0:00 What's more than likely going to happen, and I've said this since Larry Fink launched the ETF and it's looking more and more true, is they're going to tokenize Bitcoin. 0:07 So what that means is you're going to have Bitcoin in the ETF and they're putting self-custody as a bad thing. 0:13 They're putting spot exposure as a bad thing because centralized exchanges aren't good. 0:16 So they're like, look, BlackRock, Fidelity, buy my Bitcoin. 0:20 I'm going to give you a tokenized exposure. 0:22 She gets quote unquote self-custody, which we know is nonsense. 0:25 And you can lend against it. 0:27 Oh, God forbid you're hacked. 0:28 We can reverse the token. 0:30 You can get all the properties of Bitcoin you can lend against. 0:32 And you can see how that's a great story. 0:33 Like that's the game that's being played. 0:51 Welcome back, guys. 0:52 This is Bitcoin Audible. 0:54 I am Guy Swan, the guy who's read more about Bitcoin than anybody else you know. 0:58 We've got Michael Tanguma on the show today, a good friend and one of the many, many people that I was lucky to know before they started building something really cool. 1:10 And I got to know them and then see the things that they built and the reasons that they built them. 1:16 And this one is is really interesting because the question of custody is so crucial. 1:21 If Bitcoin is about anything, it's about sovereignty. 1:26 sovereignty to choose who to trust sovereignty to control without to choose where to trust and where to take full responsibility or i guess to take full responsibility of who and where you're 1:38 trusting things um how to manage your setup how to protect yourself it is about freedom it is about the ability to have full control to make choices about those trade-offs and there's absolutely a 1:52 balancing act there. It is not a simple black and white. There's so many layers of nuance and custody itself, custody solutions can so easily be a Trojan horse. They can so easily be a trade 2:08 off that seems small upfront and then ends up very, very big and very consequential on the back end. 2:16 And so I wanted to have that conversation. And Michael is just perfect and on ramp Bitcoin, the company that he and that they have built over there um is i think is a perfect example of trying 2:28 to figure out where those trade-offs are and the nuance and how to make a very different and very new digital environment work in the future with all the promises of sovereignty and control that 2:44 are available and mitigating so many central points of political or custodial or techno technical risk that exists out there um and so this was just a fascinating discussion we talked about all sorts of different custodies we pushed back on the idea of multi-institutional custody 3:03 and governments and just how many how many problems there are in the scope of the problem of controlling and keeping keys safe. 3:14 And I think these last couple months have been quite eye-opening to the realities of how nuanced and difficult all of this stuff really is. 3:25 And so I think this was a very timely conversation. 3:28 And it was also just fun, good to catch up with Michael, and always, always fascinating stuff. 3:35 So I would definitely, if you haven't listened to a chat episode in a while, This is one to sit down and let it slowly soak into your brain because I think there's a lot of really good stuff covered. 3:47 With that, don't forget to check out the Bitbox. 3:49 Speaking of responsibility and holding your own keys and sovereignty, get yourself a Bitbox hardware wallet. 3:55 Again, my favorite setup and always my recommendation is to get at least a hardware wallet or even a couple and spread your stuff out. 4:05 Use a multi-sig, simple multi-sig. 4:08 my favorite is a card like a tap signer or a sato chip and then a bit box and then a mobile key two of three it's a very easy very fun setup uh you can be um liberal so to speak with your backups 4:23 especially of your like configuration i know that's a little bit complex and out there but if you're looking for a simple like easy wallet it's just really clean really fun to use um bit box has a wonderful stack and I am actually putting together a whole bunch of details on 4:41 like just like kind of like my custody rules and the things that I've learned over the years and considerations and just like what a simple setup looks like and the options that are out there you 4:53 know what everything has a trade-off right what are those and I can't I can't just like repeat them like with a really dry frustrating annoying list every single time I mentioned custody so So I'm putting a resource together on the website. 5:07 So you'll find that at BitcoinAudible.com. 5:10 I'll get the full URL or I'll post a thing so that you can easily find it on the website. 5:16 With that, don't forget to subscribe. 5:19 Don't forget to share this out with everybody you know. 5:22 It is time to get into today's chat with Michael from OnRamp. 5:26 Bitcoin is custody a Trojan horse. 5:32 Oh, how about you? 5:34 How have you been? 5:36 You got a thing. 5:37 Y'all been building stuff. 5:39 Yeah, it's been good. 5:40 I mean, the world, it's interesting because like, I know the world's been crazy the past few years, but I can't think of a crazier time than like we sit today when you think about, I mean, specifically, I think, I mean, there's a lot of different anecdotes, 5:57 but the one that we just obviously come to is when people look at the markets, when they look at like, how do I preserve my wealth? 6:01 and I don't think there's ever been a wild or more uncertain time because you look and it's like well where do you put like traditionally right you know I have to kind of like learn these things 6:10 because we maybe came from this allocation where it's all bitcoin but the reality is most of the market is not there and most of the market is you know that has money is in a 60 40 portfolio and 6:21 they all got put into this ai trade and got put in to the magnificent set of any other exposures through that and there's no fundamental basis on why except for everyone's doing it and so now you 6:32 have like you know ai is this natural bubble that everyone could see now there's obviously insane things happening but at the same time to be like so allocated to something with the lack of 6:41 fundamentals i don't know how people do it uh we obviously know bonds or negative yielding but like even the bitcoin trade for you know or what bitcoin is is uh i don't say it's in question 6:50 but from the market's perception it's definitely questioning the sentiment people don't think about anymore i think it's a funny thing you look at gold um you know as great as gold is as money like 6:59 it's still taboo i would say gold is as taboo to normies as bitcoin is in the sense of like where would you buy it those people don't even know where to buy it so they would be like i know people that 7:08 want to buy it that don't even know they don't like make the leap because they're afraid they're going to lose it or like they'll they'll get scammed so when you look at it through that lens 7:17 you look at geopolitics you'll get energy it's just like people don't even know how to preserve and where to like think about it. 7:21 And while at the same time and why it's so pressing is because inflation is just ripping a hole through everything, even though people don't talk about it is like the substrate of like the dollar is fundamentally dying and you see this everywhere you go. 7:32 So it's been an interesting journey. 7:33 I mean, I kind of pinch myself because a lot of this bear has been a blessing because we have so much to build out. 7:39 Oh yeah. 7:40 And I thought every, all the realization and the awareness around what we're doing would have been at 250,000 or 170,000 as a price appreciates my knowledge of building like collaborative custody previously. 7:50 and seeing like when the craziness happens, whether it's the price appreciating or deleveraging like BlockFi, FTX, Celsius, everyone goes to better solutions, more decentralized, redundant, et cetera. 8:00 I would have never forecast today I was going to rip through the market like it did the past six months, specifically the past three months, starting with a cold card all the way to this week with Ledger CEO saying everyone's going to get hacked. 8:11 And now everyone's like, oh shit, we actually don't have a solution if Bitcoin's $250,000 because that means bad people are going to come for it at my home. 8:18 At the same time, these institutions can't be trusted with it. 8:22 So it's been, it's been a fascinating ride the past couple of years. 8:25 I feel like we're just getting started, but also we say here where Bitcoin's like $68,000 and we're probably all like just tired of looking at the same price for the past five years. 8:36 Yeah. 8:36 Yeah. 8:36 That's how I feel. 8:37 My, I got my obligatory text from mom. 8:42 It's like, are we worried about Bitcoin yesterday? 8:45 And I was like, no, we're not. 8:47 It's just the same old, same old. 8:50 Don't you remember we were here three months ago? 8:54 Like this is, we've just, we haven't left. 8:57 We just haven't left the zone for like five years. 9:02 The best one was my grandma, you know, God bless her. 9:04 She's 83 and we don't talk about finances. 9:07 Don't talk about investments, anything. 9:09 She just knows I'm involved in this like thing. 9:11 And she had talked to me, I think when I saw her, she goes, is everything okay after FTX collapsed? 9:17 So it's like, everything's fine. 9:18 Like, I mean, the price is in the gutter, but I've never used that platform. 9:22 I have no idea, you know, what I would use it for. 9:24 But yeah, I think our lens compared to what most people on the periphery, I mean, it's the same thing with like NVIDIA right now. 9:31 Like everyone's just like going down these rabbit holes of whatever the mainstreams are versus like what is actually really happening on the, you know, whole front with China and open source, et cetera, et cetera. 9:41 Yeah. 9:42 Yeah. 9:43 It's funny. 9:44 I think it was Francis. 9:45 I just saw this morning when I was wasting time, avoiding getting out of bed. 9:52 I opened up Twitter, and this is terrible. 9:54 It's the worst thing to do first thing in the morning. 9:57 But Francis posted a thing about the NVIDIA CEO, and I saved it. 10:01 I haven't read it yet, but I saved it about how we need open models. 10:07 It was like a month ago, you know, and then it's like, and then all this stuff drops, but he just got on Twitter, And he was just like, we need open frontier models just as badly as we need closed frontier models. 10:18 And open models are the best way to deal with the safety issue was part of his thesis from my skimming of it. 10:29 And I've felt that same way. 10:31 And I've seen other people mirror that comment or that idea that it is really the heart of safety and AI and alignment. 10:43 I don't even like that framing, honestly. 10:47 It's become like a bad meme. 10:52 But, well, there's no such thing as alignment. 10:56 See, I kind of feel that same way. 10:59 I really kind of do. 11:00 It's just like you're chasing a unicorn. 11:03 Like this idea that we're just so certain we're building a god. 11:10 Like there's so many people who are just so infatuated with the, the, the sci-fi like fantasy narrative of what this thing is, you know, like of like the God is so I'm, I'm listening to a, if you build, if anyone builds it, I'm almost, 11:29 there's like a 10 minutes left in the audio book. 11:31 If anyone builds it, we all die. 11:33 And it's the most ridiculous fear porn stuff. 11:36 Like, like all I can think is that all you really have to do is, is have a serious understanding of economics and understand why none of this is going to happen. 11:45 And I'm not saying that AI won't cause disasters. 11:47 October has been nothing but disasters that are related to AI. 11:52 You know, like all the hacking and all the poking holes in every piece of the internet right now. 11:57 Of course, there's going to be horrible transitionary pain. 12:02 But this idea that we're going to create this super intelligence that can't even be rivaled or somehow exists in this super simplistic, uniform, standardized environment that can get into everything and kill everybody at every corner of the world. 12:18 And it's just going to wipe out all of human existence. 12:20 And there will be no, I'm just like, do you not understand? 12:23 All I feel like you have to do to understand why that's not going to happen is to understand that general intelligence is horribly less efficient than specific intelligence. 12:33 Like specialization is the reason that's not going to happen. 12:36 And economics kind of explains why, like, no, we're not going to just get one giant generalized model that just has this arbitrary desire to make more paperclips. 12:45 And then it's going to wipe out everything on earth as if there's nothing else that exists. 12:50 And there are no other pressures in this environment. 12:53 It's like just saying they're like, well, the lion's the strongest thing in the jungle. 12:55 So obviously it going to eat and destroy everything Yeah You know Yeah I think I i come very like left left bell uh uh left side of bell curve and this this notion of like in 21 when this stuff was first starting to take off i had 13:11 this just like aha uh of like the reason why like none of this stuff you reference will happen is because at the end of the day like again this is very like simplistic but it's like somebody has to 13:21 plug in the AI, meaning like somebody has to pay for the energy. And if energy can either be created or destroyed and comes from some level of proof of work and economic value, like to get that 13:32 energy, you're going to have to pay in Bitcoin. Like that's just the system. Like in a theoretical like fiat world where stable coins are the only thing, maybe you can make the case that whoever 13:41 had the monopoly on money could create some crazy system to continue to stay on. But if you haven't open money eventually the system will need that until like when you kind of extrapolate now there's 13:53 more learnings that was just like back five six years ago it's like the closest you can get to alignment is effectively how to coordinate economic activity and everyone's chasing that money and it's 14:03 the same thing we're going to see play out where like alignment it's very inefficient to go and destroy and do these things versus what is like the natural equilibrium um and yeah drew drew comes 14:13 at it from like a bonsol comes at it more for me uh that's right he had a really great piece i think i read the piece i think i read he had a good piece about that you'd really like it he had a 14:23 good podcast recently with danny knolls and um he comes at it from like the metabolic kind of efficient when you think about a human and how we like you know just resources how we leverage 14:33 resources it would be nonsensical to believe like and i would be want to be inefficient um paolo also had a recent uh podcast i was i don't listen to a lot of his stuff but uh from tether it was 14:44 this notion of like it's kind of nonsensical for us to believe like ai we're going to understand the uh languages they like agents speak to each other and like why would it be english right like why 14:53 would they make their own language and when you think about that and you think about uh machine to machine uh intelligence and payments like you're going to need the thing that is like native 15:02 for and you're gonna need the thing that has better properties you're gonna need all these things that would like directly point to a finite store of value. 