Show full transcript 0:25 Find out how they started something bigger than themselves. 0:27 and listen wherever you get your podcasts. 0:30 Starting a business can seem like a daunting task, 0:33 unless you have a partner like Shopify. 0:35 They have the tools you need to start and grow your business. 0:39 From designing a website, to marketing, to selling, and beyond, 0:42 Shopify can help with everything you need. 0:44 There's a reason millions of companies like Mattel, 0:46 Heinz, and Allbirds continue to trust and use them. 0:49 With Shopify on your side, turn your big business idea into... 0:53 Sign up for your $1 per month trial at Shopify.com slash special offer. 0:59 Ready? 1:00 I was born ready. 1:18 Welcome to advisory opinions. 1:20 I'm Sarah Isgur. 1:21 That's David French, and we are here live at the University of Virginia. 1:32 That's very, very well done. 1:35 That was well done. 1:36 Yes, appreciate that. 1:37 David, it is one of the most beautiful days that you can imagine in Charlottesville, Virginia, 1:41 and I don't know why any of these people are inside. 1:44 Well, I can say I've been to Charlottesville many times. 1:48 I spent a month here during my JAG advanced course 1:51 and never had a bad day. 1:53 Oh, so maybe every day is beautiful. 1:55 I mean, they're just taking it for granted. 1:56 UVA law students are always known 1:58 as the happiest law students in America. 2:00 Beer and softball. 2:01 Yes, beer and softball, joy, and this is no exception. 2:06 Okay, well, before we get started after this, 2:08 David and I are taking one of our famous road trips 2:10 back to DC and so I thought it was weird 2:13 when we were asked what we wanted for lunch 2:15 and David ordered the tuna fish sandwich 2:19 and I said something like bold move for a guy 2:22 who's gonna be sitting in a car with me for three hours 2:24 and David was like, what do you mean? 2:26 Is tuna fish known to be smelly? 2:28 And I'm just wondering like am I crazy? 2:30 Like everyone knows you don't eat tuna fish 2:32 like right before you go on a date or something, right? 2:34 Like that would be, okay, they're nodding. 2:36 This is the thing, it is known. 2:38 What were you thinking? 2:39 I like tuna. 2:41 That was the full subject and that was the full extent of the thought. 2:45 Okay, well, we'll see how this goes. I'll report back on the next pod, I guess. 2:50 So this past week, I was at the Federalist Society Convention in D.C. 2:57 The vibe at the convention is always really, really interesting. 3:01 So let's see, this was my 21st year at the National Convention. 3:07 really that doesn't feel possible I've never been I I went to my first one in 3:14 2005 okay so some big ones that I remember tend to revolve around 3:21 presidential elections like after 2012 mind you I just come off the Romney 3:25 campaign but like so maybe I was projecting a bit but that was a sad 3:30 FedSoc convention after 2016 was a very happy FedSoc convention like 3:37 like, manic-happy, you know, against expectations, everyone thought Hillary Clinton was going 3:41 to win, and that she was going to not only appoint a replacement to Justice Scalia, but 3:45 withdraw Garland's nomination and appoint whoever the worst human fed sock could imagine to 3:52 fill Justice Scalia's seat. 3:53 So for that expectation to be turned on its head was just like, my memory of it was 3:58 people running around like, you know, minions, just going like running into walls and 4:03 bouncing and happy, and it was crazy. 4:05 Okay, so you would expect for the vibe this year to be a little bit down, maybe not full 4:14 2012 down, but like down, right? 4:18 There's no more judges that are getting confirmed for two years. 4:20 We're done. 4:22 That really wasn't the vibe. 4:24 The vibe was actually pretty upbeat. 4:26 Now it was the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and everything was 4:31 decorated very America 250, and there were lots of, you know, fun things that Fedsoc 4:37 did for that anniversary, but still, it was quite upbeat. 4:41 Yeah, well it's interesting because for those who don't know anything about Fedsoc, and 4:46 this is something we've talked about for a long time, is Fedsoc does not equal MAGA. 4:52 There are people within Fedsoc who are very much dedicated to President Trump and 4:57 In his particular view of the law, and Stephen Miller in his particular view of the law, 5:02 they do exist. 5:03 They're FedSoc people who tried to help steal the election in 2020. 5:07 But it is not an adjunct of the Republican Party. 5:11 It does not have the ethos of the Republican Party. 5:14 It is its own thing. 5:16 And that's a point that we've been making for a long time on this podcast. 5:21 And it keeps being borne out and proven out time and time again that it is its 5:24 own thing and the people within FedSoc cannot be so easily pigeon-holed and yet it continually 5:30 is pigeon-holed and is continually treated as an adjunct of MAGA. 5:35 All right. 5:36 Well, for this podcast, we are going to talk about three topics before we open it up 5:40 to question. 5:41 One, we have a new cert grant. 5:44 We need like a sound for this podcast when there's a cert grant. 5:48 Would it be like a dong or a little song? 5:51 in a wonderful life when the angel gets its wings. 5:54 Every time a bell rings, it rhymes, literally. 5:57 Every time a bell rings, an angel gets its wings. 5:59 Yeah, okay, yes, that's correct. 6:00 You think a little bell, like, 6:02 cert grant, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding. 6:04 A little more masculine than that. 6:06 Okay. Yeah. 6:07 Okay, well, we have a cert grant, 6:09 another immigration cert grant to talk about. 6:12 Then congressional subpoenas, what are they good for? 6:16 And are they criminal or something? 6:17 And last, the typo or not typo in Scalia's hella opinion is a dangerous and unusual or 6:26 dangerous or unusual. 6:29 Let's dive in to this circumvent. 6:31 So in Mullen versus refugee and immigrant center for education and legal services, this comes 6:38 from Donald Trump's January 20, 2025 proclamation declaring that quote, an invasion is ongoing 6:45 going at the southern border and suspending the entry 6:48 of non-citizens, quote, engaged in the invasion. 6:52 Trump also indicated that such non-citizens 6:54 could no longer seek protections such as asylum 6:57 that would allow them to remain in the country. 7:00 The Department of Homeland Security 7:01 then issued guidance that, among other things, 7:04 barred any non-citizens from applying for asylum. 7:08 The guidance also indicated that anyone 7:10 who entered the country despite Trump's suspension 7:12 of entry would be quickly removed 7:14 without some of the procedural protections by law. 7:17 So this case has worked its way up. 7:19 We had a two to one opinion at the DC Circuit 7:21 with Judge Walker concurring in part 7:24 and dissenting in part on some of this. 7:26 I think maybe more importantly though, 7:29 we're getting a lot of these right now, 7:31 so it's, let's say we've already had, 7:34 or rather we've already had the grant, 7:36 so we're going to hear a challenge 7:39 to the Trump administration's practice 7:40 of deporting immigrants to countries 7:42 that are not identified in their removal orders 7:45 and it's policy of detaining immigrants 7:47 who are apprehended within the United States 7:49 without the opportunity for a hearing. 7:53 David, for this case, they granted cert 7:58 on two of the three questions 8:00 that the Solicitor General's Office requested. 8:03 One is just whether that executive order is lawful. 8:06 Thumbs up, thumbs down. 8:08 But two is whether, 8:10 and I know everyone knows this by heart, 8:11 but whether 8 USC 1252 F1 bars the class-wide relief entered by the district court, and that 8:19 one's kind of a little bit interesting because Congress literally passes this statute that says, 8:25 regardless of the nature of the action or claim or of the identity of the party or parties 8:30 bringing the action, no court other than the Supreme Court shall have jurisdiction or authority 8:37 to enjoin or restrain the operation of the law, 8:42 this immigration law, other than with respect 8:46 to the application of such provisions 8:48 to an individual alien against whom proceedings 8:50 under such part have been initiated. 8:52 In layman's terms, no nationwide injunction, 8:55 no class actions to enjoin this part of the law 9:00 except the Supreme Court. 9:02 So did the district court error 9:04 and granting class-wide relief, like did they even have 9:08 the authority to do that, or did Congress take that away? 9:12 David. 9:13 Yes. 9:14 We have talked a lot about how much Trump has lost 9:17 at the Supreme Court on his major policy initiatives 9:20 to recite them again, tariffs federalizing 9:23 the National Guard, birthright citizenship, 9:26 several of the election cases, most recently, 9:29 I mean, there was the gerrymandering case, 9:31 There was the... 9:33 Mississippi absentee ballot. 