0:03 Welcome to After Party, everyone. What a 24 hours it's been. Now, if you watched Monday's edition of After Party, which, by the way, please subscribe if you haven't yet. It's the most helpful way to keep us doing our independent journalism 0:14 here on YouTube. Subscribe Apple, Spotify, email me, Emily at DevilMayCareMedia.com. 0:18 But we described two possible paths. And this is why you should subscribe, by the way. for the midterm election results. 0:23 One was a standard polling error that underestimated Republicans by a couple of points nationally. This is the type of thing we've seen over the course of the Trump era, and that would have allowed them to kind of squeak 0:34 out wins in Iowa, in Texas, South Carolina, places like that. 0:38 The second path we laid out, and this is one you were not hearing in a lot of other places. 0:42 Our next guest, Mark Halperin, is going to talk to you about it, because he was one of the few people who was laying out this possibility, and Republicans just didn't want to hear it. The possibility was that polls 0:51 were underestimating Democrats. Why would that have been? Well, and this is also why you're not you weren't hearing a lot of chatter about this in the media going into Election Day. Elites still do not understand MAGA. That is 1:04 why this path was not much discussed. They don't understand that MAGA is some of the same voters that they were previously under polling. And this is turning out to be the case when you're seeing double digit margins, potentially 1:16 a huge margin. Let's just put it that way for Tallarico. 1:18 When you're seeing South Carolina flip to Annie Andrews, when you're seeing a huge margin of victory in Georgia, when you are seeing Michigan, huge margin of victory for Abdul El-Sayed, when you're seeing the Wisconsin legislature flip, you're seeing people 1:32 who are in rural districts flip. We have numbers on the MAGA coalition swinging Democrat. We had a poll from Politico finding about 9% of Republicans planned to vote Democrat. 1:43 Democrat this time around, only 2% of Democrats planning to vote Republicans this time around. This is what people didn't understand and why the second path was much more possible as we laid out here on Monday's show than people realized. 1:55 Rural right-leaning Trump voters are the very same type of people who flipped Trump in 16 and in 2024 because of guess what? Corruption, foreign wars, and the cost of living. 2:05 So make no mistake, that is what happened last night. 2:07 Democrats won because of the war, but Democrats won by massive margins because Because the war made every other piece of MAGA baggage that has been with Trump for the last 10 years tolerable. This is not a win for 2:20 the establishment Republican Party. This is a rebuke of foreign wars. 2:23 This is a rebuke of too high cost of living. 2:24 It is a rebuke of swamp style corruption. It is a loss for Trump, too, though. I can't tell you how happy I am to be joined right now by one of the most vindicated men in America in all of political media. That's the one and only Mark Halperin. 2:36 You can follow him over at Two Way and NextUp and on Substack, markhalperin.substack.com. Mark Halperin, thank you for being here. 2:44 I know you're a busy man. 2:45 Honored to be here, Emily. Thank you for inviting me on. 2:48 Well, of course, I want to start with actually a little bit of a personal beef, but it has political substance where you were going back and forth. What was it like a month ago now with Chris Lasavita and other people who are very close to the kind of 3:00 Susie Wiles wing of the White House, obviously White House chief of staff, Susie Wiles wing of the White House. 3:05 They really seemed to believe, and I'm curious to get your take on this, that your reporting on what Republicans were seeing on the ground in states like South Carolina was wrong. They went really hard in the paint, knowing that if they turned out to be wrong, they would 3:21 look ridiculous right here on November 4th. And they still went hard in the paint saying Mark Halperin's reporting is bullshit. 3:27 Chris Lasavita basically came out and said that this was all wrong and you were going to be proved wrong. 3:33 And Mark, you had, just remind us a bit about the extent of your reporting, the scope of your reporting. 3:37 You had so many Republican operatives consultants, those types, campaign workers telling you, no, that what they were seeing on the ground was really bad in places like South Carolina and Kansas. And it seemed like, I mean, do you 3:49 think Chris LaCivita believed it when he told you that you were wrong? 3:53 Well, as a reporter, I don't like to get into fights in public or even in private with people. 3:58 No, no, no. 3:59 I'm just explaining. I'm going to give my answer, but I don't object to the question at all. I just don't like to be in fights with people I cover. 4:06 I don't think it's my role, and it kind of hinders my role. So my strong belief, based on the fact that I know Chris Lasavita knows pretty much everybody who was my source for the reporting I did over the last month or so, I'm pretty confident he knew 4:22 that things were really bad, but I get why he felt he had to go after me on Twitter, because they needed to try to push back on the notion that things were really bad, because it's not great a month or so out to have the public and the 4:34 media and Republicans think things are going to be a big blue tsunami. 4:39 So I laughed it off. I've known Chris for a while. 4:42 I like him. 4:42 I respect him. But I get what he had to do. 4:45 And maybe he did it for the boss because they knew he wanted to see somebody push back because my reporting was getting a fair amount of attention. And as I said in the tweets, I think I did one for 17 people and then one above 50. one of 4:59 the great benefits is I built new sources because as I was being assailed for it, I got a hearing from people I never knew in Republican politics saying, you don't know me, but I'm doing this Senate race and this governor's race and the super PAC. And yeah, you're 5:11 reporting almost to a person they'd say, if you're wrong, it's because you're understating how bad this is going to be. 5:18 So, I mean, again, it's a little uncomfortable. 5:22 To be attacked by people you cover, but I knew I knew my reporting was right. And and and the more I did it, the more feedback I got and more specifics I got sending me in the same direction. 5:34 Not enough focus, I think, right now being paid to the race in North Carolina that swept out Richard Hudson, who is currently the head of the National Republican Congressional Committee. 5:43 He lost to Richard Ojeda, a very hardcore populist. We had him on breaking points last night. And John Michael Rush at the Daily Mail said, had a quote from a GOP strategist who said, it's all James Blair, Lasavita's, and Chris Grant's fault. This is a little insider politics, 5:57 but Mark, you're great at insider politics. I just want to ask if you think in the next several weeks, maybe the next several months, genuinely the knives are out for Blair, Lasavita, maybe Susie Wiles herself as well. 6:08 100%. If the stories that I've been told off the record or on background over the last three weeks don't find their way into stories over the next couple of weeks, I'd be super surprised because the president's blaming the candidates 6:23 and saying, well, the candidates were horrible. That's why we did so poorly. There are many stories where folks who were doing races say this was the fault of the president's political operation. They spent their money too late. They spent it poorly. 6:36 They didn't do a good job of dealing with these campaigns. 6:38 And so I don't know how much traction this will get. 6:41 I don't know how much it's going to break into kind of the popular imagination, even in political circles. But within people who obsessively read you know, magazine and newspaper stories about these kinds of things. I think I'd be surprised if there weren't a lot of fodder. And I 6:57 think it'll cause the president's people to ramp up their telling tales about how bad the candidates and the campaigns were. 7:04 So it could get pretty ugly. And of course, it's not good for anybody except us. 7:10 Yeah. 7:11 Well, and just another little after party victory lap. We were saying it was going to be that the cope was going to be candidate quality from people like Trump if it if this all turned out to be what it was looking like. Now, I want to actually ask 7:22 you about some of these coalition swings. So the right of center pollster Patrick Ruffini put together a great analysis of exit polls last night. that found swings from, I think, really key parts of the MAGA coalition towards Democrats. Non-college, 7:35 plus seven. Men, plus 11. Latino men, plus 24. Rural voters, plus 11. Income, $ 50, 000 or less, plus 14. Independence, plus 13. 7:45 This is exactly the MAGA coalition that helped them turn Ohio almost totally red. It was helping them in places like Wisconsin and was helping them in places like Texas, totally falls apart last night. And we can do a little source note comparison here, Mark. I had two GOP 8:01 sources last night say, one, quote, America is done with Trump. 8:05 Another one said, quote, if we lose non-college men, we have fucked up and lost the plot. What are you hearing about the future of the fragile coalition that Trump put together for many years? 8:16 So the irony to me is the president is president. 