it just doesn't 63:32 make any sense. 63:33 I don't, I don't know. 63:34 Well, if we want to be annoying Bitcoiners, we can talk about a high time preference and the convenience of centralization. 63:40 Centralization is super efficient and is very cool as long as it works until it fails. 63:45 And when it fails, it's bad. 63:47 Well, decentralization is always inefficient because it's redundant, but then it's resilient over time. 63:53 And that's a very core of the debate between the fiat culture and the Bitcoin experiment at the end. 64:01 Yeah, I think, I guess, there's two interesting elements when it comes to, back to something you said, Jachim, a minute ago about how you have to trust the model. 64:11 and as the as models become more specialized and more like fine-tuned or put into any particular software i think it's probably very likely that we have models or little neural net net that we're 64:28 talking to or interacting with in almost all software very similar to how graphical interfaces became a thing right is that you just don't have stuff without graphical interfaces um these days 64:39 and uh but then there's this really kind of quite crazy like surreal because you you like you said there's a black box like you have this weird kind of like proxy human trust re-implemented back like 64:58 do i trust that my software is being honest to me you know do i trust that my wallet is talking to me legitimately or and the and the fact that it so funny too that the fact that where so many of these are going wrong there like such a brilliant like microcosm of why government becomes a disaster in how these like chat GPT is going haywire and these rogue agents and all of this stuff 65:26 Because what happens is that the AI model, when you can only train it on metrics, the metrics become the goal and the qualitative judgments or values about what the actual output is. 65:40 Literally everything that's gone wrong with like rogue agents is exactly like the cobra problem, Jeffrey, that you talk about. 65:47 I think is the first episode of the podcast or whatever is the Cobra problem of like when your metric, Oh, you have Cobras all over this place. 65:57 Okay. 65:57 So the government's going to pay people for dead Cobras that they bring to incentivize people to kill Cobras. 66:02 And instead it's incentivized people to grow, to, to, uh, to farm Cobra snakes. 66:09 And the situation got a thousand times worse. 66:12 And the government's paying them tons and tons of money for this metric of how many Cobras did we kill? 66:16 and instead they're the population 10x's and then they shut it down and now the cobras are a hundred times worse than they originally were because all the farms just let them out they're like i don't 66:27 know what to do with these i just got all these cobras they're just gonna kill people i'm just gonna leave i don't i don't want cobras in my house why would i i didn't want this in the 66:36 beginning the government was just paying me could be something like uh good good low no good good art low something like that good hearts all yeah yeah yeah yeah Good art slow, yeah. 66:48 When the metric becomes the goal, the result breaks down. 66:55 The system breaks down as opposed to the actual thing. 66:58 And that's like, AI is such a kind of aggressive or exponentially faster path to showing exactly why, you know, if your goal is to raise GDP, you just fuck the economy and print money. 67:16 You know, like you don't actually make people more prosperous. 67:19 You just figure out how to game the GDP. 67:22 And that's what politics becomes about is who can game it the best and position the narrative. 67:28 Yeah. 67:28 And this is the problem with most corporate structures too, right? 67:31 Like corporate structures are too big to actually manage. 67:35 And so they build some metrics and they hope that that's going to steer the corporation in a good direction. 67:43 and then you end up with things like, you know, you experienced it at whichever one it was. 67:52 Spectrum, yeah. 67:53 Is that like you were sent because you enjoyed fixing things properly, you were sent to clean up everybody's mess. 68:03 I liked the ones where people would go into a thing and there'd be like an explosion, in a spider web of like 200 Ethernet cables in some rich dude's house who just bought the house. 68:14 And they have no idea. 68:15 There's like some crazy custom system that's been set up. 68:18 And they're like, I just want my fucking TV to work. 68:21 I have no idea what this is. 68:23 And so like other technicians would be like, guy's going to take this job. 68:28 Guy's going to like this. 68:29 And so they call up the manager or whatever. 68:31 And they're like, I've got a job for guy. 68:33 And then I'll go out there and I'll spend all day on one job to help this guy set up. 68:38 And well, not all day, but you know, like I would dedicate real time to it to get this guy's TV working and internet working. But then it looks like my metric is I get one fourth as many jobs done as other people. And so when I actually applied to move and my customer service scores off the charts, like, you know, everything was good. And I did have, you know, good months, but like where I was like employee of the month or whatever the hell with the metrics. 69:05 But my metrics were generally lower because of that tendency. And then when I applied to move to the area that we're in and I was still working the job, I had to get like all of the managers and team leaders to vouch that the reason my numbers were bad is because I was good, not because I was bad, you know, but the corporate just wanted to be like, I don't know if we want to move him to this area. 69:31 He's got 30% lower on this metric and this score or whatever. 69:34 And it's like, no, qualitative. 69:36 You know, like this, the metric is wrong because of this. 69:39 So, but yeah. 69:41 So maybe out of this, you know, maybe, maybe LLMs will be able to build or agents or whatever, you know, some combination of the things will be able to build better, better corporate structures and incentives that, that allow us to actually accomplish what we want. 69:56 You know, like, I don't know. 69:57 Well, it's all about shrinking the distance between reality and the goal, like how to connect the input to the output, right? 70:08 And all technology is trying to shorten that gap in some way. 70:12 If the metric is gameable, somebody will game it. 70:15 And if the new metric is to please an LLM, then you can find all sorts of quirks that will please the LLM. 70:21 So I think that the less wrong metric for all the criticism you can make to capitalism and profit motives is profit and money. 70:34 Price signal money is not perfect because you cannot convey some things that are below the threshold of pricing like trust circles, family, gift economies. 70:46 But above that threshold, the price mechanism is great because you cannot really game it. 70:51 in the sense that gaming it will be that somebody is losing money and then people will get tired of losing money. 70:58 Price and profit is a very dynamic kind of metric. 71:02 So if the metric gets gamed, people will make money out of fixing it. 71:07 And so they will fix it. 71:08 It's not a static metric. 71:10 So I think that profit and price is still very good. 71:14 If instead of the amount of jobs in a day or the arbitrary conventional satisfaction rate, you just check how much people are paying Guy for his intervention, that's an interesting metric because eventually if people are really pleased with the result, they will be able to spend more. 71:36 Now, it's not perfect because you will need an infinitely efficient market. 