0:00 All of this matters because of one reason. Today, can you also use Coinbase to sell your coin? Yes. 0:06 But can you guarantee that if Coinbase disappears, your funds will be with you? No. Because it is at the end of today, their custody. Whereas in state chains, a really cool perspective is if the server 0:19 or the custodian disappears because of the design of the system, money comes back at you on L1. You you can broadcast and exit or you can do nothing and the money comes back to you. 0:30 So it's kind of becomes, you know, if something bad happens to us or to server, then still money is yours. 0:38 And I think this is a really, really cool property. 0:41 Basically being able to exit even though things become fucked up. 0:55 What is up, guys? Welcome back to Bitcoin Audible. I am Guy Swan, the guy who has read more about Bitcoin than anybody else you know. 1:10 So we have got a fantastic show today. 1:14 And our sponsor, Bitbox, is a hardware wallet. 1:19 And one that I have loved for a long time, been using for I don't even know how many years. 1:26 But this is actually, what we talk about today is actually very relevant to this. 1:32 Because of everything that's happened with Coldcard. 1:34 and I have been doing my own little which I don't know how competent I am at this this is definitely a skill that you have to get good at but at red teaming the bit box and my other software and stuff 1:49 I'll be moving on to nunchuck wallet because these are things that I use all the freaking time but red teaming it to find security holes and try to figure out how and what you know the various 2:01 risks are. And, you know, Bitbox is open source, Nunchuck is open source, like all this stuff. And, you know, I think that needs to be a new standard. But I wanted to have somebody on the show to kind 2:11 of talk about this. And then obviously talk a little bit about, you know, hindsight on what we can learn and what we've seen with BIP 110, and everything that happened there. And it just 2:23 so happened that one of the guys that we were looking at, or had been following on the various topics and all the red teaming stuff with cold card and attacking open source projects in an 2:36 effort to make them more secure was talip who also had worked he also is working with a really cool project called lx.dev on privacy research and all this stuff and their focus has just been more 2:48 recently a massive red teaming stuff with james and byrne and rob hamilton i'm sure you've heard a lot of them and what they've been up to in following uh their their findings and the reports that they've submitted to people. 3:01 And he also happened to have worked with Citria in the past and during a lot of this whole spam war and BIP-110 and all of this mess, which I thought was going to be a really interesting perspective because I wanted to see, he kind of had an inside perspective. 3:18 I'm like, what did they think when they saw all of this stuff and when Antoine mentioned Citria as an example for big opera turns, etc. 3:26 So there was just a whole lot to unpack here. 3:30 And I thought his perspective was really interesting and where he came from. 3:34 And he also just had a really good perspective on, you know, despite being a little bit spicy about his opinion on how he treated and saw things. 3:46 Like at one point, I can't even remember who it was now. 3:49 He mentioned that, you know, I insulted him on Twitter and he blocked me and then I blocked him. 3:55 but it's fine he's a smart guy and who cares I thought that was just a really good perspective so we will get into this I think you guys will really enjoy this probably a lot of great clips for the conspiracy people who hate Citria and then a lot of great clips 4:12 in the opposite side too should be a fun one I hope you guys enjoy we will go ahead and get into it don't forget you get a discount with your bit box if you're trying to replace your freaking cold card make sure it's open source 4:22 and check your red teams and their reports on things. 4:27 I'll have whatever I can find or share pretty soon. 4:32 And yeah, with that, don't forget to check out links and stuff in the show notes. 4:37 And let's get into this conversation with Talep. 4:41 This is our chat with Talep. 4:44 Is every conspiracy true? 4:50 Well, Tal, welcome to the show, man. 4:52 Yeah, my pleasure. Thanks for inviting me. 4:54 Absolutely, absolutely. I think there's a bunch of different stuff we can get into. 4:59 But just because we were talking about like getting fired up I got to say you know a lot of people I don know maybe it just like the early days of Bitcoin There like some sort of nostalgia but I really like it when everybody fighting about something 5:17 Like there's like a little part of me that just kind of loves the, 5:23 it's not like it's confusion. 5:26 It's not, it's just the, maybe it's just the passion. 5:30 Maybe it's just like the level of like conviction and everything. 5:35 Like I have mad respect for like a whole bunch of people are shitting on BIP110ers, which I mean, you know, the whole thing went kaput as which I just seemed predictable to me. 5:46 But I don't know that there was so much confidence of like, it's definitely going to work. 5:50 It's definitely going to work. 5:51 I was like, I don't like it's not you're comparing it to the UASF and it's just not it's just not the same situation. 5:57 But but like even B cashers, like I've always had a little bit of respect. 6:02 I've tried to make inroads with Roger Ver a few times in the past, like when we've crossed paths, you know, at least they were able to, you know, put their money where their mouth is, so to speak. 6:13 You know, like like they actually went the distance, you know, they forked. 6:18 They said this is going to be the path that we take. 6:21 I still think it would be better if we were all on the same one arguing because like the less consensus there is, I think the stronger Bitcoin is from a decentralization standpoint. 6:32 Because it means that only those things that we explicitly know are good will actually get done. 6:39 The rest will have resistance. 6:42 But anyway, that's just an aside from the thing we just brought up. 6:47 But welcome to the show, man. 6:48 I want to go ahead and just let you introduce yourself just because I don't know a ton about your background. 6:53 I'd probably do a pretty bad job of it. 6:55 But what you've been working on and all that stuff. 6:59 And then we'll start digging into things. 7:01 Yeah. So again, thanks for having me. My name is Talib. I'm a software engineer, nowadays webcoder. I'm originally Turkish. I'm kind of nomading around. Before that, I joined in the Bitcoin space around the end of 2022 actually, so fairly later than you guys, much later. 7:26 I mean, I've been always reading and searching and there was a point of time where I told my dad like we should buy some of it, but we didn't have much money to justify it. 7:36 But yeah, on a technical level, it is the end of late 22, I would say. 7:44 Before that I was in FinTech mostly doing some competitive programming, whatever. 7:49 And then after that, I joined Citrea, which is probably an interesting choice for many. 7:57 Yeah, the reason behind was the founders and many people in the team were my close friends. 8:03 It's mostly Turkish team. 8:04 Okay. 8:05 And yeah, I knew them from different places. 8:07 So it was a no brainer. 8:09 It was a good run for about three years. 8:12 At the end of last year, or beginning of this year, I left Citrea. 8:17 And now I'm at LX. 8:19 It's a Bitcoin privacy scaling research company. 8:24 We're a small team, but we're doing interesting stuff that I can expand later on. 8:29 But yeah, I'm mostly... 8:31 I'm not a super giga mind-cool engineer, unlike many engineers in Bitcoin, but at least I can understand what's going on and I have sometimes spicy comments about what's going on. 8:42 Spicy. 8:43 Spicy, that's what we're here for. 8:45 Yeah, exactly. 8:46 But yeah, I think that's how I would introduce myself. 8:50 And thanks for having me again. 8:52 Nice, nice. 8:53 Okay, so you mentioned you had a couple touch points and then really kind of got into it at 2022. 9:01 So what was kind of the first appeal to you about Bitcoin? 9:05 What was the main focus that had you say, this is an interesting project or this is an interesting movement thing? 9:14 Yeah, I think something that might make this even more interesting is the place that I kind of entered is through Ethereum. 9:25 So first I was more reading and doing more Ethereum stuff. 9:30 Back then with the guys at Citra, we were working on some privacy protocols. 9:35 It's like, if you ever heard of Railgun, it's like a compliant sort of tornado cache. 9:42 So I first entered through that and then compared to Ethereum, Bitcoin was like, you know, it seemed more crippled initially because the number of things you can do is much less compared to Ethereum. 9:55 And for many Ethereum people, it's mostly like, oh, there's this Bitcoin maxis that are going to eat people alive and they hate everyone sort of perspective that you have, which is maybe 10% or 20% true, but it doesn't matter at the end of the day. 10:09 So from that perspective, it initially looked like a bit old, a bit slow, and sometimes expensive. 10:17 Yeah they got the Ford Model T analogy always comes out Yeah Or they were enjoying that the price is always going up and never caring about anything else from a very outsider perspective So the initial reaction was, you know, there's this tech, it's always good. 10:36 When the price is up, sometimes you buy it. 10:40 Yeah, so that was sort of the initial reaction. 10:42 And then when we pivoted as the chain went up, when we started to implement this Citria thing, The more I read, the more I interacted with people, it started to feel like a bit more genuine, obviously, because you get to interact with more people, you get to see how they 10:57 think, you get to see why the network is progressing slower than many other networks. 11:04 You get to see that there's more fundamentals and more reasoning behind every single decision. 11:10 And these things matter a lot, to be honest. 11:13 You don't get to fork it every single day, every single year. 11:17 there is not a single guy who is deciding everything. Whereas on Ethereum, it's mostly revolving around its Alicord foundation. So does that mean Bitcoin is under no one's influence? 11:31 Probably not. Probably a lot of guys with money also influences it. As I read and catching up more, like all the wars that has happened in the past also explains it a lot as well. 11:43 So yeah, but yeah, I mean, the more I read about it, the more it started to make sense. 11:49 Is it perfect? 11:50 Absolutely no. 11:51 Is it in a good shape? 11:53 Maybe, but I think it should be a bit more, a bit more cypherpunk rather than number go up idea. 12:01 Maybe we can get to make it better. 12:04 I don't know. 12:05 But yeah, it's sort of these sort of influences. 12:07 Well, I wanted to ask what you reference with the word cypherpunk, because I think it means something a little bit different to different people. So when you say Bitcoin can be a little bit more cypherpunk, you mean it in the context that, you know, it's, it's heading too far towards the establishment? Or you meaning that it needs to have more privacy and more kind of like, rebellious tech on it? 12:35 Like what, expand on that a little bit for me. 12:39 So it's established and probably it's a good thing. 