8:20 And got elected twice because he understood the populist movement, not just of Republican populists who we call MAGA, but independents and even some Democrats who crossed over and voted for him because they understood, they believe that he understood 8:32 the populist moment. Almost every issue that caused Republicans and MAGA three-time Trump voters to defect are populist issues. Again, ironically on which Donald Trump was on the wrong side, the war in Iran, handling of the Epstein matter, the ballroom, 8:49 the Kennedy Center, the support for data centers and the support for billionaires. And then the Trump family making a lot of money off of leveraging their time in office. 9:04 All those things, if you did a focus group with Bernie Sanders supporters and said, how do you feel about those things? 9:10 They would say, we're outraged. Oh, support for Israel too. 9:13 They'd say, we're outraged. 9:14 Outrage. 9:15 This is why Donald Trump's so horrible. 9:16 And if you did a focus group of MAGA supporters and you said, let's say a politician supported data centers, Israel, a war in the Middle East with no end, covering up the Epstein files and making a lot of money off of and supporting tax cuts for the wealthy. 9:33 They'd say that person's horrible. 9:36 And for some of them, when they say, well, Donald Trump did all the things they say, well, that's horrible. 9:39 I'm going to vote for a Democrat. It's no surprise to me. That if a populist president takes the wrong side and the non-populist side of a bunch of 80-20 issues, 80% unpopular, 20% popular, and the president's on the 20% side, it's no surprise that he's going to lose a lot 9:56 of voters from MAGA who either sit out the election or vote for the Democrat. 10:01 And as best we can tell from the data, that's what happened. 10:03 And that's how you turn, without mystery, that's how you turn these states that were overwhelmingly red states into, at least temporarily, the kind of purple election where Democrats can win places like Iowa, Ohio, Texas, and South Carolina. 10:19 Yeah, and let's get to this exit polling. The NBC News exit polling in particular has been mega viral. So Sean Davis posted on X this result. It's everywhere from the NBC News exit polling. 74% of voters said the Iran war was a crucial or major factor in their vote. 10:36 62% of those voters sided with Democrats in today's election. 10:40 Let's go to the data center exit polling from NBC News. Crucial, how important was AI and data centers to your vote? 10:47 Crucial 23% major factor was, well, okay, so let's go with crucial. I have the wrong numbers in front of me here, but crucial 23%. Overall, I actually think that number was on data centers. Let me pull it up. Also, I'll mention corruption in those exit polls was 90%. 90%, 11:04 that was as high as the 89% cost of living number in these exit polls. 11:07 Yep. 11:12 So yeah, AI and data centers, um, 23% of voters overall said crucial, uh, or a major factor was 33%. 11:19 So that's yeah. 11:19 56%. 11:19 If I'm doing my terrible math correctly on air, which I always hate to do, uh, saying AI and data centers was important to them. What do you make of all of that? 11:27 Mark? First of all, I am, I'm going to get you a abacus for Christmas. 11:32 I have one. I won one in a debate that reason magazine hosted on AI last year. 11:37 Use your abacus. 11:39 Um, again, uh, If your support, your core support is predicated on them believing that you understand their lives and you're using populist policies to help them with their lives, and then you just support the policies that they hate. Again, 11:57 this list of Israel, Middle East, endless Middle East wars, Epstein class, tax cuts for the wealthy, data centers, AI, these aren't popular policies. 12:11 Populist, popular, right? 12:13 They share, they're part of the same word. 12:16 These aren't popular with his supporters. So I look at all the. 12:19 Polling in the, you know, they call it the voter poll now, not the exit poll, because some of the polling is not done as voters exit the polls, but for people who vote early. I look at the voter poll, and I just think, well, of course, of course, voters 12:33 care a lot about the economy. And of course, they care a lot about corruption. And of course, they care a lot about ending the war. And Trump's on the right, and data centers and and a relationship with Israel. And Trump's on the wrong side of every one of these, 12:47 not a 50-50 issue or a 60-40 issue, but they're mostly 80-20 issues. It's staggering that people, I think, that could have expected any other result but this given the data. 12:58 Right. 12:59 And just wanted to mention Rich Barris, the data guy, is saying, in case anyone needs to hear it, American Jews voted for Democrats and against the war hurting the economy. 13:07 American Jews opposed the Iran war more than any religious demo. 13:10 Rich goes on to say neocons can stop pretending they speak for American Jews now. But actually, the Michigan results, Mark, are fairly interesting because more than any other race in the country, that was seen as a litmus test on 13:21 how the kind of old guards messaging on support for Israel would play out at the ballot box. And I'm just curious, you know, you've been around Washington for a long time. How significantly significantly you think this changes or 13:33 does not change the way the political establishment approaches at least messaging, if not policy on that issue? 13:40 Well, first of all, I haven't lived in Washington in more than three decades. So I think I last lived there before you were born, just FYI. 13:45 You basically live on the train. 13:47 No, I cover America. 13:48 I'm not really interested in Washington or politics. I cover America. 13:51 But in terms of Israel, I think there's four big factors that will determine what happens here on this issue. 13:57 One is what Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries want to do about it. Two is what the new members of Congress, House, and Senate want to do about it. Three is what happens both in Israel and with Iran. So what happens in the Middle East is Netanyahu prime minister and what 14:16 happens in either negotiations or. 14:18 Conflict with Iran. 14:19 And then lastly is the 2028 Democratic presidential candidates. 14:22 And do any of them take on. 14:27 The mantle as their mission to try to restore the Democratic Party's support for the generations-long bipartisan consensus That Israel is a valuable ally of the United States. That's a lot of variables and they're all very big variables and 14:41 they may not all go in the same direction. But that's what I think is going to tell the tale about whether there's some sort of policy change or attitudinal change in America towards Israel and regarding America's relationship with Israel. 14:54 All right. Now, Kristi Noem is out. With a very interesting take. Kristi Noem posted, Larry Kudlow is correct. We were too successful the first year of the Trump administration. 15:04 Have you heard any of that cope, Mark? Is that something that you've heard? Because she's the only person I've seen saying that. But I don't know if you're hearing something different. 15:11 Oh, yeah. 15:12 I've heard a ton of people say the big problem was they passed the one big beautiful bill too soon. 15:16 And voters had forgotten it. You know, you got to be able to sell it. 15:20 And that's going to be consistently one of the big complaints from pundits and from the Republicans down ballot who lost, which is there was no systemic plan, no systematic plan to sell the benefits of the one big, beautiful bill. 15:35 When people talk about passing stuff too early, most of it was in that one mammoth piece of legislation. 15:41 Yeah. 15:42 And Wesleyan did its analysis of the top ads that were run towards the end of the campaign. And Republicans' top subject in ads was taxes, obviously talking about no tax and tips and that sort of thing. So Interesting. But, you know, when you put out that reporting, Mark, about 15:59 hearing so much from people that this was a really, really big problem, it sounded correct to me because on Sirius XM, right after Megan, I take calls every single day from a fairly right of center slash indie right leaning audience. And we put together a compilation of some 16:15 of those calls just to listen to what we were hearing on the show and some of what Mark was hearing, too, as he covers the country. And if you were listening, it was there for you. Let's take a listen. 16:25 I'm self-employed. 16:28 My insurance, my health insurance has turned into now, I like a huge mortgage payment with a huge deductible. Gas prices are insane. 16:37 I voted for Trump. 16:38 I was horrified at the thought of, and I still am, at Kamala being my president, that I would vote against that. 16:46 But I got to tell you, I'm angry. I feel, I don't want to say lied to, but I'm upset. 16:54 It's costing me $ 1, 300 every other day to pull off my truck. I do my job. 17:02 Diesel? 17:03 Yes. 17:04 This guy's in Michigan. 17:05 I bought two packs of. 17:06 Paper towels yesterday for the truck so I could clean my windows. Six months ago, those paper towels were like $ 1. 35 a pack. When I bought them yesterday, they were almost $ 4 a pack. 17:19 Oh my gosh. 17:20 This is for a single roll. I am almost ready to park this truck. Because I'm getting to the point where I cannot afford to drive. 17:28 The socialist left is like some crazy girl who I'd never be interested in. But the way I feel with Republicans is like my wife just cheated on me. 17:38 Kansas. 17:40 The social differences or divides, like transgender and all that stuff, that's minute compared to how huge this war is in the economy. 17:51 I'm totally over Trump, to be frank with you. He just ruins any credibility he has by, you know, all of these issues, kind of distracting issues like the Gulf of America and Lake America, all that kind of stuff. 