How Women Tricked Men into Doing All the Work While Still Playing the Victim (Forbidden History)

In this eye-opening Based Camp episode, Malcolm and Simone Collins dismantle one of the biggest historical myths pushed by both feminists and modern “trad” circles: the idea that women historically stayed home doing minimal work while men did everything.

Using cross-cultural evidence from hunter-gatherer societies, medieval Europe, Vikings, Spartans, ultra-Orthodox Jews, Islamic traditions, Africa, Latin America, India, China, Japan, and colonial America — plus genetic evidence from modern birds — they reveal the real division of labor: women handled the majority of reliable, grueling calorie production, farming (pre-plow), management, textiles, marketing, and household economy, while men focused on high-risk, high-reward activities like warfare, raiding, politics, and innovation.

They introduce the “Sword and Shield” model of relationships and explain how the industrial era, plow, and wage labor flipped traditional dynamics. A must-watch for anyone interested in real history, gender roles, and escaping modern cultural brainwashing.

Episode Transcript

Simone Collins: [00:00:00] The researchers say the finding is clear, but the reason behind it is still unknown. On average, men were able to get about one meter, 3.3 feet closer than women before the birds took off. This pattern appeared consistently across Czechia, France, Germany, Poland, and Spain.

It also held true across 37 species so Malcolm immediately turns to me and he’s like, “We know exactly why this is the case.”

Malcolm Collins: Yes. This is the question that explains everything we’re going to talk about today, and I think proves without a doubt that this is not some malcolm malcolmnipulation of historical facts. You have been in rural Latin America, right?

Simone Collins: Yes.

Malcolm Collins: Take an image in your head.

Simone Collins: Okay.

Malcolm Collins: You’re driving down a rural road. You look out the side of a car, okay? You see somebody with a 60 pound jug of something on their head.

Simone Collins: Oh, it’s a woman, obviously. Yeah.

Malcolm Collins: Always a woman.

Simone Collins: Always, always a woman. Yes.

Malcolm Collins: you go to Africa, you’ll see this as well. You go to-

Simone Collins: China too. Let’s be clear. China too. Right.

Malcolm Collins: Yeah. ‘

Was it majority women doing the [00:01:00] harder labor when you’re-

Simone Collins: Yeah,

Malcolm Collins: 100%.

Yeah. Yeah. D-

Simone Collins: Yeah.

Malcolm Collins: Guys, you do not know how brain cucked you are if, if a woman has convinced you, “ We just need to go back to the traditional way and I’ll stay at home and you do all this stuff.” Because you’re so strong, look at your muscles, could you open this jar for me? All you see as a woman, I could just never do anything.

Would you like to know more?

Malcolm Collins: Hello, Simone. Today I’m going to talk to you about the most diabolical brainwashing mind trick that feminists and women have ever pulled on males in human society.

And it is that I will hear diet in the wool, males who identify as misogynist, red pill, post pickup artists, trads, go out there and say, “Well, we need to go back to the way things used to be, where women didn’t work and stayed in the household [00:02:00] and just cared for kids.” And I see their wives behind their fans with their villainous faces going.

Speaker 5: あ。

Simone Collins: oh my God.

Malcolm Collins: Their villainous laugh. Tucked their husband’s brains and their husbands believe that historically women didn’t work. And

Speaker 11: We must let

Malcolm Collins: misogynist,

Speaker 14: think this was his I all right. That he

Speaker 13: came up with.

Speaker 14: All

Speaker 12: right.

Speaker 14: Now

Speaker 13: he’s going to

figure

Speaker 12: it out. Don’t do all. Okay. I know what to take.

Speaker 11: You don’t know what to do. Yo talk, talk, talk only.

Speaker 12: Do

you

Speaker 14: want

Speaker 12: my own? Yes,

Speaker 11: I want you

Speaker 12: to know.

Speaker 14: Vula, how is business?

Speaker 12: Oh, wow to me.

My weak constitution, my weak mind as a woman, I am simply not fit for it.

Speaker 12: Business is bad.

Speaker 15: What do you know, what’s the matter? What’s happened?

She suffers?

Speaker 14: She suffers. She has to be at the travel agency alone all day

Well, her kids are all alone at home.

Speaker 14: That’s

Speaker 12: [00:03:00] right.

Speaker 15: So,

Take the kids with you to work.

Speaker 15: You’d be with Taki .

Speaker 12: That would be good.

Speaker 14: That would be no good. No good. No good. No good. Because, um,

When a woman has her kids around, she just can’t focus.

Speaker 14: And that’s why that no work. No work.

Speaker 15: .

I have your answer. Yes.

I will do all the work for you and you stay home all day with the kids.

Speaker 11: Oh, I, I can’t believe that. Wonderful. Wonderful.

Malcolm Collins: and I saw this in the comments again recently where like even- Oh

Simone Collins: really?

Malcolm Collins: Guys were like, “Well, women held some roles historically outside the house, but, you know, they weren’t like cobblers and they weren’t like sailors and they weren’t like, you know, stone masons.”

And it’s like all of that is true.

Simone Collins: Yeah. However,

Malcolm Collins: the way that all of those businesses were managed where if a guy [00:04:00] was a stone mason or a cobbler or anything like that, his books and his inventory sourcing and his client sourcing

generally would have been handled by the woman, but it wasn’t even just that. It was if you actually look at the statistics around female labor in history, women actually did, if you’re talking about hard labor, the labor that fed the family, right? Women actually did the majority of the work over the vast majority of human history.

If you go back to let’s say hunter gatherer society, for example, because we’ve been able to study this in a great detail women produced in terms of daily caloric intake between 80 and 60% of the calories that the family ate.

Simone Collins: Oh my gosh, really?

Malcolm Collins: This is 90 human history.

Simone Collins: Well, this, you know, this also makes sense in other things where you see sexual dimorphism.

For example, women being much [00:05:00] having much higher endurance and pain tolerance versus men who are better like sprinters.

Malcolm Collins: Yeah.

Speaker 6: Or to word it another way, the female body and psychology at an evolutionary level are optimized for grueling labor while the male body in mind are optimized for warfare and di