Half-Felt Feelings and Why They Ruin Your Writing

When you open a book, what are you actually looking for?

Sure, we want a good story or useful information. But at a deeper level, most of us read because we’re looking for a mirror. We want someone who has wrestled with the hard, messy realities of being human and figured out something we haven’t quite articulated for ourselves yet.

That’s why there’s nothing more frustrating—as a reader, as a book coach, and as a human—than reading a book where the writer holds back.

In this Write Big session, I’m talking about a concept that blew my mind while listening to grief expert David Kessler on the Mel Robbins podcast. He spoke about the idea of “half-felt feelings” in relation to grief and emotional processing.

The second I heard that phrase, I knew it was the exact diagnosis for what happens when a writer hesitates on the page:

* In fiction, it shows up as characters who are only halfway experiencing their stakes.

* In memoir, it’s a protagonist who protects themselves instead of being vulnerable.

* In nonfiction, it’s an author who is so focused on sounding like a polished authority that they strip away the deep human heart of their topic.

When we hold back, equivocate, or hedge our bets, we become emotionally stingy with our audience. But our job as writers isn’t just to arrange words; our real medium is human emotion.

In this episode, I challenge you to look closely at your current draft and ask: Where am I settling for half-felt feelings, and where can I go deeper?

The goal is to stop being afraid of what’s scary to say, step into real vulnerability, and write pages that actually resonate.

#amwriting is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

You can buy Blueprint for a Book here, or take my $19 Blueprint for a Book video course, which includes the full text of the book plus 14 video lessons that walk you through the process.

Resources Mentioned in This Episode

* The Mel Robbins Podcast — Episode 352: “Your Grief and Heartbreak Will Get Better The Moment You Listen To This” (Featuring David Kessler).

* Burnout: The Secret to Unlocking the Stress Cycle by Emily Nagoski (and Amelia Nagoski)

* On Grief and Grieving: Finding the Meaning of Grief Through the Five Stages of Loss by Elisabeth Kübler-Ross and David Kessler

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit amwriting.substack.com/subscribe