0:00 Hello, hello everyone. Welcome to Happy Hour, the special edition of After Party that we do every Friday here on the podcast feed, which of course I love doing because it gives me an opportunity to go through all the 0:14 emails that you send in to emily at devilmaycaremedia.com. Please do go ahead and get in touch. I think As you can see, I do love responding to those emails and try my best to get to just about all of them. So let's go ahead and dig into this 0:31 week's batch. And as you can probably tell, I still do have a little bit of a cold. So if you hear any coughs, actually, you know what? I can probably edit coughs out. Nevermind. Pretend I didn't say that. 0:42 By the way, I'm also so bad about reminding people to leave reviews on Apple and Spotify. Super helpful. Also subscribe on YouTube if you haven't yet. That's super helpful too. 0:50 But Over on these episodes, I'm just always wanting to express how grateful I am to all of you for listening and to sending these questions in. So let's get to it. Donald says the right constantly complains about celebrities 1:01 preaching about politics at award shows and interviews, etc. But hypothetically, if celebrities suddenly started promoting right leaning conservative politics, do you think they would have the same reaction? Personally, I don't think they would. But also, I don't need my 1:12 beliefs validated by a wealthy, out of touch celebrity. Furthermore, the right constantly talks about how Hollywood only makes movies for the liberals and gated communities and not for middle America. Personally, I don't think that's true. Those are just movies they 1:22 choose to focus on. This year alone, I've seen seven movies in theaters and we'll see three more in theaters before the year is over, four of which will have been horror movies, which according to Ali Dostaki makes me a terrible Christian, but I digress. So personally, I think 1:34 Hollywood still makes plenty of movies that appeal to middle America. 1:36 If people would actually take the time to look for them instead of being outraged by some random movie that is something quote unquote woke about it. Did any of the movies I watched support my values or were conservative? No, 1:44 they didn't, because like I said previously about the celebrities, I don't need a movie to do that. All I need is for it to be good and not push an agenda, whether it be left or right. God bless and have a great weekend. All right, Donald. A lot 1:54 to unpack here. First of all, to your first point, I would say you can definitely find examples of conservatives who criticize celebrities on the principle that celebrities should not talk about politics. And then... who will elevate, for example, 2:15 Nicki Minaj. Something Nicki Minaj says about Trump or the country or Christians or anything like that. And Nicki Minaj is, of course, just one example of this. I don't know, you could also say like Jake Paul or whatever. There 2:29 are definitely people who are inconsistent on that question. I don't think there's really much dispute about it. So I think what people should be careful to... insure is if you're objecting to a celebrity. This is the whole shut 2:46 up and dribble thing, right? Like, are you objecting to a celebrity on the basis of their celebrity, right? So you shouldn't be telling me what to think. It's not part of your job. It's, you know, makes me like you less and you're not really an expert, that sort 3:02 of thing. Or are you objecting to them because they're wrong? 3:08 You know, That's where I always think it's important to say, is the principle just that they shouldn't be talking about this because they're a celebrity? And there are different kinds of celebrities, right? If you're famous for playing a president 3:22 in a movie, you're probably going to have to talk about presidents on the media tour. I mean, you could choose to just say, well, I don't really know anything. 3:27 But if Dennis Quaid plays Ronald Reagan, he's probably going to talk about Ronald Reagan. And actors have to study those roles. And I know that's kind of an exception, but I'm just using it to kind of illustrate the principles. 3:38 What kind of celebrity are we talking about and are they trying to be a moral authority? Is it built into their art in one form or another, or are they just spouting it off because it's kind of the fashionable thing to do at a given moment? Is it 3:53 related to that? So I actually try to do it on a case-by-case basis, if that makes sense. It is tiring to have celebrities act as though they're moral authorities. 4:09 On the other hand, in a sense they do shape the culture. And so I, I wonder, you know, if I was like a famous singer, a singer, how I would personally handle that. Um, I think I would, I don't know. It's just, it's, it's so hard to say, like, 4:23 I would probably want to promote pro-life causes, for example. Um, and I was like, and I would never be a famous singer because I'm not much of a singer, uh, as my family knows, but, um, you know, but, at the same time, um, some, I do also believe that there's, 4:45 there's room or you should leave room, uh, for people to feel, I don't know, like you're not constantly judging them and that they can enjoy a song or a concert without feeling morally judged or morally condescended to that sort of thing. So, Anyway, it's a long answer, but yeah, 5:10 I definitely think people are not always careful about whether this is a first principle thing or if it's just you don't like what that particular celebrity said on the movies. 5:19 In Allie Beth's defense, again, she was talking about... People can go back and listen to that episode, but she was particularly talking about movies that are not suspense films, that aren't primarily intellectual... moral stories, but are primarily intended 5:37 to engender fear, because Ali Beth was making the argument that we are to avoid that type of fear. It can be an opening for kind of darkness in the Christian mind. And I don't know that I personally take it that far, but I do... see the bright red 5:57 line with like slasher flicks that are almost pornographically violent. Um, as, as with porn, the primary intent, uh, is not like, uh, to make somebody consider humanity, morality, that type of thing. Um, and I think, you know, there were clearly films in 6:21 that genre, but anyway, um, um, is Hollywood quote unquote woke? 6:25 Does Hollywood still make quote unquote woke movies? That depends on how you define woke. I mean, there are quotas for the Oscars now that people will tell you just completely distort every single thing, every single serious piece of 6:38 cinema that the industry puts out now because you can't really trust that people were cast on the merits. That's what a lot of people will say about the industry is that it is now, you know, not just because of the Academy quotas, but people know they're under scrutiny 6:53 for those types of reasons. Um, and again, like it depends on, depends on what you define as quote unquote woke. 6:58 Like is the movie trying to tell primarily, is it trying to send primarily a woke message? Are you just having to put up with like incidental lines about, I don't know, gender or race or that sort of thing? 7:12 I do think that continues to be fairly endemic in films. Uh, and I think sometimes it's distracting because it is, uh, extra distracting. to the content, right? You know, that it was, I hate saying content, but extra to the narrative, to 7:28 the story, um, to, to the merits of the movie, because it takes you out of it sometimes. Um, because you can tell that it's, it's there as, as window dressing, uh, for commercial purposes or, uh, even like social purposes in Hollywood, 7:46 or you can tell that somebody is using the film as a vehicle for kind of personal or political advocacy in a way that's not necessarily always a natural fit with the film. Now, one of my favorite movies is... 8:01 I mean, truly one of my favorite movies. I actually think it's one of the greatest performances in American acting is Dead Man Walking, which is... You know, it's a careful movie. It's not... The messaging is... very political and it's, 8:21 I think it leaves room to explore, uh, both sides of the conversation, both families on. Yeah. It's, it's, it does a really great job and it is a piece, I would argue is a piece of political advocacy. Um, but it's just a really wonderful film. So there's a 8:38 way to do it where it's not like I am, um, 8:42 like campaigning, um, With the content of this film. So I could go off about all this for a long time. 8:50 I do still think that Hollywood is culturally progressive. A lot of Hollywood, on the other hand, is intertwined with the military-industrial complex. I've done some reporting on that. A lot of major films, Top Gun included, is made in 9:07 cooperation with the Pentagon and Pentagon propaganda offices, officials. And they use those as opportunities for training exercises. And this has long been, especially during cold war, framed as a positive thing, right? It's American soft power, that sort of thing. 9:25 You can read something more sinister in it as well, uh, which is that, um, Hollywood is kind of co-opted by the military industrial complex, but no, I, I think Hollywood makes plenty of, of movies that are critical of American power as well. So the kind of all, all over 9:40 the map on that one. Um, But I don't know. 9:43 I might disagree, Donald. I still think it's pretty endemic. 9:46 I guess it just depends on how you define woke. 9:50 And maybe I'll respond. But yeah, if you're defining quote unquote woke as, you know, the the really, some of the very specific stuff from the kind of 2014 to 2024 time period, um, that was like ostentatiously millennial leftist, 10:12 that type of thing, or cultural millennial leftist. My leftist friends don't like when I say or when I describe kind of cultural progressivism as leftism, because many of them, of course, have fantastic, often Marxist objections to identity politics. 10:27 So I get that. But that's why I try to say cultural progressivism or cultural leftism, that type of thing. Anyway, again, I could keep going on about this for a long time. 10:37 My job at The Federalist was culture editor. So I edited a lot of pieces on this, wrote a lot of pieces about this. But thank you, Donald. There's a lot to, as people can tell by my rambling, there's a lot to chew on there. And I guess I 10:49 just think that the industry is overall dominated by the center left, and that does bleed into a lot of films less so than it did five years ago. Absolutely, there's been a kind of turning of the Titanic or an effort to kind of turn the Titanic, but most 11:06 Hollywood films are not promoting a conservative morality fundamentally. Um, some still excellent stuff coming out of Hollywood though. So anyway, anyway, Logan says, I was thinking about this question last week and then heard you and Sagar briefly touched on this 11:24 question of Alito and Thomas. Oh, it's about the Supreme court on the BP election night coverage. Now that Democrats have taken the Senate, they'll most likely block any nomination and pull a 2016 McConnell. If Democrats win the presidency, 11:35 we might not get a chance to nominate conservative replacements for six to 10 years. Is there going to be any urgency to replace them before January? What have you heard? 11:41 What are your thoughts? I actually haven't heard anything other than some anxiety on the right about this because Thomas and Alito are up there. I think they are actually the two oldest members of the court. And I want to say Sonia Sotomayor is third. But yeah, I mean, 11:57 if Republicans don't get the Senate back, the map isn't great. 12:00 I've looked at the map for 2028. Not great for Republicans. 12:04 But then again, you could have a kind of 2024 to 2026 dramatic political reversal. Who knows? And Republicans win back red states and maybe make inroads in a lot of blue states. Who knows? But what it seems like, because Logan sent this on November 5th, it's now November 12th. 12:24 What it seems like in the interim period is that between the 5th and the 12th is that these anxieties have calmed. I don't know if Thomas and Alito have signaled to folks in the conservative movement. I certainly haven't 12:37 heard anything about their retirement plans, but maybe they're just really confident in their health. and they're confident with the size of the majority. So if maybe one of them, something, God forbid, happens to one of them, then they're confident 12:52 that they can withstand any new appointments and keep the majority, that sort of thing. If you're a real rock-ribbed conservative, you already think that the real conservatives on the Supreme Court are basically Alito and Thomas. So it would make 13:08 you rather nervous to lose even one of them. If you're not someone who finds Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett and Neil Gorsuch to be especially reliable, which is true of many people. You know, some of them have, you know, different problems with, you could kind of mix and match 13:27 who a kind of hardcore conservative is uncomfortable with. But I actually feel like the concerns about this have calmed over the last week. And so it's interesting. So maybe some, maybe some like, bat signal went out or that's not 13:45 the right term for it. Maybe some, some vibes, uh, were given off and it calmed people down. Uh, but they are really getting up there and anytime you're that age, again, God forbid, but anything can happen. So there's just, as 14:00 soon as Democrats have controlled the Senate, if there's no retirement, which there does not seem to be any imminent retirement, like I could be disproved by that on a random December news dump day. Um, but the closer we get 14:12 to December, the least likely or the less likely that seems, I just don't, I mean, yeah, they, they would pull a McConnell, um, Merrick Garland situation, but I don't know that you would even have enough time at this point, uh, to go through something like that. Uh, so, um, it's 14:32 a really, really interesting question because they actually are up there and they're the two most reliable, uh, conservatives on the bench. So great question, Logan. I'll keep watching it, but I've heard so much less in the last week. 14:47 this is Consuelo, who says, I watch Breaking Points whenever I have a chance and invariably find your intervention smart and reasonable, Emily, but never could put my finger on exactly why I like you so much as a thinker. 