Show full transcript 1:10 hours before the crime. A college town is shaken to its core when faith is found 1:16 murdered after a night on the town. This is our 9-1-1. Where is your 1:20 emergency? Stay unconscious. Please blood everywhere. Chapel Hill police say the 19-year-old's 1:27 friends found her body inside her off-campus apartment. Her death has 1:31 been ruled a homicide. The mystery of who killed faith unsolved after 14 long 1:37 years. So far there have been no answers. Until just last week answers finally 1:45 come to a North Carolina courtroom. Mr. Ford personally going to ask you to say as the 1:51 jury reached a verdict. I've been praying for this trial I have faith. 2:18 Our 2:18 Our story begins here at the bustling campus of University of North Carolina at Chapel 2:22 Hill. 2:23 I last came here for 2020 more than a decade ago to cover a mystery that has endured all 2:28 these years. 2:29 It's a tragic story about a 19-year-old UNC sophomore named Faith Hedgepeth. 2:37 Faith was a bundle of joy. 2:40 She was a God-seeing in my life. 2:43 She was just a daddy's girl. 2:45 Faith is always a very good spirit of child. 2:49 And I just remember that wonderful, infectious smile that she had. 2:57 When Faith was accepted to University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 3:02 that was a very proud moment for her immediate family, for the rest of the community. 3:06 She got accepted there on a gate scour. She was very intelligent. 3:12 This is the place that she had wanted to come all her life. 3:16 People know Chapel Hill for its basketball national championships, for its great athletes. 3:22 UNC is a really tough school to get into. 3:25 The fact that Faith got in tells you a little bit about who Faith was and where she was going 3:30 in her life. 3:36 Faith and Yuna Chavis became friends when they were both freshmen at the University 3:40 of North Carolina. 3:41 She smiled, I smiled, and we were best friends from there. 3:44 there. She jokingly called me Unabaloona, so she would say it in a very slow, southern 3:50 accent like, Unabaloona. And I think that people in general were just attracted to her 3:57 instantly. 4:00 Faith grew up in the remote enclave of Hollister, North Carolina. 4:04 This is a very tight-knit community. We support each other and take care of our 4:09 one. 4:11 There's a dollar general there and a couple of grills and a couple of gas stations. 4:16 And that's it for the most part. 4:18 She loved her people. 4:20 She loved being Hala Wasaponi. 4:24 Faith was very involved in the church. 4:28 So she grew up not only in the circle of the church, but also in the circle of the powwow, 4:34 meaning when they're dancing and singing, she stayed out of trouble that way. 4:42 We were both interested in health care, serving our tribal communities, because a lot of 4:47 American Indian community struggle with diabetes or alcoholism, high teen 4:52 pregnancy rates. She wanted to be a pediatrician. She wanted to give back. 4:58 Faith was having trouble making ends meet so she starts working at a local Red 5:01 Robin right and temporarily she moves in with her close friend Carina Rosario. The 5:06 two shared a one bedroom apartment and even the same bed. Faith was waiting 5:11 for some more money to come through from some scholarships so she could 5:14 find her own place to live. 5:19 September 6th, 2012. 5:22 And a seemingly ordinary night out 5:23 is about to take a deadly turn. 5:26 It's a Thursday evening when Faith and Karina 5:29 decide to blow off some steam at this popular night club 5:32 called The Thrill. 5:34 That night, while Faith and Karina were out, 5:36 Yuna says her phone rang. 5:38 I woke up about 2 o'clock in the morning, 5:42 and I had a couple of missed calls from Faith. 5:44 She's notorious for doing a butt-dial phone call where she accidentally called somebody with the phone in her pocket 5:51 So I just assumed that was what it was 5:55 And I went back to sleep and 5:57 The next morning I listened to it and all I could hear was music playing so I carried on with my day as normal 6:03 Normal well the next day was anything but normal for you 6:08 No, I got a phone call from one of our mutual friends. Someone had called her and told her faith was dead 6:14 On September 7th, 2012, the 19-year-old UNC sophomore was found beaten to death in an off-campus apartment 6:22 she shared with another student. 6:24 I get on the computer and I went to ABC News and Faith's picture was on the screen 6:31 and she had been found dead that morning. 6:35 I first interviewed Faith's parents back in 2016 and they took me back to that day that forever changed their lives. 6:42 How did you find out what happened to Faith? 6:45 I was at work, and one of my managers came to the door and said that I needed to call 6:52 this lady at the Chapel Hill Police Department. 6:56 So I called her and she said, well, Mrs. Hetchbuff, I'm sorry I have to tell you, but Faith 7:02 is dead. 7:05 And I said, no, I said, I said, she's not dead. 7:09 I said, you must be mistaken. 7:11 and it has to be someone else. 7:13 And she said, no, it's faith. 7:16 And when she told me that, I just dropped the phone 7:19 and laid my head on the desk and cried. 7:23 I called Roland. 7:25 When Connie called and she told me, 7:27 if I found Faith dead, I said, you sure Connie? 7:31 And I said, no, not my baby. 7:35 I lost it. 7:37 I cried and cried and cried. 7:40 Back at Faith and Carina's apartment, 7:43 Investigators are staring at a veritable bloodbath in the bedroom. 7:49 Faith was hanging off the bed. 7:52 Her shirt was pulled overhead. 7:55 Faith was wrapped partially in a comforter that had been located on the bed. 8:00 In that comforter is a peach-bacardi bottle, 8:06 and there is also a blue-reasling wine bottle. 8:10 Police won't say whether the 19-year-old was raped, 8:14 but they confirm she died from blunt force trauma. 8:18 Police believe that the Bacardi bottle was the murder weapon. 8:22 They found tissue fragments on it, 8:24 and they believed that it was used to bludgeon 8:28 Faith Hedgepath to death. 8:30 Faith had many contusions about her body 8:32 and some very deep lacerations about her head. 8:37 There was some blood splatter throughout the bedroom. 8:40 There was a semen found in Faith's body. 8:44 There was evidence of sexual assault and or intimacy, 8:48 and I can't tell you whether that occurred before or after. 8:53 It was a brutal, brutal death. 8:57 We think it's very likely that it's someone that Faith knew 9:00 that was in her, if not close circle of friends, 9:03 certainly someone who knew her. 9:04 Faith was a popular young lady and she had lots of friends 9:08 including several men that she actually spoke to the night she died and cops need 9:14 to talk to every single one of them I just 9:34 feel so bad for her she was in pain 9:40 she was alone faith was one of those people that you meet once in our 9:48 lifetime. Just the beauty that she brought. When the word came out that she had 9:55 been murdered it was a devastating loss. Two days after faith's murder the 9:59 community of Hollister holds a candlelight vigil in her honor. It was 10:03 really unfathomable to know that someone hurt her in such a way. Such a 10:08 beautiful person, nice person to be taken in such a manner was really a 10:17 shock. Detectives begin piecing together Faith's final hours, starting with a person who last 10:26 saw her alive, her roommate, Karina Rosario. Karina tells detectives that Faith attended 10:32 a sorority gathering before the two met up later at the library. 10:36 So as I remember the other night, you said that you and Faith left on Thursday evening 10:43 at some point to go to the library? 10:45 Yes. We went to the library. 10:49 And it's my understanding that she had returned back to the apartment around 7.30. 10:54 And then around midnight, her and Karina decided to go out to the thrill nightclub. 11:03 We were talking to some of the soccer players. 11:08 We moved them. Faith was dancing. 11:11 I was watching because I had a little cancer. 11:25 This surveillance video taken the night Faith was murdered shows her entering the thrill 11:29 around 12.40 am. 11:32 At around 2 am you see Faith and Karina leaving the club. 11:37 Around 2.15, I believe, that's when they just start wrapping everything up. 11:44 Everything kind of, around that time, got a little blurry for me because I was really drunk by that point. 11:52 After leaving the thrill, Karina said that she doesn't remember walking back up the stairs to her apartment. 11:59 I remember her trying to help me, so there was a trash can next to my side of the bed 12:07 with a trash bag in it. She had to have done that. 12:11 After throwing up, Prina says she went into the bathroom. 12:16 What we see from both of the young women's cell phones is they're making phone calls 12:22 and texts throughout the morning. 12:25 Also, in those early morning hours, Karina reaches out to another UNC student, and his 12:33 name is Brandon Edwards. 