12:41 But at the same time, there should be a play area where people should be able to feel still a lot like, a lot with the notion of anarchy, you know? 12:51 Like the whole movement and the whole revolt against governments being centralized and banks being centralized and everything going well in the world sort of kind of idea is not correct. 13:02 this sort of thought is still alive, but I think it's progressing much less, how do you say it? 13:11 It's progressing much slower. We are getting used to basically appreciate if the number goes up and dislike it if the number goes down. And we don't want to change the protocol at all 13:25 just because the number goes up. And just because there's all these bank integrations and ETFs and blah, blah, blah. And just because US government might agree, we don't want to introduce any sort 13:37 of privacy improvements to the layer one itself or anything that can make any layer two privacy, we are also not adapting these sort of stuff. I get that they come with trade-offs, but I think 13:51 these are stuff that more and more technical people should lead into it. I still believe that, I wasn't around, but the early days of Seek Road and later what happened. 14:02 It's this sort of revolt against centralized authority. 14:05 I think this should still be projected a bit. 14:08 I think it's becoming more idle, the way I see it. 14:11 Maybe it's easy for me to say because I don't have much money, but it is what it is. 14:17 This is the way I feel. 14:18 Yeah. 14:19 No, I get that. 14:20 And it's interesting because I've done an enormous amount into just the history of the Internet. 14:28 And it seems to be extremely similar in its path and how it like it kind of like diverged. 14:40 And you have this split in communities in focus where there's this more of a established like, oh, the Internet is like critical infrastructure for the world. 14:49 and like all the establishment is going to get it and the suit coiners, you know, quote unquote, the suits come in and they start building all the big companies and corporations on it. 14:59 But then at the exact same time, you have the Pirate Bay movement. 15:02 You have, and then ultimately you have Bitcoin is that it ends up being a network where everyone is there, but like it's still, you still have to specifically nurture and fight for the rebellious side. 15:14 Like we're going to have the Pirate Bay fight, you know, with whatever it is, with the privacy tools or whatever markets or whatever we create on top of Bitcoin in this, in this continued. And I think people discount how much larger the cypherpunk and like rebellious 15:31 tech movement is than it was in 2008 you know and how so deeply because of Bitcoin that change has been When you look on a long timeline, all I see is like good news, essentially. 15:50 Yeah, I mean, it also doesn't mean that, you know, you should basically kick every sweetcoiner and kick every integration and establishment and every bank out of the network. 15:59 Of course, of course. The internet's not going to work if you don't have those things. 16:04 Yeah. Yeah. But if we really want to make this in the center of our lives and really kind of want to convert this into a world currency, kind of want to achieve the hyper-Bitcoinization thing, 16:15 hyper-Bitcoinization, if I could almost say. Still, I think we need to experiment a bit more and we need a bit more on our key inside the network and inside our places. But yeah, I'm relatively new, so maybe you know better, probably know better than more experienced than me. 16:30 That's our title. 16:31 That's our title. 16:32 We need a bit more anarchy. 16:33 Coming from the Ethereum perspective. 16:36 Yeah. 16:37 Yeah. 16:38 Gotcha. 16:39 So I want to hit on Citria before we move on to some of the privacy stuff. 16:45 uh i think yeah you know and and i brought this up and i kind of attacked for it because citria seemed to be very relevant in the whole question about opera turn and like whether whether it's needed or whether it should be expanded which is funny because like when i 17:05 dug into it and i i didn't even mean i've said this on the show and then got attacked like i was spreading a conspiracy theory except that like i specifically asked like antoine and i asked um 17:17 uh like two or three people on the show like what was the justification explain like you know what the thinking was behind this to let them make their case and citria came up every single time and so like i i simply went with that but then there was this side where it was like 17:35 oh, Citria suddenly became equated with spam. 17:40 And then, you know, it's their influence in all of this stuff when it seemed to be such a minor example when I actually dug into specifics that Citria would need maybe two transactions. 17:51 It would just be such a small subset of transactions to actually utilize this. It seemed like this weird equivocation that wasn't even super relevant. 18:03 So I just want to give you the chance to answer all of the confusion and all of the two different sides about that. 18:13 Was Citria, did it even care? 18:16 Like, was OperaTerm really even relevant? 18:19 How does it relate to spam? 18:21 How do you think about it? 18:24 Yeah, so I think these answers that I will give are not new. 18:29 You can find a bunch of them on Twitter since last year, May. 18:32 I think it's good to start with a sentence first. 18:37 Citria was, is, and still does works with version V28, V29, or whatever prior you use. 18:45 So there is that. 18:47 Did Citria care about it? 18:49 No. 18:50 The entire design was designed to work without this sort of standardness change, policy change. 18:56 Did we care at that time? 18:58 Absolutely no. 18:59 No one literally gave a single fuck. 19:02 We didn't care about it at all. 19:04 I think most of the day, when the discussion started and when the stupid GitHub magic fight happened, I think the thing that I enjoyed the most was opening Twitter, scrolling, reading a conspiracy theory as like, oh, Peter Thiel found a city. 19:22 We are now trying to destroy Bitcoin. 19:24 We must resist against it. 19:25 I was basically screenshotting it and sending it to Slack and saying like, I cannot believe these guys are believing on this. 19:32 it was retarded. I'm really sorry to call it like this, but no one simply gave a single fuck about it. And it was working. And still, to this day, they didn't change it. They just changed the code change. They just merged the code, but it's still not on production. 19:47 Still, it does not use the op return v30 change. So no one cared about it even. So which probably brings you the question. What does it use for the large payload or whatever? It's like a justice transaction, right? 20:01 Like, conceptually? 20:04 There are two, three types of things that it's embedding. 20:07 The first one is, for the whole multiple hundreds of kilobytes that's been embedded every day or megabytes every day, it uses inscriptions, not operator. 20:20 And, you know, it is inscriptions. 20:24 The operator thing was about the BitPM bridge. 20:28 So there's this if something goes wrong with the bridge, if something goes wrong with the bridge, and if you as an observer want to be able to observe it and challenge it, you need 144 bytes of data that needs to be published. 20:44 And you need it in, I think, one week. 20:46 It's been a long time, I don't exactly remember. 20:50 To make sure that the transaction gets mined in one week, they just split it into three. 20:57 And this transaction to this day, C3 is live for a long time, didn't happen. 21:02 And probably it will never happen because it only happens if something goes wrong with the bridge. 21:06 One time, 144 bytes. 21:10 So yeah, they designed it. 21:12 And then if ever needed, it will be used, but it's already within the range. 21:17 it already works with v28, v29, whatever. 21:20 So that's why I keep telling like no one cared about it because we already designed it at that time. 21:26 So then people come and generally ask the question of then why is the name Citra comes up even? 21:34 Or like if they didn't care about it, why does it happen? 21:37 Story that everyone knows and that is actually true is that there are a bunch of technical developer conferences in the world and people sometimes go and talk with other Bitcoin desks, people in the area. 21:49 And one of the guys who is the main guy responsible from the bridge of the company went to the conference as well where he presented how the bridge works. 21:59 And to be fair, outside of these discussions, I think it's an amazing piece of technology. 22:04 The bridge design, the mathematics behind it, the digital proof verification or whatever. 22:09 It is very, very cutting-edge mathematical research. 22:13 So when he basically explains the bridge design, Like it is obvious that probably was obvious to Antoine that, you know, the transaction uses three transactions instead of one. 22:24 And I assume it made him realize like, you know, people need to circumvent this. 22:30 And actually people are already circumventing this because we get through Mara or through others or through Libre Relay, we are already getting transactions being mined. 22:41 So it actually doesn't even work. 22:42 And it hurts much of stuff. 22:44 basically causes... it doesn't cause. I think the cause is not the right word, but it sort of impacts the minor centralization is the better term. Or it hurts compact blocks because there's a transaction 22:57 that wasn't in your mempool, but all of a sudden it appeared. So the compact block filter is being tarnished. You need to reconstruct the block. So these sort of stuff basically hurts a lot performance. 23:10 So then, based on this influence, which Citria didn't ask and doesn't even care, which he also stated in his blog saying like, I think there was a sentence of him saying like, I'm sorry for Citria guys, I dragged them into this. 23:23 But like, Citria didn't care and they were even happy about it because Mechanic was all day screaming on Twitter saying like, oh, Citria is killing Bitcoin. 23:31 And Citria was a project that not many Bitcoiners was heard of. 23:35 So they were even just happy about the free marketing that was going on. 23:40 But they didn't ask or bribe anyone and no one cares simply. 23:45 So yeah, and so on basically kind of mentioned about it. 23:48 They started to discuss and then the GitHub PR came along. 23:51 Again, I think for technical reasons, I think it kind of makes sense. 23:56 Just because of, even just because of compact blocks. 23:58 Many people then ask me, should we then just abolish all sorts of policy rules? 24:05 That's a preference up to you. 24:08 I'm running my node. 24:09 I have the policy rules in set still. 24:13 But it doesn't mean that the policy limit for OpiTerm was super effective or not so harmful. 24:20 It wasn't super harmful, but at the same time, I think it wasn't working at all because you could get the right. 24:26 But yeah, so then the fight happened. 24:29 And then I think Jameson Love, just for the sake of enjoyment, maybe, I don't know, decided to throw people. 24:37 Was he an investor in Citria? 