9:35 ...malen ballot won. 9:37 The most recent mail-in ballot, EO, all of that, whatever. 9:43 There's an area that he's doing pretty well on, though, 9:45 and it's immigration. 9:46 Yeah. 9:47 The Supreme Court has taken all three of these cases, 9:50 all three of them, the Trump administration, 9:51 lost in the lower court. 9:53 And I have to say, my just like, these are complicated 9:56 and we'll cover them a lot more extensively 9:58 in the legal questions after oral argument. 10:01 But I got to say my gut reaction is I think he's going to win some of these and maybe all 10:07 of them on some of these technical grounds like Congress said you couldn't do class action 10:13 relief that that is the equivalent of enjoining the operation of the law. 10:17 Now the two judges on the DC circuit said no, no, because this is an executive order, 10:23 it's not the operation of the law, but the executive order is putting into effect 10:27 act as far as the legal argument goes, the operation of the law, eh? 10:33 So backing up for a minute, you and I have talked a lot back in the Biden era about how 10:40 much can a president acting just alone, how much can a president close the border? 10:46 And there are really sort of two potential answers to that. 10:49 Potential answer number one was not at all because the relevant congressional statutes 10:56 just simply don't give that level of authority to a president. 10:59 So if a president does attempt to close the border using 11:02 executive orders, regulations, et cetera, 11:05 that the INA is going to stand as a barrier to that. 11:08 And so even if a president tried, 11:12 they could not fully close the border, at least not 11:14 to the extent that Trump has, that ultimately, 11:17 even if he has temporary success with that, 11:19 that was going to ultimately be overturned by the Supreme 11:22 Court. 11:23 That's sort of area category one. 11:25 And category two is, well, a president does have the power 11:29 if Trump wins these cases. 11:32 A president would have the power to close the border, 11:35 but then the status of the border would be almost entirely 11:38 dependent on the president. 11:40 It would not be a lasting legal rule 11:44 that the next president would be bound by, 11:46 so that you would have essentially every four years 11:50 unless the INA is amended or there are other statutes 11:53 passed you would literally have hanging in the balance is what how open or 11:58 closed will the board border be and I think what you're probably going to end 12:03 up with is some version of the second that I'm with you I think the Supreme 12:08 Court is going to rule for this Trump administration on all or most with the 12:15 one case that I'm most skeptical that the administration will win will be 12:19 the one involving bond and bond hearings for. 12:22 Exactly. 12:23 That's the one that I think you're 12:24 going to see the Trump administration, in my view, 12:27 like this is preliminary before we've heard the oral arguments. 12:29 If they're going to lose one, they're likely going to lose that one. 12:33 This case is very, very interesting, 12:36 and it is very interesting precisely 12:38 because the statute under which it is being decided 12:41 is a freaking mess. 12:44 It's just an absolute mess. 12:46 I mean, if people ask me, what 12:47 What is one of the more poorly drafted internally contradictory, tough to interpret statutes 12:53 in the federal code? 12:54 I'm going to go with the INA, because one of the things that it does is it provides very 13:01 precise procedures, very precise standards, and then in other parts of the statute basically 13:08 gives the president opt-outs on the president's sole discretion. 13:12 So, for example, if you're going to go back to the Muslim ban case in Trump 1.0, you had 13:18 a statute that says the president can refuse entry to any alien or any class of aliens. 13:27 That's a big, broad statute. 13:30 So in that circumstance, does he can he say, no, asylees? 13:36 No, I'm not going to do it, even though there is this whole other set of statutes 13:40 saying, this is how you deal with asylum. This is how asylum is 13:44 adjudicated. Can he just go over that and around that and just 13:48 say no asylum? And that's what Judge Walker in the DC Circuit 13:53 basically said below was, look, if he can just gut the whole 13:57 thing, then that large power includes a lot of lesser powers 14:02 within it. And so that to me has always been at the end of 14:06 to Trump too, we're going to have an answer 14:09 for how much can a president close the border? 14:12 I think we're gonna end up with that answer 14:13 and it's largely gonna be the president can 14:17 but not in the lasting fashion 14:20 that the next president can undo everything 14:22 that the current president does. 14:25 And just worth noting, 14:27 and Congress can change the law at any point. 14:29 At any time, yes. 14:31 Because I think it's very hard 14:35 to see this as anything than a pure, messy 14:40 statutory interpretation case with, as you said, 14:44 like layers of different statutory provisions 14:46 interacting with each other. 14:48 All right, well, we've had the tech term, 14:52 we've had the Trump term, the executive power term. 14:55 This is sure shaping up to feel like the immigration term. 14:59 Yeah, and just to give you an insight 15:01 as to how much of a mess this all is, 15:03 Previous cases that we have talked about have dealt with, 15:07 for example, statutory language that says that certain 15:10 categories of undocumented immigrants shall be detained. 15:15 In other words, they must be detained. 15:18 But then Congress never authorized the funding 15:21 to build the detention facilities. 15:24 So compliance with the statute becomes literally impossible 15:28 because there's no place to detain the people 15:31 that the statute says they shall be detained in. 15:34 And so it's, this is just one aspect 15:37 of just peeling an onion of complexity 15:39 and internal contradictions 15:41 and punts to the president for his own power that... 15:45 On a super partisan issue 15:46 that divides the parties very deeply 15:48 and therefore feels like a win or loss 15:51 on a quasi-election basis, but in the courts. 15:54 Yes. 15:55 Okay, speaking of partisanship in the courts, 16:00 Counselor to the President and White House Counsel Will Scharf, disclosure, who I knew 16:07 from law school, wrote a letter to Congressman Garcia. 16:12 I will read portions of this letter. 16:15 I write to remind you of the foundational limits that the Constitution imposes on congressional 16:19 investigations and subpoenas, which you and members of the new Congress have invinced 16:24 a clear intent to transgress. 16:26 The Supreme Court has held that investigations conducted solely for the personal grandisement 16:31 of the investigators or to punish those investigated are indefensible. 16:37 Congressional investigations must further a legitimate legislative task. 16:41 Congress cannot employ them to exercise powers of criminal prosecution assigned to the executive 16:47 and the judiciary. 16:48 We are monitoring the abusive and capricious threats that are now proliferating from 16:52 Democratic legislators who seek to abuse the legislative process and to intimidate and interfere 16:58 with the lawful functioning of government. Several have compared their subpoena pledges to handing 17:03 out candy, Mardi Gras beads, and enough paper to level forests. Your own statements are rather 17:09 shocking because they exhibit all of these malicious and improper features. When Speaker 17:13 Johnson warned that you would do nothing all day every day, every hour of the day, but go 17:17 after the president, his family, his cabinet, and donors, 17:20 and figures in business and industry 17:23 for the sake of a dangerous political game 17:25 for their own benefit, you replied, he's not wrong. 17:28 When you launched your lawyer up campaign, 17:31 you prominently featured an image of a courtroom gavel 17:34 set to the tune of a song called The End. 17:37 It goes on like that for some amount of time. 17:39 We're skipping, we're skipping. 17:42 Beyond being inconsistent with the clear, 17:44 well-recognized constitutional limitations 17:46 on your investigative functions. 17:49 And here's the important part, David. 17:52 Threats to executive branch officials 17:54 designed to deter them from public service 17:57 or process designed merely to abuse 18:00 or instill fear in the recipient 18:03 may cross the line into blatant criminality. 18:07 And issuing unlawful subpoenas 18:09 with the intention of depriving citizens 18:10 of their constitutional rights and privileges 18:12 may warrant further investigation, et cetera, et cetera. 