18:10 He's not convincing anybody relative to the importance of getting rid of the nuclear weapons in Iran because he's so buffoonish on these other, you know, insignificant thing. 18:26 You know, we didn't get a wall. We didn't get to lock up Hillary. We didn't get to drain the swamp. 18:32 We didn't get affordable health care. We didn't get to eliminate the national debt with Doge. I voted for the guy. 18:39 But this guy is the big, he should be selling used 67 Cadillac Coupe de Ville at some used car lot because all we've gotten is garbage. Iran, Iran, Iran, Iran. OK, the price of oil comes down. His big buddies that are rich buy. Price of oil goes up because we 18:58 buy them. They sell, sell, sell. The whole thing is a sham. I would never vote for this man again. 19:04 And you know what? Sometimes things got to get worse before they get better. But there is no America first with President Trump. 19:13 There you go, Mark. It all sounds obvious in retrospect, doesn't it? 19:18 Yeah, I mean, again, one of the powers of my platform, Two Ways, we hear from folks as you do, all from all over the country. And again, you cannot tell your base you're going to be on the wrong side of issues that are of great emotion to them. 19:33 War, Epstein, corruption, the economy. 19:40 You can't tell them you're going to be on the wrong side of them and expect them to just be like, yeah, that's all right. We love other things about you. They're going to be angry. And angry people, you know, they do stuff. when they're given the power, like vote for 19:52 the Democrats or sit out the election, whatever it is. 19:54 So I say again, when people say, how. 19:57 Do you explain this? 19:58 The explanation was out there right before our eyes for months and months and months. 20:02 And was it finally just that some of these Republican strategists were banking on the polls? possibly, I mean, these are the two paths I laid out. One, you have the standard polling error that is overestimating Democrats. Is that 20:14 what they were really clinging to? I mean, it seemed more likely to me, at least, that they were underestimating Republicans flipping Democrats. But, you know, people who are in Trump's orbit, and Trump gets elected because, to your point, 20:25 he understands these people. He does. He's always had better political instincts than the Republican establishment. How did they miss this? 20:33 Well, I don't think they did. 20:35 Again, they knew there was a big problem. 20:38 I think there's a lot of multi-leveled reasons why they didn't react more to what they were seeing in the data. 20:47 And I think the main one is most of these people who do races in Texas or in Florida or in North Carolina or Ohio, Iowa. 20:56 They've done races, sometimes cases, nowhere else. That's just the state they know. 21:01 And the muscle memory and the modeling and the kind of attitude is, yeah, they'll run some Democrat, some former whatever, and we'll run negative ads against them. And we know how to turn out the vote, you know, and the margins in some parts of the state. And that plan 21:17 had worked for them in most cases with uninterrupted success, undefeated streaks. And in this case, you know, they just weren't ready for it. They just weren't ready for the model to be thrown out the window and there to be a real argument for why Democrats could win. 21:35 The most interesting 2028 subplot playing out yesterday involved Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, who made the decision to go on Stephen A. Smith's show on Election Day and start, I was going to say creating distance, but he had actually 21:50 kind of quietly been creating distance between himself and the Trump administration on a recent months, particularly on AI and data centers. But he's out with more this morning. I want to start with what he was saying yesterday. Get your take on it. And we're going to add what 22:05 he said this morning as well, because he's kind of taking a victory lap first. Here's Ron DeSantis yesterday on Stephen A. Smith's show. 22:12 We had 11 million people come in illegally under Biden. 22:14 It was one of the top issues. I just think having Christine Noem be the secretary was a mistake. She wanted to be, you know, like get on a horse and do this. She wanted these conflicts. I think she wanted because it created news. And I think the public 22:30 still wants the law enforced. And many Latinos do, by the way. 22:33 Yes, they do. 22:34 But he obviously ran saying he wasn't going to do a Middle East where they did. So we had some of our voters who've checked out because they're like, I didn't want any more Middle East wars. And now we're doing it. Had that been wrapped up in like a week, 22:44 like Venezuela was very quick. People probably wouldn't have been an issue right now. 22:48 Right. 22:48 But what's happened is it's kind of an open ended conflict and it's having a direct impact on people's finances. 22:55 One of the things they'll say with the tech stuff is, oh, well, we've got to beat China. We've got to be China. 22:59 Now, look, I'm a China hawk. 23:01 Like, I think the CCP is a threat. 23:03 So like Silicon Valley is not trying to beat China and trying to join them. Silicon Valley is trying to make money. And honestly, I don't blame them because they have fiduciary responsibility. 23:12 They're shareholders. 23:13 They're a public company, especially to maximize value. So don't tell me that's the reason. This swamp here is the worst it's ever been. You have some of these guys, they get to Congress. They've never shown any financial acumen. 23:28 All of a sudden, they're Warren Buffett just timing it right. 23:31 And they're making 50 grand, 60 grand here. How are we not banning the congressional stock trading? Put it in a trust, put in a 401k, do some of those things. 23:39 It's ridiculous. And Trump was criticizing Alina Haba. She's working for DOJ and she gets a $ 10 million a year contract. 23:48 And then the guy that gave it to her got a presidential pardon somehow. So public service is a sacrifice. 23:54 It's not to use the public office for private gain. 23:59 And, you know, the best way. 24:01 To end up in a socialist country is to push crony capitalism, because that will take all these young people. 24:08 They're going to choose Mindami over a crony capitalist any day of the week. 24:13 So let's now listen to the victory lap as of this morning. So that's what's playing out yesterday. He comes out this morning. He didn't technically know there was going to be a bloodbath when he went that hard. And now there's a bloodbath. And here's what he's saying. 24:26 Let's just be clear about what happened last night. This is close to an extinction level event for Republicans in many parts of the country, as we have seen probably in the last hundred years. 24:40 In January. 24:41 when everyone in office leaves who are either term limited or got voted out, of the 10 largest states in this union, only one state will have Republican control of their state, the state of Florida. 24:59 Mark Halperin, what was he seeing that other people didn't recognize? 25:04 Or maybe to your point, you're saying they did understand it, just nobody wanted to go against the president. Is that the dynamics? 25:09 Yeah, I think that's I think that's right. 25:11 But I think because look, back in the spring, every Republican strategist I talked to said, look, if the war is still going on in October, November, we're cooked. 25:19 But of course, it'll be over by then. 25:21 Yeah. 25:21 And then we got to the summer and I said, well, you told me it had to be over by the by Labor Day or you'd be cooked. You're like, oh, yeah, it's got to end by Labor Day. And then, of course, it didn't end. Ron DeSantis there, a very politically skillful 25:35 guy who I'm sure looks back at his presidential campaign and says that was not his highest and best performance. 25:41 He's doing two things at once. 25:42 He's operating as a political strategist, a political pundit, but he's also got the debate lines he'd use against J.D. 25:49 Vance if they were running against each other for president, basically saying all this stuff is super unpopular and I can't figure out why the White House would be for it. 25:59 And so the 2028 line to me, I want to test this theory out for you, is that you have to have some type of populism that is divorced from MAGA, but is also not Hawk. Well, Hawk is just the wrong word, but it's also not, it's not the Republican establishment, 26:15 but it's not going to be able to be MAGA either. 26:16 Vice President Vance is obviously out right now with like a 300 word Bill Ackman style post on the election results that a lot of the right-wing group chats I've seen so far, I think is very clever, but It can't get around. You'll remember when he was in that 26:30 town hall with Tony DiCoppo and DiCoppo asked him about corruption in the Trump administration. He said, I haven't seen it. 26:36 I don't know. 26:37 I mean, is that an opening for DeSantis big time? 26:40 Potentially it is, you know, but it will play out if if if J.D. Vance or Marco Rubio, if they want to run for president and and and Governor DeSantis runs and he wants to play this bag of tricks. 26:56 They're going to have to decide what the strategy is for doing that. They just come back at his negatives. 27:00 Do they quit the. 27:01 Administration or distance themselves from the administration? Do they change the story? Do they nod the facts? 27:06 I don't know. What I do know is that the populist DeSantis argument on the laundry list of issues he laid out there is going to be potent in the hands of someone like him with a record of legislative and executive accomplishment. and where he can talk his way 27:23 right onto the right side of issues where the president's currently on the wrong side. 27:27 Mark Halperin, two-way. Next up, Substack. We were so lucky to get a slice of your time today. 