24:39 yes is this something he hides no like did people made right when they got extreme triggered by a policy change I think no I think that was dumb did C3 ask Lop to comment no like simply we didn't care I think the whole year we were basically scrolling Twitter laughing at 25:00 conspiracy theories and then yeah that was it like no one simply gave a simple fuck it was just guys being pissed off yeah like they don't even have money to bribe anyone like probably like why would you even care about it I think if it was up to me I would say 25:21 probably Matthew Kreter is closer to Peter Thiel than C3 but then he gets mad but yeah whatever it is what it is it was a simple change that people got triggered I just see the thing is is I don't even and I talked about this a couple times on the show too 25:40 um was that the change itself I don't even think like so much of this was about politics it was about the fact that like there was a subset of people who thought this was moving in the wrong 25:53 direction and the opera turn was like you know the straw that broke the camel back so to speak right is that is that it was just like we think you moving in the wrong direction And you not thinking you not even the entire discussion around spam has changed 26:12 And so this is our political move. 26:14 And it was talked openly about this in this context many times of this, like, we're going to punish core. 26:19 We're going to show them that they don't control this thing and all this. 26:23 And it looked to me like a political move. 26:25 and this was really about like who gets say in the future direction of uh of bitcoin and it all ended up being wrapped up in and pointed at a whole bunch of things that were so irrelevant 26:40 um like i did a whole episode on the whole op return thing and i was just like it's not going to make any difference either way it's not going to fix anything it's not going to make anything 26:50 worse. Like, like it literally just set this fire off and it, it by itself is such an inconsequential piece of the actual technical picture of, you know, what's going on and what the consequences 27:06 are likely to be. But it was an important political piece of like signaling or it was the flag, right? The flag doesn't really do anything, but it was the thing that kind of set off the, you're on my side or you're on that side. 27:22 Yeah. 27:23 Obviously, it came from the inscriptions mania. 27:26 When Bitcoin Core refused to patch inscriptions. 27:31 But I think many people still ignore and as a professional ex-spammer, I can confidently say you cannot patch it. 27:39 If you patch one hole, they will come for the other. If you patch another, they will come for the other. It's just a chicken and mouse game. 27:45 Chicken and egg game or whatever you say. 27:47 cat and mouse chicken and mouse oh i'm using that it's the chicken and mouse game that's chicken and mouse game yeah i just invented um but yeah like there was no sort of incentive that 28:00 we did provide to any cord or whatever and it was solely going for the sake of technical discussions I think people are especially like by their soul I feel when they are angry about the inscriptions because it increases the fees or whatever but then still 28:22 the fork attempt I think was kind of useless because if you are trying to block spam it doesn't block runes which is the main source of spam and if you look at the inscriptions graph it's not even happening anymore it's almost dead and the only thing 28:36 Bit110 causes is to gather more attention from DGENs to spam the chain harder. 28:42 Like every single day, David Prince is naming one meta protocol that I have never heard in my life saying like, oh, they're going to kill Bitcoin, where they will probably have only 10 users and die eventually. 28:54 Like the solution to spam problem is to ignore and make sure that they die. 28:58 And because there's no other proper solution that I feel like I could do if I were on their side. 29:03 or instead of forking without listening to anyone and instead of forking by blocking everyone on Twitter so that you don't need to listen to them I think if I were them I would find an alternative client basically and probably many people would be okay to run it as well 29:21 but do it properly instead of having it look maintain only go find some people who can do it I'm sure with enough money and with enough good motivation that does not call everyone as a pedo, they could find a couple developers to do it. 29:40 This just wasn't the way. 29:41 And even though people are smart, generally, in both sides, I think we all tend to have some delusions in our daily lives and beliefs. 29:51 Oh yeah, of course. 29:52 Like looking at the reactions at the stream when they had when the fork happened, like mechanic being in disbelief, creator being in disbelief. 30:01 I felt actually sad. 30:02 because you kind of feel like they are believing something and they're going after it. 30:06 But we tried to warn them, like, this isn't going to work. 30:09 And now they're doing a hard fork, which I don't want to even comment about that. 30:15 Like, our own delusions can protect us, but also can hurt us. 30:19 And I think that was a very good example of the latter. 30:23 There was no incentives going on to bribe court. 30:25 There was no incentive to destroy Bitcoin. 30:28 If Citray was massively successful, could that have problems for fees? 30:32 Maybe. Is it massively successful? No. Will it be successful? I'm not entirely sure. 30:38 I don't think so too much. But yeah, it's like, because you're being pissed off spam and because now, even though you don't understand it fully, you see that James and Lobb commenting under a GitHub issue, you are going a full revolt. 30:54 I think this wasn't the way. I think they should have found generally a very good devs make a good alternative client, make people run it. And then maybe in two or three years when 31:04 it gets good amount of adoption then maybe it could be actually successful I don know That at least how I would do it I really glad that said that because I always thought that was actually the the better path forward was to stay and present an alternative client And like to just make knots as good as you could make knots And even have a different like a whole bunch of people are like Oh it like super inefficient for the network and bad to have different policies And I completely disagree Like efficiency and robustness often go against 31:39 each other. You know, like proof of work is not efficient. Like peacock having those feathers is not efficient, but it serves a completely different purpose. Redundancy is not efficient, 31:51 but it makes it impossible to kill. Like robustness and resiliency often conflict with efficiency. 31:59 We don't want the most efficient network. That's what fiat is after, right? Is integrate everything, centralized everything super super efficient but it's also crazy fragile and so i always thought 32:12 that staying with a different client and simply building that out like they had the best position they had that i i thought the fork was always going to cause reputational damage to this of 32:26 actually presenting a alternative path within the consensus rules of the same network um and they just played their cards too fast they went all in on the second hand and they they didn't play the 32:40 long game and that's one of the major reasons i could never get behind it um but yeah let me toss it back to you and then i just kind of want to hold on to this because there was something else 32:50 that you said that i wanted to get you to expand on but let me toss it back to you it is okay to be like questioning core governance as a human nature and as an important asset like you know that's That's quite normal. 33:04 It's important to have some alternatives. 33:07 It's important to make them proper. 33:10 But yeah, as you also said, as I also said, this was not the way to do it, particularly not in this way. 33:17 There's still some bugs like I disclosed to Luke. 33:19 I did some security stuff. 33:22 There's the bug I disclosed to Luke, but I don't even know what happened. 33:26 And probably if he had more pair of eyes that is checking the core code, he could see it. 33:31 It's not a consensus critical bug, but it was a silly bug. 33:36 And also it's the stance of it. 33:38 The thing that got me pissed the most was people calling each other, the forker side calling the other side being pedo or distributing CSAM. 33:51 This is complete bullshit. 33:52 You are not the only guy who's a good guy. 33:55 You are not the only pure soul in the world who can see it as you see it. 34:01 Because hundreds of technical people, hundreds of non-technical people who see and basically elaborates over the views that you have and does not come at the same conclusion as you. 34:13 And still you keep calling them as like being pedo or being terrible or being evil, whatever. 34:19 This is not the way to go forward. 34:21 And maybe it's because of the, you know, characteristic of Luke being Luke or people being under delusion. 34:29 But I think that also costed them a lot because many people who were sort of natural that I know of simply didn't like it because it wasn't true at all. 34:38 I think it was complete bullshit. 34:41 But yeah, here we are. 34:43 I mean, they've worked. 34:44 I don't know what they will do. 34:47 I guess, good luck. 34:48 There's still a couple people. 34:49 I think for many plebs and for many people, a lot of people around me, I don't have much people around me, But a lot of people who share the same view as me is completely okay to like reunite with everyone because, you know, people saw that this doesn't happen. 35:05 But I think there are still a couple of people who I am really pissed off and probably I'll keep calling them all day. 35:13 Particularly the people who kept harassing some core devs. 35:19 For example, the Gloria incident. 35:20 Like, first of all, we didn't do shit with Gloria. 35:24 Okay. 35:25 Like no incentives, no bribery, whatever. 35:27 But she was a very good developer. You cannot say otherwise. Whether all the articles that HODLNOT wrote or whatever, I don't care. She was a very good developer and she was doing fine. And 35:41 she was becoming a maintainer simply in the same IRC chat. There's a comment of Luke saying, sort of saying, does she have a choice or something? There's no one who can deny it. 35:51 And she did a lot of good for Lightning stuff as well. She shipped a troop, she shipped the part of Pay2Anchor helped it and then she probably helped one parent, one child stuff. 36:02 So there was a lot of improvements she also brought to table. Should you be critical of core governance or the way people are moving around? Maybe. But was it the way that they behaved? Absolutely not. And that went too far that she resigned over something that she didn't 36:19 even do Just because you don understand the policy change and just because you being over conspiracy theorist I think this wasn supposed to end up like that So I felt really bad when it happened I couldn do shit because I nowhere near these circles 36:37 But I think this wasn't the case. Like you can ask John Attack, you can ask James Orburn, like they can say like this wasn't the way and we are free to agree or disagree. But all the insults and all the shit, like it wasn't right. 36:50 Yeah, there were a bunch of like little little segments or whatever that got passed around with her to basically just form a picture of she makes a comment of she didn't own any Bitcoin, which I kind of wondered if that was a troll. 37:08 I mean, I also I also tell you like I am poor. Do you think? 