12:35 I tested Brandon as to where he was, he never responded, I think I called him, he didn't 12:43 respond. 12:44 He was Brandon. 12:45 Brandon Edwards, he's a good friend of me and Faith. 12:52 He's done a lot for the both of us, he just always been there whenever we needed him. 12:58 And Faith thought that we'd bring and like like each other and Faith thought that Brandon 13:04 like loved me and she always like, it's like Karina that boy loves you. 13:10 Brandon never answers his phone. 13:12 So Karina begins texting another man, Jordan McCrary. 13:15 One of the soccer players she had seen earlier that night at the thrill 13:19 I was there with some of my own teammates just kind of hanging out as a place that you typically go to and they were happen to be there 13:25 What we see is Karina asking him to please come pick her up 13:38 I was just curious on like why what was going on and she just kept iterating please come can you come 13:46 Jordan agrees to pick Karina up and arrives at the complex around 4.25 a.m. 13:51 I told her I was going to come outside because I knew he wasn't going to be able to find what apartment it is because the numbers were weird. 13:58 So I just got up off the floor, didn't turn off the bathroom light, didn't go back into the bedroom, just went straight up the door. 14:05 Karina said that once she left the apartment she didn't stop to look in the bedroom that she shared with Faith. 14:12 Did you say you? 14:12 No, I did not see her. I just figured she was in the bedroom, either sleeping or watching TV. 14:22 The following morning, Karina needs a ride home because Jordan's off in class, 14:29 and she said that she called Faith several times but couldn't get an answer. 14:34 So Karina calls another UNC student, Marisol Rangel. 14:38 You see, Marisol, Faith and Karina are all close friends. 14:41 I was like, I can come pick you up and I'll take you back to the apartment. 14:45 She's probably asleep. 14:46 So I picked up Karina and we came back to the apartment and we saw her car. 14:53 So that's when we went upstairs and all I remember is just calling her name just 14:59 because we knew she was there, like Faith, Faith. 15:03 That's when we went to the room and we called her and it was just fun. 15:20 Karina describes the horrifying moment when she entered that bedroom. 15:25 I started to see red blood, like red stuff on the pillows and the wall. 15:32 And then I pulled the sheet down and I saw that she had black eye. 15:36 I didn't think she was dead though. I thought it was just, she passed out. 15:41 She had suffered what appeared to be severe head trauma. 15:44 And she was obviously deceased. 15:48 You're on 9-1-1, where is your emergency? 15:51 Around 11-0-1, Karina calls 9-1-1. 15:55 She sounds very upset. 16:04 Okay, listen to, okay, okay, how old is your, how old is she? 16:11 She sounds very upset, very panicked. 16:15 The 9-1-1 dispatcher asked her to see if she was breathing and Karina didn't want 16:21 to touch her at that point. 16:23 I don't have a touch here, but... 16:26 Listen to me. Is she breathing? 16:29 I don't know. 16:31 You need to check and see. Is she breathing? 16:34 I don't think so. 16:39 Okay, listen to me. 16:40 I'm gonna drink blood everywhere. 16:44 No one had any clue about who did it 16:47 and the person who did it was still out there on the run. 16:51 As investigators begin to process the crime scene, 16:54 they believe Faith's killer left behind 16:56 and the holy grail of physical evidence, DNA. 17:00 They did a rape kit and found some male DNA on Faith Head Peth. 17:05 That DNA that was found on Faith's body 17:09 was also found somewhere else. 17:12 The Bacardi bottle appears to have a bloody palm print 17:17 and two thumb prints. 17:19 that DNA also matched DNA found on the blue re-sling bottle. 17:26 There is forensic evidence that could turn this case around, 17:29 but with more than 1,800 people on their radar, 17:32 virtually anyone could be the killer. 17:46 In our hometown of Hollister, Faith Hedgepeth is laid to rest. 17:49 It's a huge turnout to support the family. 17:53 There were so many people there that they had like four wakes. 17:57 They were all down the roads and everywhere. 18:00 We just kind of sat there in shock like I don't understand. 18:05 Days later, a memorial at her high school. 18:08 I like to cry because I know she won't want us to cry. 18:11 Keep the hope and the faith that they catch the person that did this. 18:20 Here is this promising young student, this bright energy. 18:23 She had so much potential. 18:26 And she was murdered and no one knew how or why. 18:31 I think we get so caught up in the details of her. 18:34 This gruesome murder that we forget that it was just this outstanding, great woman. 18:40 Back in the investigation room, the list of potential suspects is growing. 18:46 Faith knew hundreds of people. 18:48 She was very personable, loved by many. 18:51 So as time went on, it just grew and grew. 18:56 So the investigators did a really good job of collecting the information we needed, the 19:01 cell phone tower dumps, the video surveillance. 19:05 They were going down investigative paths in their work to try to find the killer, but 19:11 it kept turning up dead ends. 19:13 The palm and fingerprints that were lifted from the scene, police don't find any match 19:19 in any database. 19:23 Investigators turn to the strongest evidence they have so far. 19:25 that DNA found on Faith's body and at the crime scene. 19:29 They knew they had male DNA, 19:33 and it didn't match anything in their database, 19:36 so they went out. 19:37 They went out and they tried to figure out who this might be. 19:40 They start with the two men who had been texting Karina and Faith that night, 19:45 including one whom they saw at the Thrill nightclub, 19:49 the same person who came and picked up Karina in the early morning hours, 19:54 Jordan McCrary. 19:56 Chapel Hill investigators were able to link multiple men 20:00 to the murdered UNC student. 20:02 Police say some of the men were reluctant to provide DNA 20:05 while some flat-out refused. 20:07 From the beginning, I was trying to help. 20:10 The police asked me to take a DNA sample and I complied. 20:14 Jordan McCrary's DNA is tested, but it is not a match. 20:18 Next, police look at Brandon Edwards. 20:21 Now remember, he's the guy 20:23 that Karina was so desperately trying to reach 20:27 in those early morning hours. 20:30 And once again, it's a dead end. 20:33 Brandon Edwards isn't a DNA match either. 20:38 So you DNA tested scores of people 20:41 from the Thrill Night Club, from her workplace, 20:44 other people that Faith came into contact with, 20:47 and were any of them a match 20:48 for the DNA that was found on Faith? 20:50 No. 20:51 You ended up DNA swabbing everybody on the soccer team. 20:54 Because, you know, there was an association. 20:58 You know, it's an exhaustive search and somebody out there has the DNA that matches. 21:02 How many people have you pursued in this case? 21:05 Over 1,800. 21:06 1,800 people? 21:07 Yes. 21:08 I mean, does that just boggles the mind when I hear the number? 21:11 Despite that number, Faith's loved ones are still in the dark. 21:17 Everyone wants answers. Everyone needs answers, especially those closest to her. 21:21 Faith's family was really frustrated. 21:23 They were hoping investigators would have some leads, 21:25 but the family had nothing. 21:28 One of the hardest things in dealing with no information 21:31 from the police is that family is constantly 21:34 asking if they have any suspects, the persons of interest. 21:37 It's a hopeless feeling. 21:41 We're just one big family together. 21:45 So if it happens to one, then you've certainly 21:48 included all of us. 21:50 We're very understanding of how traumatic it is to experience something like Faith's 21:55 family's experience, but everything we've said or chosen not to say has been with finding 22:00 Faith's killer in mind. 22:04 I hope and praise no one we know, but it may be somewhere we've met before. 22:12 As police continue their investigation, one person who catches their attention is Karina's 22:16 ex-boyfriend, Eric DeCoy Jones. 22:18 Police say he knows both Faith and Carina. 22:22 To Koei Jones, there is the ex-boyfriend of Carina, 22:26 and he had previously lived there with Carina. 22:30 So even though Jones moved out of the apartment 22:33 just before Faith moved in, 22:36 he still lived in another building within the complex. 22:40 He also had a past with Carina 22:42 that raised some red flags for police. 22:45 So she brought a restraining order against him. 22:47 Yes. 22:48 Now according to the restraining order, 22:51 Karina alleges that her boyfriend came into her apartment, 22:55 began verbally abusing her and pushed her to the ground. 23:01 Downstairs neighbor Joy Barker says 23:03 Faith paid an active role in seeing 23:05 his relationship with Karina end. 23:08 Faith drove Karina to the courthouse 23:12 to fill out the paperwork to get the restraining order. 