Show full transcript 0:52 Shop toyota.com for deals and details or stop by your local Toyota dealer today Toyota. Let's go places 0:59 Straight up is the Friday podcast that takes the week's most talked-about stories seriously 1:04 This is what the internet does best it turns speculation into entertainment, but not too seriously 1:09 This is all fake shut up 1:12 You got a double canceled bro every week join me Vladimir Dutif and me Kelly O'Grady as we ditched the anchor desk after hours 1:20 To break down the story, the internet just can't stop talking about it. 1:24 With a cocktail to match the mood, what do we call in the show? 1:26 Straight up. 1:27 Available wherever you get your podcasts. 1:30 The following episode includes discussion of domestic abuse, suicide, and references 1:35 to sexual assault. 1:37 Fewer discretion is advised and will have resources for you at the end of the episode. 1:42 And if you or someone you know may be experiencing a mental health crisis, call the 988 Suicide 1:47 and Crisis Lifeline. 1:48 Just call or text 988. 1:54 Hi, I'm CBS News correspondent Chanel Call for 48 Hours Case by Case. 1:59 We have some news in the Noresh Bot murder trial that dropped after 48 Hours Correspondent 2:03 Natalie Morales and I recorded this episode on Wednesday, November 4th. 2:08 So in a stunning development on Thursday, November 5th, Noresh Bot testified that 2:12 he found his wife, Mamtha, dead from presumed suicide and tried to dispose of her body. 2:18 He said he saw a vomit around her body that contained pills and also said that there was 2:23 a packet of insecticide nearby. 2:25 Afterwards, he said that he tried to dismember and dispose of her body. 2:30 When asked on the stand about why he didn't phone 911 that day, he said something took 2:35 over him and that he was really panicked. 2:37 Stay tuned on the case-by-case feed for our continued coverage, and here's this 2:42 week's episode on the BOT murder trial. 2:47 My attention was drawn to three searches that were um one of which was from March 21st of 2024. 2:57 Those searches were what happened if spouse disappears, what happened if spouse disappears 3:02 in divorce in Virginia and need divorce spouse died in Virginia. There were numerous other 3:09 searches as well. Were there any searches talking about donations? Can I donate my baby to my 3:16 friend. That was Master Digital Forensics investigator Catherine Zemas testifying in 3:21 the murder trial of Mamta Khaflay Bhatt. Mamta's husband Nuresh Bhatt was charged with murdering 3:27 her in Manassas Park, Virginia, after she appeared to have gone missing in August of 2024. 3:33 We are now on week five of this trial. It is expected to take up to seven weeks. 3:39 The prosecution rested its case on Monday, November 2nd, 3:42 after supporting their argument through forensic evidence at the bot home, 3:46 testimonies from those close to the bot family, 3:49 and Noresh's Google search history around the time of Mamta's disappearance. 3:54 On Wednesday, November 4th, the defense began making its case, 3:58 and we have a major development here. 4:01 The first witness they called to the stand was actually Noresh bot himself. 4:07 As a reminder, he faces charges of first-degree murder, 4:10 concealing a dead body and physically defiling a dead body. 4:16 Momta's body has still not been found. 4:19 I'm 48 Hours Correspondent, Natalie Morales, 4:21 and this is Case by Case. 4:23 For our previous coverage on the bot trial, 4:26 you can go back to the 48 Hours YouTube channel 4:28 or check the Case by Case feed 4:30 wherever you get your podcasts. 4:33 Well, joining me today to recap 4:34 the last few weeks of the trial 4:35 is CBS News correspondent Chanel Call. 4:38 Thank you for being here, Chanel. 4:39 Yeah, thanks so much for having me. It's such a fascinating case. Yes, it is a fascinating case 4:45 And it certainly has captured a lot of attention, especially in the Washington DC area, but nationally as well 4:51 And so here it is on Wednesday, November 4th that Nourish bought took the stand in his own murder trial 4:57 Now this is a very big deal because for a while it was unclear whether or not we would be hearing from Nourish 5:03 So we're going to play a clip here of the defense 5:05 questioning him about his experiences growing up during the Nepali Civil War. 5:11 Did they, are you saying that you yourself experienced violence? 