37:11 Yeah, I have more or less. 37:13 Yeah, you never know. 37:13 And then there was a comment at like a conference or something where she was like crapping on Bitcoin maximalism or whatever. 37:23 And then, of course, you know, if you have a background at all in Ethereum, then like that's going to be easy game for a lot of like simple picture on small out of context clips. 37:38 And I never really mechanic brought that up a couple of times on the roundtable. 37:43 and I never really commented on it other than just the fact that it's something that I literally never had the time to actually dig into and I know how easy it is to watch those 15 or 20 second clips and then form an opinion when you don't know Jack about anybody or anything 38:01 and because I watch it happen to me because I've been in a total middle ground of like I'm not going to support BIP-110 I'm not really scared of the things that BIP 110 was trying to do, like removing op if from taproot, even if you take 38:18 out the whole inscription conversation, I actually think that's a good idea. Taproot was built to actually work with leaves and with tap leaves. And the beauty of it is that you actually have 38:29 privacy by using your instead of op if you have your if be in the branches. And that gives you better privacy and better efficiency in the entire construction of your transaction. Leaving op if in 38:41 that is like it's it's like having an elevator and an escalator and then like like and leaving your stair i don't i don't even know how to explain it like i'm trying to come up with a good analogy but like i sort of disagree with that but go ahead i want to well i wanted i want 38:58 you to push back on that then in just a second but um like and then i i wanted to explicitly get you to address something because i also i'm a monetary maximalist in the sense that i don't think Bitcoin needs to be super technically evolved to like it needs all these features and 39:19 all this coding and all this scripting to actually be better money. Quite the contrary, money is hardened. Money is about trust. And the less it does, the more trustworthy it can be. Like gold 39:31 doesn't actually need to be malleable and good at making spears. It just needs to be good at being gold and the nature of something that we already have programmable, like with lightning and that 39:42 sort of thing. I actually think Bitcoin would be totally fine if we added nothing. But in the context of inscriptions, I thought there would be no loss. Like I could care less whether or not 39:55 inscriptions were possible or not possible on Bitcoin. If somehow there was a way to change a rule and then inscriptions didn't work or they just became too expensive, that in my mind was always like a positive, but maybe an on net positive, but also didn't think 40:14 it was existential because I use Bitcoin every single day and all this talk about spam. 40:18 It's like, I can't, I can't think this is the end of the world because every single day I use Bitcoin and I never think about it. 40:23 Like, you know, I don't know. 40:24 Every single day, do you use Bitcoin or do you use Lightthink? 40:27 Both. 40:28 Both. 40:29 Every day. 40:29 I mean, you know, I'm sure there's a couple of days where I don't do a transaction, but like I literally use it all the time. 40:35 I've sent probably four or five today already. 40:39 Most, I think all lightning today. 40:41 But but because of that, like I never I was never like, where's my block space? 40:47 You know, like I've been paying one, two sat per V by all year. 40:51 And, you know, like and people are trying to get me in it. 40:53 Like, I do agree. 40:55 I think you should generally do something about spam. 40:57 But no, I don't think it's an existential crisis because I'm using it fine. 41:02 And so anyway, all of that aside, I wanted you to explain because I have never seen any positive value in inscriptions. 41:11 They just seem stupid. 41:12 It's all dick butts. 41:14 They're stupid. 41:16 Put dick butts aside. 41:18 What convinced me that inscriptions have a use with like Citria? 41:23 Why is it good to be able to do this? 41:27 and not a net negative or not something to be concerned about. 41:31 No, you patch inscriptions and then what happens next? 41:36 They come at somewhere else. 41:38 Yeah, they just stick it somewhere else. 41:39 And then they come somewhere else. 41:41 So retards are always going to be retard-mazing. 41:43 There's no way to stop DJs doing DJ-mazing. 41:46 Yeah, it is what it is. 41:47 It's the nature of life. 41:48 You just need to leave them on their own and they will die eventually, which they did. 41:52 Like, look at the graphs, look at the fees. 41:54 Like, it's nowhere near the inscription mania because inscriptions are dead. 41:57 And now the new idea is runes. 41:59 Everyone's using runes. 42:01 And they will be dead too. 42:03 And eventually all of this will be less and less and less and probably months out of demand. 42:08 like patching is not the right method to fight it. Ignoring is the best way to do it because from a purely technical standpoint if someone wants to beat the shit out of it, the amount of sacrifices you need to do is just way too high. Way too high. Even in beep 110 which doesn't 42:26 prevent runes, there's like four or five different ways you can spam the shit out of the chain. Then what? 42:32 Then what? They need to patch it again. 42:34 These sort of stuff is primarily the reason that I think, and the way I see it from an external observer, people are not really caring about it. 42:45 The NFT mania in Ethereum happened, all the shitcoining happened on Ethereum as well. 42:48 And now if you look at it, it's dead. 42:50 They don't care about it. 42:52 So the similar mania will also happen to Bitcoin. 42:55 One day, Ruinus will be dead no matter how retarded they were and no one will care about it. 43:00 And then another day, some other Chinese guy will embed some data and then they will use it and then it will disappear. 43:07 This is just life. 43:10 Trying to patch it, trying to cripple it in any way you want will just bring more attention rather than ignoring. 43:17 Even with the BIP110, people started to do some compatible types of inscriptions, which luckily wasn't too much. 43:24 Yeah, it wasn't too much luckily, so no one cared about it. 43:28 But yeah, the soul wants something. 43:31 But when you look at the technical rationale behind decisions, I think it becomes much much more conceivable. 43:38 For example, on the usefulness of Citria, for example. 43:41 Yeah, that's what I wanted to get at. 43:44 Yeah, yeah. 43:46 So today, like, lightning infrastructure is good, but still you need some liquidity, for example. 43:51 Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't work. 43:53 Is it private? 43:54 Yes, particularly with Bolt 12, it's great. 43:57 But still, like, there are some hiccups that used to happen and sometimes still happens with lightning because of liquidity problems. 44:04 Okay, let's not use lightning because it has problems. 44:07 else you can use. And then there is Liquid, which has custodians that can cause problems. 44:12 Or if Liquid operators and Liquid nodes decides to censor you, then your money is stuck and you cannot even connect the network and they can hide it in a black box basically. 44:23 So with Citria, on a technical level, it was kind of addressing some problems of these sidechains and some problems of Lightning. Was it bringing more problems to the table? 44:34 of yes. For example, there were cases where you couldn't exit and still is. And there were cases like your money could be stuck or there were cases like now on production, you can misanswer. Does this happen? Yes. But was it an idea? Was it a very technical idea that 44:51 was being implemented? Also yes. When ideally implemented with proper opcodes that doesn't exist and probably will never exist on Bitcoin today. 45:01 Probably rollups could be very, very useful in terms of you can be able to exit whenever you want without depending on anyone. 45:11 And you can be able to use that alternative chain, alternative shitcoin from wherever you want. 45:19 So it was giving you kind of these guarantees where sometimes Lightning was failing, sometimes Liquid was failing. 45:27 Sometimes even Bitcoin was failing in terms of transaction fees or like compression or speed because you wait for blocks or whatever. 45:35 It's kind of a trade-off where you get faster and cheaper transactions, but you compromise your security, which for 99% they don't. 45:46 It's fine. 45:47 Yeah, on Ethereum, these stuff work because they have more ways to prove that you have the funds and exit. 45:55 But on Bitcoin, we don't have this, so it doesn't bring too much to the table. 45:59 But are they over-complexed? 46:00 Yes. 46:01 Are they great inventions in terms of maths? 46:03 Definitely yes. 46:05 Like the amount of work, the math gigabrain stuff that went on with Zerolge proofs and shit. 46:11 I think it was really cool. 46:13 Did it work out? 46:14 Doesn't seem so. 46:16 Was it to destroy Bitcoin? 46:18 Absolutely not. 46:20 No one cared about it. 46:23 Did I have fun building it? 46:25 Mostly yes, it was a good experiment again. 46:28 But yeah, no one had intention to destroy shit or incentivize or bribe shit. 46:35 It was an experiment and here we are. 46:36 Give me the spill for Citria. 46:39 Like, what does it use? 46:41 Talk a little bit about the bridge and what it does and what it can do for you, since 46:47 you specifically brought up lightning and like how it creates those transactions because You said it would need hundreds of kilobytes or megabytes a day of transaction volume to basically maintain the system Yeah. 47:01 The reason for hundreds of kilobytes is loss, at least when I was there. 47:07 If you are using Liquid, for example, for something or Rootstock, maybe a name you never heard of for a long time. 47:14 Yeah. 47:14 If they decide to hide the data, if they decide not to publish anything through their RPC, and if you have some files in there, there's no way of you knowing what's going on. 47:26 So on Citria, basically what it does is publishing the data on Bitcoin so that you get to know what it does and what's happening. 47:34 And this matters if there was a way to exit the system by publishing a transaction to Bitcoin and sending a message. 47:43 In an ideal scenario in Citria Bridge, if some operators or some entities of people who are holding custody decides to steal on their own, you could challenge them in a mathematical way and take the money out. 47:57 A bit similar to lightning challenges like when someone tries to steal the money, but it's much more context. 48:04 So this is the actually entire reasoning. 48:08 It is kind of a better liquid, kind of a better rootstock where you should be able to exit or maybe challenge people if they try to steal. 48:17 But does it work exactly that way? 48:18 No, because it's not implemented as the same as the theory due to Bitcoin's capabilities. 48:25 But again, the capability additions require a fork and they don't do that. 48:34 It was just a policy change. 48:35 It's irrelevant. 48:38 Yeah, I don't know if I answered your question, but the bridge is, for example, on Liquid, I think it was 11 of 15 multisig. 48:46 If they decide to steal, they can steal. 