18:16 Thanks, William O'Sharf. 18:20 It reminds me of that Hamilton, your obedient servant. 18:25 Yeah, exactly. 18:27 I prefer your obedient servant to just thanks. 18:32 Okay, so that's the White House Council. 18:35 A day later, we get a very similar vibe 18:38 coming from the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District 18:41 of Texas, Aaron Wrights. 18:45 He sends this letter to Senator Blumenthal. 18:49 In recent weeks, you have threatened citizens 18:51 for associating themselves with the president 18:53 and other public officials. 18:55 Yada, yada, yada. 18:56 I therefore right to formally give you notice 18:58 of your obligation to preserve all documents, 19:00 communication, and other electronically stored 19:02 information relevant to your intent 19:04 to deprive citizens of their core constitutional rights 19:06 and violation of 18 USC 241 and 242. 19:10 We keep talking about that statute, David, 19:12 But this is a conspiracy against rights. 19:19 You are obliged to preserve all this. 19:20 Failure to do so may result in sanctions. 19:23 This demand applies to you and your staff 19:24 and everything else, et cetera. 19:27 Okay, so David, we're flying fast and loose here, right? 19:30 Garcia's saying lawyer up. 19:31 The White House Council is saying 19:33 this could go into criminality. 19:36 US attorneys are saying preserve all your documents 19:38 because we're gonna investigate you 19:40 and potentially bring charges under a criminal statute 19:44 and Senator Blumenthal answers 19:46 and is like, go jump off a bridge. 19:49 So I thought we should spend a few minutes 19:52 on what actually the law says in this arena 19:55 and what it does not say. 19:56 Yeah, yeah. 19:58 So first of all, 20:00 let's read from Article I of the Constitution 20:02 where we always shall start. 20:06 This is Article I, so it's Congress, House and Senate. 20:09 that they shall, they being members of those bodies, 20:13 they shall in all cases, except treason, felony, 20:17 and breach of the peace, be privileged from arrest 20:20 during their attendance at the session 20:22 of their respective houses, 20:24 and in going to and returning from the same. 20:26 You can't pull them over for speeding 20:28 if they're on their way to vote 20:29 because that could be used to prevent them 20:31 from getting to the vote for partisan purposes. 20:33 Which is a reason to run for Congress. 20:34 Probably is actually, for me, certainly. 20:36 And for any speech or debate in either house, 20:41 they shall not be questioned in any other place. 20:45 Now, if you wanna read that text really, really precisely, 20:50 it says for any speech in, I in the well of the Senate, 20:56 in either house, they shall not be questioned. 20:59 So if you're Senator Blumenthal 21:01 and you sent your you know statement out I don't know from your house outside 21:09 your house you were speaking to reporters or I don't know you were maybe 21:14 outside the White House talking to reporters does the speech and debate 21:18 clause apply to things Senator Blumensthal says that are not in his 21:23 office in the US Senate or in the well of the Senate yes it does but that is 21:29 not in the text of the Constitution, it has been broadly construed to effectuate the legislative 21:35 purpose of the legislature. 21:36 So when I say yes that it does, I'm referring to the construction of the provision. 21:43 I'm not referring to the literal text of the provision, which the Supreme Court could 21:48 disagree with the broad construction of it, but we have recent authority on this. 21:53 So seems unlikely seems more like it means if you are speaking as a US senator 21:59 That you are privileged versus if you go out and defame someone not as a senator, but you're like, you know 22:04 My brother-in-law is a real piece of shit like that's well, that wouldn't be defamatory, but you know, I 22:12 Guess we do have that. We do have an issue 22:14 I mean remember Nancy mace made some allegations against individuals in on on the house floor that were related to and 22:24 related to claims that she had been personally sexually assaulted or sexually abused. 22:30 And so the question was, wait a minute, if you're making a personal claim on the house floor, 22:34 is that going to be subject to speech and debate? But she was very smart to do this 22:38 on the house floor. So you're going to be about in as core protection as you can possibly get. 22:44 I mean, and that one says for any speech in either house. 22:47 Yes. Yes. 22:48 I think you can say whatever you want in the house floor, defamatory or otherwise. 22:52 A court deadline has a way of focusing everyone's attention. 22:56 There's a document to finish, a client waiting for an answer, 22:59 and a clock that doesn't care what else is happening. 23:01 But if you run a small law firm, the deadline on the case isn't the only one that matters. 23:06 Payday still comes around. 23:08 A good system lets the team stay focused on the clients 23:10 without treating every payroll or HR detail like an emergency. 23:14 That's where Gusto comes in. 23:16 Gusto is online payroll and benefit software built for small businesses. 23:20 It's all in one remote friendly and incredibly easy to use so you can pay, hire, onboard 23:25 and support your team from anywhere. 23:28 Gusto helps simplify payroll with an automatic tax filing and unlimited payroll runs for 23:34 one monthly price without hidden fees and surprises. 23:37 Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash advisory and get three months free when you run 23:44 your first payroll. 23:45 That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash advisory. 23:49 One more time, gusto.com slash advisory. 23:53 On advisory opinions, we spend a lot of time asking what happens when a rule meets real 23:57 life. 23:58 The interesting question often isn't what should happen. 24:01 It's what happens when things don't go according to plan. 24:04 That's a useful question at home too. 24:06 What financial support would you want in place if you weren't there? 24:09 Ethos helps make one part of that question easier to act on. 24:12 You can explore life insurance through ethos entirely online. 24:15 Get a quote in seconds, apply in minutes, and potentially receive coverage the same day. 24:21 There's no medical exam. You just answer a few health questions online. 24:24 Coverage can go up to $3 million, and some policies are available for as low as $30 a month. 24:30 No policy can account for every outcome, of course, but taking an uncomfortable hypothetical 24:34 seriously can help provide financial security for the people who rely on you. 24:39 Take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through ethos. 24:42 Get your free quote at ethos.com slash A-O. That's E-T-H-O-S dot com slash A-O. 24:51 Application times may vary, rates may vary. 24:53 Have you ever wondered how movements start? 24:55 I'm Ashley Seaford, host of Into the Mix, a Ben and Jerry's podcast about joy and 25:00 justice. 25:00 This season, we're talking to unexpected, progressive heroes who found purpose in 25:05 unexpected places. 25:06 People like Marley Diaz, making sure every kid sees themselves in books. 25:10 Kyle Mesteth, a native skateboarder building a movement for kids nationwide. 25:15 Joy Alataqun, whose music moves from protest to daily commute. 25:18 Find out how they started something bigger than themselves. 25:21 And listen wherever you get your podcast. 25:25 Let's talk about subpoenas real quick. 25:27 We'll circle back to the criminal stuff in lawsuits, but this is the Mazar's case. 25:32 So in Trump won, if you remember several House committees that at that point had 25:37 democratic majorities, sent subpoenas for Trump's tax records, and they sent them to his accounting 25:42 firms, basically. These were consolidated cases. The case was decided 7-2 with Justices Thomas and 25:50 Alito dissenting, and they basically come up with a four-factor test of when Congress can send 25:57 subpoenas. They rejected absolute presidential immunity, and they rejected a valid legislative 26:04 purpose test on sort of those two sides of the lenient to very very strict side. 26:11 Here's the four parts. One, whether the asserted legislative purpose warrants the 26:15 significant step of involving the president and his papers. Two, whether the subpoena is no 26:21 broader than reasonably necessary to support Congress's legislative objective. Three, whether 26:25 the evidence of Congress's legislative purpose is supported by a detailed showing that the 26:29 records are necessary and for the nature and extent of the burdens imposed on the 26:34 president by the subpoenas. God, I love balancing tasks because you leave at the 26:37 end of the balancing test and you're like, I don't, I have no idea where we are. 26:41 But it's also important to note this was for the president's personal papers. If 26:45 you're dealing with, if you're dealing with say, the executive, the official 26:49 papers of the executive branch of government, in other words internal 26:53 memoranda regarding say immigration enforcement or ice crackdowns in 26:57 Minneapolis or whatever you can imagine is going to be investigated it's going 27:01 to be a it's going to be a slightly different formulation. Maybe, but I think 27:08 the punchline of Mazars is that Congressional Democrats, this is Adam 27:13 White over at AEI wrote this part, Congressional Democrats will need to 27:17 explain upfront what actual legislative or constitutional amendments 27:21 might plausibly be informed by the information that they're trying to 27:24 to obtain, two, if Democrats want the information 27:28 not for possible legislation or constitutional amendments 27:31 but for possible impeachments, 27:34 they'll need to signal that upfront. 