15:12 And I think that's the closest thing you get to alignment because in a world of abundance, you need that like notion of everyone's chasing a lines on there's this one thing that I'm objectively trying to get. 15:22 And if it doesn't produce that on some economic way that I'm not going to participate. 15:26 And sometimes there'll be bad actors and they'll go rogue. 15:28 But then more often than not, as humans, like we're aligned with moral integrity. 15:33 This is the notion of why like a lie is so like blasphemous or out there. 15:38 It's because everyone tells the truth. 15:40 Yeah. 15:40 So when you hear a lie or the same way like crimes, because most people do not commit crime. 15:43 So like, why would the intelligence go out and be doing all these crazy things? 15:48 So, yeah. 15:49 And then in that kind of the same notion is that the lie eventually runs into reality too. 15:55 You know, like it has its own negative feedback. 15:57 like the the lie is meaningful because it is a falsehood because reality is going to punch you in the face if you continue with that the longer you continue with that like no lie is arbitrary 16:09 arbitrary at the end of the day um and uh and then in the same way like i always think about it in the the drastic oversimplification of insanely complex environments and the the different pieces of the puzzle. One example that always comes to mind is Bill Gates and the Gates 16:33 Foundation. They did this experiment with government, which is really kind of like bonkers crazy when you think about it. But they engineered, they genetically engineered mosquitoes to be infertile. And they, um, and so they made this huge, this massive population of mosquitoes 16:55 and their intent was, it was like somewhere in, I don't know, some African country or whatever, where they're like, whatever the consequences, if it turns into utter disaster will be people 17:05 that nobody cares about. Right. Um, so they did some deal with some corrupt government over there and they released all of these mosquitoes into the wild. And the idea was to control the mosquito 17:16 population. Like it's not even like a terrible idea on its face. Like, you know, obviously we're trying to stop malaria. Right. Um, and, uh, and they had all these predictions and models about how it was going to stop this percentage of generations of mosquito and all this stuff. 17:35 And, uh, and that if they carried the gene, there was no way they were going to be able to reproduce. 17:40 And it was like three weeks later, the population was right back where it was. 17:43 And they started checking the mosquitoes and all the mosquitoes were carrying the gene. 17:47 All of them were having babies. 17:48 It was like, it was like in no time at all, the whole like multi-year, like God knows how much money plan was just like gone because the complex environment just did not behave the way they thought it was going to. 18:00 And what do you know? 18:02 They cannot actually account for every possible genetic or environmental factor in the whole mix. 18:09 And all I can think about when it comes to like intelligence, solving all our problems are predicting what humans are going to do. 18:14 It's like as soon as you say a prediction out loud, you've changed the outcome. 18:18 You know, like it's like the human environment is the least predictable thing ever. 18:24 Like there are some like maybe big trends or whatever that maybe you can like, you can point at or whatnot. 18:33 But it's just like, it's like the price mechanism. 18:36 Like as soon as the price exists, it's no longer, like it's an input and an output. 18:41 Like it's all just a circle. 18:42 so you can't you can't know it's like trying to predict where every molecule is going to be when the wind is blowing like you know hours later if you're off by a billionth of a of an a millimeter 18:55 on any one molecule at any one point there's nothing is right now it looks like pure randomness in in 10 seconds you know um so anyway yeah i mean what's interesting about that is like when 19:11 you say about lies that's really where the money kind of like when i when i um not because this is a bitcoin podcast but because like it just my mind goes there is that like the money has been such a 19:22 lie when you think about the distortion of forget about capital allocation like the notion of deleveraging right like the 08 was a great example it's like we have things that there's moral hazard 19:32 embedded in the system you get bailed out and there's a bunch of things that should not exist that continue to exist. 19:37 And as like more liquidity comes in, you distort more of the signal. 19:42 And so that's like, that's why like this thing ends up, if it all works out, all this stuff we've talked about, it's like it ends up being a renaissance because you're ultimately going back to like first principles of like money doesn't grow on trees. 19:53 Because if you understand money doesn't grow on trees, then you have to like start to discern and derive where does money grow on. 19:58 And then from there, you can build everything up. 20:00 That's why like the food, the vaccines, all these things start to become very present once you understand Bitcoin. 20:05 because you have to look at the world for what it is, not for what it was told to you as because the money is fundamentally broken. 20:11 And so I think that's really where it gets hard for just in general, even us, like, you know, thinking we understand a lot of this stuff, it's like we just get caught. 20:19 Like, I don't know, we have a, try to find guys, love them, and we'll, I guess, sometimes call them like the Fed speak and they're getting better at it, but it's like, oh, it's 2.3% and jobs aren't there. 20:27 So it's like, A, inflation's not 2.3% or 3.3%, it's closer to 10 to 15%, just go and like go to your local grocery store. 20:33 but then even the jobs in like that we're like doing well as an economy when you like just see your friends you look at the layoffs you look at kind of closing of small medium businesses there's 20:43 just this huge distortion uh and there's like the first second and third dimension so like all stories and the first dimension when i think about is like the traditional media when you know our 20:53 parents and they go on cnn or cnbc if you're ever a hotel or gym and you're like god like you always look at it just because you know like there's some style happening there then the second order now is like social because social was meant to be like this place, 21:05 but they just poured it over a different form factor of manipulation. 21:09 And then there's a third dimension of like, okay, so what are the incentives between all of us? 21:13 And then what is the actual truth? 21:16 And we're still so far from like that becoming aware, including with this like whole NVIDIA stuff. 21:22 Dude, absolutely. Absolutely. 21:24 And when you bring up inflation, it just made me think I was, I was messing around with Pear Drive and just like kind of scrolling through the memes and gifs uh not too long ago um uh testing out like my player interaction how quick 21:39 streaming response was from a different machine and i just happened to come across this tweet that i had saved and i thought this was so great in the context of like how bullshit the inflation 21:52 numbers are and how how much people are getting squeezed while being gaslit into into basically thinking that none of this is a problem. So this is, I don't know who this person is, some Jennifer, somebody random. But she said, my husband and I were talking last night 22:13 about how a 12 pack of drinks is $9 now and how in 2020, I used to buy them four, four pack of the drinks for $10. So like that's a huge one is now $9. I decided to go back into my Walmart app and see what I was paying for a random grocery order. In January of 2020, 22:36 I paid $70.20 for 30 items. 30 items. Nothing is less than $5 or $10 now. $70 for 30 items. I added all of the exact same items to my cart again and repurchased them today. Those same 30 items were 22:57 $165.42. That is a $95 price increase in four years. That's 135.6% inflation. We can't go on living with it like this. I can't be the only one who feels this way. It's not 2% inflation that takes groceries from 70 to 165 in four years. Like the, the capacity to believe nonsense. 23:29 If the, the political apparatus just says all the same things enough times and just gaslight people like that's insane. But like, I know, I know that's true. Cause I just know how much like our grocery orders are insane. Like they're absolutely insane. Like I just, 23:48 I think about it like it's like half a mortgage, like, you know, just to just to fill up a grocery cart, especially God forbid you buy like organic stuff, stuff that's just not got, you know, 5% glyphosate in it. 24:05 And we try to do that. 24:06 We try to buy whole real foods and we're heavy on meat and protein. 24:12 Jesus Christ, God forbid you have a pound of just skirt steak or something. 24:18 That's like $28, you know, it's like, just like, just guard, just insane prices. 24:25 Yeah. I mean, I think that is really where maybe some of the anxiety comes from of like, you know, it's not sustainable for much longer. And so like, it's like, well, what is going, what's the next shoe to drop? Because that's where I think there's a direct correlation with how insane the world's kind of getting tied into this. 24:40 like uh you know people there's only so long you can get squeezed before something kind of happens whether people do things or um it's just not sustainable that point around the food you see 24:51 this around the small medium business with like restaurants growing like it's really sad because you think about and this is where a lot of people lose this idea of like the debt and inflation 25:01 they're so ephemeral when you think about the numbers and what does it mean for me but at the the day it's to your point it's all inputs and outputs so like a restaurant is great because i 25:10 like i remember this viscerally during covid at this taco shop in a small town i live in it's like they had put um you know like market prices for for tacos tacos are a couple dollars right and 25:21 there's market prices based on because the prices were changed so much and i thought like this is the stuff you see when money dies in a third world third world country and it was just this notion that the only way that firm stays alive, because we live in a free market, 25:34 is, well, A, like, they have, naturally restaurants have a problem because it's not that they're not the greatest business acumen, but they're focused on this one thing. 25:43 A lot of people start restaurants because they like to cook. 25:46 And so when you focus on that thing, you may lack the competency or focus on like, okay, well, what are my limes now costing? 25:54 What are my, like, lettuce? 25:56 What are all these things? 25:56 So you don raise the prices in proportion to where that goes So then something gets squeezed and you make less money on your margins or you start to degradate the quality of it You start to put the crap of your food The services get worse And so people naturally start going 26:10 because they stop going because the services get worse. 26:12 But then eventually they see that because the economic ramifications, they close. 26:15 So they have to raise the prices. 26:16 But when you raise the prices, it doesn't just mean the same amount of people by the same amount because those people are getting squeezed. 26:22 So you get less people coming in and eventually you go out of business. 26:25 So it's just a, it's a wild visceral loop that it's a wild loop that you can't like get out of unless you're going to hold a harder asset because that firm across the street will be less exposed to that if they're holding a harder asset because now you just have more optionality. Maybe you can stay at par with the price because you're naturally have that offsetting it. You have just more ability to, you can't insulate yourself from a harder form of money if you're a business or an individual. 26:53 mm-hmm yeah you know i'm curious what um you mentioned the ledger ceo saying uh so ledger ledger guy with the device was it was there another because i know there was a ledger data hack that was just like emails and stuff and then there's the crypto billis 27:16 and the ledgers themselves actually being modified. 27:21 Yeah. 27:21 But he recently came out and said, and I'm pretty sure you commented and I like post about this and stuff if I remember correctly, about the CEO saying everybody's going to get hacked. 27:34 Like, it's just all of them. 27:36 It's just, it's all up for grabs and it's all going to get hit. 27:39 I'm curious, what's your take on that? 27:42 What's your take on that? 27:42 Because like, there's part of me that's like, I mean, like we're going through heavy transitional period and everything is going to get hit in some way in the sense that like there is going to be face smashing and computer smashing against things and testing every corner. 27:59 And I know there's I got some rumors of like, you know, update your lightning node very recently as well. 28:07 And there's already been a couple of those situations and BTC pay server and all this stuff. 28:13 but there's this sense that I think is wrong that I think is kind of dangerous in some context that like self custody is dead and that you can't keep Bitcoin safe and maybe even Bitcoin is at threat or at risk from being a legitimate money because you'll never be able 28:38 to keep anything digital safe and i know this is close at your heart it's just why you guys are doing what you're doing so how do you tackle that how do you how do you square that yeah um so i think i mean there's a 28:59 lot here i think one of them is you know he said the quiet part out loud which is a fundamental objective truth in that everyone will have something bad happen to them. Like you can, you can take the case that he's not there and like, maybe he's a house builder and he's like, 29:15 everyone's house eventually will have some catastrophe happen, a house on fire flood. 29:21 What would your take be? It's like, well, yeah, I guess that's obvious. I should probably buy some insurance because if the house burns down, I can't get knocked out of the game, the economic game, 29:32 right if i took a million dollar mortgage and i put a hundred thousand and two hundred fifty thousand dollar down and the house burns down well on the hook for the whole thing if i don't have insurance i don't expect it so i think he kind of said the thing that is like should be 29:43 obvious to people it's like something bad will happen at some point and you have to be prepared for that um and part of the context for him saying that was he was getting squeezed because they were 29:53 referencing that you know he had this hundred million dollars ninety million but for round number is a hundred million um so where i come from is a like you know caveat because i have to um we we wear you know these like uh vests and we we play a part and we are a part of like 30:13 you know regulated and and working with trad five but at the end of the day like i'm as hardcore as you could imagine as far as it relates to where bitcoin is important what sovereignty means you 30:23 know, I sit in the middle of like this property in Texas because of a lot of things and a lot of it came from post-COVID and just the reality of like not having that happen again where, you know, 30:32 you have to kind of control your own destiny and fate. But at the same time, I'm also just a student of history and technology and I was way interested before I ever found Bitcoin into just general tech 30:44 and how things scale. And there's a reality that if we maintain the way we exist today, at the solutions, Bitcoin just won't scale full stop. 1,000% won't. Because think about it. If Bitcoin is at $70,000 and everyone is either capitulating because we're not getting exposed 31:01 because of all the risks that exist out there, and they do exist, how are we going to go to $150,000 or $250,000? Because if we just park that thought and let's just go to $250,000, most people get 31:13 excited about the price exposure, but we forget that a bunch of risk gets inserted in the system. 