14:56 Now I know I'm not a conservative, but I do care about elemental values and humility is one of them. 15:00 I just finished watching your post-election after-party podcast for November 5th. 15:03 Well said and well done. Keep it up, please. Because this is my first time ever contacting a podcast. Oh my gosh, this is so, so kind. Thank you. And yeah, you know, long-time listeners know I think that's probably the factor missing most in journalism or the posture missing most 15:22 in journalism. I think it has engendered a lot of distrust. 15:26 And so that's something that I hope is constantly coloring the way that I cover these things. It would be impossible. 15:33 I'm fallible and human. It would be impossible to keep it up 100% of the time. But I appreciate you all keeping me honest because that's definitely something I think about a lot and hope that I can hope and pray that I can do my best of keeping it up. 15:49 So as much as possible. And again, thank you all for keeping me honest on it. And thank you so much for that kind note. Ismael says, hi, Emily, wanted to share my perspective on the current state of our political movement. Having voted for Trump and initially supported key 16:01 platform supporting key platform issues, especially avoiding foreign wars and securing the border. I can no longer offer my support two years into this administration. The handling of major issues, 16:10 including inflation, tariffs, foreign conflicts, energy policy, grocery prices, and immigration, has been disappointing. Seeing the political shifts in Texas is particularly concerning, as is the tendency across the party to 16:19 point fingers rather than focus on solutions. While I had high hopes for this administration, it is clear that we need to move on from Trump and focus on a constructive path forward. Best regards. Thank you for this note, because, 16:31 you know, you're touching on something that I hadn't put into words yet, but I feel like you did. which is the tendency, as you put it, across the party to point fingers rather than focus on solutions. The last week has been astounding. And I obviously come down on, 16:53 you know, it's not fair to say I come down on one side of this because I'm sort of a new right person that's very sympathetic to old right, quote unquote old right, and still believes that actually both are fundamentally compatible. So you know that I'm skeptical, especially of 17:09 interventionist folks and free trade hawks, like hardcore dogmatic free traders, which I just disagree with. I love many of them. 17:20 Great libertarian dogmatic free traders, that sort of thing. Stephen Moore has been agitating against deportations. He said it's the D word in his newsletter that people should bring back up again, has been supporting pathway to citizenship stuff. And 17:37 You all know where I come down on that, but it's been astounding to see a lack of introspection and reflection on the last 10 years. And I don't just mean that about the people that I disagree with on some of those temperamental and policy questions, but on a 17:55 fundamental level about the media gatekeepers losing so much of their power, about younger people having dramatically different takes on these issues than older people. That is a structural challenge for the Republican Party that I don't know that I 18:13 can think of a precedent for where you have those two. 18:17 I mean, maybe it was like that in the 60s among maybe Democrats in the 60s. Yeah, that's that's one precedent I'm possibly thinking about. But this is just an enormous structural challenge that even if you think the young people are wrong about, you then have to undertake a 18:35 massive persuasion effort. The same thing on affordability and cost of living. We've had a lot of people calling into the wrap-up show on SiriusXM this week. You're saying that, and again, it's a fair perspective and we hear it on the wrap-up show, but just saying that they feel 18:51 like people are spoiled, that things are affordable, that the increase in gas prices in the grand scheme of things isn't that bad, that they see malls full and people with new iPhones and that sort of thing. And again, 19:06 it was a wipeout. I mean, it was a bloodbath for Republicans a week ago. And that means that persuasion efforts failed, full stop, right? So maybe you think people are what's the right way to put this, are kind of impervious to these good arguments and logic and reason because, 19:29 you know, they're all on social media, blah, blah, blah. And, you know, there's a sense of entitlement. Maybe you think all of that. But that means that you have to persuade those people where they are, right? Because if you 19:41 want to have political power, you cannot just throw your hands up and say, everybody's entitled and addicted to social media You have to try to persuade those people. And the best way to persuade them is probably not going to be to insult them. And so it's been a 19:59 week where... Yeah, and even some of the gloating among some people that agree more with me on these types of things I don't think is super constructive. But yeah, it's just the last week I think has shown that Trump was a sugar high for Republicans. He kind of 20:19 glossed over a lot of these changes and glued together a coalition with duct tape. And then as soon as he lost... his power to hold that coalition together because in some ways Democrats learned and in some ways Republicans, 20:36 you know, did things actively to lose that coalition. You know, if it was anti-war people or, you know, people who cared about tariffs, or I'm sorry, cared about prices and were affected by tariffs, that sort of thing. It was 20:49 glued together with duct tape. And maybe that's true of many political coalitions and many big political coalitions, right? Like there's not a lot. that always keeps people glued together. 20:59 You know, it can sometimes be a really popular politician or a particular moment where the opposition is very weak and nobody wants to vote for that type of person. 21:11 I think obviously Trump has won against Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris, who are two of the weakest candidates I can think of in modern political history, and even then sort of eked out wins, not in electoral college, but in the popular vote. So it was kind of a 21:27 sugar high for Republicans to have the standard bearer they could fall back on because most people distrusted establishment Republicans as much as they distrusted the Democrats, which gave them more trust in Trump. But once Trump lost that trust 21:41 with enough Republicans, it really hurt his ability to tape the coalition together with glue. And so Republicans is just, I honestly don't think have much of a coalition right now. 21:52 I think A lot of the traditional Republican voters never liked Trump to begin with because they believe that temperament and character are important. And they sucked it up because they thought some of the other Republicans and the Democrats 22:04 didn't have the right temperament and character. And they were sort of sick of people acquiescing to Democrats and that type of thing. They saw some merit in Trump's brash style, all that sort of thing. But it was just never 22:18 a super stable coalition. And I don't think Republicans understood that. 22:22 you know, when you go back to 2024, and maybe conservatives too, more generally, the, Michael Malice and I were talking about this, the sort of hubris of the 2024 victory, of the aftermath, the afterglow of 2024, it does look 22:40 foolish in retrospect, because Trump's political capital is always unstable. 22:46 And Yeah, if you start a war after saying no new wars and prices start going back up after saying you were going to bring prices down, and you did, and then they started going back up, yeah, that's a tough one. And I don't think Republicans fully appreciate the 23:02 level of... Maybe they do appreciate the level of disaster, of catastrophe. But yeah, it's been a lot of bitterness and hostility and not in constructive ways, not in ways that's like, let's move the ball forward, let's advance this, 23:23 but in ways that are like, I don't want anything to do with you, people who believe with you. I mean, calling J.D. Vance disloyal for that Twitter post, again, I found that astounding, and yes, I tend to agree more with Vance on some of these things, but he was 23:39 citing the president. The president's son reposted him. Like, He cited the president in that post. He cited the president's own words in that post. And to call him disloyal for issuing that post, especially after the president's son retweeted it, 23:58 reposted it with like 100 emojis, it just doesn't make sense. 24:03 It just doesn't make sense. And to me, it shows that the strategy is to take down Vance as the mascot of the new right and hope all of the other chips fall back into the right place for the anti-Vance camp. And that does not make sense because getting 24:19 rid of Vance doesn't get rid of the coalition that find, the people in the coalition, maybe people who watch Joe Rogan or Theo Vaughn and are Vance curious because they don't like traditional Republican positions on these issues. You don't 24:36 get rid of those people by getting rid of Vance. 24:38 You still have to exist in a big tent political party or political movement with those folks. So it just seems myopic. A lot of it just seems myopic. Sorry, that's kind of a bummer answer, but I really feel you on that one, Ismail. All right. Jimmy says, given 24:55 certain gridlock between Congress and Trump in the coming years, do you think the likely Democrat 2028 presidential nominee would be a newly elected governor? Hinojosa comes to mind. Governors as Ron DeSantis will humbly tell you actually have to 25:05 get things done in their states. And if Hinojosa can get legislation passed on things like data centers, lowering gas prices and immigration deportation, she will have She'll have clear evidence of responding to major concerns of the national electorate. 25:16 DSA wing would love a Latina to run. The right will love that Latina is an ASC. And Hinojosa could capture the Democrats' electoral college, White Whale, Texas. Ooh, that's interesting, Jimmy. 25:25 As for the old guard governors like Newsom or Pritzker, I think you'd agree their brands are just worn out. 25:29 When Newsom recently said he wouldn't run for president if Kamala also ran, it seemed like a narcissistic cry for national Democrat love. Please beg for me not to drop out and push a major rival aside for me in the process. But no one came, and given his woke-on 25:40 resistance baggage, he certainly wouldn't keep a Scott Colom or James Tallarico coalition intact. Do you think this is how Democrats will be thinking come 2028, or will they try to catch an Obama-type rising star senator and ride him 25:49 or her to the White House? Thank you for providing a thoughtful perspective to breaking points as well. Thank you, Jimmy. 25:57 Your point about the Texas Electoral College is really interesting. 26:00 I like the way you put it. Will they try to catch an Obama-type rising star senator and ride him or her to the White House? To me, that seems like the likeliest scenario at this point because they found such success with these folks. And remember, campaigns are going 26:14 to be launched in the new year, in the new year. 26:17 So that makes it difficult for Hinojosa or Abdu'l-Sayed but maybe it's kind of a benefit in that, you know, they won't have much of a record to run on or against. I think it's maybe either of those two seems perhaps unlikely. Maybe, maybe Tallarico. I don't know. It's just, 26:42 it seems to me like it would be really early, even if they served six months or whatever. I don't remember how long Obama was in the Senate before he ran. 26:50 I want to say he was elected in, 2004? Let me actually look that up. But yeah, I want to say it was 2004. So he was in office a few years. Yes, he won in 2004. So he'd already been in office a few years. It would be obviously very early for Abdul El-Sayed to mount a run or 27:13 Gina Hinojosa to mount a bid for president. But maybe somebody who's cut from that kind of cloth, who has that, what is it, Evan Barker has put it as economic populism and cultural moderation. I mean, it just was such a winning ticket that it's a real high for Democrats 27:37 right now. Like that recipe has Democrats on a real high right now. And I think they have genuine respect. 27:42 for Tallarico and Annie Andrews. I mean, if you are convinced by either of theirs, like either of their cultural moderation. Yeah. 27:50 And I think Newsom is an example. Harris is an example. 27:53 Pritzker is an example of a brand that is totally tired and worn out by its attachment to resistance, democratic politics that, you know, look now like the failed alternative to what won in 2026 and So, yeah, it wouldn't surprise me if somebody that we're not thinking of wades 28:18 into the race. Right now, I think it's more likely than not AOC does. But, yeah, I could see an Obama type jumping into the race. I think that's a good instinct. I don't know that it'll be enough time for Hinojosa. Again, maybe it would be... The good thing 28:34 that she doesn't really have a record. She just has this record as a massive winner in a huge electoral college state. And if she does well on the debate stage and is kind of an electric personality, a fundraiser, which is why I think Newsom is considered formidable. I 28:49 think his thing with Kamala Harris was really a message to donors. That's my personal personal take on it to, you know, see because it was coming at a time when Harris donors weren't sure what to do with their money and they didn't. And so it may have been 29:03 a sign for them to like, should take a side. Um, I don't know, but anyway, I, I, I think your theory, because there's so many of them that are so tired by this resistance brand, uh, and the resistance brand, the 29:18 persona that they adopted and their record during that time period, uh, it'll be tough. I mean, yeah. Cologne. Oh my goodness. Um, they love Adam Hamilton. Um, So we'll see. I mean, it's early for any of those guys, but maybe like a Chris Van Hollen, a Chris Murphy. I don't know 29:36 if he's doing better. I hope he's doing better. But yeah, we'll see. we'll see um anetta says hi emily i recently saw photos of ilhan as a teenager and she isn't wearing a job a quick research told me she only started wearing one more regularly after the 9-11 attacks 29:49 I was under the impression that her religion dictated she wore it starting at puberty. She also legally married another man while being married to her first husband by religious service. 