23:17 But after the murder, Jones only 23:19 He had good things to say about faith. 23:22 I mean, faith was the sweetest person 23:23 to know where I can't believe in it, but I'm still in shock. 23:27 All right, it's unreal. 23:29 He actually spoke fairly fondly of faith 23:32 and was surprised at what happened to her. 23:37 I mean, at first glance, he looked like a good suspect. 23:42 Jones's DNA was eventually compared to the DNA that 23:47 was found in Faye's apartment. 23:48 You tested his DNA? 23:51 Yes. 23:52 Was he a match for any of that DNA on faith or in that apartment? 23:55 No. 23:56 It's another DNA dead end. 23:59 Jones has eventually cleared. 24:00 Tomorrow will mark a year since the UNC Junior's friend found her body inside her off-campus apartment. 24:06 So far, there have been no answers. 24:10 All of a sudden, it's the first anniversary of the murder. 24:17 It doesn't get any easier. 24:19 That's our biggest question is why. 24:21 We can't move on we just we've been stuck for a year. I prayed it we won't be 24:27 here next year talking about you know the case is not solved. Just as the case 24:36 appeared to be going cold the cops released this message that was next to 24:40 Faith's body an ominous message who wrote it how did it get there all part of 24:45 the deepening mystery. 25:06 Was that someone random who might have seen them out 25:10 or from the neighborhood. 25:15 Someone's out there living their life like nothing happened. 25:19 Nearly two years later, 25:21 and with at least two agencies investigating, 25:24 there've been no arrests. 25:25 And it was a deepening mystery week after week, 25:28 month after month, year after year 25:29 that was really gripping this community 25:32 that wanted answers. 25:34 Despite having what they say is a strong case 25:36 and that male DNA, investigators from Chapel Hill PD 25:40 and the State Bureau of Investigation 25:42 have been unable to find a match. 25:44 Police officers probably have a lot of different cases, 25:47 but it's like, when it's someone that close, 25:50 it's like you want an answer. 25:57 Over the years, since that atrocity occurred, 25:59 a lot of us have wondered what's taken so long. 26:03 When will it come to resolution? 26:04 Because everyone wants answers, everyone needs answers. 26:07 We have a killer out there, 26:08 and we are going to find him or her. 26:12 There isn't a minute or a day that goes by 26:14 that we don't look at this case or think of faith. 26:18 It consumes us. 26:19 More than a year and a half ago, 26:21 when the UNC student was found dead. 26:23 No suspects have been identified. 26:25 No closure for faith's friends and family. 26:28 Everyone once answers, 26:29 and the media puts pressure on the department. 26:32 So, Chapel Hill decides to release 26:34 hundreds of pages from their murder book. 26:37 And this is the first time that the public 26:39 is able to take a look at that horrific crime scene. 26:44 One of the key things to emerge from these documents when they were released was 26:50 this paper bag that had a note scrolled on it at the crime scene. 26:54 What was some of the most important evidence that you collected from the bedroom? 26:57 There was a biscuit bag that was from Time Out Restaurant. Time Out is very popular in 27:03 Chapel Hill and it's immediately identifiable. 27:07 Faith's roommate Karina tells police what she remembers about the bag. 27:10 I was at time now on Wednesday. 27:14 A friend had gotten me a, it was in a white bag, a biscuit. 27:19 I literally just left it in the bag. 27:22 And was it in the bag when you left at your room? 27:25 I wouldn't have left it out. 27:27 And where do you think you ought to live? 27:29 I don't know, I just, I just throw things. 27:32 He might have just been on my side of the bed, 27:35 right next to it. 27:36 Might have been on the table. 27:37 on the bag was some writing that said I'm not stupid bitch jealous what did you 27:42 make of that obviously big evidentiary value police find that note and they 27:49 observed that it's written in pen and block letters now even though there's 27:53 blood pretty much everywhere there's hardly any on this note but guess what 27:59 there is that male DNA my biggest concern about the note was that the 28:06 Paper bag was clean. 28:08 There was no visible blood on the bag or anything. 28:10 How did this paper bag play into the investigation? 28:13 What did it mean? 28:15 Who wrote it? 28:15 How did it get there? 28:19 I have heard different experts discuss that bag 28:22 and some have said that they feel like it was written 28:26 by the person that killed Faith 28:28 and others have said that they feel like it was planted. 28:31 As to the intended target per se about the note, 28:34 there were two residents there 28:36 and it would make sense that no, it was left for one of them. 28:40 I think that Corina knows a lot more than she's seen. 28:44 I think that Corina knows what happened to Faith. 28:48 Faith's father, Roland, told us that he's long suspected 28:51 that Corina could be the key to this case. 28:54 911, where is your emergency? 28:57 Faith's family finds her 911 call questionable. 29:00 They wonder why Corina never mentions 29:02 the friend who was with her when Faith's body was discovered. 29:04 I was in the room and Karina kept walking out in and of the room. 29:10 But I was just telling her to tell him not to hurry up. Just don't hurry up. 29:17 Do you think Karina's behavior was strange on that 911 call? 29:20 It was strange. It was strange behavior. 29:25 She never, she never safe-faced named. 29:34 From that 911 call, do you think that there was something that Karina was hiding? 29:39 They were questions that resulted from that 911 call that we had to clarify with Carina. 29:49 Downstairs neighbor Joy Barker told me Carina also had what she described as a memorably 29:54 serene demeanor when she exited the apartment that morning. 29:58 That's the striking thing. 30:00 You would never have known that they had just come from discovering what turned 30:07 out to be horribly brutal murder scene. 30:09 Was she crying? 30:11 No. 30:12 No crying at all? 30:13 No. 30:14 And I was outside from 1 o'clock until about 1.30. 30:23 I never saw Karina crying or upset. 30:27 Moment of crisis, it's hard to judge whether someone's behavior is normal or abnormal 30:31 because everybody reacts differently. 30:39 Faith's downstairs neighbor also told investigators that she heard some curious noises coming 30:43 from Faith and Carina's apartment before Carina left with Jordan McCrary early that morning. 30:51 What did you hear in the early morning hours upstairs in that apartment? 30:55 Between 3.30 and quarter four, I heard three thumps. They were basically together, 31:03 thumps, and that's the right word to describe them. 31:06 And remember, Carina herself said that she did not leave that apartment until 4.30 in the 31:12 morning. Police want more answers. Whether or not she is giving us all of the 31:18 information that she knows and or truthful information continues to be 31:23 under investigation. There were questions that were beginning to emerge 31:28 about Corina and about faith and what was happening inside that apartment. 31:36 Police discover Corina's friend spots something on Corina's body the night 31:47 Today I want to tell you about our friends at Proper Hills. 31:56 Ask your mom, and she'll probably tell you, one of the best parts of the holiday season 32:00 is getting to see family and friends who live far away. 32:03 Something about actually seeing the face of someone you love is just special. 32:07 No matter how much you might talk over text and phone calls throughout the year. 32:10 Of course when the holidays are over and everyone is back at home, she'll miss 32:13 seeing those faces again. 32:14 But you can keep the warm and fuzzy feelings going by giving the perfect gift, a Proper 32:19 Hills digital frame. 32:21 Proper Hills makes sleek digital photo frames that let you display a rotation of up to 20,000 32:25 photos and videos. 32:27 The 10 inch frame is elegant and timeless, designed to complement any room no matter 32:31 the style of decor. 32:32 And the best part is that it's seamless to add new photos or videos at any time. 32:35 You can send photos from anywhere, at home, or on the go. 32:38 With our limited time deal you can scoop up this gorgeous frame for an incredible 32:42 price. 32:42 Head to abcsecretsavings.com slash 2020 to score your digital frame for more than 60% off. 32:50 You can even get free shipping and have it at your door with plenty of time before the 32:53 holidays. 32:54 Again, that's abcsecretsavings.com slash 2020 for this incredible deal. 33:00 abcsecretsavings.com slash 2020. 33:05 My life is booked and busy. 33:08 I don't have time to try on a million outfits that still don't feel right. 33:11 That's why I get styled with StitchVix. 