71:41 You will need renegotiating prices every time. 71:44 So you never had that in practice. 71:47 But it's the thing that is less bad in this regard. 71:52 Yeah. 71:53 No, that's a good way to put it. 71:54 Well, and maybe we get, you know, in terms of like, okay, the vulnerability is that did somebody train this LLM or this whatever, this model to, you know, hack my Bitcoin wallet instead of build me a good Bitcoin wallet? 72:08 Maybe if we have, you know, hopefully something along the lines of Pair Drive where you can validate where your stuff is coming from and the supplier has a reputation, maybe we end up with, you know, the combination of reputation and then skin in the game with money and everything. 72:34 Maybe those two are the balance. 72:37 Maybe they do solve most of the problems. 72:41 Plus competition. 72:42 Maybe you can ask one model to check on the behavior on the other model. 72:45 So you can try to. 72:46 Sure. 72:47 That's a great one. 72:48 I use that a lot. 72:50 Yeah. 72:50 But the result is not simple. 72:52 It's not really stripping out the complexity. 72:55 We're just moving to another kind of complexity, which is pretty exotic. 73:00 Yeah. 73:01 there's something interesting that the ledger hack had me thinking about that I had not really considered so part of why we're building in the direction that we're building with the whole pair drive stuff is just because I think like all communication that is not encrypted 73:21 will like I think that will just slowly like every gap will be closed there and one layer of that that I had not considered was inside a device um like there's no i saw it on like a podcast or something somebody 73:40 was talking about it i wish i could remember where um but talking about how like the the device the the basically where they manipulated the ledger is there was like this foam space around the screen 73:58 and so they scraped out the phone and then put in their little thing within the same little case and all it did was basically put a go-between a tiny little cell phone essentially a wife a 74:10 wireless you know cellular uh thing and then plugged the the screen the data into the screen into it and then to the screen so it could just read you just look at the screen and um so it's a 74:24 key logger for what was on the screen basically with a cell phone that called somebody and said here's the seed words and uh but what was crazy about that was it hadn't hadn't thought about the 74:35 fact until somebody mentioned it was that we have no protocol or no system where the communication between the screen and the chip is encrypted where the screen where the data isn't anything other than just the raw pixel data. 74:53 Like there's enough, one of those doesn't exist. 74:56 So you can just put in a key logger. 74:58 But now we're kind of at this place where hardware is so ubiquitous and compute is so cheap that you can actually do that. 75:05 Where your keyboard actually has a public key and actually decodes communication sent to it so that if you even plug something into the middle between your keyboard and your computer, that it can't read it. 75:20 But we've not done, that's not been a thing really, because again, the economics of creating hardware or, you know, getting into becoming a middleman between that was just didn't apply. But all those economics are changing all over the place. And it's going to be weird to think that like, you know, your bus needs to be encrypted from chip to RAM and you're been from GPU to CPU and all this stuff that might literally have every single layer. 75:50 might literally need a key and an encryption and decryption key. 75:55 Until you will have very small cameras that are fixed next to the screen. 76:00 So they just read the screen without an encryption. 76:03 So now you need to encrypt your brain with some kind of nanomachine behind your optic nerve. 76:10 Everybody call Musk. 76:13 Call Elon next up. 76:15 oh that's well does something i mean if if you have something like an encryption between a hardware device or pieces of your hardware does that not open the door to like this same like right to repair problem that you're getting with cars where where like you're you can't update 76:36 a device without permission from the company or i was about to say i would suspect it wouldn't be I mean if you have a big centralized company with an enormous amount of network power they would probably use it like that or do it like that but I think also it could be more 76:53 generic like you could establish the key well the key would just be native to the device you turn it on and it generates a public key you know and then you plug it in it's just like part of the communication standard like two computers talking to each other 77:08 you use HTTPS but nobody controls which HTTPS key you use, right? 77:13 You generate it. 77:15 And so in my perfect world, that's how it happens, you know, is that it becomes so ubiquitous that you just have to do it. 77:24 But I don't know. 77:26 That's just, that's speculation. 77:27 I don't have any idea. 77:28 Even in software, you can make sure that the functions will not produce a clear text output, but they will produce intrinsically some kind of encrypted or scrambled output with keys or fingerprint or signatures. 77:42 So a lot of software hacks also can be prevented by signing the output of a function or encrypting it in some cases. 77:53 Of course, this is just moving the goalpost. 77:55 It's not fixing anything. 77:56 You're just moving things. 77:58 But by moving things, you can make an attack more expensive. 78:01 So that can have a positive effect Yeah As the economics of attack change in one layer you have to move the solution a layer below And I think it makes sense to just especially when you know layer two is getting hit so 78:15 damn hard is that you make a change to layer one and kind of close a category of whole that exists in layer two, you know? 78:24 But it just moves, it just moves us one layer down and then we go to layer zero and layer or layer 0.9 and layer 0.8, like the layers just infinitely get deeper as well. 78:33 You know, everything just gets infinitely smaller and we never actually reach a destination. 78:37 We just keep moving down layers. 78:40 We got pretty philosophical. 78:42 Yeah. 78:43 TCP got hit in Linux. 78:46 That's, oh. 78:49 I've got a social attack sort of thing that I've been thinking about. 