29:56 I know Muslim men are allowed to have a mother and wife, but I doubt the same applies to women. 29:59 It's also confusing. Have a great weekend. You know, I don't know anything about this, to be honest. Obviously, we've done segments on the allegations about her legal marriage that was done. It was done by a Christian minister. to the man who is alleged to be her brother, I 30:18 think pretty clearly is her brother, while she had been married in a religious ceremony, a Muslim ceremony, to the father of her children. So, I mean, that we've covered. 30:32 I actually don't know anything about Islamic convention on, certainly on like, polygamy and on the hijab, I imagine that it differs in the same way that different Christian denominations have different customs and rules. I would imagine that it 30:53 differs from different countries or from varying countries and places, but I really don't know anything about that. I do You always look to Raymond Ibrahim on these questions. I'm excited to watch a debate he did recently. I haven't had a chance to watch it, but I honestly have 31:10 no idea what's going on with that. Let's see here. 31:19 This is from Margaret, who says, I'm a big fan of your podcast and look forward to listening or watching each episode. I have a question about the election. It's not one I've heard or seen anywhere. I can understand why people would vote for Republican or Democrat. What I 31:29 don't understand is how many Muslims were elected in this election. 31:31 What do you think accounts for that? Is it just the number of Muslims in our country now or is it more than that? Thank you for taking the time to answer my question and all the others you receive every week. Well, thank you for taking the time to 31:40 send it in. I haven't seen numbers on this, so I don't know if it was an unusually high number of Muslims or not. You know, certainly Republicans elevated the Abdul El-Sayed. They definitely elevated. Trump was calling him a jihadist. 32:01 So they elevated that pretty, pretty clearly this cycle. And it became a huge topic of debate in the conservative movement and in conservative media, certainly in the last election cycle. 32:14 I don't know if that is because there was an unusually high number of Muslim candidates on the ballot and then winning election. I honestly don't know. That's an interesting question to look up. It may, if it's true, it may signal that the Muslim community in the United States 32:31 is becoming kind of even more politically activated. You know, from Dearborn to Epic down in Texas, there's certainly been a recent history of Muslim political activism. Interestingly, actually, this did not I don't know why this didn't come up more, 32:53 but Dearborn was roiled by Woke One because politically activist Muslims were infuriated by the books that were being taught in classrooms. My memory is that they were actually protesting the teachers union with the Christian conservative parents in Dearborn 33:11 and in Montgomery County, Maryland. I know that that happened. 33:14 That was a case that went to the Supreme Court, if I'm remembering correctly. So I can't, for the life of me, I don't know. I actually asked. I don't know why nobody was bringing that up. Fox News did a story over the summer, if I'm remembering summer or 33:28 early fall, where they went to an event that Abdul El-Sayed was at and asked, it was a Muslim community event, and asked people there if they were aware of his positions on abortion and gender and those sorts of things. 33:42 And Again, it's hard to know from a reporter's account, a Fox News story, but it sounded like people weren't. 33:48 So I don't know what was going on with that. 33:51 And also Trump tapped into a lot of the politically activist circles in the Dearborn area during the 2024 campaign, specifically on some of the woke issues and on Middle East issues as well. Tiffany Trump's Father-in-law, I think his name is Musab Boulos, he was doing a ton of 34:14 outreach for Trump in that community at the time. So again, I don't know if it's an increase in political action from the Muslim community in the United States. I don't know if the numbers are there. I've seen numbers of 34:27 varying reliability. I haven't seen it confirmed. But it's definitely something to look at. It could signal perhaps an interesting... 34:37 trend about moving to kind of more emphasize office holding and that sort of thing. Aaron says, Happy Friday, Emily. 34:47 I'm a sub to your YouTube show. I'm a premium BP subscriber. First time sending in a question to you. 34:51 What is with this overarching narrative of Trump possibly resigning and J.D. taking over? It seems that so many talking heads are cheerleading for Vance now and completely glancing past his lack of character and clear ties to tech surveillance 35:00 state that so many people claim to be against. Thank you. 35:02 Have a great weekend. Well, this is always going to be a problem for J.D. Vance because Peter Thiel, as it sounds like you know, Aaron, is... I think he's a very compelling figure, but he is never going to be a broadly appealing political figure. He is kind of 35:22 a cartoon villain version of an oligarch. The way that he sees... his companies, his role in his companies. It's all a very interesting history. CIA venture capital firm backing Palantir, Palantir seeing itself. And I imagine this is sincere from 35:43 Peter Thiel. I don't know. He's written extensively and talked extensively about this, but believes that their mission is to be the kind of responsible stewards of this technology that's enormously powerful in terms of surveillance. And if others who 36:05 are not sort of civil libertarians, as Till fashions himself, much to the amusement of civil libertarians, don't manage this technology, then it's going to be even worse. That's the kind of pitch. And so that's the world that J.D. Vance 36:22 really comes from in his professional life. That's always going to be problem. It's a solution when it comes to raising money, of course, which worked well for him in Ohio and has worked well for Trump world. But it's such an unpopular industry and a distrusted industry and an 36:48 industry that's intertwined with the state in enormously powerful ways that have garnered rightfully an enormous amount of scrutiny. That's going to be a tough one. That's going to be a tough one. I don't know if it's, I don't 37:03 know how significant it is on the right. My inclination is that it's very significant. It maybe wasn't significant in 2024, obviously because he was the running mate and it's not maybe significant that Trump himself, you know, has been the 37:19 beneficiary of donations from Palantir and has had relationships with Some of those folks, because he's Trump, he's kind of a singular figure and people focus on other things. So I don't know if we have a good answer to that yet. If there are, you know, a lot of 37:32 enough civil libertarians in the Republican primary voter base that it's a problem for, that it's almost a genuine roadblock or an insurmountable roadblock for J.D. Vance. Oh, no, we'll see. But, Erin, your instincts on that are good. I... I did hear 37:53 briefly after the election that, yeah, just Trump step back and let J.D. take the reins. What if it's J.D. 38:00 who leaves the vice presidency? Because if he ever wants to be president, he's aware that's too much of an albatross. 38:11 He has to be able to say, I didn't see corruption in the Trump administration. He has to be able to say, the Iran war was too much for me to stomach. And even then, even if he did that, would people believe it? Open question. I don't think this 38:27 is a likely possibility, but I suppose I think it's likelier than Trump stepping down, letting J.D. Vance step in. But, you know, we're in the middle of this period right now where it does feel a bit like after January 6th. 38:41 You know, it's unclear how voters are going to continue relating to Donald Trump. Republican voters are going to continue relating to Donald Trump. I think it's going to be a longer period than after January 6th. It was pretty 38:56 quickly after January 6th establishment Republicans realized, yeah, voters are with this guy. They don't trust you at all. And they definitely don't trust media or Democrats. But this time around, the trust clearly has been broken with the war and 39:12 with the prices. I think some of that goes back to the I mean, is it a more significant severing of the trust, meaning it's a wider swath of the base. 39:30 I think that is the question that we're in the middle of learning the answer to right now. It seems clear to me, like actually just as we're sitting here, let me pull this up. This just hit my radar right before I sat down. This is from Jasper Goodman, 39:48 Politico reporter. News. Senate Banking Chair Tim Scott is calling on both Jensen Wong and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to testify before the panel at a separate oversight hearings next month. 40:00 So here you have Republican Senator Tim Scott calling Howard Lutnick to testify. This comes on the heels of an Axios leak that Scott Besson was laying into Howard Lutnick for not putting, what was it, Megaspeed, the Alice Wong company, 40:18 company on essentially a blacklist over china allegations um and so tim scott is saying well we want to hear about this was there uh some element of corruption uh howard lutnick's former firm canter fitzgerald is run now by his family they are invested in nvidia huh They are 40:42 also invested, his family's fortunes are intertwined with data center investments and that sort of thing. So here you have Republican Senator Tim Scott. Why is that significant? Well, he's from a state, a red state that just had a 40:55 seat flip blue. So I'm just mentioning that to say the incentive, if you're someone in a red state that just had a seat flip blue, the incentive structure has really finally changed. And I do think that's genuinely a new thing in the Trump era. So where does that 41:14 take us? It's an interesting question. Thank you so much for the email, Aaron. And thank you to everyone, by the way, for listening and subscribing. Really appreciate it. Darren says, has anyone done the analysis to see the extent to 41:24 which diluting stronghold districts this time around might have contributed to the landslide? I have seen, yes. This is the dummy mandering analysis. It looks like there were a lot of dummy manders. I'm not an expert on this. I 41:37 have seen analyses suggesting that's true, Darren. I wish I could recommend a really good one. I've just seen it like kind of scattered versions of that. But yeah, that's a that's a big, big question. I'm telling you, over 41:53 the summer, as these gerrymanders were happening, Republicans thought they might even be able to keep the House. They thought they were going to keep the Senate. But there was this new optimism that they actually were going to keep 42:04 the House. They really thought they had a chance at keeping the House. And we've learned now, I mean, what, 40 plus seats? They did not have a chance at keeping the House at all, even with the gerrymandering. I mean, that's the 40 seats with the gerrymander. So, Darren, I mean, 42:18 that's kind of just a good analysis in and of itself. 42:20 The numbers sort of speak for themselves. But even with those wins that Republicans thought were at their back, that's what happened. But yeah, I think it sounds to me like that was the case for sure. All right. And Corbin says, I'm writing a few days after the midterm elections. 42:36 I'm a conservative. I'm evangelical. And I find myself agreeing with your takes about 95% of the time. This week, for the first time in my life, I didn't vote for a single Republican. And I actually voted for several Dems at the state and national levels. Never done either 42:49 of those things in an election before. I think a lot of conservatives did the same nationwide. There's a lot of talk about where the GOP goes from here. This is a very necessary conversation. But I want to ask you, 42:57 what can principled Christian conservatives be doing in the coming weeks, months, and years to fight for the heart and soul of the conservative movement? I've been talking with several friends of mine the last few days, so many of us have 43:04 actually felt reinvigorated by the recent rejection of Trumpism in the GOP. We have not felt welcome to the GOP and the conservative movement for a long time. Now I feel like the time is right to fight for the soul of the party and the conservative movement to once 43:14 again become champions of liberty, free markets, and servant leadership. 43:17 In the coming weeks and months, what can decent people do to fight for a return to virtue and worthwhile principles? Specifically, what should individuals start doing right now at the local and state level to start reforming the Republican Party from 43:27 within and rebuild the it into a moral institution once again, which has a chance at getting good people elected and serving the nation well. P.S. On the happy hour episode prior to the election, you read an email from Jennifer 43:37 in Claiborne County who favorably referenced a previous email I sent into the show. Wanted to shout her out in return. Also, she neglected to mention to you that she's from one of the prettiest spots in the entire country. So I 43:46 wanted to correct the record. Oh, well, Corbin, consider Jennifer shouted out. Love that. Loved the conversation with each other there. 43:55 And we'll just say, My answer to this as somebody who's never really been involved in politics at the grassroots level is right now I think we need to find a bridge between particularly younger and older conservatives, but I would also say traditional and what's the best way to 44:18 put this? Traditional and Trump coalition conservatives. And not everybody in the Trump coalition is MAGA anymore. So I just want to clarify that. But I mean, people who came in as part of the new multiracial working class movement 44:29 that Trump architects were really trying to build. And that means we have to figure out what kind of common ground policies would actually help preserve and protect I think what, Corbyn, you're talking about, these foundational pillars of the American Republic. 