Show full transcript 0:54 up to date today on it, our 2020 episode called Justice for Faith. 0:58 It's a story of a young, bright, happy-go-lucky teenager named Faith Hedgepeth. 1:05 She was 19 years old. 1:07 She grew up just outside Raleigh, North Carolina in a close-knit family. 1:11 She had landed at the University of North Carolina, which was her dream school. 1:14 It was 2012. 1:15 She was in her sophomore year with big hopes of studying medicine, maybe becoming 1:19 a doctor, to bring her skills back to her home community. 1:23 But sadly, just weeks into a new semester, Faith was found dead, bludgeoned to death in 1:30 the apartment that she was sharing with a friend after a night out on the town with 1:35 her friends. 1:36 The murder, as you can imagine, shocked the college campus and the entire community, 1:41 and it left police with no obvious suspect and few leads to go on for years. 1:46 Well, 2020 correspondent Ryan Smith began investigating this story back in 2016. 1:51 He's been on the case 1:53 Trying to figure out how and why the case had grown cold and then of course finally an arrest in 2021 a trial 2:00 And that just wrapped up days ago. So Ryan barely off the plane from North Carolina where he's been reporting on this story 2:07 Joins us now Ryan. How are you doing? 2:12 Today been a lot of work a little bleary, but I'm but charged up and ready to go 2:17 I mean this was a case that 2:18 but they had been searching for something in this case 2:21 for over a decade. 2:23 And Deborah, you know, it's so rare for cases like this 2:26 to be solved when it goes past a year, two years, three years, 2:28 but yeah, finally it was solved. 2:30 Well, this is what we call a crash in our industry. 2:33 So you all were racing to go find this story 2:36 right after the trial had happened. 2:38 It was 2016 when you jumped into the story. 2:41 You interviewed Faith's parents. 2:43 You talked to friends, investigators 2:46 all around this case. 2:47 give me a sense of who this young woman was. Yeah, this was a truly remarkable young woman. 2:52 She embodied everything that her family, that the Hollowessa Pony Tribe wanted their people to be 2:59 and wanted her to be. She was an honor student in high school. She received a full ride to go 3:06 to UNC Chapel Hill. She had a mission to become a doctor and go back and work maybe as a pediatrician 3:14 with her tribe to help out her tribe. 3:16 This young woman just embodied everything you want 3:19 in young people and her family was so close. 3:22 She had a sister, her brother, 3:24 they all believed in each other. 3:27 They were tight with each other. 3:28 They were such good people. 3:30 And so the overwhelming thought you had 3:32 when you covered this trial, when I first got into it 3:35 and read all about her and started talking to people 3:37 was how could this happen to someone like Faith? 3:40 And I thought the same thing too when I heard about it. 3:42 And one of our team members, Alex, actually went to school there and talked about knowing 3:47 this area and what that must have felt like on campus. 3:50 Take us back to that night in September of 2012. 3:53 So Faith and her roommate went out for a night, I guess, of what, of partying and just sort 3:58 of hanging out. 3:59 Take us back to that night. 4:00 Yeah. 4:01 This was, and you know, this whole story sort of begins, the night of that story 4:05 begins with two friends at the library studying and then deciding, okay, we're good. 4:11 let's go out and have some fun." 4:13 So they go to a place called the Thrill Night Club. 4:15 They get dressed up, they go out, 4:16 they have fun with people, they stay for a while, 4:19 and they decide to leave. 4:20 And nothing that they were doing 4:22 is different from what college students do. 4:24 Go out, you did your work, right? 4:26 Go out, have fun, party a little. 4:28 They come back and around 2, 2.30 in the morning, 4:31 they go back up to the apartment. 4:33 Karina, her roommate, Karina Rosario is a little tipsy. 4:37 She- A lot tipsy. 4:39 Yes, well, she talks about vomiting. 4:40 So she gets she gets pretty drunk faith is trying to help her faith is giving her a trash can if she gets sick 4:46 And then faith goes to bed Karina had been going through a couple of things at the time 4:50 Just with relationships and different people 4:52 So she calls up a friend of hers and that friend comes and picks her up and she goes over that person's house 4:58 Karina leaves 4:59 She leaves the door unlocked faith is inside which is critical. We're gonna find out it is she leaves the door unlocked 5:04 Faith is inside she leaves she goes to her friend's house a man young man named Jordan McCrary 5:09 Karina goes. 5:10 Yes, Karina goes. 5:11 And then the next morning, you know, she's up. 5:13 She's like, I'm gonna go back home. 5:15 She calls Faith for a ride. 5:16 So Faith had a car and Karina typically got rides from her. 5:19 She kept calling her, calling her. 5:21 A lot of people kept calling Faith in the morning 5:23 because Faith sometimes had trouble getting up, 5:25 no different from any other college student. 