78:55 Is that, have y'all seen the Anakin memes that are going around it's literally designed targeted directly at libertarians it starts with young anakin and he's like i just want people to follow the non-aggression principle and then it's 79:08 like older anakin and it's like um i saw how they how they treated us or something i saw what they did to them or whatever and then and then it's you know darth vader and he's like you know we have to 79:21 enforce like we have to impose our rules with authoritarian whatever and so it's like it's this like there's this in my opinion and it's just totally made up but i i feel like this is some 79:34 sort of like like the government finally came up with one meme that kind of you know resonated with people and so there's this like psyop that like no no libertarians need to embrace authoritarianism 79:46 because the leftists are never gonna follow your ideas and and i keep like this is like just all over the place now and he was even even a guy that is like i guess some sort of semi-libertarian 80:01 alt-right person that was on recently on part of the problem you know was like saying this something along these lines in terms of like we need you know something to impose our ideas in 80:12 authoritarian way and dave smith is just kind of like you know like he didn't really have a response to that he just but he's like kind of nodding along and and i'm like this is this is the craziest 80:23 thing like i don't i don't understand how this it's like okay and and i keep getting this response that like you're just surrounded by evil you just don't know it because you're not getting punched 80:33 in the face and it's where it's like look i know people are evil like there's no like i am completely aware of it it doesn't make me want to behave like an animal yeah exactly the point to avoid the concentration of power of evil people that will not be magically less evil. 80:50 Yeah, I don't think that you're going to give authoritarian power to any sort of conservative Epstein friend, and he's going to impose conservatism on everybody. 81:02 This doesn't make any sense. 81:03 This is absolute nonsense. 81:04 So let me do a BIP 110 comparison. 81:08 I was in my BIP 110 debate starting from the North's field and then moving rapidly against 110. 81:19 I noticed, I made the point that we tried, in my tribe of anti-spam people, we tried to enforce a mempool policy change, not even to resist a mempool policy change. 81:34 We failed and then frustration set in and people started to say, okay, we tried, but we failed, so now we do a consensus change. 81:42 And my point was always, wait, wait, you were too weak to enforce something easier. 81:47 So now out of desperation, because you failed into enforcing something weaker, you just want to go all in something harder. 81:55 It's right. 81:57 It's actually a perfect example. 81:59 And I actually thought had the exact same response to that as I have to what's been going on here. 82:04 The reason there are memes targeting libertarians now is because libertarians have been wildly effective. 82:10 Like libertarianism has grown from like 12 people in Murray Rothbard's house in the 70s to like a significant portion of the population. 82:23 And like, you know, maybe still small numbers, but a significant portion of the population. 82:28 Enough to swing something one way or the other. 82:31 Yeah, absolutely. 82:32 They're the vote or the narrative pivot that matters to right or left type. 82:39 Trump had to come to the Libertarian Convention to free Ross Ulbricht because of that. 82:43 So right about the knot. 82:45 A hundred percent. 82:46 And all we have to do is keep doing what we've been doing and be patient. 82:50 Like you're not going to win. 82:53 You're not going to solve. 82:54 You're not going to solve our problems through politics. 82:57 You're going to solve our problems with the cultural wins that we have been having. 83:02 And you just have to continue doing the same thing. 83:04 And with the mempool thing, I thought we were like the exact same thing. 83:08 is that there were people running NOTS. 83:11 The NOTS numbers were growing. 83:13 There were people like if you have eventually you have enough nodes that are anti-spam and it gets harder and harder to put spam into the chain. 83:23 That is the solution to me is you just be patient. 83:27 You understand this is a slow moving thing and we just do the thing that it doesn't violate any principles. 83:35 We don't want this crap on our computer. 83:37 so we're not going to host it in our mempool until the network forces us until the transaction is made until i'm just accepting a block and if it's valid it's valid you know yeah right and so you're not 83:49 doing anything except rejecting stuff you don't want and and nobody can make you you know hold on to something you don't want and so it just the network will it'll either solve the problem will 84:02 either solve itself or it won't it's not that big a deal like but i think that's the only way to actually get like we were we were making progress and while progress was being made somebody got 84:14 frustrated and was like oh let's let's try it at this level and it's like hi i don't this is not it never felt right to me you know i will say one thing about blake to be blake to bitcoin or 84:26 whatever um is that like it's like a perfect example of like we're going to make a perfect world for this is the like essentially everybody is kind of forced to run datum and run their own 84:39 node i mean forced like there's a committee and that's that's not what i mean but essentially the way it's built is that's that is the focus which is amazing that's fantastic and because of that 84:51 they have an enormous like i don't even know i haven't kept up with it totally but i've just casually in various conversations seen people say, oh, this pool is full on Datum now and this is all full Datum and it's like a huge overwhelming majority of the network and stuff 85:07 and it's like, that's great, but it's still smaller than the amount of hash power that was running Datum on Bitcoin because it's now forked off. So percentage wise is way more on Blank2B, which is great. That's the perfect world, but it's less hash power than 85:23 the actual Bitcoin network that was running Datum. 85:27 in the grand scheme of how much energy and capital is being put to this defense. 85:32 And it's like went for perfect, but sacrificed depth. 85:37 You know? 85:38 And it's like, I just wanted to keep that game up on Bitcoin proper. 85:45 Since I'm winning too slowly in reality, let me win faster in fantasy, which is exactly like the post-libertarian fantasy. 85:52 There are many Bitcoiner friends that are now tempted by this post-libertarianism. 85:58 And their argument is like, yeah, we try to just prevent aggression against us, but it's not going any way. 86:06 So let's just instaurate a new paradisiac ethnostate and get back the land of our ancestors and the bloodline. 86:16 Wait, you failed to just secure your wrench against the taxman. 86:20 And now after that failure, you want to take back the land of your ancestors. 86:25 This is like a little bit more ambitious. 86:27 So everything post-libertarian is incredibly more ambitious than what libertarian was even claiming to try to achieve. 86:36 And they are using the lack of patience for the easy result in order to basically hijack people's focus and attention into a completely realistic thing. 86:48 Like you did fail to just keep the IRS out of your property. 86:54 And now you're going to actually control the federal government by using Trump or whatever. 87:00 This is so much absurdly harder than that. 87:05 It's an incredible trap. 87:07 And it's effective, though. 87:09 I think it plays on some other psychological mechanism. 87:12 One of that is that some libertarians, especially some libertarian thought leaders and some Bitcoiners, they are contrarian. 87:21 So when we were surrounded by normies, being libertarian felt contrarian. 87:25 So we were feeling edgy and cool. 87:28 Now, by signaling our values and by selecting, I know, but if you signal your principles and you start to peer up with people like you, after a while, everybody around you is libertarian. 87:41 So in Bitcoin conference, yeah, we're all libertarian. 87:45 It is rational. 87:48 It is right. 87:49 If I think about that rationally, I know it's right, but it doesn't feel that edgy anymore while I'm surrounded by libertarians. 87:57 In order to feel back that way, I have to go back to normies. 