48:49 For example, in the original design of Citria, it's 10 of 10, let's say. 48:55 And if, let's say, out of these 10, oh, it's so hard to explain, how do I do this? 49:03 it's a 10 of 10 but when you want to get your money you don't need every 10 to be online and if the people responsible to pay your money are being dishonest you can do mathematical proofs to kick them out so that was the theory but in practice 49:18 it is working but there's also a fallback security council which is probably a 3 of 5 multisig so essentially it's the same thing as a 3 of 5 so that's why it doesn't matter too much so it's a little bit like a like a federation multi-sig in a sense from a security standpoint. 49:39 At the end of the day, it's a federation multi-sig that was designed to be safe for a federation multi-sig that has crazy amounts of cryptography, but none of this matters because it's a federation multi-sig. 49:52 I'm curious what your thought is on it now, because you said it drops to three or five. 49:59 Do you think I tend to... 50:02 Like there were so many like cool proposals and I always kind of like geek out on them for a little bit. 50:06 Like there were spider chains and stuff. 50:07 I'm not sure if you read about that one. 50:10 Trying to do proof of stake on top of proof of work, which I think theoretically is an interesting idea. 50:16 But practically it's a mess. 50:19 I tend to think things that are overly complex just aren't ever going to work. 50:23 or they're always just going to hit some roadblock or be too difficult to implement or have too many edge cases in practice to be sustainable. 50:36 And I'm curious what you think about the idea. 50:40 So Citria is BitVM, right? 50:43 As I understand it. 50:44 Yes, on the bridge. 50:46 What do you think about BitVM generally? 50:48 Do you believe that this is something that is robust enough that it could actually have substantial adoption? 50:56 Or do you think it will mostly be like an experimental side project that may lead to just other developments or modes of applying things that are, you know, meaningful in some sense, but never massively adopted as a tool itself? 51:13 Yeah, it's a crazy cool algorithm. 51:16 It's the algorithm that I mentioned as cryptographically complex that Cydia was using for the abridge. 51:22 It is something that if you could integrate to Liquid, for example, instead of 11 people stealing your funds, being able to steal your funds, you would only need one out of 15 to be honest, which reduces the trust assumption to if everyone is honest and hacked, they can steal. 51:40 But as it is, it's not perfect because you still have this complex mechanism and you still have this assumption of one people being honest. 51:47 And the only way to make it absolutely perfect is if you would have some opcodes to make it better and trustless so that no matter who tries to steal their money, they cannot 51:59 steal your money type of shit And to make it possible you need opcat or something similar Though I think it will happen I lost hope I think it won happen at all 52:12 Is that a big problem? Probably no, but it would be cool to have. But like, if it doesn't happen, then it doesn't happen. It's not the end of the world. 52:20 It doesn't change the fact that it's a really cool algorithm, some really genius shit. But yeah, it's an algorithm. 52:28 It's not something that tries to destroy Bitcoin or it's not something that Epstein is funding to kill Bitcoin. 52:35 It's just some 200 IQ people inventing shit because they like it. 52:41 And the 200 IQ people are useful because they also help you invent lightning, which you use every day. 52:48 They're also inventing similar solutions like ARK. 52:51 They're also inventing more different stuff that could be better and useful. 52:56 They're also writing the proposals where with L2 or with CTV or with Tempoed hash, you can make the security of Lightning or similar solutions much better. 53:07 So all these things are not just to make things over complex. 53:12 There are use cases for them and there is a reason they get pushbacks or proponents. 53:18 And this is just the nature of having a network that's functional. 53:23 That's why like from a technical perspective, many people get super hyped when they see or learn something because immediately they think about, oh, can this make lightning better? 53:35 Can this make Bitcoin better? 53:38 Some of them I understand, some of them I don't. 53:40 But the ones I don't understand doesn't mean that it's an attack on Bitcoin. 53:44 It's the fact that maybe I should be humble and listen a bit more on what they're talking about and then push back. 53:50 Even technical people are keep fighting against each other. 53:52 So it doesn't matter much. 53:53 doing it for you. But yeah, I think this is the kind of feeling that I have about it. 54:00 Cool algorithms that will be discussed for a long time. We will see how it goes. That's it. I don't know if I answered your question correctly. 54:12 No, you did. I want to go ahead and get into privacy, but I just want to say one thing on the whole Epstein stuff because that frustrated me. I did a video on the whole Epstein thing. 54:23 And like there's so many, probably the only person Brock Pierce is, was deep enough in it. 54:33 Like the amount of conversation that Brock Pierce and Epstein had was just like wild. 54:37 They was like his favorite crypto buddy. 54:40 Yeah. 54:41 But what I found interesting from the context of people saying that Epstein invented Bitcoin, that Epstein controls Bitcoin, all this stuff. 54:55 And it wasn't just Bit110ers. 54:57 It was just all over the place. 54:59 Everybody's just like, Epstein's in Bitcoin. 55:01 And what I found most interesting about all the things, aside from the fact that his funding didn't line up with any narrative. 55:10 I could not find any connection between like he only funded this side in the block size war. 55:15 He's only funding companies that are related to shit coins or NFTs like nothing. 55:20 I couldn't find any association anywhere that was meaningful. 55:23 And we have information. 55:24 It's not like you have to speculate. 55:26 You can look at stuff. 55:28 But the big one was that he never showed any sign of really caring. 55:33 like I read so many emails and the overwhelming majority of them were like one and two word responses like oh he's smart cool that sounds nice that like it was just kind of dismissive like sure I'll invest in this sure I'll give you this little bit of money and it's all people 55:53 like going in it's like you want to fund my pet project you want to invest I got a new shit coin for you you know Brock Pierce is jumping in with a shit coin every two weeks and everybody's it just sounded like a whole bunch of people begging a rich guy for money and 56:06 him just being like kind of entertaining a few things, but not caring at all about what was going on. 56:13 And, and I was just like, you know, if you have these conspiracies, like have some evidence, you know, you can't just like make a connection. 56:20 Like if I bump into, to Taylor, I'm not, doesn't, that doesn't mean like, Oh, I had him on the show and it's like, Oh, I'm invested in Citrius. 56:28 Like, well, no, you would actually have, no, you don't know. 56:30 You don't know. 56:31 I bribed you, you know? 56:32 So Epstein gave me money and now I bribed you and you were having mechanic on your show just to make people believe that you're an innocent guy, but you're actually being funded. 56:41 It's all a trick. 56:42 So you are captured, GG next. 56:43 It was all underneath. 56:45 It was all under the table. 56:47 Yeah, definitely. 56:48 You don't see that? 56:49 Come on, you need to read more tweets from Bitcoin Bombadil, you know? 56:53 He explains this. 56:56 Oh, shit. 56:57 Let's go on to privacy though, because you are doing some really interesting things. 57:03 This is what you left Citria. 57:04 When did you leave Citria, by the way, again? 57:06 I forgot. 57:07 At the end of last year or beginning of this year, basically. 57:10 Beginning this year. 57:11 Okay And so now you working on was it LX I forgot the tag Yeah I working at LX It is LX It is LX LX Research LX Labs Yeah. 57:23 Give me a breakdown of what you're focused on and how you guys are thinking about privacy and research on tools and like what the best things you see going forward to kind of advance, to move things a little bit in the right direction, so to speak. 57:42 Yeah. 57:42 Yeah. So quick backstory is I'm working with Janos, who is quite a cool research guy, who is quite a cool privacy guy as well in space. So yeah, basically I have Citriandum for a while. I was hanging around, chilling, and then he was being more and more focused on, 58:04 strangely enough, statechains. Are you familiar with them, statechains? 58:08 Yeah, yeah, I use, well, I guess Spark, the Breeze SDK, but also Mercury wallet. 58:15 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 58:18 I use the word retard waxing. 58:20 I think state chain is actually the best example of retard waxing in a good way. 58:25 It's like... 58:26 I was about to say, I love state chain ideas. 58:29 Don't crap on that. 58:30 Tell me why. 58:31 No, no, it's in a good way. 58:32 Okay, okay. 58:33 Like, you know, it's like if you need to transfer a coin, what do you do? 58:39 Like instead of transferring the coin itself, literally. 58:41 Just give somebody the keys. 58:44 Yeah, you hand the keys or you do some math shit and then the key kind of becomes transferred. 58:49 Does it have some downsides? 58:51 Obviously, yes. 58:52 You need to trust the previous owners. 58:55 But at the end of the day, it's actually a very cool, clever, interesting, strange, chill idea that you can do a lot of things built on top of it which Spark exists today. 59:06 Or people try to build Mercury Layer where they try to secure things better through TEs and enclaves which is the keys cannot feed the server and even though you cannot 100% prove that they removed the keys still you can attest the programming execution or some shit. 59:25 So yeah, we were doing like we were thinking about what we can do about state of Bitcoin on privacy stuff. 59:32 So we first came up with an idea of having an interesting, fully amount preserving and hiding sidechain, kind of similar to the Quid where it's also fully Lightning compatible. 59:45 So we did experimentation around that. 59:47 We did a quick demo on Prague with some friends we know. 59:52 It's doable. 59:52 So you can build chains on Bitcoin, for example, today where you transfer some money, but no one knows how much you transfer it. 60:00 So one cool idea, for example, this was possible. 60:03 We did it as an experiment. 60:05 It was cool. 60:06 Now we are more heading towards the idea of how dark can you do trading among people? 60:14 For example, today, if I sell some Bitcoin, it's visible on Bitcoin chain. 60:19 Like when I move my UTXO, it's visible. 60:22 But if you're doing it on something like Mercury layer, or if you're doing it on a layer that functions as a state chain, because you are not moving the coin actually, but rather you and server and the previous owner and the server keep signing something and then you 60:40 kind of adjusting the key and you kind of, even without transferring and without anyone knowing, you're kind of being able to move the coin around. 60:49 That's a cool idea because if I, for example, sell my $10,000, I don't want to do this directly on L1. 60:57 I want to do it in a system where no one can know that I sold my Bitcoin. 61:01 Actually state chains can do that to some degree. 61:04 So we're kind of still experimenting around the idea of having these sort of stuff. 