31:17 Like, let's forget about TradFi and the funny business they'll do with what happened with BlockFi, Celsius, FTX. 31:23 And those same people work at the same firms. 31:25 There's nothing that changed differently as far as like moral hazard built into financial services. 31:29 But just add the awareness because right by definition, if the price is $250,000, well, there's much more awareness on the asset. 31:36 Not only from a mainstream perspective, but just the notion of more people holding the asset definitionally means more people know about it. 31:42 Well, it would be non sequitur and it would not make sense that bad actors wouldn't know it exists as well. And so when you take that price is moving directly and maybe even faster than the price moving is AI. And the hardening of the systems will always kind of for the next maybe a couple of years, decade, will be disjointed between the models and how do you harden systems. 32:05 and there's no reversals here right this isn't a stock or bond so you basically have this immutable ledger and this is why not your keys not your coins was developed as a standard because you 32:15 don't know where the risk lies and it's why people that treat bitcoin as money meaning material over 10 keep them on hardware devices that worked when the price was ten dollars or a hundred bucks but 32:25 now everyone's hacked it's been hacked all their kycs out there so you can pretty much um get down to almost 99% of Bitcoin holders. 32:33 Chain analysis was hacked. 32:34 So they have, you know, they're basically the CIA of, you know, the ability to discern who owns what. 32:39 And now you have $250,000 Bitcoin. 32:42 And again, it would be the logical conclusion to believe at that time, the K shape has widened, right? 32:49 From here to 250, let's just say ultra optimistically, we're at 250 in 12 months. 32:53 Well, we already just admitted inflation is insane. 32:55 What happens 12 months from now? 32:56 It only accelerates. 32:57 So that price appreciation also means more and more people are desperate, more and more people are bad actors we don't have to talk about what happens when water lights go out for three days and how humans turn into you know animals really quickly and when people are deciding 33:11 on how do they make ends meet how people are trying to make their food put on the table how nation states are getting squeezed and they're now it's not just lazarus group but there's 33:20 globally people sanctioning whether it's physical bad actors where latin america you talk to people in la they come up career professional criminals that will come up and they cut off the this is 33:30 firsthand knowledge of being explained they'll bring industrial style magnets to find the safe before they get in the safe they cut off the power they cut off the backup power they cut off the wi-fi 33:38 and they're looking for diamonds and gold right now uh what happens when they realize oh these people have this digital bearer asset that's not you know ten thousand dollar rolex it's 250 000 33:48 and 2.5 million dollars so you put that whole like that whole thing and you have the existing holders that we'll have to figure out, but then you put the rest of the world, which is 99.9% of people. And then you have to explain like, well, what do you do? And majority of people, 34:09 whether it's right or wrong, will say, I'll just take a negative yield in bond, or I'll take an overpriced equity market, because at least I have volatility of NVIDIA losing 20% of its market cap, 34:19 but I'm not going to get killed for it. And it's not going to take my whole portfolio out. 34:22 and so like you just play that out and that's why we build what we build that's what we work on we work on and it also ties into like when you look at industry there's a very big common misconception 34:32 and fallacy of everyone has their own version of what they want to do with custody and i believe that is kind of like not true in the sense of if you go back we're like in the 70s of the personal 34:43 computer era where everyone it was the nerds and the hobbyists that's how early we are in bitcoin in my view. Just wanted to interrupt for just a second is that I find it hilarious that because 34:53 I've done this same thing in my head is that, you know, I guess maybe five or six years ago, it was common to be like we're in the 1990s of Bitcoin or in the 1990s of the internet, right? 35:05 And this is the era we are in Bitcoin. But the further we move forward, the earlier I think we are as opposed to the later. Like it's like every year we progress further, I think we're another year earlier. 35:19 And I totally agree we're in the 70s or the 80s of the internet because we still don't even know how to build or interact. 35:28 I think people just don't appreciate the difference between irreversible push system and reversible credit-based pull system and just how deep the dichotomy is. 35:43 The two worlds are when the foundation is literally upside down. 35:50 Like it's just a different mechanism. 35:52 And how many things built on top of that do not apply? 35:56 How many practices? 35:57 How many cultural norms? 35:59 How many familiarities? 36:01 Like what all has to be rebuilt? 36:03 Sorry. 36:03 I just wanted to say that because you said we were in the 70s. 36:05 And I thought that was funny because five years ago we were in the 90s. 36:09 Yeah. 36:10 Yeah. And before going back to that, like a great example to contextualize it so it's not all like ephemeral is the notion of like Netflix and Blockbuster. What I like to think about what we build is like three dimensional solutions to what people are laying on two dimensional solutions because they believe it's a two dimensional problem because they think of physical assets versus digital and like digital bearer. 36:30 and Netflix knew Blockbuster was dead 10 years before Blockbuster died because in 96 they use the internet to ship the CDs and Reed Hastings knew that the internet he was waiting for the 36:43 bandwidth he's a student of technology understanding that once the bandwidth got to the level he was building out the infrastructure the brand awareness to be able to like bypass the physical layer so 36:52 Blockbuster doesn't pay attention for first four years they eventually like late 99 2000 start to ship the devices well Reed is just continuing to grow that business by 2002 three four the internet gets to a level where you can stream and then 37:06 blockbuster you know it takes a few years but it's done and so this is a similar concept with like it's just not in the awareness and understanding which is gives us a huge opportunity from people that understand this including 37:16 what you're building on the file stuff so so now going back to the 70s the way to like analogize if like you go to 70s and I got a lot of this really good books specifically Steve Jobs' book around you had people showing up to meetups like we've done for 37:31 the past 10 years and everyone will argue about what's the best custody setup in the same way back then they would argue what's the best personal computer setup from RAM to hard drive to the 37:40 motherboard to the desktop and then eventually you had entrepreneurs I think it was compact in Houston but the easy example is using Gates and Jobs and Microsoft and Apple and saying okay well 37:53 there's a lot of value to be delivered and getting a computer well do people really care on how it's done if it just works and if i can just have it delivered it opens up i can get my value and i can 38:04 close and jobs love the quote of the bicycle for the money what's the value that you can get in that macbook and all the work you do right so that's very valuable they've been one of the 38:10 most valuable companies before this ai boom and so that's how i think about like standardization and like yes in the same way everyone has the right it's what makes it work in self-custody in the same way everyone has a right and will make AI work 38:22 because you need the open source models to compete. 38:24 But as the stakes get higher and the sophistication gets higher, it gets further and further out for the ability for people to do that. 38:32 And if we were always in that world, we would never scale. 38:34 Another example is cars because back in the day when Henry Ford was building cars, they were for people like out in the sticks that were using it for farming and the different things. 38:43 You had to be a mechanic effectively. 38:44 And if we expected everyone to be a mechanic to drive a car, then we would just like have, you know, 1% of the adoption of cars. 38:50 Some people can still work on cars and drive them, but majority of people have no idea how to change things. 38:54 So the point being is like, when I think about multi institution, what we do is like, we just ship MacBooks. 38:58 It just fucking works You don lose your money Uh and then different people pick their percentage and how they do it But like going back to standardization is it a very like nice thing for very quote unquote sophisticated people in this space to say, 39:11 everyone can pick and has their own desire of custody. 39:14 And I think that's increasingly becoming non-true simply because how many people can understand the entropy that was generated on a private key? 39:22 I mean, I can't like on a just like picking up a hardware device. 39:25 And so point being is industries, standardized like in the same way this phone when you know you go back to the early 2000s when phones came out they all looked different now they all look like this even if they're not 39:36 iPhones in the same way cars look the same I was about to say was that an iPhone because I don't even yeah I don't even know you can't tell you can't tell anymore yeah so iPhones right like 39:44 and that's true when you go to a restaurant or you see people you'll see phones and you're like is that an that's that looks like an Android because it's not but it looks like an iPhone and same with cars look like cars laptops look like laptops screens look like screens and so 39:56 when you think about standardization, especially in this world with a digital bearer asset where everyone can get hacked and by definition of operational security, you can never know what a third party firm is doing with their custody. So you can't trust them. 40:10 But on the opposite side is you have this like pipe dream of the hardcore Bitcoiner, which was like, I'm going to live in a Citadel and I'm going to have my guns and nobody's going to come. It's like, that's completely not true because a bigger Citadel will show up 40:24 and take your money. This is why banks existed. This is where trust still exists. We don't want to live in a world where we're going to show up and have to test all of our food. When you think 40:32 about just like the flourishing of society and coordinating economic activity to do anything, we need financial services. We need trust. And so that's how I think about like how this plays 40:42 out and what he meant is he's saying the quiet part out loud. The reason why you don't hear this is because nobody has a solution. And now the problem is actually becoming apparent and it's becoming a parent simply because AI really like, you know, 40:54 kind of came out of a white or black swan, whatever you call it, this past year, and it's just wreaked havoc. 40:58 And that's at $70,000. 41:00 Imagine $700,000. 41:02 Yeah. 41:03 Yeah. 41:07 So. 41:08 I gave you a lot there. 41:10 Yes. 41:11 I will say just in kind of a general big picture view, I'm pretty solidly sold. 41:21 I'm not like, oh, never have anything on one key, because I still do have a couple of wallets that are kind of like working wallets that are just behind one key. 41:32 But I am as sold as it can be on multisig. 41:39 I still think there's some oddities in the implementation and standardization of it that need to be worked out. 41:51 But I've been personally like ass saved by multi-sig at least two times now. 42:01 And with the cold card, it was not just one save. 42:07 It was every one of my main setups. 42:09 every every one of my big like my my safes of all of the things were saved by multi-save every one of them and it was just because i kind of nerded out on it i didn't even think it was necessary 42:25 really like i just loved the idea of creating my optimal setup it's kind of like the pair drive and the the engine and the pair drop all the stuff that i'm building over there it's like i just wanted to do it the way that I thought it would be cool to do, you know? 42:40 And I knew, like, I was doing something that was, like, more secure, and I was, you know, not susceptible to one vendor or one brand of thing, and it was kind of like an esoteric protection because I just didn't think the hardware wallet was going to F me, you know? 42:55 Like, I just didn't see that, the entropy problem coming at all. 42:59 um and uh and then like that night uh i was up all night um not i was i was trying god i was trying to i was texting my one of my best friends in the whole world um all night long it's like i was like 43:14 literally i know you i know you got to go to work early but like just if you get this person it's like 3 30 in the morning four o'clock in the morning and i remember i was sitting on the bed 43:22 and uh i had uh i have this big case that's just like hardware walls because i just you know i geek out on this stuff and so i just have like slotted things i have like so many wallets and i had them 43:33 all out on the bed in the room like just spread out in front of me um and i had like my little like reading light thing over there and she was like going to sleep it's like one o'clock in the 43:44 morning she was like this is a bad one huh i was like yeah it's pretty bad i'll see you in the morning um uh but like multi-sig multi-sig literally saved my ass um and now i'm just like i don't 43:59 want to put like i even put um uh a family relative very recently we switched her stuff over and um she is on a bit key now um i almost i almost gave her a bit box where i had one of the keys in Nunchuck, but I just felt like it was going to be just that setup was still a little 44:24 bit too technical for her. Not like the hardware wallets or the stuff themselves necessarily, but of course she might have a problem with the button stuff because it's a little sensitive. 