27:31 Great to see you, Emily. Thank you so much for hosting me. 27:34 Well, fall is finally here. Thank goodness. If you want to feel your best heading into the colder months, because they're basically upon us, holiday season's upon us. And that means not just like bundling up and crossing your fingers 27:45 and hoping you don't get sick. That actually starts with your gut. So cold and flu season is now right around the corner. It feels like everyone around me is starting to get sick, like left and right. Here in DC, there's a lot of stuff going around. Let me tell 27:57 you that. September hit, I got back into a routine. 28:00 I'm still in this routine. The one habit that can make the biggest difference for you is this, cowboy colostrum. 28:06 If you start taking it, you might realize that the bloat you experience in your gut every single day that you think is normal goes away. You might notice less bloating. 28:15 You might notice better digestion, clearer skin, and your hair actually looking thicker and fuller I like to mix the vanilla into coffee. I like to mix the strawberry into a glass of milk. It tastes really good. Cowboy is a true first day whole colostrum. It's made in America 28:30 from 100% American grass fed cows with no artificial flavors or fillers. Their clinical study found that 83% of participants reported improved gut health and 79% experienced less bloating and inflammation. 28:42 Who doesn't want that? For a limited time, our listeners get up to 25% off their entire order. Just head to cowboycolostrum.com slash afterparty and use code afterparty at checkout. 28:51 That's 25% off when you use code afterparty. at cowboycolostrum.com slash afterparty. We are so lucky to have another great guest here today. I'm so excited to be joined by Roy Teixeira, of course, of the American Enterprise Institute, where 29:04 he's a fellow, also an author of really important books related to this exact subject we're discussing as we all digest the midterm results. And Roy, it occurs to me, I just pulled up your bio. It occurs to me, did you do your dissertation on voter turnout? 29:17 I did. Yes. 29:19 What a day for you. We're looking right now at, it turned out that was around 50% of the electorate. 29:25 So just give me your take on what do you think as somebody who studied where Democrats went wrong for so many years, what went right? 29:33 Well, I mean, I think what went right for them is Trump. 29:38 I mean, I think none of this happens without the cataclysmic failure of the first two years of the Trump administration, capped off by the Iran war. I think these results are, you know, like 90%, you know, screw Trump. Why didn't he fix the cost of living? You know, this is 29:57 completely messed up. and 10% pretty good candidates. So yeah, I think that's what really drives the results, the historically lopsided results and the high turnout. I mean, one thing would be interesting, Emily, is to see when people dig 30:11 into the numbers, how much of this turnout is really, I guess, in midterm elections always have less turnout, but there's differential drop-off between presidential. So if the drop-off among Trump voters was way higher, than among Democratic voters. That 30:31 would actually kind of plug into the results and explain part of it, at least. 30:35 And I wouldn't be surprised if that happened. 30:37 I'm sure there's a certain amount of vote switching among Trump voters who just decided to vote Democratic this time. 30:42 But I think a lot of them probably just didn't show up. But again, we'll have to wait and see how the data falls out and all this. But bottom line, this is a thermostatic reaction against the Trump administration. And it's kind of like Trump was like Wile E. 30:58 Coyote. 30:58 He was like running off the cliff and running off the cliff. 31:01 And, you know, his legs kept on going and then whoops, you know, nothing but thin air and down the whole thing went. 31:09 Yeah. 31:09 So I wanted to ask you about this. point Tom Lamas made, I think this was on the NBC News broadcast last night about socialism, because on the cultural issues, you've been such a student and I think a really helpful critic of where Democrats, like the previous version of 31:23 James Tallarico, were going on some of these issues. But of course, he ran away from a lot of that. 31:27 Gas was really high. Those issues fell to the back burner of Americans' concerns because they were worried about being able to live paycheck to paycheck. Here's what Tom Lamas said about socialism. 31:38 You talked about Miami-Dade in that House race. Take a look at what this looks like in the Senate race. Again, this is a massive, massive piece of political real estate here. 31:46 Trump had won here by 11 points in 2024. You have 70% Hispanic county. 31:51 Trump had won here. 31:52 By 11 points in 2024. And now, in the early vote there, Nixon with a 10-point advantage. That is a shift currently of 21 points. 32:00 This is incredible out of Miami-Dade just a few years ago. 32:02 And still to this day, really, the word socialist is a bad word in Miami-Dade County for Venezuelan Americans, for Cuban Americans. To see kind of this vote shift like this with these numbers, it is stunning. There's still 30 percent of the vote still out. We've got to wait 32:15 and see what happens. But Republicans can't like what. 32:17 They're seeing right now. 32:19 And Roy, as all these votes are getting counted, it's looking like Abdul El-Sayed won by a giant margin endorsed by Bernie Sanders. Bernie Sanders campaigned with him. Angie Nixon in Florida appears to have come within striking distance of 32:31 the Republican candidate. What do you make of this? 32:34 Yeah, no, it's fascinating. 32:35 Angie Nixon, as is known, is a DSA stalwart, really left in a variety of different ways that it's totally off the reservation. But It turns out when people are pissed off at the incumbent party, just calling someone a socialist, even if they are, just. 32:53 Isn't that effective. 32:54 I mean, I think Republicans have been suffering under the delusion that if they simply point out a lot of the crazy stuff that some of these candidates have said, at least in the past, or point out that they're socialist or quasi-socialist or close to socialist, that's going to 33:10 be enough to rescue them in an election where people think that They've totally screwed things up and haven't delivered on what they promised. 33:17 And the countries, I mean, look, when. 33:21 Trump got elected, he promised to fix the economy, make life affordable, and bring things back to normal. 33:28 None of this happened. 33:29 None. 33:29 Zero. 33:30 I mean, it's been a complete, if I may use a technical term, clusterfuck. So you can't escape from that just by saying, my opponent, even if it's true, or even if it's true. that they, like Tallarico, said all 33:45 this weird, weird stuff a few years ago. In this environment, candidates, I mean, obviously, Angie Nixon lost, but someone like Tallarico is able to do what I call the minimum and necessary heterodoxy, to associate himself from some of his previous statements, 34:03 reassure swing voters. He'd be crazy, but he's not as crazy as he was. And I hate Ken Paxton. I'm going to vote for Tallarico. I think they ran some good campaigns. But again, absent the overall national environment, I think none of this is really possible. 34:21 So you don't necessarily read into this a socialist mandate from Democrat voters. I mean, we would be remiss if we didn't point out that Adam. 34:28 Hamilton- No, I think some socialists will read a socialist mandate into this election, but I think it's not correct. 34:34 I mean, if you look at someone like Al-Said and some of the other more progressive candidates, they actually underperformed the shift, right? The candidates who did the best were those who at least tried to code as moderate in terms of the shift relative to 2024. 34:50 So even though I. 34:51 Think, well, Bernie Sanders is already on record as saying, this just shows that the American people are ready for big, bold, progressive action on Medicare for all and a long list of things. Greg Kassar, who's head of the House Progressive Caucus before the election said, we're. 35:07 Going to do great. 35:08 And I just want to be I just want to be passing so many things. And then he had a list of things they're going to vote on every week. 35:15 So the debate will rage in Democratic circles about, OK, how do we handle this majority we now have in the next two years of the lame duck Trump administration? 35:27 Do we try to basically let our freak flag wave high and try to sort of put forward before the American people all this groovy stuff we want to do? 35:38 That's very progressive? 35:40 Or do we like be very responsible and just put some things out there that, you know, like let's restore the Medicaid cuts and let's have Trump veto them. I mean, just, you know, step by step, try to really remind people 35:53 we're the responsible party. We're the moderate party. You don't need to be scared of us. We're not going to go back to the Biden era. But will that really happen? 36:03 I've got my doubts. 36:05 And it's certainly it'll be a vigorous debate and struggle. 36:08 And let's stay focused on what Democrats did right. Give Dems their flowers here for a moment, because this clip of Abdul El-Sayed was flagged by my editor over at Unheard, Saurabh Amari. And Saurabh's pointing out, if we can put 36:22 Saurabh's post up on the screen just to download this before we play the clip, Trump in 2020, this is a Trump quote from 2020, quote, We've spent $ 8 trillion in the Middle East and we're not fixing our roads in this country. How stupid, how stupid is it? We're 36:35 not fixing our tunnels, our bridges, our roads, our hospitals, our schools. It's crazy. Here's Abdul El-Sayed. 