0:04 All right, everyone, welcome to this week's happy hour, this week's post midterm edition of happy hour. This is what we do every Friday here on the after party podcast feed. 0:13 So thank you for being subscribed on Apple and Spotify. 0:15 And I should also mention, if you don't mind leaving us a review, it's really helpful. I never mentioned it. 0:21 You guys know I'm always self deprecating about how bad I am at plugging things. But if you get a chance to leave a review, that is actually really, really helpful. 0:28 I know it's really helpful on Apple. So Thanks so much, and thanks for all your great questions that you've sent in to emily at devilmaycaremedia.com this week. Still trying to work through these goofy glitches, and I found an email 0:40 that I missed back in mid-October that I want to make sure I get to, because I said I would. 0:44 So this is from Philip, who says, Finally saw. You can see everything. Obviously, I guess probably gentle spoilers ahead. 0:50 Billy looks terrible, and Elizabeth comes across as autistic at best, but did you get the sense that the movie was also critical of Amanda? Not seeing anybody else point this out, but her quote-unquote fiction comments and indifference toward Elizabeth come 1:01 across as callous and narcissistic. Sure, she shrewdly notes that Nathan is getting too attached to his subject, but I didn't get a good vibe from her. I think her unguarded nature really shines through. And that's before we consider 1:11 the Charlie Kirk comments. So, Philip, I think this is, looking at the analysis of the film, the biggest divide between people who watched it on the left and people who watched it on the right. And I don't mean Republicans and Democrats. I mean just sort of generally because 1:25 a lot of people I saw a lot of people also in like the tech world getting the same impression that you did from Amanda Seyfried in the movie and I'm kind of somewhere in between maybe some of you won't be surprised to hear that but on the one 1:39 hand I found her to be laudably authentic in the course of the film right like she's She signed up to basically do this reality TV show hunting down the truth about Billy and Elizabeth Holmes. On the other side, she really didn't like being called out on her sort 2:00 of facile BS about Charlie Kirk and politics in general. 2:05 But I actually really appreciated her getting in there and mixing it up with Billy to the point where you saw her raw emotion. And I don't think the point of the film was politics. I think the point of the film was about, I've said this here on the 2:17 show before, was about the trustworthiness of most of what goes through the kind of documentary and journalistic process in this age of information overload. And so I kind of respect her for being willing to put herself in the game. 2:37 On the other hand, yeah, of course. I mean, it showed... 2:41 it did reveal her own, I guess, yeah, facile understanding of some of these things or, uh, her kind of lack of introspection or humility when it came to what her own depiction of Elizabeth home, if that depiction was flawed and in any different way, or if it may 2:58 have had a negative effect on, uh, a woman with kids who were going to be separated from her, that sort of thing. She seemed like she hadn't totally thought through some of those consequences and had just said, well, that's her fault. Um, And I guess what Nathan Fielder 3:13 starts questioning, of course, is whether or not it was her fault. And then even if it is, does all of this make sense? So I don't think you're alone, Philip. 3:21 I saw that from a lot of different people. So you're definitely not alone. I just am personally conflicted about that, too, because I just thought it was important to... First of all, I think Elizabeth Holmes acted very poorly. I'm not talking 3:37 about in the film. I'm talking about in general. I did go back and read... as I was prepping our segments on this, I did go back and read a lot of the, actually the legal documents, the indictment and that sort of thing. And it just seems to be 3:50 unambiguously clear that she was engaging in fraudulent behavior, whether or not you want to say it meant illegally or it meant a legally fraudulent description. She was obviously misleading people. 4:04 The counterpoint to that is, well, a lot of these, a lot of these inventors mislead investors and, And investors should be kind of clear eyed about that so long as it's not crossing like legal boundaries. I think obviously a jury found she did cross legal boundaries and it's 4:19 pretty easy to understand why. So Elizabeth, I'm sorry. So Amanda Seyfried depicting her in the Hulu show, the way that she was depicted to me feels like fair game, entirely fair game. Like you're somebody who took all those 4:32 magazine profiles. You're somebody who took all that money. You're somebody who made these big promises about revolutionizing public health in the public square. So yes, if you're Amanda Seyfried and you're participating in that, you should do it in 4:47 a moral and honest way. But there's a moral and honest, very tough criticism of Elizabeth Holmes to be made. So I'd have to go back and watch the Hulu documentary myself. 4:58 I devoured it when it aired. But to get into some of the nuances, if I think there was unfairness in it. Uh, so anyway, those are my quick thoughts. 5:07 I have seen a lot of people conflicted. Um, Philip, like it sounds as though you are, and I don't think you're alone. I myself am, or maybe you don't sound conflicted. Maybe you sound like you really think she came across badly and she definitely did come across badly. Um, 5:20 I guess I'm just saying, I think part of that was maybe her signing up, knowing people would have different takeaways. 5:27 And I guess I, I have some respect for that. 5:30 It makes sense. Um, okay. Let's go to, Oh, yes. Okay, so this is somebody who wants to be anonymous and got a mailer in Ohio that said on Tuesday, November 3rd, I'm looking at a picture of it, this person sent in, 5:49 Ohio votes. Visit votingmatters.oh.org for voting info. And what's interesting is it looks like on the back of the postcard, it's addressing this person with... handwritten message that says, thank you for being a voter. Who you vote for is private, 6:09 but whether you vote as public record, please vote in the Tuesday, November 3rd election. And the person asks or says, oh yeah, asks, do you read this as an attempt at intimidation or has the Charlie Kirk assassination made me paranoid? 6:24 This is creepy as hell. Listen, I don't live in Ohio. 6:27 I didn't get any of this, but yeah, just addressing the anonymous person who wrote in here. I actually do think this is extremely creepy. Who you vote for is private, but whether you vote is public record. So you're sending that to somebody's home address. It's one way to get 6:43 voter turnout up. I doubt it's illegal. And it's written in a very polite tone. The final line is, please vote in the Tuesday, November 3rd election! Exclamation point. Yeah, this is creepy as hell. Whether you vote is public record. 7:00 If you're somebody who is doing that, targeting... areas where you know X percentage of voters are Dem or X percentage of voters are Republican, yeah, you're engaging in a little bit of a pressure campaign to get people to vote by, I guess, threatening to expose people for not 7:22 voting and to shame them for not voting. That's gross. 7:28 Whoever did this should absolutely be ashamed, whether they're Republican or Democrat, I don't know. But whoever did this absolutely should be ashamed because people have the right to not vote. 7:40 And for some people, that is a vote in and of itself. So to try and stigmatize people for not voting. 7:49 I think that's really, really gross. I think it's great to vote. It always makes me, you know, I was thinking this week when I went to vote, it almost like makes me well up. I get emotional voting and I've never, you know, even lived in any country other 8:00 than America. I mean, I can't imagine for people who have come here from Cuba or from the Soviet Union what it's like. I can't imagine. I would imagine myself being very emotional every time I voted, but I don't always vote because sometimes I don't want to vote, you know, 8:16 and that again, in and of itself, I hate times when I feel like I can't vote. But if you're in Ohio, say you're a conservative in Ohio and you don't want to vote for Amy Acton and you don't want to vote for Vivek, yeah, there are other elections, 8:32 of course, that you can be a part of. And there are probably some things that you can always vote on, but maybe somebody's tired of the process and they're checked out, or maybe somebody works a bunch of shifts and they don't have time that day and they don't believe in it. 8:43 Like there are all kinds of different reasons. well, you shouldn't shame and stigmatize people like that. So this is gross. Uh, thank you for sending it in. Uh, I don't know how widespread this was, but geez, uh, appreciate, appreciate that. Uh, 8:57 Daniel says, I love, is it Wisconsinites or cheese heads? 9:02 Love it. Uh, I guess just, uh, Wisconsinites. Um, oh yeah, this is the previous person writing it again to say, please give me anonymous. I remember getting that one. So no problem at all. Appreciate you showing that picture, crazy stuff. 9:19 Nick says, I've never understood the legitimate argument for making DC a state and not becoming part of Maryland. If the Democrats want the extra senators, what would be stopping the Republicans from breaking California into four or five states 9:29 or making the Twin Cities their own state so Minnesota would be red? How can they sell the idea that it isn't a blatantly partisan political move, just like removing the judicial filibuster? I always look forward to your shows. 9:39 Your last one with Bridget Phetasy was a lot of fun to listen to. Have you heard of Shoe on Head? 9:44 I think it should be another fun interview. Keep up the phenomenal work. I've been listening to you since the Federalist Radio Hour days when you weren't an interesting person with Inez. Yeah, that's right. That's a little joke back from, 9:55 I think it was Inez's podcast, High Noon. I loved that podcast. Loved Federalist. Radio Hour. And if you've been here with me since those days, man, do I appreciate it. 10:04 That was before a lot of people got into podcasting because I took it over from Ben Dominich, who had been doing it way before many people got into podcasting. 10:12 I want to say he's been doing that since 2014. 10:15 It was a radio show and a podcast way before anybody was doing that. And I think I started guest hosting for Ben around 2019, 2020. I may have even been earlier than that. But that was a real labor of love. So I appreciate that, Nick. And on D.C. statehood, unfortunately, 10:34 there is an okay substantive argument for D.C. statehood. And it's very simple. And it's on our stupid license plates. 10:41 It says no taxation without representation. I obviously disagree with that. 10:46 But it's a pretty... political argument if you want it to be, because the principle of no taxation without representation is a very good one. It's a very sound one. 10:56 It's a very patriotic and American one. And it resonates with a lot of people here in the federal city. 11:02 But why did I call it the federal city? Because that's my argument. It's a very simple counter argument, which is that this is the federal city. Having federal rule over the federal city, the seat of our government, actually comes with a Not all privileges. I mean, they come 11:18 out in the wash as a net, I think, but very clearly. But on the other hand, the seat of our government, where our leaders live and work and function, I think rightfully has federal rule. And if you are living in the District of Columbia, you are living in 11:39 the federal city. And so that's my very sort of simple statement. I mean, you could watch people debate that for a couple of hours, but I think it's unfortunately fairly easy for Democrats to make that argument about the 11:51 District of Columbia. And I think some Republicans and others get on board with that argument. Not many, because obviously, if you're Republicans, you're looking at adding more blue seats. 12:04 Almost certainly. I mean, looking at the election returns this week, just a blowout for our new DSA mayor, Janice Lewis George, the Republican candidates in the down ballot races, you know, between five and 10 percent, if that. So it's for Republicans, 12:20 not a not a political advantage. The moral question, I think, is unfortunately a more complicated debate, even though I totally disagree with their position on it. And it is, I suppose, kind of different. I mean, I know there are people who want to what is it, Idaho? They want to 12:35 secede from Idaho or Oregon. Is it Oregon into Idaho? 12:38 It might be Oregonians, Eastern Oregon, wanting to secede into Idaho. 