44:51 What policies exist as common ground between these warring factions? 44:56 How can we find that common ground? And How can we then talk about that? So that's, I think, maybe an important way to look at the project. How do we even talk to each other? And then how do we find what that common ground is? And then what 45:12 does that look like on a policy basis? Is it enough? 45:15 That sort of thing. Because if we don't figure out, this goes to one of the last emails we were talking about, if we don't even figure out how to have these conversations because everybody is suspicious that admirers of J.D. 45:27 Vance are secret anti-Semites, like if we were calling Megan Kelly an anti-Semite, this conversation can't happen because Megan is somebody who, um, you know, has, has been very supportive of Israel over her career and very vocal, a very 45:44 vocal opponent of anti-Semitism and got called an anti-Semite because she broke with the president on the war. Um, and yes, in, in very bold language. And of course, uh, in a very vigorous stance, vigorously articulated stance. But if we're doing 46:08 that kind of thing, these conversations are not going to happen in the first place, which means the common ground is never going to be discovered. And I think we just need to find ways to find that common ground coming from a place of good faith and find it 46:24 in ourselves. And I mean this about myself too. to approach the people who disagree with us in our own movement from a place of good faith and to genuinely be curious, to come to those conversations with open minds and to do it specifically for the sake of finding 46:41 those places of common ground that are sufficient and adequate to preserve and protect those pillars, those load bearing walls 46:51 for the system of Republican government we have here, uh, So anyway, I think it was a really good question. 47:00 And I would just say on a local level, I think find ways to model those conversations, to have those conversations and to figure out locally. It's easier, I think, sometimes on local policy, though it can be more difficult in local politics, to find that common ground and to 47:14 enact change and to feel like you have agency. And I also just think, you know, do what you can to be glue in your community, even if it's just your own family, your community. I mean, I know that's kind of broader, but just because we're a global society 47:29 now through technology, we're constantly thinking globally and neglecting local familial obligations, community obligations, and, uh, village obligations, state obligations. 47:42 And so I would, you know, so really emphasize those things and figure out how to have these conversations to specifically, not just to have conversations for the sake of having conversations because they're fun and they, they, um, They bind 47:54 us in some ways, bond us in some ways, but also because they have to be done specifically with the intent of finding common ground policy solutions and then learning how to be persuasive and pitch those to the public. 48:07 So it's a really good question, Corbin. Abe sends along the link. Whoa, AI basically owns your life, but only if any small part of your life is on the internet. 48:16 And it is a YouTube video, something to take a look at. Thank you, Abe. Matthew says, you're probably drowning in emails right now, so no obligation to respond. What if 2026 isn't the nadir for the GOP? 2006 was terrible for the GOP and 2008 was terrible yet again. 48:31 Is it possible the GOP loses even more House and Senate seats and the Democrats control the presidency with a supermajority in both chambers, along with additional gains in state legislatures and just in time for the next census? I 48:40 don't see many commentators pricing this in. No, I think that's totally possible, Matthew. I think it's also possible that we see another dramatic reversal in 2028 because Steve Krakauer, one of Megan's fantastic producers, was pointing this out on X. 48:54 The 2024 to 2026 vibe shift, which goes from the 2020 vibe shift, 2022 vibe shift to the 2024 one, maybe suggests that what we have right now is a big chunk of very persuadable voters who are very distrustful of the political system. So they're really up for grabs 49:14 by people who are against the status quo. And our, our finding ways to kind of get around the legacy media. 49:22 And I think that's a pretty good description of the trajectory. 49:28 And so it wouldn't surprise me if Republicans feel like in 2028, like Democrats do right now. And it also wouldn't surprise me to Matthew's point, if this war keeps dragging on, if it gets worse, not impossible, that there's 49:42 a black swan event that people aren't thinking about right now that makes this war really bad, if there's an economic crash, because we're in what many people feel anxious about as an AI bubble, myself included, if there's a 49:57 financial crash on Trump's watch, on Republicans' watch, and the corruption becomes a lasting albatross that It's a brand that anybody bearing the party brand is dragged down by for years in the future. I mean, these things can happen, 50:16 of course. And I think Matthew's right. There's some precedent for that. So another reason why... And actually, even just to underscore Matthew's point, perhaps the fact that Republicans aren't even able to have... constructive conversations about the vice president. 50:39 At least, again, I'm very online, but most of the political class is online. A lot of the grassroots is on X, especially because Trump was such a prolific Twitter user. 50:47 So I feel like the discourse is probably pretty reflective of people who are activists around the country, who are donors, who are consumers of conservative media. And it's just been And it's one thing for it to be hostile and 51:06 nasty and bitter, but in the least constructive way possible is how I would describe it over the course of the last week. So holidays can change things. People kind of hibernate for a bit and go back to basics. 51:17 And everything picks back up in January when there's a new Congress and there's Democrats attacking Trump. And it looks like Trump and Stephen Miller are planning to go all in on defending the president, circling the wagon, not letting any... 51:34 or not letting any arrow pierce the armor. And so we'll see how that goes, but they're definitely going to try to rally all Republicans behind them. And listen, there was a poll today, Aaron Blake over at CNN wrote about it, that found voters care much more about affordability, 51:51 seeing action from Congress on affordability than they do about investigations into corruption. It was a poll that was phrased that way. And of course that makes sense. It doesn't mean people don't care about those investigations. They don't care 52:03 about the corruption, but they do want Democrats to show that their number one priority is not just taking down Trump, but is actually getting relief. That's hard to do when you don't have the presidency, which is why people tend 52:13 to focus on investigations when they don't have the presidency. 52:16 So that's going to be a tough one for Democrats. 52:19 So we will see. I'm obviously, I think it's going to be tough for Republicans too, because they don't want to side with the administration in some of these very unpopular cases. I'll have a big piece on Monday contextualizing 52:32 some of the corruption allegations, which I do think are bad. 52:35 I've spent all week working on this, and I think they're enormously serious. And I want everybody to kind of have some of the information and make up their own takes on it. But there's obviously possible. There's obviously some 52:47 room for for overreach that galvanizes the base against Democrats and becomes a glue again for the coalition. But or duct tape again for the coalition. But, you know, Republicans do actually need to find some way to duct tape 53:04 that coalition together without Trump because he's not going to be on the ticket again. And his popularity has waned. 53:09 So what is that duct tape? And we haven't seen a good sign of what it is so far in this wilderness period on the right. Jeff says, hey, Emily, there was a time when I voted Carrie, so I'm not adverse to upsetting hyper patriotic morons who don't know 53:24 what the word means, but I'm not afraid to shift to vote for the greater good. As I've gotten older, the more paleo liberal I've become, that means while I'm definitely an economic populist who despises foreign entanglements, I've never 53:32 let go of the importance of tradition and cultural continuity. 53:35 I've never stopped being grateful to the country. Oh, that's really well said, Jeff. Jeff adds, it seems to me like no one is grateful today, and I think blind liberalism is what we don't ask of the immigration process are to blame and what we don't ask of the 53:46 immigration process are to blame. I do not think pure economic power is our strength, nor do I think immigration as economics are our strength either. I know you're a bit more moderate these days, but do you hold these views or have you ever? Thanks. Jeff, I don't think 53:57 I've ever been described as moderate, but I get where you're coming from in that sense. I've never thought of myself as a Republican. I've thought of myself as a conservative because I've always distrusted the Republican Party as much 54:09 as the Democratic Party. And so on top of that, I'm also maybe kind of paleo, like you, Jeff. More paleo-conservative than paleo-liberal, but fairly economically populist, which I think, by the way, is... You can... marry economic populism and 54:30 traditional conservatism. And you could look to Russell Kirk and different examples of conservative thinkers over the years that I think did that well. But anyway, that was a little bit of a tangent. I think you're right that we 54:47 sort of see ourselves as citizens of the world rather than citizens of real physical places, countries with borders, states with borders, city with cities with citizens and not just residents, uh, or a country with citizens and not just residents, like 55:03 even blurring that distinction. It's Victor Davis Hanson who talks about that. I think blurring that distinction has, has been really problematic. And I think it's an inevitable consequence. It's an unsurprising consequence of social media, particularly in the last 55:16 20 or so years, blurring borders, knitting everybody so closely together that we are within a second, uh, distance, wherever we are, almost in any corner of the world, especially now with Starlink. And so it makes sense to me that that's happened over time. And it does seem like 55:35 we take an enormous amount for granted. But I also think part of the reason we take so much for granted is that, and again, this gets me into some of the callers I've heard from recently as well, is that things, important things, have gotten worse over In recent years. 55:50 And so it's not to say that we, it makes it easy to lose sight of, you know, how things, how much better things are than a hundred years ago when you're looking and you're saying, well, 10 years ago, the average age of a first time home buyer or 56:03 the average age of the average price of a starter home was more affordable. That type of thing. Healthcare before Obamacare, not perfect, had a lot of flaws. The preexisting condition stuff was terrible, but it's more expensive now. And all 56:19 those sorts of things. By the way, even like constructions on new homes, like you're going to pay more and you get what feels like garbage. It feels that way in so much of the economy, obviously. And when things feel like they're getting worse, you lose perspective. And in 56:34 the micro, when things feel like they're getting worse, you lose perspective of the macro. And so I feel like I agree with you on that, Jeff. And the way we've been knitted together through technology, also has just made us less conscious of our physical location in a way 56:55 that I think really has cheapened the national bond and the national sense of identity and the individual sense of identity and purpose as a citizen and all that sort of thing. So really good observations, Jeff. And I so 57:13 appreciate the note. Super interesting. This is from Rich, who says, with Suzy Wiles moving on and perhaps others to follow, what's your guess on who will write a book, perhaps make the roundtables promote it? Biggest question, when President Trump 57:23 is still in office, would the author be critical and perhaps cause controversy? By doing so, grace and peace. Rich. Hmm. Interesting. 57:30 Who would write that book? I don't know. You've got John Swan and Maggie Haberman. They wrote that regime change book, which is apparently very good. Yeah. I've read some of the reporting from it, not the whole thing. I bet that it has a lot of Susie Wiles stuff in it, 57:46 but is there a book on the downfall of Susie Wiles to come out? Oh, I bet someone is going to do a book on that. They probably work at like, I don't know, the Times or Politico. I don't have a specific name that comes to mind. Um, but man, 58:01 if you can put that together in the next year, maybe people will have forgotten about Susie Wiles by then. Um, maybe we'll already have a couple more chiefs of staff by then. But it's a good question. Maybe Cali Means will write a book. And in that case, he wouldn't 58:18 be particularly critical because, you know, I think what we're seeing with the Cali Means media tour is an attempt to persuade Trump. I think he went on CBS specifically and said the president's staff treats him like a baby 58:33 as a message to President Trump, hoping President Trump would see that. And uh, be persuaded that his gatekeepers are destroying Maha and his legacy. That's my, uh, assumption. So yeah, maybe Callie will do it. Uh, Gil says, first off, 58:48 love your show. Secondly, while this focusing on the midterm results, I was assured by my friends on the left that Trump was a fascist dictator. And now that he was back in office, he was going to cancel all elections. 