61:08 And can you build trading on it? 61:10 Can you do dart pools? 61:11 Can you do OTC trading where if you're selling huge amount of Bitcoin or even not so huge amount of Bitcoin? Is there a way to make it hidden to the public? And is there a way to make 61:23 it like six, seven people selling Bitcoin already, but no one knows who sold, but somehow either bank transfers or Lightning payments moving around? So it's sort of this stuff making an interesting 61:35 perspective for custody we're trying to build. And all of this matters because of one reason. 61:40 Today, can you also use Coinbase to sell your coin? Yes. But can you guarantee that if Coinbase disappears, your funds will be with you. 61:48 No, because it is at the end of the day, their custody. 61:52 Whereas in state chains, a really cool perspective is if the server or the custodian disappears because of the design of the system, money comes back at you on L1. 62:03 You can broadcast an exit or you can do nothing and the money comes back to you. 62:08 So it's kind of becomes, you know, if something bad happens to us or to server, then still money is yours. 62:16 And I think this is a really, really cool property. 62:18 Basically being able to exit even though things become fucked up. 62:23 So yeah, but we're basically experimenting out this. 62:27 Can you build really cool, sort of, of dark pool designs where you can be able to buy and sell without anyone knowing. 62:35 And the answer seems to be yes. 62:37 I think we will reveal more towards that. 62:40 But yeah, this is sort of the technical nerd snipe shit we're working on so far. 62:46 That's awesome. 62:47 So how do you handle, is it mostly just kind of like a escrow situation when you're buying and selling or do you do this with tether specifically or something like is it stable coins that make this viable because how do you how do you get in and out of kind of the 63:06 fiat side of things when you're looking at buying and selling in a market? 63:09 I mean we haven't fully decided yet it's still going most research so there can be multiple answers again. 63:16 You can do stable coins, you can do even bank I assume like a bunch of cool companies that has proper bank integrations to buy and sell Bitcoin for people. 63:26 We can even use them. 63:27 I don't know. 63:28 You can even do it through some different assets that some companies already offer. 63:35 Even Spark has some different tokenization and different stablecoin designs. 63:40 But stablecoin seems viable for richer people, maybe bank transfers is viable or some third party APIs that we can use like Magnolia, maybe. 63:50 I don't know. 63:52 Yeah, that's something that I didn't think too much about it. 63:56 I'm mostly focusing on, is there a way to make this much secure and is there a way to make this cooler without assuming there won't be any opcodes added to Bitcoin? 64:06 If there is, things can be easier, but I cannot guarantee that. 64:09 No one can. 64:12 And my old friend with Citri are not helping me as well. 64:14 So we need... 64:17 But yeah, I'm mostly focusing on the technical side of things to understand it better. 64:20 but I think you definitely should have a podcast with Yanus as well he's really delighted to enjoy and talk with wait with who in privacy situations who let me search with my with my founder with my with my CEO basically I'm not a founder but to LX yeah I can send him 64:37 I can send him yeah Yanus yeah Yanus okay yeah I will send him he's he's crazy I'm curious on the you know I felt that So many people crap on stablecoins and this idea that they're CBDCs by a different route. 64:58 But I really kind of feel very differently. 65:03 Obviously, there are massive drawbacks to stablecoins. 65:08 CBDCs are a totally different thing, though. 65:10 Because we're looking at something that's plugged directly into the central bank, which has issuing and total control. 65:16 Whereas stable coins look to me like a return to traditional banking, where you actually have banknotes branded with the institution that holds the reserves. 65:29 And so Tether is based on Tether's reserves. 65:33 Spark USD is based on Spark's reserves. 65:36 and that's that means that you actually have competition in the layer of providing monetary infrastructure which i i think is a huge net gain considering how bad the environment is right now and i've also felt because swapping between stable coins and bitcoin is so freaking easy 65:59 and it can be entirely programmatic is that that's the way that you get around all of the problems of a pull system of fiat. 66:08 Yeah, it helps a lot because I think a major problem is, like, you always have this risk of tetherrugging you, like, there's no way of going around that. 66:18 But because these stable coins, or sometimes shit coins even, are much more programmable than what you would desire, you are done in an abundance of design choice that you can have. 66:30 Like, that's why the atomic swaps exist, that's why, like, bolts existed, which, shout out to them. I like them a lot. I hope they're doing fine. 66:39 Yeah, that sucks. 66:39 But yeah, like there's this... 66:41 They were a really cool team. 66:44 I think it's a coincidence. 66:46 I think the AI stuff was really hard to deal with. 66:50 But the Canary stuff, I don't buy it. 66:52 I think they're fine. It's just that it was hard to run the infrastructure probably from a technical standpoint, obviously. 66:59 But yeah, you can do now atomic slots between layers and now you can guarantee that as long as Tetra or Circle or whoever doing this table is rugging me, isn't rugging me, then you can know that your money is not stuck or stolen. 67:15 So having this flexibility, being able to move around is definitely necessary. 67:21 Of course, you can wish and it's much more ideal to live in a world where you have everything Bitcoin only, but we don't have that flex now. 67:31 So the way that makes you escape any banks is the best way that you should have. 67:37 Yeah And that why we riding along with it Does it reduce the risk of being rugged by the issuer Of course no Where does the yield come from No one knows. 67:49 But still, it's good to have. 67:52 And I think like, no matter how hostile we are, I think there's a use case. 67:56 And we cannot prevent that. 67:58 It's people's choice. 67:59 People do whatever they want. 68:00 It seems like such a natural progression to me to basically to retain the currency, the money that people are used to, but flip the infrastructure of how they interact with it. 68:17 Because you're immediately, when it comes to stable coins, you're immediately teaching bank tellers and everybody in the offices and everybody on the tech running the websites and everything. 68:28 How to manage keys, how to do multi-sig, what an address looks like. 68:33 You're teaching them all of our infrastructure without requiring them to trust an entirely different money at the same time. 68:41 It's the first step to a five-step process. 68:45 And it actually improves the banking system. 68:47 If we didn't have Bitcoin, a move from our banking system to stable coins as it is, is a significant net positive. I can receive Tether without making an account with anybody. That's a big deal. And that makes the next step to actually trusting Bitcoin and understanding how to keep it safe and dealing with its security and building companies on top of it and understanding its infrastructure. 69:12 it's just a it's fewer steps it's fewer steps if you allow stable coins to happen first and that's why some bunch of bitcoin maxis will just get on me about this i'm certain certain but i think 69:24 stable coins and bitcoin adoption alongside each other is the quickest path to getting people to understand or accept and be familiar with a monetary transition to bitcoin um yeah just use them but don't surrender that's the trick yeah yeah use as much as 69:41 you can yeah be careful as much as you can but don't surrender your entire life saving or don't stop by using like a bank treat it like fiat yeah exactly yeah exactly um well uh let's get into the red team stuff because you said you didn't think any of this 69:59 was on purpose with bolts and I haven't dug that much into it but my conspiracy brain comes up very quickly and it's like we got hit with I know this from B.110, so it's fine. 70:10 Yeah, we got cold card. 70:13 We've got, you know, Trezor. 70:15 And of course, this could all be a coincidence of people just realizing that it's time to use AI and Kimmy and all this stuff to just hack as many things as we can hack. 70:24 Like, I can't absolve my rational brain from entertaining that idea. 70:31 But I also can't let my conspiracy brain go that we're seeing huge influx into the ETF. 70:37 Um, we've, the response is a heavy push toward custodians and governments and large corporate interests with a lot of political control have been notorious about doing this type of thing. 70:52 Like they don't shy away from attacking, uh, whether it be openly and politically or behind the scenes, anything that appears to be a threat to, to kind of their position in the market or the political influence. 71:07 So I have a hard time saying it's all not, it's all just a coincidence. 71:12 But, you know, we'll see. 71:14 Maybe something will come out that will lean me one way or the other. 71:19 But in that, this presents a new very hard lesson learned, especially with cold card. 71:28 And in the age of AI is the idea of red teaming. 71:33 of like we need to be far more active and vigilant about destroying our own things so that we can fix them before someone else comes to destroy them you know as much as i love bolts and i hate that this has happened but we've got to figure and this is not an easy problem 71:57 But we have to figure out how to make limited, trust-minimized, non-custodial or pseudo-custodial type things as secure as possible and not vulnerable to massive attack, not vulnerable to DDoS. 72:15 And I know there's no magic wand solution, but we live in an age where anybody can now perform this, can play this game. 72:23 and so I want you to dig into what you guys are doing with red teaming and what you've been you said you've been working with Rob Rob Hamilton has been killing it just going through and I've 72:35 been spending my own tokens just in doing I've been doing a assessment and just kind of like brainstorming I'm like how can we attack this a different way with the bit box stuff 72:45 just because they my sponsor and god I don want this to you know I changed completely about how I think about the hardware and the software that I using now And I having to go back and rethink about how do I red team my own stuff 73:00 So anyway, run with that because I've been fascinated with this new movement and this kind of like blossoming of understanding this problem and how quickly the Bitcoin community has responded to it. 73:16 And what have y'all found, I guess? 73:19 I mean, over what I have found, I cannot speak about it, but there was some definitely bugs. 73:26 But yeah, I think, so yeah, the cold card stuff. 73:29 So the moment, I think it's good for me to start it from there. 73:35 So when the tweets of Kevin, I suppose, I don't recall his name, but there was this guy who was raising alarms on Twitter. 73:44 Yeah, so when there was some tweets over cold cards happening, I initially didn't believe it, of course. 73:49 because, you know, people are trying to make mistakes. 73:55 It happens. 