5:17 That is correct. 5:19 And can you describe, like what did they do? 5:25 Those hard works make you carry a lot of hard works. 5:30 So they physically, sexually, mentally, they abuse very badly. 5:36 And how long did that go on? 5:40 More than two, three weeks. 5:45 How old were you at this time? 5:49 Thirteen, fourteen something. 5:52 Does that trauma stay with you today? 5:55 Not right now, right here, but if I talk about it makes me feel worse sometimes, you know, when I see the wound, when I had a fight over there. 6:06 Do you have nightmares? 6:06 there's a lot. So Chanel, I mean, I think this is the first 6:11 time we've covered a defendant testifying on his own behalf 6:14 here on case by case. What did you notice there about his 6:18 testimony? Yeah, I mean, I think that the most significant 6:21 part here that we heard was that the victim, Mumtha, but was 6:25 actually not brought up in the first full hour of 6:29 questioning from the defense's side. The defense instead 6:32 chose to start their argument by discussing, you know, his 6:35 His childhood, his upbringing, you heard there specifically talking about the experiences 6:39 growing up during the Nepali Civil War. 6:42 Perhaps trying to humanize him a little bit, give a little bit more of that character, 6:47 what was maybe going on in his life prior to coming here to the United States. 6:52 But yes, making him the focus of the first part of the testimony, I mean, it felt 6:57 like a very intentional move on the defense's part. 7:00 And obviously what Nourish said about those experiences in Nepal, I mean, they're 7:05 truly harrowing. So it does sound like he experienced abuse as well as a child that I could see 7:12 impacting him well into adulthood. But I couldn't help thinking, how does this tie back to Mamta? 7:19 And is it a good way to start off the defense here? 7:22 I mean, obviously, it is a thoughtful strategy, I would think, on the part of the defense. 7:27 But I think your question is something probably a lot of jurors are going to be thinking 7:30 about as well as they continue to listen. You know, they did eventually discuss Noresh 7:35 and Monta's marriage. And then later in the testimony, Natalie, we actually heard Noresh 7:39 was engaged when they met, when he first met Monta. And he had said that his previous 7:44 relationship was coming to an end when they met. They eventually became friends on Facebook. 7:49 Well, he also spoke to those early days in his engagement with Monta. Let's play some 7:53 of that here. Did Monta get along with your family? Very well. 7:59 Um, did she get along with your parents? 8:02 Very well. 8:03 Um, you eventually had a wedding, right? 8:09 Not at that point. 8:10 But eventually you did. 8:12 Yeah, after a post-time cancel, next time, yes. 8:16 So Nourish went on there to explain the wedding was postponed due to a death in the family. 8:21 Yeah, not only we should note also that at the time of this recording, 8:24 the prosecution hadn't yet cross-examined Nourish, 8:26 So there may be more details that we'll learn once that happens. 8:30 So this is a nobody case for those who've been paying attention. 8:35 This means prosecutors are going to be relying on what is largely circumstantial evidence to 8:40 lay out their argument. What can you tell us about some of the digital evidence specifically 8:45 presented in court over these last few weeks? 8:47 Yeah. So prosecutors put together sort of a timeline based on 8:51 and Nourisha's phone activity. 8:54 So the last time Manta was seen by her coworkers 8:56 was back on July 27th, 2024. 8:59 She also, as we learned, made these daily calls 9:02 to her mother, sometimes a couple of times every day. 9:06 And that all stopped abruptly 9:07 after the last call happened on the 29th. 9:10 So prosecutors say that they believe 9:12 that she died sometime overnight, 9:14 perhaps into July 30th, 2024. 9:18 And around that time, 9:19 Nourish had actually made some very fascinating and curious Google searches that that master digital 9:25 forensics investigator that you talked about earlier actually read in court. 