36:42 It shouldn't be this hard. 36:45 Shouldn't be this hard in the richest, most powerful country in the world to afford to take a gas. 36:50 Shouldn't be this hard to pay your rent or your mortgage. 36:53 Should not be this hard to buy a second bag of groceries. 36:57 Shouldn't be this hard to. 36:58 See a doctor. And it shouldn't be this hard. 37:01 To pay your taxes and know that. 37:03 That money is going to be spent on you and your kids instead of dropping bombs on somebody else and their kids. 37:09 Yeah, you tell them, Abdul. Really? 37:14 Yeah, no, it's just like populism's alive and well, though the center of gravity may be shifting to the Democratic Party from the Republican Party. I mean, we live in a populist era where people think the system is broken and hasn't delivered. They think a lot of money is 37:28 being wasted on stuff that is not doing them a bit of good. Trump promised to stop all that. 37:34 He didn't. And now Democrats are picking up the baton. 37:38 And the fact that Al-Said would sound like this, and I think Democrats like him will sound like this, just, I think, underscores the difficulty the Democrats will have not to overreach, to try to project a moderate image, to try to be the responsible party. 37:55 Because I think a lot of. 37:59 Democratic politicians want to fan the flames of populism. Why aren't we fixing everything here with all the money we spend there? And that's a nice rhetorical campaign pitch. But what does it mean in reality? How do you do that when you don't have a trifecta? You don't have 38:19 the president. You're just going to be in Congress for a couple of years, and then the ramp up immediately has already begun, really, to the 2028 election. presidential nominating contest. 38:28 I mean, how do you position yourself within that? Is what America, American public really wants, this sort of reverse populism, right? 38:39 Not the right populism, but the left populism. Not Trump, but, you know, AOC or AOC light or whatever. So I think that's really, to me, that's going to be the most interesting thing to watch. Well, I'm also interested in how the Republicans process all this. because I got a 38:55 lot to process. But, you know, how does this debate play out? And I know my moderate friends in the Democratic Party are, basically, they feel like they have all the talking points, but they have the talking points. But do they have the wind at their back? Do they 39:10 have the energy? Do they have the big mo, as George W. Bush used to, George H.W. Bush used to put it? 39:16 So I don't know. It'll be fascinating to see how this all shakes out. It is. 39:22 It's such a wild cauldron of different things happening on the left where you have James Tallarico running as kind of a quote unquote moderate, but with populist rhetoric talking about how this is bottom up, not top down. 39:34 Not left and right. Yeah, it's vertical. Bottom versus the top. 39:37 Same thing across like these key races. You're the same thing from Adam Hamilton. You're the same thing from Abdul El-Sayed. 39:42 You're the same thing, even in Ohio from, uh, Amy Acton from Sherrod Brown. I mean, Roy, I'm going to go ahead and guess that you've known Sherrod Brown in the past. What do you make of him coming back after Ohio is ground zero for the MAGA coalition? It 39:58 produces JD Vance. It produces Bernie Marino and then Sherrod Brown comes back. 40:03 Yeah, no Sherrod, uh, You can't keep a good man down. 40:06 How can we miss you if you won't go away? 40:09 So no, he ran a smart campaign. Obviously, he's by nature, by history, a populist. 40:16 And he played into that very well. 40:18 He actually less so than some other candidates felt obliged to take ostentatiously, at least relatively moderate social stances. He mostly left that stuff alone. But yeah, I think he spoke. 40:32 He knows Ohio. 40:33 Voters very well. 40:35 And he understands, I think, maybe better than a lot of Democrats why they might have gone over to Trump. 40:40 And he basically tried to sort of, you know, pitch him as not exactly the real Trump. 40:47 But I mean, that guy is a big fake. He said he was a populist. He's not. I am. 40:51 I'm going to fix stuff. You know, Trump and the Republicans can't be trusted. You know, and he even picked up on classic, what have become new classic populist tropes like the Epstein class and all that kind of stuff. 41:04 which is extremely popular across Democratic candidates. So yeah, I mean, does this mean Ohio's now not a blue state, not a red state anymore? 41:15 I'm not so sure about that. 41:16 But it does mean, I mean, one lesson I take away from all of this, Emily, is we are in a very volatile era. Coalitions are intrinsically very unstable. Voters' loyalties are very unstable. And the mistake the Trump administration 41:31 made and their acolytes made is thinking, hey, we had this great election in 24. 41:35 They're buying what we're selling. 41:38 And basically, we just have to press the accelerator and everything will be fine. 41:43 And not true. 41:44 Those loyalties were very lightly held. Those votes were very soft for Trump. And I think the votes for the Democrats are probably in this election, and many of them are very, very soft. I mean, are Hispanics now back to being a loyal two-to-one Democratic group or 70-30? I'm 42:00 not so sure about that, but I think a lot of Democrats will interpret it that way. 42:05 You know, one of the things I was wrong about or underestimated was I think you and I both believed that because we talked about before that cultural questions would be important for somebody like Tallarico, that immigration would be 42:16 important for somebody like Abdul El-Sayed. And what I underestimated was the power of them being able to turn the page and basically say, I'm not accepting the premise of this question. You know, Tallarico said, here, I changed my mind. 42:30 Annie Andrews said, here, I changed my mind. Amy Acton said, here, I changed my mind. That's what was happening in Iowa with Turek. They all just did their straight-to-camera ad, said, I changed my mind. And then with Abdul El-Sayed, who 42:40 didn't really say he changed his mind, he just flipped the page on defund the police, on immigration. He said he granted the premise on immigration, and they were able to successfully convince voters that they weren't crazy on the border. 42:53 And voters were more easily persuaded to put trans stuff or culture stuff, defund the police in the back burner with crime rates going down, with the Trump administration putting out a lot of policies that have shifted the debate 43:04 on trans issues in the direction that most voters agree with. 43:07 So they were just able to turn the page and say, I'm not going to talk about that. I'm going to talk about what billionaires are doing to our politics. And that worked. 43:14 Yes, yes, it did work. 43:16 I mean, I think that there's no question that the Democrats underlying, at least in my view, Their underlying positions in a lot of these issues have not really changed much. 43:27 I think basically they took a little bit off the top. 43:30 They made their views less scary. They memory holed a lot of them. And I think voters were in a mood to accept that. They just wanted to be told that you're not as crazy as you once were. And, you know, I want to take out my ire on 43:45 Trump and the Republicans. And so, therefore, I'm willing to listen to what you have to say. That's what I mean by the minimum necessary heterodoxy. But I think the underlying positions of the Democrats on a wide variety of hot button issues from immigration to climate to race to 44:00 gender and law enforcement. 44:04 I don't think they really change that much. I mean, they're really pretty similar. 44:08 You go look at the things that candidates, successful candidates have said, that's really the pattern. Some toning down. of their basic positions that are in fact consistent with the positions of the National Democratic Party, but not a renouncing or 180 degree change. 44:27 Or anything like that. There are no sister soldier moments here. 44:31 There's sort of tweaks and adjustments. 44:33 I mean, it's all very carefully calibrated in a technical and it worked. And it worked because in this environment, people were willing to let it work. They were willing to let, if you pivot away from being asked about trans stuff, Voters say, yeah, fine, you know, that's not 44:48 my number one issue anyway, even if they personally still think Democrats are batshit crazy on trans stuff. So, yeah, I think that culture is really important, as we know. 44:59 These issues, you know, help define the image of a party, can sort of put a ceiling on their long-run support. 45:06 But I think in the short run, I think it turned out not to matter that much in this election because so many, the wind was blowing so hard stiffly in their favor, that even being, you know, continuing to have an image of being quite left on a lot 45:23 of issues that voters were not, didn't really hurt them. 45:26 And if you look at the, there was some times polling that was done that showed most voters in like a lot of these swing states or states where the Democrats wound up doing really well in the Senate races, the candidates themselves were viewed as being not too left, but the party. 45:42 Was viewed as being too left. Oh, great point. 