5:26 I remember those days. 5:28 And couldn't reach her. 5:29 So Karina finally makes her way home 5:30 and discovers Faith bludgeoned to death. 5:33 And it was a brutal scene, a brutal scene. 5:36 I mean, there was blood everywhere, faith had clearly been brutally attacked and Carina was beside 5:42 herself and immediately called the police. Understandably. She was the one who called 911, 5:46 and must have just been traumatized. So this scene is just shocking to everybody. 5:51 And then it goes on, no obvious suspects. They're kind of thinking, well, this all 5:57 sounds very strange. Let's talk to all the people sort of in her sphere. They talk to 6:02 Karina, obviously she winds up being clear. 6:04 They talked to a couple of guys who were involved. 6:06 Police really have nothing to go on 6:08 and it's kind of an open investigation. 6:10 They're kind of counting on us. 6:12 When you start talking to them, 6:13 they're counting on the national coverage 6:14 to make a difference, aren't they? 6:16 Yeah, it was a big deal. 6:17 And Debra, you know this. 6:18 It is, this is an ongoing case 6:21 and investigators and authorities 6:23 decide to talk to us on television. 6:25 That is not common. 6:27 Because the case is ongoing. 6:28 What they don't want to do 6:29 is make too much stuff public 6:30 like it ended up blowing something in the investigation. 6:32 But it was so critical for them to find information 6:35 that they decided to talk to the media 6:37 and decided to talk to 2020. 6:39 And what I think that really underscores, 6:41 that I think, I'm not sure people realized 6:43 from watching on Friday, 6:45 I think what it really underscores 6:46 is how dedicated they were to this. 6:48 And there's another thing about this 6:49 that makes it so tough, 6:51 made their job so hard to find the killer. 6:55 Karina and Faith were good people. 6:58 They were college students. 6:59 They had tons of friends. 7:01 So authorities, think about that night. 7:03 They go to a nightclub, hundreds of people there. 7:06 They're on the UNC campus, thousands of kids on campus, in their phones, scores of people 7:11 in their phones. 7:12 Police had to look at hundreds of people. 7:15 They had to swab DNA from scores of people just to get a sense of who might have done 7:20 this. 7:20 1800 people, they said they would talk to ultimately over the time. 7:24 Well, let's talk about Corina because Faith's family had some questions about 7:28 her in the very beginning. She left the door unlocked when she left. Talk to us a little 7:31 bit about faith and Karina and what you learned about them and their relationship and that 7:35 night. Yeah, there was there were a lot of questions about Karina and Karina had to speak 7:40 to investigators a bunch of times. So here's the deal. Karina is the one who discovers faith 7:44 and calls 911. And a bunch was made about what happened in the moments before faith died and 7:52 then afterwards. Afterwards there was some questions about how on the 911 call Karina 7:57 I don't get preferring to faith as my friend. 7:59 These two, according to their friends, were super close. 8:02 Did everything together. 8:04 So there was a lot of scuttle but about, 8:06 well, why is she not calling her faith on the 911 call? 8:08 Why are you keep saying my friend, my friend? 8:11 I just wanna say, this is just me and you, Deborah. 8:13 I just, I really think that sometimes 8:15 it can be difficult to read 8:16 into how people respond to tragedy. 8:18 That's right. 8:18 We all have different responses. 8:21 Sometimes we're in shock. 8:22 Sometimes you might look back at what you do 8:23 in a shocking moment and say, why did I do it that? 8:25 Why was I like that? 8:26 and she's 19. She's 19. That was one issue. The other issue is leaving the door unlocked. That might 8:32 speak to the safety of the area as she saw it, but for a lot of people it was why would you leave 8:38 the door unlocked at four o'clock in the morning. And that led to some scuttlebutt about maybe 8:42 she was involved in some way. The third thing was she called a young man named Jordan McCrary to 8:47 pick her up at four something in the morning. He picks her up and he says he notices blood 8:52 on her hand and asks her like a little spot of blood. He says, what's that? And she says, 8:57 I don't know. Well, it turns out that police ask her about that. And she's like, I don't know what 9:00 he's talking about. I didn't say anything about that. And then when questioned about the blood, 