12:44 Some of you will probably write in and correct me on that if I'm wrong. But it's so hard. It's such a difficult process that I don't think other folks would be able to replicate it on the precedent of adding D.C. Puerto Rico. Yeah, I think there are also 13:00 good arguments on both sides of that. I'd have to think more about it. My instinct is that I oppose it. 13:06 And I have thought about it in the past, but I'd have to refresh my own memory. I was once part of a pen and pad with the, what do we call the governor of Puerto Rico? It was Ricardo Rossello at the time, which ended up leaving. He ended 13:19 up leaving. I mean, yeah, the governor, right? The governor's mansion in San Juan is incredible. You feel like you've stepped into... I love San Juan. It's one of my favorite cities in the world. You step into... the old world, but you're in the Caribbean and a lot of San 13:36 Juan is like that, but the governor's mansion is the, uh, like epitome of it. It's just a very, very cool compound and building. Um, this is neither here nor there, but, uh, all that is to say those things. I hear some 13:51 Republicans say adding Puerto Rico isn't necessarily a gift to Democrats. 13:55 I'm very dubious and skeptical of that. Um, just given where Puerto Rican politics have gone recently, but anyway, I'd have to refresh my memory on that before publicly coming down on one side or the other. My instinct is that I've been against it. But D.C., like I said, D.C., 14:11 there's a pretty good argument that I disagree with, a substantive, I think, sufficiently apolitical one about making D.C. a state. 14:20 I disagree with it, but I think they'd be able to kind of get away with that argument if they wanted to do it. This is from Tom. Who says, I wanted to reach out regarding my novel, Project Continuum. Okay, this looks like a pitch. Looks like Tom has a 14:37 novel out on AI, tech stuff. So, very interesting. Bob says, Emily, my prediction is 240 house seats for Ds and 53 Senate seats for Ds. Bob, you nailed it. Wow. Bob says to me, it can all be explained by the following. 14:57 Trump assembled an amazing coalition of normie Republicans and working class Americans who either previously voted Democrat or never voted. 15:03 It was a brilliant insight that he stumbled across, probably without even thinking about it. In doing so, he promised two important things. One, to lower the cost of living for many essentials for those working class Americans. And two, 15:12 no foreign wars, particularly in the Middle East. He did not on the cost of living except for prescription drugs. 15:17 And he started a war that resulted in escalating gas and diesel prices. which have always been critical factors to Americans and leaves him left with only bad options going forward. 15:26 Perhaps his promises were foolish, but having made them required some effort to follow through. He blew a chance to reshape the Republican Party for years to come as the Republican Party of the Bushes had far less votes than needed to win a national election. The silver lining in 15:39 the tsunami to come. Bob, you are Bob Stradamus. You nailed this. Is that politics is cyclical and the Democrat Party writ large can be more insane than Republicans are. 15:49 The loonies in the D party, excluding Trump, Bob notes, and their hatred of Israel perhaps will allow Republicans to regroup around perhaps even a dark horse candidate in 2028. Wow, Bob, you may be the most prescient man in our listenership, 16:05 perhaps in all of America. That was a bold call and it was a good call. Our team at Breaking Points, I hate, hate, hate doing predictions. I'm like Mark Calperin on that because And I hate doing maps precisely for this reason. Because when I did my map, I kept 16:20 Texas red and South Carolina red. And Iowa red. And I actually probably would have kept Iowa red. But I said what agonized me was Texas and South Carolina. And my gut instinct on those was just Dems had a really, really, really good chance of pulling it off. But it just seemed... 16:41 that you would get enough Republicans to turn out in Texas and South Carolina. This is why I think actually I might've been wrong about Trump doing the rallies, ultimately being not as dumb of a strategy as it seemed to so many people, because even if you're talking about 16:54 senators' asses, you're also bringing awareness to the local community that a vote is happening. Not a lot of people check into politics constantly, and some check in a couple of days before an election. So What you're doing is 17:08 you're trying to squeeze every single Republican vote possible out of a place like Texas or Ohio. And so I did bet on Texas and South Carolina, certainly Mississippi. But it was, like I said, an agonizing decision because I was not confident about it. Because to me, the second 17:28 path we laid out here on the show, it sounds like Bob understood that was more likely than not. I was kind of torn between the two because, listen, we have had 10 years of Republicans overperforming polls in places like Maine. Oh, that's another one. I had Maine read 17:42 and I was not Maine and Iowa. I actually was not particularly conflicted about. And those were not that close. 17:49 So a huge miss. But that second path to me always felt very, very plausible. And I was surprised to see so many people dismissing it. And doing so in a very arrogant way. Like, that's the one thing. If you make predictions, I would just say have some humility 18:06 about it, unless you're extremely confident. And if you're extremely confident for, you know, substantive reasons and you've really reckoned with everything, I get it. But you just never know. 18:16 And so, Bob, I think you just laid out exactly why I thought path two was plausible. And, you know, personally had some humility about my predictions because I The fact that pollsters were overweighting, I mean, they underestimated Democrats 18:32 at the end of the day. It was a completely different thing than in the past. They had overestimated Democrats. 18:37 It was the opposite this time. And that was precisely because those people that are hard to poll in the Trump era, rural Trump voters who can swing Republican in the Trump era, they swung Dem or they didn't show up. 18:52 And so they were overweighted in the polls. And it's precisely because of the reasons Bob lays out here. Cost of living went up and we're now in a war. 19:02 So there I know we're going to get into this in a lot of emails. They're all kind of analyses flying around right now with different exit polls and, you know, exit polls or exit polls. But I would say even if, you know, you're finding most Americans or I'm sorry, even 19:16 if you're finding most Republicans approved of the war, you can't afford to lose 20 percent. Generally, in close elections, no. 19:26 If it's an animating issue, if it's the type of issue that gets someone out to vote, it's just like Democrats on the border in 2024. If it's an issue that's important enough to people that they're actually going to vote on it, you can't lose 20% of your own party. 19:41 That's how you lose red states. So even people looking at these polls and saying, well, only 20% of Republicans were against the Iran war, or only 35% of Republicans were against the Iran war. It's like, and? You can't lose that. And you certainly can't lose a swing of 19:56 13 points with independent voters. That's what electoral politics is. 20:03 And that's what happens in when an issue is important enough that people vote on it. And clearly cost of living and war are two issues that are important enough to people they vote on. But particularly cost of living. 20:16 And also people are throwing around exit polls that show, you know, cost of living was high, but the Iran war was low. It's like for a lot of people, cost of living is tied to the Iran war in terms of how they're voting. And obviously cost of living 20:33 is objectively tied to the Iran war. I mean, I've gone through these charts ad nauseum. You don't have to be a genius to zoom out for the last five years, for the last 10 years, because gas prices were high in the economic adjustment period after the pandemic, still during 20:52 the pandemic, depending on where you were. Yeah, of course gas prices were high under Biden. I've heard that a lot from people, too. Of course they were higher under Biden. 20:59 But people baked in the pandemic unusualness to that. And what people didn't want to see is prices going down like they were during the first year of the Trump administration and then shooting back up, which they did immediately after the war was launched. And we now know from 21:17 reporting that the Trump administration was underestimating the Iranians' willingness to close down that Strait of Hormuz. And that was really the reality. that cost so much more damage than I think they were prepared for. And listen, they know it. Internally, 21:38 they know it. Yeah, I think tariffs played a part. Yeah, I think not delivering on the SAVE Act played a part. Yeah, I think some Hispanics were swayed and some independents probably were swayed by the memification of Trump's immigration policy and 21:54 some of what they perceived as genuine cruelties. I mean, you remember those AI videos that the Trump administration posted of, like, Latino women weeping? That's just over-reading the mandate of 2024. Like, most Americans don't relish that. Some people on the right 22:13 relish that because it feels like a pressure relief valve from the era of political correctness. But most Americans don't. 22:19 So I think that stuff was important, too. I think in tariff-exposed states, that was important to people as well. 22:27 But yeah, I mean... I think you're right, Bob. And I know you were right on your prediction being closer than most people's were. So very interesting. Dunn says, Crystal Ball is showing herself today over Haley Stevens. You were too good for her. It feels like three against you. 22:43 Chin up, young lady. Oh, I don't know what this is about, but I would say I'm pretty... I was loving the Haley Stevens news cycle. Loving the Haley Stevens news cycle. I know we talked about this a bit with Ryan Gerduski, but... Boy. She is... an amusing character 22:59 to me as well. That woman, I think probably actually cost Mike Rogers some votes at the end of the cycle. 23:09 Why do I think that? I mean, I think it wouldn't have been a particularly close election either way. That's definitely one I had going blue, but why? I mean, he had to spend the last several days, the news cycle in Michigan for the last like 72 hours of 23:24 the campaign was about what Haley Stevens, That took oxygen away from Mike Rogers being able to talk about affordability, being able to talk about education. That's what he really wanted to talk about in the last days of the campaign. 23:38 He ended up talking about Haley Stevens and foreign policy. 23:42 And that let Abdul El-Sayed swoop in and say, yeah, I don't really think about Haley Stevens. I'm thinking about money or pocket, Medicare for all, money out of politics. 23:52 So I think Haley Stevens actually genuinely cost Mike Rogers votes, probably not a determinative amount of votes, probably not even that many votes. Uh, but I think she did her own cause and a major disservice, you know, her first line in her video, we covered this on the show, 24:06 her first line in her video, she put out announcing her flip to Rogers was that she got disinvited to an event by Abdul El-Sayed. I was contemplating doing the accent here, by the way, I think I did it on Megan's show once, but I have some, uh, I 24:22 have some ability to do this without it being cultural appropriation. 24:26 And the Hayley Stevens version of the Midwest accent, the Great Lakes accent, is farcical. She doesn't have it in old videos. It's like a new thing that she goes in and out of. So I don't know. I don't know, Dunn, what this is related to. But I'm also no particular 24:44 fan of Hayley Stevens. I'll say that. Hank says you should get Rod Dreher back on again. I'm sure he'd have some interesting opinions on the situation in Poland. I believe he wrote about that in his newsletter a bit. 24:55 I'm always down to have Rod on. He's got a new book with a thesis I've always found very compelling centered on, I think I've talked about it here before, whether or not we're in a Weimar America period. Rod argues yes. He argues that we're perhaps an economic catastrophe away, 25:09 like a depression-style catastrophe away from full Weimar chaos. So, Anyway, I'm sure we'll have him back on when that book comes out. I was just emailing him the other day. 25:21 This is from George who says, Dear Emily, I wanted to ask about the backlash Sydney Sweeney received over the past year or so. The criticism that followed her after the American Eagle and sports betting ad surprised me because a few years ago she appeared in a Rolling Stones 25:33 music video dancing provocatively in the back of a Mercedes convertible while the band's new single played in the background. 25:41 It seems strange that her ads for jeans and sports betting received so much criticism while the music video didn't receive any. Is the music industry the last place where beautiful women can feature in risque advertisements without much criticism? 25:51 Or maybe the Rolling Stones are such a cultural institution that they can get away with a music video like that while others can't. Or finally, maybe the criticism of Sydney Sweeney is so tied up in the perception that 25:59 she's a quiet conservative that it's all somewhat arbitrary and capricious. 