27:37 In Mazar's, guys, this whole time, oh no, oh no, David. 27:42 Where are we pronouncing it? 27:43 We're incorrectly wrong. 27:44 And I just saw the former CEO of Mazar's. 27:47 I just, and we had a good laugh over it. 27:50 And then I just did it for the last 10 minutes. 27:52 Mazars? Yeah, that's the one. Okay. Oh god. Apologies to everyone working at 28:00 Mazars who's listening to this podcast. My bad. Okay, in Mazars Congress 28:06 specifically declined to say that subpoenas were for impeachment as justices 28:11 Alito and Thomas both mentioned in their dissents and as Judge Naomi Rao noted 28:15 in the DC circuits round of litigation the incoming Democratic leaders 28:19 have downplayed calls for impeaching Trump, but the committee's imminent subpoenas might 28:24 force the I word back into headlines, wrote Adam. 28:28 So I think this is really important, right? 28:30 Like, if they use the magic I word, I think their subpoenas kind of sail through. 28:36 Totally. 28:37 But if they use the magic I word, they also undermine everything that democratic leadership 28:41 actually wants out of the next two years. 28:43 Well, it's interesting because I think if they use the I word regarding Trump, 28:47 it's going to undermine what the Democratic leadership wants. 28:50 If it's the I word regarding Hexeth, 28:53 or if it's the I word regarding Hexeth, 28:56 if it's impeachment regarding Hexeth, 29:00 or if it's impeachment regarding Blanche, 29:01 I think there's a lot more openness to that idea. 29:05 And in fact, they probably will take another run 29:07 at the Hexeth impeachment 29:08 with the new Congress would be my guess. 29:11 But my bottom line on reading Mazzars, 29:14 and also there's a long line of Supreme Court cases 29:18 that have said that the power of inquiry 29:20 is indispensable to Congress's legislative power. 29:24 And so this goes back to 1927, McGrane versus Darity. 29:29 We are of the opinion that the power of inquiry 29:31 with process to enforce it 29:33 is an essential and appropriate auxiliary 29:36 to the executive function. 29:37 It was so regarded and employed in American legislatures 29:40 before the Constitution was framed and ratified 29:43 Both Houses of Congress took this view of it early in their history, the House of Representatives 29:47 with the approving votes of Mr. Madison and other members dropping the Madison bomb there, 29:54 and other members whose service in the convention which framed the Constitution gives special 29:58 significance to their action, and both Houses have employed the power accordingly up to 30:03 the present time. 30:04 So I think that the formula will be this. 30:07 if the Democratic committee heads or whatever have a subpoena 30:13 and they put in the subpoena as part of our consideration 30:17 of the potential legal reforms regarding ethics 30:20 and government, or as part of our consideration 30:23 regarding potential legal reforms 30:24 regarding the treatment of detainees, 30:27 or as part of our efforts to determine 30:29 if P.Texeth committed high crimes or misdemeanors, 30:32 if you have that upfront language 30:34 language and the subpoena is tied to that language, it is going to be very, very, very 30:40 difficult for the administration to resist. 30:43 And by the way, impossible for the administration to prosecute. 30:48 Okay. 30:49 So, just to rehash, the administration wants to potentially prosecute members of the Congress. 30:57 Congress wants to send subpoenas to members of the administration and potentially third 31:04 parties who would hold documents for the administration, like in the Mazar's case or whatever. 31:10 Okay, I've got two more that I want to touch on. 31:13 One, this comes from an OLC opinion that was published in August 2026, like this couple 31:20 months ago, but we didn't cover it from Assistant Attorney General Elliot Geiser. 31:25 This is how OLC opinions are written. 31:27 They're basically written as almost quasi-court opinions, 31:31 but as advisory opinion, court opinions. 31:34 Anyway, this is a normal way that they read. 31:38 The president's authority to withhold 31:40 certain sensitive information for the public good, 31:42 today referred to as executive privilege, 31:44 is peculiar to our system of separation of powers 31:47 and derives from the supremacy of each branch 31:49 within its own assigned areas of constitutional duties. 31:52 You have asked whether that privilege, and particularly the presidential communications component of it, permits the president to protect communications that he has with advisors who do not work for the executive branch. 32:05 Determining whether the privilege applies to any specific communication would require additional information about the facts and circumstances surrounding that communication. 32:13 But as a general matter, executive privilege can apply to presidential communications with 32:18 private advisors, so long as the communications, one, relate to official presidential decision-making, 32:24 two, involve or reflect communications with the president or his direct advisors, 32:29 and three, are confidential. This is a 21-page memo. It is widely seen as one of the most 32:35 expansive readings of executive privilege of all time. So, again... 32:39 Also known as the Elon Musk Starlink Suppression Mimo, yeah. 32:44 Yeah, so there's criminal liability, 32:48 they're sending subpoenas in general, 32:50 then the executive branch parries back 32:52 with executive privilege, which they are gonna say applies 32:55 to anyone the president has ever talked to 32:57 about being president in any way. 33:00 So then we end up in my fourth thing 33:03 that I wanna touch on, which is, 33:05 Okay, so how do you enforce that Congress, right? 33:09 We're doing this back and forth. 33:11 And Ruth Bader Ginsburg, back in 2015, 33:16 in a case, it's kind of a funny little case. 33:18 Obviously this was before we started our podcast, 33:20 but it was about whether Arizona's initiative 33:25 to end partisan gerrymandering 33:27 and create a bipartisan redistricting commission 33:30 could be lawfully done 33:32 because the Constitution says 33:33 as each legislature shall determine? 33:36 So it's a fun little 2015 case. 33:38 Okay, footnote 12, because standing, 33:41 that was a big question of whether the Arizona legislature 33:43 had standing about this. 33:45 Footnote 12, RBG. 33:47 The case before us does not touch or concern 33:50 the question whether Congress has standing 33:52 to bring a suit against the president. 33:55 There is no federal analog to Arizona's initiative power 33:57 and a suit between Congress and the president 33:59 would raise separation of powers concerns absent here. 34:02 The court's standing analysis we have noted has been especially rigorous when reaching 34:07 the merits of the dispute, when reaching the merits of the dispute would force the court 34:11 to decide whether an action taken by one of the two other branches of the federal government 34:15 was unconstitutional. 34:18 So then fast forward, in Trump 1, we have the McGahn case, and we have the House lawsuit 34:24 on the border wall money case. 34:27 McGahn's ends up settling. 34:29 The House border wall case, interestingly, does go to the Supreme Court, but during the 34:36 Biden administration. 34:38 So the Trump administration loses at the circuit court on the standing issue, right? 34:44 The House has standing to sue under its subpoena power, to enforce its subpoena. 34:50 And then the Biden administration takes over, and they argue, the Biden administration 34:57 aware of political pendulum swings 34:59 sided with the Trump administration 35:01 and argued that the House alone 35:03 should not be allowed to sue the president. 35:05 Elizabeth Prelogger, the Solicitor General, 35:07 told the justices that letting the House sue 35:10 would inject the federal courts 35:11 into fundamentally political disputes 35:13 and upset the balance of power 35:15 between the political branches. 