9:04 she said, maybe it was vomit. I was drinking red slushies all night. And that could have been 9:07 what he thought it was. So there was an issue not only with, did she have some blood on her 9:11 hand? Could that have been somehow involved? And, you know, why does she have these 9:16 conflicting stories, which she would say they're not conflicting, because I don't know what 9:20 talking about. He never asked me that. So there were a bunch of details that for some didn't add 9:25 up but she was ultimately cleared in all of this. Right, right. Police did not see anything worthy 9:30 of charging her ultimately. So they're at square one, right? So they spend years trying to 9:35 investigate this case and we're going to take a break and I want to talk about that because 9:39 no surprise to those who follow true crime, DNA was the holy grail of evidence in this case. 9:45 So we're going to take a break and when we come back we're going to go into the details 9:48 of that Friday night show and how genetic genealogy would be the key to tracking down 9:54 Faith's killer. 9:55 So stay with us. 10:03 Today I want to tell you about our friends at Proper Hills. 10:06 Ask your mom and she'll probably tell you, one of the best parts of the holiday season 10:10 is getting to see family and friends who live far away. 10:13 Something about actually seeing the face of someone you love is just special. 10:17 No matter how much you might talk over text and phone calls throughout the year. 10:20 Of course, when the holidays are over and everyone is back at home, she'll miss seeing 10:23 those faces again. 10:24 But you can keep the warm and fuzzy feelings going by giving the perfect gift, a proper 10:28 Hills digital frame. 10:30 Proper Hills makes sleek digital photo frames that let you display a rotation of up to 10:34 20,000 photos and videos. 10:36 The 10 inch frame is elegant and timeless, designed to complement any room no matter 10:40 the style of decor. 10:42 And the best part is that it's seamless to add new photos or videos at any time. 10:45 You can send photos from anywhere, at home, or on the go. 10:48 With our limited time deal, you can scoop up this gorgeous frame for an incredible price. 10:52 Head to abcsecretsavings.com slash 2020 to score your digital frame for more than 60% 10:59 off. 10:59 You can even get free shipping and have it at your door with plenty of time before 11:02 the holidays. 11:03 Again, that's abcsecretsavings.com slash 2020 for this incredible deal, abcsecretsavings.com 11:11 slash 2020. 11:13 This show is sponsored by Progressive Insurance. 11:16 Insurance isn't one size fits all. 11:18 That's why drivers have enjoyed Progressive's Name Your Price tool for years now. 11:22 With the Name Your Price tool, you tell them what you want to pay and they'll show you 11:25 options that fit your budget. 11:27 So whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that 11:30 works better for you and your family, they make it easy to see your options. 11:34 Visit Progressive.com to find a rate that works for you with the Name Your Price 11:38 tool, progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates, price and coverage match limited 11:43 by state law. 11:46 Welcome back to 2020, the aftershow. 11:49 I'm sitting here with Ryan Smith, who has just raced back to New York from North Carolina, 11:54 covering the murder trial of Faith Hedgepat, the 19-year-old University of North Carolina 11:58 student who was found murdered in an off-campus apartment. 12:02 Ryan, one of the ominous things in this story, and it struck me on 2020, on Friday 12:08 night was a piece of evidence found at the crime scene. Very bizarre stuff. It was a paper bag 12:15 near Faith's body and it had written on it, I'm not stupid, bitch, jealous. So strange. Tell 12:24 me, what did they make of this note and were they convinced that this was somebody who killed 12:29 it? What did police make of this? Yeah, this immediately stuck to everybody who saw this, 12:34 including me. You see this paper bag from a local restaurant called Time Out. There 12:40 was a restaurant, somebody had gotten some food, and written on the bag was this note. 12:44 And immediately when you read it, you think, that has to be the killer. Just because it 12:49 looks like maybe they came back for revenge saying, did you insult me and now I'm gonna 12:54 tell you I'm not stupid, you know. And the jealous part didn't make a lot of sense. 12:58 So that led police trying to put things together. Like what impact could this have? 13:02 could this somehow be involved? That really stumped all of us. And I remember asking so many 13:09 different people, what do you make of this message? Could it somehow be related? They were trying 13:14 everything they could to try to figure out if it was. Ultimately, I don't think we really know 13:21 the connection to this, but it certainly sticks out as strange. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And going 13:25 forward in the trial, I don't know that we knew either. But before we even get there, 13:29 another piece of evidence, finally the big break in the case. DNA evidence 13:34 recovered at the scene, there's a Bacardi bottle which was deemed to be 13:39 possibly the murder weapon and DNA discovered. Tell us about that. The way 13:43 they painted a picture eventually in this case was that someone burst in the 13:47 apartment, attacked Faith with that Bacardi bottle and then ended up 13:52 not only knocking her out trying to hit her, hitting her with that bottle, 13:55 but also sexually assaulting her. 13:57 So that was the sort of theory 14:00 that they were working off of, 14:01 but that Bacardi bottle was so critical 14:03 because now they have someone's DNA 14:06 that might've been involved. 14:08 And what is so interesting? 14:09 Can I just say, Deborah, about this case? 14:10 One thing that's interesting about this case is 14:12 I don't know how many college students you know, 14:16 or how many of your listeners know college students, 14:19 but when police came on the scene, 14:21 it was difficult for them to understand 14:22 whether or not this crime scene was just a complete, there was stuff everywhere. 14:29 Chaotic kind of. Chaotic, you know, was this a result of an attack? There was a ton of evidence 14:33 on the scene. It was a very bloody crime scene. But what they had trouble finding was sorting 14:37 all that chaos out to try to find that print that could lead to a killer. 14:42 That could lead to a killer. And the fact of it is, here we are now all these years later 14:46 where DNA technology has changed tremendously. And that happens in so many of these stories 14:51 that we cover where they weren't able to piece things together years ago now they are. So let's 14:56 talk about this because what stunned me was that police are able to create a profile and kind of a 15:02 sketch from DNA that they are that they are able to discover and they did in this case which led 15:09 them to kind of an unlikely suspect. Tell us about this the suspect Miguel Salguero Olivares. 15:16 Yeah, olivarous. This is a true testament to how much, as you say, DNA and genealogy and all 15:25 these different tools that authorities used have come a long way since 2012 when faith was killed. 15:30 So they end up with a composite sketch. And in fact, the first time we showed this 15:34 story on 2020 back in 2016, we sort of work together, sort of get together on this composite 15:39 sketch that was eventually produced. So a composite sketch is produced. And they use that. 15:45 but what was interesting about this case, 15:46 especially in talking to authorities this time around, 15:49 they never gave up. 15:51 There were officers going to conferences, 15:53 trying to find out the newest technology in DNA testing 15:56 and genealogy testing to try to find matches to this print. 16:01 Over the years. 16:01 Yes, going to conferences, reading books, 16:04 trying to figure out whatever they could find 16:06 to try to get, and I think people look at authorities 16:08 and they say, well, cold cases go cold 16:10 and they don't really look at them. 16:11 They never gave up on this thing. 16:12 I mean, going to a conference asking people, one of the investigators talked about talking 16:16 to a doctor who was able to help him understand the connections between the genealogy and 16:23 the DNA. 16:24 So long story short, they have this DNA, but they couldn't find a match. 16:27 They end up getting a composite sketch. 16:29 They end up also going into genetic genealogy, which is a tool that's used to try to 16:34 figure out the genealogy of the person they are trying to find. 16:37 through testing C.C. Moore and her team and Parabon nanolabs they end up 16:43 finding that the DNA they're searching for comes from a group of people in 16:47 Guatemala. Then links are made from that group of people in Guatemala to a 16:52 community a Guatemala community in North Carolina. The connection is made to 16:57 North Carolina through somebody looking on a Facebook page and finding a 17:00 connection there who then connected back to Olivares. That's astounding. I mean 17:04 And the work that it took to get there is astounding. 17:08 And the fact that they got there is also incredible. 17:10 Well, Alavarez, it turns out, 17:12 had no connection to faith. 17:13 A 19-year-old guy at the time 17:15 who was working as a painter in the area, 17:18 near though, living near her. 17:20 And oftentimes, when we cover these stories, 17:23 there is some connection. 17:25 It's a spurned lover, boyfriend, spouse, something. 