26:03 Thank you, George. George, this is a great question. I think there's a lot going on here. Let me check the year on this music video. Because first, I think some of it is that Sydney Sweeney got a lot more. Okay, so it's from three years ago. I think she's gotten 26:17 a lot more famous in the last couple years in particular, and I think that's been... She clearly has a great publicity team, which I assume Scooter Braun has something to do with now that they're dating. I think they've been dating for like a year. But mostly what I think 26:34 it is was after the American Eagle ad, Sydney Sweeney got super polarizing because that was, what, 2024? It was in that period where... if you did anything so much as breathe in the direction of the political right, it was a feeding frenzy on social media and in elite media. 26:59 And so I think after that, she became a very polarizing figure because then people started digging into her background. 27:07 If I have my timeline correct, then people started digging into her background and doing all those sorts of things. 27:13 So I imagine that had a lot to do with it. 27:16 That's when I really remember, because I covered it at the time, her being sort of thrust into the political discourse. 27:23 And boy, I got, I don't get ratioed a lot because I'm sort of circumspect about social media and I find the whole thing unpleasant. But I will say I got ratioed so hard for criticizing Sidney Sweeney, which I'm not one to do, because I think there's something about 27:39 Sidney Sweeney that is First of all, I think, yeah, a lot of it is polarized by the left against her for being kind of conservative-coded, whether or not it's fair. 27:49 And then, on the other hand, the Novig ad that she cut, I called it softcore pornography. I said it was softcore pornography in the service of introducing more men to an addictive product. And I was like, female athletes 28:06 are criticizing her for... Like, the reason female athletes stirred up a controversy over that ad was literally just out of jealousy and a burning desire to politicize absolutely everything for the sake of virtue signaling. That's why they did it. 28:27 Which is ridiculous. And I said, if anything, if we're gonna freak out about this ad, maybe we should be mad about the fact that she is, yes, using softcore pornography to introduce more people to addictive online gambling services. 28:40 And boy, were the knives out for me. But I stand by that point. I think it's a good one. 28:46 But I do agree, George. I think so much of this is just because she's become so politicized and without, I think, really great justification. This is from Casey. How do you think Republicans in Congress and the Senate will eventually turn on Trump? By that, I mean start to 29:03 throw him under the bus politically to improve their own chances of reelection in the future. I have the same question for J.D. Vance when he runs. I'm sure he will be asked if he will reinvestigate Trump in the Epstein files. Do you think he would promise to do that? 29:14 I imagine after these 2026 elections, Trump is just a ball and chain with his low popularity. I hope your weekend is fun. So this is also prescient because this is from November 2nd. The date here, yeah, November 2nd. 29:25 I just checked. So Casey, shout out to you for also kind of seeing what was coming. I think this gives Republicans in states that saw blue wave wipeouts. So if you're the other senator from Kansas or South Carolina, Tim Scott, or you saw or Ohio, frankly, Bernie Moreno, 29:49 or you saw a really close margin. I mean, Florida saw close margins. Florida or Mississippi. Close margin. Texas, Ted Cruz, but especially if you're already a sort of moderate Republican Senator, I think this does give you some permission to break 30:14 with Trump when you actually want to break with Trump. 30:16 Cause a lot of times these guys have just been sucking it up. They don't say something when the media asks him or ask them about something he did the ballroom, for example, whatever. the Kennedy Center. You know, you've got 30:28 the reporters running around the halls of Congress, putting mics in your faces. They might want to say something about those in the past. They might have wanted to, and they just kept their mouth shut or said, don't you have something better to ask about? That sort of thing. 30:39 I think now this gives them more permission to break with Trump on some of those issues because it appears the MAGA coalition has really been shattered. When you see rural voters, male voters, independent voters, if you're in Texas, 30:53 Hispanic voters, Hispanic male voters, that Trump was able to bring into the Republican Party in 2024, swinging Dem. And for somebody like James Tallarico, who has a very woke one coded past. Yeah, I mean, if there's an impeachment vote, 31:07 if there is corruption that's a lot worse than the Ukraine call that comes up, I think this does give them some permission, if not actually feel like they have a mandate. Some of them might feel like they have a mandate to go against Trump. From their state, if 31:25 their state was South Carolina, where Annie Andrews beats Darlene Graham. 31:31 If there are more war power votes, more Epstein votes, I think it does. You know, I don't know. I don't think we have the final number of Senate Dems, but. 31:41 It's going to be somewhere in the 50s. So what you have less than 10 or around 10 Republicans that need to break with Trump and the Republican conference. If you're a kind of hardcore rock rib conservative, you don't 31:53 have a high opinion of them being real base receptive stalwarts. 31:59 And I think it really does, Casey, give them and candidates who run in 2028 as well, give them some permission. 32:07 Ron DeSantis comes out from the most MAGA state in the country election day. distances himself from the administration. He wasn't naming Trump before this all happened overtly. We'll see what he does in the days and weeks ahead. If he reads that it's going to be good for him 32:24 to take on Trump directly or Don Jr. or something like that, I don't know. But that was very, I think that was actually very telling because that's the most mega state in the country. The election turned out to be shockingly close. He was probably aware of the internals 32:38 showing that it was going to be shockingly close. And also he was probably on the ground aware of what people were saying. So with JD, I wrote about this for Unheard in a piece that went up Wednesday or Thursday. 32:53 For JD, you gotta find a version of right-wing populism that is not tainted with MAGA grifter corruption and is also not tainted by hawkish foreign policy intervention. He was always going to be able to distance himself from that 33:13 because everybody kind of knew, Megan's been pointing this out, that he was against the war. He's pretty publicly been clear that he didn't agree with the president's decision. And yet what he did in his missive on Axe after the wipeout was say he cited Trump saying that, yeah, 33:33 people were upset about the war. And Trump himself has given mixed messages on this in the last... several days about whether it was the war or people agree with him on the war. He's kind of said different things that different people are using. But the vice president cited 33:46 him saying, yeah, I guess people were upset about the war. 33:48 So he clearly still didn't totally blow off the president. 33:55 I think he very strategically and intentionally cited the president there. 34:00 So I don't know that it's possible, but it depends on what happens in the next couple of years. My gut instinct is that it's going to be very difficult for him Because of that, especially that CBS soundbite where he's asked directly by Tony DeCoppo about corruption. And he 34:16 says he hasn't seen any of it like that. We're looking at two years now laser focused on genuine. Corruption investigations, some of them will be BS, I'm sure, but a lot of them are serious. A lot of them are serious. 34:31 The Trump meme coin, Jared Kushner. For a long time, people were tuning some of the stuff out. I'm just personally very interested in corruption stories like the drain the swamp stuff. I'm like a drain the swamp conservative. I grew up in the Tea Party era. This stuff has 34:46 always mattered a lot to me. And so I've been paying very close attention to the Jared Kushner things. He comes out of the first administration, starts affinity partners, and immediately gets a massive $ 2 billion investment from Mohammed bin Salman. 35:01 And then Trump 2.0 starts. And guess who's negotiating our politics in the Middle East? It's Jared Kushner, whose fund is propped up by billions of dollars from Mohammed bin Zalman. 35:16 And he's got MBZ involved in the mix and everything like that too. I believe the Trump organization is building in Abu Dhabi. That doesn't even get into the way the meme coins were structured and the administration has been protecting crypto. There's just going to be so much for 35:35 Democrats to investigate. That is not BS. And that means it probably will be a drumbeat in the 2028 primary. 35:45 And I just really, unless J.D. Vance like resigns and protest over that, which I don't know would also be good for him politically, because then do you look like you're kind of wishy-washy? I don't know. But I think anybody who's in this administration is going to have a 35:58 hard time telling people they really didn't see any of it, especially because by the time that rolls around, a lot of this is, my prediction, going to be front and center. 36:08 So Very, very good point, Casey. Kyle says, I don't mean to be writing every week, but this seems like a safe space for an observation I haven't heard anywhere else yet. Writing this on Monday, hopefully by Friday when your show comes out, someone else makes this joke. A 36:20 white woman gets disinvited from an event, then announces she no longer supports the guy of color she'd previously been so enthusiastic about. But enough about Haley Stevens of Michigan and Jane Doe of the Cornell 7. Well, Kyle, let 36:30 me stop you right there. Megyn Kelly made that observation on, I think it was Monday's show. Kyle says the parallel struck me as funny. Did her convictions change or just her invitation status? Ambiguously stated because it could apply to 36:43 either of the two individuals. I'm sure the answer has to do with money, either from specific donors or winning it in a civil case. And Kyle says I'm not making light of sexual assault or anti-Semitism, but rather how these two stories have an obvious parallel in our media 36:55 the past few weeks. Yeah, I mean, Haley Stevens made it. 36:59 I don't know what's in her heart. I don't think she ever, ever wanted to support Abdul El-Sayed. I think she supported Abdul El-Sayed because she wanted to have a political future. And then I think when she got disinvited, she kind of, this is my like psychological analysis of 37:14 Haley Stevens, who I don't know as a person and I'm not a medical professional, but as a woman, my guess would be the disinvitation made her feel bad. It made her feel left out. It made her feel unwanted. 37:30 And that, of course, for any human being, makes it hard sometimes to engage in rational decisions because it's so powerful. 37:41 I mean, is there anything more powerful as a human emotion than feeling othered? It is enormously powerful. You don't want to feel like that. Of course, also, her fiancé was disagreeing with her going on Fox & Friends, and I'm sure he pressured her a lot, and she wants 37:56 to feel included in that sense, too. So... There's a lot going on with Haley Stevens and with Jane Doe. 38:03 I've said this before. I think she did feel legitimately traumatized and violated. And I don't think without reason. Women do feel traumatized and violated when they're in those types of situations often, unless you're one of the few women 38:16 who genuinely enjoys that. Because you realize after you're done, you didn't really want that. And it did feel kind of objectifying. And the men thought it was kind of okay to objectify her because they thought she was down 38:27 with treating sex as just another mechanical action that two objects engage in. And that's really hard for women. And so I think on top of that, the disinvitation does seem to have been the catalyst. We don't have all of the Title IX documents unredacted. We certainly don't have 38:50 all the text messages that were happening, flying back and forth at that time, nor do we have recordings of the private conversations she was having with friends, but we have reported details about what they were like. And it does seem like that was the genuine turning point. So 39:05 there's broadly something very powerful about what that can do to us. This is from Hank, who says, Tucker says we may be within days of launching a nuclear strike in Iran, supposedly under pressure from Netanyahu. Does he know something no one else knows? Is this why the EU 39:21 is telling Europeans to, quote unquote, be ready? All the Europeans that got hit with cyber attacks in the freezer system suggest something is brewing. You know, Hank, I really wanted to do a segment this week on the prepping 39:33 that's kind of quietly happening. The Financial Times had an article about how the prepping was striking the UK and the freezer situation, the midterms, the reports about uncertainty over our policy toward Iran. I think all of this was 39:48 going into that. There were weird stoplight outages here in D.C. 39:52 on Monday. I haven't heard any more about those since, and I doubt there's anything public about what was going on there yet. But people are very nervous, and not without some reason. We are literally in a kinetic war. 40:04 It has had a relatively low casualty rate, but I was telling someone this week, 21 deaths, that might even be an undercount, but 21 people dying, that means like 21 communities around the country had their local news coverage focused on that. It may not have been your community, 40:25 but maybe it was some of your communities. That does stick with people. We are in a hot war. We're in a hot war. We're in this weird AI boom. 40:37 That makes people really nervous. It makes people really nervous. 