88:00 I have to speak with my uncle. 88:02 So if I go back to normies, I rediscover how edgy libertarianism is. 88:06 But if I stay around libertarians, many intelligent people that enjoy too much to be contrarian, they will become post-libertarians just for the love of feeling different from the new social consensus around them. 88:22 It's a little bit like if the anti-poverty organization solves poverty, like, what do we do now? 88:28 Social justice. 88:32 Yes. 88:33 yes i am very much ayn rand i think has a quote that's like you can't just be against something you have to have something you know before something productive that you're aiming for and and i like a hundred percent think that is like a core part of the problem is that so many 88:53 libertarians have just identified themselves as against the government or against the crowd or against whatever and they're not they're not actually building anything or you know like if you don't have something to tie you to they don't have an anchor for progress yeah i got into 89:12 libertarianism because i was trying to do things and the government was in the way and if i get the government out of the way now i can do things and so whether i do that technologically or whatever that's not a I know what I'm doing if you just got into it because it was cool 89:30 to be against the government now what are we doing? 89:35 I saw somebody actually talking about the psychology of one of the reasons the left has gotten so has basically spiraled into this crazy more ephemeral and vague and hand wavy and can't even define anything sorts of 89:54 activism and these notions of like, like people don't have any rights. 89:59 And you ask them, it's like, well, what rights are taken away? 90:02 And then it's just like, people don't have any rights, you know, like it's a minority and all this stuff. 90:07 They, and they go to greater and greater extremes to places that they can't define and where they just associate feelings to get offended. 90:16 And like one of the reasons it's spiraled and it just naturally spirals so far out of control is that when all you are is against something and you're an activist, like you've defined yourself as an activist. If the thing that you're being an activist about is no longer 90:36 relevant or is, has fundamentally changed the conversation, like, like, you know, something it's like pushed out of the realm of government or something is that, well, now you have to go, 90:47 You just built this identity and this association that you're here solving the world's problems. 90:53 You're a hero because of what you're angry about, because of what you want to destroy, your justice incarnate. 91:04 The second that no longer your focus you just go back to being a normal person that has no career future that was an activist because their life wasn going anywhere and they were just exhausted and they had no idea what to do 91:20 And they're still a barista, you know, at a coffee shop somewhere, even though they have a, you know, $200,000 debt and feminine studies or something. 91:30 And so they don't want to go back to that. 91:33 And so they're so easily led, like just the tiniest amount of just hold my hand for a second. And here's this new thing to be an activist about. They just walk right into that because their identity is being an activist. So it's just, I just, I just get just so cleanly and easily pushed right into a different path of being an activist about this crazy thing that I never even cared about or wasn't even prevalent. 91:57 There's no, nothing of consequence ever happened in this area, but like now I'm going to make it an issue. 92:03 And then I'm going to be so obnoxious about it that people are going to argue with me. 92:06 And then suddenly I feel like, oh, this was the fight all along. 92:10 And I'm still an activist and I'm still the hero of the world. 92:14 And then it's just a cycle. 92:15 And like, they should never want to go back to being an old person. 92:17 I thought that was like so kind of like prescient or such a great part of like the human psychology of, you know, what happens when you go down these roads of just your whole world and your whole identity is just against something that you're not or something that you dislike and you have no anchor for anything to do after the situation changes. 92:43 Going to a bunch of ANCAP meetups, for sure, there's always been a significant percentage of the ANCAPs that are sweaty, weird, unfortunate people. 92:59 And Bitcoin, honestly, was a step up. 93:06 These were now the ANCAPs that actually had... 93:11 These are ANCAPs who take showers. 93:13 Yeah, yeah, pretty much. 93:16 Most of them. 93:18 No, no, I totally agree that the quality, the personal quality of people in Bitcoin is superior than in most libertarian circles because any kind of ideology which is in the minority will gather people that are not there because of rational understanding, 93:33 but because they feel their shortcomings, so they don't fit, they don't get results, so they are outcasts. 93:41 sometimes for good reasons like they have improved their life and their interactions and they just blame the scapegoat of society or the government or the Jews or whatever so it's very easy to have that in Bitcoin after a while at least 50% of the time it is the Jews 93:59 though, you got it in it at least 50% of the time it's totally the Jews yeah sure just a caveat in case anybody was thinking we were saying they weren't involved at all Most of your problems. 94:14 But the thing is that when you are in Bitcoin, you get some money. 94:21 You basically fix part of your life if you manage to not fuck it up. 94:27 And that takes away the pure resentment base for your ideology. 94:33 It's not that you are just blaming society because your life sucks. 94:37 Now your life is better. 94:39 You get a family. 94:40 you get life savings. And now, if you keep your ideas going, that must be not because you are just trying to blame your shortcomings on society. Now you are trying to defend something that you care 94:54 for in a positive way. So it's not that Bitcoiners are perfect. There is a lot of weird stuff going on there as well. Sometimes people that get, so these people become socially functional because 95:07 of Bitcoin, but they don't learn all the other things that can bring somebody to be socially functional. So you can have this kind of weird phenomenon that without Bitcoin, they would be outcast, but with Bitcoin, they are very rich outcasts. So they can now pretend to 95:22 be part of society. But I agree that the libertarians, that the amount of freak shows I've seen in my libertarian days before Bitcoin are not comparable. 95:37 we're the best libertarians for anybody for anybody who's listening there are no libertarians as good as the bitcoin libertarians so so here here's another thing that i've that i've been 95:55 thinking about like kind of off and on lately i think it is my like again all of this is very like you know, speculation. 96:04 Perfectly factual and verifiable and the AI agrees with me. 96:08 It is based on, you know, observations. I think that the world really, and maybe it's not so conscious or orchestrated, but there is some level of it, appears to be, that we have these, you know, inbred pedo families that are a problem in the world, right? The same 96:29 people that established the central banks are also the people that created Israel or did all these other things. 96:35 And so I think that we have these sort of, call them psychopaths or whatever, there's this very, very, very small percentage of society. 