58:55 So I'm at the point right now where I'm waiting for Trump to declare martial law and all this hand-wringing will be over and done. Of course, I'm just being fastidious, but my point is that today's Democrats are nuts. If they succeed in ditching Schumer Jeffries and put in the 59:05 likes of Bernie AOC in leadership positions, they will burn themselves out on their own woke nitrous oxide high. The energy of the party is what the DSA and the alleged moderates will get tainted with that stink. Democrats as 59:18 a whole have no plan for affordability, and they notoriously are in favor of expensive gas and diesel and have no motivation to make things better. If they can keep blaming Trump, just my two cents, keep the good work. Well, thank you, Gil. I am actually really curious about this 59:30 question about, like, you described the woke nitrous oxide high if Bernie and AOC end up in leadership. It doesn't look like either of them is going to end up in leadership, but people who are more favorable to them could certainly end up in leadership and AOC can certainly 59:43 run for president. Bernie even has some people encouraging him to run for president, though he's old and has signaled he's not interested in it. But I actually think they went on this tour of the fighting oligarchy tour around the country over the last year, and they never, ever 60:00 said anything about woke. And I think that was, Mamdani was the real sign to stop doing that to Democrats. 60:08 They saw him destroy Cuomo in the primary and then in the general election by talking specifically just about affordability. 60:15 That's when that buzzword hit the Virginia and New Jersey governor's races. Those candidates very intentionally ran Mamdani-inspired campaigns. And I think it's a question of whether I don't think they've really changed. I don't think most people have really 60:32 changed their beliefs on those things. But are they even interested in governing on those things? Some of them certainly are. 60:39 But I actually think some of them know that that is the most destructive force to their power. And they believe more in kind of undermining the capitalist system and ushering in what they see as true democratic socialism, Nordic 60:56 style democratic socialism, if you listen to Bernie, then they care about restoring all of the federal government's DEI, often racist DEI requirements and those sorts of things. And at the very top level, there are also a lot of 61:13 leftist critiques that AOC pays attention to, not enough, but on those types of things. So They're not really marching in locks up on that. And I'm actually curious. I mean, I'm not at all like I don't believe James Tallarico 61:24 has changed his opinion. I don't believe Annie Andrews has changed her opinion one bit on any of that. But, you know, is there an incentive for them not to touch it, even if they believe in it in the same way that, you know, they're Republicans who. believe in 61:40 some libertarian things that they never actually touch when they're in office or, uh, there are Republicans who are, are anti-abortion who just choose not to, uh, do those things when they're in office. Cause I think they're just too 61:52 toxic and destructive to their political power. Is that what happens? 61:55 I don't know yet, but it's possible. That's what happens. Um, on that question. And you know, the advantage that Democrats often have on like quote unquote affordability is that they have some short-term solutions that feel good to people, uh, 62:07 which is, you know, government programs that offer more money, which again, like I'm not an anti-welfare person. I think you probably have to have some of that, but I'm obviously deeply opposed to the way that, uh, it has 62:17 been administered since, uh, especially LBJ. And yeah, so in the short term, uh, that can help and subsidies of industries in the short term can help. And so they're attractive, uh, political solutions because they can offer short-term relief. But yes, 62:34 then are they ever punished in the long term? I think you can make the argument, not yet. I don't know. 62:40 Or like it plays into elections sometimes, but look at all these blue cities. So I don't know on the politics of it, but yeah, thank you so much, Gil. 62:50 It would be crazy to say that gas isn't higher in California because of Democrats. Of course, gas is higher in California than other states in part because of blue state taxes and energy policies. So that'll be, I mean, there may be some reckoning with that down the road 63:06 as well. Dave says, I enjoy your podcast, which I hear in SiriusXM. I appreciate your knowledge and analysis and the usual good humored way you present your arguments and observations. 63:15 I do not always agree with your conclusions, but to tell the truth, I sometimes don't agree with my own, but that's life. I also appreciate you did not raise your voice or speak in any angry or aggressive manner as not too many political podcasters or radio yakkers do. 63:25 When people do that, I'm never quite sure if the heat is sincere or part of a bit. Either way, the act gets old right quick. My one criticism, and it's a small one, is that the volume of politics and electoral politics you cover can get fatiguing and overwhelming 63:35 for a person such as I, who considers politics a bitter pill that must be swallowed to maintain the nation. 63:40 It's something that has to be done, but not necessarily enjoyed. 63:42 An election ends and immediately speculation starts as to who the frontrunners for the next election will be. I blame the Kiltons for the never-ending campaigning refusal to allow anyone to catch their breath from the last race. Um, please consider, 63:54 and I may be overstepping the balance, but doing more content about general culture and the culture that made the nation. 63:58 I refer to books, art, philosophy, et cetera. Um, and this is a long email, but, um, appreciate this Dave. 64:06 And I'm reading the rest of the email right now. Um, 64:09 Dave recommends the YouTube channel war on beauty and, And Dave, I just appreciate this. I want to say I actually go back and forth on this myself a lot because I'm much more interested in kind of deep cultural questions. 64:25 But I'm also here in D.C. and a big part of my job is covering day to day horse race. 64:30 And so I know I have people in my audience who are exactly like you, Dave, who consider politics the bitter pill to swallow. They want to stay relatively abreast and they want to be relatively informed and have a kind of fresh perspective on it. but they're mostly interested 64:42 in the cultural stuff. A lot of the audience is there with you on that, Dave. On the other hand, I know there are a lot of people who want to hear kind of horse race coverage from a, I guess, hopefully unconventional conservative perspective, or maybe the better way to 64:58 put it is independent conservative perspective. And so I want to do both. And I you know, I know that striking the right balance is tough. So I actually think about this all the time, Dave. And, you know, I appreciate hearing from people who have a take on one 65:13 side of the balance or what the balance should more closely resemble. Of course, around the midterms, it's just always going to be more politics, more to say on it, because I think there's more that's just not being covered well. But, 65:25 you know, I'd expect that the midterms are over. The balance probably shifts heavily in the direction of culture. But, you know, I love both and I work on both Um, so it's always, you know, it's, it's a question of really, that's, it's part of the toughest thing that I think I've 65:40 found with doing after party in particular is getting that balance right. So I appreciate that. Um, Eliezer says, hello, Emily. 65:47 I must admit when you and Ryan joined the breaking points universe, I wasn't that hot on you guys. Then at some points it became my favorite BP couple. Don't tell Crystal and Sagar. I've become such a fan that 65:54 I've started listening to your other podcasts. Most conservative voices come across as pretty sure you're hypocritical, but not you. 65:58 Even when I don't agree with some reviews, I know you're being honest and have no hidden agenda. Thank you. 66:02 Thank you. Thank you. I appreciate that, Eliezer. On your last show, Alistair mentioned receiving a mailer that encouraged him or her to vote and how creepy it felt. I don't know if it's the same people, but I too received something like that. Had the years I voted and 66:14 the ones I didn't. Oh my goodness. He says, as someone who was born and raised in Puerto Rico, I've often wondered if statehood is really a possibility. Oh, we talked about that last week. Even though Puerto Rico is not legally a country because it's an incorporated territory of 66:25 the USA, we are a nation. We have our own language and a culture that predates Plymouth Colony by more than 100 years. trying to force Puerto Rico into statehood for democratic gains seems wrong. See, that's very interesting perspective, uh, 66:37 because that's not how Democrats describe it. And I bet internally, uh, that's a source of much more tension than Democrats are familiar with. Uh, long email reading the rest of it here. 66:50 Thank you so much. I really, uh, I really appreciate this and I'm glad you bring that kind of outside the box perspective. Um, it's funny the first time I was in Puerto Rico within like an hour of being there, I took a walk alone to the beach and, uh, 67:05 a native Puerto Rican came up to me and started talking to me about state or I'm sorry about independence. 67:11 Actually it wasn't about state. It was about independence. Um, and so I know tensions are, are hot on this locally and, uh, Democrats definitely don't have a monopoly on that conversation at all. So I think that's a really 67:24 helpful perspective. Um, Sun Prairie Mom says, what is going on with Epstein and why is it still going on? 67:31 Why is everyone talking about Epstein? What do people want? 67:33 What do people expect? You have told us you spent hours poring over the three and a half million pages, 2,000 videos, and 180,000 images that have been released. Why do people think there's more? Why do lawmakers, watchdogs, and people underestimate, 67:42 or people estimate that millions of additional pages and terabytes of investigative data remain unreleased? Because the media told us so. 67:48 Let's be honest. There was something in those files that would nail Trump. The Obama admin would have used it again, would have used it instead of orchestrating Crossfire Hurricane and their other shenanigans. If they found a modicum of restraint, 67:57 Biden would have used it because the admin had no restraint and nothing happens when people who are found to be involved with Epstein, Prince Andrew, Bill Gates, Reid Hoffman. 68:04 Why can't we just be done with Epstein? And Sue also says, my other point of confusion, how do people think voting for Democrats is going to improve their cost of living? They'll resurrect or once they have control, Dems 68:19 will raise taxes to partially cover their overspending. Ka-ching, they will regrow the federal government. Ka-ching. So it goes on and on on this. Yeah, like that's actually also a good question because Democrats only have the House and the 68:30 Senate and not the presidency. So what can they even do at this point? That was having these conversations with people on the wrap-up show for the last six plus months. 68:39 That was part of people's calculus. It's like maybe if I vote Dem as a protest vote because I want to stick it to Republicans, it's not actually going to bring prices down. It's just going to be a sort of stick in the eye against Republicans. without a lot 68:52 of practical function about the things that I wanted. So I know some people were thinking about that and maybe thought the benefits of punishing Republicans outweighed the cost because Dems can't really do anything. Now, if we're talking about 69:05 state houses, that's totally different. Wisconsin all flipped. So it gets back to the micro macro conversation we were just having. 69:13 Often Democrats have short-term solutions And they don't get punished for some of the long-term downstream consequences of higher spending. 69:20 For example, I actually think some of our current inflation, a lot of it's from Iran, but some of it is certainly going back to the hot, hot spending of the Biden administration. And Dems didn't get punished for that 69:32 in 2028 because the Trump administration, 2026, I'm sorry, started a war and is in charge. So even if it's difficult for the president to do anything on that without the war, would Dems... be punished for that spending? Probably 69:47 not politically. So that's kind of a built-in advantage I think that high spenders always have in the political system. 69:54 I have a lot to say about Epstein. I just interviewed Massey on Breaking Points with Crystal today. And there's good evidence that the government still has many, many, many files that aren't being released. They say that what hasn't 70:07 been released has not yet been released because it is not salient or is not responsive to the demands of the Epstein Files Transparency Act. A lot of people don't trust that, obviously, because Trump was at one point a friend of Epstein's. And so if his Department of Justice 70:24 is the one making those decisions, if Ghislaine Maxwell was just moved to a cushier prison, there's, I think, reason to be dubious that the Trump DOJ is releasing absolutely everything. 70:36 If there's anything on Trump in there, would Obama and Biden have used it? I don't know, because I think there's enough on other Democrats. But if there was anything that's like smoking gun, Trump is also a pedophile sex trafficker. 70:51 I would assume the Biden administration would have found a way to release that as well. But I think the reason that the Epstein is still going on, excuse me, I just hit the desk, is the reason it's still going on, I mean, there are many, but because the 71:11 Trump administration was so resistant after saying they would release the files, people like Kash Patel, Trump himself, because they then came to office and were so resistant to releasing the files, they had to be compelled by Congress to 71:27 do so. It felt enormously suspicious. Now, is it the top priority of most voters? No. But To a lot of people, it feels like the Rosetta Stone for kind of understanding how power operates. The files show all of 71:44 these oligarchs essentially emailing each other and controlling geopolitics on their typo-written email accounts. And so some of it's kind of indelible in the worldview of especially some younger folks now. 71:58 But I think the primary problem is that this administration was so resistant to releasing files that people lost trust. 