40:40 I think I actually just got hacked today, by the way. 40:42 I've been dealing with that all day. So Those types of things feel like they're happening more and more, the Black October cyber attacks, and it does seem to culminate. 40:51 I don't know about the Tucker report. I've heard really vigorous pushback on it. I would never discount the possibility that he knows something a lot of other people don't know just because he has very, very high-level sources, believe 41:04 it or not, in the administration that he's been extremely critical of. There are people who just still disagree with the administration but think it's their patriotic duty to serve the president, and uh, yeah, I'm sure some of them 41:17 still talk to Tucker. And so I would never discount the possibility that he knows something we don't. But of course, um, I, I don't personally have any knowledge about what was potentially happening, what could still potentially happen, but it's such an unpredictable 41:32 situation that I also don't rule a lot out. Uh, okay. 41:36 This is from Chrissy who says, or Christine who says, Really enjoyed your answer to the email you read on last week's happy hour. It was basically about being disillusioned with both parties, but still being able to call yourself conservative. 41:47 I feel like you really hit the nail on the head with that response. I have felt politically homeless for quite some time, at least for the last year. I finally made the decision to change my voter registration from Republican to independent. I will never register as a Democrat, 41:58 but I've become so disgruntled with both sides that I just didn't know where to go. That's why I've been referring to myself as politically homeless. I really did appreciate your answer because it made me feel seen for sure. 42:07 I definitely have not changed on my conservative views at all, but I'm also in no way MAGA or a neocon. Anyway, I just wanted to thank you for that thoughtful response and for the email that the individual sent in to you. Yeah, I forget which one of your emails that was, but 42:18 it was a good one. I remember this. And thank you, Christine, for your note. I think a lot of people, especially maybe even after the midterms, are looking for how to describe themselves to others and even how to define themselves to themselves. And I think it's really okay to be 42:38 a conservative that can't stand the Republican Party. It's really okay to be an independent that can't stand the Republican Party or the Democrat Party. The political, and I remember we were talking about this last week, my answer was 42:50 basically that I believe there's an inherently corrupting quality to our two-party system. The way that these parties are organized here in Washington, D.C., the way that lobbying pressures both of those parties structurally, I just don't think it's really 43:07 possible for either of those two major parties to be meaningfully free from serious corruption. And because of that, it's weird also. I don't know if you all experience this just on an interpersonal level, but some of you might be surprised or some of you might not be surprised 43:25 by the amount of people who doubt that I'm conservative because I criticize the Trump administration, often from the right, by the way. on corruption, something that I've gotten a lot, or on politically bad strategy, I don't like to punch right. 43:44 I do not get off on it like a lot of people do. I actually try really hard to spend my time filling gaps that other people are not filling. 43:53 And so it doesn't mean that I think the mainstream media, quote unquote, is wrong to look into Jared Kushner. I think that's great. It doesn't mean that I think the, quote unquote, mainstream media is wrong to run down a tip that Trump is like an agent of Russia. Like 44:07 any journalist would, would chase that story down, but no, I'm not going to like spend my time amplifying like every single, um, criticism that's being made in spades elsewhere. 44:21 You know, I'm, I'm happy to mention it, but I do like to spend my time building arguments that aren't getting built because my time is actually finite. And a lot of people in the space have finite time. Like, you know, we only have like an hour on the show. 44:32 um that's one of the things i like about happy hour by the way because you just go back and forth on all these things for as long as we want and it's crazy um to i think for a conservative to spend more time amplifying rather than building new 44:52 arguments that are scarce um And so if you have a different perspective, like that's one of the reasons that I do this. I feel like I have a different perspective from a lot of the people who came out of elite journalism schools or Ivy League institutions or hardly 45:04 ever get out of D.C. and New York or try to compensate for never getting out of D.C. and New York. 45:08 And so, you know, it's just I'm sure some of you experience this interpersonally as well. It's like you criticize Trump or maybe you criticize the Democrats and all of your Republican friends or maybe some of your Democratic friends 45:18 are like, oh, so I guess you're with Trump or, oh, I guess you're with the D.S.A. It's just really frustrating. 45:24 And I think it's downstream of social media conditioning us toward the knee-jerk extreme reaction. And it's really changed the way I think we think as political animals and as human beings. Even if you're not on social media, I 45:40 really believe it has reprogrammed our political discourse overall. Because so much of our political discourse is downstream of X. Seriously. 45:51 And now a lot of it's downstream of YouTube. and TikTok. 45:55 And those algorithms prize extreme reactions. And they prize reactions. 46:00 Sometimes you actually don't even need to react. And so I think it has reshaped our political discourse and reprogrammed us. 46:06 And Christine, if it makes you feel any better, I do feel like that's part of what's happening here. And the more that you ask questions and engage with others, the more they can maybe see, oh, this person is still very conservative. We aren't talking a lot about gun 46:24 control these days. Like it hasn't been a major subject in the news, but same thing with abortion after Dobbs is kind of faded, but as conservative as it gets on guns and abortion and those sorts of things. Um, and I'm sure many of you are as well. And 46:39 it's just, yeah, the, the whole label discourse has become very exhausting. Uh, this is from Ryan who says, who was your favorite Brewers player this season? Do you feel that, uh, Jacob Mizorowski will win the Cy Young award? I think he will win the Cy Young Award and I got 46:55 to go with Sal. Sal is on a generational run. 46:57 His social media has been incredible. His parade appearance, incredible. So, I mean, they've all expressed like incredible gratitude and affection for the city of Milwaukee and Brewers fans, which I just love that have been front and center throughout the 47:11 World Series because it's an amazing city with amazing fans. 47:14 And I was talking to my dad about this. We're like, the Packers have been such a successful franchise that even though they're a small market team, they really are beloved by a lot of people in the country and they get a lot of love from broadcasters, that sort of thing. 47:27 But the Brewers haven't been as successful of a franchise overall. 47:32 And so I think people are discovering that Brewers fans are awesome and really serious and baseball culture in Milwaukee is really awesome and really serious or really robust. And I've just absolutely loved that. And I feel like Sal has been at the front of it. And man, what 47:47 a performance too. So great question, Ryan. Craig says, thank you for your response to the podcast. It's always insightful to hear how people feel about the debt. The general consensus I get is either, like you said, a tax 47:57 hike or massive cuts, both of which will be heavily unpopular. 47:59 So instead, Congress does what they do best, spend more. 48:02 It's disheartening that we must balance our budgets individually or face consequences, but not for them. Oh, well. Craig says, the midterms just happened, as I'm sure most people are wondering. 48:12 How do you feel about the upcoming makeup of Congress? 48:14 Will anything get done legislatively? Impeachments, hearings, etc.? Also, I'm not sure if you have any listeners from South Carolina. 48:19 If you don't, you have at least one. Well, thanks, Craig. 48:22 And wow, what a race in South Carolina. I had some callers into the wrap-up show on Sirius from South Carolina. 48:28 And if I remember it correctly, at least one of them was very, very disillusioned, like going back months. about Darlene Graham. And I think I got more than one call like that over the course of the last several months in South Carolina. So people on the ground in 48:43 South Carolina may have sensed the earthquake. In fact, I know they did, based on my own knowledge. I'll leave it at that. They sensed something really... And, you know, you don't even need inside knowledge. They started moving a 48:55 bunch of money to South Carolina, which you would never, ever do unless you were desperately concerned. So the writing was on the wall. Yeah, I... Again, I'm just not that panicked about the next two years. I have to take a look at the 2026, I'm sorry, the 2028 49:14 Senate map. I think they're going to, Dems are really going to be bogged down in investigation. I think some of them, like Abdul El-Sayed was on Morning Joe Thursday talking about how he wants to work with the president on, I think it was ending aid to Israel. He said 49:31 he'd be happy to work with the president on that. 49:33 I don't know. But I think, I mentioned that just to bring up, I do think some Dems from states like Michigan are going to recognize. They might be able to put, like Trump even signaled this. He said, congrats to them. They did a great job and I'll work 49:45 with them. I think they might be willing to put some bills together on potentially things like antitrust, AI. I don't know if you can convince the president on AI. 49:56 It's an open question, but maybe they can put some stuff together that gets enough Republicans involved. Maybe gets a lot of Republicans. So it's actually possible that the only stuff they can do is bipartisan in a sort of populist sense. And you all know where I fall on 50:11 most of those issues. So it might there might be some good to come out of it. And the Green New Deal, I don't think that's the type of thing they are going to be able to do any like super crazy stuff. I mean, the Supreme Court does concern me, 50:25 of course. So there's that. That's one thing to weigh really heavily if, God forbid, something were to happen over there. 