33:13 My personal stylist sends outfits picked for my size, style, and budget so I can get dressed 33:18 and get on with my day feeling confident. 33:21 It's no risk, all style. 33:24 Free shipping, free returns, no subscription required. 33:27 Get started today at stitchfix.com. 33:29 That's stitchfix.com. 33:34 T'was many nights before Christmas and one woman knew she needed a Christmas tree so 33:39 to Wayfair she flew. 33:40 Finding just the right one and for years it will last. 33:43 Wayfair shipping was free and remarkably fast. 33:46 What's this? Garland, a wreath, essentials to host? 33:49 Good thing she celebrates way longer than most. 33:52 As her cart filled with magic and decor from the heart, 33:55 Merry Christmas to all. Get your Wayfair head start. 33:58 For holiday decor you can count on year after year, Wayfair delivers. 34:16 There were questions that were beginning to emerge about Corina. 34:21 They were wondering about the relationship she had with Faith. 34:26 Is Carina Rosario a person of interest? 34:28 She remains a person of interest. 34:31 There are several people in this case 34:33 that continue to be persons that we need to talk to. 34:36 We're dealing with a lot of information. 34:37 We just want to make sure that we're clear 34:40 on everything we talk about. 34:42 How many times has the Chapel Hill Police Department 34:44 interviewed Carina? 34:45 I would estimate over 10 times. 34:48 Has she been cooperative? 34:49 Yes. 34:50 They're trying to figure out her story 34:54 and whether she's telling the truth. 34:56 So I called Jordan, and I guess I asked him to come and get me. 35:01 It was a little out of it, but I was like, 35:04 can you come and get me, please? 35:05 She called me early in the morning, 35:07 and basically she was saying, please come. 35:09 And I was just curious on, like, why, what was going on. 35:12 And she just kept iterating, please come. 35:16 Can you come? 35:17 Around what time does he get to the apartment? 35:19 Maybe about an hour. 35:20 So he arrives around four or so in the morning. 35:23 When you left the apartment, are you sure that it wasn't locked? 35:29 I'm sure it wasn't locked. 35:31 I mean, you didn't have a key to lock it, right? 35:34 Did it seem like there was forced entry going into the apartment? 35:36 No. There was no sign of forced entry. 35:39 So in your mind, it sounds like either the killer is someone she knew or the door was open so somebody could just walk in? 35:45 Yeah, and you know that we live in a college community and I would have to say just how 35:51 I was in college. Security is not on everybody's forefront. It's not unusual to find college 35:57 students that leave doors open or vehicles unlocked. 36:00 Did Jordan ever go inside the house? 36:02 No, he did not. He picked her up outside. She came outside the house. 36:06 So the only people that were ever in that house, at least when Karina left, were 36:10 Faith and Karina. 36:11 Yes. 36:15 One day after Faith was found murdered, Jordan McCrary says, 36:19 you remember something strange about Karina when you picked her up? 36:22 He calls in a tip to Chapel Hill police. 36:25 Hi, this is Jordan McCrary. You did say I called you, but I remembered anything 36:29 and I just wanted to quickly say yes, I do. 36:32 In the car ride, Karina was looking at her hand and I looked over 36:36 and that's when I remember she mentioned that there was a butt on her hand. 36:40 She looked at her finger and it was like a small smudge, a small smudge of blood. 36:47 And she was like, I don't know why I'm pulling my finger. 36:49 I said, yeah, why do you have that on your finger? 36:52 And she just goes, I don't know. 36:54 Dude, it looked like it's a fresh blood. 36:58 No. 37:00 It didn't. 37:00 It seemed like, because when she was pulling this, it didn't smear anything. 37:05 It just stayed the same. 37:06 Why does Karina have a bloody hand when her roommate is found inside beaten to death in a bloody crime scene? 37:18 Do you remember him asking you about blood on your fingers, you know? 37:30 Because apparently you had some blood on your hand that he asked you about. 37:34 I mean, I was thrown out for red stuff, but I don't remember their people in my hand. 37:43 I really don't. 37:45 Do you have any idea how that was about on your hand? 37:50 You were thrown out, but I don't know. 37:56 I don't think it was blood. 37:58 I mean, I think I wasn't bleeding anywhere. 38:06 Police tested Jordan's car door and their initial test indicated that it was blood but 38:15 there was not enough to obtain any DNA that they could identify. 38:22 2020 made numerous attempts to reach Karina back in 2016 with no luck, so I paid her a 38:27 visit in person. 38:28 Karina? 38:29 Hi, I'm Ryan Smith with ABC News is 2020, hoping to hear her side of the story. 38:33 I just wanted to know if there was a chance for us to talk to you. 38:36 We just want to clear the record on the Faith Hedge Peth case 38:39 and really just kind of get your story out. 38:42 Is there any way that we can talk to you at some point? 38:44 We just had no other way to reach you. 38:46 I don't want you to... I don't want to... 38:48 Can I ask you one question? 38:57 Police found no evidence directly linking Karina to the crime scene. 39:03 No evidence indicating Karina was involved in any way. 39:09 We maintain a master list of people many of those were those that were at the thrill 39:14 Many of those are associates of face whether they be from her hometown her place of work the apartment complex she lived in 39:21 So you DNA tested scores of people and were any of them a match for the DNA that was found on faith? No 39:28 It's been four years since Faith's murder no arrests 39:34 No suspects and the idea that perhaps Faith knew her killer 39:41 seems to have gone nowhere. 39:45 But then there's a huge development that breathes life into this cold case. 39:49 New DNA technology that could actually reveal the face of Faith's killer. 39:55 This is a real revolution in the way DNA is used in forensic investigations. 39:59 Nobody knows the killer's name, but could this be his face? 40:03 We put all of that together into this composite to play what this person may look like. 40:08 It's been four years since a UNC sophomore was found brutally 40:28 murdered 40:29 inside her Chapel Hill apartment. The UNC students killing still unsolved. 40:35 Investigators also collected a male suspect's DNA, but so far there have been no answers. 40:43 The police were not telling us really anything about what had happened to a 40:46 Chapel Hill police did not volunteer any information to me whatsoever. It was 40:51 like pulling to, so to speak, trying to get anything out of them. 40:54 A lot of us have wondered what's taken so long. 40:57 Everyone wants answers. 40:59 Everyone needs answers, especially those closest to her, 41:02 so that they can at least be able to have 41:05 some degree of closure. 41:08 Years have passed since Faith's murder, 41:10 and authorities haven't named any suspects, 41:12 let alone made any arrests. 41:15 We're going to do it. 41:16 We're going to get the guys or the people involved in this. 41:19 I promise you. 41:21 Desperate for answers, Fates' father Roland turns to a private investigator, Hunter Glass, 41:26 to take a fresh look at the case. 41:28 When I was brought in on the investigation when I was asked in, 41:31 I made a few phone calls for Roland and his family as Roland explained to me 41:35 they were not getting any answers. 41:37 But I could also understand why law enforcement does that. 41:40 A lot of times when families are involved, 41:42 you don't want to give them too much information, 41:45 you don't want them jumping to conclusions, 41:47 if you don't want any form of vigilani-ism. 41:51 One Avenue Glass Explorers is that middle-of-the-night pocket dial 41:54 that fates friend Yuna received from her the night of the murder. 42:02 Get off me. I definitely heard that. 42:08 Help me again. 42:14 That's definitely a man with a deep voice. 42:18 Police think that call happened in that club. 42:21 What did you hear on that call and what do you think really happened? 42:25 I think whatever started, started before it got here and the club just accelerated it. 42:31 Alcohol, crap talking and I think that just accelerated it and it just got out of control. 42:36 What do you think is the accelerant? 42:38 What's the accelerant that happened in that club that led to Faith's death? 42:41 Well it's written on the letter, jealousy. 42:44 I believe that maybe I just have an angry person who is very jealous of faith. 42:49 But if jealousy was a motive here, that would imply that there was some intimate relationship 42:55 that would make at least one person mad. 42:58 And it seems that theory has already gone by the wayside. 43:02 All of faith and or Karina's associates and or extended associates were canvassed or 43:09 or asked voluntarily for DNA swab, 43:13 you know, our investigative leads exhausted. 