73:55 It's the nature of being a human. 73:58 And there's been a lot of mistakes by humans, such as like pasting a mnemonic to some website or doing some stupid shit. 74:05 So it happens. 74:06 Even while accepting the podcasting, I had to check five times and on the sixth, I wasn't sure whether like, you know, if everything is fine or not. 74:14 And it could still happen if you ask me now to download Zoom, I won't. 74:17 But yeah, so people can and sometimes do mistakes. 74:22 When I saw it initially, I didn't believe it. 74:25 And then there was these discussions on Stacker News. 74:27 So I was checking it and there was a bunch of comments checking like, can it be entropy? 74:34 Can it be nulls? 74:35 What if there is some other strange bug or whatever? 74:37 So I think like a couple hours when either, I think when the way one happened or when I was trying to understand what's going on. 74:48 I basically opened 5.6 and then basically like said, there's a cold card hack happening. 74:54 It's I gave to GPT 5.6. 74:57 There's a cold card hack happening. 74:58 Just research what you find. 75:00 And then it gave me a bunch of links and I gave it to some, I gave some comments from Stacker News saying like, can it be related to entropy or whatever? 75:08 And I told it like, just analyze a bunch of transactions, see how it's happening. 75:13 Do you see any link? 75:14 And can it be related to entropy? 75:16 So it started to work. 75:17 And I think at the end of a total of 30 minutes, it responded me, oh shit, there's a problem between version 4.0.0 and version 4.1.9. 75:31 The entropy is broken. 75:33 And I was like, I read it, but I didn't believe it obviously first because the LLMs are also tend to bullshit. 75:42 It happens. 75:42 Even now when I find a bug, it says like, oh, the user phone says at risk. 75:47 And I check and the bot doesn't exist or it's on testnet. 75:52 So I was curious and then I basically reached out to Portland first. 75:56 I don't know if you know him. 75:58 So I asked Portland, can you check if this is real? 76:01 And then I think he also let Rob know. 76:03 And then I also started the chat with James as well. 76:07 And then we concluded after 10, 20 more minutes, it's actually real and we're all fucked. 76:12 so yeah that was my initial reaction that's a moment god that's a moment I think I wasn't first probably I think block guys were at it or maybe Rabin was at it even though we blocked each other I think he was also at it yeah I insulted him on Twitter and then he blocked me 76:34 and then I blocked him so it's fine but he's a smart dude but yeah so I think like a lot of people at the same time started to realize what's happening but it was too late. 76:44 Yeah, and then for the next couple days, I tried to research over what was the actual entropy range. 76:51 And the more important question was, if there was a white hat effort, is there a way to prove that the funds are coming from that particular device? 77:03 So exchanges help a lot on that one, whether fortunate or unfortunately, because they do QYC. 77:09 I was about to say the irony of KYC and a total lack of privacy for some people being the mode of actually being able to potentially recover or prove that you have your Bitcoin is not lost on me. 77:26 But still KYC is bad. 77:28 Of course. 77:28 Of course. 77:29 On that KYC is terrible, especially as like a foundational requirement. 77:34 but it still doesn't it is sad to admit that there's times where it's valuable yeah and for the next couple days like I was researching it I think there's not a proper way to say the funds or the entropy seed is coming from a particular device 77:57 there are a couple of reasons behind that but it's hard Like even the amount of presses you do kind of changes It doesn change the seed of it but it changes your key sometimes Like the cold history affects it So it a hard dilemma to have but I spent a couple days searching for it 78:17 And then I saw that Rob and Kali are starting to do some red teaming. 78:23 And I think in the initial night of the attack, I basically helped him a lot to try to understand what's going on. 78:30 So maybe particularly because of this, I kind of think about it and then I was like, you know, if you need someone, I can join. 78:40 We were familiar with how we work from the first night. 78:42 So we kind of started to work together. 78:45 And then, yeah, since then we have some LLMs to point out at some repositories. 78:55 We have been scanning them. 78:56 We've been analyzing some bugs, trying to reproduce, and then basically reporting them. 79:02 There are quite a lot of confusion and maybe suspicion around whether it's useful or not, or whether it works or not. 79:11 I think it definitely works. 79:13 We got a lot of positive feedback over what's going on and how it helped. 79:17 Found a bunch of critical bugs in a bunch of systems that people are using. 79:21 So that's definitely a net positive. 79:23 It would be much better if the BTC pay stuff didn't happen, but it just happened. 79:29 It didn't get it. 79:30 We didn't get it. 79:31 But yeah, overall, we are helping a lot of stuff. 79:36 We are reporting a lot of good reports. 79:39 Do we have bad reports? 79:40 Also probably yes. 79:41 There's a lot of slop that sometimes we need to remove or we need to sometimes apologize to whoever we are reporting to. 79:51 So particularly the American LLM frontiers are actually very good. 79:57 Like if we didn't have full safeguards, I think they could be much more useful than Kimi K3. 80:03 Kimi is also an absolute beast that we keep using. 80:06 But I think there's still a couple months of difference in the level of intelligence that you get. 80:13 Is Kimi enough to fuck the shit out of every single Bitcoin repo you find? 80:18 Probably yes, if you're determined enough. 80:20 but if an attacker had American Frontier fully unlocked probably it would be the end the world would be ended is that sarcasm? 80:33 is it sarcasm or is that the world would be ended? 80:38 it's partly sarcasm partly not it is crazy beyond crazy I cannot tell you how much silly shit we found and validated. And I have a better access tier on GPT 5.6 where I'm not really being blocked in my 80:58 personal account. And comparing to what I have with Kimi is actually like there's maybe 5.10 IQ difference, which is not too much, but still sometimes really impressive to have. 81:12 It's meaningful in certain contexts. Yeah. 81:14 Yeah, I think the way hack happens, I also don't fully believe that, you know, there's some analysis over two different GitHub accounts on cold card, which is suspicious enough. But the way I see it is I think there are some guys, particularly some guys we know from the Ethereum world as well, that actually scans code bases and tries to find some bugs. And this one was very easy to find with an LLM. If you push one to two hours. So probably they did that. 81:43 So what we try to prevent is to prevent a scenario where any script kiddie or any nation state actor after one day, two days, should not be able to find a critical bug in a system to drain some funds. 81:58 That's the goal. 81:59 And I think it's going well again. 82:01 We have thousands of reportings, more than hundreds of repositories, and more than half of it is definitely valid. 82:10 and we got a lot of appreciation about it from the maintainers. 82:13 I think in the next month or weeks or whatever, probably there'll be more details over what's going on and what's been found. 82:22 But yeah, this is it so far. 82:25 But yeah, Kimi is just amazing as well. 82:28 Thanks for China and Xi Jinping for invading it, I guess. 82:33 It's a game. 82:34 um it's kind of crazy that china is the source of the best open models that don't have guardrails that that was not on my bingo card um especially when the u.s is trying to lock them down so hard 82:51 um but uh you know i don't understand anybody who says like it doesn't help or you know isn't It isn't like a benefit when you just look at what. 83:06 LLMs are and what they provide, it's not about like having something that's totally free of slop, it's about knocking out every bit of the low hanging fruit, like there's a plateau that we have with the number of skilled and competent engineers who also have enough time 83:29 to look for and plug all of the bugs when you're looking at just human time. 83:35 You have a whole new plateau when you have the ability of LLMs to do the low-level work. 83:42 Like, time itself doesn't even become, like, it becomes less and less of a factor of simply like the obvious thing, because there's probably like some dumb JavaScript bugs that are just all over the place that a competent engineer, if you gave them 100,000 hours, 83:59 they could find 100,000 websites, you know, that have this bug or like a way to exploit it. 84:06 But nobody has that time. 84:07 But now you can hand this over to an LLM and even though it's a small bug, something that's like not super smart, you can actually find and plug those things. 84:18 And there's no way that does not get us to basically a new standard of security for when you also have a new baseline for what people can actually exploit in the exact same way. 84:33 If you have a million new exploiters, you also have a million new patchers. 84:37 You know, like the technology is not mutually exclusive on that, I guess is the way to put it. 84:42 Yeah, I mean, again, as I said to you before, am I a brilliant Gigamine engineer? 84:50 No, but with Kimi, can I basically mess with a couple of Bitcoin repositories or find some bugs in any website that I find? 84:59 Probably yes. 85:00 And I won't really need to code anything. 85:02 I just know where can we be vulnerable and what kind of attacks that are possible, like some accesses, some potential RCE places or some potential SQL injection places. 85:16 Just type it and then it will do it for you. 85:19 If you have the source code, it's even better. 85:21 So the thing is, many people asking is, should the source code be open or not? 85:27 I think it's a double-edged sword. 85:30 If you try to knock it down hard enough, I think the source code should obviously be open because people should be able to see whatever is going on. 85:40 But if you haven't audited what's going on and if you didn't even bother to scan, then I would suggest like immediate to make it private because we kind of know like cold card hack happened because they just simply scanned GitHub and found this low hanging 85:55 fruit and was like, amped for them. 85:58 Was it North Korea or not? 85:59 We don't know. 86:00 I initially believed that it was North Korea, but now my gut feeling says it's not. 86:05 but we will see. 86:06 Maybe there are multiple actors after wave one. 86:11 But yeah, if you have any project, any repository, like it needs to be scanned immediately and you need to patch it immediately. 86:18 This is what we're trying to do. 86:22 Yeah, and Rob just provides API credits and I think he will only be compensated with API credits too. 86:28 So it's something for the good of the industry. 86:31 It's not something that anyone involved is expecting some incentives or benefits. 86:39 It is just the ability to find some time to spare for it and basically secure systems. 86:49 I think this is what motivates everyone involved. 86:51 But yeah, we will see more details in the upcoming days. 86:57 I think Americans will also start releasing very strong open source models, but I just don't know how strong they will be. 87:05 I just know that probably next GPT model will be even crazier and the next one after and the next one after. 