50:32 That's something to weigh very heavily as well. But I don't know how much they're actually going to be able to do that, you know, a super left and maybe Republicans are able to turn things around in 2028, just like Democrats did after 2024. I mean, there was real 50:48 fear and Republicans gloated, not without reason, about having just ushered in a generational coalition. And Democrats were panicked and disillusioned and demoralized about it. But what we're seeing right now, some people have pointed this out accurately, is a lot 51:04 of fluidity. Like the American people are up for grabs because they're sick of both parties and they're feeling really squeezed. Especially, you know, Ted Cruz. I couldn't believe I read this from Ted Cruz. He talked about the K-shaped economy in 51:18 his reflection post on X about what happened in the midterms. Yeah, people are feeling squeezed. People are feeling really squeezed. And by the way, I meant to look up if he weighed in on the burrito discourse. But if we're now 51:30 talking about the K-shaped economy and we were saying the whole burrito thing was fake, oh my goodness. But I'm glad if people are recognizing that's a real thing. So I'm not super panicked. I do think the American people 51:42 right now are willing... If you look at polling on socialism, yes, young people are very favorable to it. But for the next two years, I'm not particularly... panicked or paranoid about what could come out of congress again i have to take a look at that 2028 senate map to see 51:59 what could happen but i also do just really think the american people are up for grabs their votes are up for grabs bob says right on emily never oh the subject line here is mark levin i never have seen you so animated on any issue you are of 52:11 course correct i really do wonder how trump himself receives this rebuke re the war and what he actually does that is the trillion dollar question right now what does he do on the war going forward and let me tell you people i've talked to here in dc do 52:29 not know because it comes down to one man who even before the war was launched was getting a lot of counsel in both directions obviously netanyahu lindsey graham mark teason jack keen there's a wall street journal story talking 52:42 about how they were strategically calling up trump um and then kind of comparing notes um that is going to still happen On the other hand, what we know from John Swan and Maggie Haberman's reporting in Regime Change is that not even Marco Rubio wanted to do this war. 52:59 He was getting counsel from people who just didn't think the intelligence suggesting the regime would be overthrown was that good. 53:07 Or saying, yeah, the intelligence was good, suggesting that would happen. Bob, I know you know all this, but just to say, it's completely unpredictable because he is... someone who makes a lot of decisions on, on whims and gut instinct and 53:29 pragmatism as he sees it. And that makes it really difficult, really, really difficult. And yeah, I was really frustrated about Mark, Mark Levin, because man, just a dose of humility, like Will Chamberlain, who I've known for a long time, who 53:43 was very supportive of this war has been talking to Batya and Blake and Andrew over in the Charlie Kirk show, really honestly and genuinely saying he got it wrong. And I'm not expecting Mark Levin to do that. I'm certainly not expecting Mark Thiessen to do that. But to turn 54:01 around and lash out at other people, to turn your fire on the quote-unquote podcasters, both Ben Shapiro and Candace Owens' audiences fell in half. Over the course of a recent time period, the New York Times did an analysis of this. They were both tied at like, I think 54:19 it was 4 million weeklies. Those are still really big numbers, but a lot of people disengaged. And let me tell you, a lot of people didn't need podcasters to make them upset about gas being for something a gallon. I mean, blame Trump. If you support the war, blame Trump for 54:36 his messaging on the war. I think it's fine to support the war. I disagree with it really strongly. But the president would say we already won the war. Then he would say, oh, no, we have to maybe we're going to do this. Maybe we're going to wipe out 54:48 a civilization. So blame the president for not convincing people to swallow $ 4. 15 gas on average and the inflation that comes with gas prices being high. But I mean, the next day to immediately or even that night to immediately 55:06 turn around and keep calling people the woke right or keep calling them anti-Semites is We now have data that shows most Jewish voters voted Dem in this election, as they always do. I was fired up in that segment, but I think I also said I just feel badly 55:26 for people whose anger is blinding them. And a lot of it is anger at J.D. Vance, but whose anger and paranoia is blinding them to their own flaws as political analysts. The moral question aside, just even as political analysts, I played that clip of Levin and Ben Shapiro saying 55:47 they didn't think the war would be an issue when people voted. Well, if people are saying cost of living is an issue, and it takes them on average 415 to fill up their tank of gas, and that changed, everybody knows, immediately after the war was launched, yeah. That's 56:07 just bad political prognostication. And Just the posture of arrogance afterwards was deeply frustrating, but now I'm honestly just sad about it. Because Trump woke a lot of folks on the right up to their own bubbles in the Washington 56:25 media think tank conservative movement establishment. Which, by the way, I've been a part of. And that's a real thing. 56:35 And Trump actually woke a lot of people up to that, and they were grateful for it. People came out and said, yeah, he showed us what was out there. What people were interested in. That people were feeling like they hadn't gotten 56:49 enough augmenting support after WTO and NATO. And that some of those decisions had come at their expense. People had gotten rich off of that. And that these deals were bad for the country. He understood that people were mad 57:03 about Iraq and Afghanistan. And demoralized. It really hurts my heart to see people leaning even further into this posture of anger and arrogance when it just seems so clear they were flat out wrong. And that's okay. Everyone went through this over the last 10 years. So it just 57:36 feels like people are slipping into old habits and lashing out at anybody who's saying, maybe consider this or that. 57:43 So anyway, and, and by the way, people who are not just saying maybe consider this or that, some of those people are really angry and animated and like shouting at the neocons right now. And it's not all my style. 57:56 Of course you all know that. But at the same time, it's like, if anyone's justified in their righteous indignation at this moment, it would be those people who have been smeared and slandered for raising the non-bigoted, rational objections to 58:12 what's been happening over the course of the last year, after they stuck their necks out for the president, some of those folks. So anyway, yeah, thank you, Bob. Dean says, first off, thank you for what you do. You've done 58:22 the impossible and equaled Megan as this listener's personal favorite journalist. 58:26 I'd like to provide my take on why exactly Megan failed so spectacularly last night. Pundits across the country are pointing to such specific policies as tariffs and the Iran war as reasons for Megan's defeat. While these are important, 58:36 the root cause, I believe, is something far deeper, more fundamental than any policy. MAGA failed and was always going to fail because Donald Trump, as a man, lacks the capacity to separate his accomplishments from himself. When George Washington 58:46 refused to become king and resigned from command at the close of the Revolutionary War, he did so not only because he believed in Republican government or because he wished to set the precedent of a leader peacefully resuming private 58:56 life instead of clinging to power. These were important reasons, but there was another reason as well. Washington understood a fundamental truth of human nature. When a revolution becomes too closely intertwined for too long with the personality of one man, 59:06 the ideas of that revolution are one day apt to fall with him. That's right. really really well said Dean goes on to say this is why the MAGA revolution ultimately failed it is the paramount centrality of ego which grounds every error Trump was both MAGA's progenitor and its 59:20 slayer for it was only ever about him Dean I've been thinking a lot about this as well I think it's probably true I mean it's easier to say now of course that Trump would always end, and we don't know how Trump ends, of course, as a politician, but 59:37 it does feel like we've reached the point of the obvious, which is that because Trump is himself such a singularly capricious, pragmatic political animal, he would always be his own downfall. 59:53 The way that I've been thinking about it is that MAGA was a sugar high. where you're running around on pixie sticks, your parents are trying to get you to calm down, but you have super strength and you're beating your parents, you're pushing them off. You know, this little 60:09 five-year-old is just going crazy on the pixie sticks. Sugar crash comes and you're out like a light. And I kind of feel like he was a sugar high for the Republican Party. Let me put it that way. Because he just had such strength. over the people trying to 60:29 rein him in, because he was just resistant to everything that they threw at him, that he got hubristic, or his hubris was never checked. And at a certain point, this is why I actually am comfortable pointing to the 60:45 Iran war, that to me felt like post-Venezuela hubris. Post-Venezuela hubris. 60:53 He made that decision And I think he's even alluded to it before. At the reflecting pool, the day before the midterms, he was saying, you know, we won the Venezuela war in one day. It's like, I think there's some real truth to the fact that he felt overconfident 61:06 about that and made the decision, hoping that he was kind of the generational. He'd been getting intelligence that they were on the cusp, their regime was on the cusp of falling. And so he thought, I can do this. 61:19 And so I think of them as sort of part and parcel, like sort of the same type of thing. 61:23 But that's a very interesting thought, Dean, about revolution centered around one person, the trajectory of them. This is from James, who says midterms of the canary in the coal mine that Trump and MAGA are done. Republicans actually read the 61:36 electorate properly for once. And before the Dems can get sworn in, they impeach Big Dean, remove him from office in an effort to win back some goodwill from the public. 61:43 This would also give J.D. a few years to try and get it out of the ditch. This is all insane, but I live in Texas and have lived here my whole life. What happened yesterday is the most insane thing ever. 61:51 arguably more insane than my preceding theory. I need your wisdom to tell me this is grounded reality or I ate too many lead-based paint chips as a child. You're awesome. 62:00 Keep doing what you do. Yeah, thanks, James. No, I think this is generally correct. The way I've been thinking about it is that, you know, Trump still will retain sway over probably about 20% of Republican voters. Before the election, I would have said it was around 33%. A third, 62:23 if that sounds oddly specific. But that's how I think about it. Of Republican voters who are, like, the hardcore merch-buying, rally-going MAGA people. Not just Republicans who identify as MAGA. 62:32 Most Republicans do. Although less, of course. But people who are, like, really hardcore true believers in Trump. They trust Trump. And so I think he will still have some sway over, like, a not insignificant chunk of Republican voters. So I think 62:48 MAGA goes on. But in a... backseat position mag is kind of the backseat driver now um and we're trying to determine who's steering actually but mag is still kind of in the back chirping um and and has some influence but is not the primary influence over the the 63:06 gop anymore and by maga i don't mean like true maga i mean trump pragmatism like whatever trump says whatever trump's political instincts are a lot of people just trust that and so trump endorsements those type of things my 63:21 prediction is Everyone right now is saying totally over, totally over. 63:25 It's over in a way that it wasn't day before elections. 63:28 It's significantly hurt because Republicans now do have, red state Republicans now do see where the electorate was in the places their voters went. So my personal theory is that it's still with us, but in a much diminished capacity. 63:46 That's what I think. And that puts J.D. Vance in a very interesting position because Trump will still have power to give somebody a boost with 20% of the voters, but does that boost itself, is it outweighed by the costs? 63:57 What's the cost benefit analysis? I don't think we have a clear sense of that yet, just to say that the costs of being associated with MAGA just became more significant when you're doing that cost benefit analysis in a way they weren't before the midterms. And we'll see how 64:11 it shakes out, especially in the new year. Jeff says, hey, Emily, I'm not the only person you've been with online, so I don't expect you to remember me, but our thread went on and on. I was still thinking about it 64:20 at the office. I don't remember this, actually. Let's see. Essentially, I was having a pre-election meltdown and challenging your conservative bona fides and general character. Oh, my. I really regret being so personal, and I think I did so because 64:31 I've been tuning into you for so long, and I thought I knew your politics well, and I think that I've seen so many people in the arena flip their politics virtually overnight. Put that sink on you. Not fair, and I'm sorry for whatever it's worth. I really don't 64:41 like doing that. It's never smart, and it's childish. I honestly don't know what this is about, Jeff, but thank you. 64:46 Jeff says, still, as you said, something I find odd. 64:49 Or still, you said something I find odd. You couldn't possibly believe that analysts on YouTube and X are just calling balls and strikes and there's no influence or metrics influencing people's analysis. I think maybe you kept that code. 64:58 You keep that code. But I look around and see opportunism. 