45:44 More people believe the Democrats were too left than believe the Republicans were too right in a place like Ohio or Kansas or whatever. So I think that image is still with them. And in a different political environment, it will actually hurt them in a sort of tangible way. 46:01 But this was just a great election for that not the matter. And I think Republicans have to take some lessons from this. Yes, the Democrats are too far to the left. 46:11 Yes. 46:12 They're culturally out of step with the American people. But just pointing that out and harping on those issues is not going to be enough to get voters to ignore the. 46:22 Fact they think you completely fucked up. I'm just sorry. 46:25 That's the way it is. That's politics. Yeah. 46:29 And my Monday morning quarterbacking, by the way, Wesleyan does the study of the top ad topics. And for Republicans, the top ad topic was taxes. And then I think third was was actually trans issues. But immigration was like 46:41 seven percent of ads during the period Wesleyan studied. I mean, to me, Monday morning quarterbacking, it seems like every single not every single but many Republican ads. should have been a class-centric messaging on, yes, Abdullah Assad and James Tallarico 46:55 made it tough for Republicans to message this, but it seems to me that would have been a much more devastating message to say, do they really want a closed border? 47:03 What are they really going to do when they get, like, they did not plant that seed. 47:05 Yeah, that's a mystery, isn't it? I mean, that was one of the most successful things Trump did. 47:09 And yet, they didn't really talk about it. And voters, I mean, the exit polls actually showed that, you know, how pro-democratic electorate this was. that they still trusted the Republican Party more in immigration than the Democrats. And mostly 47:24 that's about border security. People hated a lot of the crazy ICE raids, and that really hurt the Republicans and Trump. 47:31 But the underlying idea, who can actually, who is serious about securing the border and doing something about illegal immigration? 47:39 It's not at all clear that Democrats are, and it's pretty clear that Republicans, in fact, do roll that way. 47:47 And that was a big step, but they didn't talk about it. So this is like one of the big mysteries. 47:52 If you do something and you win, talk about it rather than maybe hanging out at the reflecting pool and doing the weave. 48:02 I'm kind of honored to get to tell you all about a brand that actually stands up for women, XXXY Athletic. 48:07 In a market that's full of brands making empty promises, they stand out as the only high-performance athletic apparel brand dedicated to protecting fair competition for female athletes at every single level. Their stuff is genuinely really good. It's not 48:21 just a bold slogan. It's a core conviction that drives everything they create. Their versatile all-sport training collection is purposefully engineered for those brutal, intense workouts that leave you completely 48:30 exhausted on the floor. We're talking ultra-lightweight, quick-dry, moisture-wicking fabrics designed for maximum durability. They seamlessly stretch and move with your body through every demanding run, heavy lift, and high-energy 48:41 class without riding up or losing shape. And when it's finally time to rest and recharge, their premium fearless fleece collection has you completely covered. Featuring insanely soft hoodies, classic crewnecks, 48:52 and flattering wide leg sweats, it's ideal for chilly morning routines, busy afternoon errands, or just relaxing comfortably on the couch, all while taking a proud stand for female sports. And let me tell you, that's not a gimmick. These guys 49:04 are fantastic and their clothes are fantastic too. They're very high quality. They're excellent. I cannot recommend them enough. So whether you're training hard or recovering in comfort, wear gear that feels great and stands for something that matters. Head 49:16 to xx-xyathletics.com and use code Emily. at checkout for 20% off. 49:22 Show them some love. Let's talk about if Democrats are on the precipice of doing something very wrong, because a lot of Republicans right now are talking about one particular word, overreach, because of course, after 2018, Dems won a great midterm 49:36 victory there. They won the presidency back in 2020. there was lawfare that ended up clearly you see Trump usurping DeSantis in the polling as soon as Alvin Bragg files that suit against Trump. The lawfare does eventually work in 49:50 Trump's favor, but Trump isn't on the ballot anymore. And we're hearing takes like this from Sean Hannity about overreach. 49:56 Let's listen in. 49:57 I promise you one thing is a certainty. Democrats will overreach They will take this as a mandate that it is not meant to be. America is not voting for socialism slash communism. It is the typical cycle that we would normally see in the midterm. I think two years 50:16 from now, we're going to have a very interesting night. 50:20 Not so typical when you're losing Kansas to South Carolina. 50:22 Yeah, not so typical. I don't know about that, Sean. 50:26 Yeah, I think that's right. Because what he's missing there, I think, is that Democrats actually learned real lessons at this point. Actually, to the Wall Street Journal, Ken Martin, chair of the DNC yesterday, said one of the things 50:36 they did differently was give leash. to people like Annie Andrews and Amy Acton and James Tallarico and Abdul El-Sayed to run away from unpopular positions in the states where they were running. Adam Hamilton being perhaps the best example 50:49 of this. Mega church pastor, former Republican unseats Roger Marshall, who nobody saw going anywhere. Cindy Hyde-Smith is in a tough race in the state of Mississippi. 50:58 Well, it looks like she's still going to win. 51:00 Yeah, it does. It does. 51:01 But holy smokes. I mean, that should not be moving close. Yeah. 51:04 And so, Roy, I'm not so sure. I mean, I think, of course, Democrats will overreach, just as any party that wins an election like this will. But I'm not so sure we're about to see 2020 or 2022 again, or 2018 or 2020 again. 51:15 Yeah, I'm not sure either. I mean, I think that they will overreach in some ways. I think the appetite is huge to hold the Republicans' feet to the fire and officials to the fire, maybe impeach Trump again. But even if that doesn't go over so well with the 51:35 public and they're really not that interested in it, Um, I think in this current environment, it's not going to be enough to disenchant, uh, voters with the Democrats just for that reason. I think a lot more, I mean, the real question is what can Republicans do to rehabilitate 51:52 their image and govern better, uh, you know, sort of get rid of a lot of these sort of crazy crusades they're on and just basically make the Republicans, you know, and this was difficult with Trump in office, let's face it. Um, 52:06 you know, a party that actually can govern responsibly well and effectively. And, you know, this prices thing is kind of a problem. And, you know, they just they don't want to walk off the cliff like Wiley Coyote did in the second half of the Trump term. So, yeah, 52:23 I think lawfare will be out there. I think on net it will probably not help the Democrats. But I think the idea it's going to undercut them the way it did before is probably not right. And I think, yeah, Democrats have learned some lessons, and I think they may, 52:39 history may not repeat itself as it did in the run-up after 2018, though I think that dynamic is real, and it may still take effect. I mean, will all the candidates be herded to the left in the primary, in sort of a context of primary debates and contests, right? 52:55 That's different than appealing to actual voters in an actual election. 53:01 That matters. I mean, this is about the Democrats talking to themselves and most active Democrats talking to themselves and making their voices heard with. 53:09 Who they want to be their candidate. 53:11 And it's not at all clear to me that a lot of these kinds of voters, the more active voters, skew educated and so on. 53:18 I mean, do they really want to run on the basis of moderation and responsible government? I don't know. 53:26 You know, I think it can be questioned. There was a political poll that came out right before the election that showed that they asked, about people's Democrats' attitudes, both moderates and progressives, if the Democrats had a small victory or large victory, big victory. 53:41 And the big victory sort. 53:43 Of question elicited more interest in running progressive candidates, right? 53:47 I mean, it's a big difference, both around moderate and progressive Democrats. So I think that's some indication that people will see this big victory, not as a signal to be even more moderate, but instead as a signal to like, you know, basically press the accelerator. 54:06 Yeah. 54:06 I mean, what do people learn? What do parties learn big lessons? Basically when they're defeated. 54:11 Right. 54:11 You know, I mean, the Democrats have changed. 54:14 Some since 2024. And that was a big defeat. They were trying to absorb the lessons. Maybe they didn't go far enough. I don't think they went far enough, but it. 54:21 Was good enough. Right. You know, when the Democrats lost to Reagan and then H.W. Bush, they learned lessons. 54:29 And that's how you get. 54:30 Lessons from from getting their ass kicked. by and large. 54:34 They don't necessarily learn lessons as well from when they do well. I mean, look at Trump. 54:41 I mean, day one, big, unexpectedly big in 2024. Did they learn lessons about it, about what to do and what not to do? 54:50 Not really. They just confirmed their priors. 54:54 Now, actually, on this point for Republicans, I'm so glad you brought this up. It Caroline Sunshine worked for the Trump White House at one point, was on Fox News digesting what happened. And this was an interesting bit of analysis from Caroline Sunshine. 