72:11 And because they see that Jeffrey Epstein was friends with Bill Clinton and Donald Trump, that Ghislaine Maxwell was working with the Clinton Foundation, that foreign governments were running around with Epstein, that our intelligence agencies had some connections to 72:29 Epstein and other business agencies. It feels like a really, really important story of non-accountability. And I think to some people it feels like kind of a Rosetta Stone for power in ways that may not be fair. But I think it does feel like that, that if we can 72:47 just get more clues together and we'll figure it out. Now, I think it's like the Kennedy assassination. We'll just get drips and drabs over the course of the next several decades and always just be left to put pieces together without knowing how big the puzzle is and not know 73:02 you don't have the box. So you can't see the picture. 73:05 You're just kind of assembling a puzzle blind. And you'll never fully know what it really looks like, what the true story really looks like. But I think the reason that people are still deeply concerned is that the administration 73:17 put themselves in that position by resisting it so strongly after saying they wouldn't. And that gave a lot of people reason to say, oh, there must be a whole lot more that we don't yet know. And I think an Epstein will be an undying source of curiosity and 73:33 anger and resentment toward elites with some faction of the public for many, many years to come. But you know what? 73:39 I think it's fair to not just be done with Epstein because there's so many currently powerful people whose moral authority is dramatically undermined by their relationships with him. Bill Gates being absolutely, absolutely one of those people is such 73:55 a good example of one of those people that it is amazing that he's still has maintained so much power and authority over American business and politics and culture. So, yeah, I think that's why it's fair. And the, I mean, yeah, we could go back to the original deal. And I 74:21 was reading the grand jury testimony before the original deal recently. 74:25 And it is genuinely shocking the amount of evidence that they have versus what he was punished with. The amount of evidence the FBI had versus what his punishment was, the fact that he was in high security prison, was killed. 74:36 I mean, these are sources of deep mystery, and I don't know that we'll ever get the answers, and people might have to learn to be comfortable in their discomfort with that. But I think there are some good reasons that people are still curious, because he died in maximum 74:51 security prison under the first Trump administration. So those are some questions that take you to this current administration then and make that relevant, I suppose. Thank you for the email, Sue. 75:07 I really appreciate it. And yeah, that second part of the email too, especially, I thought that was an excellent point. 75:14 This is Ralph saying this guy is extremely dangerous and he's doing his best to replace Charlie. It's a link to a Scott Galloway podcast. I've seen him sort of fashioned as a male guru or Svengali type I don't know. 75:31 I think Charlie was specifically a millennial, young husband-father, specifically conservative type, and Galloway is so obviously a Gen X progressive that I don't know if he's seen as somebody who's in the same slot. But I also don't actually 75:50 even listen to him that much. I find him so annoying as we covered with Michael Ballas this week. Thanks for the email, Ralph. And he says, last week, he got a long question that had bared in it what you thought of shoe on your head and your answer 75:59 got lost. Re-upping it here. I love her, which is odd as a 63 year old right winger. I don't have any answer to that. I don't I'm not familiar, really, to be honest. So I still don't have a good answer. Sorry, Eddie. 76:10 Eddie says, also, you enjoyed hearing from a South Carolina listener citing their location. Maybe more of us should drop our general location. I'm writing from Northwest Tennessee. Oh, you're in a beautiful corner of the country, Eddie, that's for sure. 76:22 This is from Jordan, who says, hi, Emily, this Harper's Magazine story from 2023 is a potent illustration of how Susie Wiles operates. It also explains the origins of the moniker De Sanctimonious. I remember reading it in 2023 and I think he would boomerang one day. Here we are. 76:36 I thought you'd find it intriguing. Ooh, thank you, Jordan. 76:38 I'm opening this link right now and saving it on my reading list for later. That sounds fantastic. All right, got another email here. Oh, yeah, okay. So this is from the person who originally sent in that picture of the creepy mailer, election mailer. And... It looks like our 77:04 Secretary of State, Frank LaRose, called out the CVI for misleading mailers sent to unregistered voters. This has also been an issue in South Carolina. Pass along a picture. Oh, very interesting. Something to take a look at. And the 77:20 person adds, FYI, on your podcast, you mentioned not knowing whether the senders were D or R. Tom Lokapach was previously director of the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee for Montana Governor Steve Bullock and also chief of staff for Senator Tester. 77:32 He also worked for Ted Kennedy. So it seems that he is a Democrat, as I suspected. Very interesting. This is an unsettling trend I hope stops. I'll point out that unmarried women might be particularly uncomfortable with the knowledge 77:42 that someone is monitoring their voting patterns, especially now. Ooh, great point. Great point to this person. I'm also just going to keep anonymous because I'm remembering the first email in this chain as well. Yeah, thank you for the note. 77:55 Thank you for the follow-up. Great point about women living alone. 77:59 Also feeling like people are potentially watching them. That original mailer was handwritten, if y'all listened to that episode. Mary says, in last week's show, you discussed how there could be an argument for D.C. and Puerto Rico statehood. That may 78:11 be true, but the problem is the issue is not about the fact that these residents don't have representation. This is just a pure power play. If the real concern is just lack of representation, then the parts of DC that were originally part of Virginia and Maryland could just 78:20 be returned to those states, and Puerto Rico could become part of Florida without changing the balance of power too dramatically. 78:24 I don't mean to be hyperbolic, but I really do think if Dems take all three branches of government in 2028 and try to stack the Supreme Court and add these territories, you will really see a civil war. The weaponization of lawfare against conservatives across the Western world is 78:37 already frightening. I truly believe it all started with Obama and the Steele dossier. Our allies knew what Obama was up to in that debacle, and they were reportedly stunned Once their shock wore off, they had the realization that 78:47 they could deploy similar methods with little pushback from the u.s and see you see that particularly in the eu with france romania and poland all prime examples you know i don't know too much about that um if there's uh something i should know but i have to look at 78:59 it um i think christopher steel being british intel is particularly interesting uh i've always found that particularly interesting um You know, what I was saying with D.C. and Puerto Rico is that the arguments Dems make will not sound 79:15 ridiculous to everybody because they make these in terms that are based on the question that I got that I was responding to. I was saying they make these arguments on terms that are not just naked power. You may believe that's what their motives are. And I think that's 79:27 probably true. It's naked political power. But I think what I was talking about in the context of the question is that there are principled reasons to believe in statehood for DC and Puerto Rico. And if they make the arguments on those terms, they're going to be much more 79:43 potent than just saying, well, this is about stacking up power. 79:47 And as far as the returning parts of DC back to Virginia and Maryland, you have to have a federal district. 79:54 So you would still have to have a district that's not part of, I mean, that was the entire conceit of DC. So you would have to have something And this is why I don't believe in D.C. Statehood, because I believe you have to have a federal district that 80:03 is federally run because it is the home and a seat of the federal government. And that is a sacrifice, sure, that residents make, but it's also a privilege that residents like me are that enjoy. So anyway, all that is to say, even if you return certain parts back to 80:19 Virginia and Maryland, you would still have to have some presumably residential area for the federal government. So that was my take on that. But yeah, it would really heighten the tensions. There's no question about it if Dems decided 80:35 to do that. Totally, totally would heighten the tensions. And yeah, in ways, listen, I've probably committed the David Betts pieces on civil war in Western Europe and possibly America to people. 80:47 He's a historian of civil wars. He went very viral, especially in UK conservative circles, European conservative circles. Man, was it like two years ago when he first started going viral on that? But I do recommend reading it. He's 80:58 kind of gamed out the possibilities there, and I definitely recommend it. This is from Tony, who says we were in touch earlier this year regarding the affordability issue. I created a website, Make America Affordable Again, that outlines market-based approaches. And, oh, Tony, 81:13 you suggested I submit an op-ed to the Federalist. Took me longer than planned, but the devastating electoral results and the central role played by affordability... provided the ideal window to pitch it and i did oh looks like it worked oh great yeah so this piece is called how 81:27 republicans can take back the affordability issue and it is up at the federalist go ahead and read it there now thanks for getting back in touch tony i'm glad that worked out uh kyle says post midterms i've heard two contrasting arguments from the donor and tech elite class 81:40 the richest 9 000 americans one is the predictable panic that we are on an inevitable path to socialism the other comes directly from degenerate chamath popped yeah who stated the economy had completely decoupled from reality. It's broken. The 81:54 economic reality in America is broken. A small percentage of asset owners of America have been fitted in every weather condition. 81:59 When rates were zero, they benefited because they were able to build their businesses with very cheap capital. When rates were high, they benefited because they had pricing power. And in every condition in between, whether there were tariffs or 82:07 not tariffs, subsidies or not subsidies, they all managed to continue to accumulate and grow assets. But they were few and far between. And there's everybody else who are wage earners and the structural capacity of the American economy to 82:17 support and grow wage earners is broken. It's clear Kyle says, my takeaway is that working class voters are rejecting this broken architecture, demanding an America-first foreign and domestic policy that stops prioritizing foreign subsidies and foreign wars, such as unconditional 82:29 military aid to Israel while domestic wage earners are hollowed out. 82:32 Do you agree that the populist midterm momentum is driven by this asset versus wage decoupling? I have to chew on that, Kyle, because my inclination is to say yes, I agree. Yes. And that what's the Lennon line the capitalists will sell us the rope to hang them with. That, 82:57 you know, as somebody who's generally pro-market, my position on that is that there's just way too much consolidation and too little genuine competition. And it's created a system that feels unfair in many ways, and in many ways also 83:13 is unfair, and that is a recipe for The Asset vs. 83:20 Wage Tension. It's a recipe for Gilded Age-style violence, like we talked about with Michael Malice in the How to Rob a Bank segment from Wednesday's show. But yeah, my instinct, I have to think more about this. I hadn't seen 83:35 Chamath say this. That's really, really interesting, Kyle, and I appreciate you passing it along. Hank says, Emily, while the recent articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth were filed by Thomas Massey, they only follow similar moves by Democrats earlier 83:46 this year. I don't think they qualify as one of the legitimate areas of investigations you mentioned Friday in response to my posting, Breonna Lyman's article. Yeah, this is about the question of whether Democrats, all Democrats' investigations will be, 83:58 will qualify as lawfare, which I don't think is true. 84:01 And I think Republicans have to be careful. That's what I was talking about in response to Hank, I think it was last week's show. But I just want to say, like, yeah, the... 84:11 I don't– Massey's articles of impeachment, even Jonathan Turley, who said most of these are bunk, I'd have to really do a deep dive in them. But like a deep, deep dive on them. We had Massey, like I said, on Breaking Points today. We didn't do a super deep 84:28 dive on the articles themselves so much as on the politics, the political– possibility that comes in the next Congress as he sees it, how he's reading his colleagues right now about their willingness to go along with it or not. 84:42 But I will say even Jonathan Turley said that two of the articles seem like they have more merit than others. 