65:00 I see venturism. What say you? I feel like I do vaguely remember a balls and strikes conversation. If I am remembering correctly, I was saying that my job is to call balls and strikes. And I do think there are people who are getting attacked unfairly who are just 65:18 calling balls and strikes on Republicans, right? And I try to do so from the right. If I'm going to do it, I try to do so from the right. 65:26 And to point out, for example, that the Jared Kushner corruption was a serious problem, that the meme coins were a serious problem, that Don Jr. being associated with Polymarket and Kalshi was a problem. It was going to bother 65:37 people because his father's administration is overseeing the regulation or lack thereof of those companies. The same thing goes for the Lutnick family and crypto, Tether and Keisha Fitzgerald, all those sorts of things. The petty corruption of Kimberly Guilfoyle, yes, 65:54 but some of these big picture stories, putting Elon Musk in charge of Doge, brilliant in some respect, but they did nothing to assure people that he was mitigating conflicts of interest. And so I think right now what they might find is there were a lot of conflicts of interest. 66:10 You know, they wouldn't let Elon go to the Pentagon with Doge. Well, Do I think they had good reason for keeping him out of there if it was about conflicts of interest? Sure. But I don't think that's why they kept him out of the Pentagon with Doge. There 66:23 was just so much over the course of the last couple of years to criticize. Like when they blamed Alex Preddy for having a gun in Minneapolis, like that stuff is just insane. And I happen to host a show where half of it is driven by people on the left. 66:37 So I have to talk about partially what they wanted. 66:39 I don't have the luxury that a lot of people in conservative media have. not to talk about what the left wants to talk about. So I have to do both. 66:46 And if you hear frustration, it's because I get it. 66:50 If I wasn't doing what I did, I would be so deeply skeptical of every public voice that I heard out there. One of the reasons I do happy hour is to take questions like this and to talk through this with people. Yeah, I mean, listen, I think it's 67:05 just like, not only is it moral, does it help you sleep at night, but it's also just dumb for your audience not to call balls and strikes because over time people pick up on that. Uh, and you know, I'm so grateful to our audience, uh, for sticking in 67:18 there when they disagree and for even challenging me when they do agree. Like I love that. And I'm really grateful to our audience for doing that. So I know not everybody, uh, you know, is this kind of willing to go back and forth with their audience. I would 67:31 recommend it to other people too, but I think there are people who get unfairly, like my colleague Sagar and Jetty. 67:36 A lot of times he gets called a lib for like reporting things that are uncomfortable for the Trump administration, for even just having conversations with Crystal that other people on the right don't have to have because they don't have to host a show with somebody on the left. 67:51 I think it has been really unfair to some people. 67:53 At the same time, Jeff, you're absolutely correct. And I talk about it all the time. The incentive structure in new media is, especially if you distribute your stuff primarily on social media. It's a little different with substacks, although 68:08 I have heard some theories about substack audience capture as well from people in the know. But especially on social media, where the discourse is inherently unhealthy, yeah, of course, the incentive structure is absolutely, definitively messed up and bad. So 68:27 of course people are I think, of course, people are opportunists. 68:32 I think that exists in every industry, but it's especially prominent in media because social media now drives so many of the incentives. So yeah, I mean, of course, I would agree with that in a big picture sense. I talk about it here all the time. I think it 68:47 is one of the defining characteristics of media in the social media age. We talk here all the time about Marshall McLuhan and Neil Postman. So That is a strong criticism of the industry that I have made over and 68:59 over again. And I'm very transparent about myself kind of responding, resisting the incentive structure and trying to actively immunize myself from that structure. And by the way, that leaves a lot of stuff on the table. There are all kinds of things I could do on this show if I 69:17 wanted to. I could increase viewers and increase clicks and make more money. Of course there are. I don't want to do that. I wouldn't be able to sleep at night. 69:25 I wouldn't be able to have these conversations with you back and forth in the emails and you would know it. 69:30 And maybe some people feel that way. I hope if you consume, you know, what I do in the full scope of it, you understand that's not the case, but nobody is totally immune from it. But you know, it's, it definitely is the defining trait, I think of some people. 69:44 And I'd be happy to say who I think that is. If, Jeff, you have theories. But yeah, I think that's 100% true. 69:51 So anyway, thanks for the note, Jeff. Dunn says, I don't see how the USA recovers from this election loss. 69:57 I thought that we were almost done. At the end of the Biden administration, Trump made a valiant effort to restore the country to give us a chance on the world stage and to bring critical manufacturing to the USA. 70:07 Dunn goes on to say we were taking on China. 70:10 We were drilling back here. Energy, this is a long email, so I'm trying to get to the key parts. We're in the grips of the DSA as voters refuse to take any pain. Let's see, let's see. If there were an identifiable way, Dunn says, I'm emotionally defeated. Don't see 70:30 how we move forward. If there were an identifiable way, I'd suck it up, continue to be a little engine that could. I'm just old and exhausted. I do not request a response. I think this email is probably just my version of screaming into the sky therapy. Sorry to 70:40 burden you if you read it. No, it's no burden done. No, thanks for the note. I think a lot of people feel very similarly to you. I know I addressed this earlier in the episode, but if it is any consolation, I don't think we're now in the grips of the DSA. 70:54 I think the DSA has an enormous amount of influence over the Democratic Party right now. But I also think the Democratic Party only had this blue tsunami because of moderate Democrats. And when I say moderate, I mean on those key cultural issues. And I don't think Annie Andrews, 71:12 for example, is a socialist. I don't think James Tallarico is a socialist. I certainly don't think Adam Hamilton in Kansas is a socialist or Mary Palpola or any of those folks. I don't even think John Ossoff is a socialist. 71:28 Do I think that they are now going to have to appease socialists at times because of the squad kind of organizing into the block in the House of Representatives and having some real sway because Bernie Sanders has been 71:42 vindicated in a lot of his diagnostics about what voters want. Yeah, of course. But if it's any consolation, I do actually think they now have to play ball with senators who can certainly not be associated with genuine socialism in a 71:58 place like Kansas or South Carolina or places where Democrats now are very high on having some power. That's six years those people are represented from those red states. So anyway, if it's any consolation, I'd say that. Stephen says, what 72:11 was the most interesting slash fun debate you've moderated? And if you can moderate a debate between any two people past or present, who would it be? I love moderating debates. 72:19 One of my favorite things to do. I think, of course, it would have to be Scott Jennings versus Ryan Grimm. 72:24 We did that here on After Party. And that was great. Oh, my gosh. At one time, I moderated a debate between Destiny and Omar, who's on Piers a lot, Piers Morgan's show a lot. That was definitely the most interesting one. 72:41 I'll put it that way. But most fun was probably Ryan and Scott Jennings. Because, first of all, I was at GW, so my alma mater. And second of all, that is just a crazy combination of personalities. And I'm very kind of familiar with the Scott Jennings personality, the 72:56 Republican consultant here in Washington, who is generally conservative, but also very close with and sympathetic to the party establishment. 73:05 And Ryan is just... He's such a character and such an honest guy that it was a wild clash of characters. 73:14 So that one's up on YouTube. You should take a look at that one if you missed it. But that's definitely the most fun that I've had in moderated debates. 73:19 It's just like, oh my goodness. Okay. Eddie says, last week you were musing over a friend positing that an impeachment conviction might be more likely if Trump's approval continues to fall. Perhaps, but two things. One, a Senate conviction 73:33 requires 67 votes rather than 60. Well, actually, two-thirds of those present. Cassidy is a cautionary tale. He was a dead man walking in Feb 2021 after his vote to convict Trump. Louisianans counted the days to vote out a 73:43 once moderately popular senator, my two cents. And then Eddie followed up and said this aged like milk. No, Eddie, it aged fine, I think, because, you know, it's still an uphill battle. Because if there, I mean, yeah, it's 73:58 a good question. We don't know that Trump's approval rating is going to dip into the 20s, but my friend did Talk about this on last week's show. Posit that hypothetical. 74:04 If he's like a 25 percent approval rating president, can you get to 67? I don't know. I do think it's possible. And I partially think that's why Trump kind of freaked out at the end when they were getting internals coming back to them, like Mark Halperin reported. And 74:20 Mark Halperin very interestingly suggested they lashed out at him as a kind of piece of performance art. so as to try and douse the flames of panic among Republicans and to make it look like they were still doing okay. 74:35 I also think a lot of them did buy into the idea that they were going to be fine and ignored a lot of the flashing red lights because they do have this correct position on the polls that they often over-represent Democrats. There are a lot of reasons to 74:49 doubt that, as we did here. But anyway, you're right, Eddie, that if you're Ted Cruz... You know that one reason a lot of people didn't come out for Paxton is actually that they didn't think he was a good Christian, honestly. 75:05 They didn't think he was a good man. They didn't like the corruption. They weren't willing to swallow the corruption when gas was also for something. It just didn't work this time because people were frustrated with prices and it made them less likely to go out and vote for 75:18 a guy they didn't think was a good dude. And so Republican voters have a lot of sway and their disillusionment is important in red states. And so- Yeah, it would kind of depend on the impeachment topic, I think, actually. 75:31 I mean, of course it does. But if it's another one of these Ukraine call impeachments, that's one thing. If it's an impeachment on an absolutely damning, unprecedented act of presidential corruption, that's another thing. So interesting, interesting. Ryan says, 75:47 what leverage do regular people have to change party leadership? 75:50 I think Schumer and Jeffries are feckless at best. You gotta write in to the people who are going to be voting in those leadership elections. That's something the Tea Party, I feel like, was pretty good at doing, was organizing 76:03 against the establishment. And yeah, I would say if you can write to your members, even their transition teams, you could probably do it on social media, just say no to Jeffries, no to Schumer. If that's your position, you can make them really feel the heat that you absolutely 76:21 don't want to see them betraying Their cause. It's a it's a tough question that I don't think enough Democrats got asked on the Senate side during this campaign cycle, because it's going to be bad for some of these guys if they vote for Schumer. If you're Abdu'l-Sayed, you 76:39 actually have a lot of incentive not to vote for Schumer. 76:42 Because Republicans will like it in your state. They'll be like, this guy's a maverick who's not going to go vote the party line and is saying no to the establishment. 76:49 I shouldn't say Republicans. I should say independents and maybe some of the Republicans who voted for you. I should be much more precise about that. But then, of course, most Democrats are in an utterly anti-establishment, burn it all down type of mood and would like it too. So 77:03 there's no real incentive to vote for Schumer. Think of like an Annie Andrews, someone who's probably so moderate that she's much more in line with Schumer than like a Chris Van Hollen. Or Chris Murphy, maybe even. I don't know. 77:15 That's an interesting one. But there are incentives there for them not to vote for those guys. So, yeah, you can write to them. You can call their offices. That's a thing that can work and can actually really put some pressure on folks. Tristan says, I honestly feel like 77:31 Tulsi is our best candidate for 2028. She was against the war from day one. She warned Trump that killing the Supreme Leader would make Iran aggressive and that they could take control of the straight. Personality-wise, she's the complete 77:40 opposite of Trump. Very professional and compassionate. Seems like she left the admin at the right time as well. Moderate mega is the future. What a smart point, Tristan. Tulsi left, not because she was pushed out, though a lot of 77:54 people had been trying to push her out from the beginning. 