17:28 But in this case, there was no evidence 17:30 that he had had a real connection to faith, right? 17:32 No. 17:32 And in fact when they talked to olivarus right away he had said I don't even know who that is 17:36 I don't know who this person is and police couldn't find that direct connection, but 17:41 That was interesting because it ended up playing against his story 17:44 In many ways of of sort of being unfamiliar with her 17:47 But what was what really got me here was especially when you look at dna people say well, there's dna on the scene, right? 17:55 so 17:56 We can connect dna to somebody and they'll find the killer right why haven't they found the killer? 18:00 there's DNA. If the other person's DNA is not in the system or if they don't have a way of accessing 18:05 their DNA, you're not going to find who did it. Right. And that's what happened here. And the fact 18:11 that there was no connection between the two of them, the fact that there was nobody who could 18:14 say, yeah, I've seen these two people together, made it all these years, all the more difficult 18:18 to connect to him. Well, ultimately, though, he stopped at a traffic stop once for what, 18:23 DUI and Bingo police are at some point able to make the connection. Absolutely astounding stuff. 18:31 Well Ryan don't go anywhere because this story just gets more and more interesting. 18:35 Oliveris is eventually charged, arrested. He was charged with first degree murder and three 18:41 other counts related to faith's murder. He pleaded not guilty but ultimately there's a trial as we 18:48 said so don't go anywhere because the trial began in early October. Just last week there was a 18:52 verdict. We're going to take a break though, and when we come back, we're going to take 18:55 you inside that courtroom with our 2020 Eagle Eye and contributor, Pat LaLama. She's going 19:01 to join us to share some of the explosive moments during the trial, including emotional 19:06 ones from Oliveras himself in front of the jury. Don't you go anywhere. We'll be right 19:10 back. 19:18 This show is sponsored by Progressive Insurance. You're listening to this podcast, so I 19:22 know you've got a curious mind. Here's a helpful fact you might not know yet. 19:25 But drivers who switch and save with Progressive save over $900 on average. 19:31 Pop over to Progressive.com, answer some questions, and you'll get a quick quote with discounts 19:35 that are easy to come by. 19:36 In fact, 99% of their auto customers earn at least one discount. 19:41 Visit Progressive.com and see if you can enjoy a little cash back. 19:45 Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates, national average 12-month savings 19:49 of $946 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2024 19:54 24 and May 2025. Potential savings will vary. 20:00 Welcome back to 2020 The Aftershow. I'm here with Ryan Smith, our correspondent and my 20:05 friend who has been covering this story of Faith Hedgepett for over a decade. And also 20:10 with us now is 2020 contributor Pat Lalama who was inside that courtroom during the 20:15 trial where Miguel Salguero Olivares was facing life in prison for Faith Hedgepett's 20:21 murder. Pat, welcome good to have you with us as always. You were right there front row and it's 20:26 always great to get your take on these stories. You know what, Deborah? It was such a fascinating case. 20:33 First of all, just along the lines of what Ryan was saying, this family, the Hedgepads family, 20:40 they are, they're not just them, but their entire community were so cohesive and showed up 20:45 every day. Remember, it's been a long journey for them. But the trial itself for me, 20:50 just kind of analyzing the prosecution and defense. 20:55 The defense knew immediately 20:57 that it had an uphill battle with the DNA. 21:00 But the points that the defense was trying so hard 21:03 to make with the jury was, A, 21:06 because his DNA was there, 21:10 you can't automatically jump from the presence 21:13 of his DNA to him being the murderer. 21:17 Also, the prosecution never really drew that nexus. 21:22 They never proved that he was in the area. 21:25 There was a barbecue that night in the parking lot of the apartment complex. 21:29 And they brought up people on the stand and tried to plant the seed of curiosity with 21:34 the jury that, yeah, maybe he was there, maybe he wasn't, but they never ever made 21:38 that connection. 21:39 And the defense also, talking about Karina, the defense had one way to try to kick up some dust in the jury's mind. 21:49 And that was to say, no, wait a minute, not that Oliveris wasn't there or wasn't involved, 21:57 but that Karina, when they got back to that apartment, Deborah, she was so emotional. 22:05 Ryan mentioned what they thought was blood on her hand, which Jordan McCrary did say 22:10 he felt he saw and talked with her about. 