96:45 They have a tendency to align themselves with each other in a weird way because there's sort of a mutually assured destruction. 96:55 And they infiltrate high trust groups. 96:58 And so it is not actually the Jews. 97:00 I think it is actually just that you don't think so? The Jewish people were a high trust group that had a victim label that was very, very ripe for infiltration. But you also see the same infiltration in Mormonism in in like Black Lives Matter, Occupy Wall Street, everywhere, right, right. 97:23 Yeah, all over the place. And I think we have I mean, like, I'm fairly certain there has been some of that in Bitcoin community, too. 97:30 I think hopefully that the Bitcoin community is a bit more difficult to infiltrate. 97:36 I think the more you are built, your ideas are built in or based in reality and rational and your people are skeptical, you know, trust nobody, whatever, trust but verify, whatever the slogan is or don't trust, verify that it's harder to infiltrate. 97:55 But I think that we need, and maybe in the... 97:59 I think feedback is just faster. 98:02 That's fair. 98:03 But maybe in the networks that we're trying to build or whatever, again, reputation will help, you know, keep a lot of the chaos agents out or at bay anyway. 98:18 But I really think, I mean, because Noster's full of chaos agents, right? 98:23 Like this is like we do have our circles that we can kind of we know who we're talking to. 98:28 But if you go to, you know, broader Noster or whatever, it's it's you know, it's crazy. 98:34 And then there are people that are connected to, you know, people that are clearly like there is this alt right, whatever, like, you know, Anakin type humor that has been around for a long time that is really, really unhealthy. 98:49 but it's it's a it's a you know heavy presence in in like some of the outer rings of you know nostril social circles um and so like i think that there is a a need to if we're going to have high 99:05 trust groups or high trust society in general there's a need to like have defenses specifically be aware that these things are happening these people there are infiltrators always and that These things are like, you know, something. 99:19 I mean, I guess it's, you know, we need a network of validation like Bitcoin or something. 99:23 I don't know. 99:23 Nodes that all validate. 99:27 Yeah, I think that. 99:29 So one thing that you have with stuff like you said, Jews, Mormons, is also that this like ethnic or linguistic or religious proximity, They are the only kind of adversarial networks that can scale up. 99:48 So usually you have the group of friends or the family, but the scale is limited. 99:53 So you cannot perceive this kind of unfair us versus them conflict over resources at scale because families are naturally constrained and even small villages are naturally constrained. 100:07 what you get with this kind of particularly compact ethnic groups that are often results of migrations or persecution. 100:17 I've seen, for example, the Armenian diaspora. 100:21 It's also, they work together. 100:23 They trust each other even if they don't know each other. 100:25 It's like this kind of extended family, which is typical also of Judaism. 100:30 And I've seen it in Christian groups as well. 100:33 My parents, they were part of this Catholic movement. 100:38 And my parents, they are chill people. 100:41 But this movement became very, very strong around Milan and Lombardy. 100:46 And they got the government of the region. 100:49 And then there was a moment in the early 2000s in which this movement had basically was expressing most of the university leaders, industry, some judges. 100:59 It was a real low-key mafia. 101:01 They were not extorting money from people, that's the government, but they were hiring each other and ostracizing other people. 101:10 They became an in-group. 101:12 And that was done because they were previously a minority group during the 70s, during the most communist part of Italian history. 101:22 They were persecuted to some degree. 101:25 That creates this kind of unity at scale that then is perceivable. 101:29 But I don't think that it's surprising that any kind of group with a strong identity can create that. 101:36 In Bitcoin, I think we can rest assured that we are relatively immune, not absolutely, but relatively immune, because we created a culture which is very loose in terms of nationality, language. 101:54 It's very diverse internally. 101:57 Diversity is our strength. 101:59 could say if we wanted to go all gay and woke. It's very, it's very heterogeneous. And part of the culture is this slayer hero attitude, which sometimes when you are on the other, on the 102:13 receiving side of that, it hurts. Sometimes people will slay me and that's unpleasant. But overall, it's a protection to me as well, because it means that the incentive for an external agent of chaos 102:26 to capture me is lower because they know that people will just send me to fuck myself very, very easily out of nothing. 102:34 And that's a very good thing that is protecting me. 102:37 Even if they're not doing anything malicious or whatever, you might just get fucked because you tweeted the wrong thing after you got out of the shower. 102:44 In Bitcoin, you can become the bad guy very, very easily, which is a good thing. 102:50 It hurts in the short term, but in the long term will protect leadership figures from being very, very attractive for blackmail or any kind of external influence. 103:05 well and you see that a lot in the podcast world too is that as soon as a podcaster starts starts like espousing the the mainstream zionist propaganda or whatever everybody's like oh 103:17 he got the call or whatever and they just like their numbers drop and everything you know everything shifts away so that's that's it that is very good you know healthy development in the world i guess 103:27 yeah and it's interesting too in that way because i think part of it you know because in bitcoin you can get canceled for opinions on every damn thing like i feel like i was getting railed against by bip 110ers when i said one thing and then i was getting railed against 103:44 cortards when i said the next thing and i thought i was being consistent i had i had like i i felt like i had a view that made sense to me at least um but it depended on which way it sounded at any particular time i was just this biggest piece of shit you know um or i was 104:02 threatening, I was dangerous to people. 104:05 And and that happens on so many little issues because of the actual diversity of other beliefs. 104:14 You know, because like Seyfedine's got raked before by a whole subsection of Bitcoiners because of his stuff on climate change. 104:21 There is like a lot of diversity in other things and so often Bitcoin is the only thing we actually agree on. 104:27 And don't forget stainless steel, the pen metal, that was a big thing. 104:35 You bitch. 