9:29 Right. The searches themselves, I mean, they were jarring to hear considering 9:34 the allegations against Nourish. I mean, some were even conflicting. And for example, on July 30th, 9:39 he searched human brain diagram. But then on August 5th, he searched missing person finding 9:46 reading rate in Virginia. Now, we should note on August 5th, that was the day that 9:51 Nourish filed a missing persons report for Mamta. Her co-workers at the UVA hospital had 9:57 requested a welfare check for Mamta after she failed to show up for work. Nourish spoke 10:01 to the police during this check on August 2nd, and then it was three days later that 10:06 he filed the missing persons report. So, Chanel, what stuck out to you when Zamus was 10:12 on the stand reading some of those searches? 10:14 There's so much that's so interesting about these Google searches, not just the content 10:18 of the searches, but also the language choices, right? 10:22 You know, I think he was trying to look up adoption, but he actually called it donation. 10:26 And I should note as well, Nuresh and Manta have a daughter together. 10:30 And days before the child's first birthday, Manta had actually been missing for three 10:34 weeks. 10:34 And Nuresh searched, quote, can I donate my baby to my friend? 10:38 I mean, based on that search, it did not sound like Nuresh had high hopes for finding 10:44 Mamta and might have even been preparing for the possibility of raising their daughter 10:49 alone. 10:50 We should say the child is now being cared for by Mamta's mother and brother while 10:54 Nuresh stands trial for Mamta's murder. 10:57 But months prior to that, what he called donation search, Nuresh also reportedly 11:02 looked up what happened if, and that's intended misspelling and grammar, what happened if 11:09 spouse disappears in divorce in Virginia? And this was not the only reference to divorce 11:15 that he made. What can you tell us about that? 11:18 Yeah, I think there's so many questions about what their relationship was like. And investigators 11:21 are saying that in March of 2024, Narash had actually asked an unknown person to set 11:27 him up with a Colombian woman. That person apparently said, Natalie, that they didn't 11:31 do that. They didn't connect him with that woman because they thought that Manta was going 11:36 to move back in with him. Nourish responded by saying that, no, they're just living together 11:41 while they're trying to figure out how to get a divorce. But you're right, Natalie. I mean, 11:44 he did have other searches about divorce. At one point, he searched, quote, 11:49 need divorce spouse die in Virginia. And again, intentional grammar there, 11:54 and quote, can I divorce if wife lost? 11:58 So the searches I should clarify here, 12:01 we don't know exactly when they were made, 12:03 we can't know the specific date because of history, 12:06 those searches could have been cleared, 12:07 the server could have been cleared, 12:08 but I think regardless, 12:10 the searches themselves give us a bit of a picture 12:13 and the jury a bit of a picture of what his state of mind 12:16 was and what potentially the relationship was like 12:19 right before all of this happened 12:20 or around the time when Manta went missing. 12:23 Something else that was really fascinating here that stuck out to me was that investigators 12:27 found that Mumpa was actually saved under the name Bad Memory in his phone. 12:38 Hi everybody, I'm Nora O'Donnell, and I want to tell you about my new podcast, Healthful. 12:43 Every week I will renew the latest science, Dr. Brem, myth busting, and trusted medical 12:48 expertise. 12:49 Cary menopause is hormonal chaos, we have biology to help you not suffer, to help 12:54 you improve your health, your happiness. 12:56 This is like such an a-ha moment. 12:58 And just to improve your life. 12:59 I think talking about this is so incredibly important. 13:02 Healthful, a new CBS News podcast, 13:05 wherever you get your podcasts. 13:10 There were also a number of text messages 13:14 that investigators recovered 13:15 between Mamta and her brother, Mahesh Kafele. 13:18 Five months before she disappeared, 13:20 Mamta reportedly confided in her brother 13:22 about the abuse she says she experienced 13:25 at the hands of her husband, Nuresh. 13:27 Now, according to WUSA, Mahesh said she told me she's unsafe. 13:33 Chanel, this isn't the first time that we've heard about abuse allegations in the bot house, right? 13:38 Yeah, and this has become a big part of this story, right? 13:41 In our last coverage of this case, we talked about Sarita Nupani's testimony. 