44:37 But really it was just about the fact that I wasn't sure if I wanted the responsibility of being a part of it when I knew that she couldn't just do it by herself, you know? Um, and I was actually really impressed with, with, uh, that Harvard wallet and that set up. Um, and I feel 44:56 like she, she really kind of got through it really nicely. Um, but I've been, I've still, I'm still like talking to friends and getting things moved. I'm going back to my best friend and we're going to do a setup that is multi-sig with a bit box and all that stuff. Um, but dude, 45:12 I will never I'll never do I will never recommend anything that doesn't have multiple keys anymore and I'll I will always be trying to find the most optimal or easiest to use interface for that you know what I mean yeah we should nerd out on this because this isn't a 45:29 this is definitely not a shill but I think I would kind of like say the opposite I want you to push back and tell me where uh where you you think there's holes because um 45:38 I think that yes, like full stop multi-sig for majority or large percentage of holdings makes rational sense in the same thing of everything. 45:49 I mean, that's literally what we're building on top of multi-sig. 45:51 Like you can go as far as saying like, you know, being around and like I talked to a lot of clients because when you go visit, right? 45:58 And you've been in a space for a long time, you get lucky and you realize how blessed you are. 46:02 And like I would see you're on that side as well. 46:04 We're like, this is all we've done for basically 10 years, however long, right? 46:07 Like every conversation is like this from like consultations to clients to investors. 46:11 But like most people don't live there. 46:13 So that's why meetups are important and other things because you get to go talk to like mine and podcasts are so important because you get to like have the affirmations and like to come back to like, okay, I'm not crazy. 46:23 But going through that process and understanding, the one thing I will say that I understand with 100% certainty is any multi-sig setup where somebody's setting it up themselves and has unilateral control has inherent scalability issues, full stop. 46:37 and whether and this is direct hand of building collaborative custody because this is how these ideas came about is as and they manifest in these weird ways it's a weird example but it's like the 46:48 idea of how big was uber's market cap most people looking in the world in a two-dimensional way would say it was just caps when in reality it's like once anybody can have a ride and you lower that 46:58 cost you basically tend to a thousand x amount of people it's the same thing of saying well how do you prove that there's inherent scalability issues well one of them is some people won't 47:07 get exposure if they have to do this other people will get rid of their exposure because of the concern because at the end of the day the price will always push people into being uncomfortable 47:14 it's the same thing with like 10 bitcoin at 10 dollars is the same thing theoretically as at 100 000 or a million but the idea of i will my descendants will never forgive me if i lose this 47:24 because the stakes that metaphorical device gets so much heavier and so what somebody does uh and then so now you start to go down the stream of okay multi-sig redundant it's native to the 47:36 protocol. If Bitcoin is successful, that will be the reason why. This is going to sound heretical. 47:41 I'm fairly confident it's right. In a lot of these things, we haven't needed the first 15 years. So the next 15 years, these will become more apparent. Is that Bitcoin could work at 25 million or 15 47:50 million. 21 million is arbitrary. The fixed number and the fact that there's non-inflation. Again, I'm not saying I want any of this. I'm just making the case that gold worked and had inflation. 48:00 Bitcoin could still work. The thing that makes Bitcoin different than gold is obviously it's gold with wings it works in a digital age but it's the fact that you can insert governance at the asset layer because it's technology that's where gold failed because it's centralized and 48:13 you ended up with too many claims in the most simplistic version but the problem with individuals and multi-sig is this is why casa and unchained exists because collapse like multi-sig is insanely 48:24 hard for somebody to do when you think about wallet configuration files xpubs derivation paths and needing to keep all that and then manage it because if you do it right it should not all be in your 48:34 house. So now you have multiple places. You've got to store seed phrases, hardware devices, the backups, that gets really complex. That is like rolling your old LLM for most people. 48:43 So then if somebody is going to do it for you, then you end up with a trust issue. And if you're known to do it for a lot of people, because I was holding a lot of keys for a lot of people 48:49 and I'm chained. And then I realized I had to get out of that position because I'm now a target. 48:53 So then you go to collaborative custody. And then most people I've seen either a never stood it up because they didn't understand because it's a lot to understand in these firms that do it. 49:03 it's kind of unscalable. So you have like one hour call. It's a lot for somebody to get on an hour to take all their assets. And most people stick with the status quo. So I spoke with people 49:11 firsthand that left their money on BlockFi because they just didn't understand it. And they shouldn't really do it because if you don't understand it, and then the people that just like blindly did it 49:19 is they put the C phrases in the hardware devices, like right there in their desk or in their safe, which is its own single point of failure. I was in LA and a guy said he was using 49:28 clap custody at both keys in a vault in his safe. A fire broke out. The wildfires in California. He was in Mexico. He had somebody have to break into his house in a cornered off area because they 49:39 shouldn't have been with like shirts over their face to go get his hardware devices. So you see where this like scalability starts to like bleed in. We're not even talking about the physical 49:47 attack vector or what about the offensive attack vector? What happens when somebody needs like dynasty trust? We just had a guy on board for 1200 Bitcoin. He probably owns 10,000 Bitcoin, and maybe more, but he needed dynasty trust. 49:59 Well, why does somebody need dynasty trust? 50:00 Because they probably think that the system lasts longer than we'd like. 50:04 And there are tax consequences if he passes away. 50:07 And so if you get those assets out of their state, well, then you're not giving the government. 50:10 You can't do that outside of it. 50:11 I'm not saying it's right or wrong, but it's the notion of these are just things that people with real wealth, if we expect it to come in. 50:18 And so when you continue to take that to its progression, you're ultimately, it goes back to putting the burden on the individual and where I've ended up. 50:28 So like I was a long time collab, cover custody maxi. 50:31 Like I was in the middle of it, believing it with my soul. 50:34 And it wasn't until starting to build this business and having the discussions. 50:37 And really specifically I was in the middle East one, one week and I had stuff in the house and my wife, you know, us guys, maybe we don't listen as best as we should. 50:46 She told me that there was somebody working on the cabinets. 50:48 And I was like, wait, what? 50:49 Somebody's in the house. 50:50 Because when you think about collaborative custody or multi-sig, you have all these pieces and theoretically it helps but it also hurts because you have an increased attack surface so if i was a bad actor i would start putting the pieces together and i 51:01 would find out where the c phrase is and i would figure out if i could get a picture of it but i would put it exactly back where it was because now i have one piece right you can start to put 51:09 it together so i'm like well shit now my attack surface is open because somebody's in my house i'm not there with it and so the what i've come to and i truly believe this is the most sophisticated 51:17 version for a lot of people is the barbell approach and the barbell and this was me you mentioned having all your box of tricks the other day is I was doing this before I left LA because I 51:27 was trying to figure out without going too far I had my own issue with cold card because I'd done the barbell right cold card passport passphrase cold card issue went down I was like I don't know 51:36 what's going to happen I don't know what's safe so I moved everything I was like I know multi institution I'm moving the rest of my money there but I also love that metaphorical bar gold I love 51:46 that like sovereignty and so before I left I was like I need to figure this out and I went and started setting up cloud custody and all the devices, the ledger had the bit rot where I couldn't see the screen, the treasurer stopped working because of the dongle. 51:59 I was just like, my God. 52:01 And so the thing that I've come to is this idea of large percentage of wealth, whatever somebody's comfortable with, all the value prop that we offer. 52:09 But then the other side of that, and it's whatever risk, is effectively a device that you can add entropy or verify, you know, feeling good about like being open source. 52:19 I think the foundation is a good actor. 52:21 I think they do things the right way. 52:22 So that could be a good device. 52:24 Adding sufficient passphrase and then cloning that on another device, meaning the seed passphrase, and then having that seed backed up. 52:31 And why I say that is because now you theoretically could always have that C phrase somewhere. 52:37 As long as you remember your passphrase, you can have it in your wallet. 52:39 I'm not saying to do that, but you can have it where you can always get out and you have that metaphorical bar of gold, your sovereignty. 52:45 You feel like you have access because in multi-sig you don't. 52:48 It's a pro and a con. 52:51 And then you have these clone devices. 52:53 So that's what I've come to the conclusion because now you have that oh shit money that's available to you without all the complexity of multi-sig. 53:00 And then on the other side of it, when the market realizes like that $250,000 moment where all these bad actors and people are there, it's like, I don't own any of my wealth because that is a market structure problem. 53:11 Nobody kidnaps anybody for their equity portfolio or bonds. 53:14 But in this world, if it's known that we can manage it, even if it's multi-state, it means that we have control. 53:19 So that's anywhere. 53:20 I think independent of what's right for us that's been around for a while, we have to think about the rest of the market and what is the form factor they'll use. 53:30 And I always liken this deal. 53:32 In this phone, Elon Musk uses it, Trump uses it in the same way we use it, in the same way multi-institution pensions use it, somebody with 3 Bitcoin uses it, somebody with 1,200 Bitcoin uses it. 53:41 It's like technology democratizes pretty significantly via the form factor. 53:47 Yeah. 53:48 There's a lot that I agree with. 53:50 It's difficult for me to, like, I still recommend multi-sig, but I do so with the caveat of like, you really need to know what you're doing. 54:00 And that's where I believe there's kind of like a simpler multi-sig. 54:09 It's to not go too hard with your multi-sig so that you have easy recovery. 54:15 And what's funny is that part of what I'm doing with PairDrive and that sort of stuff is actually about that is that how do you make sure that you can safely not lose at least two of three? 54:28 You know what I mean? 54:29 Like how do you actually make that setup feel like it flows properly? 54:36 And, you know, dealing with backups and all that stuff. 54:39 But I totally agree, actually, when you mentioned foundation. 54:42 I had not actually broken out. 54:44 They had sent me a device and I felt really, really bad because I had not actually broken out and played with it. 54:50 But now actually one of my favorite setups is a BitBox 2, the Nano and the Foundation as my two hardware keys. 55:01 I really, I really like, I'm really enjoying that. 55:04 And they're both open source. 55:06 They're both, you know, like I can verify a ton of what's going on there. 55:11 But I also got to recommend just because I keep having conversations with people about this for just like general audience stuff. There is nothing wrong with taking a totally offline old laptop, sticking Bitcoin core on it, unplugging it from the internet and generating a seed phrase and some addresses and then sending Bitcoin to those addresses and using that. 55:37 Like there is nothing wrong with the old fashioned, like one key that's never online and never connected to anything. 55:47 Granted, it has all of the caveats of like you have full control and now you have to treat that seed phrase like a bar of gold. 55:55 I am also a fan of kind of like the passphrase wallet, but I've also lost money that way. 56:02 I learned some really, really hard lessons on not knowing exactly the nuance of very, very secure password versus brute forceable if I needed to brute force it password. 56:17 So everything, everything comes with trade-offs. 56:22 Yeah. 56:22 Everything comes with trade-offs. 56:24 Yeah, the passphrase thing, that is where you have to caveat for all of one's wealth. 56:29 I would highly suggest against it simply because I've seen this happen firsthand where like to your point people have lost significant wealth because of case sensitivity, etc, etc. 56:36 And our brains are interesting creatures, right? 56:38 Like something bad happens or maybe it doesn't and you don't even remember what you did. 56:43 But I will also give them a plug because they sent me this and I finally used it. 56:48 And I owe them, you know, like it really is slick, the new prime. 56:52 and I think the reason why I would suggest and I think it's just more palatable for people was something like this because at least you can call them and get support where any role on your own ends up really hard simply because this is how I went down the rabbit hole 57:05 was like I couldn't talk too many about this whole thing and I knew I had to get my assets off of an exchange and I was scared shitless to put it on a ledger. 57:13 That was all that was around at the time and maybe Trezor but ledger was the dominant deal but then like being alone on an island and having nobody to call and that's what led me down the collaborative custody rabbit hole in this whole thing 10 years ago. 57:25 But yeah, the pairing of this is really nice because you have that form factor with the iPhone and then it gets really slick because if you have a passphrase, it'll pop up. I was telling people they didn't know this. You have the passphrase, you can add it. It'll pop 57:35 up on the phone. The second you get rid of it, it'll take off the phone. It's pretty slick. 57:39 So anyway, Zach and the guys, hopefully, don't trust Verify. 57:43 We've already seen enough of this in the industry, but they've operated very good actors. I think he's a good dude. Yeah, anybody should check it out. 57:51 if they're looking for new hardware devices. 57:53 Yeah, hell yeah. 57:58 So Binance happened. 58:01 And this is kind of gets at the heart of the whole multi, which I don't even think we've mentioned OnRamp yet. 58:08 And I don't know where this show officially starts. 