55:08 President Trump didn't win. 55:10 No. 55:11 President Trump's message won. Unfortunately, he wasn't the messenger. His staff and his team allowed his winning message in 2024 to be co-opted by his opposition. 55:21 All of the. 55:22 Candidates on the Dem side that won tonight, we were spending time talking about Hassan Piker and Al-Sayed. Hassan Piker and Al-Sayed were spending time talking to voters about how, hey, you know what, maybe you don't want to send all 55:34 your money to overseas wars and have it come back home and work hard for you here. Hey, we want to take on corruption. Hey, we want to make the economy work for you. That's President Trump's message. That is the Trump doctrine. And Republicans tonight allowed that message to 55:47 get co-opted by insincere actors. 55:52 Well, and Trump allowed it to be co-opted by doing meme coin rug polls, the schemes that his sons are up to, Jared Kushner's misadventures, Howard Lutnick's deep ties in the crypto world that could benefit his family, all of these different things swirling around it. 56:08 Yeah, that was such a confusing message from that woman. 56:11 It was kind of like Trump's message would have won, but ignore the fact that Trump was a president and dominated everything. And instead, if they'd somehow titrated, somehow if they had been like Hassan Piker instead of Trump, but of course, Trump isn't as. 56:28 I mean, to me, it's very confused. This is like. 56:32 That's what I wanted to ask you about is the Hassan Piker moment where she says Republicans are out there talking about Hassan Piker. And by the way, that is true. 56:37 They were constantly in Michigan, in particularly, talking ad nauseum about Hassan Piker. Not without reason, of course. Abdul El-Sayed had campaigned with him. Hassan Piker had that quote that is very famous about America deserving 9-11, which he later 56:51 tried to walk back. It's a whole thing. But anyway, the point is Republicans were very focused on trying to tie some of these candidates to Hassan Piker. And it just seems to have fallen flat. Her point about Democrats not taking the bait on Hassan Piker was pretty interesting, 57:04 I thought. 57:06 Yeah, well, again, this gets back to something we were talking about earlier. This was not an election and not an electoral environment where it was going to be that effective to point out socialism, Pikerism, transism, whatever the things 57:20 that Democrats or Democratic candidates were associated with that voters tend not to like. Simply harping on that endlessly was not going to do you much good. I mean, I don't know what would have done a lot of good, frankly, in this environment, but it would have been better at 57:36 least to take on the kinds of issues that Al-Said himself was talking about rather than just say piker, piker, piker. 57:45 I don't think there's any question this was, you know, I mean, at the margin, how much difference. 57:49 Was this going to make? I don't know, you know, but it certainly wasn't the maximizing strategy. And I think I mean, I don't understand how she can let Trump off the hook on this. This is like crazy. I mean, going back to that clip, you know, if they just, 58:04 if they just done, you know, Trump's message, what is Trump's message? Are you kidding me? 58:09 He talks all the time about these kinds of socialism, communism, Hassan Piker. You know, the idea that he simply is the head of the Republican party and he simply wants to talk about, you know, sort of kitchen table issues and, and the corrupt. 58:26 I just, it's wrong. 58:29 So, and I think it's interesting because if they, if Republicans choose to respond to this shellacking in that way, I don't think they'll get very far very fast, right? 58:43 I mean, it's sort of like a circle the wagons kind of thing. 58:46 The problem wasn't Trump and his administration and how much people detested it. The problem was rather the candidates who didn't correctly. 58:54 Implement the message. And I think that's just utter nonsense. 59:00 No, my colleague Crystal Ball made a really interesting point last night and this morning about how Zahra Mamdani won the primary against Andrew Cuomo. Nobody expected to see it happen. 59:09 They thought they could still take him down in the general. 59:11 But Abigail Spanberger and Mikey Sherrill, who were running in the off years, started talking suddenly after that primary victory that shocked Democrats about one thing, affordability. That's where you really hear the affordability words start creeping up. And they 59:23 were pivoting away from the culture stuff that Winston Sears in Virginia was trying to pin on Spanberger. And after that, you see Democrats... Looking to some smarter messaging, smarter candidates. 59:33 So I'm kind of just floating Crystal's point here, which is that Zoran changed the Democratic Party to this like nuts and bolts. It's a very like super socialist type mentality that, you know, you can you can get so 59:45 you can squeeze socialism into the American bloodstream, political bloodstream, as it has been in the past. especially during like Gilded Age time periods when you are fixing potholes and doing that type of thing. And it does kind of 59:58 seem like a lot of Democrats saw that and said, oh, I can do that. 60:02 Right. 60:03 Well, it's pretty easy to talk about affordability. 60:05 I mean, this is like a tailor-made slogan for this particular era and how people were perceiving the economy and the Trump administration, Republicans in general. 60:16 Yeah, people want affordability. 60:18 Now, how to actually deliver affordability is difficult. It's not clear how you're actually going to do it, but it doesn't matter for purposes of campaigning. If you promise people that you understand the problems they're facing economically, you understand 60:33 the problems for the cost of living, you are going to make life more affordable. And you say that over and over and over again, and you essentially affordability wash all your other positions with the affordability kind of label. 60:45 then I think that totally works in this context. The problem is, you know, they're the dog. 60:51 That caught the bus. Okay. 60:53 You know, you have some power. How are you going to make life more affordable? And we'll see if they're able to convince people they have the right ideas here. 61:01 But I think affordability was a great idea. And as you said, it provided a way to avoid talking about other things that were considerably less popular. I think the jury's still out on how well the Mamdami administration is going to go over, over time. But I think certainly 61:18 initially it's been successful. And I think that the sort of the concept that we should just make life affordable and make government more effective is actually like a pretty good idea. 61:29 Delivering it, I think, is harder. 61:32 But I think that did Mamdami by himself really start this cascade of affordability Democrats? 61:41 Maybe. But I think he was pushing on an open door if he did. 61:45 That's a good way to put it. Roy Teixeira, I'm really grateful we got a slice of your time in the middle of this crazy 24-hour midterm, historic midterm election cycle. 61:54 Thank you. Thank you, sir. 61:56 Thanks for having me. 61:58 $ 28 may not sound like much, but to a scared mother considering abortion, it can help provide something incredibly important, a real opportunity to pause and see her baby for the first time. Today, a woman facing an unexpected pregnancy 62:10 can reach for her phone, search for abortion pills, connect with a provider online, and have the pills delivered directly to her home. She can move from fear toward abortion incredibly quickly. But your gift can help create another opportunity. 62:23 For just $ 28, you can help provide a free ultrasound through a pre-born network clinic. There, a woman can see her baby, talk with people who will listen to what she's facing, receive compassionate support, and consider another choice before 62:35 abortion becomes her answer. And when women see their babies through an ultrasound at a pre-born network clinic, 80% choose life. 62:40 $ 28 can help provide one ultrasound. $ 280 can help provide 10. 62:47 Reach her before the pill does with your strongest gift today. 62:51 Dial pound 250 and say the keyword baby. That's pound 250 baby. Or visit preborn.com slash Emily. That's preborn.com slash Emily. 62:59 All gifts are tax deductible and preborn is a five-star rated charity. Well, as we sit here right now recording this, Vice President J.D. Vance just posted his reaction to the midterm bloodbath, and it is rocketing around Washington, let me 63:12 tell you. Someone's sitting here right now, it is rocketing through conservative group chats. Everyone is talking about what he posted. 63:19 And he actually mentions, interestingly, in this post about the causes, what could happen afterwards, he mentions at one point, this is maybe the most interesting line, he says. 63:33 While many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict, it turns out her political advice was sound. And it's true. Rachel's statement from June, she was co-hosting, or I'm sorry, she was 63:46 substitute hosting for Jesse Waters, randomly went viral on Monday again. 63:50 And she was calling for a, it was during the MOU debate. She was calling for the memorandum of understanding not to be sabotaged and to come to a peaceful resolution with Iran. And people who are very much in the pro-Israel camp And the people who are skeptics of 64:05 those who are skeptics of Israel, not to get too meta, were dunking on Rachel Campos Duffy. There was an op-ed in the Washington Examiner saying Fox News has a Rachel Campos Duffy problem. Now, this was, of course, not all 64:15 about that. It's just interesting that J.D. mentioned that because what he's pointing in his post, because where he's pointing the finger is actually at people who were criticizing critics of the war, right-wing critics of the war, who now 64:28 appear to have been much more in touch with the average American and with many Trump voters who They were the ones, J.D. is arguing, who were dividing Republican voters. 