43:16 Much to the dismay of the Hedgepath family, 43:19 try as he may, the private investigator 43:21 just didn't turn up anything new, 43:23 and the case remains cold. 43:27 Cops might not have a name to connect 43:29 to that unknown male DNA sample, 43:31 but investigators tap into a new technology 43:33 that can analyze that sample 43:35 to determine hair, eye, and skin color, 43:38 and potentially a glimpse at what fates killer could look like. 43:47 So we have a pair bond snapshot which is a makeup or a composite of the DNA profile that we can 43:54 elect it at the scene. Snapshot predicts eye color, hair color, skin color, freckling, face 44:00 morphology, and ancestry. What snapshot is doing is treating the DNA like a blueprint, 44:06 the genetic blueprint that allows us to predict what someone looks like. 44:11 I wouldn't say we would eliminate anybody based on a composite. 44:15 However, it gives us a direction and or information to further use as a resource or a tool that we have. 44:23 This person has dark olive or light olive skin. This person has brown or hazel eyes. 44:28 This person most likely has black hair. 44:31 We typically see this profile in Latino individuals. 44:35 So this gives us, again, a general snapshot. 44:38 Faith's family was looking for a break in the case. 44:41 All of us in this community were looking for a break in the case. 44:43 When Parabon Labs came out with this, it was a vivid image. 44:50 You could see who potentially was the killer, 44:54 who investigators should be looking for. 44:57 Tonight on 2020... 44:59 In 2016, 2020 aired our original program on Faith's murder. 45:03 And tonight, police are bringing in 2020 and you to help crack the crime. 45:08 We shared that sketch with our viewers. 45:10 A killer still on the loose, but by the end of this hour, you will have in your hands 45:15 what may be the portrait of that killer. 45:18 Investigators were hoping that someone might see it and put an end to the mystery of who 45:22 killed Faith. 45:23 September of 2021, that all changed. 45:28 Finally, a real face and a name will emerge. 45:32 The arrest was made this morning. He's been charged with first-degree murder of faith Danielle Hedgepath 45:44 Observe the North American dad 50s great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on 45:51 Carvana and offer appears in minutes remarkable. He squints reads it again smiles and says dang 45:59 That's a good offer the highest form of approval. No haggling. No hassle. No one called him 46:06 Boss, he's still on the couch. 46:09 Astonishing. 46:10 Sell your car today on carvana.com. 46:13 Pickup fees may apply. 46:15 My life is booked and busy. 46:17 I don't have time to try on a million outfits 46:19 that still don't feel right. 46:21 That's why I get styled with Stitch Fix. 46:23 My personal stylist sends outfits 46:25 picked for my size, style, and budget 46:27 so I can get dressed and get on with my day 46:29 feeling confident. 46:31 It's no risk, all style. 46:33 Free shipping, free returns, no subscription required. 46:36 Get started today at stitchfix.com. 46:39 That's stitchfix.com. 46:44 T'was many nights before Christmas, and one woman knew 46:47 she needed a Christmas tree, so to Wayfair she flew. 46:50 Finding just the right one, and for years it will last. 46:53 Wayfair shipping was free, and remarkably fast. 46:56 What's this, garland, a wreath, essentials to host? 46:59 Good thing she celebrates way longer than most. 47:02 As her cart filled with magic and decor from the heart. 47:05 Merry Christmas to all. Get your Wayfair head start. 47:08 For holiday decor you can count on year after year, Wayfair delivers. 47:39 Faith was an enrolled tribal citizen of the Hallowasaponi Indian tribe. 47:47 She was one of our own. 47:50 She participated in her powwows, wore a few crowns. 47:55 A 19-year-old student who had her entire life ahead of her. 48:00 Promising future, attending the UNC Chapel Hill. 48:04 Ready to pledge Native American sorority. 48:08 New wrinkles this morning in an unsolved murder case, 48:10 a college student from North Carolina was found dead in her apartment. 48:14 Chapel Hill police are releasing the gruesome details of their investigation 48:18 into the murder of University of North Carolina sophomore Faith Hedgepath. 48:25 This is not something that happens, you know, often or every day in Chapel Hill. 48:29 Everybody was just shocked, like, oh my God, you know, what happened? 48:33 Faith's story is deeply personal, but for Indigenous communities across America, her 48:38 murder speaks to a much larger concern. 48:40 The safety of Indigenous women and their loved ones. 48:45 The red handprint movement is also another name for missing and murdered Indigenous women 48:50 and people. 48:51 And I think Faith's case brought attention to the movement. 48:56 When something happens to one of us, it kind of happens to all of us. 49:01 Faith Hedgepeth was just 19 years old when she was murdered. 49:04 As the years passed by without an arrest, grief was only compounded by unanswered questions. 49:12 But investigators do have something solid that they were able to find in the early 49:19 days of this investigation. 49:21 DNA, they collected at the scene that points to an unknown male suspect. 49:28 And we have to find that person. 49:31 We never stopped looking for the person who murdered Faith. 49:36 Since we last spoke to her, 49:38 Salisa Layhew has gone from a lieutenant 49:39 with the Chapel Hill Police Department 49:41 to its chief of police. 49:44 This case always came with me. 49:47 It really did become personal 49:49 beyond just my role as an investigator. 49:53 Sometimes I would wake up in the middle of the night 49:55 and not be able to sleep and I'd come in to work. 49:57 It was really important to me to solve this case. 50:03 The last big break in the case, when a breakthrough in DNA technology led to that composite sketch 50:08 of the alleged killer, which aired publicly on 2020 and 2016. 50:13 And since our original report aired, investigators worked tirelessly to put a name to that 50:18 unidentified male suspect profile. 50:21 I knew immediately upon seeing the match list that this was going to be a very challenging 50:26 case and it would likely take a long time for us to be able to identify faith's killer. 50:32 I'm C.C. Moore. I'm the Chief Genetic Genealogist at Parabon Nanolabs. 50:38 In 2018, the Chapel Hill Police Department asked me if I could use genetic genealogy to help them 50:46 identify the suspect in the Faith Hedgepeth 2012 homicide case. So investigative genetic 50:53 genealogy is using a totally different type of DNA testing and many many more markers. 51:00 First we get a list of people who share DNA with that unknown suspect 51:05 and we have to identify all those individuals and then build their family trees. 51:10 But there were definite challenges involved because these family trees once we started 51:16 building them almost immediately left the United States. It became clear very quickly that 51:21 this person had roots in Guatemala but I hadn't been able to zero in on just where in Guatemala. 51:29 I'm not an expert in Latin American genetic genealogy, so that's why I brought Carol in 51:35 to help on that. Well Cece asked me to take a look at it in 2020 and because this was a Latin 51:42 American case it is much more helpful if you have somebody who has the ability to read the 51:48 records. I took the lead documenting these family trees and doing all of the 51:55 building back in time to you know sometimes it's over a hundred years ago 51:59 when we're looking for common ancestors and then we began bringing those 52:03 families forward in time generation by generation and so as we start to build 52:07 the trees of these matches of this unknown individual all of them are 52:12 leading back to two specific departments within Guatemala that was 52:15 one of the patterns that emerged. 52:18 The Catholic Church has done an amazing job 52:20 of documenting births and baptisms 52:23 and marriages and deaths throughout time, 52:26 really going back three, four, 500 years in some cases. 52:30 This is a marriage record from a very small town 52:33 in Guatemala that I used to help build the trees 52:36 of some of those matches. 52:38 So when we're doing genetic genealogy, 52:40 we're always looking for that branch of the family tree 52:42 that moves closer to the location of the crime. 52:45 Carol really laid the foundation 52:48 with her extensive genealogy work 52:51 and yet was unable to find a line 52:54 that came to North Carolina. 52:57 We were working collaboratively with another researcher 53:00 and as it happens, he was able to find another line 53:04 that had been missed. 53:05 That turned out to be the line as it came forward 53:07 in time that ended up right where the crime happened. 53:10 At that point, candidates were identified to be further researched and that was provided 53:16 to Chapel Hill Police Department and they took it from there. 