58:12 But we'll figure that out in post. 58:14 Don't worry about it. 58:16 But so the company, your company, OnRamp, is multi-institutional. 58:24 And Binance just got hacked. 58:27 So I am curious, like institutions get hacked. 58:31 And I want to know, how do you think about... 58:38 Like there is a trade-off to knowing how safe the setup is with another party because you know their setup. 58:48 and then there's a trade-off with not being able to verify or no and then trusting the institute like what's the what's the auditing process of like okay this is a safe institution to hold keys 59:01 with this is this is a person i'm willing to work with you know like what's the degree of direct visibility versus trust that you guys have in that whole side of things and what's the what's also the protocol without being like, oh, we call up Bob and Bob has all his keys in the 59:23 thing. Like without being like specific, what's the protocol for like, what goes, what goes wrong with when an institution gets hit? Like let's say Binance is an institution in your multi-institutional 59:32 custody. What, what does that look like? Yeah, it's a great question. I mean, there's a lot to impact. I think one of the core ones is I can speak to requirements for custodians to participate and what we do. 59:45 I can speak to processes and operational controls. 59:49 And in general, it's worth even talking about consumer grade key generation versus what an institution does. 59:56 And the fundamentals, it's like night and day. 59:58 But at the end of the day, it always comes back to trust me, bro. 60:03 And it truly does. 60:04 And so this is by definition why you should never trust a single entity. 60:08 Because when you think about it, from a pure operational security perspective, how can coinbase is the the big you know the elephant in the room credibly show an auditor or somebody their standard and then hope it never gets out and they just increased and included 60:25 attack vector and so you'll never know any one entity's key ceremony key generation process you can surmise what best in class looks like and i can talk to you about it and i can tell you fairly 60:36 confidently the institutions we work with and what they do so we can go there i will also say that there is kind of like a misnomer or fallacy built into like when an institution gets hacked goes down because we have to remember like we have to segregate first and exchange like 60:52 Binance, FTX, BlockFi, these firms that do these other things like they didn't actually lose cryptographic material. 61:00 They didn't get nuked. 61:01 They didn't get nuked because I think that's generally what people think about. 61:04 They got API attacked. 61:06 They got API attacked. 61:07 They were insolvent. 61:08 They were Ponzi. 61:08 But like, if you think about it, like their keys and the way they set them up are still there, they can still sign. They just lost the asset, however you want to decide they lost it. So it's not like they just go down and go away and everything's lost forever. So I think that kind of gets lost because like even theoretically, if God forbid, one of our custodians lost money, because most of our custodians are custodians, they're not necessarily operating in a speculative asset running cryptocurrency or like other things have different checks and balances on their systems and custody versus like the exchange. 61:37 Pico is a great example. They've been good actors at the trust company, which is custody versus like the exchange. 61:42 But point being is, so if Binance, to your example, like I can guarantee you Binance is sophisticated. 61:49 Now, there's all these questions on like, how did they lose the assets? 61:51 Like what you're hearing versus what happened. 61:53 But either way, for the cold assets, any sophisticated party in this space effectively segregates Bitcoin from crypto assets because Bitcoin has native multisig built into it. 62:03 And so they have that Bitcoin offline. 62:05 A great example and great actors is like Alex Leishman at River. 62:09 He talks about using multisig. 62:10 He talks about he had a great tweet. 62:11 Somebody said, what would cause River from not losing this? 62:13 He's like, well, first off, I don't hold $5 billion in a warm wallet, right? 62:18 But as an exchange, you need some level for withdrawals. 62:21 But anybody with a brain, and you can consider BitGo as a great example of this as well, is you segregate crypto and use multi-party computation, which is its own proprietary cryptography. 62:31 That's a whole other right. 62:31 We can go down if you want. 62:32 But then anybody that is doing things the right way is using multi-sig for native Bitcoin, and that sits cold storage offline. So in this world, if Binance was a partner, and they did have a custody arrangement with us, and they were hacked, all assets would be perfectly fine and secure, and they'd still have access to those keys and nothing would happen, right? Maybe from an optics perspective, there'd be issues, but from a pure structural perspective, there wouldn't be. 62:54 now maybe it's worth explaining how multi-institution works because a lot of people there's a lot of misnomers or it's hard it's easy but also hard it's the same thing as bitcoin easy but hard and bitcoin 21 million finite supply of money same thing multi-institution multiple 63:10 institutions no single one can move it or lose it but then it's like how does it actually work because that's how i have to learn how to trust it um and by the way same thing will happen with 63:19 bitcoin as multi-institution is we're in the adoption phase where two to three four percent of market penetration, we'll have to get it. 63:25 And the rest of the market will just understand that Bitcoin is a savings technology in the same way the rest of the market will standardize, in my view, around, I don't go to an institution that can move or lose the asset. 63:35 But when you think about three layers of security, the first layer is multi-sig, native to the protocol. 63:41 You have three institutions participating. 63:42 It can be up to whatever multi-sig scale bill is, call it 12 or 15. 63:47 You don't need that. 63:48 It would confuse people. 63:49 But you can imagine in a future world, ETFs are probably 305 or something like that because it's rational. 63:55 We're in Bitcoin's a million dollars. 63:56 Why would you want a trillion dollars sitting with X entity? 63:59 I don't think the market will allow it. 64:01 So you have each institution participating in that. 64:04 That's the custody arrangement. 64:06 Now, from a legal perspective, this gets even more important because every wallet is segregated, on-chain, and verifiable. 64:13 So every wallet is like the client has that wallet in title from a legal perspective because that's the thing a lot of people lose is that we still live in a rule of law. 64:22 We still live in a court system. 64:23 We still plan on it to be available to us. 64:26 And we have to remember, most people aren't as passionate about this asset as we are, and they don't want to die for a trade. 64:31 And they increasingly don't, even if they really are passionate when they have their kids and their family, their wife's going to kill them if somebody breaks in their house for this hardware device. 64:38 And so the legal component is huge because not only do they have title, they have direct relationships with the custodians. 64:46 So those custodians are entities. 64:50 They're regulated. 64:51 They can go to jail if they do not adhere to the legal relationship that multi-institution adheres to. 64:56 So each of the custodians has to work at the behest of the client via video verification 65:00 direction So that the second layer is like you have legal and then you have to video verify with each institution before the assets will leave We do have Lloyd of London insurance on top The last layer is I look at game theoretical This is the beauty of it. 65:12 It's very similar to like Bitcoin is that the institutions, because they're segregated, you can make the case if this was one pooled large wallet with $100 billion, there's a large enough honeypot and a long enough time horizon. 65:25 You can get through the operational controls of both organizations to manipulate and move a transaction, but they're not. 65:30 every wallet is a segregated wallet. And because of that, you need multiple operational failures to happen at the same time for just one wallet assets to be lost. And so it makes very little 65:41 sense for collusion, not only because you go to jail, but because you're only able to take X amount of Bitcoin in one wallet. And when you play this out on a long time horizon and Fidelity and these 65:52 other firms are not going away, I fully believe they will participate in this because in the same way you can't insulate yourself from a harder form of money, a custodian and financial service 66:00 firm cannot insulate themselves from a harder form of custody. So it's the rational thing that institutions and individuals that are using third-party custodians will go to the place that leverages this. Because why would you go to a place that can move or lose the asset at the 66:13 same time people are moving and losing the asset? So I'll pause there. Hopefully that answers some of how it works and then I can go kind of in the direction. I was about to say, there are a couple 66:23 different ways that we can go um and you know i think one i want to push back i want you to be direct and push back harder the harder the better no okay well that's that didn't sound right but 66:38 but uh but no really i genuinely i think we didn't we just we just ninja launched but i would have told you before i genuinely appreciate like the the dot like uh the knife fight or the bullet the 66:47 live round so whatever you got because it comes up every day on questions so i appreciate anything that you can poke holes or want to talk about, I'm happy to dive in. 66:57 Of course, of course. 66:58 Like I want to, and I know you personally, and I knew this would be fun. 67:03 But it's also like I increasingly think just from like a sentiment or kind of a cultural, just a security standpoint, just a security standpoint is that like we're in the era where security only comes from blasting the hell out of things. 67:25 Like the red teaming and all the stuff with AI. 67:28 I do this with multiple, with my agents, the pair drive stuff that we're doing almost daily now. 67:36 And I'm thinking of setting up a cron job that just does this for me, where I literally just, I tell my agents to like look at the history of attacks we've tried against the system and come up with something new. 67:52 Be creative. Go for a couple hours. I'm going to sleep. Give me a report in the morning. 67:57 You know, like of just like try to break this thing. 68:01 And I increasingly think that the only way that we get through this AI era or this transition without total disaster is that way, is that we just we just pound the ever loving crap out of stuff ourselves. 68:15 before the other guys do. 68:19 But there's got to be something that keeps you up at night about multi-institutional custody. 68:27 Like there's got to be a caveat or a point of failure that makes you concerned or is the thing that keeps you thinking about the next evolution of this or where to go or what the new layer of the new problem to solve is. 68:46 So Bitcoin's a million dollars. 68:48 What are you scared of? 68:50 Yeah, it's a great question. 68:54 And it's interesting because I have folks that reach out that are clients and friends and they'll say, I want to do X, Y, and Z. 69:02 I'm like, sure, we have Guardian and these other things that are permission levels above it. 69:05 And I'm like, I forgot how it went down, but it was like, everything's fine. 69:10 And they're like, no, this isn't the time to be fine. 69:12 you got to be uh you know paranoid i was like brother i was born paranoid this is all i think about and i don't and and so the point is is that everyone's fallible everyone can get hacked 69:24 according to um you know uh by hit ceo actually i found out said this as well as the deal what i go to sleep at night and i sleep like a baby is that i can never move or lose my client's assets 69:34 and um now to your point this is an evolution and the price appreciates and the game theory and risk increase and so you need to map to them but as far as it relates today um that i feel very 69:50 confident there like the thing that i and it's not the most commercial say but i'll say it is like the biggest risk i see in its time is really like um the notion of government intervention right and that's the thing that's out of our control like if you're putting me on the spot 70:08 And it's like, what would be the thing that could really do this? It's like, look, we are all regulated entities. We live in this rule of law, but the world's crazy. And in that world, those things are out of your control, whether it's you going to jail or your other counterparties going to jail, and then they do things. 70:23 Now, there are reasons why I don't believe that would happen today and why it wouldn't necessarily happen to us. And the main one is because, you know, there's a lot of reasons, like Parker talks about this a lot of this notion of like, they could not ban booze and Bitcoin is 1000 times more valuable than liquor. Right. And so it's like, how are you going to ban Bitcoin? But if you were going to attempt to ban Bitcoin, there's a lot better places to go, meaning honeypots, centralized custodians, because you only get really one bullet. 70:52 So that's why I don't necessarily think it's an issue today. Now, in the future, I also necessarily don't think it's an issue simply because the game theory, I think you see more of the tightening of regulations. You see the intertwineness, specifically in the West, if I think Bitcoin and digital assets are geopolitical importance, and they're going to do what they do to every other asset and work on compliance and regs and taxing and all of that. So I don't think that is an issue. 71:16 But the way I would think about it or how do you combat it is you build out the custodial network because you change the logic of violence. 71:22 And what that means is like you fast forward 10 years. 71:26 And in my vision, I believe that there'll be custodians that we bring into our network that are all over the world. 71:31 And individuals will pay appropriately based on what relationship they want with those. 71:36 At the same time, our technology is being used by others and they don't, the client doesn't have a relationship with us. 71:41 so they can pick their own cores. 71:43 Because that's the thing that most people build in in Bitcoin and crypto myths is that Bitcoin is money before it's technology. 71:48 And money requires financial services. 71:50 Financial services are relationship-based. 71:52 Where are relationships? 71:53 They're local. 71:54 So it makes zero sense to try to be a Coinbase. 71:56 It's like we can offer private banking services and then we can leverage our infrastructure. 72:00 Others can leverage it and own the client relationship. 72:02 But that's a whack-a-mole situation because you have different keys and different configurations. 72:07 And you can imagine in a future world where as a private client, let's say, I'm not saying you have this, but let's just not even you, just any person has a thousand Bitcoin with us. 72:15 Well, they can pick if they want 500 in multi-institution and a two of three, three of five, and maybe they want a hundred in their own two of three, where they hold two of the keys in this sophistication on sharding and what like, you know, we still think of passport as like a one-to-one relationship. 