22:13 She was in a flurry to get out of the apartment. 22:16 This is the defense on portraying right here right now. 22:19 She was calling, she called one guy Brandon, he wasn't picking up, and then she called 22:25 Jordan and said, come get me, come get me. 22:28 And she needed to get out of that apartment. 22:31 Downstairs, a neighbor said, told police that she heard noises, thumping that was alarming 22:39 to her. 22:40 Now, I'm just telling you what the defense's side is, okay? 22:42 I'm not saying, I believe it or not, but this is what they had. 22:45 Well, they had to create sort of an alternative theory. 22:47 They had to kick up, they had to kick up dust and confuse the jury. 22:51 And I think they did a decent job of bringing up, why didn't you stop and even say goodbye 22:55 to her when you left? 22:56 Why are you in such a hurry? 22:57 She left the door open on the stand. She said well 23:00 I had to get out of there because I knew my friend was outside waiting for me 23:04 She said that he was outside waiting, but he said she was outside waiting for him when he pulled up 23:10 So little inconsistencies here and there the defense wanted desperately to be able to connect her 23:16 They had a pre-trial hearing on what they call third-party culpability would say we want to bring her up 23:21 And we want to challenge this and we want to try to connect her the judge said no 23:25 there's not enough. You cannot do that. Right. But the defense, I think, walked right up to the 23:30 line and trying to kick up some dust that the jury might be confused about the actual timeline. 23:35 Which is, of course, what they were going to do, Ryan, you're nodding your head here. 23:39 Prosecutors argued that nothing is inconsistent with the defendant's guilt, which was interesting to 23:44 me because the prosecution, of course, painted this case and brought in witnesses, but the 23:48 defense didn't bring in any witnesses. They just wanted to create a little doubt. 23:51 And I asked prosecutors about that. Were you surprised the defense didn't call witnesses? 23:54 as they said, absolutely they were. They thought someone would be up there to at least talk about 23:59 who Oliverus was and try to explain the story. That of course would open some doors that maybe 24:04 the defense didn't want to happen. But yeah, it's interesting. I think when you look at this case, 24:10 part of the prosecution's theory that they tried to put out there was, 24:13 you know, these two young ladies come home two o'clock, something in the morning. 24:18 I went through with an officer about the distance of these things. Their apartment was 24:22 was about, I don't know, about 60 or 70 yards away 24:25 from this barbecue that was going into the small wee hours. 24:30 And Miguel and maybe these two women encountered each other. 24:32 Maybe some things were said, and then Karina leaves 24:35 and Miguel maybe uses that moment to make his attack. 24:38 That was sort of what they tried to paint. 24:41 What was difficult was, as Pat says, 24:44 no one could definitively place Miguel Olivares 24:47 at that barbecue. 24:48 And then the interaction, 24:49 No one could really say that happened either so the defense was able to paint a lot of doubt and that's all they have to do 24:55 You only need one yeah hang a jury 24:57 Yeah, and that was what they were going and that's what they were going for Pat 25:00 There was a moment in the trial that nobody saw coming and you're sitting right there all of ours breaks down in tears 25:06 After the defense plays a recorded jailhouse video call with a longtime friend of his Katie Ellen, right who has since passed away 25:13 I'm saying that she loved him. What was that moment like? 25:17 Well a little bit of backstory if I can briefly. So in court I met a woman named Laura Ellen. 25:23 Laura had a daughter, Katie, as you mentioned. Katie's now deceased sadly. But Katie was Miguel's 25:32 very closest friend back in the day around 2012. They worked at a pizza place. She was a UNC student 25:40 and they worked at a pizza place together and they stayed very close. They were not lovers, 25:45 They didn't date but they just had a connection and they watched movies together 25:51 They hung out at his house with her mom with his mom 25:53 She really loved this man now when she found out she had moved away when she found out that he had been charged 26:00 She was just dumbfound and she went right to the jail to have or she had several jailhouse calls with him and 26:10 The the reason why they played the jailhouse call the reason why the play the prosecution played it 26:15 was because he wrote they were having technical problems communicating so he 26:20 wrote a note to her and held it up to the screen on the camera to say you know 26:27 give me your number I will call you the prosecution was hoping to use that as a 26:32 handwriting comparison as to the note left at the scene but in a way maybe 26:38 Ryan agrees with me on this it sort of backfired but what it did do 26:43 So, Olavara sat in court and sobbed when he saw her on the screen, remembering their time. 26:51 I mean, sobbed. 