104:36 aluminum ceramic all the way okay cancel yeah that's it I'm done I'll never recover from that one the Jews would be fine I would have made it back from the Jews but ceramic aluminum pans absolutely not this is too much I think they've been more recently got nailed for simping 105:02 for Michael Saylor like this sailor fanboyism where in chapter 8 of the Bitcoin standards it says there's only one way to own Bitcoin which is by private keys and then he just blasts out how he loves how much Bitcoin Michael Saylor owns like direct contradiction yep 105:26 that's how it goes in Bitcoin and it's a healthier concept culture than what we have in the mainstream because it's so much it's like inflation we cancel so much and so often that cancellation is not that valuable anymore we can really hang out with 105:44 cancel people very soon because we just cancel each other every day over any kind of shit yeah i'm still gonna like if safety and says something good yeah yeah i get like railed against on 105:56 twitter or whatever i'm just like i'm gonna cut this off for i'll be back in a week i'll be back a week and I'm going to go get some work done and just let these bitches scream at each other in my thread and that's that. 106:12 Yeah. 106:12 It's not a permanent cancellation. 106:16 You know, it's not too late to do Bit.10. 106:19 You guys have been talking about it. 106:20 It sounds like you want to do it again. 106:23 You guys want to give it another go next summer? Give it another try. 106:26 Give it a year. Give it a year. 106:28 Give it another try. 106:30 I'm warming up to it, okay? 106:33 Now, finally, when the next folk war may be the one in which I can finally side with the defense. 106:40 So if they try to do some kind of quantum bullshit or stuff like that, I can finally play the part that can easily win, which is conservatism, which is highly asymmetrically advantageous in Bitcoin. 106:55 So I really hope that BuildBitcoin will try something like a sailor mandated quantum fork and I can finally try to resist a fork, which is way easier than enforcing a fork. 107:09 I hope it's tail emissions. I want that one to shut the F up. Like I want to be done. I mean, I don't think there's enough support actually for it to go anywhere. So it probably won't. But that would be a great one to see. 107:24 you know like black rock or somebody try to support make a bunch of fud about security or whatever and then support tail emissions and then and then we we throw that in their face and i get 107:37 i would love oh man i would feel like that activist who's saving the world again i'm running my node bitch so is the reason that we're not getting tons of spam now just because the the ai generated monkeys are not the best use of AI anymore. 107:55 People are just devoting their... 107:57 It just wore itself out. 107:59 It didn't have any economic legs. 108:00 It didn't have any economic legs. 108:01 I mean, there's still tokens and... 108:05 Yeah, has it gone down? 108:06 I'm not sure it's gone down a lot. 108:08 No, it did. 108:09 I think it did go down. 108:10 Has it not? 108:11 There's just the fees. 108:13 I was going to say the fees are just low. 108:15 I was about to say, I think it's just the economic weight of it is less. 108:18 like it's not it's not pushing fees up anywhere because they're only buying empty block space basically when they're doing it but yeah I think they're a buyer of last resort you know like when there's empty block space and the fees are one sat per vbite or less 108:34 they do it yes you know why not because we're not I think that the NFT hype was the cycle nonsense shit nonsense it was already going down on shit coins and the idea on NFT on Bitcoin was the last leg of the dying hype. 108:54 And so the actual expensive attempt to scam people with that stuff was at the very beginning of BRC20 and Runes, where there was actually fist spikes because of that. 109:08 Now it's just residual zero-cost trolling just because, yeah, why not? 109:16 but isn't isn't it hasn't it transitioned just away from images and to uh tokens like like runes inscription tokens where people are like minting their own token coins now using those inscriptions 109:31 i think it's the other way around i think that ordinals created the token systems and then the idea of inscriptions created some kind of narrative around the token and and then runes removed again the thing from this basic BRC20 on-chain footprint. 109:52 And now I think people are just keeping trading because these things are very diehard. 110:00 Even other sheet coins, they never really die for many, many years. 110:04 And you have this residual kind of trading noise keeping going. 110:12 I think it's also indicative of the fact you kind of have to change the narrative of what why it's worth something because the dull one just died it peters out very quickly um but um i do still think there will be tokens on top of stuff 110:27 but i don't think it will be like i don't think it's meaningful economic activity and the i think arc and lightning and these sorts of things where you're actually moving real coins just in a different way you get some sort of explicit feature or alternative network dynamics from 110:47 the asset whether it ends up being called ARK Bitcoin or whatever the hell it is And of course there be custodians too There be e and there be all this stuff But I mean that the natural Steve you mentioned this like very early There always going to be 111:00 alternatives like paper Bitcoin or something that has some sort of a specific purpose or that is created by some institution for whatever reason. And I think we'll just have a lot of that. And 111:12 And as we move into an area where a lot of that is programmatic or a lot of that is like actually a cryptography system or protocol, you get the easy version first. 111:23 You just like print some tokens on Bitcoin and then you sell them. 111:26 And it's like, you know, you like you, you've sell tokens of bullshit, nothingness before you're actually selling stock, like meaningful, like contracts or something, or a leveraged custodial thing, um, down the line. 111:42 So if there's, if there's anything of consequence that ever shows, I think the scammy empty version shows up first because it's quicker to do. 111:49 It's quicker to make something that's worthless, this meaningless, that sounds like the thing that's going to be worth something than it is to create something of actual consequence. 111:56 So I haven't tried to move my liquid coins yet, but I heard that everything is back up and running? 112:06 Yeah, one-to-one peg is back and all the most relevant peg out systems are operative. 112:14 So I am a very long-term block stream shill traditionally because of block size wars and because a friend with all the block stream people. 112:24 I don't like the way it was managed and solved. 112:28 People don't even know officially who put the remaining 600. 112:32 I think that the way the bug was managed at the beginning was very bad. 112:38 The way they managed the negotiation with the hacker was very, very bad. 112:42 Very arrogant. 112:43 A lot of Ubers, no acknowledgement of the failure. 112:48 And I think the way they managed the transition to the restoration of the bag was also similarly bad. 112:53 and now the lack of transparency about who put the 600. 112:59 I think I know because I know people behind it. 113:02 So I know it's good people that actually saved the day by putting their own private money. 113:09 But still, it was done in a very clumsy way, in my opinion. 113:13 To some degree, I think that I'm going to say something on treasures here. 113:19 the situation of this summer I think that cold card improved more than Liquid did because of the results of the hack so Liquid has been too lucky like Liquid learned nothing it's like what you say guy about MTGOX and FTX as opposed to bail out after Lehman Brothers in big banks 113:44 if you don't feel the pain out of mistakes improvement is hard because the moral hazard keeps growing because you were lucky. 113:54 You don't face the consequences of something and you don't really improve. 