35:17 The Supreme Court agreed to grant 35:19 the Biden administration's petition 35:20 and vacated the DC circuit's decision as moot. 35:24 You also, if you look back at Mazar's, 35:26 you have the Chief Justice talking a lot 35:28 about how you guys are supposed to work this out on your own. 35:31 They're supposed to be an accommodation process. 35:33 We don't really like having to decide this. 35:36 And David, you're gonna hate what I'm about to say 35:38 and I'm so pumped to say it. 35:41 And you know how in Mizzards we get this balancing test 35:43 that I said doesn't really tell you a whole lot of much 35:46 because any one of the things to balance 35:48 could end up being really heavy or light 35:51 or whatever else depending on who you are 35:52 and what you think of it. 35:55 That's what the Trump immunity case is. 35:57 This is a case where the Chief Justice is like, 36:00 you guys should have worked this out. 36:01 This is really political question. 36:03 There's an accommodation process, 36:04 but if you're really asking us, fine. 36:06 There's a four factor test and next time you come, 36:09 if you don't work it out, we're gonna apply these factors 36:11 and you don't know how they're gonna get balanced. 36:13 So, come back if you dare. 36:16 That's exactly the same as the Trump immunity decision 36:18 that you hate so much. 36:19 It's basically like. 36:20 Yes, and I don't like Mazar's either. 36:21 Like why would I think why would I find this it's basically like a look we're 36:26 not deciding at this time we're telling you how we're thinking about it and if 36:30 you come back again that's when you're gonna get the real decision and some 36:33 real law so I urge all of you to think very carefully before you come back 36:38 again the Trump immunity decision didn't decide anything just like 36:41 Mazar's didn't decide anything so you can't dislike a decision that didn't 36:45 Decide anything I can and I do 36:50 These cases are too important to be left to 36:53 at the end of the day 36:54 When you read Trump, the United States a person cannot know if bribery if a president can be prosecuted for bribery 37:02 That's a bad decision. We should be able to know if a president can be prosecuted for bribery Sarah 37:07 So sometimes I get what they're saying. It's almost like when you're in front of a federal district judge 37:13 And you have a discovery dispute 37:15 The district judge will nine times out of ten, 37:18 the magistrate judge, district judge, 37:20 nine times out of ten will give you some version 37:22 of work it out like adults. 37:24 Stop bothering me with this. 37:27 I get it at the trial court level, I get it, 37:29 and not so fond of it at the Supreme Court level, 37:32 but I think the really interesting issue is what happens 37:35 if the Trump administration just says no, 37:38 we are not going to respond to these at all. 37:42 How are we going to deal with this? 37:45 In that circumstance, the options really for Congress are limited. 37:50 You know, we have seen in two previous, at least two previous times, 37:55 we have seen contempt of Congress citations. 37:58 But then that Congress doesn't then prosecute contempt of Congress. 38:02 That is referred to a U.S. attorney. 38:04 And the U.S. attorney, oh yes, the U.S. attorney in the District of Columbia 38:08 He is absolutely going to be super eager to prosecute Trump administration officials. 38:12 No. 38:13 So we're likely to see some large-scale resistance, a lot of threats flying back and forth with 38:20 no real capacity to enforce the threats. 38:22 The U.S. attorneys who are threatening members of Congress with prosecution, those cases 38:26 that would be thrown out so quickly. 38:30 At the same time, if Congress wants to impose contempt of Congress, there's not 38:35 going to be any real enforcement mechanism. And Democrats to get information in many ways 38:40 they would have to win in 2028 and then look backwards at what records remain. It's I expect 38:48 some standoffs. Do you think Congress should be able to sue the president to enforce 38:54 It's a subpoena. 38:55 100% yes. 38:57 Really? 38:58 Yeah. 38:58 Oh yeah. 38:59 Absolutely. 39:00 What meaning is the power of inquiry? 39:03 If you can't, you don't actually have a power of inquiry, you just have an ability to ask 39:07 a question. 39:08 I have that ability, Sarah. 39:10 I hereby demand that the Trump administration release any and all documents underlying the 39:16 legal justification for circumventing Congress to go to the Oriental War. 39:22 Put a pin in that. 39:23 Do you think it needs to be passed 39:25 by a majority of the House and the Senate 39:26 or can a single House sue to enforce a subpoena? 39:30 And for that matter, can a committee sue 39:31 to enforce a subpoena? 39:32 A House, a single House. 39:34 Okay, so it has to be a majority of each House 39:37 can individually sue to support, okay. 39:40 I think I disagree. 39:42 I'm not 100% sure I disagree, 39:44 but I kind of think that's a political question. 39:48 You have the power of all sorts of other powers, 39:51 but you don't get to run to the third roommate 39:55 and have them litigate it for you. 39:58 I think, I think I don't like that. 40:01 Well, I just don't think it's a power of inquiry 40:03 unless it's enforceable. 40:05 It's not a power, it's just a question. 40:06 But then you can always deny appropriations. 40:09 An article of impeachment by itself could just say, 40:12 he refused to answer our duly signed 40:15 and issued subpoenas, the end. 40:20 Again, I, at that point, I mean, look, I can impeach, because impeachment is a political 40:25 remedy that is, it's not, it's not a legal remedy. 40:29 I can impeach for anything. 40:30 No, I know, but like I, a subpoena is issued by a court and that's why a court can hold 40:37 you in contempt and do all of the things because it is from the court itself. 40:41 A subpoena from Congress, I mean, I guess maybe what I'm getting to is it's not 40:45 a subpoena. 40:46 It's a request from Congress, and so Congress has to enforce it itself because it's not 40:51 a subpoena that's issued within Article 3. 40:54 Then it's not a power of inquiry. 40:56 Okay, then it's not a power of inquiry. 40:58 They have to back it up for something else. 41:02 What's the constitutional basis for that? 41:04 Why do you think they have a subpoena power? 41:06 Well, if you have a power to legislate, if you have a power to impeach. 41:12 But a subpoena is a court thing. 41:14 They're a legislature, so they can issue a subpoena, 41:17 but it's a Article One subpoena, like an Article One judge. 41:21 It's unconstitutional in my view, but like, whatever, 41:24 like, you can have an Article One judge imagine 41:26 in a different world where they actually did 41:27 Article One judgy things, but if it's an Article One subpoena, 41:30 maybe we need a different word for it. 41:32 And letter of inquiry. 41:34 If it were a letter of inquiry, 41:35 do you think you could enforce it in court? 41:36 I don't care what we call it 41:38 as long as it's enforceable in court. 41:41 But the idea that a legislative branch has no ability to secure documents from any member 41:51 of the executive branch of government as part of its ability to exercise its legislative 41:57 authority, including impeachment authority, strikes me as a neutering of Article 1, which 42:04 is contrary to everything that advisory opinion stands for. 42:12 Have you ever wondered how movements start? 42:14 I'm Ashley Seaford, host of Into the Mix, a Ben & Jerry's podcast about joy and justice. 42:20 This season, we're talking to unexpected, progressive heroes who found purpose in unexpected 42:25 places. 42:26 People like Marley Diaz, making sure every kid sees themselves in books. 42:30 Kyle Mesteth, a native skateboarder building a movement for kids nationwide. 42:34 Joy, a lot of Coon, whose music moves from protests to daily commute. 42:38 Find out how they started something bigger than themselves, and listen wherever you get 42:42 your podcasts. 42:42 When our first was about a year old, I thought it'd be really funny to put him in a large 42:46 shopping bag. 42:47 The picture we got is of a very confused little baby looking really adorable in this huge 42:52 bag, and it's those little moments that tend to disappear into a camera roll, even 42:57 when they're the ones we most want to remember. 42:59 over. 43:00 AuraFrames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home, where 43:04 the whole family can actually enjoy them. 43:07 AuraFrames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home. 43:11 The little moments in life are worth remembering. 43:13 You can do that with AuraFrames. 