77:56 But of course, she left to deal with her husband's cancer. 77:58 That is a very persuadable and believable reason that she left. 78:02 And I think some people have already even forgotten. So come 2028, she is actually and she was only in the admin for about a year. And she was on the national security side, not the front and center political side, in the White House, where if you're in the White House, 78:17 I mean, like J.D. Vance in the West Wing office, you're not seeing this? That's much harder to persuade people that you had nothing to do with anything. State Department side, Marco Rubio, that'll be a problem for him, too. But she was DNI. And only there for a year. So 78:35 I do think you're onto something here, Tristan. And yeah... 78:42 moderate MAGA is such an interesting term because I feel like it's almost redundant. MAGA itself has always been moderate when Trump wants it to be. And in some sense, it was powerful because... it brought in those voters that 78:51 the polls were undercounting flipping from red to blue because they weren't necessarily moderate on every issue. They're hardcore on the border. They're hardcore on America first. But they're the types of people that are also open to lower taxes. 79:11 It's an interesting combination of things. And I see what you're saying, like moderate MAGA as opposed to ideological, hardcore, conservative MAGA. So like an ideological conservative like myself, somebody who's just across the board, very pro-life, very pro-gun, like 79:29 Tulsi is more moderate on some of that stuff. And that's more appealing to the average American in a general election. 79:35 The question is, can she get through the primary? And I think, Tristan, you're making a decent case. I think you're making a decent case that she's actually in a better position than some other people are to get through a primary. Let's go now to Brandon, who says, Hey, Emily, 79:50 as the midterms wrap up, I want to pick your brain on what you think comes next. Are we looking at impeachment show trials more of the same, or is there a chance of actual progress for the American people over the next two years? Trump seemed a bit different today. 80:00 Not quite his usual bombastic self. I have expected him to deflect. Since true introspection seems pretty rare among politicians, Tristan says we're bound to keep finger pointing and avoiding self-reflection. 80:10 On another note, I wanted to applaud the rounds you made this week. I'm pretty selective about the political pundits I follow, so I was pleasantly surprised to catch you on Mario Noffel's show. It was Scott Horton. It was great watching you lay out exactly how this election was 80:22 going to go, and of course he called it. Thank you for all that you do. We love you. Oh, thanks. 80:25 Brandon signs it since day one. Well, thank you, Brandon. 80:28 I can't say I called it exactly because I still had path one as a serious possibility, but path to always seemed very plausible. So I do feel like a lot of people in corporate media were not prepared for path to, because they still do not understand Trump voters. Uh, 80:41 so anyway, uh, really great point and a really great point on the finger pointing, uh, is what I meant to say. Um, there is a, I think there's a small chance that not even small. I think there's a decent chance that there's some legislation that Trump realizes he 80:59 can work with Democrats on. That's kind of populist. Um, in terms of breaking up big tech or reigning in social media, it's possible. I do think there are going to be a lot of investigations, interrogations, and I just posted this on Twitter before I was firing up the 81:19 mic for happy hour. The idea that Dems are going to overreach, yes, is true, right? Like, do I think they're some of them are going to put the green new deal back on the floor really quickly and, uh, all that kind of stuff. Yeah. But I also feel 81:36 like they won because they learned in terms of political strategy. 81:39 Like I've always said, I don't believe a word out of James Tallarico's mouth about him changing his minds on wacky gender ideology. I don't believe it from him or Amy Acton or Andrew, any Andrews or the Iowa people. 81:52 I don't really believe it. Um, Well, I should say specifically with Tallarico. I really, really don't believe it because he was going so hard in the paint and all those leaks from the people at his church that we covered. 82:01 I don't believe it. On the other hand, they got a lot of Americans who don't follow the news super closely and who believed those issues were kind of behind us or less important than price of gas, those sorts of things, to believe them. And Kamala Harris was already 82:16 talking before the election about maybe not doing the immediate impeachment stuff. I think they're going to be really strategic about how they build a case on the corruption stuff. 82:28 And so Republicans are going to have to play that very closely. They can't look like they're just calling out Dems for overreach when they're looking into Kimberly Guilfoyle or Jared Kushner. Right. I think, honestly, hot take here. Hot take. 82:44 I try usually to do a lukewarm take, but sometimes you got to do a hot take. Some Republicans should cheer on particular investigations if they are substantive and merited. 82:55 There's no harm in saying I support getting to the bottom of this and asking all the questions. I reserve judgment on someone's guilt, but the American people want answers. 83:03 They said in the midterms they want answers. We're going to do our best here in our capacity as investigators in Congress to get to the bottom of it, as people with oversight powers in Congress to get to the bottom of it. So I think for some Republicans, they're 83:15 going to want to play that a little carefully because actually a lot of the anti-Trump lawfare was ill-conceived. Like the Alvin Bragg thing looked like selective prosecution because it was selective prosecution. And even though Trump probably did do 83:29 something a little funky there, to say the least, didn't bother people because the economy wasn't as bad. I mean, the same thing was true with the Mueller stuff. Yeah, it worked for Dems a little bit in 2018, but it wasn't like this. They weren't making huge gains in 83:47 red states. And I think it worked this time because the economy is bad. So if the economy is still bad as they're doing these investigations, I don't think this idea that it's all overreach and lawfare is going to work because the scope of the corruption is really big. 84:01 And on top of that, the economy is really bad. 84:02 So I think a lot of people are going to be like, hell yeah, haul them all up there, especially independent voters and be like, yes, ask them questions. Like, yes, ask Elon Musk questions. Hell yeah. Get Elon Musk out there and make him answer for this stuff. I want 84:15 to know what was happening behind the scenes at Doge. 84:16 I want to know if he was benefiting SpaceX, uh, with some of those decisions he made or Starlink with some of those decisions he made. I want to know. Uh, and so I think Republicans are gonna have to be careful about that, but, uh, of course it's not going 84:28 to surprise me if Dems overplay it either. Uh, Hank says, Emily, you indicated Dems learned their lesson on lawfare. Oh, well, that's a perfect transition and won't repeat 2018 and 2020. 84:39 Brianna Lyman seems to think you might have spoken too soon. 84:42 This is from The Federalist. Dems vow lawfare hours after winning on affordability. I didn't read this piece. It has people saying, oh, yeah, this is a perfect transition from what I was just saying. I would probably disagree with 84:57 Brianna on this. It has It quotes Democrats saying things like, thank you, Mr. President. I think you will come in January with subpoenas. Another representative saying, no, Mark Wayne, Miller, Homan, Bovina, what's up? Clear your schedule. Robert Garcia, lawyer up. He 85:11 warned Republicans. I don't think that's going to come across. Well, here's Hassan Piker. We're going to put your ass in jail. 85:16 Everyone get more woke right now. Exclamation points. Yeah, I don't think that's going to come across as lawfare at all if they are smart enough to focus on merited substantive investigations and We use lawfare a lot to talk 85:31 about selective prosecution, political prosecution, that type of thing. Again, do I assume they're not always going to be smart enough to focus on the best cases? But there are a lot of cases to choose from. As somebody who's 85:43 paid really close attention to this, the crypto rug polls, inviting people to private dinners with the president of the United States, depending on if they've invested X amount in your crypto coin. If they investigate stuff like that, that's 85:55 not going to come across to people as lawfare, especially not in a bad economy. So I think I probably do disagree with that take a little bit. Let me go here. Done. I just watched the Wednesday show. Really shocked that so many flipped blue over costs. I get it, 86:10 but still disappointed. I heard Halperin's reporting, but just couldn't believe it. I guess he was right. Listen, I also hear people who are frustrated with their fellow conservatives for 86:24 either voting Democrat, which again, it was about 9% of Republicans. 86:27 It wasn't most Republicans. or not voting at all. I get that. I've heard that a bit on the SiriusXM show too, because listen, you have to personally weigh the costs where you are on sending, you know, if you're in Michigan, either, you know, swallowing the bitter pill of 86:44 Mike Rogers, assuming that would be a safe Supreme Court vote for a good conservative justice, or not voting for a guy who you think is kind of a swamp creature who has been talking out of both sides of his mouth on the war, Doesn't even seem to live 86:58 in the state and doesn't seem all that concerned about the plight of the average person. Seems like he's all over the map. Do you really want to do and might be affiliated with Trump? Maybe you're sick of Trump and he came to Michigan. He was talking about asses 87:14 and Nicki Minaj and maybe just don't want to have anything to do with that. Of course, everybody had to weigh that personally in their mind. Did the cost of not voting or voting them? Was it outweighed by putting another Democratic vote in the Senate or in the governor's 87:28 office for a set amount of years. So I actually, I mean, like, I get that. I think that would be a really tough choice. It would be, I live in D.C., so that's a luxury. I don't live in Ohio or Michigan, so it's a luxury. But I get why it was a tough call for people. And I think, 87:42 you know, some people just made a different cost-benefit analysis at the end of the day. Nick says, hey, Emily, I was just wondering, have you always been classically beautiful by that? I mean, you wear very little makeup and 87:53 certainly don't kick it on like celebs. You look stunning. 87:55 like a Jennifer Garner girl next door look, you should thank your parents for those excellent, gorgeous jeans. You know, I actually don't look remotely like either of my parents, so I don't even know if we can credit them. 88:07 Both beautiful people, of course, but thank you, I guess. Yeah, I don't know. I try not to think about it too much. I try to think about it only to the extent that I absolutely have to think about makeup and hair or whatever else, probably to my detriment at 88:21 some points, but there's so much going on that It's just never been my thing. Thank you though, Nick. Marlo says, Based on these last two episodes, I realize I lack understanding on many issues, but two that rise to the top are exit polling and stats and Trump corruption. How 88:37 do you know the swings to D by sex and race that you cited? Hispanics won swung X for Trump on 2024 and Y swung for Dems in 2026. If we know this granular data about the votes cast, why don't we know the accuracy of those votes? Is the 88:50 corruption cited in exit polls specific to Trump and his family? 88:52 Is that corruption stealing taxpayer dollars? Is there a list or source of all corruption of Trump? If corruption was the top of voters' minds, why did Minnesota stay blue? 88:59 Why was Ilhan Ermi Omar voted in with 76% of the vote? Why is Mary Patola ahead in Alaska? Why did Becerra and Rahman win in California? Congress did not get important legislation codified Doge Save America Act, but now that Republicans are out of leadership, they will not even 89:14 be considered. My concern is the lurch far left is passing the point of no return, and my children will pay the price. I know we're only here now, but what if in the future the Iran war was determined to be necessary and proper, but Our impatience in this 89:24 election proved to be the turning point in the downfall of our country. Rich people think in decades, while the poor and average people think in days. I'm trying to stay educated and hopeful it gets harder each day. Marla, well, thank you. Marla is one of our regulars, so I 89:37 really appreciate that. Exit polling, everybody takes it with a big grain of salt. All the exit polling in these races was saying something really similar. The most popular exit polling so far has been the NBC News exit polling. 