87:10 But I'm an AI doomer. 87:12 I think bad things will happen and no one is ready for it. 87:17 I kind of lean this way too, but what leads you to think that we'll have a lot of American open source kind of frontier models It the pressure from the government basically because I think enough people started to complain that they being crippled by what going on 87:37 and they're being handed to China basically. 87:39 And it's not easy to run these systems locally as well. 87:43 So it's like either improve and make them easily runnable at home for people to secure themselves or at least reduce the guardrails for American companies. I'm not an American by the way but this is how I would. 87:55 Or at least reduce the guardrails for American companies and make it accessible for even small businesses so that they can secure themselves. 88:04 I think what people will lean and what many companies will lean is to go open source on that. 88:09 Like Zuckerberg released the manifesto recently. 88:12 Probably many others also will follow. 88:14 I'm not sure about Antropic though. 88:15 They're having this high moral ground where they see themselves better. 88:21 Luckily, they don't accuse others as pedos, but still it's terrible. 88:27 But yeah, there's this problem with them. 88:30 But yeah, it's really strange times. 88:32 And I think probably governments will start to interact with each other. 88:35 Like, should we stop? 88:37 Should we let each other know? 88:38 Kind of a nuclear agreement. 88:41 Because I think people from the field will know like there's this guy called Jan Lekun, who is a very godfather figure. 88:49 Yeah. 88:50 Used to work with Meta. 88:51 Yeah, the algorithm won't scale that much, the current existing algorithms. 88:56 And you need something like Jepa, which is a world model that he has in his end. 89:01 But I think things are going crazy enough that we or they will invent something even crazier. 89:07 And it's so easy to attack everything now. 89:11 It's strange times. 89:12 I hope we all be happy and survive happy. 89:17 I'm really pessimistic about it. 89:19 We'll see. 89:20 That sucks. 89:20 what's the big thing that makes you a doomer? 89:22 Is it like a political? 89:26 It's political. 89:27 It's political. 89:28 It's political. 89:29 Yeah, it's political. 89:30 Yeah. 89:30 I mean, if everyone agrees to fix cancer and like improve everything in the world, then obviously that would be great. 89:36 But that's not what's going to happen. 89:38 That's why I'm a doomer. 89:39 But I think the Pals AI guys are also missing the point. 89:41 The moment ChatGPT was released in 2022, I think, it was over. 89:47 That was the Ponderous box that got opened. 89:50 There's no way to stop it. 89:52 Yeah, it's, there's no way to end this mania. 89:58 And probably the political powers will agree on some shit to not attack each other. 90:05 And we will try to be happy with that. 90:07 We will see. 90:08 Fingers crossed. 90:09 Fingers crossed. 90:10 I tend to be really optimistic, but like I know anything that's changing aggressively is going to have. 90:20 enormous fallout. 90:23 Enormous fallout. 90:24 It's any infrastructure. 90:26 Take any open source wallet and then in one day you can build crazy rocket ships as a vulnerability hunter automated system where you just drop a GitHub link and then it works for four days straight and then comes back at you with 200 findings. 90:43 These sort of systems are now buildable. 90:46 And the cost itself is like at most a couple thousand dollars. 90:51 And if you can ace more than a couple million dollars per attack, like it's nothing. 90:57 So we will see more and more of these and that's what we're trying to prevent. 91:02 Yeah. 91:04 All right. 91:05 Well, I actually have something to get to. 91:09 This has been a wild bear market. 91:11 And it's also been interesting to have, like it's incredible how much AI has really changed. 91:18 things. And I understand the Doomer perspective. I also just tend to be optimistic, whether that's rational or not. And I'm encouraged by the red teaming. 91:36 Yeah luckily we have we have lipsetge So yeah they implemented it nice it doesn break or Bitcoin Core is also a very strong client as well So yeah the foundations being strong is what makes me happy Of course, always be paranoid and always verify your shit. 91:54 But at least knowing that the important things being not too broken is actually good. 92:01 So that's why I can sleep cool at night. 92:04 Awesome. 92:06 Well, dude, is there anything else you wanted to bring up? 92:10 I know we could talk about other things, but any last things that you really wanted to hit or a perspective that you thought the audience should hear before we wrap it up? 92:23 Yeah, I think, you know, I told what I know and how I feel. 92:28 I'm not an expert on anything. 92:30 At the same time, you know, even though I'm quite suspicious, not everything you see in life has to be correct, such as some conspiracy theories. 92:40 In that case, it wasn't. 92:43 And we have some strange times ahead. 92:46 Just stay safe, stack stats, and always verify your shit. 92:53 We are going to interesting times. 92:55 I hope we all make it. 92:56 And that's all I have. 92:58 I'm just a dumb guy. 92:59 So if anything, just you see silly, just accept it. 93:04 It's probably I said alternatively. 93:07 Awesome. 93:08 Stay safe, stack sats, and verify your shit. 93:13 I like it. 93:14 Exactly. 93:15 There's also a bunch of people who've been talking about, like, oh, if you have to roll your own dice, and if you have to do all this, you have to learn how to do self-custody, then we're not going anywhere, and this isn't working. 93:28 It's like, well, you know, if the universe doesn't care what you need to know and what you don't need to know, you know if if self custody isn't safe neither are businesses you know neither are neither are like huge corporations and governments like if everything can be 93:46 attacked it's all going to be attacked until we figure out what does work or we learn what we need to learn to do it the right way and it's a game of survival like the universe doesn't care if your plane doesn't fly it's still just not going to fly it's not going to feel sorry 94:00 for you and so it's going to be it's going to be a roller coaster and it's not going to be fun a lot of the time but I do think we're heading toward a better place ultimately but most of the time that means that bad things or irresponsible and irrational decisions that we've been 94:24 hanging on to for a really long time have to collapse or have to die and we're all tied we're all in the same boat in a lot of ways and we're all going to feel it you know it's not going 94:38 to be like oh they crashed and that doesn't affect me it's like oh shit my retirement's in that oh shit my uh my website is attached to that my keys are attached to that so yeah i guess the best we 94:53 can do is stay safe stack sats and verify our shit yeah exactly all right um well yeah thanks Thanks for having me. 95:03 Also check out lx.dev. 95:04 I didn't do a very good job of telling what I did. 95:07 Yeah, what I did, but it's some cool shit you will hear more. 95:10 But yeah, thanks for having me. 95:12 Yeah, man. 95:13 Dude, thank you so much for coming on. 95:14 Yeah, thank you so much. 95:15 Later, dude. 95:16 Yeah, likewise. 95:17 And see you. 95:18 Bye bye. 95:19 I hope you enjoyed that conversation. 95:25 That was a really good one. 95:26 I urge you to check out lx.dev. 95:29 I urge you to do a little red teaming yourself. 95:33 And I hope, you know, I got a little doomer with the whole AI stuff. 95:37 And I go back and forth so much on this, but I'm so fascinated by what I can build and what I can do that. 95:47 You know sometimes it easy to try to dismiss or maybe avoid thinking about the bad things that are likely to come out And I find it interesting probably true that his concern was a political one on the Doomer side is what are governments going to do? 96:05 What are our systems of power and our power structures going to do with AI? 96:12 And what does it mean for the future of stability and warfare when all of our networks can get attacked? 96:19 when so much of our infrastructure, you know, it's like a neural network, right, around the world. 96:26 What happens when, you know, your liver can attack your brain? 96:30 If that makes any sense at all. 96:34 But it is interesting nonetheless. 96:39 And it is absolutely a wild ride. 96:41 It's already been a wild ride. 96:42 It's crazy that this bear market has gone from what I thought was the most mundane bear market in Bitcoin's history to one of the craziest, like possibly one of the worst. 96:53 I don't know, Mt. Gox isn't so fresh in my mind. 96:58 And I do remember everyone thinking that this is it. 97:00 Like Bitcoin is dead. 97:02 Like there's no coming back from this. 97:04 And it doesn't feel like that today, but the cold card hack, like everything that's been in the BTC pay server, like all this stuff, like it's a mess of stuff just back to back. 97:15 And I do think AI has a lot to do with this. 97:18 these growing pains. So, um, stay safe, stack stats and verify your shit. And, uh, a shout out to Taylor for great conversation. Some really interesting points. Really appreciate his perspective and what they've been doing over there and trying to keep things, get things secure. 97:37 And, uh, you know, hold your own keys, troll your own freaking randomness if you can. 97:44 you know we learned there is no silver bullet there's no fix to anything I'm a huge fan of Bitbox and their sponsor and you know I've always happily I only ever show you anything that I use but nothing is perfect don't don't trust anything and that's you know it's good 98:04 that it's open source so we can beat against it check the entropy don't trust my report you know don't trust to the red team's report when we say it looks like the entropy is fine if you think 98:16 you've got a clever way that you think you can break it or a way that you can add your own randomness or your own entropy when you're creating your seed do it um there's no downside i don't see any downside to just adding a little bit more if you can so um with that check it out 98:34 don't forget you get a discount code and uh the nova 2 actually will plug right into your phone it's pretty dope I'm trying to go ahead and set it up with Nunchuck because I realize it does work on Nunchuck desktop so with that I will catch you guys on the next episode 98:50 get multisig if you haven't done it yet it's not that hard, I'll have a video on it so stay tuned, don't forget to subscribe to the Guys Take YouTube channel I don't share this out or talk about this enough it is a new channel and we have started from scratch 99:04 so it's got like no followers or subscribers and it actually is a huge, huge help. 99:11 And that is where we are trying to do the main focus on our new video content and guys take form, which is becoming the dominant thing that we do on the show. 99:20 So I hope you enjoy it. 99:22 I hope you like this stuff. 99:24 Share it out, follow, subscribe, all those good things. 99:27 They are a massive help. 99:28 You have no idea. 99:29 And thank you for sticking with me and I will catch you on the next episode of Bitcoin Audible. 99:33 Until then, that's my two sets. 99:38 Outro Music
Community discussion