113:58 So in some way, BTC preserve the entire hardware world industry with a lot of suffering, which creating genuine improvement in many directions. 114:09 While this liquid situation, I am very skeptical that going forward, that the security of liquid will be vastly improved because there was basically no suffering to the users, no suffering to the owners of the network or the owners of the process. 114:26 So yeah, I will take some shit from my friends in Blockstream, but I'm not happy with the final result. 114:35 That's interesting. 114:36 I haven't kept up with it well enough. 114:37 That's good to know. 114:38 But yeah, good to know it's back up and running, but I have a hard time completely negating or rejecting that take or that suggestion that the lack of pain, it did not in fact just allow business as usual to some degree to walk forward even though it 115:01 produced pretty dangerous, pretty terrible results but they got over the pain of it very quickly. 115:08 If the hacker of Liquid was happening one week before the hacker, the hack of Kolkard, and by the same person not giving back the 85% of the amount, now Liquid would be the villain just like Novak is. 115:25 Now, this is a little bit unfair because Novak is putting a lot of effort in being the villain by the way that he managed after the hack as well. 115:35 But still, he has been somewhat unlucky to be the first symbol of evil. 115:44 And then I think Bloxima has been very lucky in being the latest and the only one with a grey hat hacker giving back most of the amount. 115:55 It was something uncommon that you will receive back 85%. 116:01 Yeah. 116:04 I think it might be another example of like fiat propping up companies that should fail. 116:12 I mean, I'm just going to guess that this 600 Bitcoin was obtained by some kind of VC funding with a fiat loan. 116:20 And just yet another example of, you know, this thing should go away. 116:25 but it's not because of fiat. 116:27 Yeah, it's so easy. 116:28 VC culture has so much freaking money. 116:32 Yeah, exactly. 116:33 So if I'm right, and I cannot confirm or deny because I don't have first-hand information, but if my suspicion is right, this is private wealth of a very generous Bitcoin whale, which is a benefactor and a patron of much of the Bitcoin industry. 116:50 and so it's not really it's not really an exchange for any equity or any long term VC but even charity even super generous and good faith charity can be heavily distortive at scale so it's not necessarily better yeah well I gotta run here in a little bit guys I was about to say 117:15 it's probably a good time to close it out Giacomo thanks for joining us man It was good hanging out. 117:21 On this somber note, I think I depressed everybody with this. 117:25 I killed the mood of it. 117:28 Oh actually can I just mention one before Giacomo I think me and you are on the same page with a lot of the quantum stuff Both have like a background in physics and stuff and just are just not impressed by it and think everyone's misled. 117:47 I have this conjecture that if there is a form of digital or a form of computing that outcompetes digital computing, it will be something other than quantum computing. 117:57 like if you give me the field of all forms of innovations in computing versus quantum i'll i'll take the field would you do that too absolutely yes one obvious case will be a resurrection of analog analog computers with to some degree they also connected to quantum but 118:17 they are classical analog computers they are very bad in terms of reproducibility and initial creation of the initial boundaries. 118:27 But for some specific tasks, they can be extremely efficient compared to digital computing. 118:33 Digital computers are super easy to reproduce and they're good in error correction, but they are inefficient to do something analog like you can do with Ohm's law for multiplication. 118:45 So now I don't think it's reasonable to expect analog computing having a comeback, especially in the field of LLMs and generative AI, because it's a field where you don't need error correction as much as efficiency. 119:02 It doesn't need to be perfect. 119:04 Yeah. 119:04 Exactly. 119:05 Yeah. 119:05 Exactly. 119:06 So I think that that's an example. 119:08 Another example could be even more exotic stuff coming from science fiction physics. 119:13 But I think that most people trained in theoretical physics know that there is a level, a threshold where you cannot pack any more information into physical space. 119:27 The most obvious being a Planck volume. 119:30 So there is a threshold there somewhere. 119:33 Where the threshold is, and if it prevents cryptography-relevant quantum computers, I think most theoretical physicists would agree with us. 119:41 Where the threshold is. 119:42 Yeah. 119:43 I think that it's very unlikely that we can ever get to 1,000 logical qubits. 119:50 So I completely agree with Steve. 119:55 It's so sad. 119:56 It's going to be like climate change, man. 119:58 This threat in the FUD is just going to persist. 120:01 Go on for 20 years until people just stop caring. 120:04 Well, because it's invisible and no one can reproduce it and no one can ever verify it and all they'll ever have is news stories. 120:11 So there'll be no way that this stupid stuff is going to go away. 120:18 Well, by the time it does, they'll have created another one. 120:21 It will when they have room to move to another one. 120:26 When the next one is ready to go and it's going to be meaningful, that's when they shift away. 120:35 I'm not 100% convinced that it's nothing, but I'm also not worried about it. 120:40 But also because we have solutions. 120:43 Even if I try to shut down my theoretical physicist mind and I will just accept that you can pack infinite information in Hilbert states, which we know is not possible, but even assuming that and even assuming the engineering challenges 121:03 of keeping millions of physical qubits without interference and without the coherence. 121:11 Even then, what you have to do in Bitcoin is pretty trivial. 121:15 There are attack at rest, which are the easiest one because you have a lot of time. 121:19 You just need a hash, which just means that we have to go back to P2SH, P2W. 121:25 We just go back to the pre-Taproot. 121:28 Or if we really, really want to do it, we go to upgrade Taproot with an hash with BAP360. 121:35 It's not a tragedy. 121:36 it's probably good in general to have a hash in front of the public key. 121:41 People did the public key because it saves a few bytes, but it's okay to have a hash. 121:48 And if we want to protect from attack on flights, the only thing we have to do is to slow down transactions. 121:53 There are already many, many ways without any soft fork to do that, including multi-seal thresholds with lock time, including the fake proof of work with the key length grinding. 122:04 There are so many ways to fix it that is not even funny. 122:10 So I don't know, maybe. 122:12 So I think that if we want to change taproot anyway because we want to go to the next V2, then maybe we can just put a hash on top of it just because. 122:24 But it's probably an overkill. 122:27 The good thing is that we can weaponize these to stigmatize address reuse. 122:33 So what I think I'm trying to do, I want to write to exchanges and suggest to my clients to write to exchanges that by enforcing address reuse, they're being quantum raped. 122:48 Yeah, so stop quantum raping me. 122:51 Don't do address reuse. 