89:49 That is the source of a lot. The exit polling that I was citing was put together by the right of center pollster, Patrick Ruffini, who has a very good sense of what's BS. And that's where I was talking about the demographic shifts. He did a great job breaking 90:06 it down by cohort and breaking it down by the shifts between 2020 to 2024 and then 2024 to 2026. 90:10 Super interesting. It's on his X feed. And you can actually go to our Wednesday episode of the show and pause, you can see it there. And then that would also have you look up the tweet, but, um, I also posted it under, you can search my X feed for, um, 90:29 MAGA coalition. I posted it there too. Um, because you can see some of those key aspects shifting, but yeah, exit polling is, is an art, not a science. I always do think it's powerful when a lot of the exit polling is pointing to the exact same thing. Um, 90:42 on corruption, um, I think Minnesota stayed blue because people, I mean, I think it was closer than it would have otherwise been, uh, because of the fraud, because Tafoya was a good candidate. Who's really good at talking about 90:54 the fraud. Ilhan Omar got reelected because Ilhan Omar's district doesn't believe she's corrupt. Very simple answer to that one. 91:02 They don't believe it or they don't care. Um, and also people aren't taking that story seriously enough because the media is not taking that story seriously enough nationally. Um, And a lot of the Trump stuff has dominated nationally. 91:16 And again, yeah, these are blue areas. So I don't know about Palpola. The early vote probably came in before that particularly bad Dan Sullivan scandal broke through. Becerra and Rahman, I mean, California is so, so blue. And especially in 91:34 a year that's favorable to Democrats, meaning people are getting out to vote against Trump. Steve Hilton said that. He said it was a bad year to run as a Republican. 91:42 That just means the electorate is going to be much more anti-Trump. If people see him as being on the ballot, because he said he was, you're just going to have more anti-Trump people, whether they're 1 in 10 Republicans or Democrats, coming out to vote. And if people see it as 91:57 a vote against Trump, maybe they don't vote for Steve Hilton. 92:01 But yeah, I don't know. I mean, the... Actually, in L.A., a lot of people saw Karen Bass, like a lot of the Dems voted for Nithya Raman because they thought Karen Bass was corrupt. So it's kind of a race by race thing. But I think a lot of the 92:14 blue states, the media doesn't pay as much attention to the stories of Dem corruption. So a lot of people don't believe them. And it was an anti-Trump electorate and an anti-Republican electorate. So people were voting on that, if 92:30 it makes sense. Interesting questions. Let's see, what else did I miss? Yeah, I think Republicans were disillusioned by the inability to do Save America by what happened to Doge. 92:41 I think that's totally true. And the question of whether the lurch far left has passed the point of no return, that's open. You know, I think it's an open question. 92:49 I don't think it's a given that it's happened. If you look at what's happening in Europe right now, they're having a lot of swing back. Many people thought Europe was past the point of no return. But what happens in France with Le Pen? It seems improbable, but to 93:07 your point about decades versus years, yeah, that's definitely... We're seeing over decades a potential swing back in Europe in some ways. So if it's any consolation, sometimes the decades... 93:23 trajectory really does really is significant and again especially where when it looks like a lot of americans now a record number of people identify as independent that's a lot of people up for grabs uh so if that's any consolation i would say that and on the iran war 93:39 though i think the only possibility that it was absolutely necessary is if we were missing some piece of intelligence that said they were literally like weeks away actually weeks away which Rubio did not say. He said months past 93:51 the point of... They were months away from getting past the point of containment without a ground war or without something really significant. And that's intelligence that I'm also dubious of because of what we heard after Epic Fury. I'm sorry, 94:07 after Midnight Hammer. But if we get intelligence later... that this was going to absolutely, like we were on the brink, that they were about to have the nuclear weapons and about to use them on Israel, in which case, of course, 94:22 the United States would be extremely involved. Then, of course, I think you can make the argument that it was absolutely necessary, but it wasn't prosecuted in a way that I think made it less likely for them to start 94:37 racing further towards nuclear weapons because, obviously, There's been a rally around the flag effect in Iran, and a lot of people are now have been had been poisoned against the United States. They've suffered heavier casualties. Of course, their 94:51 country had 90 million people and it's hit them harder than it's hit us. So even then, it hasn't been prosecuted in a way that makes us safer is an open question, too. But yet that one, I just worry less about being kind of proven wrong on in the 95:04 long term. But interesting thought. Oh, this is Bob about the Iran war. Iran war was 99% the culprit in the historic defeat of the GOP. Yeah, and Bob, we've talked about this so far in the episode. A lot of this stuff is downstream of that. And Bob says 95:19 the proponents of this war, like the Wall Street Journal and their opinion folks, refuse to admit that even today as you read the paper. It is maddening to read their bullshit. The implication of what happened on Tuesday will reverberate for the rest of the lives of those of 95:30 us who have reached our ninth or tenth decade of life. 95:32 One cannot even imagine what the massive majority of progressive-controlled Congress and state houses will mean for this country. You know, that's a good point, too. We haven't talked about them. 95:39 Like Wisconsin, my home state, flipped after all that work during the Tea Party era that saw Republicans building Wisconsin into what they said was basically a red state. Of course, we know it wasn't. And a lot of that went 95:52 out the window after Scott Walker won reelection. What was that, 2018? 95:56 But yeah, now firmly blue. So that's an interesting point from Bob as well that we haven't even touched on. 96:04 Bob says, even more concerning the future are the implications for the state of Israel that we all love. That wonderful state has become a pariah in the eyes of the world, including so sadly the American people. This was also on the ballot in Israel during those elections. Like 96:17 a lot of people were genuinely concerned that Netanyahu had kind of pushed Americans away from supporting Israel and had pushed other people in the world on the world stage to even further away from supporting Israel, had kind of 96:33 poisoned public opinion in a lot of the important allied countries away from Israel. And that's something Netanyahu faced internally from Israeli citizens as well. And that question of whether Israel is safer today because of everything that's happened since 96:51 October 7th is, I think it's a real one. I think it's a real one for Israelis. And it's definitely, definitely true that if you believe American aid to Israel makes Israel safer, which a lot of people in Israel don't believe, by the way, a lot of people in Israel, 97:09 as Trump said in his Fox and Friends call-in, Netanyahu was the one who planted this idea with him of stopping American aid to Israel. A lot of people in Israel are no longer convinced that makes them safe because it subjects them to the whims of American politics. When 97:25 American people feel like they need to spend more at home and less abroad, then Israel's on the hook if it's dependent on that military aid. But even if you are somebody who believes that Israel needs that U.S. aid to be safe, then boy, it hasn't been handled in 97:40 a way that made that more likely. So it's an interesting point, Bob. Leslie says, how much do you think the loss of Charlie Kirk impacted the midterms? What ways do you think he might have influenced the Trump administration 97:50 and or Republican Party? I like your show, especially when you explain important points of your Christian values. Well, thank you, Leslie. 97:56 This is a question I've been thinking about over the last week. Many people have been thinking about it over the last week. I didn't know Charlie well, so I can't speak to this as well as some of his close friends and confidants would be able to. I don't 98:10 know where he would have landed on the Iran war based on his opposition to Midnight Hammer or his caution about Midnight Hammer and then after Midnight Hammer particularly. My strong assumption is that he would have sided with J.D. Vance. 98:26 He may have been an extra voice that could have prevented the war by rallying other people to support the Vance position in addition to himself, as it was being discussed throughout January. I have to imagine he would have been offering very, very friendly criticism of of the war 98:48 to the Trump administration. I don't know if you've all paid close attention to how Joe Kent has been communicating. 98:54 He's clearly, in my opinion, and I interviewed him in the spring, it must have been, he's clearly communicating to the president and to people who are loyal to the president. 99:06 And I think Charlie would have done something similar. I don't know if he would have been like pro-Joe Kent resigning or anything like that. The resignation decision is one thing itself. I'm just talking about his communication style where 99:14 you say, Mr. President, you can end this war You could be the person that ends this war. That's my best guess at what would have happened. And in the midterms, I think he really would have been encouraging people, making 99:27 the case that the Trump administration's good outweighed bad. In the Trump administration, the good outweighed the bad. And I think he probably would have been building the case that, probably in a very persuasive way, that Democrats were so 99:40 bad that people needed to adjust, like the DSA folks, the Bernie influence is so bad that people need to kind of adjust their their own cost-benefit analyses with some dose of that reality. But I think he also would have been counseling Republicans to be much wiser in how 99:57 they talk about things like the burrito and how they talk about all of that type of stuff. So that's my best guess. He probably would have been... Actually, you know what, I'll say, I think he certainly would have been a unifying force for the Republican Party in terms 100:13 of motivating voters to go to the polls. He might have even prevented South Carolina from flipping by counseling Trump not to intervene in the primary. That's possible too. But I think he would have been a force for unification and also would have been doing so in a way 100:35 that helped Republicans frame their message and adopt policy, pledges, promises, positions that would have been a bit more populist and would have been focused, like, on the nuts and bolts issues, just like Abdullah Syed decided to do money in your pocket, 100:51 money out of politics, Medicare for all. I think Charlie Kirk was starting to really understand that Republicans needed to be talking in similar ways with offerings of concrete, affordable or concrete, tangible ways to make people's lives more affordable. 101:12 So that's my best guess, but it's a really, really good question. And, uh, Man, I know a lot of people were feeling as lost this week. Abe says, Molitor was my favorite. Wausau Timbers. Oh, Paul Molitor. There you go. 101:28 All right. Well, that's all we have time for today. 101:30 It's all the emails, in fact. So thank you, everybody, for writing in. I hope you all have wonderful, wonderful weekends. 101:36 If you're depressed, if you're disillusioned, just remember Democrats were depressed and disillusioned on another level in 2024. They thought Trump had ushered a generational shift towards Republicans with all kinds of cohorts that seem to have shifted just in 101:53 the last couple of years. So that can always happen again. 101:56 Record number of independents in this country. A lot of people up for grabs. We've got a lot of strong communities and a lot of people making their communities who aren't so strong even stronger right now because they're aware that there are problems that need to be fixed. So 102:10 God bless you all. I hope you all have wonderful weekends. 102:12 We'll see you with more After Party on Monday.
Community discussion