72:30 What happens when a passport can shard a key and how institutions do it and three passports only make up one key. 72:35 And now you can give those to other people and that's participating. 72:38 That's still one key. 72:39 you can see how that progresses and then people have that and now you have effectively a key network that is distributed and created where you change the logic of how would you actually do that 72:50 so like that's basically the thing that i think about is like risky but there's time uh before we get there because most people don't even understand what bitcoin is yeah yeah what would have to happen politically for you to be for you to put non-US 73:09 institutions as the top priority of getting into the custodial setup? 73:16 What would worry you in the political sphere? Because I'll tell you, I feel like nothing politically is safe or stable anywhere. 73:25 Yeah, I mean, I agree with that, but I have to look like multiple orders deep of when I look at like Bitcoin and I just have like this, I don't want to call it like pattern recognition, but experience of like, and I don't get to talk about this a lot, but in 22, 73:44 I viscerally remember like FTX, Celsius, BlockFi collapsing and talking with people that were at the Citadels and BlackRocks of the world. 73:52 And this all got memory hold that they would not do business with Coinbase. 73:55 It's hard to put our brains there because now Coinbase is the darling. 73:58 They've been sanctioned. 73:59 They have the ETF flows. 74:00 But back in the day, coinbase was uh institutions and like people did not want exposure they called it a web 3 company and um why i'm bringing that up is because something happened between then and the etfs 74:14 where coinbase was okayed um and part of that was uh the etfs going there and even the etfs if we remember they kept getting knocked down it was political it was regs whatever you want to call 74:27 And they use the example of GBTC in some lawsuit, but I'm convinced it wasn't that. It was a notion of there's geopolitical importance. And it couldn't go back to all the way if it would get really heady with the inception of Bitcoin and the understanding of effectively the system was on a timeline that was set to end effectively. 74:48 Like this stuff that we talk about is not like novel or new to us. 74:52 Like if we can figure it out, everyone has to understand like the dollar system, the money, when, you know, societies collapse, you know, the barbarians at the gate, et cetera, et cetera. 75:01 So you can even go back to, you see this right now with like the offshore, onshore, you see this with like the banking sector. 75:06 And like, there's a real like friction slash like factions that are wanting to promote the movement of assets and Bitcoin versus others that are like, no. 75:18 And you see this already. 75:19 So the world's not all just like one direction and everyone's in that. 75:22 So point being is I've always looked at this asset as of geopolitical importance, partially because when you think about gold, we probably don't hold as much gold as we believe we do in the United States. 75:35 And China holds probably a lot more gold than we believe. 75:38 And they let people know. 75:39 And it makes sense because if everything's an input-output game, we effectively have been exporting dollars for a long time so we don't make everything. 75:45 China's been exporting goods and services and the smart rational thing to do is to rotate that into hard assets. 75:51 And so they probably hold a lot of gold. 75:54 And so if you put people that are running different factions of the government and understanding that, well, it would be a very three-dimensional game to play where you effectively can create digital gold. 76:02 And we know that empirically, a large percentage of the Bitcoin sits in the West, specifically in the United States. 76:08 And so you take this whole notion of, okay, inflation's running. 76:12 It's not rocket science to know that the market knows and people that matter know that housing prices is unattainable for most people. 76:19 It's crazy. 76:20 We look at equity markets are completely oversold. 76:22 They're dislocated from fundamentals. 76:24 Everyone plays a game. 76:24 Bonds are impaired. 76:25 Everyone's dumping them. 76:26 It's not rational to hold them once you understand that then you have a liquidity sponge that can sit there and absorb that liquidity. 76:34 I think that's where the tokenization crypto boom is going to come from because you need this like sponge and Bitcoin sits as that new collateral layer and it comes in. 76:41 So I'm painting a picture of like, I truly believe that's the plan for the West and will happen globally. 76:46 And if that is even remotely the case, well, then why would you do anything that would effectively keep people from putting more of their dollars and wealth there? 76:55 Because that's like the natural version of if you continue with this inflation, we have to, right? 76:58 Because the system is over leveraged. 77:00 Well, then you're just going to get further and further out. 77:03 So that's where like the 3D of like, I think that there's a play. 77:06 And in the short order, I don't necessarily think like that is on the table because if you effectively did anything as a government, you're basically kneecapping the United States as it relates to this new game because gold and Bitcoin are unique in the sense 77:21 you have to have proof of work. 77:22 You have to really do something to get that gold. 77:25 That didn't necessarily answer your question. 77:26 I can answer it as like how I think about leading, but that's more of like, I don't think that should be an actual concern. 77:31 As crazy as I believe the government and all the stuff is, I just don't see them integrating. 77:36 And when I talk to JP Morgan and I talk to all these firms and you look at Larry Fink, which is the machine at its finest, like what's more than likely going to happen and I've said this since Larry Fink launched the ETF and it's looking more and more true 77:47 is they're going to tokenize Bitcoin. 77:49 So what that means is you're going to have Bitcoin in the ETF and they're putting self-custody as a bad thing. 77:55 They're putting spot exposure as a bad thing because centralized exchanges aren't good. 77:58 So they're like, look, BlackRock, Fidelity, buy my Bitcoin. 78:02 I going to give you a tokenized exposure She gets quote unquote self which we know is nonsense And you can lend against it Oh God forbid you hacked We can reverse the token You can get all the properties of Bitcoin You can lend against it. 78:14 You can see how that's a great story. 78:15 Like that's the game that's being played. 78:17 It's not going to be like- They're going to make Bitcoin stable coins. 78:21 Yeah. 78:21 I mean, they're going to make Bitcoin. 78:22 Yeah, yeah. 78:23 They're going to make Bitcoin like Bitcoin for the uninitiated. 78:27 And they're going to believe they own Bitcoin. 78:29 Controllable, reversible Bitcoin. 78:30 Which are controlled, reversible. 78:31 And in that world, the price is going to rip and they're going to do the thing. 78:36 And you can kind of see how like gold is not necessarily perfect analogous to this, but I think that is much more likely to what happens. 78:44 And it's a different story, but that's kind of like where you see the digital credit and all that stuff going there because they're already setting up that narrative of like this notion of digital and it's backed by Bitcoin, but you don't need to hold it because like, why would you want to hold it? 78:55 It's too volatile. 78:56 You can't handle the volatility. 78:58 Like you can really look at this stuff. 78:59 I just don't think that they're going to do any kind of like $16 in the short order. 79:04 Long order, like there's no telling how crazy this stuff gets, how crazy the world gets. 79:09 But yeah. 79:12 Where do you think the market is right now? 79:15 You know, we talk about like how much worse these things, these problems will be at $250,000 Bitcoin. 79:23 And I feel like, like despite the fact that if you look at the lows, this really isn't true. 79:29 You know, our lows this time are 60. 79:32 And that was our highs not too long ago. 79:36 But we're still there. 79:37 We're in 60 today. 79:41 And I think to a lot of people, because we didn't have that real rip on the last cycle, feel like we've kind of been in a holding pattern for like four years, five years, right? 79:56 And I'm curious. 79:57 And to some degree, I feel like this is a infrastructure expansion period is that there's just so much groundwork to cover. 80:07 There's so much pipe to lay. 80:10 There's so many gas stations to put up before you can actually have people driving around and have running water in your house. 80:17 And, you know, like that we're in that stage of it and things are just moving very slowly. 80:23 But I do feel like I feel like the more work we're doing, the more the more companies like yours, the better the hardware wallets get, the more they get hit and fixed, the more we have more tools and stuff. 80:35 And and Jesus, I so hope that I get to play some little piece of this and the tools that we're building matter in some context in doing this and making it more approachable and easier to use. 80:48 but regardless like you look at all of these things that are happening from so many different angles i feel like there there will be a point where things like momentum really really builds 81:04 and we start a legitimate transition sometimes i just feel like it hasn't started yet is that we we're literally still just kind of like poking and and testing and and building a block here and a 81:17 block here, like with this understanding of where we're going, but nobody really knowing what the building's going to look like. And I'm curious where from your side is, especially with everything 81:31 that's happened in the last couple of months in AI, like, could the market work at $250,000 per Bitcoin right now? Or does that just scream disaster for you? Do we still have, how long is the runway in your mind, the conversations that you're having, how realistic 81:49 does that seem to people that you talk to for an institution that's considering putting in a significant amount of money or investing? What's the sentiment and state of the infrastructure and 82:04 the mindset from your perspective and the people that you're talking to? Is it still just reluctance and unfamiliarity and fear? 82:12 Or how has that conversation changed in the last couple of years to you? 82:17 Yeah, so there's a lot here. 82:21 One of them is institutions are not paying attention. 82:23 I mean, majority are not. 82:24 Bitcoin, the sentiment's never been lower. 82:26 I think that there's a lot built in that is organic and inorganic in the current price action. 82:38 and some of the things that maybe are a little organic is like maybe back then they were a little manufactured but you think about like the 17 after the rip into 20 end of 2020 21 we kind of were in 82:49 the same lull those bands between like call it four to 18 and 18 was some some people anomaly with coinbase and things happened there where it should have been 12 but point being is like 82:59 we were between four and 12 for like four years and then 2020 late 2020 happened um and it kind of feels like that. Now, I would say it's a little inorganic is that to your point, there's a lot 83:13 that's had to happen to get TradFi adoption and market structure in place. And so without going too far and being like conspiratorial, like you have to look at, you know, starting with FTX and 83:27 the notion of the building up and then the tearing down of that and Luna you can put together where you had those things rip and then you had them come down and then a lot of things, second-order effects happen where you brought on onshore regs you know you think about like 83:39 darabit was this crazy thing and then a coinbase acquires it and you just end up with like we need to clean up the industry and i think we're seeing even more now with like binance and there's just 83:47 a lot of like market forces that have to be at play if you're going to plan uh what we talked about before of like this is of geopolitical importance um simply because if you think about like trad fi and jv diamond jamie diamond's a great example of like they call all this stuff 84:03 he didn't call it rat poison, but close enough to rat poison. But now they're embracing it saying like, you know, the CAGR and it's the best performing asset for the next 10 years. 84:10 But that doesn't just flip overnight, right? Like you don't just magically start to build wallet technology and like, how do you market and explain this and all the things, institutional 84:17 research. So I think that is what a lot of this period is built for. And that's why we're kind of in this weird band. And I think that's why the sentiment is so low. I've been saying this for 84:28 the past couple of years that we never got a proper bull market. And there's a lot of empirical evidence, whether it's like on-chain activity and the amount of, I think it was like, I think it was like 21, there was like close to $60 trillion that were moved in a year, 84:40 like on-chain versus like, and that's a crazy number, but 60 trillion, 50, 60 trillion. 84:45 And then in 24, maybe it was five when this quote unquote market took off in the last run, it was like half of that. So it's like the price doubled, but the market had half of the on-chain, 84:56 you can look at hardware devices. The one that I look at is just notable entrepreneurs or net new businesses coming in because the way to look at adoption is the, I've thought about this for 85:05 probably seven years now is the best entrepreneurs have never even heard of Bitcoin yet. Like they're not even in the space because those people are working at Anthropic and other places. And when 85:13 they catch the bug, they're going to be able to develop and fix a lot of the things that we naturally see as problems and things that we can't even think of. So I've been going down that route 85:21 and then Parker Lewis, who's a good buddy, we naturally come to similar conclusions, but different angles. He had, I think it was on Marty's pod recently where he was explaining that part of 85:30 where we never got a proper bull market is we never got people in his view understanding Bitcoin the way we see it as money. And when that happens, well, you naturally get the volatility, 85:39 get the selling. This is like Wisconsin as an example and Harvard who bought a little and then sold it. They never bought anything material. And because of that, you never got net new adoption, 85:48 which is effectively energy. And so we never got the energy from a proper bull market of net new thinkers and podcasters and writers and entrepreneurs. And the best we got was this whole digital credit narrative, which basically fractured the industry and people are chasing 86:03 something that they don't understand. And so that's kind of what's led us to this weird spot of, uh, at the sentiment is at all time lows. I've talked to so many people and clients that have been around since like 2013. I was in California last week meeting with them. 86:16 And I was shocked because the one that I always remember is 2020 where I felt it in my belly of like, Oh my God, I was still smashed mine, but I was like, this thing could go to zero, but I guess I'm going out with it. And I thought they would say something similar, but they were 86:27 like, no, right now has been the lowest because you think about all the narratives and all the dreams came true from everyone and we still didn't get the price. In the meanwhile, people are getting attacked. People are worried. Their families are worried about them. So 86:39 with all that said, that's where I think we are at. I think that the problem or the reality is interest rates have been rising. Liquidity has been sucked out of the system. The market has been in this weird recession that nobody wants to call it. 86:53 Everything is raced into AI, which is its own deal. 86:56 When you think about interest rates rose and this thing sucked in the vacuum. 