122:53 We don't have to go back to pre-Taproot. 122:55 I mean, 90% of financial transactions on Bitcoin are P2SH anyway. 123:00 I mean, Taproot is 90% inscriptions. 123:06 So I use Taproot because it's pretty efficient for the manuscript. 123:12 I do decreasing threshold. 123:15 You're the one? 123:17 Yeah. 123:18 He's the 1%. 123:19 My anonymity set is basically zero. 123:26 I've been watching you. 123:28 I was wondering who that was. 123:29 I was just Steve posts his blockchain analysis it's like it's all runes except for this one guy and I'm pretty sure this is attached to it there is there is three of us you talk about it all the time there is there is me there is another Liano user there is a guy doing 123:47 single seek with Taproot and there is a guy doing Taproot channels so it's four of us so you can never say which one is me okay four of us you have no idea I'm okay with pay to key or you know that's the script path spending. 124:02 The key path spending on Taproot is pretty cool. 124:05 And I think there are a lot of legit financial transactions and key path spending on Taproot, just not the TapScript stuff. 124:12 The thing that you did, Steve, that blew my mind that I was like oh my God that so it so duh And then you would have to have some sort of an implementation Like it would have to be a standard I think this should be considered like address reuse 124:25 when it comes to Taproot of putting in a fake branch. 124:30 Because the thing that you had pointed out was that everybody is using Taproot with this idea that it confuses what branch they're using and they have no idea what's in the thing. 124:41 But there's a hash of the one branch that they're using is the hash of the whole script. 124:46 And it's like, there's nothing else there. 124:48 It doesn't mean anything if you... 124:50 It's like 96%. 124:52 Yeah, you have to write a dead branch that doesn't do anything and you'll never use. 124:56 Yeah, it's like privacy. 124:59 It's like, well, you just... 125:00 I mean, you can check the hash. 125:01 You have no privacy. 125:03 Like, you even know exactly what your transactions look like. 125:06 They don't want privacy. 125:07 They want it to be inscripted. 125:09 They want it to be published. 125:10 That was the major use of Taproot, was to reveal your transaction. 125:13 It was the opposite. 125:14 It was the opposite. 125:14 It was the opposite of what it was advertised for. 125:17 That's funny. 125:18 Oh, man. 125:19 Yeah, we messed up a little bit. 125:20 I still love Taproot as a design, but I think that we could have done better with it. 125:26 I think it's also just that we didn't need it. 125:29 I love the keyspin. 125:31 Yeah, keyspin is dope. 125:33 Keyspin is awesome. 125:34 Efficient multi-sig VA keyspin, awesome. 125:37 Yeah, and Frost, what you can do with Frost, what you can do. 125:39 And without Tupperware, we could not have ARC in a reasonable way. 125:44 So Frost, Schnorr aggregation is very, very cool. 125:49 Schnorr's awesome. 125:50 Yeah. 125:51 And eventually, I think that even partial mercilization of the script path, eventually it will be useful. 125:58 For example, right now, I can easily do a very, very complex multi-seal that I could not do with P2SH. 126:05 It's just that the design was probably over, the nerd sniping of the design was a little bit excessive. 126:13 We were after the block size war victory and the core developers, they were like divinities and they started to get nerd sniped a little bit on byte optimization and like the control block. 126:27 The entire construction is a little bit probably over-engineerized or something like that. 126:38 No, that makes sense too, is that there was a sense of cohesion and direction after the block size wars. 126:46 And we overcorrected and got to like, oh, we're definitely right about all our decisions. 126:52 and the pushback fell away, you know, because most of the pushback forked off. 126:59 And, you know, in the same sense, BIP110 was a similar thing. 127:03 There was a lot of pushback and then BIP110 forked off. 127:05 And so a lot of that pushback disappeared, but luckily not a whole lot was happening. 127:10 And so nothing has really changed in the term since then. 127:15 But had we been in the bulk of like, oh, we're going to fork and we're going to do all these things. 127:19 We're going to implement these things like we were in the block size where it's like, well, then a whole bunch of things just kind of get ushered in because the winners are socially on the same page. 127:28 So, yeah. 127:30 Anyway, we should close this out. 127:33 We tried to do that 20 minutes ago. 127:35 Thank you, guys. 127:36 That was my fault. Sorry. 127:38 No, it was great. 127:39 It was great. 127:40 It was good to see you, Giacomo. 127:41 It was really a pleasure. 127:43 Great conversation. Thank you, guys. 127:44 You're never invited to the roundtable again, but I'm going to send you an email saying we had a great time. 127:50 And that you are welcome anytime. 127:52 And we should do this again. 127:53 But just so you know, that's just me being polite. 127:56 And we'll talk later. 128:00 Legit. 128:01 All right. 128:01 See you guys. 128:02 All right. 128:02 I'm good. 128:03 Later, guys. 128:08 All right, guys. 128:09 I hope you enjoyed that episode. 128:11 I've got so much stuff in wings. 128:13 Like getting so close to the edge. 128:16 just so you know, Pear Drop has its first version out into beta testers in the Play Store. 128:24 I'm still trying to figure out keys and like API connections to the App Store so I can kind of automate this going forward as we get to the place where we're pushing a lot of different 128:34 parts of these tools and the stack that we've been working on out and making them available to people. 128:40 uh and so pair drop pair drive is getting much much closer to something real and concrete in fact i'm gonna have my wife and a good friend of mine using it for the purpose of transferring 128:55 stuff like for the reason that you would use the app like not because i mean yeah we're testing but i just think it's actually going to be the best way to accomplish a few things that we're working 129:05 on. So that's super exciting to start to really feel this in genuine action with people who literally just need it because it's a very useful tool. And yeah, so tons going on under there. 129:20 Be sure to follow. Don't forget to check out the Guys Take YouTube channel. It's literally G-U-Y-S-T-A-K-E. 129:26 still very small but we have been putting a lot of work into these videos and i i really just love the format i love doing the content this way i think we've stumbled onto something that really 129:41 is kind of fitting the the middle ground of all the stuff that we're working on so uh happy with it and more reads to come i know i've been lax on those but that's mostly been about production and workflow and all of those things. 129:55 Shout out to Giacomo for joining us today. 129:58 We had so many things to cover and Giacomo always has a really fun and interesting opinion. 130:05 Mad respect for him and always a hell of a good time. 130:08 So don't forget to follow Giacomo, Steve, Simple Steve, and my brother AgorisView on all the socials. 130:17 Follow the YouTubes. 130:18 Get yourself a bit box. 130:19 Make sure to use our affiliate links. 130:21 It helps us out. 130:22 and, you know, helps you out, gets you a discount. 130:26 So stay tuned. 130:28 I'll catch you on the next episode of Bitcoin Audible. 130:32 Until then, everybody, that is our two sets. 130:52 you
Community discussion