26:52 Well, this is a friend that he's lost, and he's right there in court. 26:57 And you know what, Debra? 26:58 Let me just say this, though. 26:59 It was right after that. 27:01 That was the last thing left with the jury. 27:03 So in a way, it portrayed him as human, which may have played into the defense's 27:10 decision not to not to to here's what I think I think the defense said they 27:15 probably gambled and said you know what I've already poked holes in Carina's 27:19 story I've already poked holes in some of the DNA in the gathering of evidence 27:23 why not just leave this here this last thing for the jury to see that this 27:28 man is capable of sobbing and hurting yeah that's my take yeah well it 27:32 seemed to be the the way the defense was going but obviously it didn't make 27:37 that big of an impact. 27:39 Pat, because after about two days of deliberations, 27:42 the jury unanimously found Olivares guilty 27:45 on all counts related to this murder, burglary, rape, 27:49 and sexual assault of Hedgepat. 27:51 Ryan, I wanna talk about the jury, 27:53 but Pat, tell me about that moment 27:55 when they came with the guilty verdict. 27:57 Well, you know, I've been around since the T-Rex 28:00 and I've watched a whole lot of verdicts. 28:02 Maybe just all those T-Rex, but that's okay. 28:06 But I have to tell you so we were I was sitting on the you know 28:09 I didn't leave the courtroom except for you know a bathroom break or two while they were 28:13 Deliberating and it was really actually like more like a full day when you think about it that they deliberated 28:18 they started the night before but got nowhere and then 28:22 Deliberated all day long, but we were all sitting there because nobody wanted to leave and all of a sudden 28:27 I look around and people are just rushing the families rushing in reporters are running down the hallway and then 28:35 we get the word that there's a verdict. 28:37 And I sat there and I have to tell you, 28:39 after all these years, my heart was still pounding 28:41 because it was just so emotional watching 28:44 the families on both sides, by the way, Deborah, 28:47 watching the Hedgepeth family over here 28:50 just being stoic and hanging on to each other 28:53 and also watching Miguel's mother 28:56 behind him who also remained stoic. 28:58 And my heart still pounded through the whole thing. 29:03 and watching the reaction of Miguel, too, 29:06 who seemed to me to be A, in shock, 29:09 and B, in disbelief. 29:11 A lot of people characterized him as being smug 29:14 and shaking his head, like, you know, yeah. 29:16 And by the way, and maybe Ryan knows more about this, 29:19 but my understanding is that they weren't all 29:21 with unanimous in the beginning 29:22 that there were four who had questions. 29:25 Yeah, let's talk about that, 29:26 because Ryan did sit down with those jurors 29:28 and they struggled with this 29:29 and there were some who were not sure, 29:31 but they ultimately came together. 29:32 Tell us about that deliberation process. 29:34 Deborah, I'll tell you, how rare is it sometimes 29:37 for us to be able to talk to jurors after these cases? 29:39 I mean, it does not often happen. 29:40 Sometimes one, but certainly not several. 29:42 Oh, it was just so enlightening because you're right. 29:46 Both of you are right. 29:47 At the very beginning, they told me, 29:49 I spoke to four jurors, they told me they took a vote. 29:52 This is often what happens. 29:53 They go back there, okay, let's take a vote. 29:55 So here we are, eight to four, eight to four. 29:58 And that is, I would say, for people out there trying to say, 30:02 okay, well, that doesn't seem so unreasonable. 30:04 That can be a very wide chasm. 30:06 Yeah, because you've got to be unanimous 30:08 and you've got to convince four people. 30:09 Yes, and we had a couple of the people 30:12 who were on the foreside in our group. 30:15 And I said, well, what did you think? 30:17 Why did you think, give me your thoughts on that? 30:19 And one of the guys said, the manager 30:21 who I was speaking to said, I just thought he was not guilty. 30:27 And I was like, well, what do you mean just not guilty? 30:29 He said, no, I just couldn't see him as guilty. 30:31 And maybe that relates, Pat, 30:33 to part of what you were saying 30:34 about the emotion that he showed. 30:35 Maybe that that could have in many ways 30:37 heightened his sense of, hey, this is the weight of this. 30:41 Can I be sure? 30:42 Is there a no doubt in my mind that he did this? 30:45 Or do I have some reasonable doubt? 