43:15 Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families, and their Black 43:20 Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year. 43:23 For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com and get up to $50 off Select Frames plus 43:28 plus an additional $5 off your order with the promo code advisory. 43:35 That's A-U-R-A-Frames.com promo code advisory. 43:39 Support the show by mentioning us a check out. 43:41 Terms and conditions apply. 43:43 Our last topic involves a New York Times piece that was headlined, How a Miss Quote by 43:50 a Supreme Court Justice Imperils Gun Restrictions. 43:53 When the Supreme Court begins weighing the constitutionality of assault weapons bans next month, 43:59 the justices will be guided by the court's own precedent. 44:01 A landmark ruling that such restrictions are allowed only if a firearm is both, quote, 44:06 dangerous and unusual, end quote. 44:09 For nearly two decades, judges across the country have invoked this language to strike 44:12 down gun control laws. 44:14 It is a pivotal legal test. 44:17 It is also based on a misquote. 44:20 Bum bum bum. 44:22 Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the majority 44:25 in the 2008 case, District of Columbia versus Heller, 44:28 attributed the quote, dangerous and unusual language 44:31 to Sir William Blackstone, an 18th century English jurist 44:34 whose writings became the basis for much of American law. 44:37 But in his seminal 1769 treatise, 44:41 commentaries on the laws of England, 44:43 Blackstone referred to weapons that were dangerous 44:45 or unusual, suggesting that a gun did not need 44:48 to be both in order to be restricted. 44:50 Okay, there was lots of OMGs about this one out there in the world. 44:56 Here's the problem, though. 44:58 That is all accurate and true, and Justice Scalia wrote and, and his citation clearly 45:05 has or in it. 45:08 But if you read the whole New York Times article, they actually do a pretty good job 45:13 of explaining why maybe this didn't matter one bit that and and or in this context 45:19 text actually refer to something quite different than what we would usually use for textual 45:23 interpretation, which is, in the literal sense, something would have to be dangerous or unusual, 45:29 like one or the other, or both, that that's not actually it. 45:33 Because dangerous and unusual predated Blackstone in other commentaries, so Scalia easily could 45:39 have cited an actual older thing that said dangerous and unusual, and that dangerous 45:45 or unusual as the either or one doesn't make any sense 45:50 in this context because all guns are dangerous. 45:54 So all guns can be banned. 45:55 Like why would you need the or unusual? 45:57 Like guns are dangerous. 45:58 That would be an implied unusually dangerous. 46:01 Right? Or yes. 46:02 And so while they're correct that many judges 46:06 have quote incorrectly cited dangerous and unusual, 46:10 many have also cited dangerous or unusual 46:12 and many have actually explained 46:14 why the distinction is actually more like dangerous and or unusual and that it is 46:22 really more about unusually dangerous. Here's, again, in the same New York Times 46:29 piece, the best translation of Blackstone's terminology, Dr. Saul Cornell, a 46:35 Second Amendment scholar and history professor at Fordham University, said, 46:39 said, would be to treat, quote, dangerous and unusual as a synonym for unusually dangerous. 46:47 So David, we have this whole piece about how Antonin Scalia might have screwed up all of 46:52 Second Amendment jurisprudence, and you know, there's lives on the line, and there's a 46:56 case this term about the assault weapons ban, and that it ends with, or actually 47:00 maybe this was totally fine and it was no big deal. 47:03 Which is it? 47:04 So, number one, I think dangerous or unusual, dangerous and unusual, I think the bottom line 47:12 is that last line you just read, unusually dangerous is going to be the way this thing 47:17 works out, unusually dangerous. 47:19 But it is once again a reason why all of this parsing of 17th century language is ridiculous. 47:25 What are we doing? 47:27 What are we doing? 47:28 I mean, look, if you have an individual right to keep in bare arms, why can't we apply 47:33 tears of scrutiny to that right, Sarah. Instead, what we're doing is diving into Blackstone 47:38 commentaries, we're diving into pre-cl- even some things that are pre-colonial about weapons 47:44 that have no resemblance in to modern weapons other than they use gunpowder. And then we're 47:53 trying to engineer, engineer a 21st century jurisprudence around a bunch of 18th century 48:00 reasoning around weapons that bear no resemblance to the current time. I much 48:05 prefer, the first part of Heller when Heller is talking about, this is an 48:10 individual right. Yes, okay, if it is an individual right then what are the 48:15 circumstances under which this individual right can be limited, perhaps 48:21 removed, what are those circumstances? Well what they did with the Second 48:25 amendment was just decided to set out sailing into this entirely new category of legal reasoning, 48:33 or mostly new category of legal reasoning, leaving behind the way that we have dealt with 48:37 individual liberty and individual rights for the last 30, 40, 50 years in creating this text 48:44 history and tradition thing that depends on ands or ores in 300-year-old documents, 48:50 and it doesn't make any sense to me, Sarah. 48:55 I've looked at it from every which way. 48:57 It doesn't make any sense to me that we are doing this, 49:02 but we are doing this, and I think at the very end of it, 49:05 it will ultimately end up being unusually dangerous 49:07 as defined by the court in its own discretion, 49:10 which means intermediate scrutiny. 49:12 Okay, we're all gonna learn a new word right now, 49:14 and we're gonna learn how to pronounce it really quickly. 49:16 You ready? 49:16 Okay. 49:19 Hendiadus. Hendiadus. 49:20 Okay. 49:21 Hendiadus. 49:22 Hendiadus. 49:23 Hendiadus. I don't know what this means. 49:25 Okay. 49:26 It is a single concept is expressed in multiple words connected by and. 49:32 So the famous example is Shakespeare's full of sound and fury, 49:36 which actually means furious sound. 49:40 So that's how dangerous and unusual or dangerous or unusual 49:44 would nevertheless mean unusually dangerous and that middle word actually doesn't matter very much. 49:49 Yeah, I know. And what are we doing? Okay. Like what are we doing? Why can't we apply 49:54 strict scrutiny to it? Okay. I had a judge recently tell me that their clerks basically were like, 50:02 oh, Sarah's not conservative anymore. And he's like, so, do you still consider yourself a 50:07 conservative? Like, I just mean this and, you know, I'm not trying to be judgy, just, 50:10 is, you know, what do you call yourself? 50:13 And I was like, well, I think that's really funny. 50:15 I would be so curious if your clerks would list out 50:17 the areas in which I am no longer conservative, 50:19 but they are. 50:21 For instance, I still want restrictive standing rules, 50:27 right? 50:28 I think standing should be like very narrow. 50:31 But a lot of people on the right now would like 50:33 broader standing. 50:35 So who's the conservative? 50:36 me who would be on the conservative side in, you know, 1985 to 2016. 50:44 Till November 1st, 2026. 50:47 Right, right. Or like someone who calls themselves conservative. 50:51 Now I don't actually have a perfect answer for that. 50:53 And I was like, but I will tell you this one thing. 50:55 There's one area in which I think I have completely shifted 51:01 versus those who call themselves conservative on the legal side have shifted. 51:05 And that is the second amendment. 51:07 And it is just, I'm not saying that this is good 51:11 or better or anything else. 51:14 But I, you know, had my first child in the summer of 2020. 51:20 Uvaldi happened shortly after that. 51:22 We taped our podcast in the hours after Uvaldi. 51:27 And I remember we had to do about like seven retakes 51:29 because I couldn't get through it. 51:32 I couldn't get through talking about it at all. 51:35 It was not ongoing, but then just, you know, the hour or two after. 51:42 And I really, I don't know where I am on the Second Amendment in terms of the legal analysis. 51:48 I don't have a perfect answer for it. 51:50 But if you want to accuse me of not being conservative anymore on something and you're 51:53 like, well, look at her Second Amendment statements, I'm like, yeah, you got me there 51:57 because man, I challenge you to be a new mom 52:02 and not be willing to revisit some of your thoughts on that. 52:06 Again, if you don't, this is not a judgment about that, 52:09 but rather, I don't have some like, 52:12 well, there's new facts on the ground 52:14 or I read this treatise. 