84:50 And one of them is on the boat strikes. If there was a double tap war crime in one of the boat strikes. And gosh, what was the other one that he mentioned? I'm acting like Rick Perry now. The other one was the targeting of Mark Kelly. So the 85:04 fact that those two gave Turley some pause, I think is somewhat interesting in the Massey articles of impeachment. But listen, I don't, I believe that our, I believe fully in the elasticity of war powers. And I don't say that because I support that, but yes, the elasticity of our 85:22 war powers is strong. And, you know, the president and Hegseth will have a lot of, I think, legal ground in the way war powers have been interpreted in American history on some of those things. But Yeah, the boat strikes. 85:35 That's going to be a big one. Michael says, I could listen to Mary Morgan talk about education all day. 85:40 I have not heard her speak on it before, but I will be seeking it out. I'd love to hear more about it from you as well. If you listen to the new season of Soul Destroyer, I'm hopeful that the tide is changing with education. We see a shift 85:48 back to traditional non-force and stick styles of educating our young. 85:52 My boys loved Hatchet. I loved Hatchet, Michael, too. Thanks for the email. So I haven't listened to that new season. And, you know, as a non-parent, I don't talk too much about education because I'm not having a personal kind of encounter with it all the time in my day to 86:06 day life. And I'm not like an expert from that perspective, but always love talking about the plight of boys in the education system and in society more broadly. And boy, did I love Hatchet. That was a great book. Matt says, congrats on the Brewers World Series win. I want to 86:19 ask about the effect playing and watching sports has on the culture. I've always loved baseball, but I've been dismissive about the role it played as our national pastime. However, I began to reconsider my dismissiveness during the World Cup. 86:29 When I read reports about soccer's growth in the U.S., it seemed like a positive development that more Americans would play a sport where running is so important. But I don't like the idea of kids growing up watching soccer players embellish their injuries to draw a yellow or red 86:39 card against their opponents. Something I've always found off-putting. So does it make a difference that baseball and not soccer is our national pastime? Areas like the Northeast and Upper Midwest better or worse off because ice hockey is especially 86:49 popular there. Does it matter that football is so much more popular than any other sport? Or would American culture be much less the same regardless of what sports we watched and played in our free time? Ooh, it'd be good to talk to a sports historian about this, about 87:02 why baseball particularly took off. Why football, which is so different from so many other sports, took off. Basketball... but football is I think probably the most interesting one because there's something just so unique about American football, uh, and 87:17 especially the evolution, uh, of its cultural importance and its cultural presentation in the United States, quick pace sport, a fairly cerebral sport, uh, but has all of the basis covered to mix metaphors here when it comes to, um, 87:36 different types of athletic, um, different types of athletic skills and, uh, talents. 87:44 So yeah, it's, it was a really, really good question. Um, I don't know. I wanted, I would want to look to like a sports historian for a good, for a good answer on that. I think it's, uh, having healthy sports culture is such a good thing because it's a 87:58 source of, uh, low risk, high reward, common ground. And, uh, So I feel like we all see good benefits of that in our communities with kids in sports and that sort of thing. But baseball in particular, I don't know, now that my parents are retired, they go to a 88:18 lot more Brewer games and it's just leisurely. It's not as constantly intense as football and there's something about it that's really slow and pleasant. And it's hard for me with like a millennial attention span actually, which is sad. Um, but. 88:40 you know, those baseball games are long. Um, and it, it, I think lends itself to conversation and quiet sometimes. Uh, if you get drawn into watching the game in ebbs and flows and conversations. So Baseball is a really interesting 89:00 spectator sport. Football, of course, too. But yeah, it's a good question, Matt. I don't think American culture would be more or less the same regardless of what sports we watch. 89:08 I think our sports totally shape. I mean, even if you just look at rap music, I think our culture is very heavily shaped by, pop culture is very heavily shaped by the sports that we watch and the sort of American iterations of the sports that we watch. Wayne says, Emily, 89:27 thank you for answering my earlier email about AI. It gave me something unique to ponder considering our modern day Tower of Babel. The happy hour audience feels like a community having an ongoing conversation trying to make sense of 89:35 each other of each week together. Oh, I love the way you put that, Wayne. At the beginning of 2025, I thought Maha would long outlive MAGA as it was based on enduring principles as opposed to personality. Part of 89:45 the midterm carnage was Zach Lane, Maha candidate for Iowa governor. 89:49 Do you think Maha movement is blunted now or were the Maha voters animated the cycle by their opposition to data centers? Given the advances of AI over the last two years unfettered, will its evolution and impact on society over the next two years make any political change pale 90:01 in comparison? This administration initially wanted a 10-year moratorium on any AI regulation. Maybe all the frontier models needed for escape velocity beyond containment was only two years and counting. 90:15 I don't know what's going to happen over the next two years. I don't think anybody knows what's going to happen over the next two years. I mean, I suppose it's possible that There's regulatory strictures that do quote unquote 90:25 pace the frontier. So the two-year timeline means that the next two years aren't totally dramatically different in the everyday lives and the labor market that we all experience day in and day out. Zach Lane lost more, lost by 90:40 more than the Senate race. And that was surprising to me. 90:43 I'm not in Iowa, but I'm sure that had something to do with the tariffs. I'm sure that had something to do with farmer's and big ag being especially upset with some of the Maha prescriptions for change. And maybe with some reason, of course, like I know you still 90:57 have to, there's such tight margins in the industry right now and such anxiety in the industry right now, especially in the tariff climate, that people are resistant to some really big changes that feel like they're coming from, in 91:11 some cases, elites, you know, really wealthy people that aren't dealing with the day-to-day problems margins. And I can make sense of it, of course. I'd actually like to talk to Zach. I thought he was a very interesting candidate. 91:25 I think Maha absolutely outlives MAGA because it predated MAGA. 91:30 It wasn't called Maha. But now that it's Maha, we've even seen AOC start reaching out to Maha. We're seeing more Democrats, including Abdul El-Sayed, make direct overtures to Maha. 91:40 So maybe Maha becomes split politically in the way that some other you know, like the kind of anti-war movement is split between libertarians and kind of hippies. Maybe Maha ends up more like that, where it's just a more 91:56 polarized movement, but I agree. I think it outlives for sure. 92:00 Christine says, I know amnesty is the big talk this week, which is slightly less annoying than the election, but add some insight into at least some of where the Trump is getting the whiff that he should soften on immigration. 92:08 Joe Rogan, who is still in contact with the president and cabinet members, definitely cabinet members. I don't know about the president. That's interesting. has been saying for over a year almost verbatim what Trump said on 60. Joe said 92:17 it ad nauseum. Hey, I thought we were going after murderers and rapists, not the fucking waitress. We're raiding Home Depot now. That's not what we thought. Worst of the worst is what was understood by the American people. I 92:25 think the American people like the idea of deportations of all illegals in theory, but in practice, the individual stories are more than they can stomach. It's like with war. 92:31 Now that we have footage and 24-7 online discourse, it's just too much, and we don't like to know how the sausage is made. And I definitely think someone from the podcast manosphere penetrated a little bit, certainly with the 92:41 public and possibly with the president. I'm kind of hoping for no amnesty, but just tackling those with criminal records first is still a tall order for the next two years. 92:47 How do you see it as a conservative? Also, thank you for being one of the voices clarifying the tariffs approval rating talking point. I genuinely think Americans are ready for a populist, more protectionist president, 28, and I pray 92:55 to God it's not one of the crazier radical DSA ones. Yeah, Christine, thanks for that question. I have a couple thoughts. I think Industry has always been in Trump's ear as a man who manages and runs and owns hotels. He has always had this industry in his ear. He is familiar 93:08 with this kind of class of shadow workers and is empathetic toward them and is definitely empathetic toward business owners. 93:16 I think business owners have been in the ear of Brooke Rollins and Trump and Scott Besant more than podcast people on this question. I just think he has much more empathy within contact with those folks who were really 93:27 upset about workplace raids in particular. And that was reflected in what he said on 60 Minutes. And I think that probably had more to do with it than the podcast stuff. I'm sure that people in the admin were very aware of what Joe Rogan was saying, though. And 93:43 I guess I disagree a little bit because we have seen deportations hitting records while virtually disappearing from the headlines. 93:50 I do think so long as you are not performatively cruel and then smug about it, you can... Do a robust deportation program without losing enormous support. What has been happening recently has been so out of the headlines. But 94:08 Kristi Noem specifically wanted to be in the headlines because people believe that's how you keep President Trump happy. And they're not entirely wrong about that incentive structure. but it obviously changed after Kristi Noem lost her job. So I 94:23 disagree a little bit, but I think that's a really interesting way to frame it. And you're definitely right that that had, I'm sure you're right that that had an effect. 94:30 And a lot of people may have missed it too. 94:32 Alex says, big fan, or I'm a fan of breaking points. 94:34 And now after party, do you think that Lindsey Graham would have won re-election if he hadn't died? On the one hand, he was a much more skilled politician and campaigner than Darlene. On the other hand, he was a staunch supporter of the dumb war in Iran. I think 94:43 he would have won Alex, but I think he would have won by like two points and we would be talking about it as like one of the surprises on election night that it would have been sort of like the Florida races. And I think it's just because so 94:57 many people are on default. They didn't like the fact that Darlene Graham was shoved down their throat by the president and they didn't like the fact that she openly said she wasn't experienced in foreign policy. That, I think, caused a lot of people actually to stay home. which 95:10 is what combined with some of the people who may have flipped, who did flip, sent Annie Andrews over the edge. 95:16 But I think with Lindsey Graham, a lot of those folks show up out of habit. They trust him. They like what he brings back to the state, whether it's with Boeing or other money. And he would have prevailed comfortably, 95:29 but uncomfortably in the process. Comfortably probably at the end of the day, but it would have been a nail biter on election night. That's a great question. Marlo says, thank you so much for entertaining my questions and providing 95:40 context and citations to your answers. I was a bit saddened by your explanation about the possible corruption on the left being underreported and or of no interest to the voters who vote for them. Therein lies one of the 95:48 biggest problems. The right at large cares about corruption no matter who does it and considers it when voting, but the broader media and the left only care about corruption on the right and uses it to vote harder on 95:56 the left, keeping their corrupt legislators in power. I'm bothered by the corruption highlighted in the Saul article. Oh, this is from Isaac Saul. of Tangle, who I really recommend. 96:05 He did an article that was called Everything Everywhere All at Once Corruption Story back in May. I recommended it to Marlo because I think it captures a lot of what has happened over the Trump administration well. And Marlo says, I wonder if the scale is partly due to these 96:18 current times or if there was much more corruption on the left that was wholly ignored. None of it acceptable. 96:23 I think, Marlo, just to answer that quickly, a lot of this with Trump is new. We've never had a president so entangled personally and through his family with major business quite in this way. But anyway, like I said, I'm prepping something for this on Monday. And Marlo says, 96:38 the only president in my lifetime who entered and left office of meager means was Carter, a great man of office, yet not a good president by many measures. All that said, I'll still vote Trump Republican because I believe in the 96:48 many things he did, not tied to personal corruption, I believe earned my vote. Yeah, for sure. I know there are a lot of people like that, Marlo. Many, many people. 96:55 On the other hand, I'll never vote for the Green New Deal. Whoever in the country propping Biden up like a ventriloquist dummy, DEI socialism, wide open borders. And yeah, many more. Marlo, totally fair. I think there are so many people just like that. Is there a recourse via 97:09 class action for the fools who bought into Trump's supposed rug pull scheme? Trump doesn't always will be a salesman who sometimes sells snake oil. And Marlo says of Mary Morgan, I tried to object to this, but she was very 97:22 young and her assertions like boys can just sit and learn. Yeah, I did disagree with Mary on that point. I think we had a good conversation, but definitely disagreed on that point. 