13:45 This is somebody who, you know, is a friend of the bot family who said the month that told her that Nourish had hit her before. 13:52 For Nourish and his defense team though, they've not admitted to or denied those allegations. 13:58 And then last week after the jury was dismissed, the prosecution and the defense's attorney 14:03 Natalie were arguing about whether or not those statements from Mahesh that you just 14:07 mentioned should even be admissible in court in this murder trial. 14:12 The judge said that, look, it depends. 14:14 Some of the things are going to be admissible and some of the things aren't. 14:16 Well, Noresh's team seemed to be making a serious effort to try to keep any mention 14:21 of domestic violence out of the courtroom. 14:24 I mean, as we've mentioned, in our previous coverage before the trial even began, the defense 14:29 put forward a motion to disallow references to domestic violence allegations during jury 14:34 selection and opening statements of this trial. 14:37 But ultimately, the judge denied this. 14:40 So it's difficult for me to imagine domestic violence not being a big piece of this 14:45 murder trial. I could see keeping any mention of abuse out of the courtroom, you know, how 14:50 that might leave a hole in the prosecution's argument. 14:53 Yeah. And I think it's important to also mention that one of Nourish's attorneys had 14:57 said that those that were close to the butts had testified their relationship had actually 15:02 improved. A friend of the couple had texted Nourish saying, I thought you guys were good. 15:07 So on October 21st, there were also a number of security cam videos which show 15:12 Nuresh bought tossing bags into a trash compactor in Falls Church, Virginia on July 31st, 2024. 15:21 Now this is the day after prosecutors believe that Mamta was murdered. I want to play some 15:25 of the prosecutors questioning of the investigators about that footage. 15:30 What did we just see him do at seven minutes in? 15:35 Throw bags into the trash compactor. 15:39 Did we see him driving away at this point? 15:45 Yes, stopping this at eight minutes and six seconds. 15:50 Chanel, what do you think the prosecutors 15:52 are trying to argue here? 15:54 So what happened to Mumpa's body 15:55 is still a huge question, right? 15:57 And prosecutors are saying here that they believe 15:59 that Nuresh dismembered her body 16:01 and then disposed of the pieces 16:02 in multiple trash compactors and dumpsters 16:05 in Northern Virginia. 16:07 So when was that trash compactor 16:08 that we just saw in Falls Church? 16:10 They've also got footage of him at a Manassas Park Virginia apartment complex and in that piece of footage 16:16 You actually see him throwing away more bags into a dumpster 16:19 So this was the apartment complex where Nuresh had dropped off his daughter on the morning of July 30th 16:25 And around that time is also when he disposed of those bags 16:29 Well according to the prosecutors and that video footage 16:32 He came back to the apartment that afternoon to pick up his daughter from Amanda who was the babysitter, right? 16:38 Yeah, and the babies that are actually testified to this in court a couple of weeks ago 16:42 She had a lot to say Natalie about Nourish's demeanor when he came to pick up his daughter that day 16:47 I want to play more of that here. You're hearing from Amanda hero Perez testifying via translator 16:53 So I opened the door and he like pushed a little bit the door and he kept going towards the inside 17:00 It's a key to sus Gina's cargo on us Gina's 17:06 So, he got into the living room and he was looking all over the place. 17:12 He was on his phone and he said something in English really fast and I didn't understand 17:18 and that's why I later asked him about that. 17:21 Was that the first time the defendant has come into your apartment? 17:28 Yes. 17:29 Did you invite the defendant in? 17:33 No. 17:33 No, it was when I went out and I just you know looked at him and I noticed that he was looking around everywhere like anxious 17:44 But always standing there looking towards the window 17:49 This testimony could be really revealing right Natalie the sitter is calling him anxious 17:53 She says that he kind of pushes his way into the apartment. He's looking around 17:57 It definitely paints a picture of someone who was on edge around the time that his wife disappeared 18:02 And I can see the jury really paying close attention to this. 18:06 Right. 