52:16 Nope, this is just one of those examples 52:17 where my own experience really did change 52:19 my thinking on something in the law 52:21 in a way that maybe we're not supposed to 52:23 as conservatives, but I couldn't help it. 52:25 So a couple of things about Avalde, number one, did Avalde help turn Texas blue in this 52:32 sense? 52:32 Because remember, why did the right go after Bob Cornyn, Hammer and Tongs? 52:38 What was his... 52:39 John Cornyn. 52:40 You said Bob. 52:41 What did I say? 52:41 You said Bob Cornyn. 52:42 I said Bob? 52:43 Yeah. 52:43 John Cornyn. 52:44 So sorry. 52:46 John Cornyn, why did they turn on him? 52:48 The primary, the number one reason was that he voted for red flag laws. 52:54 and so which is something that I have long supported because I support 52:58 individualized determinations that a person is too dangerous to possess a 53:02 weapon but it's interesting that from that that's like the first domino that 53:08 falls and that ultimately leaves only Ted Cruz is the last statewide elected 53:13 official in Texas which I still cannot believe like we were going into the 53:19 election thinking, could Ken Paxton actually lose? 53:23 And then we ended up with like, wait a minute, 53:26 every single one of them lost led by Ken Paxton? 53:30 And this is the first domino there. 53:32 The second thing, though, I think when it comes to gun 53:36 rights, is it really, to me, if you go back 53:42 and you start to think about it in the way 53:43 that we think about other individual liberties, 53:46 we're going to be on much firmer ground because at that point we have a very 53:52 well understood what is the state interest at play what are the limitations 53:56 on the right are the limitations more drawn more narrowly or less narrowly 54:01 than they need to be drawn to protect this individual liberty this is well 54:05 trod ground and so for example as I process things like the Illinois assault 54:10 weapons ban what you're looking at there is you have number one there 54:15 what is the purpose of the right, the purpose of the right, 54:17 the fundamental purpose of it, as outlined in Heller, 54:20 which I agree with, is self-defense. 54:22 This is rooted in self-defense. 54:24 Okay, so therefore, if you have a right to self-defense, 54:28 implied within that is a right to effective self-defense. 54:31 In other words, self-defense that is going to be effective 54:33 against foreseeable threats. 54:35 And if you have a situation in which 54:38 one of those foreseeable threats 54:39 is almost always going to be a person showing up 54:41 with a semi-automatic rifle or a semi-automatic handgun, 54:46 a limitation on my ability to own a semi-automatic rifle 54:49 or a semi-automatic handgun is going to be a limitation 54:52 on my inherent right to self-defense 54:55 in a way that I'm not sure that the Constitution 54:57 can justify. 54:58 So that's kind of how I walk through it, 55:00 is what is the right, 55:04 is what is the state interest in the limitation 55:07 and how broadly is that limitation sweeping? 55:09 And that's why I've always much more inclined to the individualized determination, like the 55:15 red flag law, as opposed to the sweeping gun-based determination, which does, in fact, in some 55:21 jurisdictions leave you in a position where you are going to be outgunned by the most 55:27 foreseeable threat to your life. 55:29 And I think that that's an inappropriate legal regime, one that leads you to be 55:34 at a disadvantage in facing the most foreseeable potential threat to your life. 55:39 All right, more to come on that. 55:40 Let's take some questions from you guys. 55:42 Thank you both so much for being here. 55:44 I'm Tom, I'm a three-elp. 55:46 Broadly on the right, there's this debate 55:49 that could be framed as being processed via outcomes, right? 55:52 The former being many textualists, 55:56 proceduralists, formalists, 55:57 and on the outcome side, 55:59 maybe something along the lines 56:00 of common good constitutionalism. 56:03 I'm interested, coming out of NLC 56:05 and coming out of the midterms, 56:06 who do you think has the momentum? 56:07 and some, who do you think is winning that argument? 56:09 And though I have a pretty good sense 56:10 of where you both might come out on that, 56:13 what do you think is at stake? 56:14 What do you think in four or five years 56:16 really needs to come out of that argument? 56:20 So I think if you take the common good 56:23 constitutionalism argument as Adrian from Mule 56:25 sort of initially launches it in the Atlantic, 56:28 there's two places to go from there. 56:30 One, he means it as a complete revolution 56:32 and how legal conservatives approach legal interpretation. 56:38 By that standard, I don't think things are going very well 56:41 for the common good crowd. 56:44 On the other hand, if you think of that article 56:47 as trying to sort of move the Overton window 56:52 and have legal conservatives think about 56:54 the faults of originalism and almost as a safety valve 56:59 if you will for originalism and a lot of the pent-up 57:01 anxiety about where legal conservatism had really frustrated, particularly social conservatives, 57:10 then I think it's been very effective. 57:13 And I think that there is such a thing as process worship that is a problem. 57:21 Of course, it cannot be process for process sake. 57:24 You can have a process that leads to the gas chamber, right, like, no, but I think 57:30 this idea that process is only as good as the outcomes if I like them is juvenile. 57:39 Yeah, childish. 57:41 And in the end, I think that like a lot of these moments, legal conservatism will move 57:50 10% that way and absorb that movement. 57:55 And everyone will probably actually be better off for it, believe it or not. 57:59 Well, let me echo something. I think one thing that has been helpful about the 58:03 debate is that it has exposed that legal conservatism and originalism is a 58:08 Venn diagram. It's not a complete overlap. And there is, and if you're from my 58:13 generation, you know that because when I was a young Fed soccer in the early 58:18 1990s, originalism was one of many competing theories. By the mid, by the 58:27 2000s, originalism kind of wins the day. 58:30 The one true faith. 58:31 Yeah, by the 2000s, originalism sort of wins the day 58:35 and then originalism is legal conservatism, 58:38 that those are sort of seen as the exact same thing. 58:41 That was a very short window in reality, 58:45 that in reality there's been a lot of interesting 58:48 conversations about Justice Alito, 58:50 how originalist is Justice Alito. 58:53 Well the truth is I don't think he's 58:55 the most originalist justice of the six Republican nominated 58:58 justices. I just don't think he is. And that's not insulting 59:01 him to say that somebody isn't originalist, isn't an insult. 59:03 They have a different tweaks on the philosophy. They have 59:07 permutations in the philosophy. I think all of that is very 59:10 healthy to think through. Because what it does is it begins 59:14 to open all of our minds that maybe our legal philosophy 59:18 didn't come down from Moses on Mount Sinai that this is a 59:21 human created philosophy with strengths and weaknesses. 59:25 And I think that as we now see that originalism 59:27 is the dominant philosophy of the court, 59:29 you see that it is not a outcome machine. 59:33 It is not something like input, originalism, 59:36 get conservative outcomes. 59:37 That's just not the way it works. 59:39 And so I think that's healthy. 59:41 I think a lot of the process versus outcome debate 59:43 has been dumb in all honestly. 59:46 I just think it's mostly dumb 59:48 because I always hear it when the process doesn't yield 59:52 to outcome that you want, and then it is, 59:55 okay, well we've got a process problem. 59:56 Well, it can be a sign of a process problem, 59:59 but the bottom line is, unless you're going 60:02 to with totalitarianism, you're gonna have, 60:06 there's gonna be some process, 60:07 and the process should be up for debate. 60:10 Why do we have process? 60:12 Actually, one of the reasons why we have process 60:14 is to yield better outcomes. 60:15 outcomes. 60:16 One of the reasons why we created processes was to yield better outcomes, but the problem 60:21 is if you become too process focused, the process can actually start to inhibit. 60:27 So it's a Goldilocks issue the way so many things are. 60:30 There is such a thing as too little process and there's such a thing as too much process 60:35 and there's such a thing as just right process. 60:37 And so to say that one is better than the other or one is preferable to the other 60:42 when they are actually inextricably linked conceptually. 60:46 You know, one of my colleague, Ezra Klein, 60:48 wrote this book, Abundance. 60:51 And, you know, from my libertarian-ish leanings, 60:54 I was reading Abundance. 