87:00 It was a perfect vacuum for liquidity to like take that narrative. 87:04 And maybe this is a black pill or a white pill, but at the end of the day, I've seen enough to understand that when the machine is ready, that's when this price will move. 87:12 And when the machine's not ready, it won't move. 87:13 And I've seen this with AI. 87:15 When you talk to RIAs, when you talk to family offices, when you talk to anybody, everyone's in Anthropic, everyone's in OpenAI, and they have no idea why they just do it. 87:21 in the same time when the debasement trade goes on and when the market says Bitcoin's the thing, that's when it'll go and not a second before, as much as we'd like it to. 87:28 Yeah. 87:30 I'm curious what your thought, you mentioned that, I think you said towards the very beginning of this conversation that AI is an obvious bubble or something along those lines. 87:43 Unpack that for me a little bit because I get that sentiment as well. 87:49 There are some things, like i read a um a piece by i'm not gonna remember i'm not gonna remember um i'll put it in the comments or put in the description but uh uh read a piece about the apparent unprofitability and 88:08 what looks like no actual path to profitability for open ai um and how much money they were burning through and stuff and then i also had a conversation with uh uh jc which i i hope i'll ask him and i'll bleep his name if he doesn't want me to mention him but i don't say i can't 88:29 see why right now so uh and he does tons of stuff and he had an interesting kind of reverse perspective or opposing perspective is that the people who will own the ram will be the ones that win out. 88:47 And even if they lose money for 10 years, if they own enough RAM at the end of it, which is what, you know, OpenAI and all these companies are doing because a lot of these costs are up front. 88:55 They're build-out costs to then own the infrastructure to rent, you know, to charge people for it. 89:05 But, and obviously, obviously AI is one of the most useful technologies I've ever, like it's crazy. 89:12 It has truly changed the nature of like what it costs to get one unit of human thought. 89:19 And, and it no longer equates to one unit of human life. 89:23 You know, like I can, I can get my agents to do shit for me while I sleep and I do it regularly and I wake up and I'm fascinated every day. 89:34 So without question, we're building a, there's a crazy new technology and a new space and new economics. 89:40 or economic reality kind of. 89:44 But does the liquidity come out of that? 89:48 Because I feel like everything in fiat is blown up. 89:53 I feel like so much of the pricing mechanism is just wrong that anything that has a 10x improvement and is worth 10x something and people start investing in it, it eventually goes to 100x and then collapses 90. 90:06 You know, like it just, like fiat is always incorrectly pricing things um and i'm curious how that plays into how you think about what you say as quote unquote the machine being ready for bitcoin to be the actual money 90:24 and the actual asset that it is as opposed to what it sees right now yeah i mean i think um like a good stat i had found this and it's on my twitter deep further down but it's like 90:35 Basically pre-GBT, so call it four years ago, the top 25 public and it's majority public, but it's public and private companies in the world set at roughly $6 trillion in market cap. 90:46 And today, similar top 25, but they're changing of the logos is roughly 15. 90:51 So net new companies changed over 50%. 90:54 And it's $35 trillion. 90:57 And it's $35 trillion. 90:58 Wow. 90:59 Wow. 91:00 That's crazy. 91:01 I never heard that stat. 91:03 So from six to 35 and more than half are fresh faces Yeah And so that the core idea of a like of what goes on must come down But even more than that is it was always curious. 91:20 And like this one, I haven't been able to square, you know, holding GBT and like when it came about and how it ties in. 91:27 But at the end of the day, anybody that's allocated or been around in like 21, they looked at that vintage and they wrote it off because that was Zerp era. If you got an interest like my mortgage or like 2%, like crazy stuff, right? It was like Zerp era. And valuations were insane. This is right off the backs of COVID. 91:44 and so we've had interest rates continue to rise and people think interest rates rising like you know it seems again ephemeral but it really things break because the cost of capital breaks for firms 91:54 when they think about refinancing starting businesses etc what's fundable and ai just beautifully stopped right in there i was always curious like just sat there as this liquidity sponge for all the trillions right because it basically six x the amount of liquidity in those 92:07 valuations and that went somewhere and that went to inflation that went to the valuation these companies. So that's the idea is that two things can be true is that, um, you know, this idea that 92:17 AI is insanely, uh, transformative in the same way, like railroads were insanely transformative. 92:21 But then the question is the market structure and everyone should be asking who's going to end up owning the railroads, uh, or who's going to end up owning the data centers and what they're going 92:29 to be used for because we effectively got firms to build this stuff out. And when you really like back into these things, you can see these things play back. I think COVID helped a lot of people 92:39 understand kind of just like how a machine works and how they prop things up and they'll take zombie companies and do their thing and you can start to squint and see it's like my understanding now uh and it's very cursory level but it's like um the notion of like 92:52 i'm not certain but this is at least my latest understanding is like export controls made zero sense like negative sense for the united states oh yeah because in china you effectively would 93:07 require them if they didn't have access to the gpus to go build out it's not just hardware it's software it's a whole structure and it becomes nearly impossible unless they're forced to do it 93:17 because in the same way microsoft could not get everyone into because you need developers that's what like cuda and you had developers that were coalescing around this and so you can look at how 93:26 you need the free market to kind of like build things and you can incentivize it before then you put the clause on and this is kind of like crypto when you think about it in in bitcoin exchanges It stops from the bottom's up, ground's up. 93:38 You do the thing and then you start to like FTX collapses. 93:40 Binance comes within the apparatus. 93:42 Darabit comes with the apparatus because it couldn't exist if the government was like, we're just going to make options in crypto. 93:46 And so you can see these like circular things playing out time over time. 93:49 And NVIDIA is a great example of this. 93:51 You have the GPs, you have the build out, you have all this infrastructure. 93:53 I needed to get there and then eventually get to a certain crescendo moment. 93:56 You're like, all right, now it's time. 93:58 And so, yeah, I don't know how it plays. 94:01 I mean, like this is a hundred trillion, whatever dollar question is. 94:04 Is this a local reversal and then we're going to get liquidity and anthropic and these firms are going to get juiced because they're now the de facto winners because Frontier is going to lead because now the open source thing and that the narrator that picks up or was probably more likely is that we're going to probably get maybe a reversal even more. 94:20 you're going to get some rolling over there's going to be some level of things breaking because this whole uh circular financing thing is an insane proposition itself there's nobody in my 94:30 understanding that can go and lead nvidia based on just like the person that was there and you get the number of reports and all the structure um and then you end up with probably something 94:38 breaks in the next i don't know half a year less more and then you naturally have um liquidity come in i don't know like it's crazy because we live in such an insane world that like the thing up is 94:49 down, down is up. And so we probably can't forecast what the narrative will be and where the dollars will go. Of course. But at the same time, you can just see behind the scenes, like it came out this week. It had come out a couple of months ago, but this week was like, 95:04 it was like Citi, it was every major bank except for JPM because JPM is working on their own, is launching this like stable coin network and they invest in $250 million into it. And like, 95:14 that's just one example, but you can see Charles Schwab, you can see Fidelity doing their stable coin you can just see all this market structure coalescing around building the actual things that 95:22 are going to like digitize uh finance and so it's really whatever the narrative and linchpin is that's going to cross from that liquidity cycle of everyone made their money here to like there 95:32 and you can feel it coming because inflation and all these other things are like we talked about they're just they're they're becoming more ever present and they're becoming more hard for people to look the other way and that is going to like converge with the rotation and 95:45 And then I think that's when we get on the other side of whatever is going on. 95:49 What's your take on stable coins in this whole thing? 95:52 Especially with this whole conglomerate of like creating an open stable coin protocol thing. 95:58 I can't even remember what it's called now. 95:59 Right. 96:00 I'll stop my head. 96:00 But I have so many arguments. 96:04 Well, debates, discussions, whatever, with people that I legit like so many people like, oh, we're just supporting the system or whatever. 96:14 And I'm just like, the system doesn't need any support, man. 96:18 Like how much I don't think it actually matters that like people are saying like stable coins are going to make fiat spread so much further and be so much more entrenched and all this stuff. 96:33 And I'm like, it's like the doorway out to me for people who don't understand the money problem, but are seeing the technology problem. 96:44 or can adopt a technology without the, like it's step one of adopting Bitcoin. 96:53 It's step one of adopting Bitcoin, in my opinion, is adopting the technology of how Bitcoin works. 96:59 And technology obviously moves faster than money. 97:04 Like money is an issue of trust. 97:07 Money is an issue of Lindy effect. 97:10 And technology is just a, does it work better? 97:12 Is it cool? 97:13 Can I download it? 97:14 Technology is something that moves extremely rapid. And all I can think in all my whatever degree of little internet history and technology history and protocol history and monetary history that I've studied, I can't see how stable coins don't come first. 97:31 i like when it comes to like mass adoption yeah it would seem crazy to me that the familiarity of a money that is already entrenched and that like it's like kilometers and miles you know does the 97:45 does the conversion happen before you just are familiar with i have i still to this day like i i've have interactions kilometers are on it's like a second thing in my speedometer i still have no 97:58 idea how fast I'm going in kilometers, you know, like in kilometers per hour. I have no idea. If you ask me how far is it from here to there in kilometers, I have no idea. I have to stop and I 98:06 have to do math and I have to think about it really, really hard. That same thing happens with dollars and Bitcoin, except worse really, because like you're weighing your life, like, 98:15 you know, people like what's, what's Bitcoin worth and what do you do? You name a number of dollars because that's their only relationship. They have a relationship with dollars, with a fiat currency. 98:23 so long weird rant of saying like how do you think about stable coins in this mix and their potential net positives versus net negatives because I mean they come with a onslaught of trade-offs obviously but how does that how does that play into your thesis your 98:44 your image of where things are headed yeah I mean I'm I think very similar I think it's kind of an unsophisticated view to believe that there would be a negative or not conducive to Bitcoin 98:56 adoption simply because, again, like, left side of the curve and empirically, like, Bitcoin's adoption ties directly into when you look at just, like, tether minted, right? And, like, the notion 99:06 of why were stablecoins created? And there was a, there was this idea that if you have to rely on banking wires and you're running trading, you have a problem overnight and you have a problem with 99:15 liquidity and net settlement. Now, obviously, stablecoins can be seized, but you're still in a trust-based system and we live in a trust-based system. 99:22 And so you can, if they started just like freezing everyone, then you wouldn't use it and then you would seize up those markets. 99:28 So I think two things can be true is yes, maybe there is an angle of dollar dominance, but I also believe that to your point, and it's an interesting one around kilometers and miles, it's like once people's aperture opens, that money is digital. 99:41 Well, then it's pretty game theoretical and natural. 99:45 And this is kind of how I see banking and just how all this stuff will play out is every bank, every institution will just coalesce around stable coins because they'll have to, especially from a Gentic perspective when you can just have money flow and agents can go. This is 99:58 where tokenization will also take off to find a higher yielding, whether it's dollar balance or equity. But the rational thought is, and this is what I tell fintechs and where I see every fintech 100:08 works on the wrong problem instead of the right problem because they're working on the efficiency and velocity of money versus they're not worried about the problem that everyone has. I told this 100:14 to a CEO of a fintech in San Francisco the other week. He looked at me like inflation is a problem And I was just like, brother, where have you been? 100:20 But it's the idea is that, yes, once people understand that it's digital, and then you, A, can swap. 100:30 It's pretty interoperable to get into another digital asset like Bitcoin. 100:33 But then when I think of banking, the perfect flow, this is things we work on and things I believe other banks will discuss and work on, is remember when you used to have a savings account that had some nominal yield, 100:47 like old enough, you know, remember savings right underneath the checking. 