30:46 So this jury, they said a couple of things 30:48 that were very interesting. 30:49 First, they believed that the defense 30:51 was very convincing in sowing doubt. 30:53 And that was the big problem. 30:55 In many ways they had to ask for lab reports because they couldn't remember certain things 30:59 But one thing they really struggled with was motive 31:01 They could not understand especially because you couldn't place Miguel directly on the scene 31:06 Even though they weren't sure he was there or not 31:09 But it was there was no evidence that they had been friends or knew each other 31:11 Yeah, and they were really impacted by the gruesomeness of the crime scene a gentleman who was there who was on the jury 31:18 Was like it still impacts me to this day 31:20 So they were impacted by the idea that in such a gruesome crime scene, with such a violent crime, why? 31:27 Why? And so they had to list on a board the things they were to consider and the things that they did not have to consider. 31:35 And they had to keep referring back to the board because people kept asking, well, why? Why? 31:39 Yeah, but we don't have to prove motive. We have to prove did he violate these tenets of the law. 31:43 And so they had to keep going back to it, hammering away, and they finally got to a point of a guilty verdict. 31:48 but they struggled with it every step of the way. 31:50 Right, they did struggle. 31:51 Well, Pat, I want to ask you because it was 14 years for this family, 31:55 the Hezbollah family, and they finally, I guess, got answers. 31:58 But I want to ask you, and then, Ryan, I want your take on it, too. 32:01 They finally did get an answer, but do you think they really 32:05 understood what happened at the end of all of this, 32:07 from what you could see of them in court? 32:09 No, no, no. And you know, I have to tell you, before the trial, 32:15 I spent a lot of time with members of the tribe and across the board my feeling 32:22 from talking to a lot of people involved on the family side is that yes 32:28 Oliveris they believe got what he deserved but I think a lot of people 32:33 feel that that's the story the complete story has not been told yeah yeah 32:39 Ryan I was wondering too because as you said they couldn't quite figure out 32:42 motive. Yes, the family did get a conclusion. But do you think they have a sense of what happened 32:49 and why? No, I don't think they do at all. And I think it really needs to be said that like, 32:55 faith was a pillar of their community. I mean, I just can't, you think about someone young who 33:00 had their whole life ahead of them, who got a full ride to one of the top universities, 33:04 and whose desire was to go back and help her people. Like that was who she was about, 33:09 She was the pride of their family. 33:11 And so for them, it's like, 33:14 this is not a young woman who provokes people. 33:17 This is a young woman who has her heart on her sleeve 33:19 and people love her and has friends all over on campus. 33:23 Her community loves her. 33:25 They could not fathom why any of this would happen. 33:29 So there's been a verdict. 33:31 There's been a decision. 33:32 This man is now behind bars. 33:34 But for them, I can't imagine 33:36 how difficult this moment must be 33:38 Because for them they are still left with the idea of for someone who in our 33:43 family was almost like a godsend why would this happen to them and will we 33:46 ever really know why. Right right well that's what happens so often in these 33:50 cases oftentimes people do feel that they at least can have some peace but 33:53 you wonder if they ever will but it is sort of interesting her name is Faith 33:57 and this is a family of great faith and you know the only hope is that 34:00 maybe somehow over time they will be able to maybe find something some 34:04 comfort in the fact that it's over but you know these cases go on for a while. Ryan, thank you 34:10 again for taking some time. I know you're still reeling from what has been a very long week but 34:15 thank you for coming in and doing it and Pat of course always your incredible reporting is always 34:19 fabulous and great to have you with us. Thank you. Thanks for inviting me and it was lovely 34:23 working alongside Ryan today so I appreciate that. Yeah thank you Pat. Thank you Deborah. 34:27 Absolutely well I'm sure we may be hearing more about this story at some point you never 34:31 know where it's all going to go but we thank you for choosing to spend your time with us today 34:35 and of course you can find 2020 on Friday nights on ABC and you can stream episodes 34:40 just like this one anytime on Disney Plus and Hulu. Take care everybody.
Community discussion