53:21 We were able to develop a lead using that genetic information. 53:26 We used that genetic genealogy and we got to a place in which we used other investigative 53:33 tools and one of the persons we found lived in our city. Law enforcement was 53:41 able to identify an individual they believed may be connected to this. It 53:47 was the hard work of genealogists and research that we're able to slowly, 53:53 painstakingly over the course of years fill in that family tree until we got 53:59 Closer and closer to the person we believed was our suspect. 54:04 Now, after years of searching, investigators may finally be able to find Faith's killer. 54:23 Once the branch of this family tree was found that led to North Carolina, 54:27 we knew we were getting very, very close to identifying Faith's killer. 54:31 But at that point, law enforcement investigation takes over. 54:35 In this case, social media ended up providing a lead 54:39 that we hadn't been able to find any other way. 54:42 Police find a photo on social media taken in a church 54:44 right there in Chapel Hill of a young man 54:47 who could be the person they're looking for. 54:50 His name is Miguel Salguero Olivares, 54:53 and he would have been 19 years old 54:56 at the time of face murder. 54:58 The Parabon Nano Lab's phenotype snapshot 55:00 that was released back in 2016 55:02 matches some of the characteristics that Miguel shares. 55:05 Dark hair, dark eyes, and Latino ancestry. 55:08 You feel like you have your guy, but you have to get his DNA. 55:14 How was the DNA obtained from Miguel? 55:18 Investigator spent an entire day following Miguel around without his knowledge. 55:22 So we waited for an opportunity that we could collect an item that we know would have his DNA on it. 55:31 They actually worked it like 24-7 until they had the results. 55:36 I remember calling one of the SBI investigators and saying is it back yet? 55:43 Is it back yet? And probably ten minutes later he came through my door and I knew 55:48 at that point and it was it was a lot of emotion. So as soon as we had a match 55:54 from the lab we huddled up as an investigative team and we decided to 55:58 approach him early in the morning before he went to work. The rest of 56:02 us were listening through the body-borne camera. 56:05 We just want to talk to you and see if you got any information about it. 56:09 About what? 56:10 About the case we're working. 56:12 Do you know this girl? 56:15 No. 56:16 You don't know her? 56:17 No. 56:19 Never. 56:20 You've never met her before? 56:21 No. 56:22 Have you had sex with her? 56:24 No. 56:25 He seemed very dismissive and nonchalant about it. 56:30 But it was nine years and nine days to when the crime occurred. 56:34 What would you say, Miguel, if I told you that I know that you killed this girl? 56:44 And that I know that you were there? 56:49 How are you going to tell that to me? 56:51 What if I told you that I know that 100 percent? 56:56 Would that change your mind? 56:58 I don't get that. 57:00 He was arrested right there in the parking lot and transported to the Chapel Hill Police Department. 57:07 Now, you're under arrest, man. 57:09 Finally, nine years after Faith's murder in 2021, there was an announcement that an arrest had been made. 57:16 Today is an important day as we announced that we have arrested Miguel in Rinke, 57:26 He's been charged with first-degree murder of Faith Danielle Hedgepath. 57:31 There was a sense of relief for Faith's family. 57:34 There was a sense of relief for her friends and people in the college community. 57:38 It's been a long nine years, of course, I know this is not, this is not, the case is not solved. 57:43 This is not the end. This is just the beginning. 57:45 When I got the news this morning, I didn't do anything but cry and thank God. 57:51 and praise God and praying and asking God everything would be revealed that 58:01 happened that morning or faith still. I think a lot of people think when there 58:07 is a DNA match done deal, case over. But far from it? Far from it. Why? It wasn't 58:14 like a sigh of relief because we were still working and it wasn't over yet 58:17 but it was almost like okay now we're moving on to another chapter. You've 58:22 You got to look nine years earlier, back to 2012 and start figuring out those pieces of 58:29 the puzzle. 58:30 Where was he? 58:31 How is he connected? 58:32 Is he connected? 58:33 Despite this long list of suspects, no one's heard of this person. 58:39 No one knows who he is or how he is connected to Faith Hedgepett. 58:45 Miguel arrived here with his mother from Guatemala and at the time of Faith's murder, 58:50 he was 19 years old. 58:51 essentially the same age as faith so it makes sense that two people of that age 58:57 in this college campus community could somehow get connected to each other. 59:04 My immediate thought when this person was arrested for killing faith was well 59:10 she definitely was not dating him and I say that because I've met several of 59:16 the guys she did date or casually talk to. From speaking with residents at the 59:21 apartment complex where she lived investigators developed a theory about 59:25 how Faith and Miguel crossed paths. So we're here at Hawthorne at the view 59:30 apartments. The night of the murder there was a cookout going on out here. So the 59:34 thought of law enforcement is perhaps Miguel was at this cookout and at some 59:40 point Miguel encountered Faith and Carina coming home. That is the best 59:45 theory that we have right now that fits the evidence we have. So describe 59:49 to me what's happening around 2 45 a.m. Well we believe that Miguel would have 59:53 likely seen the two girls coming back from the club. We believe that he 59:57 interacted with them and would have approached them right here. And the thought 60:00 was that it was a negative interaction. Some sort of thing went down. They go 60:05 their way but it puts him just really feet away from where they were. That's 60:10 the best theory we've got right now. Yes. None of Faith's friends had ever 60:15 seen this guy and they knew nothing about him. But we did talk to a woman named Laura Kissel Ellen 60:22 and her daughter was a UNC student at the time and actually worked with Miguel at a local pizza 60:28 place. Miguel spoke very little English so he spoke Spanish with him. They just clicked. 60:36 It just wasn't a romance. It was just a close friendship. 60:39 Katie, who sadly has since passed, told her mother she was shocked to learn that Miguel 60:46 was accused of murder because she hung out with him around that very time. 60:52 She said he wouldn't hurt anybody. 60:54 Katie was very clear. 60:56 I would have noticed a change in him, and there was no change in him. 61:02 I think what she said was, 61:05 you don't kill someone and then go to work the next day 61:12 and tell the same goofy jokes. 61:16 I'll call you. You'll be good, baby. 61:19 After she talked to him that first time on the video call, 61:24 she texted me and what she said was, 61:28 if he wasn't wearing an orange jumpsuit, 61:30 you'd never know that he was in jail. 61:34 I personally can't imagine any kind of malice 61:37 coming from this person. 61:39 Newly revealed court documents show 61:41 he is additionally charged with first degree rape, 61:43 burglary and sexual offense. 61:45 The indictment says he entered a hedge path's home 61:47 with the intent to commit a felony and assaulted her. 61:51 Miguel pleads not guilty to all charges 61:53 and finally after years of waiting for justice, 61:56 the trial date is set. 61:57 Miguel Saguero Olivares will stand trial in September of 2026. 62:04 The defense is fully aware that they've got a mountain decline when it comes to the prosecution's DNA evidence. 62:12 So on the eve of the trial, they've got a strategy that they hope works. 62:17 They want to shift the blame to someone deep inside Faith's inner circle. 62:23 Her roommate, Karina Rosario. 62:25 Somebody else might have blood on their hands. 62:37 The man charged in the 2012 murder of UNC Chapel Hill student, Faith Hedgepath, 62:42 faced a superior court judge for the first time in person since his arrest. 62:47 So a week before the trial, there was a hearing to discuss 62:50 whether the defense could introduce third-party evidence 62:54 suggesting that someone other than Miguel might have killed Faith. 62:59 That third party that the defense wants to shift focus on is none other than faith 63:07 roommate and close friend Karina Rosario and they believe that it's very 63:13 possible it was Karina who wrote that very strange note. So the defense they 63:20 were comparing to the note that was written on the white bag and the note 63:26 said, I'm not stupid, bitch, jealous. 63:30 We saw interrogation video of Karina talking with investigators 63:35 and she kept saying, I'm not stupid. 63:37 I think I heard like, yeah, I was drunk, but I'm not stupid. 