60:55 I was like, welcome, Ezra, one of us. 60:58 Because one of the problems, 61:00 one of the things that libertarians have long argued 61:02 is we have too many processes that are fouling things up 61:07 and that there is a need to shed some process. 61:10 And I believe that very strongly, but at the same time, my measure of if process is bad 61:17 is not going to be if it yields something with which I disagree. 61:21 That's way, way too simplistic. 61:25 Only other thing I'll add. 61:27 One, we actually had another debate, if you remember, in like the 2010s or like end 61:33 of the aughts over within the conservative legal movement, judicial activism versus 61:38 judicial minimalism. 61:39 had the conservative legal movement 61:41 become too judicial minimalist, 61:43 too deferential to Congress and the executive branch 61:47 on the standing thing that I mentioned, right? 61:49 Like, no, we need a broader standing 61:51 and judges getting more involved 61:53 in some of these questions to protect liberty. 61:56 Again, it's not that one side won and one side lost. 61:58 I think that the conservative legal movement was like, 62:00 oh, you know what, that's a good point. 62:01 We probably are a little too minimalist 62:04 while still wanting a lot of Berke and minimalism 62:07 baked into being a conservative. And I think that what bothers me currently about the common 62:18 good outcome side of the argument is not that they are trying to raise good questions 62:24 about the current conservative legal movement or the problems with originalism or anything 62:28 else. It is the lack of intellectual humility because it just really drives me crazy 62:32 when someone thinks that they always know the right outcome for every political question 62:36 sitting here right now at whatever age they are 62:39 in the year our Lord 2026, they have it all figured out 62:43 and the rest of us, anyone from the past 62:46 is not just wrong but like stupid and morally lacking. 62:50 Those debates, I not only don't find interesting 62:54 but it undermines the very point 62:55 that the person is trying to make 62:56 because sort of by definition, 62:58 we should all be pretty hesitant 63:00 to think that we know what the right outcome is. 63:05 Okay, sorry, that was a really long answer. 63:06 We can do better at being shorter, I mean. 63:13 I'm Anteas, an LLM, and I'm curious to go back to an issue 63:19 that you spoke on briefly in a previous podcast, 63:22 which is now in this post slaughter world where the president 63:25 or the executive branch has complete authority 63:28 over essentially all agencies, with the exception 63:30 of the Fed, and you had brought up the idea 63:34 of transitioning agencies to being legislative agencies. 63:38 And I wish you could elaborate a little bit more on your 63:42 envisioning of how that would work, how the rule-making 63:47 thing would work in the context of if you have a 63:51 legislative committee or a legislative element, how that 63:56 could go forward if we could just fold the current issue. 64:01 So I'm going on and on, but this whole topic is fascinating. 64:04 All right, keep it tight, but it's a great question. 64:06 I thought a lot about this. 64:07 So an executive agency right now tends to have, 64:11 many of them have three functions. 64:14 They might have an administrative law judge, 64:16 they might have the enforcement arm, 64:17 and then they're gonna have a rule-making arm. 64:19 So they're gonna have article one, two, and three 64:21 all within article two, okay? 64:24 Now some of them, they don't have 64:25 the administrative law judges, but a lot of them, 64:27 a lot of them have the rule-making 64:28 and the execution in the same entity. 64:35 Why not break it out? 64:36 You have a legislative agency that does the rulemaking and you have the executive agency that does the enforcement 64:42 There's nothing written in stone that says the Securities and Exchange Commission has to have its rulemaking 64:47 This holiday all plants even unlimited are just fifteen dollars a month a holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song 64:55 Like all I want 64:57 Right, okay, we can't afford that. You know I forget the music budget 65:00 We're gonna stick with whatever's in the public domain. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch 65:17 When you spend enough time around great companies, you notice that the best ones treat trust as 65:23 a growth strategy, not a box to check. 65:25 Vanta helps companies build and prove trust from day one. 65:29 Its agentic trust platform connects compliance, risk, and trust at enterprise scale. 65:34 Vanta delivers a 526% return on investment over three years and pays for itself in just three months. 65:42 Learn why over 16,000 of the fastest growing companies use Vanta at Vanta.com. 65:48 Looking under the executive branch and so there's any number of ways that you could do rulemaking 65:53 within a legislative agency and then the law enforcement, the enforcement of it goes with the executive 66:00 And that's what I, now this would be like the biggest reach goal of all reach goals because I don't see much appetite in Congress for this kind of sweeping reform. 66:08 Like let's let them pass a budget first before we like revamp the administrative state. 66:14 But I do think, because if you look back at the Watergate era reforms, what you had was the legislature never intended to delegate the rulemaking authority so completely to the executive. 66:27 They had this thing called the legislative veto and so the legislative veto was going to allow the legislature to claw back something in the lawmaking world, in the rulemaking world, and the Supreme Court said no to that. 66:41 And so for the last 20-some, I don't know, 40, it was 84, 42 years, we have had these executive agencies created and running in a way that they were not built to run. 66:53 and it has put our system under enormous strain. 66:56 And I think it was a mistake by the legislature 66:59 to send rulemaking to the executive, 67:02 but they didn't think they were doing that when they did it. 67:05 They thought they still had their thumb on the scales 67:07 with the legislative veto. 67:09 So if I could have my ideal druthers, 67:12 imagine my presidential campaign, vote for me 67:16 and you will separate the rulemaking 67:18 and enforcement capacity, the Securities Exchange Commission 67:21 and I'd win by, you know, I'd get 80 million votes. 67:24 But that's the way I would see it. 67:26 You break it out. 67:28 The legislative agency is the rulemaking agency. 67:30 The executive agency is the enforcement agency. 67:32 All right, we have time for one more. 67:33 Then we will let you guys go outside 67:35 and play softball and drink beer, 67:37 as one is want to do at the university. 67:39 As you were destined to do. 67:41 Ride ponies? 67:42 Thank you for coming. 67:44 I had a question about Heller, 67:46 because David, your analysis of the substance 67:49 of the Fundamental Right seemed to depend 67:53 on what weapons are available to the general public. 67:58 And I was wondering, considering that we live in a world 68:01 where state by state gun laws are disparate 68:04 and that people can cross state lines with guns, 68:09 how do we go about squaring that reality 68:11 with figuring out what the Fundamental Right 68:15 is supposed to substantively protect 68:18 and also the fact that our legal analysis is state by state 68:24 and that when we're doing intermediate scrutiny, 68:27 for example, we're looking at the justification 68:29 for that state's laws, not the reality 68:32 for the surrounding states. 68:33 Yeah, it's so complicated because if you do end up 68:37 with something that is quasi-intermediate scrutiny, 68:40 which is what I think we're gonna probably end up with 68:43 just the way the court is headed, 68:45 they're gonna call it text history and tradition 68:46 and it's going to be intermediate scrutiny 68:49 with an enormous amount of discretion 68:50 to interpret the history. 68:53 I think that's a mess. 68:54 I think it's going to yield a mess. 68:56 It's going to yield an awful lot of competing legal regimes 69:00 with very, of course, we have these porous state borders 69:04 to the point where, you know, if you live in Chicago, 69:08 for example, it is the kinds of weapons 69:12 that the criminals use in Chicago 69:14 Chicago are not really influenced by Chicago gun laws. 69:17 They're the kind of weapons they can purchase in Indiana, right? 69:20 But if I'm living in Chicago... 69:22 Random swipe at Indiana. 69:25 I mean, it's got more liberal gun laws. 69:27 This is why they come from Gary, Indiana, you know, it's close, you know, right? 69:31 I mean, if it was from Tennessee, they could even have, they could have howardsers 69:33 and tanks, but, but they're close to... 69:37 Wait, can I tell you a really funny story? 69:39 So, when I brought Nate up for Halloween to DC, he got to see his old friends and I'm
Community discussion