100:50 Oh yeah. That used to be a thing. I know. 100:52 Yeah. So why would it, the rational thing from the future world where banks that understand you still need dollars, you still get direct deposit from your bank, your primary relationship. 101:04 And right below that is called savings account. And you have a dollar balance and you don't care what it is. You just know that on a long time horizon, you're putting assets there and it goes 101:13 up and to the right. It's savings technology. And as a bank, you not only get the trading fees, you get the custody fees. And then you want as a financial institution, as a business, your clients to be wealthy. You don't want their wealth to be eroded. So you want those assets 101:26 because the game that people should be playing, but they're not, is how do you get your arms around as much of the 21 million? Because that's when the game really starts, when you start delivering 101:33 financial services and products. And so the way I think about how we interact with that is like, the first order is the credibility of the firm will be if they allow people to preserve their 101:43 wealth in the digital age because the market will coalesce around i need savings for that and then the credibility of how they preserve that wealth because we're going to redo this whole game with 101:51 it google launching mpc and they have all their kind of you know sophisticated version of shard in this stuff it's like we know that's not going to work for money as bad actors are looking for 101:58 it digitally then that's when you kind of revolve around that standardization layer where you go to the financial institution that not only lets you preserve your wealth but also make sure that it 102:06 doesn't get lost uh and so i think it's going to happen exactly like that and then right out of that vault is when things get really exciting because when I look at like the best example that I think 102:17 you'll appreciate this was also reading that Steve Jobs book is towards Steve Jobs end of his life he released the app store or he released the iPhone and Kleiner Perkins a generational VC out of San 102:29 Francisco Silicon Valley went to him and said let's set up a fund for the iPhone so we can incentivize people to build applications on it and he said no because in Jobs fashion he wanted to keep 102:41 things closed source and insular it took about a year maybe there's lack of adoption whatever else happened he went back to connor perkins and said let's get the fund that kick-started adoption for 102:51 the application of apps in the app store i think of multi-institution as the exact same example if it's a new design service a new application for all financial services so out of that singular 103:02 vault it makes no sense why you shouldn't be able to take a loan or line of credit and just encumber the amount of assets that you're doing without ever leaving that vault um and so yeah i think 103:12 we're just so early to your point but that's a logical thing is you have stable coins you can move to bitcoin you're able to like custody them you take a loan out maybe a line of credit via 103:20 card you get the stable coins you can do whatever um but yeah yeah there's actually something to that and i was talking to steve um on the round table he mentioned something more recently is that He thinks that credit, like we have this misunderstanding. 103:37 I don't want to misquote him. 103:38 I'll bring this up in the next roundtable in case I'm totally wrong about the way he thinks about it. 103:44 But the idea that most purchases and most exchanges will still be credit. 103:52 And but in my thinking, and I think he sees that largely as a negative thing. 103:57 But in my thinking, there's an element to usability that credit provides and that we have such a misunderstanding of what credit is. 104:09 because all credit is bad in our environment right now in the fiat world because all credit is fake. It's all mispriced. None of it is actually there. There's no reserves to actually fulfill the credit. The credit is a game of can you arbitrage low interest near money creation 104:29 and high interest near consumers and people who are getting kicked in the nuts for, you know, on the wrong side of this structure. And so we think all credit is bad, same way we like banks, right? And I don't think either credit as a concept is bad or banks as a concept are bad. 104:49 I think we have a terrible credit system and a terrible banking system because of the money, because of the foundation that they're built on top of is bad. And so it's built in an environment 105:00 that's just covered in poison. So yeah, we've just associated it with just being a terrible, a horrible thing. But in that very same vein and what you guys are building and the whole idea of 105:12 multi-institutional custody and the ability to transfer and make changes and work with something that never actually leaves the vault, but that the vault is just that much more sophisticated than 105:24 it's ever been. All I can think is that credit isn't bad if it's trustworthy. Credit isn't bad if you can actually get the reserves to fulfill the credit. 105:36 Credit is just an easier mechanism for moving things or working with someone with basically more capacity to invent relationships or invent types of transfers or ownership when it is actually backed by something real. 105:57 Yeah. 105:58 And I'm curious how a multi-institutional custody system plays into and how you are thinking about like, okay, where do financial services and payments and stuff exist in the world, in a world where there's real, there's something 106:14 actually backing credit and you have to, you have to figure out how to be able to fulfill those, pay for the bills. 106:20 So yeah, with real money. 106:22 Well, I'll give you a kind of a, something to think about. 106:24 Cause I know we've gone for a few hours and I might have to jump in a second. 106:27 Oh Jesus. 106:27 Yeah. 106:27 It's probably what time. 106:28 Oh my God. 106:29 We're two hours in. 106:29 but but we can pick this up because i do think it'll give you so like i think at its core you're exactly right and from here to like a bitcoin standard i fully believe you know when you think about credit and in the the credibility of duration right like we're working on mortgage 106:47 stuff where you can uh collateralize and not have to sell your bitcoin and this idea of appreciation and getting liquidity it's it's an arbitrage i will say that i don't know the answer to this 106:57 But on a Bitcoin standard, you'll be very curious to see if credit exists in the existing format or if it's more of equity-based credit. 107:04 And what that means is when you go back to like biblical times every biblical book and I not like particularly religious but I just like studying religion is that they prohibit usury which is effectively 107:16 credit, making money on money. And so what they've coalesced around initially was equity-based. So meaning like if you have an idea and I want to fund it, I will invest in you or invest in the 107:29 business. I will offer that, I guess, quote unquote, you can call it credit. But what I'm really getting is a piece of the business and dividend structure. The output. Yeah. Yeah. The output, 107:41 because from a moral and a congruency standpoint, we are incentivized to me not to pull the ladder out and try to rug you. And I am incentivizing your growth of your business. And so it makes the, the idea completely different of like extending a loan because independent of you 107:56 went like you win or lose, I still win versus we're in it together. And I think that's just an interesting thing it's alignment yeah it's alignment oh what do you know i don't know what 108:07 the answer is does that and that's a foreign one for a lot of people because that's a crazy thing but like you can go back to all biblical texts and they all uh reference this and so that's just 108:19 gonna be interesting to see where that goes yeah no i i totally agree i i genuinely believe credit will fundamentally change from the nature of what we have now because it's not it's not just not 108:28 possible. It's just not possible on a Bitcoin standard for credit to live in the world that it does today sustainably, I think. But I do believe the idea of equity credit is a far more aligned. And it's weird because I question how the free market, when people have availability 108:53 in the market, like where does the market settle when a interest-based credit or a usury credit is desirable of just like, I don't really care what you do with it. Just pay me, you know, like just pay me my percentage. So, but I do think there's a very, very perverse 109:16 incentive and misalignment not only that comes culturally and like trust in the in the realm of trust with that setup but it's also just so poisoned because of how credit is dominated because it's coming from where it's created in financial institutions because you can create 109:37 nine dollars for every one and that that's that used to be the the conservative amount that got created from $1 and how much of that just kind of poisons the whole well for what you can even 109:49 pull off. Like you just can't have sustainable credit. You can't have sustainable, sensible credit in this environment and survive or succeed. Like if you're, if you actually do it in a sense 110:00 that you survive you get out competed you never grow you go nowhere And if you do it in a way that you can compete it unsustainable and you just chasing the same game that everybody else is So do you see on Bitcoin as I take the Netflix analogy since you brought it up 110:21 Netflix is renting DVDs to the mail over the internet because they're waiting for the bandwidth to offer streaming. 110:28 onramp is offering multi-institution custody to secure bitcoin and like redefine what it means to safely hold bitcoin for large and small everybody in between. 110:45 is that a expectation of moving into a place where people plug into this to offer payment services where financial institutions ends up having this underneath and or even you guys offering like yeah all this other stuff is is this the dvds in the mail getting ready for 111:11 streaming. Yeah, that's exactly right. That's a very apt that's exactly what's happening is like you got to get the custody right and by the time the other rest of the participants are going to start shipping the DVE which is offering the custody, you've already gone 111:25 multiple layers deep. 111:27 Again, if we weren't limited on time, I would walk you through but like it's the only credible way I could see lending and I've seen this before in my previous firm. The thing I'll leave you with is I call it my definition of hell on earth is if you have a loan out 111:39 in a centralized custodian and it's a black box and you're getting margin called, but the whole market's deleveraging. 111:45 Again, FTX, Celsius, BlockFi moment. 111:47 And you don't know if you're depositing that Bitcoin and you're going to, if you don't deposit, you're going to get liquidated. 111:53 So you're going to lose your precious Bitcoin. 111:54 If you do deposit, you don't know if it's going in a black box because they're done. 111:58 Right, you need transparency, you need that fault tolerance. 112:01 So I'll leave you there. 112:02 And then we can always pick up because there's a lot downstream from, think about OTC, prime brokerage. 112:07 How do you ship oil tankers worth a billion dollars if you're not able to build some kind of escrow system because somebody has to still send the Bitcoin or the oil. 112:16 These are all things that will be built around this. 112:19 Nice. 112:20 All right. 112:21 Well, dude, thanks for coming on, man. 112:22 Thanks for this chat. 112:23 It's good catching up, man. 112:24 When are you going to be at the BitBlock boom? 112:26 No. 112:27 BitBlock boom this year? 112:29 I probably will. 112:30 I can know Cam was there this past year. 112:31 That's just a short drive up. 112:33 So yeah, probably will see you. 112:34 That's in April, right? 112:35 In Fort Worth again? 112:36 Yeah. 112:37 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 112:37 Yeah. 112:37 Maybe we'll see each other. 112:38 Let's do it. 112:38 We'll do a live stream. 112:39 We'll get Parker to join. 112:41 We'll run back the 2020 COVID. 112:45 2020 COVID. 112:46 That'll always go down. 112:47 There's only a select few people that have made it to Addison, Texas in 2020 when the world was hidden. 112:54 Hell yeah. 112:55 Yeah. 112:55 That was it. 112:56 That kicked off the real bull market. 112:58 Those are my Bitcoin friends that even if they went BIP110ers or we fight over every other thing, 113:04 those are the ones that will still just be your Bitcoin friends because we were Bitcoin 2020 We were there when the whole world was falling apart And we stood up and we went to the freaking hotel And we argued with all the people who were running the place 113:16 And we didn't wear a mask. 113:17 And we hung out. 113:17 And we lived Bitcoin or life. 113:19 Udi was even there. 113:20 In the midst of the world. 113:23 Falling apart. 113:23 So, epic times. 113:25 Well, I'll see you in April, man. 113:26 Yeah, dude. 113:30 All right, guys. 113:30 I hope you enjoyed that episode and that chat. 113:34 But like I said, I'm going to be putting together a resource, just kind of collecting a lot of thoughts and recommendations on self-custody and custody options and what those various trade-offs are. 113:48 And I'll just have that easily available at BitcoinAudible.com. 113:52 So you can check that out on the website. 113:54 And I'll try to remember to add it. 113:55 I'll start putting the link to it directly to it in the show notes right with the hardware wallet recommendation. 114:01 because we always partner with a hardware wallet that I really like. 114:05 Bitbox has been long. 114:06 I've loved the Bitbox for so long. 114:09 And I also just love the guys over at Swiss Crypto. 114:12 They just do a fantastic job. 114:14 All open source. 114:15 They've stayed up to date or very transparent on the bugs and issues as we go through the great hackening and how to protect yourself. 114:26 And so mad respect for everything that they do and for making such a great tool. 114:30 discount code for that one right down in the show notes, obviously. And again, details and recommendations on my own setup and various trade-offs and stuff will be available on BitcoinAudible.com. I will have an exact link so that you can go straight to it. And that will also 114:48 give you the links and discount codes and all of that stuff to do your setup the same way if you if you like it or if it seems to fit your system. 115:00 And don't forget to check out OnRamp. 115:03 And Michael, I will have their Twitters and their socials and all that stuff available right down below. 115:10 And with that, we will close this one out. 115:13 Thank you so much for listening. 115:15 Do not forget that the best thing, one of the easiest things you can do is to share this out for the show. 115:22 And of course, subscribe to the Guys Take channel on YouTube, which we're still building out. 115:26 as well as the main Bitcoin Audible channel. 115:30 And I'll catch you on the next one. 115:32 Until then, this has been a wonderful time, and I will catch you on the next one. 115:38 That is our two sats. 115:56 Outro Music
Community discussion