63:41 But the thing is, it's like, you hear about it 63:44 and you're like, oh, that'll never be me. 63:47 I'm not stupid. 63:48 I know the sign. 63:49 Like, I'm not, I'm not stupid. 63:50 I'm really not. 63:51 It's correct. 63:52 I'm not stupid. 63:53 I'm not stupid. 63:53 I'm not stupid for Ms. Rosario, first thing written on that white bag. 64:00 In his argument, the defense brings up something that we had heard from that neighbor, Joy Barker, 64:07 that just after finding her best friend's body, Karina seemed very serene. 64:14 What's the downstairs neighbor, Ms. Barker, the one that heard all the thumps? What does she say? 64:19 I never saw Karina crying or upset. 64:22 No, I can't say. I never saw her crying. 64:25 You would have never thought she had just discovered anything bad. 64:31 The defense makes note that even an investigator noticed Karina's behavior when he accompanied her back to the crime scene. 64:41 Officer Matthews talks with Ms. Rosario. 64:43 He documents, and she's trying to be emotional at times. 64:48 When Croy doesn't shut a tear, he's more specific. 64:52 There's a bloody mattress still in the room, 64:54 and if he sees her, look at it. 64:56 And notices, absolutely no emotion. 64:59 The demeanor evidence again, right, it's subjective. 65:04 And I've responded to thousands of 911 calls 65:08 where people were in crisis over my career 65:11 and everybody acts a little bit differently. 65:14 She was met with a horrific scene 65:16 of her best friend that she describes as a sister relationship and so I I don't 65:23 think there's any right way to respond to that. The case law in North Carolina is 65:27 really clear that you have to not only be able to show that there is definite 65:31 evidence that this person was involved but also that their client was not 65:34 involved. If the defendant wants a not-affiliate burden you want a fair 65:41 tribe he and us can accomplish that or tend to accomplish that by showing the 65:51 insufficiency of the state's evidence not by passing some spurious 65:56 allegations on a person who is not charged. She you know she lost her best 66:03 friend they ran out of other leads and they choose the last person to saw her 66:07 alive besides the killer and so they just went back to her and interviewed 66:11 her over and over and over again and she started second-guessing herself and 66:15 questioning herself because she was drunk and she couldn't remember exactly 66:18 what happened that night. It was just really clear to us that she had nothing 66:23 to do with this. It's now up to Judge Keith Gregory to decide if he's gonna 66:27 let the defense present this argument that Carina, who faith-considered one 66:32 of her closest friends, might have had something to do with her brutal 66:35 murder. This inference that when it says I'm not stupid that she wrote that on the 66:42 back, I don't know that. I wouldn't consider that a phrase that is so out of 66:48 the ordinary that anybody can't just use that phrase. I'm gonna sit right over 66:53 here and be fair and impartial to the best of my ability. What I'm not 67:01 gonna do is allow myself to fall for inferences and conjecture and I do 67:06 agree with the state, therefore the state does prevail. 67:10 After weighing both sides, the judge ultimately rules that the defense may not bring up Carina 67:17 as a potential third-party participant. 67:20 And one week before trial gets underway, it's a big blow for the defense. 67:25 Now prosecutors have to prove to jurors that Miguel was the killer and that he was the 67:29 one who wrote the note found next to Faith's body. 67:31 But will this video of Miguel's show to jurors help make their case or sink it? 67:42 To as many nights before Christmas and one woman new, she needed a Christmas tree so 67:47 to Wayfair she flew, finding just the right one and for years it will last. 67:51 Wayfair shipping was free and remarkably fast. 67:54 What's this? 67:55 Garland? 67:56 A wreath? 67:56 Essentials to host? 67:58 Good thing she celebrates way longer than most. 68:00 As her cart filled with magic and decor from the heart, Merry Christmas to all. 68:04 Get your Wayfair head start. 68:07 For holiday decor you can count on year after year, Wayfair delivers. 68:15 Is your closet ready for summer? 68:17 I used to dread shopping, hours browsing online, or fighting the store with no guarantee I'd find anything I liked. 68:23 That's why Stitch Fix is my secret weapon. 68:25 My stylist knows the trends and what actually works on me, then sends it straight to my door. 68:30 Free shipping, free returns, no subscription needed. 68:33 Get started today at stitchfix.com. 68:36 That's stitchfix.com 68:42 Shaq here. What's it like to buy a car from Carvano 100% online and get it delivered to your door? 68:48 Let me tell you your car is here, Mr. Shaq. Thank you, Mr. Carvano guy. Can't wait to take it for a spin only the best for you 68:55 Mr. Shaq. Hey, have you always been so big tall and handsome? Not always. 69:00 I was 6'10 once. Seven days to love it or return it, Mr. Shaq. Not that I would. You never do. 69:05 No, I never do. 69:07 So buy your car today on Caravana. 69:09 Delivery fees may apply. 69:10 See our seven-day return policy at Caravana.com. 69:21 Miguel Soluero Olivares' standing trial in Durham 69:24 on charges of first-degree murder, rape, burglary, 69:27 and sexual offense in connection 69:28 with the death of Faith Hedgepeth. 69:30 Madam Pierre, are you ready for me to bring the jury on? 69:33 It was a solemn feeling, Day 1. 69:36 14 years in the making. 69:37 A lot of anticipation. 69:41 I just want someone to pay for what they did. 69:46 To defend it, I could do her a permit, beat her in the head, sexually assaulted, and left. 69:57 Dad was still dying alone. 70:01 We walked in and there's just blood everywhere. 70:10 Faith was like someone wrapped in a comforter. 70:15 And so we just froze. 70:19 My heart cried out for Faith's family that they are still having to endure 70:25 things that happened to their daughter. 70:28 I was right there in court five feet away from the defendant 70:32 when I'm watching the prosecution tell the jury that the murder weapon was a rum bottle. 70:39 We learned that in fact it was a homicide and that she had a lot of trauma to her head 70:45 and so she died of blood force trauma. 70:49 And used the Bacardi rum bottle to come down on her head 70:52 and he did it again and again and again. 70:57 You see things in movies and all that stuff but this is a real person. 71:01 somebody's real life and it was it was horrible. Investigators would recover 71:08 DNA that prosecutors say is crucial evidence against Miguel Olivares. They 71:14 had this single male DNA profile inside her body. The analysts who examined that 71:23 internal DNA told the jury that it was 170 septillion times more likely that it 71:31 belonged to defendant Olivares than anybody else. 71:35 170 septillion is a one followed by 26 zeros. 71:41 He left his DNA on the murder weapon of the Cardi Romm model. 71:46 He left his DNA and his palm print and his left thumb print on a blue recent model 71:52 that was found on the floor of a booted event. 71:56 The palm print was compared to Lab Item 77 71:59 and identified as the left palm of Miguel 72:03 and Reed Gaye's Salvador Alvaro. 72:06 Olivares is facing up to life in prison, 72:08 but his defense is ready to attack. 72:11 You see television shows, and a crime's been committed, 72:14 and someone swallows something that says, 72:16 well, there's DNA there, we crack the case, 72:18 because that must be the first. 72:20 Don't worry about the rest of the evidence 72:21 In this case, just focus on that, because everything else is in the orcas. 72:26 Except that it's not. 72:28 During cross-examination, the defense tries to focus on some of that rest of the evidence, 72:34 like no physical signs of sexual assault, or poof when their internal DNA was left. 72:40 No, I can't determine the time and when it was deposited. 72:43 So, could have been several days prior? 72:46 Um, there is the potential. I have no way of knowing that. 72:49 The swab of blood from the bathroom doorway that never got sent to be tested. 72:54 Every time we break in evidence on a case, it's entered in individually. 72:58 That item was not there. 73:00 And that rum bottle? 73:02 So when you hear, well, this DNA is on the murder weapon, go closer. 73:08 It doesn't mean what you think. 73:12 The defense insists to the jury, those DNA results were not conclusive. 73:17 And don't tell you exactly who committed the crime. 73:22 They poked so many holes and for me they kind of made my focus shift. 73:29 But prosecutors counter. This case goes beyond DNA. 73:34 I think the DNA was great but people still want some kind of narrative. 73:39 That he didn't just fall in from the sky and didn't have any connection to this apartment complex. 73:44 Would you tell us who you knew lived in Hockernan at the View Apartments? 73:53 I lived there, Ariel Velazquez. 73:56 Ariel Velazquez lived there. 