18:06 And, you know, we've discussed extensive digital evidence around this case. 18:10 Now I want to get into actual physical evidence that has also been brought into the courtroom. 18:16 I saw that the prosecution entered a section of the bot's home's primary bedroom carpet as evidence. 18:22 Shana, what can you tell us about what was on that carpet? 18:25 Yeah. 18:26 So prosecutors talked about believing that there's evidence of bloodstains on the carpet. 18:30 it. As for how they made that determination, Natalie, they say that they use technology 18:34 called Blue Star Forensic, which is basically a luminol-based substance. You sort of spray 18:39 it on surfaces. It lights up blue if it indicates that there is any evidence of blood there. 18:46 So the crime scene investigator, Joseph Rossino, he testified that samples that he took 18:50 from the carpet actually did test positive for blood. I'm going to play some of his 18:55 testimony here and you can hear the defense's questions and then you'll hear the prosecution's 18:59 If I cut my hand and I washed my hands, could that leave a blue star reaction in the sink? 19:04 Yes, it could. 19:05 If I cut my hand and I washed my hands and I shook my hands off and it got onto the counter, 19:11 could that leave a blue star reaction? 19:13 Yes, it could. 19:15 Let's say somebody was stabbed within a bedroom, would you expect you to get a blue star reaction 19:24 reaction if that blood had, in fact, gotten onto the floor. 19:30 Yes, I would. 19:31 So I don't know if this is going to be sort of the smoking gun 19:33 in this case, but you can definitely 19:34 see the defense trying to ask if the prosecution is 19:37 sure that the substance there is really blood, 19:40 and then the prosecution sort of trying to steer the focus 19:42 back to their argument. 19:49 It was a gruesome discovery off a dirt road in Georgia. 19:53 Hunters had found a body. 19:55 Was it immediately clear to you 19:57 that this woman had been murdered. 19:58 Yes. 19:59 But who was this mystery woman in the woods? 20:03 That looks like Mindy. 20:05 I'm Erin Moriarty, and from 48 hours, 20:08 this is the woman in the woods. 20:11 I have never wanted to be wrong, 20:13 like this in my whole entire life. 20:14 Binge the full series, The Woman in the Woods, 20:17 wherever you get your podcasts. 20:19 The Unsolved Mysteries podcast is back. 20:22 I'm Jordan Murphy, 20:23 and each week I'll take you inside a new investigation. 20:26 It could be an unsolved murder, an unexplained disappearance, the search for a wanted fugitive, 20:31 any mystery that still needs answers. 20:33 We'll follow every new lead, every break in the case, and the moments when a mystery is 20:37 finally solved. 20:39 Because after all these years, one thing hasn't changed. 20:42 Someone, somewhere, knows the truth. 20:44 Listen to and follow Unsolved Mysteries, available now wherever you get your podcasts. 20:51 One of the most compelling pieces of physical evidence that came up in court is also 20:56 also a saw that Nuresh Bhatt gave to his landscaper Jose Ayala. Now investigators believe this 21:03 is what Nuresh used to actually dismember Mopda's body. Ayala took the saw apparently, but 21:09 after he heard about Mopda's disappearance, he then turned it over to the police and 21:14 And here's what he had to say on the stand through a translator. 21:22 So I didn't want to carry that in my mind that probably it could be something or probably it couldn't be nothing. 21:38 But just to be fine with me and my conscience, I decided to go to the police and tell them 21:47 that I had the saw. 21:49 So I mean, the Commonwealth attorneys are probably pretty grateful that this person 21:53 actually turned the saw over after they found out what had happened to Montha because 21:57 was investigators Natalie ended up finding 21:59 a sort of reddish brown stain. 22:02 They also found some hair-like strands on that saw. 22:06 So forensic scientists, they took a look at this 22:09 and ultimately they were able to confirm 22:11 that the strands are hair, 22:13 but because there wasn't a full follicle on it, 22:16 they couldn't conduct a DNA analysis. 22:19 Here is what the lead crime scene investigator,
Community discussion