97:31 But Marlo says one thing she said that helped me understand her generation, though, was the possibility that the poster digging up Charlie Kirk was probably a nihilist wanting to be edgy, not someone with a political bent. So sad 97:41 if she's correct. Our youth need help. Amen. I think she is correct, Marlo. That was my favorite part of the conversation because I think it's something that's misunderstood about Zoomers. 97:50 And I was glad Mary, I think, really was able to put her finger on that. Thank you for the email. 97:55 Thank you for listening, Marlo. Ryan says, do you feel that the constant stalemates in Congress will cease once Trump leaves office and is no longer able to run? I feel like the only way we can get anything done for the American people is that we need to go 98:04 back to bipartisanship. I remember the days of the Clinton admin when Newt Gingrich was able to help get Republican legislation passed and signed into law by a Democrat. Since Obama, the fighting between Republicans and Democrats is getting old. No, Ryan, 98:16 I think Congress has actually abrogated so much of its Article I power that it is just Not really interested in legislating. I think we elect people from districts that are more solidly red and blue. which just have less 98:31 incentive to do bipartisanship. I think the executive has taken so much power that should be the legislatures that we just are in a really bad position. And so, you know, Abdullah Assad is already trying to get Trump to do some healthcare deal with him. We'll see. If Dems are 98:49 able to kind of coax Trump into bipartisanship, if he feels like he's at a stagnant point with an unpopular war and wants to do legacy building, I would say it's not impossible. Not impossible at all. Something to keep an eye on. But I don't expect it to return 99:07 to more action or bipartisanship once Trump is out of office, maybe slightly more. because he has been such a polarizing figure, but Congress has just gotten so lazy. Gotta listen to Rachel Bovard on this if you haven't yet. She can 99:21 talk like a wind-up toy on this issue in particular. 99:26 She's worked for many years in the Senate and teaches younger people in the legislative branch on parliamentary procedure. It's been kind of depressing. Jesse says, I'm pretty much a free speech absolutist when it comes to comedy, so I'm 99:39 not at all bothered that Dave Chappelle would make a Charlie Kirk joke. What's weird and disappointing to me is that I have no idea what the punchline was supposed to be. The bit Shane Gillis did on SNL about how some women dress at the gym was actually funny 99:47 if you go to the gym. I still remember my confusion the first time I saw a woman doing deadlifts in what looked like her underwear. I just don't know what Dave's point was with the Kirk bit. Was there some context to the routine? I'm missing. I'm also curious 99:57 about that, Jessie. I talked about this on Megan's show earlier this week, and I said I want to see the full bit because Chappelle, in recent years, has been really masterful about weaving jokes from beginning to end. And I know some people have said they were there and 100:12 there wasn't context missing. So maybe that's the case. I am curious to see the bit. I think comedians are allowed to do this stuff. I think it probably was directly from Tony Hinchcliffe. I think it does speak to this myth of Charlie that's not connected to the reality 100:30 of Charlie Kirk. But I'm curious to see the full bit. Honestly, I don't I agree with you. It doesn't seem like there was much punchline. I wouldn't be surprised if Chappelle is some punchline that we're just not hearing, but it doesn't, it seems like he just kind of said it from 100:49 like the footage that existed. So yeah, I I'm with you. 100:54 Comedians are going to do this stuff. That's the role that they have in the ecosystem. And sometimes it's going to be, um, you know, in bad taste because it doesn't actually advance a point or make a good point. 101:04 And it's just like, okay, so you're punching a dead guy to punch a dead guy. Uh, and people can say that, but, uh, yeah, it's, it's not a type of thing that like gets me super hot and bothered. Uh, Frank says, hi, Emily. I live in Covington, Kentucky, right 101:17 across the bridge from Cincinnati. I got the creepy mailer voting as public record as well. Oh, very, very interesting. 101:23 I've heard from many of you now saying that you got these, uh, Frank goes on to say, For my actual question, I feel like a crazy person on the Al-Sayed conversation. On breaking points, any questioning of Abdul's face that is treated as racist. I particularly remember a few 101:34 comments from Crystal on the election live stream. I think generally it's not helpful to focus on a candidate's faith, but I feel like there should be an exception for Islam. 101:40 Not because Muslims are bad people, but because it's such an all-encompassing religion. And neither secular liberalism nor Christian culture seem to survive in countries where it takes root. That's a genuine question, especially considering the anti-gay sentiment in cities 101:51 like Dearborn. What's continuing to happen in the UK? Isn't that a fair concern? Oh, totally a fair concern, Frank. 101:56 I actually have no idea where Crystal stands on that. 101:58 But I think it's a very fair concern because I think there's, and listen, I actually think it's a fair concern to have about any religion. I think Islam particularly has a, in its text, political implications. And there are 102:14 political interpretations of Christianity that are totally fair game. People who interpret very specific political agendas through the Bible and incorporate them into formal structures and that sort of thing. totally, totally fair game. I hear you on that. Or I 102:28 hear people on that. But I do think, yes, there's a question of whether, there's an absolutely fair question that academics and scholars debate about the compatibility of Islam and liberalism, 102:39 classical liberalism, the American sort of Republican, constitutional Republican system. 102:44 Abdullah Syed made his argument about the constitution, always turned it back to the constitution. He said, I am a constitutionalist. 102:51 And Shadi Hamid, who writes about this at the Washington Post a lot, he also has a podcast, insists that American Islam is very particular in blending with constitutionalism. And I think it's open for debate. But Shadi has been 103:09 making that argument. If people hit a debate with William Wolfe, if people want to take a look at that, they can find it. There are all kinds of great debates about this. Like I said, Raymond Ibrahim just did a pretty interesting one. But it's a totally fair topic for debate. 103:24 And it takes us back almost to the aughts when you had Hitchens and Sam Harris and the like debating this with Ben Affleck on Bill Maher. I'd expect that to probably pop back up a little bit. But there's a fair scholarly debate about the compatibility of Islam and 103:43 classical liberalism You can make the same case about people who are integralists, who believe in generally hardcore Catholics, who would prefer to see a sort of Catholic monarchy as the ideal system for human flourishing. Totally fair question to 104:02 have about integralism and classical liberalism. Some people have had that. 104:06 Very hardcore iterations of Christian nationalism and classical liberalism. Yeah, totally, totally fair debates. But I think there are political implications of the religious text for in terms of like the system and the justice system that exists in Islam that 104:20 I would argue are not the same at all in Christianity. 104:23 But yeah, I would say it's a fair question. And I expect that debate is going to continue. This is Hank. 104:31 Can you, you noted in the conversation with Michael that you have many disagreements with Douglas Murray, care to elaborate on them? I know you like hearing different views, so he would be a good guest for After Party. Yeah, I've met Douglas and I read a lot of what 104:43 Douglas writes. I do like hearing from people with different viewpoints. 104:47 I have found him, unfortunately, to, I think, exert a more kind of sneering and condescending approach to people who dissent from his position on foreign policy. Yes, he debates. 105:02 I don't love that. And I don't love it from anybody. 105:07 You know, like... when Dave Smith disagreed with me, gosh, I forget what it was. Oh, about whether America was like a source of the greatest source of political terrorism, something like that. He was just like, what do you mean you disagree with that? Tell me why you disagree 105:21 with that. That's the kind of vibe that I like. 105:24 I don't like the, oh, how could you type attitude. 105:29 And I don't mind when people disagree, but I don't like that temperament. But I do read a lot of Douglas's work. So Definitely still read him. I read a lot of the free press. So yeah. Last email here. 105:41 John says, let's see, let's see. Do you think it is possible for our society to regain a shared sense of reality given how polarized the media have become? I see and hear things about Dem politicians and make me No one in their right mind can vote for them. 105:55 There are so many examples of corruption, incompetence, nastiness, or simply bad judgment, but then they win. On the other hand, my 25-year-old daughter and 80-year-old mother both repeat the same stories about Trump, mostly untrue and easily disproved, e.g. that 106:07 he's known to soil himself in public and wears a diaper and they're consuming vastly different forms of media. Yeah, I worry about this all the time. John says, I feel we have populations of voters now who simply don't share realities. Not very long ago, we could at least 106:20 rely on video to show us reality, but now it is so easy to create fake videos and spoof real people that it's hard for anyone to tell at a glance what is real and what is not. That is a bad foundation for a representative republic. Really well said, 106:31 I think. John says, thanks for the show. One reason I suggest we enjoy your happy hour so much and the way you connect with listeners, viewers, is that it gives us a sense of connection to your guests and your network. It's like we are one degree of separation 106:40 from them all. Best, John. Jen, thank you for saying that. That's, uh, exactly the goal. So, uh, I really appreciate that. I appreciate everyone who writes in. I like when, uh, we have these conversations over multiple weeks. It's so great. I 106:53 love it. Uh, and that one degree of separation, I just know that's what I would want if I wasn't working in media. So, uh, I hope it comes across that way. One of the biggest things I worry about is the, uh, siloed realities. Um, you know, we're in 107:09 microcultures and that means there are very few sources of, uh, mono cultural, um, information. And even if it's the same information, but that's being presented with different perspective and framing, um, it, it emphasizes different things and man, alternative facts, like the 107:34 greatest quote of the last decade or the most important quote of the last decade, perhaps like, Um, it's, and this is kind of what she, Kellyanne Conway was speaking to in that sense that like, well, she got much maligned for it. Um, but what she was saying is 107:50 that like, listen, it was kind of an Orwellian phrase coming from somebody in the government, but she was like, you have your set of facts, but these are facts that you've never considered that are also facts. Um, and if you present that fact without this fact, um, or 108:04 you present this version of a fact calculated by this group as opposed to this version of a fact calculated by that group. I mean, these things have always been true, but never have we... And by the way, like there was a time before mass media and before monoculture where 108:20 we were all getting media. Sometimes it was from partisan pamphlets and from word of mouth in the community. But we're now relying on news about the whole world. Right. 108:28 That wasn't that's not the normal human reality. There wasn't such a thing as like a global news. And when we have to make decisions like voting decisions, investment decisions, that type of thing. even like personal safety, personal health 108:42 decisions like COVID based on global news. It's very, very scary that we're getting it through so many different filters and that some people get it from one type of filter, other people from another type of filter. And then, you know, 108:56 there's some people who really get it from all the filters and make up their own decisions. I think that's the best way to go. And one thing that gives me hope about that is like we really have to get rid of algorithms or I mean, at the very least, 109:08 you have to have requirements for healthy algorithms on social media news feeds, meaning you can't be siloing people into information silos or you can't be channeling people in information silos. 109:19 There just has to be. I mean, it is just so fundamental to people's mental health and our Republican health, lowercase r. So I'm very pessimistic about it. I think it's abundantly obvious that that's what's needed. I think the 109:34 timelines all should go back to being literal timelines. Second by second, the posts appear as they were posted chronologically without any algorithmic filtering or direction that plays on the race to the bottom of the brainstem, our worst instincts, 109:50 that type of thing. And I think this would genuinely make the situation better. Then you're still, of course, choosing who to follow and that, but it's at least better than the situation now where the apps deliberately feed you content based on what is going to make you either 110:05 angry or happy or you know feel satisfied those extreme emotions that keep you scrolling so that's probably the number one thing i don't have a lot of optimism about it john but that's probably the number one thing that i worry about so i appreciate it so much thank 110:18 you for writing in thank you all for writing in hope you all have a wonderful wonderful weekend thanks also for all the nice notes it means a lot to me that you are getting a lot out of these conversations too so god bless and have a great weekend
Community discussion