73:59 Hugo Miranda. 74:01 Hugo Miranda, I do. 74:03 The prosecution calls two different men to the stand 74:06 who testify that many Guatemalan people lived 74:09 just across the parking lot from where Faith and Karina lived. 74:12 share. That's a picture that my wife took at the moment that we were making the cookout. 74:19 The cookout, the night faith. It started at about 6 p.m. and it went until about 5 a.m. the next morning. 74:28 Luis Lopez testified that there were people coming and going at all hours throughout that barbecue. 74:34 Could Miguel Olivares have been one of them? No, I don't remember. 74:40 Luis Lopez says he just doesn't remember the defense denies he was there all 74:46 together. They pulled cell tower to see if they can put his cell phone in the 74:51 area at the time. Then there's that odd handwritten note found at the scene. The 75:00 note was found on the bed at the crime scene written on a white paper bag. 75:05 Were you ever able to obtain a known sample of the defendant's writing? 75:12 Yes 75:16 It leads to the most visible display of emotion in this entire trial 75:22 As prosecutors play the video that jailhouse phone call between Miguel and his friend Katie 75:27 Miguel breaks down in tears 75:33 Prosecutors contend handwriting Olivares shows in the jailhouse camera is similar to the handwriting on the note-in-faith 75:40 department. 75:42 It's all in caps. All of the letters are the same size. There were certain letters that seemed distinctive. 75:49 The defense disputes that and they claim Olivares didn't speak English well and that the note itself is problematic. 75:55 Sure, it was speculation that somebody had to break in and block print and that it doesn't 76:03 make any sense for someone that's already been killed. 76:06 The prosecution, however, says it all makes sense. 76:10 Proof against olivaris is overwhelming. 76:13 The evidence is loud and clear, and he is guilty of murder, of being killed. 76:20 But there's one witness the defense is counting on to muddy the waters. 76:29 Even though the judge already ruled that the defense cannot say that Carina Rosario committed 76:36 any crime, they can use her to make the jury wonder, are we hearing the entire story? 76:43 Do you remember having a conversation with him about having blood on your hand? 76:47 It's perhaps the key moment of the trial against Miguel Saguero-Olivaris, as prosecutors call 77:02 Faith Hedgepess' roommate, Karina Rosario. 77:05 Thank you, Your Honor. 77:06 Yes, ma'am. 77:06 Our next witness will be Karina Rosario. 77:09 Good afternoon, Karina. 77:10 Good afternoon. 77:11 She was the last person to see Faith alive after the two came back to their apartment 77:17 after a night out. 77:19 Do you remember what, if anything, Faith was doing once she all got back to the 77:23 apartment? 77:23 No. 77:24 I don't remember. I think I was just so focused on throwing up and I was feeling really sick. 77:32 She tells the jury that she spends about an hour on the floor texting Jordan McCreary asking him 77:38 if he was going to come and pick her up. What did you do when you realized he was 77:42 there at the apartment? I got up off the floor and I walked out. Do you know where Faith was 77:49 Was it that one? 77:50 No. 77:52 Then she testifies about the next morning, 77:56 describing the horror when she says 77:58 she returns to the apartment to find Faith dead. 78:02 And I saw that she had a black eye 78:06 and she wasn't wearing anything from the waist out 78:10 and her shirt was pulled all the way up. 78:14 To me, she seemed terrified. 78:15 She stared straight ahead. 78:17 She never looked at the jury once, 78:18 giving her testimony. 78:20 Now, Judge Gregory already ruled the defense cannot argue 78:22 that Carina Rosario had anything to do with the murder, 78:25 but the defense hopes its questions about her testimony 78:28 will raise reasonable doubt with the jury. 78:31 From the time you say that you sat on the bathroom floor 78:34 until the time you left the apartment, 78:37 did you ever get off the bathroom floor? 78:40 No. 78:41 Carina testifies that Faith never came into the bathroom 78:45 to help her, and the defense wonders 78:48 as if the jury finds that strange. 78:50 Ms. Heshka was described as a wonderful, loving person. 78:54 He said, odd that she would not have come and checked on 78:58 Ms. Rosario, who was only a few feet away. 79:02 And equally curious to the defense. 79:06 In all that time, 79:07 Karina Rosario says she never cleaned herself up at all. 79:11 So in that whole 50 minute time period, 79:14 you didn't get up and go brush your teeth, 79:16 wash your hands, anything like that? 79:17 You know, I mean, I was drunk. 79:20 I wasn't thinking to look presentable for anybody. 79:26 I was home. 79:30 Police would later find evidence of blood in the bathroom sink. 79:35 And when that friend, Jordan McCrary, 79:36 testifies about picking Karina up, 79:39 he says they discussed blood on her finger. 79:42 And then she had said that she doesn't know 79:46 why there's blood on her finger. 79:47 and I asked, yeah, why do you have blood on your finger? 79:51 And she just said, I don't know. 79:55 Being asked to testify about the blood on his finger 79:59 was a nervous, I guess, moment. 80:01 I've never had to testify. 80:02 I've never been in a situation like this before. 80:06 I trust him. 80:07 I don't see him to be a liar. 80:09 Do I believe it was blood? 80:11 No. 80:11 Did I tell him I was throwing up red slushies all night? 80:15 No. 80:15 There was nothing that would have caused me to come into contact with blood, so I deduced 80:24 it to my vomit. 80:27 The defense, that was like kind of their big thing, it was Karina. 80:30 She was hard to read, so there was like little seeds of doubt that were kind of planted in 80:34 my mind. 80:35 Did you feel that the defense at times came close to crossing the line between what wasn't 80:39 supposed to come into the trial in this regard? 80:42 I think that we were ready to object. 80:44 I don't think we ever got to the point where we needed to. 80:47 If somebody did this, and if it wasn't him, 80:49 they'd got to point the finger at someone else. 80:52 Whoever did this would be covered in blood. 80:58 There's no blood on what Karina was wearing that night. 81:01 There's not a scratch on her. 81:03 This theory of Karina being involved falls apart 81:07 when you use your reason and common sense. 81:12 And first, here on Eyewitness News at five, the prosecution resting its case against Miguel 81:17 Soluero Olivares. 81:20 As the defense gets ready to present its case, everyone's wondering, will Miguel Olivares 81:27 take the stand? 81:28 Have you made a decision about whether or not you're going to testify? 81:32 Yes, I've made the decision. 81:34 I'm not going to testify. 81:36 The fact that the defendant decided not to take the stand is not unusual, happens all the time. 81:42 But what the defense did next was truly surprising. 81:46 Will there be evidence for the defense in this matter? 81:50 No, Your Honor, there will be not offering evidence and we will be prepared to close tomorrow. 81:56 Imagine the shock that filled the courtroom when the defense announced it would not be putting on any evidence. 82:01 I gasped inside. I was stunned. 82:04 I remember looking at one juror her face, she did this, grabbed her cheeks. 82:09 And all that's left for the jury to hear are closing arguments. 82:13 He beat her, he beat her, he beat her again and again and again until he could get what 82:24 he wanted. 82:25 This is a murder trial. 82:26 You have accused someone and said, beyond reasonable doubt, this person committed these 82:30 horrible crimes. You're here to test the state's evidence. That's your job to make 82:36 give you a nut. His DNA was there because he was there. Nothing else is 82:43 reasonable. Nothing else makes sense. Some people call it regering. Other people 82:49 may call it reasonable doubt. Nobody's coming in here and saying anything was 82:53 done wrong then you never can be picked on anything because they forgot to 82:57 to collect something small. 83:00 These aren't small things. 83:01 This evidence is loud. 83:03 It is clear. 83:03 It is screaming at you that this defendant did this. 83:08 That is what the evidence has been saying for 14 years. 83:13 Put the guilt where it belongs. 83:16 Find him guilty. 83:19 They have not proved their case. 83:21 Hold them to their word. 83:23 It did not prove, is not guilty. 83:37 It's hard to be totally confident, but, you know, there's always the possibility of a 83:42 hung jury. 83:42 It's hard to get 12 people to decide on a kind of pizza to order. 83:46 Could he be found guilty? 83:47 Could he be not? 83:48 I mean, his fate lies in their hands. 84:00 We are following breaking news right now. 84:02 We are being told that the jury has reached a verdict. 84:08 what's the atmosphere like in the courtroom what are you feeling I mean
Community discussion