64:37 And so much of the conversation going into this was the other way around. Vance, another very interesting line here is he says, our voters showed up and the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats. 64:51 Those four reasons, he says, are end the war, focus on cost of living, inflation, put America first and change our relationship with Israel. So he's actually acknowledging here what Politico found going into election night. is that nine percent 65:02 of republicans planned to vote for democrats and only two percent of democrats plan to vote for republicans and that's where the rust belt seems to have been the that's where jd vance is cut from he wins his ohio senate seat in 2022 on this coalition of mega voters 65:17 which erupted shattered in the results on monday as we've already talked about today they lost non-college there was a seven swing seven point swing non-college 11 point swing with men Rural voters swung 11 points towards Democrats. People with 65:32 incomes under $ 50, 000 swung 14 towards Democrats. Independent voters swung 13 towards Democrats, according to the right of center pollster Patrick Ruffini's study of exit polls. So how are other folks reacting to this? Well, let's take a look at 65:47 Dana Lash, who I've always liked, by the way. She posted on X, well, the foreign op on Iran were. 65:54 Great job, Qatari assets. Enjoy your Doha vacation houses. That is not a very thinly veiled, or I should say it is a very thinly veiled attack on Tucker Carlson. 66:04 Joel Berry, he is Jeremy Boring's producer, formerly of the Babylon Beast, someone I've also liked, said, my prediction is that neocons will blame the paleocons and the paleocons will blame the neocons. But the real story is that a 66:15 sophisticated foreign demoralization campaign led by the likes of Jack Posobiec, Steve Bannon, Alexander Dugan, Candace and Tucker viciously cracked up the only coalition that has been preventing total electoral collapse 66:27 for decades, conservative evangelicals. I can speak to that, by the way, a bit as a conservative evangelical. James Lindsay, the same trashcasters and influencers who are already telling you the Iran war cost Trump the midterms, never once even 66:40 slightly tried to make the case to Republican voters why it might be necessary. They just burned Trump at every turn over it and now blame him for the damage. 66:49 It's worth noting taking a walk down memory lane, not for the sake of dunking, and I really mean this, to what Mark Levin and Ben Shapiro were saying about the electoral effect of the war from September. Here's the clip. 67:03 When we look at. 67:03 The Fox survey, Iran is a 4% issue with the American people. So whatever happens in the midterms, it doesn't appear that Iran's going to drive anything one way or another. 67:17 What's your take on this? 67:19 I think that's exactly right. 67:21 I mean, the exit polls on this are resoundingly clear. 67:24 The vice president is resounding and clear on this. Even Trump himself, when he was calling into Fox and Politico on election night, was saying, yeah, he waffled back and forth on this a little bit. He at one point said, oh, people agree with me on the war. At another point, 67:36 he said, yeah, they don't like the war. They didn't like high prices because of the war, that sort of thing. 67:40 But what you see, if you look at, I mean, Wall Street Journal, Steve Moore, other people are already saying free trade was the real winner of tonight. But I just want to point out, we've mentioned this here on our show over and over again. There was a St. 67:52 Louis Fed analysis of tariff-related inflation. They did a great chart on this back in August, studying the effects year over year, June 2025 to June 2026. I am again reading here from the St. Louis Fed, not from some MAGA blogger that said, our estimates show that the effect 68:08 of tariffs on inflation appears to have leveled off in the last few months or even declined slightly. Inflation, what do you see on that graph? It goes right up. 68:15 After February 2026, after clearly studying, after tariff-related inflation going to, I believe it's 0.67 of that total. So data centers, how about that? Let's go to data centers. Ryan Gerdusky points out, there were 41 ballot measures to pass data 68:37 center moratoriums. It passed in every district, every district. NBC News' exit poll says, found that data centers and AI was a crucial or major factor for many, many, many people's voting decisions, a majority of people's voting decisions heading 68:56 into the polls yesterday. They found the same thing about the war. They found the same thing about cost of living. 69:01 74% said the war was crucial or a major factor. 69:04 89% said the cost of living was crucial or a major factor. 90% said corruption was crucial or a major factor. Now, that's where the electoral future for J.D. Vance gets tough. 69:13 We all remember, because we covered it here, that brutal clip of him on with Tony DeCoppo, CBS, at a town hall where DeCoppo asked him point blank about corruption. 69:21 And J.D. Vance said, well, he hasn't really seen much of that. That's the thing that, as clever as Vance's post is, could be the albatross around his neck heading into 2028, heading into 2027, as he is the vice president, he presides over the Senate. So all of this is 69:35 to say, if You are listening to a quote unquote podcaster who criticizes other podcasters. All podcasters are liable to be out of touch, by the way, just like all political analysts are, because most Americans don't consume the news 69:48 like political analysts. So, yes, podcasters are out of touch, whether they're pro-Trump, anti-Trump, MAGA, anti-MAGA. That is a fair criticism, and I take it in stride with full understanding that is absolutely accurate. But if you're listening to somebody who 70:01 says the podcasters were not influential, they were always out of touch, they were always in their own bubble, but also now says podcasters cost Republicans the midterms, despite all of the data that podcasters were just reflecting. And I say, 70:14 quote unquote, podcasters, because we know which podcasters they're talking about. 70:18 They're talking about Tucker. Some of them are talking about Megan. 70:20 Some of them are probably talking about breaking points about Sager and me. Of course, they're talking about some of the weirdo podcasters, too. And that's, you know, that's I'm sure somebody like Candace or whomever. But all this is 70:30 to say that is not consistent. You have to reconcile those two points. There's a genuine public backlash. They do not agree with the position on war. They do not agree with the economy. And to blame the podcasters and to do it in such an inconsistent way is a 70:45 cop out. And I feel genuinely sorry for anybody who has that deep of a misunderstanding of the average voter, even the average conservative American. and does this for a living. 70:55 They were wrong. And they should say they were wrong. 70:58 I have been wrong before. I think I had my map and breaking points keeping Texas. I said it was an agonizing decision, Republicans keeping Texas, because of where the polling was in Texas and South Carolina. And as I talked about here on today's show, that second path that 71:10 they were underestimating, Republicans flipping for Democrats, Republicans who are hard to poll flipping for Democrats. That was the second path we laid out here for weeks. We're one of the only people talking about that potential path because those 71:24 are exactly the types of voters that J.D. Vance knows well who were under-polled, underrepresented in surveys, and it looks like pollsters were over-weighting them to try to get a more accurate picture and underestimating the extent to which those 71:35 exact same rural voters, those exact same lower middle class, middle class voters could flip from Trump to Democrats. That's exactly what was happening. Because people don't like the war. 71:47 They don't like the costs. They don't like data centers and AI. They don't like corruption. And Trump to them represents a lot of that right now. Republicans represent a lot of that right now. I would just caution people about what was being prognosticated when it comes to the 72:02 war in the months ahead. And I think there's so much room for genuine humility. If you have anything that you think I need to be humbled by, by all means, email me, emily at devilmycaremedia.com. Every single Friday, I answer 72:13 every single question that you all send in. We're going to do it again this Friday, and I'm looking forward to it. But in all seriousness... It's okay. It's okay to understand that most Americans are against this war. You could blame Trump for messaging the war poorly. But if 72:27 you're doing everything not to lay blame at the feet of Donald Trump, whether it's for starting the war in the first place, prosecuting the war poorly, or messaging the war poorly, you're just missing the point. Thank you everyone so much for tuning in. I appreciate it. We're of 72:42 course going to be back here on Friday with more on the podcast side. You have to sub on Apple or Spotify, wherever you get your podcasts to hear our Friday episodes are audio only and they go for a long time. Otherwise we'll be back on YouTube Monday, Wednesday. 72:54 Thanks everyone. 72:54 See you soon.
Community discussion